Nightwish "Shoemaker" REACTION & ANALYSIS by Vocal Coach/Opera Singer
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 сер 2020
- This song celebrates both incredible musicians and the legendary scientist, Eugene Shoemaker.
Join professional opera singer Elizabeth Zharoff, as she listens to and analyzes Nightwish's song, "Shoemaker" for the first time.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Performed by Nightwish - Music by Tuomas Holopainen - Performers Floor Jansen, Marko Hietala, Emppu Vuorinen, Troy Donockley, Kai Hahto, and Tuomas Holopainen
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I definitely recommend watching the original video without interruptions, here's the link: • NIGHTWISH - Shoemaker ...
Show Nightwish some love: / @nightwish
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Want to video chat with me live? Join our Patreon!
/ thecharismaticvoice
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WE HAVE MERCH! Check-out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🎧 Elizabeth’s favorite headphones 🎧 : imp.i114863.net/zayoEM
Music Gear Questions? 🎤 See my list of recommendations: imp.i114863.net/yRyGoV
WANT MY CHAIR? I don’t blame you…and here’s a link to make it even sweeter:
secretlab.co/?rfsn=4692958.b2...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🎙️Podcast: thecharismaticvoice.com/podcast/
🌐Website: thecharismaticvoice.com
📸Instagram: / thecharismaticvoice
🧑🤝🧑Patreon: / thecharismaticvoice
📺Twitch: / thecharismaticvoice
📰Our FREE Newsletter: eepurl.com/gz7Z_z
-------------------------------------COURSES------------------------------------------
🎵MUSIC APPRECIATION COURSE🎵
Want to understand how to listen to and appreciate music more? My Music Appreciation course is now live. Take a look at thecharismaticvoice.com
🎶DEMYSTIFYING SINGING🎶
My intensive 7-week course on vocal foundations includes weekly group sessions and private lessons. Learn more at thecharismaticvoice.com.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Elizabeth Zharoff is an international opera singer and voice coach, with 3 degrees in voice, opera, and music production. She's performed in 18 languages throughout major venues in Europe, America, and Asia. Currently based somewhere between Los Angeles and Tucson, Arizona, Elizabeth spends her days researching voice, singing, teaching, writing music, and recording TONS. She also plays Diablo and Dungeons & Dragons.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Want a free voice lesson? Sign-up to WIN at mailchi.mp/thecharismaticvoic...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#Nightwish #Reaction #ElizabethZharoff
![LM. 08.1 [REACTION] Nightwish - Shoemaker (English subtitles)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Gwa2vX2xbUI/mqdefault.jpg)
We just released merchandise! Check out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com
Hi, I love your nightwish videos, please I have a request, please watch this video where Marco sings, let's call it a tribute to his unfortunately nightwish farewell. Nightwish - While Your Lips Are Still Red (Live at Wembley Arena)
Thank you very much, kissss
I returned to this reaction - the second one this evening - and I noticed something weird. There is no way I wouldn't have given this a like, as seems also be the case with your first encounter with Floor being "Ghost love Score" which didn't seem to have a like from me either.
Are likes disappearing after some time? In any case you received likes again on this and the other video, even though I'm convinced I gave them likes the first times I saw these reactions. Although I'm not quite familiar with the earnings model YT has agreed with creators like you, but I think the amount of likes is part of that; if in time likes are made to "disappear" it may reduce the earnings which I find - if true - a bit disturbing.
Ebba grön
It's so nice to see somebody react to this who a) did their research and memorized it too b) already knows enough Latin to not need to look up what the lyrics mean c) draws a legitimate comparison between Tuomas composing and Mozart d) actually knows what the hell they're talking about e) likes it
Thank you for existing xD you help bridge the already very small gap between the metal and classical genres
I fully agree !!!
I would heart this a thousand times if I could. It feels so good to be appreciated for the extra work I put into making these videos awesome for you all. Thank you so much!
@@TheCharismaticVoice it is what separates a mere 'fun' reaction from a great reaction. If I see one of your reactions come by for a music genre I like, I generally immediately jump on them because you indeed clearly know your stuff. I love the absolute enjoyment in what you do: both in skills of the artists involved, or intricacies you appreciate, or lyrics, or whatever. You're very expressive, and it's a pleasure to watch and listen to.
@@jukkahelminen9071 I'm with you on this
Well said
I may get some slack for this, but I think Nightwish is one of the top 5 greatest bands of all time.
Yeah you are right you will get some slack, cause they are number 1!
