What makes someone a real patriot?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 сер 2019
- Recently I have been thinking about what makes someone a real patriot.
If you have any question and feedback, please feel free to drop a comment down below, I read every single comment!
Once again, thank you so much for everyone's love and support.:)
You can connect with me:
Instagram: / simonyuthechinese
Twitter: / simonyu_chinese
You can also support me on my Patreon page.
/ simonyu
You're a true hero of your nation.
So, you should understand why Simon speak in English in his video. Negative words was forbidden in our nation, especially in Chinese character or Mandarin.
the majority of Chinese people and who get well know about china may not agree with u😂😂😂😂😂
No，he is not.our country never rely on this kind of man .just konw BB.but do nothing down to earth.China's future depend on 邓稼先、袁隆平 .
Wired Lain you can google them. they both have remarkable contribution to China .Yuan Longping help chinese people away from hunger .Deng Jiaxian help China stop being bullied. As chinese ,We appreciate people who get things done, not people who just shout about democracy but do nothing useful to the society.
@@maxtai1114 haha,just know BB. Agree with you. But many people in shanghai just like him. They don't like CCP. They don't see any merit in CCP.
Simon, 真的很喜歡你的影片，冷靜清楚的表達你的觀點和想法分享給全世界，希望你一切平安注意安全！
喜歡看你的影片，不過自己要小心安全。
當權者很希望他們這樣做，不希望他們獨立思考。
你是聰明人，不會隨別人起舞。
你的想法，至少領先他們30年。
你觉得十四亿中国人全都是洗脑洗的一点独立思考能力都没有吗湾湾☺️为什么我们大陆人今天看到香港闹成那个鬼样子一点都不羡慕反而嗤之以鼻啊？也许？？也许大陆他们做了某些事是对的呢？？
领先一光年有啥用?
中国人很容易被洗脑 文化大革命忘了？只要党愿意 随时可以把你们洗成那样
much love my friend ~
hope you'd be safe ~
Simon, you are a gentleman and a peace advocate. We thank you for your refreshing insight into a very tough issue - Less Freedom or more individual freedom. Please Keep going strong 👍
Thank you for your bravery and the way you articulate your thoughts in a differentiated manner even though you might get into trouble. Stay safe and stay the way you are! Greetings from Germany!
極權者權貴不需要一個有自我思考判斷能力的愛國者，因為它們害怕有一天你會坐上他們的位置，佔走他們後代可得的利益，它們需要的是在任何時刻不論對錯，只肯接受國家說法，可以衝到前面以各種方式來攻擊對方的韭菜愛國者，當你沒價值時，收割你的全部，然後把你當替罪羊一樣丟棄，而它們的家族後代，就是頂替各種功勞，收割你的成績，吸收你的骨血，來壯大自己，繼續維持哪充滿腐臭味的家族。
說明白點他它們需要的是愛黨者，而不是愛國者，它們不喜歡愛國者來教它們如何愛國，因為哪會凸顯出它們的自私.。
Any english?
@@littlemoutha9998 I am sorry, I don't speak English, I hope you don't mind (GOOGLE translation)
You speak good.
Mebahahaaa.
@@jamie8812 我笑了!!你讓我想起以前的一個笑話~~
台灣人總是說自己[ I don't speak English]
還說的超標準!XD
@@reko7379 沒辦法!我學英文真的沒天分，又不想打腫臉衝胖子用翻譯機亂翻，中文文法很容易被翻成四不像，短詞彙還好，這種關於理念的詞彙，錯一字就整個糊掉了，我是誠實的孩子 哈哈。
只有互相理解，理性討論才能找到最佳解決問題的方法，而不是煽動仇恨直接解決提出問題的人
Hi Simon. Thank you for your observations.
Stay safe...
Great video. I love how you're willing to honestly grapple with complex, difficult issues -- and even question your own point of view. You, sir, are a true patriot. Respect.
You are the most companionate and eloquent speaker on any subject on UA-cam. Your words give me hope that both our great nations and peoples can find a path to work out our differences. Please keep up the great work and thank you for promoting empathy and communication.
very interresting, thank you for sharing your thought with us
I like what you are doing Simon!
