Unloved and Forgotten - China's Children of Shame | ENDEVR Documentary
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 лют 2024
- Children of Shame | ENDEVR Documentary
Watch' Growing Up Poor: Hidden Homeless Kids 'here: • Growing Up Poor: Hidde...
Miao Miao, her brother Xiaolong, and Xin Liao are some of the luckier kids who live in the Sun Villages created by Mrs. Zhang Shuqin. But in reality, they have a heavy past and present to cope with. As the other young dwellers there, they are the offspring of people sentenced to death. This documentary shows the lives and daily routines of these children and their benefactors over two years.
Many of the people sentenced to death leave behind young orphans who are not taken care of at all by social services, even when their families or relatives cannot afford to do it. Also, these vulnerable children are generally despised and rejected by the rest of the community - and are not eligible for adoption. Because as a famous Chinese proverb says: «tigers do not bear puppies». Like Florence Nightingale, one woman, Mrs. Zhang Shuqin, has decided to turn the children’s destiny into her life’s struggle. She has set up ten orphanages to raise them. In these orphanages, called «Sun Villages», everybody works hard to offer the «children of shame» a more positive future.
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Subscribe to ENDEVR for free: bit.ly/3e9YRRG
Facebook: bit.ly/2QfRxbG
Instagram: / endevrdocs
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
#FreeDocumentary #ENDEVR #china
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
ENDEVR explains the world we live in through high-class documentaries, special investigations, explainer videos, and animations. We cover topics related to business, economics, geopolitics, social issues, and everything in between that we think are interesting. - Наука та технологія
Children of shame are the offspring of people sentenced to death in China. This documentary shows the lives of these innocent children who are shunned by society and their benefactor over the course of two years.
We are hopeful to bring a follow up on some of these kids who are grown ups now. We will keep you posted.
Could you start writing the year these documentaries come out?
A follow up would be amazing.
I would love a follow up. this was an amazing documentairy.
Shameful! China this is so shaming. I'm disgusted for these poor children getting the brunt of what their irresponsible parents did.
What an amazing , kind woman - with the biggest ❤!!
I’m 8 minutes in and I want to hug that sobbing great-grandmother, left alone when the others got into the van. I can only imagine how torn she felt, knowing she couldn’t take care of them but loving them and fearing for their safety with strangers.
💔😞😞
Yeah she was left alone and yelled at literally
That " aunty"is sooo rude for shouting a her like that. I really dislike people like that
Something was off with the auntie. She reeks of drug use.
🎉 I was touched by the great-grand mother. I wanted to hug her and be by her side to make her company. 😢
Wow! That woman (that runs the orphanage) just became one of my favorite people on the planet. People like her make the world better for everyone and barely anyone knows it.
Maybe she doesn't want to be famous.
And your logic makes me doubt that in 2 weeks you will change and start being a better person. Or remember you watched this...
There’s tons of abuse that goes on there still. I know plenty of Asian women that have been adapted and came to America and told me how hard it was there. The endless “cinderella” mentality, and sec abuse
She deserves intl recognition.
You are absolutely right. She is amazing ❤
Salute to that grandpa who left his whole family because they rejected their grandchildren so he chose to follow them😭 he is the real super hero
And he is rewarded with a relationship with his grandkids! ❤️ we should all be inspired by him and the others in this video who chose not to give up on these precious children
He is a real man, for sure, left everything he knew just to be close to them.
What an amazing MAN HE IS. That touched my heart.
China's government.
I felt so much respect for him
It breaks my heart that these children should be shamed because of their parents. Shame for the Chinese government not helping these children !
Why abandoned little children? Why has morality, compassion, fear is?what does a little child know. Most of a hatred against society start at a little age,so disappointed
This kind of stigma will probably take a lifetime to overcome. Healing a broken heart without the guidance of loving parents will be difficult
Esto existe en toda Asia... pregunta a los coreanos o japoneses
Omg, it like a Klignon society.... How terrible. 😢😢 Can foreigners adopt those poor children?
@@mst-pierrem5729 The Chinese government is motivated by money. It would help these poor kids if they could get out of China and to other countries.
Asking children questions like "What do you feel about your father killing your mother?" or "What do you feel being a child of shame?" is traumatic to a child. This will cause them to avoid people because they are afraid that they would ask these kinds of questions again.
exactly what i was thinking
A person needs to be careful wit- cildren.....I a-ree wit- your statement. I WELL-put.
Why to even ask a child this question!?!🐍👹💩
i think its probably a translation issue. a lot of languages are very very blunt but it isnt rude or mean. she couldve meant it along the lines of a therapist needing to know your mindset to get help
They're following a psychological method to openly treat their family and social trauma. That's very important and there's nothing wrong with it at all.
