Thank you so much to UA-cam for making it possible to produce this important episode of Middle Ground. We want to say thank you to our participants but also to our audience for always enabling respectful and meaningful conversation in our comments. We know this discussion does not address all aspects or perspectives of this very deep and historical conflict, but we did our best to represent as many perspectives as we could. For those of you that don’t know, Jubilee's philosophy for Middle Ground is to bring people together and have an open dialogue in order to develop a deeper sense of understanding and empathy. We hope you all enjoy :) If you felt as moved as we did by the conversation, please share the video to as many people as you can!
Islam is a great religion of peace ! I mean , their countries are shitholes who oppress the right of basically Everyone , but other than That , islam is a great religion of peace !
6:23 the blonde girl just made a hole in my heart this is such a smart way to talk to communicate And on a more general meaning, I feel like even though there is so much emotion involved everyone is able to make proof of calm and empathy, express mostly calmly, let each other talk and be able to understand all of the unsaid put in game by the barrier of language. Like it was a bit harsh I think to talk like that to each other and except a few slips, it was great. And also I appreciate the fact that the people involved were from different social classes
The Palestinian guy in the white t-shirt didn't smile even once. You can clearly see that when he lost his 10 year old sister in front of his eyes, his vision in life completely changed
I never experienced it in my life but I try to imagine someone's daughter being mutilated in front of you sends shivers through me. My love and prayers extend to all the Palestinians
Jubilee you MUST discuss this again, especially with what is currently going on now. Also please reach out to Arab too, he had so much to say and it would be interesting to hear him again
I'm sure the Israeli people could be contacted cause they're most likely 100% safe - alive and breathing ... but the Palestinians... well we can only pray they are still alive and well. They probably have much more pressing concerns right now than this... like protecting their families, themselves, their neighbours or just mourning over the loss of their homes, their livelihood and everything they've known. And quite frankly I think it would be extremely insensitive for them to be forced to play calm right now and hide their hurting after all the trauma their people are going through.
@ And that's happened in front of their school. Shot in the head in front of her brother and her other school friends. Even if its not my own sister but my friend its still will bring trauma for me. I still remember it till now the image of my friend's foot that had blood stain on it under the white sheet that covered her dead body when ambulance brought her home after she got hit by car on the street when I was in elementary school. Cant imagine it if I see my own sister got shot in front of me :(((
@@RealAnita926 you mean the guy who's an exec at a billionaire-backed, right-wing think tank? yeah, I wouldn't trust him if he told me the sky is blue.
Sonya Orak Sonya Orak well I’ll rephrase it for him since he wasn’t speaking in his first language : “ I was born to live but my sister was born to be murdered by a soulless soldier. “ , now go ahead and be a smartass .
Sonya Orak so you’re trying to justify shooting a 10 year old girl? Give me a break. As the Israeli guy in the video said “ they ( the soldiers) are only ordered to shoot if they feel like someone is a threat to them. “, and I can’t imagine that the guy you are trying to defend felt in danger by this girl.
Sonya Orak oof you don’t get his point smartass. My sister was born to die -> she was young, barely lived her life in war and she got killed before experiencing it. Meaning she was still a baby (no smartass, not a biological baby) and barely experienced life. Life had not started for her and she got killed. What’s so hard about understanding what he meant?
Sonya Orak : Humans are born to die, death is inevitable. His sister was born to be taken early and he was born to be sat in this interview giving his side, everyone’s purpose is different! From a ‘biblical’ perspective where does it say we have no free will? Where does it promote violence? And where does it say when you are enlisting as a solider where you go on to PROTECT LIVES, you end up taking an innocent one who must have been half if not quater his age? We humans are capable of many things, definitely peace included, you see it’s natural because it comes from within the heart! But if we do talk about ‘natural behaviour’, Cain whom killed his brother was left as a prime example to the world and was left as a ‘fugitive’ and ‘wanderer’ and ‘cursed’. As humans have elvolved today, i can happily say we learn from mistakes, Cain became a warning for those who needed it! Plus Less than 1% of deaths are caused by homocide (globally) the rest of the 99% are actually dying naturally! We are all born with some purpose in life..Just have to find yours!
I think its a terrible story. Because he told his son he had a daughter to die essentially. What a f'd up thing to say. I would never justify something like that to anyone it was a ridiculous story. And to the others is this thread. Thousands of jews died defending their homeland
lol but the israeli guy who lost 20+ friends its fine for you. just shows that you dont really care about who lost who, you just hate israel and love arabs
@@smexybear9845 but who started the conflict. imagine real quick if wherever you live/are from got taken over by another country and were like okay so yeah this isnt your country anymore sorry. plus many more Palestinians died in the hands of idf and they had a right to defend themselves. furthermore in one of the wars Palestinians fought with stones but the the idf fought with guns
Jack Zara G-D gave that land to the Hebrews. If G-D hated Esau for giving up his birthright G-D will hate Israel for giving up its promised land to palestine. Judgement day will be based on how they treated Zion. Iran, Russia, Syria, Libya, and other nations will be destroyed and will name the messiah king of kings and lord of lords and having a long lasting period of peace.
Noah Remnek we are talking politics here. religion is not an excuse for killing people nor it justifies the israeli appropriation of the palestinian lands. y’all catholic people are constantly expecting respect without giving it back and are always playing the victims of the situation
Noah Remnek i don’t care what book you romanticize, still not a good argument to bring into politics and especially when the safety of a community of people is at stake and their dignity and the preservation of their human rights is endangered
@@Enkubuss Thats Rich White Ashkenazi European Jewish Zionist privilege and that mindset are the problem as the guy in the suit so clearly showed. It showed how he and his ilk, his social class, control most of the power, capital, judicial and political resources and they run Isreal and have decided they are not giving up the land, Palestine, and neither is the IDF, and that it will be over the dead bodies of as many Palestinians as it takes. That's the message he was sending in his inability to acknowledge the history of the land. He is of a cold heart. Something that is not yours can not be given to anyone else. World War 2 was horrible but Britain can not give you the ancestral home of an indeginous people especially when they are currently residing there. Any nation would normally consider the giving away of your land by some other nation without the consensus of the palestinian people about how they felt about giving up part their land as a gift to a group of people so grievously violated by the results of WW2 as were many other groups of people, were an act of war. That would be a hostile action and would be an alien invasion that anyone would and should meet with resistance in the defense of the family and home. If any land was owed to them it lies somewhere in Europe mainly German lands. As Germany can give away their own land to a people they managed to have their homes stolen from them through their part as the Axis in WW2. They could build their own small European nation there and thrive. That's the only other thing that is owed in reparations for the Holocaust is a blood free land for Palestinians to call their own. If Jews don't want land in central Europe then give it to Palestinians to develop for themselves in repayment to their violated rights of safety family and home.
If someone told me they lost their 10yo sister in those tragic circumstances the first thing I would say is "I'm very sorry for the loss you and your family suffered". That's it. Nothing else needs to be said, no need to turn attention to yourself or make statements which make it seem as if you are defending the person that did it.
exactly. and the fact that he pulled out the "who suffered more" card and compared the death of family by the IDF to deaths of the very IDF soldiers who were already at risk of death and who very much took the lives of innocent Palestinian citizens is absolutely revolting. The way he said it and pulled out the list and tried to gain sympathy points by saying he "doesn't know which grave to visit first" seems like he's manipulating the audience to feel bad for him over the "27 friends" rather than the family.
Yeah, the way he was saying like I was never ordered to shoot someone unless there's a threat. So was the israeli soldier ordered to shoot the 10 years old child? Why did he shot her? Was a 10 years old going to school a threat to Israel? His friends from IDF joined the IDF while putting their lives on line, knowing they will probably die in the line of their duty. While a normal civilian family does not wake up every morning knowing they will be shot. But these Palestinian civilians do. They wake up knowing they'll probably be killed that day, not because they joined the military knowing that, but simply because they were born into this world.
anne smith but not all the Arab countries want to get involved, the strongest weapon Palestinians have are rocks Israelis have bombs, who do you think is innocent
The Israeli girl in glasses gives me some hope. She talks about empathy, and she obviously understands the pain that Palestine goes through. People like her are needed on both sides for this conflict to end.
@@kolerp1261 Nor can it be ruled solely on malice. Empathy can bring net benefit to a country. Better relations and compromise lead to increased trade, less conflict, less spending needed for military and defense which can then go to public services etc.
@@DalleDayul empathy is a human behaviour. It exists in everyone except in psychopaths, which are 1% of the population. All people feel empathy for people who suffer. But it's not a way to reach conclusions, it's not logic. She asks how did he determine it's his country and he gave good answers. Empathy is not one of them. If I look sad it doesn't mean China belongs to me. A lot of Israelis are sad about the Palestinian situation, if anything it's you guys who feel no empathy for the Israeli side, and ignore the fact that Jews always lived here, and bought a big chunk of the land. For example, I lost a friend. He was 10 when a Palestinian woman came into a peaceful restaurant, and decided to blow him up with his grandparents and cousin. I've never heard of a Jew doing such a thing, and being praised. I'm really grateful for the wall the wall that "separates" us, until you all decide that your greed is less important than life.
@@Abilliph I believe it is important to apply empathy as you also apply logic to create a solution. They are not mutually exclusive. I have to ask myself, is there enough empathy on either side. If one side lays down its arms, and just asks to live their lives, will the other side allow it? So empathy for the plight of your adversary, with whom you seek peace, is necessary to take into consideration when reaching any lasting agreement.
@@lamox13s so you should end the building of a Jewish state in the land of Israel? Zionism has stopped existing when Israel was founded. Today, it's just people trying to live their life, and create a barrier between them and greedy people, who will never agree to a state unless they have everything.
The Palestinian guy really broke my heart. He still cares about other sights feelings despite his murdered sister. I'm sure his gorgeus heart can beat this hatred.
@@smexybear9845 I'm sorry for his lost. I can't ignore his pain but he said that he lost his FRIENDS. Other guy lost his sister and we don't know if he lost his friends. He didnt mentioned about it. Anyway the point is forgiving and respecting other side despite the prejudice and hatred. We mustnt compare their pain. İts the reason of ongoing war.
17:55 The dude keeps saying he doesn't believe in violence, but then he also doesn't believe in peace between the 2 sides, he isn't willing to compromise, he won't allow a second state, and he requires that the state is ruled by Israelian sovereignty... Dude, you might have a list of 27 names, but you didn't name one sibling or parent. Stop acting like the only victim.
That’s the thing, as long as HAMAS exists and the majority of the Palestinian people are okay with its regime, there cannot be peace between Palestine and Israel. That’s a fact. Remove HAMAS and peace will be achieved in days
The Israelis have agreed a two state solution many times, only to have it thrown in their faces. This guy is simply being a realist. I’m sure all of those people and any one of us of reasonable mine, would agree that a two state solution would be wonderful - it’s simply not possible when the islamists that govern Palestine want all Jews out/dead!
@@Decimator69420that’s just untrue, it’s not like if Hamas was gone the Gaza Strip would just be free to exist. If you want “peaceful” coexistence with Israel look at the West Bank where there are countless unfair actions taken against Palestinians.
It’s so sad having been in Israel for about a month and getting to know Israeli and Palestinians alike., they’re all just regular people trying to provide for themselves, their families. Even the Israeli soldiers are at average, 18, 19 year olds. It’s so heartbreaking that they were all born into this conflict.
There is a deep pain and sadness in the eyes of the Palestinian guy. I don't know how he could sit with them and tried to pretend that it's okay but he is dying inside. I hope he finds happiness and peace in his life.
Man the Palestinian guy is destroyed from inside, I saw him “smile” just two times in this video, and those “smiles” were just because I think he didn’t want to spread sadness, but I think we all agree see pain in his eyes.
