Its gonna be really funny seeing all the comments complain I didn't like the expansion as a whole when I address that in the first two minutes. Funny how some people love to be hateful without actually watching the video🤭 (Im also interested if anyone can spot the music I used from a particular show, bonus points of you know which tracks)
I love your videos, except for the way you communicate your talking points. You come off as an irritated 20-year-old brat. That's not exactly your fault though (I talk like that too btw), people are just less likely to pay attention to you. I know, it sucks.
TBF, Lore in Destiny has always served as a way to steer the ship back on track when the campaign would not, in addition to flesh out the whole world of Destiny. But the fact that almost every expansion heavily relied on the lore to keep it just somewhat understandable is shockign to say the least. I say this as someone who likes reading the lore
The lore has mostly been well done and interesting, credit where due. But you're right, it has been overused to right the ship and that's not good. Jez talked about that in his Lightfall story analysis, and he's 100% right. Lore should not be considered "the story." Lore should expand on the story and give it more context for those interested enough to seek it out.
That was the taken kings problem, it has a solid campaign fun wise, but narrative? Nope. Gotta collect all 50 calcified fragments if you wanna learn anything about the hive.
Dunno about that one. Deep Stone Lullaby just hard carries the soundtrack for beyond light so far and above everything that came before and after. The atmosphere and the dialogue as you do the space walk and that track kicks in. One of the best Destiny moments ever.
@@Chaotic_H3LL nah come on the raid tracks for one are fire, the music overall is quite good with not a lot of weak spots, which I can't say the same for some other expansions
Which it should, bungie in general needs more flack for sunsetting, seasons too. Seasons were such a waste for destiny's potential over the years, the content might not have been that great in the seasons but the fact they wasted time making something that would go away from anywhere from 3 months to a year is inexcusable, my only issue with people shitting on bungie during the lightfall era was everyone focused on microtransactions and the bad dlc and not the glaring problem of seasons.
Btw, about us using darkness despite the exo stranger saying we gave in, it's explained VERY SLIGHTLY, in the campign, and also agian in lightfall, that we control stasis. So basically, stasis in most timelines takes control of us because we didn't have the strength to overcome it or the discipline to control it. To use stasis, we have to bind it to our will completely, like holding down your leash when your dog sees a squirrel. This is again explained in lightfall multiple times with Osiris at first thinking we need to control Strand like we do with Stasis, this leads to the whole back and forth between Nimbus and Osiris anout control vs flow when trying to learn strand. (Which means our and Osiris' understanding of stasis and lack of listening to Nimbus is what killed Rohan...). So basically, in most timlines, we let stasis overpower us and give in to darkness and rage. Or we dont use stasis at all, and we have no way to fight back against Eramis. But this timeline, we control and discipline stasis so that we may safely use it to defeat Eramis. The problem is that this is hardly (but still done) explained in the campaign.
This is actually wrong. I refer you to the lore book Bitter, "The Crux was broken." This lore book details how the Exo Stranger came to control Stasis, and her upbringing as a Bray went against her initial efforts and she lost control of Stasis. Why? Because she tried to control it. She comes to control Stasis because she learns to let go of that control. We never struggle with this in game, because the player character instantly masters every power they come across with Strand being the only exception. Lightfall effectively establishes that to use Darkness powers or abilities, you have to surrender control. That could, in hindsight, explain why Eramis doesn't seem to have full control over Stasis; she believes it is not only her gift, but it is her right and hers alone. She tries to control it to such a degree that what happens to Elsie happens to her, and unlike Elsie she doesn't have help to break free. Why and how the player Guardian "falls" in the Dark Timeline is never stated or explained. It could possibly be the Witness having a direct line to our Ghost somehow, something that I don't think it does to ANY other Ghost. It could possibly be a reference to how many players joked about joining the Darkness when Beyond Light originally previewed Stasis. EDIT: I am double checking the Dark Future lorebook just to fact check myself. It seems that, in that timeline, the Black Heart had corrupted the Guardians sent to investigate it; those Guardians presumably including us, given Destiny 1's story. We were corrupted long before Stasis even entered the Solar System there. As an aside, there is a hint there that Stasis cannot be controlled by mere strength alone. What this tells me is that Bungie cannot keep their own story straight. Actually, this makes Lightfall's story even worse, because with this knowledge we should not have struggled with Strand AT ALL.
discussing destiny campaigns pre witch queen is terribly boring since they are so uninteresting and ass in terms of narrative and gameplay. Looking forward to your analysis of the witch queen/lightfall/final shape trilogy since even the worst of those (being lightfall) , has some redeeming qualities
What's so annoying about Eramis is that she was so boring, cringy, poorly written, and wierdly animated in Beyond light. But come Season of the plunder when she came back she was way more interesting, then even more so in season of the seraph. Then she came back agian in season of the defiance to save mithrax, now in the final shape she abandoned the witness, which was foreshadowed at the end of season of the seraph and defiance. Now she's teased to return in episode: revenant. It's so annyoing how interesting the idea of eramis is, despite how poorly she was handled in the expansion where she was the main villian, but now that shes no longer the main threat for obvious reasons, shes WAY more interesting.
@@filipgasic2642 It's so odd to me how whenever they make a new villain they tend to immediately kill them off in a raid but older villains get to have real effects on the story. Nezerac and Rhulk should have been much more important but instead Calus gets all the spotlight as a deciple of the witness. Even the witness is a new villain imo. While he did appear in older dlcs we didn't really know it was him nor see him until lightfall and then he's killed in tfs where all his lore is revealed. Characters like savathun, calus (till we killed him) and eramis get to keep popping up for no good reason. Xivu Arath is kinda a step in the right direction but she's probably gonna die in 1 dlc too.
it's clear that the design for eramis clashed heavily with making her an antagonist. her design works far better with her being an anti-hero type character.
6:12 The Eliksni don't *need* Servitors to generate Ether, but other methods are less efficient due to the scavenger-esque nature that has become of their people. Actually, in terms of story, this is one of the few points I really enjoyed, as we know from Destiny 1 (without delving into lore) that the Eliksni built the Servitors in the shape of the Traveler as a form of reverence. Eramis destroying one in front of her new house with Darkness power is actually a huge message in-world. I think they fumbled the aftermath, not really knowing what to do with Eramis and House Salvation, but in Beyond Light, this actually got me a little hyped.
6:30 hey Nanokk, about the servidor thing, its stabilished in a campaing, i think during the red war but dont quote me in that, that the Eliksni as a race that lived under the traveler's light long ago, venerates servidors because they are like an effigy to the traveler (along with the ether thing) So Eramis destroying a servidor with stasis is meant to represent her shattering the obsession the Eliksni had with the light. Its a cool and meaningful scene, probably the most well thought scene in this entire expansion... A shame it is tied to poor storytelling
I know you said you'd disregard unstated lore comments, but I can't help myself. The reason why Eramis destroying that Servator was a big shocker to the Fallen is because they are extremely revered among their kind. Not only, as you stated, they create the ether they need to live, but they were made spherical to be in the image of the Traveler, and in fact, Fallen treat machines really highly due to the Traveler itself being a Machine God to them. So Eramis destroying that Servator, and having all House Salvation Servators be desecrated, is her essentially spitting on the image of her former god and saying "we don't need to worship the Traveler anymore!", and to instead join the Witness, who will give them the salvation they desire.
I would disagree on the idea that Europa is boring. It was on of the coolest and unique aesthetics in the game where you have such a barren landscape contrasted by the massive fallen city in the north and then the futuristic bray labs. Not to mention the incredible skyboxes. It is way more diverse than any other location aside from the pale heart in my opinion.
I just deleted a character recently just to replay the Beyond Light campaign and i can honestly say its really not boring i find the story quite interesting also learning about stasis as the campaign progressed was quite fun.
I agree. I also love Europa too. It’s my favorite destination in the game lol. I can’t argue that The Witch Queen and Final Shape campaigns may be objectively better, I think Beyond Light is my favorite in terms of just the fun I had with it. I personally loved Beyond Light lol
One thing I think you touch upon is the return of bag story telling. Forsaken and Shadowkeep had some grim themes that broke away from the cartoonish tone of year 1. This expansion just seemed to be not as narratively dark as I hoped considering that we are supposed to be helping the fallen escape a brutal dictator, the introduction of the dark vanguard, and the introduction of darkness powers. It just did not seem to be as compelling when shown in game because the game did a horrible job SHOWING the struggles that characters were going through unlike forsaken and shadowkeep.
0:50 Just stumbled on this video today, but THANK YOU for analyzing Destiny campaigns in this fashion. I ask people all the time, and have yet to receive a concrete response..."tell me the entire story of Destiny 2, just using free in-game content and expansions, no external lore or seasonal stuff that's removed...and tell me, honestly, if that sounds like a cohesive narrative." The amount of CRITICAL story beats that took place during seasons, that specifically build up expansions, that are NOT present in the game to replay anymore, is insane. Final Shape, for a person who wasn't playing during the last two years of seasons, will likely not hit anywhere near as powerfully as the hardcore pre-order goblin dropping $100 every 12 months on content that's mostly sight unseen.
