Chinese people are good people they believe in Education, in Peace, is just the Corrupt Politicians ,they are Ambitious to POWER. Lot Chinese people , fleeing their homeland ,because of the bad government .
Your reasons are consistent with those from foreign observers who have spent years in China. What is interesting, is hearing them echoed and confirmed by someone who is native-born. Please keep producing your informative videos. They are singularly valuable as your perspective on mainland China is unique.
@@whocares3680 You are brainwashed! The current government, by using taxpayers' money, who controls 90% of the mainstream newspapers, TV stations, furthermore, hires net "cockroaches" to attack opposite camps! Remember what the Vice-Presidential candidate, Lai, said: President Cai, please stop attacking me with those 網軍! "很多韩粉都是老人…不讲逻辑，不讲理…" You're totally wrong about this! Be an independent thinker instead of being controlled like a string puppet! Read news from both political sides, go back to how things were said originally instead of ill-intention and twisted info fed to you by "cockroaches"! Lastly, observe and think for yourself! "韩粉" just two words, but with different backgrounds, age groups, occupations - doctors, professors, lawyers, economists,...! If you're not aware of the fact, just Google it! Taiwan is actually marching toward dictatorship! Be aware! 台灣的病源 國民黨沒有以恨教育台灣人恨日本人，而民進黨是以恨教育台灣人恨國民黨，以恨掩飾民進黨胡作非為創造偽聖人，偽聖人代表林義雄，他的反對表面是為公益，而他的公益是以顏色為基準點，以個人利益為出發點。 當民進黨發出恨的怒喊，所有吸取民脂民膏，殘害台灣的道德倫理，歪理都成為合理，惡魔化身的民進黨儼然成為正義化身，台灣人民已被民進黨教育成慈母，民進黨任何錯都是國民黨造成，台灣人民溺愛民進黨已無是非可言，這絕對是國家的不幸，而人民忘了當國家的不幸，最後受傷害是人民的代代子孫。 善良的台灣人，為何被教育成如此是非不分？與其怪民進黨，不如說是民進黨恨的教育污黑了我們的良心。 www.storm.mg/article/1463369 today.line.me/tw/pc/article/%E8%A7%80%E9%BB%9E%E6%8A%95%E6%9B%B8%EF%BC%9A%E5%8F%B0%E7%81%A3%E7%9A%84%E7%97%85%E6%BA%90%EF%BC%8D%E7%84%A1%E6%81%A5%E7%9A%84%E6%B0%91%E9%80%B2%E9%BB%A8-orXo8p
Keep 'em coming, Simon. the format and subject matter of this video were absolutely superb. from my perspective, you covered all the different points of view and then some. thanks so much for making these videos, and thanks for the walk at the end. the reverse film walk is a brilliant concept for an outro. anyway, cheers mate, here's to much more!!
Unfortunately, I think it's going to take decades, if not more, for China to catch up with Taiwan in this area because of Mainland China's sociocultural history. Take Hong Kong (my birthplace) as an example. It doesn't share Mainland China's horrific sociocultural history, yet, despite close to 150 years of British colonial rule and a highly educated and wealthy population, it still lags behind Taiwan when it comes to manners, civility, and kindness. (But I have to say Hong Kong is still WAY better than Mainland China regarding all these three traits. Let's say it may take Mainland China several decades to catch up with Hong Kong, and probably another century to catch up with Taiwan.) These qualities are unique to the people of Taiwan, and it needs historians, sociologists, and psychologists to explain why this is so.
This breaks my heart. God bless you; you have a good heart I can see it. I pray for your safety and also that China would evolve and be free someday. Also your English is really good.
Good content as always Simon! It seems to me that money and financial stability plays a big role in the Chinese mindset. In fact I can sort of relate to this topic. Once when I was in South Korea, I nearly slipped and fell whilst walking down the street. I was next to a group of Chinese tourists when it happened. I didn’t expect them to help me, however they pulled their friends away from me and looked at me with bad expressions, as if I was deliberately falling into them 🤔. At first I couldn’t understand why.. but they probably thought I was trying to scam them 😂 (I wasn’t).
Fascinating discussion. The effect of the Cultural Revolution is undeniable. In my interactions with people of Chinese descent, I noticed the cultural characteristics you mentioned and assumed it was a spin-off of Confucian rules which seem to tie most Asians up socially into continuous knots and mind games. But what you describe is also common in my experience in Thailand which of course has a large Overseas Chinese immigrant culture influence. It is the norm for Thais to avoid Good Samaritan situations for the same reasons you outline, it can backfire easily and the mind games that are ever present can really cause trouble for not only oneself but ones family which is unacceptable. Nobody can be trusted and no good deed goes unpunished which is not too much of an exaggeration. There is some moderation of all this in some Thai as Buddhist teaching put great emphasis on compassion, empathy and mercy but most Thais are just looking out for themselves and rightly so as it can be very dog eat dog. Foreigners are often seen as exempt from all this mental gymnastics as they are not expected to think like Thai and are all crazy any way, at least that is not far from common Thai opinion. .
@@SimonYu However, Samaritans are known from the Bible because of the story of the "Good Samaritan" who offers help, so if you say "Samaritan", most people will know what you are talking about anyway.
I am from Singapore. I grew up in Singapore as a hearing impaired person, only having learnt English language. Since the Ministry of Education in Singapore has prioritised English as the main language so we the hearing impaired people learnt only English. I had some bad experiences in Beijing. I got hungry somewhere near the hotel. I tried to turn on VPN and used the google translate app. I translated the message into Chinese words and asked the passerby for some directions to the nearby eateries. The passerby simply ignored me and I got helpless. Even I was shocked that the monk ignored me as well. I was thinking how come this kind of religious person could ignore me when I helplessly asked for directions to any nearby eating places. I was not in rags or worn out clothes. After the trip to Beijing, I went back to Shanghai and felt relieved that I am more familiar with metro and some places. I felt that Shanghai is way a lot better than Beijing
Brother I really appreciate your bold honesty. I’ve never heard a chinese person speak out so openly on chinese issues. I pray there will be more that come forth and share their thoughts and feelings like you. I have the utmost respect for you and I wish you good health, prosperity, peace, and love!
Thanks for diving deeper into the cases. There is a lot of misunderstanding all around, but the final and most important message is that we all need to take responsibility no matter the consequences.
CK H True, I seem to be handicapped by an education that included Latin, philosophy, logic, mathematics and science. Mr. Milk’s statement is so fuzzy as to be incomprehensible. Must have been an IT major.
@@ckh2815 How did you get over the firewall, with a little help. Ha boys, I think we got ourselves 50 cent soldier. I think your work for the 50 cent army, leave laowhy alone, C.C.P. worshiper and incompetent prick.
For those who stayed to the very end, when everyone are walking backward, you was walking forward said something about you. You can make a difference by being different.
I love the topics you choose for these videos as it is such a nice change to hear the views of a mainlander. Unfortunately its slowly feeling like parts of the west are turning the same way. People are scared to help during issues like this because it so often ends up backfiring. Theres enough stories of people saving someone from being attacked but being charged or sued for getting involved in the altercation. Even just that Disney-land fight from the other day. Most people were too scared to get involved even as a woman was beaten in front of her child and I even saw people suggesting the woman who lifted the child and pulled him away from the fight could be in trouble because of the way she lifted him. The world is crazy...