他們愛的是共產黨，你才是愛國者。不要讓那些狂熱民族主義者影響到你，專制國家的愛國主義只是當權者的遮羞布，我替香港人祈禱，希望他們平安。
Josh H 到底有多少人愛共產黨啦，反正我認識的大陸人很正常，不會無腦擁護共產黨
硬要比的话，比起香港暴徒，那还是共产党更好一点
他只是一个偏见者罢了，爱国根本谈不上。看看他起的标题就知道因为娶了一个台湾媳妇开始迎合你们的胃口说这些话罢了，不起这些名字说这些话题你们怎么会看他的视频。还有中国有十几亿的人呢，各种各样的想法的人都有。你以为老共真的能把十几亿人全都洗脑了，今天的十几亿人看到香港为了民主自由闹成这个鬼样为啥一点都不羡慕，为啥我们都嗤之以鼻。你们都没想过为啥嘛？也许你们说的“专制者”做对了什么？香港啊，他们继续吧~他们越闹，大陆的城市可是迫不及待取代它的位置
Jessy Ouyang 地区的当政者都会有选择性报道对他们有利的新闻，长期时间作用下。湾湾民众自然会觉得老共十恶不赦，中国专制独裁。在大陆老共会把这些负面信息过滤掉，也是为了维稳，毕竟人口太多了。我们从小到大真的见过台湾的正面新闻比较多，书本也都是夸台湾好的。可是去了台湾乃至翻墙出来看到台湾大部分人对大陆人都是存在偏见的。
Max Tai 你都講了洗掉 那也是片面的報導 看多了 你跟我說這不是洗腦？ 你有想過 在老共片面製造歡樂 和諧的情況下 就像溫水煮青蛙 鍋中的人 沒感覺到罷了
that was a very compassionate video, Simon, and your references to the cultural revolution are important to be able to understand how it is that people can be used to frame national interests versus the common humanity of families and individuals in the same society.
You are a real voice and real hero
Being allowed to think independently, question things and access information from all different sides freely is what helps a society grow and change.
Take care and thank you for your honesty.
Simon, you're an absolute legend! Love from Australia.
Hm, I respectfully disagree. I think students that do hyper-nationalist things like throwing around symbols like the flag and the anthem aggressively is not constructive. They do it not for the psychological reason that they deeply care about the country; they do it because being able to attach themselves to a national pride makes them feel good. It is for their own self pleasure and ego that they do this.
A true patriot will do what benefits their country when it means sacrificing themselves. Saying things that are unpopular but you believe is the truth and for the benefit of your country, this is patriotism. Doing this will not feel good. Society will punish you socially. But the patriot says it anyway, because their own self pleasure of throwing around symbols and feeling good is not as a important as the truth and benefit of the country.
You sir, Simon, are a patriot. You say what you feel is true, even if it is an unpopular opinion among your peers. China is not great because of the people seeking their own self pleasure by aggressively indulging in symbols like the flag and the anthem. China is great because of people like you, Simon. 加油！
right, its a modern hitlerjugend, its all fun and games until someone tell you there is an enemy.
Very well said. I agree.
謝謝您論述真實情況，但也請您注意自身和家人安全
By the way, you are doing well and you have been doing a great job!!! Keep flourishing!!!! Such a fresh perspective from your country. Much respect!!!! 🗽🗽🗽
看著你的影片讓我想起小時候的我也是這麼想的
我認為中國終有一天會民主
我對於大陸的人還是充滿情懷跟信心
不知什麼時候漸漸的意識對立影響
身為台灣人的我反而想跟對岸劃清界線的認為自己是台灣人而不是中國人
看著你的擔憂喚醒曾經也替中國擔憂的我
真的替你們感到難過
之前影片腳踏車的比喻實在震撼了我
我放在心上希望哪天能用這個比喻喚醒我身旁的中國朋友
我想全世界的華人
沒有人不希望中國幸福的
我們一起幸福
比較可悲的是有些中國人覺得中國很幸福經濟很好 什麼都很新 屌打先進國家 一切都以利益跟唯物主義優先 忘了人與人之間該有的溫度
是我 小屁孩几岁了？民主就是投票？哎，也不怪你，毕竟国内的人从小到大看到的书籍报刊新闻电影都被严格过滤审核，没有完整的世界观也正常。
这个博主被他的台湾媳妇洗脑了，脑子不正常。
张皮皮 呵呵，瞎说大实话就是脑子不正常？跪着高唱赞歌才是正常？
@wen wen wen chen 哈哈，说谎不会心痛吗？就在香港示威如火如荼的时候，英国首相专门致电中国驻英大使馆祝贺中华人民共和国成立70周年。
Thank you, Simon!
