US Secretary admits Israel killed 25K women and children in Palestine’s Gaza
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 лют 2024
- US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin admitted to Congress that Israel has killed more than 25,000 women and children in Palestine’s Gaza since October 7, 2023. The Pentagon later backtracked, claiming Austin’s figure came from Gaza’s Health Ministry, not US intelligence.
Subscribe: trt.world/subscribe
Livestream: trt.world/ytlive
Facebook: trt.world/facebook
X (Twitter): trt.world/twitter
Instagram: trt.world/instagram
Threads: threads.net/@trtworld
TikTok: / trtworld
WhatsApp: trtworld.com/whatsapp
Telegram: t.me/trtworld
Visit our website: trt.world
They're liars, and they know it...
And they know we know but still continue to lie and they don't care
The Lord Jesus Christ is the Messiah and King of the Jews. He shall soon return to save Israel and give them the Holy Land. "Yet have I set my king upon my holy hill of Zion" (Psalm 2:6, KJV). Even so, come, Lord Jesus! Establish the Kingdom of Peace in Jerusalem (Isaiah 9:7, KJV)!
And your evidence for lies is??
Calling something a lie with zero evidence, when it challenges one's bigotry, is the easy way to go.
But it doesn't make the allegation of lies any more valid.
I thought we left this behaviour behind Iin the school yard.
@@liamevans1630 they lied about wmd in iraq, they lied about 911, they lied about Libya. They lied about israel being a victims of palestinian.
@@liamevans1630 Their lies are evidence.
We know that these are corrupt and liars.
Provide evidence of lies or corruption.
Verifiable evidence.
Otherwise you are presenting a (perhaps) bigoted opinion masquerading as a fact.
I live in Israel. I have a deep stake in the future of this society.
And here is a fact.
The people of Palestine have a right in international law to a sovereign and independent state of their own.
Without this we in this region are doomed to repeat the madness of previous decades.
I refuse to bequeath this to my Israeli children
America itself killed half a million Iraqi children after throwing all kinds of internationally prohibited weapons at civilians in Iraq. This is why you should not be surprised when you see America supporting the killing of children and civilians in Gaza
❤️🔥God loves Israel .. Joel 3.19 ... Because of violence against the people of Judah,
For they have shed innocent blood in their land (of Judah) .
20 But Judah shall abide forever,
And Jerusalem from generation to generation.
21 For I will acquit them (israel) of the guilt of bloodshed, whom I had not acquitted;
For the Lord dwells in Zion.”
The reason that the Israeli government banned DNA testing inside Israeli settlements is that the DNA test proves that you are not from the Middle East, and that you are European occupiers.... A person comes from Ukraine and Poland and claims that he has the right to the Middle East... The Palestinians are the people are the true Semites, the Arabs are the children of Abraham, you are the children of Japheth and the occupiers....And what is worse than this is that we do not even need to do a DNA test to know where you are from...Your face alone shows your true origin.
@@Jesusiscoming24They were chosen people but they went astray and they will pay for their crimes soon.
He admitted ' It's over 25000 women and children ' killed. Yet the supply of arms and ammunition would not stop.
Since when does the US care about " international law?"
People forget the U.N. is in New York...
And what does the U.N even do? Not like they do anything.
International law does not apply to US and EU or their ally
BASTA. Also USA is also obliged to follow International Law. No exceptions. God bless ICC. .
It violates domestic law first and foremost. Wouldn’t make it to international court without the consent of pretty much the entire legislature turning a blind eye.
It’s illegal under International Law to supply weapons to a Nuclear State.
Wow, didn't know that
The USA is above and beyond any international law, The Veto House just vetoes its way ahead against any kind of international law
They are not a nuclear state
chery it's illegal to supply to even non nuclear illegally
Please constantly make up interpretations and claim it's international law.
Shameful and sickening.
trust me this is nothing
turkey is equally corrupt and liar , it is in NATO with US, turkey should leave NATO and not shed crocodile tears on palestine
US nuked over 100k women and children in ww2.
Israel is WAY below that level of murder.
You referring to Hamas?
😂❤
For 35 years in this country, never did I hate politicians this much .
Only "over 25 000", as they are just numbers, hear how easily and confortably he utters. Disgusting.
