Everything Wrong With Dredd In 13 Minutes Or Less
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 бер 2019
- Dredd kicks ass and is far better than the Judge Dredd adaptation that preceded it. But it still has sins, yo. So we counted them.
Next week: Older horror sins, newer hero sins.
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
•CinemaSins website: www.cinemasins.com •
•Channels•
--TVSins: / @tvsins
--MVS: / @musicvideosins
•Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!• / cinemasins
•Merch!• teespring.com/stores/cinemasins
•Podcasts•
-SinCast A weekly chat with Jeremy, Chris and Barrett about their love and hatred for movies and entertainment. cinemasins.libsyn.com/
--Behind the Sins: CinemaSins writers Aaron, Jonathan and Deneé, give a behind the scenes look at what it takes to release the previous week's videos across the CinemaSins brand. redcircle.com/shows/behindthe...
•Writers Social•
Jeremy: / cinemasins
Chris: / sincastcinemasins
Barrett: / musicvideosins
Aaron: / aarondicer
Jonathan: / samloomis13
Deneé / deneesays
•Discord: Request on Facebook or Reddit!
•Reddit: / cinemasins
•Jeremy's Book: cinemasins.com/book - Фільми й анімація
50 sins removed for Urban keeping the Helmet on and just KILLING SHIT!!!!!
That guy playing The Mandalorian should have been made to watch this movie however many times it took to keep his ego in check.
@@Voltaic_Fire didn't he show his face at some point. What a pussy
@@sugmabolzack4971 Mando? Yeah but that's not the issue, he threw a hissy fit, full prima donna, because he wasn't getting enough face time, thus the sudden abandoning of the helmet rule for the second part of the second season.
@@Voltaic_Fire You have to be fair about it. By that point, he had already learned that born children of Mandalor (ethnic Mandalorians as opposed to religious Mandalorians) didn't follow or believe in that rule. Maybe it was enough for him to question his own religious adherence to the tenets of his faith.
@@AaronCMounts If I didn't know about what was going on in the background with the actor then that might be enough for me but I loathe when an actor's ego gets in the way of a good show/movie, it's rare that anything they say or do sounds like anything more than someone complaining that their second Bugatti is stuck at their holiday home.
I think Urban's commitment to the character, by never taking off the helmet, deserves an un-ding.
Do you mean a gnid?
@@laurenpeck77 hahaha, nice one.
And that mouth.
He acts only with its expressions, head tilts and his voice.
Dredd in the comics is frowning exactly like this.
Commitment to the character by never taking his helmet off? Naw... that's just being TRUE to the characters source material... his commitment to the character shined through after this film was released and all the efforts he went to, to try and get a sequel happening. Iirc there was even a brief talk of a tv series with him.
His commitment to the character really showed with how much he didn't want to give the character up, after the fact! :P
He doesn't learn anything, he doesn't develop his character, he doesn't make any startling realisations, to Dredd it's just another day at the office. He nailed it.
The fact that you didn't take any sins off for that top-notch action sequence in the stairway with gas-grenades and respirators IS a sin on your end. Man, this movie rules, and probably one of the best action flicks of the decade.
Ikr, two gas masks... 3 survivors
Where is the "Everything Wrong With The Raid" where "Lack of Judge Dredd cameo" rates a sin?
Also: NOT removing a sin for _USING_SLOW_MOTION_ appropriately instead of the Snyder School method??
Last but not least: Jeremy has yet to propose a viable alternative to "you should look at this thing that will help move the plotline forward" & affiliated clichés (DING!)
That scene rocks!
@@mechanicaldavid4827 Yeah, it honestly had the best appropriation of slo-mo effects because it was embedded so well into the plot itself. No other movie (to my knowledge) had done this.
And in vr 3d the whole thing was insane.
I have never seen a movie more beloved and in demand of a sequel than this one
The you sir are young
@@aris5444 Ehhhh...there are a LOT of great movies that don't need a sequel - I think most of the best movies would be disrespected with a sequel.
The difference with Dredd is that this entire plot was 24 hours in a single complex busting a single drug lord and nothing about the outside wastelands/underground ruins of the old world/moon penal colonies is explored or even hinted at.
Now the point this movie made is that none of that was necessary...unlike the avengers. First they save a city, then the world, then multiple worlds, then all of reality and then all realities, and in between they gossip and quip and bicker for cringe memes.
I never watched anything past winter soldier because it's so exhausting and full of social programming - except for guardians 2; that one was a special fluke with some solid themes in it.
