MythVision Podcast Tovia is a Ashkenazi Jew! Dr Elhaik's paper, 'The missing link of Jewish European ancestry: contrasting the Rhineland and the Khazarian Hypotheses', examined a comprehensive dataset of 1,287 unrelated individuals of 8 Jewish and 74 non-Jewish populations genotyped over 531,315 autosomal single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). This was data published by Doron Behar and colleagues in 2010, which Elhaik used to calculate seven measures of ancestry, relatedness, admixture, allele sharing distances, geographical origins, and migration patterns. These identified the Caucasus-Near Eastern and European ancestral signatures in the European Jews' genome along with a smaller, but substantial Middle Eastern genome. The results were consistent in depicting a Caucasus ancestry for all European Jews. The analysis showed a tight genetic relationship between European Jews and Caucasus populations and pinpointed the biogeographic origin of the European Jews to the south of Khazaria, 560 kilometers from Samandar -Khazaria's capital city. Further analyses yielded a complex multi-ethnical ancestry with a slightly dominant Caucasus -Near Eastern, large South European and Middle Eastern ancestries, and a minor Eastern European contribution. Dr Elhaik writes, "The most parsimonious explanation for our findings is that Eastern European Jews are of Judeo-Khazarian ancestry forged over many centuries in the Caucasus. Jewish presence in the Caucasus and later Khazaria was recorded as early as the late centuries BCE and reinforced due to the increase in trade along the Silk Road, the decline of Judah (1st-7th centuries), and the rise of Christianity and Islam. Greco-Roman and Mesopotamian Jews gravitating toward Khazaria were also common in the early centuries and their migrations were intensified following the Khazars' conversion to Judaism… The religious conversion of the Khazars encompassed most of the Empire's citizens and subordinate tribes and lasted for the next 400 years until the invasion of the Mongols. At the final collapse of their empire in the 13th century, many of the Judeo-Khazars fled to Eastern Europe and later migrated to Central Europe and admixed with the neighbouring populations."
MythVision Podcast; here is a bit of truth for you! The Ashkenazic Jews: by Paul Wexler page 12; Department of Linguistics Tel Aviv University Israel. (The author) "refute the opinio communalis that the contemporary Jews are a people possessing an uninterrupted history of three and a half millennia." The Ashkenazic Jews: by Paul Wexler page 13a; Department of Linguistics Tel Aviv University Israel. .......(The Jews) "succeeded in surviving as a group thanks to the incorporation of overwhelming numbers of indigenous non-Jews who repeatedly joined the Jewish fold all throughout the first millennium of the first era." The Invention of the Land of Israel: Shlomo Sand "I believe neither in the past existence of a Jewish people, exiled from its land, nor in the premise that the Jews are originally descended from the ancient land of Judea" The Invention of the Land of Israel: Shlomo Sand; "To the dismay of anti-Semites, the Jews were never a foreign “ethnos” of invaders from afar but rather an autochthonous population whose ancestors, for the most part, converted to Judaism before the arrival of Christianity or Islam."
@@saultarsus3659 The genetic material in his DNA is irrelevant. The accuracy of the textual material in his head is what matters in this conversation. Refute that.
@@nikkola33 true. all christian bibles have completely mistranslated the hebrew scriptures. They translate the greek, or they are forced to translate in a certain way so that JC remains true.
This is crazy ! The more I learn the more am not able to listen sermons in same way !!! Actually find my self almost not able to listen them. My stomach turns upside down …
The Judaism today has absolutely nothing to do with the Judaism described in the Old Testament. The fact that the Jews now believe in Kabbalah and the Talmud and have FULLY distorted what the Pharisees of the days of Jesus believed is of course unknown to you. Or not... I would like to know what your opinion is about the current state of Israel which is built on a theological and metaphysical myth and not on objective facts. Are you that negative?
...every minute you've listened to 'bible lessons' , DailyPixels you've been LIED To -- whether naively by Layity who never Thought to Question what They've been told, or -- Most Aggregiously -- by University-Educated 'Professional' clerics who've had not just the Opportunity, but the DUTY to both Learn- AND pass-along awareness of all the Outlandish FALSITIES in EVERY Fundie faith...
...you, @abraham mani, are Exhibit "A" of the DANGERS posed by the Willful Ignore-ance peddled by Fundamentalist Religiosity. Your mind is mired in a quick-sand of Man-Made Myths -- many of them predating The Bronze Age -- and almost NONE of which prepare you to be a well-informed Citizen of Any multi-cultural Society in our current Micro-Electronics Age. I will HAPPILY 'Leave You Alone' in Your Demon-Infested 'World' of 3,000 BCE -- but how can I Trust YOU to Keep YOUR Primative fingers out of My Forward-Looking Future..?
...you, @abraham mani , are Exhibit "A" of the DANGERS posed by the Willful Ignore-ance peddled by Fundamentalist Religiosity. Your mind is mired in a quick-sand of Man-Made Myths -- many of them predating The Bronze Age -- and almost NONE of which prepare you to be a well-informed Citizen of Any multi-cultural Society in our current Micro-Electronics Age. I will HAPPILY 'Leave You Alone' in Your Demon-Infested 'World' of 3,000 BCE -- but how can I Trust YOU to Keep YOUR Primative fingers out of My Forward-Looking Future..?
It does not change the fact that Jesus is Christ and his words are eternal. this dude is claiming what ever he saying can be summerized as " trust me bro, I know because I am Jewish"
I had a grief hallucination a month or two after my daughter died. It was so real it took me a few days to reconcile what had actually happened. It was very comforting because in the hallucination I was able to hug her and tell her goodbye, which I not been able to do. 💔
@@marginmega7840It is no different than what “believers” do. They think that THEIR god and holy book are above thousands of ALL others and is the only “right” one. They believe that any non believer are the dumb ignorant ones, and that they are the clever ones to hit the jackpot in choosing the only “true” belief.
For people who are interested, it's worth reading a book called, "When Prophecy Fails" -- it describes what happens within cults/religious movements when predictions go wrong -- and often what happens is that the members, instead of rejecting the beliefs, make adjustments, keep believing - and start proselytinzing.
That's exactly what happened with Christianity. The so called messiah got killed as a criminal NOT IN THE JOB DESCRIPTION. His shocked followers adjusted their teaching, invented new ones to explain why they were right all along and kept on going.
@Christian Soldiers Quite simply, this phenomenon -- that of people who are experiencing deep grief and trauma after the loss of a loved one, seeing the departed, talking to them, etc., post mortem, is far from uncommon. It happens all the time. And in a case like this, with a person who carried so many people's hopes and expectations, the "news" of his return would spread and multiply and, instead of dying out like the last flickers of a burning ember, one could easily see it such incidents stoking and reinforcing one another. "What? You say him?" Why, yes, I saw him too. We both saw him. What, George and Larry saw him? Me too! We all saw him!" Over forty years of marriage I've heard my wife tell the same story -- well, many many times and I can tell you first hand how a single account of a real event has the tendency to "improve" with the telling. And I have no doubt that stories of Jesus' resurrection, which might easily have started in this way, might easily have "improved" in the same way. And as for martrydom -- people died for Joseph Smith and for the Branch Davidians -- but I don't think anyone says -- "See, how do you explain that?" I explain it because they believed it -- not because it was true. Ultimately, we don't have to explain the events -- we have to explain the accounts -- and the account of a miracle, or of a resurrection is often much easier to explain than an actual miracle an actual resurrection. The world is full of accounts of miracles and of resurrections.
Rabbi Singer is a gold mine for christian skepticism. Please have him on as much as he is willing. I'd love to hear his opinions on so much that gets discussed on Mythvision.
@GMBCATASTROPHE The problems with Christianity that Rabbi Singer points out go well beyond the problems created by mean Christians. Is it really "helpful or positive" to encourage people to believe, with absolute certainty, claims that are so transparently false? The catastrophic consequences of such thinking throughout history are clear enough, but I doubt you can demonstrate that such beliefs actually make better, more moral, people. Bishop Fulton (Sheen), for example, played a role in covering up child molesting Priests when he was a bishop of Rochester. I value the Rabbi's "genius and humor", but value more the lessons we ought to learn from his scholarship.
@GMBCATASTROPHE I wold rather explore Christianity in light of such passages as John 8:44, 1 Thessalonians 2:14-15, Titus 1:11, and say... Matthew 22:44?
Curtis Scissons Curtis, Paul said, “Brothers, my heart’s desire and prayer to God for them is that they may be saved. 2For I bear them witness that they have a zeal for God, but not according to knowledge (Romans 10:1,2). He also said, For just as YOU were at one time disobedient to God but now have received mercy BECAUSE of THEIR disobedience, so they too have now been disobedient in order that by the MERCY shown to you they also may now RECEIVE MERCY.” (Romans 11:30,31). Paul had a strong desire that the Jews would be saved and accept Yahshua as Messiah and Savior, but it seems that you want to curse them. You post verses that are out of context to “prove” your point in a destructive way. If you want to know who crucified Yahshua then post also these verses: “for truly in this city there were gathered together against your holy servant Jesus, whom you anointed, both Herod and Pontius Pilate, along with the GENTILES and the peoples of Israel, 28to do whatever your hand and your plan had predestined to take place” (Acts 4:27). “No one can take my life from me. I sacrifice it voluntarily. For I have the authority to lay it down when I want to and also to take it up again. For this is what my Father has commanded.” (John 10:18).
Sticky Steve Sticky Steve , how can make an assumption like that? I have watched and listened to Tovia mislead a lot of people by his erroneous way of interpreting the Holy Scriptures.
I can't believe I only just discovered your channel. Rabbi Tovia (along with Rabbi Michael Skobac) challenged my Christian beliefs years ago, causing me to completely rethink. Ultimately I became an agnostic atheist and I'm so thankful that I left Christianity behind. Rabbi Tovia is such a fount of knowledge and his enthusiasm is infectious. Because of him, I love learning about the Hebrew and the Christian bibles and have read and learned so much more than I ever did as a Christian.
That's cool bc I feel the same way. Now that my evangelical glasses are off, I feel like I'm able to learn so much more about the Bible now that a large swath of scholarship is no longer taboo to me.
