The Abrahamic Religions Iceberg
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 жов 2024
- Here we delve into the Abrahamic faiths, Christianity, Judaism, and Islam and a few more as well. We discuss theories and concepts about each of them and discuss ideas people have or do have about them. There are a couple youtubers I name drop in the video so they will also be down in the description. Wendigoon, The Lore Lodge, and Let's Talk Religion being the main 3 I brought up or recommend myself if you want to learn more. I hope you all enjoy the video about religion and have a great day!
---@Wendigoon
----@TheLoreLodge
---@LetsTalkReligion
Time Stamps in the pinned comment
Time Stamps :)
Tier 1- 0:47
Tier 2- 8:18
Tier 3- 16:32
Tier 4- 30:25
Tier 5- 40:55
Tier 6- 51:12
Tier 7- 1:00:00
Tier 8- 1:07:00
Tier 9- 1:14:20
Tier 10- 1:21:24
Eastern Orthodoxy Is The One True Apostolic Catholic Church. Eastern Orthodoxy Is The One Truth.☦️💙📿
Sabbath is no longer for us to keep, otherwise we would ruin the 6th commandments, which says: DO NOT KILL!
Matthew 5:21 Ye have heard that it was said by them of old time, Thou shalt not kill; and whosoever shall kill shall be in danger of the judgment:
it is the sabbath or the 6th commandment. Cant have both.
Souls, know and understand the bible as we all should:
2 Timothy 2:15
Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.
The 2 most important commandments for us to keep TODAY are:
Matthew 22:37
Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind.
Matthew 22:39
“And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself.”
the 3 wise men were priests from the Babylon, Persia and Greece at that time asia was already worship Alexander the Greek. As a poetic justice he made them warship his son for their sins against the Lion of Jhuda, after this their coutrys become christian.
Abraham was neither Jew, nor christian. But he was a sincere monotheist, Muslim (which means: someone who submits to God). And he was not an idol worshipper.
(Quran 3:67)
The people most deserving of Abraham are those who followed him, and this prophet, and those who believe. God is the Guardian of the believers.
68
This verse refutes all religious claims against Abraham. He is not an idol worshipper, christian, jew. No religion is left except submission to God =Islam). The sincere monotheists in the world will follow him.
Muslim - from Islaam = to Surrender/submit (to God)
Silm = to be at Peace, and protected from disasters and problems.
Allah's name is al-Salaam = to be perfectly complete, free from faults and weaknesses.
So the person who is Muslim; surrenders and submits to God, then he feels peace because he is divinely protected from disasters, and the more he follows the guidance - the more he will become a 'complete' human, free from faults and weaknesses.
thanks!
A little difference in Islam regarding Adam and Eve is that we believe that the Devil convinved both the man and the woman to eat from the tree. In the Qur'an when that story is mentioned dual is used(Arabic has dual when refering to two people, alongside singular and plural) and in one chapter it is mentioned that the Devil talked to Adam directly.
Most Christian’s believe Adam and Eve both ate the fruit too
@@TheGymBroSkii yes but I am not talking about that. Christians believe that the devil coerced the woman and that the woman coerced the man to eat from the tree. We believe that they BOTH fell for it by getting tricked by the devil. So we believe that the devil directly tricked the man too.
@@stevy2318 and Adam was destined to it by the will of allah also
@@durrangodsgrief6503if that is true, then why would Adam be punished for it?
@@TheLikesofMee
Going to earth wasn't a punishment to began with in islam God says to the angels that he will put a successive authority on Earth, so Adam put on earth was already the plan before his creation but the whole thing in heaven is to teach Adam a lesson which is to know that the devil is his real enemy so he shouldn't trust him and that he shouldn't disobey God ever again and Adam asked for forgiveness so God forgave him and then he send him and the devil to Earth to start humanity's test on Earth
The Trinity is not the belief that God is three distinct beings. The Trinity is the belief that God is one being comprised of three coeternal aspects.
Humans are three aspects of one being as well, having a mind/body/soul. God likewise, has a Face (The Father), a Word (Who incarnated as the Son), and a (Holy) Spirit.
Yes, and all are inseparable and each 100% God.
is Trinity God's act or God's nature?
you just corrected by providing an even worse explanation.
The Trinity is one being, three persons who are coeternal and coequal
@@abhijaman4792 it's gods nature
@@ReuvenGoldstein1 That's what I said. Each aspect of the trinity is personal. Three coeternal personal aspects of the one Lord God.
This guys research into each topic is equivalent to reading the first 2 paragraphs of each topics Wikipedia page
Maybe even the first paragraph, still a nice video to get into the topic.
for real bro, i wasn't paying full attention but my smile dropped instantly when he said "graham hancock" around 13:23 🥲 still respect the time put into the video but this one's definitely more for entertainment than accuracy
It's a iceberg video what are u expecting
It’s a video about a ton of different concepts. You can easily do more research on these concepts on your own
The best channel for studying religions and beliefs is let's talk religion.. the amount of research is unreal
This made my day, also hella cool shout out to the goon and lore lodge both amazing channels! Glad to see your channel grow can't wait to see you hit the coveted 1mil subs
i believe “the sword of islam” is referring to Khalid ibn al Walid, he was a companion of Mohamed peace be upon him and he was named the sword of Allah because of his skill in battle as he is one of if not the best military leader in record history having never lost a battle.
