@tonystarrk4859 , yeah play during the founding era of Ashina. Either fight or fight alongside Isshin Ashina in his younger years. Tomoe as the ultimate lightening boss. Maybe see a younger version of the sculptor during his ninja days.
@@EthanJackson-e4gsaying "I think you robbed Messmer" is also an opinion. besides just because it's an opinion doesn't mean we can't challenge them lol
@@Based1889what makes him #1? a boss like Gael outclasses him in almost every way, better arena, ost, lore, spectacle, and honestly while Messmer is good in moveset compared to the rest of ER bosses, Gaels is just better. Than with Ludwig also having a better arena, ost, design, cutscene, and is more difficult while still being balanced, with Messmer being balanced yet not THAT difficult compared to the rest of the bosses. Bayle has a better spectacle, buildup, difficulty though with maybe slightly worse balancing, better arena, etc. I really do like Messmer, but heck, Orphan is better better than him too, better arena, moveset, much more difficult yet just as balanced, I could keep going however I don’t wanna be here all day.
I absolutely loved Messmer personally, maybe I’m just a Messmer simp but I think he topped Gael. Something about his moveset and the way you have to master it and not just dodge roll right the entire time, it just feel so good, like a true duel for the fate of the land of shadow.
I personally think you ranked Messmer WAY too low. He is definitely the best Soulsborne boss I have fought since Slave Knight Gael. He has a ton of significance and build up in the lore, his moveset is visually spectacular and fun to master, and his second phase cutscene is easily on par with Ludwig for the best cutscene in FromSoft history. I legitimately got goosebumps throughout my entire body when I was fighting Messmer.
In no particular order (it's like ranking my children), Messmer, Rellana, Gael, Ludwig, and Orphan are my top 5. As for this list, I find Messmer and Rellana underrated and DS3 bosses overrated, but this largely comes down to personal preference.
@@ianmcclure3936 Rellana is just spam with near to no windows to attack imo, her balls are cool though, Orphan is just a weird case for me idk, i don't like Bloodborne. Also it's personal opinion lol
@@WeirdTroll666 I actually felt the same about Rellana at first, but once I learned her moveset and where to find those windows of opportunity to punish... She became one of my favorite fights in the game. Also, Morgott is one of my favorite Fromsoftware bosses, and he has a really complex moveset like Rellana. So that's probably why I like her so much as a boss. I can understand Kos though, if the game isn't your thing... I guess it would make sense why you wouldn't like the bosses in the first place.
Romina has a lot of bad hitboxes, her aoe does guaranteed damage if she starts it when you are next to her, and she is too easy aside from that. She really isn't that good
@@theholypopechodeii4367 i must agree about the aoe doing guaranteed damage. And she's to easy when you do her right before enir Ilim but otherwise she's really ok difficulty wise. She's a nice breather between the other bosses who are "too hard" lol. I always do her as my 3th or 4th remembrance Boss and then she's perfect imo
I think Mesmer has topped Gael for me, one thing is for certain, Mesmer is harder than Gael . Gael attacks looks flashy but for some reason they are lot easier to dodge, Mesmer blends his fast and delayed attacks very masterfully. This makes mastering the boss more harder but also presents a challenge which feels new and refreshing to learn. That snake part is peak gaming too, it not only looks cool but brings a new dynamic to the fight, it feels like dodging a beast but it blends that knight sort of element with regular Mesmer moves quiet well And that music, god damn. Just the extra points that I can give to Gayle will be his story, I think as a whole Gael is a better character, not saying Mesmer is bad, but he is best second. Mesmer is an abandoned but loyal child, who gets used by his mother. Gael is a man who left for a greater cause but that same cause made him loose control over his goal, and he end up becoming a monster that we eventually fight, he is the true tragic hero. And I belive he has the best cutscene and dialogue out of all from soft bosses And that arena is top tier too.
Idk I think gael has a significantly cooler arena, music, and overall design. Yes he's easy but that shouldn't be the tierbreaker for what makes a boss better or worse. Messmer also has some glaring hitbox issues in a way that gael doesn't, especially in phase 2 where his snake attacks sometimes hit before the animation even ends. It's fine if you like messmer more but I personally think gael a better package overall, same with ludwig and maria imo
Idk I think gael has a significantly cooler arena, music, and overall design. Yes he's easy but that shouldn't be the tierbreaker for what makes a boss better or worse. Messmer also has some obvious hitbox issues in a way that gael doesn't, especially in phase 2 where his snake attacks sometimes hit before the animation even ends. It's fine if you like messmer more but I personally think gael a better package overall, same with ludwig and maria imo
Messmer is significantly cooler and more difficult than Gay-is Gaius is the only boss in the dlc where it felt like he was glitched the whole time I couldn’t dodge his attacks, his horse had 2 seperate hit boxes etc. horrible fight and I won cause I got lucky. Messmer was fun as hell to learn the moves to though
That's what I'm saying I've played every fromsoft game besides ds3 and bb which I hear the fans glaze saying it's peak but when I look at some of the bosses they seem like good mini bosses in terms of moveset compare to elden ring bosses with their mix up game
@@bmxgu2361 no there’s def way too much praise for those 2, especially for ds3. That game is legit a bottom 4 game in the series. Bosses can’t carry the lame areas, mid lore, braindead mechanics and the samey music
I love how you rag on Shadow of the Erdtree for not having enough cutscenes for bosses when it has the most of any DLC. SOTE has 6 across 4 bosses. Old hunters has 5 across 4 bosses. Artorias of the Abyss has 3 across 3 bosses (including the one where Kalameet is shot down). Ringed City has 2 for 1 boss. Ashes of Ariandel has 2 for 1 boss. Crown of the Sunken King has none. Crown of the Old Iron Kinb has none. Crown of the Ivory King has none.
@@WeirdTroll666 Where did I mess up? SOTE has both the most bosses and the most boss cutscenes? The bosses I listed were the bosses with cutscenes (some have 1, some have 2).
@@jamesbell1186 oh oh my bad, i thought you were listing ALL the bosses per dlc, you are totally right! I'm just tired didn't read that well... whoops :)
I just beat Dark souls 3 and it’s two DLC’s for the first time yesterday, and Gael and Sister Friede were perfect! Sister Friede took me a lot of tries, but it felt so damn satisfying when I finally won. I had an easier time with Gael cause he only took me 5 tries, but his fight was soooo fun! It wasn’t frustrating at all and after Sister Friede I appreciated him having only one health bar. Even if he had a ton of health lol. And don’t get me started on Lady Maria. She’s one of my all time favorites, too. Finishing her fight with a parry felt sooo good.
Just some constuctive critisism. I reccomend adding in some kind of break between bosses, even if its just so much as adding a "Number X: Boss Name", each entry I found to transition into eachother in an awkward way, where I wouldnt even realise you swapped bosses for a second or two. Good luck on future videos!