Anyone who disagrees ain't listening
No why? They probably better
You are absolutely right🤘🙌👏
@@fozzylozzy1131 🤘🤘🤘✊
"I didn't want to stop it" Thank you Elizabeth
Thomas is an underrated genius. They way that he has been putting these songs together for over a two decades is amazing!
Thank you Duncan Allers, come and visit my Patreon patreon.com/thecharismaticvoice as we explore the world of music, voice, and more! See yah!
Tuomas.
That part at the end...gets me in the feels EVERY TIME. like...crying. It is just so beautiful.
Same. Floor does it to me more time than I care to admit. It’s insane.
Big burly NASA engineer here crying like a baby.
Same! Lots of Nightwish songs along with Floor's storytelling ability hits home every time.
Is that Floor at the end ?
@@ysinvangulik1004 Yep and.... Troy and Marco+ Johanna with a reverb and slight choir backing track.... :)
I saw them 5 months ago and when that part towards the end happened, the entire crowd literally stopped and was completely taken over with Floor’s voice. It was like the entire night stopped for a bit. Amazing 🤘
I saw them back in November myself and now that I've read this comment, its reminded me how quiet the arena was. Everyone in that room was silent as soon as the first syllable of the first Laudato came out
Ad astra comes from the latin phrase "Per aspera ad astra" which means "through hardships to the stars". At NASA it is our motto. And I think we just found our theme song.
Per ardua ad astra is the phrase you're thinking of.
@@linabasilisk1955 that's the motto of the RAF and the RAAF.
@@linabasilisk1955 I think we are both correct.
"ardua" is the latin root of the English word "arduous", but is also captured by the English words "difficult" and "struggle"
Per ardua ad astra could then be translated as "through struggle/difficulty/adversity to the stars". It is the official motto of the RAF and Air Forces of countries in the British Commonwealth, interestingly save the South African Air Force, which adopted "per aspera ad astra" as their motto.
A literal translation of aspera is "rough" but seems to find better meaning in English word "hardships" So "per aspera ad astra" would translate as "through hardships to the stars".
Given the deaths of NASA astronauts in the Apollo 1 fire and Columbia and Challenger disasters, I think "per aspera ad astra" might be a better motto for NASA. Many of us in the Agency just use 'ad astra" as a closing salutation in our emails. I knew there was more than just that, but hadn't pursued it further. So thank you for prompting me to dig deeper into the topic.
Oh, and while the RAF and other Air Forces use "per ardua ad astra" as a motto, I think a better motto for organizations like Air Forces that fly machines to reach great heights but not so high as to reach the "stars" a better motto might be "per ardua ad alta".
ad astra,
Father Rocket
You guys are so cool!
Won a Boy Scout model rocket contest in early '72 and received an Apollo 15 mission patch as my prize, courtesy of one of our leaders who was a NASA engineer...still have it (and other NASA goodies) on a wall in my office!
Theme song, of course. Should probably also consider them for video soundtracks, STEM education ambassadorships and off-planet performances!
@@roblaw4554 On a hot July in 1969 I was nine years old watching with rapt attention a grainy black and white video of a learned ape from Earth set foot on another celestial body for the first time. On that day I found what I wanted my future to be and for the last 40 years I have had the privilege to get to live my dream.
The singing on this song is HARD. What Floor is doing is incredibly difficult and she sounds absolutely flawless, as always. SO good.
Yours is an empty hope - live Wembley. You will never forget it, guaranteed.
"Different side" of Floor's vocal.
Elizabeth? =)
YES. THIS. 100%
Oh, yes! I usually ask people to listen to "Yours is an..." before "Shoemaker" but reversed is just fine.
Indeed, only, pay attention to who is "singing" what, lol.
Fuck yes!
IMHO the Nightwish cruise live version of that song is better. People usually recommend the Wembley version because it has livelier atmosphere and Floor is more audible but the reason Floor is more audible is because Marco has been mic'ed down. I like Floor & Marco harmonizing when they have the same mic settings - they just blend together perfectly. I am not a big fan of the EQ settings on Floor's vocal track in any of the Wembley songs either. Whoever was the sound engineer that day made Floor sound slightly boomy and muddy. Compare that to her vocal track in Wacken 2013 the difference is night and day !
In an interview Floor said, that she discovered, that her operatic singing did a leap, lately. She also said, that it might be part of her voice maturing with age and that she wants so see further into it.
I hope so too.