He lost in the Battle of Uhud against Ali ibn Abi Talib
@@mirfallteinnameein6343was that his last battle?
@@m_s_5750no; khalid actuslly won that battle but it was one of his first. it was before he became muslim and he was leading the battle against the early muslims Muhammad and Ali amongst others.
@@m_s_5750 no
later on he became a Muslim (he was against Muslim during battle of uhud) and didn't lose a war after that
technically I would say battle of uhud was a draw
@@mirfallteinnameein6343Technically that was a draw
14:47 it is also beleived in Islam, as it is said in the Quran in Surah al-Hajj : " And they challenge you to hurry up the punishment. And Allah will never break His promise. But a day with your Lord is as a thousand years of your count "
Islam is copied from Christianity and jews islam is a false religion
This is in general a comprehensive video, but it's very important to note that some concepts in this video are described in their Christian versions, which is very different in Islam - for instantce, the story of Adam and Eve and the original sin mentioned in the video is a Christian idea. The Islamic view is much different. In Islam, Eve was not created from Adam's rib, and it was not Eve who was deceived, but both Adam and Eve, and God subsequently forgave them, so there is no concept of "original sin" in Islam.
The story of the "Satanic Verses" is widely considered inauthentic.
Musllims believe that Jesus did not die on the cross, but God made it so everyone saw it that way. Jesus is believed to instead have been raised to heaven.
In general, also looking at where he used the words "supposed" or "said to be" and where he did not use them, I think the narrator was biased and had a Christian perspective, even if he did not realize or intend that. I apologize if I'm wrong. I think also laughed after saying "wisdom" during the Valley of the Ants section, implying that he found it funny, but I may have misheard that.
Honestly, there were a bunch of inaccuracies on Islam just in the first 5 or 10 minutes. I fast forwarded and skipped a bunch after that, will probably not watch fully.
But I think Eve was created from Adam's rib in Islam, as it's mentioned in sahih hadith (and possibly alluded to in the Qur'an). It's certainly not definitive that she wasn't.
Also, God didn't necessarily “make it so everyone saw it that way” in the sense of a mass hallucination. “It was made to appear so” could just be referring to the fact that it was made to seem so; maybe his disciples didn't witness it, but got the news from Romans who mistakenly identified the wrong guy, or other possible explanations.
@@ha.alaminI second this. Btw, do you have another iceberg or youtubers who are more thorough in islamic teachings like this?
And also Adam did not give names to things. He was taught the names of things by God.
@@m_s_5750 dunno about iceberg, but here's a few educated Muslim UA-camrs I like: Muslim Lantern, Muslim Skeptic, Thought Adventure Podcast channel and its hosts' channels (esp. Muslim Metaphysician), Mohammed Hijab, Subboor Ahmed, Sadat that Canadian Brother, EFDawah, DawahWise, Imran Hussein Epistemix, Hamza's Den. These are just a few off the top of my head in rough order.
Def a Christian perspective, as a Jew a lot of the stories were the Christian version and not exactly what the Jewish perspective would be
3:14 Just to clarify, Muslims do recognized Jesus being the Messiah and having miraculous birth, but they do not believe in Jesus having divinity or being God or his son
@Rareorgans45Magic like bringing the dead to life and after a while they die is not magic
@@mrfact03s?
@@astronoman008 Muslims also kiss and worship Blackstone of Kabbah, which was a Quraishi Temple, conquered and converted just like Haggia Sophia and many others
@@2066cj 💀
@@2066cjif u don't know you can learn. At least don't prove yourself illiterate. The Kaaba is the direction we pray. So Allah's throne is located where kaaba is above 7 sky. May Allah guide you.Ameen.
I know you just started but I like how good you create these informative videos. Thank you for the hard work please keep it up and also please don’t forget about me and us… your first supporters ❤️
Have a great day🎉
23:49 'a Nephilim'. In Hebrew, '-im' is a suffix signifying a plural. The singular is probably 'Nephil'. Saying 'a Nephilim' is akin to saying 'an angels'.
Good job buddy you enriched all of our life’s…
Ngl now I can't stop saying "it's an Angels!" With a redneck accent lmao 🤣😂😆 thanks for making my day better
it can also be used to indicate greatness
@@15richardsonjm what does the life own? (Lives, not life's)
Okay Mr. Smart Guy
Actually there is nothing in islam called the original sin, in islam you will be judged passed only on what you yourself have done that is the first thing, the second thing is that God told the angels before he created Adam that he will send him to Earth, the whole heaven thing is a lesson to make Adam and Eve ready to began there test on Earth and the lesson was that the devil is there enemy so they shouldn't trust him and that they should never diobey God again because he knows what is best for them and Adam asked for forgiveness so God forgave him and send him and Eve and the devil to Earth to began humanity's test
This video is so annoying. Less than 10 minutes in and it's mistake after mistake. Shallow iceberg is scraping the ground. I'm done 😅
How can I contact you?
