The defense atrorney is just doing the best job she can with what she has to work with. It's hard to listen to but you want everyone to have a compentent defense. If a person doesn't get a competent defense then they have a case for appeal. I'd bet that attorney tried like crazy to her to take the plea deal knowing this was an undefenseable act she would have to try to defend.
I do agree. "The evidence won't show bs.." blah blah won't show a strong argumentative case. She is in court and evidences needs to be shown and proven. Her argument is so weak emphasizing what is not there to show. Ohh well. Ohh well.
The poor darling dogs, you could see how scared they were, their tails were straight down between their legs, that’s a massive sign of fear, to then watch their human dad to be shot too. Dog’s are so intuitive and sensitive, I pray they are ok 😢
The way she went about texting her step dad from her moms phone after shooting her essentially urging him to come home shows she knew exactly what she was doing and also proves she had the intention to commit the act and was thinking ahead. Premeditated. Period.
I agree, if they can do an adult crime then they should do adult time! Personally I don't think the potential for rehabilitation should take precedence over the safety of the innocent people they could hurt.
I agree. And they should be identified as well and applications for suppression orders should be denied. Sadly here in Australia, even if a child (under 18) commits a very serious crime, their identity is kept secret, which is ridiculous. They commit adult crimes, they should be punished and treated like adult offenders. None of this bullshit, oh they’re still young and should be given a chance to be rehabilitated and guided in the right direction. No, they’re old enough to know what they did was wrong, yet still choose to commit crimes, so they should do the time and be named and shamed.
@@nevadatan7323 That very well may be true. However you’re either born with empathy & compassion or you’re not! It can’t be taught. Your parents can tell you or teach you why you should feel bad for something you’ve done but they can’t teach you or show you how to actually be that!
The stepdad's 911 call was so heartbreaking. You can really tell how utterly devastated he is. And as another comment said, Carly crying over hearing that call kinda irked me for some reason. But more like "Oh no, who knew killing your mother would have permanent consequences?" Either way, RIP Ashley.
He even calls her "daughter" during the call, not step-daughter. I can't believe that Tiktok's discourse is that he was involved somehow or he was sexually abusing her and that triggered Carly to kill her mom. Do they really believe that her lawyers wouldn't have brought that up if that was the case? Or that the police didn't check Carly's phone? She would have told someone or said it somewhere if that was the case, especially if she was so over the edge that she was willing to kill her mom, IMO.
I thought it was kind of nice seeing her respond to the consequences of her actions on other people. Ideally, they would make her listen to it every night before bed so she could cry herself to sleep. Even if we assume the worse, people still grow emotionally. Especially young people. It's been a year and a half since she did it and she is in her formative years. It is inevitable that she would mature emotionally during that year and a half. But yaknow, it's a comment section, so we're just supposed to shame her and pat ourselves on the back for being better than her. 🙄
I did a double take, personally i believe in her rage she didn’t initially remember the cameras, and as a half-effort she threw it in the fridge. It shows cognitive effort to hide her crimes, lazily
The fact that she thought nothing of texting her friend to come see her mums body tells me that this something she was not afraid of the friend telling on her about. I wonder what sick conversations they would have like it was normal?
Seriously cuz she knew her stepfather was coming home, and she didn't even try to warn him or nothing?? It's not like she thought she was bluffing. She showed her her her mom's body like it was a science experiment smh
I know, some really fucked up weird conspiracy theories out there, really appaling, he loses his wife and his step daughter tries to kill him and then he has to listen to that shit, some messed up people out there
Yes ppl are sick perverts. They're obsessed with molestation to a sick degree. Even if it has nothing to do with anything, that's the first thing that comes to their minds. I hope that poor man finds healing 💔😢
Why is no one talking about the mother? She seemed to be mentally ill as well. Ashley was so paranoid that her ex-might come over and kill her that she kept a loaded gun beside her bed. That reeks of mental illness. Was she getting treatment? Probably not. It also sends a message to others that gun violence is justified. Imagine your own mother making preparations to kill your father. How would that affect you if you were just a teen?
@theeclectic2919 You make it sound like Ashley was planning a murder... Plenty of women are terrified of their exes. I don't necessarily think she was paranoid in a pathological way. She was scared of him and kept a gun for self-defense. The only thing she did wrong was keeping it in the manner she did. Zero gun safety.
No she doesn't? She literally looks like any teenager, absolutely ordinary in every regard. There is nothing about her that makes her "look" like a psychopath.
Likely fear: Gregg had just shot her own mother several times in cold blood over basic parental boundaries. Who's to say she wouldn't murder a close friend over something more incriminating, as a witness to her crimes.
Not only check her mental health but she should’ve been charged with accessory or something for not warning Heath, for not calling the police to report Carli killing Ashely and for hanging out with Carli and waiting with her for Heath to come home and watched him get shot. She needs to be held responsible for her inactions as well.
I’m so sick and tired of defence teams using mental illness ALWAYS in smurder cases. This had nothing to do with mental illness, she is pure ev!l and knew EXACTLY what she was doing!!
But they just said no one knew she had a mental health disorder. I have chronic depressive disorders. I've never killed anyone. Tried to kill myself, but know one else.
@@Iwishiwasanyoneelse I have had depression beginning at age 7. I've never committed murder either. But it effects people differently. I don't understand why they don't hospitalize them before they get to this point.
I, and I’m sure many others, have a mental illness (I have Bipolar) but have also NEVER had a violent tendency. Nihilism is something some people are unfortunately born with
I agree, though hearing voices is filed under schizophrenia. However, she wasn't experiencing any evident psychosis around the time of the murder. Besides all the signs still point to premeditated.
@@Brandon-u9q has an impact over long term use and just because her mom freaked out doesn't warrant her daughter's action to murder her. Guess we have to tip toe around our teenagers...😑
My mum had a stroke last week. I don't say this to garner sympathy, - My mum is doing really well (at the moment). But there was a few days where I had to face the sobering reality that Mum might be gone, and I would never have her support or understanding ever again. To see her gradually re-emerge from pain, fear and confusion has been one of the most uplifting and hopeful things I will ever experience, but makes this case all the more confusing to me. One day I will lose the woman who is possibly the only person who truly understands me, a woman who will stand by me and advocate for me, no matter how much I may mess up. Our past hasn't been smooth sailing, there have been times I have been so angry with her I haven't been able to contain it. But I would never do anything to hurt her. I cannot understand this girl. I wish I could talk to her to try.😔
@@moniquetheobald889I'm really sorry to hear that. It's hard to imagine what that must be like, even having this insight.😔 Thank you for the good wishes.xx
I am so glad your mum is doing better. I could never imagine, purposely, hurting my mom. She is my best friend! ❤😭 this child , is an absolute psychopath, she does not deserve freedom.
Much love and get well wishes to your dear Mum. I lost my Mum in 2020 and it hurts still that I can't ask her advice or have a fun day with her among many other things. You are right, our Mums are our support and strength. I would give anything for another chat with mine. This girl is beyond help. I wish your Mum a speedy recovery ♥️ xxxxxx
Defence " Had no intention of hurting anyone that day" So that's why she went and got the gun? Defence "Her step dad looked for an intruder not recognising his daughter would do that" First thing he said on 911 call "My daughter shot me" 🤷🤷🤷
It's only about if someone has evil inside of them, and then they go and collect excuses like mental health/alcohol/drugs etc. to justify their behaviour. I've only seen one case so far where I could honestly say this person had no chance to even develop normally hence he is 100% the product of his surroundings and upbringing. But in this case here she didn't grow up being tortured and abused from birth.
