With all due respect I do not believe the equivocation with the Hadith of Ifq is related to this incident. An investigation was DONE and evidence provided and arrest made based on that evidence. The community has right to be horrified and condemn this individuals actions. No one jumped to accuse, the evidence was provided first. Also no one celebrated this news or were happy to hear what he did. We were devastated and horrified. The example of Zinq is NOT relevant to cases of child abuse. Rape is not equivalent to Adultery between two consenting adults in the Shariah and CHILD ABUSE is definitely not equivalent. Really disappointed that the respected sheikh responded in this way.
I think his point is we don't know if the evidence is real or not. In other words, we will never know of its actually true or not. In the end let the courts do their job and we should keep our mouths shut to avoid defamation in case we are wrong. Refer to 07:30 in the video.
@@giovannioro1642 The point is in Islam a person honour is a right , before we have every social media youtube influencer/sheigh jump on the fitnah train,they should rather remain silent and let the authorities deal with the evidence and prove the person is guilty.Now everyone is sensationalizing this issue without due process,It has become this easy to drag people names through the mud,what is worse, the person spreading the rumours or the person who committed it.
@@galielachmat2087 I don't disagree with you. Also he does distinguish between openly committing fasaad versus doing it in private. Unfortunately many Muslims and non-Muslims are looking for views. In fact we should be this way to both Muslims and non-Muslims. We need to stop sensatiinalizing and gossiping.
Whoever is listening to this talk my advice is if you have any concerns that someone might be be commiting a crime go directly to the police to investigate unfortunately too many of these crimes have been committed and turned a blind eye to, these religious figure cannot be relied on anymore.
I am so happy that you gave this talk. It teaches us how to behave according to Quran and authentic Sunnah. May Allah reward you and protect you all in this life and the next. Ya Allah bless our Nabi (s) and forgive us all.
Shaykh Salman really asks some solid questions. He is speaking for a lot of the people who love to gossip on such issues. He is really balanced and puts the shaykh on the spot. Very good questions on the 15-30 minute mark. Questions that have been bothering us for years. JazakAllaahu Khayr Ustadh Salman!!!
Pray to cover the crimes of another? Whether that person is Muslim or not I dont see doing so..May Allah grant me the ability to discern the truth from falsehood.
I would encourage the shuyookh and content creators to take this into consideration: i) Speak from a trauma informed lens and check your emotional intelligence. ii) Bear in mind that in your audience, there are victims that have or are being silenced, oppressed and isolated by their abusers. Address existing victims to make sure they are comforted. While you want to stop the keyboard warriors, you have to prioritize victims and not exacerbate their injury further. iii) Be cognizant of unintended spiritual bypassing. Theological guidelines are frequently weaponized by 'people of knowledge' to oppress, gaslight and demonize victims, sometimes even coerce them. I struggled to watch this 50 minutes; the first thirty minutes sounded like the traumatic investigation victims go through and the second half sounds like heavily biased "dignitaries" who generally place the burden of forgiveness, rationalization & mercy on the victim. This is exactly how victims and weaker people in society are abandoned & isolated from the 'strong body' of the ummah.
Whilst you mention some important points, I think you are missing the point of the video. The shaykh is addressing the masses on how to safeguard their own Akhirah in this situation, as it is so easy damage our own hereafter with how we react to news of this nature. It is not to address the victims or perpetrators.
@@abuzubayr2404I'm curious if you can explain the point of my response. And perhaps you might be able to explain who and what I was trying to address as well.
@@abuzubayr2404 Yes I agree this video is not intended for one audience or not for trauma victims. It is for everyone who doesn't know about the people involved in the situation. Well said brother. MashaaAllaah.
You totally missed the point of the video. This is a video not intended for trauma victims. It is islamic etiquette in regards to rumors about a religious figure, whether they are true or not. Trauma victim videos should be made by those who are licensed in such fields. Shaykhs are not necessarily licensed to deal with such situations.
If a non-muslim court has video of s abuse, do we say it is unacceptable islamically? If there is tangible evidence of abuse, it is abuse in any religion. We should take precautions to protect our vulnerable from all predators.
We should be willing to follow the guidelines of the Shari'ah. Its teachings are timeless. Let's just be humble so as not to be punished for not following the path of the righteous.
He also says that if something must be immediately reported to the police by law, then you should do that first - eg child abuse. The accused may be arrested and in jail at this point. Also Shariah is not easy on these kind of crimes- some SA cases under shariah are punishable by death to the abuser. This person does not go back to being a protected member of society afterwards. The victim is protected including their privacy but not the perpetrators once they are found guilty.
If what has happened to our brother and others is true, may Allah place sincere tawbah in the hearts and ours and save us from this. Ya Allah, don't let him despair of Your mercy and forgiveness.
This has also highlighted the issues boundaries being lost within digital platforms. Meaning, even with online Quran Islamic platforms women and men during such interactions should still be treated based on Islamic rulings. Not having the women camera on etc Because it can protect women from any evil and perverse nature of someone who might even be in a position of power including position of faith etc May Allah save us.
This is the most important topic to talk about concerning the recent issue. Everyone just jumped on the wagon of judge and jury under the guise of giving advise but under the obscure premise that the accused already did it. Islam is just in imposing penalty but it also invented the concept of due process and the presumption pf innocence until proven guilty. Get down your high horse and submit to the Shariah. This is a real scholar talking with wisdom providing us guidance.
It’s literally already been detailed in court documents. People are reading the evidence not spreading rumors. The FBI already has presented all the evidence and it is tangible evidence.
Thank you my brother. First person talking sense. Obviously the sheikh is talking truth. I hope people listen to this and understand that islam has rules and regulations.
As humans we make many mistakes in our lives. When we seek forgiveness and atone for our sins, then I would say our “aaib “ ( the sin or wrong) must not be exposed. This is to help the person reform.
But in the case of premeditated sin as sexual abuse on different accounts, then it should expose the perpetrators so that no other will fall as victim.
