Vocal Coach/Musician Reacts: DISTURBED 'The Sound of Silence' In Depth Analysis!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 кві 2024
- Watch The Sound Of Silence Disturbed with me for the first time!
Watch the original video: • Disturbed - The Sound...
Join my Patreon family: / ninaschofield
Come on over to my Wisio page where I can help YOU sing and answer any questions you might have for me:
www.wisio.com/NinaSchofield
*I have a new single out called 'Who Is She’', I'd love your support:
Stream/Download Spotify: open.spotify.com/album/6PqMth...
Find in all digital stores and streaming sites.
Watch the official video here: • Nina Schofield - Who I...
And support my previous release ‘Not Perfect Now’ below...
Watch the Official video here: • Nina Schofield - 'Not ...
Stream/Download: ingroov.es/not-perfect-now
*Buy my brand new merch! Ships worldwide: www.teespring.com/stores/ninas...
Listen to my Healing Hits Playlist: open.spotify.com/playlist/0PB...
#VocalCoach #disturbed #thesoundofsilence
Well this was quite something! If you’d like early access to videos such as this one then go ahead and check out my Patreon: www.Patreon.com/ninaschofield Thank you so much for watching!
Wonderful reaction and they are a good group. But, Nina I can't believe your sleeping on HI REN. By the artist Ren. If your bored and want something different from the upcoming and greatest storyteller independent artists of our time. Please do this reaction I promise you, most are almost speechless at the end. I got bored with most music until I came across him. His creative level is off the charts.
You should listen to the live version of this song on Conan! It felt more powerful though the sound might be a tad off.
I'M SHOCKED THAT THIS IS THE FIRST TIME YOU HEARD THIS VERSION OF THIS SONG. IT'S AWESOME AND IT'S BEEN AROUND AWILE. IT'S ABOUT WW3 THAT'S WHY IT SOUNDS QUITE IN THE BEGINNING, THEN BUILDS AS WAR DOES. HE'S TRYING TO OPEN PEOPLE'S EYES TO THE FACT THAT THE END IS NIGH, LOOK AROUND THE SIGNS ARE EVERYWHERE. BLESSED BE.❤
@@gus2747 Totally agree....... The man is a genius!
You need to listen to the original version simon and Garfunkel sound of silence then listen to this one..
I believe disturbed did a interview about this song. If I remember correctly simon and Garfunkel had a tone more as warning to humanity and disturbed they chose their tone as anger for humanity not listening to the warning of simon and Garfunkel. If I remember correctly.
My son forced me to listen to this years ago I grew up with the Simon & Garfunkel version in the 1960s. Thought I’d hate new version. Absolutely blown away by Disturbed’s version - I understand the power of the lyrics more - brilliant.
I also grew up with the S&G version. I believe this version brings the angst that the lyrics convey.
As has been said multiple times, and I think it beautifully summarized it:
Simon&garfunkels version was a warning to what might happen
Disturbeds version is rage, because that warning was ignored.
I grew up listening to Simon & Garfunkel in the 70's. But I will admit that, as a small child in the 1970's, I liked "At the Zoo" the best. When one is a little kid and they're singing about elephants, and monkeys, and what-not... As I grew up, however, the meaning of that song became more about judging by facile appearance. My point is that Paul Simon was arguably one of the best lyricists to ever put pen to paper!
I think that three favorite evolutions of this song are Simon and Garfunkel first. Then came the Disturbed version. Notably, the Pentatonix version. I love them all. Thanks so much for your brilliant overview.
I grew up with parents telling me to listen to S&G. Aunts. They knew OF Disturbed through one Aunt who was a Social Worker but not this song. I MADE them listen to this.
The social worker Aunt acutally said this is that OH AH AH AH AH AH guy?! I told her, before Oh Ah Ah Ah Ah Ah? He was almost a trained CANTOR. For those not familiar with my faith. Think of our clergy as a split of two. A speaker and a lot of the time another guy. A trained singer. A trained singer that a lot of the time is damned near an OPERA TRAINED singer.
I get goosebumps every time I listen to this song. His voice is insane.