@acoustic_. No, friend. Reread my comment. "Tell me Destiny 2's story ONLY using free intro content AND expansions...NOT content that doesn't exist anymore." That's the problem. The free intro content and expansions MISSING the seasonal story beats? Horrible skeleton of a story that makes little sense and removes most build up and gravity from bigger climaxes. Like Final Shape, for instance. If a person didn't experience Uldren returning as a Guardian and getting his memory back...hell, if all they saw was Uldren killing Cayde, then sees him in the Traveler, what does it mean to that person to see Crow and Cayde making nice? Catch my drift?
@acoustic_. I mean yeah, they made 3 of them free when TFS launched, so yes technically, those too. But Lightfall still costs money, I meant that one too. In the exercise, I mean...JUST the expansions and free stuff that still exists, like the intro, NOT seasonal content OR the first four campaigns that were removed. The point I'm making is...the seasonal content that was removed, and to an extent the first four campaigns...help build up a lot of a tension and details in later releases that lose some punch without that context. And since they can't be replayed, how would a new player, who only played the first Forsaken mission, connect the dots to how Uldren (they don't even know he's crow when they reach Final Shape) is an ally leading the charge into the Traveler. 🤷♂️
Ngl I like Europa better than neomuna at least it makes sense that it’s a barren empty space where as neomuna is supposed to be a lived in city and doesn’t feel like it at all
@@Nanokk_ I agree with your take on the eventide ruins and how cool it could have been. but for some reason bungie hates vertical maps and city maps which sucks because I think they could make a really good one. also I hate the 3 area map structure they have with a majority of the destinations
Can I JUST SAY YOUR AMAZING AND I LOVE THESE VIDEOS! 1. Beyond light is the best expansion tho 2. I can’t wait for lightfall video. Please include many funny moments on what the Veil is Tho. Thanks love you!/
Love the video. I made sone few funny ideas fir future videos if you like them For Witch Queen: Witch is winning! Lightfall: We are falling Final shape: The line is drawn Made these Catchy based on the themes of the titles you did here
Destiny 2 Beyond Light in Content: this was when sunsetting occurred pretty much killing off all the fun weapons. It felt like you were being forced to pay for having most of your gear become useless and prior campaigns vaulted. It was done for reasons I understand but the approach and the lack of upfront new content really came off as bad faith practice. Your video helped me understand why playing the game during this time in its lifecycle it felt so hollow and half baked.
When I look to play a video game, I’m looking to be entertained. The fact that I didn’t have a single memorable or fun moment through the campaign speaks volumes about BL.
The DLC's setting was supposed to be Encaledas instead of Europa, with the Scarlet Keep serving as the original Deep Stone Crypt. I believe this change was due to budget limitations at Bungie, which forced them to reuse existing assets to meet their DLC plans and prioritize upgrading the game engine. Originally, Beyond Light was intended as a rough draft for Destiny 3. Destiny 2 was seen as a temporary solution since its launch, plagued by bugs, frustrating developer tools, and only basic features. At that time, Bungie was more focused on venturing into the Chinese mobile gaming market with pay-to-win games, which led to their decision to leave Activision, especially after realizing that Activision had generated $1 billion in revenue from Eververse. However, this plan was disrupted when the Chinese government started banning video games. Subsequently, Bungie decided to upgrade the engine and continue with Destiny 2 until ultimately being acquired by Sony. This upgrade wasn't as comprehensive as developing a brand-new game, but it allowed for some quality-of-life improvements without disrupting the game's uptime. In short, Bungie kept changing long-term plans and was in budget mode. So they pinched every penny. The lockdowns had their challenges, but they probably weren't the reason BL sucked.
honestly put it really well. when beyond light works it works. crazy how the majority of d2's seasons have better stories. they tend to be full of lore so i think its why i see it like that. happy to see your sub count go up :]
It's so hard for me to imagine there was a time when not even the baseline expectations for an expansion campaign could be met. Stuff like a well paced coherent story, actual difficulty in missions, actually impactful cutscenes. This stuff that we take for granted now literally didn't exist before witch queen. Back in shadowkeep and beyond light Bungie strung together a bunch of patrol objectives and 3 or 4 missions and called it a campaign. Those were truly the dark ages and I have no idea how I even tolerated it.
2:26 I know it seems extremely minor... But this cutscene (Or at least a particular part of it) has stuck out to me for how "jank" it is... It feels like the discussion being had should be in a different setting or something, and at the end when they trace a signal to being somewhere on the planet, they proclaim it as if they've literally just teleported there for the first time (Even though they've just been standing around and doing "something?" On the planet for some amount of time.)
Beyond light is up there for me, not because it’s necessarily good, but because it’s nostalgic and kept me company through the initial isolation of the pandemic.
I introduced a friend to Destiny a little bit before TFS dropped and I was bewildered at how much he loved Beyond Light. Honestly I think us veterans are just a little spoiled atp, but I’m ok with being spoiled. Makes the wow moments hit that much harder :)
Even tough the campaign is kinda boring, this is probably in my top 4 expansions, for its lore, for trying to retcon elsie bray's story, for how beautiful europa is, for how fun stasis is, etc etc, i can't help but realy enjoy the content that it has, also eramis was really redeemed in the later seasons and lore, wich made me appreciate her as a character much more
Aside from the missed potential of the abandoned skyscrapers (I’ll admit, that is a flaw), I actually quite like Europa. Sure, there isn’t a ton to do, but then again it’s that case for just about every patrol zone bar the Pale Heart. I feel, however, that Europa makes up for the lack of activities with the amount of things to go and see. The I love walking through the Bray Exoscience facility, just for the sight seeing, and Riis Reborn is a pretty cool place to check out every now and then. Overall, as far as patrol zones go, I wouldn’t say Europa is the perfect patrol zone (again, especially when compared to the likes of the Pale Heart) but overall, I’d say Europa is pretty nice, and definitely above average when compared to the other places we’ve gotten in the past (Unrelated, saying lore doesn’t count for a location literally built up in the lore kinda blows the wind outta it. Lore exists in the game for a reason, and if you don’t want to read it that’s a subjective flaw, not an objective flaw)
Love Beyond Light tbh. I’ve always played destiny but Beyond Light was the only D2 dlc that pulled me in back like D1 days. Loved the mystery of the pyramid ship and intro to darkness. Born in Darkness is also the best story quest in Destiny history imo and the dark future lore book was so freaking good. Plus the soundtrack was sooooo freaking good. I know TFS, WQ, and Forsaken would be rated higher but idk, Beyond Light is my favorite. I also loved Europa as a destination
This expansion was my introduction to Destiny and it will always hold a discuss place. The story, the location, the characters, enemies, the music. Exploring Europa for hours while learning the mechanics of the game. My first raid.
I get the difficulty aspect, however this looks like a recent playthrough where you're WELL above the suggested power level. When this dropped it was a lot harder. But playing with my brother its terribly easy.
I mean I don't blame you for not liking the campaign (twas boring and bad) but Eramis has had her full character arc, it just wasn't here. She basically had all of season of Plunder and then a good chunk of Seraph before she decided "Fuck it no gods I'm going to take as many of my people with me as I can and we're getting the fuck out of this cursed system" Her Character arc was actining rashly in spite, hitching her wagon to THE FUCKING THING THAT CAUSED HER PEOPLE'S APOCALYPSE, realized she was an idiot, and noped out rather than die choking on our bullets on the witness' orders.
@Nanokk_ lore should be to flesh out the world. Not fill in the blanks of moments the story itself doesn't bother to explain. Which is the one part of Destiny storytelling that really bothers me.
When I take a step back and look at it, witch queen was a lot like this dlc, when you ask someone what made witch queen great, it's only two things, the campaign and the raid. Okay the campaign is an 8 hour experience at most isn't very hard on legend either, story is alright I guess, kinda corny and predictable. And the raid? One of the best. But everything else? Witch queen doesn't have much to offer. That's why I don't think witch queen ever deserved to be compared to forsaken or taken King, it did a campaign right for the first time in destiny history, but it barely did it right. And even then was forgettable, savathun didn't feel like a villain, you telling me the only thing the trickster hive God did, was lie to us and bring the traveler to the throne world? Her theme didn't fit the dlc at all
Between Bungie living in survival budget mode after leaving Activision and them stretching content, it is a wonder the story was cohesive at all. You had things like the Scarlet Keep being taken from Encaledas (Deep Stone Crypt) and used as a Hive castle in an irrelevant side plot. You had Beyond Light being recycled from a rough draft of Destiny 3. You had Witch Queen which was supposed to introduce Strand. You had Lightfall taking stuff clearly meant for Final Shape's introduction of Prismatic, from the holographic rainbow colors to weapons like Conditional Finality. Witch Queen might have had a fun campaign and raid, but it was significantly smaller in content than Taken King and Forsaken before it. All for the same price.