Dredd deserves a sequel, and hopefully they'd stay small and focused. No need for doomsday every year - just another window into this deus ex/mad max/batman hybrid world. I mean this was broad daylight; what happens at night in this steel/concrete hell?
Nothing. There is nothing wrong with Dredd
there are plenty of things wrong with this movie ......that does not mean it`s not a very good movie
The box office earnings should have been higher.
_ding_
Amen
Right my man
no there is one
THE HELMET
Stop it. We all know there's only one thing wrong with Dredd: The absence of a sequel.
There's rumor of a Netflix series, Stallone and Urban together.
@@TuriGamer you say edgy. The rest of us say Gritty and pretty accurate to the original comics in regards to atmosphere and tone.
@@chainsawpanda2 yes, pretty accurate to the original edgy comics. Not really making a strong case for not edgy here.
@Adam Christopher I read somewhere that it was originally going to be a trilogy: the first one we got, the second was going to be Judge Death (possibly with the Dark Judges), and the third was going to be _America_ . This pretty much means there can't be a 4th movie because the _America_ story line was so good that it basically ruined the character afterwards (good stories came out after that, but it was never really the same)
No
Dredd was as close to perfection of a movie as you can get; strong male and female characters, no sappy romance, great one liners, the unbiased trash disposal of an assortment of drug dealers, drug users, bad cops, and gang members.
if it hadnt been for the stupid feminazi bullshit that was mama it woulda been perfect
Think you are missing the point of 2000AD
1 of the most underappreciated underrated movie of all times. Woulda killed for a 2nd movie
Seconded. Carl Urban does it really well.
Not really, they would've just ruined it
Sadly the lost money i think even thoughbi agree the movie was awesome
Well then you wouldn't be alive to watch it because Dredd is the law and would've killed you for being a killer.
I think that Urban being so into his character deserves several unpings. Such a good Dredd.
His mouth itself deserves an Oscar
Urban immersed me with how into his character he was, made me think this dude would stop at nothing to enforce justice
Several what's?
If there is one movie that deserves a sequel it is this one. But instead we are more likely to get Despicable Me 5.
Wait there’s a 4th?
@The Gonad i heard it was supposed to be a netflix series or some such?
@@secerno1987 please no
They would probably make an incoherent, CGI, cartooney, empty shell of a movie. Just like they do with all se / pre /quels & reboots these days.
Well those movies make money....That's why they make more of them. When movies don't make money...why would they want to not make money?
I let the reputation of the first Judge Dredd keep me from watching this movie in the theater. After watching it on Netflix, man did I regret that decision.
I actually really enjoyed this movie
Same. I bought it digitally after seeing it.
I like Stallone's Dredd
Then you know nothing about judge dredd
@@mr.krakengard5014 me too. Both are.fckn great.
The crime rate was for his "Sector" which they don't mention the population of.
As well as you are not taking in crime to judge ratio.
Shame on you for not removing a sin for that awesome moment in the elevator.
Anderson: [reads Kay's mind] Sir, he's thinking about going for your gun.
Judge Dredd: Yeah.
Anderson: [reads it again] He just changed his mind.
Judge Dredd: Yeah.
OMG I love this movie, I need to rewatch it.
This movie also deserves at least -5 points for saying "I am the law" in a non-ridiculous not-Stallone-over-the-top way.
Seriously, this movie deserves half of its sin points removed for NOT being in any way like the Dredd-ful Stallone movie ;-)
WOOT, I gave you 1K!
That moment had me in stitches
This movie is just pure gold. I was lucky to watch it in a proper cinema in 3d. That was a hell of a ride.
The only thing wrong with "Dredd" is that it did not get a sequel. Karl Urban is a perfect Joseph Dredd.
I agree .
He is the law .
Yessss!!!
Is still in talks for playing him in the series.
Stallone is the perfect Dreed, but this guy was good.
@Joshua Black - you clearly know NOTHING about Judge Dredd at all.
"No one's slamming on the breaks or swerving out of the way of f*cking automatic weapon fire?"
Welcome to Mega-City 1 ;)
I love how you can tell he's sinning a movie he REALLY likes by how much emotion he puts into his commentary.
I dont believe you everybody is sarcastic nowadays
@@blackouthorus1519 not really, some people really shouldn't be sarcastic and aren't being sarcastic. exhibit one: your very own comment
@@spookshankaman1038 i wasn't being sarcastic though
@@blackouthorus1519 It's ok buddy, we've all been there
@@piterpraker3399 what
This movie is SO. GOOD. Shame it didn’t make more
RepeatStepNine Productions agreed
Agreed times a trillion i want a sequel so bad it hurts
Karl urban played the shit out of dredd
Really used the 3D to good effect.