Nah messmer for me was 💯 percent my favourite souls dlc boss oat. The voice acting was seriously amazing and the moveset was flashy but not too flashy. The fight was just golden and the guy had straight up aura.
Demon Prince at number 3 is based. I will forever love that boss, it is the best duo boss Fromsoft boss has ever made and it's not even close. I love Elden Ring and Shadows of the Erdtree but it's disappointing that we didn't have a good duo boss in ER.
@cobracmr4 problem with maria is that once you learn you can just mash l2 anytime she moves, she's not really fun anymore. I don't think parrying is super fun in general, but at least most of the time there's a risk to it. With Maria there is no risk, you either parry her or she gets stunned and you get off scot free.
@@cobracmr4 I apologize for implying anything like that. I think the fight would be very good if I could resist shooting her all the time. The thing is, they just make it so easy it's hard not to do it.
ER DLC bosses Imo: Dancing Lion: 8.4/10 Rellana: 9.3/10 Putrescent Knight: 6.2/10 Metyr: 6.3/10 Scadutree Avatar: 6/10 Messmer: 9.5/10 Commander Gaius: 4/10 Bayle the Dread: 9.3/10 Romina: 7.9/10 Mitra: X/10 (Havent played It yet, seems good though) Consort Radanh: 6/10(Very mixed with this one) I feel that the roster for this DLC was overall very good, although Some bosses could qualify better as mini-bosses than remembrances ones.
@@konstantino2009For me a 10/10 would mean that they would be unbeatable. That Fromsoftware would never make a fight better ever again. Although more than a 9/10 for me means that the fight was magnificent and have a tiny room for improvement.
@@watfunstu9086 Putrescent Knight because I feel It more like a miniBoss. His attacks didn't impresed me as much personally.Its a good fight though? Indeed. Although being lower than Metyr is because I genuely loved everything regarding Metyr aesthetic. Although I think the same for her. Gaius for other hand... Not original music for a remembrance Boss, very questionable hitboxes that makes Horse combat uncomfortable, and Some rolls as well, I played pre-patch which make him dash towards you and attack even before you could summon Torrent, and I think that his balance Damage/Agresion is very weird... Like a Kick did like 70% of my health with two defensive buffs and good Scadutree Blessing, why? It has cool attacks, specially that Gravity one, but I think It needed way more love on development.
@@lBadSport Depends which Radahn you mean, but first of all Kalameet just isn't a outstanding boss anymore, second of all Artorias moveset just is really basic nowadays these bosses were incredible back then but nowadays they are outclassed and should be regarded as such it is not because they were great back then that they should remain on your top forever....
@@lBadSport i beat artorias hitless at sl1 and it clearly feels dated. movement is clunky, hitboxes are too large or linger for a bit too long. manus is good but the runback kinda sucks. both are the best ds1 bosses, but the game is so dated that it drags them down
My DLC boss ranking for a top 10 wouldve been a little different: 1. Messmer 2. Gael 3. Bayle 4. Ludwig 5. Demon Princes 6. Midra 7. Maria 8. Orphan 9. Rellana 10. Romina If you include sekiro inner bosses im putting inner father at 1 and inner geni around 4-6 and inner isshin just in the top 10 (think normal ssi is more fun than his inner version)
@@Glorb-TopicI've just defeated him and although it's probably one of my favorite bosses in elden ring, I agree that phase 2 is a complete mess, too aggressive, too flashy, and the giant aoe is a bit too fast, if you don't run IMMEDIATELY you can't avoid it, anyways I also agree with the guy above and I think Radahn is overall better than some of the bosses that top him in this list
@@Glorb-TopicAlso I don't think Miquella's attacks are a problem in terms of damage, on the opposite I think it's pretty fair, but I hate the fact that you get stunlocked by them. Regarding the hitboxes I didn't have much problem with it tbh but the x cross slash combo is the worst
Agree, he didn't even mentioned any of Sir Alonne's attacks. he just said that Alonne and Fume Knight are pretty difficult and that Alonne does a seppuku if you kill him hitless. Bullshit
@theholypopechodeii4367 Yeah romina has bad hit boxes but honestly I only started to notice it trying to no hit her, and compared to metyr at least she has amazing moveset and peak visual design, metyr is just annoying, summons enemies and has this totally bs pulsar aoe
Nah... Most people consider her to be at least a top 5 boss in the DLC. Although if we are talking about underappreciated bosses... It would be Romina.
Messmer being lower than demon prince and ludwig is crazy glazing lol, messmer objectively has way better gameplay than both of them combined and his arena, buildup, presentation are all ez 10/10.
Yo bro grow up tb Mesmer better than Ludwig hell no he’s better than demon prince he right but not Ludwig he has one the best osts, arena, lore, moveset and cutscenes
@@dylananderson2979 cutscene is fine but his moveset is no where near messmer's, ost of messmer is amazing and his arena is miles better than ludwig's garbage blood arena, I can't tell you how many times I've got stuck in a corner or accidentally climbed that shit staircase in the end of the arena to get stuck and die.
Bayle gets overrated because of his peak visual effects but visual effects doesnt determine everything. Where demon prince laxk visually, they make up for it with their very good mechanical boss design
Ranking elden ring bosses so low when they are much more complex and interesting both design and moveset wise, and with much better atmosphere… bah. I think you’re feeling a lot of nostalgia for fights that arent really that great.
I can understand Bloodborne, but putting Demon Princes over Bayle, Messmer, Rellana, Midra, Midir, Ludwig, Orphan of Kos, and so many other great bosses is literally insane! Like sure Demon Princes are a solid duo fight, but that's about it. They really aren't that memorable imo.
We need demon souls dlc, like they already have the area and the archstone. All they have to do is add enemies and a boss and boom, they could sell it for 10 dollars and would probably sell several million copies, so that’s tens of millions of dollars and all they have to do is finish a project that is already 70% complete
You’re really gonna put living failures over Lawrence!? I mean to each his own but idk about that…Not gonna lie Lawrence was a breeze the first few times I fought him but I never killed him on NG+6 and above idk what it was about him but I remember suddenly I was getting trounced by him once i hit a particular NG+ cycle. It was suddenly the boss I had the most trouble with I kept getting 1 shot by him in his second form and just never ended up killing him after that he was the only boss I eventually gave up on since fume knight many moons ago
I might get burned for this, but I honestly feel like Ludwig is kinda overrated. Of Orphan, Maria and him, I've always thought he is the weakest gameplay wise, but the one that puts the biggest spectacle.
