When Doctor Who's continuity is on point: Don't forget me

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 сер 2021
  • Now that's what I call continuity. Across two iterations of the show, two spinoffs, and more than 30 years, a single plot thread carries on like no time has passed at all

КОМЕНТАРІ • 917

  • @djco5782
    @djco5782 2 роки тому +4052

    I love the unintentional foreshadowing at the end of The Hand of Fear, with the dog and Sarah Jane whistling "Daddy wouldn't buy me a bow-wow", and the Doctor later sending her K9. They couldn't have planned that any better.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +262

      I had no idea that was what she was whistling. I didn't even draw the connection with the dog.

    • @djco5782
      @djco5782 2 роки тому +91

      @@PenneySounds It's an old music hall tune and it's perfect. Great vid.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +187

      Now I'm glad I didn't trim out the whistling part like I thought of doing. Now it's a smash cut from a song about getting a dog to a scene about getting a dog.
      If you want to see more unintentional foreshadowing (backshadowing?) from this show, check out my video "When Doctor Who does a callback to something that hasn't happened yet"

    • @zacmumblethunder7466
      @zacmumblethunder7466 2 роки тому +20

      Serendipity. Like Jo Grant messing up the mushrooms at the Nuthutch in the story before Sarah Jane arrived.
      Also the name of the crafts programme Katy Manning went into after leaving the show.

    • @stevenbaxter9099
      @stevenbaxter9099 2 роки тому +1

      666 likes the devil's number

  • @Thestarsandseassystem
    @Thestarsandseassystem 2 роки тому +4613

    "Don't forget me"
    Oh Ms Elisabeth Sladen, no-one's EVER going to forget you

    • @rolandbaldwin
      @rolandbaldwin 2 роки тому +178

      It's been 11 years and I still tear up when I see any of her scenes.

    • @Thkaal
      @Thkaal 2 роки тому +43

      No...you hit me in the feels.

    • @raflamar4146
      @raflamar4146 2 роки тому +73

      Sarah Jane Smith, didn’t want to be forgotten.
      10th Doctor, never wanted to go.

    • @jakesinclair69420
      @jakesinclair69420 2 роки тому +29

      @@raflamar4146 neither did Elizabeth Sladen 😢😢

    • @RogueWJL
      @RogueWJL 2 роки тому +6

      🙏❤

  • @proctifer9833
    @proctifer9833 2 роки тому +4084

    I love that she wanted a goodbye. She didn't want to be left thinking that she *might* see him again like he did the first time.

    • @AlrightThere
      @AlrightThere 2 роки тому +160

      Yeah an official goodbye rather than waiting for years of her life for her space man to return

    • @RosyRecluse
      @RosyRecluse 2 роки тому +96

      It... Also works where if you don't follow her spin-off, it's still closure for Elizabeth Sladen's character, since she... Well.

    • @ChaoticTempest
      @ChaoticTempest 11 місяців тому +11

      ​@@RosyRecluseyeah😢

    • @hannahstewart5337
      @hannahstewart5337 9 місяців тому +12

      The Doctor has a habit of doing that to his companions...

    • @aaronkay101kinetic
      @aaronkay101kinetic 9 місяців тому +5

      Although he does follow up on his companions. He mentions it in an episode of the Sarah Jane Adventures

  • @Esprix
    @Esprix 2 роки тому +2629

    "My Sarah Jane!"
    Makes me cry every single time.

    • @DravenGal
      @DravenGal 2 роки тому +11

      Me too.

    • @wheelyjon
      @wheelyjon 2 роки тому +2

      @@DravenGal glad I'm not alone

    • @DravenGal
      @DravenGal 2 роки тому +1

      @@wheelyjon I meant I cry too.

    • @Prismatic_Truth
      @Prismatic_Truth 2 роки тому +2

      Yep. Never fails.😭

    • @KelilaBennet
      @KelilaBennet 2 роки тому

      Every time! Just the way he said it!

  • @badwolf66
    @badwolf66 2 роки тому +1975

    Sarah Jane has met the 1st, 2nd 3rd, 4th, 5th 10th and 11th
    That's pretty Good track record.

    • @highlander723
      @highlander723 2 роки тому +171

      Sarah Jane would definitely be on the founding members council

    • @rockysandman5489
      @rockysandman5489 2 роки тому +224

      Another one with a good track record is the Brigadier, who on-screen has met the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th (DIT), 7th, and 12th (Cyber-Brig).
      EDIT: And of course from the new series, Clara met Doctors 1-11 all in the same episode, and later traveled with 12 too.

    • @jennacrafts8129
      @jennacrafts8129 2 роки тому +22

      Ooh, when did she meet 11?

    • @rockysandman5489
      @rockysandman5489 2 роки тому +123

      @@jennacrafts8129 The Sarah Jane Adventures, episode: "Death Of The Doctor".

    • @Kryojenix
      @Kryojenix 2 роки тому +46

      She met the 7th Doctor in the comics - it was great, long before the emotionalism of Russell's reboot in 2005, the Doctor and Sarah are equals (in height) and share a fond hug, before foiling the human livestock trafficking operation of the Kalik. There's a London bus as well!

  • @KingKhanAbz
    @KingKhanAbz 2 роки тому +1684

    "No one's ever gonna forget you."
    Then The Doctor remembers Donna Noble.