RepeatStepNine Productions ...it Finally got green lit for a netflix series..starring Karl Urban! I prefer a series over a movie. Look how amazing Altered Carbon is! Dredd was a perfect movie...watched it wayyy more times than Heath Ledgers Dark Knight
Yes, Dredd really would judge a vagrant in the middle of a block war. Because he is the law.
I AM THE LAW
LAAAAAAAAAAAAWWWWWW
Exactly. Dredd does everything by the book like Judges are supposed to even if they don't agree with it because that's what Dredd was programed to believe. The guy killed his own brother for breaking the law so sending a homeless man to an iso cube wouldn't bother him
@@Sleepy_DOOD1701 Yea, the "Law" itself is not shown much in the movies, but is elaborated much more and is a much more opressive presence in the comics.
@@Sleepy_DOOD1701 The law in the movie probably dictates that certain crimes must be prioritized since Anderson cited it without the need of Dredd stating it, so most likely he was following the protocol
@2:05 a Hot-Shot round is an independently targeted, heat seeker round. It increases accuracy against designated targets, so was the right call to reduce accidental injury to the hostage. #knowyourdredd
But how does that round know not to hit the hostage?
@@leonpaelinck Considering how high tech their gear is, most likely scenario the gun was able to scan whatever it is pointed at and probably detected who had the gun and who didnt. Considering how advanced even their First aid kit is, I can imagine the guns being like that
@@hidan407 You forgot the most important part - it's fiction. Easy handwave for everything.
Oh so thats why it got into his mouth. I love it :D
@@Tekisasubakani Uh no. It's because he was trying to be hot shit; also, the missile knows where it is.
The world of Dredd is purely autistic; very rarely do they handwave anything as "because fiction"; even in the comics Judge Dredd himself ages in real time, and it's expected that when his natural life span concludes they will shelve the comics.
Unless they replace/clone him or do some shenanigans.
The point is I respect autism - it builds incredibly (obsessively) detailed worlds.
The Judge Dredd movie we deserved. Genuinely, just a great movie. And it's aged incredibly well, considering how some releases from around 2012 look.
I swear, it's so much more faithful and feels almost like a comic book made reality. I always got that feeling during the slow motion sequences, especially. Not to mention that it actually includes the Psi Division, which is arguably one of the coolest things about Megacity(except for the Judges, obviously.)
Only clicked this video to say there’s only one thing wrong, and that’s the lack of a sequel.
Well, there is that it only has maybe 10% of the satire from the source material while even the Stallone movie had maybe 30%.
Sequels by definition are inferior films, or so I'm told. Why would you want that?
@@thepickygamer4450 Empire Strikes Back just called.
@@HolyknightVader999, Go and watch Scream 2, then come back here.
Just Some Jew Terminator 2 and Toy Story 2 would like to have a word with you.
Thanks for checking out this movie. It deserves extra exposure.
I think “review” is a very loose term.
this is NOT a review ... not even a critiquevideo ...
They don't review
They talk shit/give occasional credit for our entertainment
I think you guys already told him enough.
I swear i see you all over youtube commemts. Its like you watch everyone i do
Minus 1000000 sins for dredd NOT removing his helmet an seeing his face
Remove one sin every time Stallone doesn't appear; - minus 119 sins.
Agreed
Talking bad about Dredd.
That's 50 years in an iso-cube
No chance of parole!
Life in the Cursed Earth
No, that deserves 25 years of hard labor on Titan
Drokk that, send him straight to Resyk!
eyeballs & ears lol that's funny
The fact that you didn't take a sin off for
"MaMa is not the law...I am the law."
*angers me*
I am the LEEWWWWW!
"Ma, I AM the Law!"
--Stop, Or My Mom Will Shoot
"I am the lawn!"
-One of the High Lords of Terra
I know, right? I was waiting for him to take a sin of for that line.
Just thinking the very same thing. Can we Ding CinemaSins?
"Why would he use any other than incendiary?"
moments later
"Why isn't it on armor piercing all the time?"
uh ... duh?
There is a time and place for all types of ammo. The incendiary one is apparently quite slow, has short range, and causes a lot of collateral damage. Similarly, armor piercing is more likely to cause collateral damage by going through objects that might be protecting civilians.
Plus the cost factor. Realistically, specialty rounds would cost a fair bit more than their generic counterparts. Pretty sure the round effects are some sort of additive or something, and presumably limited capacity in any case. Would partially explain the large size of the handguns.