Great Grandmother likely died of a broken heart. The absolute look of dispair on her face was gut retching
Exactly what I thought
She was over 90 tho. 93 I think they said so she wouldn’t have lasted long enough to raise those children. But she was so broken hearted I cried
Definitely could be a factor. Part of me wants to believe she knew her grandchildren were safe now and could finally pass on :C
grief takes a heavy toll and the elderly are even more vulnerable to it.
Agreed
9 years old and she would rather work 10hrs a day than go to school because she's aware they can't afford to send her to school breaks my heart. Children shouldn't have to experience this..😢
a country that does not allowtheir kids to attend school and be treated equally for whatever reason should be ashamed - at least some of the people in China do not follow their government's despise
My heart broke for that Beautiful Grandmother, but how rude and abusive was the younger woman yelling at her. God bless the children. The children shouldn't have been subjected to the prison visit.
It's their culture. Did you watch her daughter shame her in son while holding his children for the last time? Let her granddaughter work in a factory at 9? The girl can't attend school because they have no money. Prisoners selling their organs or having them stolen. They have death busses, ffs! They're not westerners. China has spent hundreds of years as a closed society. I'm shocked this documentary was even allowed to be released. Then again, China can see the decline in the west. They have nothing to be ashamed of anymore.
im pretty sure she was cheering her up but it sounded like she was yelling because you dont know the language
The younger woman is not yelling at the grandma (looks like it). She just talk her out no to be so sad, let the kids go to have a better life.
@@bingbingdan . Exactly, I worked with Chinese people and sometimes I thought they were arguing but it's the way they speak normally
I used to volunteer in a prison helping kids who visited offenders. In my country we don't have the death penalty, but it was still important for the kids to see their family. Its sad, but that little boy had the right to meet his father. I do think the grandma was making things worse though, but I doubt I'd be calm if my son was being killed.
So sad yelling at the grandmother, because it’s easier for them to give them up than for her. So hard watching them scold the father, while the children cry. Heart breaking.
Cruel is what it is.
RIGHT! let her grieve the separation of her grandkids
I cried seeing this
Sooo sooo sad...that kids came to this world abandoned by their parents ....they don't know love....but stranger are angle send by God to save them ...stay happy children's of God🙏🙏🙏
Seems very familiar to me and many other Chinese-Americans. Is someone crying for an understandable reason? Of course then double-down and scream at them even harder, tell them to get over themselves. Ugh.
I do hope that this lady with a golden heart will receive a Noble prize she is a Angel in disguise , a rare Chinese treasure . God bless her
Unfortunately she definitely won’t win because it will bring shame to the fact that china government provided no support or funding for the children. In fact, China was more focused on 1 child policy and aborting babies when she was rescuing innocent lives.
Nobel Prize.
Sure, she's not allegedly selling the kids to sex work or something so, yeah... Sure...
Watch at 49:25
she got a Nobel price and recognize by the awesome Chinese government, and she is well known in China 😃👍. Love my awesome and beautiful China always 💕💕💕🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳 love Vietnam 💕💕💕🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳 love Russia 💕💕💕🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺 love Thailand and Singapore💕💕💕🇹🇭🇹🇭🇹🇭🇹🇭🇹🇭🇹🇭💕💕💕🇸🇬🇸🇬🇸🇬🇸🇬🇸🇬🇸🇬!!!
The great grand mother at the beginning broke my heart. May she rest in peace. May these poor children be able to heal from all this pain. There is no such thing as 'children of shame', but little human beings who need love and protection.
As the only survivor of 3 abandoned and abused children, I can boldly say that if we had been put in a place like this , all 3 of us would have survived, so, thumbs up for everybody doing this type of lives saving labor
I’m so sorry, you are so strong and loved and my heart goes out to your family. No one should have to have memories like that. I pray that your life becomes easy one day 🤍
"My father killed my mother and was imprisoned. He came home in a box of ashes"
I am just heartbroken for these children.
It is such a horrible thing for a child to go through, seeing your parent in prison for the last time.
Sorry about that
And he sold his organs before execution and family never got the money. Painful
I feel heartbroken for them, the first boy on beginning of the movie put me in tears so much sadness on his eyes, no children should go through this sadness 😢
but but but china is the safest place on the earth and with out crime... how can this be so?!? /s
@@raymasternobody says that about china..youre thinking of japan🙄
The translation is inaccurate in the beginning making Mrs. Zhang sound cruel. She didn’t say, “They (the parents) will never look after you.” She was telling them that their parents have long prison sentences, the dad won’t be out for 17 years, and the mom was sentenced to death, so they won’t be together for a long period of time.
Should be pinned
There were quite a few mistranslations in this documentary, some were plain wrong.
OHHH thank you for mentioning this... I was so disturbed by her explanation. It seems like a lot of Chinese content is poorly translated.
Thank you for the correction
Thank you!