@@Dwogrix
Why do you want to contact me ?
@@omaraboal-azm8705 For collaboration
38: 20 They are described as 'Magi', the plural form of 'Magus', itself a Latinised form of 'Magush', the word used in antiquity to describe Zoroastrian priests and astrologers. While it is not stated explicitly, it is implied through the use of the term 'magi' to begin with. For more information, I refer you to Justin Sledge's video on the Magi on the channel Esoterica.
I just watched your Medieval iceberg video - I’m a history buff, but a huge-r theology buff - have my sub - looking forward to watching this
quick addition, muslims believe that ishmael was the son that god told abraham to sacrifice, not isaac
Not all. Islam isn't explicit on this detail AFAIK, and scholars differ.
yes all u kid. the MAJORITY of scholars agree it is ishmael, use ur brain. @@ha.alamin
Yes
@@سلامہريکےjeez, why are you being rude to a fellow man. And the majority doesn't mean all the scholars
Actually its not specifically told in the quran who was sacrificed, it could've been Isaac
Ngl I’m a bit disappointed, this list is a little shallow. But then again it was made on Reddit so what should I have expected
Lmao, yeah I wish it was better organized and had better entries overall tho I did find it interesting still
@@Blue_Squidnah bro do better. Anybody can do a video on a subject but give us the entire breath of understanding
@@jamaalsjourneyyou do it better
Great channel. Discovered it today. Love the iceberg format- lots of research!
Thank you for this Awesome content Sir!! This really takes my mind off of all the Bs life throws at Me. I greatly appreciate it 🙏🏼
Solomon ain’t a simp, he’s a giga-chad and a pimp. Incels just get mad that they aren’t blessed with a fraction of the Rizz of Solomon.
If someone married more than one woman today, they would be called like that, let alone 700 women army.
I dont know how he had the power to do so
@@mohammed44_ he was built different
@@cyberyousef7519
Modern men will not even have a chance after less than 10 women at most, I can't see anyone producing all that many sperms and never turn into egyptian mummy from lack of fluids, they will die from dehydration :P
@@mohammed44_ bruh he commanded jinn's. he was a powerful and just man.
@@Darkest_matterhe commanded demons not jinn. God created jinn and human where satan created demons. Jinn are like loa is the voodoo religion and many pagan religions.
The video: an iceberg about the abrahamic religions
The comments: literally twitter
nicely described
The comments actually corrects some inaccuracies which is much appreciated there is only handful of "twitter" like comments or whatever it is.
Subscribed at 1.5k. Can’t wait to see you reach 10k, then 100k and so on.
Dudes definitely got 1 mil sub potential!!!
I'm just waiting for gen alpha to make a bible translation translating "Gehenna" to "Ohio"
have you seen the jamaican bible? it's funny.
Great video man, God bless.👍🏾
Another great video. Keep up the great work
43:22 To add to this, scholars currently identify the land of Sheba with the southern Arabian kingdom of Saba (located in modern Yemen), which was a trading hub during antiquity. The Queen herself has some interesting lore attached to her as well-- Islamic lore gives her the name Balkis/Bilqis, and portrays her as being a djinn, thus tying in with the lore of Solomon as a demonologer.
Thought she was half dijinn or something
She was never portrayed as a djinn, what are you on about 🤨?
WRONG, she was NEVER portrayed a djinn. But she was carried by an ifrit (large djinn) through the skies to solomon's palace.
She wasn't a jinn, but she had jinn in her service.
Also the ethiopians used to believe that Solomon got busy with her and their child created the Ethiopian monarchy
At 53:35- Legion as the name is significant because it was a prophecy that Jesus would throw the Romans back into the sea, not just that "Jesus could banish 1,000 demons." The Gospel of Mark is extremely anti-Roman, and Rome's association with pigs throughout the Gospel parallels their acceptance in Roman diet/ritual and the Jewish law's ban on eating pork.
I think the lost books of the bible in tier 10 isnt really talking about the apocrypha, its talking about books in the Bible (mostly in the old testament) that are mentioned but arent in the canon, like the Book of Jasher in Joshua, Laments for Josiah, Book of Shemaiah, Chronicles of the Kings of Israel, etc
Man you’re coverage of these super complex icebergs is really exceptional. Well done!
This video is DESTINED to start hundreds of wars in the comment section...
Thank you so much for sharing this
Great overview of all three religions.
As a Muslim, This is a great video explaining all the Abrahamic Religions, Good video!👍
1:00:57 The point that's being got at here (albeit badly, as is the case with the Jormungandr = Leviathan argument) is that all of these monsters fill the same 'primordial chaos serpent' archetype slain by a storm god. It's a type of narrative called The Chaoskampf by mythology scholars-- at the beginning of, or during the early days of the world, a storm god or demigod battles and slays a many-headed dragon of chaos, and either makes things from its body or gains a great treasure from slaying it. In the Biblical tradition, this is God slaying the Leviathan, as is mentioned in the Book of Job-- passing mentions of the Leviathan in Psalms and Isiah describe it as having multiple heads as well. In the Greek tradition we have both Zeus trapping Typhon under Mt Etna, thus creating the volcano there today, and Heracles slaying the Lernaean Hydra. In the Babylonian tradition we have Marduk slaying Tiamat and making the world from her body, in the Canaanite tradition we have Baal Hadad slaying Lothan, in the Japanese tradition we have Susano slaying the Orochi and extracting the Japanese imperial regalia from its body, and it is likely that Jesus doing battle with the Beast in the Book of Revelation was meant by the author as an exact parallel with the slaying of the Leviathan by God.
