US-China: Is A New NATO Emerging In Asia? | When Titans Clash 2 - Part 1/3 | CNA Documentary
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 вер 2024
- As the Ukraine crisis unfolds, China accuses the US of creating an Indo-Pacific version of NATO, and warns of a “Ukraine style tragedy” for Asia. On the other hand, countries like Japan, Philippines, India, Australia and South Korea, seek closer ties to the US as concerns emerge over China’s actions. Could Asia witness a war in the years ahead?
WATCH MORE When Titans Clash 2
Part 2: • Could China And India ...
Part 3: • The Taiwan (Japan & So...
Season 1: • When Titans Clash | Fu...
======
About the show: As the war in Ukraine takes place, US-China relations worsen. China accuses the US of creating an Indo-Pacific version of NATO, and warns of a “Ukraine style tragedy” for Asia.
============
#CNAInsider #WhenTitansClashCNA #USChina #SouthChinaSea #Quad #Politics
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER!
cna.asia/insid...
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnain...
Former Singapore diplomat: “They say that the definition of a diplomate is someone who can tell you to go to hell In such a way he feels he’s going to enjoy the journey to hell.” 😂😂😂
China should stop their BS claim of entire South China sea,or they'll be surely seeing hell.
That’s a very rude and bold statement. China has never outright destroyed as many nations as USA has.
Ask him to try telling the SG govt to go to hell n see what that will bring him .. ha
I have nothing but respect for that man for saying that. That is definitely a diplomat speaking truth to power.
@@christophersmirnoff5222 yygyyq
I love Mr. Muhbubani's comment about diplomacy being a way of telling another country to "go to hell" but in a way that they enjoy the journey, is hiliarious and true.
As a malaysian wherever NATO had set foot they only brought destruction and complete annihilation, world please take heed.
When superpowers fights, the small countries suffers.
It won't if they could playing with both side, unlike Ukrainian zelensky.
Ya but thanks to one arrogant Regional power who thinks its better than the rest
Russia's goal is for the extermination of Ukraine. If they don't defend themselves, they be forced to learn Russian or die.
Exactly, that's why NATO needs to go!
@@socialistsolidarity small in terms of what ? Russia economy way smaller than EU
War have started... We are all in the same boat, hunger and misery just waiting to spread everywhere.
Okay
And many many cannon fodders are needed for the USA side. Interested applicants please volunteer yourself at your own peril.
Where got war ? You dreaming is it ?
Shi* happens. When people bury their heads in the sand instead of standing up to corporate giants controlling every aspect of their lives then one have only themselves to blame.
ASEAN itself needs to be more solid in its region beyond these geopolitical tension. Long live ASEAN!
_Asia has had enough of past colonialism and now want no more!_
Easily dad, but difficult in action. There’s wars in some ASEAN country now (Burma), while other ASEAN country stand idly by.
ASEAN needs to be like the EU
No more colonialism…..just our own politicians CHEATING your own people. Lol lol
@@tommypaget2294 cheating or not, we would at least control our destiny
"The enemy of my enemy, is my FRIEND."
Nay, more like
The enemy of my enemy is another potential enemy.
Pls no..there is no need for another No-Action-Talk-Only (NATO)-like group at that part of the world 🙏
There should be an Asian NATO. Composed of US, Australia, Japan, S. Korea, Taiwan, India, Philippines, Indonesia.
and the war will be fought in the US or Australia rather than in Asia.. that would be nice
ASEAN countries are already quite close with each other. I think most of them have some brushing up against China... mostly over disputed territory. However, it seems the course of action being taken currenlty is someting more diplomatic and peacful.
No they are not, Paj33t. Phillipines, Malaysia, Brunei, Vietnam as well as Indonesia to some extent have territorial claims in the SCS. But don't worry the only war, if China ever goes to war against would be against you Paj33ts. Delhi is only 300 kms from the Ladakh border within range of ground artilleries, let alone precision strike missiles.
😄 you really believe what you just said?
@@waltertodd4479 "you really believe what you just said?"
Yes.
Then you should have a conversation with Filipinos who were mistreated at the hands of chinese contractors over the last 7 years and then review the results of the Marcos election to see that CCCP China has passed beyond those glory days you are so fond of remembering in the Philippines. 😉 The days of ill mannered CCCP China Aggressions are now numbered in SE Asia! CCCP China's arrogance and lack of respect for Filipinos has left a lasting memory!
We all clearly knew, the us is the only and most ferocious enemy.
Nobody wants to fight, only these old men. They should gather their own ilk, and battle it out with the other govt.
you are wrong many people will fight for money
american just give54 billion to ukraine
@@wengwang5361 Over $100 billion now if we included the whole West.
Kudos to CNA. This was an excellent video.
Very glad to see many commentors are smarter than the editors of this episode.
Fortunately, there are people who are not lazy to research and not depend on spoon feeding propaganda by Western MSM. Western MSM are full of lies. We can see clearly in Russia - Ukraine conflict, Hong Kong riots, etc.
@@route55qatar can't agree more
CNA and Spore are pro-Americans. It's a shame to their Chinese ancestors to want to kixx fellow Chinese.
😂
i can google 100 bad things and 100 good things about the US and find results on google and youtube. in China's media, you can't find a single bad thing about china's government. as a non- american, it is clear which side is more brainwashed.
We the innocent people we just want to live until the time that we are old and ready to die we dont want war every people wants peace and leave freely and following the rule of the law those who seek war and uncertainty ask your self how do you feel if your love one is killed at war.
nope. We live for an equil and fair world. We should fight the bullyer to death.
We want war
@@unknownnamr9518 "for the wages of sin is death but the gift of god in eternal life" you dont know what you are saying you make sure you assumed that words when time comes when we phase god in heaven court and dont include innocent people to your war becase we just live our life free and following god.
38:01 "In 1945, there is no independent Indonesia"
Oh really. Remind me again what year Indonesia declared independence? If I remember correctly it seems to start with 19 and ends with 45.
