You know you are a UA-camr when you make reaction videos when they are really scripted reviews. I love when people lie by claiming something too many times forced by guilt ("I've never listen to this before" 3 times before the first note) :)
That's such a perfect statement from him. David's performance really captures that feeling the words are trying to convey. I love the original, but Disturbed's version really hits it home.
I binge watched dozens of reaction to this, vocal coaches, musicians, random people, they all have one thing in common. The look of absolute joy on their faces from hearing something so blindingly beautiful, even when it’s making them cry at the sorrow it wrenches from their soul at same time.
I did the same thing. I probably would have gotten a lot of views if I had been recorded because I really get into it. Lol. I just love to see others enjoy it as much as I do. I never get tired of this amazing song.
When he paused where he did all I could think was, If you like the first part i cant wait to see him blow your face off with the rest. His smile said it all from there.
Mike Goodrich David is one of my BIGGEST singing influences and as a person he is absolutely amazing. You don’t see a lot of people within this type of music getting praise like this. You’ve absolutely gained my subscription as well! 💚
I totally agree with SpaceCowboyMugen. I totally love the song, but the greatest joy of watching this video is seeing the joy on Mr. Goodrich's face... throughout the whole song. Mr. Goodrich, your love of music is very evident and very appreciated!!! This video made my day! Thank you!
I know Simon and Garfunkel sang “Sound Of Silence” when I was a teenager. I heard this fellow here I think it was in the 90s.This guy from Disturbed takes it to a whole new level!!!
I had never heard this before it started showing up in these "reaction" videos - literally gives me chills. such a beautiful performance. I'm not a metal fan, but Disturbed has impressed me.
Fun fact: Disturbed wanted to cover this for YEARS, but held out until they were confident they could do it justice. I'm happy you could hear their reverence for the song.
The amazing arrangement did gorgeous justice to David Draimans voice!! First time I listened, the tears rolled!! I've had a few songs affect me like that. Just phenomenal. Of course, I'm a huge fan too!
I was 16 years old when I first heard this, and now at 73 I heard it again, for the first time. Smiling, crying, full body goosebumps, if I could feel like this every day for the rest of my life I could die happy. Wonderful, just wondeful.
Ruth, I've read so many comments on UA-cam vids, I even have a premium subscription. Your comment is the most real and wholesome that I've ever witnessed
Perfect sentiment. I saw Simon & Garfunkel when I was 15 at Constitution Hall in DC. And now this? Astonishingly perfect and moving. Paul Simon linked to it on his social media-the only cover he ever linked to. I read somewhere that Paul said that David/Disturbed owns the song.
My father (77 in June), had the 78 and I listened as a kid. I played this version for him a couple years ago, and he fell in love with it. Keep in mind, the song was REVERED in our home, and an attempt at a cover would have been sacrilege. Incredible version, and love you had the same reaction Dad did
David was SO SICK with the flu when he was singing this onstage. True testament to his love of the song and his love of the fans who waited to see him.
2 points: First that David (the singer) received a personal email from Paul Simon appreciating the rendition shortly after this performance. and second, the best way I've heard this described in respect to the original is that the original was a warning, this version was the anger that the warning was not heeded.
It's why I love both versions. The original has that soft warning gloomy tone to it. And the new one has the power and rage. I love that we have both now.
Joshua Duncan, exactly. The other great side-by-side is "Imagine" by John Lennon and Tool. Lennon's version was hopeful and inspiring, while Maynard's take was with a sarcastic, cynical undertone.
There are millions of songs that the human race has composed and performed over thousands of years of music. There are a rare few that give people a certain reaction, you get goosebumps and your hair stands on end, some even bring people to tears either because of the message the song holds or just because you realise you are listening to something extremely special. This is most definitely one of those songs.
People love to write off metal as just noise, but metal artists are so incredibly talented. So many are classically trained and complete music nerds! That's one of the reasons I love the genre so much. I introduced my professional opera singer mother to heavy metal when I was a kid and she became obsessed and eventually was the one to teach me all the ways it's similar to classical and operatic music. Now my mom is Disturbed's biggest fan and I loved watching this video because your reactions reminded me so much of my mom's first impressions when hearing them for the first time. It's always such a joy to see the artistry celebrated like this!
I love how he says “this gentleman”... I would have never thought that the first time I listened to disturbed that I would be listening to them singing a Simon and Garfunkel song, via a vocal coach reaction, with them being referred to as “this gentleman” -💖
this video was your first disturbed song? awesome! they've got a lot of other great covers and original music. i'd personally recommend at least checking out The Light and Darkness, i feel like they're both good transition songs from the ballad here and the harder metal/rock they usually prefer.
@@icefox94 oh no, this is not my first disturbed song. I am a long time fan and know all their songs. They touch my soul deeply. I don’t have any education with music, but their songs seem so complicated and simple at the same time. And their songs run deep like a river in my heart. I love it! But when I heard this song, my father was dying that summer... it touched me so deeply. A scar in my heart and their words pierced my grief, while helping me deal with the tragedy. It was a blessing and almost supernatural how it affected me. And I don’t even believe in any of that... They’re interpretation was like they saw my world - amazing
My dad and I listened to this version the day it came out. My dad’s reaction his face his mouth opening and closing the joy in his eyes. I didn’t want the song to end……. Just watching your reaction to a song that is and always will be a part of my life. It was like listening to this version all over again. Thank you. My dad passed away a couple weeks after we heard the song. I’m never going to forget you daddy.! Thank you so much for your reaction.
That is such a heartwarming story. Makes me feel warm and fuzzy that you were able to listen to it with your Dad and that he heard it before he passed. I want everyone I know to hear it. It is beyond explanation. I'm sorry for your great loss. You obviously loved him very much.
I can tell this guy is a legitimate teacher because he’s humble. “I don’t know how this is done.” He knows what he doesn’t know ... but you just know he’s going to get smart on that technique in the coming weeks and months.