Two Enochs could also refer that there are thought o be two separate authors for the apocryphal books of Enoch thought to have been written some time apart.
Within Adam's family line there is one enoch of cain. Then a later enoch down seths line who was the son of jarred. I think that's what it's in reference too.
I think some of these statements should be double checked. For instance, Gehenna being used as a sacrificial place for followers of Moloch and Ba'al. I'm pretty sure modern studies show that it was used by followers of Yahweh to sacrifice.
yahweh or the god that's praised by the abrahemic religions asking for human sacrifice as oppesed to moloch and baal the demons literally mentioned in the biggest occultist books? yeah there might something about your "modern scientific studies"
Ah yes the Shin Megami Tensei Iceberg
Persona 3 moment (am i cooked?)
@@bomboclaaat92 yep you cook
bro dont get what i mean @@Femboy_Shota 😭😭
OP’a name 💀
@@lionelgideom the context is I want to make the most unique + memorable name
Know you probably wont read this but you are amazing for a small channel just starting out
Two shades of purple out of 5 colors is definitely a choice.
The Book of Enoch is not considered canon in most sects of Christianity. It IS considered canon by Ethiopic Christians, for example. It was also considered canon by some early Christians as it is cited in Jude, which is considered canon by all sects.
Correction: not three wisemen. Several, as in more than three. Could have been ten or a hundred. The Bible mentioned many magi, but they only gave three gifts, giving the misconception of three men.
⚜️ The thumbnails is beauty’s so colored, and assorted of things.
* random Latin saint being included in tier one with foundational beliefs * 💀💀
Gnosis is something you should cover if you do this again. I was really hoping for some more exploration into these gospels
Edit: I commented this before finishing the said part below (Sorry😂)
In the Lucifer/The Devil/Iblis part...
Even though, they are somehow similar beliefs, in Islam, we don't have the concept of a Fallen Angel, as it is believed that it is the nature of an angel to obey God, we believed that Iblis is a Jinn, but he was with the angels, at the time that Prophet Adam (A.S) was created, Allah (God) ordered the angels along with Iblis to prostate (Not to worship adam, but to oney God), but the iblis became insecure, in his perspective he would never prostate to a being that is lower than him (Fire > Mud/Clay), that is why he disboyed Allah (God), since Jinns, and Nas (Humans) in their nature, make mistakes, unlike Angels.
Iblis was furious about this, so he made a oath that he would distruct (Distract, Tempt) humanity until the day of judgement
You could've added the fact that Iblis was so devoted in worshipping Allah that Allah made him on the rank of the Angels.
Thank you for this
1:02:26 there is some people who say that jesus went to the Himalayas during his lost years and learned under buddhists and then preached buddhism to the jews
1:08:21 dont forget some saints like St. Francis of Assisi talked and preached to animals
All 613 commandments actually are found in the Torah (they all have a verse in the Torah where they are derived from, such as Exodus 20:13 for not murdering). The number 613 isn’t explicitly stated but is hinted to by the fact that the numerical value of the word “Torah“ is 611; two commandments were heard by the Israelites collectively at Mount Sinai, and the rest are in the Torah.
AS SOMEONE WHO LOVES LEARNING ABOUT ABRAHAMIC FAITH THANK YOU GAAHHH I'm not even Christian/Jewish/Muslim I just find it interesting
I swear these videos find me at the right time
I can answer any questions about Christianity if you have any, in a more downlow perspective
@@BongBing11 Here’s two:
1. Why do you trust a book to be from God if your earliest codex is centuries after the fact? Even then, aren’t laundry lists of contradictions sufficient enough to distrust it?
2. Why would you believe in an absurd concept such as the trinity or original sin? Even if _somehow_ true, isn’t it said that God isn’t the author of confusion- why would he reveal something so obviously absurd yet expect people to believe it? Why would he provide us with such thing as intuition if it would become the very mechanism by which people disbelieve in his supposed message?
@vibz8346
Sure.
1.The Gospels are attested by the Church Fathers to have existed in the first century and be written/dictated by the Disciples themselves. Coupled with the fact that every manuscript we find, the earlier back we get, matches up quite perfectly. And on 'contradictions'- it's really stuff like 'Moses used the word 'Pharoah' for an old Egyptian king because he's used to the term'. It's much different than say, the Quaran, where little mistakes and contradictions damn the text because it's supposedly written by God, while the Bible was written by the Prophets and Apostles.
2. God is not the author of confusion, but is the author of concepts most high. Is God the author of confusion because He made math concepts that we haven't even figured out yet? And original sin is easily seen and understandable- we all carry this imperfection and sin, which causes literally everything awful for humanity.
