Led Zeppelin - Immigrant Song (Live 1972) (REACTION) with my wife

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 чер 2024
  • Thanks for stopping by and check out our channel! We do appreciate all the nice words from you guys. If you would like to support us, check out the links below. Hope you enjoy our reaction and see you again next time.
    🎞️ More About Us
    / andthirteen
    📦 Andrei&Dominika Unboxing: / @andreidominikaunboxing
    📷 Instagram: / merchantofalba
    💲 PayPal: www.paypal.com/donate/?busine...
    ☕ Buy Me A Coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/Merchant...
    🎵Request a Song: www.buymeacoffee.com/Merchant...
    📺 Official Video: • Led Zeppelin - Immigra...
    This is my musical reaction, breakdown and commentary analysis of the song and video. This is for educational purposes only. I intend no copyright infringement, and this is not a replacement for listening to the song. As covered under fair use copyright laws listed below, we simply reacted to the video by giving constructive feedback, criticism and comments.
    Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 186

  • @anthonyblakely399
    @anthonyblakely399 8 днів тому +32

    I saw Led Zeppelin in 1975 in L.A. My concert ticket: $5.99!

    • @owl-gd6ce
      @owl-gd6ce 7 днів тому +2

      lol those were the days

    • @sicotshit7068
      @sicotshit7068 7 днів тому +3

      I know early 69 & 70 that were close to me were $4.00, sad to think these guys deserved the outrageous ticket prices of today. Imagine if Peter Grant didn’t get them the 90% on ticket sales, they only would have gotten 10% of that. They were the first band to get a higher % of ticket sales. None of these audio tune acts deserve what their ticket sales are.

    • @musicairplanes4884
      @musicairplanes4884 7 днів тому

      Same here. At The Forum in Inglewood. Saw them two times at that venue.

    • @EdA1
      @EdA1 7 днів тому

      Yep, saw them for the first time at the Nassau Coliseum in 1972 for $4.50!

    • @gistechrep3816
      @gistechrep3816 7 днів тому

      I got scalped, had to pay $14.00...

  • @eugenehahn9355
    @eugenehahn9355 8 днів тому +21

    Both are great of course.

  • @markferrett700
    @markferrett700 8 днів тому +11

    Just think,this is 1972 😮.....amazing rock n roll, really don't get much better, rawer, real than this.🎸🎸

  • @AngeloMarcheschi-vj9em
    @AngeloMarcheschi-vj9em 8 днів тому +23

    Studio is polished to perfection. I love the live it's raw unfiltered in your face. Zeppelin were the masters at improvising.

    • @Frankincensedjb123
      @Frankincensedjb123 7 днів тому

      And like all live performances it's hit or miss, but that's the live experience. Great stuff 😊

    • @juliemanarin4127
      @juliemanarin4127 7 днів тому

      They sure were!

  • @dbclassic8733
    @dbclassic8733 7 днів тому +4

    Led Zeppelin concerts between 70-73 will never be matched

  • @swamihuman9395
    @swamihuman9395 8 днів тому +9

    -"It's a win-win. You have more Zeppelin in your life."
    - AMEN! :)

  • @davidcarter4247
    @davidcarter4247 7 днів тому +5

    I was at the concert - Sydney February 1972 - that provided the video footage. The audio came from a concert at the Long Beach Arena. LA, few months later. The video was done professionally by the ABC (Australian ABC, not US) TV show GTK but its audio was off a mike. While OK for 1972 TV broadcasting, it was not good enough for a CD release. The indoor LA concert was recorded on the soundboard. The variations in the song over such a short period of time meant they could be spliced together.
    The people running at the start of the video was the audience jumping over the fence and running to the base of the stage. Plant was shouting go back during the song. The showground trust did not want the audience on the grass because it was feared they would damage the surface ahead of the Royal Easter Show about 5 weeks later. The threat was to shut down the concert but with over 30,000 people there, the trust wisely decided not to. There was no damage to the surface. The concert lasted 3 hours, brought to an end by a strict 5pm noise deadline. Housing adjoined showground on two sides.
    The other aspect is this was summer. It was very humid and about 25C. A storm threatened at one stage but passed around the showground. A storm would have ended the show. Sydney did not have indoor venue that could hold more than 5000 people. As it was, Led Zeppelin was limited to 25,000 ticket sales but more than 5000 went over the walls of the showground during the night and hid until the gates opened at 10am. There was no real security and no CCTV in 1972. I was in the 10am rush and got a great seat in the grandstand front row, centre. But by midday it was apparent that there were many many more people there than seats. Tickets had been taken at the gate, so no one could show they had paid. It was that overflow who rushed the stage.