@@ThatSoddingGamer AP rounds is actually terrible at keeping collateral damage low too，you would want your projectile to stay in suspects body instead of exiting at the other end and end up hitting some unlucky bystanders
Also, AP rounds don't expand, they just punch a bullet-size hole, so blood loss is slow. Hollowpoints deform and spread out, making a big messy hole for rapid blood loss. You use what suits the situation.
Armor piercing-incendiary also exist. And if we're talking minimal casualties, then we must consider frangible rounds. And while abit expensive, green bullets too because in a world with Mega Cities (and their horrible pollution problems), you'd want to minimize your toxicity level as much as possible.
Arent the special rounds why there's the bulky clip at the front of the gun? Saying why fire any other round would basically be like telling a grenadier why fire anything but 40mm...
i love how all the sins were just there to be there, no real reason
Then where in the movie are the sins explained?
@@johns5638 Are you a troll or do you seriously believe this channel is serious?
@@lief3414 I take this channel as it is: a guy being funny and an asshole who also points out some legit stuff.
@@johns5638 Except most of the legit stuff is so heavily mixed in with the random 'pad-for-time' bollocks that it's kind of hard to tell when.
Also, and this is just personal, the comedy isn't even that good. It's a mix of recycled jokes they've used from the start that have lost what little meaning they did have, and petty nitpicks that are usually either already explained and they weren't paying attention, explained in the next scene, or so obvious that a brain dead vegetable could see it.
All those sins don't matter because Dredd is one of the greatest action movies ever made. Karl Urban is 100% Dredd.
In my eyes, this is a total classic. 20 years from now I’ll still be recommending this to people
Its the _Die Hard_ of comic book movies!
@@architeuthis3476 Yeah thats a perfect comparison. Its also good to see a comic book movie where the stakes aren't world destruction.
Well TBH for an modern day action movie this sin count was really low at 111 especially one being it was worth 20 extra sins you can tell he really likes this movie especially since alot of the sins were legitimate plot holes and things the average movie critic was thinking while watching it. Like I had alot of the same thoughts I thought the movie was going to be shit watching the first scene and like how in the hell he got so lucky throwing her off the balcony worked when I figured he would of took her back to the Justice hq instead of risking 70k life's lol.
Urban was an absolute beast in this film
I mean, I thought this was a really solid action movie. Woulda loved a followup.
About 73.84% of "Sins" nowadays are just nitpicking for comedic effect.
It’s comedy he isn’t serious about that stuff also the channel is called: Cinema Sins not I’m talking about how great movies are
@@sirpeterbaum4695 Exactly. That's what Cinema*W*ins(by a different guy) is for.
Um i mean yea sure but you didn’t say anything about him? And neither did i so why are u talking about him now???
@@sirpeterbaum4695 Because CinemaWins *is* "I'm talking about how great movies are"(Quote: You)
Dredd: They're all dead, Jim.
Anderson: Dammit, Dredd, you're a Judge, not a doctor.
"This is like an imperial droid talking smack about a Jedi just because..." NEEEERRRRRRDDDDDD!!!
Re: the crime rate sin. Dredd works in one of Mega City One's sectors (there are 305 of them apparently) which has the highest crime rate. 17,000 offences a day happen in that sector, not the city as a whole.
There's less sectors now because of chaos day.
Fewer.
Randy There’s less sectors now because of chaos fewer.
That was 17000 per day. That means that you have about a .75 percent chance of being involved in a serious crime each year. That's actually sounds pretty bad. That would be as if at my office, someone was raped or murdered every year.
@@Randy.Bobandy Thanks, Stanis
Fun Fact: The person who did the slow mo shots for this scene is Gavin Free, who is a member of Rooster Teeth and also has his own YT channel with over 12 mil sub's called The Slow Mo Guys.
DennislovesSwift - no way, is that true? Did also do Red vs Blue?
@@spetsnaz1014 Yeah it's the same guy
Yep, this kind of art is def related to the people who brought us day 5.
I just watched their video filming the speed of light last night. Mind blowing.
I just can't back this video. About 30 sins and it's only 3 minutes into the video? This movie is astounding and should of had a sequel
I have to respect the maniacal laughter as he fired the incendiary round, because that was my exact reaction back when this came out.
I find the RoboCop reference funny, because originally RoboCop was supposed to be a Judge Dredd film.
@Naughtysauce It is
I had no idea.
@Biggie Smalls *80's movie
@@Bigalinbklyn83 Robocop was a ripoff of Judge Dredd.
Dead Purple - no it wasn't, Robocop was a rip off of judge dredd. A complete and blatant rip off.
Removing 19 sins for when Dredd comes out of the smoke and throws the bad guy off the edge and walks back into the smoke would have been acceptable. Or nine sins. Just make them even.