@@BongBing11ok now explain the trinity
@@BongBing11name one mistake/contradiction in the quran
The reason you're scoffing about the story of the valley of ants is that you're missing the main point of it.
" Until, when they came upon the valley of the ants, an ant said, "O ants, enter your dwellings that you not be crushed by Solomon and his soldiers while they perceive not." So Solomon smiled in amusement at her words, and prayed, “My Lord! Inspire me to ˹always˺ be thankful for Your favours which You have blessed me and my parents with, and to do good deeds that please you. Admit me, by Your mercy, into ˹the company of˺ Your righteous servants ".
the key word here being " perceive not". The reason solomon thanks god is that even animals know of his mercey and wisdom as a king that they know he won't hurt them knowingly. This story is also better understood in the context of solomon in islam, where he's always depictied as the king who has everything and rules over everything, animals, djinns, and even the forces of nature like the wind and the rain. But always remains thankful to god, and kind to the small creatures like ants, which are easily passed by and noticed when you have such power.
I wish more people understood- calling Hinduism one religion is like saying the Abrahamic faiths are all one religion, rather than a multitude of radically different ideologies and lifestyles all grouped together based on a mutual spiritual ancestor. Some branches of Hinduism even embrace the Abrahamic faiths as fully valid spiritual practices under a broader ideology. It matters less what name of God you use, but rather the position of your heart when you serve God. Love and devotion to the almighty creator and protector is the only thing that matters. There's no point to claiming names and labels if it's only something you wear on Sundays. As a Hindu I still think it's better to be a good Muslim/Jew/Christian than it is to be a casual Hindu.
WELL SAIDDDDDDD
"For as I passed by, and beheld your devotions, I found an altar with this inscription, TO THE UNKNOWN GOD. Whom therefore ye ignorantly worship, him declare I unto you. God that made the world and all things therein, seeing that he is Lord of heaven and earth, dwelleth not in temples made with hands; Neither is worshiped with men's hands, as though he needed any thing, seeing he giveth to all life, and breath, and all things;" (Acts 17:23-25)
"Hinduism" is neither one religion neither is it many seperate religions (in the codified sense of distinction that the Abrahamic religions have to each other).
I was going to say it seems like it would be the other way around because of how terrible the other three are.
I believe "The Sword of Islam" in 1:03:30 refers to "Zulfiqar" which is a two-pointed magical sword given to Ali by Muhammed
I'm pretty sure it refers to khalid ibn walhid
Ramadan is not a holiday. We have 2 Eids as holidays. I don't get why you mentioned Dantes inferno. Which religion claims it as part of their religion?
He didn't make the iceberg and Ramadan is enough of a holiday to be considered so
@@Daxe382 your opinion doesn't matter to me bud
@@Daxe382 it ain't aa holiday, it's a month... and we don't get time off work or school.
There was a couple things wrong in this vid which I mean is to expect since he is not an expert at studying that but I think he left the points pretty clear. good video bro
2 enochs likely refers to how in the book of genesis there are two figures named Enoch, the first is the son of Cain and the 2nd is the enoch the book of enoch is based off, he is a descendant of Seth and ancestor of noah
Zoroastrianism is older, and 100% influences the abrahamic faiths
Not,really
What part of 100% don’t you understand?
There is no recorded evidence that Zoroastrianism influenced the Abrahamic religions. The oldest manuscript of ot we got was written sometime between the 1st - 3rd century AD. So evidence is contrarily that it was inspired heavily by Gnosticism. Not to say it didn't exist beforehand but there is no evidence it influenced Abrahamic faiths.
@thehungh0nkey853 no most scholars agree that when the Jews were forced into exile in Persian controlled lands Jewish writing start to inherit the dualism of Zoroastrianism (in early written biblical books there isn't really a concept of "Satan" or an evil counterpart to God. Once the Jews gained contact with the Persians, they started writing in this dualistic way; Satan becomes the great evil counterpart to God, and you start to see mentions of all sorts of Demons.
Christianity and Islam inherit this from late Judaism.
all religions are from Allah
1:22:25 lost books predominately refers to books that were never in the Bible, typically taking form as gnostic texts such as the infancy of Thomas, gospel of Mary, protoevangelium of James, and so on. We have not been able to locate any “lost” books from the Tanakh apart from the ones history channel detectives conjure up.
There were some apocryphal books that were included prior to council of nicaea
@@epiccrusadr8583 no. Enoch and company are not rightly considered apocryphal
Islam isnt an abrahamic religion
but it is
It is
We literally have a whole holliday about Abraham
Every time someone mentions Dante's Inferno I can't help but think of the animated movie I watched. Every time it just pop up.
Islam was probably the least complex of the Abrahamic religions
Bc it's a copied perversion taught by a demon to a warlord. And demons are unoriginal in their thought.
Nah, Islam is a very complex religion, man.
@@JackRebholzno it’s really not
as someone from Islamic and Arabic environment, let me tell that islam is stupidly complicated. You may assume otherwise because nearly all of that complexity is in the Arabian convo and debates between scholars of today and the past.