    • @MerchantOfAlba
      @MerchantOfAlba  7 днів тому

      Oh eow, thanks for this. It's so interesting to learn all those things. Much love from Romania 💚

  • @johnwdaley4727
    @johnwdaley4727 8 днів тому +8

    They smash this... extraordinary performance

  • @billtaylor3382
    @billtaylor3382 8 днів тому +5

    You had to go to a concert back in the day to see the Greatest Band Ever!

  • @paulyoung8108
    @paulyoung8108 7 днів тому +2

    The combo of improv and energy create a great live experience, the studio is what the artist considered their best efforts, live shows were organic for them

  • @jessicaleblanc-nh1yl
    @jessicaleblanc-nh1yl 7 днів тому +1

    One of the greatest bands ever! This has always been a favorite of mine. Led Zeppelin is just an incredible band. Thank you!

  • @targetshootr
    @targetshootr 8 днів тому +4

    I think they put out four albums by '72 and each one blew our minds.

  • @stevepas1
    @stevepas1 8 днів тому +4

    There was no other way for me to see them. I was lucky enough to win the ticket lottery. Greatest band ever.❤

    • @MerchantOfAlba
      @MerchantOfAlba  7 днів тому +1

      Oh wow, really lucky 👍💚

    • @stevepas1
      @stevepas1 7 днів тому

      @MerchantOfAlba got to see them 5 times and everytime I got a ticket it was pure luck.

  • @scotttrainer9704
    @scotttrainer9704 8 днів тому +18

    Jimmy Page was an expert in the studio, but he himself said he wanted Zeppelin to be a concert band. So live is what he truly intended the band to excel at.

  • @owl-gd6ce
    @owl-gd6ce 7 днів тому +2

    this is one of the best jam sessions ever..the musicianship is outstanding..AND THEY ROCK!!!!

  • @juliemanarin4127
    @juliemanarin4127 7 днів тому +2

    Always magnificent!! No concerts were not on tv!

  • @kevinharalson4538
    @kevinharalson4538 7 днів тому +1

    Studio is precise like a thundering marching band. Live is like a carouselambra!

  • @richardromney9205
    @richardromney9205 8 днів тому +7

    live and in person is magic. with friends and in the moment. its an event and never lost in time. great pick.

  • @colibri1
    @colibri1 7 днів тому +3

    On live versus studio versions, back when these songs came out, we always heard the studio version first because we heard almost all music on the radio and only very occasionally went to concerts or saw songs performed live on TV. As exemplified with this song, the studio versions contained the originally intended sound, which usually included some studio enhancements, sound balancing, etc. They didn't have the immediate pitch correction that is the norm now, but they did do multiple studio sessions to make sure every note was precise and as intended. Live versions can contain more experimentation/improvisation, and here they actually add a guitar solo that the original doesn't have, but live versions also contain more mistakes. Plant's voice is frequently flat on his highest notes here, for instance, which bothers me a little but is just part of it.
    On how we were able to see what performers looked like back then, we didn't have as much access to their appearance as people have today. The main way to see them was probably album cover photos, if the album cover included that. We could occasionally see them on weekly TV music programs (there were only three to five TV channels in most places in the seventies and no dedicated music channels) or maybe see their images in newspaper articles, and there were rock magazines that people read where we could see them, too, but if you didn't see the album covers, watch those TV programs, or didn't read rock magazines, you might have no idea what, for instance, Queen looked like or Todd Rundgren looked like or Led Zeppelin looked like, etc. Also, the idea of songs always being accompanied by images in videos didn't become normal until the eighties, so we didn't expect visual image associations with songs the way people do today; we were freer to let our minds establish their own associated images with the songs we heard.

  • @eugenehahn9355
    @eugenehahn9355 8 днів тому +5

    Plus the Visual.

  • @paulyoung8108
    @paulyoung8108 7 днів тому +1

    In America, we had 3 networks for TV, led Zeppelin were mysterious, no singles, but they were a phenomenal success,despite only being seen in concert,so yes options were very limited

  • @nightcitypunk8517
    @nightcitypunk8517 7 днів тому +1

    Don't overthink it. Led Zeppelin studio albums are great. Zeppelin live is mind blowing. Lol

  • @Frankincensedjb123
    @Frankincensedjb123 7 днів тому +1

    I see sixteen-year-old me as you guys explore your first-time Zeppelin experiences. Keep going.

  • @RonHouck-eb1cn
    @RonHouck-eb1cn 6 днів тому +1

    Both are great. But live you get to see much more of who Led Zeppelin is The talent, the improvising and the raw reactions

  • @johnrose813
    @johnrose813 8 днів тому +4

    Some great breaking music was available from 1971 on The Old Grey Whistle Test.