Exactly bro. I was thinking the same thing.
Also, the excellent delivery of "I am the law" in a way that was actually bad-ass rather than cheesy warrants erasure of all the other dialogue-related sins!
I LOVE that Dredd never takes off his helmet. No matter the actor underneath :D
There is NOTHING wrong with Dredd. It is a masterpiece!!
I would not call Dredd a masterpiece but yeah, it's pretty damn close to it. I want sequels!
"The Sin? I *AM* the Sin!"
-CinemaSins Guy, probably.
SIN!
"Do you really believe your own hype THAT much?"
*I AM THE HYPE!!*
Not. Yet.
I am the law .
- Dredd .
"What are you even saying? I am the Schwinn? I am the singe? I am the tangent?"
Dredd it. Run from it. Destiny still arrives.
"Your optimism is misplaced asgaurdian"
"For one, I'm not asgaurdian...and two, We have (had) a hulk"
Unfortunate for us, that game sucks!
The last time you talked about destiny, you got beaten by an enraged dragon slayer
At the end you are missing all the same
And Destiny is the LAW!
This movie DESERVES a sequel.
5:19 - dialog say "Shielding must be blocking our transmissions", Jeremy writes "I'm sure they must be blocking our transmissions"
-1 sin from the movie and +1 sin on Jeremy!
One bored Friday night I went out to the movies myself and came across this. Decided I needed some mindless shooty action. Discovered this absolute gem. Best 10 pounds I ever spent
My first thought was how them hell did you manage to watch a movie by losing weight
Then I oh yeahed
Damn even Brits get fucked on movie prices
10 POUNDS ON A MOVIE TICKET ? BRAH, THATS ARMED ROBBERY
@@TTaikodom At least it was a good movie so wouldnt feel robbed. Probably amazing to hear the soundtrack and see the amazing action on the big screen.
I discovered this bad boy while running on a treadmill randomly equipped with Netflix enabled tablets. Had no idea it existed before that despite being familiar with the franchise. Damn shame this isn't more widely known
You can exchange weight for movies? Where at?
Well I at least give him credit to keep his helmet on the entire time...unlike silvester Stallone
No lie..that bothered me.
I liked the Stallone movie.
I only liked it more cause it took place in multiple places..but only slightly more.
I dont see much of the problem with the Stallone movie.
Loved both of these. But the helmet off thing was fine.
Agree
Much credit to Urban for showing far more respect for the source comics material than Stallone did.
@CappleNine irked some fans. The irked ones were just louder. And as we move into the generation of "I hate anything that's not 1 to 1" and "everything from the past, with its limited technology will be judged against more modern remakes with better tech...the hate is heard louder.
I was a fan of the comics. But I saw the movie as..another thing. Like..another issue. As a young person, I never expected the ,movie to be an exact replay of a comic. And as an adult, I'm glad they arent always an exact replay of what I've already read many times.
Reading the comics, I wanted him to take off his helmet. Being a marine vet, .50cal gunner in Iraq, ..I can tell you, there will be times when that hot ass helmet comes off, even if just to pour water on your head.
Sure, I.E.D. are around, sniper territory etc. But sweat in the eyes, blinding you doesn't help anything.
So I felt even MORE irked at the newer Dredd for not even 1 scene..at least the end, where he at least takes the helmet off omce... mayne it couldve went to black out.
I'd at least laugh at myself for being anxious to see then BLACK lol
Anyhow..the helmet off thing, to me, doesn't matter. It's just unworthy of a mention.
Also..I have a problem with any movie that stays stuck in one scenery for the full movie. I like a lot of them, not I'd always prefer different scenery.
Especially at the time this ,movie came out, there were a good few many movies I saw that were one scenery ,movies. Almost a trend for a while.
Loved both, hate neither. The old Dredd was great and everyone's point against it is always rationlized by me
Stalone is a massive fan of the character and fought against taking his helmet off. He didn't want to do it and it was the fault of the producers wanting to max out his star appeal, not Stalone.
10:58 - the film does explain it, even if it doesn't say it out loud. In fact, CinemaSins explains it themselves with their "why would you use anything other than AP" - it's obvious he's run out because HighEx wouldn't be an appropriate bullet in this circumstance if there was any other choice for Dredd to use *continues grumbling*
Over penatration
Yea a LOT of these “sins” are reaching more than a Stretch Armstrong
As usual, when he does a CinemaSins for a good or great movie, he just needs to pad the video time with dumb sht
Watched this again yesterday. Hell of a good action movie, I forgot how fun it is. Both great characters. Deffo need a sequel !
