How To Choose Between GE GTW335ASNWW and Amana NTW4516FW: A Technician’s Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
- In this video, we closely examine two popular washing machines: the GE model GTW335ASNWW and the Amana NTW4516FW. As a service technician, I have experience working on both models and know their common component failures. I compare these failures and share my recommendations on which washing machine is more reliable and efficient. I also discuss the features and performance of each machine, so you can make an informed decision when purchasing a new washing machine. Whether you're in the market for a new appliance or just curious about the differences between these two models, this video is a must-watch for anyone considering an Amana or GE washing machine.
Links to the videos I mention in the video:
1: Diagnose Washer in 60 Seconds • Diagnose Washer In 60 ...
2: How to Diagnose a Hotpoint or GE Washing Machine • How to Diagnose and Re...
3: You Should Check the Suspension Rods | Here's Why and How to Fix it
• How To Replace Suspens...
4: The Best Washing Machine You Can Buy In 2023 • How To Choose the Best...
▶️ SUBSCRIBE for more washer and dryer repair videos:
www.youtube.co....
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Buy me a coffee:
www.paypal.com...
Send me something:
Harper & Knowles
2945 Highway 1153
Oakdale, LA 71463
My Gear
My Vlog Camera: amzn.to/43vbRv3
My Backup Camera:amzn.to/3UGIz8H
My Studio Camera: amzn.to/417DV5Y
My Wireless Camera Controller: amzn.to/3L4MhWg
My Preferred Memory Card For Cameras: amzn.to/41xIHtc
My Portable Charger: amzn.to/41dtTAc
My Studio Microphone: amzn.to/41fcrLO
My Lavalier Microphone: amzn.to/3UC8Tkn
My Studio Teleprompter: amzn.to/3KJikts
My iPhone Gimbal: amzn.to/3GMLd76
My iPhone Chest Mount: amzn.to/3zZUZ1I
My Main Studio Light: amzn.to/3mvBV8N
My Secondary Studio Light: amzn.to/3GM2v45
My External Hard Drive: amzn.to/3GMLDKI
My Publications
My pen name is Cal Kasheau. Hey, I'd like to shamelessly promote my literary accomplishments while I have your attention. I have several short story titles you can get on Amazon; the links are below. Some are humorous, some reflect events in my life, and some are legends I heard of as a child in the swamps of Louisiana. They are only a dollar or two, and most are free with Kindle unlimited membership. I hope you will take the time to read one or two and give me your honest opinion in the comments on whether or not I should continue to pursue a side gig as an author.
The Legend of the Loup Garou: A Louisiana Horror Story
amzn.to/3EJE4o2
The Legend of the Parlangua: A Louisiana Swamp Tale
amzn.to/3VtF3ys
The Fuzz vs, The Buzz: A Backwoods Beekeeper Meets a Traffic Cop
amzn.to/3EEvwP7
The Story of Buster the Cat: How I survived the Ride From Hell
amzn.to/3T5BM6L
Tell a Story ,Teach a Lesson
amzn.to/3CUd2I3
The Dreaded BMI Index: How it Was that I Went on a Diet
amzn.to/3T5W53Y
My Misadventures as a Moonshiner
amzn.to/3CAmBLT
The Magic Blanket
amzn.to/3yGE8AS
All the Girls I've Loved: A series of stories about a young man's life and the women he loved
amzn.to/3esvIXb
Thanks for watching! - Навчання та стиль
The issues you highlighted with both machines were spot on the center of the nail. For a while I ran into more GE machines with malfunctioning lid locks then any other brand, until machines with the three wire Whirlpool locks begin to come into my shop. This video is a confirmation of things I've observed over the past two-and-a-half years since starting my service. Thank you sir have a good one!!
I'm glad to know other technicians see the same issues. Thanks for the feedback and I appreciate your taking time to watch and comment!
How big are the GE motors compared to the Amana ones?
I bought an old Inglis made by Whirlpool machine years ago. That thing was solid. It never let me down.
It's great to hear about your positive experience with the Inglis! Older appliances were often built to last and had a solid performance that many people appreciated. Thanks for sharing your story, and I'm glad you found a reliable machine that served you well. Keep watching my channel for more tips and comparisons!
@@HarperandKnowles I had a GE washer with plastic tubs from 2001-2017 which replaced my filter-flo.
I miss our old Maytag washer that allows you more control of the wash cycles.
They were great machines back in the day!
Maytag. Junk
With the Whirlpool made units you can no longer choose the water level. It's either sensing or deep fill. My 2012 era Roper has a selector. The lower end GEs with an agitator have low, medium, high settings.
You can blame government regulations for that. Thanks for watching!
