Noisy engine tapping? Can I fix it? Citroen C1, Toyota or Peugeot Engine

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 95

  • @startfromscratch4858
    @startfromscratch4858  2 роки тому +31

    OK, so I had it fixed. It turns out it was the timing chain. I will upload another video of it fixed when I get a minute.

    • @sebastianborek3591
      @sebastianborek3591 2 роки тому +4

      I don't think you fixed it.Thats no timing chain.

    • @startfromscratch4858
      @startfromscratch4858  2 роки тому +3

      @@sebastianborek3591,, interesting you should say that I will add the other video and let me know what you think

    • @marekerin1057
      @marekerin1057 Рік тому +11

      Still waiting on that video

    • @sebastianborek3591
      @sebastianborek3591 Рік тому +6

      And what?I replaced timing chain as well and sound remained the same.cause it's not chain that's piston slap.
      Thank you that'll.

    • @startfromscratch4858
      @startfromscratch4858  Рік тому +6

      @@sebastianborek3591 Got rid of the car now. It seemed to improve it massively

  • @pintercsaba5264
    @pintercsaba5264 2 дні тому

    Hi. did you find out what was wrong? What makes the engine knock?

  • @gerhardgugelhupf2272
    @gerhardgugelhupf2272 2 роки тому +17

    As many wrote piston slap due to vvt and ignition timing (ignition starts way before piston is at top position causing slap sound). Nothing bad with that. Your engine still runs smootly for 1kr type.

    • @japreet_kah
      @japreet_kah 2 роки тому

      Not the problem with mine. When I put my foot down it does a proper loud chug. That's all I can describe. "Chug chug chug chug chug" when I put my foot down? HELP!

  • @curtis8516
    @curtis8516 2 роки тому +8

    Mine did the same after it had sat on a forecourt for months. A good drive and regular use, it's not done it in 5 years.

  • @unspecified5112
    @unspecified5112 10 місяців тому +9

    It's the timing chain hitting on the inside of the engine block.
    I've had an Aygo since 2006 and it has done it ever since it was driven out of the Toyota dealership until the engine warms up. Last year I replaced the engine because it was just drinking oil after reaching 200,000 miles. When I took the old engine apart, you could see the scratching on the inside of the engine block where the chain was hitting the top.
    As long as you use good quality oil and change it regularly, it won't be an issue. Low quality or the wrong oil will clog up the timing chain tensioner and hinder its performance / stop it working altogether.

    • @sebastianborek3591
      @sebastianborek3591 10 місяців тому +1

      It's not timing chain it's piston slap as I know from my experience .besides timing tensioner is mechanical not oil tensioner!

    • @startfromscratch4858
      @startfromscratch4858  9 місяців тому

      Changed the timing chain. Didn't make much difference

    • @unspecified5112
      @unspecified5112 9 місяців тому +2

      ​@@sebastianborek3591 I'm not saying you're wrong because it's also a common fault with these, but with piston slap, you'd expect to see blue smoke and a drop in the oil level? When the piston hits the side of the cylinder wall you'd end up with scoring and deformation which would allow oil to seep through past the oil seal and burn.
      Also I know the timing chain tensioner is mechanical and my point was that low or bad quality oil can cause the mechanical parts of tensioner to not work as effectively. I'm not saying it would make the chain loose as such, but that tiny bit of play can cause it to hit the side/top engine block due to there being such little clearance.

  • @onepalproductions
    @onepalproductions 2 роки тому +18

    This is normal for this vvt engine. It is explained by a former mechanic in a video called:
    "CityBug "Ticking sound on engine" Explained" Toyota Aygo Peugeot 107 Citroen C1 1KR-FE Tapping Noise"

  • @ratpoision9298
    @ratpoision9298 2 роки тому +8

    Hi I have a 2006 Toyota Vitz with the same 1KRFE 1Litre 3 cylinder engine with a little over 55,000 KM. I am getting that sounds too. To me there are portions of the engine that gets restricted from engine oil flow. The sound is more noticeable at low rpm/ when idling. If it requires attention, the sound would be progressively louder at higher rpm or when driving. Also it sound like a pre-donation/ pinging maybe the quality of gas or dirty throttle body. Anyway, I have mine still going strong with all the unwanted noise and vibration

    • @sakisaki9398
      @sakisaki9398 5 місяців тому

      Exact the same issue here. What could it be?

  • @sebastianborek3591
    @sebastianborek3591 2 роки тому +15

    That's piston slap.Nothing helps but after some driving when engine is really warm knock disappear.

  • @user-2uf2kr2c
    @user-2uf2kr2c Рік тому +4

    Hello, if it's the 1KR-FE engine, they say it doesn't have hydraulic valve lifters...Regards
    Any engine with a timing chain needs the right grade/clean/quality oil regularly because if the hydraulic tensioner gets clogged you'll get a loosely fitting chain that will make a rattling sound and may cause severe engine/valve/piston damage.