Rellana above Messemer is crazy. Messemer felt rewarding to learn, and his cutscene and lore went crazy. Rellana was just “hope you have enough stamina for my infinite combos, oh and if you do good luck swinging back”
Bro, ludwig is so overrated, take the nostalgia glasses off. My top 10 1 - Messmer 2 - Bayle 3 - Friede 4 - Gael 5 - Consort Radahn 6 - Orphan of kos 7 - Midir 8 - Lady Maria 9 - Rellana 10 - Demon Prince
"Take the nostalgia glass off 🤓" The honeymoon phase you pass, give it time, SoTE is not that great, the only GREAT and fun fights are Messmer and Midra. Bayle is just for the spectacle and Igon top-notch VA
@@liszt646 Hahahah. Messmer, Bayle, Rellana, divine beast, midra and radanhn are among the best bosses. Tier A or S. Don't get me wrong, I like Ludwig, but most of the epicness comes from the lore and ost. The combat itself is good but A tier, second phase is pretty easy, can't be above messmer, midir, Rellana, orphan of kos, lady maria, friede, etc.
@@liszt646 That is because skill issue. Same happened with Malenia at first but now she is considered either A or S but not less. The only bad thing abour radahn is the cross slash attack and the fps drops. Light beams are easy to dodge when you learn how to and it is a very hard yet fun fight. You have bad taste if you don't like SOTE or elden ring. The delayed attacks must be a pain for you haha. Git gud.
The free hate on dark souls 2, your worst boss is an actually good duo boss... Blue smelter is a good boss too, you are puting pvpblade from ringed city above them, ridiculous
@@dylananderson2979 Mesmer over Gael has room for debate I’ll admit. But Bayle has everything midir has got, but more and better. In terms of spectacle Bayle is far above midir. I think Bayle is in contention for the most visually impressive boss fight in the series, and while Midir puts on a show but Bayle is in a different league. As for the actual fight, Bayle takes everything that made Midir and Placidusaxs great, combined it and improved it. You can focus the head like Midir but the rest of body takes decent damage too. His moves leave the head open for attacks, but unlike Midir who does the same 4 combo strings throughout the whole fight, Bayle can mix his up for more variety. And they blend well into each other because they are so well animated and telegraphed. Bayle also just has a lot more attacks from which to choose from (I think he has the most in the game). And most importantly, the lock on is so much better here than with Midir. No matter where Bayle jumps to the camera will follow without breaking. Sometimes the player ends up under his neck but the neck is see through from the inside and most of his attack have Bayle rearing his head back at the beginning, whipping the camera back to focusing on him.
@@mannytprimeministerofthemanate u kinda selling me on bayle but I think the ost for midir and arena is still both better and u right midir does the same stupid claw attack too much with fire at the end but phase 2 kinda fixes it
@@LuM4rex this one is more open to debate and there’s more baias involved, but to me Gaels attacks and combos feel a lot more rigid and limited than Mesmer. Like in phase one Gael legit has 4 moves and the most you have to worry about is whether he does one sword swing or two. In contrast Mesmer has way more attack strings and mix ups. While Mesmer still has simple bread n butter ( his thrust and swing combo) he has a much wider flow chart and can mix in his fire for even more mix ups. Phase 2 Gael is really why the fight. Here he has a some more attack and you have to worry about his cape when dodging. But again, he is still limited to combo string. They always start and end the same way and he rarely does any mix up. Even his wild spinning attack is mostly fanfare. Majority of the attack fly right over your head is you stay still. Gael p2 feels like a simpler version of Mesmer p1. Mesmer p2 integrates the snake attacks in a way that doesn’t get in a way of his p1 moveset, but fills in the gaps that were present. Now he has more ranged attacks (but doesn’t spam them) and more mobility when he transforms. The transformation attacks are especially good because they don’t have shit hit boxes (like another boss in the shadow keep) and leave him vulnerable for a while afterwards. P2 Messmer builds on p1 instead of replacing it like Gael does. TLDR: fighting Gael feels like a well rehearsed dance number while fighting Mesmer is more like two pro dancers doing improv.
Ngl this order is pretty ass, Manus and Fume Knight are INSANELY low. Calling Scadutree Avatar or Putrescent Knight a better boss than those ones is crazy. Also, I hate to say it, but Ludwig is so ludicrously overrated. His first phase is just obnoxiously erratic, and his second phase, while cool, has like 4 moves. He’s great but I just can’t get on board with calling him anything close to perfect. I went through and made my own rankings and Ludwig came in at #13 among DLC bosses. I respect your opinions though, seems you’re pretty positive on a vast majority of the bosses. ALSO MESSMER AT 9??? EXPLAIN YOURSELF!
im one of the few ppl who fully agree on the messmer placement, like him but don't think he is in the upper echelons like gael, ludwig, orphan or lady maria
Seeing you fight SotE bosses in this way and give them bad ratings hurts meentally. Even Bayle - he has lots of problems, but camera issues aren’t one of them. You are almost always supposed to be in front of his head, as he punished you being under him with his fire breath. If you are behind his head, you should lock off and run. It’s actually better to fight most of the time locked off and only lock on during specific attacks or when you want to attack (the later being optional given his low head position). Also, Romina deserves better. She is one of the easier bosses, but her main hitbox being in the middle between the scorpion and the centipede makes her probably the best half-arachnid boss. Her attacks in addition to being gorgeous feel rewarding when you think of better ways to dodge them.
My boy midir deseves better than this... I feel you put radahn a bit low considering how hype the 2nd phase is but it does have some bs that drove me insane. It's kinda sad that there's bs like the cross slash mixed into that gold like the one combo with swords glowing gold.
i love gael but he was never number one for me and never will be. top five for sure but he felt just a tiny bit overrated. like the way people talk about him makes me think that he can cure cancer and while he is a very cool and flashy boss, he *is* ultimately another guy with a sword. just an extemely unique one with heavy lore attached to it no one will top friede for me. she has everything. a good gimmick fight for first phase, an AMAZING duo fight for second phase, a better lady maria for 3rd phase and she even pulls a fucking gotcha plus, no one will convince me that ringed city takes place after ashes. gael is *not* the final fight, friede is. she is the one guarding your pathway to give the painter the dark soul and for her to create a world of blood(borne) i will die on this hill. money is the only reason these expansions were seperated
Yeah, like I get the praise he gets, but I just feel there have been better bosses compared to him. Like Messmer for example might be the best DLC boss they've ever made and has the cool factor that Gael had, while also having what Gael lacked which is a fun and fair difficult moveset to learn. Like sure Gael is cool and all, but I swear the DS3 fans treat him like this untouchable god or something.
