Pride & Shame: The Roots Of US-China Tensions | When Titans Clash | Ep 1/4 | CNA Documentary
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 січ 2021
- US China relations are at its worst in modern history, how did the two countries get to this point? Understand the historical forces driving the conflict - from China’s Century of Shame to the slow decay of deindustrialisation in the US. Further adding to tensions is China’s perspective that US meddled in Hong Kong’s internal politics, and the American perspective that China is in part to blame for the coronavirus pandemic. After 4 years of escalating conflict under a Trump administration, what will Biden’s approach to China be?
Continue watching When Titans Clash: • When Titans Clash | Fu...
=======
About When Titans Clash: There are historical forces at play in ongoing US-China tensions. How do sentiments of pride and shame fuel the rivalry? And how might a Biden administration confront Beijing?
===========
#CNAInsider #WhenTitansClashCNA #USChina #TradeWar
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER!
cna.asia/insideryoutubesub
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnainsider
Who really loses when China and US clash? And will Southeast Asia be forced to take a side? Continue watching When Titans Clash: ua-cam.com/play/PLkMf14VQEvTbTGw6gbmIHoWz4nmolfkpU.html
of course China will suffer more than US. US have more technology and more connection to europe which USA wil ask to block China. After china give more market to US, than US will leaving the sanction. USA got money and china will be money source for USA. We wait how long China can stand.
@Mixed Nats are you sure?? 2 is Communist party like china, 2 militer gov, 1 dictator, 1 base on tribe, 2 never change gov etc. so what value? Have ever US complain about Vietnam and Laos recenly??
@@Johntor8888 If you think that way, then there is must be something wrong with you. If you think Europe will bow down to the USA to block China? Even if they manage to convince europe to block China, europe will also suffer. And if you think China won't survive just because US and Europe block them, that is your second mistake. They already manage to survive when the world block them, do you think they won't survive now? come on, for real? Look who is backing up china behind, the rusia.
@@glowinz correct, Europe’s economy and demographics are collapsing, and they need China to keep themselves afloat when America does not want to help as much anymore.
As an Asian European who has lived in three continents and studied in SG, I've met the typical racist douchebags but what I can't stand are xenophobic Asians who look down on other Asians and don't have a clue what it is to be one in a Western country. Who do you truly think will be there for you and your children in 10, 50, 100 years? In what situation are they now compared to any Asian country?
In Spain, we are deep into our third Covid wave, the worst since it started and it's because people do not follow rules and are allowed to protest against masks and vaccine. The government is too busy in-fighting and caring about their political gain.
I can't wait to get out of here.
Only a Singaporean Media company CNA, can tell such a difficult story in such a fair, bipartisan, objective way. Thank you CNA for telling both sides of the story.
America did it to itself. They forced the world to trade in Dollars, and therefore the world needs to earn those Dollars by trading goods to America. America pays with an unlimited number of checks that will never be cashed. So their debt grows endlessly. Until the time comes when the checks WILL be cashed.
what are you smoking? China has bought out every country it can. Hong Kong one of the freest Democracies and free market capitalis is going to side with Communist China. Dream on suckers!!! Look at the human rights violations in China. Hong Kong knows whats going on.
@@wolfgangk2824 NOPE..UR JUST A COMMUNIST TROLL
@@1aikane4u You're a fcking joke - Epoch times aka NTD aka FALUNGONG ! We know how loony toony you are !
@@wf645 You're a fkng joke. We know how loony toony you are.
Fa x Lun x Gong is not a cult.
It is only branded as a cult by the Chinese CCP. Nowhere else on earth people call them a cult.
Fa x Lung x DaFa is a belief system similar to QiGong, yoga , Taoism 道教, etc.
We don't care what they believe in . They can believe in the Devil or the earth is flat. They can even be a cult like Scientology. That is their right as protected by international Law , Freedom of belief , Freedom of religion, and Freedom of Speech. (China CCP agreed to uphold this rule under the WTO guidelines).
When you say American “allow” China to join WTO, probably you forget it is called World Trade Organization, not American Trade Organization
@sneksnekitsasnek are you trying to play smart ass?
US set the rules after WWII and is now super annoying to see any members not obeying what they say or challenging its position as an organizer and fundraiser. It simply wants the world to follow everything it says, including Europe.
Um excuse me its the american world and you all have these privilages because its the american world
Kelly Tan and if they know wjats good for them they follow the rules as we saved the world from hitler and the japameese empire, know you history. The atrocities the japaneese and the nazis commited were vast, the usa has done nothing like that
The usa didnt "allow" china to join the wto. The usa shutup every other major country so china could join. The usa courted china to the wto and ignored the objection by every other major country who didnt want china to join including great britain, france, germany, and japan. Those countries didnt want china as part of wto because they hadnt forgotten the despotic rule of mao after a true vicious murderous revolution overthrowing jen kai shek (im sure i spelt that wrong). Nobody else but the us want china in the wto because theyre like russia on steroids.
Absolutely blown away by how unbiased and truthful this was. Omg it was like a shock to the system to actually see media coverage that’s actually fair and balanced!! Fantastic breakdown of what’s going on between China and USA.
I don't see why so many people are calling patriotic education "brainwashing" when Americans, who consider themselves the global leader in democracy, have elementary and secondary schools that host flag-raising ceremonies weekly and ask children to pledge daily. It's technically optional, but as far as my experiences go (trust me, I've been to a lot of schools), teachers never really told us that we had the other option. And even when my friends and I found out about it, people stared at us strangely and in a way shamed us for sitting through pledges... Similar double standards are found in the aftermath of the Hongkong riots. Yes, they say it's for democracy and human rights (I don't really agree, so we'll agree to disagree), but it's undeniable that they were causing chaos and violence. I'm sure those rioters at the White House truly believed that they were somehow "defending their country from political manipulation" or whatever else justifications they had, but they were considered terrorists regardless. I'm not saying the rioters were mal-intended but law enforcement is not based solely on intentions but also on results. So, what you were thinking when you caused such chaos and violence doesn't matter. You have every right to hold your own political view, and the government cannot prosecute you for it, but once you break a law you go to jail. Once you start breaking into government buildings you're a terrorist. It's as simple as that.