The other drivers driving as if it is a normal monday during gu fire."
Well... It IS a normal monday in MC1 ;)
Kind of a slow day in MC1, really. 😊
It's also a normal day in South Africa, where this was filmed. :P
@@thegothicprince2218 Or a very calm day in Ney York today :P
Jeremy, I'm a little disappointed that you didn't say anything about Dredd's guns being named "Des" and "Troy".
Time out. And the same actor named those his guns in Ragnarok?
@@zom8680 which happens to be Eomer of LotR which he played alongside Cate Blachett. Karl Urban FTW!
Its a masterpiece and one of the right ways to continue a franchise, "a day in Judge Dredd's life".
There still needs to be a sequel to this and yes Karl Urban still needs to judge.
Should have taken a sin off for his “I am the law.” Much better than Stallone’s.
William Moore agreed
a feel like they should have ended with "batman" on their after sentencing redubs. So that's 2 sins.
I AM THE LEEEWWWWW!!!
Sorry, I guess I shouldn’t make fun of speech impediments
And keeping his mask on unlike Stallone
YOU BETRAYED THE LOOWW!!!
LLLLOOOWWWWW!!!!
The radio signals address blocked because the block's in War mode.
As in nuclear.
So yeah, you need to block blast, atmosphere, radiation and EM shocks.
Piddly little radio signals will just bounce off
radio signals are actually bigger higher wavelengths than gamma and x-ray
The EM protection is only on the outside though. I thought it didn't work because the transmitter couldn't send a signal a kilometer away.
One way blocking sounds unlikely.
I'm assuming these things were build quickly and on the cheap, they'll just have used anything cheap, plentiful and quick.
They could just be Faraday cages?
With all those metal shutters around, maybe they're all linked and earthed.
@@spencerwood6816
True, I'm guessing they didn't put much thought into inter block communication though and just put up whatever broadband shield they could set their hands on.
Just big Faraday cages maybe? Because it's reinforced concrete?
They probably just hack the local radio/network router to disable comms. You always find a repeater in underground car park etc. I'm betting the cops in Dread city probably used 40G broadband to communicate. Weird for a lockdown to disable comms. Concrete is a pretty good Faraday cage tho. And EMP is a myth. Lol
Who else gets on the edge of their seats whenever Cinema sins starts laughing just to see if he’s gonna remove a sin?
Everything wrong with Dredd in about five seconds, as there is little wrong with it.
Take sins off for all the hidden and not-so-hidden references, as well as Urban's performance.
If only there was a way to help turn THIS DREDD into a franchise. Just like Downey, Jr. was born to be Iron Man, Evans - Cap and Hemsworth - Thor, Karl Urban was destined to be DREDD. There are so many places they could go with the story and the characters after this and with this actor/s. Very, VERY good film.
possible series coming to netflix
Sorry Stallone is Dredd... "I never broke the law! I AM THE LAW!"
@@Wargod1395 Stallone's Dredd was a decent movie, but he wasn't a good Dredd. I read somewhere that in the original movie, Stallone was gonna keep his helmet on the whole time, but refused that part of the movie, so they had to rewrite large parts of it.
@@Wargod1395 Stallone was in a crappy 'action movie' loosely based on the DC adaptation of the Judge Dredd universe... It was all Hollywood, and zero Megacity One. Dredd was a faithful adaptation of the original source material... No Dredd face, No DC Justices line-up, ect. - All Megacity One, and as little Hollywood as possible.
Stallone was not Judge Dredd, he was in a flashy Hollywood cosplay designed to mimic something akin to, but not related to, the Judge Dredd universe.
I liked the scene in the old movie where the criminals figure out who Dredd is by covering up the top of his face and going by his prominent jaw. I guess this is one of the few times “Clark Kenting” doesn’t work
I hope this becomes a tv series eventually.
Nothing was wrong with dredd. I freaking love it.
This was one of those movies i watched expecting it to be cheap crap pushed out for some quick cash, but its a _really_ damn good movie that has some Paul Verhoeven vibes.
Verhoeven has some Dredd vibes ;-)
I think that's exactly the reason why I loved it so much. If you go into a movie, expecting a 4/10 and it ends up being 8/10, you like it a lot more than an 8/10 movie you expected to be 9/10.
Took you look enough. This movie is so criminally underrated. It needs a sequel!!!
Hah! Criminally...
Word.
YES this movie is so badass, need the rookie to cut sick some more
Meanwhile we get another couple of fast and furious movies and butchering of stephen king movies.
Yooo!!!!!!
I read the comics in the late 80s and 90s I still have boxes full in the attic. I even played the judge dread RPG game among others.