It really is!
As do I!
I weep every time. Without fail.
We come here in droves to watch people experience this for the first time because we are jealous that we can't. This song is an addiction.
Please watch the live Conan version.
Totally addicted to this version and I get goosebumps every time I listen to it!
100% with you there. I have lost count how many times i have watched reactions to this incredible song and as you said, i never saw the amazing lyrics for what they were before hearing Disturbed's version.
Paul Simon politely warned us in the Sixties, we didn’t listen. David & Disturbed is making sure we get the message this time. Society is too stupid to see the road to destruction we are on. I truly hope the oblivious masses open their eyes, but I doubt they will. I will be gone, but I fear for those who remain. Love your reaction, Nina, as always!
It was said after he performed this live on Conan O'Brien, that the Simon and Garfunkel version was our warning, and this version conveyed the anger that we didn't listen.
Agreed
Absolutely.
So, so true..heartbreaking.. 💔💔💔
Braindead comment.
This is a full-on visceral experience. David' voice, the anger, the tempo, the instrumentation, the video conveying the true meaning of the lyrics. Chills.
Watching people discover this song is always amazing. There's so much rage and sadness in this cover that it sends a shiver down my spine every time
Glad you enjoyed it.
I particularly like this version for they way the video fits in with the song, the sound of silence with all of the destroyed instruments at the start is particularly poignant.
There is also a live performance on 'Conan' but I find the sound balance a bit off. That said, Paul Simon liked it:-
From Wikipedia:
In April 2016, Paul Simon endorsed the cover. Additionally, on April 1, Simon sent Draiman an email praising Disturbed's performance of the rendition on American talk show Conan. Simon wrote, "Really powerful performance on Conan the other day. First time I'd seen you do it live. Nice. Thanks." Draiman responded, "Mr. Simon, I am honored beyond words. We only hoped to pay homage and honor to the brilliance of one of the greatest songwriters of all time. Your compliment means the world to me/us and we are eternally grateful."
Man of few words 🤣🇦🇺🏄♂️
From what I found out about the Conan performance is, David had the full blown flu and still belted the song out. True performance!
Fkn masterpiece. Every time. 🤯
Singer David Draiman was trained as a cantor when he was young, and many people who were only familiar with a few Disturbed songs were quite shocked to hear just what he was capable of.
The last scene ties it all up. they rescued the instruments on one side and the music (notes) on the other. They crossed the chasm in the end to have the instruments and music as together as one.
Incredible Epic Song. He is a beast
One of the best covers of all time. Perfect production, arrangements and vocals. 👏🏻
I've always interpreted the original S&G version and this version as follows: S&G we're worried about where the self-centred nature of the glitz and lights of the 60s were heading, and where it would lead society in terms of people being verbose and self-important without ever really having anything meaningful to say, and hearing each other but never really listening. Then enter David with Disturbed and this version is them being really angry that no one heeded the warnings of the original, and everything it foretold has come to pass, hence the heightened emotion and weight behind the new version.
Agreed
I was one of those annoying people that didn't want to listen to this version for a long time, because the original by Simon & Garfunkel was absolutely amazing and one of my favorite songs and I thought this version would never compare and was not how the song was meant to be. (As if I know the writers, but oh well, lol.) Then one day I heard it by accident and was blown away and still every time I hear it, I get chills. The lyrics in combination with this much musical power have imo even more strength than in the 'silent' version and omg I adore it.
This version always gives me goosebumps! I heard this song when it came out, but all Simon and Garfunkle were able to convey with their first song was a pale imitation of the full-throated roar of anger and grief that David Draiman gave this song. He was trained as a cantor but had something to say and as a Jewish man, he couldn't say it. This is when he decided to sing Metal.
In my opinion, Simon & Garfunkel wrote the amazing lyrics (piece of art), but they sang it in a way that didn't fit the lyrics and the message they wanted to send with this song. Disturbed's version is in my opinion how it should've sounded like. Disturbed actually brings the message accross. And so intense. My God, I get tears rolling down my face and chills all over every single time I hear Disturbed's version 😢
@@RissaFirecat
This is a cover of Simon and Garfunkle. They are not doing an imitation of a cover. They produced a masterpiece.