  • @supertrexandroidx
    @supertrexandroidx 8 днів тому +2

    Live was usually the only way to see your favorite bands back then. There were various shows that different bands would have a spot on, but those appearances were usually few and far between and you'd get only a song or two. I don't think I had ever seen a Zeppelin performance on TV by the time the band broke up. And alas, I never got to see them live. When I was 16, my uncle had bought tickets for us to see Zeppelin, but then just days before we were to see the show it came over the radio that Bonham had died and that the tour had been canceled. :(

  • @malcshone4409
    @malcshone4409 7 днів тому +1

    Zep didn’t do tv shows. There was no internet. You had to try to buy a show ticket and go see them live on stage. I saw them for the first time in 1971 and they started the show with “ Immigrant Song”. This show was and still is the loudest thing I have ever heard in my 70 years alive. Hard to describe except you could feel your teeth rattling. Personally I would always go studio then live. Both provide equally valid but different experiences. Best wishes to you both from England 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿.

  • @bowtiefidenine
    @bowtiefidenine 8 днів тому +4

    Thanks guys for more Zeppelin ❤

  • @Comtorn
    @Comtorn 7 днів тому

    Led Zeppelin is great both ways, Studio version and live. Either way they're both such a tremendous experience for different reasons. My favorite 2 groups all time were and still are, The Beatles and Led Zeppelin. Neither one could no wrong by me ever!

  • @NehatEmini-jl4bk
    @NehatEmini-jl4bk 8 днів тому +3

    Love U,Love Led Zeppelin🤘

  • @kevinmarker-cz3bx
    @kevinmarker-cz3bx 6 днів тому

    I have the boxset of these live performances..it is a treasure and reassurance that we as humans can obtain magical things. Through will and commitment and love of the art itself. Enjoy my friends.

  • @dellblackman4565
    @dellblackman4565 7 днів тому +1

    Back then, only in concert could you see them. Once in a while, maybe someone might perform a couple of songs on certain shows, and even then, usually, they weren't the supergroups like Led Zeppelin.

  • @brandonjones1349
    @brandonjones1349 8 днів тому +2

    Love the studio to live combo. Great choice MOA! 🤘.....☘️🇺🇲

  • @tombarr561
    @tombarr561 8 днів тому +2

    Thank you guys for listening to both the studio and the live versions. Studio usually lets you hear the vocals more clearly to better understand the lyrics. In my opinion however, Seeing a live version of the music gives you the full experience of the performance. Just hearing the audio, I always feels like I am missing a large part of the performance. And of course, there is no substitute for actually being at a concert and immersed in the experience. It is interesting to me how often an artist changes certain parts of a song when they are live and free from any restrictions a studio/ producer puts on them.

  • @anthonyblakely399
    @anthonyblakely399 8 днів тому +2

    Good reaction!!! Love Led Zeppelin!

  • @TheMinster1960
    @TheMinster1960 8 днів тому +2

    In America there were a few music-related shows--such as, The Midnight Special and Don Kirshner's Rock Concert--where you could see some live performances from the artists of the time. Many of The Midnight Special performances can be found on youtube.

  • @ronniecarter2645
    @ronniecarter2645 7 днів тому +2

    I loved your story.
    Thank you.
    I feel we all know you a little bit more. Never apologize for being human. Keep sharing your stories we love to hear them. Another Great reaction. I believe you should first hear the studio version to see what the artist intended you to hear and then afterwards the live version to see how they improvised the song.
    Thank you for sharing.

  • @Bluewizard7131
    @Bluewizard7131 8 днів тому +3

    Led Zeppelin is first and foremost a LIVE band. The albums are great, but the live performances are all better! Yes, the only way to see them back then was in concert. They never released singles, and their reputation was built by word of mouth from the live concerts.

  • @sicotshit7068
    @sicotshit7068 8 днів тому +1

    The studio versions had more of a space on an album restriction, live they could go with what they were feeling, feeding off each other & the fans. The albums you are listening just to the music, the lives you experience their love of performing. Both versions are beautiful & amazing in their own way, let’s face it, they knew how to give an amazing show. I LOVE Led Zeppelin!!!

  • @ryanr5319
    @ryanr5319 7 днів тому +3

    You two are the best. I agree with you both. Jimmy is a production/studio genius, the albums are headphone and good speakers candy. So glorious...BUT...you don't get that added guitar solo. 😊or the moans.
    You are welcome for not watching to the end. 😅

    • @MerchantOfAlba
      @MerchantOfAlba  7 днів тому +1

      Haha, thanks a lot. Much love from both of us 💚

  • @tonyperez3920
    @tonyperez3920 7 днів тому +1

    I've been listening to Zeppelin since 1970 and this is the first Zeppelin song I ever heard which was a studio version. In my opinion the majority of the Zeppelin songs should be listened to the studio versions first. You get the real feel of it.
    Especially with all the backtracking that Jimmy Page does.