He truly enjoyed the song, I think the fact that he didn't know was a joy to him, so often teachers get stagnant and bored with what they teach, it seems he found bliss in his ignorance, its a trait many of us lose after years of experience, that child like innocence of discovery, I know it was a joy to me to see it
I'm not a singer, I'm not a musician, but I know what sounds good and what sounds absolutely awesome. If any so called musical expert can find distain in this particular rendition, then I'm sorry but they are inept. Maybe one or two tiny points could be picked out but to me this is as good if not better than the original. Wow! Powerful perfection.
Me too. Grew up with the original, and Dave's version is just fabulous. The words don't come from his mouth, they come from his heart, and you feel every one of them. I love Disturbed's music. It's a real treat to hear Dave's "church voice". I wish they'd play it on the radio more often.
most people have taken to describing simon and garfunkels version was a warning, but disturbeds version is more of an angry reminder, as nothings changed
The look on this man's face!! I have listened to Disturbed's cover of this song so many times one of my all time favorites . And love watching everyone's reactions hearing this for the first time. The excitement is apparent on this man's face . David Draimin's voice blows me away!!! Disturbed you guys ROCK!!
I fully agree. It’s as if the song has grown angry in the years since it was originally sang, because we just aren’t listening. This version is absolutely perfect for where we are today.
Disturbed totally transformed a beautiful ballad into a beautiful power ballad. I agree with you, sir, David's timing of 'escalation' (going higher, adding pressure, rasp, then grit) was impeccable, so synced with the contents of the lyrics.
@Todd Hendricks I'm worried for you lol. I've been a Disturbed fan for 20 years and their discography is very different from what this song presents if you are looking for chill sounds 😂😂
I have gotten really interested in watching various professionals from neurologists to this teacher, and every one realizes the extraordinary talent and voice and artistry. When I see their reactions, it gives me the goosebumps all over, because their genuine overwhelmed and thrilled reactions brings me back to mine!!
I have to say that I absolutely love seeing the genuine joy in his face when listening to the song. I've watched many reaction videos to many different songs by other youtubers and most of them have such fake exaggerated expressions so watching this pure reaction was truly a pleasure.
Having the flu while singing can provide so much vocal variation in the lower key, it's really about being able to control your breathing through the congestion. The first time I heard this version of The sound of silence which was quite a few months ago, I had such a powerful emotional reaction. I really enjoyed this video.
I was in high school when Simon and Garfunkel came out with this song. It was soft and tranquil almost. The words sort of got lost in the melody. When David sings it, it's a pay attention. in your face, slap you up against your head achingly beautiful rendition.
I was in high school then as well and, even though Simon and Garfunkel were the hottest thing around, I thought the song was really boring. I never appreciated it until I heard Disturbed perform it 🤔
performed in the choir in school. Was the truest thing my teacher ever said: the best critique you can get from a judge is when they just put the pencil down and listen.
Mike: "I can't believe that this wasn't done like this..." That's, almost, exactly what I said when I heard this outstanding version the first time in 2018.
I love watching people being switched on to this song. This copy brings me to tears all the time. Hair on my arms & neck stands up, my chest becomes a little tight & the tears just happens but in a good way. This man's voice is very soothing to me. Sounds strange but it's a song I get lost in & feel safe in for a few mins at least. Thankyou David, Thankyou Disturbed ❤️🤘
Actually, it’s time all us aging hippie/peaceniks started SHOUTING AT THE TOP OF OUR LUNGS, before it’s too late. I love this rendition. It is not just perfect; it’s NECESSARY !!!
Something else that really sells this version for me is that as his voice builds, the accompaniment builds also. When he's soft and gentle, it's just the piano. As his voice grows the orchestra starts in, and finally the powerful timpani as it hits the peak. Very moving song that gives me goose bumps every time I hear it!
There's a video of him talking about how they determined the arrangement of the song. When to do what and where, etc. Very interesting. Ill post link here if i can find it 👍🏻
I absolutely LOVE watching the reacts to this. David Draiman has some legit pipes and to just see the looks on your faces, not only hearing him for the first time, but hearing THIS. Beautiful. LOL the smile on my dudes face at the 5 minute mark. He got the feels. And just gotta say man. Your reactions are straight up genuine and it shows. You love the art, and it shows. We are all smiling right along with you when he just lights it up. Good react vid. And yea...that build up...intense. It's ok to cry :)
It’s crazy to see how someone who sings in a metal band can go back to something like this and totally pull it off as amazing as he did here, the amount of control it takes for something like this is unreal, you know someone is good when they can do this
Simon and Garfunkel good as they were/are, were too smooth and "soft" to portray the true menace and danger in the message of the song. this is (IMHO) the best version ever.
4 роки тому+4
I think disturbed's much more vocal dynamic and angrier version is a justified interpretation to the message in the original version, many years ago, being ignored. S & G's version was perfectly ok for the time since that version was an initial warning.
Saw a comment on another video for this song and it was the best description I saw for this song... Original... a warning if we don’t listen This version... actually what happened because we didn’t listen to the warning
@@SARA-11-1 While I totally understand your frustration and felt it myself, the song's full unpaused performance is out there - this video is about the particular listener's reaction, and pauses like this help avoid talking over the music, which I personally would hate much more than pauses themselves
He changed it without changing it and it's beautiful. His voice gets right down to your soul with feeling. Love the drums and strings. I too love he arrangement.
The absolute, genuine happiness on Mr. Goodrich's face when he hit those higher notes was lovely to see. As someone who doesn't know the technical side of music but appreciates the beauty of the voice, it's nice to see others appreciate a genre that doesn't always get recognized.
Gotta say, out of all the "Voice Teachers" that I've watched react to this, you are the only one who actually seemingly knew how to to teach. Everyone else just points out obvious things, but you actually have good advice for people to take lessons from.
My son played this for me the other day and I have never heard an interpretation like this. Your analysis is spot on, Davis Draimand's vocals are incredible. The soul feels the honesty and reverence for this song and that can't be faked.
I love when you said what he did with his voice matched so well with the lyrics that you couldn't believe it wasn't done that way originally. What a compliment! I appreciated your expertise and the labeling of the notes David hit on.
