Why Do YOU Believe in GOD?? Call Seth Andrews & Aron Ra | Sunday Show AFTER DARK 07.07.24

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 лип 2024
  • 07.07.24 Our #: +1-720-619-2288 or online thru www.callinstudio.com/show/The...
    Support the Show!
    SUPPORT THE NETWORK
    ---------------------------------------------------
    Patreon: / calltheline
    Become a Channel Member:
    SUPPORT PRODUCTION
    ---------------------------------------------------
    Paypal: www.paypal.me/mratheist
    Cashapp: cash.app/$jimmyasnow
    Amazon Wishlist: www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls...
    MORE LIVE SHOWS & CLIPS
    ---------------------------------------------------
    / @callthelinex
    CONTACT US
    ---------------------------------------------------
    contact@qnaline.com
    HOSTS
    ---------------------------------------------------
    Jimmy Snow: @JimmySnow
    Matt Dillahunty: @SansDeity
    Arden Hart: / theardenhart
    Katy Montgomerie: @KatyMontgomerie
    Forrest Valkai: @RenegadeScienceTeacher
    Dr. Ben: @FamilyDrBen
    Aron Ra: @AronRa
    Shannon Q: @ShannonQ
    John Gleason: @godlessengineer
    Erika: @GutsickGibbon
    Eve Was Framed: / eve_wasframed
    Paulogia: @paulogia
    Alyssa Ljub: @AlyssaLjub
    Eric: @skepticsandscoundrels
    Dr. Aaron Adair
    ADDRESS
    ---------------------------------------------------
    The Line
    110 N Interstate 35
    Suite 315-1027
    Round Rock, TX 78681
    United States
    SHOWS ON THE LINE
    ---------------------------------------------------
    Sundays: The Sunday Show
    Monday: Skeptalk
    Tuesday: Chewed Gum
    Wednesday: The Hang Up
    Thursday: The Trans Atlantic Call In Show (TACIS)
    Friday: Debates and Bonus Shows!
    Look out for “HOSTility” and “Cus I Wanna” any day, any time
    #CallTheLine
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 527

  • @voxpopuli348
    @voxpopuli348 9 днів тому +140

    Protecting yourself from abusive parents is not disrespect.

    • @USS_Sentinel
      @USS_Sentinel 9 днів тому +27

      Every child deserves a parent but not every parent deserves a child.

    • @TheRaven_200
      @TheRaven_200 9 днів тому +7

      Facts!

    • @HystericalSej
      @HystericalSej 8 днів тому +8

      And protecting your children from abusive grandparents is RESPONSIBLE PARENTING.
      !@#$ this "honor thy abusive parents" bullshit.

    • @Alienshade
      @Alienshade 8 днів тому +3

      Grandparents should normally only give the children love and don't try to change anything with the education of the children. Because it will probably not end that well for the grandparents.

    • @IRGeamer
      @IRGeamer 8 днів тому +4

      Never underestimate a narcissists burning lust to manufacture oppression for themselves when faced with even the most reasonable and minor criticism.

  • @ClutchCargo001
    @ClutchCargo001 9 днів тому +40

    Hearing Seth say 'God dammit!" live on air kinda made my day. You tell 'em, Seth!

    • @RidetheGeoffening
      @RidetheGeoffening 8 днів тому +2

      He earned it , having sat through the better part of a call from the insufferable Amir

  • @joelonsdale
    @joelonsdale 6 днів тому +11

    The more I hear Aron deal with callers, the more I love him. His fellow hosts shouldn't try and soften his approach, he has been doing this long enough to know just the right amount of disrespect, disappointment and crushing logic to apply. I would love an Aron-only phone-in show where we can enjoy his personality in full.

  • @FaiaHalo
    @FaiaHalo 9 днів тому +244

    I recently added the TS of the latest show. Hope you have a wonderful week!
    9:39 River (he/him) - Atheist | Caller wants to know if there is any historical truth to the bible.
    15:53 Jeff (he/him) - Theist | Caller says "you get the knowledge and you know it by faith."
    34:55 Amir (he/him) - Theist | Caller claims that the god he believes in "is the best explanation for why anything at all exists." And also throws the "you have faith in science" claim in the mix.
    53:28 Announcements.
    54:24 Weird *ss troll call.
    1:01:40 Jay (he/him) - Pantheist | Caller shares what he believes in: that the Universe is god and the cosmos are divine.
    1:19:49 Jeff (he/him) - Atheist | Caller wants to talk about "evidence," how it is talked about and how we define it.
    1:26:30 Jimmie (he/him) - Theist | Caller wants to put Aron on blast for the piece of cloth behind him lol
    1:41:49 Theopolis (he/them) - Theist | Caller claims hosts have a "laughable" basis for morality, yet shows he has a laughable basis for his own.
    1:56:37 Reynaldo (he/him) - Theist | Caller claims to be "god of all."
    2:01:43 Cloud (he/him) - Atheist | Caller's father keeps dismissing him and claims he is an atheist because "he is too young to know," so he asks advice from hosts regarding this. [Much love to Caller

    • @Marko_Ilic
      @Marko_Ilic 9 днів тому +12

      Thank you Faia!