If I was a Shaykh, people wouldn't like me because my answer would be so short: (1) We live in the West, let authority do it's work (prison/fine/sex offender list etc..).(2) Set preventive measures for this to not happen again. Maybe send emails to madrassas (3) Tell the community to focus on themselves and their family, leave what do no concern them. (4) Leave Allah to deal with his sins and forgiveness, and whether it is kufr or not.
Khutbahs used to be short. People used to share more Islamic knowledge and see one another implementing Islam and talk to one another about Islam. Islam is a complete way of life, the best of manners, the best of legislation.
MAY allah reward this aheikh for giving comprhensive elaboration of sharia law regarding these kinds of sensitive issues ,my respect to oridnary people ,they speaks out of emotions but scholar always speak the truth using wisdom
I think that the sheikh has dwelt a lot on the point of not spreading the news. Although it's true from the Shari'a perspective, it should be highly emphasised that this is a severely punishable sin. Otherwise, if he keeps on repeating not to spread the news some people will think that he is protecting or covering for the crime.
But the point is, the crime at this moment is only an allegation and hasn't been substantiated. We haven't even heard from the accused yet. Imagine the damage that would have been done already if the allegations were found to be false. Also we need to remember that the source of the allegation is from an evil entity, and the Quran warns us about spreading allegations that come from evil.
This situation is part of a bigger problem where our 'western scholars' have pushed and pushed young brothers and sisters into the limelight without the correct tarbiyyah, years of nurturing and studying, testing their rigor, etc and this is the result of what you see today. We need to start revaluating this dawrah culture we have created which has led to celebrity statuses.
Subhanallah jazakallah sheikh. We really needed to hear this. Shaytan is always sitting on the straight path waiting for anything to happen and he pushes us away from Allah. May Allah protect us from sins and if we have committed them may Allah swt hide them ameen.
The Quran explicitly tells us that a large number of those involved in propagating religion are not close to God "Verily, there are many of the rabbis and the monks who devour the wealth of mankind in falsehood, and hinder from the way of Allah" (Tawbah verse 34). God does not send down angels to prevent immoral people from working in churches or mosques or synagogues. It is our job to distinguish between moral people and immoral people in the houses of God and not to blindly "revere" anyone who wears a cross or grows a beard. God commands us not to follow preachers or pastors or imams and to follow His verses. People who obey "men of God" in things God forbade are themselves not close to God.
Interesting. The most vocal who are yelling saying how horrible of a person he is are the same ones who usually oppose implementing the shariah for gender separation. Whereas the leaders we should be following are the ones who are calm and level headed like this sheikh who happen to usually be at the forefront fighting to implement gender separation
Only a Miami Heat fan would see these contradictions. I completely agree at the hypocrisy of some liberals - not all of course. Education should be segregated for the safety of our kids. Always. Alhamdulillaah.
@@ARmirzaful I didn’t understand “the Miami Heat fan” reference. Important point though, Sh. Hamza Yusuf said that in shariah, both boys and girls are not allowed to be left alone with non-mahram men. Most Muslims don’t realize that but when you hear these tragic stories of boys who get abused - that could have been prevented too. May Allah protect all of our children, Ameen.
Have you heard from the sheikh himself in the defence of the allegations? How do you know he is guilty and where is your islamic source to present as evidence as I won't accept the sources from the Zionist FBI as evidence. Also, when Allah says in the Quran that when a source comes from an evil source we should investigate it, are you rejecting the ayat of the Quran?
its a public matter and we are concern because we send our kids to these schools.dictatorship mentallity ,no empathy ...for the victims the only concern is to protect the authority using islam it is sad ..you don t protect women and children then you turn around and accuse them of being at fault because they put make up oh my GODim just disgusted..may ALLAH guide yoiur hearth to protect the vulnerable and not the unjust.....
I encourage all to stop insulting this man (me included), and instead follow the prophetic saying where the prophet told us to say whenever we see someone falling in an ibtila "affliction" "Praise is to Allah Who has spared me what He has afflicted you "Wisam Sharief" with, and preferred me greatly above much of what He has created." This must be extreme strict and spoken against. Freemixing, violation of Islamic rulings in Islamic institutions and things of this nature. May Allah guide us and punish those who transgress against vulnerable Muslims, and may Allah protect us from them and the fitnah that he aflicted him with.
Sheikh Haitham, May Allah preserve you. Perhaps you could have waited or contacted Al Maghrib. The organisation whole heartedly believes the victim. This talk of yours will bring more harm than good as people are going to assume that you have more husn Ad dhan towards him than even his wife and immediate colleagues.
Jazak allah khair sheikh you explained very well and in details muslim please listen to your scholars and submit your ego to sharia law this difference between real beliver and fake beliver
The Shaykh is trying to give general principles for any accusations. It’s not necessarily meant for the severity of the case you mention. At 52:10 and other points where the host brings up children, the Shaykh immediately says if it’s something that must be reported to police/authorities by law, then report it right away. If there is dhulm (abuse), it must be stopped immediately and any vulnerable people must be protected immediately.
@ But the timing matters. Imagine making a video on etiquettes of treating an alleged killer who is Muslim man, after the police caught that Muslim man. Imagine that This Muslim man had killed a Muslim boy with video evidence and the evidence was submitted to police by the Muslim man’s wife. Respected Sheikh Haddad didn’t dwell enough on how the community needs to support the victim, most of the talk is focused on protecting the honour of the accused and not of the victim.
@@AbdussamadAbdulRazakMost of video is addressing ourselves and how to safeguard our own Akhirah as people on the sidelines. The byproduct of that may benefit the honour of the accused by minimising discussing him, but that isn't the point of the video.
@@AbdussamadAbdulRazak that’s true. People are more scared about their safety and their children’s safety and what is being done to both deal with these kinds of cases and how to protect people from future incidents. The accused’s honour and even protecting from gossip is a lower priority.