@@alessioalbanesi3826 they didn't. Paul simon literally can't because he passed. The interview was with Draiman, in which he said he had gotten word that art Garfunkle had seen the conan performance and thought it was amazing
Your facial expressions are total gold. You epitomise how we all felt the first time we heard this. I still react with shock and awe every time if I'm honest.
You never talked about the MOST awesome part, which was how he throws the heat on his voice and then completely removes it like it was never there. The sweetness of those last few notes is just gorgeous!
David had the flu this might with 103 fever. 10 min standing ovation. This is an experience...goosebumps and tears. So incredible. At 77 i listen to this a few times a day for inspiration and to calm both. David was asked did he sing like an angel or a devil. I think he responded " yes". Great response by you. Go listen to it again alone. Bathe in it, experience it. If you dont feel, get goose bumps, tear up or just cry then you are souless. Davids voice crawls inside you and grabs your soul.
David has been under the vocal tutelage of Melissa Cross for the past several years. He has credited her with teaching him how to combine rasp and vibrato in a safe and effective manner.
There's two amazing parts about this cover 1) how he covers a couple octave jumps through the song, he really takes you on a journey starting low and building higher and higher with his vocals as the pace picks up. 2) the fact that he can sing like that with all the damage to his throat. He said in an interview with Loudwire that he has severe acid reflux and the flap in his throat is 95% just gone, that he had it fixed once and now there's nothing left for him to fix so he has to be really careful with his diet, make sure not to eat within a couple hours of bed and he has to sleep elevated so it doesn't try to come back up on him.. yet he can still sing like that. I know some people are going to say it's not true, but that's what he said in an interview so I believe the man himself. I just thought of something, he kind of reminds me of Bob Segar. Back in the day Bob sang deep really comfortably and then could go pretty high with it and still have it clean and his natural was a mid level somewhat high pitch. I will say I think David has more of a range than Bob did though.. but I can't help but want to hear him sing Like a Rock or Katmandu now :P (or maybe even Mainstreet, even if Uncle Kracker did a great cover of it)
The Simon & Garfunkel version was a caution/warning for us. The Disturbed version shows some of the anger for the warning not being heeded. Personally, I'm loving these reaction videos from you. Thank you for taking the time to make them and sharing them with us!
Google Paul Simon’s comment on this performance. Powerful. And I agree with this assessment and analysis. Listen or listen again to PTX version of this song. It is their own version (with new member Matt) but you can see how they we influenced by Disturbed’s version,
I love it when a singer can actually sing. For Michael Jackson, his dancing was his song, the words living in his movements. For David, his voice becomes the song. It is an amazing and breathtaking talent. I like Mike Goodrich. He has intelligence that has become wisdom. Priceless in this world. I subscribed.
The best way I've heard the song described is this: Simon and Garfunkel sang the song as a warning. Disturbed sang it as anger because the warning wasn't headed. I entirely understand what you mean about covers. Most of the best are ones that transformed the song into an entirely new form. Nobody cares if someone sings a song in the same way we're used to. It's when they make it into something new that we remember them. I loved your reaction. I could see all the times that you wanted to pause the video and make a comment but didn't want to interrupt the music. You are a true lover of music.
It reminds me of how "Hurt" was transformed when Johnny Cash sang it. I was thinking of this when i heard Pink's cover of "Me and Bobby McGee." She sang it well, but did nothing new with it. It was just the same song.
What a BEAUTIFUL song by DISTURBED. I just love the song and it is so moving. His raspy voice and range of emotion is just a song I love to hear. He's just beautiful ❤️
I've watched a hundred-billion reactions to this song, and will watch more. Your commentary and reaction was by far the most on point, relate-able, and informative. Good job.
8:03 and his amazed and joyful face had my heart melting for a moment ❤️ this cover is a true masterpiece (imho), but Disturbed is an amazing band too! I highly recommend it ❤️
I love this guy. My music teacher was my favorite teacher of all time. Every time I hear this song, I get huge goose bumps and can't help but smile and get excited I love this song I think this is one of my favorites!
Oh I just LOVED how much he loved this rendition of this iconic song..he literally glowed while describing how he felt,and praised David D 😊😊😊..every time I hear this song, I feel enveloped in it and his voice,and I figure he felt that too…
I love David Draiman's version of this song. However, I never could have fathomed watching a reaction video of the performance could make it even better. If I'm ever having a bad day, I'm watching this teacher express sheer, unbridled joy listening to this piece of music. I can't think of anything more uplifting. Thank you sir.
Your smile and reactions as David Draiman takes off with his style of the song are priceless, a clear love of everything going on. Thank you for sharing your reaction to and thoughts on this performance really lifted my afternoon!
I have seen a number of reaction videos to this song, and I love watching the faces of the coaches, but Mike's reactions were priceless and made me grin also. Brilliant reaction. :-)
I've never looked at it like that. Since Disturbed first released the cover, I've had a hard time even acknowledging the original. This, however, ties them back together in a way that I had not yet thought of
I dont remember where I read it, but i read that one of them really wanted to sing the song in a darker tone but at the times, the other didn't think it would be as big of a hit so they went with a lighter tone. They would be proud of this rendition.
@@jndvs95 that's true. It's been stated in a few interviews decades past i dont remember if it was Simon or Garfunkel that wanted to do it darker though
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
You know he is a real teacher because he didn't move the mouse after hitting play😂
😂
Lmao true
Sooooooooo legit, the times we had to riot for a teacher to press F11 is rediculous!
You know you are a UA-camr when you make reaction videos when they are really scripted reviews. I love when people lie by claiming something too many times forced by guilt ("I've never listen to this before" 3 times before the first note) :)
@@fredbegin3850 i had a stroke trying to read that
This guy looks like one of those teachers everyone loves
Edit: glad so many agree
Arlind Sejdiu that’s the exact thought I had haha
Sounds like a kiss ass who'd praise anyone. I bet he has a stock of participation medals in his desk.
More like cpt. Pike from Star Trek movies. Just few years older :)
Kinda looks like he could be Stephen Kings brother.
He reminds me a lot of my Algebra II teacher back in high school, who happened to be one of those teachers everyone loves
When Paul Simon first heard this version he said, "This is the way it should be sung".. High praise indeed.