Declared in 1945, but the dutch return, and we fought them all the way to 1949. So he was right, we declared it, but we didnt have independence at all untill the dutch really left
saat itu juga belum ada komunis china yg ada kuomintang. emang suka ngehalu komunis china.
Feel better now bud?
also, the China fighting the WW2 is the Republic of China currently based in Taiwan
@@BINGCHILING-1912 both Communist and national socialis(present Taiwan ) fought together in WW2
US should be aware that ASEAN is playing a double game.
Double game is good enough for China, but not enough for USA.
Lol asean barely function as it is, all it have is a no tariff for all members inside asean. Hell most of their law do ar align or there any law that close to the freedom of movement
everyone is playing each other
Asia do not need a NATO like organisation. What Asia needs to do now is to enhance its existing organisation which is ASEAN. ASEAN needs to be free from all major power players be it US or China. ASEAN for Asian should be the driving force forward. ASEAN has all the formulas needed to be another major BLOCK in the world in terms of trade, human resource, natural resources and etc.
Which Asian nation will dare disobey the big bully? Singapore, kuai kuai! Sanction Russia. Malaysia? No sound. ASEAN should work with China. The west should go back to the west and stay away from the east. Bye.
Stop dreaming. ASEAN cannot even stop the ongoing massacre and military takeover in Myanmar after two years. There's nothing in common between the ASEAN countries. All have different ancestries unlike NATIO which are almost all Europeans.
@@cyber1991Myanmar is difffernt situation ..itt is their own government
Wheres UNSC for Myanmar?
I hope so, ASEAN have plenty of resources..
@@cyber1991 Myanmar is in this situation because of US meddling through NGOs like NED Nation Endowment of Democracy aka CIA or George Soros foundation
If China still insist that all of South China Sea belong to them, then I think the Chinese can’t blame other countries from taking a confrontation stance against them.
Is Singapore in the South China Sea?
China speaks by strength! The South China Sea has been China's territory since ancient times
@@nikitazxz8752 No, but its economic interests are aligned with rules based order (that made them rich).
It's you that is ignorant to think china don't owns scs islands.
Face the fact. The big and power will somehow dominate the smaller one! Live with it by balancing your act skilfully.
23:34 in response to Mr. Mahburani's suggestion about the power of trade agreements, Germany tried that with Russia and it didn't work. China is not Russia but still, trade agreements can evaporate.
Well it's complicated. Germany & EU not only funded Russia in favor of cheap gas but most importantly they strategically weakened Ukraine by cutting its leverage, the pipelines. They minimized dependency on Ukraine. That's the lesson to be learnt.
Is Ukraine part of Germany or EU?
The US did everything possible to stop Germany and Russia becoming close. Because that would diminish US power.
i think it is the western power want to put their army in the doorstep of russian
@@wengwang5361 for what purpose? Russia has nothing to offer the west other than cheap energy. The only way it was cheap is because corrupt russian politicians sold it under market value.
This Victor Gao is a funny guy...
Justifying a country that has problems with all the other countries and then stating everyone else but them is wrong... 🤣
Well. That’s communist supporters for you. They never change and accept. Even after multiple failures like Venezuela, Cuba, Soviet Union. History is bound to repeat for china as well.
All chinese analyst talk like that😅
Someone says NATO = former Nazi... current NATO is not staying in its purpose at beginning. And I agree.
NATO was formed as a buffer against the USSR following World War 2. However, in my opinion, the organisation has been hijacked by its main contributor the USA. The bombing of Serbia and Libya by NATO proves it is not just a defensive organisation but has become an offensive one.
Good News, our ASEAN countries could use both great powers to make our region more rich. China and India are too big and the USA's power in Asia (not including West Asia and Central Asia) is just equal to the strong regional power. However, China or/and India may be not great power outside Asia but superpowers in Asia. Our ASEAN do not hope to challange their power instead helping China and India to exercise their power more rational.
Imagine, if Malaysia to join the NATO with 9 another ASEAN countries including Indonesia, Singapore, Thailand & Philippines, China should be impose to sanctions against the 10 ASEAN countries
@@azimisyauqieabdulwahab9401 NATO could provide military assistance and aid to help the defense of our Asean. But we do not think NATO or/and the US would declare war againsr China and/or India to defend any of the ASEAN countries including Phillippines.
Indonesia is the strongest in Southeast Asia in fact stronger than China.
@@bobafett5757 Are you insane?
@@ThienHoang-tr3dh Indo is powerful
I like how you switch back to Victor Gao every so often as a opposing opinion
"Liberal Democracy" Australia. Read The History. The Rum Corps ran the Prison Colony and nothing happened, including supplying Muskets to create Power Imbalance within the New Zealand Maori Tribal System without Montefiore giving The Nod.
Why USA always keeps bullying my cute president Xi from China and my favourite Kimmy from North of Korea......
Dont you adore the cuteness of this two leaders🥺🥺🥺
What’s up with the battle music when Chinese spokesmen opens their mouth? Contrast that with the yoga music played when American politicians speak. Clear bias here.
E.g. Kamala Harris - 7:05
E.g. Chinese spokesperson - 8:30
Lol tell me I’m not seeing and hearing these callous media bias attempts in real time?
Western journalism is nothing but manipulation.
Wonder how much of a role media played in "manufacturing consent"
Weak ones usually need allied with others together to share their daily fears and try to get back up by others.
I wouldnt say weak but its insidious. US and its allies always say they are democratic and ensure peace & stability while upholding values that lets others be soverign in their own right but from what I see its only if it benefits them.
To deny the second largest economy a right to develop in the world as if its some local power and not globally intertwined from globalization is a weak argument imo
So, the Global South Should forget about their vast Population and ensure American Military 800 Bases Surrounded the World has Jobs and live well ? American Military ensure new Slavery. 👹
We must stand up to the bully that claimed that stoopid 9 dash lines at SCS
@@bobafett5757 you stupid useless cancer! get informed, moron!