@ianmcclure3936 I have not played ds3 or BB but I can tell that I'm going to be sad when the bosses like Ludwig and Gael are not as good as anyone says unlike those bosses I did not see any praise of Artorios when I played ds1 in 2023 and now he is in my top 15 probably my top 10 I have only played ds1 ds2 sekiro and elden ring
I know my pfp is artorias but maria and gael are just better(gameplay wise) and maybe radahn and messmer(but if he was a bit harder he would be the best boss in the world and radahn is a bit too hard but i guess i dont have much skill it took me a lot of time to beat him)
@@WeirdTroll666 He's just a great fight imo. Well telegraphed attacks, varied combos, no bullshit aoe effects or clothing that cover the arena so you can't see shit, no delayed attacks designed to catch you off guard like 95% of Elden Ring bosses have, great theme, tragic lore, and the fact we never fight him in his prime just leaves us to imagine what a legend he must have been before his corruption.
Ever since I fought Gael all those years ago, he’s been crowned as my favorite boss and what I regard as the best boss fight ever created, and I’ve fought a TON of bosses in all different types of games. Dmc, Final fantasy, metal gear rising, all the fromsoft games. Gael is king
@@jameslough6329 honestly don’t blame you. Messmer is an incredible fight and I’m itching to fight him again. Honestly if he had a third phase, or his 2nd phase was another health bar with more moves I prob would nearly agree w you
Still holding out for that Sekiro dlc
Tomoe, Dogen, and Kingfisher boss fights when 😭
@tonystarrk4859 , yeah play during the founding era of Ashina. Either fight or fight alongside Isshin Ashina in his younger years. Tomoe as the ultimate lightening boss. Maybe see a younger version of the sculptor during his ninja days.
aren't inner bosses kinda a dlc?
don't look up the malenia boss fight in sekiro
Me and you are never getting that brother. I have a can of copium though.
Gael, Messmer, Midra & Maria my Goat Dlc bosses
Midra is actually so goated
ludwig too
@@Sephirothkingdom782 yea Ludwig and Friede also top tier for me. But didnt feel like naming 6
@@jesusseinpferd__9628 oh yea lol
I agree. I would personally swap out Midra for kos or rellana but Gael and Messmer are my two favorite fights across all the games
Messmer is in my opinion an almost perfect boss mechanically. My favourite boss fight of all time.
Yeah, he is easily a top 3 boss in the Souls series for me. Alongside Isshin and Orphan of Kos for me.
@@ianmcclure3936w ranking I respect it
He‘s my number one if you exclude Inner Genichiro
he is really good and fair. İ think he is better than gael. He is at my top 5
BuT gAEl (jk messmers way better)
My top 3
1-Gael - Messmer
2-bayle the dread
3-lady maria - rellana
Slave knight bael vs gayle the dread😂😂😂
Never let bro cook again
Thank👏you👏for👏giving👏the👏demon👏princes👏their👏flowers👏! No one ever talks about that fight but it was one of my favorites ever
I think you robbed Messmer
Fr, he's either top 2 or 1, there's no way he's below demon prince, this man is glazing ds3 and bb fr.
yup
Messmer doesnt have the presence he should. And bloodborne and ds3 are better than ER get over it.
@@EthanJackson-e4gsaying "I think you robbed Messmer" is also an opinion. besides just because it's an opinion doesn't mean we can't challenge them lol
@@Based1889what makes him #1? a boss like Gael outclasses him in almost every way, better arena, ost, lore, spectacle, and honestly while Messmer is good in moveset compared to the rest of ER bosses, Gaels is just better. Than with Ludwig also having a better arena, ost, design, cutscene, and is more difficult while still being balanced, with Messmer being balanced yet not THAT difficult compared to the rest of the bosses. Bayle has a better spectacle, buildup, difficulty though with maybe slightly worse balancing, better arena, etc. I really do like Messmer, but heck, Orphan is better better than him too, better arena, moveset, much more difficult yet just as balanced, I could keep going however I don’t wanna be here all day.
I absolutely loved Messmer personally, maybe I’m just a Messmer simp but I think he topped Gael. Something about his moveset and the way you have to master it and not just dodge roll right the entire time, it just feel so good, like a true duel for the fate of the land of shadow.
He deserved two health bars
I am a Messmer Simp, and proudly so. Me second favorite boss ever, right behind Inner Genichiro
You might be a messmer simp but you are at least no gael simp
@jakeniclaz5393 Been slamming Inner Geni for fun the last few days, and he is definitely growing on me as one of the all time best
@@Kaleb._ 100%
I personally think you ranked Messmer WAY too low. He is definitely the best Soulsborne boss I have fought since Slave Knight Gael. He has a ton of significance and build up in the lore, his moveset is visually spectacular and fun to master, and his second phase cutscene is easily on par with Ludwig for the best cutscene in FromSoft history. I legitimately got goosebumps throughout my entire body when I was fighting Messmer.
and that’s YOUR opinion buddy
@@noscotti yes and he just shared his opinion, just like the guy who made the video did.
@@noscotti that's why he said "i personally think," little bro
I absolutely love all of them but fighting Radahn again was nothing short of amazing and an absolute honour indeed
It was an honor until his twink boyfriend decided to step in.
Well it's unfair sekiro doesnt have a dlc but for me all top spots would go to inner genichiro
Inner isshin
And my no.1 inner father
nice i would put them in reverse
@@WeirdTroll666 i really wish we get a followup to sekiro.... my absolute favourite game in the catalogue deserves more love
Inner Father is such a good fight.
Inner Genichiro is my absolute favorite
In no particular order (it's like ranking my children), Messmer, Rellana, Gael, Ludwig, and Orphan are my top 5. As for this list, I find Messmer and Rellana underrated and DS3 bosses overrated, but this largely comes down to personal preference.
rellana and orphan are a bit mid but sure
@@WeirdTroll666thats crazy
@@WeirdTroll666Please explain how they are mid?
@@ianmcclure3936 Rellana is just spam with near to no windows to attack imo, her balls are cool though, Orphan is just a weird case for me idk, i don't like Bloodborne. Also it's personal opinion lol
@@WeirdTroll666 I actually felt the same about Rellana at first, but once I learned her moveset and where to find those windows of opportunity to punish... She became one of my favorite fights in the game. Also, Morgott is one of my favorite Fromsoftware bosses, and he has a really complex moveset like Rellana. So that's probably why I like her so much as a boss.
I can understand Kos though, if the game isn't your thing... I guess it would make sense why you wouldn't like the bosses in the first place.