That's such a perfect statement from him. David's performance really captures that feeling the words are trying to convey. I love the original, but Disturbed's version really hits it home.
Paul Simon told him that he 'owns this song' now , i watched a interview with david awhile back, thats about as high praise you can get.
@@antonytheolddog8626 same with Hurt by Nine Inch Nails. Johnny Cash did the cover and now the lead of NIN says that its Johnny's 100%.
@@yourstalker7386 Yep. Cash really made that song his own. With good reason.
I always wondered what Paul Simon thought of it. Thank you for sharing!!
I binge watched dozens of reaction to this, vocal coaches, musicians, random people, they all have one thing in common. The look of absolute joy on their faces from hearing something so blindingly beautiful, even when it’s making them cry at the sorrow it wrenches from their soul at same time.
Phew, I’m glad I’m not the only one who did that. Such a great performance.
I do the same. I don't ever get tired of listening to it 😜
I'm doing that right now for the fourth time.
Add a me too! 😍Loved it……
I did the same thing. I probably would have gotten a lot of views if I had been recorded because I really get into it. Lol. I just love to see others enjoy it as much as I do. I never get tired of this amazing song.
That last part of the song, you looked like a little child on Christmas morning, the expression on your face. Love it!
De Co ~ Right? You described his smile perfectly.
I couldn't have put this better. Mike's face was lit up and brilliant!
I thought the exact same thing. Surprise, joy, entertainment.
Exactly. His face was like a physical representation of my soul the first time I heard this version of the song.
When he paused where he did all I could think was, If you like the first part i cant wait to see him blow your face off with the rest. His smile said it all from there.
The joy on Mr. Goodrich's face when the higher notes were being hit earned my subscription. Love the passion
Thank you!
Mike Goodrich David is one of my BIGGEST singing influences and as a person he is absolutely amazing. You don’t see a lot of people within this type of music getting praise like this. You’ve absolutely gained my subscription as well! 💚
Me too!
I totally agree with SpaceCowboyMugen. I totally love the song, but the greatest joy of watching this video is seeing the joy on Mr. Goodrich's face... throughout the whole song. Mr. Goodrich, your love of music is very evident and very appreciated!!! This video made my day! Thank you!
Agreed reminded me of my old music teacher
This guy is the Bob Ross of vocal coaching. Such a smiley,appreciative guy
😂💯
You've gotta sing those happy little notes. 😊🎨🎶
THIS!! ^^^
Thank you. (-:
I believe you nailed it...happy little tree songs folks
I know Simon and Garfunkel sang “Sound Of Silence” when I was a teenager. I heard this fellow here I think it was in the 90s.This guy from Disturbed takes it to a whole new level!!!
This fella is the type of teacher that everyone remembers from their education. So much passion for his expertise.
Totally agreed ❤️
Exactly. My high school vocal teacher I still remember her. Hell I still go back and visit her!
Totally
Indeed.
And that everyone wholeheartedly loved.
This is more than a cover - it's a damned TRIBUTE.
I had never heard this before it started showing up in these "reaction" videos - literally gives me chills. such a beautiful performance. I'm not a metal fan, but Disturbed has impressed me.
I have listened to the original song by Simon & Garfunkels over many many years, but in my mind this "Trbute" just blows it out of the water
This was a flat out theft!
David stole this song for Simon and Garfunkel.
I can never go back to the original again.
It's almost the greatest song in the world. It's just a tribute, but I'm totally satisfied by that.
onwardtowaffles and they played the first song that came to their head, and it just so happened to be, the best song in the world....
Fun fact: Disturbed wanted to cover this for YEARS, but held out until they were confident they could do it justice. I'm happy you could hear their reverence for the song.
The amazing arrangement did gorgeous justice to David Draimans voice!! First time I listened, the tears rolled!! I've had a few songs affect me like that. Just phenomenal. Of course, I'm a huge fan too!
On a side note: It's been a while since I've seen "reverence" spelled correctly. Props to you!
They would be the only band to be able to disturb the sound of silence...
Also, most people don't realize that David was classically trained as an opera singer.
natkatmac fun fact Disturbed blew the original into the weeds
This version of this song delivers the MESSAGE of the song. Period.
I was 16 years old when I first heard this, and now at 73 I heard it again, for the first time. Smiling, crying, full body goosebumps, if I could feel like this every day for the rest of my life I could die happy. Wonderful, just wondeful.
Ruth, I've read so many comments on UA-cam vids, I even have a premium subscription. Your comment is the most real and wholesome that I've ever witnessed
Perfect sentiment. I saw Simon & Garfunkel when I was 15 at Constitution Hall in DC. And now this? Astonishingly perfect and moving. Paul Simon linked to it on his social media-the only cover he ever linked to. I read somewhere that Paul said that David/Disturbed owns the song.
Be happy to live…God Bless!
❤
My father (77 in June), had the 78 and I listened as a kid. I played this version for him a couple years ago, and he fell in love with it. Keep in mind, the song was REVERED in our home, and an attempt at a cover would have been sacrilege. Incredible version, and love you had the same reaction Dad did
Do you want a voice like an angel or a devil?
Yes
Demons are angels tho
*Old El Paso girl suddenly appears*
"Bueno es dios?"
@@user-hk8yp7cw1v no, the devil is the only angel of hell.
@@maxst2 all demons were angels that fell from the sky...
@@maxst2 all demons were angels that followed Lucifer. A third of all the host of heaven.
The pure joy in your face while listening to this song made me smile man. First video of yours I’ve watched and I’m a fan!
Same!
I really appreciate that, thank you!
@@MikeGoodrich I absolutely agree with this comment. Your face was so excited listening to the vocal range, made me excited as well. Thank you!
Same!
Same man that look is the reason people sing and write songs
David was SO SICK with the flu when he was singing this onstage. True testament to his love of the song and his love of the fans who waited to see him.
guess you could say he was down with the sickness.
@@zenny8877 bruh 😂
@@smolaether someone was bound to say it
He was sick when he sang this-?? No way. Wow. Immense props.
@@dazzlingdeb8427 That's why he was sitting on a stool. He didn't have the strength to stand for the performance.