@Ștefan Cel Mare no, totally wrong. He is sad because israeli settlers who came from ukraine and russia in 1948 and by using weapons handed to them by britain have slaughtered and killed the children of palestinians, have also killed his beloved ones
@Ștefan Cel Mare how is killing the people with no power and trying to make "peace" with the ones who have power peace? And don't get me started on "their land"
@Ștefan Cel Mare Besides, so what if some people don't want to accept the peace offer? I mean it is called an "offer" for a reason. A burglar comes in and shoots all ur guests in ur home and you are supposed to accept peace with him when he points his knife at you? If not, you are a bad dude? The thing is, it is very very very vividly clear where the right and wrong lies. It is very obvious that the israeli colonization of the holly land is a wrong deed. I am pretty sure if you asked a 5 y.o about it he would say the same thing.
It’s incredible that Palestinians after going through everything from being slaughtered, homes set on fire, ethnic cleansing, forced immigration … they are still willing to sit and have a dialogue. They are still hoping for peace… that’s how much humanity and love they have to their land. This experience humbled me to always seek humanity and peace even in the worst of situations. For Israelis out there you are in the position force and power. Your Religious book promised you a land were indigenous people were living. You have taken many innocent lives to take this land. I hope this experience opens your minds and hearts to peace now. It’s enough blood shed and tears.
at the very end of this video... seeing them Smiling and having a meal with them ,talking....i really cried...how can people be this humble and warm...
Hamas….not the elderly, not the mothers, not the hospitalised, and not the children of Gaza. But that’s who paid for this by a ratio of 1200:30,000 (plus the damage and destruction of every school, hospital, all infrastructure, all means of normal medical, power, food and water services)
The Palestinian guy is still grieving. There's a lot of sadness in his eyes yet what is so heartbreaking is he still believe in peace and empathy despite everything. He isn't bitter and become vengeful when he got all the reasons on earth to be one.
Palestinians: My beloved innocent family members were brutally and mercilessly murdered by Israeli soldiers in front of my eyes... Israeli guy: Here's a list of some random Israeli soldiers who got hit by a pebble thrown by little toddlers terrorists. I wrote them on paper because you know, they're not that important to me. I might forget their names.
I agree. Having lost his sister yet still being the only person who came forward for two-state solution. He looks like one of my Israeli friends who is Jewish. You really can't tell Jews and Arabs apart sometimes. Which says everything really.
@@shrubbygaming8665 the war started in 1948, when the Arabs were pissed at the fact that their land was given to the jews. Since then, Israel has been oppressing Palestinians.
@@SatoYuqi12 key word THEIR land who wouldn’t be pissed that their land was being given to someone else in 1948 the nakbah forced palestinian’s out of there homes who wouldn’t be mad?
@@shrubbygaming8665please do research. Palestinians were literally being pulled out of their homes and told it’s not their land by Israel’s well before October 7 2024. This started before any of us we born. The iron dome was built in 2005 for a reason.
I remember my aunt going to Israel to work as volonteer at orphanage for palestinian kids. When she was asked at airport in Israel about a reason of her trip she told the truth. They kept her for few houres before leting her go and shortened time she could be in Israel. Then when she was leaving this country she heard: no more Israel for you. How could taking care of orphan kids be consider as wrong and harmful for anyone? In what kind of messed up world are we living in?
Thanks for sharing. You hear many instances like this, Doctors Without Borders would have video tapes confiscated or erased. What are they fearful of?? It’s a shame but most people who visit both sides come away with the same impression, Palestinian perspective is not highlighted in mainstream and Israel prefers to keep it that way. Do you know which orphanage?
@@RealYunoCS this is complete stupidity sir! Would you give up on your land , home , family just because of fear?? The little girl was brave and the soldier was scared enough to shot her even tho she is literally a 10 yr old child
@@RealYunoCS The fuck out of others land? Palestinians have lived here for centuries and centuries while Zionists Jews have recently arrived and now because of that power, they’re oppressing Palestinians to say that “this land is ours and we don’t want peace with you”. So go fuck yourself.
the Palestinian guy, i think his name was Arab he just fascinates me. how can u have so much peace inside you after going through all that. u deserve all the happiness in the world!
Humans naturally want peace. It's just the 99% is easily led by the 1% . Were doctrined at youth to look for packs. Ever heard of the phrase divide and conquer? Its a real strategy and works every time.
Arab, a beautiful man. I can see his pain, yet he took his father's words to heart: he is meant to live, so he continue on to live and not let hate envelope his mind.
I find Hannah a very amazing human being, her dad getting murderred by the other side yet she still says no to violence and wanted to end it all by stopping the cycle. Very heroic woman.
how are you so sure given the calling for taqiya and public face saving of muslims. furthermore, muslims are literaly calling to exterminate jewish ppl. How do you know if the tide change and muslims try to off jews she would fight for the jews
It is one of many I am Arab and I know a lot about our Palestinian brothers، our hearts break daily،We are one body if one part of the body suffers the whole body suffers with it All Palestinians has a sad story But the world does not care about them
I’m a Chaldean my family and I had to leave Iraq because of the constant harassment and terrorism from certain groups. My Father served 9 years in the military and my Grandfather was involved in WW2 and the war between Palestine and Israel.
@@lolea8405 You know why no one cares about them? That's because they don't care about themselves. They always lack solidarity and unity among each other. Sad but true. BTW: I'm not Pro-Israeli. I favor the Palestinian cause but one of their tragedies is that they always play the victim role and you know why? Because they lack love for each other and they are dispersed in the whole Arab world.
Coming back to this conversation 5 years later and sharing in the aftermath of the recent violent outbreak. We need to have more hard conversations like this.
For ex: i imagine that my 9th great grandfather had a piece of land and was forced to move out of and then i come all of a sudden to claim that this land is mine after thousands of years and after people already got settled in this place for hundreds of years
@@YoGrannyGotNoKnees yes they did but stop being a she*p and think critically! Hamas is not that powerful to hit hard without israel knowing about it! Like think about it the most well equipped military with all most powerful and intelligent weapons they have and still cannot figure out that Hamas was going to hit them! It’s either the west was selling hard the idea that the military of israel cannot be defeated which turns to be a lie and israel is very weak that some militants can turn it upside down in a blink of an eye 😂 Or there actually a plan that is going on and israel scapegoated its civilians to have a reason behind for race cleansing!
“how about empathy?” such a powerful moment! i literally love that woman so much. she doesn’t just blindly agree with the dude because he is on “her side”.
I remember seeing this for the first time. Opened my eyes to the issue. Then Oct 7th happened and everyone thought the attack happened out of nowhere for no reason.
its insane, people older than me pretending october 7th was when this conflict started. Israel's occupation and idf killings have been happening for decades
Its not rare to see people like the one in suit, because we are brought up the way to mostly suck up the nationalism without thinking about the innocent lives we have to step on to sometimes achieve it
@Lucas Kyte-Tremblay Why are you kidding yourselves? Peaceful actions have already been tried and Israel has stated that they supress peaceful protests even more than violent once. Sorry, educate yourself before you post.
@tanner loehr shut the fuck up anti palestinian israelis started this conflict. crying about hamas when its only a consequence of the genocidal and settler state that funded them in the first place? lol. i'm sorry but it's like crying about slaves finally snapping and fighting back.
@tanner loehr hammas only fired because of what happened in sheikh jarrah and what the IDF soldiers did to the mosque. You cannot expect them to just sit there and continue to be attacked.
@tanner loehr Omg I’m not justifying it but when you put into perspective that israel has killed more civilians in the last 3 days than hamas or al qads (which Palestinians DO NOT claim or condone) has in 10 years, then there should be some sort of thought that yes violence in general is wrong but Israel’s oppressing over Palestinians and the lives they have taken is too much at this point. and secondly don’t ever ever ever say “over that?” how can you be so insensitive, during their month of Ramadan as the Palestinians are peacefully praying, IDF barges in throwing grenades at children, men, and women and ruining the structure inside of this sacred place of worship. A tree then catches on fire outside and the Israeli citizens are on the other side watching it cheering and blasting music and dancing. Next, you cannot “legally” kick Palestinians out of their homes, not again. Do you not know the nakba? Why would they ever let them get away with what they did, AGAIN? im not justifying the rockets but for you to sit here and act like Israel is on the right side is disgusting. do you know how many innocent lives they’ve taken? and about that did you see the Palestinians that were lynched in the streets yesterday by Israeli settlers? Did you see the Israeli settlers also throw rocks at their cars and terrorizing the Palestinians at checkpoints? im not justifying but Israel’s packed with US’s aid. they knew the rockets wouldn’t damage them, lemme guess you forgot about the dome israel has that blocks everything?
Research pls Jews lived in the kingdom of judea for not centuries 3000 years and have been discriminated since then during Roman times a Roman emperor took over the Jewish kingdom and named it Palestine after ww1 British took over Palestine and isreal was formed to protect Jews and obviously was pushed back by Arab nations…
I'm older than South Sudan, does that mean Sudan is justified in retaking South Sudan? The oldest person alive was born in 1907, does that mean the world map should reverse to Pre-WW1 borders? Are you pro-colonisation? This is pretty racist, not gonna lie.
@@HaithamAbdullah-fg2op. All over the world, countries have always been at war with their direct neighbors. You just have to look at the history of the world - most conflicts have started with direct neighbors. The best solution is for everyone to have a country and accept the borders of the other country. As long as your neighbor claims your land, there will never be peace.
hahah yes im first generation here in Israel i mean he is came from Europe it really crazy i agree they souldent let somone like him talk to them he is to radical lol he need to chill
he was the one who killed the 10 year old girl ? No . Therefore your argument is invalid. He can only answer for himself and not for the other soldier who disrepected rules
Thefilipe58 but they also said that if an idf soldier wrongfully murders someone they go to jail yet the guy that murdered the 10 old girl didn’t go to jail so it wasn’t only the soldier that didn’t follow the rules but the idf as a whole since the soldiers represent the idf and their rules
Ehsan Abdullatif the rules are to go to jail if a soldier kills an innocent person ... sometimes is hard to know who shoot, or in which circumstances the innocent girl died... this is war and sadly there are innocent people who on both sides die ... but idf tried its best to try to diminish it ... but it’s naive to think that all innocent deaths will lead to prison in the middle of a war
Thefilipe58 yet it is still an innocent little girls life lost and as you said innocent lives are lost in war that is inevitable but why are the idf seen as soldier of justice and the people in the right and the Palestinians as terrorists, they both have killed innocents, they both fight for what is rightfully theirs so tell me what the difference is since both sides are bombing each other and shooting each other why are Palestine the bad guys?
@@Thefilipe58 it's not a "both sides" situation it's only the palestines who are dying there is a study shows that 50.000 palestines died guess what ? Zero Israeli died why is that u think ? Of course ur going to say it's a war they attacked us blah blah but no, no one kills 50k people in the head because they were threatening u this is ridiculous and needs to stop.
@@Arcaryon no this is a very important topic among other important topics, most of the people are misunderstood by government and rumors, who knows that this topic would change the thoughts of millions of people and also bring peace and prevent upcoming wars.
BIG RESPECT for the PALESTINIAN GUY. You can tell that he was raised in love. Even after such a huge tragedy with his sister, he stayed focused on peace (a peaceful fight). Palestinian people are just like others. We, other nations put them down. Now, we need to bring to the table all we can for them to have a prosperous life in Palestine.
And it's not just an incident. This has become so common unfortunately. Innocent kids and people are killed. Most of the cases are never highlighted and it's a silent funeral and pain to live by. Worst part is people support it even after knowing... Tho majority are just brainwashed and not shown what's happening actually.
@@felixromano3091 if the parents have these things at all they would have set Palestine free ages ago , but all they have is rocks , may god show you how is it feels to lose a brother a sister a daughter a son a nephew by rock hearted soldiers that’s all i can say
Arab (the Palestinian guy) saying, "i hope we all live long and in peace" not knowing what's gonna happen 4 years later (which is now) is heartbreaking. I hope they are all alive.