I had a dream about 30 years a go,I saw a man very humble without any color.He was built a wall while I watched him.Soon I saw Jesus showed up with a ball on his hand. He threw the ball to me ,and I had a desire to hit the humble man with the ball; then he spoke to me: I thought you’re with me, I hesitated and confused. When he realized I was confused,he gave me permission to do what I had desire to do with the ball, then I knocked him with the ball;as soon as I knocked him, he was burned to dust. Then Jesus started to walk to the direction he came and I started to fallow him,as I made one step behind Jesus,the humble man I was destroying with the ball embracing me like you put 2 things on the blinder together and the mixed together until you can’t make any different between the two. It took me about 15 years to understand this dream. I do not go to the church anymore since I understand who is Jesus. The creator who spoke to Moses and Abraham,or to any true prophet,he is exist. But he is a different person to Jesus.
Thoroughly enjoyed your hosting I've been watching the rabbi on tanaktalk for the past year-and-a-half since I've jettisoned Christianity after 65 years Your heart shows through it's awesome brother
@Abraham Mani not true there is no power in the name or blood of Jesus or Yeshua or hoochie coochie Christianity is a lie especially that book of Revelation and nobody's coming back to get you The Creator does not have a son named Jesus the Creator's first begotten son is the nation of Israel his suffering servant his son Army called out of Egypt, all the nation of Israel Isaiah 43 11 I, even I am the Lord and beside me there is no savior
@@drb1641 oh I guess that is all the proof we need! Just sit and wait, maybe he will come back soon, He may be late according to his words "there be some standing here who shall not taste of death until they see the son of man coming in the clouds of heaven" Those folks have been dead a long time! Is Jesus taking a nap or stuck on the throne? "childish" theology!
Rabbi Tovia Singer, I own and read (often) Let's get biblical, and love your discussions. I often bring up your truth nuggets in various settings at church (SDA) and no one seems to care , understand, or accept. It is sad. Thank you though.
Ι will say only one thing. Everyone has the Ι right not to be a Christian for their own reasons. But he has no right to pretend he does not know one thing. That Judaism, or at least what we call Judaism today, has absolutely nothing to do with the Old Testament Jews and their views on the Messiah at that time. Judaism today is what partly benefits them from the Old Testament and the invented Talmud and Kabbalah which were both written AFTER Christ during the medieval times. Both of them, the Talmud and the Kabbalah, annul the Old Testament itself.
Best podcast ever! You have got to get this Rabbi on again. Learned so much from your channel and look forward to learning much more. I see this was recorded 3 years ago but still in style. Derrick thank you for the awesome content. Now to binge-watch and get caught up.
The earliest completed version of the Christian Old Testament dates back to around 300 A.D., while the oldest completed Jewish Bible dates around 1000 A.D. Given this, it's noteworthy that 2 Chronicles, the final book of the Jewish Bible/Old Testament, concludes with accounts of Jewish kings engaging in sinful actions. Considering the condemnation of these kings for their wickedness, one might wonder whether it's plausible that the nation of Israel could have deliberately edited their Bible version, removing references and prophecies about Jesus. This concept isn't entirely implausible.
Zechariah12.10 Do you think Isaiah is a prophecy of Jesus? what’s Isaiah about, not just Isaiah 53? What’s Isaiah 52 about? What’s the last word in Isaiah 52? Christians have repeatedly misused Isiah as some sort of prophecy.
I Am Michael .your smart right . I'll assume but not that smart obviously. It says in the Bible God will confound your beliefs , the traditions of men . That would include atheism and agnostics. That God would respond . PR is important. You better believe God can question your beliefs or lack of progress there of . Call the cops , they'll tell you , it's true . Wine to your mother about it . She might know more than you , Michael is God .
Hell is real!!! Where will you go when you die??? If the rapture took place today, would you be left behind??? Jesus loves you and He died for your sins. Anyone who rejects Jesus Christ will not see the Kingdom of Heaven. Humble yourself to REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior. Mark 1:15 For the Kingdom of God is at hand, repent and believe in the gospel.
Brothers and sisters this is just a little message to everybody keep believing in the Lord and God and try to do the best you can in life and you'll be fine
What an amazing job you’re doing. The scholarship is amazing that you are bringing to us and I am thrilled by how prolific you have been it must be exhausting but we are thrilled to see a new episode popping up every few days. Thank you for your efforts
The Judaism today has absolutely nothing to do with the Judaism described in the Old Testament. The fact that the Jews now believe in Kabbalah and the Talmud and have FULLY distorted what the Pharisees of the days of Jesus believed is of course unknown to you. Or not... I would like to know what your opinion is about the current state of Israel which is built on a theological and metaphysical myth and not on objective facts. Are you that negative?
Well, many highly incisive minds over the millennia have believed in Torah. National Revelation is a tough one to get around. Plus, the unbroken chain of transmission from generation to generation; the falsifiable prophesies vis a vis Jewish history; and the improbable continued existence of the Jewish People despite landlessness and all the various hostile diasporas over thousands of years. Taken as a whole, it's hard not to entertain the possibility that something is going on with Torah and the Jews.
@@dabneydee9109 all of those things are present in other cultures and religions. It is incredibly hard to take the Torah seriously, it's one of the main problems with the Christian Bible, so I fail to see how it's not a problem for Judaism.
@@SnakeWasRight Ok, maybe you're right. I don't know enough about all the cultures and religions of the world to definitively declare the Jews unique in the things I listed. Can you give an example of anther religion that claims national revelation? Or another religion/nation that has ancient ties to a specific land - via its scriptures - that lived out a scripturally-prophesied history of being "vomited out" of their land and returned to that land after 2 millennia of being scattered among many other (often hostile) nations? I'm not trying to be facetious, nor am I attempting to convince you of anything. You don't have to take the Torah seriously and you are free to believe in whatever you want. It's just that when you assert that "all those things are present in other cultures and religions", I'm not sure that's a true statement.
Trouble is Islam started 7 centuries later than the Christian religion so their source for Jesus is also the Gospels, they don’t have an independent opinion
You don't know how the Quran was put together . You're just as deceived as Christians are. You have no idea about the roots of Allah either. Neither the god of the Jews nor Allah have anything to do with the true Creator God. Wake up!
Omg 😁😂🤣😂😁😂🤣 Tovia's face when this kid this talking is priceless..... He reminds me of myself in that no matter how tollerent, patient and supportive of others pursuing truth, sometimes you just can hold it in...
What about the Jerusalem Bible it's based on AD BC GREEKS ROMAN AND JEWS NOT JEWISH SO DEFINITELY THERE' ARE MORE QUESTIONS THAN ANSWERS THANKS FOR THE INFORMATION ALSO KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK
The Judaism today has absolutely nothing to do with the Judaism described in the Old Testament. The fact that the Jews now believe in Kabbalah and the Talmud and have FULLY distorted what the Pharisees of the days of Jesus believed is of course unknown to you. Or not... I would like to know what your opinion is about the current state of Israel which is built on a theological and metaphysical myth and not on objective facts. Are you that negative?
@@etinarcadiaego7972 the Pharisees are the authors of the first part of the Talmud, the Mishnah. The religion of Orthodox Jews is the religion of the Pharisees.
Hell is real!!! Where will you go when you die??? If the rapture took place today, would you be left behind??? Jesus loves you and He died for your sins. Anyone who rejects Jesus Christ will not see the Kingdom of Heaven. Humble yourself to REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior. Mark 1:15 For the Kingdom of God is at hand, repent and believe in the gospel.
I agree a lot with Tovia Singer except for the fact that he's a rabbi and therefore an apologist for the first part of the most incredible story ever told
I like to see Rabbi Tovia expose some Old Testament lies just to show that he isn't only pointing his finger away from himself and his own unfounded beliefs. Scammers calling out scammers is beneath decency.
Here are Some Examples!!! I agree with Saul of Tarsus corrupting and misappropriating the truth in the Tanakh and also teaching contrary to the Word of GOD Elohim Most High, also given and created in his begotten Yahushua Ha'Mashiah. I don't agree with your position on PERFECT and being Tamim. I found Joe Atwill's book "Caesar's Messiah," to offer an interesting case for Roman authorship of the Gospels. He believes the Gospels are a typology of Josephus's work, "War of the Jews." He noted that certain events described in the Gospels follow the same chronological sequence and locations to be exactly the same as they are recorded in "War of the Jews." Atwill was initially dismissed by academic Biblical scholars from both Christian and non-Christian camps, but on closer examination, some of them saw that Atwill's notations of parallel times and places were consistent between both works. Atwill further speculated that these writings may have been intended initially for the amusement of the Flavian court as they recounted the exploits Vespasian and Titus as parodies. Then somewhere along the line, they saw these writings as useful tools of propaganda to pacify the peoples of the Eastern Mediterranean. The motive is certainly plausible. With the destruction of the Jewish nation, Jews were scattering to other parts of the region and beyond. What better way would there be than to marginalize them by converting non-Jewish people to a religion that supports Roman Rule and chastises rebellious Jews?
1 Corinthians 1:22-25 [22] For Jews demand signs and Greeks seek wisdom, [23] but we preach Christ crucified, a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Gentiles, [24] but to those who are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God. [25] For the foolishness of God is wiser than men, and the weakness of God is stronger than men.
This is amazing. Rabbi Tovia Singer has a delightful sense of humor I love to see people who can remark upon the patent absurdity demonstrated by the cultists
Isaiah 35 “Then will the eyes of the blind be opened and the ears of the deaf unstopped. Then will the lame leap like a deer, and the mute tongue shout for joy.
Also Daniel quoting messiah will die/cut off.... "Seventy sevens have been decreed for your people. . . . So you are to know and discern that from the issuing of a decree to restore and rebuild Jerusalem until Messiah the Prince there will be seven sevens and sixty-two sevens; it will be built again, with plaza and moat, even in times of distress. Then after the sixty-two sevens the Messiah will be cut off and have nothing, and the people of the prince who is to come will destroy the city and the sanctuary.”