Have you heard from the sheikh himself in the defence of the allegations? How do you know he is guilty and where is your islamic source to present as evidence as I won't accept the sources from the Zionist FBI as evidence. Also, when Allah says in the Quran that when a source comes from an evil source we should investigate it, are you rejecting the ayat of the Quran?
U dont know basic thing that who is in charge of that ? Ulema, shurta, Qazi , and people of authority have that amr bil maroof nahya anil munkar , common people are not in charge of it
Put emotions on the side. We have principles in Islam for cases like this. The allegations of our mother Aisha, may Allah be pleased with her, is far greater than this in its gravity.
And even if it is true... Shouldn't we surround the person and support the person to change. Either we support him or the shaitan will! This is why we are so attacked because we don't have the spirit of our Nabi (s) and the sahabi! Ya Allah help us!
It's not very good as protecting your children is very important as getting 4 eye witnessing is probably not likely, and so a person of knowledge would know this. Everything can be fabricated, so some of the things the Shiekh said dont seem right . A person of knowledge should be more responsible as they are in a position of power just like teachers
These are beautiful statements however often these criminals hiding behind religious garb are protected by the religious ilk and they move on to other places and do the same. For one it should he outlawed religiously that there is private counciling between a male and female and that a religious figure is alone with minors or have camera's installed where teaching is taken place. Too much of these crimes have been committed and swept under the carpets and being plastered with religious text to silence people. Its precisely this type of religious talk that gives these criminals cover.
Help your brother who is oppressed. Help your brother who is an oppressor, by stopping him. I found the mention of sharia unclear as there is halal and haraam, commands and prohibitions, but sharia is not implemented partially or within non-Islamic legislation. We are all accountable and should know Islam and try to study and learn the wisdom of Islam by seeking knowledge. Injustice without an appropriate response due to the absence of Islam. We need to learn and implement Islam.
@purplelove3666 dear one. The protection for the victim is there, if handled properly. What this video and the advice are about is guarding our souls by protecting each other when news comes to us. What to say initially to gain the pleasure of Allah and taking it to the proper authorities. Which, by the way, is not myself. You may be a judge, social worker, or law enforcement officer. Me, just someone who visits youtube and would like for a case to be tried in a court of law and proven and not tried in the court of lay people and youtube bloggers.
@59:51 "feminine" can be misinterpreted, in the original english meaning of the word, "feminine" means "manly" or the word "women" in the original meaning of the word means "we men" (manly women) and that is what the shariah command to the ettiquette/behaviour of female folks when around non-mahram males. the correct terminology is that sisters should not be "frivolous/scantly" around non-mahram male folks.
One of the better videos I have seen on the issue with Imam celebrities and their private life cases that may catch our attention. The most islamic based for sure. A great message to stay away from commenting at all on such business. You are only giving more good deeds to the person accused in such situations, from an islamic perspective.
Have you all ever considered that the female involved had mental issues and infatuated with the alleged? Such heinous allegations. May Allah ta'ala rectify this affair and bring the guilty to justice and make evident who is innocent 🤲
They have video evidence. They aren’t allegations. His wife saw the videos on his phone. The authorities have the proof. Don’t make excuses for munkar otherwise your corrupt yourself
I did say may the guilty be brought to justice. However if the wife saw the messages and videos she needs to bare witness of it in public. The matter is very serious.
@@AlGhuraba1446in public,what the heck is the public going to do? Is the public the judge or the criminal justice ? Your comment did not make any sense
he keep talking about the perpetrator ,no real advice for the victims or regards..he s only concern is to protect the uthority its a mentality,thats how a lot of perpetrator had been covered and some time flee back home.He is soo wrong
Have you heard from the sheikh himself in the defence of the allegations? How do you know he is guilty and where is your islamic source to present as evidence as I won't accept the sources from the Zionist FBI as evidence. Also, when Allah says in the Quran that when a source comes from an evil source we should investigate it, are you rejecting the ayat of the Quran?
That's right! yes go to the authorities "" that would be police. Start getting familiar with what crimes are, You don't have to go to another Imam you can go straight to the police if it is serious crime such as Sexual Assault Rape, Rape of Child, unlawful connection with a minor & Theft, Fraud.. If it is too sensitive to share go straight to the police they can help you the best and they will go and talk to the imams to the other avenues and asked questions
Have you heard from the sheikh himself in the defence of the allegations? How do you know he is guilty and where is your islamic source to present as evidence as I won't accept the sources from the Zionist FBI as evidence. Also, when Allah says in the Quran that when a source comes from an evil source we should investigate it, are you rejecting the ayat of the Quran?
Are you serious! Give Witness if you see something directly occurring to you or to your neighbour Within community Jesus said do not give false Witness against your neighbour do not lie in a court because the consequences can be far reaching particularly if someone is innocent far reaching on you when you do that you are not balancing Justice and you are bringing it all back on you in your future generation
This man is misleading and is out of touch. Firstly these people live in non Muslim countries and have no say of doing checks on who is their religious leaders or managing their mosques or teaching their children Quran as they do in Muslim countries where the religious department do the checks and approve them first . He is approving for covering up for these evil people. Anyone that has clear proof should just report them to the authorities they are registered with , to save their religion and themselves and their children.
Thank God for this video and this knowledgeable Sheikh. I was disgusted by the many Muslim chan̈nels and videos discussing the details of the alleged crimes. Why do Muslims want to go into the details partivularly of pornography ? It's enough to prove that the crime was committed, and we need to check that proof. That's our only job, not to examine and expose the details of crimes by Muslims.. Then our responsibility as Muslims is how we will help and support victims in our communities to recover That's it.
I think we've put our trust in some of our 'western scholars' for far too long making excuses for your hiccups along the way but Im sorry enough is enough. This incident has broken the Islamic community, more needs to be done.