It only shows how much you don't have any idea of the conflict, they're from the west bank and the war now is taking place in Gaza: two seperated areas far from each other,if you don't even know this simple fact then it's really disappointing. He literally talks about that at 12:00
Yeah, it's unfortunate that the Palestinian Authority promoted a warpath that led to all of this death. This is why I personally don't support terrorism and/or Nazism.
Portugal was ruled by the Spanish for 60 years from 1580 to 1640. But guess what we weren't less Portuguese because of that and we freed ourselves in 1640. Ireland was ruled by the British for 121 years from 1801 to 1922 and they weren't less Irish because of that and freed themselves in 1922. So, I picture the same for Palestine. Even if it takes 200 years, Palestine will be free. ⌚ It's just a matter of time.
The Palestinians have denied every 2 state agreement offered since 1948 because their leaders like Arafat what the land just for Arabs aka Palestinians.
As an Algerian this is remaind me of us Algeria remained occupied by France for 130 years From 1830 to 1962, but we gained our independence and we live in safety today. The Palestinians are our brothers, and I want there to be a state called Palestine in which the Palestinians live.
Please please PLEASE do another one of these with the same people, but this time, bring a translator for Arab. This young man has so much to say, and the world must hear it.
when he said „my grandfathers 14th generation behind is here“ that one hit me hard, 14 generations behind burried on their land but israel says its not their land. this young palästinian made me almost cry.
@@jubaii4142 first of all, at least say Qur’an and not just “their book” if you’re going to make a statement like that. and secondly, you’re incorrect. nowhere does it say in the Qur’an that another man’s faith makes them a mistake. The Prophet (pbuh) showed the utmost respect for his fellow Jewish and Christian neighbours and us Muslims lead by his example as much as the Qur’an. I think you’re possibly thinking of the fact that because Muslims consider Islam the ‘true and final word of God’ that all non-believers will enter Hell. That’s a sort of twisted mentality that’s been slight;y contrived by you, but there is some strand of truth to it, in the sense that each (main) religion believes they are the correct religion and the others are wrong, therefore they won’t get into Paradise. It isn’t an exclusive statement that only relates to Islam, it also it mentioned in Christianity and Judaism. pls don’t spread false facts or contrived and twisted statements. it’s not helping anyone and is just worsening the issue at hand. your comment also had nothing to do with the original comment which was about the grief in the man’s eyes over the loss of his young sister. please look at the context next time.
@@jubaii4142 you cannot say that you’re referring to the Qur’an then switch up and claim to be talking for an entire religion filled with individual thinkers. you only speak for yourself, no one else.
My heart breaks when Arab speaks ; he’s seen it all and experienced the worst this world has got to offer. Regardless he’s still willing to sit down, reason, and understand in an effort to reconcile. That is *HUMANITY* and *MERCY*
@@d.o.p.d.o.p.1775 She lost her father, not her friend. There is a huge difference. But yeah, she's awesome too. Love them both and I hope they're both alive and well.
The brother Arab, is a strong man, may Allah protect him and grant him Sabr. You can see through his eyes; his body language, the difficulties and hardships he has gone through.
Yet seems to have not learned history. Empathy is important, but the problem is that history actually proves this is our land and we have the right to live here. They can also live here too, no one actually stops them from doing so.
@@liamfrederic5203 True, but the Palestinians still use the "this is our land, we live here" card which can be used by Israeli people too. The difference is that the UN gave us the official ownership over this land.
@@ihatethisusernameupdate I understand that and I don't think I can truly judge it, not living there. I like what Tchelet said, that that you have the power now gives you more responsibility. I don't think one side is right or wrong as a whole but the notion that an ideology should be worth more than a life is. I hope the two sides talk to each other more like this.
I can't stop crying every time I look into Arab's eyes and I know there are too many like him and him willing to sit down and hear that Palestine isn't his home you can tell what he went through.
can we appreciate how the palestenian guy had his sister shot right infront of him by an Israeli soldier and despite all the pain he went through he still signed to this and managed to shake hands with one of them, what a beautiful soul..
@@procon3080 no. All because of, for example, the soldier that killed his sister. Don't shift blame around. The guy that pulled a trigger on a child is the one at fault no matter how u spin it.
I came back to rewatch this today, and it really hit me...they might not be alive today. Or their families. My heart goes out to so many human beings in this country.
The Palestinians should be alive, they are from the West Bank and Jerusalem, not Gaza. I would love a follow up as well or at least a link to their social media of they have any. They (Palestinians) all spoke so eloquently and calmly.
Very true, but he's not hateful or spiteful. He has not let his heart rot, but has instead maintained his values. He has not given them the reaction they wanted. He is strong.
@@Ethiopianexposer Yeah.. It's in the bible... Israel will be divided... But in the end Jesus will rise Israel again and he will judge the people who divided it...
@@johanna3381 No.. I'm saying that every country will be judged by Jesus... Even Israel... And in the end God will create a new world.. And also a new Israel.. And that Israel is different... Read the bible...
I can only imagine how uncomfortable it felt for the Palestenian guy not to be able to express his ideas because of the language it felt like he had too much to say but the language was an obstacle. Also, I really liked when they showed they don't fear the other side that was really powerful and deserves respect.
@@RussianBot1998 Its not ID POL to recognize the fact that, someone who knows that their ancestry is from another country should be self aware enough to recognize that they are far less qualified to tell a native what is not their land. I don't even personally recognize the moral authority of the (any) state or country.. but you cannot tell me i don't belong somewhere i was born and my father(s) are all buried. *It's not saying "This is NOT your homeland" to say that "this is clearly my homeland". notice the difference? Too many people are conflating people with the state. Some of us want nothing to do with state or law enforcement but rather are only interested in preservation of peace and human rights. * To disregard all of these types of people as mere casualties of war is the key pervasive ideological problem. Military violence towards civilians, especially when those deaths outnumber that of combatants, should never be regarded as mere casualties of war. There should be nothing casual about civilian death in legitimized war because there are in fact rules to modern warfare.
the guy in white Tshirt bought tears to my eyes his words and thoughts were so beautiful Also how the other Palestinians were calm and composed even after their personal loss.....huge respect to the blonde girl in specks she was a beautiful soul and had empathy
I don't like how everyone is being happy about the israel girl that "supports the lost of palestinians" while not looking on the other side israelis lost people too especially this time
I WATCHED this video long ago. But now again it has even more meaning. Very sad too how some had to keep correcting what they said, even though they said it clear the first time. Especially when it came to the simple word PEACE.
The most heartbreaking thing for me is many things... the one that stood out is when the Palestine guy was talking about his sister and what his dad told him about her death. And the other guy responds with.... that's just words or a saying. So rude. I get that too, he probably had watch what he said since he was enlisted in the military.
I have sooo much respect for Arab (the palestanian guy) in every way possible. I admire his (mental)strength, empathy, maturity, ideology etc., just LITERALLY *EVERYTHING* .
The Palestinian guy was just showing how a Muslim should react.The way he looked at things and explaining himself,despite the language difficulties,was great.I honestly felt he was the one who wants peace the most.I hope they all have it soon 🙏
Smash 456 it’s not implying in Islam this is exactly how a Muslim is suppose to act no hatred no violence just talking being open minded being peaceful
We all came back to this video for the same reason and with what has been going on recently, this episode is even more heartbreaking than the first time I watched it.... Praying for Palestine
Same... How can you look someone in someone's eyes-- someone who was *born and raised* on that land-- and tell them that it isn't theirs? It hurts my heart...
Because God gave the Israelites that land, then people kind of settled there, and then called it Palestine. Hence the conflict Israel wants the land back, bc it was Gods given right, but Palestine believes that is their land, and maybe wants to expand as well. Just saying conflict ain't it. Property isn't everything but that's what's happening
I'm with the Israeli soldiers 100% ... just imagine that you are a soldier what is the first thing you do when you see a little girl Of course you'll shot her
As a Palestinian, my Anger issues could never Handle The Israeli Guy, Saying that its not your Land, What do u mean my 9th Great Grand Father Was born In this Land, It was ours, it is ours, and it will be Ours. Peace
Do not confuse private property with an organization such as the state. Furthermore, some Jews lived there as early as the 12th century. So what? In Hebron, Jews lived continuously until 1929.
I feel like they could accomplish anything- I feel like they truly COULD put the KKK and Black Panthers in a room and nothing crazy happen- they truly do have the gift of getting people together non-hostilely
@@JimmyR42 Ran responded just fine to that. You can have empathy for someone and still hold your position against them. This is a major problem with politics today. Both sides just declare the other just has no heart or they're evil or they have no empathy and then expects to not have to defend their position.
@@JimmyR42 you missed my point entirely but thank you for the short essay. I always enjoy a good read. empathy is not a solution nor an argument. Questioning someone's empathy is what people use as a mechanism to downplay an opposition's significance by calling their virtues immoral.
@@GiggityxGamer Yes I ignored your point because it doesn't concern the question at hand, and I pointed out why in my previous comment but let's try again. What you're saying is about how opposing political sides demonize the other, some of which lack empathy and use the term as a rhetorical device, proving themselves as lacking empathy by doing so. The fact that some people use that term in such a way doesn't mean that it's the only way the term is used, and I'm not saying that what you're describing didn't happen in this conflict but it is a byproduct of the bigger problem she accurately pointed at. The way she used it wasn't to accuse him of lacking empathy as a person but rather to point out that the tool he's using to justify his position, history, is the same tool that both sides are using and the reason why they are both entrenched in their position pointing fingers at each other, like kids saying "the other one started it first". An empathy-based reasoning would not look behind and look at the now(to stop the killing) and the future(to bring hope) and is the only way out of such a conflict without a blood bath to determine the "victor". Also "Questioning someone's empathy is what people use as a mechanism to downplay an opposition's significance by calling their virtues immoral." This can sometimes be true(it often is in american politics), but it is also true that immorality has often tried to justify itself as a necessity via some other "virtue" and that this rigid mindset of "my virtues are infallible" is not only proof of a lack of empathy, it might even go as far as just a basic lack of sympathy. So how would you differentiate both cases?
I could not hold back my tears while watching this, especially when thinking of what is happening nowadays in Palestine. I could feel the pain in their eyes. Although Arab couldn't speak English fluently and couldn't express all he wanted to say, he didn't need to say anything. I could read his mind when looking into his eyes. I find it very kind of the two Israeli girls to communicate nicely and show empathy, not only for Israel. As for the politician Ran, I am very disappointed. He made his point very clear: he doesn’t see Palestinians as human beings and wants Palestine to disappear. He can't even compromise. This shows that most ordinary Israeli people aren't the reason for this conflict, but the government is the actual problem. Wish peace for everyone
The pain in Arab's eyes when he tells of the loss of his sister and the calm they all manage to keep while remembering their killed family members touches me. I'm so sorry for them. No one should experience that.
He's got more to say but they are sometimes interuping which makes go little mad because they I think have the right to talk in this whole video since... IT'S THEIR LAND! don't they get it🙄🙄😕🤔
This is the way UA-cam should be used. This 23 minutes long video presented how human beings can be dispersed in such a cruel way, but also showed how they can be integrated into one respectful value, peace.
희수 exactly I love watching entertaining videos but I absolutely love watching videos like this middle ground is amazing. Instead of watching videos about people spilling tea on other youtubers and talking about first world problems this should be topic and more controversial.
@@abdultawwab486 I'd say 23 mins is not enough time. These questions and answers seems like they are at least 30 mins each. And to just edit it down to 23 mins seems unjust. It really does leave gaps in the conversation and your understanding of there personal experiences.
I can’t exactly say for the Israeli brunette, but the one with glasses said she was afraid because of the things her people did to the other side. Not completely sure, but that’s what I got from what she said.