I don't know anyone with a Speed Queen washer but most of the families I know have front load LG units. They seem to be a step up in quality and wash performance over the low end top loaders (say $650 vs $500)
Most service calls I get on LG units are water pump related. Otherwise they seem to be well built. Thanks for watching.
@davestvwatching2408 the amana 4516 has a true, dual action agitator and is significantly better at cleaning clothes than those front load LG's. It will also FILL with water. Most top loaders these days just have an impeller with a pole on it and the pole does absolutely nothing to agitate. In that case, the LG front load is better.
The agitator basic Whirlpool units (I have a Roper) are really nothing special washing wise plus they stretch clothes needlessly and use too much water.
@@davestvwatching2408 no issues like that with my Amana. And my water supply is not metered, it is a flat rate charge. So the more water my washer uses, the better. These new "efficient" machines that use little water are trash. You need water to clean! You need water to rinse! It's like the difference between cleaning and rinsing yourself with a wet sponge, compared to cleaning and rinsing yourself in the shower. Big difference!
My trusty 2009 Kenmore 800 just died & we ordered this GE model yesterday. Keeping my fingers crossed.
I hope your new purchase will last a long time but it will never be as good as the old 800. Thanks for watching!
I had that machine! I really didn't like it. It only had " eco warm" which didn't work for me. Someone gave me a Frigidaire front loader ( small) and it was reliable considering it was used. I think it was a preference, I could imagine someone liking that machine but it wasn't for me
Thanks for watching!
Good luck : mine didn’t last 18 months. Absolute garbage
Is a yearly inspection from a qualified mechanic a must?
I will probably go with a Speed Queen next time. I think they make about 3 different models and I am not sure which one is the most dependable. These Whirlpool and GE's are now 2-3 year models
You'll never regret it! They are solid machines.
Plan to spend 4 times the cost of this one. Mine ( speed queen) broke at 6 years, transmission. It was a great machine for about 2 years and various parts broke after that, finally inoperable.
@@Kevin-nm8ihwhich model of speed queen?
Get the Speed Queen Classic.
i use whirlpool drain pumps in the ge washers just cut the cord on the ge and fashion it to the whirlpool pump.
That is a clever hack considering the difference in cost between the two. Thanks for that tip, I’m sure others will see this and benefit from it! And thanks for watching too.
You get what you pay for. Samsung gives you about six months. I had a GE and it lasted about three years. I bought a Speed Queen TR-5. Had to get on a waiting list to buy one. Love it. Will NEVER go back to these crap brands again.
Thanks for leaving a comment on my video comparing the GE and Amana washing machine models. I appreciate your insights and experiences with different brands.
I agree with you that "you get what you pay for" when it comes to buying a washing machine. It's important to invest in a high-quality brand that will last you for many years to come. You mentioned that you had a GE washer that lasted about three years, but then you switched to a Speed Queen TR-5 and love it.
I'm so glad to hear that you're happy with your Speed Queen washer! In fact, I did a review video of the Speed Queen TC5 and TR7 models In January ua-cam.com/video/qlkdxWfTZVw/v-deo.html, so you might want to check that out as well. These washers are known for their durability and performance, and I think they're a great investment for anyone looking for a high-quality washing machine.
Thanks again for your comment and for sharing your experiences with different brands. I hope my videos have been helpful to you in making informed decisions about your laundry appliances.
I agree with the claim that those other brands are crap brands. Wholeheartedly. They all need to be sued the crap out of. Total and utter crooks the lot of them.
GE is so stupid!
My Crosley washer has a very loud spin cycle and makes this rumbling sound when I spin it manually
That is the symptom of bearings going out. You will have to change the gear case to fix the machine. A very costly repair that most people choose to replace the unit instead of throwing money at it. Thanks for watching!
@@HarperandKnowlesIt seems like bearing failures on the newer GE washers are quite rare, I’ve seen it online but a bearing failure on a GE is rare, bearing failure on an Amana is much more common.
@@HarperandKnowles On a GE the bearings probably last longer than the machine, maybe it’s because the transmission is lubricated with grease, which is why a bearing issue on the newer GE top load washers is rare, I know bad bearings are much more common on the older GE washers tho, like the HydroWave types.
I've had a GE GTW335ASNWW dryer for a couple of years and the last couple of months my clothes have been ripped, torn, and full of black marks from the dryer. Is it worth to fix the machine or buy another GE dryer? Your video is great by the way, thanks in advance!