Karl Urban kills it as Dread .
It's the closest we will ever get to the comics
I remember buying the first issue of 2000 a.d. when it first came out, I was so excited as a kid. It came with a free frisbee-like plastic spinner. I was instantly a fan and collector of that comic. Stallone's campy Dredd was ok but Urban totally captivated the essence of Dredd. I hope that at least the series Mega-City One gets made. And I agree with the others, the only fault with this movie was the lack of a sequel.
Yip, I agree...bought the first 'Prog' when I was 10 (1977). Issue 2, I believe, had as it's free gift the bionic dude stickers...ace man, ace...👍🏴
Correct, i forgot about the bionic stickers. I always thought that "Flesh"with the time travel dino meat would make a great movie or series.
@@nigelnix1 Definitely...there were so many storylines in 2000 AD that put today's efforts to shame, and Flesh was one of a good few. Like anything else, some were not as good as others but the originality alone in most of them made it worth the while. Ah, memories mate...👍
Glasgow Gallus yes!! I had the stickers too...and have always been gutted I missed prog 1. I wrote in once and got a reply from Tharg :) Borag Thungg, if memory serves....Awesome comic. Judge Death was terrifying...Strontium Dogg (Joe Pineapples was my dude), Captain Constanta, Rogue Trooper.....damn, happy days.
@@mrc2662 Visible Man 🤣
ahh, dredd...u deserved more-attention, money, sequel, etc
Karl Urban was great as Dredd. I love that he keeps his helmet on the entire movie.
Not just the helmet, but the scowl.
As a years late commentator, I love how many of these "cinema sins" are literally a case of "I do not read 2000 AD"
"You, sir, need the Holy Spirit!!"
3:35 slo-mo is ingested by vapor/smoke inhalation. There's no reason for it not to have some effects instantly.
Right. Smoked DMT effects are almost instantaneous.
@Anoneemus Noename I think he was speaking out of experience.
Or asthma inhalers... just saying lol
@@jackburton3212 that one's not a fair comparison. Asthma inhaler drugs work on the lungs
This shit (slow mo ) had to get to the brain. So I'd honestly say it take between 4-8 seconds depending on your how fast you hit it, your heart rate, lung size and a few other minor biological things that slow down the transfer of chemicals in the body. Vs the blood vessel restrictior designed to work on contact that it designed to be forced into the lungs with a compressed gas under the assumption that you can't take a to save your life. (If I'm wrong that the broccoli dilater is not a blood vessel construing drug feel free to correct me but it is ment to work on connect and make your lugs work right emetitedly )
@@sethgilcrist8088 I see your point, however, as an asthma sufferer myself I can attest to the fact that lightheartedness, shakiness, and rapid heartbeat can occur almost instantly after using an asthma inhaler. At least in my case it does. Plus in the movie they will present an exaggerated version for the sake of time and effect.
This movie was fucking awesome. Glad cinemasins was willing to dig it up to give it some justice.
Edit: Just realized the pun. Absolutely not intended, but no regrets.
...wheres the pun?
@@scopestv3975 "Glad cinemasins was willing to dig it up to give it some justice." Dredd is a judge, who literally says, "I am the law." He gives out justice as judge, jury, and executioner. I said cinemasins gave the movie Dredd "justice." I have some crayons if it'll help...
3:35 Cinema sins has clearly never smoked rock.
The fact that you sinned this movie has pretty much destroyed any remaining credibility you might have been hanging onto.
Completely forgot that Smooth Criminal was used in Matrix. 1:03
Also the name of the city in the Matrix was mega city.
my thoughts exactly!
5:18 "[The] *Shielding* must be blocking our transmissions" It's not a machine that's blocking it, they can't get a call out on the radio because the metal barrier around the building is so thick. *DING*
The walls would have to be 6 feet thivk concrete and the steel would have had to be 3 feet thick of it was mentioned to keep Gama radiation out of the building.
No way a hand portable radio is going to get threw that
Man that's some fucking thick ass shit.
Isn't science fun.
Faraday cage...
"Slandering an excellent action movie: 5 years in the iso-cubes."
Subtract 50 sins for Karl Urban NEVER taking his helmet off once during the movie.
Another sin is that “I am the Law” by Anthrax wasn’t in the end credits
Prediction for next week:
Pet Sematary (1989) and Aquaman
Oh God...
Aquaman is already out on Blu-Ray?
@@DavidRay39 have u been living under a rock
David Ray - It came out this week. That gives them time to make a video in time for Shazam.
@@DavidRay39 Yeah, plus a super high quality 4k digital copy already began circulating a month ago.