Still continues to think they'll use it responsibly
Nah hes not THAT stupid. He just doesnt care
Да, самое страшное в человеке это - равнодушие....
@@gaghhuh2943his ratheon stocks went up so its all good.
What else can they say?
Good Gawd- like WHAT'S THE EXACT DEFINITION OF THAT!!??😂 OH! MAN! THEY ARE STUBBORN AND HARD!
Mr. Secretary calmly says “ITS OVER 25000”. Let that sink in for a second. Imagine a stadium filled with women and children who no longer exist.
He says it without any emotion in his voice - just business as usual 💔
It's shameful
He needs to go to court!
@@anak.-ix5zgno need for court, his crimes are already on public display
That's the whole NFL stadiums worth of people and a couple NBA stadiums
We are talking about human lives here and some people acted like it’s nothing
It’s really upsetting 😢
War criminals should be sanctioned
Its called business lmfao, US making bank with their missiles
@@mrautismo420the choice of greed over human lives never ceases to make me feel sick
They feel no shame when they lie.
Who give Hamas the one they are using. Do you know the history of Ishmael children and Israel children fight. You people don't know how evil Islam is
@@chukwudumanyadike9452
Really?? Please tell me!
@@user-Eq3qR8fn8 Ishmael children and Israel children fight is not today it starts, go and study the holy Bible with prayer and God's insight. You will know why God promised Israel that war will never depart from them and one of God's promises to Israel is that no man born of a woman that will ever defeat Israel in war. God also promised them that course is anyone that course Israel and bless is anyone that bless Israel. That's why that Turkish senator that course Israel on a live broadcast slumped and die. Whether the whole world is against Israel they will never win them. God is with Israel. It is written in the holy Bible.
@@chukwudumanyadike9452 More evil than genocide?？
On the day of judgment you will find if Islam is evil.
More than 30k
25k women and children
@@gounch.1186 seems like you've been watching bbc
@@gounch.1186 they don't count the dead people under roubles.
25k women and children and over 7k men it’s heartbreaking 😢
There are definately more than 30k coz Gaza is a very densely populated place😢
Stop Genocide in Gaza 🇵🇸
There is none
American tax payers must do something this is unacceptable
What do you expect them to do?
@@Cmteamconradvote for the green party
Another war criminal
Au lieu de se repentir et s'occuper de son cancer
😢so next time don't declare war crime on Israel ok? 🥺
and don't promise Israel more 0kto07 war crime ok?🥺
Shame on US
Yes, it's over 25k, it's actually 40,000 killed with 8,000 missing under the rubble.
Hypocrisy at its best.
❤️🔥God loves Israel .. Joel 3.19 ... Because of violence against the people of Judah,
For they have shed innocent blood in their land (of Judah) .
20 But Judah shall abide forever,
And Jerusalem from generation to generation.
21 For I will acquit them (israel) of the guilt of bloodshed, whom I had not acquitted;
For the Lord dwells in Zion.”
@@Jesusiscoming24 hhhhhhhha dove era nei anni 40 .libro falso scritto da psicopatici 11 secoli fa .regno inesistente tempio inesistente tutto falso confermato dai archeologi izreliani .
🤢@@Jesusiscoming24
@@Jesusiscoming24surely you know that God has no love for thieves and killers.
@@olivetree633 .. he doesn't that's why Jesus returns in power to stop people from stealing from Israel Matthew 24.29 and Psalms 83 ❤️🔥☺️
War crimes against humanity
Especially against women and girls, unfortunately
Hammas no Israel
@@aloysiusliberiatus6111 .anche la maggior parte dei cittadini izreliani nei Kibbutz li ha uscissi esercito izreliano DIRETIVA ANNIBALE .
@@aloysiusliberiatus6111 Israel isn’t innocent why did nathyamou brag about funding hamas then cries victim later
@@aloysiusliberiatus6111Isreal been murdering Palestinians for more than half century and it's Khamas fault?
America cannot preach democracy, law and order, international law, UN resolutions or human rights. It's a shame.
Shame.
"In a responsible way"
Nah💀
The whole government needs to go.
The WHOLE government
So we just hoping for a coup then?
AIPAC needs to go too. They make the US Politicians traitors.