    • @inaneglory7431
      @inaneglory7431 9 днів тому +8

      Thank you! 🎉

    • @USS_Sentinel
      @USS_Sentinel 9 днів тому +8

      O7, Faia!

    • @freakishuproar1168
      @freakishuproar1168 9 днів тому +7

      Thank you for the detailed timestamps Faia :D I for one don't always have the time to watch an entire VOD, so your posts are a saving sight for sore eyes.

    • @russwren3373
      @russwren3373 9 днів тому +8

      Faia you are my hero!

  • @JayMaverick
    @JayMaverick 8 днів тому +50

    Jeff trying to challenge Aron with "Look at the trees" and then the subsequent "Oh look at the time" was predictable and hilarious.

    • @infinite_array
      @infinite_array 8 днів тому +6

      Yeah, funny how he got called away the second he was challenged to provide actual evidence.
      I doubt we'll hear back from Jeff again.

    • @littlefurrow2437
      @littlefurrow2437 8 днів тому +5

      Look at the time trees.

    • @riccardozanoni2531
      @riccardozanoni2531 8 днів тому +2

      @@littlefurrow2437 this wouldn't be out of place as a doctor who episode title, weirdly enough

    • @trafficjon400
      @trafficjon400 8 днів тому +3

      Matt say's oh' your going to run away now".

  • @bortiz11
    @bortiz11 6 днів тому +5

    Seth was my intro to atheism, when I didn’t believe but didn't know what an atheist was. Can't think of a better representative and first contact for newbies than he.

  • @LogicAndReason2025
    @LogicAndReason2025 9 днів тому +50

    Amir - show us 20 dentists with genuinely conflicting advice, and we'll show you at least 19 people who are not certified dentists.

    • @Nava9380
      @Nava9380 8 днів тому +3

      dishonest caller.

    • @titania2112
      @titania2112 7 днів тому +4

      @@Nava9380 Correct, like all christians.

    • @Wolf-ln1ml
      @Wolf-ln1ml 7 днів тому +2

      Nah, depending on the medical problem, there could be 2-3 significantly different, but perfectly reasonable recommendations. So in his example of 25 different dentists all giving different advice, it could "only" be 22-23 people who are frauds...
      But yeah, of course he *_had to_* go with such an extreme example since that's exactly what we see in religion...

    • @richardearnshaw2719
      @richardearnshaw2719 6 днів тому

      Long before the twentieth dentist I'd have gone to Doctor - even a witch doctor would have given a bit of perspective. ALSO I might have driven past a dentist school or two to make sure they weren't burnt to the ground. 😂

    • @daniel-panek
      @daniel-panek 5 днів тому +2

      Here's the problem with this caller's statement. You don't have 20 dentists with 2 different theories. You have 1 million scientists with one theory, and maybe 19 with 19 different theories.
      This isn't 5% and 5% and 5% and so on for each theory. There is like 99.98% and 0.01% and 0.001% and 0.004% and so forth.

  • @SquidwardQSagan
    @SquidwardQSagan 9 днів тому +71

    I love how Aron cuts straight to it. So tired of callers bullshit, and i’m glad aron challenges them instead of babying them. Some people need a shaking out of it. Aron doesn’t allow the caller to set the terms as they are use to doing to all their other (captive) audiences

    • @trafficjon400
      @trafficjon400 8 днів тому +2

      Could there be 2 Matt D, personalities coming ? Aron - RN ' is getting tired of bullshit, your not joking.

    • @trafficjon400
      @trafficjon400 8 днів тому +2

      RN for Aron! it's pronounced like RN , though Aron is not a nurse. lol

    • @Hobbes250
      @Hobbes250 7 днів тому

      I think Aron can have great moments but he often seems to miss the point the caller is asking about. In this episode alone Seth had to correct Aron a few times on what the caller was asking.

    • @daniel-panek
      @daniel-panek 5 днів тому

      Aron is a tired old atheist. He's got no energy for bullshit. I'm not as old as he is and I'm already tired.

  • @corringhamdepot4434
    @corringhamdepot4434 9 днів тому +32

    Theists don't get that the certainty of their "faith" is nothing like the "uncertainty" of the scientific model. The "uncertainty" of science is it's greatest strength, not a weakness.

    • @TheChancellor212
      @TheChancellor212 9 днів тому +12

      When you believe without evidence, the existence of contrary evidence is a threat.

    • @trafficjon400
      @trafficjon400 8 днів тому

      @@TheChancellor212 911 they actually believed, God tolled them, to crash 767's in to the Towers and Pentagon. many christian believers in the towers, and God couldn't, save one, for a strange reason had not enough power, so he let them suffer a horror we couldn't fathom then, die as well. theist just keep your mouth shut !! you have nothing to think through your teeth about.

    • @cy-one
      @cy-one 7 днів тому +1

      Science not saying "We have the definitive answer to X" leaves the door open for scientific advancement.
      Just imagine where we would be now if science would've stuck to "The sun definitely revolves around a stationary earth."
      Imagine where we would be now if the Bible wouldn't have amended that slavery or marital rape are bad. ... Wait...