Once upon a time there was a tribe living in the Middle East that had a collection of sacred texts written in Hebrew, Chaldean and Aramaic. It is the nature of sacred tests to be venerated and transmitted from generation to generation unaltered. As time passed members of this tribe emigrated to areas where Hebrew and Aramaic and Chaldean were not spoken. A large community settled and prospered in the city of Alexandria in Egypt. Greek replaced their tribal language. They needed an accurate translation of their venerated documents into Greek. Around 250 B.C. seventy rabbis translated the sacred texts into Greek. This translation was not a bootleg edition. The project was approved by the High Priest and the Sanhedrin in Jerusalem. The Septuagint, the translation of the seventy, was an official document. A Hebrew Bible exists today. It is used by Jews everywhere. It is called the Masoretic text. It was compiled around 700 A.D. It is almost one thousand years newer than the Septuagint. The rabbis who compiled the Masoretic text were not accountable to the High Priest in Jerusalem. There no longer was a High Priest. The rabbis who compiled the Masoretic text were not accountable to the Sanhedrin in Jerusalem. There no longer was a Sanhedrin. The Septuagint predates the first appearance of the Masoretic text by almost ten centuries. The Septuagint is based upon Hebrew texts at least twelve centuries older than the texts upon which the Masoretic version is based. Yet, modern Christian translations of the Old Testament rely on the Masoretic Text, not the Septuagint. Where is the problem? Most of the quotations from the Old Testament in the New Testament used the Septuagint as their primary source. The integrity and truthfulness of the Septuagint is completely dependent on the Septuagint being a truthful translation. Discredit the Septuagint and there is no New Testament. There was no controversy about the integrity of the Septuagint from 250 B.C. until 135 A. D. What had happened to provoke dissatisfaction with the Septuagint among the Jews? Annas and Caiaphas and the Sanhedrin had rejected the messianic claims of Jesus. The New Testament documents had been written and were circulating by A.D. 70. The Jews knew that the credibility of the Christian Gospels depended on the credibility of the Septuagint. Something had to be done. Around 95 A.D. Rabbi Akiva, who later proclaimed Bar Kochba as the messiah, hired a man named Aquila to translate a Hebrew to Greek version of the Old Testament that would undermine the messianic claims of Jesus found in the Septuagint. Some scholars believe that the Masoretic text was based in part on this tendentious translation by Aquila. How is the Masoretic text different from the Septuagint? Psalm 22:16 the word “pierced” has been replaced by “lion”. Psalm 145: 13 omitted entirely. Isaiah 53:11 the word “light” is omitted. On 134 occasions the Tetragrammaton, the name of God, has been replaced by “Adonai”. Psalm 151 was omitted entirely. (It is now omitted by almost all Christian Bibles !) Exodus 1: The number 75 replaced by 70 Genesis 10:24 some generations removed. Deuteronomy 32:8 “Angels Of Elohim” replaced with “children of Israel.” Jeremiah 10 verses 6 and 7 have been added in the Masoretic. Psalm 96:10 “Say among the nations, YHWH reigns from the wood” omitted. Isaiah 19:18 “city of righteousness” changed to the “city of the sun” or in some versions “the city of destruction.” The Masoretic scribes purposely and willfully rearranged the original chapter order in the prophetic Book of Daniel, so that the chapters make no sense chronologically. Isaiah 61:1 “recovery of sight to the blind.”. Omitted. In Psalm 40:6 “a body you have prepared for me” was replaced by “you opened my ears.” Deuteronomy 32:43 ‘Let all the messengers of Elohim worship him.’” Omitted. Genesis 4:8: “Let us go into the field” is omitted. Deuteronomy 32:43. Moses’ song is shortened. Isaiah 53 contains 10 spelling differences, 4 stylistic changes and 3 missing letters for light in verse 11, for a total of 17 differences. Isaiah 7:14. “Virgin” replaced by “young woman.” (When Aquila made his Greek translation of the Old Testament at the behest of Rabbi Akiva, he changed the Septuagint’s “virgin” into “young woman”. The Masoretic compilers may have followed his lead.) The Masoretic text differs from the Septuagint in hundreds of places. How do we know which text is accurate? The Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered just after World War II. According to carbon dating, textual analysis, and handwriting analysis the documents were written at various times between the middle of the 2nd century BC and the 1st century AD. There are fragments from all of the books of the Hebrew Bible fragments except the Book of Esther and the Book of Nehemiah. In addition an independent Aramaic translation of the Hebrew Bible exists, the Peshitta. Control of the Dead Sea Scrolls was a military objective of Israelis. It was achieved by their victory in the Six Days War. The publication of the scrolls slowed to a trickle. After 1971, the international team even refused to allow the publication of photographs of the material. They excluded scholars who wanted to make independent evaluations. The embargo was not broken until 1991. An addition to the Dead Sea Scrolls, scholars can use the Peshitta to decide between the Masoretic text and the Septuagint. I have given examples above of some of the places the Dead Sea Scrolls, the Peshitta, and the Septuagint agree. The Masoretic Text is part of a tradition that began with Rabbi Akiva. Rabbis rewrote the Jewish Bible to destroy the credibility of the New Testament. The Hebrew versions of the Old Testament have been used to proclaim scores of “messiahs” . The Septuagint was only used once.
I think Singer is wrong, it’s not Luke who added the passage of the blind in Jesaiah 61 and it was than added to the Septuagint. That’s just nonsense. Luke just used the Septuagint like Mathew and other writers of the New Testament. The question should rather be, why was it in the Septuagint in the first place? It’s a translation from the Hebrew which would indicate that there were Hebrew manuscripts that contained that passage which are now lost.
The only problem with your point is, if you check up the history of the Septuagint, only the first five books of Moses were translated. The rest of Tanak wasn't. So you have been lied to
@@CaesarRenasci It relates to Rabbi Tovia going to Hell if he doesn't Trust in Jesus Christ who is Lord God and Saviour. You too if you're an unbeliever.
Somehow I got this im my suggestions by listening to a metal band called Testament. I started watching this video and found it fascinating, now I'm watching more of this Rabbi. I'm also a atheist. Lol
Finding out how the New Testament came to be has completely change my mind on everything. If Jesus did exist I think he was preaching Gnosticism and the Roman’s put their Greek mythological spin on it
Can you die on the cross within 6 hours even if you have perfect weather? Yes, you can if you lose blood heavily from flogging and resulting wounds for more than 12 hours continously.
@Zechariah12.10 It's not true that there wasn't a Hebrew version containing the version from Luke 4:18. There was. The similarity of that passage which opens Isaiah 61 to the one in Isaiah 42 is striking. I say this as one who is not in any way a Christian whatsoever. It's just that this (what's said about this matter in the video) is an invalid criticism of Christianity.
@Abraham Mani Okay. Well, I actually have come to basically believe that Revelation was originally a Gnostic book and that the king who rules during the end times referred to as "the Beast" is actually Dowid Ha Melekh, while the so-called "false prophet" is Eliyahu whom the "Old Testament" also portrays as returning during the end times. Both the "false prophet" and Eliyahu are described as calling down fire from heaven in the sight of men, for one thing, and given that the Gnostics refer to the God of the Jews and of Abraham as a "false god", so too would they refer to His prophets as "false prophets". This is not to mention the parallels between the "kings" associated with the "Beast" and Dragon and those kings/archons Gnosticism portrays as being associated with "Yaldabaoth", its depiction of the God of Abraham, and many other indications of the humanistic, psychopathic, Gnostic origin of the book.
@@DD_Davey I am not a rabbi nor even a Jew, but sure: That chapter describes apostasy based on the lure of paganism. Christianity is the ultimate and most insidious example of such luring of Jews away from the Jewish system, including the priesthood, which most of the prophets belonged to. Christianity is the most disturbing example of such enticement toward apostasy because it blasphemously claims that exactly what was good for the Romans, such as the rejection of the Torah and submission to THEIR law, is what the God of the Jews wills.
It is always great to see Rabbi Singer debating a Christian Apologist because he blows them away with his knowledge. He is far more expert on the Christian testament than ANY Christian!
When the young man in Matthew asks Jesus what he had to do to get to heaven, Jesus says "keep the commandments". That's it. In Acts the disciples ask Jesus when he was going to restore the kingdom to Israel. THAT was the job of a messiah. He simply failed to get the job done.
@Abraham Mani A Christian threatening someone with hell carries as much weight as a child warning an adult that they won’t be getting any presents from Santa.
Hell is real!!! Where will you go when you die??? If the rapture took place today, would you be left behind??? Jesus loves you and He died for your sins. Anyone who rejects Jesus Christ will not see the Kingdom of Heaven. Humble yourself to REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior. Mark 1:15 For the Kingdom of God is at hand, repent and believe in the gospel.
I don't agree with the rabbi but respect his way of teaching. He seems sincere. If I ever had a debate with someone Jewish I would hope that they carry themselves accordingly. From what I understand the Septuagint was actually written by Jews for the Greek rulers of the time. So it could be included in their vast library. And I read more of the Old Testament these days because I believe that both Testaments are important at this point in history..
WE NEED THE HOLY SPIRIT TO UNDERSTAND THE BIBLE CORRECTLY. St. Luke 24:25 He said to them, "How foolish you are, and how slow to believe all that the prophets have spoken! St. Luke 24:26 Did not the Messiah have to suffer these things and then enter his glory?" St. Luke 24:27 And beginning with Moses and all the Prophets, he explained to them what was said in all the Scriptures concerning himself.
@@CaesarRenasci That is another jewish tale and is not writen anywhere in the Bible. G has sent only 1 jewish messiah for all world for all time and the world does not need more jewish messiahs. Only JC has the title Messiah in all history of the world. Jews wait their messiah, not another messiah.
The Hebrew we have today is not the true ancient Hebrew language. Today's language It is a modern dialect. A waste of time to learn it or read anything written it.
@@LordJagd The Smartians where half-breds or as they are call bi-racial. They the offspring the Hebrews who married strange women in Samaria. They were half Hebrew. According scripture God made them put their wives and children away.
It is very interesting to observe Rabbi Tovia's way he express and talk (from psychological point of view). Before he tells what he wants to tell he puts huge label on his conclusion. "It's going to blow your mind away" , "Have to sit on the chair with your gravity centred" ...) and he is revolting that label on and on. Rabbi Tovia you just didn't convince me.