@@anunknownperson4018 I think bcuz of religion there is still peace.Otherwise people would do anything whatever they wanted to do.If there wasn’t religious issue then there would be the issue of, racism, ethnic cleansing, apartheid, so on
@@moni7803 This is obviously about religion. Israeli want the Al-aqsa mosque, our first qibla because on the day before the war started last Ramadan, Israeli military first attacked Al-aqsa mosque and now they break the ceasefire by attacking Muslims during jumaah prayer in Al-aqsa mosque. Why is this not related to religion if you said so ? Even in quran, bani Israel will never be happy with muslim because they rejected to believe that our last prophet was Prophet Muhammad and not one of them
It started way before then. I here what people are saying, reading the comments, about how the Arabs lost people they new, but the jews, the Israelis, we didn't? We didn't lose people we know? I'm not losing people I know this very second? I feel terrible that human lives are ending on the 'Palestinian' end. But at the end of the day, a lot of these people are not innocent. And the ones that are, are being used as human shields by Hamas. Black lives matter. Gender equality. Palestinian lives matter. That's what everyone says. But Jewish lives don't? Hm, something is just a TAD messed up here. And don't argue against me until you have learned history, looked at PROVEN facts, and gained some knowledge. Then we can speak.
You see, when people stop seeing others as beliefs, geography and their histories, and instead as human beings, they can come together and break bread. Arab is an amazing person.
@@jeffbezos8392 not at all, these things are just comfortable fictions concocted by politicians and capitalist to keep workers fighting and to themselves stay in power
Thank you so much to UA-cam for making it possible to produce this important episode of Middle Ground. We want to say thank you to our participants but also to our audience for always enabling respectful and meaningful conversation in our comments. We know this discussion does not address all aspects or perspectives of this very deep and historical conflict, but we did our best to represent as many perspectives as we could. For those of you that don’t know, Jubilee's philosophy for Middle Ground is to bring people together and have an open dialogue in order to develop a deeper sense of understanding and empathy. We hope you all enjoy :) If you felt as moved as we did by the conversation, please share the video to as many people as you can!
Ah, what a huge, important milestone. This is raw, groundbreaking art and I'm so SO proud of you Jubilee!!
Jubilee as a idea for one of the next videos I would love to see a discussion of pkk pro people and (anti pkk)Turkish people
YOU GUYS DO SUCH A GREAT JOB
This was the best episode yet. Maybe you should also have an Afghan and Indian one also.
i love these, I've watched all seasons in one day. I need more..hahaha
"The best revenge is not to be like your enemy."
Arab has a great heart. I hope he'll find peace.
He’s faced so much pain, he had to gain the wisdom of compassion at a very young age if he was going to continue to live. May he be peaceful indeed.
I hope he's okay right now😔
Came back to this video because of what’s going on right now 😔
“Always forgive your enemies. Nothing upsets them more.”
- Oscar Wilde
Islam is a great religion of peace !
I mean , their countries are shitholes who oppress the right of basically Everyone , but other than That , islam is a great religion of peace !
Arab deserved a translator, the man had so much more to say
Kookie IK?????
Yeah
Ye he couldn't express his feelings and thoughts the way he wanted
Ikr
6:23 the blonde girl just made a hole in my heart this is such a smart way to talk to communicate
And on a more general meaning, I feel like even though there is so much emotion involved everyone is able to make proof of calm and empathy, express mostly calmly, let each other talk and be able to understand all of the unsaid put in game by the barrier of language. Like it was a bit harsh I think to talk like that to each other and except a few slips, it was great.
And also I appreciate the fact that the people involved were from different social classes
The Palestinian guy in the white t-shirt didn't smile even once. You can clearly see that when he lost his 10 year old sister in front of his eyes, his vision in life completely changed
If that happened to me I would be in a mental hospital.
I cried when I saw his expression..
I never experienced it in my life but I try to imagine someone's daughter being mutilated in front of you sends shivers through me.
My love and prayers extend to all the Palestinians
I lost my grandpa
He smiled tho
Jubilee you MUST discuss this again, especially with what is currently going on now. Also please reach out to Arab too, he had so much to say and it would be interesting to hear him again
FORREAL‼️‼️
THISS
Very inappropriate to have this now. Making content out of genoc!de.
they wont they will lose the account
*Humanity First*
*Love* for all hatred for none
Preach *Empathy*
BIG respect to the guy who lost his 10yo sister and still wants to discuss solutions to the conflict, we need people like you for a better future
People say he died by a bullet to the head days ago, while he was trying to save his brother who was being beaten by Israeli soldiers
@khaled khateb , who? Arab? Seriously?
@@khaledkhateb8665 what ? I hope not ... That's just too sad to be true
@@amokana well i think its true its on the news
@@khaledkhateb8665 give the source please :(
Jubilee should contact these people again and have a second middle ground meeting.
the arab guy is dead now ( shot by the IDF) so I think what are you saying is impossible
@@hamzaez-zayany4091 Source: Trust me bro
@@hamzaez-zayany4091 please I hope this is not true
I'm sure the Israeli people could be contacted cause they're most likely 100% safe - alive and breathing ... but the Palestinians... well we can only pray they are still alive and well. They probably have much more pressing concerns right now than this... like protecting their families, themselves, their neighbours or just mourning over the loss of their homes, their livelihood and everything they've known. And quite frankly I think it would be extremely insensitive for them to be forced to play calm right now and hide their hurting after all the trauma their people are going through.
@@hamzaez-zayany4091 For the love of god, please tell me you're just trolling
the man who lost his 10 year old sister. i cant even begin to imagine.
And to make it worst she was murdered in front of him. He might spend his entire life thinking he could've saved her but failed☹
@ And that's happened in front of their school. Shot in the head in front of her brother and her other school friends. Even if its not my own sister but my friend its still will bring trauma for me. I still remember it till now the image of my friend's foot that had blood stain on it under the white sheet that covered her dead body when ambulance brought her home after she got hit by car on the street when I was in elementary school. Cant imagine it if I see my own sister got shot in front of me :(((
How about the the Israeli who lost many?
@@RealAnita926 you mean the guy who's an exec at a billionaire-backed, right-wing think tank? yeah, I wouldn't trust him if he told me the sky is blue.
@@RealAnita926 no one tell them to steal palestine land
I will never understand how people stay so calm
Do you condemn Hamas?
They're trying to have a constructive conversation
@@chrisdawson1776do u condemn israel?
@@user-zk1oq6ym3v nahhhh
They're adults not kids
"I was born to live but my sister was born to die" this made me flood in tears
Sonya Orak Sonya Orak well I’ll rephrase it for him since he wasn’t speaking in his first language : “ I was born to live but my sister was born to be murdered by a soulless soldier. “ , now go ahead and be a smartass .
Sonya Orak so you’re trying to justify shooting a 10 year old girl? Give me a break. As the Israeli guy in the video said “ they ( the soldiers) are only ordered to shoot if they feel like someone is a threat to them. “, and I can’t imagine that the guy you are trying to defend felt in danger by this girl.
Sonya Orak oof you don’t get his point smartass. My sister was born to die -> she was young, barely lived her life in war and she got killed before experiencing it. Meaning she was still a baby (no smartass, not a biological baby) and barely experienced life. Life had not started for her and she got killed. What’s so hard about understanding what he meant?
@@sonychka You are heartless
Sonya Orak : Humans are born to die, death is inevitable. His sister was born to be taken early and he was born to be sat in this interview giving his side, everyone’s purpose is different! From a ‘biblical’ perspective where does it say we have no free will? Where does it promote violence? And where does it say when you are enlisting as a solider where you go on to PROTECT LIVES, you end up taking an innocent one who must have been half if not quater his age? We humans are capable of many things, definitely peace included, you see it’s natural because it comes from within the heart! But if we do talk about ‘natural behaviour’, Cain whom killed his brother was left as a prime example to the world and was left as a ‘fugitive’ and ‘wanderer’ and ‘cursed’. As humans have elvolved today, i can happily say we learn from mistakes, Cain became a warning for those who needed it! Plus Less than 1% of deaths are caused by homocide (globally) the rest of the 99% are actually dying naturally! We are all born with some purpose in life..Just have to find yours!
arab's story about his father, and his family makes me cry. his purity, torn away from conflict, is heart wrenching.
That’s actually a very small part of the stories, maybe not the saddest of them .
Thousands of Palestinians got killed for defending their land
I think its a terrible story. Because he told his son he had a daughter to die essentially. What a f'd up thing to say. I would never justify something like that to anyone it was a ridiculous story.
And to the others is this thread. Thousands of jews died defending their homeland
lol but the israeli guy who lost 20+ friends its fine for you. just shows that you dont really care about who lost who, you just hate israel and love arabs
@@smexybear9845 but who started the conflict. imagine real quick if wherever you live/are from got taken over by another country and were like okay so yeah this isnt your country anymore sorry. plus many more Palestinians died in the hands of idf and they had a right to defend themselves. furthermore in one of the wars Palestinians fought with stones but the the idf fought with guns
This video got recommended to everyone just in the right time..
Should’ve been recommended a long time ago 😭
no, i searched for this
@@maremilia8148 samee....i saw it 2 yrs ago when it was released and searched it again today.
That's called algorithm
Agree.
Arab deserved a translator. What a beautiful soul
Do you condemn Hamas?
@@chrisdawson1776 I do.
@@chrisdawson1776no
@@chrisdawson1776yes
@@chrisdawson1776Hamas was created by Jews. Educate yourself.
“how about empathy?” this girl 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Jack Zara G-D gave that land to the Hebrews. If G-D hated Esau for giving up his birthright G-D will hate Israel for giving up its promised land to palestine. Judgement day will be based on how they treated Zion. Iran, Russia, Syria, Libya, and other nations will be destroyed and will name the messiah king of kings and lord of lords and having a long lasting period of peace.
Noah Remnek we are talking politics here. religion is not an excuse for killing people nor it justifies the israeli appropriation of the palestinian lands. y’all catholic people are constantly expecting respect without giving it back and are always playing the victims of the situation
Jack Zara The Bible is most accurate book ever written
Noah Remnek i don’t care what book you romanticize, still not a good argument to bring into politics and especially when the safety of a community of people is at stake and their dignity and the preservation of their human rights is endangered
Jack Zara Once the messiah comes he will figure everything out.
I like that she corrected herself 'your sister didn't pass away she was murdered' shows major respect to her death
Yes, that was important
Did she just said she is a Zionist at the beginning or what ?
@@aykutyuksek8086 in all honesty I have no odea what that is
@@aykutyuksek8086 @21:05
@@Enkubuss Thats Rich White Ashkenazi European Jewish Zionist privilege and that mindset are the problem as the guy in the suit so clearly showed. It showed how he and his ilk, his social class, control most of the power, capital, judicial and political resources and they run Isreal and have decided they are not giving up the land, Palestine, and neither is the IDF, and that it will be over the dead bodies of as many Palestinians as it takes. That's the message he was sending in his inability to acknowledge the history of the land. He is of a cold heart. Something that is not yours can not be given to anyone else. World War 2 was horrible but Britain can not give you the ancestral home of an indeginous people especially when they are currently residing there. Any nation would normally consider the giving away of your land by some other nation without the consensus of the palestinian people about how they felt about giving up part their land as a gift to a group of people so grievously violated by the results of WW2 as were many other groups of people, were an act of war. That would be a hostile action and would be an alien invasion that anyone would and should meet with resistance in the defense of the family and home. If any land was owed to them it lies somewhere in Europe mainly German lands. As Germany can give away their own land to a people they managed to have their homes stolen from them through their part as the Axis in WW2. They could build their own small European nation there and thrive. That's the only other thing that is owed in reparations for the Holocaust is a blood free land for Palestinians to call their own. If Jews don't want land in central Europe then give it to Palestinians to develop for themselves in repayment to their violated rights of safety family and home.
If someone told me they lost their 10yo sister in those tragic circumstances the first thing I would say is "I'm very sorry for the loss you and your family suffered". That's it. Nothing else needs to be said, no need to turn attention to yourself or make statements which make it seem as if you are defending the person that did it.