A documentary about China and the US that is fairly balanced and nuanced, highlighting both perspectives without denigrating either side, is a rare sight indeed in today's world of neo-Cold War self-righteousness and jingoism. Well done CNA!
Of course it's done by Singaporeans who are Chinese but neutral.
@Joseph Arden it's cause us Singaporeans are too pragmatic and only care about facts
@@salted5245 It's because the US has been corrupted by a form of capitalism so vicious and intolerant of other models that it sees anyone else showing success as an attack upon its fundamental values and its very existence so it will lie, cheat and attack China no matter what because it is losing the race and it doesn't know any other language.
@caleb Wow, you almost convinced me.
@@rosesprog1722 exactly,the truth hurts....
The best documentary I ever seen you won't see this on BBC or CNN
I was amazed "wow this news channel seems really unbiased, could this be a western media news channel?" -> searched up CNA Insider -> "Of course not"
totally agree. btw, im a cna fan.
this is propaganda
@@fffwe3876 omg, it's a Singaporean state-run media. you mean the Singapore advertises for china? this is a totally neutral media that picks neither of the sides.
@@yxeanget-any its a FACT.
America says: Only we can live a good life. You are only allowed to live in poverty.
Well put👏👏👏👍👍🤗🤗
Regardless of the arguments here, the USA has lost, and it is in decline. China did not force US companies to move their production to China, but the companies decided to move to China to take advantage of low costs and high returns/profits.
Apple manufacture and create opportunity for India and Vietnam. Why don't you guys force Apple to build factory and fully manufacture for American citizen to be employed. Not just Apple. Rich American that own a manufacture company outside America that should be blame. Your own decision ruin your country.
@Finn Hansen ..Exactly. Stop propagate the worsening America job market, America is deteriorating, for it creates too many sleazy people.
then for Apple to made the same profit, iphone now cost 3000$
Many non-apple supporter chinese would be happy to see apple move their production back to US or India. Then apple products would become expensive and unreliable. Losing market share along the way.
@@AT-pi5to its a great idea
Dollar is too strong and dominant over global economy. It kinda forced US to be a “buying economy” rather than a “making economy”. We got Wall Street to thank for.
There is nothing wrong educating young Chinese to love their own country and US does same. I don't understand that even now China doesn't make one car for US market but got blame for the factory closing in Detroit
China does make buses for US market. Many public transport operators in the US bought Chinese buses due to cheap costs.
Loving your country is great but it can also be very dangerous love can turn to nationalism and nationalism into fascism where you look to an old map seeing what your Nation once was and forcefully seizing those pieces of Land back Taiwan is a great example where the mainland demand for it to rejoin even tho Taiwan and a over whelming amount of citizens do not want this. this is ignored by Chinese nationalists as the believe Taiwan is a rogue province whilst they ignore the Xinjiang concentration camps and crack down on Hong Kong's civil rights which was not allowed under a signed international agreement with the UK. American nationalism is quite bad as well but the key difference is America does not hide it's history there are also some key difference whilst China forcefully expand America more vias for global power through politics and agreements and barely fails to meet treaty obligations unlike China
(2) Detroit had much more than just a car industry building consumer and house hold product but the main reason for Americans being mad towards China is the collapse of the American dream where if you work hard you would get what is earned to support a family and a stable life when China joined the WTO Americans with this outlook didn't stand a chance as the Chinese would work for far cheaper because anything past dirt poor was enough for a Chinese person in the late 1980s so when the jobs moved the people of Detroit's stable jobs collapsed leaving most destitute
@@markgroves7851 na，we are not planning to get taiwan back any way, It's actually a strategy to prevent
tiwan from getting to close with America, America has It's many military bases in the Asia, but not any of
these bases could compare with the importance of taiwan, if taiwan goes independen completely, the US will
have every excuses to build military bases on it, and i would be sure to say, that many local people will agree
taiwan is just a finger touch away from main land, if the US lunched a missile on taiwan, it will only take
a few hours to reach mainland, and with the force with the US, it will be much threatening than the taiwan
forces now. And plus, the gov what to show their new muscles (just like the US), if a small part of land that
they have been claiming for decade suddenly go independent, it will be a big slap on the face. so both
politically and military won't agree on this. this is my analysis
@@yikunwang7193 thanks for responding but America already has troops installed in South Korea a missile system there will do almost as much damage also recent ramping up of mainland agression has probably done more to convince Taiwanese people to further pull apart from the mainland and towards the US
@People Liberator I never said anything about cars you Muppet merely facts also the claims of the poc were the same but not any more Taiwan can't enforce such claims
This is the correct way of educating the children to be patriotic to their homeland and not to forget how their ancestors be bullied,hurt and killed by foreign invaders.....how they suffered seriously and painfully in life.
It's almost impossible to find unbiased report like this. Thank you cna
The old man was dying and asked his son what to do if the cats and dogs in the house are very dissatisfied with the current life. The son replied that they should improve their housing, give them the best food, and try to meet their needs to improve their lives. The old man said to his son, you don't have to do anything. Give them votes to make them feel like the owner of the house. They will attack each other for their own benefit, they will completely forget their dissatisfaction with you, they will only feel that this is due to the other party’s attack
The assumption is that the owner is forever competent, incorruptible and benevolent to the cats and dogs. In a single party rule, your fate lies in the luck of having a competent government at all the time and if you don't, you can't switch and criticism of the government might even be censored. At least in the democracy, there are options to expose and get rid of terrible leadership, and dissenting voices do not get silenced.
@@khalmasonart In fact, everyone must admit that the media controls information. I swear that no media is fair. Check their bosses and shareholders. You will discover who owns this country. The simplest election method. Grasp the weakness of the competitor and attack him frantically in the media. I believe most people will not vote for such a person. As long as the media has the channels through which you understand information, trust me, you will only see what they want to show you. In this case, most people cannot make correct judgments and can only vote according to the guidance of the media. So do you think that this misleading election is indeed elected by the people?
