Mahrang Baloch, Governance and Educational Crisis in Pakistan - Rafiullah Kakar -
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 тра 2024
- Rafiullah Kakar comes back on The Pakistan Experience to discuss why Governments fail in Pakistan. On this deep dive episode, we discuss Balochistan, Mahrang Baloch, The Elections, Why Governments Fail in Pakistan, Service Delivery, Education and more.
Rafiullah Kakar is a Public policy and development specialist from Balochistan.
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
shehzad89
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
1:30 Mahrang Baloch's Protest and Baloch separatism
12:04 Balochistan Elections
14:30 Why Governments fail at service delivery
25:00 Conflict, Interference, Governance and Demands of People
44:00 Pakistan's Education Crisis unpacked
1:16:00 Conclusion - Розваги
This is the most accurate, up to date, real, uncensored, unsensationalized version of Balochistan situation.
Thank you so much for bringing Rafiullah Kakar again.
🙌
We Baloch are happy that we have brother Like Mr kakar such gem talent from our beloved province
I heard once from shabbar zaidi that intellectually top tier of Pakistan have already left and now second tier is running the country.
But after hearing Rafiullah it sounds like we still have someone from top tier and he is trying his best to improve the system.
Best wishes for kakar sab ❤❤
❤️
Not for long
I am from Baluchistan........This gentleman is a GEM......Such quality of unbiased analysis.
Free Balochistan 😢😢
without criticizing a single, he explained and articulated many issues very well, every person can listen to this, and everyone should
Gazzab clarity of thought. It is flowing. Captivating. I wish I could sit in his class and he was my professor in Political science in law. His reasoning is so orderly.
Rafiullah is one of our brilliant star from Balochistan.He share his ideas , thoughts for those specially who understand the situation of Balochistan.
Free Balochistan 😢😢
Kakar sahab ko sun k optimist ho jata hun that yes we can solve all these problems. Bas sab sa phaly us problem ko identify karny ki zarorat hy and then demand in the organised form. Good work shehzad 👏
🙌
So much learned and so much sanity and clarity in identifying the issues and always suggesting a resolution along with it. No doubt that RUK is such a GEM who is needed in our politics. It is always a great experience to listen to him. Great work
Need 2nd, 3rd and 4th sessions with this gentleman.
Pakistan needs people like him with great insight and deep knowledge of inner working of connected wheels of the system to be part of policy making and planning.
Thank you Shehzad for this wonderful podcast.🎉
🙌
Pakistan army need advisor like him not Pakistan.
I really enjoy listening to rafiullah kakar , a very balanced approach.
This guy knows what he is talking. Liked the demand-supply format to reforms and story telling overall.
Dr.Mahrang Baloch is a brave bold and iron lady. More power to Mahrang Baloch and entire community ❤
Free Balochistan 😢😢
I have never seen such bold sound and clear speaking person he is great to represent Balochistan
Proud of Balochistan❤❤❤
Honestly integrity and accountability is required for all actors of this system in Pakistan
this guy understands Pakistan's socio-political landscape so so well
Thanks for bringing such a wide variety of guests to your podcasts . The guest had a great knowhow of the subject with clear thoughts to express
It is important to have these voices be heard in mainstream
Keep going !
🙌❤️
I have not seen/heard better than this understanding of Pakistan's issues and required solutions. In case of educational difficulties, I did hear any issue of curriculum. I expected lack of modern curriculum. I am glad that it is not a problem..
this gentleman is just gem, watching his podcast giving me an accurate knowledge i really enjoyed his podcastss
Thank you so much for bringing Rafiullah Kakar again
🙌
Another fantastic episode. Rafiullah has to at least appear annually now.
❤️
This is what a podcast must be. More of the same, please.
🙌
His way of articulation is very good.Happy to see him again❤
❤️
Yaar kya zabardast banda hai. Thanks for inviting him once again, Shehzad.
🙌
One of the major reasons for the downfall and downward spiral of Pakistan is the normalization of what shouldn't be normalized, what is wrong, and what should be fixed. The latest in the series is the normalization of election rigging. Even top journalists are saying' Well, elections are rigged but so what? elections were rigged in 2018 also and before that also.' They are uttering this as if there is absolutely no need to fix it and election rigging should be accepted as normal.
Pakistan has similarly normalized so many wrongs like Army interference in politics, misogyny, religious extremism, fanaticism and intolerance, maltreatment of religious minorities, tax evasion and whatnot.