The biggest irony is, those students are using values that doesn’t exist in china, like protesting and freedom of speech freedom of media, to oppose the same values that Hong Kong citizens are trying to uphold.
That's not irony, that's related to guerrilla tactic approach.
You are implying you musn't be using a system to criticize it, lest you be invalidated as a hypocrit. (Which people are not as long as they are not benefitting from such activity in a way that defeats the purpose of the critique.)
China is speaking its story to the USA using the USA's 'language', while the USA wants to only speak to China in USA language. So what do you expect?
Dowlphwin I don’t think you understand irony, nor guerrilla tactics. Yes they definitely are hypocrites, using exactly your definition.
It is you who doesn't understand either then. - Even the CCP themselves are openly admitting they don't have a system with the personal freedoms as in the West, but that it is not the right one for China at the time, and that the USA shouldn't believe they are better and everybody else needs to do things their way.
So with a known super-hypocrit like the USA committing an imperialist onslaught on the rest of the world, it is reasonable to use their methods of communication to try and wake them up to their madness. But of course the USA, through cultural warfare, has implanted this pathological projection in people's minds where they always accuse others of their own doing, the dumbest trick in the book that works quite well on the dummies they cultivated.
The USA as a nation in their behavior towards other countries is a clinically diagnosed psychopath, and in that context one has to understand world affairs. More power means more influence. Chinese protesting in the USA to leave China alone are a reaction to a war waged on them and they are using the system of the aggressor to have an impact.
All this conflict is perpetuated by war addicts. By people who are not merely reacting to aggressions, but who are devoted servants of suffering. And John Bolton, who is *national security* advisor, is personally receiving leaders of the HK protests. It's the same regime change shit as always, the same crap that has pushed neonazis into mainstream politics and pretty much government in Ukraine (with Israel's approval, naturally), to name just one of so many examples of the USA's ongoing madness, including their hypocrisy of condemning a bogus meddling in their internal affairs that they have committed for ages on others and is why some have reacted to that.
So what's the worst that China has done? Something horrible, but *to themselves* . Even that was an *internal* affair.
To the USA, anything that happens that they don't like is considered a threat to their national (in)security. And right now they are pushing for another massacre because burning up the fools, the pawns in their game, would be a success, for then they could cry "human rights violations" again and commit military intervention.
thegrayzone.com/2019/08/17/hong-kong-protest-washington-nativism-violence/
Dowlphwin it’s nice to speak your own mind yes?
@@L33tw0rk He won't get it.
Thank you Simon. I have moved from Taipei to SH for one and a half year so far. I strongly agree with your opinion and thanks again for speaking it out.
Je spreekt mooie woorden. Ik vind uw visie duidelijk en begrijp dat wij in het Westen meer genuanceerd naar China moeten kijken. Uw video's maken dit duidelijk, je bent blijkbaar een vriendelijke en goed opgevoede mens ! Doe zo voort en ' stay safe'
The world needs to hear your voice. Great video
Keep saying important things!
Stay safe ,you are a brave man. Very impressive, love your video's.
Wow Simon, you're dealing with something big here. May it permeate and calm some minds.
Great video! BTW, Serpentza sent me. I hope there are more and more people in China like you.
Keep it up!
Take care Simon.. For love & peace in the world!
很喜欢这位大哥的视频，内容取材很真实独特，希望可以坚持做下去，顺便练练听力嘻嘻
200萬香港人上街都無視，好奇要有多少你這樣的中國人，才有辦法鬆動共產黨畫好的圈（權利&利益範圍）？
中国又不是没有改朝换代过，老共是有很多不好，不过离被推翻还很远。
leo xu 希望中國越來越好
？？？一國兩制哎，管你説過多干涉。不管説中共不肯鬆動權利藍圖？？你們到底是多雙標？？
中共的基本盘还很扎实，底部洗脑和建墙之后，很拥护，要翻盘，任重而道远
无视？一位大陆跟示威者后变暴徒然后又如何遭到一群所谓示威者如何对待很明显是吗？一开始跑路去美国然而以一个杀人犯案例去推动这样已经得不到分数，如果是以修例案去商讨作出调整还会得到大量人支持，间接帮凶杀人犯无罪！无良心可言！
謝謝你。讓我看到不一樣的中國人，客觀、理性、有禮。
A mental exercise: How do you think China would resolve the situation if they knew 100% for sure that the US and Europe would never know of their actions?