Totally agree with everything you said about rellana but damn you did Laurence and Romina some injustice haha
Romina has a lot of bad hitboxes, her aoe does guaranteed damage if she starts it when you are next to her, and she is too easy aside from that. She really isn't that good
Laurence is definitely F tier brodie💀
Leurance is totally joke
Laurence is garbage but romina was an amazing fight imo
@@theholypopechodeii4367 i must agree about the aoe doing guaranteed damage. And she's to easy when you do her right before enir Ilim but otherwise she's really ok difficulty wise. She's a nice breather between the other bosses who are "too hard" lol. I always do her as my 3th or 4th remembrance Boss and then she's perfect imo
I think Mesmer has topped Gael for me, one thing is for certain, Mesmer is harder than Gael . Gael attacks looks flashy but for some reason they are lot easier to dodge, Mesmer blends his fast and delayed attacks very masterfully. This makes mastering the boss more harder but also presents a challenge which feels new and refreshing to learn. That snake part is peak gaming too, it not only looks cool but brings a new dynamic to the fight, it feels like dodging a beast but it blends that knight sort of element with regular Mesmer moves quiet well And that music, god damn. Just the extra points that I can give to Gayle will be his story, I think as a whole Gael is a better character, not saying Mesmer is bad, but he is best second. Mesmer is an abandoned but loyal child, who gets used by his mother. Gael is a man who left for a greater cause but that same cause made him loose control over his goal, and he end up becoming a monster that we eventually fight, he is the true tragic hero. And I belive he has the best cutscene and dialogue out of all from soft bosses And that arena is top tier too.
is Gayle the child of Bayle and Gael? ;)
Idk I think gael has a significantly cooler arena, music, and overall design. Yes he's easy but that shouldn't be the tierbreaker for what makes a boss better or worse. Messmer also has some glaring hitbox issues in a way that gael doesn't, especially in phase 2 where his snake attacks sometimes hit before the animation even ends. It's fine if you like messmer more but I personally think gael a better package overall, same with ludwig and maria imo
Idk I think gael has a significantly cooler arena, music, and overall design. Yes he's easy but that shouldn't be the tierbreaker for what makes a boss better or worse. Messmer also has some obvious hitbox issues in a way that gael doesn't, especially in phase 2 where his snake attacks sometimes hit before the animation even ends. It's fine if you like messmer more but I personally think gael a better package overall, same with ludwig and maria imo
I absolutely love messmer! However for me personally nobody can top gael! Not in terms of difficulty but I’m just sheer epicness!!
Messmer is significantly cooler and more difficult than Gay-is
Gaius is the only boss in the dlc where it felt like he was glitched the whole time
I couldn’t dodge his attacks, his horse had 2 seperate hit boxes etc. horrible fight and I won cause I got lucky.
Messmer was fun as hell to learn the moves to though
Sanctuary Guardian is like a chimera manticore hybrid. Pretty cool imo
Theres no way sir alonne is under romina
Jesus dude… messmer that low
That's what I'm saying I've played every fromsoft game besides ds3 and bb which I hear the fans glaze saying it's peak but when I look at some of the bosses they seem like good mini bosses in terms of moveset compare to elden ring bosses with their mix up game
@@pressy-fb1hs You gotta play those two. It's not glazing. They are legitimately that good.
@@pressy-fb1hs FromSoftware fans when boss fight is not only about moveset but also about atmosphere and lore (Gael tops any ER boss)
@@bmxgu2361 no there’s def way too much praise for those 2, especially for ds3. That game is legit a bottom 4 game in the series. Bosses can’t carry the lame areas, mid lore, braindead mechanics and the samey music
@@Stanzbey69 It's subjective. Personally It's my favourite Dark Souls game, the same thing can be said for many others.
I love how you rag on Shadow of the Erdtree for not having enough cutscenes for bosses when it has the most of any DLC.
SOTE has 6 across 4 bosses.
Old hunters has 5 across 4 bosses.
Artorias of the Abyss has 3 across 3 bosses (including the one where Kalameet is shot down).
Ringed City has 2 for 1 boss.
Ashes of Ariandel has 2 for 1 boss.
Crown of the Sunken King has none.
Crown of the Old Iron Kinb has none.
Crown of the Ivory King has none.
AOTA has 4 bosses... Old Hunters has 5 bosses... Ariandel has 2 bosses, Ringed City has 4 bosses, SOTE has 10 bosses.... you messed up a bit lol
@@WeirdTroll666 Where did I mess up? SOTE has both the most bosses and the most boss cutscenes? The bosses I listed were the bosses with cutscenes (some have 1, some have 2).
@@jamesbell1186 oh oh my bad, i thought you were listing ALL the bosses per dlc, you are totally right! I'm just tired didn't read that well... whoops :)
@@WeirdTroll666 Alg lol
Messmer is my best dlc boss. I only wish he was harder.
I just beat Dark souls 3 and it’s two DLC’s for the first time yesterday, and Gael and Sister Friede were perfect! Sister Friede took me a lot of tries, but it felt so damn satisfying when I finally won. I had an easier time with Gael cause he only took me 5 tries, but his fight was soooo fun! It wasn’t frustrating at all and after Sister Friede I appreciated him having only one health bar. Even if he had a ton of health lol. And don’t get me started on Lady Maria. She’s one of my all time favorites, too. Finishing her fight with a parry felt sooo good.
Just some constuctive critisism.
I reccomend adding in some kind of break between bosses, even if its just so much as adding a "Number X: Boss Name", each entry I found to transition into eachother in an awkward way, where I wouldnt even realise you swapped bosses for a second or two.
Good luck on future videos!
Nah messmer for me was 💯 percent my favourite souls dlc boss oat. The voice acting was seriously amazing and the moveset was flashy but not too flashy. The fight was just golden and the guy had straight up aura.
Gael the goat
bot
Messmer and midra the goat
@@Based1889 cook
messmer, bayle, and midra >>>>
@@skoop4477 midra 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Demon Prince at number 3 is based. I will forever love that boss, it is the best duo boss Fromsoft boss has ever made and it's not even close. I love Elden Ring and Shadows of the Erdtree but it's disappointing that we didn't have a good duo boss in ER.
Can someone explain the hype for Lady Maria to me, fought her 3 times and she’s just to easy to stun for her to be any challenge
Sometimes a boss don't gotta be hard to be good. Maria is just so fun to fight
@cobracmr4 problem with maria is that once you learn you can just mash l2 anytime she moves, she's not really fun anymore. I don't think parrying is super fun in general, but at least most of the time there's a risk to it. With Maria there is no risk, you either parry her or she gets stunned and you get off scot free.
@dontknow452 idk man maybe I'm just weird but she's my personal favorite boss of the entire series. I just have a blast with her fight.
@@cobracmr4 I apologize for implying anything like that. I think the fight would be very good if I could resist shooting her all the time. The thing is, they just make it so easy it's hard not to do it.
