Been listing since 67, when at 7 I heard them on the radio. Can't believe Mo's been gone 20 years and Robin what, 11 now? There will never be a group that comes close.
Robin Gibb....one of the best vibrato voices in musical history. Never to be repeated or duplicated in this life time. I was a teenager when this came out and remember it like it was yesterday. Music of today can not touch this. I can not remember some of todays music that was put out last year. The Gibb brothers music shall last us a lifetime.
Correction: Pop-music of today can not touch this. Just one example of a fantastic musician and singer of today is Devin Townsend. Very different genre(s) but he is fantastic in everything he does.
Robin is NATHANIEL ROBERTO'S idol he has a version of this beautiful song please watch him if you have time and if it's ok with you please subscribe it would be a great help for him thank you 🙏🙏
Robin WAS the lead singer for a time, but then falsetto came in, and Barry could do it. Robin left the band once, because he felt Barry was getting all the attention. They were ALL so talented, and some one has to be the lead singer. He came back, and I'm so glad he did. Bee Gees forever!!! And now Barry is a Christian, thanks to Ricky Scaggs, and thinking of moving to Nashville and recording solo. That would be great. He'd be busy, and it would help his sorrow. August 20, 2017
Watching this video Dec 23 , 2022 . There's something special about the harmony that comes within a family . They all contribute to the unique sound called the Bee Gees . I still have some vinyl records .
Does any else think this is a singing duel between Robin and Barry? Robin is so good that Barry has to sing even better. It results in amazing vocals by both brothers. Personally I give the win to Robin, but I was always partial to his voice, and this was the first Bee Gees song I ever heard when I was 9 or 10. I was pretty blown away.
It's small minded to come on here and criticize how they look. It was from a different era - just shut up and enjoy the harmony that can't really be taught when it comes to this trio.
Sad that nobody has commented on this wonderful video for over 5 years !! I'm now 62 and these tunes still bring back lovely memories of my 1st love..... and how their music was just so timeless.
Random Hong Kong-er here. You probably won't believe it, but everyone here were crazy for Bee Gees in the 60s~80s. Many people from those generations can hardly say a complete sentence in English, but they will always be able to sing or hum along with Bee Gees' songs. That's how influential the Gibbs brothers were, or still are.
I remember, as a little kid, when "I Started a Joke" came out and I fell in love with this song and would cry when I heard it on the radio. I never knew who did the song, but I will always remember it. When the Bee Gees started their meteoric rise to disco fame, I liked these guys, too. It was only later, that I found out that the Bee Gees also did "I Started a Joke", so I deduced that I was a Bee Gees fan, long before the 70s. =)
I could have written this post. My experience also. This song and some other earlier songs, I didn't know who song them when I was young. Seems like I have always been a fan also.
The song wax said by Barry Gibb that Robins song I started a joke had a righteous content and I knew then exactly what it was about amazing for someone so young
Barry had a beautiful voice, but there was something very special about Robin. His voice reaches to the soul and makes you free for at least 3 minutes. Beautiful beautiful
Their songs give me the chills!!!!!!! I am 70 now and adore them and love their music as much if not more than I did the first time I heard them!!!!!!!!
Say what ya like, but The Bee Gees is one of the greatest bands in the history of pop music and these are two of their best. Fantastic Video. Perfect Performance.
I love you always, Robin. No band will ever again get even close to the Bee Gees. I''ve watched bands for 58 years, and the Bees Gees are right up there among the very best. RIP Robin, you are just precious!
Cette chanson je m en souviendrai tte ma vie je l a dansais avec mon boy Friend du moment..et il est parti ..il y a 50 ans de cela ..vous imaginez des souvenirs qu on oublie pas .
ROBIN IS VERY CUTE AND I LOVE HIS LONG RED HAIR HE IS SO SWEET WITH HIS BIG BEAUTIFUL BROTHER BARRY SINGING HIS HEART OUT AND YES IT IS VERY SAD LOSING ROBIN HE WAS LIKE ROBIN HOOD AND HE WAS TOO YOUNG TO DIE HE SHOULD BE ALIVE TODAY
Rest in peace Robin, Andy and Maurice. You will never be forgotten. You were part of my childhood and adulthood and will always be a part of my life forever
Robin Gibb had a tremendous voice. Always enjoyed his leads. I'm so thankful God gave us the Bee Gees. Great contributions to music! Best wishes to Barry.