Few more subs and you will be hitting 10,000 subscribers!!! More to go Simon!!! 🔆
Thanks Yu, please continue to ponder and explore the relationships between the peoples of our countries. I hear no judgement or pronouncements in your observations. A fairly objective and rational consideration of the issues is conveyed and you must consider yourself an emissary to others outside the context of the current geo-political struggle. It is individuals, not governments, that we make progress and substantive change possible. Both China and the U.S. suffer from the "cult of personality" which conveniently shuts down discourse, debate, and progress. Thinking that returning to the past will bring a better future is not a well thought out idea. Make the world a better place, even if it is one human at a time. Keep up your good works--you are a bridge.
From your presentation it is clear you understand the challenges and opportunities, please, do not give in to the cynical nature that surrounds you.
China is very different from the West. In the West, we can hate the government and so forth but still love our country. However, in China, the country is synonymous with government. Chinese people have a hard time to differentiate between country and government. If we criticize the Chinese government, its leaders or its policy, we do not really criticize the country China or the Chinese people. These are different things. In China, it is almost as if you have to be a good party member and communist in order to be a patriot. That is just wrong in my opinion. You can believe in other things and still be a patriot. I do not have to love Trump or any political party in the USA in order to love the USA.
Thanks for your great idea. I think the main law supports communities party is that Chinese contusion writes that china must rule by the communist party.
@@zhazha6555 Of course because it is ruled by a totalitarian communist party.
What is Freedom and Democracy? Is it suitable for everywhere? Can it protect you from trade war? Sorry, it can't. US become the most poweful country because of WWII and good policy for innovation, not democracy. In US, you will also be in trouble if you support Syria. Look at Palestine, how dare you say that US is more peaceful than China? Look at Saudi Arabia, how dare you say Democracy is the key value of US? Don't always judge other countries, please just admit that US try to be the King of the World no matter you like it or not. Naive.
you do not know china and chinese people.
what is "the west" we live on a SPHERE !!!!
Simon, you are a brave man. someone like you in China is getting less and less. it is not easy to speak what you think when you live in China.
Serpentza sent me. Great video. Hope u can influence the mainland in a positive way
Your English is superb Simon. You are filling a very important role in being a voice of young Mainland China to the English-speaking world.
“Nothing is easier than to denounce the evildoer; nothing is more difficult than to understand him.”
I always find myself starting to hate on Chinese people when I see the recent horrible events, but videos like this always remind me to take a step back and understand that most people do have good intentions and that they may just be misguided.
Including yourself. (Generally speaking.)
Hubris is an insidious mind trap and the West is rife with it. I think it still stems from the colonialist mindset combined with the severe state propaganda storm that has and is being inflicted on people.
Totally feel you here. I once thought many Chinese students share the same view as me, at least international students who study abroad. But over the past few weeks (during the Oct 1st when the 70th anniversary of PRC was happening), I realized how many students really are blind and not really rational patriots but followers of the Chinese government's mainstream narrative. 非常欣赏你的视频 总是很中肯而且尽可能地严谨表达你自己的观点 总是能提到事情的多面性 作为在北京长大并在国外学习的学生 很欣慰能看到这样的视频 keep it up!
Thanks for your thoughtful comments.