The point at 6:26 is really bad. While I know it isn't said strictly in the campaign neither is "servitors make ether", servitors are made to look like the traveler. Eramis kills the imitation Traveler with darkness while saying "we begin breaking free from our chains." She is subtextually saying that house salvation doesn't need to rely on the light anymore. I'm not a huge fan of beyond light either but don't downplay good story points.
Ghost probably didnt know those fallen because that was the 1st house salvation platoon, so it makes a bit more sense. Can't wait for the last 3 campaigns
eramis got unfrozen in season of the sereph by the witness who basically try to turn the warsats on the traveler but failed cause Rasputin sacrificed him self and destroy the warsats and now eramis is around randomly sometimes talking to us
This is my first time playing destiny, the problem I already have is that you need to be at some missions to play PVP, the campaign has an unnecessary amount of enemies, and the second mission feels like 2 hours
This is probably my favorite video of yours yet because you're so angry throughout and it's completely justified - this campaign was a complete nothing burger 😂
"Our Motivation to kill the big bad is '[they] murdered someone important'" I hope to god you bring this back up in TFS; because if we're talking 'wide reaching threat and consequences' oh boy, oh boy, oh boy, I'd consider that an abject failure. Good fan service. Poor villain, threat and resolution. No honestly, think about it from the perspective of 4/5 years. What did they *actually* achieve that we still feel now?
Don’t get me wrong, beyond light is pretty eh But I do think it is largely because of Covid, like that’s the main reason why drifter and eris have like- zero voice lines (hell, they even got ghost to voice drifter in salvations grip quest.)
Yeah and if you enjoy it that's cool, I have no issue with it. These videos aren't made to tell people you can't like something. It's far from the takeaway one should have when watching
I agree with a lot of what you said, though I do personally love the Eliksni aethetic whenever it appears. However, I can't agree with you about Eramis on the whole, she's not as impactful or manacing as some villains, no, but I think being dissapointed that she's not some insane war criminal is odd because that isn't really what she's meant to be, she's Destiny's most sympathetic antagonist, someone conflicted between a genuine love for her people and an insurmountable desire for revenge against the thing that took everything from her. Granted, she is at her best in the lore and in later releases, and I know the focus was on the campaign, however, to do a character judgement, you need to take into account everything the character has done, and if you're going to consider the aftermath of Oryx and Uldren's actions as part of their character, you need to do the same for Eramis. And also, reguarding the notion that she has no effect on the world, that's actually not true, she's the reason Rasputin is dead, and the reason Misraaks is alive, the former of which is definately a big deal since Rasputin was humanities greatest weapon. And reguarding where she is now, BUNGIE had her leave the system in a lore tab. And I do need to point out your hypocricy with the Savathûn thing, you complained about Xol by saying he'd be dead by the end of the expansion and so didn't matter, so complaining about Savathûn remainig relivant past the end of her expansion doesn't seem right. Especually since I think it's generally agreed upon that the stuff with Savathûn has all been pretty good. Please don't become like November Hotel and complain about everything even when it means contradicting yourself and the content is genuinely good.
Okay so I originally had this entire response written but then I accidentally clicked back on my mouse so apologies if this is a bit scrambled, I just wanted to get a response out. I appreciate the comment, I genuinely respect spending the time to leave the comment. I find Eramis to be a sympathetic villain somewhat true I guess, I feel pity on her for being so pathetic, but ultimately I find her continued failures to be one I don't care for. I acknowledge I left out the Rasputin part, genuinely I thought it was the Witness that was the reason for the sacrifice, but upon looking it up I was wrong. If I had known that I would've changed it, but I'll keep it noted. Unfortunately one success in a sea of failures doesn't change much for me. But Rasputin's sacrifice is an important moment in Destiny, I won't dispute. I can't attest to Eramis in the lore, since I explicitly don't read it as to not conflict with the campaign scripts, so I'll take your word for it regarding the lore. Also not surprised she fled the system lol Regarding that final point, I think Savathun is being milked. I didn't like that we didn't just kill her ghost when we had the chance, and I haven't been a far of her being dragged around since. Also with that Xol point, I complained that he was pointless as a villain, we already had the warmind, we didn't need a worm god, and the expansion itself agrees with me since he died and it really didn't matter to the larger story of Destiny. Having a character remain for longer isn't the issue, its how its done. For example, how Oryx is handled is something I enjoy, he hasn't been brought back over and over and used several times to push the plot forward. I'd really prefer not to be seen as another November Hotel, since I find that guy to be intentionally disingenuous and complains for the sake of complaining. My Witch Queen video is going to be actually quite long, and incredibly complimentary towards it. Plus once I've made all my videos, I plan on taking all the criticism I've gotten and fixing the issues in a huge video. Your criticism here will be noted. Once again I appreciate the comment
@@Nanokk_ Thank you for taking the time to make a respectful response, that's already better conduct than several big UA-camrs. I won't deny that Eramis has too many failures, and it does frustrate me to a certain extent as well, especually in season of the plunder in which she can'f aquire even one of the dozen relics she was after, and even in the Rasputin case, she still failed since her target was the Traveller, Rasputin sacrificed himself to stop her, which did a critical blow to the alliance, but it wasn't what she originally planned for. That said, I still think she's a great character because she has some genuine points, the house of light are protected by the last city, but they aren't allowed their own autonomy or sovereignty, they're only allowed to live so long as they play by humanities rules, they're basically a client species like the psions to the cabal and it makes sense for Eramis to oppose that. However she's also someone who could never let go of the past even to the point of self-destruction and hurting the people she wanted to protect, and she's been slowly learning that and growing from it, realising what truly matters and that the future means more than the past. That's why I think she's a great villain, you can map her full character arc, and I do believe she should have died before Final shape, I was dissapointed by Warlord's ruin because I was genuinely expecting a conclusion to her story, and instead we got a fun, but pointless side quest that could have been an exotic mission instead of a dungeon, and Eramis got tossed away in a lore tab despite the plot seemingly building to her, her dying would have also openned the door for a potentual guardian ressurrection, but that was never implied, just a thought. As for Savathûn, I still can't really agree with the idea that she's being milked, so far all her uses seem pretty good and it does seem to be building to something, the one spectre being that way back at the end of season of the Deep, BUNGIE said she'd never be as important as she was pre-witch queen, but they also said the Witness was the biggest bad in the universe and now they're shoving the Winnowwer in, so things might have changed there. I just think her uses have been sparse and important enough to claim she's being milked yet, if she's still doing the same stuff at the end of the next saga, then I'll say she's being milked. And as for Xol, I think the fact was that Warmind needed a villain, and there are a lot of people in the community that didn't care enough about Rasputin for him alone to carry an expansion, and the worm gods are also an important part of the lore. Nokris was also forshadowwed since the Taken King and Xol being the weakest worm god is supposed to make you fear the others, and probably would have succeded had the strike been harder. As for why I said that, I just got the impression from the Warmind video that you didn't like a villain that would die at the end of the expansion, so seeing you upset about one that lived past it raised my red flag, apologies if I missinterpreted that. And finally, reguarding the November hotel thing, my apologies, as I said, I interpreted it as you being upset about a solution to a problem you were also upset about, and that just reminded me of him, sorry, that was overly harsh. I woule like to stress the importance of research, since this video was expansion-focused, misrememberring the Rasputin thing is certainly forgiveable, however I just wouldn't like to see you fall into the same pitfall as EvenF, who neglects to research anything and then frames it as BUNGIE being bad writers, critisizing them for mistakes they didn't make. Generally, I believe in critisizing people for things they did, but defending them when they're accused of things they didn't do, no matter your feelings on someone on the whole, they should never be critisized for things of which they are innoccent.
I enjoyed this video and was just about to give a like until you said there “milking savuthun” and I was shook, savuthun is one of the best written characters in d2 history and the “milking” one of the best characters is not a bad thing in my opinion
Glad to see someone who hates Eremis. Surprised you didn’t point out that there’s nothing stopping us from throwing Eremis in a wood chipper after she gets frozen. Why we didn’t finish her off is beyond stupid I know you said you didn’t care about lore but since you asked about it and brought up season of defiance, Eremis essentially just ran off like a coward trying to find the Fallen homeworld and her mate Athrys so she could see her one last time before the witness ends all of existence
Hey by the way, I made the exact same mistake with Kridis across multiple playthroughs….i legit thought she was the rando fallen in the cosmodrome lost sector
I actually loved Beyond Light and the whole finally discovering darkness storyline. Although, Forsaken is by far the best designed content ever by Bungie, even compared to The Final Shape. I say that mostly because of The Last Wish being the best raid in Destiny history still.
