at 16:10 he said ''Modiji Kehte Hain Muzalmaano Ko Pakistan Bhej Do .. Clean Kardo ..'' If i file a case against him in UK or USA for defamation and falsely maligning a person through lies, he could be made to pay 50k pounds minimum, or else he could be barred from those countries. Also, your channel, could face issues for promoting falsehoods.
Good point indeed. But entire Pakistan was made on false ideology and falsehood is in their blood. As Richard Clarke says "Pakistanis are pathological liars".
@@Padosidesi2828 Don't make me go into what Pakistani Muzalmaan leaders say on national television. Do you remember your ISPR's Ad in which Pakistani children featured.
What India is spending today in building infra both physical and digital was last seen in China in early 2000s. India has pulled 443 millions people out of poverty (source :UN report), yet India is “ struggling with populism”. Of course India has her challenges, our per capita income is only 2000 USD, but remember it was only 200 USD 30 years ago. Critique Modi by all means, there is so much out there to be critical, just don’t be lazy by just saying “India is struggling under populism” 15:11
They are blind, they don't upgrade their knowledge. Their source of knowledge through propaganda, everyone in pak are experts about india. They don't have any knowledge, they just follow newspapers and youtube and thinks theyknew everything about India. let them think like that. one day they make comparision videos and reaction video in future. we are growing, we are trying to solve issues, we are in right path.
1. well haters! put Modi in the same league as populists ...Modi remains popular because he delivers unlike populists! 2. this is not the hate for Modi but for Hindus (non-muslims) which is totally understandable from brainwashed people of 21st century that follow a guy (ashique rasool!!) who commited pedophilia, lusted his son's wife, kept sex slaves, ordered killings loot, committed murder, persecuted non-muslims, destroyed other places of worships, persecuted women - made them 3rd class citizen, promoted religious hatred, (humanity is ashamed!) ... 3. Modi has been the most popular leader because he has delivered. He was just a pracharak from a very humble background... BJP's internal party structure is totally democratic unlike dynasts parties...got promoted as a CM of Gujrat cuz of his hard work and effectiveness....took Gujrat to a different league, whole India started talking about the Gujrat model...his popularity rose as a national leader... 4. since the past 9 years he has been doing very good work as a PM...be it structural reforms, social welfare, physical and digital infra, cleaning & upliftment of the financial and banking sector, foreign policy, promoting innovation, start-ups, NEP, ease of business, etc. etc. etc. if you do an objective assessment, the socio-economic upliftment of Muslims that happened during Modi has never happened before......
16:00 So called Pakistani intellectual for information. India main Muslim ko caste base resarvation diya jata OBC,SC. Pakistan mein dete ho. Pakistan Muslim main upper caste nhi hai??.
The best thing I like about the host, SGS, is that he prepares well before every podcast: he analyses the opinions, negates as he deems so, and sometimes bombards counter questions - in this way, the listeners learn.
What a lovely dialogue between two intellectual giants of Pakistan, surely a very positive journalism, shall make difference in the present state of affairs though not immediately but in the long run . Raza's analytics and perceptions of the current situation with reference to Imrando phenomenon was marvelous 🎉🎉 . What I loved the most is his 5 remedies for current depressing scenario. Yes I totally agree with him when he says Number 1 is consolidation of local self governments in Pakistan. These days in Pakistan there is a lot of talk in section of Pakistani press about India progressing, it's strong economy, independent foreign policy, it's strong diaspora, education system and so on ! Unfortunately no one talks about how over last 50 years , Local self Governments have established themselves and contributed massively to overall democratic process and bringing in an inclusiveness in the total political process. Reservation of seats for women, socially backward s 0:07 ections was really a game changer. Well, the local self governments are not merely restricted to Gram Panchayats, Municipal Councils, Corporations etc but to Zilla Parishads, Panchayat Samitis, Agriculture Committees cooperative societies, banks, factories and so many other institutions. Bringing in primary and secondary education, health, PDS, under the preview of these local self governments gives people much required voice in state affairs.! The elections are fairly fair and these institutions act as lungs for national democratic system . These are the real propellers of progress.
I had a bet with my friend that these two Pakistanis will surely take name of Modi and India even though these title of this podcast has nothing to do with India or Modi... And within 16 minutes they have taken these two names. My friend was like why do they take these names and I said oh well khana nahi pachega inn do naamo ke bina😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@manu.ba374 mujhe to ye youtube me aaya aur main samjh gaya ki yahan modi aur india ki bitching hogi hi, mera dost bola ki nahi to 20 minutes jhelna pada just only for 500 ka bet
This is a podcast about populism. It's no surprise that people like Erdogan/Trump/IK/Modi etc will be mentioned. Yani obvious baat kar ke special feel kar rahe ho. 😂 Choose non-economic/political podcasts and you won't find any mention of Modi/Trump/Erdogan etc.
@@animeshkumar3121 Jani, jhoot kiun bol raha ha? Multiple videos par comment karne ke baad YT par daal raha ha. 😂 Deflections like these won't help, you're engaging in a similar type of behaviour that you're criticising the podcaster for.