    • @startfromscratch4858
      @startfromscratch4858  Рік тому

      Thanks

    • @sebastianborek3591
      @sebastianborek3591 Рік тому +2

      There is no hydraulic tensioner.

    • @user-2uf2kr2c
      @user-2uf2kr2c Рік тому

      @@sebastianborek3591 how do think the chain gets up to "tension"? To my knowledge every engine with a timing chain has an hydraulic tensioner and every engine with a timingbelt has a spring operated tensioner. Regards

    • @sebastianborek3591
      @sebastianborek3591 10 місяців тому +1

      It's not oil tensioner it's mechanical!

  • @jusb1066
    @jusb1066 2 роки тому +4

    Back in the day those additives used to be super thick and that's how they quietened things down. But that was pretty thin so I can see why did nothing. The valves are shims and not hydraulic

  • @alfredjamesdelgado2037
    @alfredjamesdelgado2037 27 днів тому

    mine stays at idle until 2000 revs
    but disappears above 2000
    is this normal😊

  • @kenclarke1952
    @kenclarke1952 Рік тому

    glad its fixed. just read some of the stupid remarks and on that basis i thought it was low air pressure in the NSR tyre🙄

  • @thebeardyone
    @thebeardyone 2 роки тому +6

    Give it some time! A couple of hundred miles might do it, but I reckon that it'll be the same hydraulic tappet issue that my AYGO has. Have you tried using a piece of dowel as a stethoscope to narrow down the problem to an individual cylinder? My noise usually disappears for a little while after an oil change, but it soon returns - strangely, it can go away some days, and fortunately it's not apparent when you're on light throttle, so on journeys it's not a real problem.

    • @henryrolt3747
      @henryrolt3747 2 роки тому +4

      The 1KR-FE does not use hydraulic lifters. It uses solid bucket lifters directly acted upon by the camshafts.

    • @littlelegs4086
      @littlelegs4086 2 роки тому +1

      The Argo don’t have hydraulic tappers there shims a cam out job

    • @steveo3002
      @steveo3002 Рік тому

      @@henryrolt3747 mad aint it ,..dont stop idiots handing out dud advice

  • @danielmabella
    @danielmabella 7 місяців тому

    Crankshaft bearing - visible when one removes the oilpan, then sometimes the oil pump is not OK and can cause the crankshaft bearings to ring dry…

  • @johnnyboyle4811
    @johnnyboyle4811 2 роки тому +7

    My aygo was running that badly it looked like it was trying to jump out of the car. Iridium plugs, wynns oil stabilizer and steel seal later, smooth as any engine ive ever heard.

    • @tiagofermar
      @tiagofermar 2 роки тому

      Are you using 5w30 on your Aygo?

    • @johnnyboyle4811
      @johnnyboyle4811 2 роки тому +1

      @@tiagofermar i had 5w30 but I've now put 10w40. I would say stick to 5w30

    • @tiagofermar
      @tiagofermar 2 роки тому +1

      @@johnnyboyle4811 Thank you for your time answering! I used 10w40 3000miles each time but notice that the engine would make a ticking noise, especially in the morning (I do live in the UK) now with the 5w30, I notice that the noise is way less and the engine seems to run smoother. Maybe will get some iridium plugs to see if it helps a little more. Do you think that 5w40 will do the job? thank you for your time Johnny!

    • @oceanwave7087
      @oceanwave7087 2 роки тому +1

      @@johnnyboyle4811 Hi my son was supplied 15w40, now taping sound very bad. could it be because of oil too thick? we live in warm temeratures. thanks

    • @johnnyboyle4811
      @johnnyboyle4811 2 роки тому +3

      @@oceanwave7087 although the engines on these are supposed to be able to run on 0w20 or 5w30 and I've heard of people using 15w40 it's best to stick to a good quality 5w30

  • @abitofeverything1985
    @abitofeverything1985 9 місяців тому +1

    Them 3 pistons are slapping shit out of it.. 😂

  • @Aaron_of_Arnor
    @Aaron_of_Arnor 2 роки тому +6

    Max oil level ( 3.2 liter ) makes my aygo really quiet.. but after 3000 km its noisy.. i give the bi tch 500ml 5w30 from action every 3000 km. And oil change every 10.000km as mister haynes advices

    • @automotivepaint5664
      @automotivepaint5664 6 місяців тому

      Alle 7000km

    • @sakisaki9398
      @sakisaki9398 5 місяців тому

      Doesn’t this engine need 0W20 engine oil? That’s what it says in the manual book 😮

  • @superelectic45
    @superelectic45 2 роки тому +3

    If you look in the owners manual it says check and adjust tappets at 60,000 miles. It has solid lifters not hydraulic.

  • @piotrczaplinski8525
    @piotrczaplinski8525 2 роки тому +1

    The same problem in my Aygo mk1. The first thing that came to mind was valve clearence.