Just watched it again tonight... Still fucking amazing.
Too bad we will never get a sequel.
"Dirt City" while definitely feeling silly, also feels very accurate and in tone with this movie.
I would've barely batted an eye if it was called Dirt City, its just as good if not better than "Mega city one"
But the city in the comic is called Mega City One. Calling it anything else would be moronic.
MEGADIRTDISEASEOPOLISCITY ONE
Such an underrated movie in all aspects! Everything about it is just awesome!
Thanks for doing it CinemaSins!
Why? He lies and misrepresents the movie from the first minute. If anything, he's insulting the movie.
@@Xanthosking it's called sarcasm. intentional nitpicking
@@Xannyphantom905 Really? Have a look at number 4.
DREDD (narrating): Megablocks... Megahighways...
CinemaSins: Mega-ladons? *sin counter +1*
In order for something to be nitpicked, there needs to be an actual item to criticize, even if it is small and inconsequential item, as the term "nitpicking" might suggest. Jeremy has not offered any point of critique, and yet considers those two words to be a flaw with the movie, with his attempt at a joke being the only reasoning he gives as to WHY they are a flaw.
Look through the rest of this video, and this kind of lazy, non-critique is seen again and again and again. The delivery is designed to distract you from the lack of logical consistency, and simply chuckle when you can say "oh, i know that!" It is rapid fire and non-stop so that you don't have time to think about the inconsistency, but I have the magic of the pause button.
Just because CinemaSins is sarcastic doesn't mean he's immune to reason.
@@Xanthosking Could't say any better :D Imo his first videos were more interesting to watch, new ones not so much.
1977 was when dredd was introduced, so hall of justice has been around quite a while.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hall_of_Justice_(comics)
The Hall of Justice in the Superfriends and in Pre-Crises DC Comics still predates it.
@@VunderGuy eh, in the comics they call it Grand hall of justice. Not much of a difference, but still.
@@VunderGuy Well san francisco has one since over a century now, and some other large city probably has one even older.
So.... who copied who?
MC Chase hate to nitpick here since this is such a common mistake, but whom not who
I could do an "Everything Right With Dredd in 95 minutes Or More" (its entire running time) video.
"This is totally arbitrary."
"Welcome to cinema sins."
00:54 „Clerks. Typists. Coffee Vendors” - I just lost it hahaha
U won’t them it’s yours my friend as long as u have enough money
How did you NOT remove a sin for THE line?!
*I*
*AM THE LAW*
Because he clearly knows shit all about Dredd.
This vid was posted in March 2019 and I only just now caught the "Pretty sure he's a Judge and not a doctor, Jim" joke. #fanfail
You can sin this movie to death and beyond. I still love it.
Why we can't have a sequel of this?
It's about *TIME* Captain Falcon gets his own movie...
Only liked because falcon, and ness profile.
12:43 ... kind of surprised you didn't say:
"THE SENTENCE IS DEATH"
Commuted to Life in the 'cubes if you knock 20 sins off for the soundtrack
you invented 60 sins and add 20 just because, that's how good is this movie
5:17 THE SHIELDING MUST BE BLOCKING, you dolt.
* *Everything Wrong with Dredd in 2 Seconds or Less* *
.....Nothing.
* *Video Ends* *
Exept that damn volksvan in the beginning.
Well, there is that it only has maybe 10% of the satire from the source material while even the Stallone movie had maybe 30%.
huh.... WELCOME TO CINEMASINS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Dude they finally shoot out the tires, when there wasn't a ton of traffic and you sin that..c'mon man
3:35 Actually there's a drug called DMT that you breathe in that acts almost immediately after a big enough hit. Only lasts a couple of minutes. Difference is you enter a crazy world of shapes and colours and you aren't sure if your arms are moving so or just your perception of them is slow. So it's not impossible for a drug like slo mo to exist.
The only thing wrong with this movie is that there was not a 2nd one .
There's is a show in the works, it's called Mega City One
Really?
I'm looking forward to it then.
would it be too much of a stretch to suggest a cross over with Mega-man because the two cities are similar in name?
More like out of work if there's 96% unemployment
I sure would hope it gets more seasons than Almost Human did
“ I guess Miss Cleo didn’t survive the radiation”
I’m dead 🤣🤣🤣
So is Miss Cleo
Everything wrong with CinemaSins: They think there's anything wrong with Dredd.
2:20 "I am sick and tired of movies making mutants out to be scorn worthy by the very nature of their mutatiion! THey didnt ask for this!"
Man's literally said he's annoyed by racism being a plot point in movies lmao.