This advice is wrong on so many levels, it does not address the context of the what actually happened, Allah knows best, burying heads in sand do not solve the problem
@@grow_up290not assaulted this price was doing video chat with the mother and daughter and asking them them to do dirty stuff he recorded in his phone so it's child abuse and child pornogrphy his wife saw it and reported it to police
Alhamdulillah. Amazing sheik yes if some one make mistakes 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢you forgive them 🙏 😀 😊 😄 👍 🙂 🙏 😀 😊 😄 👍 🙂 🙏 but the have to stop ✋️ 🫸 🫷 😄 😀 😆 ✋️ 🫸 🫷 😄 😀 😆 ✋️ 🫸 🫷 😄 😀 😆 ✋️ 🫸 🫷 peoples are innocents they not responsible 😑 😉 😆 😀 😄 🤣 😑 😉 😆 😀 😄 🤣 😑 😉 😆 😀 😄 🤣 😑 for certain actions but peoples can over step their boundries. They feel too power full they are un touchable 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢very wise sheik may allah blessed you for your wisdom 🙏 😊 ❤️ ✨️ 💖 ☺️ 🙏 😊 ❤️ ✨️ 💖 ☺️ 🙏 😊 ❤️ ✨️ 💖 ☺️ 🙏 😊 ❤️ ✨️ 💖 ☺️ 🙏 😊 ❤️.
As a Muslim we should not be washing our dirty laundry in public . Listen to shiekh , why take the blame of others on you . If it’s true he will be punished in duniya and Akhira . Making dua it’s not true.
@@giovannioro1642 this is thought control. ppl arent lemmings with only 'scholars' being allowed to express a opinion on a matter. dont try and gate keep. noone cares about this 'appeal to authority' fallacy
Take heed, Unfortunately I attended such a lecture, and I started speaking to a beautiful hijabi in attendance, we ended up alone and because she was a virgin ....we ended up commiting zina in a way which disavows oneself from that which was revealed to prophet Muhammad sws...is the sin just that of zina or is it DOUBLED because of the prohibited manner it was done? Be careful brothers and sisters, one smile can lead to regrettable actions which will lead straight to jahannam, despite endless duas seeking forgiveness I cannot turn back the clock and prevent the shameful act from occuring.
@@LitewizTrust me, your comment isn’t going to be a wake up call for anyone. You’re not saving anyone with this comment and instead you’re putting yourself at risk for not being forgiven simply because you are sharing it publicly. So really, no it’s NOT worth it to share this. Delete it.
@husainpatel7683 Naqwi is one of the founders of Deobandi sect: UA-cam the following: "Miaan engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza " Use google translate for the pdf book references
In other words Islamic etiquette when its a deed done in private according to the video is: Innocent until proven guilty, in a court of law. AND If it doesn't affect you, keep your mouth quiet. Do not gossip or even just convey even if you see it, unless its to a person of knowledge. Just conveying something you see to a regular person opens yourself to punishment. We want to ask for forgiveness and also ask Allah SWT to free us from such bad deeds and also ask for protection for the victim.
Sub7haan ALLAH, from the first few minutes Shaikh Haitham gives the answers that I was looking for and the answers that my Islam teaches me !!!! I have seen a few "youtubers" already jumping on the bandwagon and mentioning the name of the accused who I have never heard of !!! I think there is a conspiracy against him because he is spreading Islam , the western governments will do anything to halt the spread of Islam !!!
Join us live this December! BOOK NOW whilst tickets last: annualdinner.co.uk/sm
With all due respect I do not believe the equivocation with the Hadith of Ifq is related to this incident. An investigation was DONE and evidence provided and arrest made based on that evidence. The community has right to be horrified and condemn this individuals actions. No one jumped to accuse, the evidence was provided first. Also no one celebrated this news or were happy to hear what he did. We were devastated and horrified.
The example of Zinq is NOT relevant to cases of child abuse. Rape is not equivalent to Adultery between two consenting adults in the Shariah and CHILD ABUSE is definitely not equivalent. Really disappointed that the respected sheikh responded in this way.
you are really ignorant,its like the sheigh talked to a deaf person open you freaken ears.
I think his point is we don't know if the evidence is real or not. In other words, we will never know of its actually true or not. In the end let the courts do their job and we should keep our mouths shut to avoid defamation in case we are wrong. Refer to 07:30 in the video.
@@giovannioro1642 The point is in Islam a person honour is a right , before we have every social media youtube influencer/sheigh jump on the fitnah train,they should rather remain silent and let the authorities deal with the evidence and prove the person is guilty.Now everyone is sensationalizing this issue without due process,It has become this easy to drag people names through the mud,what is worse, the person spreading the rumours or the person who committed it.
@@galielachmat2087 I don't disagree with you. Also he does distinguish between openly committing fasaad versus doing it in private.
Unfortunately many Muslims and non-Muslims are looking for views. In fact we should be this way to both Muslims and non-Muslims. We need to stop sensatiinalizing and gossiping.
Yes agree
Whoever is listening to this talk my advice is if you have any concerns that someone might be be commiting a crime go directly to the police to investigate unfortunately too many of these crimes have been committed and turned a blind eye to, these religious figure cannot be relied on anymore.
Subhan’Allah ! What a sad reality, may Allah preserve and protect all of us, amin 👐
I am so happy that you gave this talk. It teaches us how to behave according to Quran and authentic Sunnah.
May Allah reward you and protect you all in this life and the next. Ya Allah bless our Nabi (s) and forgive us all.
Shaykh Salman really asks some solid questions. He is speaking for a lot of the people who love to gossip on such issues. He is really balanced and puts the shaykh on the spot. Very good questions on the 15-30 minute mark. Questions that have been bothering us for years. JazakAllaahu Khayr Ustadh Salman!!!
Shaykh?! This is what's wrong putting people into positions they are not deserving of
Pray to cover the crimes of another? Whether that person is Muslim or not I dont see doing so..May Allah grant me the ability to discern the truth from falsehood.
I would encourage the shuyookh and content creators to take this into consideration:
i) Speak from a trauma informed lens and check your emotional intelligence.
ii) Bear in mind that in your audience, there are victims that have or are being silenced, oppressed and isolated by their abusers. Address existing victims to make sure they are comforted. While you want to stop the keyboard warriors, you have to prioritize victims and not exacerbate their injury further.
iii) Be cognizant of unintended spiritual bypassing. Theological guidelines are frequently weaponized by 'people of knowledge' to oppress, gaslight and demonize victims, sometimes even coerce them.