The whole Eramis destroying a servitor, has to do with rejecting the traveler, since the servitors are modelled after them. But that means reading lore for context, and it is kind of stupid, since it is litterally their food source. And Eramis isnt even her real name, its Veekris, the Shipstealer, it was her name in d1, and Variks mentions her, a Wiki made a mistake, and Bungie for some reason used the wrong name. The wiki even corrected itself.
Destiny 2 always had so much potential, yet a lot of time its just wasted a water down version of what we get told and teased about, with the worst part about people defending the game with their life like a Stockholm Syndrome.
It's a shame they spent so much marketing time teasing a pyramid ship army, and getting us hype for a war just for the pyramids to be empty and the campaign to basically have nothing at all with the campaign 😅
Idk man, I don’t think BL was like great, but I don’t think it was bad. It was just alright. Looking at it from the lens we have now makes it seem even worse. Kinda jarring in some points, like how Eramis randomly appears, the whole salvation house and their gimmick is kinda like we’re here now, now deal with us. But like it wasn’t bad like I said. Like the complaint we wish we could’ve had the subclass for the whole campaign I only really saw around lightfall. And then looking back on this campaign you’d say the same thing, but back then it wasn’t like that. It was the first time a new subclass and the implications behind it existed like that. Upon having it be the way it was executed once, lightfall should’ve learnt from it. But I don’t feel like BL should take some marks off for this or other stuff like that. It’s not near TFS or Forsaken or TK, but it wasn’t bad at all imo. Like a classic destiny expansion. And maybe that speaks to the fact Bungie could make their expansions go above and beyond and have the skill in their employees to do so. But for what Destiny has delivered as a whole, it was like a solid 6/10 for me, if 5 was an exact average. 90% of BL was average, a few things were kinda under average, stasis (especially for the time) was way beyond average. And it kinda evens out around that 6.
Postgame carries this expansion tbh Tho about the dark vanguard, IIRC this was the covid year expansion and a lot of content was lost. They had to cut them out mostly and with the lack of time they had to make ghost speak for the dirfter (I think the voice actor was sick and they had no tiem no wait or he was occupied with something else) The mission was still a banger thanks to exactly ghost's impression of drifter but MAN this DLC was really hurt by covid.
I feel not addressing the raid in this case especially is a bit of a poor decision considering its one it the best in D2. I get why you don't address them, but they add a lot to the DLC's content The campaign is whatever. A bit mid. They should definitely move back to the TK subclass model. Stasis and Strand were handled very poorly. If you don't mind me asking, when did you start playing Destiny?
1. I've stated in every video this series explicitly only covers the campaign, the only execption I'll make is TFS when the time comes. 2. I've been playing Destiny since The Taken King on the ps3, I started playing Destiny 2 during Curse of Osiris on ps4, and moved to pc halfway through shadowkeep
@@Nanokk_ 1. Idk if you meant to but you kinda sound like a smartass here. I get why you don't cover raids- and honestly just covering the campaigns works best for reviews like this, but I feel like having a separate video covering the raids after the TFS review would be nice seeing how they're almost a companion piece of sorts to their campaign. 2. Good shit fr, personally been playing since the D2 Beta.
@@SpankyMcPants. 1. My bad, I didn't mean to sound like a smartass lol. I plan on making a larger retrospective on Destiny 2, where I'll cover the raids and their storylines maybe, I'm still working out the structure
I enjoyed Shadowkeep's campaign more, even the Dark Below's campaign had more substance than this. The only reason to buy this DLC is DSC. But DSC is worth the whole price of the DLC.
Shadowkeep is more of a snoozefest in my opinion it did absolutely nothing compared to forsaken and the whole campaign can be boiled down to doing bounties instead of an actual story
i genuinely just straight up ignored the story cause i just wanted to get the new stasis subclass also u should do reviews on waframe mission cause they are actually goated
Same situation with Tormentors and Subjugators. Pocket Sized Raid bosses that introduce a new mechanic or two. Which I actually really like. Only really completely new singular units are the Wyverns and Lightbearers. The rest of the big tanky enemies added to factions are likely downscaled raid bosses
Beyond light has my favorite villain, eramis, my favorite element, stasis, and my favorite music of the entire franchise. Everything else? Complete ass. It sucks it didn't get a good campaign like witch queen
Man I agree with a lot of the complaints but some things just land weird. Eramis isn't a great villain, but it looks way worse when you compare her in-campaign activities to other villains lore-defined activities. Talking about how easy the campaign is with a post Witch Queen sandbox also feels a little offputting especially since the vids on Forsaken and prior use footage from much weaker sandboxes (by necessity, I know). Europa being boring is a matter of personal taste imo - I love it as a true sci-fi destination especially when compared to Dreaming City/Throne World/Pale Heart - but i can see where you're coming from. The mid campaign kill enemies grinding sucks ass, i wont contest that at all. Just because other MMOs do it during their MSQs doesnt mean Destiny should
So something I mentioned at the start is I don't care about the lore, I don't focus on it, and eramis' impact (at least at this point) was minimal at best. Talking about how easy the campaign was became almost a necessity because you can't ignore just how easy it is now. It was harder at launch I'm aware but it's been power crept to hell and back, it needs addressing. I personally wouldn't call the Dreaming City, throne world, or the pale heart sci-fi locations, and more fantasy. Which Bungie should lean into way more
Its gonna be really funny seeing all the comments complain I didn't like the expansion as a whole when I address that in the first two minutes. Funny how some people love to be hateful without actually watching the video🤭
(Im also interested if anyone can spot the music I used from a particular show, bonus points of you know which tracks)
I love your videos, except for the way you communicate your talking points. You come off as an irritated 20-year-old brat. That's not exactly your fault though (I talk like that too btw), people are just less likely to pay attention to you. I know, it sucks.
Personally I think this is the worst of the $40 expansions so this video was great
Algorithm showed me this video, so I've never seen your content. I also watched so I think I earned being hateful. :)
Death note, Light Theme
@jakarreh you're 75% right, you missed a track, but nice job lol
TBF, Lore in Destiny has always served as a way to steer the ship back on track when the campaign would not, in addition to flesh out the whole world of Destiny. But the fact that almost every expansion heavily relied on the lore to keep it just somewhat understandable is shockign to say the least. I say this as someone who likes reading the lore
The lore has mostly been well done and interesting, credit where due. But you're right, it has been overused to right the ship and that's not good. Jez talked about that in his Lightfall story analysis, and he's 100% right. Lore should not be considered "the story." Lore should expand on the story and give it more context for those interested enough to seek it out.
That was the taken kings problem, it has a solid campaign fun wise, but narrative? Nope. Gotta collect all 50 calcified fragments if you wanna learn anything about the hive.
At least the Soundtrack was absolutely banging. Easily the best until TFS came out.
Personally I like Forsaken and The Witch Queen the most, I need to listen to TFS more
Dunno about that one. Deep Stone Lullaby just hard carries the soundtrack for beyond light so far and above everything that came before and after. The atmosphere and the dialogue as you do the space walk and that track kicks in. One of the best Destiny moments ever.
@@Chaotic_H3LL nah come on the raid tracks for one are fire, the music overall is quite good with not a lot of weak spots, which I can't say the same for some other expansions
@@Chaotic_H3LL Frigid Tomb is also a certified banger tho
I like the Lightfall sountrack the most. The female melodic vocals are heaven to me
This DLC got a LOT of Flack cause of Sunsetting and whenever i bring up discussion about it, Everyone mentions sunsetting in some way
As it should
Which it should, bungie in general needs more flack for sunsetting, seasons too. Seasons were such a waste for destiny's potential over the years, the content might not have been that great in the seasons but the fact they wasted time making something that would go away from anywhere from 3 months to a year is inexcusable, my only issue with people shitting on bungie during the lightfall era was everyone focused on microtransactions and the bad dlc and not the glaring problem of seasons.
as it should
@@filipgasic2642 No it should not lmao.
@@-HezSEs-So you're fine with content get taken away? Especially the ones you paid for?
Btw, about us using darkness despite the exo stranger saying we gave in, it's explained VERY SLIGHTLY, in the campign, and also agian in lightfall, that we control stasis.
So basically, stasis in most timelines takes control of us because we didn't have the strength to overcome it or the discipline to control it. To use stasis, we have to bind it to our will completely, like holding down your leash when your dog sees a squirrel. This is again explained in lightfall multiple times with Osiris at first thinking we need to control Strand like we do with Stasis, this leads to the whole back and forth between Nimbus and Osiris anout control vs flow when trying to learn strand. (Which means our and Osiris' understanding of stasis and lack of listening to Nimbus is what killed Rohan...).