You are the hope of China, open minded, tolerant, peaceful, and tells it like it is with a mind on your own, not automatically follow the orders of dictators blindly.
Thanks for the post Simon. The key to carry from this is that everyone is indirectly affected by this type of behavior all over the world. Sure, there are reasons for this type of behavior but now is the time to encourage information exchanges that shows how everyone can benefit by helping not harming each other. Remember 什麼人都有才成其為世界! I used to tell my classmate in Beijing this.
I commented before on one of your videos "There's hope for the future !" You represent a heightened level of awareness for a young person. People are noticing (many positive comments, including mine) !
I recommend the Chinese/Canadian movie "Old Stone" 老石. About a taxi driver who saves a 外卖小哥 (food delivery boy)'s life after having a crash. It's about all the problems he faces after being a good samaritan. It's a really good suspense & psychological thriller, and quite recent. And, is banned in China.
@Hey Ho Just watched it because of your comment. Good recommendation. That was a tough movie to watch, so tragic. That ending tho!😮😪 I literally looked away...but thankfully the scene froze.
As a tort lawyer in England and a person trained in first aid and AED , it's virtually the opposite. There is generally immunity in law to someone doing their best to help. Eg, if I broke someone's ribs whilst doing heart compressions) Also whilst not legally expected of a bystander, it is almost a duty to step in and help wherever possible. And failing to do so, such as not reporting a crime (ie the attempted rape in your story) could lead to the person who didn't report it facing a charge. I won't bore you with case law haha. Just thought I'd point out the difference.
One more possible reason. I am Chinese and living in USA. In my point of view (baby boomers generation), culturally, Chinese in general value money as top priority in life. The love of money is pretty extreme compare to other ethnic groups. Favorite hobbies: saving $ , hunt for best deals, love free stuffs...etc. We often make our decisions based on money (cost). If it is too "expensive" (even though we have cash in the bank), we won't spend it. Since time is money, therefore we value our time very high also. Help some strangers, go vote, do community work, participate volunteer work...etc are not popular. My mentality was like that when I was younger. I am actually writing this comment because I am better now.
I so agree. I'm such a tightwad. Every new year I promise to do better and enjoy the life I'm given but fear always holds me back. I'm still trying --- work in progress.
Thanks Simon I always wondered why Chinese were not good Samaritans, you explain things so well and connect the dots. I think many just assume that it is part of Chinese Culture without looking too deeply at the history. I pray that the younger generation can overcome the shadow of brutality caused by the CCP and that there can be Freedom and Human Dignity for everyone
ekami here in the U.S. people used to sue people who helped them claiming they were injured. So that sent a chill because people here would try to correct a wrong is they see one. That's when many states passed the Good Samaritan laws. It appears China has a convoluted version of the law and they are not being serious. If they really care about their own people they would pass similar Good Samaritan laws. Or better people can drive around with cameras on their dashboard with cameras running to protect themselves.
0:55 I saw that video when I was 21 and I was crying so hard for that little girl. I am now 31 year's old and I almost cried again after seeing that video again.
Here in my country, we often look up to Good Samaritans as heroes, those that go above and beyond for the GOOD of humanity and help the person who is needing help, this is usually taught by parents and encouraged by stories listened to by young people told by teachers and parents. It won’t happen overnight but it can become a righteous way of thinking and acting over time. Find a story such as Aesop’s fables “the lion and the mouse “ and tell it to the children and then you and your child can discuss this foible (tale) together.there are many lessons to be learned through Aesop’s fables an old Greek ( I think ) philosopher.
China in general isn’t plagued with violence especially gun violence. I don’t think bar fights are a thing in China either. What I’m saying is, the chances of people getting into these situations are nil, but I guess people want certainty when it comes consequences. Fighting anywhere in the developed world isn’t encouraged either, and punishment is usually determined after the authorities figure out what happened.
i really like this guys videos. Informative, not sugar coated 他就是直接告诉我们 from a Chinese perspective things we 老外 are afraid to as as we don't want to be seen as being too 'critical' of China. Keep up the good work.
Very interesting content Simon! I liked the walking backwards at the end - very original. Make sure to take care about you and your family's privacy. I don't want anything to happen to you
2:43 is about Chinese Cultural Revolutionary movement 50 years ago that have many people reporting their family members, report their professors. That is so sad! Btw, awesome traditional Chinese caption. The translation is very clear and eloquent, but be careful if the content revealed too much.
Yeah dude, I've heard many stories of other foreigners fighting back when being attacked or threatened then being punished more, kind of sucks but yeah that's just how it is here. Good if you have Chinese friends that can vouch for you/help you
Smithy lincoln Yu Haiming case is very debatable in 2018.A drunk man called Liu Hailong failed to use a broadsword to kill Yu Haiming and dropped his broadsword by accident.Then Liu wanted to return to his car,but Yu picked it up and killed Liu.The case is very popular with Chinese people,especially us lawyers.Eventually,the Supreme People’s Court ruled Yu’s innocent
Good episode Simon. A documentary series by Ruben Terlou was very popular for a while in Holland. People loved it. A Dutch fotografer travelled along the Yangtze River and interviewed a lot of people. He also met a couple of good Samaritans on the way. Very interesting and sometimes heartbreaking. Life in China has been very though and many people are still struggling. I like to watch your videos and I think you are a good Samaritan too. Keep it going and good luck!
Was there a period in Chinese long 4000+ year history when there was more altruism? My personal experience is that mainlanders (met many) and Hong Kongers (met few) are less altruistic than other people. The few Taiwanese I have met were quite compassionate people. I also met people Chinese from Malaysia, Indonesia, and Peru - these were cold/stern, but very honest and disciplined. Just some random observations.
There were definitely some discussions of being altruistic and empathetic towards others in Chinese culture (as shown in some typical sayings), but the teachings may not be so well-spread as people in the past were not all well-educated (often to the point of being illiterate) and the majority were peasants during the dynasties. Under the Communists, there are more people educated, but still there are a great number of uneducated or poorly educated people. I think the issue needs to be tackled by both better education and media promotion. Since the problem has been around for a while, it won't get better overnight, but hopefully with more educated masses, things will turn for the better.
I've seen some of the younger generation doing things to protect animals and such. I think in that way people are getting better about trying to do the right thing. I still see a lot of the younger generation not helping other people though. I think it is getting better though. Perhaps it just needs time.
explained very well I can see why the people don't want to get involved China needs capitalism not communism here in the states the Chinese people for the most part are very compassionate and very good neighbors they will go out of their way to help you they have business which they manage the employees that work there are kind and are of mixed nationalities. this has been my experience.
Hey, I am Chinese and I went through the cultural revolution. It's not that the cultural revolution trained people to be cold, people were culturally cold, but mao amplified it.
I would love to see your grandparents talk about it. But..... I fear for your family if you guys do.....so maybe forget about it and continue with small videos like this.
