I am watching all these interviews and all that's on my mind is that these poor citizens speaking up must have been persecuted by the chinese government when this documentary came out. I truely hope they are all fine and safe.
My parents paid a large fine retroactively, after I was born in late 70s, because I was the 2nd child. The 3rd child didn’t have my luck, so I never got the chance to meet my little sister or brother.
It seems that the 1 child policy has become a mere money-making racket, as there is no longer any need for severe family planning in China. But the policy is continued because women have to pay high fines for more pregnancies. In other words, it's allowed to have more children, as long as you can pay the tens of thousands of euros "fines" for it
Thanks for this documentary and thanks to all participants for their bravery to speak their truth. Truth, trust and morality are human gems, sometimes they have to be hidden for reasons that make no sense. Systems that take human rights and are inflexible in responding to crimes hurt the very people they pretend to protect. The mental health toll on the women, the families, doctors and staff that abort and people that round up women would be enormous. I hope the future will look different. Control is not breeding morality.
A government should never be against their majority people. A government should never rule over human rights. Russia China North Korea and Cuba are wrong in trying to take over people’s fundamental right of happiness and dignity of freedom. People in different countries should have the right to learn how to be free and equal to others and not be punished for their rights to choose what they want in their lives.
Believe or not, the Russian government is trying to discourage women from getting higher education and having carriers, but rather encourage (force) women to have kids. One politician even said, 'First the baby, then the University'.
That is nice to say BUT communist countries care less about human rights. Everything they dictate is "for the good of the country." ie. the whole. Individualism is not number one, but rather the good of the collective. Many countries unfortunately have that ideology (my opinion).
Its crazy that you used yo be called tp do a pregnancy test and ultrasound and are MADE to abort if pregnant . The mental and physical damage of these women must have been huge .thank goodness they stopped it in 2016. But it doesnt help these women that it happened to .
Men must be educated to were protection as not to impregnated their girlfriend or wifes under China's Family Plan rules. Men must be responsible in their relationships.
This issue is so difficult. If a large number of families opt for having like four, five or more children, this would cause problems. On the other hand, this is very unlikely. Writing in 2024, families are now entitled to have three children, but most families now choose to have only one due to economic pressure. The problem of an aging population remains
Doubt that would make a difference. Communist countries have many women who will enforce the gov't line. The women are the worst for forcing other women to hold up to 'community standards ' In communist countries, the collective (town, village, city) pressure, enforce the company line. Those who do not comply are punished, shamed, ghosted, and sometimes assaulted. The power of community rules and entrusted by gov't to do it.
So sad and scary ordeal for pregnant mothers. Come stay in Malaysia to give birth and return back to China. I always think that the government should have a general country quota for household who wants extra babies can apply. Aiyah! Malaysia need more chinese population. Our Chinese Population is not enough.
They do treat their people differently but they force them into place and expectations of what everyone needs to do. They were mention that a lot of people are unsatisfied with their closed system and want it to be open. It was told to me that they usually frown on the people asking for it to be open. They have a decent amounts of suicide and attacks within their own people because they don't like what their culture is doing within there. "They are offended to be me." When I was in there, there had recently been one family member going homicidal on another member of the government and the suiciding. They were torturing the family to find information to see if the others were like it.
Great job in the disguise department! No one will ever know that woman's identity bcos the thrift store wig completely changes her face 🤣 especially since facial recognition tech is used by the ccp
One child policy is harsh and against human rights however, if China do not have this policy, then they will face problems from over population. Damn either way. Watched a few documentary about poverty and the main cause is mainly over population. Like in the Philippines, every family has so many children.
We need to keep praying in our lifes for couples in china because they are still restrited to having children. We need to keep praying that God can put knowledge in us and love in our hearts to respet and enjoy the rigth to life 🙏 wishing better times for people opressed in this world 🙏 may humanity opend their mind to love.
I'm so sad that so few of you western people really care about what china gov done to chinese people, but so many of you are happy to see videos show how China "helped the africa".
DECEMBER 7TH 2023. 11:54 PM DALLAS TEXAS🇺🇸 I HAD TO STOP WATCHING FOR NOW..MY HEART IS SO FULL OF TEARS I CAN'T CONTINUE TODAY. MAYBE TOMORROW I WILL FINISH WATCHING. . BLESSINGS TO ALL MANKIND.
Lol cent army, why CCP didn’t allowed free internet? And kill more people than other other empire and dynasty combine. Like CCp kill 70 million chine and kill 500 million baby. I was like wow 70 million.
@@chaos5104 A death toll of 100 million figure has been documented by the authors D.E. Stannard, author of American Holocaust, D.E. Stannard has said, "The destruction of the Indians of the Americas was, far and away, the most massive act of genocide in the history of the world." . And apparently it didn't take long for the Europeans to get this genocide started. Today there are only around 5 million Native Americans left in the United States (Navajo Times). Is it really likely that the area encompassing the U.S. only had 5 million people when the Europeans arrived? We doubt that. After all, as a point of comparison, the population of Africa had approximately 86 million people in the year 1500 (Demography: Analysis and Synthesis, Four Volume Set: A Treatise in Population, p. 42).