He was sick when he sang this live on Conan. That’s his “less-than” voice you’re hearing. Amazing, isn’t it.
Yup
Yes, and the tech added autotune against his wishes. One case where the studio recording is purer.
He had a temp of 102, and was advised to cancel, he didn't, still pulled off a great rendition
The version with Myles Kennedy is probably my favorite live version of this song.
@@TheBucklessYooper i have both the studio version and that version on spotify playlist
2 points: First that David (the singer) received a personal email from Paul Simon appreciating the rendition shortly after this performance.
and second, the best way I've heard this described in respect to the original is that the original was a warning, this version was the anger that the warning was not heeded.
Agreed.
And never will be heeded.
It may not be heeded but that is our own fault.
It's why I love both versions. The original has that soft warning gloomy tone to it. And the new one has the power and rage. I love that we have both now.
Joshua Duncan, exactly. The other great side-by-side is "Imagine" by John Lennon and Tool. Lennon's version was hopeful and inspiring, while Maynard's take was with a sarcastic, cynical undertone.
Effortless control. What a beautiful voice this man has ❤
There are millions of songs that the human race has composed and performed over thousands of years of music.
There are a rare few that give people a certain reaction, you get goosebumps and your hair stands on end, some even bring people to tears either because of the message the song holds or just because you realise you are listening to something extremely special.
This is most definitely one of those songs.
People love to write off metal as just noise, but metal artists are so incredibly talented. So many are classically trained and complete music nerds! That's one of the reasons I love the genre so much. I introduced my professional opera singer mother to heavy metal when I was a kid and she became obsessed and eventually was the one to teach me all the ways it's similar to classical and operatic music. Now my mom is Disturbed's biggest fan and I loved watching this video because your reactions reminded me so much of my mom's first impressions when hearing them for the first time. It's always such a joy to see the artistry celebrated like this!
I was wrong in my judgement. I’m an old man that was blindsided by how good this song was.
@@bishopchalik8561 brother we all were
Whats your fav song from disturbed?
@@Alexandra-ek7kh symphonic metal 😉
@@Alexandra-ek7kh this like a million times! Classic was f*cking Metal! :D
"Thirty, forty years ago when Simon & Garfunkel did it..."
Us old people still think of 1964 as being 30 or 40 years ago.
Yeah my dad was born in 1960. He's definitely older than 40 now lol
I'm only 30 and I have to remind myself the 60s weren't 40 years ago.
@@Aster_Risk I’m in my 20s and I’m definitely not okay with 2012 almost being 10 years ago
This is how I am with Nirvana lol. I still think they were around ~10 years ago sometimes then remember what year it is.
isn't it?
I love how he says “this gentleman”... I would have never thought that the first time I listened to disturbed that I would be listening to them singing a Simon and Garfunkel song, via a vocal coach reaction, with them being referred to as “this gentleman” -💖
hahah agreed
I love this comment
this video was your first disturbed song? awesome! they've got a lot of other great covers and original music. i'd personally recommend at least checking out The Light and Darkness, i feel like they're both good transition songs from the ballad here and the harder metal/rock they usually prefer.
@@icefox94 oh no, this is not my first disturbed song. I am a long time fan and know all their songs. They touch my soul deeply. I don’t have any education with music, but their songs seem so complicated and simple at the same time. And their songs run deep like a river in my heart. I love it! But when I heard this song, my father was dying that summer... it touched me so deeply. A scar in my heart and their words pierced my grief, while helping me deal with the tragedy. It was a blessing and almost supernatural how it affected me. And I don’t even believe in any of that... They’re interpretation was like they saw my world - amazing
@@vwiccy This is amazing. Music can do amazing things. I hope you're doing okay now with your father's passing. My condolences 💙
My dad and I listened to this version the day it came out. My dad’s reaction his face his mouth opening and closing the joy in his eyes. I didn’t want the song to end……. Just watching your reaction to a song that is and always will be a part of my life. It was like listening to this version all over again. Thank you. My dad passed away a couple weeks after we heard the song. I’m never going to forget you daddy.! Thank you so much for your reaction.
That is such a heartwarming story. Makes me feel warm and fuzzy that you were able to listen to it with your Dad and that he heard it before he passed. I want everyone I know to hear it. It is beyond explanation. I'm sorry for your great loss. You obviously loved him very much.
My condolences 😢😢😢😢
What is the range of your voice?
David Draiman: Yes!
I just made a comment about this exact thing. I totally agree lol
Pretty much
Lol, very true 😂
Haha...Yes!
His voice should be insured 😂
I can tell this guy is a legitimate teacher because he’s humble. “I don’t know how this is done.” He knows what he doesn’t know ... but you just know he’s going to get smart on that technique in the coming weeks and months.
He truly enjoyed the song, I think the fact that he didn't know was a joy to him, so often teachers get stagnant and bored with what they teach, it seems he found bliss in his ignorance, its a trait many of us lose after years of experience, that child like innocence of discovery, I know it was a joy to me to see it
one thing I noticed here: You nearly couldn't stop yourself singing yourself. Thats the feeling I get every time I hear this song.
I can not stop myself from singing* along to this song, brings tears to my eyes every time I hear this version.
@@sleepypigeon8560, I am very sorry about your friend. I don't know if there are any words that ease the ache of someone gone too soon.
I’ve watched a few reactions to this, and you are the first vocal coach that totally gets it. You sir, have won me over. You have soul.
Check the charismatic voice channels reaction. She does a very good job breaking it down and appreciating it.
I'm not a singer, I'm not a musician, but I know what sounds good and what sounds absolutely awesome. If any so called musical expert can find distain in this particular rendition, then I'm sorry but they are inept. Maybe one or two tiny points could be picked out but to me this is as good if not better than the original. Wow! Powerful perfection.
Every time I hear Disturb's version of this piece, I end up in tears.
You're not alone....
Me too. Grew up with the original, and Dave's version is just fabulous. The words don't come from his mouth, they come from his heart, and you feel every one of them. I love Disturbed's music. It's a real treat to hear Dave's "church voice". I wish they'd play it on the radio more often.