It’s always a pleasure to listen to Raza Rumi Saheb.. Really admire him. A slight disconnect with him about Modi n India which appears to be highly biased n not in sync with reality. It appears that he is drawing his conclusions on stray incidences or the misinformation spread by political opponents.Moreover all along since independence of India, Pakistan n it’s intellectuals are talking of atrocities on Indian Muslims but I would urge all to look around the world, muslims are killing Muslims in thousands if not lacs, be it in Pakistan, Afghanistan, Middle East, Africa or elsewhere. Muslims are the safest in India… by any stretch of imagination 💭.. Having said that weather more to be done, yes. But don’t paint absolutely bizarre picture of India.
sorry to Say yesterday two Muslims boys shot dead by railway guard (who supposed to safe them) and he was chanting Modi and Yogi..... second incident A mosque in Gurgaon near Delhi Indian Capital was burned and naib imam was killed by Hindu Extremist Mob still Muslims houses are burning but no police no one care .... you know who support Yogi and Extremist Hindus.
Weird how you could ask any specific group and they'd accuse people like him of the same thing. Ask any IK/Erdogan/Trump etc fan and they'd accuse him of the same bias and not being in touch with "reality" but he'd be correct about the other groups lmao. It's always bizarre to see how little people introspect and analyse their positions.
@@waleedabbas4996 weird as you are sou ding as not able to appreciate or comprehend the varying point of view... how little n bizarre someone like you sound when not tolerant of other point of view..
Overseas have invested more but were waiting for the system to be fixed. IK was intelligent to break the assemblies to show all touts, and if not, with time, all of his members were tamed by agencies, and by the time elections happened, everything would be against IK. IK was winning already. If Establishment brought IK, why not they bring sharifs as all departments' chiefs are PET of Nawaz Sharif. These programs are new methods by establishment to start slow poisoning against IK
Good episode! A small correction: Raza Rumi teaches at the Ithaca College which is independent of Cornell University. The only thing they have in common is their location in Ithaca. I was surprised that Raza didn't correct you when you introduced him as teaching in Cornell.
And it should not be in a good way….. Modi is driving us where Pakistan already is. It will take 10 years for the well read Andh bhakt to realize that, the rural illiterate Andh Bhakt will never get it
@@dodiraj1 Yes, why would Modi be mentioned in an episode about Populism? Why are Erdogan/IK/Trump etc all mentioned? This isn't remotely a surprise. Ajeeb unparh awam uth kar aa jati ha tumhari. Jani, watch a non-political/economic episode and you won't find Modi.
Its pleasing to listen to Raza Rumi just as his writings. I beg to diff with him when he says that jo PTI k sath ho raha hay wo pehlay bhee hota raha hay. That was wrong and this is wrong too. So plz for the sake of our coming generation stop saying it.
Hi Shezad, great talk as usual. Would like your take on the new law passed by the parliament giving sweeping powers to the military . That is if it is safe for you to discuss considering the "New law" bulldozed through by the ruling party.
These converted " PUNJABI MUSALMAANAA DEY MUNDEY INKALAB JUNG MAIHNAAT NAI KARDEY BUSS SODEY DEALAA SURRENDER KARDEY NAI " Under the influence of 8th century feudal brutal barbarian blood thirsty political ideology called Isl.....
Sir can you please make a Podcast where you can invite the all 3 leaders of 3 big parties like PTI, PPP, PML and interview Infront of each other face to face. if anyone of them like if anyone of them claim anything just ask them with prove.
Dear Shehzad You conduct fanatastic interviews. I wish you would invite Mr. J Sai Deepak and discuss his book India Bharat & Pakistan. I think this interview would be enlighten not only Pakistani public but also give you a deeper understanding of the concerns/point of view of the Hindu Community.
Dear Mr Sehjad I saw your program on 1971 / Bangladesh, Urdu and Sabnis mother - who had spent childhood at Dhaka and Kolkata. You are the only Pakistani whom I heard crying in pain agony trauma and tears - on the massacre of Hindus and Sikhs. I respect your feelings Urdu - we cannot separate mother mother tongue and motherland from a person. It will be zulm which Pakistani are suffering. I beg to Disagree with your guest ( I had seen his many program with Mr Nazam Sethi ) No Indian or BJP or Modi ji want Muslims should go out of India. Statement is cheap demeaning and irresponsible in poor taste Indian culture - you may call it living habits religions values - accept all faith followers Population of Muslim are rising in India since 1947 There is no outbound migration towards Pakistan of Muslims from India Hatred with India and Hindus, text books of schools, will not take society towards peace harmony and progress Aforesaid is for guest You are a pure soul
Solutions of Pakistans path to development in the views of Raza Romi and Pervaiz Hoodbhayi is similar to a top chef who was hired by a restaurant owner to teach his cooks.when the cooks asked chef how to fry an egg. The chef asked was chicken born first or egg.
Yaar Shezad aap toh Imran Khan ko zameen mai gar ke hi jaoga. Bhai aga bad jao Imran se bhi. It's becoming quite frustating, I can't even bear the podcast longer than 20 minutes. It feels like a tape recorder which is playing a single tape for months now.
@@ThePakistanExperience You are not making dedicated videos on Imran or PTI but there are enough snippets and name calling of Imran Khan in these podcasts. I just think that he has become irrelevant and I have heard about him a lot in the last year
@@gosliglitzho you don't seem to be from this neck of the woods my friend - he said it earnestly and so did I - facts are sarcastic in the promised land (Edit) I love PMJ too, by the way.