Wow! I’ve seen this reacted to at least a 100 times. I really found your analysis fascinating! Very spot on. Even some things I haven’t thought of, so I’ve Subscribed! I’m a 73 year old grandmother who’d never heard of Disturbed. Saw this video pop up on UA-cam when we were all locked in Spring 2020. I’ve explored a lot of their heavy metal and their more rock songs and become a huge fan. I’ve loved Simon and Garfunkel for almost 60 years, actually still have the vinyl this song is on…but I’m with Paul S. Disturbed now owns this song.
He did this live on Conan, its incredible!
Gotta do the live version on Conan! 🩵
I can't get enough of this song, and my neighbors too 😁
Hi Nina. David Draiman's range is absolutely insane and he never seems to strain it. As has been said, he was trained as a cantor in his younger days, but chose to take up the world of heavy metal rather than stay within the Jewish religion (despite his grandfathers disapproval).
This is by far the best cover I have ever heard. I heard the original back when I was a kid. I believe it was my grandmother who played it. I was maybe 5 at the time. I grew up listening to Disturbed in the 2000's along with many many other hard rock and grundge bands. Disturbed had always been my number 1. The talent David has and the range he truly has is spone chilling. Add that Paul Simon himself passed the torch and said this is now Disturbeds song tells how powerful they made the message he tried to send many many yrs ago
Some people have said that Simon never gave the song to Disturbed. Did he, or not?
It's always amazing to see people's reactions to David's voice, particularly those who aren't familiar with Disturbed. Yes his voice is absolutely incredible.
I really love how you break this piece down into its components! I’m also amazed how quickly you can accurately mimic the background instrument parts.
If you loved the studio version .... hold on to your hat because the live version on Conan Obrien's show will absolutely knock your socks off ..I have seen women weeps and grown man outright cry it was that good .. so good in fact the live version got nominated for 2016 Song of the Year but went to David Bowie Poshumously .. but that does not take anything away from the song .. seriously do yourself a favour Davids live version is freaking epic epic epic
Not only is that version absolutely awesome, Draiman was ill and they thought about cancelling it. Thats why he was sitting on a chair on stage and still blew everybodys minds.
It's hard to believe this song is 60ish years old, but still very relevant. Paul Simon wrote amazing music!
How is that possibly hard to believe? There are endless writings from centuries, even millennia, ago that are relevant. 60 years is nothing. Humans haven’t fundamentally changed for hundreds of thousands of years
I might say the words are more relevant now than back when they were written.
I love Disturbed but when I first heard this it really got to me. Sends chills down my spine. This is the best version of a great song I've ever heard. David has a great voice anyway. Absolutely beautiful.
You need to hear the live version on the Conan show
The man has such a powerful voice that sends chills! Absolutely beautiful!
Wow. It's been a number of weeks since I've been on your Channel, but wow did I enjoy that reaction. Everything about it. I love everything you had to say I like what you called out on the keyboards and vocally and demonstrated some. Just everything about it.
Miss Nina Schofield YOU GOT GOING ON !!!!! *****
i Agree 100%
Hello Nina, apart from this insane voice, the meaning of the song is much clearer to me than in the original. That was a very good song for decades. It was a very beautiful and calm song.
But now it belongs to Disturbed. His interpretation is exceptionally well sung. No wonder with this voice and the power. The images support the effect he intended very well.
Greetings from Germany
This cover of Simon and Garfunkel is almost a religious experience. His vocals grab your soul and make not only listen but also feel
My understanding of the lyrics is that Paul Simon saw people sitting in front of the TV (the neon god) and not interacting and communicating. It was a warning that we would lose ourselves and our ability to interact. Now, in this day and age, David and Disturbed have interpreted the lyrics to conform to a society of texting and social media and are lashing out that the original warning was not heeded and we are paying for it.
Ah that makes a lot of sense!