Didnt find her so great either and she was ez, there are just to many simps tbh
laurence at 29 is a crazy take, one of the more memorable BB bosses imo
Yes But his fight is garbage
@@hkiolo474 nah
@Max_0055 YEAH
But I respect your opinion
ER DLC bosses Imo:
Dancing Lion: 8.4/10
Rellana: 9.3/10
Putrescent Knight: 6.2/10
Metyr: 6.3/10
Scadutree Avatar: 6/10
Messmer: 9.5/10
Commander Gaius: 4/10
Bayle the Dread: 9.3/10
Romina: 7.9/10
Mitra: X/10 (Havent played It yet, seems good though)
Consort Radanh: 6/10(Very mixed with this one)
I feel that the roster for this DLC was overall very good, although Some bosses could qualify better as mini-bosses than remembrances ones.
i think bayle,messmer,mindra and rellana deserve 10/10
@@konstantino2009For me a 10/10 would mean that they would be unbeatable. That Fromsoftware would never make a fight better ever again.
Although more than a 9/10 for me means that the fight was magnificent and have a tiny room for improvement.
why Putrescent knight so low? and Gauis?
@@watfunstu9086 Putrescent Knight because I feel It more like a miniBoss. His attacks didn't impresed me as much personally.Its a good fight though? Indeed. Although being lower than Metyr is because I genuely loved everything regarding Metyr aesthetic. Although I think the same for her.
Gaius for other hand... Not original music for a remembrance Boss, very questionable hitboxes that makes Horse combat uncomfortable, and Some rolls as well, I played pre-patch which make him dash towards you and attack even before you could summon Torrent, and I think that his balance Damage/Agresion is very weird... Like a Kick did like 70% of my health with two defensive buffs and good Scadutree Blessing, why?
It has cool attacks, specially that Gravity one, but I think It needed way more love on development.
@@JoseViktor4099 Midra is awesome! I personally liked Romina a bit too much
Nah bayle is peak boss fights
Midir >
Sorry not sorry.
Only visually.
@@TifffanyTaylorBayle >>> midir
Not in the gameplay term
@@RetroSpark13 midir feels designed to be 1v1'd. BAYLE (curse you) feels designed to be taken on with multiple targets swapping agro.
i feel like this guy didnt play ds1 dlc and found clips but artorias, magnus and kalameet being this low is insane.
Nah they just are clearly dated...
@@maran947 you CANNOT tell me that manus OR artorias isnt better than radahn himself. you clearly never played it
@@lBadSport Depends which Radahn you mean, but first of all Kalameet just isn't a outstanding boss anymore, second of all Artorias moveset just is really basic nowadays these bosses were incredible back then but nowadays they are outclassed and should be regarded as such it is not because they were great back then that they should remain on your top forever....
@@lBadSport i beat artorias hitless at sl1 and it clearly feels dated. movement is clunky, hitboxes are too large or linger for a bit too long. manus is good but the runback kinda sucks. both are the best ds1 bosses, but the game is so dated that it drags them down
@@keskorian5820 youre so dumb. no way you said “oh easy boss? he sucks. Runback sucks? boss sucks.” bro you make zero sense
Messmer robbed ONGGGG
people that only played elden ring:
I would’ve personally put messmer right next to gael at 2. Midra top 6
Nah putrescent knight over ivory king and fume knight? You crazy for that
Ivory King is annoying as hell after the first time. Having to find all the knights is such a chore.
@@raultorres9909 Eh the process itself on repeat playthroughs can be annoying but the fight in a vacuum holds up great
My DLC boss ranking for a top 10 wouldve been a little different:
1. Messmer
2. Gael
3. Bayle
4. Ludwig
5. Demon Princes
6. Midra
7. Maria
8. Orphan
9. Rellana
10. Romina
If you include sekiro inner bosses im putting inner father at 1 and inner geni around 4-6 and inner isshin just in the top 10 (think normal ssi is more fun than his inner version)
Discovering Midra on top of his fight being good makes him easily my favorite sote boss.
Gael is still my favourite souls boss ever
Glad you gave Ludwig the love he deserves. He blew me away in terms of visuals especially.
Yeah bro never cook again
Laurence is great. Can’t believe you put him at 29.
14:18 The phantom dying to the moon attack had me rolling
Midir, Friede, and Gael are the fights that made me fall completely head over heels for DS3
I always respect everyone's opinion but man... Midir not even making it in the top 10 feels wrong. But great video!
Sanctuary guardian is a traditional chimera
Sanctuary guardian is definitively a chimera. Very standard monster
Radahn at 15 is crazy, yes he’s annoying to go against but once you learn his attack pattern, it’s really fun
Nah he should be unironically be lower. There are so many garbage hitboxes and flashbangs to actually say this is a good fight
@@Glorb-TopicI've just defeated him and although it's probably one of my favorite bosses in elden ring, I agree that phase 2 is a complete mess, too aggressive, too flashy, and the giant aoe is a bit too fast, if you don't run IMMEDIATELY you can't avoid it, anyways I also agree with the guy above and I think Radahn is overall better than some of the bosses that top him in this list
@@Glorb-TopicAlso I don't think Miquella's attacks are a problem in terms of damage, on the opposite I think it's pretty fair, but I hate the fact that you get stunlocked by them. Regarding the hitboxes I didn't have much problem with it tbh but the x cross slash combo is the worst
I agree
@@Glorb-TopicComplete nonsense 😂
Sir alonne and romina lower than metyr? One of the worst elden ring bosses? Irrelevant list
Agree, he didn't even mentioned any of Sir Alonne's attacks. he just said that Alonne and Fume Knight are pretty difficult and that Alonne does a seppuku if you kill him hitless. Bullshit
Lmao metyr isn't a good fight but romina is not good either. Romina has a tonne of dogsbit hitboxes, metyr only has 1 attack with a bad hitbox.
@theholypopechodeii4367 Yeah romina has bad hit boxes but honestly I only started to notice it trying to no hit her, and compared to metyr at least she has amazing moveset and peak visual design, metyr is just annoying, summons enemies and has this totally bs pulsar aoe
THIS
fume knight unironically goated, no boss even comes close to it for its time.
Artorias, Gael & Maria
sir alonne that low is a crime
gael is too old right now all messmer is his completed form imo i'd take messmer 1 bayle 2 gael 3
Pretty solid list, i'd put midir a lil bit higher tho
My top 5
Messmer
Geal
Demon prince
Midra
Ludwig
My top 5 (didn't play Bloodborne 😢)
1.post nerf radahn
2.friede
3.gael
4.rellana
5.messmer
putting demon prince above the seven bosses before him is fucking crazy
thank you for giving rellana the credit she deserves she is so great and no one talks about her
Nah... Most people consider her to be at least a top 5 boss in the DLC. Although if we are talking about underappreciated bosses... It would be Romina.
Kalameet at 24 is kind of insane tbh. He's better than most dlc bosses
How exactly? He’s awesome but compared to some of the later dragon fights he just doesn’t quite stack up IMO. Other than lore maybe
nah he is worst dragon fight in dlc but still not bad boss tho
@@aganbraganca4156 there’s only 1 dragon in the dlc…
I might be a little too low on Messmer too, because I beat him pretty quick. I actually liked Rellana (twin moon knight) better.