I am sorry for your mental health, and being sexually abused. I congratulate you on your perseverance in life. I was physically abused as a child (My dad would whip me so hard with a belt that my little buttocks and sometimes my stomach would bleed...Mom would later start stepping in to protect me...I grew up in a religious household and I am grateful, and I agree with spanking but not whipping a child so hard while he was angry...I had very bad ADHD and us being poor farmers my Daddy didn't understand the disorder...He DID LOVE me, but he never whipped my sister and my little brother was rarely whipped and that was usually by Mom who would do it so Daddy wouldn't) so my Dad inadvertently gave me High anxiety or PTSD from the beatings and the hard farm work that I ONLY had to do...like making me climb up into Tobacco Barns at around12 or 13, these barns housed tobacco and you had to stand and balance yourself between to beams, only 2 to 3 or 4 inches wide. I then would have to take my hands of the rails/beams and pull up tobacco on sticks and lay them across where my feet were and the beams near my head. These railings could go as high as approximately 17 feet high. I got good at it quickly. I would later start having trouble in school and would pass out...the funny thing was it could be positive energy like when I got my first kiss, and the little girl (I was in 5th grade and she was in 4th grade) stuck her tongue in my mouth (LOLOL yes my friends still won't let this go)...I dropped like a sack of taters. Other times I would be Bullied or get in trouble due to my ADHD (remember I wasn't on medicine) and I would pass out. Like you, I persevered and but abused alcohol in college (I used it to be able to ask girls out in college). I was pulled out of college by my dad, and I joined the Army/ARNG. I graduated all my classes in medical school and became a Combat Medic (God really helped me during Boot Camp...I never had a panic attack/passed out. I then went back to EKU University in KY and graduated as a Rec Therapist under a BS in Health and Sciences and later earned titles of Mental and Behavorial Specialist. I worked with initially SVP's Sexually Violent Predators for the state of California (I performed stand-up and was in 2 movies ...I'll leave this part out...I hate texting and typing, but I have written a short story comedy, and it was put into a screen play format, and I wrote and illustrated a children's book) at the Infamous Atascadero Maximum State Mental Hospital. Later on, I worked in Anchorage, AK. at North Star Childrens Behavior problem Center (they lived here). Now I am a broken physically from back disorders, injuries, fighting for real and some MMA, over 12 surgeries with 9 being attributed to my spine. I can't work at the present time even though they pay here $80K. I still love video games and a more than a couple years back finally proved that I had severe anxiety disorder (not hypoglycemia like they told me as a kid) and that I have one of the worst cases of ADHD that my Doc said he's seen in 30 years. So, I take a few pills and several natural/supplement medications. Also, several years ago I became a Christian and before that I was just blind, awful Temper, and drank too much. I am now trying to get my pain taken a way or reduced...don't look good for me going back to my previous lifestyle and helping others while getting paid well (lifestyle without the Temper and Alcohol). So here I am and not ashamed. Do you have a personal relationship with Jesus? Anyway, feel free to reply or not. Sorry typing so much and God Bless. Ajax
I'm autistic (functioning), have ADHD and major depressive disorder. The thought of merely forcing my will upon another person, let alone maiming or murdering them, is entirely anathema to every fibre of my being. The 'mental illness' defence tarnishes all those good people struggling with their mental health as being cliff-edge teetering, time-bombs, capable of monstrous acts at the flip of a switch. Nothing could be further from the truth, in my experience.
Poor mother escaped one abusive relationship only to endure another and die from the person you were trying to protect 😢 I'm sure the ex-husband, Kevin is dancing on her grave. RIP Ashley 😞🥀
What the hell do you get out of commenting something like this? Also, there is no evidence that Heath ever abused Ashley? So why’d you say “Escaped one abusive relationship, only to endure another” unless you meant the way her daughter treated her.
@@Brandon-u9q I totally agree. Have you read this book?: "The Pill That Steals Lives - One Woman's Terrifying Journey to Discover the Truth About Antidepressants" by Katinka Blackford Newman?
Thanks so much for covering this one. Cleared up a lot of things i was curious about in this specific case. I also really appreciate the way you break everything down in each video. You're the best!
😂😂😂 thanks that’s funny. This video is not. Still hit like every time though. I know what I’m going to see but nobody done it as well as it will be done here
There is only a handful of good true crime channels on youtube at the moment and yours is one of them. I appreciate all the hard work you put into your videos. Have a nice day!
I live two miles from her house. I taught at that high school. There is an energy that affects a lot of the kids and a system set up for failure. Look at her before high school- like a totally different person. The psychiatric misdiagnosis and prescribing of drugs exacerbated her mental health issues and increased her ideation of callousness. I’ve watched prescription drugs combined with negative social media destroy or at least irreparably harm a generation and open the door to this sort of insanity.
"The evidence will show...." is common phrase in ALL opening statements in a trial like this. There was nothing unusual in what the said. Defending the accused is her job. What did you expect her to say?
@@theeclectic2919 you don’t need to say it 10 times and then another 10 sentences starting with “the evidence won’t show…….”. I listened to it several times and several of these statements made no sense whatsoever. There’s always someone that feels the need to point out the obvious. The other people are smart enough to understand what I meant.
I heard about this case. I lost my mom 23 years ago to cancer. I'd give anything, literally anything, to have her back. I simply cannot fathom how anyone could murder their own mother in ice cold blood
The way she looked in the kitchen with the gun behind her back and then did that to her mother tells me she knew exactly what she was doing. Pure evil.
I have a very unpopular opinion to share; I don’t expect anyone to agree but I do think it’s important. I’ve raised a child with a severe mental illness with psychotic features. That child is now thirty and thriving, with a masters degree and having served in the Peace Corps. There were many many times during their life where that future was not secure. Watching this story unfold was like watching an alternate reality in which my child could have been Carly. I was fortunate to have my child diagnosed very early and to have gotten excellent care particularly at the beginning, and very lucky in that my child was not at all interested in drugs or alcohol. It was not easy and there is no way to describe how difficult it was at times. I think it’s easy to dismiss a child like this as evil, and I understand the sentiment but I don’t think it’s that simple. If we as a society can’t recognize a child with a mental illness as having the potential to be rehabilitated, I’m not sure what the justice system is really for. Again, I respect that I’m in the vast minority on this, and I don’t want to dismiss the very valid feelings and opinions that differ from my own. I just wanted to give a glimpse into a world that most parents never see.
You may be in the minority, but you are correct. People are emotional creatures, and the majority is unable to put that aside in order to make progress - and some are fully aware of it and abuse the fact for their own selfish desires or agenda. You're absolutely correct though, and we all could do with a little more empathy and understanding for our fellow people. The human condition is something we are all suffering from.
People would rather demonize kids as 'evil' and move on with their day rather than facing up to the wider issues. It will happen again. Hopefully to someone elses family and not theirs.
And that’s great for you & your child. This girl doesn’t have a mental illness. She’s completely void of empathy & compassion. The vast majority of monsters are made through years of abuse & or neglect and then there are the rare few that are simply born that way for whatever reason! It’s not easy or comfortable labeling a kid as evil. I don’t know where you’d get that idea… This has been debated for some time and it’s not taken lightly on either side. It’s commonly referred to as the Bad Seed Theory. And there’s a split down the medical community about its validity. You’re either born with empathy & compassion or you’re not. It can’t be taught. Your parents can tell you why you should feel bad or guilty for hurting someone but they can’t make you feel it. Ted Bundy was an adorable little boy once too! And he more than likely committed his first murder at 12! How about Aaron Campbell from Scotland? He r@ped & murdered 6yo Alisha Mcphail! He was 15! Carson Peters-Berger, he was 14 when he r@ped & murdered his cousin 10yo Lily Peters! Josh Philips 14, who murdered his neighbor Maddy Clifton, 8yo! And that’s just a few examples…
I think no chance of parole is too harsh on a person who's brain is not even fully developed yet, she certainly needs to be in jail but should have the possibility for parole .
Her “crying” in court seems so fake and hollow. Hope she can get help in prison and stay there. It’s just cruel killing anyone for such silly reasons like them looking through your room; especially your mom.
I have worked within mental health for 20 yrs. I have worked with some really poorly people. From watching the video/reaction of her in the police car she wasn't comprehending the situation correctly. In my experience I could clearly see Carly was 'vacant'. This is SUCH a sad case
She clearly wasn`t all there. I`m still wondering why. Why did she feel that was her only option at the time. Was there something other than pot or sleeping pills she needed to hide. Maybe a sex tape on a burner phone. Who knows. We don`t get to ask her She may never tell.
Sobbing in the courtroom, like _she's_ the victim. I hate the proliferation of cultural victimhood that's increasingly infecting the minds of people these days.