What does this even mean
@@nachiket481 Replace the government
When was the last revolution that happened in the west? People are living under dictatorship, and they think they are living a democratic life
animals right but not humans right why?
Palestinian or Muslim rights USA does not believe in
Human rights ONLY for women and girls
Because they have different color 😢
True
Shame on you America 😢😢😢
He just says “over 25,000” casually like it doesn’t matter
That's because he's an actual four-star general, so unlike you kids from tiktok he knows 25,000 is a relatively tiny number for a war.
Well, it's nowhere close to America's tally in either Iraq or Afghanistan.
@@LDNRDR That's not "America's tally", most of the casualties in both those wars were inflicted by their own insurgencies.
America didn't 💀600,000 Iraqis, 600,000 Iraqis 💀each other while America was supposed to be on guard duty.
and what is the correct way to say it according to you?
@@twelvecatsinatrenchcoatmother america
Free Palestine
Free the world. ✌️
Free Palestine from Hamas
Free palestine to do what?
Why does EVERY NATION block Palestinian refugees?
@@claudiapodolsky2105Free the world from zionism.
@@claudiapodolsky2105FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸 FREE AMERICA 🇺🇸 FROM ZIO--NISTS
Shame on USA, France and all complices !!!
As British African we should fight for Palestinians people 😢😢
Evil to the core
He knows the numbers killed but doesn't the numbers of weapons sent to Israel
If Isreal is evil then what is Palestine which first attacked 💔🤔
you think that's too much ??
figure includes 12,000 of Yahya Sinwar's terror operatives, so what
turkey is equally corrupt and liar , it is in NATO with US, turkey should leave NATO and not shed crocodile tears on palestine
That's disgusting
Deflected the hell out of that question. His ancestors are rolling in their graves smh
They know EXACTLY what they're doing over there
It’s weird that they are using dark people to do this… I bet that the brother doesn’t want to be there but they PUT HIM THERE…
The Palestinians are "resident aliens". They're not native to Palestine. The only lives that truly matter are those who respect the lives of others.
After Oct 7th, America opened many eyes including mine. Now I know that America, Israel and Europe have no right to talk about human rights.
They are the ones who is truly practicing human rights
👏🏽🤍
that's true bro
@@user-df6iu3du2gwhat? The human right to kill other humans?
@user-df6iu3du2g The thing with human rights is that if you only apply them to your population, you're not doing them right😅
Against international law and no country is holding them accountable
Couple of countries do
How do the secretary of defense Not Know how many of his military s weapons he's in charge of went to the idf?
I know Sth Africa, Ireland and Brazil support the people of Gaza
Every country, bar the USA and a Sth Pacific Island, voted for cease fire at the UN
Its the united states. What is anyone gonna do?
@jaythomas3224 good question
Shameful
Despicable!! 😡
At least the US defense secretary had the guts to admit and say it out loud that “over 25000 women and children have been killed”.
yes because of HIM
@@user-fo5zv4ld4z yes the *US secretary of defense* is personally responsible for Israel's reaction to Hamas' heinous acts. 🙄
No remorse and heartless . listen to yourself bro.
@@user-fo5zv4ld4zhes not the one sending munitions or making decisions like that
@@HallingtonA he literally is part of the problem. if you cant see that then you are delusional.
“May the eyes of cowards never sleep”
Ears too.
Irresponsible.
I'm sick to my stomach
The secretary and the president have lost their humanity.
How is it possible to lose something that never existed in the first place?
Yeppp
They have also lost control of their country. They pull funds from the American tax payer and the zionist hold a higher seat in the US then the president himself.
They never had any.
Crazy the USA use to atleast pretend to care now it’s like they support Israel unconditionally even if all 2 million Palestinians die
This is one of very few Congressmen who dares to question the blank check given by the US to Israel. Thank you sir.
@@ThatOneInTenThousand.. i don't think so. Because this time, Americans actually used their brain to think and that's why we have a lot of Palestine supporters in USA. Maybe this was the plan of God
Bullcrap
I bet this congressman will be soon kicked out for daring to tell the truth just think of Assange,justice and democracy American style has to prevail.Disgusting and sickening
In February 2023 USA introduced a new conventional arms transfer policy. Josh Paul former Director at U.S. Department of State described it as setting the "More likely than not standard... that arms that are being provided or being proposed to be provided that are going to be used to commit human rights violations then they will not be authorised" US pledged arms transfers to Israel will lead to further significant civilian fatalities, human rights violations. Which is against US arms transfer policy.