Messmer being lower than demon prince and ludwig is crazy glazing lol, messmer objectively has way better gameplay than both of them combined and his arena, buildup, presentation are all ez 10/10.
Yo bro grow up tb Mesmer better than Ludwig hell no he’s better than demon prince he right but not Ludwig he has one the best osts, arena, lore, moveset and cutscenes
@@dylananderson2979 cutscene is fine but his moveset is no where near messmer's, ost of messmer is amazing and his arena is miles better than ludwig's garbage blood arena, I can't tell you how many times I've got stuck in a corner or accidentally climbed that shit staircase in the end of the arena to get stuck and die.
@@dylananderson2979 the First phase of Ludwig is full of dirty Attack like the charge and the jump
@@bondrewd5935 none of them are dirty, the charge is easy to dodge what are u on about?
@@eyer0n9 The Jump Is extremely dirty and the charge Is too fast
Messmer is #1
Dude, I mean, it's your opinion, I get it, but metyr and romina above sir alonne and kalameet? Holy shit, that's wild
Personally I'd like to see you rank every legacy dungeon in elden ring.
Demon Prince over Bayle is crazy
u mean demon prince over bayle?
@@vongolamistowl yeah
No its not. bayle is honestly overrated rn. Demon prince is a near perfected fight.
Bayle gets overrated because of his peak visual effects but visual effects doesnt determine everything. Where demon prince laxk visually, they make up for it with their very good mechanical boss design
@@Akd6869 bayle has one of the most complicated mechanics and a dynamic moveset tho. Visuals being flashy is just on top of that.
Ranking elden ring bosses so low when they are much more complex and interesting both design and moveset wise, and with much better atmosphere… bah. I think you’re feeling a lot of nostalgia for fights that arent really that great.
Agreed 100%
This man is glazing hard for bb and ds3
I can understand Bloodborne, but putting Demon Princes over Bayle, Messmer, Rellana, Midra, Midir, Ludwig, Orphan of Kos, and so many other great bosses is literally insane!
Like sure Demon Princes are a solid duo fight, but that's about it. They really aren't that memorable imo.
Womp womp
ER bosses are just trash, spammy, imput reading and AOEs bosses lol Messmer and Midra are good though
Bro has the same opinions as me I love him
We need demon souls dlc, like they already have the area and the archstone. All they have to do is add enemies and a boss and boom, they could sell it for 10 dollars and would probably sell several million copies, so that’s tens of millions of dollars and all they have to do is finish a project that is already 70% complete
The revered spirit ashes do buff torent.
You’re really gonna put living failures over Lawrence!? I mean to each his own but idk about that…Not gonna lie Lawrence was a breeze the first few times I fought him but I never killed him on NG+6 and above idk what it was about him but I remember suddenly I was getting trounced by him once i hit a particular NG+ cycle. It was suddenly the boss I had the most trouble with I kept getting 1 shot by him in his second form and just never ended up killing him after that he was the only boss I eventually gave up on since fume knight many moons ago
I might get burned for this, but I honestly feel like Ludwig is kinda overrated. Of Orphan, Maria and him, I've always thought he is the weakest gameplay wise, but the one that puts the biggest spectacle.
Nothing wrong with that. I find him to be impeccable, but that's just my subjective take.
Take a shot every time he says duo-boss
Rellana above Messemer is crazy. Messemer felt rewarding to learn, and his cutscene and lore went crazy. Rellana was just “hope you have enough stamina for my infinite combos, oh and if you do good luck swinging back”
Bro everyone is talking about how Messmer got robbed....
Like dude, did you SEE what this man did to Kalameet!? Put several spots below Metyr!
Bro, ludwig is so overrated, take the nostalgia glasses off.
My top 10
1 - Messmer
2 - Bayle
3 - Friede
4 - Gael
5 - Consort Radahn
6 - Orphan of kos
7 - Midir
8 - Lady Maria
9 - Rellana
10 - Demon Prince
hell no
"Take the nostalgia glass off 🤓"
The honeymoon phase you pass, give it time, SoTE is not that great, the only GREAT and fun fights are Messmer and Midra. Bayle is just for the spectacle and Igon top-notch VA
@@liszt646 Hahahah. Messmer, Bayle, Rellana, divine beast, midra and radanhn are among the best bosses. Tier A or S.
Don't get me wrong, I like Ludwig, but most of the epicness comes from the lore and ost. The combat itself is good but A tier, second phase is pretty easy, can't be above messmer, midir, Rellana, orphan of kos, lady maria, friede, etc.
@@ZeikerYT Bro you like Radahn BS fight 😭 just shows how poor your taste is. Even ER biggest fanboys didn't like Radahn's BS light beams attacks lol
@@liszt646 That is because skill issue. Same happened with Malenia at first but now she is considered either A or S but not less. The only bad thing abour radahn is the cross slash attack and the fps drops. Light beams are easy to dodge when you learn how to and it is a very hard yet fun fight.
You have bad taste if you don't like SOTE or elden ring. The delayed attacks must be a pain for you haha. Git gud.
In what world is Rellana better then Messmer? But beides that, we tend to agree with the others.
Orphan is too low I think, top 5 AT LEAST
The free hate on dark souls 2, your worst boss is an actually good duo boss... Blue smelter is a good boss too, you are puting pvpblade from ringed city above them, ridiculous
Shit game with shit bosses get the lowest spot I know big shock
6:24 a manticore
Why tf is laurence so low, one of the best bloodborne bosses
Mesmer > Gale and Bayle > midir. The future is now old man
Newgen of hell omg Mesmer is great and should be in top 5 but not better than Gael and for bayle hell no hes not better than midir
@@dylananderson2979 Mesmer over Gael has room for debate I’ll admit. But Bayle has everything midir has got, but more and better. In terms of spectacle Bayle is far above midir. I think Bayle is in contention for the most visually impressive boss fight in the series, and while Midir puts on a show but Bayle is in a different league. As for the actual fight, Bayle takes everything that made Midir and Placidusaxs great, combined it and improved it. You can focus the head like Midir but the rest of body takes decent damage too. His moves leave the head open for attacks, but unlike Midir who does the same 4 combo strings throughout the whole fight, Bayle can mix his up for more variety. And they blend well into each other because they are so well animated and telegraphed. Bayle also just has a lot more attacks from which to choose from (I think he has the most in the game). And most importantly, the lock on is so much better here than with Midir. No matter where Bayle jumps to the camera will follow without breaking. Sometimes the player ends up under his neck but the neck is see through from the inside and most of his attack have Bayle rearing his head back at the beginning, whipping the camera back to focusing on him.