@@annehenry6243 you mean synagogue voice? ;p
@@thomashollingsworth9048 oh yea, duh! What I meant to say was, "CHOIR voice". It was late, I was sleepy, my bad!!😜
Such an emotional song and he nailed it
The absolute joy on this man's face was so beautiful and wonderful. He looked so happy and surprised it made me smile
I kinda had a tearful smile. It's a like a return to innocence for him despite having seen plenty in his lifetime.
He’ll yeah!!! I felt the same way!!! Soooooooo much joy and happiness!
SAME!!!
most people have taken to describing simon and garfunkels version was a warning, but disturbeds version is more of an angry reminder, as nothings changed
I dig that.
Smartest shit I’ve read today...
The look on this man's face!! I have listened to Disturbed's cover of this song so many times one of my all time favorites . And love watching everyone's reactions hearing this for the first time. The excitement is apparent on this man's face . David Draimin's voice blows me away!!!
Disturbed you guys ROCK!!
I fully agree. It’s as if the song has grown angry in the years since it was originally sang, because we just aren’t listening. This version is absolutely perfect for where we are today.
S&G’s was the warning, Disturbs’s “Ten Thousand Fists” was the fight, this version is the reminder.
Beyond his magnificent voice, his timing is impeccable. He takes you with him and you feel the cobblestones beneath your feet. Absolutely amazing!
Disturbed totally transformed a beautiful ballad into a beautiful power ballad. I agree with you, sir, David's timing of 'escalation' (going higher, adding pressure, rasp, then grit) was impeccable, so synced with the contents of the lyrics.
In my opinion, this is the most amazing cover ever done. EVER.
Worst case top 3
Bad Wolves zombie comes close
All along the watch tower is definitely up there
Not to mention Johnny Cash, hurt
Yes! I always feel like a proud mama hen every time David sings this to me..I mean us 😁
In Italy we say: “he sings with his heart in his hand” ❤️
in Poland we say 'chlop co robi' and i think its beautiful
That's a beautiful saying
In the uk we say “ he fucking nailed it”
"I wish i had a voice sounded like that" said by every man, everywhere.
He is a trained cantor and also classically trained. He also had the flu when he performed this
Didnt David also perform at that one concert in the middle of the desert when he had the flu?
Came down here to make this exact comment.
@@aceundead4750 unless he did recently. The time I'm thinking you're referring to was uproar 2010 in Tempe, AZ
@Todd Hendricks I'm worried for you lol. I've been a Disturbed fan for 20 years and their discography is very different from what this song presents if you are looking for chill sounds 😂😂
@Hunter Edep I'm saying the voices may stupify him 😂😂
Man, the joyous expression on your face witnessing his mastery was almost more enjoyable than the performance itself. Love your analysis!
Thank you! It's not possible to hide it! Haha
I have gotten really interested in watching various professionals from neurologists to this teacher, and every one realizes the extraordinary talent and voice and artistry. When I see their reactions, it gives me the goosebumps all over, because their genuine overwhelmed and thrilled reactions brings me back to mine!!
I am 75 yo., and yes this song reaches the very core of me. For many, many reasons! Beautiful!
He has the voice which comes once in a1000 years!
I have to say that I absolutely love seeing the genuine joy in his face when listening to the song. I've watched many reaction videos to many different songs by other youtubers and most of them have such fake exaggerated expressions so watching this pure reaction was truly a pleasure.
Thank you. (-: I love music and singers!
@@MikeGoodrich It really shows!
This song takes my breath away every single time. Really, I forget to breathe.
🙀Hope you’ve resumed your breathing by now
Hair stands up on my arms everytime I listen to this performance.
It makes me cry. This version is so filled with despair and anger. It's beautiful but painful too.
@@melissakenealy8868 I have the same feeling. Its so powerful that gets deep inside you and won't let go. Im having this played at my funeral!
Fun fact. he had the flue when he did this. Sick as a dog and still pulled this off. amazing.
Having the flu while singing can provide so much vocal variation in the lower key, it's really about being able to control your breathing through the congestion. The first time I heard this version of The sound of silence which was quite a few months ago, I had such a powerful emotional reaction. I really enjoyed this video.
Savagery
So... you're saying he was down with the sickness?
Jon Smith XD omg you get a gold star for that pun
@@JonSmith-hk1bq well done sir
I was in high school when Simon and Garfunkel came out with this song. It was soft and tranquil almost. The words sort of got lost in the melody. When David sings it, it's a pay attention. in your face, slap you up against your head achingly beautiful rendition.
I was in high school then as well and, even though Simon and Garfunkel were the hottest thing around, I thought the song was really boring. I never appreciated it until I heard Disturbed perform it 🤔
So agree with you!
And the video makes the meaning and symbolism jump out at you.
performed in the choir in school. Was the truest thing my teacher ever said: the best critique you can get from a judge is when they just put the pencil down and listen.
Mike: "I can't believe that this wasn't done like this..." That's, almost, exactly what I said when I heard this outstanding version the first time in 2018.
Me too
"I finally know what this song's about'. That is so profound, and so true.
I love watching people being switched on to this song. This copy brings me to tears all the time. Hair on my arms & neck stands up, my chest becomes a little tight & the tears just happens but in a good way. This man's voice is very soothing to me. Sounds strange but it's a song I get lost in & feel safe in for a few mins at least. Thankyou David, Thankyou Disturbed ❤️🤘
Actually, it’s time all us aging hippie/peaceniks started SHOUTING AT THE TOP OF OUR LUNGS, before it’s too late.
I love this rendition. It is not just perfect; it’s NECESSARY !!!
@@mousiebrown1747
❤️❤️
I love watching vocal coach reactions to this song because I feel like David's technique is so underappreciated lol
Something else that really sells this version for me is that as his voice builds, the accompaniment builds also. When he's soft and gentle, it's just the piano. As his voice grows the orchestra starts in, and finally the powerful timpani as it hits the peak. Very moving song that gives me goose bumps every time I hear it!
You're right! That's really a great build!
There's a video of him talking about how they determined the arrangement of the song. When to do what and where, etc. Very interesting. Ill post link here if i can find it 👍🏻
Well?