  • @SquidwardQSagan
    @SquidwardQSagan 9 днів тому +28

    Seth’s words with amir were top tier

  • @Heathen.Deity.
    @Heathen.Deity. 3 дні тому +2

    Jimmie’s phone was doing its absolute best to prevent Jimmie from embarrassing himself.

  • @xfer43
    @xfer43 8 днів тому +4

    Huge AronRa fan. Been a member of his community for over a decade. His use of language and his verbal pugilism is second to none. I am aware of Seth and have enjoyed his quality of discussion. This was a fantastic “good cop/bad cop” team up. Thank you, gentlemen!

  • @monsterinhead214
    @monsterinhead214 9 днів тому +46

    Check out Aron's horns. Nice.

    • @feedingravens
      @feedingravens 9 днів тому +2

      On a video where he was on an expedition for finding fossils, he proundly presented his Jeep with huge bullhorns on the cowling.
      I commented that here in Germany that would never be allowed because when you hit a pedestrian, you can literally impale him.
      And Aron even responded, very honest
      I think I also told him (not quite sure anymore) that by chance they had shown some moments of this expedition on german TV, and I had practically looked around whether I see a Klingon around there.

    • @MrCanis4
      @MrCanis4 9 днів тому +1

      Coincidence ?? 😂😂😂

    • @Diviance
      @Diviance 9 днів тому +1

      @@feedingravens
      Here in the US we don't care much about pedestrians. We even have a completely road legal gigantic chunk of unpainted steel in a wedge shape masquerading as a truck that appears to be designed to ensure pedestrians do not survive an impact.

    • @feedingravens
      @feedingravens 9 днів тому

      @@Diviance I know, The carrot-cutter and cucumber-shaving device. I find it amazing that most videos about it are people that buy it to shoot at it.
      The wheel covers that cut up the tires were hilarious, the wheel arches are measly plastic,
      and the "bumpers" are just to hide the protruding ends of the chassis.
      Meaning when you crash into something, the stress goes directly into the load-carrying structure, and when that bends (Tesla shops do not repair, they ONLY replace) it is a write-off.
      Like Elon Musk wants to show off, I have the impression the Cybertruck's market segment is for those that need to pretend to themselves what tough guys they are, that they will be the ones that survive The Stand that QAnon predicts, in a postapocalyptic world where all is destroyed, but your socket still has power.
      People that love their long hard rod (of their gun barrel) always ready, cock-ed and loaded, always ready to shoot its load as often as you want to.

    • @Diviance
      @Diviance 9 днів тому

      @@feedingravens
      Yep. Less than brilliant people with delusions of grandeur and a Main Character Syndrome.

  • @jimteutsch5957
    @jimteutsch5957 8 днів тому +2

    I am an atheist. Yet I love my snakes, skulls, Baphomet, pagan folk art, pentagrams, etc. Thanks Aron and Seth!

  • @thomasgallipoli8376
    @thomasgallipoli8376 8 днів тому +4

    Seth & Aron are tag team champions. Every time they are on together, it’s a must watch for me.

  • @creatressmwk8226
    @creatressmwk8226 9 днів тому +13

    Seth, you speak to my heart and you give callers genuine concern to protect themselves. I have to say, after a bathroom break, I came back to find you with the "Help Me" post-it on your head. Bwhahahahaha.....oh my gawd you gave me a much need belly laugh for the night! Thank you, thank you, thank you both!!!

  • @robertshepard2117
    @robertshepard2117 4 дні тому +2

    "Don't try to confuse me with facts and logic,my mind is already made up"

  • @Icypenguigo
    @Icypenguigo 6 днів тому +2

    Aron and Seth are amazing. A very interesting duo. Seth's silky smooth voice and lovely, compassionate view of the world contrasts with Aron's stubborn, science and fact-based view which we all need in our lives. I love both you guys. Thank you for all you do!

  • @LogicAndReason2025
    @LogicAndReason2025 8 днів тому +5

    Whenever someone threatens me with their hell, I ask them: "What if there really is a god, and she reserves heaven for skeptics and heathens, and hell is reserved for people who claim certainty about stuff they have no idea about just to scare people into compliance and take their money? What if this is all a gullibility test?"

  • @Better_callMe
    @Better_callMe 6 днів тому +3

    For Cloud, If you grew up as a JW, it will be tough to get your father to understand you unless he is willing to accept he is wrong. I left the JWs about 10 years ago, but luckily my family did not stop talking to me. Unfortunately, my family seems to be the exception.

  • @wesmanpipes9430
    @wesmanpipes9430 9 днів тому +29

    Theopolis is using a voice changer and from the hostility Im willing to bet hes one of Darths soy boyfriends.

    • @jonnowds
      @jonnowds 6 днів тому +2

      100% his cadence ✅

    • @facundotorres175
      @facundotorres175 15 годин тому +2

      Yeah he was using a vocoder and he was too stupid to keep it away from the mic

  • @isaganipalanca8803
    @isaganipalanca8803 8 днів тому +3

    I just love the music that opens the stream! It reminds me of all the raves I attended in the late Nineties and early 2000s! Happy memories!