  • @TomTom-ui9hg
    @TomTom-ui9hg 7 днів тому +2

    Back in the day you would have to watch shows like The Midnight Special or the Ed Sullivan Show to see the great bands or musicians. You would have to go the concerts to see them. You would have to buy the albums to see what they looked like. Albums were the way to look at pictures and lyrics of songs on the record. I know I loved bands but had no idea what looked like unless you bought the albums. Kind of miss those days. Peace!

  • @kirstenstewart5758
    @kirstenstewart5758 8 днів тому +2

    When I need a shot of adrenaline-soaked confidence and courage, it’s the immigrant song. If you can belt out that Robert Plant Viking cry, you are ready to take on the world!!

  • @LawrenceFogal
    @LawrenceFogal 7 днів тому +2

    In the 1970s you only had the live concert to actually see any of the bands. There was no acceptance of this on mainstream TV. It was considered unacceptable by the establishment as we referred to the rich owners and managers of mainstream TV.

  • @GaryCain-qf5vi
    @GaryCain-qf5vi 8 днів тому +2

    A sad story, 1 stereo record player 4 friends😂 Led Zepelin Album, and only one head phone plug in😢 so just turn it up and rock out,😂 the good old days👍 Peace✌️ and Love❤️ Gary😊 that was the 70's 😮

  • @andrewmason7207
    @andrewmason7207 8 днів тому +1

    cheers guys . look forward to more zep.

  • @stephenmaclean3422
    @stephenmaclean3422 8 днів тому +1

    Watched to the end. Great stuff.

  • @chickmcgee1000
    @chickmcgee1000 8 днів тому +1

    In the early eighties our little town of Hannibal Missouri sponsored a concert series down on the banks of the Mississippi River. I will always remember before Bob Dylan started playing Like a Rolling Stone, he said, “you remember how it used to sound, well this is how it sounds now!” It makes me laugh whenever I think of him. It took me a little maturing to really appreciate live versions of music.

  • @robertmysliwski7881
    @robertmysliwski7881 8 днів тому +2

    Fun fact Led Zeppelin sold out everyplace they played. This concert was at Yankee Stadium in New York City in 1972 in front of 80,000 plus.

    • @robgeorgeoff4045
      @robgeorgeoff4045 8 днів тому +4

      Incorrect, the audio is from a 1972 concert in California the video is from a concert in Australia the same year..

    • @tektoniks_architects
      @tektoniks_architects 8 днів тому +2

      @@robgeorgeoff4045 you are correct.

  • @dalemcmillan7231
    @dalemcmillan7231 8 днів тому +1

    Excellent!!!! ❤❤❤❤

  • @ultantierney8562
    @ultantierney8562 8 днів тому +2

    Unlike most bands, Led Zeppelin didn't release singles, only albums and tired to promote them, so concerts were the only place to see them.

  • @billtaylor3382
    @billtaylor3382 8 днів тому +1

    The Goat!

  • @merlepedigo3994
    @merlepedigo3994 7 днів тому +1

    If only we had a time machine, y'all would fit in the seventies

  • @dangaiser4729
    @dangaiser4729 7 днів тому +1

    Just pour that Zeppelin into your ear 👂

  • @anthonyblakely399
    @anthonyblakely399 8 днів тому +1

    I don't remember the "galloping riff" in music before Led Zeppelin presented it in this song. Andrei is correct. Live version has distorted sounds of instruments and vocals. In the studio version you hear everything quite well.

  • @DarthVader-km6ku
    @DarthVader-km6ku 7 днів тому +1

    Led Zeppelin steadfastly refused to do television. They never appeared on British or American TV back in the day. They did a TV broadcast in Denmark in 1969 but it wasn't released officially until well into the 2000s. I followed them from the moment their first album came out and never saw them live until 1975. Tickets were like gold. Not only were they never on TV, they were almost never live on the radio either. In fact it was 1975 before I even HEARD them live, when I bought a bootleg of a BBC broadcast they had done in 1971. Remember that back then they almost never rebroadcast these things. The first time they appeared on film was 1976 when the Song Remains the Same movie came out and I drove 50 miles to see it in a theatre with what was called "four channel sound" which today you would call surround sound. They used to screen that movie in a local movie theatre every weekend for about 10 years in the 1980s. It was busy every weekend, like a party. Almost all of the videos you have watched of them online were released in the last 25 years.