"Article 2
It is recognized that under Article 2 of the Treaty of Peace with Japan signed at the city of San Francisco in the United States of America on September 8, 1951 (hereinafter referred to as the San Francisco Treaty), Japan has renounced all right, title and claim to Taiwan (Formosa) and Penghu (the Pescadores) as well as the Spratly Islands and the Paracel Islands."
Silly argument. Why not build Alliances if they want security they will need to put into common defence. The bully China does not like it, well that is too bad! it’s not our fault all their friends are failed states.
World peace must be maintained at all times and this is the ideal and very objective enshrined in the founding of the United Nations and its Charter. If there is any alliance every nation on earth must maintain and strengthen, nothing could be more acceptable to all stakeholders than alliance to the United Nations as the overall every nation's organization for the maintenance of world peace and, consequently, the development of every member nation's economy for a better life for all! International diplomacy is key for a clear and better understanding for each state's concerns for their resolution. Continuing dialogue between or among parties or stakeholders are very important more than ever in this time of human advancement. In communication, almost everyone has the tools and systems to make a clearer and better appraisal of what really is or was for a definitive and truly effective information or knowledge that warrants an all-unified UN action and resolution. Having said my views here on world peace, I pray the 5 permanent members of the UN Security Council work together for a peaceful and prosperous world order for all nations! It cannot be denied, effective world peace is anchored on them!
Some are saying that by the time Biden gets finished, we won't have anything but war. Now every American has to wear that label? He could have prevented a lot of what is happening in the world today. People will hate us (all North Americans) here in the USA because of it. You'd think we are the ones he hates. I hope Russia and China realize he does not have the backing of the majority of the USA citizens! Not even close! They doubt that Trump could even get us out of this horrid mess! Have mercy on our American Citizens.
My God get real. What a load of drivel. Where has the United Nations been lately? The worlds in a mess.
The UN is just as evil as the rest of them. Banish them all. Quit trusting in these elitists, they dont care about you, they don't care about humans or humanity, they don't care about the world, they don't care about peace and prosperity. They are not there to serve we the people, they are not here to help us.
The double talk in this video is beyond belief! Well done!
That is because you are from 2 cent tell army
America is the greatest thread to all humanity including peoples in the US.!!!!!!!!!!!!
@@Kilimanjaro5896 Even if that were true, it would be far less than the number of innocent civilians killed by the United States in its more than 100 years of foreign wars
A fake tianamen agian how stupits peoples.!!!!!!!!!!! Infact China beaten America agiant a fail colors revolution coupe.!!!!!!!!!! Only the terrorists killed 400 hundreds soilders.!!!!!!!!!!!
@@Kilimanjaro5896 a fake agiant this how stupits peoples in the west can be easily fool.!!!!!!!!!!!! Infact China beat America CIA and Gorge Soro A fail colors revolution coupe.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Point being is nothing in this world's for free. All diplomatic ties and mutual agreements come at a cost, and always with the bigger nations gaining the upperhand. A bitter pill to swallow for third world countries like us, that we have to agree to terms where we will be less exploited.
All these problems stem from greed , power and control. This has been around for millennia. One empire falls another one rises. There is enough food , shelter , clothing and water to go around for everyone , that is if the aforementioned pernicious factors were not present and dominant. So, this show will go on as long as people who are addicted to power are among us and in charge.
China is a bad actor and this puff piece program by the Singaporean company in support of Xi's CCP is very gross and disgusting. It is based on and perpetuates Chinese hate.
Iraq war was a criminal war too
James teh And
@@theguyishere249
It means the rules based order the United States likes to talk about is total bullshit. They break it all the time.
Now they have met their match with two nations, china and Russia also breaking the so called rules based order with Russia invading ukraine and china kidnapping the two michaels after the United States kidnapped meng wanzhou
In 1945, Indonesia proclaimed its independence, while in the same year China had civil war. So if they claimed north Natuna sea belongs to them, so sorry, we won't sit and watch only. For our territory there's no bargaining.
You people murdered many Chinese-Indonesian in the early 60's and in 1998. One was under Sukarno and the later under Suharto. Both of them have Chinese blood on their hands. There will be karma on you people. All the islands of Indonesia will be swept with Tsunami including Sumatera (happened before) and Jawa. Jakarta is sinking that is why they want to move it to Kalimantan. The 1st Karma was served in Acheh for the sins of Sukarno and now waiting for the 2nd Karma to come to Indonesia for the sins of Suharto.
Really and what could Indonesia do? China's coast guard fleet alone is already bigger than your navy and if the Chinese navy is included it's bigger than all the Asian navies combined.
And why are you so uptight about this issue? You think Indonesia will loose all the oil and gas resources over there? Most of the oil and gas rigs there were operated by major western oil corporations with very little flow back to Indonesia anyway. Why don't you take a step back and think through why China needed a buffer zone to protect itself against AUKUS?
@@buddyoo4942 nope.. that's not buffer zone, but fishing spot for them..
@@Zergcerebrates Look at the map. all shipping lane that in and out of south China Sea must come thru Indonesian waters. So the most important shipping lane is Indonesian waters, NOT the SCS... Go ahead think what Indonesia could do.
Around the 16th minute, an American commentator used the term export instead of deport when referring to the prosecution of criminals between Australia and China. Given the severity of the topic, a slight smile was appreciated at the thought of exporting someone back to their home country.
'Extradited' is the right word to use
We Chinese tend to view ourselves as the victim of colonialism and imperialism, but few realize that in the eyes of our neighbors we are becoming the oppressor. The Ukraine conflict has revealed that there is considerable anti-West sentiment in Asia. China should capitalize on that and avoid being over-aggressive against our neighbors.
