The Mob Votes Are Killing Minecraft, Here's How

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 жов 2022
  • Mojang holds a yearly event where the community votes for a mob to be added in Minecraft and it’s killing the game.
    -Socials-
    Twitter: / xayxayyt
    -Support me through Super Thanks if you like my videos!-
    -Specific Credits to-
    Video edited by me!
    Loosely Inspired by @SunnyV2
    Big thanks to my friends: Restless, Tsuki, Kataga, Moonshine, Marseeya, Tunie, Forsy and Gamo for providing feedback
    Yae Miko Minecraft skin (By timeforcrime):
    www.planetminecraft.com/skin/...
    -External Sources (in video order)-
    [0] Minecraft Live 2022: Which Mob Gets Your Vote?
    • Minecraft Live 2022: W... (By Minecraft)
    [0] Minecraft Mob Vote: Will you pick Mob D during MINECON Earth?
    • Minecraft Mob Vote: Wi... (By Minecraft)
    [0] Minecraft Live: Vote for the Glow Squid!
    • Minecraft Live: Vote f... (By Minecraft)
    [0] Minecraft Live 2021: Vote for the glare!
    • Minecraft Live 2021: V... (By Minecraft)
    [0] Glare Texture
    / 1447781464750243842 (By AxolotePurpura)
    [0] Minecraft Live 2022: Vote for the Sniffer!
    • Minecraft Live 2022: V... (By Minecraft)
    [0] Sniffer Texture
    / i_made_the_sniffer (By Alguna_Cosa_69)
    [0] Minecraft Live 2022: The Mob Vote is Back!
    • Minecraft Live 2022: T... (By Minecraft)
    [1] allay Winner (Sad animation copper golem and glare Lost 😭😔)
    • Video (By Ender Dragon Supremo)
    [2] Don't Fight - This is Nokia Lumia
    • Don't Fight - Microsof... (By Nokia)
    [3] Minecraft Live 2022: Mob Vote Winner
    • Minecraft Live 2022: M... (By Minecraft)
    [4] The Darkest Timeline: The '1' Timeline | Community
    • The Darkest Timeline: ...
    [4] Minecraft Live 2022: Vote for the Rascal!
    • Minecraft Live 2022: V... (By Minecraft)
    [5] Minecraft: Caves & Cliffs 1.17 - Update Reveal Minecon (2020)
    • Minecraft: Caves & Cli... (By Minuthu)
    [5] Minecraft 1.19 Trailer | The Wild Update
    • Minecraft 1.19 Trailer...
    [5] Minecraft 1.19 Won't Add Fireflies, So I Did…
    • Minecraft 1.19 Won't A... (By doctor4t)
    [5] MasterChef US Season 3 Episode 10
    [5] “Client is bad”: Why we 'LOVE' League Client
    • Why we 'LOVE' League C... (By Vandiril)
    [5] Village & Pillage: Official Trailer
    • Village & Pillage: Off... (By Minecraft)
    [5] Nether Update: Official Trailer
    • Nether Update: Officia... (By Minecraft)
    [5] Minecraft Live 2022: Get Ready to Vote!
    • Minecraft Live 2022: G... (By Minecraft)
    -Music used in the video (in video order)-
    [0] Minecraft - Warmth
    • Warmth (By C418) (© Mojang)
    [1] Minecraft - Mice on Venus
    • Mice On Venus (By C418) (© Mojang)
    [2] The Powerpuff Girls | Theme Song
    • The Powerpuff Girls | ... (© Cartoon Network) (RIP)
    [2,3] Minecraft - Pigstep
    • Pigstep (Stereo Mix) (By Lena Raine) (© Mojang)
    [4] Minecraft - Mellohi
    • Mellohi (By C418) (© Mojang)
    [5] Minecraft - Sweden
    • Sweden (By C418) (© Mojang)
    -Viktor, Arcane (Season 1 Episode 2)-
    "When you’re going to change the world, don’t ask for permission.”
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 773

  • @RealSonofGod69
    @RealSonofGod69 Рік тому +1401

    I agree. Doing these mob votes is a sure fire way to disappoint roughly 66% of the community. It sows division, allows for large amounts of toxicity, and just overall pulls the community apart

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +186

      Glad to see the messiah himself agrees with me, I strongly believe that Mojang has ways to work around all of these without removing the mob vote itself outright.

    • @Demax_14
      @Demax_14 Рік тому +32

      Amen🙏

    • @macmcleod1188
      @macmcleod1188 Рік тому

      Plus they often feel like this...
      Vote "to slit your own throat"
      Vote "to burning to death"
      Vote "to die from poison"
      You must choose one. And your vote applies to anyone that doesn't vote.

    • @thelordz33
      @thelordz33 Рік тому +42

      More than 66% since it also disappoints those who don't like any of the choices.

    • @WaterLemon147
      @WaterLemon147 Рік тому +14

      If the mobs came back in future updates that would be nice just like the biome votes (i just want moobloom and hovering inferno)

  • @FungiCaptain
    @FungiCaptain Рік тому +515

    with how much stuff has been "considered for a future update" it feels like we could have a whole one, two, or even three updates just adding all the broken promises from over the years

    • @cleverman383
      @cleverman383 Рік тому +65

      1.21 - The Broken Promises Update

    • @kertisjones2092
      @kertisjones2092 Рік тому +32

      That would unironically be a really good idea for an update.