Between 200million and 400million births prevented by one child policy. Forcing family planning such as this is absolutely disturbing and China is now suffering the consequences with a rapidly declining population growth. The great leap forward was bad but then unfortunately things go worse, especially for women.
If ur going to narrate, narrate everything! Not a few narrated sentences and the rest has to be read onscreen! There are people who can't see the print!
Exactly, different country, different social economic background, DIFFERENT LAW!! Unfortunately, she knowingly broke the law so she must face the consequence. Harsh as it may appear to those 'Well Fed' people of the FREE WEST, but given China's dire social economic background, this 'one child' policy was a necessary move in reducing abject poverty and propelling rapid development, it is another 'SACRIFICE' made by the people. Obviously there are some blowback including a huge ageing population and an imbalanced boy/girl ratio, but every action has a consequence.
No woman should be forced to have a child through rape, incest, trafficking or pedophila Nor should a woman be forced to terminate her pregnancy.
You are talking about the 4% of the causes of induced abortions, dont use that weak argument
I am watching all these interviews and all that's on my mind is that these poor citizens speaking up must have been persecuted by the chinese government when this documentary came out. I truely hope they are all fine and safe.
They're all Chinese people.
@@peekaboopeekaboo1165 We all know that. It was a post about worrying about repercussions for speaking out.
My parents paid a large fine retroactively, after I was born in late 70s, because I was the 2nd child. The 3rd child didn’t have my luck, so I never got the chance to meet my little sister or brother.
I’m so sorry. Please know the rest of the world has heavy hearts for your suffering. ❤
It seems that the 1 child policy has become a mere money-making racket, as there is no longer any need for severe family planning in China. But the policy is continued because women have to pay high fines for more pregnancies. In other words, it's allowed to have more children, as long as you can pay the tens of thousands of euros "fines" for it
This is an abomination and is a crime against humanity. My god.
Thanks for this documentary and thanks to all participants for their bravery to speak their truth. Truth, trust and morality are human gems, sometimes they have to be hidden for reasons that make no sense. Systems that take human rights and are inflexible in responding to crimes hurt the very people they pretend to protect. The mental health toll on the women, the families, doctors and staff that abort and people that round up women would be enormous. I hope the future will look different. Control is not breeding morality.
Prayers 🙏 for all those hurt and hurting from the unfairness of all this. God Bless
This makes me so angry! I have no words to say about the coward court!
A government should never be against their majority people. A government should never rule over human rights. Russia China North Korea and Cuba are wrong in trying to take over people’s fundamental right of happiness and dignity of freedom. People in different countries should have the right to learn how to be free and equal to others and not be punished for their rights to choose what they want in their lives.
Believe or not, the Russian government is trying to discourage women from getting higher education and having carriers, but rather encourage (force) women to have kids. One politician even said, 'First the baby, then the University'.
@@АнастасияКуликова-р2ч very traditional 😂😂😂
That is nice to say BUT communist countries care less about human rights. Everything they dictate is "for the good of the country." ie. the whole. Individualism is not number one, but rather the good of the collective. Many countries unfortunately have that ideology (my opinion).
Its crazy that you used yo be called tp do a pregnancy test and ultrasound and are MADE to abort if pregnant . The mental and physical damage of these women must have been huge .thank goodness they stopped it in 2016. But it doesnt help these women that it happened to .
Men must be educated to were protection as not to impregnated their girlfriend or wifes under China's Family Plan rules. Men must be responsible in their relationships.
Corect
To have a spine and realize that they literally CAN NOT do that. It is a crime/evil by all rules of nature.
Thats not the bloody point
@@marionsmith4728 Makes me wonder who sponsored those replies. Let me guess ... lol
My heart hurts for Xia & her family 💔😢
This issue is so difficult. If a large number of families opt for having like four, five or more children, this would cause problems. On the other hand, this is very unlikely. Writing in 2024, families are now entitled to have three children, but most families now choose to have only one due to economic pressure. The problem of an aging population remains
You are doing a comendable , exceptional and outstanding job with your art work❤🎉
Me quedo con este video para pensar durante todo el año. Gracias👏👏
There are no women on the standing committee
Doubt that would make a difference. Communist countries have many women who will enforce the gov't line. The women are the worst for forcing other women to hold up to 'community standards ' In communist countries, the collective (town, village, city) pressure, enforce the company line. Those who do not comply are punished, shamed, ghosted, and sometimes assaulted. The power of community rules and entrusted by gov't to do it.
Does anyone know if he sells his paintings???? I would be very very interested in buying one!!
i can only shead a tear 😢and say a prayer 🙏 for you
🤲God hears your case, and He will give you justice.