  • @algoru16
    @algoru16 Рік тому +2

    Yo tengo el mismo problema en mi Yaris, ni cambio de cadena, ni bujías, ni limpiar el cuerpo de aceleración, ni pcv, ni maf ni nada, además con la vibración golpetea el escape entre 1500 y 2000 rpm, horroroso

  • @northernowl7087
    @northernowl7087 2 роки тому +3

    Piston slap it’s a common thing in the older ones don’t ever put any cleaners into a engine .

    • @carlosdionisio5227
      @carlosdionisio5227 2 роки тому

      No engine cleaner? Might get worst?

    • @ELECTROMARINEMANIA
      @ELECTROMARINEMANIA Рік тому

      ​@@carlosdionisio5227 yes I put liquimoly valve cleaner....then this tik tiknnoise small cames

  • @pauloisidoro2
    @pauloisidoro2 11 місяців тому

    Sincerely for me it sound like a major mechanical fault , pistons ,tappets ,timing chain,you name it, like a very high mileage car probably neglecting regular oil change

  • @jirispachman898
    @jirispachman898 Рік тому +3

    I have the same car that made the same noises. The problem was the clutch. After the clutch was replaced, the noise stopped.

  • @foxspeed197
    @foxspeed197 2 роки тому +4

    it has shimmed buckets in the engine....not hydraulic tappet adjusters!!!

  • @karabomoalosi6578
    @karabomoalosi6578 2 роки тому

    Hello pliz I use 2zz alles make that noise and it hv oil light

  • @cs56076
    @cs56076 Рік тому +4

    This is the timing chain. Even though low mileage I’m wondering if the mileage is 1. Genuine or 2. Has had a diet of poor quality oil.
    I’ve found that although people claim the 1KRFE is bulletproof, it really is sensitive to correct grades and needs premium oils. It’s known in certain circles that Toyotas own oil is Mobil 1.
    The problem with cheaper oils is that not only do they increase wear, but they lead to varnishing and organic particulates which clog the timing chain tensioner. The chain may not be that much stressed, but the tensioner takes increased time to reach full pressure, or as can be seen here, perhaps never does along with wear.
    These are very good, simple engines and considered, sadly - as almost throwaway by many owners … that is until austerity, Covid and the end of affordable sub compact class really hit in. As a result, many of these cars are neglected.
    They really do rely on top quality oils as the sumps are so tiny and for the more delicate cam gear and softer piston rings for higher MPG.
    Only use mobil 1 or another premium oil

    • @startfromscratch4858
      @startfromscratch4858  Рік тому +1

      Mileage is gen. Not so sure about the oil thought.

    • @cs56076
      @cs56076 Рік тому +2

      @@startfromscratch4858Ah, so I was right about it being the chain though, when others were saying piston slap and lifter tick. I wonder what else I might be right about? You would of course know that lifted tick on most cases develops from low quality oil and neglected oil change intervals.
      So, what do you put the stretched chain / failed tensioner down to? What oil do you use and what history of oil changes / quality did it have?

    • @startfromscratch4858
      @startfromscratch4858  Рік тому +1

      Not sure how well maintained it was

  • @dunks4212
    @dunks4212 2 роки тому +3

    Doesn't sound that bad 😃

  • @Chris1ar
    @Chris1ar 2 роки тому +2

    Old lady owner, low miles. That needs a proper Italian tune up

  • @camdenlighting8140
    @camdenlighting8140 Рік тому

    Dirty or leaking injector

  • @dalenaq
    @dalenaq Рік тому

    There was a fuzzy noise and it cleared

  • @Kamilsmk
    @Kamilsmk 2 роки тому +2

    piston slap

  • @deanevans6616
    @deanevans6616 4 місяці тому

    Yep

  • @abdulsijad2419
    @abdulsijad2419 5 місяців тому

    its defo the 6 cylinders that have messed up in this 3 cylinder bag of crap

  • @Gggggggg618
    @Gggggggg618 11 місяців тому +1

    PISTON SLAP😂😂😂

  • @fabiopinzani3044
    @fabiopinzani3044 Рік тому

    Secondo me è la catena della distribuzione. Buona fortuna e fammi sapere.

  • @antoinepatrick8716
    @antoinepatrick8716 Рік тому +1

    No difference 😂😂

  • @dorothykelley5392
    @dorothykelley5392 2 роки тому

    ᑭᖇOᗰOᔕᗰ 🙌

  • @Jbourne247
    @Jbourne247 2 роки тому

    Bent Conrod hitting lower cylinder bore

  • @lennonpolo
    @lennonpolo 2 роки тому

    Might be a bent Con Rod?

    • @northernowl7087
      @northernowl7087 2 роки тому +1

      😂😂😂don’t be silly

    • @lennonpolo
      @lennonpolo 2 роки тому

      @@northernowl7087 Why's that?

    • @northernowl7087
      @northernowl7087 2 роки тому

      @@lennonpolo because these engines are renowned for piston slap and pinking

    • @lennonpolo
      @lennonpolo 2 роки тому

      @@northernowl7087 See here! ua-cam.com/video/Ah7HgW4E2rs/v-deo.html

    • @Alf-Garnish
      @Alf-Garnish Рік тому

      you've been watching another video 😂