    • @Aspect.04
      @Aspect.04 8 місяців тому

      they shoooould@@cleverman383

  • @ukkisragee9983
    @ukkisragee9983 Рік тому +309

    I'm still salty about chillager not getting into the game just because "it's not a completely new mob" and "dream said vote glow squid" and i'm still mad that we're probably never gonna see a hostile mob native to the mountains because of that

    • @HURR_EMERALDS
      @HURR_EMERALDS Рік тому +6

      Well that's just dream's vote don't let it affect yours

    • @davidkinkade81
      @davidkinkade81 Рік тому +8

      stray: I am a joke to you?

    • @ukkisragee9983
      @ukkisragee9983 Рік тому +50

      @@davidkinkade81 i said mountains not cold biomes

    • @jsw973
      @jsw973 Рік тому +22

      I'll be honest, 90% of my reason not voting ice-ologer is the phantom, I don't trust Mojang to make an actually good hostile mob from the votes. They'd just make them annoyances and let the community blame the people that voted it in the first place. So, I picked the passive but potentially useful mob; glow squid.

    • @Soccerfandan120
      @Soccerfandan120 Рік тому +60

      @@HURR_EMERALDS It isn't just Dream's vote. He makes his votes VERY public, so his army of fanboys vote the same thing. It isn't just Dream's vote, it's most of his community.

  • @beholdenpie
    @beholdenpie Рік тому +83

    I don't know why they go through the trouble of designing, modeling, and programming 3 different unique jobs that would all make great additions to the game only to throw 2 out

    • @PacoReer
      @PacoReer Рік тому +5

      Are they actually designed, modeled and programmed? Their designs are very basic, so you can argue they're designed, but most of the chosen mobs have gone through several redesigns and retextures (like the phantom). They're good concepts, but I'm sure Mojang has already scrapped many good concepts throughout the years

    • @sandraswan9008
      @sandraswan9008 Рік тому +11

      @@PacoReer love how you've just proved their point further

    • @BigMastah79
      @BigMastah79 Рік тому +4

      The other two mobs likely never get programmed beyond prototypes.

    • @thetheory6159
      @thetheory6159 19 днів тому

      ​@@BigMastah79and then modders are able to make the mobs completely in like... an afternoon.
      It's REALLY not much work. There's no reason not to add all three.

    • @BigMastah79
      @BigMastah79 19 днів тому

      @@thetheory6159 I mean, it kind of is? The mob has to be developed on both platforms and goes through far more rigorous debugging. That’s not to mention that Mojang did all of the concept work that modders utilize.
      And lets be real, the mobs aren’t THAT great? Like, it’d be a lot to add 3 pretty inconsequential mobs every update.

  • @Sercil00
    @Sercil00 Рік тому +54

    I didn't even vote on the last mob vote anymore. It was way too unclear what the mobs even did and what they were good for. They all sounded like you'd interact with them 2-3 times and then forget they existed. I refuse to vote with low information, because this gave us the phantom.

    • @bobosaurus331
      @bobosaurus331 5 місяців тому +2

      Exactly, all the mobs have literally one purpose

  • @breadprime
    @breadprime Рік тому +154

    This dude just woke up and decided to be a comedic genius and just...a genius. Absolute banger video.

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +10

      Absolute banger comment from you my dude, glad to hear you found the video funny, I'm always striving to find the right balance of educational/informational and entertaining and it's comments like these that let me know when I'm going in the right direction.

    • @breadprime
      @breadprime Рік тому +5

      @@XayXayYT You are doing great, man. Brilliant editing and script. Would love to see your channel develop and grow. Earned a sub.

    • @BigMastah79
      @BigMastah79 Рік тому +1

      Comedic? Mehhhh…. Genius? This isn’t exactly an original thought either

  • @doctorrogue1923
    @doctorrogue1923 Рік тому +342

    They really should just do 2 things imo
    A: As you stated, make the mob vote decide the ORDER that the mobs are added rather than what to add
    B: Make the mob votes more than just mobs, let us vote on more wacky things like what the next big update is about, such as that experimental combat update.

    • @HURR_EMERALDS
      @HURR_EMERALDS Рік тому +2

      U mean the one that lessens attack reach instead of attack strength the faster u hit something?

    • @doctorrogue1923
      @doctorrogue1923 Рік тому +8

      @@HURR_EMERALDS There was a build where weapon not only had differing attack speed and damage, but reach as well, and a much more intuitive interaction with shields, it also had some new enchantments iirc and generally had more interesting combat, and introduced auto swing, but you would get higher damage from timing it as the swing would happen a frame or so before the increase damage indicator, but iirc the stronger attack also had slightly increased range in that build on top of the damage? But I haven't checked in for a while

    • @HURR_EMERALDS
      @HURR_EMERALDS Рік тому +2

      @@doctorrogue1923 that would be interesting to try out.

    • @zulus3
      @zulus3 Рік тому +3

      We really need an End update

    • @RotmgTrollerFan
      @RotmgTrollerFan Рік тому +7

      @@zulus3 there are other parts of the game that need updates on way more than the End. this is why i disagree with OP's opinion that major updates should be voted. people would just vote what's "cool-sounding" rather than what's actually good

  • @quirinoguy8665
    @quirinoguy8665 Рік тому +28

    The lesson of the story is, Democracy sucks, go anarchy, just hold a massive brawl in a Minecraft server and let them PVP for their respective sides, whoever wins gets their mob added, and whoever loses? Skill issue, I'm sure this won't be a terrible idea at all... Totally sure...

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +9

      Damn, Mob Revolution

    • @babylonas9143
      @babylonas9143 11 місяців тому

      And Dream would "win" this one once more 🙃 PvP is his element.