    • @BYERE
      @BYERE 2 роки тому +157

      As long as Donna doesn't remember The Doctor, she'll be alright.

    • @pastlife960
      @pastlife960 2 роки тому +34

      Oh god no my feels

    • @larniieplayz6285
      @larniieplayz6285 2 роки тому +6

      Oof

    • @highvoltage7797
      @highvoltage7797 2 роки тому +7

      Or Jamie and Zoe.

    • @zacmumblethunder7466
      @zacmumblethunder7466 2 роки тому +37

      @@highvoltage7797 They remember their first adventure with him but don't remember that they travelled with him afterwards. Donna didn't even get that. Although it makes me wonder what she thinks happened that she didn't get married first time around.

  • @EX7Sonic
    @EX7Sonic 2 роки тому +2516

    As someone who's never watched a full episode of classic Who, I really love the lack of music in that goodbye. It felt more real and relatable. I've said goodbye to a lot of people that I haven't seen again (with hopes to even if it's no longer possible) and it feels just like that. No music, no fanfare. Just parting words and then the ambiance of wherever you are.

    • @hotdog1214
      @hotdog1214 2 роки тому +87

      Agreed, definitely a case of less is more.

    • @HOTD108_
      @HOTD108_ 2 роки тому +112

      @@hotdog1214 Doctor Who in general is often a case of less budget equalling more creativity.

    • @Shoetoe2000
      @Shoetoe2000 2 роки тому +53

      It'd be quite a thing if dramatic music started playing automatically every time you said goodbye to someone:P

    • @writershard5065
      @writershard5065 2 роки тому +48

      I agree and disagree. There's a beauty to the silence of the moment. But also while we don't have music playing in the background of our most emotional moments, we do listen to music while thinking about these memories. And often we associate specific musical tracks with specific memories or eras of our lives (so much so that when we listen to those tracks again, we feel those feelings rushing back to us, i.e., nostalgia). So adding background music to a scene can be seen as an abstraction of that phenomenon.

    • @ShezzaisBezza
      @ShezzaisBezza 2 роки тому +1

      Beautiful way of putting it 🥹

  • @OptimusPhillip
    @OptimusPhillip 2 роки тому +1422

    For those who don't know (I certainly didn't), Aberdeen is over 400 miles away from Croydon. They're basically at opposite ends of the Island of Great Britian.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +325

      The Doctor does seem to have a strange tendency to end up in Scotland unintentionally.
      CLARA: This isn't my home, by the way.
      DOCTOR: Sorry. I'm sorry about that. I missed.
      CLARA: Where are we?
      DOCTOR: Glasgow, I think.
      CLARA: Ah. You'll fit right in. Scottish.
      DOCTOR: Right. Shall we, er. Do you want to go and get some coffee, or chips, or something? Or chips and coffee?
      CLARA: Coffee. Coffee would be great. You're buying.
      DOCTOR: I don't have any money.
      CLARA: You're fetching, then.
      Next episode:
      CLARA: Where the hell have you been?
      DOCTOR: You sent me for coffee.
      CLARA: Three weeks ago. In Glasgow.
      DOCTOR: Three weeks, that's a long time.
      CLARA: In Glasgow. That's dead in a ditch.

    • @mochapoke3100
      @mochapoke3100 2 роки тому +83

      Honestly I love when the dctore just gets locations wrong like that it's funny every time

    • @schubertuk
      @schubertuk 2 роки тому +72

      But for those who live in other "proper sized" countries, where 400 miles is frankly local - and perhaps doesn't even cross the state-line; the UK has a road-network so bad that we make 400 miles feel like 4000... ;-) It's our own sort of special TARDIS effect where the country feels bigger on the inside!

    • @mochapoke3100
      @mochapoke3100 2 роки тому +34

      @@schubertuk yeah it's a good thing his companions live in England and not America, a texan would end up in Washington

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +79

      @@schubertuk There's a Scottish comedian named Danny Bhoy who does this joke when he performs in Australia or here in Canada where he talks about driving for 9 hours and looking on the map and seeing that he's still in the same state/province. He says "If I’d got a car in Scotland and drove for nine hours, I’d be in the heart of the Czech Republic"

  • @CelesteStClair
    @CelesteStClair 2 роки тому +5683

    bonus that is NEVER mentioned:When Ten meets Sarah Jane in School Reunion she says "You've Regenerated" and he says "Half a dozen times since we last met" so 6 times.What no one ever mentions is that this was originally a mistake. You don't always catch it as you think oh 4th doctor to 10th doctor, 6 regenerations.HOWEVER! In "The Five Doctors" Sarah Jane meets the 5th doctor, played by Peter Davison.With the addition of the War Doctor, this makes Sarah Jane the only person the Doctor never lied to about how many times he had regenerated.It's a mistake turned long-term easter egg, and it really holds that Continuity together.

    • @Jonathan-ic9ef
      @Jonathan-ic9ef 2 роки тому +226

      Yes but she still talks as if she hasn't seen him since he dropped her off.

    • @abcdefgh6951
      @abcdefgh6951 2 роки тому +214

      @@Jonathan-ic9ef maybe they all got mindwiped or smt lol, five doctors was weird anyway only doctor that embraced or even cared or seemed to be aware of Susan was first doctor when Susan should be completely used to the concept of regeneration as they run away from galifrey, and the older doctors should be even more emotional about seeing her because they didn't see her for a long time

    • @chrisstory563
      @chrisstory563 Рік тому +100

      the doctors and the companions on that specials may have their memories of the event automatically erased after they return to their own time stream. with acceptation of the fifth doctor. same thing with the three doctors and day of the doctor. so SJS meeting with the fifth doctor was automatically forgotten.