I absolutely LOVE watching the reacts to this. David Draiman has some legit pipes and to just see the looks on your faces, not only hearing him for the first time, but hearing THIS. Beautiful. LOL the smile on my dudes face at the 5 minute mark. He got the feels.
And just gotta say man. Your reactions are straight up genuine and it shows. You love the art, and it shows. We are all smiling right along with you when he just lights it up. Good react vid.
And yea...that build up...intense. It's ok to cry :)
It’s crazy to see how someone who sings in a metal band can go back to something like this and totally pull it off as amazing as he did here, the amount of control it takes for something like this is unreal, you know someone is good when they can do this
Simon and Garfunkel good as they were/are, were too smooth and "soft" to portray the true menace and danger in the message of the song.
this is (IMHO) the best version ever.
I think disturbed's much more vocal dynamic and angrier version is a justified interpretation to the message in the original version, many years ago, being ignored. S & G's version was perfectly ok for the time since that version was an initial warning.
Your so right!
I never really knew what the song was about till this one...(-:
Saw a comment on another video for this song and it was the best description I saw for this song...
Original... a warning if we don’t listen
This version... actually what happened because we didn’t listen to the warning
@@MikeGoodrich me either, and I've heard that song forever...now it makes sense
The fact he didn't want to even interrupt the song at the end...wow. love the respect and the critique!!
bu he did interrupt right before the best part...this song and his voice takes me away, and just when Im waiting for it...he stops the video
@@SARA-11-1 While I totally understand your frustration and felt it myself, the song's full unpaused performance is out there - this video is about the particular listener's reaction, and pauses like this help avoid talking over the music, which I personally would hate much more than pauses themselves
For me it's one of the greatest Live performances of all time... just incredible
This version gives me chills - amazing. I never care too much for the song until I heard this version. Thanks Disturb.
oops Disturbed (I have not heard of them prior)
He changed it without changing it and it's beautiful. His voice gets right down to your soul with feeling. Love the drums and strings. I too love he arrangement.
The first time I heard this version when driving a few years back, I got goosebumps and got tears in my eyes!!
I saw disturbed twice last year in concert....cried both times I heard it!! Amazing live!
I'm a 40 year old man, tougher than a nickel steak, and it nearly made me cry.
At 50 years old I still cry when I hear this song, it just really pulls that out of me. I love seeing peoples first time hearing it too.
Same
**Casually mentions Queensrÿche**
You've earned a new sub, good sir.
The absolute, genuine happiness on Mr. Goodrich's face when he hit those higher notes was lovely to see. As someone who doesn't know the technical side of music but appreciates the beauty of the voice, it's nice to see others appreciate a genre that doesn't always get recognized.
Best "Vocal Coach" on UA-cam ever.
It's that joy in his face, which is so cool and not cringe Like other Vocal Coach's! 👍👍
Thank you so much!
"I love that rasp and that grit"
Disturbed-"you obviously don't know what we sing."
LUL
They have unknowingly created "SOUND OF SILENCE: DEFINITIVE EDITION"
OH AH AH AH AH
He also had the flu during this performance
🤣
I love the huge genuine smile while he belted.
Much as I love the original, this version puts chills up my spine. No matter how often I hear it. Just love it, and loved your reaction!
Yea, there is so much emotion and power in it.
Goosebumps, every damn times...
Very boring depressing cover.
@@Bacfire83
Put a jumper on if you have goosebumps.
@@terencedempsey151 Or the best cover ever of that song.
Gotta say, out of all the "Voice Teachers" that I've watched react to this, you are the only one who actually seemingly knew how to to teach. Everyone else just points out obvious things, but you actually have good advice for people to take lessons from.
Check this one out too ua-cam.com/video/6fR1B1pMdeg/v-deo.html
My son played this for me the other day and I have never heard an interpretation like this. Your analysis is spot on, Davis Draimand's vocals are incredible. The soul feels the honesty and reverence for this song and that can't be faked.
I love when you said what he did with his voice matched so well with the lyrics that you couldn't believe it wasn't done that way originally. What a compliment! I appreciated your expertise and the labeling of the notes David hit on.
"people writing songs, that voices never shared." One of the best lyric lines ever.
There's really not a whole lot to say, Simon & Garfunkel endorsed this version as the all-time best version of their song, including their own!!
really ?in which interview ?
@@alessioalbanesi3826 they didn't. Paul simon literally can't because he passed. The interview was with Draiman, in which he said he had gotten word that art Garfunkle had seen the conan performance and thought it was amazing
@@Youmama187 Paul Simon is still alive! Don't kill him off just yet!
@@ReviewCrap you are correct. I thought he has passed, but I was wrong
ua-cam.com/video/ntNfwoKD0XA/v-deo.html
I can count on one hand how many songs literally give me the chills. This is one of them.
Your facial expressions are total gold. You epitomise how we all felt the first time we heard this. I still react with shock and awe every time if I'm honest.
I love this mans facial expressions. I’ve seen other voice teachers react and they don’t seem as impressed as this man was
Watch this reaction: ua-cam.com/video/uFmNaXAg0sw/v-deo.html she's really emotive and clearly impressed by this cover
He loves music!
You never talked about the MOST awesome part, which was how he throws the heat on his voice and then completely removes it like it was never there. The sweetness of those last few notes is just gorgeous!
The look of awe and astonishment on the voice teacher's face, especially the second half of the song, is awesome.
David had the flu this might with 103 fever. 10 min standing ovation. This is an experience...goosebumps and tears. So incredible. At 77 i listen to this a few times a day for inspiration and to calm both. David was asked did he sing like an angel or a devil. I think he responded " yes". Great response by you. Go listen to it again alone. Bathe in it, experience it. If you dont feel, get goose bumps, tear up or just cry then you are souless. Davids voice crawls inside you and grabs your soul.
❤❤Well said!!!👏 I get chill bumps each and every time I hear this! 😢 And tears!
What a voice!! Bravo!! 👌🎉
David has been under the vocal tutelage of Melissa Cross for the past several years. He has credited her with teaching him how to combine rasp and vibrato in a safe and effective manner.