The answer to this is because there is only One who revealed the Quran and Sunnah. Whereas a multiple unknown authors with different intentions and beliefs added and abrogated verses from the bible, be it the OT or the NT, and innovated rituals, be it from Judaism or Christianity, and deemed them to be holy. The more authors of a book and teachers of religious doctrine are, the more contradictory the religion is, the more complex and confusing it will be.
You know you did a good job on the video and everything, I just wish that the last tier was full of something weirder
I think the Sword of Islam thing actually refers to a ceremonial weapon that was given to Benito Mussolini by the Libyan resistance movement.
no, sword of islam referrs to the great muslim generals of the first caliph and before
@@Darkest_matter Look up Sword of Islam Benito Mussolini.
@@chancelloryusuf ohh I've heard about him. He did something in Libya or something.
Zoroastrianism is what gave rise to the monotheistic practices that formed Judaism out of Yahwism. I'd argue that both Zoroastrianism and Judaism had predecessor religions (i.e. Yahwism for Judaism) and it would be likely impossible to tell which of the predecessor religions came first.
A lot of what Muslims reject they do so with the argument that it was made up. They can keep their dogma intact by rejecting anything that threatens it as "never happened, bro."
Perhaps the greatest iceberg ever... gonna need a part 2,3,4 and 5. And then a part 6 to finish up with part 7. Make it happen thx.
Sir yes sir
3:46 For clarification the Jews have the Tanakh, The Torah is a part of the Tanakh, It would be better to show the Jewish bible, Christian bible, and Quran. Also note the Christians also have the torah, The torah is just the first five books of the old testament. Which both Christians and Jews have.
Think I’d like to hear this from someone more open than you. The way that some of these subjects were touched was just so aloof.
Can you do Pagan Religion Iceberg?
Good idea
The Pagan stories are so CRINGE
@@Kotenok_s nah i think its cooler compared to pale void of creativity abrahamic ones
@@greatmusic142 burn the Quran it's not Abrahamic, do you even know how Odin lost his eye?
i can imagine hinduism andshinto evolving to have 'god if A.I, god of electric, god of iphones'
hochelaga has some amazing religious content id recommend to anyone who liked this video
Ayyyy yo did not do it justice Jesus does have sin story’s
Still good video tho
My parents grew up in middle east as muslims but they moved after the war so, I grew up in the church and thought that was the whole religion just going to church every Sunday and eventually stopped going and started to do my own thing. But I wanted to find the purpose of life because I knew everything we worked for would pass away. So I started to look into all the religions to see if christianity was even really the ultimate truth. Later on opened up the Bible and saw the Jesus people talked about was completely different from what was in the Bible. I started to draw closer to the higher power and had a supernatural encounter with him and I felt the most love and peace and was truly indescribable and out of this world, and nothing i've ever felt from then on and never will tbf will come close to that experience, but I was shocked because I wasn't expecting this encounter, so I went up to my balcony and everything looked brand new like it was the first time seeing the nature when I looked outside. Almost like a new born and it was like it was so detailed . Every time I used to go outside it looked so boring and mundane and natural but this time that all changed, and I’m here to tell you it’s about a relationship not religion and he is real and did die on the cross for you willingly and thinks you as the only person and was thinking of you while dying.
Islam is the right bath serch in youtube for debats islam and christianity I just want you to know right bath and ask god to lead you to the right bath
@@عمارمنصور-ه3خ I have, when I saw this I was watching a debate. I suggest you look at UA-camrs like Christian prince and Sam Shouman or Bob on speakers corner, please look at those, God bless you and may God guide us to the truth Amen
it saddens me to see that theres so little islamic entries
because islam is fake 😧😧
@@pisseaterretard🤡
I agree. I was interested in learning more about it
What? You want to include your prophet is a mass murderer, pedophile, breaks social morals even his own Arab society, and suicidal?
It's honestly better there wasn't cause this guy did not do a good job even with the simple things.
41:15 this is only true in the sense that they both are part of a Chaoskampf narrative and both fill a 'primeval chaos-serpent' archetype. They are obviously not the same, because the one is part of an Indo-European tradition (Jormungandr, which has a long series of counterparts across Indo-European myth-- Typhon in the Greek tradition, Vritra in Hinduism, etc.), and the other is part of an Afro-Asiatic tradition (Leviathan, which has its own correspondences in the Canaanite Lothan, the Babylonian Tiamat, the Egyptian Apep, etc.)
31:30 i also think its interesting that the first man's name starts with A and the first woman's name starts with E...
@@TheGymBroSkii Because so do Adam and Eve.
Well in Arabic it's Adem and Havva
another very similar fun fact/theory is that in Hinduism, one of the main gods is "Brahma" which possibly stemmed from a common name used for a pre-Abrahamic God pronounced similar to "braha". This could potentially be the same early "braha" that turned into "Abraham" which connects the two religions in a pretty cool way.
Me clapping my hands when the algorithm presents me a god tier video for my cereal
there is no catastrophe more devastating than monotheism
Muslims and Jews believe in ONE God, the only God.