    • @MerchantOfAlba
      @MerchantOfAlba  7 днів тому +1

      Wow, that's something. I guess the whole experience was much more meaningful. We can only imagine the excitement before the concert. Thank you for sharing 💚

    • @lyndoncmp5751
      @lyndoncmp5751 7 днів тому

      The March 1969 Danmark tv show was actually shown on the BBC twenty years later in March 1989, introduced by Elvira (who used to be a groupie and had some er 'interaction' with Jimmy Page back in the 1960s). I recorded the show on VHS at the time and that's how I became a fan. I played it to death. That and The Song Remains The Same was all I had to watch.

  • @matthewashman1406
    @matthewashman1406 7 днів тому +1

    i think its always best to first hear a song how everyone else 1st heard it at its release. Normally the studio cut.

  • @mtnvalley9298
    @mtnvalley9298 8 днів тому +1

    Let's Go Again!

  • @EdA1
    @EdA1 8 днів тому +3

    Thanks for doing both versions! OK my apologies but a lot to talk about here… Welcome to the battle of Zeppelin studio versus Zeppelin live lol… Jimmy Page always said that the studio versions were a starting point for these songs and that they would evolve even further live and that what Led Zeppelin did. There really shouldn’t be any battle at all, both are great! But I’ve mentioned it before, keep in mind that just because the studio was a starting point, they weren’t just throwing something together quickly. They were masters in the studio and they spent a lot of time creating the songs plus also the studio gave Jimmy Page the opportunity to overdub multiple guitars which creates a different soundscape than what you would get live with the single guitar. That being said, of course live gives you a whole different type of energy!… But also keep in mind that there were many great Led Zeppelin songs that they never performed live so the only way you’re going to hear them is the studio version. Also it was the 70s so little of it was actually recorded and filmed… That brings us to the next thing answering your question about back then were we able to see them other than going to the show… No, you were not! I saw them in 72, 73, 75 and 77. The ‘73 MSG film came out in 76… Prior to that you never saw them at all in any way on television or film, etc., unless you were lucky to find some unreleased bootleg thing which none of us did at the time. And that’s what was so fascinating. All you had was the album and photos that you would see in a rock magazine… It was actually a big freaking deal just to see them on the cover of a rock magazine! You would sit there and put the album on and flip through the pictures in the magazine, and that was the only experience you had… So when they DID come to town it was more than just a show, the anticipation of you being in the same building with them was so beyond anything that happens now with all of the instant gratification from the Internet and UA-cam and zillions of live videos, etc.… It’s unfortunate that today’s youth will never be able to experience, what we did. There was no instant gratification you had to wait and dream, wait and dream!

    • @MerchantOfAlba
      @MerchantOfAlba  7 днів тому +1

      Many thanks Ed for sharing your favourite music with us. Seems like everything was a little bit more special back in the day. Much love from both of us 💚

  • @joegaffey7609
    @joegaffey7609 7 днів тому

    For years the only live Zeppelin I ever saw was the movie The Song Remains The Same. John Bonham died before I could see them in concert. I did eventually see Page and Plant 2x in Boston Massachusetts in the mid 1990’s. Needless to say, they were awesome 👏 ☘️✌️

  • @taniaPBear
    @taniaPBear 8 днів тому +1

    I personally like to hear a studio version first, not necessarily because it's better, but just so I know the song first. Sometimes in a live performance, the lyrics or melody or even one of the instruments can get a bit lost, but if you know the song already, it doesn't matter, and you can appreciate the differences. That's just me. Thank you for a great reaction. ✌❤

  • @scotttrainer9704
    @scotttrainer9704 8 днів тому +2

    From what I understand there was no official live version of this song. Jimmy Page went through the video archives from stage hands and pieced this together with live audio from a different concert.

    • @kurtsaxton823
      @kurtsaxton823 8 днів тому +2

      He did the same with the whole How the West was Won tracks, which is pretty brilliant. He was definitely a studio master.

  • @mjtribby6328
    @mjtribby6328 8 днів тому

    I think seeing a performer perform gives you a new appreciation for the talent, the soul and the emotion the artist puts into their music. I am sure in the studio it is similar but unfortunately we do not have the ability to be a part of the studio recording. I understand your point of view. When listening to the studio I do feel something different, which may be my focus on what they are trying to pass on to the listener. The live gives your senses a whole new level of experience.

  • @victorstefanovsky6902
    @victorstefanovsky6902 8 днів тому

    There is a recording for Dutch Tv from 1969, black and white, great! There is a movie from Madison Square Garden 1975 called The song remains the same.