@@Kilimanjaro5896 just as ordinary Americans are not, but their foreign policy
Which neighbor are we aggressive towards? Please give an example? We've been weak enough to lose a lot of territory in Tibet. Those Western colonies in the South China Sea that did not exist before World War II, taking advantage of the large South China Sea islands occupied during the Chinese Civil War, should China hand over its energy lifeline in the South China Sea to the control of the US allies? In order to please these countries, you know that China has paid How much? But they are never satisfied. If you are interested in politics, learn to study maps first.
Too late for that...CCCP China has had numerous contractor jobs in SE Asia like the philippines where the locals were underpaid and disrespected so much that philippinos sent the Chinese home. Additionally Chinese contractors were using inferior materials on the job just to make a buck or two.
@@Kilimanjaro5896 you should blame Kuomingtang because Taiwan today also claim 11dashline, but CCP only claims 9dashline.
@@Kilimanjaro5896 thank you
China is right, the US does not want to give up "hegemony"... to China.
No, the US does not want to "give up" hegemony to the tyranny.
@@damirkozlica1709 all anyone should have to do is look at North Korea. That is what a Chinese Vassal looks. A country that has nuclear weapons aimed at Tokyo and Seoul. China thinks just because it is powerful that other countries have to follow it. How would anyone from the west choose China... They betrayed the US in 1949 when they went communist. They hated capitalism, now they are capitalist, but still hostile. They are hostile because they want to expand. They must be resisted, by everyone.
Asian region remember western colonialism, thus will not ever trust them or join such an alliance. Pump all the money and weapons you want into region, but no one will initiate a war with it's biggest trading neighbor.
Panda Digital Love Really how much you want to bet. Also you really need to get over imperialism. I can name any countries past crimes, as if it really matters anymore.
@@theguyishere249 But honestly, you have o be an Asian to ever get it n know this ..
India is the only country in Asia which can counter balance China miltarily even though china is far more stronger in all spheres
Such confrontational thinking shows how the world is deeply brainwashed by Warmerica
@@renawong8249 india can stand on its own leg india will never be a another Afghanistan or Ukraine
@@renawong8249 we Indians will never believe USA nor China forever
Why can't you just rule Indian ocean, not South China Sea, then we should all be happy. You can still use Mi cellphone.
@GOKUL Jayaraman 50 years later, India may still have a little chance.........🤣
I don't understand Philippians, you were colony of US. Now people in Philippine like Americans again? Because you are agree with colonial master's value?
Stockholm syndrome is what the Pinoys are experiencing. In fact they have forgotten about the Filipino-US war where the Americans killed and caused 2M to die from famine and they have forgiven what the Americans did to their forefathers. This can only happen to people who have weak culture and poor national identity or needed money to survive and therefore they bend over. Disgusting.
As a Filipino i dont hate anyone,
I am not living from the past.
We have to move on . And enjoy life now..BAHALA kayo😂👌 Peace All!
@@Yamie1101
Maybe not you but I have a problem with most Filipinos. All the comments are so anti China, so anti Chinese as if the Chinese killed your whole flicking family and yet, there you are, Filipino like you who says -"Oh I don't live in the past, oh I live for the future". Yes sure. after 100 years you must have forgiven the Americans, I mean you are not psychotic, you can't hold a 100 years hate. They only killed and murdered your great grand relatives or family members of the past and 2M others. I get that.
But when it comes to the Chinese, "oh the Chinese government is evil." Did they killed any Filipinos? did they at war with pinoys now or ever before? HELL NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, they took some of your islands and hell broke loose. I WANT CHINESE BLOOOOOOOOOOOOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ok i will explain one you claiming areas that do not belong to you two this a stupid chinese talking point three the level arrogance from this show you lack of empathy for other people lastly you people look down on others same as the WW2 version of Imperial Japan clear enough for you?!
@@bldomain Well look at the Imperialist talking points oh really Weak cultural said the person who destroyed its own culture at cultural revolution to favor communism (A western concept and ideology) this statement alone proves your lack of recognition and empathy for other expect from communist imperialist who killed millions of its own people enjoy making more enemies people people are hated throughout the region btw from India to South East Asia so enjoy being encircled by people you made enemies with morons
India is the only country which can counter & deter China bcz India's armed forces are experienced & have faced multiple wars battle hardened unlike China's. Also India's rapid technological advancements in space & electronic warfare is at par with China's or even US Japan if not more is worth noting. India is definitely a balancing force in the world order.
I don't get why the Westerner keep help Asian to sow discord about the 9 decline issue, sounds like we Asian cannot solve it out the problem by ourselves 😂
Divide and conquer strategy. They don't want a United SEA Nation which will be a threat to them in the future. A United ASEAN means prosperity. Imagine hiring maids from Western countries. Hahaha
bcz we always chose dogs who love dollar's only Asian suffers they just print dollar's
They are trying to deflect attention as their economies have lost their competitiveness , their debt levels have piled up n their social system is fraught with problems that they cannot resolve ..
You can't form an alliance without willing participants. They want outside forces to counter the influence of PRC.
If countries want to form an alliance with China they would. I don't see any countries will to do that. Goes to show how much of the world thinks of China. Unreliable, Untrustworthy and Unfriendly!
No, I think the usa doesn't want to have to clean up the mess again like what happened to the philippines after the Japanese invaded manila in 1942.
@@waltertodd4479 Or the mess in China when the CCP left and hid, leaving the ROC to fight the Japanese
Spoiler alert:
Ostriches don't actually put their head in the sand to avoid conflict. They're often seen changing the position of their eggs which are located inside dugout nests.
Angmohs: War and prosperity.
Chinese: Peace and prosperity.
PAP angmophiles: Follow the angmohs, sure can make money.
India should stay away from China's internal matter in south China sea ,
And focus on economy
India has potential to be economic Prosper country
India people are lazy, do not know how to help themselves.
Ladakh is not over yet.