  • @rickwilliams7431
    @rickwilliams7431 7 днів тому +4

    *_Faith is the excuse people offer, when they don't have a good reason_** .*
    (If you had a good reason, you would not require faith)

  • @user-nk3tt6zt2l
    @user-nk3tt6zt2l 9 днів тому +18

    Seth, no apologies at all is necessary. You were logical, and the caller was blood lusting at straws.

  • @alienskinmusic
    @alienskinmusic 4 дні тому +1

    The combination of Aron and Seth is a winner and needs to be repeated. They have different approaches but compliment each other so well, it makes for a very watchable show!

  • @dma8657
    @dma8657 8 днів тому +3

    Aron and Seth, thanks for everything you do. You have helped so many people think better about religion!

  • @rocketsfan6116
    @rocketsfan6116 8 днів тому +4

    Jeff, I mean this genuinely because every single time you've called in I've perceived you to be both genuine and honest...you're making an equivocation. Faith in the christian sense (Hebrews 11:1) is not the same thing as the colloquial usage of the word faith, which is what you're referring to in this call. One is essentially a placeholder for evidence and the other is a synonym for trust and is almost always based on prior information, precedent, and/or confidence based on lived experience.

  • @daniel-panek
    @daniel-panek 5 днів тому +1

    To Seth's words at the end, the mere fact that someone gave birth to you doesn't give them ownership over your entire life.

  • @frmrchristian8488
    @frmrchristian8488 9 днів тому +5

    At 141:50, Aron gave a beautiful and articulate answer. Well done, mate!

  • @jillum89
    @jillum89 9 днів тому +11

    Amir did what nearly _every_ argument for a god does. Claim standard 1, that things need an explanation, and the explanation needs an explanation, and the explanation for the explanation needs an explanation ... reach back to an imagined magical being for which there is no evidence ... and _now_ that you got there; throw away standard 1 and accept standard 2, that things can’t go on forever and ever, so now we have to stop and rather accept that things can and do happen for no reason with no cause.

    • @johnnehrich9601
      @johnnehrich9601 9 днів тому +2

      He is a really frequent caller, under different names, but the same tired old nonsense.

    • @Locust13
      @Locust13 8 днів тому +2

      Yeah amir was just standard basic god of the gaps fallacy.
      He tried to dress it up behind "well you have faith in scientists" but Seth annihilated his dentist analogy.

  • @VGVindaloo
    @VGVindaloo 4 дні тому +1

    "I'm 57 now and I'm turning 58 soon. Back when I was 5 years old...." is a pretty long way to say, "No, I don't have evidence"

  • @JayBandersnatch
    @JayBandersnatch 9 днів тому +11

    Theopolis needs to give Dwight back his "con-quack-ulations" Mallard!

    • @Mmmmilo
      @Mmmmilo 8 днів тому +2

      This is a deep reference. Gotta love it.

    • @JayBandersnatch
      @JayBandersnatch 5 днів тому +1

      @@Mmmmilo Only truly intelligent people will get it😁

  • @Vondoodle
    @Vondoodle 9 днів тому +5

    Apologists have the worst phones

  • @jonnowds
    @jonnowds 6 днів тому +5

    Theopolis: ‘your stance is laughable, now could you tell me what your stances ARE?’ 🤣🤡

  • @wesmanpipes9430
    @wesmanpipes9430 9 днів тому +21

    Jeff used to call in to Talk Heathen. Hes insufferable! Rambles and wants to preach.

    • @guybrush1701
      @guybrush1701 9 днів тому +3

      I haven't listened to that call yet. Is that the Jeff who said "I love you" to Eric and V all the time?

    • @wesmanpipes9430
      @wesmanpipes9430 9 днів тому +2

      @@guybrush1701 Yes it is!

    • @guybrush1701
      @guybrush1701 9 днів тому +4

      @@wesmanpipes9430 oh FFS. Now I'm not sure if I want to listen to this episode or not, lol. He's not as insufferable as Mr. Delicious, but he's still an unending source of bad arguments nonetheless.

    • @jamierichardson7683
      @jamierichardson7683 8 днів тому +2

      ​@@guybrush1701to be fair Monsieur rancid sets a really high standard of insufferable. Ninja levels of skills in that turd

    • @guybrush1701
      @guybrush1701 8 днів тому

      @@jamierichardson7683 this is true. It does take quite a lot to be that arrogant and that ignorant.

  • @warmstrong5612
    @warmstrong5612 7 днів тому +2

    None of those 20 dentists are gonna recommend prayer as a treatment method while demanding 10% of your annual income.

  • @LogicAndReason2025
    @LogicAndReason2025 9 днів тому +8

    Any being that would create a world in which sentient animals eat each other alive, would be a monster.

    • @ChuckBaxter-sv2tn
      @ChuckBaxter-sv2tn 8 днів тому

      Yea I agree 💯 and what's worse we are on the food chain as well yikes!😩 scary indeed.💪🍷🌍🤔🦉

    • @jamierichardson7683
      @jamierichardson7683 8 днів тому +1

      Where almost every family meal in one group is a tragedy in another groups dwelling. Usually be being ripped apart while alive.
      Sick beyond words

    • @Imperial-Socialist
      @Imperial-Socialist 8 днів тому

      If meat is murder, make mine a bacon double cheese murder

    • @solomonverrico
      @solomonverrico 6 днів тому

      The smell of freshly cut grass is their screams.
      If this is designed, it was designed by Freddy Krueger.