Paul Simon wrote this in the 60’s during the Vietnam war & civil unrest with the hippie movement against the establishment for involving our young men in such a hideous war & also racial unrest. So many with radical ideas. The government with its full powers that be unleashed on people/students voicing in the streets tear gassed beaten up. The songs written during this period had so many meanings for people.
The song is about lack of communication…in this version you can feel the frustration in all the ways to communicate but no one wants to ….his anger and anguish comes out perfectly in the lyrics and tone…perfection!!
I saw this and was like no way you haven’t heard it. I’m so excited!! I this is one of my top 3 covers of all time. In no order: this, The Weeknd - Dirty Diana, and Bad Wolves cover of Zombie. David is a master of this craft.
Vocals both powerful and gentle at other times. Yes the video did take us on a journey with the music and vocals.
In the video at the end, it seems to me as if they're bringing the musical instruments over the chasm to the people who are stuck in silence (talking without speaking, hearing without listening, etc...). It feels like a rescue mission almost.
This is just the right version for THIS crazy times! I know exactly what is meant with the "Neon God's they pray"....😢
Chills run through my body EVERY TIME I hear Disturbs version.. it’s just spectacular! Possibly one of the best most dynamic covers of all time 🔥
You definitely need to check out more David Draman. He is an interesting vocalist, and the way he places emphasis, clarity, and other techniques is really good.
I absolutely adore David both as an amazing artist, but also as an incredible human being.
Good song, should look up his live version he did on Conan
This is amazing but not normal for Disturbed for that check out “down with the sickness” I recommend the video version. You should watch the original sound of silence by Simon and Garfunkel very different vibe.
Hi Nina. Wonderful reaction. I am surprised that you are not familiar with this Simon and Garfunkel song. Paul Simon is a genius songwriter. The original song was so different than this performance. The new interpretation is stunning. There is also a video where they performed it live on the Conan O'Brien Show. I actually like that version a little better.
Ah I think what i meant to say was I have heard the original song but all these covers are very new to me and I've never properly looked at the lyrics before - It's so nice to be able to re-discover a song like this! I'll definitely have to listen to the Conan O'Brien performance too. Thanks so much for watching!
@@ninaschofield Now I get it.
@@ninaschofield so what did you think of the Conan live version. I found it impressive how good that was. Even more chills.
YOU WERE NOT READY FOR THE FRY!!!!!!!!!
All of this song is just stunning.... one of the best covers ever made
Simon and Garfunkel wrote this song really well , but the Interpretation from disturbed is just on point ..... nearly perfect❤❤❤
The final shot in the video shows the people with instruments but no music crossing the water that had separated them from the people who had music but no instruments. Apart neither could express themselves fully, they needed each other. They had to find a way to work together. Communication is a two way exchange. The lyric says, "People talking without speaking, people hearing without listening, People writing songs that voices never shared..." They were isolated. There are many possible interpretations of the song but from what the video presents one could be the impact that segregation has on communicating and understanding others and why that's socially detrimental.
everybody is overwhelmed by this cover..the best ever version
Disturbed did a cover of a Genesis song called Land of Confusion. You should check them both out.
I have heard this before, but I did not sit down and really analyse the Disturbed track until now. Your great reaction, guides me through the track, on what I may have missed. The track is amazing 10/10. His voice is fantastic 10/10. This is one of those tracks which attracts a wide variety of music enthusiasts. There is a voice in this Metal genre like the Disturbed singer which gives people Goosebumps, especially from ladies is: Peter Steele of "Type Negative - Love You To Death".
Simon and Garfunkel created this song but Distributed took it to a whole new level
As a long distance hiking wilderness survivalist , this adaptation of "The sound of silence" resonates with me in my own understanding of its meaning..... I've come to personally know silence and stillness of serenity within the forces of "Nature".... what drove me to this awakening and growth of comprending in the understanding was the falsehood of society.... "Nothing wrong with quiet" ... We can make the next step in our evolutionary journey by first remaining calm minded and focused while contemplating the life lessons that "Nature" shares openly and with moral blindness to us as "humans". ❤ ✌ 👣
Amazing vocals of David Draiman!! Get goosebumps everytime I hear him sing...also his voice control is stunning. I don't know another singer than can actually use vibrato while also using distortion/rasp! .... extremely difficult to do!! This touches your soul in so many ways!