    • @vinzo0913
      @vinzo0913 Рік тому +43

      In retrospect it still holds true with the war doctor existing. 5 to 10+1

    • @leejjjjjjj1
      @leejjjjjjj1 Рік тому +36

      the 12th doctor literally went into detail about all 11 generations + the war doctor (so 12 generations) with clara, so she knows about all of them truly too

  • @profilefeather
    @profilefeather 2 роки тому +947

    As someone who was born in raised in Aberdeen I can confirm that it would be a piss take to be stranded there, even for half an hour it would suck, and I’ve lived here 20 years so far

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +47

      There was a place named after it near where I grew up, and that wasn't a fun place either.

    • @BarryLetts379
      @BarryLetts379 2 роки тому +16

      did a mysterious man drop you off at some point?

    • @schubertuk
      @schubertuk 2 роки тому +17

      It could have been worse... It could have been Inverness ;-)

    • @DizzyDungeoneer
      @DizzyDungeoneer 2 роки тому +26

      Just move to Croydon. I have it on good authority that it's right next door.

    • @james4thedoctor482
      @james4thedoctor482 2 роки тому +3

      How far from Croydon?

  • @MeleeHellBot
    @MeleeHellBot 2 роки тому +862

    Who is the Doctor?
    Affirmative
    That's such a genius line

    • @DaphneHarridge
      @DaphneHarridge 2 роки тому +11

      I love that! So clever. 🥰

    • @Macroman595
      @Macroman595 Рік тому +7

      Oooh I get it now

    • @ZUnknownFox
      @ZUnknownFox Рік тому +5

      wait so the Doctors name is Who?

    • @tiffanymarie5674
      @tiffanymarie5674 Рік тому +9

      ​@@ZUnknownFox I think Missy says that, she calls him Doctor Who and says that's his name

    • @onyourleft4194
      @onyourleft4194 11 місяців тому +7

      @@ZUnknownFox i think it's another case of "the name you choose is a promise you make". so just like "the doctor" is their name, "doctor who" is too

  • @jeffreysanders612
    @jeffreysanders612 2 роки тому +343

    "who is the doctor?" "affirmative" such a bad joke, I love it

    • @TheGayToastyBoi
      @TheGayToastyBoi 9 місяців тому +4

      Hah! I didn’t even realize until you pointed it out

    • @totallyoutofit6989
      @totallyoutofit6989 8 місяців тому +2

      omg i didn't realise either 😭

  • @elliotcrossan6290
    @elliotcrossan6290 2 роки тому +1559

    It's heartbreaking both in-world and in the real world when the Tenth Doctor sees Sarah for the last time in the End of Time. The last ever appearance for probably the most iconic Doctor Who companion ever...

    • @dubbingsync
      @dubbingsync 2 роки тому +142

      In the main series anyway. She still had at least a series and a half of her own adventures.

    • @elliotcrossan6290
      @elliotcrossan6290 2 роки тому +24

      @@dubbingsync Yep, I meant in the main series

    • @edadankmemes
      @edadankmemes 2 роки тому +67

      No, she sees the 11th doctor in her second to last series.

    • @elliotcrossan6290
      @elliotcrossan6290 2 роки тому +13

      @@edadankmemes Yep, I meant in the main series

    • @Knight049
      @Knight049 2 роки тому +4

      @@edadankmemes Can you not read?

  • @gonzaloirala5776
    @gonzaloirala5776 8 місяців тому +16

    -who is the doctor?
    -affirmative
    that's so clever

  • @MrWasjig
    @MrWasjig 2 роки тому +1836

    "He recognises me!" that delivery was diabeetus inducing levels of adorable.

    • @teresaravenshaw5477
      @teresaravenshaw5477 2 роки тому

      Diabetes.

    • @serPomiz
      @serPomiz 2 роки тому +50

      there are moments when the fan re-emerge. it happened with Hartnell, with baker, McGann, here with tennant, with Smith, and Capaldi (every other episode or so), and it's something that makes the show so much more

    • @charlieward5439
      @charlieward5439 9 місяців тому +8

      you could have used the word sweet

    • @algomaone121
      @algomaone121 6 місяців тому +1

      A-firmative ❤

  • @holyflutterofgod
    @holyflutterofgod 2 роки тому +283

    Oh my god, the way she giggles and says "he blew it..." is so wonderful

    • @EthanMiguelScott
      @EthanMiguelScott Рік тому +9

      ...and then she talks to a human and finds out she's at least half a day from home, probably with no money.

  • @ItsMeGPZ
    @ItsMeGPZ Рік тому +351

    Imagine growing up to play the person you watched as a child, AND getting to hang out with one of the companions FROM said time! dream come true, RIP Elizabeth Sladen

  • @infinitemonkeytheorem4327
    @infinitemonkeytheorem4327 10 місяців тому +163

    I love how Sarah-Jane was never mad at the doctor for leaving her, yes she was a little sad, but you can see she held no animosity towards him, I really like that it cuz it shows how close they became

    • @TheGreatCalsby
      @TheGreatCalsby 7 місяців тому +7

      I think she was angry, at least a bit. She talks to Rose at one point and warns her about him

    • @iGotBulletproof-Insomnia
      @iGotBulletproof-Insomnia 7 місяців тому +8

      It's also been decades. She could have been angry when she was younger, but learned to let go and forgive him, especially if she thought he was dead.