I struggled to watch this 50 minutes; the first thirty minutes sounded like the traumatic investigation victims go through and the second half sounds like heavily biased "dignitaries" who generally place the burden of forgiveness, rationalization & mercy on the victim. This is exactly how victims and weaker people in society are abandoned & isolated from the 'strong body' of the ummah.
Well said
Whilst you mention some important points, I think you are missing the point of the video.
The shaykh is addressing the masses on how to safeguard their own Akhirah in this situation, as it is so easy damage our own hereafter with how we react to news of this nature.
It is not to address the victims or perpetrators.
@@abuzubayr2404I'm curious if you can explain the point of my response. And perhaps you might be able to explain who and what I was trying to address as well.
@@abuzubayr2404 Yes I agree this video is not intended for one audience or not for trauma victims. It is for everyone who doesn't know about the people involved in the situation. Well said brother. MashaaAllaah.
You totally missed the point of the video. This is a video not intended for trauma victims. It is islamic etiquette in regards to rumors about a religious figure, whether they are true or not. Trauma victim videos should be made by those who are licensed in such fields. Shaykhs are not necessarily licensed to deal with such situations.
Alhamduillah . May Allah swt give sheik haitham a long life. This is true ilm. This is the difference with people of knowledges and a layman.
If a non-muslim court has video of s abuse, do we say it is unacceptable islamically? If there is tangible evidence of abuse, it is abuse in any religion. We should take precautions to protect our vulnerable from all predators.
Yes exactly
How do you know for sure if it wasn't set up and fabricated ,?
@@haveaniceday365. Who matters more? The victim or the accused?
@@Dust2Turaab THE TRUTH MATTERS THE MOST (whoever is on the side of truth should be sided with]
We should be willing to follow the guidelines of the Shari'ah. Its teachings are timeless. Let's just be humble so as not to be punished for not following the path of the righteous.
these things should not be confidential 😢these individuals should be ostracized from our communities!!!
لَا إِلٰهَ إِلَّا الله مُحَمَّدٌ رَسُولُ الله
Exactly
52:10 If the accusation involves “dhulm”(oppression) that has to be stopped immediately and those who are vulnerable have to be protected immediately.
He also says that if something must be immediately reported to the police by law, then you should do that first - eg child abuse. The accused may be arrested and in jail at this point. Also Shariah is not easy on these kind of crimes- some SA cases under shariah are punishable by death to the abuser. This person does not go back to being a protected member of society afterwards. The victim is protected including their privacy but not the perpetrators once they are found guilty.
If what has happened to our brother and others is true, may Allah place sincere tawbah in the hearts and ours and save us from this. Ya Allah, don't let him despair of Your mercy and forgiveness.
Jazak allahu khair for your advice.
This has also highlighted the issues boundaries being lost within digital platforms. Meaning, even with online Quran Islamic platforms women and men during such interactions should still be treated based on Islamic rulings. Not having the women camera on etc Because it can protect women from any evil and perverse nature of someone who might even be in a position of power including position of faith etc May Allah save us.
Brilliant video
Jazakamullah khair Shaykh, we needed this perspective on this issue
Much needed video!
This is the most important topic to talk about concerning the recent issue. Everyone just jumped on the wagon of judge and jury under the guise of giving advise but under the obscure premise that the accused already did it. Islam is just in imposing penalty but it also invented the concept of due process and the presumption pf innocence until proven guilty. Get down your high horse and submit to the Shariah. This is a real scholar talking with wisdom providing us guidance.
It’s literally already been detailed in court documents. People are reading the evidence not spreading rumors. The FBI already has presented all the evidence and it is tangible evidence.
JAK, my brother, well said
Real talk!
Thank you my brother. First person talking sense. Obviously the sheikh is talking truth. I hope people listen to this and understand that islam has rules and regulations.
Mufti menk is paedophile
As humans we make many mistakes in our lives. When we seek forgiveness and atone for our sins, then I would say our “aaib “ ( the sin or wrong) must not be exposed. This is to help the person reform.
But in the case of premeditated sin as sexual abuse on different accounts, then it should expose the perpetrators so that no other will fall as victim.
Protect yr kids folks. Don't trust anyone. If u abused my child I'd exposed u & shame u. To protect other victims
If I was a Shaykh, people wouldn't like me because my answer would be so short: (1) We live in the West, let authority do it's work (prison/fine/sex offender list etc..).(2) Set preventive measures for this to not happen again. Maybe send emails to madrassas (3) Tell the community to focus on themselves and their family, leave what do no concern them. (4) Leave Allah to deal with his sins and forgiveness, and whether it is kufr or not.
Khutbahs used to be short.
People used to share more Islamic knowledge and see one another implementing Islam and talk to one another about Islam.
Islam is a complete way of life, the best of manners, the best of legislation.
Good answer, mash'Allah!🙂👍🏾❤️☝🏽
Thank you for uploading. This is a comprehensive islamic perspective with reference, explanation and objectivity. Much needed.
Jazakallah khair
MAY allah reward this aheikh for giving comprhensive elaboration of sharia law regarding these kinds of sensitive issues ,my respect to oridnary people ,they speaks out of emotions but scholar always speak the truth using wisdom
I think that the sheikh has dwelt a lot on the point of not spreading the news. Although it's true from the Shari'a perspective, it should be highly emphasised that this is a severely punishable sin. Otherwise, if he keeps on repeating not to spread the news some people will think that he is protecting or covering for the crime.
But the point is, the crime at this moment is only an allegation and hasn't been substantiated. We haven't even heard from the accused yet. Imagine the damage that would have been done already if the allegations were found to be false. Also we need to remember that the source of the allegation is from an evil entity, and the Quran warns us about spreading allegations that come from evil.