As a foreigner living in Shanghai, one rainy day i slipped and fell down the floor in the metro. Everybody passed by and said or did nothing. It felt a bit cold hearted, but i tried to look at the bright side and thought, oh well...at least they are acting like it didn't happen so i feel less ashamed of my fall hahahaha
你好，我是一位大陸女婿，我幾年前與我老婆回大陸過年，在全家出遊的路上，就遇過一次有位年約五十幾歲的人，騎著三輪車自己翻車摔倒了（當時路上有積雪所以路面比較滑），我當時看到時馬上請我妹婿停車，想去幫忙那個人，可是我的岳父母馬上就阻止了我，要我不管怎樣都不可以去，因為他們說幫了他很有可能會被“訛錢”，當時的我心裡真的很不是滋味，所以我就和他們爭論了起來，因為我覺得世上壞心的人不會那麼多，而且我們車上還有行車記錄器，但是一番激烈的爭論後，他們就直接跟我說。。別把大陸的人想的像台灣人一樣好。。當下我就很無語了。。最後我想說，既然不讓我去幫他，那麼讓我幫他打個電話叫警察或是救護車也好。。他們還是阻止了我。。這件事情讓我到現在都還有點無法釋懷。。
台灣人和中國人從思想上來講早就是兩個民族了，走在路上我光憑對方眼神就可以分辨兩國人，
但是在台灣還是有一部分人沒辦法接受這個現實。你的下一代千萬不要讓他產生身分認同混亂問題，不然他會背負很多維護中國價值觀的壓抑。
@齐小儒 是湖北人，他們不是惡劣喔，反而他們只是個非常樸實、老實又善良的鄉下人，只是被一些奇怪的新聞和傳聞嚇怕了，所以不敢隨便信任人，而且鄉下的地方還真的發生了不少我意想不到的事情。。
@齐小儒
一個公民思想成熟的社會，別人會首先看你是一個"人"，至於你的背景是之後的考量。中國人整天就先自己把自己隔離了，你們看世界首先就是中國人與非中國人，然後再用兩種不同外在表現面對這兩種人，真的非常詭異。
@@twccz-329 perfectly said, you make a good point, good discussions like this are wonderful, good luck everyone
曾經幫助過騎腳踏車摔得頭破血流的人也幫助過車禍的狗。幫助人很簡單，幫助狗時很掙扎，因為醫藥費一定很貴而我很窮，但圍觀的人沒一個願意出手，我不幫一定良心不安，還好送醫後有找到主人。在台灣也有很多人會幫助流浪貓狗和受傷的動物，這些默默行善的人都很偉大。
你的好心註定你一生平安
台灣.....有次路上發生車禍..一位傷者倒地不起 路過的高中生孩子們 上前圍住傷者 並高居雙手警示後方來車 這個果也是努力很久的 台灣人並不是全力集中在賺錢這檔事 宗教制約 善惡因果循環 深植人心
it's so refreshing to see a mainland chinese with an open mind. Keep up the great work
Chinese people are good people they believe in Education, in Peace, is just the Corrupt Politicians ,they are Ambitious to POWER. Lot Chinese people , fleeing their homeland ,because of the bad government .
@@marylamarr6194 Let's hope they all escape the evil CCP
@@FoodforThought12345678dsds no let's hope for West Taiwan :>)
@@toxy3580 Taiwan is what Mainland China could have been, such a shame
在台灣我也曾經遇過出車禍想要敲詐的人，但台灣有強制險的保障， 所以我都是直接請警察來處理，相對的糾紛就會變少，而我還是堅持助人為快樂之本，因為這是我們從小教育的，我相信教育和社會制度的完善是和諧的根本。
台灣白色恐怖時期也造就了互不信任的社會，長輩也都教我們別多管閒事，但民主化讓特權體制式微，台灣人開始找回失落的勇氣。這要感謝犧牲自己完成台灣民主化的前輩，他們證明了勇氣是可以被感染的傳承。
與民主不相干(￣(ｴ)￣)ﾉ
相反，自開口閉口的民主自由開始，鬼島人與人之間，長輩與晚輩之間的情誼早就式微。
見義勇為現象變成稀有品種，倒是隨處打罵他人情境，日日見著。
別用門縫看世界，台主也是用美國視角看中國。
基本就是顛倒是非，黑的說成白的。
在此告知: 鬼島台灣有五百多萬人口屬於黑道與經常性詐騙人口。
此等社會，想見義勇為，除非找死(=｀ェ´=)
Your reasons are consistent with those from foreign observers who have spent years in China. What is interesting, is hearing them echoed and confirmed by someone who is native-born. Please keep producing your informative videos. They are singularly valuable as your perspective on mainland China is unique.
看到女童影片覺得好心痛...在台灣早就一堆人圍上去...也許不一定來的及獲得急救...但至少不會讓第二台車壓過她
Elliont Lee 這個新聞台灣當時也有報導...說中國的冷漠程度 令人髮指
而且跟中國網友交談 他們認為幫助別人 是一個智障的行為....只有白癡才會幫助別人
南京彭宇案的後遺症,誰都不願當好人了....
我的中國網友說：管好自己就好，沒事別惹麻煩。
@@XiaoZhang-dj8dw 那你是你这个网友白痴
其實台灣也是一步一步走過來, 為了美好的生活, 大家一起加油, 努力. 希望有一天, 真的可以世界大同, 到處充滿愛與和平.
Lingya Hsu 不知道说的对不对，我觉得这就是民主制度下的人们会变得正常一些。极权制度下，人们好像对权力有很大的迷恋，社会容易畸形。
上一代台湾人也经历过独裁，所以很多韩粉都是老人…不讲逻辑，不讲理…不知道是不是因为政治影响人的思维方式…
@@whocares3680 You are brainwashed!
The current government, by using taxpayers' money, who controls 90% of the mainstream newspapers, TV stations, furthermore, hires net "cockroaches" to attack opposite camps! Remember what the Vice-Presidential candidate, Lai, said: President Cai, please stop attacking me with those 網軍!
"很多韩粉都是老人…不讲逻辑，不讲理…" You're totally wrong about this! Be an independent thinker instead of being controlled like a string puppet! Read news from both political sides, go back to how things were said originally instead of ill-intention and twisted info fed to you by "cockroaches"!
Lastly, observe and think for yourself! "韩粉" just two words, but with different backgrounds, age groups, occupations - doctors, professors, lawyers, economists,...! If you're not aware of the fact, just Google it!
Taiwan is actually marching toward dictatorship! Be aware!