  • @Apostate_Alexei
    @Apostate_Alexei 8 днів тому +2

    Jeff had plenty of time to suck up to Seth, but there was no time to answer a difficult yet vital question about the reason he was calling in the first place.
    Fascinating.

  • @solly119119
    @solly119119 9 днів тому +10

    At about the 28:00 minute mark, I was glad to see Seth push back on Aron Ra that telling Jeff - PA why he believes is not a good approach. Let's leave the arrogance of telling someone what they believe or why they believe it to the theists.
    Because they're great at that, and we shouldn't try and match them.

    • @Krawnbundungle
      @Krawnbundungle 8 днів тому

      And yet Aron was correct

    • @solly119119
      @solly119119 8 днів тому +2

      @@Krawnbundungle Whether Aron was correct or not wasn't the point. The point was his approach was as arrogant as Christians who do the same.

    • @Locust13
      @Locust13 8 днів тому +1

      But Aron was RIGHT though. Aron threw down the gauntlet and Jeff ran away.
      Jeff came in with his finger in his pocket saying he had a gun and Aaron looked him in the eye and said "no you don't" and Seth got nervous, but Aron was right.

    • @solly119119
      @solly119119 8 днів тому +1

      @@Locust13 If Aron was right ... wasn't ... my ... point.
      The point was the arrogance of his approach. Which BTW, Seth seemed to recognize because he pushed back on it and instead asked Jeff why he believes instead of stating ... it ... for ... him!
      Aron's arrogance was the point of my post.

  • @SingleDigitDriven
    @SingleDigitDriven 3 дні тому

    50:00 “God damn it Amir”. Aron laughs “you just got Seth to say God damn it” 🤣🤣🤣 that was a priceless moment my friends, thank you Aron and Seth for all you do, you guys are awesome!! 👏

  • @crizolaczarrazcalozirc6052
    @crizolaczarrazcalozirc6052 7 днів тому +2

    Being peer reviewed is an important point here

  • @TheJimtanker
    @TheJimtanker 8 днів тому +2

    @FaiaHalo is the main reason why I watch The Line. I hope she's getting compensated some how. Love what they do.

  • @AmyGrape-wc9uy
    @AmyGrape-wc9uy 7 днів тому +2

    The story about grandpappy Seth and his grandkid was too wholesome for my cold dead atheist heart! 💗🫠

  • @JamesBrown-xb7yi
    @JamesBrown-xb7yi 7 днів тому +1

    I love that guy bailed out when he had to produce evidence, oh Im being called back to work lol

    • @Wolf-ln1ml
      @Wolf-ln1ml 7 днів тому

      It could just be bad timing of course, so we shouldn't jump to conclusions, but that timing _was_ very convenient for him indeed, so we should certainly not just take his word for it either 🙃

  • @kushy2508
    @kushy2508 8 днів тому +5

    is 'Amir' Mr British?? 😂

    • @knownonsenseman8283
      @knownonsenseman8283 8 днів тому +2

      When I saw the name "Amir - UK" I immediately assumed that the call would begin with a broken Pakistani/English accent as in "Rubber dinghy rapids Bro!" (from the movie Four Lions)... but as soon as I heard the actual accent, voice and lack of any hint of an Asian accent, I instantly thought "Mr British".

  • @michaelluckey2353
    @michaelluckey2353 9 днів тому +10

    Uhhhhhhhhhhh,I have to go back to work

    • @ArKritz84
      @ArKritz84 9 днів тому

      Immediately. I'm sure he'll call back, though...🙄

    • @hailsagan8886
      @hailsagan8886 8 днів тому

      He's working on the sabbath. Big sin.....

    • @ryanspangler4569
      @ryanspangler4569 7 днів тому

      Chop chop🤣

  • @gamozzie
    @gamozzie 8 днів тому +2

    When that post-it note came up I almost choked 😂

  • @joehellno9097
    @joehellno9097 8 днів тому +7

    I like many of the Atheist-come-lately young turk hosts and hostesses, but veteran unbelievers Aron and Seth are a team supreme. Expressing their obviously expansive range of actual factual info, they're so amiably relaxed ( until righteously pissed off ) and relatively patient, offering sympathetic support and advice to the perplexed, right up to the moment they are, by rudeness, repetition, or downright denseness, forced to lay down the law ( usually a scientific one ). They are a delightful anti-deist duo. And I do like those moments when these guys crack each other up.

    • @adamredwine774
      @adamredwine774 8 днів тому

      They are entertaining, and I like the content as much as anyone, but I see a lot of the same sort of in-group defense mechanisms in this community as I did in the fundamentalist religion of my family. It is disappointing to see groupthink here even though it is just a reflection of human nature.

  • @generyan2332
    @generyan2332 8 днів тому +1

    Goodness is the opposite of badness. The how that we feel goodness is through good, which is the opposite of badness that we feel when there's bad. That should be your reality Jeff.