25:28 Finally, a family member with a heart. One that wasn't "ashamed" to not stick around. That grandfather is awesome 👏🏻
Well, he was probably shamed in his village b/c it was his son that murdered his daughter-in-law. He too has a better life at the orphanage, being accepted and being able to be there to see and support his grandchildren daily. It was a win-win situation.
@@megostop9650yet his wife stayed behind and wants nothing to do with her own grandchildren, who are innocent of their father’s crimes. I think the grandfather’s motives are much more for his grandchildren than himself.
I feel that these documentaries should be shown in schools.I get influenced by these videos positively,as it makes me more sympathetic and encouraged to proceed such charitable acts.I hope one day I could help the destitute,lonely,needy
THISSSS
I was thinking the same. These sort of videos shows how little we do for our society and that in fact are tons of people out there that need help and we don't even know it.
I'm glad we all agree
The woman that opened sun village is an absolute saint! And deserves the Nobel peace prize. She’s an amazing caring loving woman who has given all those children a chance a home and love .
The Nobel Prize is a scam, only thieves, liars and fraudsters receive it (I have no doubt that there are people who deserve it like this beautiful lady) I would appreciate more the gifts from people who admire her, those for me would be the real Nobel Prizes.
Yes been said many times.⬆️
@jesseniavargasGood!!!...It needs to be stated more!!!6969
She deserves the Nobel Peace Prize! She has shown true compassion and love for the forgotten children of China.
Yes been said many times.⬆️
Against the society, she is a beacon of hope, and with great passion she will be loved and cherished by many. People like her give hope for all humanity.
Sadly, she was up against Obama, so she lost.
SMH!
She’s prolly selling them into sex slavery
Lol nobel Peace 😮😅 ✌🏽
That was unnecessarily traumatic for those kids.
What a selfish grandmother to wail at her son while he holds his kids for the first and last time.
what can she do? her son is dying. she was saying her grandson looked exactly like him as a kid :(
Adults can express their anguish too especially in such a desperate hopeless situation. Bottling it up is not going to fix it
@@damla5665 the kids will be here so much longer than she will. Why be so selfish in that moment to affect those kids memories of their dad that way.
You can directly see the effect it had on those kids. They need protecting not traumatizing. Your opinion is a selfish attitude. It should always and only be about the small suffering children.
@@priskruger314 the kids need protecting from the words the grandmother was wailing.
In that moment, it wasn't appropriate to hear their grandmother speak about their father like that. He was holding them both. For the last time. And that is what they had to hear from her. Those words will stay with them forever.
It should have been a private quiet moment. She ruined it with her selfish trauma dump.
End of story.
It should be and always is about what's going to help and protect the kids. They had suffered enough.
It's incredibly selfish minded to overlook that.
@@emmadoesyoutubeYes all she cared about was herself. Then took the little girl out of the orphanage to poison her mind and use her as a slave.
that she was a prison guard stunned me, amazing turnaround to being godmother of 2000 and more. i havent cried these kinds of tears in a long time, am thankful that this came up on my feed.
'' I haven't gone out to play for so long, I've forgotten '' This is the most heartbreaking,heart wrenching thing I've ever heard a child say. She's completely broken down emotionally and at a tipping point 😢😢😢😢😢
The saddest thing on Earth is to see children suffer
Heart wrenching when I heard those words 😢😢😢
That broke my heart! How come?Why? I feel like crying and crying......I pray Jesus to come soon and rescue children like them they deserve better.
She should go to school. I understand her grandmother but she really shouldn't work at that age.
At the orphanage she and her younger brother have a better chance at a good future.
As they get their education and discipline they can earn more money and have better jobs. And in return they will be able to take better care of their grandmother.
This video touch my heart and I’m crying and can’t stop. The beautiful lady that runs the orphanage is so caring, she is saving those beautiful little children. She deserves the Nobel peace prize for all the hard and good work she does. She gives all her love and dedication to the children and that is exactly what those innocent kids need.
the woman running the orphanages has made a difference to every child that walked through the doors and stayed. she is a savior .and a hero. we need more like her in this world.
be that person
There are many small phrases she said that weren't translated but are extremely heart-warming. Like walking by the garden, she pointed out to some pea plants and asked the girl if she knows what peas are and would she like to plant them. It's easy to tell she really changes the world over and over with each child, breaking the cycle.
You see her on film for a few seconds and you assume she is a good person. People have many sides to them. You need to understand that Chinese act polite that way, but are not always really that nice on the inside.
I would not trust her 1 second! Cold cruel lady! Telling children their mother is sentenced to death, what more damage can be done? Sadistic!
You should also wathc the documentary "dying rooms" about what happens in many chinese orphanages.
Oh my heart hurts for these babies 😓. Grandma Zang is an incredible woman and deserves the Nobel peace prize!