(Josh Paul as Director at U.S. Department of State resigned Oct 19 2023.)
turkey is equally corrupt and liar , it is in NATO with US, turkey should leave NATO and not shed crocodile tears on palestine
Shameful 😡😡😡😡
They can never change
What a shame this country is doing!
Tigers still have stripes and leopards still have Spots
Israel is not a country
Spartan and his administration are warmongers they're wanting to start war with their own people Texas
The real shame is Hamas and their ideology I---m. The total reason this war started in the first place. thanks
@@joman388 go educate yourself then come back!
“Using them in a responsible way”. Why is there NEVER a follow-up question, not even by journalists, stating “do you feel that 35000 civilians killed in 5 months indicate that they do?” Or “they obviously haven’t, have they?”.
Huh?
No one has said 35,000 civilians have died. This is an exaggeration since at least 6,000 are Humus Nazis.
25,000 women and children dead in Gaza
@@TmanRock9 Euro Med Monitor 35,490 Civilians Killed in their last update.
@TmanRock9 l see no Nazis other than Israel, and it's terrorist IDF
Hypocrites
SHAMEFUL 😮
Austin: "I'm a coward, sir. I'll go along with any war crime the President directs me to commit."
That is what is happening now , your response is right on
Well said. Sheep's following a blind Sheppard.
And they don’t even feel ashamed saying it because they are heartless!!!
At least they are NOT celebrating and taking videos of their victims and parading a young girl they took captive, to parade her in front of the cheering Israelis who are taking videos of her only to have her found dead and dumped near the Hospital.
If you need more information
> on who she was
> What her name was
> How old she was
> Which nationality she was
I will gladly provide.
@@doremi131 Israel been doing the same thing for years or you just talking about the only thing media showed you?
Why can’t the president be there to answer the questions??
😔😢 15000 of children, THIS IS BEYOND BRUTALITY ONE COULD THINK OF 🥺
This is a war criminal. Needs to be held to account
Right
Yes Hamas and I---m that inspired this wickedness is criminal. thanks
@@joman388 Have you heard of 2022?
It's this thing that happened before 7th Oct 2023...
Any idea what Israel was doing then?
@@kieranharwood7186 Yes I have a great idea that Is israel has been trying to live in peace since they were given their land back that God had promised them . God said I will curse those who curse them{Jews} and I will bless those who bless them. Proof of your nonsense is that Apparently Arabs live beside Jews in Israel and have full rights.Try that in the Gaza? thanks
FREE FREE PALESTINE !!
Do something then, yes you, go help them
@@kaima8002what an ignorant response “oh yeah I’ll go there and they’ll let me in easily , it’s such an easy task to do “
🤦🏻♂️
There is no Palestine, read the Quran Allah gave the land to the children of Israel 🇮🇱
Yes free Palestinians from hamas
@@HowlingWo1f the land belongs to the Palestinians , they are the chosen people . Those jews are not the chosen people they are from Europe. Even the real jews in Palestine believes the lamd is for the PALESTINANSz
Shameful shameful
It's only over 25000 . How comfortably he is saying this. This is 😔
Stop the genocide in Gaza 😢
This is a war. People die in war. If this was genocide they would all be dead in a week.
He knows the figures and he knows they still sending weapons that are being used to in the most horrific way possible. A true American patriot paid the ultimate price In support of the abused RIP. Aaron
He said he doesn’t know. Maybe he doesn’t have a tv.
@@PenArrowNation it’s his job to know , if he doesn’t know then he’s not doing his job
They are clearly P5YCH0PATH5
A complete liar
And this guy is fighting cancer??
Sick
shameful.. 👎
DISGUSTING!
turkey is equally corrupt and liar , it is in NATO with US, turkey should leave NATO and not shed crocodile tears on palestine
But no one says anything about the women and children being killed in ukraine. Which has ten times higher numbers, theres been full towns of people found bound, tortured and raped (including minors). Infact most people supporting palestine actually support russia simply because they are anti US. Kind of hypocritical right
Its very legit when they are either protecting terrorists and/or used as human shields.