How beautiful and young the boys were then. These songs were my mother’s and mine favorites. I would sing these pretty songs as a child and so would my mother.
It's impossible to see this video and don't cry. Sweet memories of The Bee Gees, specially Maurice and Robin, cause they had gone to eternity, R.I.P. brothers, I love you and keep you allways in my heart.
The sweetness of robin's eyes struck me the very first time I saw the group on TV. I was in primary school....and I have never forgotten them since then...
My favorite song by the BeeGees, what an incredible lyrics,it get's me evertime i hear it. The passion and emotions sung by Robin is felt deeply. The BeeGees song writing capabilities are right up there with Lennon&McCartney,Jagger&richard, no doubt about it!
They were amazing men, they did it all write, sing, produce. Robin had the most amazing beautiful voice I've ever hear. They were the greatest group ever.
I loved only classical music,til I heard the Bee Gees on a rock station back in the sixties.Not meaning to stay tuned listening to the Detroit rock station,but I was completely taken in by the group's music, especially Robin's singing of the song, (Massachusetts.) Have admired their music since that time, so long ago.
Love all the Bee Gees songs. i do miss Maurice and Robin gone to soon but not forgotten. God bless the Gibbs family. Thank you Barry for not quitting keep up the good music... like to see more of your daughter and son and MAURICE DAUGHTER. they have the Bee Gee"s sound. God Bless all of you are in my prayers.
Pues la mayoria opina que la mejor voz es la de Robin, y era mejir por supuesto, eres fan de Barry pero mira lo que opinan todos,por que Robin gustaba mas a ls gente?
@@estelacobas4416Most people think Barry has a better voice. It’s just that most people aren’t concerned with comparing the brothers like some insecure Robin fans are. Most Barry fans just enjoy Barry’s voice without having to bring the others into it, or without saying anything. Robin has a small, determined, vocal group of fans on here that try their best to drum up business for Robin. You know that’s a fact. Robin has a unique voice. I’ve heard Barry call Robin’s voice unique, too, but unique doesn’t mean the best. Now some may like his voice best and there’s nothing wrong with that. But some really love Barry’s sweet, soulful, gorgeous voice and there’s nothing wrong with that, either. Robin fans are just too insecure.
Robin's voice was phenomenal.
Agreed ❤❤
Superb voice Robin!!! Love you!!!
A talent like robins is once in a lifetime. Sing with the angels where you belong. Missed here but we have your music.
Quelle voix magnifique j aime pour toujours .
You got that right 😊😊😊😊❤❤
His voice was so beautiful. Always saddened me when the older songs had that horrible falsetto. It wasn't the same minus his vocals.
Been listing since 67, when at 7 I heard them on the radio. Can't believe Mo's been gone 20 years and Robin what, 11 now? There will never be a group that comes close.
not even close
Robin had a beautiful voice!!!❤️💋💋🌹
I agree.
Robin had a voice of an angel. 💖😢
I agree.
Robin Gibb....one of the best vibrato voices in musical history. Never to be repeated or duplicated in this life time. I was a teenager when this came out and remember it like it was yesterday. Music of today can not touch this. I can not remember some of todays music that was put out last year. The Gibb brothers music shall last us a lifetime.
Correction: Pop-music of today can not touch this. Just one example of a fantastic musician and singer of today is Devin Townsend. Very different genre(s) but he is fantastic in everything he does.
In a nutshell.
@@SecondSince I would suggest that you with four likes; and the other person who has over 160.
Means you've lost the suggestion.
What about Michael Jacksons Vibrato?
⁰0⁰pppp⁰p⁰pp⁰⁰00⁰⁰00000000000
Robin was such a beautiful singer and a beautiful man. With his hair
The first time I've seen The Bee Gees on a black & White TV; I'm 69 now but a teenager back then. RIP Robin,
grandissimo Robin, una delle più grandi canzoni d'amore di sempre. Ci manchi
Bee Gees are the greatest Singer and Songwriter. They Touch my deep soul somuch.. Robin ist so great ...
i think robin is the gem of the beegees group
GREAT voice.