  • @D.20
    @D.20 8 днів тому +1

    Thanks! The Line For bringing these wonderful hosts together, this is the content I need. Love you all and keep up the good work ☺

  • @BambiAndBeauty1128
    @BambiAndBeauty1128 8 днів тому +2

    Jimmie from NY sounds like my 11yo on the phone... Quite literally not realizing that they need the phone/watch somewhere near their mouth and to not have it covered by their sleeve

  • @KillerKarchesky
    @KillerKarchesky 9 днів тому +18

    Was gonna like but its at 666 haha

    • @jameswest8280
      @jameswest8280 9 днів тому +4

      They lose a lot of likes that way.

    • @seivaDsugnA
      @seivaDsugnA 9 днів тому

      Multiples of 666 are accepable.

    • @pommy0113
      @pommy0113 9 днів тому

      @@jameswest8280 Always like the 666 so other people will click like!

    • @KillerKarchesky
      @KillerKarchesky 9 днів тому

      @@jameswest8280 ok?

    • @hopelessnerd6677
      @hopelessnerd6677 8 днів тому

      Somebody has to take the arrow.

  • @alexandfelicity
    @alexandfelicity 8 днів тому +2

    I absolutely love how that background is perfectly lined up with Aron, and I love how Andrews noticed it and said something :)

  • @docmartin9489
    @docmartin9489 8 днів тому +2

    I want more shows with aaron and seth. Love you guys!

  • @jameswest8280
    @jameswest8280 9 днів тому +6

    Looks like we interrupted Aron during one of the ceremonies

  • @JoshuaSmithit
    @JoshuaSmithit 8 днів тому +3

    "I'm a grown ass man" --Seth Andrews

  • @ScottM1973
    @ScottM1973 8 днів тому +2

    Jimmie: That background isn't cool
    Me: I disagree it is very cool

  • @GoodieWhiteHat
    @GoodieWhiteHat 2 дні тому

    Seth’s has the classic ‘velvet’ radio voice. Perfect and soothing for listening. He worked in radio and has both quality and learned skill. If people have never heard that sort of voice they might be surprised but to compare that to a robotic AI voice that can’t get nuance or proper nouns right they need to train their ears better.

  • @feffiescottage
    @feffiescottage 7 днів тому +1

    Seth, just sitting there rocking the Blue Steel look. 1:26:52

  • @solly119119
    @solly119119 9 днів тому +5

    Jeff - PA,
    If you look at the comments like other times you've called, here's another way to look at why your name example is faith doesn't work:
    - I have no knowledge of your name until you tell me
    - Once you tell me your name is Jeff, then I do have that knowledge
    - Prior to you telling me your name, "I don't know" is the only honest position I can take
    Do you see how that so perfectly aligns with the atheist position?

    • @adamredwine774
      @adamredwine774 8 днів тому +1

      Also, the moment that a person refers to him as "Jeff" and he responds, the claim "Jeff is his name" is demonstrably correct.

    • @Wolf-ln1ml
      @Wolf-ln1ml 7 днів тому +1

      Someone's name is also a pretty bad analogy to begin with, unless we agree on "it's the word that's on any official documents with my picture on them". Because _all_ other "names" are purely subjective for that person, whether they react to it, whether they identify with it, whether they lie about it, whether it's a nickname, ... - it's _all_ up to that person, unverifiable for everyone else (I guess there might be some neuro-imaging stuff that would help with verification, but I don't think that'd be within the scope of any of this).

    • @adamredwine774
      @adamredwine774 7 днів тому

      @@Wolf-ln1ml I suppose we could distinguish between a "name" and an "alias" but that seems pretty nitpicky.

  • @iconifyme
    @iconifyme 8 днів тому +2

    I would ask Amir why, every mystery we have ever solved in all of human history has turned out to be completely natural and NOT ONCE has the explanation ever been "god" or the supernatural. Not once.

  • @Locust13
    @Locust13 8 днів тому +2

    Haha it made Seth nervous but I like how Aron just straight up told Jeff he didn't have evidence.
    Jeff had his finger in his pocket saying he had a gun and Aron was just straight up calling bullcrap.
    And you know what? Jeff didn't pull out the gun. He didn't skin that smoke pole, he ran away.

  • @ClementGreen
    @ClementGreen 9 днів тому +2

    Tangerine Palpatine - I love it!!!! hahaha

  • @kashandi2
    @kashandi2 4 дні тому

    This was a particularly good show. Thanks!

  • @bodricpriest8816
    @bodricpriest8816 8 днів тому +1

    Dear Theists, if you're going to call please make sure you aren't in the bath, down a mine or up a tree in the middle of a hurricane....

  • @solomonverrico
    @solomonverrico 6 днів тому +1

    Regarding Aron's point of doing good because you're afraid of what will happen if you don't doesn't make you moral. Mark Twain said something about patriotism that stuck with me, because I think it also applies to religion. "We teach them to take their patriotism at second-hand; to shout with the largest crowd without examining into the right or wrong of the matter". I think it's an aspect all on its own that theists don't just have merely the threat of Hell over them to keep them from determining any real sense of morality, they also never question it. They never look at why something is right or wrong and as a consequence we get this neverending parade of ignorance struggling to understand the same damn thing. It's alien to them.

