Prom 12 - NYO 2019 Tchaikovsky Violin Concerto
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 лип 2019
- The National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain with Nicola Benedetti conducted by Mark Wigglesworth
Royal Albert Hall, 27.07.2019
The performance was given 5 stars by the Times, The Guardian and the Arts Desk.
This is so utterly amazing that I can hardly believe my ears. Music like this is almost too good to be true.
Excellent performance, very refined. The orchestra didn’t sound like students, very professional. Soloist was flawless. Bravo!
Absolutely beautiful
Nicola Benedetti and the NYO under Mark Wigglesworth deliver a performance of this fabulous concerto that blends rigorous control and attention to the finest of details with seemingly unbridled spontaneity and sheer enjoyment. A clear sign of meticulous rehearsing and genuine passion.
Thank you all for an unforgettable evening.
Viewers: If you turn off the sound from 35:00 to 37:55 you'll spare yourselves the inane drivel spouted by the two radio presenters.
Astonishing performance and wonderful bonus having the NYO too! Altogether impressive!
Another unbelievable performance, from an unbelievable artist
Bravo! Nice playing. Thanks.
Great performance as always and great speech on the gratitude to the Orchestra.
Nicola was Superbly Classical Musician
Beautiful Girl.
Robin❤️
You are great!
My favorite!!
Just wonderful
Benedetti ha un braccio destro davvero eccezionale.
本当に素晴らしい演奏で素晴らしいパフォーマンスです。
二コラ・ベネディティさんは今の世界では一流のバイオリン演奏者だと言って過言ではありません。
greeting from island nikki!
Exquisite. No less
audio clip low, amazing performance faster than the devil.. so passional in red dress
A very nice and natural performance this is. Nicky does not sound like she's trying to play,...she is playing.
The soloist was undermiked on the BBC broadcast, in my opinion . I would imagine that the sound here on utube is from the same mix but it doesn't seem quite as bad as the live broadcast.
Have you been live there in the hall? I mean, how can you know how loud she really played….?
I have no idea how it sounded in the hall. I was at home listening to the signal sent by the media.@@leonardoiglesias2394
dommage que le son ne soit pas très bon pour un morceau si magnifique, on entend à peine avec le son de la video à fond
Showing this to my little girl who, like Nicola, is a leftie, and just getting started on the violin!
Most of this is amazing! When I first saw it on TV live I didn’t think it was great, about a month later I saw her play it live and it was truly outstanding. I think it was way too fast, and I don’t think that was Nicola’s fault, as when I saw it live it was slower. The orchestra was amazing but overall it was conducted far too fast,. Not one of Nicola’s best, but it was still incredibly characterful and bright!
Try this, same orchestra and conductor, different soloist. It was recorded a few days after the Proms. ua-cam.com/video/yeLdCMTK1cg/v-deo.html
Quem veio pelo kami ver essa beleza? Sz
The sound of the video is low, but still enjoyable. The tempo a bit too fast for my taste. Benedetti wonderful, as ever. And the orchestra, boy, they're so young xddd but they sound fabulous.
I miss more agresivity in some violin solo phrases and in the FF of 1st mov theme of full orchestra less fast
the 2010 Decca version, here on utube, is far better. Check it out.
the conductor has made it too fast! they are all wonderful players otherwise
generally a good performance but sounded a bit thin. Could have been just the way she plays but sometimes have difficulty hearing the violin as a solo instrument
Still as fizzy as eh!
Too fast
way too fast in my opinion and also some of the scale runs are not very in tune
Couldn't agree more. It's not about being a Beckmesser and finding fault with every little thing, rather why do performers (not just her, Yuja Wang, among pianists) take such insanely fast tempi - faster than what the music will actually support, and, in this case, faster than the solist can play them? The 3rd movemnt is an absolute mess, which is a shame, because I'm sure this artist could play it better.
She is seriously over rated when you look at the competition(Batiashvili, H Hahn, Hadelich...the list goes on.)
Miles too fast for the soloist and orchestra, who cannot handle the faster development section of the 1st movement, let alone the final movement which is a blurred disaster of manic overspeed. It doesn't make the music more exciting. It just makes everything sound like a complete mess. The NYO strings sound fundamentally very good, as do the brass, but they lose rhythmic control when directed to play at ridiculous speeds. It's not their fault. It is the conductor. Nicola would also benefit from a much slower pace. She is rushing, seemingly out of desperate panic, smudging and glossing over many difficult phrases because again it is too damn fast. Mark Wigglesworth is very poor in this performance. He fails to reign in runaway speed.
Having said all that I think that Nicola is a lovely person and a very good teacher.
And yet this concert was given 5 * and chosen by the Arts Desk as one of the best classical music concerts of 2019...
shutup cut them some slack, they're all under 18 players. By that standard this orchestra is incredible.
@@Cocolinmichela that means nothing.
@@hotelkilo5190 Its not the orchestra's fault-they're fine: its the conductor. At 6.40 he adopts a speed that's faster than anything so far. Clueless.
@@matthewtaylor7725 Good point.
Mediocre version by Nicola Benedetti of the Tchaikovsky Violin Concerto, perhaps a problem with the microphone, its a struggle to hear her play ?
under-miced yes, but if you can't hear the quality in her playing, you're deaf 😁
You were clearly listening to a different performance.
@@lesleyvivien2876 And you are easily satisfied !! I am used to listening to both live and video performances of far higher quality performances of many amazing violin concertos including this one by Tchaikovsky. To mention just one case of comparison, I have been on separate occasions to live performances of the virtuoso violinist Sarah Chang and Nicola Benedetti playing the Bruch Violin Concerto, Sarah Chang far more powerful performer and expressive violinist, just different class. As a few others have mentioned, she may have had problems with her microphone in this performance.
@@512Squared
SHe is ok, but nowhere near the very best violinist who I have watched both in live performances and on UA-cam. Even when only 12 years old, the young Sarah Chang was far better and a lot more powerful and expressive violinist. She of course became on of the very best violinists in the world, Nicola Benedetti is not at the same level as Sarah and many others I could mention. As a few others have mentioned, she may have had problems with her microphone in this performance.
@@lesleyvivien2876 Two more FAR better recording ...now try to tell me you cannot notice the vast difference !!!
ua-cam.com/video/pgGk9tdqP28/v-deo.html
Sayaka Shoji plays Tchaikovsky : Violin Concerto in D major, Op.35
The young Sarah Chang....different class !!
Tchaikovsky Violin Concerto in D Op 35 장영주(Sarah Chang)
ua-cam.com/video/sjPBkATHlgM/v-deo.html
Bad conductor. Too big orchestra