    • @ThatCzechMapper
      @ThatCzechMapper 2 місяці тому

      ​@@babylonas9143 Dream is not that good at pvp

    • @babylonas9143
      @babylonas9143 2 місяці тому

      @@ThatCzechMapper Good or not, the word "win" was in quotation marks

    • @emirkara8660
      @emirkara8660 27 днів тому

      Hoi4 minecraft mob vote edition :D

  • @user-ej7sr3ow8b
    @user-ej7sr3ow8b Рік тому +68

    Throwing lost mobs is really a bad idea. If the mobs are similarly good, then it will just make most people sad; if one mob is overwhelmingly better than others (just like sniffer for this time), the vote itself is meanless

  • @BonziBUDDY
    @BonziBUDDY Рік тому +71

    It always amazes me that either one person or a small group of people can create a mod that adds all or most mobs from votes within a day or two, meanwhile mojang only adds one and it takes like 6 months. I don't see a reason they can't just add all at once, or at least include them in a future update.

    • @RotmgTrollerFan
      @RotmgTrollerFan Рік тому +8

      It requires much more thought than mods. Mojang is making something that will affect tens of millions of players while mods only make something that will affect the people who install it, and even then if it negatively affects the people installing it they can just uninstall.

    • @nimi5570
      @nimi5570 Рік тому +29

      @@RotmgTrollerFan Mojang also has dozens of full time programmers. The hardest part about making Minecraft updates isn't the programming, it's more the coming up with ideas and how to smoothly integrate them into the game part

    • @jinx5673
      @jinx5673 Рік тому +4

      @@RotmgTrollerFan That’s not really an issue. If they added a new realm, people getting upset would be idiots because they can just not go there. If they add new passive mobs, the people can just ignore them, etc etc. especially when the majority of players would rather have more features, than dull boring mobs that have no reason to exist.

    • @BigMastah79
      @BigMastah79 Рік тому +2

      Mojang has ro develop for two distinct platforms with different coding languages, they actually design and conceptualize the mobs, and their implementations are generally less buggy and more thought-out.

    • @BigMastah79
      @BigMastah79 Рік тому +8

      @@jinx5673”ignore it” is such a weak argument. If something is bad, then you can criticize it. If Mojang ever puts out anything that is low quality, it will rightfully be criticized. If a new dimension were completely optional but the gameplay suck and was at odds with the game’s spirit, it should be slammed, period.

  • @bottlecapbrony366
    @bottlecapbrony366 Рік тому +28

    I always thought that if Mojang has a good idea for a mob that will objectively make the game better, then they should just add it into the game and bypass the mob vote altogether. They are the creators of the game, they decide its fate.

  • @VoidHxnter
    @VoidHxnter 11 місяців тому +8

    I am still angry that the sniffer won the mob vote, like overwhelmingly angry. All he offered was digging up flowers, that’s it. The rascal added a fun mechanic that rewarded you for playing with it. A pretty good reward too, it allowed you to stay underground for so much longer and could save you from all of your pickaxes breaking.

  • @PepekBezlepek
    @PepekBezlepek Рік тому +18

    "I want them to sell me a masterpiece of a game, not a promise." THIS

    • @sandy_nes31
      @sandy_nes31 Рік тому +4

      This slaps harder than Will Smith

  • @kingoftheisles
    @kingoftheisles Рік тому +314

    I have never seen a video that I relate to so much. Mojang needs to listen to the community more and I feel like that’s another problem. If they listened to our opinions, Minecraft would be a much better game than it is now. Not saying it is not an amazing game already, I just feel that they could make it even better if they just listened.

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +28

      Glad to hear that someone shares the same sentiment as I do. There are certain times where I feel like Mojang needs to listen to the community but they don't, examples of these are the combat update, the mob vote and the infamous chat reporting system.
      All we can hope do is hope they change their ways.

    • @nobodys_here07
      @nobodys_here07 Рік тому +13

      I feel as if instead of having to choose 1 out of 3 mobs to be added, Mojang should instead allow players to vote on whether a mob should be added or not. As in instead of choosing one mob over the other like we usually get, give the players the option to pick yes or no on a certain mob idea.
      Example:
      Instead of
      ____________________________________
      Choose one:
      🔲[Option A]
      🔲[Option B]
      🔲[Option C]
      ____________________________________
      We could have
      ____________________________________
      Should we add this mob?
      [Add basic descriptions and mechanics]
      🔲 Add
      🔲 Don't add
      ____________________________________
      You'll still get the community's votes and it would lessen the probability of angering people as well as not discarding unique mob ideas.

    • @HURR_EMERALDS
      @HURR_EMERALDS Рік тому +2

      @@nobodys_here07 It was a joke.

    • @benjaminwade7489
      @benjaminwade7489 Рік тому +4

      @@nobodys_here07 everyone would always vote in favour of adding the new mob

    • @saltananda3227
      @saltananda3227 Рік тому +4

      The thing is; when a game is going in a good direction, the most vocal opinions are people who want it to go "their way", everyone else is busy having fun, so the vocal minority gets their way. Then once a shitty change is implemented the rest of us are like "but we never wanted this, can we at least have an option to disable it ourselves?" (no. no we cant).

  • @jakube1735
    @jakube1735 Рік тому +35

    copper golem wouldve been game changing for redstone, it wouldve also added more functionality to copper, other than it being a metal that turns blue-green after a while.

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +15

      I think randomizers already exist for redstone, but I do agree that it would be much cooler for contraptions if they had a little copper button masher in em

    • @BigMastah79
      @BigMastah79 Рік тому +1

      Yeah no Copper Golem wouldn’t have changed much for Redstone lol.