One very disturbed young girl. In a way she is a victim of herself. She knows what she was going to do was wrong but couldn`t stop herself. That is something she will have to live with the rest of her life. Why she didn`t have more self control. I think she has excepted her guilt. Question is how will she be able to live with that for the rest of her life. Will she be able to forgive herself in time? Nobody knows,not even Carly. Why was there a loaded gun laying around the house when they knew she was having problems. Didn`t they think that maybe she was considering suicide knowing she had been hurting herself. People failed her. Her brain isn`t fully developed yet. Teenagers often lack self control,most of the time it doesn`t end in tragedy.
I swear, instances like this are akin to possession. Such evil has no rightful place in the world. Also holy crap, I want whatever that lawyer was smoking if she believes half of that spiel
You should cover the case of Brandon Scott Hole, who ended the lives of 8 people at his former workplace at the Indianapolis Airport FedEx plant in 2021. Hole had mental health problems and dealt with tragedy, and was also prescribed Lexapro.
Poor girl, I do feel for her, to have come into a world with an abusive Dad, to then was diagnosed with Bi-Polar, going through puberty and not understanding the rules fully by her parents. Teens are genuinely going through a transitional stage and hormones kicking in. Now put that in a teen child with a mental illness makes life for them even tougher. I don't condone what she did but I can empathise with how she must have felt during that time. I want to offer my condolences to all those effected by the loss of Carly's mother Ansley Gregg. Also may the child Carly get the help for her mental health and the support.
I think her mother was mentally ill as well. She was so paranoid that her ex-might come over and kill her that she kept a loaded gun beside her bed. That reeks of mental illness. Was she getting treatment? Probably not. It also sends a message to others that gun violence is justified. Imagine your own mother making preparations to kill your father. How would that affect you if you were just a teen?
idk, if you look at the earlier pictures of her compared to around the time of the crime she definitely had gone weird. to me it doesn't seem so much like manic depression as her being what's called 'prodromal' for schizophrenia, which is hard to catch and is often mistaken for depression, it's like a phase before someone becomes fully schizophrenic. perhaps, like she said in her diary, she really had just had her first psychotic break before this. but to me i think maybe that was more causing stress that triggered the crime, rather than her being actually confused at the time. but like the defence lawyer said, sometimes it's hard to tell, sometimes people can seem rational but reacting to weird thoughts and perceptions. another element of the prodrome of schizophrenia (and the full blown condition), is they can sort of stop fully understanding that other people are 'real' as they lose grips with reality in general, they often actually write stuff like she was writing about things being meaningless, because their brains aren't properly assigning meaning, then under full blown schizophrenia they have like spurts of meaning which makes like random things seem super important, that's what leads to the disordered thoughts and paranoia, in part. i would be interested in seeing what her school friends say, if she had bouts of disassociation where she was just starring off into space or had started talking about weird things that didn't make sense. just my thoughts tho, no expert.
This was total premeditated. She took the gun and was looking for her mother. They didn’t even have an argument. The cameras shootings show. She killed her mum and sat asking for friends to see her dead mum’s body… then called step father pretending it was her mum asking for when he was was going to be home “honey”. Bollocks. She premeditated the whole thing. I hope she will rot in prison.
Thanks for sharing this, she looks so innocent BUT her actions were callous & cruel. Theirs .nothing wrong with her she bragged to her friend , she new exactly what she was doing.. I'd have given my right arm to have a mother like hers, someone who cares , she didn't realize just how lucky she was. .
Now she has nothing and will be locked up for the rest of her life. She got what she wanted. Because these types of individuals won’t k*** themselves if they’re miserable but will blame outwardly and take it out on others. Just evil.
She was prescribed zoloft, that's not a painkiller it's an antidepressant. She said it wasn't working so they changed it to surprise another antidepressant lexapro. They only thing She is a victim of is the word NO.
I'll preface this by saying I am not suggesting in any way that the mother deserved or caused this, and I completely understand her need to have a weapon at close hand after her experiences with her former husband. However, having an unsecured firearm in a home is always a bad idea, let alone when one member of that household is a mentally unwell, self-harming teenager... if only because the risk of her taking her own life was so high.
My sentiment exactly. Many people failed her. Her stepdad is still under investigation. Tampering with evidence and maybe neglect charges. Who knows. They may decide to kill the whole family. Some of these prosecutors these days can get out of control.
That 911 call was so heartbreaking. I wonder if this little girl ever considered the permanency of her actions. You're not just losing someone who might ground you if they find your vape; you're losing the person who cooks your favorite meal, who decorates the Christmas tree with you every year, who makes sure you have clean sheets to sleep on at night. What a self centered act this was by an immature, narrow-sighted, small-minded child.
Bruh "The evidence will not show" her defending another client again "The evidence will show" shes only been a public defender hired for only 3 days smfh😮💨🙄😒🤦🏿♂️
Children taking drugs before, during and after school is nothing new. I smoked my first spliff in school time, my best friend was off his head on acid at almost all of his final GCSE examinations. I've heard of kids smoking Crystal meth on their way to school. Shits fucked up and I can't see anything improving soon.
I never would have made it to the 12th grade without weed. It was the only thing that helped with the panic attacks I got from being in school. Drugs aren't the problem, they're a symptom of a broken education system.
Hey kid! I’m about to download the last few vids, from both channels, to watch while I’m traveling on Wednesday! I hope this finds you well and happy ❤ (I listen to everyone else in the background, but I like to stop what I’m doing so I can actually watch your vids because you always find images and clips that no one has ever seen or heard before) I’m sending love your way, little brother. Please extend my best wishes 😊
DeeDee!!!! loads of love to you and yours, hope your dad is ok. I honestly sond sooooo much time looking for clips, news articles books etc to try and add something to my stories, seriously I think I spend too much time researching but hopefully it pays off. Hope everything is going well for you in the Silver State
@@aspentakoradi You can mention other things that are going on :) watch i'll show you how you used a logical fallacy there ; Another you could reply to your comment by accusing you of not caring enough about a person who died. "Who cares about some comment about poor dogs ...when a person has died ." im joking lol :) I was thinking ,why have a gun accessible to a child ? Especially a child with any extra problems however or whyever those problems came to be?
You know it's crazy, as a bipolar person (with other mental illnesses), I've never killed anyone. I'm so tired of people acting like being bipolar is a good excuse or a reason for people to commit awful crimes.
she wasnt just bipolar, not to mention it differs from person to person. Carly was strugglig 24/7 with multiple mental illnesses, and was literally insane
America needs help! Nowhere else are guns such a "normal" thing in a household. And here in this case, these parents should also shoulder the burden, by keeping a gun so nonchalant, open to a depressed child who has showed violent behavior. This is also the case of kids doing school shootings, they have open access to weapons. Even the american police are so trigger happy. I live in South Africa , where though it is said crime is high....BUT Most of the population, don't know how to use a gun, haven't held or seen a real one. And that is a absolutely great thing.
@@sunilphalakdhari3869"EVEN the American police are so trigger happy"?! The police are the most trigger happy members of the population. They applied for a job that gives them a gun and ALLOWS them to brutalize and kill people with total immunity. This is what highschool bullies do when they grow up.
@@sunilphalakdhari3869It isn't the guns, it's the people. A gun doesn't go around shooting by itself. I think we need to focus on the real problem, the people and the youth of this country
She has no idea how lucky she was to have a mom there trying to discipline her from right and wrong. I hope it haunts her for the rest of her life. She deserved life in prison even at her young age...just awful
Society: Hey, how old are you? Carley: Idk, somewhere between 10 and 72? Yeeeesh, what a horrendously unnecessary and selfish tragedy. Poor Ashley, I hope she rests peacefully and all of her loved ones feel a sense of justice! Carley is pure evil in a bad haircut. She is exactly where she belongs.
When you have lived with someone with a mental illness you loose sympathy. She knew what she was doing and then show cased her actions. I would not want her as my neighbour. She needs to be away from society. RIP Ashley my heart breaks for your partner real family and friends.
No you don't lose sympathy but in fact you have empathy. I know because my mother had it, my Dad had it, my siblings all had it, my children have it and I have it also. We all deal with it in our own ways, that's how we learn to live it. We are also LESS judgmental than the 'norm' society.
@@LyndaCoulson64 I lived with it too, with bashings and insults from a very young age. I didn’t need to hear but, he’s sick. So was I, sick from the abuse.