After few more weeks the lawyer and those people disappeared 🥸
So sad and scary ordeal for pregnant mothers. Come stay in Malaysia to give birth and return back to China. I always think that the government should have a general country quota for household who wants extra babies can apply. Aiyah! Malaysia need more chinese population. Our Chinese Population is not enough.
They do treat their people differently but they force them into place and expectations of what everyone needs to do.
They were mention that a lot of people are unsatisfied with their closed system and want it to be open.
It was told to me that they usually frown on the people asking for it to be open.
They have a decent amounts of suicide and attacks within their own people because they don't like what their culture is doing within there. "They are offended to be me."
When I was in there, there had recently been one family member going homicidal on another member of the government and the suiciding. They were torturing the family to find information to see if the others were like it.
Great job in the disguise department! No one will ever know that woman's identity bcos the thrift store wig completely changes her face 🤣 especially since facial recognition tech is used by the ccp
One child policy is harsh and against human rights however, if China do not have this policy, then they will face problems from over population. Damn either way. Watched a few documentary about poverty and the main cause is mainly over population. Like in the Philippines, every family has so many children.
This is true. Although this programme is sad, we can't underestimate the problems over-population causes.
God prayers for these women we got the opposite problem here in the states
The government is afraid someone competent is gonna be born and take over 🤣🤣🤣
These Doctors should be ashamed off themselves ,what about there hypocratic oath "do no harm"
Doctors in china do not take the hippocratic oath 😢
@@Mink_Tracks They shouldn't be doctors then
Thank you for showing truth!!
We need to keep praying in our lifes for couples in china because they are still restrited to having children. We need to keep praying that God can put knowledge in us and love in our hearts to respet and enjoy the rigth to life 🙏 wishing better times for people opressed in this world 🙏 may humanity opend their mind to love.
I'm so sad that so few of you western people really care about what china gov done to chinese people, but so many of you are happy to see videos show how China "helped the africa".
That lawyer is doing God's work 🙌
DECEMBER 7TH
2023. 11:54 PM
DALLAS TEXAS🇺🇸 I HAD TO STOP WATCHING FOR NOW..MY HEART IS SO FULL OF TEARS I CAN'T CONTINUE TODAY. MAYBE TOMORROW I WILL FINISH WATCHING. .
BLESSINGS TO ALL MANKIND.
What of women who were forcefully starilised
Chinese are very harmless, childish, innocent, cute, and naive to god.
FAMILY PLANNING GLOBALLY, JUST MAKES RESPONSIBLE SENSE
Yes Commy what about
Ethics won’t allow that.
56:06 wow bravo
traduzir em português 👉🇧🇷
so ENDEVR is another CIA and MI6 collaboration? congrats to the two agencies - your production values are much better than before
Lol cent army, why CCP didn’t allowed free internet? And kill more people than other other empire and dynasty combine. Like CCp kill 70 million chine and kill 500 million baby. I was like wow 70 million.
@@chaos5104
A death toll of 100 million figure has been documented by the authors D.E. Stannard, author of American Holocaust, D.E. Stannard has said, "The destruction of the Indians of the Americas was, far and away, the most massive act of genocide in the history of the world." . And apparently it didn't take long for the Europeans to get this genocide started.
Today there are only around 5 million Native Americans left in the United States (Navajo Times). Is it really likely that the area encompassing the U.S. only had 5 million people when the Europeans arrived? We doubt that. After all, as a point of comparison, the population of Africa had approximately 86 million people in the year 1500 (Demography: Analysis and Synthesis, Four Volume Set: A Treatise in Population, p. 42).
Between 200million and 400million births prevented by one child policy. Forcing family planning such as this is absolutely disturbing and China is now suffering the consequences with a rapidly declining population growth. The great leap forward was bad but then unfortunately things go worse, especially for women.
If ur going to narrate, narrate everything! Not a few narrated sentences and the rest has to be read onscreen! There are people who can't see the print!
I had to slow the "closed captioned" to .75 or 75% speed so my students had a chance of trying to read that fast.
Must tell ALL this country bumpkins to watch The Story of Xing Fu 😂😂幸福到万家
BBC's under-world-color-effects all through 😅😅😅😅
I like chinese.
China 1 child
If you believe this....u believe anything
sure, go and live in rural China to find out, you CCP symp.
👏
but in my opinion there is also a rule so they should first follow that and avoid second child🤪
Exactly, different country, different social economic background, DIFFERENT LAW!! Unfortunately, she knowingly broke the law so she must face the consequence.
Harsh as it may appear to those 'Well Fed' people of the FREE WEST, but given China's dire social economic background, this 'one child' policy was a necessary move in reducing abject poverty and propelling rapid development, it is another 'SACRIFICE' made by the people.
Obviously there are some blowback including a huge ageing population and an imbalanced boy/girl ratio, but every action has a consequence.