@@nurizzati3499 your post is nonsense.
exactly. and the fact that he pulled out the "who suffered more" card and compared the death of family by the IDF to deaths of the very IDF soldiers who were already at risk of death and who very much took the lives of innocent Palestinian citizens is absolutely revolting. The way he said it and pulled out the list and tried to gain sympathy points by saying he "doesn't know which grave to visit first" seems like he's manipulating the audience to feel bad for him over the "27 friends" rather than the family.
@@nurizzati3499 wtf are you saying
@@greentea0956 what do you mean?
Yeah, the way he was saying like I was never ordered to shoot someone unless there's a threat. So was the israeli soldier ordered to shoot the 10 years old child? Why did he shot her? Was a 10 years old going to school a threat to Israel? His friends from IDF joined the IDF while putting their lives on line, knowing they will probably die in the line of their duty. While a normal civilian family does not wake up every morning knowing they will be shot. But these Palestinian civilians do. They wake up knowing they'll probably be killed that day, not because they joined the military knowing that, but simply because they were born into this world.
6:28 "how about empathy?" this girl rocks, she's not blinded by zionism
Do you condemn Hamas?
@@chrisdawson1776”there is a list”?? No but seriously youve been rocking with this sentence yet israel hasnt published proof. Do you condemn the idf??
@@chrisdawson1776”there is a list”?? No but seriously youve been rocking with this sentence yet israel hasnt published proof. Do you condemn the idf??
@@free_palestine_yeah yeah lets just ignore this troll he probably thinks this all started on 7.10. 💀
@@slattistcool prob😭
tchelet stopping him and saying "yes. how about empathy?" was such a powerful moment from a well spoken woman.
@anne smith why they can't today ???
@@unknowngirl1624 cause they are not together
anne smith Palestine will be a state then instead of Israhell.
anne smith but not all the Arab countries want to get involved, the strongest weapon Palestinians have are rocks Israelis have bombs, who do you think is innocent
anne smith no they don’t tho
The Israeli girl in glasses gives me some hope. She talks about empathy, and she obviously understands the pain that Palestine goes through. People like her are needed on both sides for this conflict to end.
@@kolerp1261 Nor can it be ruled solely on malice. Empathy can bring net benefit to a country. Better relations and compromise lead to increased trade, less conflict, less spending needed for military and defense which can then go to public services etc.
@@DalleDayul empathy is a human behaviour. It exists in everyone except in psychopaths, which are 1% of the population.
All people feel empathy for people who suffer.
But it's not a way to reach conclusions, it's not logic. She asks how did he determine it's his country and he gave good answers. Empathy is not one of them.
If I look sad it doesn't mean China belongs to me. A lot of Israelis are sad about the Palestinian situation, if anything it's you guys who feel no empathy for the Israeli side, and ignore the fact that Jews always lived here, and bought a big chunk of the land.
For example, I lost a friend. He was 10 when a Palestinian woman came into a peaceful restaurant, and decided to blow him up with his grandparents and cousin. I've never heard of a Jew doing such a thing, and being praised. I'm really grateful for the wall the wall that "separates" us, until you all decide that your greed is less important than life.
@@Abilliph I believe it is important to apply empathy as you also apply logic to create a solution. They are not mutually exclusive. I have to ask myself, is there enough empathy on either side. If one side lays down its arms, and just asks to live their lives, will the other side allow it? So empathy for the plight of your adversary, with whom you seek peace, is necessary to take into consideration when reaching any lasting agreement.
Zionism is the thing that we should end nothing’s else !
@@lamox13s so you should end the building of a Jewish state in the land of Israel?
Zionism has stopped existing when Israel was founded. Today, it's just people trying to live their life, and create a barrier between them and greedy people, who will never agree to a state unless they have everything.
The Palestinian guy really broke my heart. He still cares about other sights feelings despite his murdered sister. I'm sure his gorgeus heart can beat this hatred.
@@fish4779 the way he spelled it made me laugh lol
hmm, what about the israeli who had lost 20+ friends. you dont care? so I thought
@@smexybear9845 I'm sorry for his lost. I can't ignore his pain but he said that he lost his FRIENDS. Other guy lost his sister and we don't know if he lost his friends. He didnt mentioned about it.
Anyway the point is forgiving and respecting other side despite the prejudice and hatred. We mustnt compare their pain. İts the reason of ongoing war.
He lost his team mates in war what is he excpecting from going to war ? Chocolate? Ofc dead..thats war.
But the guy lost his sister inside his home
My heart went out to him as well.
17:55 The dude keeps saying he doesn't believe in violence, but then he also doesn't believe in peace between the 2 sides, he isn't willing to compromise, he won't allow a second state, and he requires that the state is ruled by Israelian sovereignty... Dude, you might have a list of 27 names, but you didn't name one sibling or parent. Stop acting like the only victim.
صحيح
That’s the thing, as long as HAMAS exists and the majority of the Palestinian people are okay with its regime, there cannot be peace between Palestine and Israel. That’s a fact. Remove HAMAS and peace will be achieved in days
The Israelis have agreed a two state solution many times, only to have it thrown in their faces. This guy is simply being a realist. I’m sure all of those people and any one of us of reasonable mine, would agree that a two state solution would be wonderful - it’s simply not possible when the islamists that govern Palestine want all Jews out/dead!
probably 27 IDF soldiers that were conditioned into terrorism by israel.
@@Decimator69420that’s just untrue, it’s not like if Hamas was gone the Gaza Strip would just be free to exist. If you want “peaceful” coexistence with Israel look at the West Bank where there are countless unfair actions taken against Palestinians.
coming back to this after 4 years with everything going on now is so heartbreaking honestly
So sad religion is allowed to poison people in 21st century.
I need to know is palestinian guy okay, can't find his socials
@@maidamaljevac2465 That was my worry when I saw this was four years ago. I hope he is okay.
It’s so sad having been in Israel for about a month and getting to know Israeli and Palestinians alike., they’re all just regular people trying to provide for themselves, their families. Even the Israeli soldiers are at average, 18, 19 year olds. It’s so heartbreaking that they were all born into this conflict.
@@maidamaljevac2465he said he’s from west bank not gaza
There is a deep pain and sadness in the eyes of the Palestinian guy. I don't know how he could sit with them and tried to pretend that it's okay but he is dying inside. I hope he finds happiness and peace in his life.
Allah gave him strength, I hope he finds happiness as well :)
Bro he looks so far gone man, it hurts to see.
This was filmed a while ago. I just hope he's alive and well
he looks like the type that throws rocks and yells allahu akhbar, not much of a future in that.
@@KpK1Cioby what a pathetic and embarrassing response.
Man the Palestinian guy is destroyed from inside, I saw him “smile” just two times in this video, and those “smiles” were just because I think he didn’t want to spread sadness, but I think we all agree see pain in his eyes.
@Ștefan Cel Mare no, totally wrong. He is sad because israeli settlers who came from ukraine and russia in 1948 and by using weapons handed to them by britain have slaughtered and killed the children of palestinians, have also killed his beloved ones
@Ștefan Cel Mare making peace ?? Fuck off ! U didnt know anything
@Ștefan Cel Mare the truth is they are not trying to reach peace; they are trying to end the conflict in their favor
@Ștefan Cel Mare how is killing the people with no power and trying to make "peace" with the ones who have power peace?
And don't get me started on "their land"
@Ștefan Cel Mare Besides, so what if some people don't want to accept the peace offer? I mean it is called an "offer" for a reason. A burglar comes in and shoots all ur guests in ur home and you are supposed to accept peace with him when he points his knife at you? If not, you are a bad dude? The thing is, it is very very very vividly clear where the right and wrong lies. It is very obvious that the israeli colonization of the holly land is a wrong deed. I am pretty sure if you asked a 5 y.o about it he would say the same thing.
It’s incredible that Palestinians after going through everything from being slaughtered, homes set on fire, ethnic cleansing, forced immigration … they are still willing to sit and have a dialogue. They are still hoping for peace… that’s how much humanity and love they have to their land. This experience humbled me to always seek humanity and peace even in the worst of situations. For Israelis out there you are in the position force and power. Your Religious book promised you a land were indigenous people were living. You have taken many innocent lives to take this land. I hope this experience opens your minds and hearts to peace now. It’s enough blood shed and tears.
at the very end of this video... seeing them Smiling and having a meal with them ,talking....i really cried...how can people be this humble and warm...
And who staring this war?
Hamas….not the elderly, not the mothers, not the hospitalised, and not the children of Gaza. But that’s who paid for this by a ratio of 1200:30,000 (plus the damage and destruction of every school, hospital, all infrastructure, all means of normal medical, power, food and water services)
@@motherhoodsbeauty9279 Israel started the war in 1948
This was 5 years ago
The Palestinian guy is still grieving. There's a lot of sadness in his eyes yet what is so heartbreaking is he still believe in peace and empathy despite everything. He isn't bitter and become vengeful when he got all the reasons on earth to be one.
Palestinians: My beloved innocent family members were brutally and mercilessly murdered by Israeli soldiers in front of my eyes...
Israeli guy: Here's a list of some random Israeli soldiers who got hit by a pebble thrown by little toddlers terrorists. I wrote them on paper because you know, they're not that important to me. I might forget their names.
@@ObamaSexGaming2007 Never did the idea that he carries a list of names he might forget because of the reason there are too many came to your mind?
as opposed to most Palestinians that just want to take back Israel, they don't care about peace they just want Israel
@ming chocolate It is also to honor them... and even if they weren't close to him, it's horrible to lose that many people you know.
He's a strong person
The Palestinian guy "Arab" had a lot to say, he wanted to say more but the language failed him but I felt his words.
I felt the same too
I felt his words too😢
Me too 😢
yea i felt it too :(
😭😭😭😭
Arab held lot of sadness in his eyes ,it really made me cry , he has a big heart
I agree. Having lost his sister yet still being the only person who came forward for two-state solution. He looks like one of my Israeli friends who is Jewish. You really can't tell Jews and Arabs apart sometimes. Which says everything really.
he deserves the world. i hope he is okay.
Notice how it says in the description that this video was made 5 years ago. This did NOT start October 7. It even started wayyyyy before 5 years ago.
Pro Israelis will still defend this.
The war was started on oct 7 by hamas, but the conflicts between the two started way before then
@@shrubbygaming8665 the war started in 1948, when the Arabs were pissed at the fact that their land was given to the jews. Since then, Israel has been oppressing Palestinians.
@@SatoYuqi12 key word THEIR land who wouldn’t be pissed that their land was being given to someone else in 1948 the nakbah forced palestinian’s out of there homes who wouldn’t be mad?
@@shrubbygaming8665please do research. Palestinians were literally being pulled out of their homes and told it’s not their land by Israel’s well before October 7 2024. This started before any of us we born. The iron dome was built in 2005 for a reason.
I remember my aunt going to Israel to work as volonteer at orphanage for palestinian kids. When she was asked at airport in Israel about a reason of her trip she told the truth. They kept her for few houres before leting her go and shortened time she could be in Israel. Then when she was leaving this country she heard: no more Israel for you. How could taking care of orphan kids be consider as wrong and harmful for anyone? In what kind of messed up world are we living in?
That's so messed up what does taking care of innocent children have to do with this
Thanks for sharing. You hear many instances like this, Doctors Without Borders would have video tapes confiscated or erased. What are they fearful of?? It’s a shame but most people who visit both sides come away with the same impression, Palestinian perspective is not highlighted in mainstream and Israel prefers to keep it that way. Do you know which orphanage?
@@beebee242 The one in Bethlehem
Yep "Zionests" it's just another world for sociopaths
@Robert D lol and Israel agenda is to occupy arab land and calld it Jew's land a thief will remain a thief no matter what
“The soldier who killed my sister didn’t go to jail” I can feel his pain.
@@RealYunoCS they have the freedom to protest against an isreal ideology that oppressed Palestine’s isreal is an idea a bad idea
@@RealYunoCS this is complete stupidity sir! Would you give up on your land , home , family just because of fear?? The little girl was brave and the soldier was scared enough to shot her even tho she is literally a 10 yr old child
@@RealYunoCS yes exactly
a 10 year old girl protesting ?!?