I agree he went to work that morning and by the evening had essentially lost everything and had a bullet in his shoulder as well, how you come to terms with that is anyone's guess
The stunning tragedy of the misunderstanding of mental health. A 14 year old killing their parent and acting this way is the LARGEST indicator of her mental instability than anything else. She is not evil, she is afflicted. Humans have lost there humanity and compassion. We have all become crazy and insane. To the point where we think this girl exibited sane behavior with a sane mind. Insanity.
I'm wondering about her friend who told Carly's mother about the pot smoking, but not that Carly had been saying for a while that she wanted to kill her.
When I was 15-16 … I joined a Singing Contest … just so… I can .. “win a BAG of grocery items” consisting of canned sardines… Canned milk .. 2 kls if sugar….. 2 kls. of rice… and 2 loaves of bread…I told my Mom … I will come home that day…with THAT bag of grocery items…My Mom got blind because of diabetes… … and since then… can’t work.. … Fast forward… I lost!!!!😂😂😂 I felt so sad and cried lots!!! I thought … I can surprise my Mom and “ see her smile again” … yeah… she actually laughed … because she told me” I know you won’t win….. but I “ listened “ .. over the radio and I heard you sing…. With a voice “ only a Mom can love lustening to!.. For me… You are the Winner!.. never mind the grocery items… You are MORE than a TON of grocery items for me”””…I love my Mom… I missed her a lot… May she rest in peace..
"She got her NIPPLE pierced at 13" also narrator " nothing about this teenage behavior was unusual" Huh? Uh... Yeah it was unusual to pierce your nipple at age 13! Yeah it IS. Wow.
The USA Supreme court voted that any young person under 18 cannot be sentenced to life...they also said 25 years was the most and will have chances for parole.
That's what I commented during her trial and I guess for whatever reason that's not exactly true. I also thought that minors weren't allowed to have their faces shown. Don't get me wrong, she deserves the lw/o sentence and have her face shown to everyone, but I remember when they overturned the whole not sentencing a minor to lw/o. I haven't had my morning caffeine yet so I apologize if this came out as word salad. Lol
The judge mentioned some supreme court cases but wasn`t able to make a ruling on them. It would have to be done at higher court. So there will be another trial about the sentencing phase of the trial. The trial will have nothing to do with guilt as when you plead insanity you are pleading guilty.
The Defence might have been aiming for the sweet innocent Catholic School Girl look. But she wound up looking like the chick from that horror movie “The Orphan”. It’s not unusual for a teenager to take permanent/drastic action to solve a temporary issue. But the extent of this particular action, is so damned tragic. The abundance of calculated thought, planning, strategic action & evasive manoeuvres taken by Carly on that day was overwhelming. She may not have been mentally “well” but she knew exactly what she was doing. What a waste
![The Horrific Crimes of Jemma Mitchell [True Crime Documentary]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Kyu4tULR_5w/mqdefault.jpg)
![The Horrific Crimes of Jemma Mitchell [True Crime Documentary]](/img/tr.png)
![The Horrific Crimes of Gavin Plumb [True Crime Documentary]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_luTEBS4D58/mqdefault.jpg)
I think her lawyer smoked her vape pens because the stupid shit she was blabbering made no sense,I'm glad everyone saw past the bs
oh it made sense, it's just not going to be believed by the jury. And they didn't believe a word of it.
I had to fast-forward her speech - it was making me feel ill. The "mental health" defence should be banned IMHO.
The defense atrorney is just doing the best job she can with what she has to work with. It's hard to listen to but you want everyone to have a compentent defense. If a person doesn't get a competent defense then they have a case for appeal. I'd bet that attorney tried like crazy to her to take the plea deal knowing this was an undefenseable act she would have to try to defend.
I do agree. "The evidence won't show bs.." blah blah won't show a strong argumentative case. She is in court and evidences needs to be shown and proven. Her argument is so weak emphasizing what is not there to show. Ohh well. Ohh well.
@@SuzyQ334I did the exact same thing I couldn't handle the shit she was trying to spin!!
The poor darling dogs, you could see how scared they were, their tails were straight down between their legs, that’s a massive sign of fear, to then watch their human dad to be shot too.
Dog’s are so intuitive and sensitive, I pray they are ok 😢
Same
The dogs just wanted to play, not witness murder. 😢
I know, the dog's reaction upsets me too :(
The poor Mother....
I thought the same thing. I love animals.
The way she went about texting her step dad from her moms phone after shooting her essentially urging him to come home shows she knew exactly what she was doing and also proves she had the intention to commit the act and was thinking ahead. Premeditated. Period.
And putting the security camera in the fridge. That screams premeditation.
I agree!
Obviously! She is an actual psychopath!!!
Yep 👍 @@ThePinsay
I will never understand why people think kids like this deserve a light sentence. 😳
I agree, if they can do an adult crime then they should do adult time! Personally I don't think the potential for rehabilitation should take precedence over the safety of the innocent people they could hurt.
Coz their brains aren't even formed yet.
I agree. And they should be identified as well and applications for suppression orders should be denied. Sadly here in Australia, even if a child (under 18) commits a very serious crime, their identity is kept secret, which is ridiculous. They commit adult crimes, they should be punished and treated like adult offenders. None of this bullshit, oh they’re still young and should be given a chance to be rehabilitated and guided in the right direction. No, they’re old enough to know what they did was wrong, yet still choose to commit crimes, so they should do the time and be named and shamed.
Well that didn’t happen thank goodness 🤷♀️, I imagines she wished she’d taken the plea deal now
@@nevadatan7323
That very well may be true. However you’re either born with empathy & compassion or you’re not! It can’t be taught. Your parents can tell you or teach you why you should feel bad for something you’ve done but they can’t teach you or show you how to actually be that!
The stepdad's 911 call was so heartbreaking. You can really tell how utterly devastated he is. And as another comment said, Carly crying over hearing that call kinda irked me for some reason. But more like "Oh no, who knew killing your mother would have permanent consequences?" Either way, RIP Ashley.
Yes I was annoyed at how hard she was crying
He even calls her "daughter" during the call, not step-daughter. I can't believe that Tiktok's discourse is that he was involved somehow or he was sexually abusing her and that triggered Carly to kill her mom. Do they really believe that her lawyers wouldn't have brought that up if that was the case? Or that the police didn't check Carly's phone? She would have told someone or said it somewhere if that was the case, especially if she was so over the edge that she was willing to kill her mom, IMO.
I thought it was kind of nice seeing her respond to the consequences of her actions on other people. Ideally, they would make her listen to it every night before bed so she could cry herself to sleep. Even if we assume the worse, people still grow emotionally. Especially young people. It's been a year and a half since she did it and she is in her formative years. It is inevitable that she would mature emotionally during that year and a half. But yaknow, it's a comment section, so we're just supposed to shame her and pat ourselves on the back for being better than her. 🙄
@@paucalderon8326 Yeah. It seems like he genuinely cares for her. I just wanna give the poor man a hug.
It was so cringe. At one point I seriously couldn’t tell if she was trying to hide a snicker that turned into a phony sob.
Nothing says premeditated like putting the security camera in the REFRIGERATOR
I did a double take, personally i believe in her rage she didn’t initially remember the cameras, and as a half-effort she threw it in the fridge. It shows cognitive effort to hide her crimes, lazily
It may be a way to destroy the camera and it's content. Which is not knowing how a camera works.
It shows that she understood what she did was wrong. But removing the camera *after* the fact kind of does the opposite of proving premeditation. Lol.
...and, nothing says DUMB like doing it AFTER the fact!
The fact that she thought nothing of texting her friend to come see her mums body tells me that this something she was not afraid of the friend telling on her about. I wonder what sick conversations they would have like it was normal?
Seriously cuz she knew her stepfather was coming home, and she didn't even try to warn him or nothing?? It's not like she thought she was bluffing. She showed her her her mom's body like it was a science experiment smh
The amount of people accusing Heath of having involvement with Carly is so appalling. Carly did this all by herself
Exactly
I know, some really fucked up weird conspiracy theories out there, really appaling, he loses his wife and his step daughter tries to kill him and then he has to listen to that shit, some messed up people out there
Yes ppl are sick perverts. They're obsessed with molestation to a sick degree. Even if it has nothing to do with anything, that's the first thing that comes to their minds. I hope that poor man finds healing 💔😢
Why is no one talking about the mother? She seemed to be mentally ill as well. Ashley was so paranoid that her ex-might come over and kill her that she kept a loaded gun beside her bed. That reeks of mental illness. Was she getting treatment? Probably not. It also sends a message to others that gun violence is justified. Imagine your own mother making preparations to kill your father. How would that affect you if you were just a teen?