台灣的病源
國民黨沒有以恨教育台灣人恨日本人，而民進黨是以恨教育台灣人恨國民黨，以恨掩飾民進黨胡作非為創造偽聖人，偽聖人代表林義雄，他的反對表面是為公益，而他的公益是以顏色為基準點，以個人利益為出發點。
當民進黨發出恨的怒喊，所有吸取民脂民膏，殘害台灣的道德倫理，歪理都成為合理，惡魔化身的民進黨儼然成為正義化身，台灣人民已被民進黨教育成慈母，民進黨任何錯都是國民黨造成，台灣人民溺愛民進黨已無是非可言，這絕對是國家的不幸，而人民忘了當國家的不幸，最後受傷害是人民的代代子孫。
善良的台灣人，為何被教育成如此是非不分？與其怪民進黨，不如說是民進黨恨的教育污黑了我們的良心。
www.storm.mg/article/1463369
today.line.me/tw/pc/article/%E8%A7%80%E9%BB%9E%E6%8A%95%E6%9B%B8%EF%BC%9A%E5%8F%B0%E7%81%A3%E7%9A%84%E7%97%85%E6%BA%90%EF%BC%8D%E7%84%A1%E6%81%A5%E7%9A%84%E6%B0%91%E9%80%B2%E9%BB%A8-orXo8p
“The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.” ― Edmund Burke
Keep 'em coming, Simon. the format and subject matter of this video were absolutely superb. from my perspective, you covered all the different points of view and then some. thanks so much for making these videos, and thanks for the walk at the end. the reverse film walk is a brilliant concept for an outro. anyway, cheers mate, here's to much more!!
It is really heartening to see there are thoughtful compassionate people in mainland China.
Somehow I understand why you have to upload this video in English... Good luck! Totally agree your points.
Rachel Chen thanks:)
當人與人間缺乏信任，見義勇為的意願就會少一點 !
@張小舟
看完留言区
就您这句话 「最酸」
我收集的vcr 那你們都教些什麼🤔？
@張小舟 這樣算酸民喔
I am sure that China will getting better if more younger people like you willing to talk about problems.
Unfortunately, I think it's going to take decades, if not more, for China to catch up with Taiwan in this area because of Mainland China's sociocultural history. Take Hong Kong (my birthplace) as an example. It doesn't share Mainland China's horrific sociocultural history, yet, despite close to 150 years of British colonial rule and a highly educated and wealthy population, it still lags behind Taiwan when it comes to manners, civility, and kindness. (But I have to say Hong Kong is still WAY better than Mainland China regarding all these three traits. Let's say it may take Mainland China several decades to catch up with Hong Kong, and probably another century to catch up with Taiwan.) These qualities are unique to the people of Taiwan, and it needs historians, sociologists, and psychologists to explain why this is so.
@@flyingzone356 身為台灣人，我一直覺得這是理所當然的做人道理，但是看完影片和您的留言以後我突然也開始好奇台灣人民是如何發展到這一步了，畢竟台灣也有經歷過類似的白色恐怖時期，也還是有很多壞人，但大部分的人都還是願意發自內心的熱心親切並且幫助別人（甚至比小時候的時代更好）
@@DLAfvr 國民黨的白色恐怖與文革的差別實在太大，黨國教育只是利用國家機器包括軍隊和警察來控制言論和思想，並沒有發動群眾來進行階級鬥爭和大規模的檢舉揭發，值得一提的是，在黨國教育和威權統治之下，蔣中正不斷灌輸「做堂堂正正中國人」的傳統儒家思想，其中包括服從，但也包括仁義忠孝的思想，中華傳統文化在台灣得到完好的保留和繼承，而在中國大陸的文革中，中國傳統文化遭到毀滅性的抹除，破四舊、燒孔廟不僅毀滅了中華文化在實物上的存在，更把這些傳統文化、思想、道德從中國人精神裡抽離了出來，造成了思想的真空，接著就是改革開放之後從上的拜金主義、物質享受、追逐利益不管一切倫理道德，把西方資本主義壞的一面注入到這種思想的真空之中，基於如此，造成了中國人現在這種冷漠、缺乏同理心、喜歡爭搶鬥爭的群體特質。
I don't believe that China will get better.
The Chinese Communist Party has always been evil
@@China_is_a_piece_of_shit 沒錯
This breaks my heart. God bless you; you have a good heart I can see it. I pray for your safety and also that China would evolve and be free someday. Also your English is really good.
My husband is from mainland China. He is living here with me ( and our baby boy) and he loves every little small things in Taipei
在台灣行政院2012年宣布通過救人免責條款~
就是救護人員以外之人，為免除他人生命之急迫危險，
使用緊急救護設備或施予急救措施者，
適用民法、刑法緊急避難免責之規定。
救護人員於非值勤期間，前項規定亦適用之
我想應該是因為這個原因~
所以反而在台灣更多的民眾願意對身旁的人伸出援手~
畢竟今天你救人一命或許以後別人也會救你一命~
hello，我想问一下如果是我去撞了别人，再去施救，也会被免责吗？
@@wanlima4520 當然啦～～我說的是以台灣法律相關規定為主～～大陸那邊"傷害罪"是怎樣判斷我就不清楚了～～=.=
這也是現有政權需要的，人民越是冷漠、自私、本位主義，
這樣人民不容易形成力量、共識，政府要處裡任何一個人，才不會有人站出來，
Simon,原來您的太太是台灣人,難怪您這麼了解台灣.
歡迎您成為台灣的女婿喔. ^^
其實台灣人民樂於助人,除了從小學習華人禮教外,我覺得更重要的是:
1.宗教自由,絕大多數的宗教都是教人為善的.
2.法律制度與社會福利的健全,遏止了碰瓷事件的發生機率.
Good content as always Simon! It seems to me that money and financial stability plays a big role in the Chinese mindset. In fact I can sort of relate to this topic. Once when I was in South Korea, I nearly slipped and fell whilst walking down the street. I was next to a group of Chinese tourists when it happened. I didn’t expect them to help me, however they pulled their friends away from me and looked at me with bad expressions, as if I was deliberately falling into them 🤔. At first I couldn’t understand why.. but they probably thought I was trying to scam them 😂 (I wasn’t).
除了小時候學校就教導要幫助弱小，台灣在2013年推出了「緊急醫療救護法」，在路上對陌生人施救，都不用負法律與賠償責任，所以台灣不會擔心遇到碰瓷的，碰到車禍或暈倒都會馬上有人去幫忙
Peggy Li 不知道谁说过一句话：台湾的什么最美，人最美。
Peggy Li 台灣的高中都有一門cpr的考試...合格的人可以取得cpr證照...如果在路上遇見有人需要實行cpr的動作可以直接進行...但是...如果你救死了又沒證照...你可能要負責任⋯⋯
@@OSCAROscarOscarOscarOscar 第24條第1項前段
因避免自己或他人生命、身體、自由、財產之緊急危難而出於不得已之行為，不罰。
只要不是侵入性醫療行為
，不在醫療處所，救護人員到場前立即由救護人員接手都可以免責
幾年前我姐去福建找她老公,出門時忘記帶手錶,等不到我姐夫,急著問路人現在幾點結果竟然沒人願意告訴她,她納悶了半天到底怎麼了,回台灣時說起這件事我們也猜文革時把人與人之間的信任摧毀殆盡,要重新建立起來要花數倍的時間。不過中國人好客可是沒什麼改變,熟識後對客人之好,我們都覺得很窩心。
愛吃麵條的緹 谢谢分享您的经历🙏：）。希望未来我们能做的更好
@@SimonYu 我一直相信會愈來愈好的。
Fascinating discussion. The effect of the Cultural Revolution is undeniable. In my interactions with people of Chinese descent, I noticed the cultural characteristics you mentioned and assumed it was a spin-off of Confucian rules which seem to tie most Asians up socially into continuous knots and mind games. But what you describe is also common in my experience in Thailand which of course has a large Overseas Chinese immigrant culture influence. It is the norm for Thais to avoid Good Samaritan situations for the same reasons you outline, it can backfire easily and the mind games that are ever present can really cause trouble for not only oneself but ones family which is unacceptable. Nobody can be trusted and no good deed goes unpunished which is not too much of an exaggeration. There is some moderation of all this in some Thai as Buddhist teaching put great emphasis on compassion, empathy and mercy but most Thais are just looking out for themselves and rightly so as it can be very dog eat dog. Foreigners are often seen as exempt from all this mental gymnastics as they are not expected to think like Thai and are all crazy any way, at least that is not far from common Thai opinion. .