100% agreed, his voice is a force of nature! So much talent!
The people crossing the river in the boat have instruments. The people on the shore are holding sheet music in their hands. I think that is about coming together.
David the singer was so emotional after three hours of laying down the vocals that when he came out to listen to it he was crying, he stood looking away from the band and everyone and they all thought he must've hated it but no he loved it so much it brought him to tears.
I recommend more of Disturbed and also a band from the 70, 80 and 90's called Dire Straits. I recommend their songs Sultans of Swing and Telegraph Road from the 1983 Alchemy Live concert.
I'm sorry but that was the most adorable intro i've ever seen.
Great reaction Nina. I always thought that the Simon & Garfunkel original version was powerful then until Disturbed performed it. It gave me Goosebumps and broke me emotionally, excellent by Disturbed.
Thanks so much for watching!
You definitely want to listen to him sing live…. It’s absolutely CHILLING!!!
I watched an interview with David when he finished recording the song. He said when he stepped out of the booth afterward all the band members were just standing staring at him. After he listened to the recording he said he forgot that he had that good a voice.
Another WOW from a music coach! Love this song and Hold on to memories
I love your reaction and you are very knowledgeable. I'm obsessed with him and this song!
There is nothing better than watching the first time reactions to this cover done by people that know what they are talking about as they are always blown away by the artistry David put into this already amazing song. I love the comment I saw that said the original S&G song was a warning about separating ourselves from those around us while this version conveys the anger that all these years later we haven't listened & are happy to sit on our cellphones instead of talking to the person sitting beside us.
Were can you watch those type of clips?
I watch them on UA-cam, search ‘sound of silence disturbed reactions’ in yet search bar or just ‘sound of silence reactions’ for reactions to other covers
@@mikaelohlson5120 Forgot when the list of reactions appear look for things like ‘singer’, ‘vocal coach’, ‘music teacher’ so on in the title
A must listen is Goeff Castellucci , his cover of this iconic song is amazing
i dont cry often but i had tears listening and watching this version. beautiful
When you listen to this just make sure you have some tissues to hand. Beautiful song
This is our graduation song waaaaaayyyy back in '86.
Written by Paul Simon, it is in part a song about writing songs. It is about blocking external stimuli out so that all you have left are your own thoughts, it then alludes to being able to bring back ideas that you once dreamt about but can't normally recall. It is also interpreted as an inability of people to communicate with each other emotionally.
Paul Simon used to lock himself away in a bathroom in order to do this with only a tap running because he liked that sound apparently.
The Viking theme is because it was used as the theme of 1st series of “Viking” tv. The “neon god” some says refers to the invention of tv They also say that S-G were plaintively singing a warning, Disturbed was an angry rendition to show that people hadn’t got the message and PTX was again a less forceful but still asking the same question. I’m going for a sleep now - too much thinking
Here is my interpretation based upon listing to S&G back when I was a child.
The sound of silence is an affect that is created when people no longer communicate with one another. Now back in the 1960-70s, the television (and the pop culture shown on the television) began to replace simple things like families talking to one another at the dinner table, falling asleep to the TV instead of reading children night time stories, etc. Additionally, television shows began introducing new slangs and jargons that only TV show watchers would understand. This also impacted music and musicians who were now writing TV jingles for shows and commercials instead of ballads. So a "divide" began to develop that "like a cancer grows" creating "people talking without speaking. People hearing without listening." So S&G were basically giving us an advanced warning of this developing phenomena that will "divide" the community.
Now Disturbed has taken the song and added an anger to it for not listening to S&G's warning and actually doubling down with the creation of cellphones/Ipads/internet. As for the video itself, Disturbed is focusing on a specific subset of the community: Musicians and songwriters. Both sides are equally necessary in order for beautiful music to be made. Could Disturbed be upset that they are not "considered" to perform songs by other songwriters?
FYI: Was kind of surprised to see that you have not reacted to any Evanescence. Seems like it would be right in your wheelhouse.