  • @tombraybrook6650
    @tombraybrook6650 8 днів тому +1

    Thank you 😊

  • @CoreyJohnsonMusician
    @CoreyJohnsonMusician 8 днів тому +3

    Glad Seth was there to push back on Aron a bit. On a show about what you believe and why, I don’t find it productive at the start of a call to just proclaim “you don’t have any evidence.” I don’t find that a very honest way to engage with someone.

    • @Wolf-ln1ml
      @Wolf-ln1ml 7 днів тому

      Yeah, while I completely understand Aron's reaction, even find it rather cathartic, I agree. And Seth wasn't _overindulging_ the caller(s) either (unlike some other "YT atheists").

  • @generyan2332
    @generyan2332 8 днів тому +1

    You're a good guy Seth.

  • @crizolaczarrazcalozirc6052
    @crizolaczarrazcalozirc6052 7 днів тому +1

    Yeah, that was the rabbit hole king Mr. British I am almost positive

  • @nessaarandur7740
    @nessaarandur7740 4 дні тому

    You two make a great hosting combo

  • @v0id616
    @v0id616 9 днів тому +7

    Great show! Aron and Seth are a great duo, some of my favorite hosts. Much appreciated.

  • @chinkasuyaro8983
    @chinkasuyaro8983 7 днів тому +1

    Now appearing: Seth Andrews as 'Tengu'. ;)-

  • @LogicAndReason2025
    @LogicAndReason2025 9 днів тому +2

    Another episode proving that most apologetic is 3D: Divert, Distort and Dissemble. Like the mental gymnastics Olympics.

  • @gornser
    @gornser 5 днів тому

    What a nice host combo

  • @surfsnow1371
    @surfsnow1371 6 днів тому +1

    I second the Mindhunter request, make it happen jebus.

  • @kevinmoses4201
    @kevinmoses4201 8 днів тому

    For Cloud, when I was still a believer my favorite Bible verse was Job 32:6-10. Good thing to throw back in the faces of Christians who try to argue that they are wise just due to age.
    "So Elihu son of Barakel the Buzite said:
    “I am young in years,
    and you are old;
    that is why I was fearful,
    not daring to tell you what I know.
    7 I thought, ‘Age should speak;
    advanced years should teach wisdom.’
    8 But it is the spirit[b] in a person,
    the breath of the Almighty, that gives them understanding.
    9 It is not only the old[c] who are wise,
    not only the aged who understand what is right.
    10 “Therefore I say: Listen to me;
    I too will tell you what I know."

  • @Locust13
    @Locust13 8 днів тому +3

    Darth Dawkins' online fangirls like Theopolis always take a jab at the pronouns, whether it's the pronouns they give or them just not being able to get over it. One of the ways you can identify them.

    • @Imperial-Socialist
      @Imperial-Socialist 8 днів тому

      I'm having a chat with a gender critical that has issues with pronouns that he didn't learn in the 60s when he went to school. They said thst they had no preferred, but when I used she/her they got offended

  • @facundotorres175
    @facundotorres175 День тому

    Jay: I just want to believe there's a god so I'm just going to call the universe god

  • @jayarr961
    @jayarr961 3 дні тому

    I have been an atheist for about seven years but I still love Jesus Christ Superstar. I prefer the Broadway version, but I like the movie version too.

  • @ThePsyko420
    @ThePsyko420 8 днів тому +1

    I just wanted to say that i do do whatever i want to do, its just the things i want to do don't include things like rape and murder

  • @Wilhelm-100TheTechnoAdmiral
    @Wilhelm-100TheTechnoAdmiral 8 днів тому +1

    Amir: Okay, so, like I know about God of the Gaps fallacy. This isn't that. This question goes so deep it includes the supernatural. Unmoved mover. Magic man.

  • @pher5661
    @pher5661 8 днів тому +2

    Thank you Seth Andrews for correcting Amir that the 20 dentists cannot have different opinions. That’s absurd. 👍🏼

    • @mactallica9293
      @mactallica9293 6 днів тому

      Then using amirs hypothetical, he couldn't even think of 1 contradictions and just says string theory

    • @noodlekeeper5150
      @noodlekeeper5150 6 днів тому

      Right? My first thought was how that was such a shit analogy. You might get two or three different opinions, such as "pull it", "cap it", and "repair it".

  • @DavidSmith-wp6wx
    @DavidSmith-wp6wx 8 днів тому +2

    Theophilus asks "do you know world history" and immediately goes to the USSR and the CCP and a bit later asks if you're a socialist. Guy just comes off as a typical conservative, young Republican evangelical.

    • @mactallica9293
      @mactallica9293 6 днів тому +2

      Almost every person that throws around socialist,Marxist or communist, has no idea what they're talking about

    • @solomonverrico
      @solomonverrico 6 днів тому +1

      I think he was calling from Italy? So he could be a follower of Rachele Mussolini.
      Yeah, that name's not a coincidence.