I think Barry is.
Robin may be a gem, but Barry's the mine.💎
@@kthor Good one.
I luved Robins voice i luv the Bee Gees Brilliant Xxxx
Love you Robin ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I've always felt that no one should ever attempt to sing "I started a joke". That song belongs to Robin's voice only.
I’ve written many, mostly unread, paragraphs and comments on that very fact.
The song should END at 2:24.
Robin is NATHANIEL ROBERTO'S idol he has a version of this beautiful song please watch him if you have time and if it's ok with you please subscribe it would be a great help for him thank you 🙏🙏
@@daytonagreg8765 🙄
And no one should sing To Love Somebody but Barry.
@@daytonagreg8765Barry wasn’t singing I Started a Joke. He was singjng First of May. Don’t be selfish. It was Barry’s turn.
Robin... Simply the best
Barry....simply superb!
He had such a beautiful voice
His voice overcame the bucket look.......
cruel, but funny
Good
@@cpospish ignorant, rude and false. Robin was attractive. He didn't have the luxury of getting braces during that time. Show us what you look like.
but not a beautiful hairstyle ...
Robin Gibb's singing was truly one of a kind.
yes, may favorite from the Bee Gee's too
absolutely.👍
Robin WAS the lead singer for a time, but then falsetto came in, and Barry could do it. Robin left the band once, because he felt Barry was getting all the attention. They were ALL so talented, and some one has to be the lead singer. He came back, and I'm so glad he did. Bee Gees forever!!! And now Barry is a Christian, thanks to Ricky Scaggs, and thinking of moving to Nashville and recording solo. That would be great. He'd be busy, and it would help his sorrow. August 20, 2017
+Carol Wade There was no era where Robin was the main lead singer for the Bee Gees, pre or post "falsetto".
Both Baz and Rob were lead in the early days. Rob's leads were the first to chart.
Started listening in 1967 and still listening in 2020 ! Amazing music !
Watching this video Dec 23 , 2022 . There's something special about the harmony that comes within a family . They all contribute to the unique sound called the Bee Gees . I still have some vinyl records .
FOREVER IN MY HEART AND SOUL. I MISS YOU ROBIN . FANTASTIC VOICE .BEST.
Anos 60.
Dècada de ouro!
A cultura no seu apogeu!
Pena que um apagao cultural, viria dècadas depois!
Santo Antonio do Monte.
MG.
BRASIL.
@@alvimarcosta8453 CALITATEA era un lucru pe care se punea preț atunci ☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️
How old are you
Magnificent! Robin's voice just vibrates with every note. What an excellent voice.
HERMOSO!!
@scottwilliams1709 You words did indeed bring a smile to my face. Also, listening to the Bee Gees always gives me a lift and brightens my spirits
Lib sync.
yes it vibrates for me to turn this off
@@thankyouforyourcompliance7386 No, this is live. That is, if you meant, "LiP sync".
Does any else think this is a singing duel between Robin and Barry? Robin is so good that Barry has to sing even better. It results in amazing vocals by both brothers. Personally I give the win to Robin, but I was always partial to his voice, and this was the first Bee Gees song I ever heard when I was 9 or 10. I was pretty blown away.
It's not a competition or duel between anyone, unless Robin saw it that way, which he often did.
Personally I give the win to Barry
@@kthorI am sure they had a sibling rivalry, like most brothers do.
@@raysmith2694 Yep. And Barry was a peacemaker & didn't like confrontation. Robin was moody & didn't often agree, which should tell you everything.
It's small minded to come on here and criticize how they look. It was from a different era - just shut up and enjoy the harmony that can't really be taught when it comes to this trio.
Those who criticize their faces are just people who has no talent at all,they just did is to be look good even though they ain't.
@@EDUCPHILcom com certeza absoluta irmão,bee Gees cantavam com o coração, parece até que cantava para anjos 😢
Música triste e perfeita
You got that right
I think they look gorgeous ❤
All i can say is I'm crying hearing and watching this guys.
Sad that nobody has commented on this wonderful video for over 5 years !! I'm now 62 and these tunes still bring back lovely memories of my 1st love..... and how their music was just so timeless.