He is a trained opera singer, so he has such an incredible voice control.
Isnt he a trained cantor? Not exactly same as opera? Not being a smart ass, just asking 😁
There's two amazing parts about this cover 1) how he covers a couple octave jumps through the song, he really takes you on a journey starting low and building higher and higher with his vocals as the pace picks up. 2) the fact that he can sing like that with all the damage to his throat. He said in an interview with Loudwire that he has severe acid reflux and the flap in his throat is 95% just gone, that he had it fixed once and now there's nothing left for him to fix so he has to be really careful with his diet, make sure not to eat within a couple hours of bed and he has to sleep elevated so it doesn't try to come back up on him.. yet he can still sing like that.
I know some people are going to say it's not true, but that's what he said in an interview so I believe the man himself.
I just thought of something, he kind of reminds me of Bob Segar. Back in the day Bob sang deep really comfortably and then could go pretty high with it and still have it clean and his natural was a mid level somewhat high pitch. I will say I think David has more of a range than Bob did though.. but I can't help but want to hear him sing Like a Rock or Katmandu now :P (or maybe even Mainstreet, even if Uncle Kracker did a great cover of it)
This is what im having played at my funeral. So much power and depth. It can pull you inside out. The longer it goes on the more you are drawn in.
4:50, holy shit, the hair stood up on the back of my neck. Full body chill. Damn!
The Simon & Garfunkel version was a caution/warning for us. The Disturbed version shows some of the anger for the warning not being heeded.
Personally, I'm loving these reaction videos from you. Thank you for taking the time to make them and sharing them with us!
Thank you for you kind words and that is great insight on those 2 versions. I agree!
Google Paul Simon’s comment on this performance. Powerful. And I agree with this assessment and analysis.
Listen or listen again to PTX version of this song. It is their own version (with new member Matt) but you can see how they we influenced by Disturbed’s version,
I love it when a singer can actually sing. For Michael Jackson, his dancing was his song, the words living in his movements. For David, his voice becomes the song. It is an amazing and breathtaking talent. I like Mike Goodrich. He has intelligence that has become wisdom. Priceless in this world. I subscribed.
Listening to this song over and over ... had NO idea my body had SO many goosebumps!!
The best way I've heard the song described is this:
Simon and Garfunkel sang the song as a warning.
Disturbed sang it as anger because the warning wasn't headed.
I entirely understand what you mean about covers. Most of the best are ones that transformed the song into an entirely new form. Nobody cares if someone sings a song in the same way we're used to. It's when they make it into something new that we remember them.
I loved your reaction. I could see all the times that you wanted to pause the video and make a comment but didn't want to interrupt the music.
You are a true lover of music.
It reminds me of how "Hurt" was transformed when Johnny Cash sang it.
I was thinking of this when i heard Pink's cover of "Me and Bobby McGee." She sang it well, but did nothing new with it. It was just the same song.
🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯
I hate to be that stickler but Heeded, not headed
What a BEAUTIFUL song by DISTURBED. I just love the song and it is so moving. His raspy voice and range of emotion is just a song I love to hear. He's just beautiful ❤️
This is the best version of that song I have ever heard. I’m glad you’re reacting to it, finally.
It is awesome for sure! Thanks for you comment and all the other ones on other videos! I still have a few to answer. (-:
I think this is better: ua-cam.com/video/relfz3ZFsZA/v-deo.html
@@torbjrnlund903 I wouldn't say better, different. Good, but not really better - it's a different rendition.
Great job. I’m usually not a huge fan of reaction videos because people want to pause every 12 seconds to pontificate for four minutes. Nicely done.
His voice has such a commanding and rich presence will forever love David’s voice and Disturbed.
I've watched a hundred-billion reactions to this song, and will watch more.
Your commentary and reaction was by far the most on point, relate-able, and informative. Good job.
Simon & Garfunkel: Warning
Disturbed: Pissed because we didn't listen.
Why does this comment don't have more likes?
Disturbed: You were warned once before. This is your second warning. There will not be a third.
@@MrZiva82 because its on 50 other videos
Love the analogy
@@stoleyourmojo2162 So true
I love how his eyes light up to David's voice. You got yourself a new subscriber from my very first watch!
8:03 and his amazed and joyful face had my heart melting for a moment ❤️
this cover is a true masterpiece (imho), but Disturbed is an amazing band too! I highly recommend it ❤️
He was actually sick with a cold or just recovering from one when he did this so you can give serious props to David for how good he sounded!
I love this guy. My music teacher was my favorite teacher of all time. Every time I hear this song, I get huge goose bumps and can't help but smile and get excited I love this song I think this is one of my favorites!
Oh I just LOVED how much he loved this rendition of this iconic song..he literally glowed while describing how he felt,and praised David D 😊😊😊..every time I hear this song, I feel enveloped in it and his voice,and I figure he felt that too…
I love David Draiman's version of this song. However, I never could have fathomed watching a reaction video of the performance could make it even better. If I'm ever having a bad day, I'm watching this teacher express sheer, unbridled joy listening to this piece of music. I can't think of anything more uplifting. Thank you sir.
Your smile and reactions as David Draiman takes off with his style of the song are priceless, a clear love of everything going on. Thank you for sharing your reaction to and thoughts on this performance really lifted my afternoon!
I have seen a number of reaction videos to this song, and I love watching the faces of the coaches, but Mike's reactions were priceless and made me grin also. Brilliant reaction. :-)
That smile says it all i love the joy in his face
As I've seen posted elsewhere, Simon and Garfunkel: A warning. Disturbed: Rage because the warning was ignored.
I've never looked at it like that. Since Disturbed first released the cover, I've had a hard time even acknowledging the original. This, however, ties them back together in a way that I had not yet thought of
WRONG!
I dont remember where I read it, but i read that one of them really wanted to sing the song in a darker tone but at the times, the other didn't think it would be as big of a hit so they went with a lighter tone. They would be proud of this rendition.
that comment is definitely floating everywhere lol
@@jndvs95 that's true. It's been stated in a few interviews decades past i dont remember if it was Simon or Garfunkel that wanted to do it darker though