在台灣也有類似的情形
台灣的主流政治色彩是藍綠
而獨立在藍綠之外的政治人物
如果不選邊站，沒有獲得某一邊的支持
下場就是變成藍綠公敵
會被兩邊政黨以及相關媒體聯合批鬥
雖然會獲得少數明辨是非的選民支持
但杯水車薪，很難在選舉中勝出
我認為政府是服務人民的
而政治人物是替政府工作
不是來統治人民的
人民才是國家的主人
值得花時間寫下自己的理想理念，可以討論 也清楚
無私無我才能讓臺灣國家正常化運作，藍綠墮落20幾年要強力改變！
其實不要說台灣，很多歐美國家甚至日韓也是兩黨政治，小黨出頭的很少，而且小黨眾多的政體就算執政了，還是得尋求和其他政黨合作，這就是政治現實。而且應該再細想，為何小黨很難成氣候的原因？是否其主張並非主流民意？
@@54heton 你說的對 再來要找小黨 做對的事， 我們兩黨很大機率不會做，為了台灣的民生，還是希望做對的事。 其他國家就參考就好。
畢竟人身在台灣。
@@rhyther台灣的小黨有330個，夠百家爭鳴了吧！但綜觀枱面上叫的出名號的小黨：新黨、親民黨、統促黨（這個實在應該稱黑社會組織）、台聯黨、建國黨、綠黨、時力、社民黨、基進黨，最近成立的民眾黨、一邊一國、喜樂島,以上都算還叫的出名號，從中你看到了什麼？除了時力和民眾打著超越藍綠外（但真的超越嗎？）,哪個不是藍和綠的延伸，其中的成員也都是不乏藍綠出走的，頂多是小藍小綠，或深藍、墨綠，所以台灣真有第三勢力存在空間？之前綠黨是真的較與政治無關，主打環保議題，但後來可能生存不易所以也開始向政治靠攏，印象中綠黨後來因理念不同，分裂成樹黨、綠黨。另外時力自身路線定義不明，泡沫化是必然的？下一屆大概只剩黃國昌了。民眾黨的外號是什麼？資源回收黨！所以你說超越藍綠的第三勢力，我認為在現階段的台灣是不可能純無色的. 再往深一點看，扣除統獨立場，藍綠不也是左派右派路線的理念之爭？以上純屬個人看法。
It is like when I had my first job, a colleague said to me love your job but not the company. It stuck to me through the years and can be applied here. Love your country but not necessarily your government because governments are like companies/corporations, they have agendas and not necessarily your best interest. Should always think critically if those agendas would benefit the greater good in the end
Simon is remarkably level-headed and really understands both sides of today's issues..very funny at 2:00..thanks for all these videos and your great efforts to bridge the China-West divide
很簡單一個擇木而棲道理，我們幾十萬年前的祖先，為了生存過更好生活，辛辛苦苦從非洲遷移走出來才有今天的我們。
政府被極少數人把持，國家不受老百姓控制，為什麼要愛這樣的國? 盲從愛國行為只會被天上祖先笑你笨而已。
看看中東一堆逃難的人，換你們不逃要繼續受苦，像北韓人民一樣乖乖待著不逃不反抗，一個個營良不良等著病死餓死?
中东不是发生阿拉伯之春了吗，为啥还要逃难？
@@user-xe5tp9pi4g 因為還有中共的同類人在亂啊
That was an amazing video Simon, honestly I also get a bit depressed when I see things like prejudice and hate on both the internet and the news. I never liked too look at things black or white. Every country has issues but instead of people fighting and pointing fingers it's always better to work to find a solution together. Keep this up and don't let the haters discourage you 👍
You are brave
覺得心有戚戚
我自己有香港朋友也有中國朋友
讓我覺得比較難過的是 我的香港朋友會希望知道內地朋友的想法 同時也想跟他們解釋香港的情況
可是我中國朋友通常都是看著中國的報導
就覺得出來示威的都是港獨廢青
好一點的情況是我解釋香港人的五大訴求和遊行後 他們會多少願意聽一下
壞一點就是覺得我是台灣人 現在台灣民進黨執政=台獨 所以我才支持香港 然後就沒有然後 直接被block
因為這件事我失去了五個朋友 這幾個都還是自己先來問 跟他們說明了又神經過敏
搞得我也不是很愛解釋了😔
打砸抢烧不是假的吧 老是解释这么多干什么.一个清洁工被砸死,好多跟大陆有关系的商店都被砸了 烧了 还有浇汽油到人身上.到底在支持什么?
always enjoy your videos & perspective. i was hoping for some backwards walking at the end so I could see it raining UP! ;-) now THAT would be very anti-establishment! hehe
great idea! next time I would try, thanks!:)
Hi Simon, love your channel and I really appreciate to hear your views on China and it's people, a rare thing to hear as an outsider. I am following quite closely the protests in Hong Kong and I really understand their view on all that is happening.
I am from Ireland, one of the most democratic countries on the planet. I really appreciate the fact that the Irish people can hold their government to account, we the people have a voice on how our country is run. If that were to change you can bet that I would be out protesting along with my fellow citizens. Protesting is one of the few ways citizens can push for change. It is a vital part of our country and I would never want that to change. This is why I feel strongly for the Hong Kongers, to loose the right to self govern is devastating. To have freedoms taken away from you would be unacceptable for many.