And perhaps as a bit of a baseline you might watch "Floor Jansen interview (with subtitles!) and Puccini Aria Live in Tiende van Tijl 2013-1-2". They bring her on a TV show all about classical music. The host introduces her and then shows the audience a Nightwish clip (watch some of their faces!) before she performs this lovely piece from Gianni Schicchi. You know, this metal...person...with the nose ring will dare to attempt opera? Hmmmph. ua-cam.com/video/Od_qcbw3f5Q/v-deo.html
Enjoy!
Wow, Floor is getting better, how can we keep up, I’m already overwhelmed with tears and goosebumps 🤣, what an amazing voice and highly impressive music and song writing.
@JediNxf7 Gianni Schicchi is apparently the title of this opera...
@JediNxf7 With pleasure :)
@JediNxf7 I find the fact that Nightwish increase fluency in opera and musical theater, and maybe even science, just deeelicious!
The childlike innocence on Elizabeth's face when she tunes in is so, so beautiful to witness. It is that recognition that magic truly exists. Yes I love Elizabeth's reactions and am a new Nightwish/Floor fan. Truly magical 👍😊
So, then we have to keep you "Indoors" for sure!
I heard this song first live I am a huge Nightwish fan but had not heard this album yet before the concert she hit the opera passage and it was amazing my hair stood up on my arms I teared up it was beyond beautiful.
@@anaguq4651 Indoors or out magic exists 👍😊
I apologize in advance if my english is not perfect, not my mother language (I'm Italian), but I want to add something about the ashes being sent to the Moon.
The thing is that Eugene spent a lot of his career studying the moon and its craters (to better understand the impact craters on earth), at the point that he wished one day he could go up there and study them on the spot. Then the possibility of taking astronauts to the moon became reasonable, and Shoemaker applied immediately to be an astronaut and be part of the program, but he was later declined due to his health conditions: he had addison's disease (which affects adrenal glands and some hormones production).
Quoting him directly "Not going to the moon and banging on it with my own hammer has been the biggest disappointment in life".
Listening to this song strikes me very hard, as I'm a Physicist with an extreme love for my subject, and I feel I can understand what he felt was taken away from him.
He was a geologist, and all he wanted to do was to go up there and replicate the same movements and activities typical of his field of studies on the moon's surface.
Knowing that he died without ever making it to the moon, one of his student, managed to put some of his ashes into a NASA probe which would "crash" into the moon (like a meteor that creates a crater, ironic detail), along with a photo of the Beringer crater (the one he was famous for) and the quote from Romeo and Juliet that is at the end of the song...
...making him the ONLY man buried on the Moon.
Now, the quote
"And when he shall die
Take him and cut him out in little stars
And he will make the face of heaven so fine
That all the world will be in love with the night
And pay no worship to the garish sun"
assume a new, beautiful meaning in my perspective
Thank you for this addition!
great! thank you
In addition to being part of the team to find the comet Shoemaker-Levy, what a dude.
@@tyrantworm7392 the team was Eugene, Catherine Shoemaker(his wife) and Levy, an old and very appassionate friend.
I'd recommend checking this out, too, for backstory:
NIGHTWISH - Shoemaker ( Story and Reaction ) - HalfLifeSistah
ua-cam.com/video/v3AG8lLjAXs/v-deo.html
I absolutely love the reaction.. this is REAL reaction... with intelligent voice commentary. I can't get enough of these videos. Thank you for being authentic.
Thanks, Brandon! Much appreciated!
Floor told in one of her YT videos that the operatic vocals part took her some time to get just right as she is a perfectionist. They had already recorded the vocals for the song & were pretty happy with them, but Floor decided to give it one more go. So she took an audio track with also the choir in it, as previously she had sung her part without hearing the choir, and used it at her home studio for recording her vocals once more & was finally completely satisfied with them.
P.S. Because the Moon is tidally locked with the Earth, one side of the Moon always faces toward Earth. Interpretation of this fact would lead one to believe that the Earth's position is fixed on the lunar sky and no earthrises can occur; However, the Moon librates slightly, which causes the Earth to draw a Lissajous figure on the sky. This figure fits inside a rectangle 15°48' wide and 13°20' high (in angular dimensions), while the angular diameter of the Earth as seen from Moon is only about 2°. This means that earthrises are visible near the edge of the Earth-observable surface of the Moon (about 20% of the surface). Since a full libration cycle takes about 27 days, earthrises are very slow, and it takes about 48 hours for Earth to clear its diameter.
That makes so much sense. That section isn't easy, and having support from choral vocals would really help to find the perfect tone.