American media is doing this
@反共 The US President’s Twitter is banned, but you are discussing freedom of speech with me LMAO
@反共 Look at the changes in Zuckerberg's attitude towards Trump. This is how the media is, disgusting. I hate that others share some so-called analysis videos with me. I have my own eyes, and I will analyze whether he is right or wrong. I don’t take the analysis of others as fact. You are talking about freedom of speech, but unfortunately I did not see him. You change the name to, you like CCP, and your account will soon disappear from the world. If you want true justice and freedom of speech, I'm sorry, he doesn't exist. I used to believe in freedom of speech, but I only saw double standards. My friend told me that the CCP is evil, but in my opinion, no matter what freedom of speech is, he must defend his right of speech. As a result, I did an experiment. , I was treated as a robot XD from China
This channel is fair world media, straight to the point and very easy to understand. Thanks cna
As a Chinese, I feel that Chinese people's perspective this documentary shows is precise and objective, which I rarely see in an English channel, to be honest. But what I didn't expect is that this documentary also helps me see things from American people's perspective, making me sympathize with their predicament and for the first time understand why American politicians can easily direct them to hate China by making use of their depression and anger.
if you remember what US did to its ally Japan with the Plaza Accord then it would all make sense. US simply wants to remain the sole superpower. if not, then the almighty petrodollar will fall by the wayside.
Indeed, the US did the exact same thing with Japan when it was catching up in the 80's. The history doesn't repeat itself but it sure rhymes.
@@catonpillow have you been to Japan? It's even more closed off than China, practically, for trade. The reasons are complicated wholesale structures and influence of the large corporate groups. It has aging population and of course had lots of government spending during high growth stage. It also has many inefficiencies that aren't obvious without living there. Prior to signing the Plaza Accord, US had in fact given massive assistance to Japan as a geopolitical counterweight to communism, the USD had strengthened 50% against the yen, and Japan wanted to preserve certain other protectionist arrangements that might have been required as alternative proposals to Plaza accord.
@@happyhappynuts If you're interested in the details of that period, search for an article called: 'HOW JAPAN PICKS AMERICA'S BRAINS Much of its economic success has been built on bought, borrowed, or stolen technology. Now U.S. companies are striking back', FORTUNE Magazine December 21, 1987
@@catonpillow my basic point here is to say the Plaza situation isn't a simple case of USA bullying Japan, and also to say USA had a role in building up Japan.
@@happyhappynuts And my point is that the US bullied Japan long before the Plaza Accord. Just read the article mate :)
Love watching this as an American, esp because this is from a Singaporean production.
Love watching this as an Chinese, a mainland Chinese in Guangzhou China
@@Kingofcathay I support cooperation and friendship between Americans and Mainlanders. We should not let our governments get in the way of humanity. Plus I didn't vote for Trump.
@@laughter95 Relax. Biden will do the same as Trump, when it comes to China, nothing changes. Chinese government have prepared for this. Honestly, Chinese likeTrump more than Biden.
@@laughter95 there a lot of things that we can discuss about, but if we have to take it very seriously, I have to say that Trump actually helps China surpass the US, or at least accelerated it, time will tell. The achievements that Trump’d accomplished for us is so great to the extent that we really suggest the government give a piece of land to Trump for free and without any tax, he can build whatever he wants to build on that land or maybe he can build a monument for himself or 300-floor building. Just to a name but a few, He had showed what the US-democracy really looks like, the beckon of hope isn’t that shiny anymore. The once formidable superpower shows its weakness for the very first time and we start to realize that we have the chance to turn the tide and end the centuries of humiliation.
@@Kingofcathay give me a link supporting the suggestion that China would consider giving land to Trump for free?
Great Work, the two sides of the coin. It has to be something from Singapore to be able to get some unbiased news, definitively subscribing to this.
说得很好thank you
I can ditch Netflix for CNA documentaries on some occasions. This is the second one I watched. Worth the binge. I hope they have playlist.
Edit: Yes they do!
Yes, CNA is probably the most reliable of all the outlets reporting on China-US relations. They aren't pro China or pro US.
@@jeremyliu122 One David before Two Goliaths.
CNA, you forgot to put the scenes of hk"protesters" burning public facilities and burning randomly innocent people in this video.
Very true. They make beautiful documentaries like RT.
Such a breeze of fresh air after watching all the superficial, name-calling, corporate controlled news outlets..
HongKong people really hates the protesters and westerners for supporting and funding the revolution.
Yes so refreshing to see some ccp propaganda. The narrator says "the doctors says the same what ccp officials has been saying". In other words "the doctor is forced to agree with his government"
@@patrikpass2962 You believe you are free while imprisoned by ignorance; a victim of western propaganda, in other words, "in a state of perpetual hypocrisy."
@@defianceforhumanity Alot of edgy teenagers think your way. You dont understand the concept of freedom of you think CCPs system are just as free as western democracies. You seem to forget you use youtube, a western site, to spread your opinion. Maybe its time you stop being spoiled and defend the system you seem to prefer: youtube and western media.
@@patrikpass2962 I received my MD from Loyola in Chicago in 91. Since then I have lived in México, England, France, Italy, Egypt, Indonesian, Thailand and China. I am fluent in 6 languages.
You need not say more about your pride, prejudice and ignorance. Its really sad that there are so many uneducated and uncared for people in the USA.
It's definitely the best documentary on China-US tensions I've ever seen on youtube.
It’s rare you get a documentary that compares countries, empires, wealth, resources, strength etc with a big air of politics and opinionated-views in the mix AND get positive feedback from all!
Bravo CNA! Great job with this one.
No discussion of the military spending? Last I heard the US spends more money on military than 8 or so countries combined. Maybe we could delve into why we waste money on weapons?
US military industry has kidnaped the US people.
without the 11 aircraft carriers the greenbacks would just be another currency. US couldn't have told the world US invade Iraq and Libya to keep the USD hegemony.