@@mannytprimeministerofthemanate u kinda selling me on bayle but I think the ost for midir and arena is still both better and u right midir does the same stupid claw attack too much with fire at the end but phase 2 kinda fixes it
Why is Messmer better than Gael?
@@LuM4rex this one is more open to debate and there’s more baias involved, but to me Gaels attacks and combos feel a lot more rigid and limited than Mesmer. Like in phase one Gael legit has 4 moves and the most you have to worry about is whether he does one sword swing or two. In contrast Mesmer has way more attack strings and mix ups. While Mesmer still has simple bread n butter ( his thrust and swing combo) he has a much wider flow chart and can mix in his fire for even more mix ups. Phase 2 Gael is really why the fight. Here he has a some more attack and you have to worry about his cape when dodging. But again, he is still limited to combo string. They always start and end the same way and he rarely does any mix up. Even his wild spinning attack is mostly fanfare. Majority of the attack fly right over your head is you stay still. Gael p2 feels like a simpler version of Mesmer p1. Mesmer p2 integrates the snake attacks in a way that doesn’t get in a way of his p1 moveset, but fills in the gaps that were present. Now he has more ranged attacks (but doesn’t spam them) and more mobility when he transforms. The transformation attacks are especially good because they don’t have shit hit boxes (like another boss in the shadow keep) and leave him vulnerable for a while afterwards. P2 Messmer builds on p1 instead of replacing it like Gael does.
TLDR: fighting Gael feels like a well rehearsed dance number while fighting Mesmer is more like two pro dancers doing improv.
Ngl this order is pretty ass, Manus and Fume Knight are INSANELY low. Calling Scadutree Avatar or Putrescent Knight a better boss than those ones is crazy.
Also, I hate to say it, but Ludwig is so ludicrously overrated. His first phase is just obnoxiously erratic, and his second phase, while cool, has like 4 moves. He’s great but I just can’t get on board with calling him anything close to perfect. I went through and made my own rankings and Ludwig came in at #13 among DLC bosses.
I respect your opinions though, seems you’re pretty positive on a vast majority of the bosses.
ALSO MESSMER AT 9??? EXPLAIN YOURSELF!
Radahn !!!
Seeing Artorias not in the top 10 saddens me
Best out of ds1 ds2 and it's in my top 10 probably permanently and this is not nostalgic because I played it last year
Manus midra and midir should be way higher
im one of the few ppl who fully agree on the messmer placement, like him but don't think he is in the upper echelons like gael, ludwig, orphan or lady maria
Gael at #1 got you the like. A man of fine taste.
Seeing you fight SotE bosses in this way and give them bad ratings hurts meentally. Even Bayle - he has lots of problems, but camera issues aren’t one of them. You are almost always supposed to be in front of his head, as he punished you being under him with his fire breath. If you are behind his head, you should lock off and run. It’s actually better to fight most of the time locked off and only lock on during specific attacks or when you want to attack (the later being optional given his low head position).
Also, Romina deserves better. She is one of the easier bosses, but her main hitbox being in the middle between the scorpion and the centipede makes her probably the best half-arachnid boss. Her attacks in addition to being gorgeous feel rewarding when you think of better ways to dodge them.
What a massive L take on Radahn
My boy midir deseves better than this... I feel you put radahn a bit low considering how hype the 2nd phase is but it does have some bs that drove me insane. It's kinda sad that there's bs like the cross slash mixed into that gold like the one combo with swords glowing gold.
Living failures over laurence is crazy
I disagree on Laurence and Romina, think they are great. Also your saturation on Elden Ring hurts my eyes bro
i love gael but he was never number one for me and never will be. top five for sure but he felt just a tiny bit overrated. like the way people talk about him makes me think that he can cure cancer and while he is a very cool and flashy boss, he *is* ultimately another guy with a sword. just an extemely unique one with heavy lore attached to it
no one will top friede for me. she has everything. a good gimmick fight for first phase, an AMAZING duo fight for second phase, a better lady maria for 3rd phase and she even pulls a fucking gotcha
plus, no one will convince me that ringed city takes place after ashes. gael is *not* the final fight, friede is. she is the one guarding your pathway to give the painter the dark soul and for her to create a world of blood(borne)
i will die on this hill. money is the only reason these expansions were seperated
The man in your pfp is the best boss fromsoft has ever made
Yeah, like I get the praise he gets, but I just feel there have been better bosses compared to him. Like Messmer for example might be the best DLC boss they've ever made and has the cool factor that Gael had, while also having what Gael lacked which is a fun and fair difficult moveset to learn.
Like sure Gael is cool and all, but I swear the DS3 fans treat him like this untouchable god or something.
@ianmcclure3936 I have not played ds3 or BB but I can tell that I'm going to be sad when the bosses like Ludwig and Gael are not as good as anyone says unlike those bosses I did not see any praise of Artorios when I played ds1 in 2023 and now he is in my top 15 probably my top 10 I have only played ds1 ds2 sekiro and elden ring
I agree Gale is best boss ever
bro ıdk but ı always forgot bayle man
Mesmer is easily top 3 maybe top 5
I know my pfp is artorias but maria and gael are just better(gameplay wise) and maybe radahn and messmer(but if he was a bit harder he would be the best boss in the world and radahn is a bit too hard but i guess i dont have much skill it took me a lot of time to beat him)
Lawrence over Gaius has to be the worst thing in this video.. utter blasphemy.
gaius over laurence is crazy
Both dogshit bosses so
@@M__FO nah laurence is decent but gaius is one of the 10 worst soulsborne bosses
Only thing is good in leurance his ost and all fight is dogshit @hhcq
Artorias so low is criminal
fr he's legendary (and his ost is top 3 fromsoft ost)
@@WeirdTroll666 He's just a great fight imo. Well telegraphed attacks, varied combos, no bullshit aoe effects or clothing that cover the arena so you can't see shit, no delayed attacks designed to catch you off guard like 95% of Elden Ring bosses have, great theme, tragic lore, and the fact we never fight him in his prime just leaves us to imagine what a legend he must have been before his corruption.
Ever since I fought Gael all those years ago, he’s been crowned as my favorite boss and what I regard as the best boss fight ever created, and I’ve fought a TON of bosses in all different types of games. Dmc, Final fantasy, metal gear rising, all the fromsoft games. Gael is king
I felt the exact same about Gael until I fought Messmer. I really do think Messmer has topped him
@@jameslough6329 honestly don’t blame you. Messmer is an incredible fight and I’m itching to fight him again. Honestly if he had a third phase, or his 2nd phase was another health bar with more moves I prob would nearly agree w you
I kinda think fromsoft might've peaked with elden ring. Fingers crossed for neowiz to show they're not here to mess around.
Gayle.....is the most average boss for me.
messmer clears gael
kalameet is way too low