    • @Milo_hAt3r
      @Milo_hAt3r 10 місяців тому +7

      ​@@BigMastah79They would be the first mob to use buttons, which means we can make the mob decide to execute someone or not, since their coaxed to copper buttons

  • @potionmaster100
    @potionmaster100 Рік тому +7

    "1.14, village and pillage. it added JOBS! RAIDS! and SLA-"

    • @potionmaster100
      @potionmaster100 Рік тому

      Thanks for the heart @Xayllernste

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому

      @@potionmaster100 ay no probs my man

  • @robmitch4085
    @robmitch4085 Рік тому +15

    I think they should have a loser bracket. Every other year they bring back the ones that lost and you can vote on which two gets added so the list doesn't get too long. This also opens up the opportunity for team lineups. So you could do something like the creepy watchers (glare/rascal) vers golemancy (tuff/copper) and whatever team wins those two get added.
    This will give them an additional year to fully fleshed-out the next mobs they want to add and will have a lot lower of a chance to make a majority of the community feel left out.

  • @nathankudrle6553
    @nathankudrle6553 Рік тому +15

    idk how your video ended up in my feed but i didn’t realize you were a really small channel until after the video was over. the editing and style of video made me think it was some random 100k sub channel getting pushed in my feed. genuinley great work

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +4

      First of all, I'm flattered to hear that my video's qualities are equivalent to those with larger audiences. It's always been a philosophy of mine to create high quality videos no matter who's watching and it's comments like this that reassures me that I'm making the right move.
      Second of all I'm glad to hear that you've enjoyed the video and welcome to my channel my friend!

    • @Soldier-po9tp
      @Soldier-po9tp Рік тому

      Same, man. I only looked and saw becwuse i was gonna like.

  • @user-yg9ye9gu1o
    @user-yg9ye9gu1o 7 місяців тому +4

    We will fight for the builders, for the fighters, for the modders, for the redstoners, for the admins, for us and for all those who fight every day for a fair future, WE WILL DO IT FOR ALL OF THEM!

  • @user-xy7yl1qb9x
    @user-xy7yl1qb9x 7 місяців тому +4

    I have a idea : in the mob and biome votes mojang will make a special Snapshot when theres every mob or biome and the players will test it and after vote and in the real update mojang will add only the mob or biome that has the most votes and the others are still playable in the special Snapshot .

  • @justarandompersoniguess
    @justarandompersoniguess Рік тому +14

    This echoes exactly what I’ve been thinking the whole time. The mob votes are great for the ideas they bring, but it’s a crime to see most of it thrown away with no promise we’ll ever see it again. Just like with the updates practically… am I right?

  • @ianbirchfield5124
    @ianbirchfield5124 Рік тому +7

    mojang should occasionally do a throwback vote where they take all the previous mobs that lost and allow the community to pick maybe 1 or 2 to be added.
    and by occasionally i mean every 3-5 years. maybe not even occasionally, only when it feels right, heck maybe only once.

  • @hauntedvessel
    @hauntedvessel 7 місяців тому +5

    a year later, we are on the next mob vote. the same rules apply.. the crab is such a better implementation in terms of the other two when in concept with the others. it isnt fair for the other mobs, like the armadillo which has a cool concept but the mob is just so limited. im glad to see the evolving backlash against mojang for this yet again

  • @dontkickmychick6076
    @dontkickmychick6076 Рік тому +4

    Anyone else feel like the Glowsquid wasn't just underwhelming but also actively MISLEADING? In the video it appears to have a hypnotizing effect Ala the Mesmer from Subnautica. It pretty clearly uses it on Agnes.

  • @karynbrunton3218
    @karynbrunton3218 Рік тому +7

    They should have had a new mob every vote with the other 2 rolling over each time. They don’t have to create 3 different mobs knowing 2 will never be added. Also they DEFINITELY know that having 3 instead of 2 means that unless it’s a landslide more than 50% don’t get what they want.

  • @kiriakos.17
    @kiriakos.17 Рік тому +17

    totally agree. one thing that I don't like about today's Minecraft is how existing Worlds get updated. for me it's affected the space i played in and the are definite signs of changes in terrain that didn't use to be there at all.

    • @jinx5673
      @jinx5673 Рік тому +1

      That was always the case.

    • @henryfleischer404
      @henryfleischer404 Рік тому +1

      Changes in already generated terrain sounds like A bug that should be reported to Mojang...

  • @omniambitionsbadediting6765
    @omniambitionsbadediting6765 11 місяців тому +3

    Wildfire would've been a great mini boss in the nether, although speedrunners might disagree. For me, I don't care about the 2020 mob vote, I'd probably go for Moo bloom because it'd probably be a good way to farm yellow dye. The copper golem would be so good for redstone and would give copper an actual use, they can also be used as decorations when they oxidised. Rascal would've been so useful in caves while Tuff Golem would've been a great decoration. To anyone that think Tuff Golem is just a walking item frame, just remember, the Sniffer gave us 2 decorative plants.

  • @DaveGamesVT
    @DaveGamesVT Рік тому +4

    Mojang: Vote for one of these three mobs that will get added in months after multiple delays.
    Random UA-camr: So I modded all three of these mobs in the game with their full functionality over a weekend so we could try them out.
    Me: ??????????

  • @ShadowPlayz-ud5qc
    @ShadowPlayz-ud5qc 7 місяців тому +2

    Well this years mob vote is actually quite split, crabs extend reach which is what we've needed for awhile, Amadillos give wolf armour which the community has very much wanted, and penguins make your boat faster, which is just way more useful then the dolphins grace

  • @dripdripsplash
    @dripdripsplash Рік тому +15

    Awesome video with good editing, expected to see 100's of thousands of views. Instant sub.

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +1

      Ay thanks my friend! Glad to hear you've enjoyed the video and welcome to the channel.