So you can stay free to spread stupid conspiracy theories. Without those weapons you will now be under china.
@@veritesanspeur3733 I guess you like being stepped on by US
@@YoungXelDong good talk from a country with colonisation and slavery.
The Americans do the same in their primary schools~ the kids have to sing national anthem, salute to their flag and cite their Constitution every morning, and it is not considered patriotic education? Is it not indoctrination? They even systematically teach racism in school~ look out for Jane Elliot videos on systematic racist indoctrination in US...
Singapore does the same thing (singing national anthem and cite the Pledge) from primary to secondary schools too... What's wrong with that? Why is it that when it is done by China it is indoctrination?
American Student here. We do recite the pledge of allegiance every morning, every classroom has an American flag in it of some type and we stand up, hold our hands over our hearts, and recite the pledge. In elementary and middle school everyone is expected to say it, but by highschool most just stand silently and listen to the announcer say the anthem instead. The words really mean nothing to us and we kind of loathe having to say it. If the government was going for indoctrination, it is the worst attempt I can think of.
Besides, as Megan mentioned, we pledge allegiance to our constitution and country in principle: "the republic", "with liberty and justice for all" (both direct quotes from the pledge). It would be unthinkable to pledge to one political party or one person.
Unofficial English translation:
I pledge to be loyal to the Constitution of the People's Republic of China, safeguard the authority of the Constitution, fulfill the legal responsibilities of my position, be loyal to the Motherland, be loyal to the people, show the utmost respect for my duty, pursue public affairs with integrity, accept the supervision of the people, and strive for a prosperous, strong, democratic, civilized, and harmonious socialist country!
我宣誓：忠于中华人民共和国宪法，维护宪法权威，履行法定职责，忠于祖国、忠于人民，恪尽职守、廉洁奉公，接受人民监督，为建设富强、民主、文明、和谐的社会主义国家努力奋斗！
Which part of the oath/pledge mention "party" and whatsoever? Only relevant "party" members need to pledge allegiance to the relevant "party", ordinary people just need to pledge allegiance to the country! Isn't that common sense? Or have you guys been brainwashed or fed with lies? According to your logic, the whole population of China are communist party members?
@@chilliwatski You've never experienced freedom you could not understand it
@@regulahjoeshmoe2633 you are so right! I have never experienced random gun shootings in malls/schools/community centers/road side, riots, house break-in, robbery, strangers punching/spitting on/attacking another strangers for whatsoever or no reason, drug abuses, chaos, wars, etc~
But if you talk about peaceful harmonious orderly clean neighborhood I have aplenty here! I can go out at 12am for supper and come back home at 3am walking alone on the street with no fear no worry! I can say and talk about anything I want, criticize my government through proper channel with facts and evidence anytime I want! I travel to at least 100+ cities in my line of work, so what kind of freedom are you talking about! Freedom to lie without consequence?
Only criminals need unlimited freedom, ordinary people just want a peaceful and safe environment where they can live their life and reap the result of their hard work!
you make good points.
The wise Chinese guy sumarised it perfectly at the beginning:
USA always Blame someone for her woes, and China was the convenient scapegoat !!!
Great Video BTW 👍👍👍
Subscribed 👍👍👍
Very educational,it brings light to so much..
once, american guitars were top quality.Then came the japanese in the 70s - 80's, the Koreans in the 90's, Now the chinese make guitars at a fraction of american prices, with the same computer programme machines.Using top quality woods from all over the world.They learnt fast.The quality of the guitars keep getting better all the time .The craftmanship is very good. Guitarist from Sweden.
I am sure Vince Gil is selling his Martins and Stratocasters for those superior guitars 😂
Material products improved as has slavery. You do remember the Uighurs?
@People of China live free and destroy the CCP 对对你说的都对 自由最重要 利比亚推翻卡扎菲 伊拉克推翻萨达姆 因此两国从此拥有了大量的自由 人民在自由的海洋中遨游？或死亡 ？哈哈
@@drewesalan2958 起码维族还在人口激增到500万 印第安人才是要记住的人 印第安人哦
Det kanske är viktigare att inte stödja slavarbete än att få en billig gitarr.
I really appreciate a Singaporean media could document a story with views from both sides. I hope SG can play a vital role to bridge the eastern and western world.
You will need an intermediary highly respected by both sides to do that, and that no longer exist since March 2015.
LOLS..the haven for corruptors from Indonesia..trying to act as hero?
The SG government owns Singapore media. The media freedom of SG is slightly better than PRC. Ranked 160/180. It's one of the worst on the globe.
@@petergriffin9902 On the opposite, I think it's one of the best. The open and free media in the west has created social division and tribalism with hatred words between different camps. Messy and chaotic. It's bringing more negativity than positivity to the society.
@@caomilo1031 From a mainland nationalist Chinese like you, the Singapore has to be relatively free.
这个视频太好了！
A balanced documentary. Didnt expect to see one these days
Well done CNA for objectivity and fact based reporting. Really puts the PBS, BBC to shame!
Let me understand one thing:
The Americans blame China for stealing jobs, but was the USA that helped China to get into WTO, and was the industries that wanted to move to China, because of the cheap labor.
What this have to do with China if your industries wanted to gain more cash and your government helped to do??
Asuki.....you are absolutely correct. As an American, I recall the days back in the 60's and 70's when the USA was known for its manufacturing. However, if one recalls, we had very strong unions in many of our large industries. The role of unions was to always protect and advocate for the workers and that they did with continuous proposals for increased wages, cost of living increases, expanded medical insurance coverage for not only the workiers but for members of their families, more vacation and illness allowances with pay, retirement pensions, etc.. And workers who had been in the industries for many years were demanding up to $30-$50 dollars an hour, not to mention overtime pay of time and 1/2.