"Modiji kahtey hai musalmanoko pakistan bhejdo..." WOW. I wonder where did you hear that? When you claim to be a fact based journalist and then mention lazy hyperbole lines like these it becomes very difficult to trust you as being an honest journalist.
Im doing this unpaid internship and it gets stressful but when you release an episode, i can relax listening to your conversations and the day gets a little better. thank you shehzad❤️❤️
Thanks a lot Shehzad !!! 👍👍👍 Since you are doing some of the podcasts with the noted journalists/columnists/analysts, therefore I am also requesting you to do a few more with the following (if possible): Zubaida Mustafa (Dawn, Khi) Huma Yousuf (Independent/Dawn, US) Ayesha Siddiqua (Independent/The Express Tribune, UK) Mubashir Zaidi (VOA Urdu, US) Rafia Zakaria (Independent/Dawn, US) Wajahat Masood (Hum Sub, Lhr) Azhar Abbas (GEO News, Khi) Zafar Abbas (Dawn, Khi) Arifa Noor (Dawn/Dawn News, Isb) Zahid Husain (Independent/Dawn, Isb) Dr. Anjum Altaf (Education/Dawn, Khi) Dr. Nazir Mahmood (Independent/The News/Jang/Dawn, Isb) Akbar Zaidi (IBA/Dawn, Khi) Dr. Tariq Khosa (Police/Defense Analyst/Dawn, Khi) Haris Khalique (Independent/Dawn, Isb) Kishwar Naheed (Independent/Jang, Isb) Raza Ali Abidi (BBC Urdu/Jang, UK) And many more obviously 😊😊😊 The above-mentioned are the saner voices of our country & the ones who are not visible much in our mass media in Pakistan & abroad. So please do try your best.
Most of discussion is rational, I enjoyed the conversation but it's too short to cover the relevant questions of current situation in Pakistan. Overall it's good podcast 👍
One of the best Podcasts on this Channel. a very beautiful experience of Listening to Raza Rumi Sahab. Thank You Shahzad ❤ Keep Educating Pakistani Youth on Current Political Situations.
Very nice discussion going on I would like to give my comment's point by point as per my knowledge and understanding Imran Khan was supported and brought into power by the Establishment To counter Nawaz Shareef Reason is Nawaz Shareef did not accept the supremacy of the Army over rule of politicians and parliament Although Nawaz Shareef was a popular leader Three times he was elected Prime Minister of Pakistan Last time it was General Bajwa who had developed differences with Nawaz Shareef Imran Khan acted as he was told He was on good books on the same page with the Establishment Differences between General Bajwa and Imran Khan erupted Vote of no confidence was passed Since then there is a political turmoil in the country God Almighty had given Imran Khan a golden chance But not only he missed the opportunity He seems to have lost the chance
I don't think until or unless feudalism is completely removed from a state, democracy can even start there... Pakistan is one of the last countries in the world where feudalism is still in practice.. How can democracy even be born there if govt still supports feudalism?
True but land reforms should've been done at the country's inception. India did so and look at it now, there might be some of it still remaining in India's part of Punjab but as a whole not much. I just wish India and Pakistan could come together and really sit down and focus on trade, challenges such as water, poverty, food scarcity etc.
Modi is populist? Lmfao 🤣🤣 the guy is a establishment stooge .... he's all alone and isolated and some people on the right side of the spectrum see through it ...and we want him to go...
Shehzad please do a detailed series on Fauj org businesses and it earning streams , can’t the org start paying back the national debt with such huge earning they have , apparently 24 billion each year … what is the real story ??
Shehzad big fan... but we're not facing any populism look at our GDP look at our foreign reserves look at how the world is treating us...i respect you a lot because you do your research before you comment on something this is not what we expect on you
Establishment hi sub say zy qasoorwar hai, politician to yaqeenan corrupt aur moqa parast hain lekin establishment ne ajtak political culture ko itna strong honay hi kab diya hai , pakistan bantay hi inki beghairtiyan shuru ho gayi thin, courts say lay kar media tak per inka control hai, inhi ki waja say aj tak koi aur idara itna mazboot nahi ho saka ,
Thank you for posting! I'm listening this to release my stress 😅 Also, I graduated recently from a Top 50 globally ranked university. Lemme know if I could contribute in terms of R&D for The Pakistan Experience. I'm willing to drop my email for a while.