Are you joking ?!!!
@@RealYunoCS The fuck out of others land? Palestinians have lived here for centuries and centuries while Zionists Jews have recently arrived and now because of that power, they’re oppressing Palestinians to say that “this land is ours and we don’t want peace with you”. So go fuck yourself.
@@nitrofiregamingtv1155 thank you
the Palestinian guy, i think his name was Arab he just fascinates me. how can u have so much peace inside you after going through all that. u deserve all the happiness in the world!
When you know that every soul will pay for its wrongdoings on the day of judgement
@@ak-th5xt true 👍
Lad soo strong 💜
Humans naturally want peace. It's just the 99% is easily led by the 1% . Were doctrined at youth to look for packs. Ever heard of the phrase divide and conquer? Its a real strategy and works every time.
Humans before evil
Arab, a beautiful man. I can see his pain, yet he took his father's words to heart: he is meant to live, so he continue on to live and not let hate envelope his mind.
I find Hannah a very amazing human being, her dad getting murderred by the other side yet she still says no to violence and wanted to end it all by stopping the cycle. Very heroic woman.
how are you so sure given the calling for taqiya and public face saving of muslims. furthermore, muslims are literaly calling to exterminate jewish ppl. How do you know if the tide change and muslims try to off jews she would fight for the jews
she was very smart! she knows what to say to shut an argument..
And gorgeous as well
She is ❤️
Why doesn’t she look like an Arab at all?
''How about empathy?'' Is one of the best things I heard someone say in a while and it made me tear up.
I agree the one of the best things I heard this video
@@roqayaal-musawy4802 Do you condemn Hamas?
Empathy is not a solution here
For the israeli guy to look a Palestinian in the Eye and say" it's not your land" is PURE DELUSION
Do you condemn Hamas?
Exactly he needs to come out of his delusional world
@@chrisdawson1776nah
@@georgejojan5621 Why?
@@chrisdawson1776I Condemn your ancestors
The Palestinian guy really is so deep. His pain. It breaks my heart.
It is one of many
I am Arab and I know a lot about our Palestinian brothers، our hearts break daily،We are one body if one part of the body suffers the whole body suffers with it
All Palestinians has a sad story
But the world does not care about them
I’m a Chaldean my family and I had to leave Iraq because of the constant harassment and terrorism from certain groups. My Father served 9 years in the military and my Grandfather was involved in WW2 and the war between Palestine and Israel.
@@lolea8405 You know why no one cares about them? That's because they don't care about themselves. They always lack solidarity and unity among each other. Sad but true. BTW: I'm not Pro-Israeli. I favor the Palestinian cause but one of their tragedies is that they always play the victim role and you know why? Because they lack love for each other and they are dispersed in the whole Arab world.
Allah yrhamha.
@@lolea8405 who said? I care, really really care
Coming back to this conversation 5 years later and sharing in the aftermath of the recent violent outbreak. We need to have more hard conversations like this.
This is one of most influential conversations if not the only one. As an Egyptian i totally understand what the Palestinians are going through
What i just dont understand is why the guy from IDF is saying that this is not your land.. just because his book says so doesn’t make it his land!
For ex: i imagine that my 9th great grandfather had a piece of land and was forced to move out of and then i come all of a sudden to claim that this land is mine after thousands of years and after people already got settled in this place for hundreds of years
@@ayahashim100yeah still palentine terrorists attacked first. You ounch someone, expect the other to hit you harder.
@@YoGrannyGotNoKnees yes they did but stop being a she*p and think critically! Hamas is not that powerful to hit hard without israel knowing about it! Like think about it the most well equipped military with all most powerful and intelligent weapons they have and still cannot figure out that Hamas was going to hit them! It’s either the west was selling hard the idea that the military of israel cannot be defeated which turns to be a lie and israel is very weak that some militants can turn it upside down in a blink of an eye 😂 Or there actually a plan that is going on and israel scapegoated its civilians to have a reason behind for race cleansing!
“how about empathy?”
such a powerful moment! i literally love that woman so much. she doesn’t just blindly agree with the dude because he is on “her side”.
All she did by saying that was verbalize her ‘feelings over fact’ mentality
the government doesnt work with empathy
@@熊ちゃん-h7t Ben Shapiro entered the chat
@M K i didnt blame any side i just said the world doesnt work that way. the world isnt empathy and rainbows
@@熊ちゃん-h7t feeling are facts too. What you feel matter. That is literally why people go to war.
I remember seeing this for the first time. Opened my eyes to the issue. Then Oct 7th happened and everyone thought the attack happened out of nowhere for no reason.
its insane, people older than me pretending october 7th was when this conflict started.
Israel's occupation and idf killings have been happening for decades
@@elbownio5820 yeah its crazy how in some countries they brainwash you to think israel is a actual country with history
They never talk about the occupation & apartheid
“How about empathy” man even the people on ran’s “side” felt his toxicity
Maddie Leigh IKR?!
Maddie Leigh Yea,I literarily was pissed off about the man in the suit throughout the video,white shirt guy barely got to speak half of the time!😕
Its not rare to see people like the one in suit, because we are brought up the way to mostly suck up the nationalism without thinking about the innocent lives we have to step on to sometimes achieve it
Lucas Kyte-Tremblay dude now ur being racist,chill it ok?
@Lucas Kyte-Tremblay Why are you kidding yourselves? Peaceful actions have already been tried and Israel has stated that they supress peaceful protests even more than violent once. Sorry, educate yourself before you post.
The guy in the white shirt deserves so much good! God bless him and his family 💛
1 year after I watched this video,with everything that is happening to Jerusalem as of the moment,this episode shatters the heart.
This is so heart wrenching :
Agree
@tanner loehr shut the fuck up anti palestinian israelis started this conflict. crying about hamas when its only a consequence of the genocidal and settler state that funded them in the first place? lol. i'm sorry but it's like crying about slaves finally snapping and fighting back.
@tanner loehr hammas only fired because of what happened in sheikh jarrah and what the IDF soldiers did to the mosque. You cannot expect them to just sit there and continue to be attacked.
@tanner loehr Omg I’m not justifying it but when you put into perspective that israel has killed more civilians in the last 3 days than hamas or al qads (which Palestinians DO NOT claim or condone) has in 10 years, then there should be some sort of thought that yes violence in general is wrong but Israel’s oppressing over Palestinians and the lives they have taken is too much at this point. and secondly don’t ever ever ever say “over that?” how can you be so insensitive, during their month of Ramadan as the Palestinians are peacefully praying, IDF barges in throwing grenades at children, men, and women and ruining the structure inside of this sacred place of worship. A tree then catches on fire outside and the Israeli citizens are on the other side watching it cheering and blasting music and dancing. Next, you cannot “legally” kick Palestinians out of their homes, not again. Do you not know the nakba? Why would they ever let them get away with what they did, AGAIN? im not justifying the rockets but for you to sit here and act like Israel is on the right side is disgusting. do you know how many innocent lives they’ve taken? and about that did you see the Palestinians that were lynched in the streets yesterday by Israeli settlers? Did you see the Israeli settlers also throw rocks at their cars and terrorizing the Palestinians at checkpoints? im not justifying but Israel’s packed with US’s aid. they knew the rockets wouldn’t damage them, lemme guess you forgot about the dome israel has that blocks everything?
saying its not your land to someone whose ancestors and very great grandparents existed longer than israel did is crazy
Research pls Jews lived in the kingdom of judea for not centuries 3000 years and have been discriminated since then during Roman times a Roman emperor took over the Jewish kingdom and named it Palestine after ww1 British took over Palestine and isreal was formed to protect Jews and obviously was pushed back by Arab nations…
نعم هذه هي الصهيونيه فماذا تنتظر
I'm older than South Sudan, does that mean Sudan is justified in retaking South Sudan? The oldest person alive was born in 1907, does that mean the world map should reverse to Pre-WW1 borders? Are you pro-colonisation? This is pretty racist, not gonna lie.
@@HaithamAbdullah-fg2op. All over the world, countries have always been at war with their direct neighbors. You just have to look at the history of the world - most conflicts have started with direct neighbors. The best solution is for everyone to have a country and accept the borders of the other country. As long as your neighbor claims your land, there will never be peace.
hahah yes im first generation here in Israel i mean he is came from Europe it really crazy i agree they souldent let somone like him talk to them he is to radical lol he need to chill
We are taught only to defend ourselves as IDF when threatened.
You were threatened by a 10 year old little girl outside her school?
he was the one who killed the 10 year old girl ? No . Therefore your argument is invalid. He can only answer for himself and not for the other soldier who disrepected rules
Thefilipe58 but they also said that if an idf soldier wrongfully murders someone they go to jail yet the guy that murdered the 10 old girl didn’t go to jail so it wasn’t only the soldier that didn’t follow the rules but the idf as a whole since the soldiers represent the idf and their rules
Ehsan Abdullatif the rules are to go to jail if a soldier kills an innocent person ... sometimes is hard to know who shoot, or in which circumstances the innocent girl died... this is war and sadly there are innocent people who on both sides die ... but idf tried its best to try to diminish it ... but it’s naive to think that all innocent deaths will lead to prison in the middle of a war
Thefilipe58 yet it is still an innocent little girls life lost and as you said innocent lives are lost in war that is inevitable but why are the idf seen as soldier of justice and the people in the right and the Palestinians as terrorists, they both have killed innocents, they both fight for what is rightfully theirs so tell me what the difference is since both sides are bombing each other and shooting each other why are Palestine the bad guys?
@@Thefilipe58 it's not a "both sides" situation it's only the palestines who are dying there is a study shows that 50.000 palestines died guess what ? Zero Israeli died why is that u think ? Of course ur going to say it's a war they attacked us blah blah but no, no one kills 50k people in the head because they were threatening u this is ridiculous and needs to stop.
The Palestinian guy in the white t-shirt his have a good heart
I disagree. What he calls peace, is a complete erasure of the Palestinian identity and subservience to Israel.
they all do. sadly western media just never wants to sympathize with them
@@lonokonane1796 wtf does that even mean
dont drink the kool aid Go back and listen to the conditions he listed for there to be peace.
Hannah and Arab the Palestinians wanted to give their opinions but Ran the Israeli interrupt them 11:58 until 12:35
This is probably the most important episode that Jubilee has done. Props to you guys for making this.
There are many important topics. This is a small but very famous topic.
@@Arcaryon no this is a very important topic among other important topics, most of the people are misunderstood by government and rumors, who knows that this topic would change the thoughts of millions of people and also bring peace and prevent upcoming wars.
@@shaikmohammed6570 Wishful thinking but not unrealistic. Still, I have come to believe that change takes a lot of time, the bigger, the longer it is.
i agree
@@Arcaryon It’s not just famous, it’s what’s causing a borderline genocidal war.
I genuinely do not see how anyone could be on Israel's side in this conflict. It is mind boggling to me.
It's because you don't know sh1t about anything
@@thehinduguy2888who says you do?
To outsiders it is definetly more true, when it ever was bevor
Netanyahu is a War Criminal
I’m with Israel 🇮🇱…
thats what sad you only see one side in this story
BIG RESPECT for the PALESTINIAN GUY. You can tell that he was raised in love. Even after such a huge tragedy with his sister, he stayed focused on peace (a peaceful fight). Palestinian people are just like others. We, other nations put them down. Now, we need to bring to the table all we can for them to have a prosperous life in Palestine.
Very well said
He support violence. Honestly everything can just be dropped in matter of seconds.
@@JessieR2023Have you watched the video where he keeps repeating the exact contrary ? If not, keep your mouth shut.
Big respect to all of them❤
palestianians want peace and the other group don't . Its that simple
shooting a child in 10 years !!! how could be a self-defence ?
Right? I'm 14 and the best I can fight with is, is a freaking pencil. How can a 10 year old be dangerous?!
Amberly Sweet *John Wick*
And it's not just an incident. This has become so common unfortunately. Innocent kids and people are killed. Most of the cases are never highlighted and it's a silent funeral and pain to live by. Worst part is people support it even after knowing... Tho majority are just brainwashed and not shown what's happening actually.