These were all great benefits for private companies as well as governmental ones. So, when the US-China "cold war" ended in the early 80's and China was willing to offer cheap labor for factories opened in China, the US CEO's and many US manufacturing leaders calculated how much labor and employee costs would be saved by transferring over to china its the manufacturing processes. . Concurrently, US manufacturers eventually looked at China and thought....."what if we could get the Chinese to purchase our products" and that also drove them to support closing out factories here in the US and transferring it to China and take advantage of inexpensive, no benefits required, Chinese labor. Profit, profit, profit......drove them to look to the east !!
Little did they know that with the Chinese mindset, eager beavers to create their own success stories, many worked in the Chinese factories with the low pay......but, they learned the American manufacturing process as well as how to manufacture specific American products. They would then leave the company and with capital possibly provided by the Chinese government, would open up their own factories and produce the same products that the Americans were producing but, sell them at much cheaper prices. This theft of technology laid the basis for the creation of a huge Chinese millionaire population. This became one methodology used by the Chinese that resulted in the story of China's growing economic miracle.
@@ronquan5382 What you mentioned is no different to what America did when Britain was the superpower. Your neocons and oligarchy are the ones to blame for the mess the US is in.
Informative. Well done!
It would be great if this documentary series could have subtitles in top-nonenglish languages so that it could reach wider audiences. This is truly special and valuable work. I wanted to share it with my family but they don't understand english well, so even if I share it, they will still be excluded from accessing it.
CNA deserves praise and respect for courageous enough to produce such a relatively balance documentary.
Always the same game,
Always someone else to blame.
Never one to shy away from fame,
And never one to admit it's shame.
Love this documentary! It shows both side
4:56 was very emotional for me I used to raise flag in elementary. All people should love and protect their country when invaded by foreign power. I think sometimes humanity just need a common goal for all the people in the world. Abolish world hunger, establish equality and sustainability for future generations. Anything else should come second to those goals. Educate youth to resist greed and embrace virtues of respect and mutual tolerance. Everyone should work for keeping the Earth sustainable and available for the future. Donate to charities volunteer for the old and weak who has noone to take care of them. Who knows maybe someday we might even get a visit from the outerworld beings and when that time comes it would benefit us to be united and peaceful. Humor me the idea of extraterrestrials knowing our existence and choosing to wait for us to become united as one before making first contact. Nobody wants to introduce themselves when two people are busy fighting each other. Good video btw.
Working in an organisation whereby we have interaction between both the Chinese and American trading over the years, none i would firmly say wanted to have any trade wars of such, everyone just wanted to make a decent living for their families regardless of colors, nationalities or religions.
They all wanted progression together in harmony.
A great neutral documentary by CNA. Thumbs up.
This is the most objective documentary I have ever watched on the topic of the relationship between US and China, big thumbs up to CNA! Also, Singapore is such a fascinating country in this planet, on my bucket list to visit!
No its not. Its totaly biased for ccp. Everyone forgets how bad a communist system is. Capitalism and democracy is not the same thing.
no,it's not. it try to be objective but still use western thinking method, even dare not to criticize capitalism.
@@patrikpass2962 China is capitalist asf now
@@feather563 ua-cam.com/video/x1IAwzWqiu8/v-deo.html
@@patrikpass2962 that just proves my point. Communism is just a facade
Im really shocked that the US doesnt have proper Workers protection.. I thought every industrial country has this... Greeting from Germoney. Also very well, 2 sided Documentary, such things u see rarely these days. Mostly you see US Propaganda against China. Kudos to the producers of this. More Americans need to see this!
This is a well-put-together documentary.
Singaporean must be proud of ourselves !!
They bend to wind. Wind is changing
@@jameslovesapeacefulworld341 singapore bend to whoever benefit
The US Congress wouldn't like to see such news or documentary...
@my BMW , No
@my BMW lmaoooooo didn't know a little red dot can bring up the whole china ....lmao you are way too proud of yourself...
CNA, you forgot to put the scenes of hk"protesters" burning public facilities and burning randomly innocent people in this video.
They fear there could be copycats.
CNA is anti China. They are more incline to western ways.
If HONGKONG want to be independent and ok u can go back to your colonial country uk
@@gc1653 sure
@@gc1653 The whole world is anti China except for some 3rd world countries
kid reading "the nature of war" at 4:54 got me laughing
American politicians telling people to play by the rules is the most hypocritical thing ever
To blame others for a problem is easier than to solve the problem.
And to destroy other countries is easier than to fix your own country.
It’s rare to watch a balanced documentary from CNA. Normally it will be very anti-China, but this is not the case for once. I hesitated to watch it, but finally I appreciate the effort to show many perspectives.
so not anti china is very balanced presentation? Little pinks are everywhere, even in singapore
One of the best documentary.
Great Journalism! But I want to find the original ending song. I love it. It explicitly expresses the bewilderedness with a nostalgic and desolate tone. "Got trouble in my heart. Got trouble in my mind. Digging through the wreckage, trouble's all I find..."
Misallocation of resources is the main cause of US 's social problems.
Yes that's really is a big problem
The GDP per capital of US is $63809.64 which is higher than most of the developed countries like UK and Japan. So misallocation is really a problem.
$750bn to the US military when US schools have to cut school week from 5 days a week to 4 day because the school district cannot afford to pay to keep the lights on. When spending on science has only barely kept to inflation since the Clinton era. And since 2009, primary research has been curtailed with most funding aimed at applied science. In 20 years (2030).. US scientific might will begin to dry up as all the newest and latest will be done by others.
@@huazheng9910 Yet they have high expenses too ... duh ..
@@nickl5658 Yup. Its no rocket science why China is catching up fast.
China produced the most STEM graduates, almost 5X more than US, 2X more than India.
www.industryweek.com/talent/article/21998889/the-countries-with-the-most-stem-graduates
hrmasia.com/china-will-overtake-the-us-in-stem-talent-by-2030/
Not forgetting that the central committee were made up of engineers or scientist that contributed to planning. And the leaders rose through the ranks regardless if they are princelings or not. Unlike some US politicians that virtually do not have any experience in running governments ...
gineersnow.com/leadership/chinese-government-dominated-scientists-engineers
Not forgetting, that China had a Made in China 2025 vision akin to Industry 4.0 since 2015 to be reckon with. With the continuity of the CPC as versus to the flip flopping policies of US or other democratic nations. This constant has allowed continuity of policy to allow China to advance.
nhglobalpartners.com/made-in-china-2025/
Don't blame on China. US itself did something wrong for the wars in Iraq and Arkansans.