All this collectively has made Pakistan a nation-state heading for disaster, disintegration and dissolution sooner than later.
@@ThePakistanExperiencepodcast se related usne kuch kaha hi kaha?
Usne to Pakistan ki reality batai hai, 1-1 point 100% sach hai
Zabardast. Every time I listen to Rafi sb I learn so much.
Same
Its a real treat listening to Rafiullah Kakar. He is highly articulate on the issues he talks about. Well said, a "Masterclass", Highly Informative.Thanks for inviting him again ❤
❤️
Don't twist the facts Baloch woman has taken up the street not because that they are progressive but because all the Baloch men are either jailed or are being tortured by the Pakistani Army. These women wants closure that whether their family member are even alive or not.
😢
Even if they weren't in jail, Baloch women would still be active. That is their culture.
@@balajjamal2671free Balochistan 😢😢
شہزاد، آپ کا بہت بہت شکریہ کہ آپ نے رفیع اللہ کاکڑ کو اپنے پوڈ کاسٹ میں مدعو کیا۔ پچھلی بار بھی جب آپ نے انہیں بلایا تو مجھے بہت پسند آیا۔ مجھے کافی کچھ سیکھنے اور سمجھنے کو ملا۔
About to start the podcast shehzad Bhai. My presumption about the question is cuz there was no political insight from day 1 after independence.. Muslim league fought for Pakistan but they didn't had the slightest idea what to do next...All Mohd ali Jinnah wanted was as much area of northern India as he could.. He had no interest in KPK or Baluchistan.. and that has been the insight of the state ever since regarding these areas..
Brilliant session by Rafiullah Kakar -- absolutely love it every time he comes on the podcast! Can not wait for another one with him
🙌
Good to see the legend Rafi jaan himself on the show..he is one of the sane guys
Legend!
Wow once again , he is my favrt
He really should be essential listening for all Pakistanis
What an insightful conversation. Mr. kakar’s articulation of problems that Pakistan faces is remarkable! Thank you Shehzad for this
🙌
Easily the most clear articulate expert I’ve heard on a pakistani show no pretensions, clear empathy for the challenges we all face this is my most favourite speaker from this show! Please do a series with him
🙌
An excellent podcast, Rafiullah Kakar, to my mind is an absolute gem out of Balochistan. He talks about the skewed federal structure, the variety of issues that confront smaller provinces, and Balochistan in particular; the disconnect between the various branches and departments in the government, the absence of accountability of the senior members of the administration, and a focus on holding people at the lower level accountable, the issues that confront education; the stunted evolution of political parties and leadership owing to short tenures owing to the intrusion of the military etc, etc,. His analysis presents remedies and is not simply a series of complaints. Kudos to Shehzad Ghias Shaikh for inviting quality people and being extremely prepared to ask probing questions.
🙌
Such a great gem of knowledge will meet him one day insha'Allah,, and congrats to Rafiullah Kakar for selecting in Oxford university for PhD well deserve sir more power to you
Shahzad, it would be great if you could get a journalist from Balochistan on your Podcast. I know there are not many who talk openly about things, but someone who can discuss how journalism and journalists have been controlled in the region would be valuable.
Adnan Amir
Syed Ali Shah (Dawn Beauchief Balochistan)
Kiya Baloch
Shahmir Baloch (Writes for The Guardian)
The few names that I can remember but there are others as well.
Very rewarding Podcast!
Rafiullah Sb has a very charming personality and its always a pleasure listening to him especially since I'm a student of Public Policy.
His Analysis about the recent protest movement of Mahrang Baloch is wholly accurate, anybody who wants to inform themselves about Balochistan should listen to him!
Are waah, please promote this much more guys, i bet uneducated won't understand it, but the baloch guy almost cried it out all he had to say in just one hour and he was so to the point , quick, in simple words and every other things possible in an interview. Kudos to speaker and host bhai as well...
Kakar sb never disappoints. Very insightful.
🙌
Here you go again Rafiullah sir. Amazing to have you again .
Extremely accurate about Dera Jaat. DGKhan being part of Punjab and DIKhan being part of KP have always been considered to be Either Pashtun or Punjabi areas because they are part of respective provinces but in reality, these are Baloch areas.