As for the Chinese mainlanders giving the Hong Kongers a hard time, I feel they do not quite understand why the Hong Kongers are protesting. They do not seem to understand what the Hong Kongers are loosing because they themselves have never had the same freedoms.
I hope your channel continues and I get to hear more of your thoughts. Keep below the radar and take care of yourself! ^_^
Thanks Simon for voicing for yourself and the minorities in this country. Keep it up and stay safe.
I like to see other common man's views from around the world. Thanks.
爱国，就是当你发现国家存在问题时会忧国忧民，想尽办法去解决，哪怕自己的力量很小
而不是：放弃，谩骂，将其踩在脚下
Simon, you are the first young man that I know of have a conscience from China. I really appreciate your UA-cam channel. Keep it up. You could be censored and be careful.
Being a dissenter is never easy, but it is patriotic.
you give me hope, keep your freedom of thought, talking is good, shouting bad,
Simon,
Yes,
What you think of wong fei hung?
Simon, stay Awesome and be Safe. May I suggest you get a copy of George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-four for some thoughtful reading. You actually discuss the Cultural Revolution a bit - that takes "BALLS" in this day and age, so thank you very much. History has many important lessons for future generations - Unfortunately, those who do not study the past are usually doomed to relive it. Let us all hope that does not occur. Be seeing you and waiting for your next commentary.
He should study more about us ugly war history, what do you think?
mwbahahaaaa
很喜欢你的影片， 看待问题的角度比较多元和中立，现在在国内传达这种声音的人可以被听到的真的不多，冷静的观点和分析，希望你一切平安照顾好自己
Given how sensitive it is said a certain party can be to *any* form of criticism, perceived or otherwise, I think you have been immensely brave to make and publish this video. I hope your closing call for constructive dialogue between groups with differing views and opinions, is taken in the right context. You, Simon, are a shining example of a patriot and all that is good about China and its people.
Simon Yu makes me so optimistic for the future of China
I think a good idea for a video would be trying to explain the constitution in China to people outside of China who have never seen it or don't understand it.
今天的中國最大的問題，就是習慣將問題簡單化．
1.你是不是中國人：
譬如說，談到香港，台灣，就是"這是我們神聖不可分割的領土．"忽然，他忘了，是你的祖先割讓給英國，日本的．
尤其可笑的，是說"台灣人被日本人殺死那麼多人，還愛日本人．"，"我們有殺死那麼多台灣人嗎？"．
他們忘了，一八九五年到一九二O年期間，台灣人不願做日本人，起來反抗日本殖民政府，才被屠殺的．
如今，香港和台灣都是迎接王師後，接著對統治不滿，起來抗爭卻被鎮壓，屠殺．兩者情況相同嗎？
2.我很有錢：
中國有一種思想"貧窮，落後，才會被挨打．"在這個思想下，如今的中國人覺得自己是有錢人了，同時，整個思想也剩下錢．
他們完全看表面，開始嘲笑世界各地的人都很窮，都不如中國．
只是，也許有一天他們醒來，就會發現自己還是窮人．不但物質生活是貧窮的，精神生活也是貧窮的，他根本無法打入別人的社交圈裡．
julian2021able 政治問題不可調和，看似獨立思考，我們這邊看你那邊也是跟傻子說話。意識形態不同方式自然不一樣，民眾安居樂業比民主災難好太多。‘為什麼來美國？’‘我來學習你們怎麼洗腦的。’‘我們不洗腦，我們是民主國家’ ’對對對，我要學的就是這個‘
@@zhugexiaocong 有位歷史教授問學生"從學習歷史中，給你們什麼啟示和幫助？"接著，他自己給了答案"什麼都沒有．因為，人習慣一直犯重複的錯誤．"
中國人，可以將國家大事當作下一場棋．只是，一個純屬娛樂；一個也許下場淒涼．就坐著看戲吧．
julian2021able 在國際舞台上誰不是你方唱罷我登場，不管願意不願意，都在其中，只是在其中大多數以為自己是棋手其實只是棋子罷了。日本軍事上不是一路打到佔領半個亞洲，經濟上不是打到世界第二麼？你政治上受美國制約，想作戰第一毫無希望。日本本以為自己是棋手，到頭來還不是美國的棋子？
@@zhugexiaocong 是啊．日本，南韓，和德國，如今都有美國駐軍．
台灣，從一九四九年開始，就在美國的保護傘下．
台灣說要"光復大陸"，那是國民黨要給統治台灣提供正當性．
美國從來主張以台海為界．
如今，就看中國自己如何下這盤棋了．
臺灣才是無法融入社交圈的吧。喏，又斷交好幾個“邦交国”，中國可是天天wto、一帶一路社交圈打的火熱呢
我承认我是大意识形态下的爱国者，却也是相信媒体的报道无法做到真正意义上的公正。没有太多机会和香港或者台湾聊过政治方面的问题，但是从各方媒体的评论如果只有一边倒的情况也是可怕的，在我更了解的大陆中，确实对异见持有者并不包容。我认为认可当今政府的一些成绩，可是却又觉得政府对人民不“放心”.