The adults give them guns Molotov cocktails and bombs because they can sneak up more easily I blame the child’s parents
@@felixromano3091 if the parents have these things at all they would have set Palestine free ages ago , but all they have is rocks , may god show you how is it feels to lose a brother a sister a daughter a son a nephew by rock hearted soldiers that’s all i can say
Arab (the Palestinian guy) saying, "i hope we all live long and in peace" not knowing what's gonna happen 4 years later (which is now) is heartbreaking. I hope they are all alive.
It only shows how much you don't have any idea of the conflict, they're from the west bank and the war now is taking place in Gaza: two seperated areas far from each other,if you don't even know this simple fact then it's really disappointing. He literally talks about that at 12:00
Yeah, it's unfortunate that the Palestinian Authority promoted a warpath that led to all of this death. This is why I personally don't support terrorism and/or Nazism.
@@tom12804exactly, if anything - hamas are the ones putting him in danger, not Israel
@@gabik240200 yeah, hamas is using gaza as a giant human shield, and people on the internet keep on supporting them for some reason
@@tom12804You don't know the simple fact that the West Bank has been attacked TOO
Portugal was ruled by the Spanish for 60 years from 1580 to 1640. But guess what we weren't less Portuguese because of that and we freed ourselves in 1640. Ireland was ruled by the British for 121 years from 1801 to 1922 and they weren't less Irish because of that and freed themselves in 1922. So, I picture the same for Palestine. Even if it takes 200 years, Palestine will be free. ⌚ It's just a matter of time.
The Palestinians have denied every 2 state agreement offered since 1948 because their leaders like Arafat what the land just for Arabs aka Palestinians.
@@bmunsky sure, Sherlock, keep making excuses for you whit.e su.premacy
@@carolinacastanheira9304 what did he say wrong?
I agree!♥️
🇧🇷🇵🇹 🤝🏻🇵🇸
As an Algerian this is remaind me of us
Algeria remained occupied by France for 130 years From 1830 to 1962, but we gained our independence and we live in safety today. The Palestinians are our brothers, and I want there to be a state called Palestine in which the Palestinians live.
i think jubilee needs to revisit this discussion...
Yes pls
100 percent
Yesss! And I hope they're still alive and safe
Definitely
Yeah 1000%
Please please PLEASE do another one of these with the same people, but this time, bring a translator for Arab. This young man has so much to say, and the world must hear it.
He must’ve been so frustrated, I really want him to be able to speak
I feel like he must've had more to say and more emotion to show in his words speaking his mother tongue, I really wish they let him have one.
I understood him completely fine. But if he would prefer that or anyone else why not.
@AppleJuice ehm!
With the current situation it might probably with different people
when he said „my grandfathers 14th generation behind is here“ that one hit me hard, 14 generations behind burried on their land but israel says its not their land. this young palästinian made me almost cry.
“My sister was born to die” you can see the pain in his eyes.
@@jubaii4142 what?? Where is it written ?? I don't think so it's true...
@@saffiyabikodalayil2646 You don't know that because you didn't look for it
@@jubaii4142 first of all, at least say Qur’an and not just “their book” if you’re going to make a statement like that. and secondly, you’re incorrect. nowhere does it say in the Qur’an that another man’s faith makes them a mistake. The Prophet (pbuh) showed the utmost respect for his fellow Jewish and Christian neighbours and us Muslims lead by his example as much as the Qur’an. I think you’re possibly thinking of the fact that because Muslims consider Islam the ‘true and final word of God’ that all non-believers will enter Hell. That’s a sort of twisted mentality that’s been slight;y contrived by you, but there is some strand of truth to it, in the sense that each (main) religion believes they are the correct religion and the others are wrong, therefore they won’t get into Paradise. It isn’t an exclusive statement that only relates to Islam, it also it mentioned in Christianity and Judaism. pls don’t spread false facts or contrived and twisted statements. it’s not helping anyone and is just worsening the issue at hand. your comment also had nothing to do with the original comment which was about the grief in the man’s eyes over the loss of his young sister. please look at the context next time.
@@zarakhan02 I say what the Jews think and not what the Qur’an says
@@jubaii4142 you cannot say that you’re referring to the Qur’an then switch up and claim to be talking for an entire religion filled with individual thinkers. you only speak for yourself, no one else.
My heart breaks when Arab speaks ; he’s seen it all and experienced the worst this world has got to offer. Regardless he’s still willing to sit down, reason, and understand in an effort to reconcile. That is *HUMANITY* and *MERCY*
US could cut weapon supply to both countries, but it's profitable.
What about Hannah? She lost her friend at 10 years old, around the same age to a sniper.
@@d.o.p.d.o.p.1775 She lost her father, not her friend. There is a huge difference. But yeah, she's awesome too. Love them both and I hope they're both alive and well.
The brother Arab, is a strong man, may Allah protect him and grant him Sabr. You can see through his eyes; his body language, the difficulties and hardships he has gone through.
"Yes, but how about empathy" there yah go ladies and gentleman, someone remembered how to be a human.
Yet seems to have not learned history. Empathy is important, but the problem is that history actually proves this is our land and we have the right to live here. They can also live here too, no one actually stops them from doing so.
no land truly belongs to anybody. in a sense, we're all just visitors. everybody should be allowed to live everywhere.
@@liamfrederic5203
True, but the Palestinians still use the "this is our land, we live here" card which can be used by Israeli people too. The difference is that the UN gave us the official ownership over this land.
@@ihatethisusernameupdate I understand that and I don't think I can truly judge it, not living there. I like what Tchelet said, that that you have the power now gives you more responsibility. I don't think one side is right or wrong as a whole but the notion that an ideology should be worth more than a life is. I hope the two sides talk to each other more like this.
@@liamfrederic5203
Yeah. But not everyone from both sides is willing to talk, sadly.
You guys should be this video again... Now ppl need this more than ever...
Do you condemn Hamas?
@@chrisdawson1776do you condemn bots
It is sad when people voluntarily behave as bots
@@chrisdawson17761/10 ragebait
True
my eyes won't leave the Palestinian guy. I wish I could give him a warm hug.
same here :(
Jerry Murillo what...
brudha osas 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🙏
Jerry Murillo lol that’s not even him, it’s a picture of a celebrity u dumbass
@Jerry Murillo stop being RACIST!!!!!
I can't stop crying every time I look into Arab's eyes and I know there are too many like him and him willing to sit down and hear that Palestine isn't his home you can tell what he went through.
can we appreciate how the palestenian guy had his sister shot right infront of him by an Israeli soldier and despite all the pain he went through he still signed to this and managed to shake hands with one of them, what a beautiful soul..
just shows how people of islam are🥰
ikr
@@demhreyani3185 lol
@@demhreyani3185 no, it doesn’t
@@demhreyani3185 Umm no, regardless of religion, anyone can be a good, down to Earth person.
Doctor : your last word pls
Hungarian guy : this is our land
Loll he's so delulu
Doctor: your last word pls
Palestinian guy: this is our land
not hungarian...
@@botiabonyi yes Hungarian
@@Professorxdxd *Israeli
I just wanna give that Palestinian guy a hug. Seems like he went through a lot.
...
...
All because his leaders are not ready for diplomatic relations with Israel too bad
@@procon3080 no. All because of, for example, the soldier that killed his sister. Don't shift blame around. The guy that pulled a trigger on a child is the one at fault no matter how u spin it.
@Edward Teach A.K.A Blackbeard You're taking a side..
Very ignorant and childish, of you.
I came back to rewatch this today, and it really hit me...they might not be alive today. Or their families.
My heart goes out to so many human beings in this country.
Ya :(
YES. HUMAN. BEINGS. THANK YOUU
The Palestinians should be alive, they are from the West Bank and Jerusalem, not Gaza. I would love a follow up as well or at least a link to their social media of they have any. They (Palestinians) all spoke so eloquently and calmly.
@@caseymintzer they seem so precious :( the israeli girl with glasses too.. this situation is so so sad
The boy in white is very hurt. His sadness can be seen through his face.
people said that he got short trying to save his brother from an Israeli soldier beating him :(
Yes and in Palestine you can see a lot of people like him
@@imaffyy Where did you get this news from?
@@imaffyy is there a source?
@@imaffyy wtf bro , are you surious ?
the Palestinians were so much kinder and more open for peace
The Palestinian guy has gone through some serious lows in his life. I hope he finds at least a little happiness and smiles again.
True 😭
Very true, but he's not hateful or spiteful. He has not let his heart rot, but has instead maintained his values. He has not given them the reaction they wanted. He is strong.
@@Ethiopianexposer Yeah.. It's in the bible... Israel will be divided... But in the end Jesus will rise Israel again and he will judge the people who divided it...
@@stevensj6527 Wait I don't get it! So Palestinians won't have their country ?
@@johanna3381 No.. I'm saying that every country will be judged by Jesus... Even Israel... And in the end God will create a new world.. And also a new Israel.. And that Israel is different... Read the bible...
these type of videos make me realize how ignorant and unaware I am of what's going on in the world and outside of my country
Well, at least you're learning. Knowledge is power, after all. :)
Good that's their whole purpose
This shows how broken the American school system is
Yup
I just rely on the internet for actual schooling
I can only imagine how uncomfortable it felt for the Palestenian guy not to be able to express his ideas because of the language it felt like he had too much to say but the language was an obstacle. Also, I really liked when they showed they don't fear the other side that was really powerful and deserves respect.
it is very funny how we arabs always have the foreign languages blocking us from expressing ourselves
@@lcdream4213 bro fr
@ضحى عبد الهادي
Thanks for the recommendation I will check them out 💙
We are not scared of them, or else we would not fight back knowing that we are the weakest due to less armed ( guns) tanks...
yeah, I feel like they should've brought in a language interpreter for him, so he could accurately express his ideas.
A Hungarian telling a Palestinian that that is not his land, we have overcome the absurd
Anyone can determine that it isn't his land regardless of where they come from. No need for the identity politics.
@@RussianBot1998 Its not ID POL to recognize the fact that, someone who knows that their ancestry is from another country should be self aware enough to recognize that they are far less qualified to tell a native what is not their land.
I don't even personally recognize the moral authority of the (any) state or country.. but you cannot tell me i don't belong somewhere i was born and my father(s) are all buried.
*It's not saying "This is NOT your homeland" to say that "this is clearly my homeland".
notice the difference?
Too many people are conflating people with the state.
Some of us want nothing to do with state or law enforcement but rather are only interested in preservation of peace and human rights.
* To disregard all of these types of people as mere casualties of war is the key pervasive ideological problem.
Military violence towards civilians, especially when those deaths outnumber that of combatants, should never be regarded as mere casualties of war.
There should be nothing casual about civilian death in legitimized war because there are in fact rules to modern warfare.
Arafat was a egypten and he is consider the greatest "Palestinian“ ever
Best joke ever haha
Oh and they took the name Palestine from the greek there isnt even a p in arabic, so so funny
Aww you didn't know??@@hansipeppbisch4540 it's "filisteen" in arabic
the guy in white Tshirt bought tears to my eyes his words and thoughts were so beautiful Also how the other Palestinians were calm and composed even after their personal loss.....huge respect to the blonde girl in specks she was a beautiful soul and had empathy
Fr. I don’t think I could be as composed if I were them
I don't like how everyone is being happy about the israel girl that "supports the lost of palestinians" while not looking on the other side israelis lost people too especially this time
I WATCHED this video long ago. But now again it has even more meaning. Very sad too how some had to keep correcting what they said, even though they said it clear the first time. Especially when it came to the simple word PEACE.
The most heartbreaking thing for me is many things... the one that stood out is when the Palestine guy was talking about his sister and what his dad told him about her death. And the other guy responds with.... that's just words or a saying. So rude. I get that too, he probably had watch what he said since he was enlisted in the military.