@@bobafett5757 India is capable to defend sovereignty but your countries' are looser they are in the bed of China's
US is the biggest issue in the world. Just look at the unrest and wars happened in the past 50 years, US was behind all of them. It is wise for India to grow economy, but beware of US, they will attack india when India is big enough to challenge US' supremacy, just like how they attack China now.
@@bobafett5757 They won’t mess with India anymore. They already got the answer!!
The problem with some US government officials, they used to intervene with the internal affairs of other countries. that's where conflict between two countries usually starting.
Hit the problem on the head ????? alike Tawain South Korea tried in Venezuela Iran Afghanistan 20 yrs to no avail Australians and New Zealand as puppets japan
You say they "used to" as if they don't anymore. Lmao. "Freedom military coups" all around the world have one thing in common.
India GDP (1980): US$186 billion
China GDP (1980): US$191 billion
India GDP: (2021): US$2.8 trillion
China GDP: (2021): US$17.7 trillion
Now you know why daddy America loves India?
Ha ha ha!
Daddy America loved China till 2013. US-China cooperation started when Nixon visited China in 1972. US funded Chinese growth. Even now US buys more from China than from any other country. US has supported China even during its entry in WTO. Shenzen was developed opposite Hong Kong- an investment hub for Western funds.
China has been built on western cash.
@@sublimefermion2205 Sheep, if you stop consuming information from western media and politicians, you will find yourself become intelligent suddenly.
@Great Asia is just a 50-Cent Army (WuMao) foot soldier... the more you reply to him/her/it ... the more money they make.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party
It's 3.2 trillion
@@sublimefermion2205
Western cash do not come free. There is no free lunch. The West invest in China because of cheap labor and high profits and to pull China away from Russia. They are not investing from the bottom of their heart. They tolerate China as long as they produce low end products but once China wants to move up the value chain that is when hell broke out in the West. China is second to the US in economy, technology and military and this made the US poop in their pants. They cannot handle the heat of competition from China and thus resort to smearing China with its dominance in international media. China do not owe the US anything and the last time I checked the US owes China $1 trillion in US bonds. Cheers.
Quad isn't as strong of an alliance as NATO by any means.
Also, while China and Russia have many similarities, such as being totalitarian governments.
They are very different in many ways.
China is much more economically focused while Russia is more militarily focused.
If you look at actual wars fought in recent years, China behaves very differently from Russia. Russia's invaded georgia, Crimea, and went head to head against the US interests in Syria and sided with the brutal dictator Assad, and now obviously the full blown war against Ukraine.
China has shown aggression and hostilities but has not actually invaded any sovereign nation in recent decades. We'll see if that changes as they grow more powerful, can never be to careful when a powerful country gets hostile even if it's only in postering and rhetoric so far.
Are you a Chinese dissident by any chance? China and Russia do not go round the world building hundreds of military bases. It is not China or Russia you should be afraid of but a hegemonic power which is in terminal decline.
Well said, I think China has been boxed in economically. Russia has oil for war and fairs well. China doesn't.
I know Vietnam Vets who say the Chinese attacked us in Vietnam.
So Vietnam was likely a Proxy War with China and Russia as Was Korea.
@Shiang Chen Yeah, but china wasn't as powerful as it is now. China is not stupid. They seem more tactical sneaky then their Russian allies.
中国和邻国因一些历史原因，几乎和周边所有国家都存在边境纠纷，经过这些年，中国的陆地边境线除了印度，都完成了边境线的确定，实现和平再无纠葛。而海上边境线始终还是坚持实际控制线为准，多年来并没有任何扩张或退让，当有争议时，都是尽可能的以谈话为主。2022年，中国将与东盟达成南海行为准则协议。这才是美方紧张的原因，并总想插入进来挑起争议区域的矛盾，妄图制造战争。
Who sided with brutal dictator Saddam Hossain in Iraq's war with Iran?
> The shepherds flock was threatened by the wolf, so the shepherd got a dog. The dogs’ teeth were not sharper or its bite more vicious than the wolf, but the wolf would rather go hungry than face the dog.
Taiwan should be very worried now. It could be next Ukraine.
🇨🇳 should respect India,s border. Then every thing will be solved.
and india should Respect China border, it was india who crossed the line and mob killed 4 PLA.. don't expect China will sit still and do nothing! 😁
if your country dont have military power to compete with its enemy, this is what happens.
rules based order ? what a joke
Victor Gao keeps talking about peace but China's action speak differently.
Explain how China action speaks diff?
@@sorder6509 The way they initiated a deadly conflict with India in 2020 and Victor still talking about peace which the Chinese never considered an option.
china is the same as the US
@@pratikthakur5052 Stop watching wion
@@sorder6509 CCP bot
So the US wants war but wants Asia to be their battleground far away from their territory? Isn't it unfair to countries to carry all the burden and the aftermath of the war US has created while they sleep comfortably on their homes? Asia will be in chaos living in a total desolation while the US is spared from being burdened in rebuilding their country.
Coming from America, most Americans don't want war. We just wanna live our lives
Great documentary 👍 .Now onto Part 2.
The "rules-based order" is a problematic term. It is critical to first address the question of whose "rules" and to whom it benefits.
It is patently clear that the present rules-based order is promoted by some one or some group of nations that were "at the table "formulating those rules". (Please bear in mind that the "rules" referred to by those characters in the video come most from a certain group of countries. The only "rules" that should be acceptable internationally, must first be endorsed by the UN through a protocol that has at its core the majority of the countries represented by the UNGA (UN General Aseembly).
there is but one set of international rules that's agreed to by all nations, the Rules of United Nations.
US can never produce in black and white their set of rules because there is none. US and its gang invaded Syria and Russia stepped in and ruined their game plan. that's why Russia and China are a threat to US rule-based order. 😁
The main beneficiary of the existing rules-based order has been the people's republic of China. It is kind of ironic that they are so intent on destabilizing it due to having emotionally insecure leaders.