@theeclectic2919 You make it sound like Ashley was planning a murder... Plenty of women are terrified of their exes. I don't necessarily think she was paranoid in a pathological way. She was scared of him and kept a gun for self-defense. The only thing she did wrong was keeping it in the manner she did. Zero gun safety.
This case is so disturbing. She looks like a little psychopath.
she is a little psychopath
No she doesn't? She literally looks like any teenager, absolutely ordinary in every regard. There is nothing about her that makes her "look" like a psychopath.
@@Tebbylousi think the OP was commenting more on her behavior in the courtroom. No remorse at all.
@@kcm4511 she wept like a baby when they played the recording of the 911 call.
@@Tebbylous
It’s in the eyes! They all have it. Like a sharks eyes seeking to devour prey!
Couldn't "Bianca" have warned Heath before he walked into the ambush? I hope they checking out her mental health as well.
Likely fear: Gregg had just shot her own mother several times in cold blood over basic parental boundaries. Who's to say she wouldn't murder a close friend over something more incriminating, as a witness to her crimes.
My thoughts exactly. She was right there when he pulled up.
I did wonder this too. Seems odd.
@@PBI45 She *didn't* run away in fear. She hid behind a bush and ran away *with* Carly.
Not only check her mental health but she should’ve been charged with accessory or something for not warning Heath, for not calling the police to report Carli killing Ashely and for hanging out with Carli and waiting with her for Heath to come home and watched him get shot. She needs to be held responsible for her inactions as well.
I’m so sick and tired of defence teams using mental illness ALWAYS in smurder cases.
This had nothing to do with mental illness, she is pure ev!l and knew EXACTLY what she was doing!!
But they just said no one knew she had a mental health disorder. I have chronic depressive disorders. I've never killed anyone. Tried to kill myself, but know one else.
@@Iwishiwasanyoneelse I have had depression beginning at age 7. I've never committed murder either. But it effects people differently. I don't understand why they don't hospitalize them before they get to this point.
I, and I’m sure many others, have a mental illness (I have Bipolar) but have also NEVER had a violent tendency. Nihilism is something some people are unfortunately born with
I agree, though hearing voices is filed under schizophrenia. However, she wasn't experiencing any evident psychosis around the time of the murder. Besides all the signs still point to premeditated.
Her defence lawyer was talking complete rubbish
I am unreasonably infuriated watching her cry during the 911 call in court. Like GIRL 🤬 you took out your own mama...over some friggin vapes smfh
To be fair, the mother shouldn't have freaked out over it. It's just Mary Jane, should be legalized.
@Brandon-u9q not for 14 year olds
@@Brandon-u9q has an impact over long term use and just because her mom freaked out doesn't warrant her daughter's action to murder her. Guess we have to tip toe around our teenagers...😑
Fake crying...
She can have all the weed and drugs in prison
My mum had a stroke last week. I don't say this to garner sympathy, - My mum is doing really well (at the moment). But there was a few days where I had to face the sobering reality that Mum might be gone, and I would never have her support or understanding ever again. To see her gradually re-emerge from pain, fear and confusion has been one of the most uplifting and hopeful things I will ever experience, but makes this case all the more confusing to me. One day I will lose the woman who is possibly the only person who truly understands me, a woman who will stand by me and advocate for me, no matter how much I may mess up. Our past hasn't been smooth sailing, there have been times I have been so angry with her I haven't been able to contain it. But I would never do anything to hurt her. I cannot understand this girl. I wish I could talk to her to try.😔
I hope your mum gets well soon, lots of love ok, I lost my mum young and she is your best friend, God Bless you and your family ♥
@@moniquetheobald889I'm really sorry to hear that. It's hard to imagine what that must be like, even having this insight.😔 Thank you for the good wishes.xx
Big love keep strong and your family and friends close ❤
I am so glad your mum is doing better. I could never imagine, purposely, hurting my mom. She is my best friend! ❤😭 this child , is an absolute psychopath, she does not deserve freedom.
Much love and get well wishes to your dear Mum. I lost my Mum in 2020 and it hurts still that I can't ask her advice or have a fun day with her among many other things. You are right, our Mums are our support and strength. I would give anything for another chat with mine. This girl is beyond help. I wish your Mum a speedy recovery ♥️ xxxxxx
Defence " Had no intention of hurting anyone that day"
So that's why she went and got the gun?
Defence "Her step dad looked for an intruder not recognising his daughter would do that"
First thing he said on 911 call "My daughter shot me"
🤷🤷🤷
Then he repeated my stepdaughter shot her mum /my wife !
I have mental health issues, was sexually abused as a child, I have autism. I would NEVER hurt a fly.
It's only about if someone has evil inside of them, and then they go and collect excuses like mental health/alcohol/drugs etc. to justify their behaviour. I've only seen one case so far where I could honestly say this person had no chance to even develop normally hence he is 100% the product of his surroundings and upbringing.
But in this case here she didn't grow up being tortured and abused from birth.
Someone known in the media?? If so, who?? Tia.
I am so sorry for what happened to you as a child, I hope and pray you have now managed to find happiness in life ❤
@drips1030 I had to look for the case because I had forgotten the name, but it's Nikko Jenkins. In my opinion he was doomed from birth on.
I am sorry for your mental health, and being sexually abused. I congratulate you on your perseverance in life. I was physically abused as a child (My dad would whip me so hard with a belt that my little buttocks and sometimes my stomach would bleed...Mom would later start stepping in to protect me...I grew up in a religious household and I am grateful, and I agree with spanking but not whipping a child so hard while he was angry...I had very bad ADHD and us being poor farmers my Daddy didn't understand the disorder...He DID LOVE me, but he never whipped my sister and my little brother was rarely whipped and that was usually by Mom who would do it so Daddy wouldn't) so my Dad inadvertently gave me High anxiety or PTSD from the beatings and the hard farm work that I ONLY had to do...like making me climb up into Tobacco Barns at around12 or 13, these barns housed tobacco and you had to stand and balance yourself between to beams, only 2 to 3 or 4 inches wide. I then would have to take my hands of the rails/beams and pull up tobacco on sticks and lay them across where my feet were and the beams near my head. These railings could go as high as approximately 17 feet high. I got good at it quickly. I would later start having trouble in school and would pass out...the funny thing was it could be positive energy like when I got my first kiss, and the little girl (I was in 5th grade and she was in 4th grade) stuck her tongue in my mouth (LOLOL yes my friends still won't let this go)...I dropped like a sack of taters. Other times I would be Bullied or get in trouble due to my ADHD (remember I wasn't on medicine) and I would pass out. Like you, I persevered and but abused alcohol in college (I used it to be able to ask girls out in college). I was pulled out of college by my dad, and I joined the Army/ARNG. I graduated all my classes in medical school and became a Combat Medic (God really helped me during Boot Camp...I never had a panic attack/passed out. I then went back to EKU University in KY and graduated as a Rec Therapist under a BS in Health and Sciences and later earned titles of Mental and Behavorial Specialist. I worked with initially SVP's Sexually Violent Predators for the state of California (I performed stand-up and was in 2 movies ...I'll leave this part out...I hate texting and typing, but I have written a short story comedy, and it was put into a screen play format, and I wrote and illustrated a children's book) at the Infamous Atascadero Maximum State Mental Hospital. Later on, I worked in Anchorage, AK. at North Star Childrens Behavior problem Center (they lived here). Now I am a broken physically from back disorders, injuries, fighting for real and some MMA, over 12 surgeries with 9 being attributed to my spine. I can't work at the present time even though they pay here $80K. I still love video games and a more than a couple years back finally proved that I had severe anxiety disorder (not hypoglycemia like they told me as a kid) and that I have one of the worst cases of ADHD that my Doc said he's seen in 30 years. So, I take a few pills and several natural/supplement medications. Also, several years ago I became a Christian and before that I was just blind, awful Temper, and drank too much. I am now trying to get my pain taken a way or reduced...don't look good for me going back to my previous lifestyle and helping others while getting paid well (lifestyle without the Temper and Alcohol). So here I am and not ashamed. Do you have a personal relationship with Jesus? Anyway, feel free to reply or not. Sorry typing so much and God Bless. Ajax
The defence lawyer is soooo annoying…..” the evidence will show” 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
Right?! How infuriating. Just lying through her teeth.