    • @potsdam28
      @potsdam28 4 місяці тому

      She was already preparing to leave.

  • @JA-fh4yw
    @JA-fh4yw 10 місяців тому +111

    I love that Sarah/Elisabeth became just as beloved in New Who. Credit for RTD for bringing her back.

    • @idle_speculation
      @idle_speculation 2 дні тому

      I can see him trying to do something similar with Mel right now, and it seems to be working, especially considering the dislike for her in her original tenure as a companion.

  • @Walesbornandbred
    @Walesbornandbred 2 роки тому +213

    David Tenant saying, "My Sarah Jane!" Still makes me cry.

  • @KrisRyanStallard
    @KrisRyanStallard 2 роки тому +721

    Elizabeth Sladen deserved her own spin off much earlier than she got it.

    • @JimmyBoy9878
      @JimmyBoy9878 2 роки тому +50

      agreed but im very happy that i watched it when i did as a kid.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +117

      But at the same time, the first one they tried to give her wasn't very good. She deserved a spinoff as good as "The Sarah Jane Adventures" all the way back when they made "K9 And Company", because she definitely deserved better than that one.

    • @anonygent
      @anonygent 2 роки тому +24

      She deserved a spin-off that was about her and not random kids.

    • @kennethjackson4716
      @kennethjackson4716 Рік тому +10

      @@PenneySounds K9&co. was actually one of my favorites. Of course K9 was also my favorite Whoniverse character. Even over the Doctor (heresy I know)

    • @thatpeskyrat
      @thatpeskyrat 11 місяців тому +9

      @@anonygent as long as she was happy with what she was making, i don't think it matters what we think she deserved

  • @darrenskjoelsvold
    @darrenskjoelsvold 2 роки тому +467

    I have to admit watching these clips brought a little tear to my eye. Rest in peace Sarah Jane Smith nobody will ever forget you.

  • @mcarp555
    @mcarp555 2 роки тому +159

    "My Sarah Jane" - then the tears start, every single time.

  • @gregorde
    @gregorde 10 місяців тому +11

    You can tell David Tenant was over the moon to be working with Liz Sladen.

  • @TimRichards
    @TimRichards 10 місяців тому +51

    Brilliant set of clips. I'm so glad they decided to make the new series of Doctor Who in continuity with the original series, rather than starting from scratch. It lends depth to its history.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  10 місяців тому +8

      As a Star Trek fan, I can attest that rebooting and reimagining the lore is NOT the way to go about it. Doctor Who did it right.

  • @CaptZenPetabyte
    @CaptZenPetabyte Рік тому +57

    I like that on multiple iterations of the Dr over different times, K9 knows who he is and how to interact with the Doctor perfectly straight away ... now *thats* great AI programming.

  • @woodrobin
    @woodrobin 2 роки тому +81

    "is this the last time I'm ever going to see you?"
    "I don't know."
    Rule #1: The Doctor lies.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +13

      He did see her after that. Once with that same face, and once more with his next.

    • @HepCatJack
      @HepCatJack Рік тому

      He's also regenerated lying down before.

  • @mikelv1
    @mikelv1 Рік тому +88

    I like to think that whenever they had 10 do some stuff with some classic Who things, that David was loving every minute of it due to him being probably the biggest Who nerd to exist

    • @maouliamediaofficial
      @maouliamediaofficial Рік тому +9

      Ehm, Peter Capaldi?

    • @krispykrushems
      @krispykrushems Рік тому +25

      Bit late but you're absolutely right. In a Comic Con Panel in like 2009, there's a video of it somewhere here. David said that it was amazing and surreal to hear his childhood companion call him the Doctor.

  • @davidhammond3033
    @davidhammond3033 2 роки тому +54

    "My Sarah Jane" - if that isn't a goosebump moment, I don't know what is. Absolutely heartbreaking.

  • @theironpone035
    @theironpone035 6 місяців тому +5

    That final hug scene is made even better knowing that Tennant grew up watching Sladen and Tom Baker flying through the stars in that rickety old police box. And now here he is, playing the role of the Doctor, flying that very police box through the stars, and getting to meet and work with Sladen herself. Bet that was truly a magical moment on set. Rest in peace Elisabeth Sladen, you will never EVER be forgotten...

  • @skits2240
    @skits2240 2 роки тому +243

    I wish they'd bring back more characters like Sarah this was so beautiful 😭

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +26

      You're in luck. Stay tuned for the next episode

    • @skits2240
      @skits2240 2 роки тому +3

      @@PenneySounds looking forward to it

    • @1978rharris
      @1978rharris 2 роки тому +9

      Ace and Tegan are coming back later this year for Jodie’s last episode.

    • @skits2240
      @skits2240 2 роки тому

      @@1978rharris nice 👌

    • @johnlarro6872
      @johnlarro6872 10 місяців тому +7

      Sadly we're losing those characters one after another... :( And not all of them could easily come back "in universe". The return of Mel is great IMO, as whilst she's by far probably nobody's first choice, I think under RTD she could be brilliant... Although given the last time we saw her, I really don't see how she made her way back to 'current' Earth...