Another well thought-out video! In answer to your question on the protesters, I see it as embarrassing. In essence they are using their right to protest, which I fully support, to shut-down & silence those they don't agree with. They are attempting to remove that right from others, and are thereby completely missing the point. And when anyone resorts to violence they do their side more harm than good.
Simone will the Dark Era can possibly come back? Is that possible?
中國有好人，有腦袋清楚的人。老實說撕毀一些文宣的絕對是愛國的年輕人，但愛過的方式受不到人尊重，反而讓其他國家的人厭惡了他最愛的國，有更好的方式能夠讓別人尊重他愛的國。
你這集的內容我非常喜歡，特地留言支持，另外希望能上中文字幕，googl幫忙翻譯的字幕有些錯字，編排也不太好，小小建議，請繼續加油！我會分享你的頻道給朋友的
I may not be a citizen of Republic of China but somehow I can feel you . I mean I agree with your thoughts on this video
Do CPC give mainland Chinese people freedom of speech, if it is not pro CPC?
Thats what he said; " at least we have it in the constitution."
It's a bit like Henry Ford when he said you can have any colour as long as it's black. In this case you have freedom to say anything you like, so long as it doesn't go against the official lines. I guess you could say the Mainland Chinese have it in theory, but not in practice.
@@NearbyCactus the classical liberal theory of " there are only 3 rights; freedom, private property and life. " a piece of papers cannot guarantee anything. Trust me, my country of birth has had a copy of the French constitution for over 200 years and it has been an absolute disaster. Freedom of speech is a precedent put forward by the citizens against their elected leaders. What I mean is that so long as there exist any government, it will do it's best to undermine your own freedom. The red line is put by citizens. Hence why HK people are protesting nowadays. They understand it is an ongoing struggle. Mainland people never lived through democracy or ruled of law so they can't comprehend this. Even many westerns (most) fail to understand the value of citizens being able to Express themselves freely.
@@resistencialiberal9555 Agreed
CCP is doing something against the law.
When people get into ideology, it is hard to -open their mind. instead we should tell those people what benefit you can get, what is the Pro and con on Each side. people will open their mind If they know they can benefit.
Are there copies of videos of the guy that went to HK on UA-cam?
Correct ... "human rights, protected by the law."
Our rights come from our Creator... not scribbles on paper somewhere.
i didnt see anyone march, when and where was this?
dang did not chance to see rain fall up words.... I feel that the china students in US protesting Hong Kong are closed mine to fact that they are doing the same thing Hong Kong but can do it in the US
支持支持
Thank you for your rational voice. From all that I have watched and read the last 12 weeks. I would say 99% of the HKers want nothing to do with HK separation with China. The protesters just want what was promised in the original one country two systems basic law. They are now more concern with police brutality and lack of response and dialogue from Carrie Lam's government. The best thing that can happen for HK is for mainland chinese citizens like yourself to have real conversation with HK residents.
Simon being a patriotic means you love your country and want the best for it like yourself it doesn't mean you hate other countries it means you love your own :)
這個問題曾經也纏繞我很多年,當我弄明白後我變得更孤獨。......有朋友來幫孩子的同學帶了些"禁書",他卻對孩子說;"你不要去了解這些,不然你怎麼能通過考試,沒法考!等出社會了,你想要了解再自己去了解。"我想我們的未來呢,沒有自由獨立思考的能力,不關心社會?甚至我問朋友聽說那邊地震了還不小,他回我不知道沒有關心這個!...甚至一個旅澳多年的朋友抨擊談論深埋地下的胡適,他回我他太愛國了。
When country provide for its people and is at peace with the world then patriotism is warranted?