I think you meant afghanistan
What is the name of the last song? SO hard to find it by lyrics!
This is very interesting thank you 🙏🏾 😊
China is making every country look in the mirror, and by its own example, China is influencing the whole world in a positive way.
@Gaylord Manlove Not as you say Sir. A disease called the USA has killed over 20 million people in foreign countries since 1945. Something most Americans haven't got a clue about, but continue to finance this human travesty.
You are right. I'd like to have forced labor camps on my country too. Oh, and genodice and organ-harvesting as well, if possible.
@@kenrose9065 I don't want social media censorship and bat eating culture here in Korea. China can gtfo 🖕🖕
@@kenrose9065 care to remind everyone how THE GREAT LEAP FORWARD went? Its clear you chinese know how to choose your leaders.
@@kenrose9065 what do you have to say to the Gambians who burnt down chinese factories that have been used to exploit them and their fish? Gambians have been going hungry because the Chinese government has been killing off the fish and overfishing and turning it into food for China's pigs. How do you feel about that?
That apple store in Beijing was the school where I attended Olympic mathematics classes when I was 10years old in elementary school, every Saturday morning my father brought me there with 30mins bike riding. How China developed, everyone works harder from born
Wonder if that math Olympiad school is still open elsewhere...knowing china and math contests it probably is
Watching it in hindsight today. Many events has changed from good to bad or vice versa. CN & US are having many similarities & differences. I believe that the best way is mutual respect, understanding, trust to co-operation between CN & US. Peace is good for all of us. Both US & CN need smart diplomatic solution. Let's watch it again in N years time.
Opening your economy and globalization is definitely beneficial. America since shifting businesses and manufacturing into China has made more money than before, not less. The problem however is that moving businesses overseas means loss of jobs locally, and the big companies making money overseas refuse to invest the money into local market and society, heck, they even tried to dodge taxes. Apple alone dodge over 100 billion dollars in taxes, and the next 500 American companies operating overseas collectively dodged over 500 billion dollars in taxes. This is the problem with capitalism, the money goes to the top 1-10%. The socialist mechanism of taxes, social welfare, common infrastructures etc has broken down in America.
“We built our economy based on your financial system...The world is in crisis because of your mismanagement... We are no longer your student.” I didn't know Wang said that.
Wang never said that’s, for sure.
There are a lot of wrong things being said from both sides to make themselves look better, and the other part worse. I am only familiar with Chinese history and politics.
@@taiwanisacountry Taiwan is province, as the ROC's constitution says
@@Watchen98your way of thinking is flawed.
What year did Taiwan become a province? 1949 did Tibet.
that is a little paradox here. :-) if they were a province of the PRC, then they their constitution is null and void.
Else anybody person who have attained the year of 23 may be elected.
Any person who has attained the year of 40 may be president. Any person who has attained the year of 20 may vote for the election.
But anyway they are no a province of anybody or anything. :-) even if we go with the UN resolution on Taiwan. That does not give it to the PRC. :-D
Are you telling me that the PRC has fair and open election for anybody?
But please. Tell me, in what article do you find that nonsense? :-) it is almost like you are just repeating people who have no idea what they are talking about.
Let me guess the person you Copied does not even read or speak Chinese?
@@taiwanisacountry you never become a country.. Even US know that .. LOL
Anti-communist? Did the US beat little North Korea or little North Vietnam? No and No.
Two northern halves of two little countries kicked US ass! US have held a grudge for 60 years.
US blame Big China, hoping other countries will stop teasing and laughing. We won't.
Abandon ideological prejudice and jointly follow a path of peaceful co-existence, mutual benefit and win-win co-operation. Xi Jinping.
@Dio Y with the help of euro union
@Joseph Arden Losers always make up excuses.
The Chinese got their ass kicked by the Vietnamese in 1979 and got their ass kicked by South Korea in the Korean War lmao. Not to mention China can’t even handle India.
Politics aside I really liked the American song at 25:02. Does anybody know what it’s called?
When the titans clash......I learn that patriotism can bring us greatness and unity...
Blame Trump and top 1%. The rich got richer. The middle class and the poor got poorer.
@Al Castill Trump have products made in other countries. That's how the rich get richer and the poor get poorer in the US. Per capita, the US economy grew much faster than any other countries. Where did all the money go? Went to Trump and the top 1%.
永不会忘记当年1989年， 我目睹坐在武汉大桥，湖北省政府门前的学生一人一台短波收音机， 聆听来自美国之音的“圣谕”！ TMD！傻呀！这应该是美国颜色革命最早的一次实践，太成功了！差点害了一代的中国青年！
还好，没成功
Chúng mày sủa cái lồn gì vậy?
领头的那几个现在在美国生活呢草
VIRUS
颜色革命差点害死中国，随时警惕
I pray that this tension will finally stop because people and economies are suffering 🙏😭❤️
This episode has pirate's logic: The step down of US industry is the fault of China? Please! The core of capitalism is to gain profit using whatever. The bigger benefit allure factry owners to move manufactory to a cheaper labor area.
If you are really asking, the answer is that the US sold its manufacturing economy to China in exchange for China recognizing US IPO's. China instead stole them and now directly challenge US tech economy. While China understandably doesn't want to be behind the USA forever, they just proved that only the most strict deal will survive.
Even China is beginning to have this illusion. They advocate moving low-end manufacturing out of China and upgrading the industries remaining in China. But they forget that a country with a population of 1.3 billion can not be all high-end industries. Due to the problem of probability, there will always be people who can only engage in low-end industries with knowledge and technology, and low-end industries often have the largest employment
@@meganh9460 Do you think businessmen are fools? The most successful American brands in China: KFC, McDonald's, Starbucks and apple. So what technology do you think China can steal from these companies?