So basically, in most timlines, we let stasis overpower us and give in to darkness and rage. Or we dont use stasis at all, and we have no way to fight back against Eramis. But this timeline, we control and discipline stasis so that we may safely use it to defeat Eramis. The problem is that this is hardly (but still done) explained in the campaign.
Yeah I got all that, but it came off as too subtle and incredibly corny
@@Nanokk_ true
This is actually wrong. I refer you to the lore book Bitter, "The Crux was broken." This lore book details how the Exo Stranger came to control Stasis, and her upbringing as a Bray went against her initial efforts and she lost control of Stasis. Why? Because she tried to control it. She comes to control Stasis because she learns to let go of that control. We never struggle with this in game, because the player character instantly masters every power they come across with Strand being the only exception.
Lightfall effectively establishes that to use Darkness powers or abilities, you have to surrender control. That could, in hindsight, explain why Eramis doesn't seem to have full control over Stasis; she believes it is not only her gift, but it is her right and hers alone. She tries to control it to such a degree that what happens to Elsie happens to her, and unlike Elsie she doesn't have help to break free.
Why and how the player Guardian "falls" in the Dark Timeline is never stated or explained. It could possibly be the Witness having a direct line to our Ghost somehow, something that I don't think it does to ANY other Ghost. It could possibly be a reference to how many players joked about joining the Darkness when Beyond Light originally previewed Stasis.
EDIT: I am double checking the Dark Future lorebook just to fact check myself. It seems that, in that timeline, the Black Heart had corrupted the Guardians sent to investigate it; those Guardians presumably including us, given Destiny 1's story. We were corrupted long before Stasis even entered the Solar System there. As an aside, there is a hint there that Stasis cannot be controlled by mere strength alone. What this tells me is that Bungie cannot keep their own story straight.
Actually, this makes Lightfall's story even worse, because with this knowledge we should not have struggled with Strand AT ALL.
discussing destiny campaigns pre witch queen is terribly boring since they are so uninteresting and ass in terms of narrative and gameplay. Looking forward to your analysis of the witch queen/lightfall/final shape trilogy since even the worst of those (being lightfall) , has some redeeming qualities
"Darkness was mentioned 52 times."
The Veil: "Hold my Radial Mast."
>create character
>realise i need stasis
>realise i have to do the BL campaign again
>esc, exit to desktop
This. 🤯🔫
@@BungieStudios no way the real bungie omg !!1!
>Man up
>Speed through campaign
>Complete it within an hour
@@wickermind6668 what i did in the end
What's so annoying about Eramis is that she was so boring, cringy, poorly written, and wierdly animated in Beyond light. But come Season of the plunder when she came back she was way more interesting, then even more so in season of the seraph. Then she came back agian in season of the defiance to save mithrax, now in the final shape she abandoned the witness, which was foreshadowed at the end of season of the seraph and defiance. Now she's teased to return in episode: revenant.
It's so annyoing how interesting the idea of eramis is, despite how poorly she was handled in the expansion where she was the main villian, but now that shes no longer the main threat for obvious reasons, shes WAY more interesting.
Even still they are fuck1ng it up. I HATE recycled villains. Just give us something new and approved upon previous villains ffs
@@filipgasic2642 It's so odd to me how whenever they make a new villain they tend to immediately kill them off in a raid but older villains get to have real effects on the story. Nezerac and Rhulk should have been much more important but instead Calus gets all the spotlight as a deciple of the witness. Even the witness is a new villain imo. While he did appear in older dlcs we didn't really know it was him nor see him until lightfall and then he's killed in tfs where all his lore is revealed. Characters like savathun, calus (till we killed him) and eramis get to keep popping up for no good reason. Xivu Arath is kinda a step in the right direction but she's probably gonna die in 1 dlc too.
it's clear that the design for eramis clashed heavily with making her an antagonist. her design works far better with her being an anti-hero type character.
The entire dlc can be boiled down to 3 boss fights and one strike. You play it for stasis then forget it like lightfall
6:12 The Eliksni don't *need* Servitors to generate Ether, but other methods are less efficient due to the scavenger-esque nature that has become of their people. Actually, in terms of story, this is one of the few points I really enjoyed, as we know from Destiny 1 (without delving into lore) that the Eliksni built the Servitors in the shape of the Traveler as a form of reverence. Eramis destroying one in front of her new house with Darkness power is actually a huge message in-world.
I think they fumbled the aftermath, not really knowing what to do with Eramis and House Salvation, but in Beyond Light, this actually got me a little hyped.
6:30 hey Nanokk, about the servidor thing, its stabilished in a campaing, i think during the red war but dont quote me in that, that the Eliksni as a race that lived under the traveler's light long ago, venerates servidors because they are like an effigy to the traveler (along with the ether thing)
So Eramis destroying a servidor with stasis is meant to represent her shattering the obsession the Eliksni had with the light.
Its a cool and meaningful scene, probably the most well thought scene in this entire expansion... A shame it is tied to poor storytelling
I know you said you'd disregard unstated lore comments, but I can't help myself. The reason why Eramis destroying that Servator was a big shocker to the Fallen is because they are extremely revered among their kind. Not only, as you stated, they create the ether they need to live, but they were made spherical to be in the image of the Traveler, and in fact, Fallen treat machines really highly due to the Traveler itself being a Machine God to them. So Eramis destroying that Servator, and having all House Salvation Servators be desecrated, is her essentially spitting on the image of her former god and saying "we don't need to worship the Traveler anymore!", and to instead join the Witness, who will give them the salvation they desire.
“I can’t be wrong! Plenty of people in my echo chamber agree with me!”
I would disagree on the idea that Europa is boring. It was on of the coolest and unique aesthetics in the game where you have such a barren landscape contrasted by the massive fallen city in the north and then the futuristic bray labs. Not to mention the incredible skyboxes. It is way more diverse than any other location aside from the pale heart in my opinion.
Most underrated destiny series
The mbdtf reference is such a good thumbnail 😭🔥
I've been sitting on this thumbnail foe over a year, I finally get to use it
I thought tha thumbnail looked familiar. Still can't remember what it is though.
@@bro_izzy [My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy By Kanye West (MBTDF)]'s Album Cover
@@retentionx2 Oh I see. Though, I could've sworn I've seen this exact thumbnail before. Idk
I just deleted a character recently just to replay the Beyond Light campaign and i can honestly say its really not boring i find the story quite interesting also learning about stasis as the campaign progressed was quite fun.
I agree. I also love Europa too. It’s my favorite destination in the game lol. I can’t argue that The Witch Queen and Final Shape campaigns may be objectively better, I think Beyond Light is my favorite in terms of just the fun I had with it. I personally loved Beyond Light lol
Beyond Light is why I only bother playing one character. I'm too impatient to unlock Stasis for them.
Every time variks was talking all I was hearing was “SYLOK, THE DEFILED”
"...thirst for your light."
the first 2 dlcs i bought were lightfall and beyond light (i got them for free with ps+)
One thing I think you touch upon is the return of bag story telling. Forsaken and Shadowkeep had some grim themes that broke away from the cartoonish tone of year 1. This expansion just seemed to be not as narratively dark as I hoped considering that we are supposed to be helping the fallen escape a brutal dictator, the introduction of the dark vanguard, and the introduction of darkness powers. It just did not seem to be as compelling when shown in game because the game did a horrible job SHOWING the struggles that characters were going through unlike forsaken and shadowkeep.
I get to play as edgy Queen Elsa/Frozone with guns and a chainsaw that you wield as an anime sword, therefore your point is invalid.
0:50 Just stumbled on this video today, but THANK YOU for analyzing Destiny campaigns in this fashion. I ask people all the time, and have yet to receive a concrete response..."tell me the entire story of Destiny 2, just using free in-game content and expansions, no external lore or seasonal stuff that's removed...and tell me, honestly, if that sounds like a cohesive narrative."
The amount of CRITICAL story beats that took place during seasons, that specifically build up expansions, that are NOT present in the game to replay anymore, is insane. Final Shape, for a person who wasn't playing during the last two years of seasons, will likely not hit anywhere near as powerfully as the hardcore pre-order goblin dropping $100 every 12 months on content that's mostly sight unseen.
This is a dumb critique. “Tell me if destiny’s story makes sense without including expansions, which is where the story progresses the most.”
@acoustic_. No, friend. Reread my comment. "Tell me Destiny 2's story ONLY using free intro content AND expansions...NOT content that doesn't exist anymore."
That's the problem. The free intro content and expansions MISSING the seasonal story beats? Horrible skeleton of a story that makes little sense and removes most build up and gravity from bigger climaxes.
Like Final Shape, for instance. If a person didn't experience Uldren returning as a Guardian and getting his memory back...hell, if all they saw was Uldren killing Cayde, then sees him in the Traveler, what does it mean to that person to see Crow and Cayde making nice?
Catch my drift?