He Has Convinced me Along Time Ago!!! Here are some Examples!!! I have not been a burden to you. Yet, crafty fellow that I am, I caught you by trickery! - Paul. Paul taught against the alliance Genesis17 exodus12 Joshua 5 numbers9 John 7 : 23 acts7: 8 Ezekiel 44 8 - 9 Luke 2 : 21.. He twisted scripture he is a Pharisee which Jesus warned of. t literally took me only the first 5 chapters of 1st Corinthian’s to realize Saul tried to puff himself up and contradicts Jesus. False teacher. First Paul killed believers in the flesh, then he attacked them spiritually. Paul with his duality: either the "law" or "grace" - and the Apostle John, "keep the commandments". With this argument against Paul totally destroys the catholic church's apostolic succession. Paul taught against the alliance Genesis17 exodus12 Joshua 5 numbers9 John 7 : 23 acts7: 8 Ezekiel 44 8 - 9 Luke 2 : 21.. He twisted scripture he is a Pharisee which Jesus warned of. First Paul killed believers in the flesh, then he attacked them spiritually. Paul with his duality: either the "law" or "grace" - and the Apostle John, "keep the commandments". With this argument against Paul destroys the catholic church's apostolic succession. I would make a couple of corrections: 1. It's just a "Greek proverb"; Paul is directly quoting from Euripides play from which he ripped off the entire conversion story and this quote is word for word stolen from the play. 2. He is not "Pharisee Saul"; there is no evidence whatsoever that he had a Jewish background or any Jewish training and there is no evidence that he was from the house of Benjamin. He was a Roman. 3. The "first love" that the church was told to return to was referring to the Torah, to keeping the Commandments. With that said, this is a pretty good break down of the evidence that proves Paul was a false apostle. Excellent video Rabbi Federow and Steve! The differences between Deuteronomy 30:11-14 and Romans 10:6-9 are really quite shocking. The Scripture could not be more clearer! But the natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him; nor can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned. I Corinthians 2:14 NKJV. Jesus didn't come back and rule the world before his disciples died like he said he would in Matthew 16! Jesus said in Matthew I come not for peace but for the sword, Jesus said in Matthew 22 the world will not have love or marriage he was wrong don't pray for us we don't need your modern Jesus we rolled the dice love is cool in Danny Gallagher Paradise, UA-cam Portugal the man live Lala 2018. Paul was changing word of God all the time. He even contradicts Himself and James! The New Testament is Complete nonsense. I was raised Atheist. Looked for Christianity for the last few years but felt really silly trying to worship some Dude who was probably a good political agitator and public speaker but a saviour??? (Goes right against not having any other God) I now have a better perspective. I am also relieved to hear that is much more forgiving NSW highway patrol. Corinthians 12:16 Be that as it may>
Hi rabbi. I’m an Orthodox Jew and wouldn’t delete my comment. You said over here that most rabbis would agree that the Talmud is talking about Jesus. But another more recent video you said it can’t be because it’s a totally different time period. Love your videos btw.
At the time of Jesus, Jewish people spoke Arameo, not Hebrew; and given the dominance of the Hellenic world, Jesus was most likely reading from the Septuagint version of the Tanak.
Rav Tuvia is a genius. Hhazak ubarukh. Yet the UA-cam ads are an extreme interference every few sentences and another xxxx ad. More than in movies or music clips. I'm wondering if UA-cam is purposely interfering
For those of us who have not spent much time with these texts, some breakdowns explaining why these revelations and discrepancies are so meaningful would be great. It’s a bit lost on me.
The discrepancies are meaningful because Christianity makes fantastic claims about Tanach (so-called "Old Testament"). Christianity claims to be the fulfillment of Tanach, and the Church the replacement of the Jewish People. The NT has a series of "proofs" to demonstrate how this is so. When you examine these proof-texts against the original Hebrew Scriptures, they fall apart. There are so many misquotes, mistranslations, phantom verses, and so on.
Mark effectively says there was no virgin birth. His family thinks he lost his mind. 3:21,33-35. That would not be the case if they thought Mary had been a virgin.
The biggest miracle Jesus performed was the resurrection of Lasarus from the dead after 4 days and of course his own resurrection and not the healing of the blind as you incorrectly claim
I used to avoid Rabbi Singer because of Dr. Mike Brown saying he was a liar then "using" scripture to refute him. I've since gone down the rabbit hole and wow! Shout out to this channel and Dr. BART EHRMAN!
Wow😂😂😂😂 the level of pure energy used to purposely mislead the masses. Book of Isaiah discusses what Jesus would do when he comes...not once but twice. The way he belittles it is amazing😂😂
What you are Reading is a Corruption of Old Testament by Church of Niacin! The Old testament remains Unchanged since it was Written. Who Gave the Church of Niacin the Right to Corrupt the Bible i,e, Tanakh!!! They Changed the Holy Scriptures that is the Narrative to Fit the Out Right Lies of New Testament!!! Above in Comments is Proof of that!!!
Rabbi singer speaks truth, i have not watched this video, and have seen the rabbi in many other videos, but truth is truth! We must all accept God knows truth! GOD 100% know the truth of all individuals of the past, present, and future, ...i hope and pray i will be healed and all who trust in God will be provided for! Amen!
It was in Egypt. It was manufactured for the Greek King Ptolemy of Egypt. It was never in a synagogue. Why would a Hebrew synagogue in Israel, have a Greek translation from Egypt?
@@casper8662 The Judaism today has absolutely nothing to do with the Judaism described in the Old Testament. The fact that the Jews now believe in Kabbalah and the Talmud and have FULLY distorted what the Pharisees of the days of Jesus believed is of course unknown to you. Or not... I would like to know what your opinion is about the current state of Israel which is built on a theological and metaphysical myth and not on objective facts. Are you that negative?
@@etinarcadiaego7972 not a part of Judaism, don't follow it, nor study it. I do read the scriptures, from the very first page to the end. Must be why I am not a fan of Christianity.
@@casper8662 since you don't know the historical context and don't have a wide variety of knowledge it's very easy to consider as right some random UA-camrs or a biased rabbi.... I don't care about the way you "read" the scriptures either way. Cause it's false
@@casper8662 you don't study Judaism, you don't know it BUT you still have an opinion. The fact that Talmud and Kaballah derive from the Gnostic philosophy of the 70 AC and are almost similar to philosophical satanism (eg Dönmez Jews) doesn't bother you. And you trust a biased rabbi that thinks he's God's chosen one 🤡
GET RECOMMENDED BOOKS HERE:
👉 amzn.to/35FqNYf
MythVision Podcast Tovia is a Ashkenazi Jew!
Dr Elhaik's paper, 'The missing link of Jewish European ancestry: contrasting the Rhineland and the Khazarian Hypotheses', examined a comprehensive dataset of 1,287 unrelated individuals of 8 Jewish and 74 non-Jewish populations genotyped over 531,315 autosomal single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). This was data published by Doron Behar and colleagues in 2010, which Elhaik used to calculate seven measures of ancestry, relatedness, admixture, allele sharing distances, geographical origins, and migration patterns. These identified the Caucasus-Near Eastern and European ancestral signatures in the European Jews' genome along with a smaller, but substantial Middle Eastern genome.
The results were consistent in depicting a Caucasus ancestry for all European Jews. The analysis showed a tight genetic relationship between European Jews and Caucasus populations and pinpointed the biogeographic origin of the European Jews to the south of Khazaria, 560 kilometers from Samandar -Khazaria's capital city. Further analyses yielded a complex multi-ethnical ancestry with a slightly dominant Caucasus -Near Eastern, large South European and Middle Eastern ancestries, and a minor Eastern European contribution.
Dr Elhaik writes, "The most parsimonious explanation for our findings is that Eastern European Jews are of Judeo-Khazarian ancestry forged over many centuries in the Caucasus. Jewish presence in the Caucasus and later Khazaria was recorded as early as the late centuries BCE and reinforced due to the increase in trade along the Silk Road, the decline of Judah (1st-7th centuries), and the rise of Christianity and Islam. Greco-Roman and Mesopotamian Jews gravitating toward Khazaria were also common in the early centuries and their migrations were intensified following the Khazars' conversion to Judaism… The religious conversion of the Khazars encompassed most of the Empire's citizens and subordinate tribes and lasted for the next 400 years until the invasion of the Mongols. At the final collapse of their empire in the 13th century, many of the Judeo-Khazars fled to Eastern Europe and later migrated to Central Europe and admixed with the neighbouring populations."
MythVision Podcast a wannabe son of Abraham teaching Torah?! Expose that!
MythVision Podcast; here is a bit of truth for you!
The Ashkenazic Jews: by Paul Wexler page 12; Department of Linguistics Tel Aviv University Israel.
(The author) "refute the opinio communalis that the contemporary Jews are a people possessing an uninterrupted history of three and a half millennia."
The Ashkenazic Jews: by Paul Wexler page 13a; Department of Linguistics Tel Aviv University Israel.
.......(The Jews) "succeeded in surviving as a group thanks to the incorporation of overwhelming numbers of indigenous non-Jews who repeatedly joined the Jewish fold all throughout the first millennium of the first era."
The Invention of the Land of Israel: Shlomo Sand "I believe neither in the past existence of a Jewish people, exiled from its land, nor in the premise that the Jews are originally descended from the ancient land of Judea"
The Invention of the Land of Israel: Shlomo Sand; "To the dismay of anti-Semites, the Jews were never a foreign “ethnos” of invaders from afar but rather an autochthonous population whose ancestors, for the most part, converted to Judaism before the arrival of Christianity or Islam."
@@saultarsus3659 The genetic material in his DNA is irrelevant. The accuracy of the textual material in his head is what matters in this conversation.
Refute that.
Apostate Prophet Morehammered
Do you wanna teach the (( true Holy Torah )) or the (( Masoratic text ))🙂
Rabbi Singer is the best! Baruch HaShem!
The best Anti Christian!
@erniesentillas9133 he isn't anti-christian, he is pro god.
This proves that so few Christians actually know their scriptures, and even fewer know Tanach.
True.
I have found all bibles have been mistraslated.
@@nikkola33 true. all christian bibles have completely mistranslated the hebrew scriptures. They translate the greek, or they are forced to translate in a certain way so that JC remains true.
True.
This is crazy ! The more I learn the more am not able to listen sermons in same way !!! Actually find my self almost not able to listen them. My stomach turns upside down …
The Judaism today has absolutely nothing to do with the Judaism described in the Old Testament. The fact that the Jews now believe in Kabbalah and the Talmud and have FULLY distorted what the Pharisees of the days of Jesus believed is of course unknown to you. Or not...
I would like to know what your opinion is about the current state of Israel which is built on a theological and metaphysical myth and not on objective facts. Are you that negative?
...every minute you've listened to 'bible lessons' , DailyPixels you've been LIED To -- whether naively by Layity who never Thought to Question what They've been told, or -- Most Aggregiously -- by University-Educated 'Professional' clerics who've had not just the Opportunity, but the DUTY to both Learn- AND pass-along awareness of all the Outlandish FALSITIES in EVERY Fundie faith...