So many tragic stories. I feel most heartbroken for Distant Heart. She's endured so much and then taken out of the orphanage to become what looks like the family's indentured servant, and working 10 hours a day. Unimaginable. 😢
Don’t yell at the grandmother she’s allowed to cry, and worry that’s love ❤❤❤😢
Exactly
Yes 🥹
I feel sad seeing her granddaughter yelled at her like that. Obviously to the sister, her brothers' kids are baggage and she doesn't wanna be financially responsible, while the great grandma genuinely care about the children and sad to see them go. After all with her age she can't easily see them anymore once they are sent out.
@@Quadrilingual_mom So very true! Grand-daughter is very disrespectful to her grandmother to say the least.
@@Quadrilingual_momgrandma should tell her to go live elsewhere if she is that nasty imo.
Little Dragon & Little Bud`s grandfather is a higher spiritual being, who follows that beat of a different drum. Seemingly he understands the difference between the letter of the law and the spirit of the law. People who resist caring for their orphaned children, because of shame, need to learn that they are the very ones, for whom we should feel shame. Such a loving, dutiful grandfather, will no doubt be remembered for many generations, in the stories of his grandchildren. A kind heart enables spiritual growth. Pridefulness shrinks and diminishes the soul.
The grandfather is a wonderful human being, puts his grandchildren above his wife (who didn't want to see the grandchildren)..which is sad all around...
Its not they feel shame but are shamed by neighbors & government it's only human to not want that persecution therefor will confirm. I agree most are doing what the goverment expects of them while the granpa is following his heart despite being judged and shamed for it
That poor grandma... my heart wept for her and how she must have felt. Thank you for sharing this documentary with us... certainly eye opening to a different cultural struggle.
The welcoming ceremony is so heart warming! New brothers and sisters 😭
Its so hard to wrap my head around how mothers, grandmothers, uncles, etc just abandon these kids and even refuse to see them!! The one grandpa had to leave the grandma because she'd rather be alone then help raise her grandbabies. OMG
China is a desperately poor country. There is no food stamps, no welfare, no food banks, you must pay for school and school supplies. People starve to death in China. It is a brutal place and I lived there for 2 years. You have old people working hard physical labor but not earning enough to afford a bowl of noodles. When they say they can't afford to keep the children it it true. Children must have food, medicine and schooling. This orphan lady is a rare gem. Most Chinese care only for their own family and they aren't charitable at all. It is a harsh, unforgiving place where there is a 97% conviction rate and you are guilty unless you can prove your innocent. It is a terrible place.
Very sad indeed! This is the CCP system, and I hope the world won't head in that direction@@happycook6737
HE WAS BETTER OFF WITHOUT THE WOMAN
@@happycook6737China is not a poor country- it has rural/poor areas just like anywhere else. I have friends that come from normal middle class families there and no one is starving. How do you think the US borrows billions from China if they are poor? Thats a horrible and incorrect generalization.
@@happycook6737 damn.... Communism at its finest.
The amount of trauma inflicted upon these poor children is absolutely astounding. Praying things change for them and all the innocent children affected by being forced orphans. Thank goodness Sun Village seems to provide a safe alternative for them.
I PRAY FOR CONTINUED GOOD HEALTH OF GRANDMA ZANG.
I also pray that she will receive more blessings, health and financial support for her work! 10 orphanages not cheap to run!@@williamgarcia1909
No child anywhere in the world deserves to go through this. This documentary was absolutely heartbreaking. Beyond listening to the individual stories of these innocent children (their voices are invaluable), the other take away I see is that the orphanage should get sponsorship.
How can we help?
@@williamgarcia1909absolutely agree with you! 🙏❤️
The lady running the orphanages is an angel. Such a heartbreaking story for the children.
The way people in China communicate so harshly is painful to watch. It’s one thing to speak candidly to an adult but there is a way to explain things to children w/compassion/consideration. Everything is so matter of fact, the tone of voice/yelling doesn’t help either. Highly emotional situations but also symultaneously promoting suppression as a coping mechanism. Seems like a lot of emotionally neglected little people growing up there. “Stop crying, don’t cry… it’ll be ok” meanwhile the child’s entire life is crumbling, they’re abandoned, shamed, confused & scared. Seems like a perfect formula for everything to be ok to me. 🤯
Man. I didn't know this would be so sad. Great documentary so far. Just feel sorry for these babies💔
@ensley97, Life is fill with sadness in many ways, I cry when I see or hear other people cry especially little children a person just wants to hug them and made all their sadness and pain go away from children. To me no child is shameful they are great spirits of love and great spirits. I struggle seeing sad things happen to small children. even grown up's I feel life should be enjoyable feeling great and be rich with life and wellness. thanks for your comment.
@@darleneatkinson3906 I couldn't have said it better ❤️
THANK GOD THERE IS THIS LADY WITH A HEART OF GOLD TO HELP THESE BABIES.