The evidence will NOT show.....
Omg Jesus, we get it! She had to have said both phrases 100 fucking times, good Christ.
@@blackknight1360i mean, that’s literally her job lol
All attorneys say this during their opening statements. "The evidence will show....." is a common phrase. Have you never been in a courtroom?
She's a monster in the making..
Glad She's in prison now
I'm autistic (functioning), have ADHD and major depressive disorder. The thought of merely forcing my will upon another person, let alone maiming or murdering them, is entirely anathema to every fibre of my being.
The 'mental illness' defence tarnishes all those good people struggling with their mental health as being cliff-edge teetering, time-bombs, capable of monstrous acts at the flip of a switch.
Nothing could be further from the truth, in my experience.
Poor mother escaped one abusive relationship only to endure another and die from the person you were trying to protect 😢 I'm sure the ex-husband, Kevin is dancing on her grave. RIP Ashley 😞🥀
Because he abused that woman means he’s going to be happy that his daughter killed her?
Stupid claim
What the hell do you get out of commenting something like this? Also, there is no evidence that Heath ever abused Ashley? So why’d you say “Escaped one abusive relationship, only to endure another” unless you meant the way her daughter treated her.
So weird to see a video of my neighbors. RIP - you were wonderful dear friend
that's evil, right there. in the form of a child. evil.
I think it was the prescription pills she was taking.
@@Brandon-u9qgive me a break
@@Brandon-u9q I totally agree.
Have you read this book?: "The Pill That Steals Lives - One Woman's Terrifying Journey to Discover the Truth About Antidepressants" by Katinka Blackford Newman?
mental heath card played every time just the same in the UK. These individuals know what they are doing 100% and should not be given any exceptions.
And if they dont thats all the more reason to lock them up, not a slap on the risk or a get out of jail free card,😢
Unfortunately in horrific cold-blooded crimes like these, the mental health card is all the defence have.
Thanks so much for covering this one. Cleared up a lot of things i was curious about in this specific case. I also really appreciate the way you break everything down in each video. You're the best!
This was both premeditated and preventable. Justice was served. What a waste of two lives.
Carly should be convicted on that haircut alone. Geez
No! The person who cut her hair like that needs to be arraigned on charges.
😂😂😂 thanks that’s funny. This video is not. Still hit like every time though. I know what I’m going to see but nobody done it as well as it will be done here
Beautiful head of hair though, and she's still just a child.
Not weird at all to say about a 14 year old girl @@jamesb.9155
I think her attorney had her get a kid's haircut and dressed her like a child to make her look innocent.
I don’t buy the mental health excuses for this case one bit. She need to face her consequences.
@@cherchuhaikieu4328 only God knows what went on in her mind as the Bible say judge not and you will not be judged
She’s evil.
Sometimes you can just tell. Maybe it’s her hair that gives away her evil lol. Nobody cuts their hair like that on purpose
Her transformation certainly did seem to reflect a “possession”.
@@Gilbert_Dice_GottfriedYou should know aye.
Agreed.
Hopefully she will never be able to get out of prison.
No she's good.
There is only a handful of good true crime channels on youtube at the moment and yours is one of them. I appreciate all the hard work you put into your videos. Have a nice day!
I totally agree with the summisation. Feel sorry for the step father and hopefully he can rebuild his life.
Me too, how he comes to terms with all of this is beyond me
Something was going on between stepfather and psycho kid
I live two miles from her house. I taught at that high school. There is an energy that affects a lot of the kids and a system set up for failure. Look at her before high school- like a totally different person. The psychiatric misdiagnosis and prescribing of drugs exacerbated her mental health issues and increased her ideation of callousness. I’ve watched prescription drugs combined with negative social media destroy or at least irreparably harm a generation and open the door to this sort of insanity.
I have followed this. It’s horrific and so unbelievable.
I can’t stand listening to that defence lawyer. “The evidence will show blah blah blah
I barely made it through all of that
Even she didn’t believe what she was saying.
@@AuntieL_ATL I couldn’t be a defence lawyer, I can’t lie convincingly 🤭🫣😓🤥
"The evidence will show...." is common phrase in ALL opening statements in a trial like this. There was nothing unusual in what the said. Defending the accused is her job. What did you expect her to say?
@@theeclectic2919 you don’t need to say it 10 times and then another 10 sentences starting with “the evidence won’t show…….”. I listened to it several times and several of these statements made no sense whatsoever. There’s always someone that feels the need to point out the obvious. The other people are smart enough to understand what I meant.
If I were her lawyer referring to how much Ashley loved Carly, I would stay away from the word "revolve" for sure.
I heard about this case. I lost my mom 23 years ago to cancer. I'd give anything, literally anything, to have her back. I simply cannot fathom how anyone could murder their own mother in ice cold blood
Why didn't Bianca warn Carlys stepfather when he pulled up what she did and planned to do to him?
Obviously just a another little shit
Just guessing: She was afraid Carly would shoot her if she did that. Remember, she had the gun.
@@fc7307 I thought the same thing, but she went outside, away from her, they could have called 911, at the very least.
“Bianca” sure does look like a boy in the video.
@@caliblue2so do you
The way she looked in the kitchen with the gun behind her back and then did that to her mother tells me she knew exactly what she was doing. Pure evil.
Precisely
I have a very unpopular opinion to share; I don’t expect anyone to agree but I do think it’s important.
I’ve raised a child with a severe mental illness with psychotic features. That child is now thirty and thriving, with a masters degree and having served in the Peace Corps. There were many many times during their life where that future was not secure. Watching this story unfold was like watching an alternate reality in which my child could have been Carly. I was fortunate to have my child diagnosed very early and to have gotten excellent care particularly at the beginning, and very lucky in that my child was not at all interested in drugs or alcohol. It was not easy and there is no way to describe how difficult it was at times. I think it’s easy to dismiss a child like this as evil, and I understand the sentiment but I don’t think it’s that simple. If we as a society can’t recognize a child with a mental illness as having the potential to be rehabilitated, I’m not sure what the justice system is really for. Again, I respect that I’m in the vast minority on this, and I don’t want to dismiss the very valid feelings and opinions that differ from my own. I just wanted to give a glimpse into a world that most parents never see.
You may be in the minority, but you are correct.
People are emotional creatures, and the majority is unable to put that aside in order to make progress - and some are fully aware of it and abuse the fact for their own selfish desires or agenda.
You're absolutely correct though, and we all could do with a little more empathy and understanding for our fellow people.
The human condition is something we are all suffering from.
People would rather demonize kids as 'evil' and move on with their day rather than facing up to the wider issues.
It will happen again. Hopefully to someone elses family and not theirs.
It definitely didn’t help that the mom had a fucking gun in a drawer all non chalant
And that’s great for you & your child. This girl doesn’t have a mental illness. She’s completely void of empathy & compassion. The vast majority of monsters are made through years of abuse & or neglect and then there are the rare few that are simply born that way for whatever reason!
It’s not easy or comfortable labeling a kid as evil. I don’t know where you’d get that idea… This has been debated for some time and it’s not taken lightly on either side. It’s commonly referred to as the Bad Seed Theory. And there’s a split down the medical community about its validity.
You’re either born with empathy & compassion or you’re not. It can’t be taught.
Your parents can tell you why you should feel bad or guilty for hurting someone but they can’t make you feel it.
Ted Bundy was an adorable little boy once too! And he more than likely committed his first murder at 12! How about Aaron Campbell from Scotland? He r@ped & murdered 6yo Alisha Mcphail! He was 15!
Carson Peters-Berger, he was 14 when he r@ped & murdered his cousin 10yo Lily Peters! Josh Philips 14, who murdered his neighbor Maddy Clifton, 8yo!
And that’s just a few examples…
I think no chance of parole is too harsh on a person who's brain is not even fully developed yet, she certainly needs to be in jail but should have the possibility for parole .