  • @SunDragon1221
    @SunDragon1221 Рік тому +2

    Amazing video! I got this recommended on my feed, and I didn't realize you were a small youtuber until I checked the comments.
    So tbh I think Mojang has definitely started trying to rework the ideas from earlier votes. It's slow, but it's definitely happening to some extent. The Swamp update from the 2019 biome vote being the most obvious example.
    From the 2017 mob vote, the squid creature that sucks people into the water was used as the inspiration for the magma blocks that create the downward bubble columns in the oceans. The trapinch looking mob with the ability to consume enchantments was reworked into the grindstone. The shielded Blaze is in minecraft dungeons, and I think they're still planning to rework that into some game mechanic in the future.

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +2

      Glad to hear you enjoyed the video!
      It's good to know that they're beginning to rework ideas of previous votes, in fact one of the reasons why I exclusively criticised mob votes in this video is because Mojang updated Swamps and presumably will rework Deserts in 1.20, both of which having lost a biome vote before.
      I'm also happy to know that they changed the trapinch into the grindstone, that was a rather intuitive way of reworking it into a game mechanic, but I'm still rather disappointed that the squid creature never became a mob itself since the ocean doesn't really have a variety of mobs to fight other than drowned and guardians.
      However, this gives me some hope at least that they'll be bringing the blaze boss in the future and potentially the other losing mobs as well.
      Cheers my dude

  • @TankieBoi
    @TankieBoi Рік тому +2

    Wildfire got done dirty; It was finally a chance for a new thing added to nether fortresses since wither skeletons, and we got phantoms, a previously overpowered and mechanically broken mob over-nerfed into being purely annoying. Love both of the mobs and their designs but if there's something wrong with a mob, it needs to get fixed right asap or risk leaving a permanent ripple of damage when people simply get used to it being a negative part of the game

  • @Motyy
    @Motyy 10 місяців тому

    2:24 these memes are waaay too funny and I have to subscribe now
    btw I love that you use pigstep as beackground music :)

  • @toolazytorenamemyself
    @toolazytorenamemyself Рік тому +6

    I agree with this, the copper golems and iceologer were two of my favorite choices.

    • @RotmgTrollerFan
      @RotmgTrollerFan Рік тому

      ew

    • @Yappinton
      @Yappinton Рік тому +1

      Dude this youtuber is the worst he scratched out roblox
      I think minecraft is actual shit!

    • @sirgreatmuffin34
      @sirgreatmuffin34 Рік тому

      @@RotmgTrollerFan degenerate

  • @Enirom
    @Enirom Рік тому +1

    i don't remember when that new blaze was in the mob vote but it could fit so well in the nether update
    i can't believe they didn't think of that

  • @kaielmacmillan9258
    @kaielmacmillan9258 Рік тому +22

    Even if iceologer did win, which it probably would have, glow squid fans would have been really close (due to how many people voted in comparison to how many dream subs there are) which would still have upset an almost as large community who are more into aesthetics then gameplay, which is valid. So even if it was best case scenario, the majority of players would STILL be upset. So yes mobs have to be more similar in either usefulness or aesthetic appeal. You can’t really mix those without isolating peeps

    • @swapandas1273
      @swapandas1273 Рік тому +2

      i liked iceologer :(

    • @kaielmacmillan9258
      @kaielmacmillan9258 Рік тому +1

      @@swapandas1273 I did too. Just saying that glow squid fans are more prevalent than the internet would portray

    • @yummynubs3646
      @yummynubs3646 Рік тому +1

      what aesthetics? it doesn't even glow

  • @foxxowoxxowillow7855
    @foxxowoxxowillow7855 Рік тому +3

    Yeah, I've never liked mobvote because before, most mobs were added to solve a specific issue or add a specific interesting feature. Mobvote adds mobs just to add them first, utility comes as a far second.

  • @pratyushpandya8243
    @pratyushpandya8243 3 місяці тому

    dude he links his videos so beautifully and smoothly at the end man!!!really like you for that reason

  • @saltycube
    @saltycube Рік тому +1

    The first thing i shall type on this channel is wow you posted 1 video 9 years ago and came back 8 years later

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому

      Maybe I just took 8 years to discover what video editing is lmao.
      But hey, it's never too late to start again y'know? The passion for creating never really died.
      I'm tired of wishing to be a UA-camr, so I might as well start actually putting in the work to become a UA-camr.

  • @oxyque.
    @oxyque. Рік тому +5

    Woah you deserve much more subscribers and viewers, this was an amazing video!

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +1

      Thanks my friend, I'm glad you enjoyed the video!

  • @TheGBZard
    @TheGBZard Рік тому +1

    I’ve been on the losing side every year except the sniffer. And I did eventually see that the allay was better if you count that

  • @RubaeRuby
    @RubaeRuby Рік тому +1

    Maybe instead of a mob vote, they could do an community idea contest every update with a different theme? And instead of just adding the top voted one, they could add the top 3 or something.

  • @thomashalsted1888
    @thomashalsted1888 Рік тому +1

    I do have an idea to fix the Glow Squid. Give it hypnosis, so players that look directly at it lose control.
    Make it a challenge to get that ink.

    • @monodoe761
      @monodoe761 7 місяців тому

      No fixing needed its good how it is. Only mob vote winner I actually make use of.

  • @emilypoole3898
    @emilypoole3898 Рік тому +2

    I agree that they should bring back the old mobs in the mob votes. I actually was okay with the glow squid because of the glow item frame and glow sign. I think they were good additions to the game. I would like the iceolliger to be brought to Minecraft in the future.

  • @zerotheliger
    @zerotheliger Рік тому +2

    theres something to be said about the mod that continues to add all the cut mobs i never play minecraft these days without it..... if a single person can add these complex mod mechanics whats stopping mojang.