Trinity is pagan.
The Jews will worship dajjal, oh and they don't believe in one god, they believe in moloch
My fav thing about Abrahamic religion is that it a iceberg
can we have the full iceberg picture
icebergcharts.com/i/Abrahamic_Religions here you go :)
The problem of evil and the problem of suffering aren't "bad thing happen so there is no god." They are critiques of the idea of a tri-omni god, since explaining away evil and suffering in the context of an omniscient, omnipresent and omnibenevolent being require severe mental gymnastics on the part of the believer.
All praise To Lord of The All prophets Allah
1:26:00 the song of songs isn't celebrating the love between a husband and a wife but of god and the Jewish people, it uses the characters of a husband and a wife/ two lovers to represent them
Song of Solomon 5:16 ACCEPT ISLAM
THIS SHOULD SHOULD HAVE JUST GONE OVER
THE ONE TRUE FAITH
🇻🇦THERE'S ONLY 1 HOLY CATHOLIC & APOSTOLIC CHURCH🇻🇦
I’m Catholic as well! I just wanted to make a video exploring the religions. in the future I will hopefully do a Catholic iceberg!
Idk I’m Lutheran, but whatever floats your boat man
Quran 112
@@AshtonIsExistingQuran 112
Found the schizo
Minor correction- Romans did not invent crucifixion. It’s far older than Roman civilization. Alexander crucified people and I have seen sources claiming that Sargon was known to crucify people. Even if it was Roman, it would not be “pagan” because that would imply it is connected to their religion, which it wasn’t because Romans were abhorred by the idea of human sacrifice
rib is a deliberate mistransalation the original word is half
And he completely doesn't mention that in islam that's not the case
@@victorien3704 well, what can you expect when he didn’t really do his own research, he just read this off of Reddit.
The jesus and Buddha anime is kinda good, it's a slice of life wholesome comedy, kinda slow paced but can be enjoyable if you are open-minded.
It's called Saint Oniisan i think there were 2 adaptations, but since there is not much in the plot you wont be missing much watching anyone you like first
✝🤝✡🤝☪🤝🔯
Finally a positive comment lol
pretty sure the 4th emoji isn't a jewish symbol
@@HiImCool2008 yeah relizied
As a Christian, I would do this and wash my hand
You got yourself a like and subscriber, don't forget to put this comment on your 10k video
See you there soon
I think there is a lot of mistakes in the Islamic perspective. It’s not true at all
*Says there's a lot of mistakes about Islam
*Questioned on how it's wrong
*refuses to elaborate
*leaves
In christianity, god is born and died also
god died and we are still alive 😂
@@ishrakahmedchoudhury9538when? He conquered death
@@ishrakahmedchoudhury9538god can't be born. God can't eat or sleep. God creates and sees and hears and only feels when you pray. Jesus is a prophet peace be upon him.
You're true
You need to sell us on why we should watch your video over anyone elses on the topic. You need to make us want to come back to your channel for what it offers, uniquely.
Or you could just subscribe and come back whenever you have the time and inclination, and just be appreciative that someone is doing hard work and putting it out into the world for us to see.
These are topics that basically try to paint these religions in a positive or semi-neutral way while at the same time downplaying the other religions mentioned here and how they are proven wrong or are rejected by Christians, Muslims, and Jews. While the video does give a broad perspective on these religious topics, they don’t mention the times when these religions played a part or had influence in some of the worst periods in human history or the many controversies that surround these religions, no mention of the crusades, or the toxic relationship between church and state, the Salem witch trials and the thousands of innocent people who were tortured and killed by the inquisition or the Christian fanatics of the time, nor any mention of the Church and how they would reject the advancement of scientific theory and medicine because they were considered to be heretical. It’s fair to say that this person belongs to one of three religions hence the apologetic statement made in the beginning, the way he speaks about the similarities found in other religions and the explanation he gives that I can only imagine a Christian apologetic would make the same statements. The reason why he does not go fully in depth into most of these topics is because he would be ironically going against his own religion and can only speak very limited about them, it’s like walking on egg shells and not feeling bad about cracking a few of them as long as they don’t hurt your religion. It would be easier for an atheist or an agnostic person to make a better video because they don’t have the fear of going against god since they do not belong to any of the abrahamic religions/ monotheistic religions mentioned here, and they can actually offer a different perspective besides a religious one. Christians should just stick to the Bible and Bible iceberg videos leave the other religions behind because your speech gives way to your thinking and beliefs. Iceberg videos like these can’t be covered by religious people not without sounding religious or sounding like they belong to a certain belief. You can only gloss over topics but not go in depth which makes the educational part of this video null and void imo. Regardless if the iceberg wasn’t made by you or not you should give us the full picture of what this iceberg looked like on Reddit like the many other iceberg videos floating around on YT.