Side note: You have to say "good Samaritan", since it is based on an allegory. Samaritans are simply a certain group of people.
Dowlphwin thanks for the correction! :)
That’s right. The Good Samaritan was a person in a story.
@@SimonYu
台湾没有文革,那么为什么台湾是诈骗岛,虐童岛。
规模编辑
台湾警方估计[8][9]，全台湾有将近10万人从事诈骗犯罪[10]。2005-2014年之間，台灣破獲詐騙嫌犯超過20萬人；仅2015年，詐騙嫌犯就有1萬7000人[11]。全国人大代表陈伟才称，“电信诈骗有90%是以台湾犯罪分子为头目的犯罪集团实施的跨境诈骗，目前台湾有将近10万人，以面向大陆实施改号电话诈骗为主”[9
来自维基百科,/台湾诈骗集团。
tw.youcard.yahoo.com/cardstack/5a672190-5f2f-11e8-be85-e5d79e28d9c9/%E5%8E%BB%E5%B9%B4155%E5%80%8B%E5%8F%97%E8%99%90%E5%85%92%E6%AD%BB%E4%BA%A1%E5%89%B5%E6%96%B0%E9%AB%98+%E5%8F%B0%E7%81%A3%E7%82%BA%E4%BD%95%E6%B7%AA%E7%82%BA%E8%99%90%E7%AB%A5%E4%B9%8B%E5%B3%B6%EF%BC%9F
去年155個受虐兒死亡創新高 台灣為何淪為虐童之島？
@@SimonYu 假民主的油管,我上次留言,居然删我的号.
@@SimonYu However, Samaritans are known from the Bible because of the story of the "Good Samaritan" who offers help, so if you say "Samaritan", most people will know what you are talking about anyway.
我覺得做為個人，我們可以選擇自己成為怎樣的人，物以類聚，也就靈識聚，就可以成為同樣信念的國家。。我改變，所以我自由
I am from Singapore. I grew up in Singapore as a hearing impaired person, only having learnt English language. Since the Ministry of Education in Singapore has prioritised English as the main language so we the hearing impaired people learnt only English. I had some bad experiences in Beijing. I got hungry somewhere near the hotel. I tried to turn on VPN and used the google translate app. I translated the message into Chinese words and asked the passerby for some directions to the nearby eateries. The passerby simply ignored me and I got helpless. Even I was shocked that the monk ignored me as well. I was thinking how come this kind of religious person could ignore me when I helplessly asked for directions to any nearby eating places. I was not in rags or worn out clothes. After the trip to Beijing, I went back to Shanghai and felt relieved that I am more familiar with metro and some places. I felt that Shanghai is way a lot better than Beijing
Brother I really appreciate your bold honesty. I’ve never heard a chinese person speak out so openly on chinese issues. I pray there will be more that come forth and share their thoughts and feelings like you. I have the utmost respect for you and I wish you good health, prosperity, peace, and love!
Thanks for diving deeper into the cases. There is a lot of misunderstanding all around, but the final and most important message is that we all need to take responsibility no matter the consequences.
What?
Clearly you don't live in China.
CK H True, I seem to be handicapped by an education that included Latin, philosophy, logic, mathematics and science. Mr. Milk’s statement is so fuzzy as to be incomprehensible. Must have been an IT major.
CK H clearly you live in China
@@ckh2815 How did you get over the firewall, with a little help. Ha boys, I think we got ourselves 50 cent soldier. I think your work for the 50 cent army, leave laowhy alone, C.C.P. worshiper and incompetent prick.
Whoah, that backward walking scene at the end was so convincing and had a great visual effect. Good work, Simon!
I agree that Taiwanese are very kind. Now I understand the mainlanders better. 👍
Hi Simon ，我想回饋你講的兩個司法案例，第一個 彭先生的案例，他若是不小心推倒，導致老婆婆受傷，他送去醫院是合理的。
但是 人性面對司法的時候，會傾向保護自己沒有犯錯，他沒有坦白，但是還是他被判罪，很可能是依據老婆婆推倒的傷勢方向來判斷，於是判有罪。
但是 他到最後才坦承自己不小心推倒老婆婆，這在台灣人應該是判過失，而不是犯罪，然後在輿論的壓力下，加上你們對於司法的不信任，所以會認為法官是恐龍法官，為判罪而判罪，但是這是人之常情，台灣也會這樣，只是輿論的渲染，變成法官誤判好人。
第二案，一個小姐她差點被強姦，有人下去救人，而這個救人的先生被判罪，在台灣是不會這樣判，因為這個算正當防衛，因為台灣也有小偷闖進家，被男主人打死的案例，這個最後男主人判無罪。
其實，你們是相當不信任司法體制的。
再來，台灣所經歷的白色恐怖，也是活在互相舉報 監視的時代，到1990年才沒有，那時候發生的受害人，漸漸可以透過轉型正義去把正義討回來，這是台灣正在努力的方向。
但是 我覺得只要是人都是善良的，不是見死不救，而是你們經歷的文革，對於每個人每個家庭，整個國家對於人性是非常遲疑與害怕的，所以才會遲疑到底對方是否需要被救，或是救人是否會惹上麻煩，台灣也是會，但是感覺你們的社會，這種集團意識的恐懼更明顯。
在中國跟在台灣，因為國情不同，我們所處的社會氛圍不同，判決也會不同。
社會的現貌是由一點點累積造成的，不會是轉眼之間變成的，在我們身處在的社會，國家，每個人都有責任每個人都是局內人，沒有人可以說自己是局外人，面對問題雖然不是發生在自己身上，但是選擇冷漠或是裝作沒事或無感，其實就是幫兇，台灣也是一點點在修正跟改變，台灣也是從一次次的新聞，從媒體跟社群網路裡逐一建立起共識，首先一個媒體的自由度是必要的，要容許媒體的報導跟言論自由，再來是法制，法律的問題不是在建立或是修訂條文，而是如何使用跟執行，法律常常是被當成一種高官權貴的武器，如果執法不嚴或是朝令夕改，都是會讓人民不能相信法律的，一旦法律不被信任成為共識，就沒有人會遵守法律，每個人都想盡辦法鑽漏洞做壞事，人心的失望常常是三年五年之間就崩解了，那時候沒有標準沒有一個中心規範的生活，對一般小老百姓是無助可怕的，對於一些壞人卻是最好的，因為他們不要那些規範，那些規範從來也是管不住他們的，只是一個獲得利益的手段跟話術而已。
最好的規範是道德，法律是最後的手段
你们的阿扁抓进去了吗？
@@user-lk8tm5pf9v 有興趣的話 可以自己上網搜尋 扁案的各種判決, 有換法官,未審先判的宣言,還有偽證人, 當然 我相信你們只想嘴砲 根本不會去了解司法程序,以及程序正義.