Simple all empires rise and fall Roman 500 + years Latin dead now the colonial empire on the decline English language will eventually die slowly BRICS ideology Build the next empire Humans liv a very short time 98 % of Germans turned a blind
Eye when the Jews were bing gassed European colonialism slaughtered 90 million + destroyed 5 thousand + ciultures and their languages how many Jewish children born today with terrible as in Vietnam and Afghanistan people like you appease your puppet war lords usa and North Atlantic terrorist organisation NATO your a shame to your family I tell my
Great gran children the truth tell the it’s all to see internet but Free Basher bans you no Yankee or Israeli can be charged with war crimes SO FAR Very convenient ????????
But China didn't recognize it, especially the UNCLOS. They want SCS for themselves because Japan controlled it in WWII; they believe Japan gave it to them, and it is a very idiotic assumption to say that it already belongs to them only because most countries in the ASEAN region have not yet gained their sovereignty before WWII; it's a greedy mentality by China. SCS was never a territory of any country before Japan took it, so it is natural that if Japan relinquished its ownership, it should be a neutral territory by default. That is why it should be decided by the UNCLOS.
by rules based order they mean the west can do anything at will and the east and africa gets exployted for anything possible
How come they don't want to talk about how the COVID-19 originated in China, or about the own expansion agenda in the south China sea?
Who told you COVID-19 originated in China? Actully it originated in UAS. It is the American who brought the virus to Wuhan during the Military World Games in 2019
Imagine Taiwan having NATO-style protections from West Taiwan.
You idiots say West Taiwan as if it is an insult to mainland China. If Taiwan also claims the mainland China as its territory (as the KMT used to do), then it legitimizes a Chinese invasion as part of an on-going civil war and delegitimizes the entire basis of Taiwan independence.
and that day will be the end of Taiwan as you know it.
Delusional. Republic of China is the official name not Taiwan.
Love the quad. Thank you for the vaccines
Every country should fight for their own independence. Every American country fought to free itself. What other countries do is to back up their efforts with food, receiving refugees and play good friends.
Why does America think it should have ALL the marbles…why can’t we share?
ASEAN will go back 50-60 years if the asian nato comes on
NATO isn't only the US, the world keeps underestimating the NATO force
The truth is the US is the foundation of NATO …take them out …and no one will want to go down with them... with the dollar at an all time low, i cant see how the Americans will win against China, India and Russia on matters of business, trade and military.🤷
@@wikichumba you make it look like it's NATO vs Russia, China and India???? You're completely missing the point of the alliance 🤷
Quite a US-sided documentary here
But its the truth that China starts with all the aggression at South China Sea and it must be stopped
bot
Have you watched a Chinese propaganda TV?...lol
@@iaoshua bot
The easiest solution to this world problem is simple. Just support India.
to build toilet?
Accuse the enemy of what you are doing yourself - Goebells
Mr. Gao is dreaming. His recollection of the ownership of the islands in the SCS is somewhat misplaced for lack of historical and/or legal basis.
Go improve your knowledge. Of course it's china
Taiwan claims 11dashline, so you should ask why West supported ROC's 11dashline since 1945
Australia is one of usa fight dogs, why you reported so many views of a dog?
Here are more fight dogs of The United States. This is something China can only dream of.
ua-cam.com/video/llIYFjxkZ10/v-deo.html
And ur mom is a b*tch.
K. Mahbubani has certainly developed a reputation as an analyst of the geopolitics especially in his backyard. But I did not hear anything original from the insights he had shared in this documentary. Also his saying that ASEAN countries can tell Chinese "to go to hell" on the South China Sea issues, using diplomatese, will work because it would make them feel that the trip will be enjoyable is pure naivete.
It makes me sick when the US, UK or AU politicians talk about sovereignty of other nations and rules based order.
The reality is that the force makes the rules, and the rules apply only when it suits the force.
Look at all the CIA bots.
Victor Gao is a good comedian
We Need to Create an Asian NATO --> POTO (Pacific Ocean Treaty Org) : USA , Japan, Australia, Philippines, South Korea etc....
For what? Who have colonized ASEAN in the past, America, Japan and NATO members, not China.
ASEAN Block
MAPHILINDO is being revived to choke China in the South.
China is on course to eclipse usa as the world super power. All the rest of the countries you mentioned are at it sunset mode except for India. Only the smart one knew how to drift with the wind of change.
The name POTO is very appropriate. They should change the last letter to a Y instead of O. Then it would be called POTY because that is what these warmongers are - POTY.
The documentary was very informative and up-to-date. The Philippines is in the verge of a Marcos presidency and is perceived as a continuation of Duterte's policies. As a filipino, i am proud to what Pres. Duterte has done for the country. With his daughter as incoming vice president, working hand in hand with BongBong Marcos, i believe the Philippines will go further in bringing prosperity to the Filipino people.
hmm so how will Filipinos prosper in the future if their territory and rich oiland gas resources, fisheries, etc. are stolen by another country????
How?! Isko will be a far better pick and i hate all Politicos anyway Jesus these BBMs zealots! Its like asking a Rapist to guard your daughters and your sexy wife may i ask how is that possible? And are you mental!? This a man from a family that stole billions with a B from the Philippines in dollars may i add and who did nothing in his time as Senator and Governor of his home province and had a Boat Party at age 20 while everyone else was starving?! and never work a single day of his life how the hell would he improve the country? The man is so out of touch with his own people to care so how? If this guy becomes President we are all screwed i would rather have other more 6 years with lord moron (Duterte) than lord inutil (BBM) again asking Rapist to guard your daughters and your sexy wife is not a bright idea
@@castilloalvin7384 Philippines will side to US.
Around 80% of your country's economy is controlled by the Chinese. The people governing your country seems to come from only a few powerful elite families. Many of your local politicians are only interested in enriching themselves through your "pork barrel" projects. Many of your leaders in both the local level up to your national level seems incompetent, corrupt, and mediocre.