It is precisely the cheap products provided by China. It eased the inflation of the dollar. In addition to printing dollars, has the United States really produced any products? In ancient China, merchants had the lowest status because they did not provide any products at all. They just left hand in and right hand out, and sometimes hoard products. Wait until the price is high
I had no idea who CNA was. I was hesitant to click on this for a second. I am so surprised by the level balance, unbiased illustration. This is a rare sight on UA-cam, not even remotely joking.
I am sure over 99% of Americans have no idea what this clip is talking about. They cant even point out where China is on a global map while they blame China for all hardship they encounter.
lol so true, and most of their knowledge about China come from Trump's tweet and Fox news, it's so funny that they believe Chinese people are the ones being brainwashed
When I thought 2020 was bad 2021 was laughing maniacally in the back...
Who know what this new year will bring. Given what we've all gone through, make our peace and live out our dreams !
新加坡媒介的视角真的不错。CNA,Great Work!
Very unbiased news from CNA, puts CNN, FOX, BBC, DW to complete shame
dw not so biased.
Really? Are you blind?
@@kevinw4267 nope，am your father
@@MichaelLee-mj3ye friendly fire, that was for Tobi L, who obviously part of 50 cents army. As you can see, they are overselling it, everyone can accept CNN and FOX is bias, when you add BBC and DW to that list, there is something fishy going on. I watched the whole thing, the entire report is bias for China, didn’t mention Dr. Li Wenliang at all
add al jazeera too
I grow up in the 80's, the US had already been through the de-industrialization back then when the Western Europe and Japan rose first followed by the Asian Tigers and then China. It has been for 30 more years from now. The American should look into the problems within their own system to find a way out.
At the 42-minute mark, the CNA documentary claims that China having a low death-rate from COVID-19 is an "insult". Think about that.
Mini-BBC sometimes can have high quality documentary. This is a very fair report. Great Job!
“Whenever you have more involvement by the United States, you have instability, anywhere in the world. Look at the Middle East, look at some other places like Latin America. It’s so obvious that when you are ‘rebalancing’, or ‘pivoting’, whatever the word might be, then there’s more instability in the region,” says Ambassador Cui Tiankai in his interview with Fareed Zakaria.
What Cui says may be paradoxical and ironic, perhaps. But an undeniable truth, it is!
He is so correct, the middle east was perfectly fine before the 90's.
This is so incredibly ignorant
I've seen all 4 of this documentary series. and yes, it's one of the best documentary series I've seen this year. not only tells about the threat of a new cold war, and the trade war between the US and PRC but becomes a kind of projection of economic, trade, industries, and technological affairs. truly becomes a very valuable reference about the future for a country, community, and individual human beings.
I just can't understand people who refused to wear mask, for those people I hope you don't come to hospital in case you are infected.
That bar owner towards the end was off his rocker. "My bar is closing because the shutdown wasn't harsh enough". Really? People are mental
problem is where US federal and state are so broken that helping is very much a state issue. Their state has alot of autonomy yet their politicians are never bothered to fix or help their people. US companies are not even helping their own population.
You are responsible for your own well being. Neither federal government nor the local govt is responsible, much less the private sector.
The govt exist to protect us from external threat and maintain internal order thru law enforcement, *NOT* to ensure that you are living a comfortable life.
If you can't compete against cheaper and more effective Chinese labors, then you have nobody to blame but yourself.
@@ihl0700677525
You really know how to over simply a complicated issue.
But I agree with your 2nd paragraph, US is losing its edge to compete, it should blame itself, not China.
When US move jobs overseas, US government should hold corporations accountable for their tax evasion that does not flow back to US job market and investment in creating more innovation jobs for vast job training to tradition new jobs for new industries. But most US politicians work for big corporations and industries, their job now is to protect the big corporations interest, not majority of average Americans.
@@lavendereucalyptus3225 "Tax evasion" is *NOT* necessarily illegal, and corporations and individuals that caught in illegal financial deal related to tax evasion are indeed convicted and fined. So it has been *done.*
America lost its edge on basic and "low end" manufacturing, but retain its edge on specialized manufacturing. Combined with American absolute dominance in global banking & finance, food & beverages industry (e.g. Starbucks, McDonald's, etc), pop culture (movie and music), etc, I see no reason to be so worried about the future.
American GDP per capita ($64,000) is, after all, comparable to Swiss ($68,000), and significantly higher than many other industrialized countries like Germany ($54,000), France ($50,000), Britain ($49,000), and Japan ($40,000).
@@ihl0700677525 if Gov is not responsible,that you get in hardship better life,then you have no right to await from them protection,agains't outside threat's.
Simply as that.
from my perspective you are P......e
@@workingproleinc.676 Lol. Politicians and bureaucrats are no better than corporate CEOs. After all, politician's job desc is to lie and get elected.
They will waste your tax money on some useless vanity projects (e.g. golden statues, inflated govt office building, etc), lining their own pocket, or worse: starting a foreign wars.
You're a either a *naive fool* or a *moron* if you think those conniving politicians actually care about your well being.
This is one of the few videos that can objectively describe the relation between China and US. Good job.
I am afraid it is not entirely true. The reality is that China has been helped by the West, out of the good will, and it turned against the West. They now tried to dominate and control the rest of the world.
@@Shenl999 Out of good will? Or they want to make money through China?
@@haotong6095 Let's not pretend either party is doing any of this out of "good will".
@@Shenl999 Look I admit that western countries have helped china and its USA, but look, they never thought that China will be getting that strong after they helped china so they are started to get jealous about the whole thing and they are angry and ashamed that they have helped china and that's why they have started the hong kong protest and wanted to disturb china to getting more stronger that's what he wants. (when the USA said that he is the country who will send the peace to the other countries actually he is the most violent countries and cruelty county I have ever met there have gun attacks every day in the whole country there will be racism and stuff even now they are attacking asain Americans look America is just a country who loves to play tricks so don't fall into his hole.)