Thanks Shahzad for giving us such an invaluable podcast. This sir just stated all the facts what Inspector Poirot would say "as they are not as you want them to be" Hats off to your courage Be healthy be safe especially BE SAFE
Unfortunately we have become a nation of beggars For the last 75 years every outgoing government government hands over the begging bowl to the incoming new government Every new government which comes into power Promise the same old statement But nothing happens
Hey Shehzad you’ve done so well for these podcasts!!! Since you came to Lahore this time and I forgot to recommend someone. It would be so helpful if you could get the editors of the Khorasan Diary like Iftikhar Firdous and do a podcast with them. They can give the best explanation of the conflict in Balochistan and KP something every Pakistani needs to know in order to understand the scale of whats about to hit them
For all those Pakistanis badmouthing Modi on his alleged mistreatment of Muslims please answer following questions 1) Is true that there is public holidays on Bakri id, Eid ul Adha, Christmas and Diwali. Does Pakistan have holidays on Holi and Diwali 2) What is number of mosques, temples, gurudwaras in each Indian city. A simple Google maps search can suffice 3) Has any government schemes denied to minorities 4) Has any minority political candidate or party been denied tickets 5) How is CAA discriminatory and what is normal process of getting Indian citizenship 6) How much land was to UP waqf board for Babri Masjid case verdict in 2019
Shehzad bhai: Good to know that you didn't eat any "crap" before this podcast (like you did recently in Jhelum). "Once bitten, twice shy" is the philosophy. 🤓😀
at 16:10 he said ''Modiji Kehte Hain Muzalmaano Ko Pakistan Bhej Do .. Clean Kardo ..''
If i file a case against him in UK or USA for defamation and falsely maligning a person through lies, he could be made to pay 50k pounds minimum, or else he could be barred from those countries.
Also, your channel, could face issues for promoting falsehoods.
Good point indeed. But entire Pakistan was made on false ideology and falsehood is in their blood. As Richard Clarke says "Pakistanis are pathological liars".
Don’t know about Modiji but Modiji’s party colleagues and ideological co-travelers have said this again and again and most certainly much worse.
@@Padosidesi2828 Don't make me go into what Pakistani Muzalmaan leaders say on national television.
Do you remember your ISPR's Ad in which Pakistani children featured.
Quite interesting conversation ❤
❤
What India is spending today in building infra both physical and digital was last seen in China in early 2000s.
India has pulled 443 millions people out of poverty (source :UN report), yet India is “ struggling with populism”. Of course India has her challenges, our per capita income is only 2000 USD, but remember it was only 200 USD 30 years ago. Critique Modi by all means, there is so much out there to be critical, just don’t be lazy by just saying “India is struggling under populism” 15:11
India par fact par nhi bas wahi Inka Lahori churan bechne wala Kam hai.
Ssshhhhh..... Inko ye sab mat batao. Let them live under the impression that they live in
@@animeshkumar3121 Bhai bolna jaruri hai
They are blind, they don't upgrade their knowledge. Their source of knowledge through propaganda, everyone in pak are experts about india. They don't have any knowledge, they just follow newspapers and youtube and thinks theyknew everything about India. let them think like that. one day they make comparision videos and reaction video in future. we are growing, we are trying to solve issues, we are in right path.
@@dipakggupta5933bhai murkho se behas ni ki jaati ..wo apne jahil pane se aapko bewkuf sabit kr dega.pak is run by pak army not politicians
1. well haters! put Modi in the same league as populists ...Modi remains popular because he delivers unlike populists!
2. this is not the hate for Modi but for Hindus (non-muslims) which is totally understandable from brainwashed people of 21st century that follow a guy (ashique rasool!!) who commited pedophilia, lusted his son's wife, kept sex slaves, ordered killings loot, committed murder, persecuted non-muslims, destroyed other places of worships, persecuted women - made them 3rd class citizen, promoted religious hatred, (humanity is ashamed!) ...
3. Modi has been the most popular leader because he has delivered. He was just a pracharak from a very humble background... BJP's internal party structure is totally democratic unlike dynasts parties...got promoted as a CM of Gujrat cuz of his hard work and effectiveness....took Gujrat to a different league, whole India started talking about the Gujrat model...his popularity rose as a national leader...
4. since the past 9 years he has been doing very good work as a PM...be it structural reforms, social welfare, physical and digital infra, cleaning & upliftment of the financial and banking sector, foreign policy, promoting innovation, start-ups, NEP, ease of business, etc. etc. etc. if you do an objective assessment, the socio-economic upliftment of Muslims that happened during Modi has never happened before......
16:00 So called Pakistani intellectual for information.
India main Muslim ko caste base resarvation diya jata OBC,SC. Pakistan mein dete ho. Pakistan Muslim main upper caste nhi hai??.
Zaid hamid aur Haroon ur Rasheed ke khalu ke bete hain ye.
Brilliant. Kya kahoon! Solid and fact based discussion on the current events.What a honest conversation. Bravo.
🙌
I have been critical of Raza Rumi in Naya Daur to. But for a change I agree with him here.
I think Pakistan has extraordinary people with amazing talent.
Soft Islamist 😂😂😂. 2014 se Modi hai kitne % muslim papulation Kam hue koe data hai. So called Pakistani intellectual.
ua-cam.com/video/6KG5uCJ-bHM/v-deo.html
Bro, Pakistanis hate Modi more than they love allah.
The best thing I like about the host, SGS, is that he prepares well before every podcast: he analyses the opinions, negates as he deems so, and sometimes bombards counter questions - in this way, the listeners learn.
❤
Thanks was privileged to hear you guys
🙌
This particular podcast was such a pleasure to listen to. Shehzad, I hope this hits the 1 million mark. You rock!
🙌
Blind following needs to stop @ 11:30 - Super agreed !!! We must question our leader and our leader MUST answer to us
No mention of human right issues in the banana republic of Pakistan
I guess social justice does not matter to this crowd
What a lovely dialogue between two intellectual giants of Pakistan, surely a very positive journalism, shall make difference in the present state of affairs though not immediately but in the long run .