@@RedShadowOfSaturn oh, I thought you meant free expansions. I was so confused lol
@acoustic_. I mean yeah, they made 3 of them free when TFS launched, so yes technically, those too. But Lightfall still costs money, I meant that one too.
In the exercise, I mean...JUST the expansions and free stuff that still exists, like the intro, NOT seasonal content OR the first four campaigns that were removed.
The point I'm making is...the seasonal content that was removed, and to an extent the first four campaigns...help build up a lot of a tension and details in later releases that lose some punch without that context. And since they can't be replayed, how would a new player, who only played the first Forsaken mission, connect the dots to how Uldren (they don't even know he's crow when they reach Final Shape) is an ally leading the charge into the Traveler. 🤷♂️
@@RedShadowOfSaturn beyond light is free now? Shit I just bought the legacy bundle
Ngl I like Europa better than neomuna at least it makes sense that it’s a barren empty space where as neomuna is supposed to be a lived in city and doesn’t feel like it at all
Yeah there are elements of Europa I like, but I don't really like anything about neomuna
@@Nanokk_ I agree with your take on the eventide ruins and how cool it could have been. but for some reason bungie hates vertical maps and city maps which sucks because I think they could make a really good one. also I hate the 3 area map structure they have with a majority of the destinations
They def missed out by not expanding eventide ruins
variks is the goat idk what you're talking about i love his munching noises he does randomly like hes feasting on some walnuts or some shit
Can I JUST SAY YOUR AMAZING AND I LOVE THESE VIDEOS!
1. Beyond light is the best expansion tho
2. I can’t wait for lightfall video. Please include many funny moments on what the Veil is Tho. Thanks love you!/
Holy shit thank you!! I really appreciate the donation so very much!
Fancy seeing you here redrix
Love the video. I made sone few funny ideas fir future videos if you like them
For Witch Queen: Witch is winning!
Lightfall: We are falling
Final shape: The line is drawn
Made these Catchy based on the themes of the titles you did here
Destiny 2 Beyond Light in Content: this was when sunsetting occurred pretty much killing off all the fun weapons. It felt like you were being forced to pay for having most of your gear become useless and prior campaigns vaulted. It was done for reasons I understand but the approach and the lack of upfront new content really came off as bad faith practice. Your video helped me understand why playing the game during this time in its lifecycle it felt so hollow and half baked.
When I look to play a video game, I’m looking to be entertained. The fact that I didn’t have a single memorable or fun moment through the campaign speaks volumes about BL.
I imagine BL turned out as it did because of Covid. VAs couldn't come to recording sessions and a lot was cut.
The DLC's setting was supposed to be Encaledas instead of Europa, with the Scarlet Keep serving as the original Deep Stone Crypt. I believe this change was due to budget limitations at Bungie, which forced them to reuse existing assets to meet their DLC plans and prioritize upgrading the game engine. Originally, Beyond Light was intended as a rough draft for Destiny 3. Destiny 2 was seen as a temporary solution since its launch, plagued by bugs, frustrating developer tools, and only basic features. At that time, Bungie was more focused on venturing into the Chinese mobile gaming market with pay-to-win games, which led to their decision to leave Activision, especially after realizing that Activision had generated $1 billion in revenue from Eververse. However, this plan was disrupted when the Chinese government started banning video games. Subsequently, Bungie decided to upgrade the engine and continue with Destiny 2 until ultimately being acquired by Sony. This upgrade wasn't as comprehensive as developing a brand-new game, but it allowed for some quality-of-life improvements without disrupting the game's uptime.
In short, Bungie kept changing long-term plans and was in budget mode. So they pinched every penny. The lockdowns had their challenges, but they probably weren't the reason BL sucked.
honestly put it really well. when beyond light works it works. crazy how the majority of d2's seasons have better stories. they tend to be full of lore so i think its why i see it like that. happy to see your sub count go up :]
It's so hard for me to imagine there was a time when not even the baseline expectations for an expansion campaign could be met. Stuff like a well paced coherent story, actual difficulty in missions, actually impactful cutscenes. This stuff that we take for granted now literally didn't exist before witch queen. Back in shadowkeep and beyond light Bungie strung together a bunch of patrol objectives and 3 or 4 missions and called it a campaign. Those were truly the dark ages and I have no idea how I even tolerated it.
2:26
I know it seems extremely minor... But this cutscene (Or at least a particular part of it) has stuck out to me for how "jank" it is... It feels like the discussion being had should be in a different setting or something, and at the end when they trace a signal to being somewhere on the planet, they proclaim it as if they've literally just teleported there for the first time (Even though they've just been standing around and doing "something?" On the planet for some amount of time.)
Beyond light is up there for me, not because it’s necessarily good, but because it’s nostalgic and kept me company through the initial isolation of the pandemic.
I introduced a friend to Destiny a little bit before TFS dropped and I was bewildered at how much he loved Beyond Light. Honestly I think us veterans are just a little spoiled atp, but I’m ok with being spoiled. Makes the wow moments hit that much harder :)
Even tough the campaign is kinda boring, this is probably in my top 4 expansions, for its lore, for trying to retcon elsie bray's story, for how beautiful europa is, for how fun stasis is, etc etc, i can't help but realy enjoy the content that it has, also eramis was really redeemed in the later seasons and lore, wich made me appreciate her as a character much more
What do you like about how they changed the stranger's lore?
Lmao, the two ads I had combined were longer than the Eramis fight
Maybe I should start placing ads myself instead of getting youtube to do it lol
Aside from the missed potential of the abandoned skyscrapers (I’ll admit, that is a flaw), I actually quite like Europa. Sure, there isn’t a ton to do, but then again it’s that case for just about every patrol zone bar the Pale Heart.
I feel, however, that Europa makes up for the lack of activities with the amount of things to go and see. The I love walking through the Bray Exoscience facility, just for the sight seeing, and Riis Reborn is a pretty cool place to check out every now and then.
Overall, as far as patrol zones go, I wouldn’t say Europa is the perfect patrol zone (again, especially when compared to the likes of the Pale Heart) but overall, I’d say Europa is pretty nice, and definitely above average when compared to the other places we’ve gotten in the past
(Unrelated, saying lore doesn’t count for a location literally built up in the lore kinda blows the wind outta it. Lore exists in the game for a reason, and if you don’t want to read it that’s a subjective flaw, not an objective flaw)
Didn't Eramis ditch the solar system after the events of Final Dawn?
Love Beyond Light tbh. I’ve always played destiny but Beyond Light was the only D2 dlc that pulled me in back like D1 days. Loved the mystery of the pyramid ship and intro to darkness. Born in Darkness is also the best story quest in Destiny history imo and the dark future lore book was so freaking good. Plus the soundtrack was sooooo freaking good. I know TFS, WQ, and Forsaken would be rated higher but idk, Beyond Light is my favorite. I also loved Europa as a destination
This expansion was my introduction to Destiny and it will always hold a discuss place. The story, the location, the characters, enemies, the music. Exploring Europa for hours while learning the mechanics of the game. My first raid.
I get the difficulty aspect, however this looks like a recent playthrough where you're WELL above the suggested power level. When this dropped it was a lot harder. But playing with my brother its terribly easy.
This playthrough was recorded during season of the Seraph, but yeah I played it when it released when it was a harder. But it's about right now
Oh shit hell yea I love this series
Real
@@MeatusMaximushuh?
does anybody know what's the song at 13:45 ?
Good take, well edited video I hope you blow up! Manifesting 2 billion subs.
Beyond Light is why I never play my other two characters. I don't feel like running the long ass campaign and quests again to unlock Stasis for them.
I should probably add Lightfall to this comment as well. 😒
I mean I don't blame you for not liking the campaign (twas boring and bad) but Eramis has had her full character arc, it just wasn't here. She basically had all of season of Plunder and then a good chunk of Seraph before she decided "Fuck it no gods I'm going to take as many of my people with me as I can and we're getting the fuck out of this cursed system"
Her Character arc was actining rashly in spite, hitching her wagon to THE FUCKING THING THAT CAUSED HER PEOPLE'S APOCALYPSE, realized she was an idiot, and noped out rather than die choking on our bullets on the witness' orders.
I wish Destiny lore wasn't always such a huge crutch, imagine how good Destiny would be if they... showed this stuff in game
they did. It was just in seasonal content that has since been removed :(
The seasonal content dilemma
@Nanokk_ lore should be to flesh out the world. Not fill in the blanks of moments the story itself doesn't bother to explain. Which is the one part of Destiny storytelling that really bothers me.