  • @eljamilaurus3410
    @eljamilaurus3410 Рік тому

    Man you are a master on drivinh people to other videos from yoruself, excelent work and excelent videos :D

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому

      I'm glad you like my videos! I always felt that people should have a reason to go from one video to the next, give some sense of continuity and reason for people to, rather than just "check out my other stuff" y'know?

  • @darellarocho5729
    @darellarocho5729 10 місяців тому +1

    I just want the Tuff Golem and Copper Golems in the game, man. I'm a Golem enthusiast, I want to build a facility with all 4 Golems running it.

  • @nan01ynk
    @nan01ynk Рік тому +2

    i thought this had 500,000 views, and then I read the top comment that suggested otherwise
    436 views for a video of this quality is criminal, fantastic work and excellent video, youve earned a like

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +1

      You're way too kind, I'm glad that you've found my video to be of that high quality.
      Thanks for the like and cheers my dude

    • @No_king1143
      @No_king1143 Рік тому +1

      Bro wth i just checked and the channel has exactly 436 subs
      Crazy

  • @hyperionhelios190
    @hyperionhelios190 Рік тому +1

    Regrettably, the last two years have really showed us that Microsoft has no interest in growing Minecraft with real new mechanics and value added updates.

  • @logan-sq6te
    @logan-sq6te 3 місяці тому +1

    hello I am a time traveler, if you see this message:
    we had the choice between a crab which allowed us to place blocks further and a super cute penguin
    they voted for a useless armadillo...

  • @JackTheDog795
    @JackTheDog795 11 місяців тому +1

    After knowing sniffer just grabs decorative seeds that barely even work, i think we need the rascal asap

  • @HurricaneGabby
    @HurricaneGabby Рік тому +2

    It would be cool if hostile mobs were occasionally added to the options. We don't have enough hostile mobs, so PVE gets pretty stale quickly.

  • @mechchococh.4313
    @mechchococh.4313 Рік тому +3

    Mob vote is just killing Minecraft and Mojang's potential
    If they dont bring back the losing mob, we might never see some mob with good and exciting mechanics
    If they do, Mojang's reputation will surely drop not alot, but still dropping due do lying

  • @happytoonz4506
    @happytoonz4506 Рік тому +6

    Your videos are so good man. Keep it up

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому

      Happy to hear this video was enjoyable for you as well my friend, cheers.

  • @Icyharce5904
    @Icyharce5904 11 місяців тому +2

    Someone just send this video to Notch please I beg the community.

  • @grimsage5809
    @grimsage5809 Рік тому +3

    Soo not to be the modded player but there's absolutely mods that add in the rejected mobvote mobs.
    May the algorithm bless you.

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +4

      I'm well aware that there are mods that add in the losing mobs, however I think those mods should further prove that Mojang is capable of adding more than 1 mob into vanilla Minecraft if they wanted to.
      And thank you my friend, I hope your day gets as blessed as the algorithm blesses this video ;)

  • @NotBrainytrust
    @NotBrainytrust Рік тому +1

    Biome votes where better as they still came or might come to the game (example: swamp biome update after they lost to the mountain biome)

  • @JezElectro13
    @JezElectro13 Рік тому +2

    i mean, Iceologer not being added clearly was. he was literally only Completely New mob, alongside Bee-friended Cow and Squid... But DIFFERENT TEXTURE.

    • @CreeperCombos
      @CreeperCombos Рік тому +3

      Yeah I really wanted the Iceologer because it added new mechanics and added a unique mob to the mountains

    • @swapandas1273
      @swapandas1273 Рік тому

      @@CreeperCombos plus new illager too

  • @wortwortwort117
    @wortwortwort117 Рік тому +2

    Sniffer may have won by 51%, but that also means 49% of people wanted something else...
    If anything the top 2 should be added, or all mobs will be added eventually.

  • @Quackra
    @Quackra Рік тому +1

    I will say with the updates we got to swamps I think we have a good idea that Mojang is at least considering adding things that lost the vote outside of the first two mob votes.

    • @tapgames3465
      @tapgames3465 Рік тому

      Well unlike mob losers being vague, mojang does want to readd loser boome contestants

  • @Rusty-the-datsun
    @Rusty-the-datsun Рік тому +1

    i feel the priority on whats added first is a better idea

  • @draketheduck1144
    @draketheduck1144 6 місяців тому +1

    lets stop the mob vote
    Do it for moo bloom
    Do it for rascal
    Do it for Justice

  • @Felfu_
    @Felfu_ Рік тому +1

    The mob votes suck, it even feels like Mojang knows this and always give 1 mob way more features which, of course, everyone picks

  • @retroaspectgaming
    @retroaspectgaming Рік тому +2

    If the copper golem is ever in another mob vote I'm going to spend 200+ hours making alt accounts to vote for it so it wins

  • @FluffyAngelUwU
    @FluffyAngelUwU Рік тому +1

    2:01 Mangrove, frogs and Boats with chest exist.

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому

      I excluded them since they were more of the Biome Votes, rather than the Mob Votes.
      They seem to add the losers from the biome votes so I just question why can't they do the same for the mob votes y'know? The Blaze Boss would've been perfect for the Nether update, The iceologer and other mobs had several updates to be considered and they are still exclude to this day, hence why I say I don't wanna get my hopes up.

  • @thanoscreeper
    @thanoscreeper Рік тому +1

    What editing software do you use? This video is really well made! You deserve more subs

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому

      DaVinci Resolve my friend! I'm using a really rundown 4 year old laptop to edit my videos so I didn't want to buy Premiere Pro if my computer couldn't handle it and then I just got used to it.
      And thanks my dude, glad to hear you enjoyed the video!