@@sparky1282 its not that, its the fact that she just wants peace period. she just wants the war to end and wants the violence to stop.
I have sooo much respect for Arab (the palestanian guy) in every way possible. I admire his (mental)strength, empathy, maturity, ideology etc., just LITERALLY *EVERYTHING* .
Really
The Palestinian guy was just showing how a Muslim should react.The way he looked at things and explaining himself,despite the language difficulties,was great.I honestly felt he was the one who wants peace the most.I hope they all have it soon 🙏
G G No I'm a Kurdish living in Turkey since I born 😊
Smash 456 it’s not implying in Islam this is exactly how a Muslim is suppose to act no hatred no violence just talking being open minded being peaceful
Watching this now is completely heartbreaking
It’s not their land, but they pay for it and live on it and work it. You think it’s yours why? Bc someone told you it was??
We all came back to this video for the same reason and with what has been going on recently, this episode is even more heartbreaking than the first time I watched it.... Praying for Palestine
I wonder what suit dude is up to these days. Maybe back at the IDF, waiting to go into Gaza.
@@ratzabur He's raiding the homes in Jaffa probably
@⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻ reported for violence
Bless you
Arab was so well-spoken despite English likely not being his first language. His words were very powerful, and his story was an honor to hear.
Not powerful enough to lift objects 😅
@@t0m653 ur so funny
@@omtaruchiha5809 your name too lol
❤❤
It is easy to tell palywood lie stories! They seem to be true, but they are full of lies!!
The girl with glasses is really understanding, smart, empathetic.
Won my heart.
Hell nah
Bet your Indian 😂😂😂
@@royaldragon1175 how does my comment relate to my country?
@@Farmlover453 me saying your indian is not racist killing lil kids that talks arabic is racist
"...won my heart"
You're an easy touch.
This was absolutely beautiful, almost cried in the end when the meal came and they all share it.
Broke my heart when he tried to tell him it's not his land. Broke it.
Same... How can you look someone in someone's eyes-- someone who was *born and raised* on that land-- and tell them that it isn't theirs? It hurts my heart...
Because God gave the Israelites that land, then people kind of settled there, and then called it Palestine. Hence the conflict Israel wants the land back, bc it was Gods given right, but Palestine believes that is their land, and maybe wants to expand as well. Just saying conflict ain't it. Property isn't everything but that's what's happening
@Blue Flexin lollll
@@ibi137 I think your autocorrect got in the way, please, come back and change it for Palestine. thank you.
@@edithl8625 change my mind I'm open to hear your opinion . It's true though , That's part of the land God promised to Abraham's descendents
I feel like I've just watched something extremely special.
Wow. You are 100% correct. A video like this is one in a billion. I only hope it reaches enough people.
TRULY
I gotta agree
When the Palestinian guy say that the reason we are here is to live, that touched my core
Me 2 , he's so peaceful
We stan.💅🏻
Orion Milan oh hush it
I'm with the Israeli soldiers 100% ... just imagine that you are a soldier what is the first thing you do when you see a little girl
Of course you'll shot her
Sara Melle yep lets just shoot a lil girl who was walking. GrEaT iDeA
As a Palestinian, my Anger issues could never Handle The Israeli Guy, Saying that its not your Land, What do u mean my 9th Great Grand Father Was born In this Land, It was ours, it is ours, and it will be Ours. Peace
Do not confuse private property with an organization such as the state. Furthermore, some Jews lived there as early as the 12th century. So what? In Hebron, Jews lived continuously until 1929.
Same
@@MichaelK___ yeah Palestinian Jews are a thing. But not all Jews are israeli.
You so emotional, bro
As a non Palestinian, my blood boils watching that psychopath speak
That Palestinian guy deserves all the best things in this world.
can't be more agree
Why?? Africans suffer more than these privileged victim card losers. I prefer donating all my wealth to the impoverished peoples of Africa.
Night Prowler literally africa wasn’t even mentioned
I don't like my eyes it reminds me of this Israeli soldier.
@@nightprowler6336 are you blind or something?
Jubilee outdid themselves. THIS IS EPIC
Aww, thank you!! ☺️
Okay this is epic
I feel like they could accomplish anything- I feel like they truly COULD put the KKK and Black Panthers in a room and nothing crazy happen- they truly do have the gift of getting people together non-hostilely
alexa, play despacito
I really liked how understanding the Israeli girl with glasses was
"How about empathy", the closest rebuttal I've heard to a hitchslap since we lost Hitchens.
@@JimmyR42 Ran responded just fine to that. You can have empathy for someone and still hold your position against them. This is a major problem with politics today. Both sides just declare the other just has no heart or they're evil or they have no empathy and then expects to not have to defend their position.
@@JimmyR42 you missed my point entirely but thank you for the short essay. I always enjoy a good read. empathy is not a solution nor an argument. Questioning someone's empathy is what people use as a mechanism to downplay an opposition's significance by calling their virtues immoral.
@@GiggityxGamer Yes I ignored your point because it doesn't concern the question at hand, and I pointed out why in my previous comment but let's try again. What you're saying is about how opposing political sides demonize the other, some of which lack empathy and use the term as a rhetorical device, proving themselves as lacking empathy by doing so. The fact that some people use that term in such a way doesn't mean that it's the only way the term is used, and I'm not saying that what you're describing didn't happen in this conflict but it is a byproduct of the bigger problem she accurately pointed at. The way she used it wasn't to accuse him of lacking empathy as a person but rather to point out that the tool he's using to justify his position, history, is the same tool that both sides are using and the reason why they are both entrenched in their position pointing fingers at each other, like kids saying "the other one started it first". An empathy-based reasoning would not look behind and look at the now(to stop the killing) and the future(to bring hope) and is the only way out of such a conflict without a blood bath to determine the "victor".
Also "Questioning someone's empathy is what people use as a mechanism to downplay an opposition's significance by calling their virtues immoral."
This can sometimes be true(it often is in american politics), but it is also true that immorality has often tried to justify itself as a necessity via some other "virtue" and that this rigid mindset of "my virtues are infallible" is not only proof of a lack of empathy, it might even go as far as just a basic lack of sympathy. So how would you differentiate both cases?
Cola Slimes She was the only good person who was from Isreal that was there
I could not hold back my tears while watching this, especially when thinking of what is happening nowadays in Palestine. I could feel the pain in their eyes. Although Arab couldn't speak English fluently and couldn't express all he wanted to say, he didn't need to say anything. I could read his mind when looking into his eyes.
I find it very kind of the two Israeli girls to communicate nicely and show empathy, not only for Israel. As for the politician Ran, I am very disappointed. He made his point very clear: he doesn’t see Palestinians as human beings and wants Palestine to disappear. He can't even compromise.
This shows that most ordinary Israeli people aren't the reason for this conflict, but the government is the actual problem.
Wish peace for everyone
The pain in Arab's eyes when he tells of the loss of his sister and the calm they all manage to keep while remembering their killed family members touches me. I'm so sorry for them. No one should experience that.
"I was born to live but my sister was born to die". I could see pain in his eyes in the whole video.
JeremyD how tf do u know
@@bok1829 the fear of eternal oblivion
He's got more to say but they are sometimes interuping which makes go little mad because they I think have the right to talk in this whole video since... IT'S THEIR LAND! don't they get it🙄🙄😕🤔
@@bok1829 😂
Doraemon New Episodes ok fuck you
I really felt the sadness of Arab (the Palestinian guy/brother) still struggling to make sense for his murdered sister.
May you find peace.
It would be interesting to see this same group today and see how feelings have stayed the same or changed.
The guy with white t shirt was real….I felt his emotions in everything he says
Meanwhile, the opposite can be said about the one in this suit
@@narimannarimanxool4443 yas
You put emotions over logic
@@firstnamesurname8531 wait to u stand with the Palestinians or Israeli
@@Laking1234 He was more logical too lol
This is the way UA-cam should be used. This 23 minutes long video presented how human beings can be dispersed in such a cruel way, but also showed how they can be integrated into one respectful value, peace.
희수 exactly I love watching entertaining videos but I absolutely love watching videos like this middle ground is amazing. Instead of watching videos about people spilling tea on other youtubers and talking about first world problems this should be topic and more controversial.
23 minutes well spent ☺
@@abdultawwab486 I'd say 23 mins is not enough time. These questions and answers seems like they are at least 30 mins each. And to just edit it down to 23 mins seems unjust. It really does leave gaps in the conversation and your understanding of there personal experiences.
It's interesting that the only people who said they were afraid of the other side were the only ones who had never lost relatives to the conflict.
I can’t exactly say for the Israeli brunette, but the one with glasses said she was afraid because of the things her people did to the other side. Not completely sure, but that’s what I got from what she said.
Ikr, why play the victim? (I’m not categorising everyone but the people that do)
That’s because they feel guilty, and they fear justice from the Palestine people, retaliation
Plus they’re the ones with so much military power and support. Says a lot about them.
I laughed so hard when one of them said she was afraid of someone shooting her...
“I’m afraid of going into Gaza” Palestinians have to live that same fear everyday of living in their own land
Because of who? (prior to the conflict)
jews arent allowed in palestine
@@etsiPolitiquestill Israel
I think it’s important to bring a translator for people who are not as fluent in the language. Everyone deserves to fully express themselves.
completely agree.
Strongly agree
indeed
i can't believe they didn't
just learn english properly if you dont its your problem not theirs, also how would they guess you dont know proper english? bring your own translator
My heart is aching after seeing The Palestinian guy.See into his eyes.His eyes are tired of experiencing awful things throughout his journey 😔
I hope i dont offend anyone and feel free to correct me but i see that most conflicts are cause of religion. (my point of view and opinion NOT A FACT)
@@anunknownperson4018 this isnt a religious issue tho its an ethnic one
@@anunknownperson4018 I think bcuz of religion there is still peace.Otherwise people would do anything whatever they wanted to do.If there wasn’t religious issue then there would be the issue of, racism, ethnic cleansing, apartheid, so on
@@moni7803 This is obviously about religion. Israeli want the Al-aqsa mosque, our first qibla because on the day before the war started last Ramadan, Israeli military first attacked Al-aqsa mosque and now they break the ceasefire by attacking Muslims during jumaah prayer in Al-aqsa mosque. Why is this not related to religion if you said so ? Even in quran, bani Israel will never be happy with muslim because they rejected to believe that our last prophet was Prophet Muhammad and not one of them
I really really wanna hug that Palestinian guy who lost his sister.... 😢😢 I can feel his pain 🙏
Trust me
So you lost one of your sister because of someone?
Ya the other side lost 27 of his colsest friends... i feel him for also
@@amallukose1485 🧢 he had 0 friends
@@sheeshkabish42 you have 0 friends
And people think this all started oct 7😂
The video itself is 5 year's ago
It started way before then. I here what people are saying, reading the comments, about how the Arabs lost people they new, but the jews, the Israelis, we didn't? We didn't lose people we know? I'm not losing people I know this very second? I feel terrible that human lives are ending on the 'Palestinian' end. But at the end of the day, a lot of these people are not innocent. And the ones that are, are being used as human shields by Hamas.
Black lives matter. Gender equality. Palestinian lives matter. That's what everyone says. But Jewish lives don't? Hm, something is just a TAD messed up here.
And don't argue against me until you have learned history, looked at PROVEN facts, and gained some knowledge. Then we can speak.
he is talking about present people who thinks that this conflict started after oct 7@@Mohsameer10
@@Mohsameer10 Do you condemn Hamas?
@@ghofranelaouar1164 Why?
You see, when people stop seeing others as beliefs, geography and their histories, and instead as human beings, they can come together and break bread. Arab is an amazing person.
Who deserves his land and the many generations his family lived on in peace.
Yeah, me too, i see arab is a tough person
but humans are histories, beliefs, geographies. thats the thing. theyre much more than just bodies. they represent cultures.
@@jeffbezos8392 not at all, these things are just comfortable fictions concocted by politicians and capitalist to keep workers fighting and to themselves stay in power