  • @ed6720
    @ed6720 8 днів тому

    I have listen to them since I was a kid and though it's been great to see them live, I have always liked the studio versions better, even at the ripe old age of 65. Your not wrong Andrei. I do love the shock in Dominika's face when you eluded to maybe liking the studio version better lol

  • @emmafrench7219
    @emmafrench7219 8 днів тому +2

    Hi. In the 1970's it was mostly from going to concerts that I saw bands. However we did have "Top of the Pops", on Thursday night's on tv which I'm sure you've seen or heard of. Other than that it was listening to their albums. Oh and of course on a Sunday evening the top 40 charts show.😊 I am really glad that I saw all my favourite bands and singers when I did because everyone was really watching and listening to the music. Now all you see in the crowd are almost everybody filming on their phones to watch another time?? Makes no sense to me. The only lights that our audiences showed were from holding up cigarette lighters or matches which almost burned your fingers if not careful.😂. Cheers from UK.✌

    • @MerchantOfAlba
      @MerchantOfAlba  7 днів тому +2

      Everything was a bit more special back in the day 😊

    • @lyndoncmp5751
      @lyndoncmp5751 7 днів тому +2

      Yeah, Top of the Pops used Whole Lotta Love for its theme tune but Zeppelin never performed on it.

    • @emmafrench7219
      @emmafrench7219 7 днів тому

      @lyndonc Oh yes, I completely forgot! Now I've got the graphics from the start of TOTP in my head as well as the music.😊

    • @emmafrench7219
      @emmafrench7219 7 днів тому

      It certainly was.✌

  • @neutech1426
    @neutech1426 7 днів тому +1

    NO TV with Zeppelin in the 70s ... made them very mystical with a lack of info we take for granted today ... you had to hit up every rock and roll magazine to get info/updates on the band and concerts OR go to the concerts (after competing with everyone else for tickets)

    • @MerchantOfAlba
      @MerchantOfAlba  7 днів тому +2

      Oh wow. The excitement before the concert where you would finally see them for the first time...😍

  • @LarryLewis-nz1oy
    @LarryLewis-nz1oy 7 днів тому +2

    I think repeating a song exactly is from practice being able to do a song differently each time requires more talent in my opinion.

  • @user-oe9hj9yl7m
    @user-oe9hj9yl7m 8 днів тому

    I can never understand how Bonzo’s drums withstand that pounding !!!

    • @lyndoncmp5751
      @lyndoncmp5751 7 днів тому +1

      There were tiny people inside desperately holding them together with tiny ropes 😂.

  • @HeavyBrocks
    @HeavyBrocks 8 днів тому +2

    The reason I always prefer the studio first… Jimmy Page was an absolute Master in the studio. To me, those are the “songs” of Led Zeppelin. But live, they were all Masters of improvisation. This song is a great example. There is no guitar solo in the studio version. But live, they did whatever they wanted. Live is the “band” Led Zeppelin.

  • @kimzwolinski9919
    @kimzwolinski9919 8 днів тому +1

    🔥🔥🔥😊

  • @williamcabell142
    @williamcabell142 7 днів тому +2

    Live is always better…the studio is great…but Live is better! 😎🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @user-ch4gn6ws3w
    @user-ch4gn6ws3w 7 днів тому

    Claro que sí. En vivo son mucho mejor..más sentimiento es correcto.
    En concierto Zeppelin es el mejor..!!!!!!!

  • @Mikeluvdrums
    @Mikeluvdrums 8 днів тому

    Led Zeppelin, a very improvisational band and doing their songs over and over again on tour granted the boys the opportunity to continue developing the songs and building on them as they performed. The studio is a more controlled environment they had to behave themselves .

  • @CosmicVagabondPixie
    @CosmicVagabondPixie 8 днів тому

    OOOOH YAY OMG Weeeeeeeeeee **LUVLuvLuvIT** can not wait to see YOUR *Reactions* **MyKickAssBeautifulJimmyWizardBabe** & just **ALL* of it course! **YUM** heh k goin to watch now heh...

  • @audreybiester8309
    @audreybiester8309 8 днів тому +1

    No, never seen on TV. Had to go to a concert.

  • @scotttrainer9704
    @scotttrainer9704 8 днів тому

    We had pay per view in major markets here in America. I don't recall seeing Zeppelin on pay per view though.

  • @stevepool8034
    @stevepool8034 8 днів тому

    Gee, guys , I have heard this banger before for sure, but now in my head it just says opening theme from Thor Ragnorok, Lol, awesome pick 👍🏻

  • @patrickseevers3858
    @patrickseevers3858 7 днів тому +1

    I know that you guys reacted to since I’ve been loving you live, but if you can please react to the studio version. It’ll blow your mind

  • @vernhoke7730
    @vernhoke7730 21 годину тому

    This version is about a minute longer than the studio version.