    • @thanoscreeper
      @thanoscreeper Рік тому

      @@XayXayYT Thanks! And no problem!

  • @stormostormo9465
    @stormostormo9465 Рік тому +1

    I have to agree making it to where a sandbox game like Minecraft having it to wear features get voted upon by the players with the other features disappearing and never getting added as a terrible terrible idea
    Now something I couldn't make sense is if whenever people voted on it decided the order in which specific things would get added or even if the voting took place with player-made content being added
    But realistically the Mambo as it is is extremely flawed most people haven't just stopped going to the mob vote at this point

  • @lool8421
    @lool8421 Рік тому +2

    tbh minecraft was struggling quite a lot recently
    1.16.5 was great, but then 1.17 was scuffed, 1.18 hurt the performance even more... as if they couldn't clean up the mess they left after releasing 1.13, 1.19 was the mild update, warden is just a 1-off, swamps are only gonna interrupt on your way, maybe swift sneak is okay for general use, but for example frogs don't do anything besides making alternate sea lanterns, and those are stupidly awkward to farm, chest boats are also interesting, but only useful in early game, once you get settle down, it's pretty much useless, 1.20 is also in a questionable state right now
    all i want to say is that updates don't really improve the game at this point, those are just random junk that don't really affect the game too much, only a few more items to clutter your inventory, but there's not much innovation, even OPTIONAL features don't get added, just like crafting some functional blocks, when they alr enforce annoying things on you like random raids, phantoms, creepers giving back just 1/3 of the blocks...

  • @waterierStone
    @waterierStone 9 місяців тому

    Now that we have the sniffer in the game it's just a long side quest to get two boring flowers and a noisy hill.

  • @braxeton671
    @braxeton671 Рік тому +17

    Bro you're underrated af. Your videos are very well made and the topics in discussion are very interesting as well. New sub 👍

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +1

      Welcome aboard my dude! Glad to have you along this journey, and I'm glad to hear that you enjoy the videos and the topics they cover.

    • @HURR_EMERALDS
      @HURR_EMERALDS Рік тому

      He is gaining a lot of subs since that 'why diamonds don't feel special anymore' vid tho :)
      Edit: I was one of them actually

  • @lukaasgames8468
    @lukaasgames8468 Рік тому

    you are way to underated, love your videos. this was an instant sub

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому

      I appreciate the sub my friend, glad to hear you enjoyed the video and glad to have you onboard our UA-cam journey!

  • @bobbodaskank
    @bobbodaskank Рік тому +1

    I haven't even watched your video yet, but I'm gonna go out on a limb and guess that the reason is the one any toddler could have told Mojang: it's typically bad practice to gleefully advertise all the cool content you definitely already built and have working, but that you aren't putting in your game for no reason.

  • @alt2137pl
    @alt2137pl Рік тому +1

    2 years ago in my school someone punched a kid because they voted for the wrong mob in the mob vote

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому

      I think that's going a bit too far, like I'd be disappointed my mob didn't win but resorting to violence is something else.

  • @JadeHakola
    @JadeHakola 7 місяців тому +1

    Mob votes have caused so much fights and i'm so worried if the game literally dies of lack of money..

  • @avangion80
    @avangion80 10 місяців тому

    I absolutely and totally love your style and humour. I also almost totally agree with things you say. In this video with everything... But Copper block is a nice building block in my crazy opinion.

  • @EsteVante
    @EsteVante Рік тому +1

    "1.14 they added JOBS, RAIDS, SLAVE-"
    LMAOO

  • @michaelr3077
    @michaelr3077 Рік тому +3

    Tuff golem wasnt useless, it was clearly a decorative customizable mob. Uncreative people just dont get it.

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +3

      I'm well aware of the Tuff Golem's uses, in fact I've even made a video on how it can be useful in terms of decoration and making builds livelier by having them move items around.
      That part of the video was not shitting on any of the mobs because every mob in the mob vote has a use, it's me poking fun at my own bias for the Glare by not calling it "useless" or "niche" like the other 3.

  • @SethPlayz4316
    @SethPlayz4316 11 місяців тому +2

    Just saying, THE SNIFFER IS USELESS

  • @vaclavsedlaty4595
    @vaclavsedlaty4595 Рік тому +1

    you need to send this to mojang headqaurters

  • @garettskott
    @garettskott 7 місяців тому +2

    These are great suggestions, but I doubt Mojang will even consider them. Players have been suggesting objectively good things in every aspect for years, but when has Mojang ever listened? Even stuff like improving the game's horrible performance was ignored!

  • @zombiesalmon4997
    @zombiesalmon4997 8 місяців тому +2

    Mob votes nowadays:
    • Skiimpus blimpuss
    -has the most complicated gimmick of all time
    -boring design
    -people only vote for it because popular UA-camrs like it
    -somehow wins and then everyone hates it onces it gets it
    • Neon cow
    -very pretty and cool design
    -everyone loves it and makes memes of it yet nobody votes for it for some reason
    - “best boi”
    -you will literally never encounter this mob in an average play through
    • Dirt block golem
    -another fucking golem
    -no ones voting for this guy
    -they didn’t even bother to program him because they know he aint winning
    -who cares

    • @AlanArc
      @AlanArc 8 місяців тому +1

      Dirt block golem? Are you talking about Copper Golem?