...you, @abraham mani, are Exhibit "A" of the DANGERS posed by the Willful Ignore-ance peddled by Fundamentalist Religiosity.
Your mind is mired in a quick-sand of Man-Made Myths -- many of them predating The Bronze Age -- and almost NONE of which prepare you to be a well-informed Citizen of Any multi-cultural Society in our current Micro-Electronics Age.
I will HAPPILY 'Leave You Alone' in Your Demon-Infested 'World' of 3,000 BCE -- but how can I Trust YOU to Keep YOUR Primative fingers out of My Forward-Looking Future..?
...you, @abraham mani , are Exhibit "A" of the DANGERS posed by the Willful Ignore-ance peddled by Fundamentalist Religiosity.
Your mind is mired in a quick-sand of Man-Made Myths -- many of them predating The Bronze Age -- and almost NONE of which prepare you to be a well-informed Citizen of Any multi-cultural Society in our current Micro-Electronics Age.
I will HAPPILY 'Leave You Alone' in Your Demon-Infested 'World' of 3,000 BCE -- but how can I Trust YOU to Keep YOUR Primative fingers out of My Forward-Looking Future..?
Join the crowd
It has been about 12 years since I stopped believing in Christianity. This Rabbi is amazing!
How is he amazing? He believes in sillier stuff than you used to.
It does not change the fact that Jesus is Christ and his words are eternal. this dude is claiming what ever he saying can be summerized as " trust me bro, I know because I am Jewish"
The Bible said people like this would come before the end of days. Well here he is. Jesus said don’t be deceived.
@@makunga_yokopal
What you're actually stating is a delusion as your claim does not appear to align with reality.
@@makunga_yokopalhe provided verses from Luke and Isaiah to compare, what else do you need?
I had a grief hallucination a month or two after my daughter died. It was so real it took me a few days to reconcile what had actually happened. It was very comforting because in the hallucination I was able to hug her and tell her goodbye, which I not been able to do. 💔
So this man thinks he is clever than everyone else and those who believe are Morrons
@@marginmega7840 Believers may not always be morons but they are all indoctrinated (as I had been) or they are G U L L I B L E.
@@marginmega7840I agree. He is saying dangerous Things. Poor man.
I’m sorry for your loss.
@@marginmega7840It is no different than what “believers” do.
They think that THEIR god and holy book are above thousands of ALL others and is the only “right” one.
They believe that any non believer are the dumb ignorant ones, and that they are the clever ones to hit the jackpot in choosing the only “true” belief.
For people who are interested, it's worth reading a book called, "When Prophecy Fails" -- it describes what happens within cults/religious movements when predictions go wrong -- and often what happens is that the members, instead of rejecting the beliefs, make adjustments, keep believing - and start proselytinzing.
That's exactly what happened with Christianity. The so called messiah got killed as a criminal NOT IN THE JOB DESCRIPTION. His shocked followers adjusted their teaching, invented new ones to explain why they were right all along and kept on going.
99 cents Kindle version, thanks for the info
@@robertfrotlarranaga5725 Rude. I don't have the learning of rabbi but I am quite knowledge able. Studied this for 30 years.
@@emilywyatt9340 studied for 30 years to still listen to a youtube rabbi who twists scripture on a daily basis
@Christian Soldiers Quite simply, this phenomenon -- that of people who are experiencing deep grief and trauma after the loss of a loved one, seeing the departed, talking to them, etc., post mortem, is far from uncommon. It happens all the time. And in a case like this, with a person who carried so many people's hopes and expectations, the "news" of his return would spread and multiply and, instead of dying out like the last flickers of a burning ember, one could easily see it such incidents stoking and reinforcing one another. "What? You say him?" Why, yes, I saw him too. We both saw him. What, George and Larry saw him? Me too! We all saw him!" Over forty years of marriage I've heard my wife tell the same story -- well, many many times and I can tell you first hand how a single account of a real event has the tendency to "improve" with the telling. And I have no doubt that stories of Jesus' resurrection, which might easily have started in this way, might easily have "improved" in the same way.
And as for martrydom -- people died for Joseph Smith and for the Branch Davidians -- but I don't think anyone says -- "See, how do you explain that?" I explain it because they believed it -- not because it was true.
Ultimately, we don't have to explain the events -- we have to explain the accounts -- and the account of a miracle, or of a resurrection is often much easier to explain than an actual miracle an actual resurrection.
The world is full of accounts of miracles and of resurrections.
Todah Rabah Rabbi Tovia Singer!
We are so blessed to have you!
Rabbi Tobia singer is my absolute favorite rabbi thanks for having him on this video
Tovia
Rabbi Singer is a gold mine for christian skepticism. Please have him on as much as he is willing. I'd love to hear his opinions on so much that gets discussed on Mythvision.
Morte' yes, have him as much as possible
@GMBCATASTROPHE The problems with Christianity that Rabbi Singer points out go well beyond the problems created by mean Christians. Is it really "helpful or positive" to encourage people to believe, with absolute certainty, claims that are so transparently false? The catastrophic consequences of such thinking throughout history are clear enough, but I doubt you can demonstrate that such beliefs actually make better, more moral, people. Bishop Fulton (Sheen), for example, played a role in covering up child molesting Priests when he was a bishop of Rochester. I value the Rabbi's "genius and humor", but value more the lessons we ought to learn from his scholarship.
@GMBCATASTROPHE I wold rather explore Christianity in light of such passages as John 8:44, 1 Thessalonians 2:14-15, Titus 1:11, and say... Matthew 22:44?
Curtis Scissons Curtis, Paul said, “Brothers, my heart’s desire and prayer to God for them is that they may be saved. 2For I bear them witness that they have a zeal for God, but not according to knowledge (Romans 10:1,2). He also said, For just as YOU were at one time disobedient to God but now have received mercy BECAUSE of THEIR disobedience, so they too have now been disobedient in order that by the MERCY shown to you they also may now RECEIVE MERCY.” (Romans 11:30,31). Paul had a strong desire that the Jews would be saved and accept Yahshua as Messiah and Savior, but it seems that you want to curse them. You post verses that are out of context to “prove” your point in a destructive way. If you want to know who crucified Yahshua then post also these verses: “for truly in this city there were gathered together against your holy servant Jesus, whom you anointed, both Herod and Pontius Pilate, along with the GENTILES and the peoples of Israel, 28to do whatever your hand and your plan had predestined to take place” (Acts 4:27). “No one can take my life from me. I sacrifice it voluntarily. For I have the authority to lay it down when I want to and also to take it up again. For this is what my Father has commanded.” (John 10:18).
Sticky Steve Sticky Steve , how can make an assumption like that? I have watched and listened to Tovia mislead a lot of people by his erroneous way of interpreting the Holy Scriptures.
Man, I just love Rabbi's teachings.
Dear Derrick Lambert,
Thank you so much for the show!!!
Love you!
I can't believe I only just discovered your channel. Rabbi Tovia (along with Rabbi Michael Skobac) challenged my Christian beliefs years ago, causing me to completely rethink. Ultimately I became an agnostic atheist and I'm so thankful that I left Christianity behind. Rabbi Tovia is such a fount of knowledge and his enthusiasm is infectious. Because of him, I love learning about the Hebrew and the Christian bibles and have read and learned so much more than I ever did as a Christian.
That's cool bc I feel the same way. Now that my evangelical glasses are off, I feel like I'm able to learn so much more about the Bible now that a large swath of scholarship is no longer taboo to me.
Stand firm on your Christian faith. Jesus is our Lord n Savior. He is returning soon!
@@seplemisio6155 I don't have one but thanks anyway.
@@Suxipumpkin By your own tongue and your own mouth. Condemned thine ownself?
Ask him what Goyim means
I had a dream about 30 years a go,I saw a man very humble without any color.He was built a wall while I watched him.Soon I saw Jesus showed up with a ball on his hand. He threw the ball to me ,and I had a desire to hit the humble man with the ball; then he spoke to me: I thought you’re with me, I hesitated and confused. When he realized I was confused,he gave me permission to do what I had desire to do with the ball, then I knocked him with the ball;as soon as I knocked him, he was burned to dust. Then Jesus started to walk to the direction he came and I started to fallow him,as I made one step behind Jesus,the humble man I was destroying with the ball embracing me like you put 2 things on the blinder together and the mixed together until you can’t make any different between the two. It took me about 15 years to understand this dream. I do not go to the church anymore since I understand who is Jesus. The creator who spoke to Moses and Abraham,or to any true prophet,he is exist. But he is a different person to Jesus.
Thoroughly enjoyed your hosting
I've been watching the rabbi on tanaktalk for the past year-and-a-half since I've jettisoned Christianity after 65 years
Your heart shows through it's awesome brother
@Abraham Mani not true there is no power in the name or blood of Jesus or Yeshua or hoochie coochie
Christianity is a lie especially that book of Revelation and nobody's coming back to get you
The Creator does not have a son named Jesus the Creator's first begotten son is the nation of Israel his suffering servant his son Army called out of Egypt, all the nation of Israel
Isaiah 43 11 I, even I am the Lord and beside me there is no savior
King 👑 JESUS came back from the dead
April 17 AD 30
Deal with that
Where's the dead body of King 👑 JESUS then?
He is risen❤
@@drb1641 oh I guess that is all the proof we need!
Just sit and wait, maybe he will come back soon,
He may be late according to his words "there be some standing here who shall not taste of death until they see the son of man coming in the clouds of heaven"
Those folks have been dead a long time! Is Jesus taking a nap or stuck on the throne?
"childish" theology!
@@johncrookston6111 be blessed.
@@johncrookston6111even the Torah talks about Jesus.
Rabbi Tovia Singer, I own and read (often) Let's get biblical, and love your discussions. I often bring up your truth nuggets in various settings at church (SDA) and no one seems to care , understand, or accept. It is sad. Thank you though.
Brilliant Derek! The Rabbi is brilliant and been a great source for me over the years too and he is funny ...
That was fantastic! Thanks so much!!
Derek as an atheist who cannot be able access all the infirmation and knowledge, I have learned a lot from Rabbi Tovia Singer. Thanks a lot Derek.
Stop reposting your blather.