Thank you Shazad for bringing up Rafiullah again. It's always a treat to listen to him. I always listen your podcast on Google podcast before going to bed. In my opinion, Dawn and your podcast are uncensored and very well articulated. Please, invite Rafiullah sb often. We would like to listen to him on range of subjects.
❤️
This guy should be the Prime Minister !!
one of the best things about your podcast that you gave us RUK and atif Mian. such a gem of a persons.
the only thing in the podcast was the demand side doesn’t want things. the problem is Demand side were deliberately kept aside from original issues. Now peoples like Shehzad and Muazmil are the one who must be appreciated to point out what was kept out of sight from us.
🙌
Appreciated
Listened to this podcast from a small central Florida city Sebring where I work as a physician. WHAT A Masterclass! This podcast has inspired me to work on education in my hometown Peshawar soon along with expat friends iA.
🙌
What a smart analysis of the situation and wider view of the issue, instead of repeating the same old stuff like most punjabi commentators.
I think Islamabad lack the vision to solve the problems facing Pakistan.
This man should be the politician in Pakistan.
The great Rafiullah Kakar....
Wonderful discussions. Overwhelming negative stats laid out that are eye opening. The guest is gifted speaker 👏👏
🙌
You all can talk and talk until Army and all institutions report unconditionally and accountable directly to Civil Govt Head as in: Prime Minister (interim or fully elected). That’s the elephant 🐘 in the Room
Definitely one of my favourite people that come on your podcast, keep up the great work!
Here we go 🤗
Rafiullah kakar Saab again .. I think you should release different long episodes of podcasts with him on different topics , in which you should cover problems/roadblocks and wayforward ....
Really very accomplished, informed, humane and a lovable guest and a great conversation. Such men surely make difference in the fortunes of society / nation, but in long run and largely not visible and go unsung and not recognised,
Actually the backwardness in education and “ lack of demand “ argument doesn't hold well. In my life I haven't seen any mass protest or demand for better educational / health facilities in our south asian region and least in Europe or America. The local governments at village, ward and municipal levels take care of the issues. The school administration including it's staff, resources and finances are handled by elected authorities at these levels. They have highstakes in smooth running of the education and health facilities as these things help them in their re-election to office and strengthens their position in the party .18th. Amendments needs to be extended till village / municipal levels. Yes he was very correct when he said spending on education isn't less or comparable to any fellow asian countries buttge way this budget is utilised remains a spoilt of huge worry.
His discourse on individual morality vis-a-vis political morality was very good
In Sindh, government primary schools have improved after the appointment of new teachers. However, there is still a need for more focus as thousands of children lost access to education due to the floods.
Rafiullah is very intelligent and articulate.
Salam. Nice talk. Very informative and insightful. Karkar Sb is very articulate and factual.
JazakAllah kher
Great and reasonable analysis about Balochistan
Every word of Kakar Sahab is a beautiful reflection of refined insight on public policy matters... Love an respect from Quetta
All time favorite kakar saab❤
I only have notifications on for this channel,so underrated,keep doing good work 👍🏿
🙌
My sincere condolences to all Balochis, Sindhis, Saraikis and Pathans to be part of this Pakistan concept.
Education minister banana chahihy Kakar sahib ko amazing guy🎉🎉🎉
He’s amazing
This is one the all time fav podcast plz do engage with mr kakar
Wow, amazing brilliant mind. When I listen to people like Kakar Sahab, hope floats for Pakistan. True Jihadis!! Thank you for inviting him over again Shehzad.
🙌
بھت اچھے انداز سے مسائل کو بیان کیا
Thank you kakar sab one of the most informative podcast everything is explained very well
🙌
That was brilliant. Every sentence was a gem 💎
❤️
No words, surpassed expectations!
Superb analysis! Please do a session with him on his life story and experiences. We can learn a lot and it will inspire countless youngsters in PK.
🙌
How nice, a pleasure listening to Mr. Kakar. Eloquent, passionate and very thoughtful personality. Thanks for organizing and masterfully conducting this chat.
🙌
Very informative
Abul kalam azad 24 prediction of pakistan came true
What were those predictions?
Pakistan needs a secular liberal democracy. There's no chance we're going to make our people's lives better otherwise.
Perhaps one of the biggest personalities in Pakistan!