10/10 Yap
sir why are you spreading misinformation the church never once rejected science that is an myth the church is the foundation of modern science as it was viewed as what did god do in creation and how do we better understand it even the Big Bang theory was coined by a man of the church, the Salem which trials are more myth than fact and while some could have happened it wasnt as big an event as people think
you have the arrogance to mention these topics shaming him for not going into them while not doing research yourself wake up and abandon anti-christian dogma cause thats all this is anti-christian
But he didn't make the iceberg. He said that in the beginnig
@@secretreader2345 yes I know that’s why I said at the bottom of my first comment to show us the full iceberg, he said he got the image from Reddit. All I asked was that he gives the full picture/ complete picture of the iceberg so we can see it with all the listed topics it had on it. I’ve seen several iceberg videos, they would display the entire iceberg with all the listed topics on it from top to bottom.
a few problems here.
for starters, we are currently living in the worst time in history, being the modern age. It’s the most unsafe and violent times, due to World War 1 and 2, along with the Vietnamese war contributing to those numbers. Another thing is that it’s a modern myth, that the early church or medieval churches would reject scientific advances in the perspective that they thought were witchcraft, when the contrary was actually the case. The early church was the main foundation for most science we have nowadays, which was called the study of natural philosophy, and they made a huge contribution to society’s scientific development.
Another thing you seem to have misunderstood are some church related events, like the crusades and the witch trials. The crusades being some one sided massacre is also another modern myth, with the reality being that their catholic church often lost against the muslim adversaries, in their struggle to reclaim Jerusalem as their territory. As for the Salem Witch Trials, I’m not too sure how you think they happened since you didn’t clarify, but if you follow the common assumption that it was just a bunch of innocent women being burnt to death, then you’d be wrong. Out of over 200 people that were accused, only about 30 people were found guilty, with the majority of them being executed by hanging. The church did not actually believe they were witches, as Saint Augustine notes that whoever claimed to be a witch was a fraud and a liar, because their powers are fake.
While Christianity in particular does have its darker moments on behalf of the believer’s deeds, I do not believe it’s fair to assume that the creator of this video is a Christian who’s biased towards his religion, just because he’s made the statements that Christians have proven other religions wrong. It is quite literally just history.
The crazy part is there is so many similarities to ancient Egypt and Sumerian religions that people didnt realized
there would be, because they are close to each other in geography and culture
Wish we could have pagan societies that see the divine in everything like Romans. Wtb just one civ like that in my timeline…
try converting
Go to India 😭
@@tatumfanclub8295based
india should be heaven for you.
A difference regarding Christianity and Islam is that it is believed Ishmael was supposed to be sacrificed and not Isaac.
Torah is also not the Hebrew Bible. The Hebrew bible is the Tanakh.
Guys just read all the books on your own.Dont take it from someone on youtube that probably hasnt picked up all three and read through them completely with the intent to understand.
Abraham was neither Jew, nor christian. But he was a sincere monotheist, Muslim (which means: someone who submits to God). And he was not an idol worshipper. (Quran 3:67)
The people most deserving of Abraham are those who followed him, and this prophet, and those who believe. God is the Guardian of the believers.
68
This verse refutes all religious claims against Abraham. He is not an idol worshipper, christian, jew. No religion is left except submission to God =Islam). The sincere monotheists in the world will follow him.
Muslim - from Islaam = to Surrender/submit (to God)
Silm = to be at Peace, and protected from disasters and problems.
Allah's name is al-Salaam = to be perfectly complete, free from faults and weaknesses.
So the person who is Muslim; surrenders and submits to God, then he feels peace because he is divinely protected from disasters, and the more he follows the guidance - the more he will become a 'complete' human, free from faults and weaknesses.
It is more believable that Obama is Muslim than Abraham.
The quran literally says mohhamed is the Frist Muslim and what you're doing is a true scotts man fallacey
Zoroastrianism had a huge influence on Christianity. You did not talk about their profit Zarathustra, but he is a prime example of it. I suggest you look into it a bit more because it is very interesting and is also accepted by most theologians. Feels like you didn't really try with that one because the similarities are everywhere.
It's like 3 kids fighting each other because they think they're Santa's favorite.
Its mostly christians and some muslims, never seen any jew yet in these comments
@mohammed44_ You're actually right. Jews believe that their religions is theirs only and they don't really seem to care whether outsiders believe it or not.
No thank you westerner we as Muslims don't believe in that lovely Santa Claus thing
@@drhamedelafery5854 nor do Jews.
@@exaucemayunga22actually only a larping kid and others try to debunk his claims.
Woah this guy did his research
bro did 0 research
WENDIGOON MENTIONED RAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH 🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Hi, please don't put Islam in the category of "Abrahamic" Faiths. We don't accept this description as we believe that all prophets (including Adam, Noah, Abraham, Jesus, and Muhammad) are Muslims. Also, I don't plan on watching this video as to not end up learning some false beliefs, but know that Islam is about worshipping Allah alone with no partners.
Ignorance
What? Islam is an Abrahamic religion, and I'm saying as a Muslim.
I’m a Muslim and have no clue what you’re trying to say
You're wrong bud. The Quran literally say that Islam is merely the following the "millah [i.e. religion] of Abraham". It's Abraham who had named us as "Muslims" in the first place. You don't know what you're talking about.
There is no such thing as "Abrahamic".
53:56 small correction, a legion consisted of 6000 fighting men, not 1000.