When I take a step back and look at it, witch queen was a lot like this dlc, when you ask someone what made witch queen great, it's only two things, the campaign and the raid. Okay the campaign is an 8 hour experience at most isn't very hard on legend either, story is alright I guess, kinda corny and predictable. And the raid? One of the best. But everything else? Witch queen doesn't have much to offer. That's why I don't think witch queen ever deserved to be compared to forsaken or taken King, it did a campaign right for the first time in destiny history, but it barely did it right. And even then was forgettable, savathun didn't feel like a villain, you telling me the only thing the trickster hive God did, was lie to us and bring the traveler to the throne world? Her theme didn't fit the dlc at all
Between Bungie living in survival budget mode after leaving Activision and them stretching content, it is a wonder the story was cohesive at all. You had things like the Scarlet Keep being taken from Encaledas (Deep Stone Crypt) and used as a Hive castle in an irrelevant side plot. You had Beyond Light being recycled from a rough draft of Destiny 3. You had Witch Queen which was supposed to introduce Strand. You had Lightfall taking stuff clearly meant for Final Shape's introduction of Prismatic, from the holographic rainbow colors to weapons like Conditional Finality.
Witch Queen might have had a fun campaign and raid, but it was significantly smaller in content than Taken King and Forsaken before it. All for the same price.
@@BungieStudios hmm i didnt know that and it make a lot of sense. I mean..why would i question you? Your are bungie studios official after all.
The point at 6:26 is really bad. While I know it isn't said strictly in the campaign neither is "servitors make ether", servitors are made to look like the traveler. Eramis kills the imitation Traveler with darkness while saying "we begin breaking free from our chains." She is subtextually saying that house salvation doesn't need to rely on the light anymore.
I'm not a huge fan of beyond light either but don't downplay good story points.
Ghost probably didnt know those fallen because that was the 1st house salvation platoon, so it makes a bit more sense. Can't wait for the last 3 campaigns
The Darkness Vanguard was cut due to Covid restrictions and delays/chaos
eramis got unfrozen in season of the sereph by the witness who basically try to turn the warsats on the traveler but failed cause Rasputin sacrificed him self and destroy the warsats and now eramis is around randomly sometimes talking to us
This is my first time playing destiny, the problem I already have is that you need to be at some missions to play PVP, the campaign has an unnecessary amount of enemies, and the second mission feels like 2 hours
This is probably my favorite video of yours yet because you're so angry throughout and it's completely justified - this campaign was a complete nothing burger 😂
Looking at the director in Beyond Light fills me with depression
Trash video. Shadowkeep is 100x worse than Beyond Light.
I disagree with people in that BL was "bad" but I 100% agree that it was boring
I appreciate this series quite a bit! Good work here
"Our Motivation to kill the big bad is '[they] murdered someone important'"
I hope to god you bring this back up in TFS; because if we're talking 'wide reaching threat and consequences' oh boy, oh boy, oh boy, I'd consider that an abject failure.
Good fan service.
Poor villain, threat and resolution.
No honestly, think about it from the perspective of 4/5 years.
What did they *actually* achieve that we still feel now?
Don’t get me wrong, beyond light is pretty eh
But I do think it is largely because of Covid, like that’s the main reason why drifter and eris have like- zero voice lines (hell, they even got ghost to voice drifter in salvations grip quest.)
darkness vanguard would be amazing
Babe wake up, new Nanokk video just dropped
I recently wanted to get cloudstrike but holy shit the process makes me wanna run it down in mid.
I politely disagree, Beyond Light was very flawed but I loved the new environment, music, and atmosphere.
for me it's destiny 2: beyond mid I think it's a drag getting stasis for every character but it's somewhat fun but overall its a snoozefest
I dont know why but I loved beyond light. The vibes felt so nice and the raid made me cream. Its the only raid I have the seal for and I still love it
Yeah and if you enjoy it that's cool, I have no issue with it. These videos aren't made to tell people you can't like something. It's far from the takeaway one should have when watching
BABE WAKE UP NANOKK JUST DROPPED ANOTHER EXPANSION VIDEO 🗣️‼️‼️‼️‼️
The Darkness Vanguard would've been a really good idea
That among us joke caught me off guard
Good 1
I agree with a lot of what you said, though I do personally love the Eliksni aethetic whenever it appears. However, I can't agree with you about Eramis on the whole, she's not as impactful or manacing as some villains, no, but I think being dissapointed that she's not some insane war criminal is odd because that isn't really what she's meant to be, she's Destiny's most sympathetic antagonist, someone conflicted between a genuine love for her people and an insurmountable desire for revenge against the thing that took everything from her. Granted, she is at her best in the lore and in later releases, and I know the focus was on the campaign, however, to do a character judgement, you need to take into account everything the character has done, and if you're going to consider the aftermath of Oryx and Uldren's actions as part of their character, you need to do the same for Eramis. And also, reguarding the notion that she has no effect on the world, that's actually not true, she's the reason Rasputin is dead, and the reason Misraaks is alive, the former of which is definately a big deal since Rasputin was humanities greatest weapon.
And reguarding where she is now, BUNGIE had her leave the system in a lore tab.
And I do need to point out your hypocricy with the Savathûn thing, you complained about Xol by saying he'd be dead by the end of the expansion and so didn't matter, so complaining about Savathûn remainig relivant past the end of her expansion doesn't seem right. Especually since I think it's generally agreed upon that the stuff with Savathûn has all been pretty good.
Please don't become like November Hotel and complain about everything even when it means contradicting yourself and the content is genuinely good.
Okay so I originally had this entire response written but then I accidentally clicked back on my mouse so apologies if this is a bit scrambled, I just wanted to get a response out.
I appreciate the comment, I genuinely respect spending the time to leave the comment.
I find Eramis to be a sympathetic villain somewhat true I guess, I feel pity on her for being so pathetic, but ultimately I find her continued failures to be one I don't care for. I acknowledge I left out the Rasputin part, genuinely I thought it was the Witness that was the reason for the sacrifice, but upon looking it up I was wrong. If I had known that I would've changed it, but I'll keep it noted. Unfortunately one success in a sea of failures doesn't change much for me. But Rasputin's sacrifice is an important moment in Destiny, I won't dispute.
I can't attest to Eramis in the lore, since I explicitly don't read it as to not conflict with the campaign scripts, so I'll take your word for it regarding the lore.
Also not surprised she fled the system lol
Regarding that final point, I think Savathun is being milked. I didn't like that we didn't just kill her ghost when we had the chance, and I haven't been a far of her being dragged around since. Also with that Xol point, I complained that he was pointless as a villain, we already had the warmind, we didn't need a worm god, and the expansion itself agrees with me since he died and it really didn't matter to the larger story of Destiny.
Having a character remain for longer isn't the issue, its how its done. For example, how Oryx is handled is something I enjoy, he hasn't been brought back over and over and used several times to push the plot forward.
I'd really prefer not to be seen as another November Hotel, since I find that guy to be intentionally disingenuous and complains for the sake of complaining. My Witch Queen video is going to be actually quite long, and incredibly complimentary towards it. Plus once I've made all my videos, I plan on taking all the criticism I've gotten and fixing the issues in a huge video. Your criticism here will be noted.
Once again I appreciate the comment
@@Nanokk_ Thank you for taking the time to make a respectful response, that's already better conduct than several big UA-camrs.
I won't deny that Eramis has too many failures, and it does frustrate me to a certain extent as well, especually in season of the plunder in which she can'f aquire even one of the dozen relics she was after, and even in the Rasputin case, she still failed since her target was the Traveller, Rasputin sacrificed himself to stop her, which did a critical blow to the alliance, but it wasn't what she originally planned for. That said, I still think she's a great character because she has some genuine points, the house of light are protected by the last city, but they aren't allowed their own autonomy or sovereignty, they're only allowed to live so long as they play by humanities rules, they're basically a client species like the psions to the cabal and it makes sense for Eramis to oppose that. However she's also someone who could never let go of the past even to the point of self-destruction and hurting the people she wanted to protect, and she's been slowly learning that and growing from it, realising what truly matters and that the future means more than the past.
That's why I think she's a great villain, you can map her full character arc, and I do believe she should have died before Final shape, I was dissapointed by Warlord's ruin because I was genuinely expecting a conclusion to her story, and instead we got a fun, but pointless side quest that could have been an exotic mission instead of a dungeon, and Eramis got tossed away in a lore tab despite the plot seemingly building to her, her dying would have also openned the door for a potentual guardian ressurrection, but that was never implied, just a thought.
As for Savathûn, I still can't really agree with the idea that she's being milked, so far all her uses seem pretty good and it does seem to be building to something, the one spectre being that way back at the end of season of the Deep, BUNGIE said she'd never be as important as she was pre-witch queen, but they also said the Witness was the biggest bad in the universe and now they're shoving the Winnowwer in, so things might have changed there. I just think her uses have been sparse and important enough to claim she's being milked yet, if she's still doing the same stuff at the end of the next saga, then I'll say she's being milked.
And as for Xol, I think the fact was that Warmind needed a villain, and there are a lot of people in the community that didn't care enough about Rasputin for him alone to carry an expansion, and the worm gods are also an important part of the lore. Nokris was also forshadowwed since the Taken King and Xol being the weakest worm god is supposed to make you fear the others, and probably would have succeded had the strike been harder.