  • @ghostspider2056
    @ghostspider2056 2 роки тому +53

    Doctor: “I studied geography, well I failed.”
    - Smith and Jones, S3 x E1.
    So true.

  • @authorrayrogers
    @authorrayrogers Рік тому +47

    Oh, Liz Sladen. I will always believe that The Doctor loved Sarah Jane in a way he never loved any other companion. It wasn't romantic love. It wasn't familial love. It was simply... love. I think their love rose above a label and a surname. Time didn't change it. Distance didn't break it. Sarah Jane was/is the best companion of them all.

  • @dallassukerkin6878
    @dallassukerkin6878 Рік тому +33

    A grown man of sixty should not be moved to tears by a clip from a 'kids' TV show ... but here we are :O
    And watching that section with Tom Baker (the bulk of 'my' years tho' Pertwee was truly my Doctor) I suddenly realised why I had such a love for Kaylee from Firefly and Dr. Keller from Stargate Atlantis ... it's because Jewel Staite strongly reminds me of Elisabeth Sladen

  • @alexrobertssings
    @alexrobertssings 10 місяців тому +40

    That last "don't forget me" is especially poignant given that The Doctor must have only recently lost Donna. You can see it eat him up inside!

    • @hannahk1306
      @hannahk1306 10 місяців тому +7

      It's also poignant because it was the last time Sarah-Jane appeared in the main series before Elisabeth died.

    • @the25thdoctor
      @the25thdoctor 9 місяців тому +3

      ⁠@@hannahk1306nope, there was one time with the eleventh doctor in 2010

  • @flyhyland
    @flyhyland 2 роки тому +236

    Fun fact about the final scene in this video: This was also the final scene David Tennant ever filmed during his tenure as the Tenth Doctor.

    • @BarbusCraft
      @BarbusCraft 2 роки тому +49

      No, David said in an interview with The Guardian that his final lines were "You two, with me, spit spot", which is a scene when they're trying to escape the wedding locale early in the episode.

    • @JohnSmith-bk9iz
      @JohnSmith-bk9iz 2 роки тому +8

      According to the BTS on the DVDs… his last was some wire work for END OF TIME P2

    • @arthemis1039
      @arthemis1039 2 роки тому +4

      Excluding the 50th

    • @obiwankenobi687
      @obiwankenobi687 2 роки тому +19

      His last scene as the tenth Doctor in Sarah Jane adventures was with the kids inside the wedding venue. And his last scene in Doctor who was against a blue screen falling through the sky towards the Naismith mansion.

    • @schubertuk
      @schubertuk 2 роки тому +4

      @@arthemis1039 Well that was not during his tenure.

  • @CrusherX1000
    @CrusherX1000 2 роки тому +13

    "Who is the Doctor?"
    K9:Affirmative

  • @Staceyatkinson4496
    @Staceyatkinson4496 2 роки тому +21

    Even now, that bit still gets me, the bit where Tom says"till we meet again Sarah "

  • @RCP641
    @RCP641 2 роки тому +22

    For those who want to know Aberdeen and South Croydon are 915.717 kilometers (569 miles) apart.

    • @jaschul
      @jaschul 2 роки тому

      Jeez. Well, the 12th Doctor could've gotten there perfectly.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому

      @@jaschul He'd have just ended up in Glasgow instead

    • @benswindlehurst1857
      @benswindlehurst1857 2 роки тому

      Thank you, google maps

  • @richardbourton4523
    @richardbourton4523 2 роки тому +101

    Great compilation! I was worried the SJA scene wouldn’t make it in and then there it was in all it’s quiet beauty.

    • @iangreen4572
      @iangreen4572 Рік тому

      Missed 11's apperances though.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  Рік тому +4

      ​@@iangreen4572 This isn't a compilation of every time the Doctor and Sarah Jane met, it's just a compilation tracing the running reference of "don't forget me", which doesn't get referenced in 11's SJA appearance.

  • @Wolf359inc
    @Wolf359inc 2 роки тому +31

    Thanks. I hadn’t planned on crying today, so well done…

  • @ellie6718
    @ellie6718 2 роки тому +11

    “Who is The Doctor?”
    “Affirmative!”
    Missed that first time 🤣🤣

  • @judithsixkiller5586
    @judithsixkiller5586 2 роки тому +14

    Despite the enormous talent and creativity that each Doctor has brought to the role, Tom Baker will ALWAYS be my favorite jelly baby!

  • @Wyrmwould
    @Wyrmwould 2 роки тому +98

    I must admit that I quit watching the regenerated series right after the big 50th anniversary special, but I absolutely loved it when it first returned. And the first episode with Sarah Jane and the Tenth Doctor was just magical. When she found the Tardis and then realized she was talking to the Doctor again at last, I think I probably had a tear in my eye.

    • @lanewright1143
      @lanewright1143 Рік тому

      Is that a new special? With Sarah Jane and the tenth? I don't recall that scene at the end of the video

    • @ClawedAsh
      @ClawedAsh 6 місяців тому

      @@lanewright1143 It's from "Sarah Jane Adventures" and I believe the episode is "The Wedding of Sarah Jane" which had the Tenth Doctor cameo

  • @KitsuneAdorable
    @KitsuneAdorable Рік тому +5

    David Tenants "He recognizes me!" It just too damn adorable.