Its well documented at this point , we dont have to try to twist the narrative nor lie about it
I agree, what the Palestinians did on 10 / 7 was disgusting.
@@twelvecatsinatrenchcoat apparently Israel didn't, cuz they knew about it long before it happened and chose to stand down and allow it.
42.000 children and women slaughtered in Gaza
Imagine Hamas stops hiding behind women & children...
Mr secretary forgot a small fact that transfer of arms to Israel is illegal!
Why would that be illegal?
@@xxxhoodooxxxit violates international law.
@@jturtle5318 Helping their ally is not a violation
@@thuongvu0204 nothing done by US gov could be illegal. Everything done by US gov enemies is illegal.
@@jturtle5318since when I need heard anything like that
Shame on the corrupt politicians . Unfortunately there is no humanity left in them.
They already haven't used them in a responsible way. What a crazy dismissive way to answer.
The UN has never condemned hamas .
Thank you Hon, Khanna for bringing officials to accountability
As an orthodox jew, I condemn the terrorist acts and war crimes of Israel. I support the creation of a free and independent Palestinian state. This will end all the violence. As Jews we need to accept that Israel is the occupying force and we need to do the right thing and give Palestinians their own independent state free from Israeli interferences. LASTLY, CRITCIZING ISRAEL ISN'T ANTISEMITISM!!!
You have a Christian name though
@@abubibsParissa? How is that a Christian name?
@@jturtle5318 khoury in Arabic means Christian priest
@@GETMAD87 🤣
What do you think about a one state solution where all can live in a democratic free country in which they all get equal representation where the number of population won't change facts on the ground. Really, what's wrong with viable solution?
There are fact on the ground that prevent the creation of a viable 2 state solution. Whereas the only obstacle to a one state solution is just the idea that Isreal wants to be called a Jewish state. If they Isreal insist on that, then they are also chosing war over lasting peace
“in a responsible way” WTF!
Seriously wrong.
Absolutely sickening.
FO
Not really that is politics. They don't play by emotions they play by interest.
No it’s not 😅
@@mitchklinger3128over 25,000 INNOCENT people have been killed almost half of which are JUST CHILDREN and not one world leader is doing anything about it. That’s not sickening to you?!
If they don't want to be war criminals, they should stop sending weapons to a state that ignores the international laws
‚If‘
If? Aren’t they already?
@@TheTsexy1 i was challenging their will which katina postulated because yes, clearly they dont want to
They are a criminals ,too late
There's no evidence that they're breaking some sort of international law, people will cite the south Africa ICJ case but that hasn't happened yet, it's just been agreed to be heard and nothing else
Austin should be behind bars
Stop paying taxes
Im just wondering what kind of responsible way to use rockets and bombs?
They don't talk enough about how the anti-war movement blew up the pentagon's computers during Vietnam.
@lynn-235 exactly!!!!
Next generations will look at this time with disgust and disbelief
No they won’t this is just another conflict in the Middle East ,no one remember the war in Yemen
@@theymaycry9725 Future historians will remember this, as it directly affects the world's only superpower. A shift in geopolitics is taking place, a destabilisation of post-war norms is underway and American foreign policy (the war on "terror") is coming to a head. Whatever happens after this conflict, it will be seen as a key factor in explaining this current period in history, and perhaps as a culmination of colonial history.
The wars in Yemen, Sudan, Myanmar, these are all incidental because they don't directly affect the US, but they will be looked at collectively as a shift in political focus alongside the historically ignored Palestinians -- Gaza will throw light on marginalised regions. These won't be "forgotten wars" like Korea and East Timor, they've had too much of an impact through social media.
That has to be the most depressing over 9k reference I've heard.
The president is in no position to make such a important decision,
He cannot even follow a teleprompter for gods sake
“Responsible way”
Caused the death of more than 30,000 Palestinians😖😔😭
I am very sad for my people
My brothers and sisters,who are still trying their best to stay alive
I watch everything from Turkey,praying for being lucky bc they aren’t😩😭
I wish they are set free
Free Palestine🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸❤️❤️❤️
O beloved of Allah o Palestinians, Allah has chosen you among all Muslims to love and cherish you? Because of your faith and trust in Allah and steadfastness. O beloveds of Allah, please be patient. Allah is with you! May Allah shower you with his mercy in this earth and in hereafter the highest ranks of Janah, InshaAllah! 😭😭😭😭😭🥲😢🥲😢🥲😢🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🕋🕋🕋🕋🕋🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🌺🌸🌺🌸🌺🌸
@@RamosayReturns1 Thank you brother,thank you🥹😣🥹❤️🩹🇵🇸
turkey is equally corrupt and liar , it is in NATO with US, turkey should leave NATO and not shed crocodile tears on palestine
What are the Muslim doing to The Armenian Christians right Now?