Thanks for that scientific explanation. Learned something more :-)
@@PeaceweaponPT You're welcome, but the thanks go to whoever wrote the Wikipedia article.
@@strogaa You're welcome, but the thanks go to whoever wrote the Wikipedia article.
@@tarmotyyri6733 You're right, but I'm not an exzessive Wikipedia reader ;-)
In fact, the question started in my head the moment she mentioned it: "No, wait a moment..."
And while I read the comments I saw your explanation about exactly that topic. Therefore I think, my thanks go to the right person :-)
Anyone else here after watching the virtual concert? ... Goosebumps!
The woman quoting the Shakespeare is Tuomas' wife, Johanna Kurkela. And for me, she had one of the most beautiful voice I've ever heard. You should check her singing, her voice is magically enchanting
I love her cover of "Nothing Else Matters" 🥰
Floor's agility on How's The Heart live acoustic at Planet Rock is amazing! It's a must watch 😎
Siiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii. Es una tremenda versión acústica.
Oh yes, this is a must - it's a really good video for voice-coach analysis too, since you can see and hear everything she's doing without the camera moving off her.
THIS please
Oh yes, a lovely acoustic song. One take, nowhere to hide and I don't think everybody appreciates how difficult a song it is to sing.
Agreed, if you want to listen to Floor in a pure naked unlayered way please listen to this fantastic live acoustic recording. It is so skillful. Also awesome guitar playing by Troy.
The first time I heard that last classical part in Latin, I cried my eyeballs out. So gorgeous and respectful. It still gives me the tingles all over my skull every time I hear it. A beautiful ode to Eugene Shoemaker.
You can always accurately determine the moment when Elizabeth begins to count the time signature.
"praise be to the stars" best lyrical sentiment ever
I cried like a baby when I first heard it. Then I went to read about Shoemaker and cried some more. This is a masterpiece! Thank you for the review
onion ninjas arrive almost every time I hear this
okay, maybe every time
Same here, I get an odd throat knot every time I read the lyrics, like in not being able to try and sing a single riff without my voice breaking.
It's just so beautifully written it blows me away.
I am here for the way Elizabeth's face brightens and shines every time she listens to amazing singing.
Laudato Si isn't actually latin, not in the classical sense( it would have been laudatum). It is ancient Italian, or medieval ecllesiastic latin. It is in fact a famous lyric from the Canticle of the Sun of Saint Francis ( Laudato Si o mi Signore...)
Great reaction
The body of work Floor represents at this stage is quite astonishing. I suspect that adoration for her will grow as the world slowly absorbs her impact. Like Freddie Mercury who is more popular now 30 years after his passing than in his own lifetime. Floor is that calibre.
Yes, she is. Freddie was her idol, also. Would love to have seen them sing together. That would have been a truly magical experience that you only get once in a lifetime.
"sounds like Mozart" Well Tuomas IS known as metal Mozart, so thats not too far off! :)
Sibelius ☝️
#Charismaticnailedit
@@TheCharismaticVoice you are AWESOME !!!! thank you ! maybe Floor's performance of Vilja Lied from Beste Zangers 2019 would peak your interest as well ?
5:29 Profit Strategy 2020
ua-cam.com/video/qCTMnqf1EL8/v-deo.html
When the male voices singing "Ad Astra" come in to join Floors "Laudato Si", I tear up Every. Single. Time.
I always enjoy your reactions. You are so insightful, and it's so easy to see how you LOVE music.
is that Troy (and marco in layers)? or is it a full choir?
@@brentverb1295 I think it may have been a choir but if it were Troy and Marco in layers, imagine the three of them (Floor, Troy and Marco) singing the outro live. ; A;
6:19 Easy Strategyua-cam.com/video/OW2VDi6QI48/v-deo.html
I just started listening to this band and it blew my mind🤯🔥🔥
I have two thoughts. Troy's vocals are such a great addition to the band, and Tuomas is beyond musical genius. Thank you for your insight into this song. Always a pleasure.
"Not a normal time signature"... For Tuomas it is :D
hahahaha truth
DjKorppi fFloor has said that she had a hard time mastering the singing on this on because of the magical but wondering time signature...but did a nice job didn’t she...:)
This gonna be stellar!
tee he he hee!
I see what you did there...😏🌟
/facepalm
Already is
BA DUM TSS
The second chorus was not a harpsichord. It was a dulcimer you were hearing. Just like is mentioned in the lyrics, "Stars calling with the sound of a dreamlike dulcimer". That last visual from the perspective of Eugene's crater and burial site on the moon, watching the Earth set and then the Sun set over the horizon of the Moon is epic. Loved your analysis and reaction to this very special "Ode to Eugene Shoemaker". See you soon lovely lady. Peace.