@@macgurkha1973 what? Chinese Filipinos are not mainlanders the rest is true but seriously Filipino Chinese are Filipinos racist
this victor ngo is making up dreamy stories. bravo!
china is smart to put the blame on others first ( therefore china is not guilty ) .
They would be dumb to allow Americans to get their foot in the door like Ukraine. Let's not forget how the whites took over America, Australia themselves. The natives just let them land their ships and before you know it, everyone's dead and they rule the entire continent
Very dangerous when US with Australia now move the Cold War situation to Asia. Asia could be a battle zone for the powerful nations.
Australians shafted in Vietnam North Korea Iraq Afghanistan Iran Yemen Puppets for the the west Other naive puppets japan Tawain regime change South Korea canon fodder like all USA conflicts dismal defeat
The US with Australia won’t move unless China becomes a problem with Taiwan and the SCS. Catch is, China is determined to invade Taiwan as core a policy. We should know more about AUKUS next year. With the UK, the three countries are planning to integrate their defence capabilities. We should know more about AUKUS next year. Taiwan has never been part of China. China should just settle down. Agree ASEAN and the Pacific could be drawn into the conflict. The Solomon Islands have just signed a security pact with China. The Solomons inserting itself between China and AUKUS in a conflict? Mad. I wonder how many Solomon Islander politicians are buying new cars?
@@petersinclair3997 In AUKUS, US lead so whatever US decide, they move. As for now, US is trying to create trouble to weaken China and I am afraid Australia maybe used by US as Proxy to US evil plot and all killed or destroyed are Australian men and properties while USA watching from afar.
USA isn't going to risk direct war with China just like now in Ukraine with another super power with nuclear weapons which can hit America soil.
Remember that the World including USA recognized Taiwan is part of China therefore, to involve if China is engage in battle with Taiwan is to interfere into the internal affair of another country. How to justify to be involved.
Australia puppet for USA and the Zionists still controlled by the English colonial royal parasites still lay alliegance to the queen of England called commonwealth law took Ireland 150 yrs to get rid of the royal parasites
The ocean.... open sea....
China
Builds an island out of nowhere 🤣
This was well done. Thanks!
Rational men know the devastating forces that would be unleashed (may God forbid), in the event of all-out nuclear war between the US and Russia. The world would be irrevocably changed. Let's just hope that the minds of rational men will prevail in this situation.
Unfortunately Russia and China are led by irrational men.
Whose mind would that be then? Biden?
Wait so you saying invading a country is wrong but usa with the middle east ??
it is ok the USA invades with lgbt missiles and bullets so it is ok
I hope one day Asian unite and establish Asian Alliance Treaty Organization or AATO.
AATO means rest in peace NATO and America.
namaste love from Nepal
shut up nepali
Okay you do that but then don’t use anything from the west and start wearing your own clothes
@clemathieu JT The is no peace Asia moron.
Japan, South Korea, China and Taiwan are not best of friends
@clemathieu JT Say what you want.
Asia today is mimic of the west it has practically copied everything from the west.
Even China builds European copied cities like wtf!!!
@clemathieu JT Where do you think steel structures come from moron.
Like I said Asia copies the west in every field.
From the industrial revolution till now Asia has followed the west.
Could you imagine if Asia didn’t you would be left behind.
Look at your clothing none of you wear your traditional clothing it is all western.
No matter what the differences, WE SHOULD STRIVE FOR WORLD PEACE. Each Country respecting each Countries values and Cultures. I am Thai and I live in the US. I respect Thai culture 100%. Just like I respect Chinese Culture 100%.This will make our World a very unique and interesting place to live and learn. Thai culture has different food and a different energy. My Dad is German . I can tell his culture is unique. I love them ALL. And it would be a dream to taste each cultures values, tastes, interests and the way they do things differently then me. I find that to be very interesting. We're not Gorilla's fact check, we're human beings. From the trillionare too the broke were all created equally.
🎯💯💪🏾
CCP LACKEY. ALL of your scum "peacelovers" class were MARXIST CCCP 5TH COLUMNISTS and now PUTIN'S &CCP ONES
Respect is earned.
@@skillbopster define what you mean " respect is earned between Humans made of the same atoms, cells, quarks etc as each other "? Are you referring too violence?
Mark - exactly!! I think there is a desire in most people to get along with others, no matter what country or culture they’re from. Maybe even MORE SO when they are from other countries and cultures. Reaffirms our humanity. We’re all in the same family: all made by God. Or if you don’t believe in God, then all from the same big gene pool of humans.
is it me or has china and its people, just reeking of power and class?
If government leaders, news media and others would STAY OUT of it, the people of all countries would get along just fine. Give peace a chance.
Give peace a chance? I dont think so. Without wars, US cannot survive.
WTF. You never turn your back on someone who wants to hurt you.
If that person is 30x larger - Talk to your friends - Asking for help is not a sign of weakness.
Australia's friends came and helped us - Bought our coal, wheat, beef and so many other products = China got to pay twice extra for our Iron while we were eating lobster and drinking wine.
@@Oscarcat2212 Exactly, and six months ago, the Afghan are still wondering why the savior Americans left them to the mercy of Taliban
@@michaele4830 80 years ago Afghanistan was the shinning light in that area of the world - It have a very benevolent king who was trying to abdicate and hand over power to his people.
The ruling class were educated in the west. To appease its big neighbor to the North he allowed his army to be trained by The Soviet Union.
The Army revolted and killed him and all his family.
The Americans should have trained and armed the Afghan women. They would have fought for their lives against the Taliban.
@@Oscarcat2212 Afghanistan have history stretching thousand of years before Islam. Buddhism and tribalism were their way of lives, and have not change much to up the present day except their religion. Women have always been out of sight. Whatever deal Biden had made with the Taliban, it does not include their women.