This situation is part of a bigger problem where our 'western scholars' have pushed and pushed young brothers and sisters into the limelight without the correct tarbiyyah, years of nurturing and studying, testing their rigor, etc and this is the result of what you see today. We need to start revaluating this dawrah culture we have created which has led to celebrity statuses.
Huh?
Shouldn't we inform people to save their children.
52:10 if the accusations involve dhulm (abuse) it must be stopped immediately and any vulnerable people must be protected immediately.
He also said, serious suspicions, eg of child abuse, that have to be reported by law, should be reported to the police or proper authorities.
@@Nishful5yeah but not only police. The whole community should be made aware.
Why not expose them when they harm others not between them and Allah
I like the Shaikh explaining the foundational principles ma sha Allah.
Subhanallah jazakallah sheikh. We really needed to hear this. Shaytan is always sitting on the straight path waiting for anything to happen and he pushes us away from Allah. May Allah protect us from sins and if we have committed them may Allah swt hide them ameen.
The Quran explicitly tells us that a large number of those involved in propagating religion are not close to God "Verily, there are many of the rabbis and the monks who devour the wealth of mankind in falsehood, and hinder from the way of Allah" (Tawbah verse 34). God does not send down angels to prevent immoral people from working in churches or mosques or synagogues. It is our job to distinguish between moral people and immoral people in the houses of God and not to blindly "revere" anyone who wears a cross or grows a beard. God commands us not to follow preachers or pastors or imams and to follow His verses. People who obey "men of God" in things God forbade are themselves not close to God.
I am anti Muslim, but i like this text you wrote here.
Absolutely right
Interesting. The most vocal who are yelling saying how horrible of a person he is are the same ones who usually oppose implementing the shariah for gender separation.
Whereas the leaders we should be following are the ones who are calm and level headed like this sheikh who happen to usually be at the forefront fighting to implement gender separation
Only a Miami Heat fan would see these contradictions. I completely agree at the hypocrisy of some liberals - not all of course. Education should be segregated for the safety of our kids. Always. Alhamdulillaah.
@@ARmirzaful I didn’t understand “the Miami Heat fan” reference. Important point though, Sh. Hamza Yusuf said that in shariah, both boys and girls are not allowed to be left alone with non-mahram men. Most Muslims don’t realize that but when you hear these tragic stories of boys who get abused - that could have been prevented too. May Allah protect all of our children, Ameen.
And th4y use immature language and emotionally charged words likegaslighting,
you are defending clearly the perpetrator...silence to control thats what he wants to use.. nobody beleive in that
Have you heard from the sheikh himself in the defence of the allegations? How do you know he is guilty and where is your islamic source to present as evidence as I won't accept the sources from the Zionist FBI as evidence.
Also, when Allah says in the Quran that when a source comes from an evil source we should investigate it, are you rejecting the ayat of the Quran?
its a public matter and we are concern because we send our kids to these schools.dictatorship mentallity ,no empathy ...for the victims the only concern is to protect the authority using islam it is sad ..you don t protect women and children then you turn around and accuse them of being at fault because they put make up oh my GODim just disgusted..may ALLAH guide yoiur hearth to protect the vulnerable and not the unjust.....
Exactly. Instead of supporting the Ummah, they are all trying to stifle the issue. Kudos to Sheikh Yasir Qadhi for speaking about it.
Mashallah beautiful
I encourage all to stop insulting this man (me included), and instead follow the prophetic saying where the prophet told us to say whenever we see someone falling in an ibtila "affliction" "Praise is to Allah Who has spared me what He has afflicted you "Wisam Sharief" with, and preferred me greatly above much of what He has created."
This must be extreme strict and spoken against. Freemixing, violation of Islamic rulings in Islamic institutions and things of this nature. May Allah guide us and punish those who transgress against vulnerable Muslims, and may Allah protect us from them and the fitnah that he aflicted him with.
Sheikh Haitham,
May Allah preserve you. Perhaps you could have waited or contacted Al Maghrib. The organisation whole heartedly believes the victim.
This talk of yours will bring more harm than good as people are going to assume that you have more husn Ad dhan towards him than even his wife and immediate colleagues.
Jazak allah khair sheikh you explained very well and in details muslim please listen to your scholars and submit your ego to sharia law this difference between real beliver and fake beliver
The Shaykh is trying to give general principles for any accusations. It’s not necessarily meant for the severity of the case you mention.
At 52:10 and other points where the host brings up children, the Shaykh immediately says if it’s something that must be reported to police/authorities by law, then report it right away. If there is dhulm (abuse), it must be stopped immediately and any vulnerable people must be protected immediately.
@ But the timing matters.
Imagine making a video on etiquettes of treating an alleged killer who is Muslim man, after the police caught that Muslim man. Imagine that This Muslim man had killed a Muslim boy with video evidence and the evidence was submitted to police by the Muslim man’s wife.
Respected Sheikh Haddad didn’t dwell enough on how the community needs to support the victim, most of the talk is focused on protecting the honour of the accused and not of the victim.
@@AbdussamadAbdulRazakMost of video is addressing ourselves and how to safeguard our own Akhirah as people on the sidelines. The byproduct of that may benefit the honour of the accused by minimising discussing him, but that isn't the point of the video.
@@AbdussamadAbdulRazak that’s true. People are more scared about their safety and their children’s safety and what is being done to both deal with these kinds of cases and how to protect people from future incidents. The accused’s honour and even protecting from gossip is a lower priority.
I reject this position in this matter. Misuse of Hadith for this case and Allah knows best. Enjoin good and FORBID EVIL.
Have you heard from the sheikh himself in the defence of the allegations? How do you know he is guilty and where is your islamic source to present as evidence as I won't accept the sources from the Zionist FBI as evidence.
Also, when Allah says in the Quran that when a source comes from an evil source we should investigate it, are you rejecting the ayat of the Quran?
U dont know basic thing that who is in charge of that ? Ulema, shurta, Qazi , and people of authority have that amr bil maroof nahya anil munkar , common people are not in charge of it
Put emotions on the side. We have principles in Islam for cases like this. The allegations of our mother Aisha, may Allah be pleased with her, is far greater than this in its gravity.