  • @artsilva
    @artsilva 8 днів тому

    In the 70s, before MTV, outside of buying tickets to see bands live, the only way to see them is on TV talk shows or music variety shows on TV, and even then they were live TV performances where they sinked the studio versions of the song for television and familiarity to what we hear on the radio.
    The live concerts were where the artist could really improvise on their songs like you hear in this video.

  • @scotttrainer9704
    @scotttrainer9704 8 днів тому

    Watched every second. Loved the story. Reminded me of taking my daughter to see The Rolling Stones, she was only 12 and petrified when we first got to our seats. I lost her in a drowning accident 4 1/2 years later so you brought back a wonderful memory.

    • @sicotshit7068
      @sicotshit7068 8 днів тому

      I’m so sorry to hear that, my sincere condolences. A great memory together to always have.

    • @MerchantOfAlba
      @MerchantOfAlba  7 днів тому

      Much love from both of us 💚

  • @fadmax1
    @fadmax1 8 днів тому

    Enjoy the reviews. Roberts voice has texture, the guitar is another voice, the drums sometimes flows with the guitar, and then the base. It's all good, and so creative as you said.

  • @lyndoncmp5751
    @lyndoncmp5751 8 днів тому +1

    Yes you are right. Led Zeppelin NEVER performed on either British or American tv so they were never seen on tv in those countries. They turned all offers down. In 1969 they did a couple of tv shows (Denmark and Germany) but nobody outside those countries saw these clips until decades later.
    It wasnt until The Song Remains The Same came out in cinemas in late 1976 did people around the world get to look at Led Zeppelin performing, unless you actually went to one of their concerts live.
    Zeppelin were the most underground and mysterious of all the big rock bands.

    • @MerchantOfAlba
      @MerchantOfAlba  7 днів тому +1

      Oh wow, hard to imagine this in today's world 💚

    • @lyndoncmp5751
      @lyndoncmp5751 7 днів тому +1

      Yeah they never even appeared on the famous Top of the Pops tv show in Britain (even though the theme tune to that show used Whole Lotta Love).
      The were offered one million dollars to play a live coast to coast tv satellite show in the USA for New Year's Eve 1970/71 but turned it down. That was a huge amount of money for one show back in 1970.
      Manager Peter Grant wanted to keep that air of mystery about them so that everyone would have to go to the concerts to see them. Plus he often spoke about the poor quality of tv sound recordings and only wanted people to hear them in the best conditions.
      Cheers.

  • @billpimentel-vm6cu
    @billpimentel-vm6cu 8 днів тому

    This footage was recorded in Australia, one and only show they performed there.

    • @EdA1
      @EdA1 7 днів тому +2

      They actually performed a bunch of shows in Australia in early 72 but this is the only one with pro shot footage.

    • @billpimentel-vm6cu
      @billpimentel-vm6cu 7 днів тому +1

      @@EdA1 thanks for educating me on that I heard it was just one

    • @EdA1
      @EdA1 7 днів тому

      @@billpimentel-vm6cu sure thing, they played six shows. If you do a Google image search on Melbourne there are some really cool photos with a huge storm brewing!

  • @fixzeichner5592
    @fixzeichner5592 8 днів тому

    This is not a professional recording, but was probably filmed by stagehands using 8mm film. This was on their only tour of Australia. However, it is the only film recording of the song that they did not play live later. The long screams probably put too much strain on Robert's voice. This is why they did not play Immigrant Song at the one-off reunion concert in 2007. Led Zeppelin almost never played on television. The concert film of the concert in Madison Square Garden was only released in cinemas and on vinyl. Jimmy Page had an aversion to television recordings and was of the opinion that the concerts did not work in TV format and the sound quality in the 1970s was not that good either, mostly only in mono.

  • @em17jayvee
    @em17jayvee 7 днів тому

    You could go to concerts, but most people didn’t have great seats, and therefore could hear great but not see that well. We had many great photographers who provided amazing photos for magazines and album art. That’s the way I enjoyed images of all those great bands. Also studio photos.

  • @tgward313
    @tgward313 6 днів тому

    I wasn't there so studio is good

  • @antoniocarlin5026
    @antoniocarlin5026 7 днів тому

    You need hear "Achilles Last Stand" Led Zep on mood Heavy Metal...!

  • @verginithe
    @verginithe 8 днів тому

    Studio is obviously cleaner and sounds better but lives where it's at. It gives more excitement and weeds out the pretenders. With Zep some songs were better live and some studio. Live was perfect for Page to shine, always extending his solos.

  • @tomm7305
    @tomm7305 8 днів тому

    "Improvise" Correct. They did improvise. They always experimented. Sometimes things worked. Somethings they did not. But they always pushed their songs forward, developing them over time.
    One other note: how you love your 2-year old child will not be the same as loving that same child at age 55. I view studio versus live arguments the same way. There is something very special about that first release. But the songs developed and changed. What follows becomes richer. But never forget the DNA, from the beginning. We get both. "More Led Zeppelin." Or, "the cherry on top."