  • @swiftbird4846
    @swiftbird4846 2 роки тому +20

    Sarah Jane, what a companion. She will never be forgotten.

  • @kieranjohnson6752
    @kieranjohnson6752 Рік тому +19

    I don't care how much time has passed. Any Moment with The Doctor and Sarah Jane always hurts knowing we don't have Elisabeth Sladen anymore

  • @Tamla1959
    @Tamla1959 11 місяців тому +14

    4:59 davids acting is just fantastic, his face just leaks out the doctor and who the doctor actually is and how the doctor actually feels, makes your heart sink. Its so unreal. Wish i know the song.

  • @gemmel3197
    @gemmel3197 2 роки тому +41

    The Sarah Jane character ranked with the best of the Doctors, she is sadly missed.

  • @BAYBAY_316
    @BAYBAY_316 9 місяців тому +3

    She was so gorgeous in every possible way. She is truly missed.

  • @lcoyle1998
    @lcoyle1998 2 роки тому +26

    My god, this makes me miss Elizabeth Sladen so much 😔

  • @thechrisandmikeshow
    @thechrisandmikeshow 8 місяців тому +5

    Tom and Liz played Sarah's departure scene beautifully...really gets you in the feels...the best companion farewell scene in the classic series. - Chris

  • @PenneySounds
    @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +29

    I had some fun pan-and-scanning the 4:3 clips into 16:9. I wish I knew how to upscale the footage though

    • @HeatherAckroyd
      @HeatherAckroyd 2 роки тому +5

      You could have left the original as 4:3 and had the black bars on the side, then switched to 16:9 with the modern clip. I think it would have looked fine.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +8

      @@HeatherAckroyd Yeah, but this looks a little more consistent in terms of format. And it's kind of fun, and makes the video look more unique than just a montage of clips.

  • @elvensteen1
    @elvensteen1 Рік тому +5

    No one's ever going to forget you, Elizabeth Sladen...

  • @autumbreeze1129
    @autumbreeze1129 6 місяців тому +2

    Oh... that last line.
    Yes, it was remedied in The Star Beast, but the fact Sarah says no one will EVER forget The Doctor when he KNOWS Donna is going to HAVE to forget him and he'll live with that for thousands of years and his face as Sarah's leaving...
    That hurts more than I remembered

  • @robertbrighton9797
    @robertbrighton9797 8 місяців тому +9

    Quite poignant that the finale scene was not only the actual last scene David Tennant filmed as the doctor while playing the 10th doctor it was also at a moment where the character knew he was going to die soon.

  • @captainstage2009
    @captainstage2009 2 роки тому +34

    Looking back, it’s so funny how in New Who, they played every goodbye scene with Sarah Jane as a permanent, solemn goodbye, but then she sees him 4 more times and gets her own spin-off show :/

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +15

      In the last clip, she's gotten over that fear that he'll disappear forever, but he thinks he's going to die soon. They meet twice more after that

  • @wolfielps4411
    @wolfielps4411 2 роки тому +16

    All the scenes with Elisabeth sladen had me in tears 😭 a true doctor who legend

  • @omega311888
    @omega311888 Рік тому +3

    Rest in Peace, Liz. you were one of the absolute best! miss you like crazy!

  • @tiredenby437
    @tiredenby437 8 місяців тому +5

    My mother's favourite classic who companion was Sarah Jane Smith, because her first two names were also Sarah Jane. Unfortunately both her and Elizabeth Sladen died from breast cancer.
    RIP to my two childhood heroes

  • @jackal59
    @jackal59 2 роки тому +10

    Partly continuity, and partly that when you have a character played by an actress as compelling as Elizabeth Sladen, you bring that actress back every time you can.

  • @SuperPokekami
    @SuperPokekami Рік тому +7

    That goodbye scene with Tennant always gets the tears rolling

  • @nicktroisi6347
    @nicktroisi6347 7 місяців тому +7

    “No one’s ever going to forget you”
    Trust us, we will never forget him and we will never forget you Sarah Jane. RIpP Elizabeth always

  • @petersimpson633
    @petersimpson633 Рік тому +5

    She was my favorite of all The Doctor's companions by a very long shot, and I had a schoolboy crush on her to boot. So sad she went at still a young age, Rip Elizabeth Sladen

  • @rubaemaster7036
    @rubaemaster7036 2 роки тому +75

    The day someone forgets the Doctor is the day the Doctor looks back and doesn’t feel guilty.
    Maybe he’ll eventually forgive himself but I’m pretty sure that guilt will always be there. Even if the majority of his “misdoings” were not his fault he did have some like Gallifrey’s burning and nearly fracturing time because of saving Clara.

    • @r.o.e.408
      @r.o.e.408 2 роки тому +6

      Unfortunately, if I recall, Let's Kill Hitler shows guilt in the memory of Donna.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +6

      ​@@r.o.e.408 Most of his companions are a source of guilt. After it showed Rose, Martha, and Donna, it should have shown Adric, and had the Doctor say "Oh come on!"

    • @r.o.e.408
      @r.o.e.408 2 роки тому

      @@PenneySounds Not super familiar with classic Who. Is that the boy he got killed?

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +1

      @@r.o.e.408 Yes

    • @r.o.e.408
      @r.o.e.408 2 роки тому +2

      @@PenneySounds Yeah, maybe they should have. But I think he asked the TARDIS "show me someone I like," so I guess that was just up to its interpretation.