@@致良知 是啊 搞出各种名堂 糊弄一下台湾人 就忘了 他是一个国际公认的贪污犯 呵呵 手好抖 (*^__^*) 嘻嘻…… 真的很搞笑
@@致良知 台湾的司法？你们的东厂还好吗 ？
碰到事, 我的大陸朋友永远是一句话 " 少管閑事" 這時候我才知道我们之间的距离
这样的人在你帮助别人的时候会发自内心的觉得你很傻
列舉的事件，我也在我們這裡的新聞報導裡看過，影片裡都有憑有據，再加長期觀察的看法，比較客觀！
現在真的無國界，不管書籍、網路，還是國內或出國，總會接觸不同國家的人 ，沒有言之有物，也沒法持續分享。影片內容、字幕、語調、畫質，都不錯，最棒是同步開小視窗，就說的內容提供相對應之影片、資料，儼然像新聞主播般的製作。很棒！
在台灣，我小學的時候，老師都會教青年守則，其中有一條是「助人為快樂之本」。
現在有沒有教，我就不知道了。
總之，在台灣我們幫助別人時，我們通常都會說這只是「舉手之勞」。
其實這些文化都要從小教。才能養成習慣。
如果大陸把以前文化都破壞了，也就要再去想了，趕快重建比批評重要。
加油。
实际上大陆的民众并不冷漠，热心肠的人真的很多。但是，法治的各种不健全导致见义勇为者可能会有种种不好的后果，所以造成大家不敢热心肠。
牆內都在讚揚共產黨的進步 事實是民主世界把他們拉起來的 不管事疫苗還是工具 但共產黨卻要挑戰民主世界的基本價值 說是美國陰謀洗腦 牆內人民可憐
For those who stayed to the very end, when everyone are walking backward, you was walking forward said something about you. You can make a difference by being different.
謝謝你的觀點幫台灣發聲，希望更多外國朋友透過你的頻道來了解及關心一些公共議題
I love the topics you choose for these videos as it is such a nice change to hear the views of a mainlander.
Unfortunately its slowly feeling like parts of the west are turning the same way. People are scared to help during issues like this because it so often ends up backfiring. Theres enough stories of people saving someone from being attacked but being charged or sued for getting involved in the altercation.
Even just that Disney-land fight from the other day. Most people were too scared to get involved even as a woman was beaten in front of her child and I even saw people suggesting the woman who lifted the child and pulled him away from the fight could be in trouble because of the way she lifted him. The world is crazy...
Love Taiwan. Many friendly people.
You are the hope of China, open minded, tolerant, peaceful, and tells it like it is with a mind on your own, not automatically follow the orders of dictators blindly.
I love the backwards walking part at the end. Very cool, well done.
台灣會有這樣的優良品性，是這30年來不斷努力教導才有的，但不夠好，還在努力中，，，，共勉之！
Thanks for the post Simon. The key to carry from this is that everyone is indirectly affected by this type of behavior all over the world. Sure, there are reasons for this type of behavior but now is the time to encourage information exchanges that shows how everyone can benefit by helping not harming each other. Remember 什麼人都有才成其為世界! I used to tell my classmate in Beijing this.
因為幫忙別人的成本比較高，台灣最多是不被謝或說多管閒事，關你屁事，中國可能要花錢消災甚至有人身安全問題，這應該才是幫助別人最大的考量，紐約人也是，幫你打電話叫警察是他們最友善的幫助了，不可能要求別人冒著被槍殺的可能去幫忙
I commented before on one of your videos "There's hope for the future !" You represent a heightened level of awareness for a young person. People are noticing (many positive comments, including mine) !
I recommend the Chinese/Canadian movie "Old Stone" 老石. About a taxi driver who saves a 外卖小哥 (food delivery boy)'s life after having a crash. It's about all the problems he faces after being a good samaritan. It's a really good suspense & psychological thriller, and quite recent. And, is banned in China.
@Hey Ho
Just watched it because of your comment. Good recommendation. That was a tough movie to watch, so tragic. That ending tho!😮😪
I literally looked away...but thankfully the scene froze.
As usual, interesting content and sensible reasoning from you.
Keep it up. 👍
As a tort lawyer in England and a person trained in first aid and AED , it's virtually the opposite. There is generally immunity in law to someone doing their best to help. Eg, if I broke someone's ribs whilst doing heart compressions) Also whilst not legally expected of a bystander, it is almost a duty to step in and help wherever possible. And failing to do so, such as not reporting a crime (ie the attempted rape in your story) could lead to the person who didn't report it facing a charge. I won't bore you with case law haha. Just thought I'd point out the difference.
在台北遇到一條狗，給機車撞傷，就馬上有人叫動物救護車，竟然即刻就到，真是大開眼界！
One more possible reason. I am Chinese and living in USA. In my point of view (baby boomers generation), culturally, Chinese in general value money as top priority in life. The love of money is pretty extreme compare to other ethnic groups. Favorite hobbies: saving $ , hunt for best deals, love free stuffs...etc. We often make our decisions based on money (cost). If it is too "expensive" (even though we have cash in the bank), we won't spend it. Since time is money, therefore we value our time very high also. Help some strangers, go vote, do community work, participate volunteer work...etc are not popular. My mentality was like that when I was younger. I am actually writing this comment because I am better now.
I so agree. I'm such a tightwad. Every new year I promise to do better and enjoy the life I'm given but fear always holds me back. I'm still trying --- work in progress.