Seen them live and he’s flawless. A lot of metal singers don’t get credit for their talent but are incredible ❤
I Absolutely Love The Way He Sings This OMG I Could Listen To It All Day Every Day
I Don't Think My Neighbors Would Like It But As I Say Don't No One Pay My Rent But Me So If I Want To Listen To It All Day Every Day So Be It ! ! !
I Can't Wait To Hear More Of His Other Music OMG I'm 68 yrs I'm Age It Just Sends Chills and Thrills Through My Whole Body
yeah that resonant sound just goes deep into the soul
I love watching Disturbed shred the souls of these reviewers! The deer-in-the-headlights look they always give... :)
The way I understand it...the broken instruments in the beginning are picked up and taken by boat (with the band) at the end across the water to the people holding the lyrics/songs...essentially to re-unite them
it's a song that builds itself step by step....like those steps that we will have to take towards each other
Metal baby!!
Such a great rendition of this song. There's a fantastic live version (live in Houston) of this on youtube, where Disturbed are joined by Myles Kennedy, who comes in to sing harmony. Absolutely stunning performance, which you might enjoy immensly :)
Check out the live versions of Disturbed performing this!
Classic . Great reaction and explanation of the music .
Written by Paul Simon in 1964. Originally performed by Simon and Garfunkel.
Paul Simon's explanation:
“One of the biggest hang-ups we have today is the inability of people to communicate, not only on an intellectual level, but on an emotional level as well. So you have people unable to touch other people, unable to love other people. This is a song about the inability to communicate. It’s called, “The Sound of Silence”. - Paul Simon 1966
You can see/hear him say this before they begin their performance here:
ua-cam.com/video/DczvzKzNLbU/v-deo.html
Love this more than the original. Check out the Conan Obrien live performance too. Only small issues, but well worth your time. Many reactors do both versions.
The song is about communication and the lack there of. "People talking w/o listening." - in a nutshell. I'm sure someone will expand on this in the comments.
Also, Pentatonix has a popular take on this version.
This video has had hundreds of millions of views for a reason, it's blown peoples minds.
The opening scene shows the instruments SILENCED!
Without a doubt, the best version I have ever heard of this amazing classic. Everything about it is impressive... you should check the Live version. Cheers Nina, have a beautiful week!
I love your music 🎶
Loved your reaction and analysis. I liked the original by Simon and Garfunkel but I absolutely love this version. The only one better is the live one from Conan.
I know this comment is way late but I must say you are so lovely! Your beauty truly is timeless.
This is probably my favourite song version of all time. Amazing lyrics and meaning - while the original was lighter and “before”, this version tells the “after” darker side. Masterclass… and very different from their other work
First time I've heard someone mention that incredible arrangement
I'm 69. I bought the orignial Simon & Garfunkel album. I never thought I would hear a better rendition than the original. I kept an open mind. OMFG. This cover is now the standard. DISTURBED now "owns" this song.
One of the best reactions to this song I have heard. i love the way you pick up things most do not. Well done, Nina. I will be watching you react. I hope your reactions to detail in other songs.
I'll join the chorus of voices recommending the Conan live. Hopefully it's available where you live...
best cover of this song ever
You should look at the live version on the Conan O'Brian show, its was amazing.
The motif you loved is a nod to Alice Coopers trilogy on his Welcome To My Nightmare Album (part 2 of the trilogy, Steven).
One of the most accurate reactions. You are one of the only ones to appreciate the nuance written in this arrangement. AWESOME
This cover by disturbed is beautiful and powerful
Simon, of Simon and Garfunkel, wrote the lyrics. He would walk into his bathroom and run the faucet, and sing due to the nice echo in there, and he'd sing "hello darkness my old friend, I've come to talk with you again". From there the lyrics grew out, during the time of the assassination of JFK and the turmoil of the US due to that.
One of best covers for any song ever
oldschoool❤
for obvious reasons it is popular to listen/react to the live version. but this studio/video production is perfection in its ability to inextricably bond the emotions from the vocal, the instrumental, and the visual. each element relies on and plays off of the others