  • @davidrosler5413
    @davidrosler5413 2 роки тому +72

    The best companion with number 4, the best Doctor. We'll never see on-screen chemistry on Dr Who like that again; this video just proved it. Great compilation video, Penny. Thank tou.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +11

      The chemistry was still able to work just as well with all the doctors she met since. This show is still nailing it, and always will

    • @davidrosler5413
      @davidrosler5413 2 роки тому +2

      @@PenneySounds well, we'll agree to disagree, as the Doctor would have it.

    • @grandmalovesmebest
      @grandmalovesmebest 2 роки тому +11

      Ah, david tennant and catherine tate. What a pair!

    • @HappyLarry.
      @HappyLarry. 2 роки тому +1

      @@PenneySounds I mean...with Sarah Jane certainly, with chemistry in *general*, well, the new stuff is pretty rank amateur ain't it

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +8

      @@HappyLarry. No

  • @swanvictor887
    @swanvictor887 10 місяців тому +1

    I am 59 years old today. I still remember that gutted feeling, when Elizabeth Sladen left the Doctor, over 40-odd years ago. I loved her as a companion and Tom of course, was just the perfect Doctor. For me, the most amazing thing about Dr Who, is the emotional blow it delivers to its audience every few years, when a Doctor regenerates or a companion departs: perhaps in many ways, it taught us kids, how to deal with life, the ups and downs...?
    With regards to Elizabeth Sladen....a beautiful woman who never seemed to age and I'm so glad she became a star in her own right, with her own show, sadly, all too short a time. My god, I was lucky as a kid: the actors who entertained me, were professional, classy and knew what the hell they were doing!! Great upload, thanks for my birthday present.

  • @diesel5357
    @diesel5357 7 місяців тому +2

    I cried so much when Elisabeth Sladen passed away, she was always my favourite companion and I loved her spin off series too!

  • @donnydoeschildren3517
    @donnydoeschildren3517 2 роки тому +13

    Sahra : no one's ever gonna forget u
    Donna later *forgets the doctor*

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +11

      That had actually already happened, which was probably why he said that

  • @testicularoxide5055
    @testicularoxide5055 2 роки тому +7

    Godspeed, Sarah Jane... And Godspeed Liz Sladen... Never, EVER forgotten...💜

  • @aannddrryyaa
    @aannddrryyaa Рік тому

    That was so needed for me right now. Thanks for this. I may have to go back and rewatch S2, 3, 4... oh can't seem to stop ;)

  • @DonnaLang42rockglobally
    @DonnaLang42rockglobally 2 роки тому +17

    Ironically the song Sarah Jane is whistling at the end of "Hand of Fear" is called "Daddy Wouldn't Buy Me A Bow-Wow"; now take into consideration that K-9 hadn't been written into the show yet and the thought of the attempted spin-off "K-9 and Company" was not even a glimmer in Bob Baker and Dave Martin's combined imagination and it just shows how much gold can be found in pure coincidences. ^_^

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +3

      I didn't even know what the song was until another commenter here told me. I considered cutting out the whistling part, so I'm glad I didn't.

  • @DragonsSongStudios
    @DragonsSongStudios 11 місяців тому +3

    R.I.P Elisabeth Sladen, no one can ever forget you 😢

  • @MrMann0123
    @MrMann0123 2 роки тому +5

    That break in her voice when she says "home"

  • @jakejones5895
    @jakejones5895 2 роки тому +2

    The woman who waited

  • @TheMikester307
    @TheMikester307 10 місяців тому +4

    Absolutely love this! The scene where Sarah recognizes The Doctor in the reunion show about made me cry! And I loved "The Sarah Jane Adventures."

  • @BlueSmoke216
    @BlueSmoke216 2 роки тому +29

    Someone help remind me - with Capaldi, at one point he's going through a series of notes of polite things to say, and I swear one of them says "I'm sorry I left you in Aberdeen."

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +19

      Yes, it said "It was my fault, I should have known you didn't live in Aberdeen"

    • @thegrimmretails3777
      @thegrimmretails3777 2 роки тому +5

      The subtext being, Clara somehow found out about Sara Jane and included that in the flash cards.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +5

      @@thegrimmretails3777 Considering her first outing with 12 ended with him abandoning her in Glasgow, I think what happened to Sarah Jane may not have been a one-off
      CLARA: This isn't my home, by the way.
      DOCTOR: Sorry. I'm sorry about that. I missed.
      CLARA: Where are we?
      DOCTOR: Glasgow, I think.
      CLARA: Ah. You'll fit right in. Scottish.
      DOCTOR: Right. Shall we, er. Do you want to go and get some coffee, or chips, or something? Or chips and coffee?
      CLARA: Coffee. Coffee would be great. You're buying.
      DOCTOR: I don't have any money.
      CLARA: You're fetching, then.
      CLARA: Where the hell have you been?
      DOCTOR: You sent me for coffee.
      CLARA: Three weeks ago. In Glasgow.
      DOCTOR: Three weeks, that's a long time.
      CLARA: In Glasgow. That's dead in a ditch.
      DOCTOR: It's not my fault, I got distracted.

    • @anonygent
      @anonygent 2 роки тому +1

      To be fair, the Doctor almost never ends up where he thinks he will.

  • @Spacejockey426
    @Spacejockey426 2 роки тому +51

    Now this is what they call powerful writing by those who care about the show and its characters.