Tuomas wanted to Tribute Shoemaker - and he really did it here. The video images make it complete. His wife read the lyrics of Shakespeare.
Always enjoy your analysis. Your habit of going back to catch the transitions is very much appreciated. Also, you dive into the lyrics, time signatures, vocal qualities and harmonies, and always catch those instrumental details that so many others miss. Well done!
Thanks for also noticing the transition catch. I made that shift not too long ago, and also feel like it helps me to experience the music more fully.
Your face when Floor started the "Laudato Si" passage was exactly as I imagined. Excellent! Another Floorgasm?
just one?! several...
@@TheCharismaticVoice That's what we like to hear haha!
well ppl said she wont be able to do it live and she proved them wrong only a few weeks ago on there live concert it was amazing
It is now established that we need a reaction to every song of the album, because each one is unique in its own way.
Yep..🤗
The Shakespearean narration is performed by Tuomas' wife.
Oh really? That's cool, I didn't know that.
Johanna Kurkela
Silmu pelaa that’s right, I couldn’t remember her name.
You can hear her sing in Tuomas second band "Auri" together with Troy :)
@@daydreamer2064 Also in Tuomas's solo album The Life and Times of Scrooge. She sings the character of Goldie O'Gilt (It's a concept album based on the Scrooge McDuck comics and even features cover and sleeve art by Scrooge McDuck illustrator Don Rosa), most notably as the lead voice in the songs The Last Sled and A Lifetime of Adventure
Great reaction as usual.. Incidentally the lady doing the spoken word is Tuomas wife. Johanna Kurkela you can hear her sing with Troy and Tuomas in their side project Auri.. Tuomas said after writing some of the songs for the Auri album he had inspiriation to write the music for Human to Nature the new Nightwish album..This song features Johanna and Troy singing..........AURI - Desert Flower (OFFICIAL LYRIC VIDEO)
Amazing reaction from you as always 👍
A little fact. Floor told us in an interview that the last part - the recorded it several times before Tuomas were satisfied. Then they all went home - but Floor didn't have the right feeling at the end, she couldn't feel it deeply enough - so she listened and rehearsed further and then recorded it in her home studio - and nailed id. The feeling was there. She sent it to Tuomas, this is the ending you hear on the album. Floor is such a perfectionist and a voicenerd - and this is why this song goes right into our soul and heart. Floor had done her magic once again - you can actually feel her emotions in that ending.
Incredible - but Floor in a nutshell - pure perfection, and the song has a soul. 🤘 🤘 🤘
The last "Laudato Si" before the first "Ad Astra" - where she transitions from the light and sonorous tone, and slides down into a more powerful tone just gives me the absolute chills every time. Major goosebumps all the way up my spine to the base of my skull - not just my forearms or something. Absolutely incredible. Some kind of "the note" or harmonic that really hits me just right. I love a lot of her work, but this just nails me to the wall! :) Thanks for doing this one. Lots of fun!
Exactly this! That moment in the song is amazing
I could not have said it better
Did you notice the end shot? View of the earth, sun going down, as if from the crater where Eugene has found his last resting place... homage indeed! Thanks Elizabeth for enjoying Shoemaker and pointing things out to us!
I love this idea--I mean it's misleading and factually inaccurate and scientifically devoid of merit, and I absolutely love it--VERY pretty idea!
5:18 Good Profit Strategy
ua-cam.com/video/lkQjl9Gz8Fg/v-deo.html
"...calling with the sound of a dreamlike dulcimer..." - there you have your elegant, classical, harp-like instrument that you noticed. It actually makes an appearance in the lyrics as well. :)
I was thinking it could be a kantele as well, or maybe a kantele played hammered like dulcimer would be
Beautiful instrument too, to compliment this piece!
Crap .. didn't see this comment, before I posted one mentioning the same. Oh well, off to delete my original post then it is xD
@@Lacrimarimus it's the hammered dulcimer. I've been practicing that line on mine and while compared to this track it sounds like crap when I play it (so far, it's NOT an easy line even without the crazy timing) it's definitely the right instrument.
I'm always impressed by how much detail a professional singer/musician can pull out of just hearing a song. Really great analysis and reaction as always!
Loved the way you talk about the spoken word part, can't wait to see the reaction to Dead Boys Poem some day way down the timeline (I refuse to believe the Nightwish train can ever fully stop!)