My heart goes out to the family. If there are any signs of a child with mental health issues remove all weapons from the home ….
That's another thing. If you own a weapon, it needs to be hidden and locked up! The parents negligence caused this.
Her “crying” in court seems so fake and hollow. Hope she can get help in prison and stay there. It’s just cruel killing anyone for such silly reasons like them looking through your room; especially your mom.
Her stepdads 911 call brought me to tears. My god this poor man. 😢
Her lawyer is absolutely DELUSIONAL.
i mean her lawyer KNOWS she’s guilty regardless of that it’s her job to get her the lightest sentence possible
@@black_pig_ironfuck lawyers who defend POS don’t care if it’s their job
This is a devastating case . How would she do this to her family like this
This is so evil
Think about it my friend
Thanks for the video. Cant imagine the toll these take on you, thanks as always EAU
I have worked within mental health for 20 yrs. I have worked with some really poorly people. From watching the video/reaction of her in the police car she wasn't comprehending the situation correctly. In my experience I could clearly see Carly was 'vacant'.
This is SUCH a sad case
She clearly wasn`t all there. I`m still wondering why. Why did she feel that was her only option at the time. Was there something other than pot or sleeping pills she needed to hide. Maybe a sex tape on a burner phone. Who knows. We don`t get to ask her She may never tell.
Hope you had a well-deserved break. Take care and thanks for the videos 💙
Just have to add, these 911 operators are always so shit, terrible to victims was making me angry
@@nzx9796i keep thinking the exact same. considering they are the first point of contact, you would expect a lot better
I agree I head the kid rock 911 call they just released when his friend crashed a Polaris car in tue woods bad!! The dispatch was super rude!!
Thank you so much for this
Oooo been looking forward to someone covering this! 🙏
Sobbing in the courtroom, like _she's_ the victim. I hate the proliferation of cultural victimhood that's increasingly infecting the minds of people these days.
One very disturbed young girl. In a way she is a victim of herself. She knows what she was going to do was wrong but couldn`t stop herself. That is something she will have to live with the rest of her life. Why she didn`t have more self control. I think she has excepted her guilt. Question is how will she be able to live with that for the rest of her life. Will she be able to forgive herself in time? Nobody knows,not even Carly. Why was there a loaded gun laying around the house when they knew she was having problems. Didn`t they think that maybe she was considering suicide knowing she had been hurting herself. People failed her. Her brain isn`t fully developed yet. Teenagers often lack self control,most of the time it doesn`t end in tragedy.
“The evidence will not show” 😬
I swear, instances like this are akin to possession. Such evil has no rightful place in the world. Also holy crap, I want whatever that lawyer was smoking if she believes half of that spiel
You should cover the case of Brandon Scott Hole, who ended the lives of 8 people at his former workplace at the Indianapolis Airport FedEx plant in 2021. Hole had mental health problems and dealt with tragedy, and was also prescribed Lexapro.
There does seem to be a lot of cases with this drug. This isn`t the first time.
Poor girl, I do feel for her, to have come into a world with an abusive Dad, to then was diagnosed with Bi-Polar, going through puberty and not understanding the rules fully by her parents. Teens are genuinely going through a transitional stage and hormones kicking in. Now put that in a teen child with a mental illness makes life for them even tougher. I don't condone what she did but I can empathise with how she must have felt during that time. I want to offer my condolences to all those effected by the loss of Carly's mother Ansley Gregg. Also may the child Carly get the help for her mental health and the support.
Uhmmmm male school shooters and young gang members have issues too
I think her mother was mentally ill as well. She was so paranoid that her ex-might come over and kill her that she kept a loaded gun beside her bed. That reeks of mental illness. Was she getting treatment? Probably not. It also sends a message to others that gun violence is justified. Imagine your own mother making preparations to kill your father. How would that affect you if you were just a teen?
idk, if you look at the earlier pictures of her compared to around the time of the crime she definitely had gone weird. to me it doesn't seem so much like manic depression as her being what's called 'prodromal' for schizophrenia, which is hard to catch and is often mistaken for depression, it's like a phase before someone becomes fully schizophrenic. perhaps, like she said in her diary, she really had just had her first psychotic break before this. but to me i think maybe that was more causing stress that triggered the crime, rather than her being actually confused at the time. but like the defence lawyer said, sometimes it's hard to tell, sometimes people can seem rational but reacting to weird thoughts and perceptions.
another element of the prodrome of schizophrenia (and the full blown condition), is they can sort of stop fully understanding that other people are 'real' as they lose grips with reality in general, they often actually write stuff like she was writing about things being meaningless, because their brains aren't properly assigning meaning, then under full blown schizophrenia they have like spurts of meaning which makes like random things seem super important, that's what leads to the disordered thoughts and paranoia, in part. i would be interested in seeing what her school friends say, if she had bouts of disassociation where she was just starring off into space or had started talking about weird things that didn't make sense.
just my thoughts tho, no expert.
My thoughts are that sounds like bullshit.
The anguish in her stepfather's voice is heart wrenching. His world is shattered.
This was total premeditated.
She took the gun and was looking for her mother.
They didn’t even have an argument.
The cameras shootings show.
She killed her mum and sat asking for friends to see her dead mum’s body… then called step father pretending it was her mum asking for when he was was going to be home “honey”.
Bollocks.
She premeditated the whole thing.
I hope she will rot in prison.
Agree 1000000%
Thanks for sharing this, she looks so innocent BUT her actions were callous & cruel. Theirs .nothing wrong with her she bragged to her friend , she new exactly what she was doing.. I'd have given my right arm to have a mother like hers, someone who cares , she didn't realize just how lucky she was. .
Now she has nothing and will be locked up for the rest of her life. She got what she wanted. Because these types of individuals won’t k*** themselves if they’re miserable but will blame outwardly and take it out on others. Just evil.
She was prescribed zoloft, that's not a painkiller it's an antidepressant. She said it wasn't working so they changed it to surprise another antidepressant lexapro. They only thing She is a victim of is the word NO.
Seeing the happy dogs jump around her right before she went on the killing spree was heart breaking.
The one dog legit barked at her and bucked, as if it KNEW🫢
I'll preface this by saying I am not suggesting in any way that the mother deserved or caused this, and I completely understand her need to have a weapon at close hand after her experiences with her former husband. However, having an unsecured firearm in a home is always a bad idea, let alone when one member of that household is a mentally unwell, self-harming teenager... if only because the risk of her taking her own life was so high.
My sentiment exactly. Many people failed her. Her stepdad is still under investigation. Tampering with evidence and maybe neglect charges. Who knows. They may decide to kill the whole family. Some of these prosecutors these days can get out of control.
You know times are good when EAU uploads, considering the unfortunate circumstances.
That 911 call was so heartbreaking. I wonder if this little girl ever considered the permanency of her actions. You're not just losing someone who might ground you if they find your vape; you're losing the person who cooks your favorite meal, who decorates the Christmas tree with you every year, who makes sure you have clean sheets to sleep on at night. What a self centered act this was by an immature, narrow-sighted, small-minded child.
Bruh "The evidence will not show" her defending another client again "The evidence will show" shes only been a public defender hired for only 3 days smfh😮💨🙄😒🤦🏿♂️
Children taking drugs before, during and after school is nothing new. I smoked my first spliff in school time, my best friend was off his head on acid at almost all of his final GCSE examinations. I've heard of kids smoking Crystal meth on their way to school. Shits fucked up and I can't see anything improving soon.
I never would have made it to the 12th grade without weed. It was the only thing that helped with the panic attacks I got from being in school. Drugs aren't the problem, they're a symptom of a broken education system.
It'll get worse before it gets better. If it even will
My heart goes out for her stepfather. I was practically in tears hearing the extended version of the 911 call you shared. I am so sorry for his loss.
Those poor dogs having to witness and listen to their owners murder.