@@williamgarcia1909 Yes. Exactly!!❤️
💔 I can’t watch this I’m already sad. Bless those poor children
This really brings back memories of my childhood. I spent 13 years in a Chinese orphanage from birth before being adopted by an American family. You know, what they show on TV about orphanages? It's mostly just the good stuff. I remember when the media or some charity event came around, we had to be on our best behavior and spruce up the place. But behind the scenes? Totally different vibe. I won't go into detail about my experience in the Chinese orphanage, but just imagine one teacher trying to manage 40-50 kids with different age range. Growing up in a state-funded orphanage as a girl, it wasn't easy. Before I was adopted, they had to find your birth parents first, but that's tricky because, well, abandoning kids is illegal in China. So, of course, no one is going to come forward claiming they're your birth parents. Lucky for me, they couldn't find my birth parents, and I was able to come to America. Also, back then, it was rare to get adopted at the age of 13; the cut-off age, I think, was 14. Otherwise, I'd probably be stuck in China with not much to look forward to.
Tights Hug
how are your adopted parents?
Thank you for coming to America
Welcome to the US. God bless you.
Your story is very inspiring. I hope you get complete healing for the experience
44.54 : This compassionate lady has a heart of gold. She more than deserves to be nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize. People who are able to show love and kindness to broken kids are angels on earth. Bless her soul.
yes, and I know for sure what she'd be doing with the prize...
My heart broke when the little kids started crying in their fathers arms no child should have to go through that
That's so wrong that they are not adoptable their are people all over who can't have children and would love to adopt one of these little ones and give them a good home and a future.
I don't think China allows overseas adoption anymore.
They see the children as being damaged goods so to rehome them they feel the children would bring shame on china by being like their parents
Not in China though we heard one grandmother say they tried to find families with no children, but no-one will adopt the children of criminals who have been executed. Even their own extended families wanted nothing to do with them.
@@juanitarichards1074 seriously? but the babies are innocent.
@@juanitarichards1074superstition!
Im a great grandmother now and I'm remembering my great grandmother. She helped raise me. My father had died and my mother was severely crippled. I loved her So Much! My heart tore out at the pain of the great grandmother here.😢😢
I feel your pain. I am named after my Great-grandmother. She raised me too, as my grandmother died of breastcancer before i was born. I remember her kitchen and flat so vividly, the way she taught me to whip cream, sew, doing crissword-puzzels. and always had time and a heart full of love. My heart breaks for this Great-grandmother too, as i cannot fathom seeing the offspring of so many generations being torn from her. She probably knew it is for the best. But that pain. I wish her healing.
I never knew my great grandmother - I only knew one of my grandparents - my dad's mom. I glad people can know their great-grandparents ! Just how crazy it is for your great grandkids to hear about your own great grandparents!
I remember both of my great grandmothers ❤🥰 Both died 1 week before my daughter's were born. So I nickname my girls Grandma b/c they have old souls.
I felt so much for the all of them.🎉❤😊.
That lady is an angel.🎉❤
Yes. That was at about 8 minutes and I almost decided not to watch the rest because it was so sad.
I am crying my heart out. It hurts so much. God bless those children and their parents.
Wow it's horrible how that woman yelled at her son in front of his children. The poor grandmother who was yelled at by the family member for crying when they were taken away was heartbroken. They are going to suffer the memories the rest of their lives. I surely hope that the children are well taken care of at the orphanage and her sweetness and lovingness wasn't just for the cameras.
Most Chinese are like them. Very insensitive and brutal. People are used to it
Nonsense! How can you say that! You can see that the children were truly loved and loved her back..
Beautiful documentary. I felt very close to tears at that lovely grandfather who moved to the orphanage to be with his grandchildren. My grandmother died when my mother was a baby. She had a lot of brothers and sisters and her father tried but found it so hard to take care of them as well as work. They were put in an orphanage and he moved next door giving his time every Saturday to do any work needed at the orphanage he made sure he was there for his children and although he died before I was born I feel such admiration and love for him.
❤❤❤
Wow life can be so tough! My grandma became an orphan when she was 9 months old and life was very hard for her!
Well, I cried.
I cried for the children’s suffering.
Even though they’re being taken care of well, they still suffer.
I’m so happy many made it good after getting out.
I pray Mrs. Zhang live much longer, and more sponsors to come.
This women who opened orphan for the kids God bless her beautiful heart ❤ .
Also the grandfather who moved to be close to his grand children God bless him . I wish for the innocent kids happiness and success when they grow up
Grandma Zhang is a beautiful, beautiful soul. 🥰🥰
I was cry during whole video … by all my heart , all this kids grow up and have a happy life ! ❤
Heartbreaking.
The psychological damage caused to those kids is really heartbreaking. I hope the Chinese government start realising that if they help fund these orphanages, they will prosper too.