    • @MerchantOfAlba
      @MerchantOfAlba  7 днів тому

      Oh, that makes sense. Much love from both of us 💚

  • @markacuna2828
    @markacuna2828 7 днів тому +1

    Peter Grant the manager wouldn't put them on TV u wanna see led zeppelin live u have too buy a ticket

  • @emfer3010
    @emfer3010 7 днів тому

    Personally I prefer the studio versions of all their songs. It took me a long time to appreciate the live versions. I can undertand why many love the live versions. On the other hand I love seeing them on stage interacting with eachother, brings a whole new dimension to the songs than hearing only the audio, I was lucky to have seen them live just a few months before John Bonham passed away.

    • @lyndoncmp5751
      @lyndoncmp5751 7 днів тому

      In my opinion Zeppelin improved many of their songs live, including this. I was always underwhelmed by Immigrant Song on Led Zeppelin III. For a hard rocking song, it never packed the punch of their other rockers for me. Something always seemed sedate about it. Maybe the was intentional, I don't know. Anyway this live version blows the studio version out of the water as far as I'm concerned.
      Cheers. ✌️

  • @CosmicVagabondPixie
    @CosmicVagabondPixie 8 днів тому

    With **MyBelovedOtherWorldlyLeZeppelin** they did not like doing TV or interviews back in the day so like the ONLY way i could see them myself anyway was in the **Rock Magazines** back then & i would cut the pictures out & put them on my **Wall** & i carried **One** in particular of **MyJImmyMagicalWizardBabe** with me **ALWAYS** another of **THE Best Reactions EVER!!!** I sooo *LUV* both your **LUV** & **Enthusiasm** of **OurBelovedLedZeppelin** & to me **BOTH** studio & live are **MagicalFantasticalOutOThisWorld** Awww **Dominika** i am so very sorry bout your **Concert** experience BUT ahaha YAY for your **Friend** who held your **Purse** for you & YAY **LUVD** when ya said **Happy Bunny** heh Ya **Both** are THE **Cutiest** EVER!!! i watched til the end & YAY freakin **Luvit** Ha **PixieHugz&Luvz** & All The Best!!!

    • @MerchantOfAlba
      @MerchantOfAlba  7 днів тому +1

      Thanks a lot! Much love from both of us 💚

  • @snakeinthegrass7443
    @snakeinthegrass7443 8 днів тому

    If you can do both, than sure go ahead with the studio. But for these guys, live is almost always better for the reasons you both mentioned. God bless.

  • @jimsebastian2846
    @jimsebastian2846 3 дні тому

    I agree with you, live music is much better to me. They do add great differences when live. You should check out the Grateful Dead, they are known for their live performances

  • @WillyAffentranger-jb1oi
    @WillyAffentranger-jb1oi 8 днів тому

    Hello again, i have a long time nothing heard of you. 1974 version, with my guitar, a Gibson les paul standard model iced tea. I bought it three years ago to my 60 birthday for 3000 swiss Franks. I think, you know that i'm born in adliswil with tumor 1961, i think everybody knows thats near zürich, of course switzerland. Have good wendsday, and a better thursday. Its actually EM, and the swiss Team is playing actually against scotland, oh what a beautiful Whisky scotish evening it will be. Also the weather is beautiful, loke your wife. I saw a few months ago, that you get a suprice of top subscribers. I know, you're both a very rare coupe,

    • @MerchantOfAlba
      @MerchantOfAlba  7 днів тому

      Thank you kindly. Much love from Romania 💚

  • @stephentarry4475
    @stephentarry4475 8 днів тому

    you'll love it.././../

  • @vincemac2223
    @vincemac2223 6 днів тому

    We had music videos on MTV ( Music Television ) Channel, which now doesn't have music anymore. We also had their movie. " The Song Remains The Same " other than that, no we didn't have internet or phones to watch videos on. If you were unlucky enough to not see them live you just missed out.

    • @oldzephead1237
      @oldzephead1237 6 днів тому

      There was no MTV during the Zeppelin years. It wasn't around until the early 80's. We just had the three major broadcast channels, CBS, ABC, & NBC. ☮️

    • @vincemac2223
      @vincemac2223 6 днів тому

      @@oldzephead1237 yep exactly It was about 1980 when I discovered them at 13 years old. Anyone older had just those few TV appearances .

  • @scottrbloom
    @scottrbloom 7 днів тому

    You see in this video why John Bonham is considered one of the greatest rock drummers of all time.