And even if it is true... Shouldn't we surround the person and support the person to change. Either we support him or the shaitan will! This is why we are so attacked because we don't have the spirit of our Nabi (s) and the sahabi! Ya Allah help us!
What about the victim?
1:03:00 Such scholars should be harming the society and they need to be questioned and exposed by the other scholars!
If you don't like accusations and allegations and being questioned
R U Worried about having your reputation
Soiled... then don't act that WAY!
It's not very good as protecting your children is very important as getting 4 eye witnessing is probably not likely, and so a person of knowledge would know this.
Everything can be fabricated, so some of the things the Shiekh said dont seem right .
A person of knowledge should be more responsible as they are in a position of power just like teachers
These are beautiful statements however often these criminals hiding behind religious garb are protected by the religious ilk and they move on to other places and do the same. For one it should he outlawed religiously that there is private counciling between a male and female and that a religious figure is alone with minors or have camera's installed where teaching is taken place. Too much of these crimes have been committed and swept under the carpets and being plastered with religious text to silence people. Its precisely this type of religious talk that gives these criminals cover.
I agree. This prohibition to speak about it only provides cover for their crimes.
Institutions can be corrupted.
Not the institution. Specific individuals in the institution. Shaykh Yasir Qadhi talk on this check it out.
@@ARmirzaful Mohammed was corrupted.
Your religion started with a liar. Why are you building your life around this lair?
Help your brother who is oppressed.
Help your brother who is an oppressor, by stopping him.
I found the mention of sharia unclear as there is halal and haraam, commands and prohibitions, but sharia is not implemented partially or within non-Islamic legislation.
We are all accountable and should know Islam and try to study and learn the wisdom of Islam by seeking knowledge.
Injustice without an appropriate response due to the absence of Islam.
We need to learn and implement Islam.
And when we try to protect each other, we are looked at as naive or just downright stupid.
Yeah,but no protection for the victim right?
@purplelove3666 dear one. The protection for the victim is there, if handled properly. What this video and the advice are about is guarding our souls by protecting each other when news comes to us. What to say initially to gain the pleasure of Allah and taking it to the proper authorities. Which, by the way, is not myself. You may be a judge, social worker, or law enforcement officer. Me, just someone who visits youtube and would like for a case to be tried in a court of law and proven and not tried in the court of lay people and youtube bloggers.
This is crime? What does he mean by you need knowledge and laying foundation? You need the law to investigate and punish the criminal...
he just basically care about their authority not being question..no amppathy for that mother or child...
@59:51
"feminine" can be misinterpreted, in the original english meaning of the word, "feminine" means "manly" or the word "women" in the original meaning of the word means "we men" (manly women) and that is what the shariah command to the ettiquette/behaviour of female folks when around non-mahram males.
the correct terminology is that sisters should not be "frivolous/scantly" around non-mahram male folks.
This talk was really weak by this shaykh on many many levels.
One of the better videos I have seen on the issue with Imam celebrities and their private life cases that may catch our attention. The most islamic based for sure. A great message to stay away from commenting at all on such business. You are only giving more good deeds to the person accused in such situations, from an islamic perspective.
Have you all ever considered that the female involved had mental issues and infatuated with the alleged? Such heinous allegations. May Allah ta'ala rectify this affair and bring the guilty to justice and make evident who is innocent 🤲
They have video evidence. They aren’t allegations. His wife saw the videos on his phone. The authorities have the proof. Don’t make excuses for munkar otherwise your corrupt yourself
I did say may the guilty be brought to justice. However if the wife saw the messages and videos she needs to bare witness of it in public. The matter is very serious.
@@AlGhuraba1446in public,what the heck is the public going to do? Is the public the judge or the criminal justice ? Your comment did not make any sense
@purplelove3666 your absolutely right...
@purplelove3666 what i meant was that the wife has to confirm the allegations publicly. We haven't heard from her.
Islam is totally corrupt. Therefore its not surprising that there are scandals.if Momo lived now he would be locked up for life.
Tell me about the Archbishop of Canterbury then. There are pedos everywhere.
he keep talking about the perpetrator ,no real advice for the victims or regards..he s only concern is to protect the uthority its a mentality,thats how a lot of perpetrator had been covered and some time flee back home.He is soo wrong
Well that’s not the subject of the video..
Disappointing.
Have you heard from the sheikh himself in the defence of the allegations? How do you know he is guilty and where is your islamic source to present as evidence as I won't accept the sources from the Zionist FBI as evidence.
Also, when Allah says in the Quran that when a source comes from an evil source we should investigate it, are you rejecting the ayat of the Quran?
What’s disappointing?
❤❤❤
That's right!
yes go to the authorities ""
that would be police.
Start getting familiar with what crimes are,
You don't have to go to another Imam you can go straight to the police if it is serious crime such as Sexual Assault Rape, Rape of Child, unlawful connection with a minor & Theft, Fraud..
If it is too sensitive to share go straight to the police they can help you the best and they will go and talk to the imams
to the other avenues and asked questions
Go to authorize not wise imams
Huh
English please
@TherealStevenSeagal go to authorities
Complete bollocks
Have you heard from the sheikh himself in the defence of the allegations? How do you know he is guilty and where is your islamic source to present as evidence as I won't accept the sources from the Zionist FBI as evidence.
Also, when Allah says in the Quran that when a source comes from an evil source we should investigate it, are you rejecting the ayat of the Quran?
Are you serious!
Give Witness if you see something directly occurring to you or to your neighbour Within community Jesus said do not give false Witness against your neighbour do not lie in a court because the consequences can be far reaching particularly if someone is innocent far reaching on you when you do that you are not balancing Justice and you are bringing it all back on you in your future generation
This man is misleading and is out of touch. Firstly these people live in non Muslim countries and have no say of doing checks on who is their religious leaders or managing their mosques or teaching their children Quran as they do in Muslim countries where the religious department do the checks and approve them first . He is approving for covering up for these evil people. Anyone that has clear proof should just report them to the authorities they are registered with , to save their religion and themselves and their children.