On that dryer only the front side of the drum can contact your clothes and cause this. Usually the metal lip that runs on the drum glides has worn through and separated from the drum part of the way around. You might be able to feel this with your fingers but beware, this will be very sharp. When the tub has worn this badly a machine like this will end up in my bone yard. It’s cheaper to replace it. It could be that something is just caught between the drum and the bearing (large plastic piece that holds the glides on the front) and is catching your clothes. I’m glad you liked my video. Thanks for watching!
@@HarperandKnowles Thank you for your response ! Would it be wise to buy a 3 or 5 year warranty on my next dryer?
I’m not big on buying extended warranties. I’m not exactly sure of what they cover but most of my customers who have purchased them regretted doing so. That’s why they call me. I found this on the web “Washers and dryers: Consumer Reports found that 20% of washing machines and 16% of dryers broke or stopped working over a 10-year span. That rate is lower than other major appliances, meaning you should feel safe skipping the extended warranty here. That said, it’s up to every homeowner to decide what appliances they want coverage on.” Speaking strictly for myself, I wouldn’t do it.
I don’t like lid locks. Why did they even come up with such a frustrating thing? I’ve had to stop the cycle, then run it again, then again…just to get the lid to open, so I can start again.
Some models of Speed Queen don't have lid locks. Thanks for watching.
Hi have hotpoint set about two years old how to use precise fill thank you
To use this option properly, follow the loading instructions listed in the Owner's Manual for your washer and keep the lid closed during the wash cycle. Precise Fill senses the load during the water filling portion of the cycle to determine how much water is needed. I hope this helps. Thanks for watching!
What machine would you advice to buy for a small family that would last but is NOT a speedqueen?
I’d go with the GE.
I purchased that exact GE unit (and its matching dryer) for my elderly dad who lives alone and maybe does 2 loads of laundry per week (that I did for him since he can no longer manage stairs). The washer stopped working within 11 months - thankfully within the “one year warranty”. A GE technician was dispatched to diagnose the issue - which according to him was “the cellar is too damp”. Seriously??? It’s a washing machine, ie HOLDS WATER IN IT. So okay, I bought a dehumidifier and what do you know, the washing machine now worked. But not for long. Flash forward to 6 months later and now the spin cycle fails to spin bulky items such as towels adequately. The dryer stopped heating up at the 18 month mark, rendering it absolutely useless and absolute garbage. I can say with all honesty that GE SUCKS and I’ll never spend one cent on a GE item again. The units were barely used and are now garbage. Pathetic.
Thanks for watching!
How to get this GE JUNK thing to fill up? Does this thing have a sensory?
They are designed to save water. As California goes, so goes the manufacturing! Thanks for watching!
I'm having trouble with having to press down on my lid so that he hesitates can you explain to me what is wrong
t sounds like you might be experiencing an issue with your washer's lid switch or latch mechanism. The lid switch or latch is a safety feature that prevents the washing machine from operating when the lid is open. If it's not functioning correctly, the washer might not start or pause during the cycle, as it's not detecting that the lid is closed.
To help diagnose the issue, first, check for any visible damage or debris around the lid switch or latch area. If you don't see any physical damage, the lid switch or latch itself might be faulty and need replacement.
Before doing any repairs, please ensure that you unplug the washing machine from the power source. You failed to tell me which machine you have but you can check these videos to learn how to diagnose your problem. ua-cam.com/video/M6EQUP4iTHM/v-deo.html or ua-cam.com/video/jsBtbH8EhYg/v-deo.html. If you're not comfortable performing the repair yourself, consider contacting a professional appliance technician for assistance.
I hope this information helps you resolve the issue with your washer. If you have any more questions, feel free to ask. Thanks for watching my channel!
@@HarperandKnowles thank you it a Amana 15 years old this is the first time we're had a problem it.
What oil does GE use in their transmission? What are their belts like?
They use grease and their belts are very similar to the Amana belt. I think there are five V grooves and constructed of rubberized cords, perhaps of Kevlar.
@@HarperandKnowles What about the gtw525 series? Is it a steel driven transmission or plastic?
I really don’t know. There are a lot of plastic parts on modern machines though.
@@HarperandKnowles The GE commercial washer model is gtw525acpwb which claims to have a 1/2 horsepower motor and steel drive transmission. How big are the transmissions between the Amana and GE?
How much grease does GE use in their transmission compared to Amana?@@HarperandKnowles
Bought a whirlpool wtw4955hw2 gave hell jump all over not fill up 2 years later wont even work all sudden. Now bought this ge model. Just now figuring out. I need bit one where not loud and cheap. But to late next time I go in debt for a 900$ will that fix problem
Go in debt a little deeper and get a Speed Queen. You won't need another washer for 25 years. Thanks for watching!
Any washers under 600 that actually fill to top ?