Every time I play Shoemaker I know I'm going to replay the last section over and over again because it is so gorgeous. I get full body shivers every time I hear it.
This is the Nightwish song that will blow your socks off! Cannot wait!
I love Nightwish but I really don't like this song for some reason. But hey, not everyone likes every single song right?
.Shoemaker live..it blows us away..i am shure..what a Masterpiece again from Nightwish 🥰
I really enjoy your videos. Not just for the perspective and expert knowledge of application of technique, but also to know I'm not alone when I get so worked up and excited over things in music that other people don't often notice or don't care about. I think my favorite thing about music is the way you can FEEL how much love and care and craftsmanship went into a track like this.
Thank you! This is such a sweet and insightful comment, and it made me smile extra big.
You must be in that 20% of the population, who is highly sensitive,
most artists and musicians are too, especially Tuomas and Floor.
Wonderful reaction Elizabeth. I've been following your Nightwish reactions Since the Ghost Love Score and your journey of discovery has been so much fun to watch.
And this is how you make Elizabeth very happy 😂❤
Funfact: The Man who sings together with Floor in the Duett Section of the Song is the incredible Troy ... the Flute and Bagpipe Player of the Band. :)
Also Marco is singing there too so it is not a duet.
It’s actually not the bagpipe it’s called the uilliean pipes. I believe it’s Gaelic and instead of feeding through the mouth it’s fed through the elbow which gives its name. Troy has talked about that in a few interviews. :)
@@mantailuaa Yup, he is the high male voice in the background. Very soft, so it's easy to miss, however with any decent headphone you should be able to hear it.
@@tjitsekoster9379 Troy typically sings the lowest part; Marco typically sings the middle harmony ...just sayin'
Her opera voice reminds me of an opera singer called Elżbieta Towarnicka - she was singing in many soundtrack to Kieślowski's films composed by Preisner. Very delicate aproach to high notes with much less vibratto than normally in opera-style singing. It's absolutely amazing that Floor can do something like that too. And it sounds just great. This ending... Wow...
You are definately my favourite vocal coach reactor. You seem so genuine, in love with your craft and a warm hearted person in general. Shout out from Finland! o/
Your facial expressions and personality are amazing!
The harmonies, with Troy as the dominant voice, I think is meant to be "Shoemaker" singing back to us.
And with Marko too. They all three are singing the harmonies.
love this idea.
it is a beautiful idea, and almost certainly wrong. Shoemaker is not a character with a part in this piece; he is the SUBJECT of it--all 3 voices (Troy, Marko, and Floor) beautifully sing the exact same words to honor the life and accomplishments of this extraordinary scientist--no one sings "Shoemaker's part".
@@evilchipmunk4090
I don't know. The lyrics of that part feel like they are being sung in the first person, where as the rest of the lyrics are being sung about Shoemaker.
@@ChrisHinton1967 sung in first person, by all three people, and somehow Troy is singing Shoemaker's part? I think it's almost CERTAINLY wrong--Troy's voice isn't meant to represent anything that Marko's or Floor's is--they're all singing in unison!
yes, technics, talent, singing, writting, lot of work, etc, etc, ... but something else is here, a bigger thing: she speak to your soul. her tone and emotion navigate throught your hears to your heart.
In France a singer said "I sing to save my soul". I believe it's the point here.
I love your Nightwish reactions. You always seem SO excited while giving one of the most in depth analysis I've seen. Your giggles, gasps and excitement always make me smile. A please to watch someone genuine who knows audio so well! :)
I love this woman, can’t wait 😊 What a Masterpiece : Shoemaker ! ☄️💥🤘🏻
Any chance of reaching out to Floor on her social media? Would love to see you two discussing the technicalities of singing..
As always a wonderful reaction/analysis. The end still draws tears after hearing it a hundred times.
Floor did say that Tuomas challenged her more than ever at the time of that album and it speaks volumes about him as a composer.
"Laudato Si, Ad Astra"= "all praise be to the stars"
I loved the way u explained everything about that kind of singing, the technique and how difficult is to do that.. Floor did a magnificent job!
Thanks! Yes - that last part in particular is technically much more difficult than I think a lot of people would initially imagine. It was so fun to get nerdy and go into those details.
I loved your reaction and analysis of "Shoemaker". You pointed out some stuff that I didn't even hear the first time and made me appreciate the song even more. Thanks and looking forward to the next reaction video.
You're definitely my favorite vocal coach from UA-cam.