The point that RafiUllah mentioned is that we don't have the qualified teachers and this is also a big reason that children lost interest in their studies because the teachers have not been able to teach the students very well. When I was in my 10th class in a government school in Dera bugti I can't even explain the simple definition of physics. But when I completed my matric by doing cheating in papers, and then went to a private academy to study my fsc. The professors in that academy were so great in their subjects that when I gave the medical entrance test after fsc the physics became my top scoring subject. We need qualified teachers or we have to train the teachers that are already in their service.
He is soo good at explaining things. We need a new series with him🤧
Pakistani army never won a war and never lost any election 😂
Get a job kid
@@urdukahaniyan1834 🙂
The pak fauj is now losing elections!😂
The kid must have heard this comment from some Fauji hating Pakistanis and now he will keep regurgitating it until his next janam. Just another sad Hindutva soul whose sole purpose of existence is watching and commenting on Pakistani podcasts.
The kid must have heard this comment from some Fauji hating Pakistanis and now he will keep regurgitating it until his next janam. Just another sad Hindutva soul whose sole purpose of existence is watching and commenting on Pakistani podcasts.
Your external environment shapes you and vice versa.
one of the best Talks
🙌
Thank you Shahzad , For bringing this gentleman again on podcast❤
❤️
VP Singh government lasted 16 months from 89 to 90. ChandrashekhR government lasted 5 months from 1990 to 1991. That is when Narsimha Rao came to power with a coalition government. He could not have expected to last a full term. But he brought in transformational reforms. After Narsimha Rao govt. Lost in 1996, there were two governments that were out if power within 1 year each. At that time Vajpayee came to power in 1998. He did not ecoect a 5 yearcterm. But he initiated a transformationsl peace pricess with Pakistan apart from the nuclear detonation in 1998 may. Within 1 year he lost vote of confidence. He was re-elected in 1999. Did he expect a 5 year term when no non-congress government had ever completed one? No. But even then he took some major structural reforms.
I do not agree with the hypothesis that politicians can be given a free pass if they do not expect a full term. Neither Narsimha Rso nor Vajpayee had that expectation but they did what was right for the country.
Just brilliant ❤
❤️
Free Balochistan 🧡
He is simply the best. PM material.
I agree
Abey order to usney Army chief ki hi follow karni hai after being PM. Anwar ul haq kakar ko hi dekh lo. Army chief ka Spokesperson hi to hai. Ekdum foji style me baat kartaa hai.
I actually love your podcasts. This is my fav podcast when I walk my dog. As an unbiased Indian I would choose to believe we really don’t want to take over Pakistan. POK maybe. But we actually want a secure border with Pakistan so I would really recommend that we get over the punjabi revenge mindset and move over to more fun times. Lots of fun to be had, why do u need a fauj on your Eastern front when they are happy with what the country has done to itself. 50% reduction in fauj and a border with India is good enough to take care of Af. Lots of benefits to be had if u just agree. Remember 100 years of Franco German conflict and now they have no borders so nothing to win
Kya gajab ka aadmi hai 🙏🏾, maja aa gaya bhai ki baat sun ke.
👐
Rafiullah Kakar is so brilliant that my brain hurts while listening him. Superb discussion especially the social morality part. We, as a society, have normalised professional dishonesty.
🙌
Listening to this man for the second time, I am extremely influenced by his brilliance.
Pakistan armed forces need civilian advisor like this gentleman for policy making.
Luv to RUK ❤ thanks Shazad🌹
❤️
I have downloaded podcast go app for the android, and i cannot find a lot of your podcasts there which are present on the UA-cam why is that so?
I'd love you and your guests using simple and easily understandable terms in order to reach out to a larger audience because I am sure most people don't understand some of the terms used by Kakar sahb or even other guests..
Rafi Ullah Kakar should be invited to The Black Hole, Islamabad and to tv talk shows.
One of the finest mind
I agree
Rafiullah the great ❤
❤️
The fundamental reason why Pakistanis are stuck or not progressing is because the leaders and even people don’t love the land they live in. They struggle with identity issues and other issues.
A leader like Modi will fix Pakistan. One can only pray that Pakistanis find that Modi for themselves.
Shazad well said......."Mere tak aaya hai to na hi samzo "
So true..........😂
:D
@@ThePakistanExperience
Sorry didn't understood....:D???? What does it mean???
@@kiranmoghe3716it's a smiley
@@khadijakashaf4369
Ok. Thanks
بہت ہی عمدہ تجزیہ کیا کاکٹر صاحب نے۔
🙌
very informative vedio
Video*
🙌