I have always believed, that dissent should not only be a right, it is a responsibility of a countries citizens to speak out.
Well I’m glade that the guy, what’s his name, was trying to see both sides’ view on the Hong Kong protest. But doe he support Hong Kong to be a full independent state?
Cody Shi no one knows since his follow up videos did not make it on internet
Good video again Simon. Two thing: over the next two decades China will evolve, remembering that Xi Jinping wants more democracy within the CCP, which will undoubtedly branch out. Secondly, the censorship in China is not by one individual, but will always be subjective according to the guidelines established by the government. The main criteria being harmony. I am sure many people will have different viewpoints which will be to the contrary.
政治對大陸人是奢侈的，你一直觸及很怕有一天你有事😱
沒騙你 這就是大陸人害怕 的 所以 寧可做傻b嘍
本來只是想練聽力確不小心找到你的影片並聽到這個話題。
首先，感謝你讓其他人知道，中國還是有不少理智且願意自主思考的人，再來請務必要注意安全。
對於中國遊學生去抗議其他人遊行的片段其實我看了覺得充滿著矛盾，一方面是他們的行為是如此的無理霸道，卻可以看得出來他們是發自內心的認同他們自己的行為並且愛著自己的國家。我們確實無法從影片去了解他們的觀點，如果他們持續這樣做只會造成大眾更大的誤解，希望他們能用正確的方式愛國。希望除了要求別人留意彼此間的相同前要能夠尊重已經存在的不同。
There is nothing wrong with showing your support for your country on your own.
But we all know that most of the support demonstrations are organised by the students on insistence by Chinese consulates/embassies. So in a way, the support isn’t organic one.
Hey Simon the students that you are talking about are Chinese Nationals that came about one to two days before the protest that was setup for support on Hong Kong and the CCP sent them to cause problem with the protester. The stupid thing that happen in Toronto was that the Hong Kong protester was saying "FREE HONG KONG" and the CCP protesters were saying "FREE CHINA". So what was the CCP nationalist really saying is a FREE CHINA is best but the Government does not want to lose their automatic credit card...which is the people that is under their slavery control.
100👍💞
西方教育價值讓你真正有當人的感受，也知道如何才能做個人而不是教育成為黨奴！
新貴高鐵 不是谁的意识形态好或不好，当你成长过程中有一定阅历就明白，人好简单安稳乐业对出生地方有根的情感，一个小孩子长大成人开始长知识，就如一个国家一样必须经历阶段
我都不敢相信，21世紀了信息封閉造成巨大誤解的事情還好發生，特別是有意得操弄後，發生的。香港人其實並不在乎內地人怎麼想怎麼看，因為他們知道任何討論並沒有意義，並不是基於公认事實的討論。內地最近偏激的報道，各種假新聞，假罪名都扣在了香港示威者身上了。你真是少之又少的，能夠理性思考，並且了解其中問題的內地人。Respect!
I can't believe they shot him down...... wow
Khabib Nurmagomedov I think he said “He got shut down”.
If you want a good book on how regular people can get caught up group behavior Id reccomend reading "The Lord of the Flies" or if you wanna see the bad side of patriotic behavior Id reccomend watching one of the documentarys on The French Revolution, where If you didn't agree with the revolution fully, you were considered a traitor.
我非常喜歡閣下闡述事情的態度跟方式 雖然時常與您的看法是相左的
非常感謝！：）我的想法未必是正確的，但是我覺得能夠心平氣和坐下來，大家探討各自的觀點，那就是非常有意義的一件事情。我最希望的就是未來無論在哪裡，大家都可以各自發表自己的觀點，然後友善的交流。：）
I do not recall seeing in any of your recent videos if you, as does the Chinese government, believe that the U.S. government has any responsibility for the demonstrations happening in Hong Kong?
如同你說的中國人民本性善良，如同台灣人民也是中國血脈。
人的良善面務必要發揚，社會才會走向正循環，而國家和政治是關鍵因素。
I need to download these videos. They might be deleted soon. Take care, son.