As for why I said that, I just got the impression from the Warmind video that you didn't like a villain that would die at the end of the expansion, so seeing you upset about one that lived past it raised my red flag, apologies if I missinterpreted that.
And finally, reguarding the November hotel thing, my apologies, as I said, I interpreted it as you being upset about a solution to a problem you were also upset about, and that just reminded me of him, sorry, that was overly harsh.
I woule like to stress the importance of research, since this video was expansion-focused, misrememberring the Rasputin thing is certainly forgiveable, however I just wouldn't like to see you fall into the same pitfall as EvenF, who neglects to research anything and then frames it as BUNGIE being bad writers, critisizing them for mistakes they didn't make. Generally, I believe in critisizing people for things they did, but defending them when they're accused of things they didn't do, no matter your feelings on someone on the whole, they should never be critisized for things of which they are innoccent.
I enjoyed this video and was just about to give a like until you said there “milking savuthun” and I was shook, savuthun is one of the best written characters in d2 history and the “milking” one of the best characters is not a bad thing in my opinion
Glad to see someone who hates Eremis. Surprised you didn’t point out that there’s nothing stopping us from throwing Eremis in a wood chipper after she gets frozen. Why we didn’t finish her off is beyond stupid
I know you said you didn’t care about lore but since you asked about it and brought up season of defiance, Eremis essentially just ran off like a coward trying to find the Fallen homeworld and her mate Athrys so she could see her one last time before the witness ends all of existence
Hey by the way, I made the exact same mistake with Kridis across multiple playthroughs….i legit thought she was the rando fallen in the cosmodrome lost sector
I actually loved Beyond Light and the whole finally discovering darkness storyline. Although, Forsaken is by far the best designed content ever by Bungie, even compared to The Final Shape. I say that mostly because of The Last Wish being the best raid in Destiny history still.
The whole Eramis destroying a servitor, has to do with rejecting the traveler, since the servitors are modelled after them. But that means reading lore for context, and it is kind of stupid, since it is litterally their food source.
And Eramis isnt even her real name, its Veekris, the Shipstealer, it was her name in d1, and Variks mentions her, a Wiki made a mistake, and Bungie for some reason used the wrong name. The wiki even corrected itself.
I get it was an F you to the traveler, it's just dumb lol
@@Nanokk_ true, it just makes her look like a hot head.
Beyond light has grown on me but its 100% nostalgia. Even at release I remember this shit felt like a chore to complete. It is insanely boring.
After you're finished reviewing D2 Campaigns, you should go back to d1, would love to see your input throughout the vanilla campaign 😂
Now imagine a patricianTV level video on D1, it's a work in progress
@@Nanokk_ holyyyyy I can't wait 😂
best soundtrack + best atmosphere to a planet in the game
i like my snow :>
True and true and true and true and yeah, that's pretty true.
Destiny 2 always had so much potential, yet a lot of time its just wasted a water down version of what we get told and teased about, with the worst part about people defending the game with their life like a Stockholm Syndrome.
It's a shame they spent so much marketing time teasing a pyramid ship army, and getting us hype for a war just for the pyramids to be empty and the campaign to basically have nothing at all with the campaign 😅
POV: You Witness Beyond Lights not so biggest hater.
I like the ice subclass thing
Idk man, I don’t think BL was like great, but I don’t think it was bad. It was just alright. Looking at it from the lens we have now makes it seem even worse. Kinda jarring in some points, like how Eramis randomly appears, the whole salvation house and their gimmick is kinda like we’re here now, now deal with us. But like it wasn’t bad like I said. Like the complaint we wish we could’ve had the subclass for the whole campaign I only really saw around lightfall. And then looking back on this campaign you’d say the same thing, but back then it wasn’t like that. It was the first time a new subclass and the implications behind it existed like that. Upon having it be the way it was executed once, lightfall should’ve learnt from it. But I don’t feel like BL should take some marks off for this or other stuff like that. It’s not near TFS or Forsaken or TK, but it wasn’t bad at all imo. Like a classic destiny expansion. And maybe that speaks to the fact Bungie could make their expansions go above and beyond and have the skill in their employees to do so. But for what Destiny has delivered as a whole, it was like a solid 6/10 for me, if 5 was an exact average. 90% of BL was average, a few things were kinda under average, stasis (especially for the time) was way beyond average. And it kinda evens out around that 6.
Postgame carries this expansion tbh
Tho about the dark vanguard, IIRC this was the covid year expansion and a lot of content was lost. They had to cut them out mostly and with the lack of time they had to make ghost speak for the dirfter (I think the voice actor was sick and they had no tiem no wait or he was occupied with something else) The mission was still a banger thanks to exactly ghost's impression of drifter but MAN this DLC was really hurt by covid.
I feel not addressing the raid in this case especially is a bit of a poor decision considering its one it the best in D2. I get why you don't address them, but they add a lot to the DLC's content
The campaign is whatever. A bit mid.
They should definitely move back to the TK subclass model. Stasis and Strand were handled very poorly.
If you don't mind me asking, when did you start playing Destiny?
1. I've stated in every video this series explicitly only covers the campaign, the only execption I'll make is TFS when the time comes.
2. I've been playing Destiny since The Taken King on the ps3, I started playing Destiny 2 during Curse of Osiris on ps4, and moved to pc halfway through shadowkeep
@@Nanokk_
1. Idk if you meant to but you kinda sound like a smartass here. I get why you don't cover raids- and honestly just covering the campaigns works best for reviews like this, but I feel like having a separate video covering the raids after the TFS review would be nice seeing how they're almost a companion piece of sorts to their campaign.
2. Good shit fr, personally been playing since the D2 Beta.
@@SpankyMcPants.
1. My bad, I didn't mean to sound like a smartass lol. I plan on making a larger retrospective on Destiny 2, where I'll cover the raids and their storylines maybe, I'm still working out the structure
@@Nanokk_ That'll be a good way to round off the series, and probably give each individual DLC a better chance to shine overall
Eramis was in season of plunder and seraph…
At least the raid Is one of the best we’ve seen.
I enjoyed Shadowkeep's campaign more, even the Dark Below's campaign had more substance than this. The only reason to buy this DLC is DSC. But DSC is worth the whole price of the DLC.
Im gonna say it....... Beyond Light > Witch Queen
really missed not titling the video “beyond boring”
good job good vid good luck with new vids
i love alot of the destiny videos i watch theres always a small subtle kingdom hearts reference 🤣
Shadowkeep is more of a snoozefest in my opinion it did absolutely nothing compared to forsaken and the whole campaign can be boiled down to doing bounties instead of an actual story
When did owen wilson start reviewing destiny?
That is the first time I have ever been called Owen Wilson ever
Horrible campaign. I unironically thought that it'd be the best campaign when I first played it. I was shook and taken back by how dogshit it was
i genuinely just straight up ignored the story cause i just wanted to get the new stasis subclass
also u should do reviews on waframe mission cause they are actually goated
Tried warframe, couldn't get into it. If I'm gonna review any mmo after this it'll be Elder Scrolls Online
@@Nanokk_ lemme guide u through warframe i have like 200 hours into it
The Brigs were reused from Scourge of the Past? I've never raided before, so I didn't know that. That's hilarious.
It isn't 1 to 1, but yeah it's basically a reskin lol
Same situation with Tormentors and Subjugators. Pocket Sized Raid bosses that introduce a new mechanic or two. Which I actually really like. Only really completely new singular units are the Wyverns and Lightbearers. The rest of the big tanky enemies added to factions are likely downscaled raid bosses
Beyond light has my favorite villain, eramis, my favorite element, stasis, and my favorite music of the entire franchise. Everything else? Complete ass. It sucks it didn't get a good campaign like witch queen
Man I agree with a lot of the complaints but some things just land weird. Eramis isn't a great villain, but it looks way worse when you compare her in-campaign activities to other villains lore-defined activities. Talking about how easy the campaign is with a post Witch Queen sandbox also feels a little offputting especially since the vids on Forsaken and prior use footage from much weaker sandboxes (by necessity, I know).
Europa being boring is a matter of personal taste imo - I love it as a true sci-fi destination especially when compared to Dreaming City/Throne World/Pale Heart - but i can see where you're coming from.
The mid campaign kill enemies grinding sucks ass, i wont contest that at all. Just because other MMOs do it during their MSQs doesnt mean Destiny should
So something I mentioned at the start is I don't care about the lore, I don't focus on it, and eramis' impact (at least at this point) was minimal at best. Talking about how easy the campaign was became almost a necessity because you can't ignore just how easy it is now. It was harder at launch I'm aware but it's been power crept to hell and back, it needs addressing.
I personally wouldn't call the Dreaming City, throne world, or the pale heart sci-fi locations, and more fantasy. Which Bungie should lean into way more