Hey kid! I’m about to download the last few vids, from both channels, to watch while I’m traveling on Wednesday! I hope this finds you well and happy ❤ (I listen to everyone else in the background, but I like to stop what I’m doing so I can actually watch your vids because you always find images and clips that no one has ever seen or heard before) I’m sending love your way, little brother. Please extend my best wishes 😊
DeeDee!!!! loads of love to you and yours, hope your dad is ok. I honestly sond sooooo much time looking for clips, news articles books etc to try and add something to my stories, seriously I think I spend too much time researching but hopefully it pays off. Hope everything is going well for you in the Silver State
Poor dogs
who cares about some dog care about the person who lost their life
@@aspentakoradi You can mention other things that are going on :)
watch i'll show you how you used a logical fallacy there ;
Another you could reply to your comment by accusing you of not caring enough about a person who died.
"Who cares about some comment about poor dogs ...when a person has died ." im joking lol :)
I was thinking ,why have a gun accessible to a child ? Especially a child with any extra problems however or whyever those problems came to be?
@@aspentakoradi Crawl back into your gutter.
Nah, they were not hurt.
@@aspentakoradi You're just oozing with empathy.
I’ve seen this case covered a lot recently but I hadn’t seen footage of her crying hearing the 911 call. Guns need to be kept away from children!
You know it's crazy, as a bipolar person (with other mental illnesses), I've never killed anyone. I'm so tired of people acting like being bipolar is a good excuse or a reason for people to commit awful crimes.
she wasnt just bipolar, not to mention it differs from person to person.
Carly was strugglig 24/7 with multiple mental illnesses, and was literally insane
American teens need help
America needs help!
Nowhere else are guns such a "normal" thing in a household.
And here in this case, these parents should also shoulder the burden, by keeping a gun so nonchalant, open to a depressed child who has showed violent behavior.
This is also the case of kids doing school shootings, they have open access to weapons.
Even the american police are so trigger happy.
I live in South Africa , where though it is said crime is high....BUT
Most of the population, don't know how to use a gun, haven't held or seen a real one.
And that is a absolutely great thing.
@@sunilphalakdhari3869"EVEN the American police are so trigger happy"?!
The police are the most trigger happy members of the population. They applied for a job that gives them a gun and ALLOWS them to brutalize and kill people with total immunity. This is what highschool bullies do when they grow up.
They should stay away from drugs
@@sunilphalakdhari3869It isn't the guns, it's the people. A gun doesn't go around shooting by itself. I think we need to focus on the real problem, the people and the youth of this country
@industrialover💯💯
I swear I hear her mother say help me and then thr daughter starts humming
Um
@@industrialover um
Im so happy you are doing longer content! I remember you from the beginning of your channel. Great video
Thank you, ooh were you here from the very beginning, channel is going well isn't it? you going to stick around until we get to 100k subs and beyond?
I hated my mother, she treated me very cruel but I wouldn't ever have done something like this.
Good grief!! The defense attorney is struggling with her opening statement because she knows it’s a load of nonsense. She was annoying!!
Thank you for the new vid EAU :)
She has no idea how lucky she was to have a mom there trying to discipline her from right and wrong. I hope it haunts her for the rest of her life. She deserved life in prison even at her young age...just awful
Thanks for the video EAU.
My pleasure 😀
Society: Hey, how old are you?
Carley: Idk, somewhere between 10 and 72?
Yeeeesh, what a horrendously unnecessary and selfish tragedy. Poor Ashley, I hope she rests peacefully and all of her loved ones feel a sense of justice! Carley is pure evil in a bad haircut. She is exactly where she belongs.
Like I always say, you deserve more subs!
RIGHT?! I love this channel
Great video, thanks!!! ❤
33:49 lmfao what is the defence on about 😂😂😂
Seriously! Like ma'am I know you have a job to do but this is just pathetic
Standard issue defense lawyer. Who cares about justice, gotta win! Time to waffle about nonsense
When you have lived with someone with a mental illness you loose sympathy. She knew what she was doing and then show cased her actions. I would not want her as my neighbour. She needs to be away from society. RIP Ashley my heart breaks for your partner real family and friends.
No you don't lose sympathy but in fact you have empathy. I know because my mother had it, my Dad had it, my siblings all had it, my children have it and I have it also. We all deal with it in our own ways, that's how we learn to live it. We are also LESS judgmental than the 'norm' society.
@@LyndaCoulson64 I lived with it too, with bashings and insults from a very young age. I didn’t need to hear but, he’s sick. So was I, sick from the abuse.
Giving a 13 year old brain Zoloft and Lexapro can damage it permanently.
I can't Imagine marrying a loving woman and then almost got unalived by her daughter. Lost his wife daughter and almost his life
I agree he went to work that morning and by the evening had essentially lost everything and had a bullet in his shoulder as well, how you come to terms with that is anyone's guess
Rest In Peace Ashley, my sincere condolences Heath 😓
Amen
why not talk about the step dad’s bizarre mannerisms and actions during the trial? it’s going viral, idk why it wasn’t included
Maybe because it's irrelevant, he didn't murder anyone!
Where is her tears this girl is not good soul never let her again
Keep these videos coming pal 👍
Will do brother
"Cool shirt"
"Thanks hun..Penneys"
The stunning tragedy of the misunderstanding of mental health. A 14 year old killing their parent and acting this way is the LARGEST indicator of her mental instability than anything else. She is not evil, she is afflicted.
Humans have lost there humanity and compassion. We have all become crazy and insane. To the point where we think this girl exibited sane behavior with a sane mind. Insanity.
That poor stepdad… you can hear the heartbreak in his voice
So sad. A family destroyed .
I'm wondering about her friend who told Carly's mother about the pot smoking, but not that Carly had been saying for a while that she wanted to kill her.
My cousin has lived with bipolar for 37 years and has never hurt anyone. Lame excuse
She`s not bipolar. She was hearing voices at one time.
When I was 15-16 … I joined a Singing Contest … just so… I can
.. “win a BAG of grocery items”
consisting of canned sardines…
Canned milk .. 2 kls if sugar…..
2 kls. of rice… and 2 loaves of
bread…I told my Mom … I will
come home that day…with THAT
bag of grocery items…My Mom
got blind because of diabetes…
… and since then… can’t work..
… Fast forward… I lost!!!!😂😂😂
I felt so sad and cried lots!!!
I thought … I can surprise my Mom and “ see her smile again”
… yeah… she actually laughed
… because she told me” I know
you won’t win….. but I “ listened “
.. over the radio and I heard you
sing…. With a voice “ only a Mom
can love lustening to!.. For me…
You are the Winner!.. never mind the grocery items… You are MORE than a TON of grocery items for me”””…I love my Mom… I missed her a lot… May she rest in peace..
Bet she wishes she’d taken the plea deal! Terrible advice from the lawyers
"She got her NIPPLE pierced at 13" also narrator " nothing about this teenage behavior was unusual"
Huh? Uh... Yeah it was unusual to pierce your nipple at age 13! Yeah it IS. Wow.
i just wanna know what piercer needs to be in jail rn for piercing a childs nipple tbh
I think by “normal” he meant that it wasnt something that would make you think shed murder both her parents
That is what I meant Erica 😊
The evidence will show that defense lawyer is terrible at her job. The evidence will show that defense lawyer is really hard to listen to.
I completely agree with you, it is essentialy trying to equate mental illness with being violent/dangerous or evil same with autism/ADHD etc etc
The USA Supreme court voted that any young person under 18 cannot be sentenced to life...they also said 25 years was the most and will have chances for parole.
That's what I commented during her trial and I guess for whatever reason that's not exactly true. I also thought that minors weren't allowed to have their faces shown. Don't get me wrong, she deserves the lw/o sentence and have her face shown to everyone, but I remember when they overturned the whole not sentencing a minor to lw/o. I haven't had my morning caffeine yet so I apologize if this came out as word salad. Lol
The judge mentioned some supreme court cases but wasn`t able to make a ruling on them. It would have to be done at higher court. So there will be another trial about the sentencing phase of the trial. The trial will have nothing to do with guilt as when you plead insanity you are pleading guilty.
The Defence might have been aiming for the sweet innocent Catholic School Girl look. But she wound up looking like the chick from that horror movie “The Orphan”.
It’s not unusual for a teenager to take permanent/drastic action to solve a temporary issue. But the extent of this particular action, is so damned tragic.
The abundance of calculated thought, planning, strategic action & evasive manoeuvres taken by Carly on that day was overwhelming. She may not have been mentally “well” but she knew exactly what she was doing. What a waste