Sadly, the Chinese government isnt interested in the wellbeing of the people. Their only goal is being and staying in control
The Chinese government doesn't care about life.
The CCP won't help! They are only for themselves!
They can barely help is own in poverty how can they help them
The government is creating orphans.
Geez the prison scene with the crying and all is traumatic those poor kids!
Yeah that woman seems crazy
@@user-xx6ud8iq7g Yes - crazy with grief.
@@user-xx6ud8iq7gHer son is the one who recklessly committed a crime despite knowing he has children to care for but she's the crazy one? lol ok
@@RD-nm2xj I don’t think you are even having the same conversation as me? Who are you replying to?
@@user-xx6ud8iq7g Crazy with grief and stress. Looking at her son, about to be executed, children she has to let go of, and brutal farm work ahead for her, as she has to take the place of her son in the fields.
The childrens goodbye to Dad, would've been better if a councilor or support person could've been there, to see the children through, and separately from the distraught family members.
Thank you for this video!! This woman is one of the best people on Earth and definitely deserves Nobel Prize. I also loved the siblings, the girl and the boy are so intelligent. They’re right, capital punishment is a shame on China government, when children are left orphans and also shamed for their parents deeds. I hope after your video Sun Village receives more support and donations, and more organisations like that could be opened.
Such an amazing woman❤ reminds me of the nuns who raised me, back when i was an orphan in Lagos Nigeria...women like them, deserve the world 🌎
❤ from another Nigerian who lived in lagos
They truly do
I like seeing how the community comes together to help these children. Did you see the volunteer doctors? The orphanage would not even run without donations made by members of the community. There are many heroes in this story.
Thank you for pointing this out! The hairdresser even said that she likes to give back because she too used to live in the orphanage as a child.
There are many heroes in this story, indeed!
Shared goodness ❤
I wish there a way to donate directly to this orphanage and others like them, if any more exist. Poor babies. They might have at least spared the mother!!
@@CateVeidt your best bet is contacting the creator of this documentary. I would be very careful though. If you are not sure if the money will go to the people in need, I would not donate.
@@CateVeidtSun Village has a website were you can donate
@@AndrewFreeston-qn7cksuch as ? Please, do elaborate on that.
The joy on their lil faces during the welcome celebration...warmed my heart!! These lil ones will be in my prayers from now on!
This is one of the BEST documentary .. THANK YOU SO MUCH!!
A 9yo working 10hr days in a textile factory. "I didn't like the work, I had to keep my head bent and it gives me back pains". I can't believe her grandmother took her out of Sun Village. What life does she get now? One of poverty and endless shaming. How messed up and sad.
The grandmother took her out to work in the house and in the factory. It is called survival.
@@imhere8380 It's blatant greed.....I'd rather die than subject any child to that.
@@juanitarichards1074 You are looking at it from a Western perspective. At least these children are not subjected to trafficking, addicted to phones, seeing pornography on the internet, not eating junk food etc. Yes, through the lens of privilege westerners it is easy to judge. Life is very difficult for millions around the planet and videos like this show the hard reality of children's lives who have not had a good start to life. It is tragic, frightening and terribly sad.
It is also tragic in our western countries, so many children have parents that take drugs, drink, are addicts, their needs are not met at school or not fitting into social norms. It is tragic too how children have phones accessing into the adult world, losing their innocent so young. It is tragic, so many western children are trafficked, take drugs, run away, are murdered or sexually exploited.
I would rather see that poor kid not go to school, work with their grandparents than be subjected to porn, drugs, junk food, trafficked, sexually abused. I
have spent years in these Chinese villages, and I too was shocked and alarmed, yet in the world we live in today, I don't know who is better off..the kid pulled out of school to help his grandparents, but eats healthy food, or the obese child who is subjected to porn, social pressure, junk food etc.
Life is very tough.
@@juanitarichards1074 a lot say that but the belly tend to disagree
As the director of the orphanage said: I cant do anything against ignorance. This will be a very heavy burden for the girls life. Such a shame
This is the kind of woman I would love to see getting the Woman Of The Year award!!!!
100 %
An actual real 100% woman with a heart of gold. God bless her and the children.
I fully agree with this!🏆🏆
well...
This woman is beyond amazing. She saw a need I never thought of and stepped up big time.
I love love love that beautiful soul who runs the orphanage! You can tell she means the world for those children and she’s so genuine and warm
Look at grandpa he has so much joy to watch his grand kids
OMG! I bawled through that whole documentary :( Those poor children who are not only left orphans, but they are shunned by society and their own families won't raise them. How utterly heartbreaking. I wanted to hug all of them. They deserve so much. The woman running the different Sun Villages is a saint. What a beautiful heart she has. If i had millions of dollars, I would go over there and give them the coolest orphanage they could imagine. New clothes, electronics, supplies, beds, paint job, new buildings....They deserve the best.