Sadly the sheikh is not capable of speaking on this topic !!!!!!
Thank God for this video and this knowledgeable Sheikh. I was disgusted by the many Muslim chan̈nels and videos discussing the details of the alleged crimes. Why do Muslims want to go into the details partivularly of pornography ? It's enough to prove that the crime was committed, and we need to check that proof. That's our only job, not to examine and expose the details of crimes by Muslims.. Then our responsibility as Muslims is how we will help and support victims in our communities to recover That's it.
I think we've put our trust in some of our 'western scholars' for far too long making excuses for your hiccups along the way but Im sorry enough is enough. This incident has broken the Islamic community, more needs to be done.
100%
This advice is wrong on so many levels, it does not address the context of the what actually happened, Allah knows best, burying heads in sand do not solve the problem
❤
❤️❤️🌹🌹🍉🍉🤲🤲
Please someone explain what happened because dr.Yaser qadhi also gave a lecture on something like this!
apparently a Pakistani Quran teacher assaulted his student and got reported to the authorities by his wife
JazaakAllah khairan for this information.@@grow_up290
@@grow_up290not assaulted this price was doing video chat with the mother and daughter and asking them them to do dirty stuff he recorded in his phone so it's child abuse and child pornogrphy his wife saw it and reported it to police
Are y'all trying to whitewash Wissam?
Of course his wife rated him out but I think his wife is a bad person now😂
This isn't about him or any particular person. This is the general principle in Islam to deal with such situations. Read Suratun Noor.
Alhamdulillah. Amazing sheik yes if some one make mistakes 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢you forgive them 🙏 😀 😊 😄 👍 🙂 🙏 😀 😊 😄 👍 🙂 🙏 but the have to stop ✋️ 🫸 🫷 😄 😀 😆 ✋️ 🫸 🫷 😄 😀 😆 ✋️ 🫸 🫷 😄 😀 😆 ✋️ 🫸 🫷 peoples are innocents they not responsible 😑 😉 😆 😀 😄 🤣 😑 😉 😆 😀 😄 🤣 😑 😉 😆 😀 😄 🤣 😑 for certain actions but peoples can over step their boundries. They feel too power full they are un touchable 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢very wise sheik may allah blessed you for your wisdom 🙏 😊 ❤️ ✨️ 💖 ☺️ 🙏 😊 ❤️ ✨️ 💖 ☺️ 🙏 😊 ❤️ ✨️ 💖 ☺️ 🙏 😊 ❤️ ✨️ 💖 ☺️ 🙏 😊 ❤️.
As a Muslim we should not be washing our dirty laundry in public .
Listen to shiekh , why take the blame of others on you . If it’s true he will be punished in duniya and Akhira .
Making dua it’s not true.
The comments section proves that laymen shouldnt be commenting on issues they have no knowledge of using their nafs to guide what theyre saying.
And what are you? A scholar? Be quiet yourself. You clearly don’t understand
@daee121 so you are a scholar that can freely give your opinions creating fitna. Nice
@@giovannioro1642 this is thought control. ppl arent lemmings with only 'scholars' being allowed to express a opinion on a matter. dont try and gate keep. noone cares about this 'appeal to authority' fallacy
@daee121 social media makes everyone think their opinions matter.
Loooool sheik stopppppp
Take heed, Unfortunately I attended such a lecture, and I started speaking to a beautiful hijabi in attendance, we ended up alone and because she was a virgin ....we ended up commiting zina in a way which disavows oneself from that which was revealed to prophet Muhammad sws...is the sin just that of zina or is it DOUBLED because of the prohibited manner it was done? Be careful brothers and sisters, one smile can lead to regrettable actions which will lead straight to jahannam, despite endless duas seeking forgiveness I cannot turn back the clock and prevent the shameful act from occuring.
delete theis comment, do not admit your major sin.
@@dom3073 If it prevents even one brother or sister from going down the same dark hole (no pun intended) then its worth it. Jazakallah khr.
@@LitewizTrust me, your comment isn’t going to be a wake up call for anyone. You’re not saving anyone with this comment and instead you’re putting yourself at risk for not being forgiven simply because you are sharing it publicly. So really, no it’s NOT worth it to share this. Delete it.
Deobandis and Barelvies "ullema" do such things per their books. Ganghoi was being rubbed by Nokavi.
Who on earth is Novaki? Be ready to answer about this on the Day of Judgement.
@husainpatel7683 Naqwi is one of the founders of Deobandi sect:
UA-cam the following: "Miaan engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza "
Use google translate for the pdf book references
@husainpatel7683 he listened to eng Ali Mirza 😂
@@native5647 engineer only show us the books Deobandis try to hide feeling embarrassed by their elders.
In other words Islamic etiquette when its a deed done in private according to the video is:
Innocent until proven guilty, in a court of law.
AND
If it doesn't affect you, keep your mouth quiet. Do not gossip or even just convey even if you see it, unless its to a person of knowledge. Just conveying something you see to a regular person opens yourself to punishment.
We want to ask for forgiveness and also ask Allah SWT to free us from such bad deeds and also ask for protection for the victim.
Its people like you the Sheigh is referring to,its better to keep quiet
Without lies, Islam DIES! (Everytime)
shame is that all you got,a poor lame cliche
Grow up.
Cringe!
You will die sooner or later but Islam will prevail because it’s the truth.
The blind cannot see.
Regardless.
Islam is the only religion how can it die
A shike said it was death penalty
Sub7haan ALLAH, from the first few minutes Shaikh Haitham gives the answers that I was looking for and the answers that my Islam teaches me !!!! I have seen a few "youtubers" already jumping on the bandwagon and mentioning the name of the accused who I have never heard of !!! I think there is a conspiracy against him because he is spreading Islam , the western governments will do anything to halt the spread of Islam !!!
Hafidh p diddy