Greatest band of their time!!!!!!!!!!
I’m 61 and only people our aged know good music
This kind of music went straight to your heart
I go right back to the start of these gifted boys, loved them then and still do..Barry still my favourite ❤
I started a Joke geschreven voor domme regeringsleiders .
The generation that grew up with cell phones will never know, they live on Tik Tok
My daughter was born on 1 May.
I always send this song video on her birthday every year without fail.
Robins voice is so angelic,the world lost something really special for ever,I’m so glad I was here to hear this beautiful music
Robin's vibrato is out of this world! He is one of my very favorite singers in this world
Robin really had a great and unique voice
Wonderful song and the only person who can sing. It. R.I.P. God bless you for 2023.
One of My fav ❤❤
I love Robin. His voice soothes and relaxes me.
Random Hong Kong-er here. You probably won't believe it, but everyone here were crazy for Bee Gees in the 60s~80s. Many people from those generations can hardly say a complete sentence in English, but they will always be able to sing or hum along with Bee Gees' songs. That's how influential the Gibbs brothers were, or still are.
God bless you Robin Gibb You were one of the best vocalist on earth
Robin has a beautiful unique voice🤗😘🥰❤️♥️love you Robin 💋💋💋R.I.P
The best ever in the world. I still listen everyday. Love them. B
A very good song by Robin and his brother. Best regard worldcall.
I love them, I'm wailing.
love this man's voice just amazing so wish he was still here to sing to me Thank You Robin!
I remember, as a little kid, when "I Started a Joke" came out and I fell in love with this song and would cry when I heard it on the radio. I never knew who did the song, but I will always remember it. When the Bee Gees started their meteoric rise to disco fame, I liked these guys, too. It was only later, that I found out that the Bee Gees also did "I Started a Joke", so I deduced that I was a Bee Gees fan, long before the 70s. =)
I could have written this post. My experience also. This song and some other earlier songs, I didn't know who song them when I was young. Seems like I have always been a fan also.
The song wax said by Barry Gibb that Robins song I started a joke had a righteous content and I knew then exactly what it was about amazing for someone so young
Realmente é uma música lindíssima...
It's my favorite. I listen to it over and over. My favorite is Robin♥️♥️🥰
Twin brother Maurice plays piano 🎹 his voice is also incredible
Robin's voice was my favorite. Always such a sweet tone to his voice. Natural talent for all three brothers.
I Started a Joke Love that song and every Robin Gibb performance of it that I've found on UA-cam.
Robin Gibb - one of the finest voices of his generation. Simply divine
The Bee Gees, the finest voices in generations!
je cesserai JAMAIS d'écouter cette chanson MERCI MERCI je vous aimes
Couldn’t agree with you more. Robin will forever be remembered for his unbelievable vibrato 😢❤
The 60's Bee Gees were pretty incredible!
Yes they were. Wish more people listened to their 60s stuff its so iconic
@@applescruffs2894 Love your name. They should also listen to their Australian recordings, made while serving their apprenticeship out here.
Very early BeeGees they were heaven sent
Barry had a beautiful voice, but there was something very special about Robin. His voice reaches to the soul and makes you free for at least 3 minutes. Beautiful beautiful
very well said👍🏼
Barry had an excellent voice! Robin's had too much quiver going on.😵💫
This song still gives me chills, it's so poignant.
Their songs give me the chills!!!!!!! I am 70 now and adore them and love their music as much if not more than I did the first time I heard them!!!!!!!!
Agreed
When Robin sings the bridge here in "I Started A Joke," I got serious chills! What a voice he had! Anyone who doesn't like this music has no soul.
Agreed. The falsetto at the end of his song always gets me.
Cathy Wood:well said...
me too,everytime!
@@JuIietaAmezcua
I've never understood why Barry got more lead vocals than Robin.
@@edwardlayden6935 probably because he wrote everything.
" Till I finally died, which starting the whole whole living . . . "
Rest in peace, the whole The Bee Gees, we love you, and love this song.
Why whole? Barry still alive
Apeng Great I know, that comment scared me for a second
Barry still alive bruh
Yes we do
Barry is still alive And also Colin Petersen as well
Omg...Robin ...you sang so emotional in this clip!