I cried too :( My childhood was very abusive. I am just about to have my first baby- a little boy. He will be so very loved. God bless all those who go through such suffering.
I can’t think of anyone who deserves the Nobel peace prize more than Grandmother Zhang. What an amazing woman?!
What is interesting is that they are so concerned about shame but they have no shame in neglecting and rejecting their innocent children when the children need them the most
Wow that prison reunion was just awful! How traumatic for everyone. And the man’s mother “you ruined everything!” Right in front of his children she said that. And instead of a memory for dad it was an occasion filled with shame! That was just terrible! It would have been better if the dad could have hugged them and read a story and played a game so the children would have a happy moment to remember.
Absolutely agreed!
I agree.
mother shouldn't be there honestly.
That was really heartbreaking. So traumatic for those poor children.
You can’t say that…it’s not your culture. The documentary focuses on the kids because they are innocent, but the father is in death row. His mom is expressing her anger and disappointment, and frankly, if that was me, it be worse infront of the kids. Your cautionary tale right there.
What a beautiful introduction to the home and their new family. She's an amazing woman. These children are all blameless and will be helped to make a better life for themselves. We all need to love one another more and we can heal each other.
I can relate to their sorrow, my father died in prison, most walked away from me, so sad. Stay strong. You are not alone.
This is 10 years ago!.. i wonder how all those beautiful souls are now? ❤❤❤
What a cruel country, blaming children for the crimes of the parents. This is the country greedy corporations are making all their products, looking the other way, while all these atrocities happen.
How do you know it's 10yrs old? I only ask because it was only posted 8 days ago on this channel...
@@katharinewhitsthis was filmed in 2014
@@hajtube5189 How did you find out that date? Thank you.
No. this was 8 days ago.
The reunion and goodbye of the father and his children was one of the saddest things I’ve ever watched 😥
Yes for the boy it was the first and last time he would ever meer his father.
I don't think it allows them to mourn. Instead, they become traumatized, especially with grandma wailing all the time.
it was so upsetting to watch. He didn't deserve to see them again, all he did was hurt his children even more, and his mother wailing did not help. it was only for his benefit, not the benefit of his poor children.
Yesss yelling at Grandma
This is a happy and sad documentary. The orphanage is such a beautiful place for these unfortunate children.
So heartbreaking. The poor precious innocent little children are not the ones who committed sins. The people at the orphanage are wonderful, especially that one woman they call grandmother. Such a deep love she has for the innocent children who committed no crimes. Ive been crying this entire documentary. Good job making this.
@7:30 my heart breaks for this beautiful & sweet great-grandmother. She loves them so much and wants to keep them close but finances are in the way. I hope her heart was able to heal. ❤
AT LEAST HER BABIES WILL HAVE A GOOD LIFE TAKEN CARED OF BY THIS LADY WITH HEART OF GOLD.
And the other woman yelling at her. I know it’s probably their culture, but jeezus. Have some compassion for the grandmother !
@@anotherpenny1942it's not her culture. She is rude. I can't stand people like that. Poor old lady!
@@anotherpenny1942Chinese is a tonal language so it sounds harsher than it really it
@@anotherpenny1942 They evolved without the ability to feel compassion.
This documentary is so hard to watch without crying. 😢prayers to all the children.
Thank you. This is my third viewing. I see and hear new things each time. Everyone who watched this film knows there are many more young men and women living in similar circumstances
The lady that runs the orphanage has a heart of GOLD. May God bless her and protect her for her kindness and compassion towards the children. I promise to donate to her cause when I become a millionaire, In shaa Allah.
Why will you only donate when you have so much money you don’t know what to do with it? How about as soon as u have any extra money u will donate
Grandmother Zhang did wonders and deserves the Nobel Prize more than anyone. What a loving and generous woman, she saved so many children with love and compassion.
would never get the Peace Prize, the CCP would never allow it !
They said she has opened nine Sun Villages. Wonderful. God's Blessings on her.
Fantastic documentary. Wept the whole way through.
What an amazing lady, children, and documentary. I cannot stop shedding tears.
These poor children have to deal with so much trauma, it's heartbreaking.
@8.00 Those children were probably the only joy in that grandmother's life. The relative that yelled at her, says everything. It would have been them getting rid of her grandchildren. She will die of a broken heart.
exactly, my instant thought was why are you screaming in her face like that?!
@@felicityjohnston9276disgusting
Chinese is a tonal language. They just talk directly, not out of anger.😊
@@felicityjohnston9276I think it's frustration and desperation. They all are financially supporting and caring for those babies. They can't afford it and realize the kids will have a better life than they can provide. They will eat better live in better conditions and get a better education than the people in their village.
She did die 3 months later likely of a broken heart
Thanks Grandma Zhang for having a big heart. God will bless you abundantly.
It’s amazing how these Sun Villages work . Lovely to see them being well fed and they are nurtured by the lovely lady who runs it.