Raza's analytics and perceptions of the current situation with reference to Imrando phenomenon was marvelous 🎉🎉 .
What I loved the most is his 5 remedies for current depressing scenario. Yes I totally agree with him when he says Number 1 is consolidation of local self governments in Pakistan. These days in Pakistan there is a lot of talk in section of Pakistani press about India progressing, it's strong economy, independent foreign policy, it's strong diaspora, education system and so on ! Unfortunately no one talks about how over last 50 years , Local self Governments have established themselves and contributed massively to overall democratic process and bringing in an inclusiveness in the total political process. Reservation of seats for women, socially backward s 0:07 ections was really a game changer. Well, the local self governments are not merely restricted to Gram Panchayats, Municipal Councils, Corporations etc but to Zilla Parishads, Panchayat Samitis, Agriculture Committees cooperative societies, banks, factories and so many other institutions. Bringing in primary and secondary education, health, PDS, under the preview of these local self governments gives people much required voice in state affairs.! The elections are fairly fair and these institutions act as lungs for national democratic system . These are the real propellers of progress.
🙌
I had a bet with my friend that these two Pakistanis will surely take name of Modi and India even though these title of this podcast has nothing to do with India or Modi... And within 16 minutes they have taken these two names.
My friend was like why do they take these names and I said oh well khana nahi pachega inn do naamo ke bina😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Tu yahan par kyun hai??
Pakistan ke liye??😑
Hypocrisy ki bhi seema hoti ha pRakash😕
@@manu.ba374 mujhe to ye youtube me aaya aur main samjh gaya ki yahan modi aur india ki bitching hogi hi, mera dost bola ki nahi to 20 minutes jhelna pada just only for 500 ka bet
@@manu.ba374 waise modi ka dialogue maara to padhke achcha laga
This is a podcast about populism. It's no surprise that people like Erdogan/Trump/IK/Modi etc will be mentioned. Yani obvious baat kar ke special feel kar rahe ho. 😂
Choose non-economic/political podcasts and you won't find any mention of Modi/Trump/Erdogan etc.
@@animeshkumar3121 Jani, jhoot kiun bol raha ha? Multiple videos par comment karne ke baad YT par daal raha ha. 😂
Deflections like these won't help, you're engaging in a similar type of behaviour that you're criticising the podcaster for.
Pakistani experts never disappoints!
Pakistanis should focus internally. Calling others populist won’t help you . We will handle our problems
GROWTH RATE DID INCREASE UNDER IMRAN KHAN THAT IS A FACT. AND PEOPLE FROM OTHER COUNTRIES CAME TO PAKISTAN ON A RECORD HIGH . THAT IS ALSO A FACT.
nicely articulated and intellectual discussion.
🙌
Very informative..... Thanks. Intelligent discussion... Maza aa gaya...
🙌
These guys are really funny, they are still living in a different world, actually this is called applying soap on each others back 😂😂😂
😂...what happened??
contradicting
Raza rumi is an establishment tout turned sour due to the treatment meted out to him during Bajwa/Faiz regime.
It’s always a pleasure to listen to Raza Rumi Saheb.. Really admire him. A slight disconnect with him about Modi n India which appears to be highly biased n not in sync with reality. It appears that he is drawing his conclusions on stray incidences or the misinformation spread by political opponents.Moreover all along since independence of India, Pakistan n it’s intellectuals are talking of atrocities on Indian Muslims but I would urge all to look around the world, muslims are killing Muslims in thousands if not lacs, be it in Pakistan, Afghanistan, Middle East, Africa or elsewhere. Muslims are the safest in India… by any stretch of imagination 💭.. Having said that weather more to be done, yes. But don’t paint absolutely bizarre picture of India.
ua-cam.com/video/6KG5uCJ-bHM/v-deo.html
sorry to Say yesterday two Muslims boys shot dead by railway guard (who supposed to safe them) and he was chanting Modi and Yogi..... second incident A mosque in Gurgaon near Delhi Indian Capital was burned and naib imam was killed by Hindu Extremist Mob still Muslims houses are burning but no police no one care .... you know who support Yogi and Extremist Hindus.
@2107Slash How it is poor? What real reason on ground you have to say so? Any real stats?
Weird how you could ask any specific group and they'd accuse people like him of the same thing. Ask any IK/Erdogan/Trump etc fan and they'd accuse him of the same bias and not being in touch with "reality" but he'd be correct about the other groups lmao.
It's always bizarre to see how little people introspect and analyse their positions.
@@waleedabbas4996 weird as you are sou ding as not able to appreciate or comprehend the varying point of view... how little n bizarre someone like you sound when not tolerant of other point of view..
Absolute class! Shehzad is a Pakistani treasure and Rumi as a commentator is equally good.
❤
Overseas have invested more but were waiting for the system to be fixed.
IK was intelligent to break the assemblies to show all touts, and if not, with time, all of his members were tamed by agencies, and by the time elections happened, everything would be against IK.
IK was winning already. If Establishment brought IK, why not they bring sharifs as all departments' chiefs are PET of Nawaz Sharif.
These programs are new methods by establishment to start slow poisoning against IK
What a sensible sounding person
🙌
Wonderful, balanced analysis by Raza Rumi.