Robin, such a beautiful voice
Say what ya like, but The Bee Gees is one of the greatest bands in the history of pop music and these are two of their best. Fantastic Video. Perfect Performance.
Agree
I’m an eye surgeon. I play The Bee Gees in the OR every week. Everyone loves it. Their talent is insane
AGREED😊😊❤
Concordo plenamente.
@@ariplatt8192 oi
What a voice! RIP Robin
What a freakin voice!!! The Bee Gees have a sound like no one ever, and it's stunning.
Barry's voice is incredible!♥️
Robin stoked my heart and early bee gees ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️💕
Stole my heart*
Brilliant!! The quality of their songwriting and performing was amazing! Definitely one of the most distinctive and important bands of all time!
🤣😂🤣😂
POETS, ALL!!!!
My favourite bee gees song all ways will be feel sad now he is gone.
Robin et ses frères nous ont fait de si beaux cadeaux avec leur musique et leur voix.
I love you always, Robin. No band will ever again get even close to the Bee Gees. I''ve watched bands for 58 years, and the Bees Gees are right up there among the very best. RIP Robin, you are just precious!
Sorry folks, Ive watched all this bands too.. But no one got over Beatles...
Including Bee Gees the biggest Beatles's fans!!
That is because the Beatles were the first boy band.
Randi Holbrook It is because they were the best period! Having said that the bee gees are still incredibly great.
Well said
Robin was an awesome vocalist that vibrato wil never be duplicated
One of my all time favorite songs. I remember the first time hearing it on the radio. Robins vocals are hauntingly beautiful. He is adorable
the best song all time. The voice of Robin is very beatiful, for me 1° in the world. Thank you Bee Gees...
Two of my favourite Bee Gees songs together - effortless and haunting at the same time
Beautiful to look at, and oh so beautiful to listen too
Cette chanson je m en souviendrai tte ma vie je l a dansais avec mon boy Friend du moment..et il est parti ..il y a 50 ans de cela ..vous imaginez des souvenirs qu on oublie pas .
Robin looked like an Irish Setter sweet puppy dog just adorable . heart-wrenching beautiful voice so sad he's gone
... a composite of various British Romantic poets of the 19th century.
Only 20 years old too.
ROBIN IS VERY CUTE AND I LOVE HIS LONG RED HAIR HE IS SO SWEET WITH HIS BIG BEAUTIFUL BROTHER BARRY SINGING HIS HEART OUT AND YES IT IS VERY SAD LOSING ROBIN HE WAS LIKE ROBIN HOOD AND HE WAS TOO YOUNG TO DIE HE SHOULD BE ALIVE TODAY
Rest in peace Robin, Andy and Maurice. You will never be forgotten. You were part of my childhood and adulthood and will always be a part of my life forever
🙏🏻
😔🙏
Robin Gibb had a tremendous voice. Always enjoyed his leads. I'm so thankful God gave us the Bee Gees. Great contributions to music! Best wishes to Barry.
How beautiful and young the boys were then. These songs were my mother’s and mine favorites. I would sing these pretty songs as a child and so would my mother.
They talented....and in clothes...not like today's talentless half naked pretend to be singers...Well done Bee Gees
Just beautiful
Maurice is a great piano player! I will always miss him and Robin.
I miss the two Gibb brothers. Their songs are the music of my life. RIP beautiful souls.
It's impossible to see this video and don't cry. Sweet memories of The Bee Gees, specially Maurice and Robin, cause they had gone to eternity, R.I.P. brothers, I love you and keep you allways in my heart.
What a song.
I like his hairdo! Loved the Bee Gees!
Robin is most special and my favourite.
Robin fantastyczny
Very very special
Robin is why I like the band - a true one of a kind and a kind soul.
Barry is most special & my favorite!♥️
HOW CAN U NOT LIKE THIS SONG
Robin had such a beautiful voice what a gift ..... R.I.P. my friend and thank you.
Che voce aveva sto ragazzo non ci sarà mai nessuno come lui per sempre Robin❤❤❤❤
Grande Miriam Franco da
The sweetness of robin's eyes struck me the very first time I saw the group on TV. I was in primary school....and I have never forgotten them since then...