@@RamosayReturns1He can't Love. Allah is completely Alien, right you can't hope to think that.
Responsible usage is killing 25000 civilians? These people are void of emotion and lost
turkey is equally corrupt and liar , it is in NATO with US, turkey should leave NATO and not shed crocodile tears on palestine
They got in the way
No hint of embarrassment when he says 25.000 Palestinian women and children were killed by Israel with the help of the weapons they supplied them. And the USA was the country we were looking up to for years. How wrong we were.!!
"it's over 25,000" according to the terrorists who claim to have immediate accurate counts, which appear to indicate that the population of Gaza is mostly children.
He said that 'over 25000' so casually like it's nothing !😡
Over 500K killed in Yemen, and people like you act like it's nothing.
25,000 were killed in Dresden in 3 days
Well it's not and neither was 2500+ which started the war
@@alexknex5898get real dude, that did not start the war
@@gilbenavidesalvarez1533 get real dude it did don't be blinded by lies or politics that's all for them we are common people fighting for our lives so i hope everyone get's what is said and understands that weather it is 13000 soldiers + civilians of Israel or weather it is 25000+ Palestinian people (soldiers, terrorists and civilians included) not all of them deserved to die they deserved a peaceful life and to people saying isarel is not a nation or the people who say Palestine is not a nation are the people humanity should disown as they are against humanity, Palestine was free and isarel was free until the War started
The Mr. Secretary was shocked when he updated him about the numbers!!!!
"they'll use in responsible ways." Wow!
Where to go 😢
He is secretary of defense of most powerful country in the world and he doesnt know how many precision-guided munitions send to Israel but he knows how many innocent children and women have died with an expected respectful manners of Israel!! What a shameful statements…
Dear muhamed, you need to get down on earth 😅
@@uckthis8079 true. USA isn't the most powerful nation on earth. Israel owns them
This is a war. People die in war
This shows how far a person could go down, immorally for the sake of money and power
This man admitted he suffers from racial bravado
This is puppet, he will not answer
disgusting, this whole administration is disgusting
Not just this asministration. This is America's modus operandi. Listen to Roy Casagranda's lectures to wake up what America does.
The secretary has no little sign of regret or remorse for the over 25,000 he has mentioned. Sickening and gut wrenching.
He is a cog that has one gear, engaged or not.
Yes he does about as much as you have for them. If you were as responsible as you are trying to make the secretary be perhaps you should go to Iran to stop the flow of weapons to the diverse terrorist groups in the middle east.
Don't start trouble and you won't get trouble
He is something that rhymes with saloon. UA-cam hates that word also...
How shameful mr secretary, can u look the eyes of your children, grandchildren, relatives and your people!
"Use them in a responsible way". Really?
Clearly the US Secretary violated the Leahy Law which prohibits the Department of Defence from providing military assistance to foreign nations that violate human rights with impunity.
No!! It's not clear!! Israel made every reasonable effort to clear the path of civilians before launching their counter offensive. Israel is within their rights & is not violating any law, international or otherwise, in their lawful and appropriate measures to protect their people from attacks. It's a lie to say otherwise.
köszönöm az § nevét !!👌⚖️🏹🔥☝️Istenünk áldása önnel !!free free Palestine
It's. Biden put him in charge he will do his best to make it thousand times worst
Over 25k people killed in Gaza this's heartbreaking.
That's only women in children.
It's well over 40,000 now and counting
Not really. They want a war to destroy Israel..well here it is. No crying now.
Israel 🇮🇱 doesn’t kill innocent ppl these ppl 25k’s are either refused to move, terrorists or simply they didn’t know what the hake was going on period.
Who reported how many killed, where did that number come from
Where is the rest of this interview. I need the rest