  • @knowgods
    @knowgods 5 днів тому

    Damn I’d love to share a beer with Aron🍻 Loving the horns!😂

  • @LogicAndReason2025
    @LogicAndReason2025 9 днів тому +2

    Perhaps we need a web site with a list of the most common apologetic arguments and their rebuttals, then require those who call to either show how the rebuttals don't work, and/or a new argument.

    • @Imperial-Socialist
      @Imperial-Socialist 8 днів тому

      There probably is something collected. I mean axp is 28 years strong.

    • @solomonverrico
      @solomonverrico 6 днів тому +1

      Good luck getting them to actually look at it. I mean there are hundreds of videos (at least) that explain perfectly why these arguments don't work but we're still answering the same stupid questions.

    • @LogicAndReason2025
      @LogicAndReason2025 6 днів тому

      @@solomonverrico They could give priority to callers who do so.

  • @johnsperry9494
    @johnsperry9494 8 днів тому +4

    If you want a real belly-laugh, listen to a Christian describe what it means to be an Atheist. Hilarious! In second place, listen to a Theist’s understanding of science.
    Every time you hear a Theist say, “What Atheists say” or “What Atheists believe,” prepare for some major straw-manning

  • @iconifyme
    @iconifyme 8 днів тому +2

    Amir is being dishonest talking about the "so many models". Everything he names is not a model of the origins of the universe. He has called into the shows before and it's always the same refusal to listen, refusal to accept actual definitions over his strawman version of what things mean. Just a dishonest caller who has made up his mind and asks questions but doesn't actually care about the answers. His questions are just excuses to give his opinions and what he thinks are disprovers.

  • @kimdillen4778
    @kimdillen4778 9 днів тому

    *Love* the H2G2 reference from Aron! 😊

  • @paco-8-8
    @paco-8-8 9 днів тому

    I really don't understand people who are talkative on Facebook, but when they have the opportunity to call and defend their positions, they hide! If I didn't live almost on the other side of the planet and didn't sleep when the broadcast was live, I would constantly call and to talk to Aron,Seth,Matt,Forrest and all my other favorite hosts on these shows ❤️

    • @Wolf-ln1ml
      @Wolf-ln1ml 7 днів тому

      I'm not particularly good when it comes to on-the-spot responses, the more "deep" or nuanced a question or topic, the more quiet time I need to think about (and possibly look into) it. Some people are really good with on-the-spot-thinking like that, and all the more power to them, but I'm not, have never been, have _tried_ to practice it, have never done any better. I'm perfectly fine in normal, friendly conversations, but when it comes to confrontations of _any_ kind, even friendly ones, my "performance" just sucks.
      When I _do_ have some quiet time to think about it, work on at least halfway decent formulations, can write my thoughts down and even edit them before the other person gets to read them, I do much better.
      I'll spot fallacies, nuance, problematic formulations, loaded terms, ... easily when I have a bit of time - but I'd bet a paycheck that a lot of "simple" street preachers, let alone anyone like the usual "YT apologists", could run over me in a direct conversation. Once tha conversation was over and I had time to think about it again, I would see the faults - but not during.
      So as much as I like exchanging comments with theists here for example (and would certainly do just that on Facebook as well if I didn't despise that abusive, harmful bulls**t of a "social media" corporation as much I do), I would absolutely _not_ call in to an apologetics show with a format like this.

  • @cmack17
    @cmack17 8 днів тому

    Chaos seems to mean order that we lack the analytics to map perfectly.

  • @HisZotness
    @HisZotness 7 днів тому +1

    GOAT horns!

  • @LogicAndReason2025
    @LogicAndReason2025 8 днів тому +2

    If the theist can judge the morality of a god, he didn't need the god to make moral judgements, now did he?

  • @LogicAndReason2025
    @LogicAndReason2025 9 днів тому +1

    Everything once believed to be supernatural, but is now understood, has never once been found to be supernatural. The odds are on natural by default. Just like flying pigs.

  • @forbiddenmonk
    @forbiddenmonk 8 днів тому +2

    theopolis: "if i lie and specifically claim you believe the opposite of what you believe then I can trap you!" too bad that's not how reality or conversations work guy

  • @CHRISHADDON1010
    @CHRISHADDON1010 8 днів тому

    my favorite people ... 100%

  • @toniheikkila5607
    @toniheikkila5607 8 днів тому +2

    "All of reality testifies the existence of god "
    Well, someone else says that "All of reality testifies the non-existence of god."
    What now?
    Not a very good point to cling to, eh?

  • @jonathanrussell1140
    @jonathanrussell1140 5 днів тому

    They call him Flipper, Flipper
    Faster than lightning
    No-one you see
    Is smarter than he
    And we know Flipper, Flipper
    Lives in a world full of wonder
    Lying thereunder
    Under the sea.
    You're welcome 😊😊

  • @averycoleman2422
    @averycoleman2422 8 днів тому +2

    Fuck that troll caller Pitbulls are gentle loving puppies and they absolutely will not just turn on you for no reason.

  • @crizolaczarrazcalozirc6052
    @crizolaczarrazcalozirc6052 7 днів тому +2

    Is that Mr. British