Chinese also fears that if they invade Taiwan with Full force India might invade China
Yeah. Sure India would. China has the high ground. But unfortunately, it is a bit too high. So high that neither country could possibly send a large enough force across it.
In dia invade china ? With what ? Cow manure ? Loool
India tried before in 1950s, while China was busy fighting against US in North Korea. But Chinese Army defeated India badly which becomes the biggest nightmare of Indians now.
@@jielinzhou1442 .......haha what happen in galwan valley ??......messing with india gone wrong...........india will attack china in surprise
@@Dangermonkey1000 I am sorry for the huge Indian soldiers lost in Galwan Valley. These low caste Indians die with no meanings.
But I am a little surprise to learn that Indian like you don't study history? Do I need to remind you what happen in 1962?Or do I need to remind you the gap between China and India now and in 1962..
If I am a wise Indian, I would more focus on how to make my country stronger rather than make myself happy with lies.
BTW, I predict there will be conflicts between China and India soon as food prices are definitely rocketing up later this year. When some of poor Indian farmers have no food, your government will surely create conflicts with China as always. I just hope Modi is familiar with Indian history.
NATO in Europe and now in Asia. NATO must expand in all continents to prevent those evil and totalitarian regimes.
The autocrats only know the language of force, that is why they must be stopped before they became too strong.
Sure. Particularly those autocrats disguised as "democrats". Those are the most dangerous autocrats.
Who has china invaded or attacked or threatened to overthrow?
@@francismusali676 Ladakh and Arunachal region of India
@@idk321 just incidents but not invasions
@@francismusali676 They did in 1962 and 1967
"Rule based international order " 45:09. Her choice is aligned with State Department, or she won't have a job in the institute based in London.
We will assure you ?
In the world political landscape, there is no justice, because every country is considering its own interests. Looking back on the wars that NATO led by the United States has launched over the past few decades, is it just? Of course, it is no exception for China to expand its influence abroad for its own interests. ASEAN is like the EU, and each country has its own interests to consider. It is of course right for Ukraine to join the EU to develop its economy. I don’t think Russia can find any excuse to embarrass Ukraine, but the Ukrainian government is wrong to be a pawn of the United States and has always maintained an ambiguous relationship with NATO, which is why Russia cannot tolerate it. , in the end it was the Ukrainian people who were unlucky.For a small country, there is not much right to choose, and it is even more stupid to blindly choose one side.
most reasonable comment !
"In the world political landscape, there is no justice, because every country is considering its own interests" ..yeah then forget about environment protection / climate change or until the Martians coming to attack earth then you will realized how foolish you are. Why can't there be justice for everything? Your brain is too simplistic to comprehend how to live a righteous life?
Better to be a pawn if Russia?
@@Rob_F8F you are either a pawn to the US or a pawn to Russia, looking at what both of those countries do to their pawns, there is really no difference.
Nice try Russian bot! lol
My neighbor is claiming my house and someone is advising me to adopt politeness and diplomacy to resolve the issue. Just wow. The choice of word of Philippines FM is what the land grabber's eardrum are itching to hear.
If the beef was with one neighbor once can understand both could be partially responsible, but this country has brawl with everyone (most country) near and far from it's territory. Clearly, the problem is the country itself.
How is the kingdom of Sikkim now? Is this nation still existed?
@@tupolevi English is certainly not your best suite, is it?
China has recognised Sikkim as part of India. Are you saying Xi Jinping is wrong?
Only Kingdom that remains contested is Tibet.
@@sublimefermion2205
What if China didn't recognise Sikkim as part of India? Btw, where're the documents and proof, and the last time an indian like you also made the same claim that China reconigise all their disputed territories belonged to India .Errr.. but with an attached map inside a meeting memorandum that vaguely indicated the disputed boundary lines.
Even with China recognition, this stain mark will never be removed since India army had actually and illegally annexed a sovereign nation of a different history, culture, ethnicity by using Force!
Shiny and incredible claims
Indian's proof = Bulls
Indians's peace = Xxxx
@@sublimefermion2205 but those north eastern endians look completely different from rest of the mainland endia, i mean those people in north east endia are discriminated just for their looks they are even called chinky minky, chowmein, momo by those dark endians, therefore northeast endia has right to be independent from cow dung eaters
@@manishgrg639 and so does the south indians look different from north.The northies call them dosa,idli and the southies call northies pani puri,pan masala. What's your point? no part of india has same culture and there's always been some sort of discrimination between each states. Nothing new
When LKY suggested to the U.S. to pivot to Asia to counter-balance China, Chinese netizens cursed at him. He came out to explain that counter-balanced did not mean 制衡....Anyway, he did the right thing as we cannot allow China to roam freely in South East Asia.
在美国的帮助下，你们会变成第二个阿富汗，成为一个用人命和鲜血作为武器来消耗中国实力的土地
So more American troops mean more American run military brothels near American military camp, institutionalised to serve American masters (American soldeires stationed in Philipines and South Korea)😎
have you been to sea ? you dont need military the women throw themselves at you desperate for $$$
They're horrible. American soldiers commit many rapes in Japan and South Korea, and their government has no right to try those rapists at all. It's so pathetic to be a colony of America.
and more brothels in Japan serving American servicemen🤣
China has been building presence in the South China sea, claiming reefs and islands. This is expansionism and should be a big concern as this can create problems in the future.
You typically ma usa an North Atlantic terrorist organisation NATO puppet chi in Asia Europe in Europe you dumb idiot The natzi’s were destroyed by Russia usa stay in your neck of the woods colonialism slaughtered 90 million plus sole 50 trillion in wealth like the German natzi’s usa ideology Cuba 60 yrs sanctions in my opinion your verbal farts do not impress me
I don't understand why the world is acting like the war in Ukraine is the 1st war after WW2?especially the western world. what about Iraq,Afghanistan,Syria,lybia and Palestine?
The push for Western hegemony, by hook or crook, is centuries old...