Ι will say only one thing. Everyone has the Ι right not to be a Christian for their own reasons. But he has no right to pretend he does not know one thing. That Judaism, or at least what we call Judaism today, has absolutely nothing to do with the Old Testament Jews and their views on the Messiah at that time. Judaism today is what partly benefits them from the Old Testament and the invented Talmud and Kabbalah which were both written AFTER Christ during the medieval times. Both of them, the Talmud and the Kabbalah, annul the Old Testament itself.
ua-cam.com/video/gYfZxkrqS_E/v-deo.html
@abrahammani-3445 psycho
Lose the ego , Arcadia
Every miracle Jesus did was a miracle found in the Old Testament.
Really? Where in the Old Testament someone turned water to wine, cast out demons?
What is the point of your statement?
Show me.
Best podcast ever! You have got to get this Rabbi on again. Learned so much from your channel and look forward to learning much more. I see this was recorded 3 years ago but still in style. Derrick thank you for the awesome content. Now to binge-watch and get caught up.
The earliest completed version of the Christian Old Testament dates back to around 300 A.D., while the oldest completed Jewish Bible dates around 1000 A.D. Given this, it's noteworthy that 2 Chronicles, the final book of the Jewish Bible/Old Testament, concludes with accounts of Jewish kings engaging in sinful actions. Considering the condemnation of these kings for their wickedness, one might wonder whether it's plausible that the nation of Israel could have deliberately edited their Bible version, removing references and prophecies about Jesus. This concept isn't entirely implausible.
The idea that the Earrh is controlled by little green people from the outer space I'd plausible, too. Have you heard of the Occam's razor?
So happy Tovia agreed to this. I love Tovia and his biblical understanding of the Old Testament is unparalleled by Christians.
Zechariah12.10
tovia was so good and i like him:)
Zechariah12.10 Do you think Isaiah is a prophecy of Jesus? what’s Isaiah about, not just Isaiah 53? What’s Isaiah 52 about? What’s the last word in Isaiah 52? Christians have repeatedly misused Isiah as some sort of prophecy.
@Abraham Mani I don’t care what threats the 2000 year old book of talking animals makes.
I Am Michael .your smart right . I'll assume but not that smart obviously. It says in the Bible God will confound your beliefs , the traditions of men . That would include atheism and agnostics. That God would respond . PR is important. You better believe God can question your beliefs or lack of progress there of . Call the cops , they'll tell you , it's true . Wine to your mother about it . She might know more than you , Michael is God .
Hell is real!!! Where will you go when you die??? If the rapture took place today, would you be left behind??? Jesus loves you and He died for your sins. Anyone who rejects Jesus Christ will not see the Kingdom of Heaven. Humble yourself to REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior. Mark 1:15 For the Kingdom of God is at hand, repent and believe in the gospel.
One of the most informative guests you have ever had on the show. Way to go Derek. Give us more!
Er, MIS-INFORMATIVE, bitch!
I have a Persian Bible, translated from Hebrew, Chaldean, and Greek languages. I checked the book of Isaiah, the blind bit, is not mentioned.
@abraham mani
That book is great. A collection of old myths from the Middle East. If there was no Bible, we might not know about all those myths.
That's one impressive Rabbi. Cool dude.
I can listen to you for hours
Brothers and sisters this is just a little message to everybody keep believing in the Lord and God and try to do the best you can in life and you'll be fine
I had to rewatch this!💯💯💯 Love You Guys. Very Excellent Gentlemen😎💯😎💯
Great show- thanks- loved it! Quite an eye-opener at times too and love the humour between you!
What a gripping convo!! :)
@Abraham Mani oh ok
My favorite part is when the jewish Rabi is explaining to the ex-Christian that Jesus did in fact exist...
The ex-Christian did not liked it when the so called Rabi said that Jesus did in fact existed 😁. Feeling some guilt and fear I guess 🤣😂
🙏
He talks through his Talmuds & Kabbalah having Egyptian origins, remember it was just not Israel but a mixed multitude that came out of Egypt,
Those converted to Judaism or left by the time of arrival to the Promised Lamd.
What an amazing job you’re doing. The scholarship is amazing that you are bringing to us and I am thrilled by how prolific you have been it must be exhausting but we are thrilled to see a new episode popping up every few days. Thank you for your efforts
The Judaism today has absolutely nothing to do with the Judaism described in the Old Testament. The fact that the Jews now believe in Kabbalah and the Talmud and have FULLY distorted what the Pharisees of the days of Jesus believed is of course unknown to you. Or not...
I would like to know what your opinion is about the current state of Israel which is built on a theological and metaphysical myth and not on objective facts. Are you that negative?
Tovia please debate Don K. Preston.
To believe him requires immense credulity. Certainly have it.
Its amazing how Tovia's incisive mind can believe in the torah. Would love to see him take that on one day.
Well, many highly incisive minds over the millennia have believed in Torah. National Revelation is a tough one to get around. Plus, the unbroken chain of transmission from generation to generation; the falsifiable prophesies vis a vis Jewish history; and the improbable continued existence of the Jewish People despite landlessness and all the various hostile diasporas over thousands of years. Taken as a whole, it's hard not to entertain the possibility that something is going on with Torah and the Jews.
@@dabneydee9109 all of those things are present in other cultures and religions. It is incredibly hard to take the Torah seriously, it's one of the main problems with the Christian Bible, so I fail to see how it's not a problem for Judaism.
@@SnakeWasRight Ok, maybe you're right. I don't know enough about all the cultures and religions of the world to definitively declare the Jews unique in the things I listed. Can you give an example of anther religion that claims national revelation? Or another religion/nation that has ancient ties to a specific land - via its scriptures - that lived out a scripturally-prophesied history of being "vomited out" of their land and returned to that land after 2 millennia of being scattered among many other (often hostile) nations?
I'm not trying to be facetious, nor am I attempting to convince you of anything. You don't have to take the Torah seriously and you are free to believe in whatever you want. It's just that when you assert that "all those things are present in other cultures and religions", I'm not sure that's a true statement.
Exactly what I was thinking!
Sight to the blind is referring to waking the brainwashed sheep up
Great Work Derek! Please continue your work with Rabbi Singer ...
The Quran affirms and attests to the fact that Issa (Jesus) healed people by the Power and Will of God (Allah), not of his own powers.
Definitely… Metaphysically speaking Prophets don’t really perform miracles, it is God alone who does so according to the Abrahamic Tradition.
Trouble is Islam started 7 centuries later than the Christian religion so their source for Jesus is also the Gospels, they don’t have an independent opinion
You don't know how the Quran was put together . You're just as deceived as Christians are. You have no idea about the roots of Allah either. Neither the god of the Jews nor Allah have anything to do with the true Creator God. Wake up!
Love Rabbi Singer, have hm on again!
Mythvison your show is incredible . It's helping immeasurably
Omg 😁😂🤣😂😁😂🤣 Tovia's face when this kid this talking is priceless..... He reminds me of myself in that no matter how tollerent, patient and supportive of others pursuing truth, sometimes you just can hold it in...
What about the Jerusalem Bible it's based on AD BC GREEKS ROMAN AND JEWS NOT JEWISH SO DEFINITELY THERE' ARE MORE QUESTIONS THAN ANSWERS THANKS FOR THE INFORMATION ALSO KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK
The Judaism today has absolutely nothing to do with the Judaism described in the Old Testament. The fact that the Jews now believe in Kabbalah and the Talmud and have FULLY distorted what the Pharisees of the days of Jesus believed is of course unknown to you. Or not...
I would like to know what your opinion is about the current state of Israel which is built on a theological and metaphysical myth and not on objective facts. Are you that negative?
@@etinarcadiaego7972 the Pharisees are the authors of the first part of the Talmud, the Mishnah. The religion of Orthodox Jews is the religion of the Pharisees.
@@etinarcadiaego7972 it's fake
Hell is real!!! Where will you go when you die??? If the rapture took place today, would you be left behind??? Jesus loves you and He died for your sins. Anyone who rejects Jesus Christ will not see the Kingdom of Heaven. Humble yourself to REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior. Mark 1:15 For the Kingdom of God is at hand, repent and believe in the gospel.
Rabbi is spitting facts here.
Spitting fire - pure fire! Absolutely 👍
@@richardearnshaw2719 strange fire
Rabbi singer i find everything youve said facinating great interview myth vision
I agree a lot with Tovia Singer except for the fact that he's a rabbi and therefore an apologist for the first part of the most incredible story ever told
a great guest, very entertaining and educational. I am glad you have had him on several times!
Bless Rabbi Tovia Singer a great man dedicated to truth entirely
Except when it comes to the Torah.
I like to see Rabbi Tovia expose some Old Testament lies just to show that he isn't only pointing his finger away from himself and his own unfounded beliefs. Scammers calling out scammers is beneath decency.
If the old testament is false, so is the new one. ☠☠☠
Here are Some Examples!!! I agree with Saul of Tarsus corrupting and misappropriating the truth in the Tanakh and also teaching contrary to the Word of GOD Elohim Most High, also given and created in his begotten Yahushua Ha'Mashiah. I don't agree with your position on PERFECT and being Tamim. I found Joe Atwill's book "Caesar's Messiah," to offer an interesting case for Roman authorship of the Gospels. He believes the Gospels are a typology of Josephus's work, "War of the Jews." He noted that certain events described in the Gospels follow the same chronological sequence and locations to be exactly the same as they are recorded in "War of the Jews." Atwill was initially dismissed by academic Biblical scholars from both Christian and non-Christian camps, but on closer examination, some of them saw that Atwill's notations of parallel times and places were consistent between both works. Atwill further speculated that these writings may have been intended initially for the amusement of the Flavian court as they recounted the exploits Vespasian and Titus as parodies. Then somewhere along the line, they saw these writings as useful tools of propaganda to pacify the peoples of the Eastern Mediterranean. The motive is certainly plausible. With the destruction of the Jewish nation, Jews were scattering to other parts of the region and beyond. What better way would there be than to marginalize them by converting non-Jewish people to a religion that supports Roman Rule and chastises rebellious Jews?
How is he scamming ? Explain
Bless you Rabbi! I really enjoy your episodes, I like Mythvision, but especially when the Rabbi is on. All the best you guys
1 Corinthians 1:22-25
[22] For Jews demand signs and Greeks seek wisdom, [23] but we preach Christ crucified, a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Gentiles, [24] but to those who are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God. [25] For the foolishness of God is wiser than men, and the weakness of God is stronger than men.