simon的评判说大陆比台湾见义勇为的少实在是太过武断，大陆也分很多地区，在湖南以及两广地区见义勇为帮助他人的行为也是很多，一个大陆就给14亿人戴上帽子并不可取。
全部拿个案出来举例并不能代表，我们这里广西柳州就经常看到当地媒体报道见义勇为的事，说得有点偏激了，否定了很多人
可能從小被教導要對弱勢有同理心，去幫助需要幫助的人。
看見壞事要挺身而出，因為或許某一天自己或親友也會遇到，如果大家都是自掃門前雪的心態，這個社會就完了。
馬零糬 不知道你在香港街头看到打砸杀会不会站出来，希望都可以了
我們台灣的教育就是日行一善，助人為快樂之本，大家都可能為人父母，也希望自己孩子在外頭被善待。
@@user-wv1rk3mc8d 看到打砸殺就知道又是一個接收中共說法的。
我這些話是寫給聽過中國說法，但是想要知道不同方向角度，認為還是想要中立或沒有立場，但是想要自己進行思考的人。還有加入我個人對於牆國人的不滿的發洩情緒
當時也發生幾件事情。當時救護車經過的時候，原本擠滿人群的道路頓時讓開一條路讓救護車經過。人們靜坐示威，人們相反警察每次出事都阻止救護人員入場救人。當時有人混進示威人群砸小米的商店入內偷東西，被示威者見到直接抓起來商品放回店內將來亂的小偷綁在燈柱等警察來抓（當時市民還是信任‘警察’的）。我小粉紅和同學不要說這些都沒聽過了，她人不在牆內卻連兩百萬人上街遊行都不知道，也不知道市民的訴求，只以為香港人港獨。喊著我沒有去過中國不應該批評中國？笑死，還這句話給沒住香港來自東北的她
警察第一次開槍的那一天，示威者中槍倒下，失血過多。其他示威者原本可以跑的，但是有一個示威者衝了回去。警察將他撲倒，他還喊著「我不會離開，我有急救經驗，先讓我救他！我不會離開！先讓我救他」（這段影片我看了不同的媒體的拍攝角度，偏什麼顏色的都有藍的黃的，路人拍的，外媒的）
這兩個人是不認識的，因為中期就已經提倡無大台快閃式抗爭。時候那位被救的示威者有點愧疚讓那位返回去救他的抗爭者因而被捕。但是那位本該有美好未來的大學生卻說，他救他是不後悔的。
討厭看到示威者有人性光輝？因為你們想要認為的反派必須是邪惡到底的反派。但是到底是寧願失去自由也要救人的‘反派’有人性，還是連倒地的小女孩都視而不見的祖國人更有人性光輝？
香港人在危急時刻也會站出來了，哪怕不和政治有關。元朗白衣人事件，元朗黑社會白衣人衝進地鐵站無差別攻擊市民。當時也有孕婦。一些男市民用自己的身體護住孕婦，叫人快去叫警察。結果警察拖了許久才到，看到情況，什麼也沒做沒說什麼，轉身離開。市民拍到的都是警察的背影。哪怕把孕婦帶走吧！但是沒有！他們什麼也沒做！
香港人，哪怕在黑暗。也不會為黑暗說話，說真話的記者被警察帶走的時候，有香港市民選擇追著警察的車喊著加油。有人在圍牆外讀書抗議。
相反，呵，祖國人還會為著不救人的路人講話。正常化非正常的事。說「你們也不看看環境的黑暗使人害怕，不救人是正常的」甚至還會批評救人的多管閒事。到現在中國內還不為黑暗說話的中國人我是尊重的，為了人們為了中國想要改變黑暗的，我很難去指責他們為什麼不跑，跑了就沒事了。牆國人，呵，連基本邏輯都快沒了還談什麼人性呢
Thanks Simon I always wondered why Chinese were not good Samaritans, you explain things so well and connect the dots. I think many just assume that it is part of Chinese Culture without looking too deeply at the history. I pray that the younger generation can overcome the shadow of brutality caused by the CCP and that there can be Freedom and Human Dignity for everyone
ekami here in the U.S. people used to sue people who helped them claiming they were injured. So that sent a chill because people here would try to correct a wrong is they see one. That's when many states passed the Good Samaritan laws. It appears China has a convoluted version of the law and they are not being serious. If they really care about their own people they would pass similar Good Samaritan laws. Or better people can drive around with cameras on their dashboard with cameras running to protect themselves.
0:55 I saw that video when I was 21 and I was crying so hard for that little girl. I am now 31 year's old and I almost cried again after seeing that video again.
Serpetza directed me here.
Me too
Here in my country, we often look up to Good Samaritans as heroes, those that go above and beyond for the GOOD of humanity and help the person who is needing help, this is usually taught by parents and encouraged by stories listened to by young people told by teachers and parents. It won’t happen overnight but it can become a righteous way of thinking and acting over time. Find a story such as Aesop’s fables “the lion and the mouse “ and tell it to the children and then you and your child can discuss this foible (tale) together.there are many lessons to be learned through Aesop’s fables an old Greek ( I think ) philosopher.
China in general isn’t plagued with violence especially gun violence. I don’t think bar fights are a thing in China either. What I’m saying is, the chances of people getting into these situations are nil, but I guess people want certainty when it comes consequences. Fighting anywhere in the developed world isn’t encouraged either, and punishment is usually determined after the authorities figure out what happened.
i really like this guys videos. Informative, not sugar coated 他就是直接告诉我们 from a Chinese perspective things we 老外 are afraid to as as we don't want to be seen as being too 'critical' of China. Keep up the good work.
加油! 已訂閱你的頻道。我很少訂閱youtuber的頻道，但你提的觀點很特別，角度是我身在台灣看不到的，很寫實，很棒。持續加油。也小心人身安全。
If all one can focus on is his own survival, he probably has nothing left over to give to someone else.
"如果天总也不亮，那就摸黑过生活；如果发出声音是危险的，那就保持沉默；如果自觉无力发光，那就别去照亮别人。但是--但是：不要习惯了黑暗就为黑暗辩护；不要为自己的苟且而得意洋洋；不要嘲讽那些比自己更勇敢、更有热量的人们。可以卑微如尘土，不可扭曲如蛆虫。"
台灣有句話，法律不保護好人和壞人，法律保護懂法律的人。
以前聽到這句話有點心痛，但到了中國才知道，就算懂法律你依然是受害者。
Very interesting content Simon! I liked the walking backwards at the end - very original. Make sure to take care about you and your family's privacy. I don't want anything to happen to you
2:43 is about Chinese Cultural Revolutionary movement 50 years ago that have many people reporting their family members, report their professors. That is so sad!
Btw, awesome traditional Chinese caption.
The translation is very clear and eloquent, but be careful if the content revealed too much.
“many people reporting their family members, report their professors. ”-----which is exzacly happening in HK right now
一方面可能文革帶給中國太深遠的影響, 一方面台灣的教育, 是日行一善, 這是你走入台灣的小學, 幾乎所有小學布告欄或者校區都會有的標語, 台灣的學校教育不會教導要愛黨. 愛國, 但一定會時常教導學生要"多做好事多說好話" , 父母的教育也是, 要聽師長的話, 幫助同學, 長久下來從學校及家庭教育延伸至社會, 會起很大的作用.
台灣當然也有對社會冷漠的人, 但比例來講, 絶大多數都是樂於助人的.
還有一個我覺得對台灣人民很重要的因素, 就是宗教, 佛祖慈悲為懷, 勸人向善, 善有善報. 惡有惡報, 因果業障報應輪迴的觀念, 舉頭三尺有神明等....深耕人民心中, 如果沒有教導慈悲的信仰, 人們心中沒有依歸, 善惡那把尺容易迷失方向, 在台灣就算你不是佛教徒也會深受宗教影響的.
能夠獨立思考的你～很棒！當然身為同是台灣女人的我，更覺得你娶了個好老婆👍
Yh bruh run as far as you can is my policy as a foreigner in China ......you will never win any case against Chinese even if you were attacked
Yeah dude, I've heard many stories of other foreigners fighting back when being attacked or threatened then being punished more, kind of sucks but yeah that's just how it is here. Good if you have Chinese friends that can vouch for you/help you
Smithy lincoln nah.In 2018,A man called Yu Haiming changed self defence forever.