@@Shenl999 出于善意？你是有多单纯？政治小白
Why don't close American embassy in Hong kong?
Absolutely agreed. I want to claim back my peaceful HK before 2019. Without the violence happen in 2019 HK is the best place in the world
Why woudl they close their embassy? I dont see any reasons
Excellent piece!
热泪盈眶
非常有趣，你好吗？
As the mayor of Dayton, Ohio, said: "The broken dream is that the children aren't doing better than their parents.". Very well said. The success of a government/nation is to make sure that does not happen. But it is happening in US, in Hong Kong. When that happens, unrest is growing in the grassroots.
well then it must really suck because the average chinese wage is less than half of the average american wage. gtfo with your gaslighting and propaganda
@@keithdonaldson4623 red guard is a product from chinese only the so call democracy people in hong kong and communist under mao both produce red guard
@@wengwang5361 that literally made 0 sense
@@keithdonaldson4623 wage maybe lower but you can buy a lot more for $1 in China than in America. If you don’t understand the simple concept of PPP than STFU.
I agree with you on the cause of unrest and anger i.e. dissatisfaction with their life. People should make no mistake, democracy is not the solution. Socialism and more government interventions are needed in order to correct market/system imperfections. Invisible hand failed badly.
Very good job CNA
Very good ducumentary 👍👍👍👍
The US foreign policy is based on supremacy, while China is based on security. That's the main difference between the two superpowers.
@@limjiahe531 How old are you 10? very childish to result to name-calling.
The root is simply one sentence.. the United States can not afford to lose their hegemony. The loss of that would lead to the fall of an empire like the UK after the world war...
Agreed. As an overseas chinese, i would like to see the rise of China becomes a reality in the near future.
@@honedreade4979 Trump is also banned by tweeter UA-cam etc. it is not to ban but who own these platform.once China own a these platform and can manage them like what us company manage and then there is no problem
@@honedreade4979 they even go out of their way to use vpn just to access google hahaha 😆
@@honedreade4979 🙈good news for u ...after 2 decades gordon chang going to publish book "the coming collapse of china 2021" en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Coming_Collapse_of_China
Once upon a time United States is the Powerful and Wealthy country in the world, but today (2050) United States is one of the poorest country in the world.
-CNA Insider
It's pretty much impossible for US to become extremely poor, at worst they would be the world's 4th largest economy.
In some way, China feels humiliated by the 100 years of Western and Japanese imperialism. But there is more than just only about imperialist past - for many decades, China exerted control over its sovereign neighbours via tributary or colonisation. When these empires come, China lost control and now, it wants to restore the imperial domain. The United States have, ironically, accelerated the process of China's imperialist restoration dream because of wrongly believing on words by Deng Xiaoping.
中国的朝贡体系本质上是贸易，和美国对中南美洲那种赤裸裸的掠夺完全不同！
It is worthy of being a news station in Singapore🇸🇬. It is more professional in reporting on Asia than the Western media. It is neutral and does not engage in ideology. Come on 👍
make sure EVERY young people in HK and TW watch this and learn actual history.
It's not about history, it's about how they feel about who they are. Even the clip shows how patriotism is installed in Chinese people's minds through history education and they all feel united under the name of China but TW and HKers don't share the same mentality as the mainlanders.
@@KJ-bd2ku the way you phrase it says it all kid. And no they should not feel special about who they are comparing to others in our country. No matter where you live, "freedom" gained at cost of your motherland, especially under foreign aid, is treason, not "democracy".
@@KJ-bd2ku And you are contradicting yourself. How they feel about themselves is exactly the result of "free", "unbiased" western media and yes, deliberately deleting Chinese history from their education.
@@fangwen9256 you are wrong about empathising so much on history education and think that's what you shape in terms of who you are and where you belong. They basically grew up in different environments. I don't know what kind of education they received but one thing I know for sure is they feel offended being called Chinese. Even the HKers who only speak Chinese says so too. To me, if they are happy to be a part of China and be called Chinese I'm happy to call them so but they are not. I don't think it's necessarily the western media to be blamed, China also failed to manage to let (for example) HK blend into the new system in an effective manner, only resulted in having hostilities towards China by young people. If you think history rules everything and that's what determines who you are, you have nothing to say about Tibet, Uyghur, Inner Mongolia etc. Call themselves all differently.
@@KJ-bd2ku you are missing the bigger picture my friend. Try to think about the consequences of promoting extrem individualism, the answer is selfishness. Of course you would have known some Chinese from HK and TW that did not think they belong because that's where you get most of the knowledge and ideas on this matter, try think about the opinion of the other 1.3 billion people. I agree that China failed to tackle this issue effectively because it should be done much earlier. For some reason, they believed that simply by giving them whatever they want, helping them benefit from China's growth, they will naturally blend in. At least they won't side with others at times of crisis? But no, people are selfish by nature and somehow that can be promoted and celebrated. P.S. If you visit Tibet, Xinjiang, and Inner Mongolia yourself, you will actually know whether they call themselves Chinese.
Very balanced presentation well researched
This is such a high quality documentary with balanced coverage of both side and neutral narrative. Thank you so much!
the man at 44min is a genius. he hit the nail on the head and more american citizens need to think like him
Thats one man's opinion Jessica, both sides are to blame. First it's the fault of the Chinese Communist Party fault for taking their sweet ass time in announcing this virus and secondly, unlike China, where one party has been ruling the country for decades, here in the U.S.- we have a different system, granted its not perfect, but a hell of alot better than china's.
For any business to be successful internationally it have to compete not just against China but the rest of the world in a free market. The rules are all written and created by Western countries, the world will continue to rotate and modernise. You just have to live and move along with the world, modernise change with the flow.
WHo will fight???????
The West only writes the rules. They follow none of them, their rules only apply to others
There is no free market in a planned economy.
The market of free ideas died when the 8000 started drumming.
17:55 "The damage was quite significant. Some words were sprayed". You know this is a peaceful place if people are complaining about some words being sprayed.
A video that's well said and documented