My recommendation will Kamelot's"Elizabeth" Parts 1, 2 and 3. It's one of the most theatrical performances I've seen, with another singer who's a master at evoking every emotion in each song he does
Yes this one, I think it's better than the studio album..
Yes! Roy Khan is a very theatrical performer and the song is incredible.
Great suggestion! Also: Kamelot ft Simone Simons in The Haunting.
Abandoned + When the Lights are Down is a good one too
7:25 Easy Strategyua-cam.com/video/OW2VDi6QI48/v-deo.html
Dear Elizabeth, this whole album is really out of the box even for Nightwish, and it´s absolutely mindblowing. I just hope you will react to more songs from it.
Music?
@@kevytmelankolia3395 Yes, Music, Noise, Pan. Any of these. :)
6:29 Auto Money Strategyua-cam.com/video/OW2VDi6QI48/v-deo.html
Nightwish just gets better and better, and with Floor's voice added, they are reaching the stars, for sure
@Chelley Fulljames What a blessing, then, that Nightwish tied together Eugene and his craters for the rest of us. A beautiful song for a beautiful reason. Enjoyed your comment. (And your English is wonderful, by the way)
"Laudato si ad astra": All praise belongs to the stars.
As Carl Sagan once famously said, "We are star-stuff that has taken destiny into its own hands". Every atom in your body (and everything else in the entire universe) came into being either in the death throes of stars that went supernova, or from the Big Bang itself. Laudato si ad astra, indeed. Tuomas knew what he was doing when he wrote that lyric. And Eugene Shoemaker was undoubtedly also aware, and in awe of, this fact as well.
IS a genuine piece of art, for the real story, the connection with Shakespeare, the moon and space. THE MUSIC IS NOTHING LESS THAN MAGNANIMOUS. YOU WILL EXPERIENCE A journy, , AN EXPERIENCE ..... THANK YOU VERY MUCH FROM CHILE.
This song is incredibly moving. Brought me to tears💗😭🌌🌑
If you are interested to Floors operatic side more. You could react hers Vilja Lied from Beste Zanger or Epica and Floor Stabat Mater Dolorosa.
Yes stabat mater dolorosa
yes, please react to Vija Lied from Best Zangers, you will love it :)
6:34 Auto Money Strategy
ua-cam.com/video/qCTMnqf1EL8/v-deo.html
I truly appreciate the professionalism you bring to these reactions. How informative you are! AND the emotional appreciation you also allow!
I dont know any other group that can take metal, elements of folk and classici, and blend it together,the way it's done by nightwish.
Laudato si ad astra
Praise be to the stars
😊❤🖖
I love how that song speaks to me both as a Nightwish and a SciFi/space exploration fan! 😊
This speaks to me as a Nightwish fan and space engineer :)
LLAP ;)
@@elenazorzolirossi4236 oooooohhhhh ... that's so coool!!! 😊😊
Your translation is not quite accurate. It actually means "Be praised to the stars". "Laudato si" means "praised be". It's taken from Franciscus of Assisi "Laudato si, o mi signore" = "Be praised, oh my Lord" and "per aspera ad astra" = "through hardships to the stars".
Back with Nightwish yeeeeeaaayyyy... reminder set....can't wait . Keep safe and healthy ..💖💟👍
This always smacks me right in the feels. A beautiful performance. Great reaction / analysis cant wait for more :D
I love watching your eyes light up when you hear something amazing! Your reactions are always the best because they are always the most genuine and you clearly just appreciate good music 💕
Your expression changing as you listen to the ending has made my Friday. Great reaction!
Stellar reaction, Elizabeth. You're a star 🌟
I would love to see Tuomas's first reaction hearing that when she ended that song with that.
Amazing Reaction !!! Such detail and technical breakdown ! I enjoy this so much ❤️, it helps me to even further appreciate the amount of work and talent in each Nightwish performance !!!
I love, love, love watching your reactions on your face as you listen to music! Your passion is infectious and inspiring and your commentary is educational. It changes the way I listen to music. Thank you!
As the flower breathes the sun, you breathe the music...enormously appreciated, for you bring back the tears I shed on my first listening.
I can't wait to hear this song Live !!! and it's so amazing how you can explain every particularity of this song. Thanks again Elizabeth :)
Thank you for this wonderful reaction, one of the best ones I have seen.