@@stevenshen32 which man
@@stevenshen32 name names ‼ tell us more about this foreigner who recieved "the rule of law" in China ❤🇨🇳❤
Smithy lincoln Yu Haiming case is very debatable in 2018.A drunk man called Liu Hailong failed to use a broadsword to kill Yu Haiming and dropped his broadsword by accident.Then Liu wanted to return to his car,but Yu picked it up and killed Liu.The case is very popular with Chinese people,especially us lawyers.Eventually,the Supreme People’s Court ruled Yu’s innocent
cool you did the foreword walk with everyone walking backwards : to me it give that, you see what other don't see
好人沒有好報的故事台灣也流傳很多，甚至還有不少利用人的同情心來詐騙的新聞出現。早年如果開車看到有人摔車躺在路邊都會猶豫該不該幫忙，現在有行車記錄器可以記錄真相，比較不會害怕被掐害，所以比較不擔心。
其實我還是相信台灣年輕一代的道德有在進步，比我們與上一代好，值得欣慰。
Here from Serpentza. Quality content, thanks for sharing 👍. Subbed 😎
I agree with all ur points, couldnt elaborate more on this. The society in PRC is lacking of trust between each other obviously.
for some reason I think the political system influence is beyond our imagination.
生活文化這種東西不能求快，而是要慢慢地演變，台灣今天社會會成為這樣子，也是經過演化而來的，並不是從天上掉下來變成這樣子，教育是文化的根基，所以我相信新一代的大陸中產階級興起之後，這種現象就會慢慢地改變，不要忘記了板主也是上海的年輕人。
Good episode Simon.
A documentary series by Ruben Terlou was very popular for a while in Holland. People loved it. A Dutch fotografer travelled along the Yangtze River and interviewed a lot of people. He also met a couple of good Samaritans on the way. Very interesting and sometimes heartbreaking. Life in China has been very though and many people are still struggling.
I like to watch your videos and
I think you are a good Samaritan too. Keep it going and good luck!
No！
中國的統治者不希望人們有同情心，同情心會帶來更多對弱勢同情，這會形成力量，專制者不希望人民形成力量，最好是個個自私像豬一樣只顧自己吃。
中國是人治社會，人治社會在法律面前誰都沒安全感，沒安全感當然選擇明哲保身，選擇自己能生存。
以上才是中國為什麼會形成一個自私冷漠甚至冷血社會的原因。
同意。直指问题本质
聽您講到當年那個小女童的事，我還是會發抖........無法想像小朋友當時有多痛苦!!!!
一個是從小的學校和家庭教育 , 一個是法律的保障 . 如果這兩點都沒有的話 , 的確會讓整個大環境變得對陌生人不友善 .
感動耶！還是那句：
幸好有姨丈，幸好有老婆，幸好你有智慧讓全世界看到尊重生命的可貴😄
唯有自由，才能自然形成創新，自然形成公民社會，自然形成人類互信，尊重
慢慢地自然形成
跟自由沒有關係，自古中國也是集權，這跟社會風氣，教育，法律有關。
Why don’t you move to Taiwan life is just 100% better over there and you love it too!
我是台灣人不是中國人,但看了你的這集影片心情還是很沉重,心情低落不想做任何事了...
還有一個原因台灣有宗教自由，從小被教育要心存善念，善惡有報，要幫助別人，與人分享，我們的教育也是如此，所以我們台灣人大部分人較為良善，喜於助人
看過中國一百多年前的紀錄片，那時候的人，比現在更有禮貌，比日本還跨張，敬禮敬超久。
@王雅菲 所以你沒有禮貌，更沒有素質，客觀事實。怎麼你打臉自己那麼爽啊！我也從來沒說自己素質高，有禮貌，所以對你更不用。
@王雅菲 …妳的素質好？
Was there a period in Chinese long 4000+ year history when there was more altruism? My personal experience is that mainlanders (met many) and Hong Kongers (met few) are less altruistic than other people. The few Taiwanese I have met were quite compassionate people. I also met people Chinese from Malaysia, Indonesia, and Peru - these were cold/stern, but very honest and disciplined. Just some random observations.
There were definitely some discussions of being altruistic and empathetic towards others in Chinese culture (as shown in some typical sayings), but the teachings may not be so well-spread as people in the past were not all well-educated (often to the point of being illiterate) and the majority were peasants during the dynasties. Under the Communists, there are more people educated, but still there are a great number of uneducated or poorly educated people. I think the issue needs to be tackled by both better education and media promotion. Since the problem has been around for a while, it won't get better overnight, but hopefully with more educated masses, things will turn for the better.
You are a very caring man. Please stay safe and thank you for sharing
文化大革命確實影響很大，在台灣幫忙別人是應該也是很平常的事，對於在台灣出生的我們，這是日常生活。因為這是應該做的
I've seen some of the younger generation doing things to protect animals and such. I think in that way people are getting better about trying to do the right thing. I still see a lot of the younger generation not helping other people though. I think it is getting better though. Perhaps it just needs time.
PERHAPS, as in maybe, as in not likely,
@@ckh2815 LOL
After 200 years of peace and prosperity the Chinese people will warm up ❤🇨🇳❤ to being good samaritans.
Very welcome to Taiwan !
看完你的解析，讓我們以另一角度看大陸，也同理大陸人為什麼會有這種行為，大家相互同理，吸取各自的優點，共同成長中，少點口水，有一位大陸人的留言，一直攻擊台灣人，台灣人也因他而生氣，這麼喜歡引起紛爭，奇特的一個人，可能內心缺愛，想引起關注吧！祝福他找到愛。
Nancy Chang 中國啦！
台灣好，友善，生活機能方便^^
explained very well I can see why the people don't want to get involved China needs capitalism not communism here in the states the Chinese people for the most part are very compassionate and very good neighbors they will go out of their way to help you they have business which they manage the employees that work there are kind and are of mixed nationalities. this has been my experience.
你是一個很有深度、很有思想、很有想法、且觀察入微的人~
非常好的視頻
訂閱了！
Hey, I am Chinese and I went through the cultural revolution. It's not that the cultural revolution trained people to be cold, people were culturally cold, but mao amplified it.
I would love to see your grandparents talk about it. But..... I fear for your family if you guys do.....so maybe forget about it and continue with small videos like this.
大陸會這樣，人與人之間的不信任 ，有很多原因。
政治造成的優良文化的催毀和動盪，還有對宗教信仰的打壓和輕蔑~
Tsai Vikki 亂說
@@backlighting9220 怎麼了，讓你想到宗教了。信仰不只是宗教啊。連「惡有惡報，善有善報」「人在做，天在看」這些古人用來勸戒人們別做壞事的‘信仰’，在堅持唯物主義拿著習近平思想的小粉紅眼裡可是迷信的話啊。
Thanks for the informative videos, you have a great channel going. Keep up the videos.
As a foreigner living in Shanghai, one rainy day i slipped and fell down the floor in the metro. Everybody passed by and said or did nothing. It felt a bit cold hearted, but i tried to look at the bright side and thought, oh well...at least they are acting like it didn't happen so i feel less ashamed of my fall hahahaha