The fact that we get free videos on UA-cam by ENDEVR is truly a gift ... Keeping education and knowledge alive. 👏👏👏
I think this woman deserves the Nobel Peace Prize. I love her so much
SO DO I. I BELIEVE MOST WHO HAVE WATCHED THIS DOCUMENTARY AGREE.
I agree! But we give a noble prize to war mongering Obama for peace before he was even president. The Nobel prize was forever stained.
Yes been said many times.⬆️
That sweet little girl waving out to someone, just breaks my heart. God keep watch over these dear ones and may there be a family waiting for them.
I cried when the grandmother cried.... the pain and helplessness
These criminals , killers and murderers commit crimes not only against their victims but also against their own families, this documentary highlights the aftermath, the sufferings of the families of the criminals, the heartbreak of these indirect victims is too sad..😢
True, though their treatment after has made society and the government guilty of further crimes of a moral nature.
The Comunism party of China is doing the same. Many people would love to adopted those children, but they created a law that they can not be adopted. In the future, they will use these kids for their own benefits to commit a crime for the elite.😢😢😢😢
The government actions of no support is just an extension of the Chinese concept of justice.
@@JB-et7zs It would be viewed as some kind of reward for the criminals by the families of the victims and their societies. It is a complex issue. Such a criminal has to pay a big sum of money to the families of the victims, according to the Chinese law. The children are supposed to be supported by their extended families. It would cause outrage in the society, if the criminals are viewed as being rewarded.
So, such a program would have to be possible through more private channels or semi-private channels. Zhang's villages had been aided by
China Charities Aid Foundation For Children
which looked like a semi-private foundation. It is authorized by Ministry of Civil Affairs.
How is it better in America? The same thing happens. @@deeb.9250
This documentary deserves high praise and recognition.
It was fascinating and so heartbreaking and sad, all at the same time..
Mrs. Tsang is the definition of a Bodhisattva, living to do good and help humanity her entire life. ❤
Thanks!
That mother and sister yelling and admonishing the man during a prison visit with his poor children should be ashamed of themselves. It was so wrong to do this in front of the children.
Yes it's very wrong but in china kids are just little soldiers in training, It's the same in russia !!!!!!
Damn right
@@jimmybufford5052do not bring that into this situation. The mother was grieving and the kids likely barely understood what was happening.
I was thinking the same thing. Likely the last time (and first for the boy) ever seeing him. A time to say goodbye. Soo sad.
They were grieving in pain, not yelling!
This is absolutely heart broken, I have a 6 year old, even if i somehow passed away, I still want her to be taken care of. I cannot imagine children who are being labeled as unadaptable, they have done nothing wrong.
what about your husband
Thank you for sharing these kids stories and their lives. It was hard to watch. I cried a lot. 😢😢 do you guys have an update on how these kids are doing now an adults? may God continue blessing that woman for opening up her heart to help these kids out because it’s not their fault what their parents did
Thanks so much to the people who takes care of these kids…it’s heartbreaking
Had to watch this documentary in three intervals, being father of two toddlers it was too much to handle this all at once. I am glad there is help for these kids, wish every kid on this planet receives a helping hand and a shoulder to cry on.
that boy Little Dragon is obviously so intelligent. I hope he does well.
Chosing pride over your own family is horrifying
What a heartbreaking and then again very uplifting documentary. Grandma Zhang has a heart of pure gold. How she even stays in touch with the children when they are adults is amazing and a true testament that she truly loves these children and deeply cares for them all……God Bless this beautiful lady and all the sweet children in the orphanages🙏🏼🥰👋🏼🇨🇦 Btw, Mrs.Zhang urgently needs a Nobel Peace Prize!!🍀🌟
This woman is heaven sent ❤ She shines like the sun, even in the very midst of darkness.
God bless her 🙏❤️
When I see that toddler in the arms of his father...wow! The mother/ grandmother can't stop crying. When you have a child they are always a toddler to you, their mother. Seeing her watch both man and boy and know the man (just as much a toddler in her eyes as the boy) will be executed! I can't imagine that kind of pain!!!
Words can't express the emotions I felt throughout this documentary. Bless this woman. ❤
Outstanding documentary. Beyond angelic for the sacrifice and dedication to Mrs. Zhang for her hard work. For the children past present and future, take care and none of this burden should have been placed on your tiny shoulders.
The woman that run the orphanage has the heart of gold. She should be helped by the government and other internationals charity organisations. God bless her.
God bless each one that loves those children
God already took his blessings away. Why not do something real for these poor kids?
@@taylorbug9well you don’t know there is blessing in disguise.
I literally sat here and cried watching this and I thought I had it rough growing up and I did in New York City homeless on the streets at eight years old, begging from chains because of the crack error but I tell you globally it’s just sad thing when I see through so much ❤🙏🏽