🙏
This is amazing. Rabbi Tovia Singer has a delightful sense of humor I love to see people who can remark upon the patent absurdity demonstrated by the cultists
Isaiah 35
“Then will the eyes of the blind be opened
and the ears of the deaf unstopped.
Then will the lame leap like a deer,
and the mute tongue shout for joy.
Also Daniel quoting messiah will die/cut off....
"Seventy sevens have been decreed for your people. . . . So you are to know and discern that from the issuing of a decree to restore and rebuild Jerusalem until Messiah the Prince there will be seven sevens and sixty-two sevens; it will be built again, with plaza and moat, even in times of distress. Then after the sixty-two sevens the Messiah will be cut off and have nothing, and the people of the prince who is to come will destroy the city and the sanctuary.”
Once upon a time there was a tribe living in the Middle East that had a collection of sacred texts written in Hebrew, Chaldean and Aramaic. It is the nature of sacred tests to be venerated and transmitted from generation to generation unaltered.
As time passed members of this tribe emigrated to areas where Hebrew and Aramaic and Chaldean were not spoken. A large community settled and prospered in the city of Alexandria in Egypt. Greek replaced their tribal language. They needed an accurate translation of their venerated documents into Greek.
Around 250 B.C. seventy rabbis translated the sacred texts into Greek. This translation was not a bootleg edition. The project was approved by the High Priest and the Sanhedrin in Jerusalem. The Septuagint, the translation of the seventy, was an official document.
A Hebrew Bible exists today. It is used by Jews everywhere. It is called the Masoretic text. It was compiled around 700 A.D. It is almost one thousand years newer than the Septuagint. The rabbis who compiled the Masoretic text were not accountable to the High Priest in Jerusalem. There no longer was a High Priest. The rabbis who compiled the Masoretic text were not accountable to the Sanhedrin in Jerusalem. There no longer was a Sanhedrin.
The Septuagint predates the first appearance of the Masoretic text by almost ten centuries. The Septuagint is based upon Hebrew texts at least twelve centuries older than the texts upon which the Masoretic version is based. Yet, modern Christian translations of the Old Testament rely on the Masoretic Text, not the Septuagint.
Where is the problem?
Most of the quotations from the Old Testament in the New Testament used the Septuagint as their primary source. The integrity and truthfulness of the Septuagint is completely dependent on the Septuagint being a truthful translation. Discredit the Septuagint and there is no New Testament.
There was no controversy about the integrity of the Septuagint from 250 B.C. until 135 A. D.
What had happened to provoke dissatisfaction with the Septuagint among the Jews?
Annas and Caiaphas and the Sanhedrin had rejected the messianic claims of Jesus. The New Testament documents had been written and were circulating by A.D. 70. The Jews knew that the credibility of the Christian Gospels depended on the credibility of the Septuagint. Something had to be done.
Around 95 A.D. Rabbi Akiva, who later proclaimed Bar Kochba as the messiah, hired a man named Aquila to translate a Hebrew to Greek version of the Old Testament that would undermine the messianic claims of Jesus found in the Septuagint. Some scholars believe that the Masoretic text was based in part on this tendentious translation by Aquila.
How is the Masoretic text different from the Septuagint?
Psalm 22:16 the word “pierced” has been replaced by “lion”.
Psalm 145: 13 omitted entirely.
Isaiah 53:11 the word “light” is omitted.
On 134 occasions the Tetragrammaton, the name of God, has been replaced by “Adonai”.
Psalm 151 was omitted entirely. (It is now omitted by almost all Christian Bibles !)
Exodus 1: The number 75 replaced by 70
Genesis 10:24 some generations removed.
Deuteronomy 32:8 “Angels Of Elohim” replaced with “children of Israel.”
Jeremiah 10 verses 6 and 7 have been added in the Masoretic.
Psalm 96:10 “Say among the nations, YHWH reigns from the wood” omitted.
Isaiah 19:18 “city of righteousness” changed to the “city of the sun” or in some versions “the city of destruction.”
The Masoretic scribes purposely and willfully rearranged the original chapter order in the prophetic Book of Daniel, so that the chapters make no sense chronologically.
Isaiah 61:1 “recovery of sight to the blind.”. Omitted.
In Psalm 40:6 “a body you have prepared for me” was replaced by “you opened my ears.”
Deuteronomy 32:43 ‘Let all the messengers of Elohim worship him.’” Omitted.
Genesis 4:8: “Let us go into the field” is omitted.
Deuteronomy 32:43. Moses’ song is shortened.
Isaiah 53 contains 10 spelling differences, 4 stylistic changes and 3 missing letters for light in verse 11, for a total of 17 differences.
Isaiah 7:14. “Virgin” replaced by “young woman.”
(When Aquila made his Greek translation of the Old Testament at the behest of Rabbi Akiva, he changed the Septuagint’s “virgin” into “young woman”. The Masoretic compilers may have followed his lead.)
The Masoretic text differs from the Septuagint in hundreds of places.
How do we know which text is accurate?
The Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered just after World War II.
According to carbon dating, textual analysis, and handwriting analysis the documents were written at various times between the middle of the 2nd century BC and the 1st century AD. There are fragments from all of the books of the Hebrew Bible fragments except the Book of Esther and the Book of Nehemiah.
In addition an independent Aramaic translation of the Hebrew Bible exists, the Peshitta.
Control of the Dead Sea Scrolls was a military objective of Israelis. It was achieved by their victory in the Six Days War.
The publication of the scrolls slowed to a trickle.
After 1971, the international team even refused to allow the publication of photographs of the material. They excluded scholars who wanted to make independent evaluations.
The embargo was not broken until 1991.
An addition to the Dead Sea Scrolls, scholars can use the Peshitta to decide between the Masoretic text and the Septuagint.
I have given examples above of some of the places the Dead Sea Scrolls, the Peshitta, and the Septuagint agree.
The Masoretic Text is part of a tradition that began with Rabbi Akiva. Rabbis rewrote the Jewish Bible to destroy the credibility of the New Testament.
The Hebrew versions of the Old Testament have been used to proclaim scores of “messiahs” . The Septuagint was only used once.
Thank you. 🙏
I think Singer is wrong, it’s not Luke who added the passage of the blind in Jesaiah 61 and it was than added to the Septuagint. That’s just nonsense. Luke just used the Septuagint like Mathew and other writers of the New Testament. The question should rather be, why was it in the Septuagint in the first place? It’s a translation from the Hebrew which would indicate that there were Hebrew manuscripts that contained that passage which are now lost.
The only problem with your point is, if you check up the history of the Septuagint, only the first five books of Moses were translated. The rest of Tanak wasn't. So you have been lied to
Rabbi your voice can put me to sleep so soothing
And for 300 years, Christians suffered torture and death for the lies the apostles told them ❓️
Yes.
Without Jesus, ALL will perish into Hellfire
And how is that related to the topic?
@@CaesarRenasci It relates to Rabbi Tovia going to Hell if he doesn't Trust in Jesus Christ who is Lord God and Saviour. You too if you're an unbeliever.
Somehow I got this im my suggestions by listening to a metal band called Testament. I started watching this video and found it fascinating, now I'm watching more of this Rabbi. I'm also a atheist. Lol
Your work really gives me hope in the future. Much gratitude.
Finding out how the New Testament came to be has completely change my mind on everything. If Jesus did exist I think he was preaching Gnosticism and the Roman’s put their Greek mythological spin on it
Can you die on the cross within 6 hours even if you have perfect weather? Yes, you can if you lose blood heavily from flogging and resulting wounds for more than 12 hours continously.
Thanks Derek! The Rabbi’s knowledge is humbling and inspiring. Great stuff guys!
@Zechariah12.10 It's not true that there wasn't a Hebrew version containing the version from Luke 4:18. There was. The similarity of that passage which opens Isaiah 61 to the one in Isaiah 42 is striking. I say this as one who is not in any way a Christian whatsoever. It's just that this (what's said about this matter in the video) is an invalid criticism of Christianity.
@Abraham Mani Okay. Well, I actually have come to basically believe that Revelation was originally a Gnostic book and that the king who rules during the end times referred to as "the Beast" is actually Dowid Ha Melekh, while the so-called "false prophet" is Eliyahu whom the "Old Testament" also portrays as returning during the end times. Both the "false prophet" and Eliyahu are described as calling down fire from heaven in the sight of men, for one thing, and given that the Gnostics refer to the God of the Jews and of Abraham as a "false god", so too would they refer to His prophets as "false prophets". This is not to mention the parallels between the "kings" associated with the "Beast" and Dragon and those kings/archons Gnosticism portrays as being associated with "Yaldabaoth", its depiction of the God of Abraham, and many other indications of the humanistic, psychopathic, Gnostic origin of the book.
@@Tsadi9Mem9Khet9 for sure. Let’s talk about Isaiah 42 Rabbi
@@DD_Davey I am not a rabbi nor even a Jew, but sure: That chapter describes apostasy based on the lure of paganism. Christianity is the ultimate and most insidious example of such luring of Jews away from the Jewish system, including the priesthood, which most of the prophets belonged to. Christianity is the most disturbing example of such enticement toward apostasy because it blasphemously claims that exactly what was good for the Romans, such as the rejection of the Torah and submission to THEIR law, is what the God of the Jews wills.
ua-cam.com/video/gYfZxkrqS_E/v-deo.html
Rabbi Tovia Singer is an amazing rabbi!
He's a fraud
It is always great to see Rabbi Singer debating a Christian Apologist because he blows them away with his knowledge.
He is far more expert on the Christian testament than ANY Christian!
Mhm.
When the young man in Matthew asks Jesus what he had to do to get to heaven, Jesus says "keep the commandments". That's it. In Acts the disciples ask Jesus when he was going to restore the kingdom to Israel. THAT was the job of a messiah. He simply failed to get the job done.
So lost.
Love this guest
Meeting the virgin Mary every day for lunch I love it
@Abraham Mani A Christian threatening someone with hell carries as much weight as a child warning an adult that they won’t be getting any presents from Santa.
@Abraham Mani kick rocks
@Abraham Mani BOO!
Hell is real!!! Where will you go when you die??? If the rapture took place today, would you be left behind??? Jesus loves you and He died for your sins. Anyone who rejects Jesus Christ will not see the Kingdom of Heaven. Humble yourself to REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior. Mark 1:15 For the Kingdom of God is at hand, repent and believe in the gospel.