🙌
I wish this podcast was longer :( an hour is nearly not enough to hear the guest's views and insights.
❤
What a power pack episode.
🙌
کیا زبردست پوڈ کاسٹ کی، بہت بہتر انداز میں چیزوں کو بیان کرنے کی کوشش کی، 🎉
Super episode. Heard Rumi sir after a long time. His show with Najam Sethi was always interesting. ❤
❤
Very good and realistic discussion. Delight to listen to Raza Rumi.
🙌
Good episode! A small correction: Raza Rumi teaches at the Ithaca College which is independent of Cornell University. The only thing they have in common is their location in Ithaca. I was surprised that Raza didn't correct you when you introduced him as teaching in Cornell.
He teaches at Cornell too
@@SuhaibZafar He might teach a course or two there as an adjunct but he's a permanent faculty at Ithaca College.
He meant that Cornell is associated with Ithaca, NY State, where Ithaca College is also located.
If what India is going through is called struggling with populism - May the entire world experience such populism.
phat gyi
He meant I.N.D.I.A. struggling with populism. Not India. 😂 Which is true.
Give it a few years hotice.
.. Chaddi populism.. Later Hindus wonder why India is still a shizhole..
How long before Modi is mentioned ? Taking bets that it will be in first 10 minutes in a 1 hour podcast
15:50 You're slipping Ghisass. Man up boy - Pak sarzameen needs you.
lol
And it should not be in a good way….. Modi is driving us where Pakistan already is.
It will take 10 years for the well read Andh bhakt to realize that, the rural illiterate Andh Bhakt will never get it
@@paripatel352 Don't want to get into an argument about India with a so called Indian on a Pakistani portal. Cheers mate.
@@dodiraj1 Yes, why would Modi be mentioned in an episode about Populism? Why are Erdogan/IK/Trump etc all mentioned? This isn't remotely a surprise.
Ajeeb unparh awam uth kar aa jati ha tumhari. Jani, watch a non-political/economic episode and you won't find Modi.
Very interactive podcast. Thank you so much Shehzad
🙌
Its pleasing to listen to Raza Rumi just as his writings.
I beg to diff with him when he says that jo PTI k sath ho raha hay wo pehlay bhee hota raha hay. That was wrong and this is wrong too. So plz for the sake of our coming generation stop saying it.
I disagree with you many things Shehzad but this podcast was sublime! Good information and lots of understanding into our twisted history.
Thank God . Raza Rumi finally comes to Pakistan ❤
I second Raza Rumi, Shehzad you’re doing a great job:)
🙌
Hi Shezad, great talk as usual. Would like your take on the new law passed by the parliament giving sweeping powers to the military . That is if it is safe for you to discuss considering the "New law" bulldozed through by the ruling party.
twitter.com/Shehzad89/status/1686469760513368064?t=_0a4zD92_nqdMsUMF4Nr5A&s=19 terrible
🙌
Nazr e karam 👍
Excellent Podcast!
🙌
Good effort as always.
🙌
@@ThePakistanExperience
Plz sound quality improve kar dein. Full volume par bhi hardly sunna ja sakta hai.
Shukriya
These converted " PUNJABI MUSALMAANAA DEY MUNDEY INKALAB JUNG MAIHNAAT NAI KARDEY BUSS SODEY DEALAA SURRENDER KARDEY NAI " Under the influence of 8th century feudal brutal barbarian blood thirsty political ideology called Isl.....
Sir can you please make a Podcast where you can invite the all 3 leaders of 3 big parties like PTI, PPP, PML and interview Infront of each other face to face. if anyone of them like if anyone of them claim anything just ask them with prove.
Good work shahzad ❤
❤
Dear Shehzad
You conduct fanatastic interviews. I wish you would invite Mr. J Sai Deepak and discuss his book India Bharat & Pakistan.
I think this interview would be enlighten not only Pakistani public but also give you a deeper understanding of the concerns/point of view of the Hindu Community.
I wish the podcast was 3 hours long . What an excitement to discuss with such talented minds
❤
Dear Mr Sehjad
I saw your program on 1971 / Bangladesh, Urdu and Sabnis mother - who had spent childhood at Dhaka and Kolkata.
You are the only Pakistani whom I heard crying in pain agony trauma and tears - on the massacre of Hindus and Sikhs.
I respect your feelings
Urdu - we cannot separate mother mother tongue and motherland from a person. It will be zulm which Pakistani are suffering.
I beg to Disagree with your guest ( I had seen his many program with Mr Nazam Sethi )
No Indian or BJP or Modi ji want Muslims should go out of India.
Statement is cheap demeaning and irresponsible in poor taste
Indian culture - you may call it living habits religions values - accept all faith followers
Population of Muslim are rising in India since 1947
There is no outbound migration towards Pakistan of Muslims from India
Hatred with India and Hindus, text books of schools, will not take society towards peace
harmony and progress
Aforesaid is for guest
You are a pure soul
Thnks for uploading 2160p 👍🏻
🙌
Thanks for educating us Raza Rumi
Saved for future. Great episode
🙌
Very sane! enjoyed the conversation thoroughly
🙌
AS LONG AS SALUTE TO BOOT REMAINS IN LAND, ..............!