You’d have to buy an old school rebuild model to meet that requirement. Thanks for watching!
Why not bypass the lidlock on the Amana?
The lid lock on the Amana is combined with a lid switch. It tells the machine whether the lid is opened or closed. I can’t tell you how many machines I have had to replace control boards on after the customer attempted to bypass the lid lock. You will fry the control board almost 100% of the time attempting this. Thanks for watching.
@@HarperandKnowles What if I just unscrew the lid lock and place it in the hole and start it? It worked. Will it damage the machine?
No, it won’t damage the machine. Thanks for watching!
My washing machine is very loud in the spin cycle
I do have videos of it on my channel
Probably the bearings are failing. Thanks for watching!
GE or Hotpoint?
Hot Point is like a low end product of GE. GE parts in a Hot Point. Thanks for watching!
Are the Hotpoint washers that much different than GE? At one point in time GE and Hotpoint were basically the same washer in the USA.
They still are. I think some of the components on the Hotpoint are of less quality like the lid locks and knobs. But for the most part they have GE parts. I worked on a Crosley dryer the other day that was a GE in disguise. It looks like GE and Whirlpool are building machines for this brand now. Thanks for watching!
@@HarperandKnowles Crosley is an old name we used to have a dealer that sold Crosley appliances and RCA televisions. Later on they Sylvania TVs. They used to have an ad on the radio that Crosley had the first patent for refrigerator shelves in the door. I live in a small town. When I bought my first washer we had four places that sold appliances. Now we're down to 2. In 1992 I bought my first washer. I ordered a $419 GE washer in the Sears catalog store. I put it on my Sears card at 0% financing for 12 months. I thought I won the lottery because they substituted it for a $600 1993 model. It's been a good washer. Although I was told to scrap it in 1998. I had a rebuilt transmission put in it in 1998 because it was leaking oil. In 2002, it had a malfunction and I replaced the clamp where the freshwater goes into the drum. It was getting pin holes in the outer drum. I removed all the rust and plugged the holes with JB weld. I replaced the enamel coating with JB Weld in certain areas. The outer drum is still holding up. However, my transmission is leaking oil again, and my timer is getting too hard to turn. I recently put a new knop on the timer and it still has events where it doesn't want to turn. I have learned to just use the next cycle on the timer because it beats going to the laundromat. It will jam up on the very top. If I let the timer move into the next position it frees up. The last appliance store left in town sells Frigidaire/Electrolux. Oddly they sell Hotpoint washers and dryers. Our Ace Hardware started selling Whirlpool appliances although they have a lot of young people working there. That's another story...
They're still the same.
No links?
This is a common problem with UA-cam videos. A lot of creators complain about this. I think it depends on what you use to view a video. I can't see those links on my iPhone 13, but when I view them on my MacBook Pro, they are perfect. the problem seems to fix itself the longer the video is listed. I will start putting those links in the comments from now on. I updated that today after reading your comment. Thanks for letting me know. If anyone else watches this video and reads this comment, I would appreciate you letting me know if you can see the links and what you are viewing them on. Thanks.
Thanks!
How long can we expect a budget machine like these two to last for say 1-2 loads per week?
I would say 5 to 7 years before a repair. Perhaps more. Thanks for watching.
@@HarperandKnowles Would you say that the lifespan would be longer if we paid more - but not for a speed queen, but say a big box store LG or a Maytag that was $1,200 as opposed to $600 GE or Amana? If so, what would you guess is the lifespan of a LG or Maytag that costs twice as much as these budget washers? Thank you!
My best guess would be 10 years for a direct drive machine.
I expected that exact GE machine to last quite a few years when I purchased it in 2022 for my elderly dad (and a matching GE dryer). He did maybe 2 loads per week - and months of no loads when he was in the hospital or a nursing home rehab. The washing machine broke at 11 months, was repaired, and at the 18 month mark no longer spins out. The dryer no longer heats up as of the 18 month mark - out of the lousy one year warranty of course. $1300 down the drain for a man living on a fixed income of social security. Disgusting
I bought this GE. It lasted a year and a half. Oil on belt and cover. Have extended warranty, they are cutting me a check. I really liked the options, except locked lid. Now researching to find which one to get. Afraid of GE! Nothing is made well anymore due to our government regulations and restrictions….😡
Try a Speed Queen. How To Choose the Best Washing Machine: Speed Queen TC5 vs. TR7 Review
ua-cam.com/video/qlkdxWfTZVw/v-deo.html. Thanks for watching!
Speed Queen.
Buy it nice or buy it thrice.
Very wise words. Thanks for watching!
😊😊😊
Thanks for watching!