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +9

      Some franchises could learn from this

  • @Mr.Bobble-236
    @Mr.Bobble-236 7 місяців тому +1

    "Did I do something wrong..?"
    *"AFFIRMATIVE."*

  • @donnydoeschildren3517
    @donnydoeschildren3517 2 роки тому +8

    Sahra : don't forget m-
    Doctor : so anyways I started to move on

  • @hotdog1214
    @hotdog1214 2 роки тому +9

    I don't think I've ever seen a video which connects the Sarah Jane moments like this so directly, its lovely. And now I'm off to find out why someone is cutting onions in here... 😪

  • @Hockeyfan268
    @Hockeyfan268 Рік тому +8

    As someone who has never seen an episode of Dr who in their life..this was downright beautiful

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  Рік тому +2

      I do have a viewing guide if you're interested in trying it out. The link is in the description of my "Doctor Who Minisodes" playlist.

  • @squegeemcgee2403
    @squegeemcgee2403 8 місяців тому +2

    "who is the doctor?" "affirmative"

  • @samfri3nd
    @samfri3nd 2 роки тому +5

    RIP Elisabeth Sladen...sorely missed 😔

  • @subsonicdeathmonkey
    @subsonicdeathmonkey Рік тому +3

    It was always be too soon 🥺 but I’m so glad she got the hug she always deserved. What a wonderful character and lovely woman. Vale Elisabeth Sladen 💕💕💕

  • @bartohawk7643
    @bartohawk7643 2 роки тому +12

    "No one's ever going to forget you"
    Give it 3 seasons Sarah Jane

    • @lis_mayakovsky
      @lis_mayakovsky Рік тому

      Tennant was iconic af, he was a doctor to remember.

  • @JennaArgent
    @JennaArgent 7 місяців тому +1

    The goodbyes brought me to tears since we will never see Sarah Jane again. RIP Elizabeth

  • @Sky-bu1jj
    @Sky-bu1jj 2 роки тому +4

    "Who is the Doctor?
    _"Affirmative."_ lmao

  • @sy2see
    @sy2see 2 роки тому +3

    Such beautiful scenes. At least he got to say goodbye before she passed away.

  • @hiccuphufflepuff176
    @hiccuphufflepuff176 2 роки тому +6

    You missed the one with the 12th Doctor in "Under the Lake" when the Doctor was being anti-social and Clara pulled out cue-cards of prepared not-rude things for him to say, one of them read "I should have known you didn't live in Aberdeen."

  • @madmanmark8387
    @madmanmark8387 Рік тому +1

    Thanks from your last video of redirecting me here and again tears are formed. Despite her being one of the fans favorite companion, for me it was Leela. She was feisty and had the doctors back. A warrior.

  • @thomashauguel6811
    @thomashauguel6811 8 місяців тому +2

    I always loved Sarah Jane. She was my Doctor's companion (Tom Baker and John Pertwee) growing up. When I found out she passed away, I'm not afraid to admit I shed more than a few tears. She was taken away from us far too early.
    Rest in Peace, my Sarah Jane. 😢

  • @woodrobin
    @woodrobin 2 роки тому +4

    "Who is the Doctor?"
    "Affirmative!"

    • @woodrobin
      @woodrobin Рік тому +1

      "The first question, the oldest question in the universe, hidden in plain sight . . . Doctor who? Doctor who? DOCTOR WHO?"

  • @ThePsycoDolphin
    @ThePsycoDolphin 9 місяців тому +3

    4:22 This scene is doubly sad. Not only does the Doctor know hes going to change soon, as SJ's death is canon in show as in real life, and as she only had a couple of years left from that episode, its almost as if he knew that. Thay giant pause between "is this the last time ive ever going to see you?" and the doctors slightly glib, uncommited awnser, plus the thousand yard stare after she leaves almost makes it seem like he knows shes on borrowed time but cannot possibly face up to the fact that she will in fact, die. He knows, to some extent that, yes, this is going to be one of the last time he sees her, and coupled with his own impending sense of mortality it must kill him inside. The doctor knowing the deaths of alot of his companions does seem the kind of morbidly worldwise thing hed do. It adds *layers* of sadness to that one scene.
    What a beautiful show and what a beautiful woman. It breaks your heart.

  • @cdevjoshlolo
    @cdevjoshlolo 6 місяців тому +1

    Ill never forget her. I watched 3rd doctor and i loved her adventures. I will never fprget her. Perfectly cast

  • @cerooscuas
    @cerooscuas Рік тому +1

    That scene at the end was tennant's last scene he filmed in the tardis which is why he began to cry

  • @motionadapt1589
    @motionadapt1589 Рік тому +3

    God I miss liz so much she’s brilliant

  • @stevesm4
    @stevesm4 2 роки тому +7

    Lovely montage beautifully put together, but I was hoping to see Capaldi and his prompt cards! I know, there's no satisfying some people...

    • @PenneySounds
      @PenneySounds  2 роки тому +4

      Oh right, that could have been a funny inclusion. I could make a separate video about that

  • @meatballg8655
    @meatballg8655 Рік тому +1

    "who is the doctor?"
    "affirmative!"
    A+ writing

  • @jeremycaufield8605
    @jeremycaufield8605 2 роки тому +2

    Tom Baker and Elizabeth Sladen were my introduction to Dr. Who.