@@ChristianSoldier71There is no rapture.
I don't agree with the rabbi but respect his way of teaching. He seems sincere. If I ever had a debate with someone Jewish I would hope that they carry themselves accordingly. From what I understand the Septuagint was actually written by Jews for the Greek rulers of the time. So it could be included in their vast library. And I read more of the Old Testament these days because I believe that both Testaments are important at this point in history..
WE NEED THE HOLY SPIRIT TO UNDERSTAND THE BIBLE CORRECTLY.
St. Luke 24:25 He said to them, "How foolish you are, and how slow to believe all that the prophets have spoken!
St. Luke 24:26 Did not the Messiah have to suffer these things and then enter his glory?"
St. Luke 24:27 And beginning with Moses and all the Prophets, he explained to them what was said in all the Scriptures concerning himself.
Really great conversation! You guys have an amazing dynamic! Love it! :)
😂🤣😁
Why do we even have going-on-churches these days? Use them as departments/shelters for homeless people instead.
The problem without solution of judaism is that never was a prophet saying that would be a great fake messiah.
This is because the Creator sends a person ready to be a Messiah in every generation, but He decides whether the world is ready for his work.
@@CaesarRenasci That is another jewish tale and is not writen anywhere in the Bible. G has sent only 1 jewish messiah for all world for all time and the world does not need more jewish messiahs. Only JC has the title Messiah in all history of the world. Jews wait their messiah, not another messiah.
The Hebrew we have today is not the true ancient Hebrew language. Today's language It is a modern dialect. A waste of time to learn it or read anything written it.
What’s the ancient Hebrew? That of the Samaritans (proto-Hebrew)?
@@LordJagd The Smartians where half-breds or as they are call bi-racial. They the offspring the Hebrews who married strange women in Samaria. They were half Hebrew. According scripture God made them put their wives and children away.
Going back and marathoning!!! So many great videos...so little time😀💪💜
It is very interesting to observe Rabbi Tovia's way he express and talk (from psychological point of view). Before he tells what he wants to tell he puts huge label on his conclusion. "It's going to blow your mind away" , "Have to sit on the chair with your gravity centred" ...) and he is revolting that label on and on. Rabbi Tovia you just didn't convince me.
Gravity doesn’t exist.
He Has Convinced me Along Time Ago!!! Here are some Examples!!! I have not been a burden to you. Yet, crafty fellow that I am, I caught you by trickery! - Paul. Paul taught against the alliance Genesis17 exodus12 Joshua 5 numbers9 John 7 : 23 acts7: 8 Ezekiel 44 8 - 9 Luke 2 : 21.. He twisted scripture he is a Pharisee which Jesus warned of. t literally took me only the first 5 chapters of 1st Corinthian’s to realize Saul tried to puff himself up and contradicts Jesus. False teacher. First Paul killed believers in the flesh, then he attacked them spiritually. Paul with his duality: either the "law" or "grace" - and the Apostle John, "keep the commandments". With this argument against Paul totally destroys the catholic church's apostolic succession. Paul taught against the alliance Genesis17 exodus12 Joshua 5 numbers9 John 7 : 23 acts7: 8 Ezekiel 44 8 - 9 Luke 2 : 21.. He twisted scripture he is a Pharisee which Jesus warned of. First Paul killed believers in the flesh, then he attacked them spiritually. Paul with his duality: either the "law" or "grace" - and the Apostle John, "keep the commandments". With this argument against Paul destroys the catholic church's apostolic succession. I would make a couple of corrections: 1. It's just a "Greek proverb"; Paul is directly quoting from Euripides play from which he ripped off the entire conversion story and this quote is word for word stolen from the play. 2. He is not "Pharisee Saul"; there is no evidence whatsoever that he had a Jewish background or any Jewish training and there is no evidence that he was from the house of Benjamin. He was a Roman. 3. The "first love" that the church was told to return to was referring to the Torah, to keeping the Commandments. With that said, this is a pretty good break down of the evidence that proves Paul was a false apostle. Excellent video Rabbi Federow and Steve! The differences between Deuteronomy 30:11-14 and Romans 10:6-9 are really quite shocking. The Scripture could not be more clearer! But the natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him; nor can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned. I Corinthians 2:14 NKJV. Jesus didn't come back and rule the world before his disciples died like he said he would in Matthew 16! Jesus said in Matthew I come not for peace but for the sword, Jesus said in Matthew 22 the world will not have love or marriage he was wrong don't pray for us we don't need your modern Jesus we rolled the dice love is cool in Danny Gallagher Paradise, UA-cam Portugal the man live Lala 2018. Paul was changing word of God all the time. He even contradicts Himself and James! The New Testament is Complete nonsense. I was raised Atheist. Looked for Christianity for the last few years but felt really silly trying to worship some Dude who was probably a good political agitator and public speaker but a saviour??? (Goes right against not having any other God) I now have a better perspective. I am also relieved to hear that is much more forgiving NSW highway patrol. Corinthians 12:16 Be that as it may>
Thanks!
Thank you so much for the support my friend 🧡
Hi rabbi. I’m an Orthodox Jew and wouldn’t delete my comment. You said over here that most rabbis would agree that the Talmud is talking about Jesus. But another more recent video you said it can’t be because it’s a totally different time period. Love your videos btw.
Rabbi Singer is not only brilliant he’s also hysterical.
Why don’t you do a video with Tovia about Old Testament criticism
😁
That is to mend the broken hearted, how do you do this if my mom were blind it would break my heart so Jesus made her see again healing my broken 💔
At the time of Jesus, Jewish people spoke Arameo, not Hebrew; and given the dominance of the Hellenic world, Jesus was most likely reading from the Septuagint version of the Tanak.
The people spoke Aramaic in daily life but they nearly always, except for a couple of books (example, the book of Esther) read the texts in Hebrew.
Rav Tuvia is a genius. Hhazak ubarukh.
Yet the UA-cam ads are an extreme interference every few sentences and another xxxx ad. More than in movies or music clips. I'm wondering if UA-cam is purposely interfering
Only from Rabbi Tovia Singer, we can know the true about christianity.
It’s so sad that most people are so scripturally ignorant (including Pastor’s), that it truly is a case of the blind leading the blind.
Thank you ❤
For those of us who have not spent much time with these texts, some breakdowns explaining why these revelations and discrepancies are so meaningful would be great. It’s a bit lost on me.
It's all on his channel.
The discrepancies are meaningful because Christianity makes fantastic claims about Tanach (so-called "Old Testament"). Christianity claims to be the fulfillment of Tanach, and the Church the replacement of the Jewish People. The NT has a series of "proofs" to demonstrate how this is so. When you examine these proof-texts against the original Hebrew Scriptures, they fall apart. There are so many misquotes, mistranslations, phantom verses, and so on.
Mark effectively says there was no virgin birth. His family thinks he lost his mind. 3:21,33-35.
That would not be the case if they thought Mary had been a virgin.
The biggest miracle Jesus performed was the resurrection of Lasarus from the dead after 4 days and of course his own resurrection and not the healing of the blind as you incorrectly claim
I used to avoid Rabbi Singer because of Dr. Mike Brown saying he was a liar then "using" scripture to refute him. I've since gone down the rabbit hole and wow! Shout out to this channel and Dr. BART EHRMAN!
Brilliant guy, funny guy, great interview.
Derek, you rule brother! What a fantastic guest! I love the raw information without opinion, just the facts.
So when die call on Derek's name you'll be alright
@@E.Concep456 What?
Don't listen to Derick they are talking against Jesus
@@E.Concep456 so am I.
@@E.Concep456 shut up.
Wow😂😂😂😂 the level of pure energy used to purposely mislead the masses. Book of Isaiah discusses what Jesus would do when he comes...not once but twice. The way he belittles it is amazing😂😂
What you are Reading is a Corruption of Old Testament by Church of Niacin! The Old testament remains Unchanged since it was Written. Who Gave the Church of Niacin the Right to Corrupt the Bible i,e, Tanakh!!! They Changed the Holy Scriptures that is the Narrative to Fit the Out Right Lies of New Testament!!! Above in Comments is Proof of that!!!
Rabbi singer speaks truth, i have not watched this video, and have seen the rabbi in many other videos, but truth is truth! We must all accept God knows truth! GOD 100% know the truth of all individuals of the past, present, and future, ...i hope and pray i will be healed and all who trust in God will be provided for! Amen!
Wouldn’t the Septuagint be a scroll not a book, at that time period, if Jesus is stated reading from a scroll?
It was in Egypt. It was manufactured for the Greek King Ptolemy of Egypt. It was never in a synagogue. Why would a Hebrew synagogue in Israel, have a Greek translation from Egypt?
". . . that Mark wouldn't mention a virgin birth?! It's INCONCEIVABLE!" That made me laugh. 😃
Paul McCartney wrote the song let it be… After he had a dream where he saw his mother. His mother died when he was 14 years old.
This is a real eye opener !!
Take everything Christianity tells you and turn it around 180° and you will start in the right direction.
@Abraham Mani I well know yeshua but deny Jesus.
@@casper8662 The Judaism today has absolutely nothing to do with the Judaism described in the Old Testament. The fact that the Jews now believe in Kabbalah and the Talmud and have FULLY distorted what the Pharisees of the days of Jesus believed is of course unknown to you. Or not...
I would like to know what your opinion is about the current state of Israel which is built on a theological and metaphysical myth and not on objective facts. Are you that negative?
@@etinarcadiaego7972 not a part of Judaism, don't follow it, nor study it. I do read the scriptures, from the very first page to the end. Must be why I am not a fan of Christianity.
@@casper8662 since you don't know the historical context and don't have a wide variety of knowledge it's very easy to consider as right some random UA-camrs or a biased rabbi....
I don't care about the way you "read" the scriptures either way. Cause it's false
@@casper8662 you don't study Judaism, you don't know it BUT you still have an opinion. The fact that Talmud and Kaballah derive from the Gnostic philosophy of the 70 AC and are almost similar to philosophical satanism (eg Dönmez Jews) doesn't bother you. And you trust a biased rabbi that thinks he's God's chosen one 🤡
Maybe he can also do one on the lies in the Old Testament?
Have nothing to say on the subject? Why say anything, then?
@@CaesarRenasci have no meaningful answer to my question? Why post anything then?
This is amazing thank you.
Correction for typing mistake......
Brother Rabbi....