NO PROSPERITY, NO BETTERMENT IN LAND.
Wow Very Amazing Podcast Keep it up Good work 🙂❤
❤
16:15 Modi ko gaali but Turkey ko gaali aur tareef for economic miracle... waah! Mulleh ki daur masjid tak
IK was expected to raise above the din. As it turned out he became the din. Says a lot about his real ability as opposed to what he professes.
Solutions of Pakistans path to development in the views of Raza Romi and Pervaiz Hoodbhayi is similar to a top chef who was hired by a restaurant owner to teach his cooks.when the cooks asked chef how to fry an egg. The chef asked was chicken born first or egg.
Raza sahib 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Very good i really liked him.... And Shahzad thats called being Neutral...you should learn from him
18:49 Your PM has suddenly found 5 trillions today - buried underground in the shape of minerals. All it requires is a little mining.
Yaar Shezad aap toh Imran Khan ko zameen mai gar ke hi jaoga. Bhai aga bad jao Imran se bhi. It's becoming quite frustating, I can't even bear the podcast longer than 20 minutes. It feels like a tape recorder which is playing a single tape for months now.
7th June ko last podcast thee on Imran Khan. So many episodes on other things since then and so many episodes on other topics after this also.
@@ThePakistanExperience You are not making dedicated videos on Imran or PTI but there are enough snippets and name calling of Imran Khan in these podcasts.
I just think that he has become irrelevant and I have heard about him a lot in the last year
@@ThePakistanExperience Thanks for replying BTW Shezad.
MashaAllah 🥰 Imran Khan will soon be the prime minister of Pakistan InshAllah 🥰
Khatme nabuwat, tauhine rasalat and aakhirat are the most important issues in pakistan.
Implement Sharia and let Taliban merge napakistan into Greater Afghania
@@TheGrimStoicI think he said that sarcastically
@@gosliglitzho you don't seem to be from this neck of the woods my friend - he said it earnestly and so did I - facts are sarcastic in the promised land
(Edit) I love PMJ too, by the way.
"Modiji kahtey hai musalmanoko pakistan bhejdo..." WOW. I wonder where did you hear that? When you claim to be a fact based journalist and then mention lazy hyperbole lines like these it becomes very difficult to trust you as being an honest journalist.
Zaid hamid ke bhai hain ye dono.
@@nuhuman88 Zaid Hamid inke agey bachcha hai - these two are masters of meetha zehr aka subtle jihad
Obviously modi won't say it directly, he is referring to his hard core supporters
It will be hung parliament all over pakistan so the army can have the final say.
Every Pakistani want nehru ka India 🤣
Once Yogi arrives, they'll be nostalgic for Modi's India.
Once Yogi arrives India will be nostalgic of India
@@tapanthakur It is already Bharat
Im doing this unpaid internship and it gets stressful but when you release an episode, i can relax listening to your conversations and the day gets a little better. thank you shehzad❤️❤️
❤❤❤
Thanks a lot Shehzad !!!
👍👍👍
Since you are doing some of the podcasts with the noted journalists/columnists/analysts, therefore I am also requesting you to do a few more with the following (if possible):
Zubaida Mustafa (Dawn, Khi)
Huma Yousuf (Independent/Dawn, US)
Ayesha Siddiqua (Independent/The Express Tribune, UK)
Mubashir Zaidi (VOA Urdu, US)
Rafia Zakaria (Independent/Dawn, US)
Wajahat Masood (Hum Sub, Lhr)
Azhar Abbas (GEO News, Khi)
Zafar Abbas (Dawn, Khi)
Arifa Noor (Dawn/Dawn News, Isb)
Zahid Husain (Independent/Dawn, Isb)
Dr. Anjum Altaf (Education/Dawn, Khi)
Dr. Nazir Mahmood (Independent/The News/Jang/Dawn, Isb)
Akbar Zaidi (IBA/Dawn, Khi)
Dr. Tariq Khosa (Police/Defense Analyst/Dawn, Khi)
Haris Khalique (Independent/Dawn, Isb)
Kishwar Naheed (Independent/Jang, Isb)
Raza Ali Abidi (BBC Urdu/Jang, UK)
And many more obviously
😊😊😊
The above-mentioned are the saner voices of our country & the ones who are not visible much in our mass media in Pakistan & abroad.
So please do try your best.
🙌
Brilliant, the term I loved the most: Populist Caesarism❤
Most of discussion is rational, I enjoyed the conversation but it's too short to cover the relevant questions of current situation in Pakistan. Overall it's good podcast 👍
🙌
What substandard podcast. U subscribing now.
You nailed it when you said Al BadUrn Nahi Al PaisUn and next comes Islam touch in the DNA discussion which defines Pakistan
One of the best Podcasts on this Channel.
a very beautiful experience of Listening to Raza Rumi Sahab.
Thank You Shahzad ❤
Keep Educating Pakistani Youth on Current Political Situations.
❤
کیا اچھا ہے؟ رومی اول فول بک رہا ہے۰ اپنی ہر بات کا نفی خود کر رہا ہے۰ اسکی عقل خراب ہی نہیں بلکہ اسے کسی اچھے ڈاکٹر کی ضرورت ہے
@@risingsun2251
If you don't like something, ignore it and move on.
Grow up.