I loved Robin's voice from this first song. Powerful. Great singer, writer, and person from what i have seen.
Robin Gibb : what a sound !
Beautiful Robin! I love these brothers...so sad they're not here with us anymore...we love you Barry hang in there!
So true I never can get enough to listen to there songs and music
Robin was a great singer! Love you Robin rest in peace
They were all great singers, especially Barry.
I LIKE THESE EARLY SONGS BY THE BEE GEES MORE THAN THE ONES THEY RECORDED DURING THE DISCO ERA
I do too, awesome lyrics
ALAN GREEN I agree, beautiful harmony, clear voices.
+ALAN GREEN I must be in a minority. I like both eras.
Did anyone see The Bee Gees tribute a few weeks ago? It was great. So sad that Barry is the only one left.
I agree with you Alan, I was always disappointed once they tried to join the disco crowd.
Oh that beautiful voice!!! Can NEVER be duplicated!!! ❤❤❤
Hello friend 🥰🌹
@@deanbillyciao amico!🙋😍😘💘🌅
Love Robin's voice, soulful singing. Barry's so handsome.
Ce sont des années incroyables et qu'elle voix, la voix de Robin Gibb🙏🎶☁️🎈👍
You guys will live forever in our hears.. love your music so much
My favorite song by the BeeGees, what an incredible lyrics,it get's me evertime i hear it. The passion and emotions sung by Robin is felt deeply. The BeeGees song writing capabilities are right up there with Lennon&McCartney,Jagger&richard, no doubt about it!
Robin you were an angel here on Earth only God gives this kind of voice to one such as you & Barry what memories .
It's First of May 2020 just passed and it's the same old feeling listening to the Bee Gees. It hurts to know Robin and Maurice are gone
ua-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/v-deo.html
They were amazing men, they did it all write, sing, produce. Robin had the most amazing beautiful voice I've ever hear. They were the greatest group ever.
Rip brothers
É verdade, o melhor grupo musical de todos os tempos.
This is the BEST song they ever did. RIP mate!
I wish I could sing
John Hutchins Without a doubt the best.
Learn to play an instrument instead? I can't sing for toffee but I'll quite happily sing along to songs like this. Mind you I do live on my own😄
I miss the 70s and that music era. I was a child of the 70s.my mom always listened to the Bee gees and I still love their music to this day.
I loved the early stuff, fantastic lyrics and vocals.
Gorgeous Barry and his sweet, soulful voice.💗
I loved only classical music,til I heard the Bee Gees on a rock station back in the sixties.Not meaning to stay tuned listening to the Detroit rock station,but I was completely taken in by the group's music, especially Robin's singing of the song, (Massachusetts.) Have admired their music since that time, so long ago.
Love all the Bee Gees songs. i do miss Maurice and Robin gone to soon but not forgotten. God bless the Gibbs family. Thank you Barry for not quitting keep up the good music... like to see more of your daughter and son and MAURICE DAUGHTER. they have the Bee Gee"s sound. God Bless all of you are in my prayers.
Robin Gibb Best Voice !
Barry Gibb has the overall best voice in music history!
@@kthor THANK YOU FOR SAYING THAT ABOUT MY HUSBAND BARRY SAYS THANK YOU
Pues la mayoria opina que la mejor voz es la de Robin, y era mejir por supuesto, eres fan de Barry pero mira lo que opinan todos,por que Robin gustaba mas a ls gente?
@@estelacobas4416Most people think Barry has a better voice. It’s just that most people aren’t concerned with comparing the brothers like some insecure Robin fans are. Most Barry fans just enjoy Barry’s voice without having to bring the others into it, or without saying anything. Robin has a small, determined, vocal group of fans on here that try their best to drum up business for Robin. You know that’s a fact.
Robin has a unique voice. I’ve heard Barry call Robin’s voice unique, too, but unique doesn’t mean the best. Now some may like his voice best and there’s nothing wrong with that. But some really love Barry’s sweet, soulful, gorgeous voice and there’s nothing wrong with that, either.
Robin fans are just too insecure.
@@BGWhispererYep, so true! Almost every comment is by an obsessed fan who knew Robin would never measure up to Barry's invaluable vocals.