    • @bennittotheburrito9606
      @bennittotheburrito9606 7 місяців тому

      “Another golem” you mean the third one and the second one that actually does anything

  • @dylan_likes_purple8589
    @dylan_likes_purple8589 7 місяців тому +2

    11 months ago you were right this year the people woke up 😂

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  7 місяців тому +1

      It is pretty funny to see this video pick up again a year later lmao

  • @VincentCowboysAndTrains
    @VincentCowboysAndTrains Рік тому +1

    Hey if u work at mojang I think y’all should add the dodge feature from 360 and older versions for both

  • @yuvalorp
    @yuvalorp Рік тому +1

    The biggest problem of mojang is that they consistently refusing to do balance changes for old additions even that all of the community say that they are to op for example new Villagers and raid farms

    • @jinx5673
      @jinx5673 Рік тому

      Something literally cannot be op in Minecraft because everything in it is designed for you to use it if you want, and not use it if you don’t. This isn’t a multiplayer battle Royal like Fortnite where a weapon can be op and ruin gameplay. If you want to do something in a single player world and villagers allow it, then go ahead. The 1% who are too dumb to realize that shouldn’t mess it up for the majority.

  • @alessiomuccio2795
    @alessiomuccio2795 Рік тому +2

    Dude, dont ask them this much: they were very busy in making the chat reports in a way that would displease everyone!

  • @jowell6921
    @jowell6921 Рік тому +1

    We wanted the Creature of Night Skies cuz we didn't had much flying mobs, but it turned out to be a terror

  • @RUGER5264
    @RUGER5264 4 місяці тому

    One thing I really hate is how the Hovering inferno, and Monster of the depths could have been features for 1.13 and 1.16. But now they might now ever make it into the game.

  • @janicegalaura8418
    @janicegalaura8418 Рік тому

    Amazing content you deserve more subs than you have im sure you will be popular in the future.

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому

      Thanks my friend, glad to hear you enjoyed the video and hey, if I do end up hitting success in the future I'll be sure to remember you :)

  • @obledoesstuff
    @obledoesstuff 11 місяців тому

    I voted for the Allay and Sniffer for Mob Vote 2021 and 2022, and I voted for the Icologer in 2020 (I wasn't in the Minecraft Community in 2017). Hello, fellow stranger who has ended up on both sides on the mob vote spectrum!

  • @thegreenbacon514
    @thegreenbacon514 Рік тому +1

    Like the guy said, there are obvious choices in it mojang basically Riggs it themself the allay was clearly going to be the winner as soon as it was revealed, same thing with the sniffer and the iceologer like he said, the reason, the glow squid won It’s because of dream in my opinion mojang is gonna keep it up with the style then I think they should actively speak out against creators sharing their votes online because it’s been proven that it does heavily affect the vote.

  • @teslafistforge8716
    @teslafistforge8716 Рік тому +1

    My biggest frustration with the mob votes is that I never hear about them until after they are already finished.

    • @recycledwaste8737
      @recycledwaste8737 7 місяців тому

      There's a new one going on now! Maybe you won't miss this one!

    • @teslafistforge8716
      @teslafistforge8716 7 місяців тому

      @@recycledwaste8737 yea I am trying to actually catch this one.

  • @tarczownikovstolecki1214
    @tarczownikovstolecki1214 Рік тому

    7:10 i've realised that i'm playing this game for 11 years now, when did this time go, it was like a blink of an eye

    • @tarczownikovstolecki1214
      @tarczownikovstolecki1214 Рік тому

      started playing on Beta 1.5 btw and started watching this on youtube even a year earlier

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому +1

      Damn, absolute Minecraft boomer, you experienced Minecraft for almost every single update it got

  • @firetiredesire
    @firetiredesire Рік тому

    i thought this was a channel with atleast 20k subs by the quality of the vid nicely done

    • @XayXayYT
      @XayXayYT  Рік тому

      Subs or no subs, quality comes first, glad you enjoyed the video my friend!

  • @garfled23
    @garfled23 Рік тому +1

    How tf did glow squid even get added

  • @waterierStone
    @waterierStone 9 місяців тому

    I've never heard of anyone complaining about the one time they had us vote on the next biome. We still haven't gotten merecats, but we got frogs. Imo the mob votes should just be what animal they should add next.

  • @raphdm3776
    @raphdm3776 Рік тому +1

    literally every worst mob wins the vote, we missed out on a cool blaze boss, iceologer, a new golem, AND ANOTHER NEW GOLEM

    • @monodoe761
      @monodoe761 7 місяців тому

      Glow squid is more useful than Iceologer to me.

    • @raphdm3776
      @raphdm3776 7 місяців тому

      @@monodoe761 Bruh wtf I can't even tell if its a joke

    • @monodoe761
      @monodoe761 7 місяців тому

      @@raphdm3776 its not dumbass

  • @cegicreator2476
    @cegicreator2476 Рік тому

    let's not forget about the illusioner!!

  • @Erwyn_
    @Erwyn_ Рік тому +1

    the thing that makes me laugh the most is how after having voted almost everyone complains, if a mob won it will be because most of the community voted for it, right? there's no point getting angry when the problem is the community how many games would like a system like this I think they don't add all the mobs it's for the one block at time design discipline that I like I would advise the community to maybe kindly explain what the mobs add and why they think they should be added without insulting

  • @lunarhexagon8108
    @lunarhexagon8108 11 місяців тому

    Mob vote wozld be better if mobs included would be very similar and differences would be minor, like putting 3 'decorative' mobs or 3 hostile mobs or animals

  • @rockhound3.14
    @rockhound3.14 Рік тому +5

    Fireflies were a good example. They were to add them to the swamp biomes as well with frogs during the swamp updates. Well, some douchey teenager claimed fireflies are poisonous to frogs so they cut fireflies. Forever. Added the frogs tho