Bhetreen podcast shehzad❤
❤
I saw ur podcast on eon holdings and i was amazed how intellectual u r shehzad .. may allah give you more success in life .. ameen .. ❤️❤️
Yaar 1 baat samajh nahi aati, Erdogan jab Church ko mosque bana de to wo soft islam; Modi Islamophobic. Pls same yard stick use karen.
Don't bother about India look at Pakistan first
Why here??
@@manu.ba374 to shit on a madrasachap jihadi mulk called porkistan
@@manu.ba374 don't need ur permission Bhikari jihadi
Very nice discussion going on
I would like to give my comment's point by point as per my knowledge and understanding
Imran Khan was supported and brought into power by the Establishment
To counter Nawaz Shareef
Reason is Nawaz Shareef did not accept the supremacy of the Army over rule of politicians and parliament
Although Nawaz Shareef was a popular leader
Three times he was elected Prime Minister of Pakistan
Last time it was General Bajwa who had developed differences with Nawaz Shareef
Imran Khan acted as he was told
He was on good books on the same page with the Establishment
Differences between General Bajwa and Imran Khan erupted
Vote of no confidence was passed
Since then there is a political turmoil in the country
God Almighty had given Imran Khan a golden chance
But not only he missed the opportunity
He seems to have lost the chance
The Buddha on table looks so beautiful. Keep going Shehzad♥
❤
Very very interesting talk.....maja aa gaya ...by the way shezad sir you are looking really gorgeous
❤
I don't think until or unless feudalism is completely removed from a state, democracy can even start there... Pakistan is one of the last countries in the world where feudalism is still in practice.. How can democracy even be born there if govt still supports feudalism?
True but land reforms should've been done at the country's inception. India did so and look at it now, there might be some of it still remaining in India's part of Punjab but as a whole not much. I just wish India and Pakistan could come together and really sit down and focus on trade, challenges such as water, poverty, food scarcity etc.
@@murti101 i don't know where u got your information from, but feudalism is not present in India
Modi is populist? Lmfao 🤣🤣 the guy is a establishment stooge .... he's all alone and isolated and some people on the right side of the spectrum see through it ...and we want him to go...
Yes modi is populist,kejtiwal is also populist
@@Bhatti_69 both are establishment thugs that's what both are
Amazing podcast .. Shehzad well done 🎉
🙌
Shehzad please do a detailed series on Fauj org businesses and it earning streams , can’t the org start paying back the national debt with such huge earning they have , apparently 24 billion each year … what is the real story ??
Shehzad big fan... but we're not facing any populism look at our GDP look at our foreign reserves look at how the world is treating us...i respect you a lot because you do your research before you comment on something this is not what we expect on you
Very nice discussion. However, at 47.58minutes Shehzad’s breathing is a bit heavy. Maybe could have been edited a bit better..
We need to provide for our people there needs to be a comprehensive plan not politics,
Establishment hi sub say zy qasoorwar hai, politician to yaqeenan corrupt aur moqa parast hain lekin establishment ne ajtak political culture ko itna strong honay hi kab diya hai , pakistan bantay hi inki beghairtiyan shuru ho gayi thin, courts say lay kar media tak per inka control hai, inhi ki waja say aj tak koi aur idara itna mazboot nahi ho saka ,
Thank you for posting! I'm listening this to release my stress 😅 Also, I graduated recently from a Top 50 globally ranked university. Lemme know if I could contribute in terms of R&D for The Pakistan Experience. I'm willing to drop my email for a while.
❤
Thanks Shahzad for giving us such an invaluable podcast. This sir just stated all the facts what Inspector Poirot would say "as they are not as you want them to be"
Hats off to your courage
Be healthy be safe especially BE SAFE
🙌
Unfortunately we have become a nation of beggars
For the last 75 years every outgoing government government hands over the begging bowl to the incoming new government
Every new government which comes into power
Promise the same old statement
But nothing happens
Hey Shehzad you’ve done so well for these podcasts!!! Since you came to Lahore this time and I forgot to recommend someone. It would be so helpful if you could get the editors of the Khorasan Diary like Iftikhar Firdous and do a podcast with them. They can give the best explanation of the conflict in Balochistan and KP something every Pakistani needs to know in order to understand the scale of whats about to hit them
Sir Zabardast
🙌
One of the best podcast
❤
Agree with Raza Rumi here
Pounding the like button just for that stanza at the end.
😅❤
For all those Pakistanis badmouthing Modi on his alleged mistreatment of Muslims please answer following questions
1) Is true that there is public holidays on Bakri id, Eid ul Adha, Christmas and Diwali. Does Pakistan have holidays on Holi and Diwali
2) What is number of mosques, temples, gurudwaras in each Indian city. A simple Google maps search can suffice
3) Has any government schemes denied to minorities
4) Has any minority political candidate or party been denied tickets
5) How is CAA discriminatory and what is normal process of getting Indian citizenship
6) How much land was to UP waqf board for Babri Masjid case verdict in 2019
Neither Zia Ul Haque was Shaheed, nor Z. A. Bhutto was Shaheed!!
Shehzad bhai: Good to know that you didn't eat any "crap" before this podcast (like you did recently in Jhelum). "Once bitten, twice shy" is the philosophy. 🤓😀