I’ll be at work when this premieres, but I’ll watch it as soon as I possibly can 😁 This is an amazing song and I can’t wait to watch an awesome performer lose her mind a few times (especially at the end 😉)
Have a fantastic night and I’ll catch this tomorrow 😎👍
Cant' can't can't wait!!! So, so, so much still to discover in Nightwish, looking forward to your videos. Keep it up!
PS: thanks to your analysis video I discoverd a bit of The Dive Dance in an acient Nightwish track from 1998, thank you for expanding my horizons and bringing the knowledge I never knew I needed :)
PPS: I recommend "Endlessness" from the same album, gives me goosebumps everytime: lyrical analysis mandatory! Hope they are able to bring us a live version soon, which I am sure will be even better than the album track.
PPSS: Nightwish "Yours Is An Empty Hope" and "While Your Lips Are Still Red" (live at Wembley) for some awesome vocal diversity from the same singers...
The Best Music Reactor..breaking down my Favorite Female Singer, Floor.😍💯
Thank you Elizabeth for explaining this song, music and lyrics. I Never felt the need to listen to this song but now, thanks to you i did and it was a real eyeopener.
Hey Elisabeth! Here's the daily reminder that HEILUNG are waiting for you! If you fancy some antique, mezmerizing, tribal atmosphere and interesting singing techniques, Heilung will definitely be a good trip!
The song In Maidjan (Lifa version), while it doesn't show the male singers at their best, has some incredible female vocals by Maria Franz. I wonder if you'll be the one to bring an answer the question we all ask ourselves: "how the heck did she do that?"
Other great songs: Othan, or Hamrer Hyppier (all from the same live called Lifa).
Love, Jo.
Yes, I second your reminder. I love Maria's voice and the primal sound of their music.
Thanks, Jo!!!
I third this. Heilung as VERY primal. Id recommend the song Norupo.
I'm joining anyone making the case for some Nordic style music, but I have to mention Einar Selvik from Wardruna once again. Wardruna made large parts of the soundtrack for the show Vikings. For Einar solo, I recommend him performing Volüspa live with only an ancient viking Harp and a little bit of classic orchestra ua-cam.com/video/k43yzC-dUqU/v-deo.html, Wardrunas latest song "Healing Mountain ua-cam.com/video/VEizKmZlUAw/v-deo.html, or Wardruna performing Helvegen live with Aurora (singing in Old Norse !) ua-cam.com/video/FnkTuHP9q3o/v-deo.html
Uhmmm, yes.
You'll notice that the same kind of people who listen to Nightwish and The HU, often also listen to Heilung.
I attended Lifa live at Castlefest 2017, and I was enchanted. I have no other way to describe it.
Heilung was recommended by Kati Rán, Dutch nyckelharpa player (I also play nyckelharpa and that's a small community), who performed just before Heilung at Castlefest, at a different stage on the other side of the terrain, and she was going to watch Heilung from backstage so she had to rush and couldn't sign her merch. :D
Anyway, after you've done Heilung, do Kati Rán - Suurin, where the people of Heilung are guest musicians.
Thank you, Elizabeth, for recognizing the work of Tuomas Holopainen as well as the other members of this amazing band of minstrels. Most people get carried away by the obviously exceptional talent of Floor Jansen, and often forget the work of the rest of the band.
A wonderfully thorough and insightful job with this song, of course. Thank you. Peace, love and light from Downunder.
Thank you again for a fantastic reaction and analysis!
And I just love it when I see such a consummate professional andf excellent singer like yourself really gets emotionally involved in a song like Shoemaker, and clearly get the chills as well :).
Lovely!
Kindest regards, Wim
Thank you Elizabeth, and yes, The Song Is AWESOME in every way.
This song blew my mind when I first heard it. Knowing the story behind it makes it so much more emotional
Great analysis; I absolutely loved it. I recently watched a video of her performing this song live and the control she has when singing the Latin section is just soooo amazing.
You have my favourite reaction videos. You point out things that I didn't notice even though I've already listened to the song 100 times, and it makes me love the song even more.
Great reaction again. Thank you, Elisabeth!
"Pan" is one of my favorite new songs from Nightwish! Definitely worth checking out. Honestly the whole album is fantastic. Thank you for having such a great reaction channel. I look forward to your reacts of my favorite artists/bands more than others.
you have to listen to this again but then sung live on 28/07/21. phenomenal
Your song reviews have become my favorite channel on UA-cam. You are obviously madly and deeply in love with music and everything involved with it. Your facial expressions while listening to a song are like watching a child open Christmas presents. I love to hear you talk about time changes and how they impact the songs. Your knowledge of music inspires me!!!
Sublime,tears in my eyes.