🍁 Canadian Guilt 🍁
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 сер 2024
- I actually forgot to mention the fact that progressives burnt down a dozen or so churches in Canada in response to the 'mass grave' scandal. They're literal terrorists.
-----
Join the community discord! ► / discord
Watch Us LIVE (And Click Dat Sub Button!) ► / gameboomers
GB Archive Channel ► / gameboomer
Dev Kit Channel ► / @thedevkit
SFO Backups Channel ► / channel
-----
SUPPORT THE SHOW:
BTC:bc1q6udqgvfm9uaj59l24ut7f73wvsfu707kk6pn3m
SubscribeStar! ► www.subscribes...
Streamlabs! ► streamlabs.com...
Patreon! ► / shortfatotaku
Paypal! ► paypal.me/short...
Humble Bundle Affiliate Link! ► www.humblebund...
Amazon CAN Affiliate Link! ► amzn.to/322aFAa
Amazon USA Affiliate Link! ► amzn.to/30PLxgN
Amazon CAN Wishlist! ► www.amazon.ca/...
Amazon USA Wishlist! ► www.amazon.com...
-----
SFO-CIAL MEDIA! HYUK HYUK
DA TWEETS ► / sfosecretary
DA FACES ► / sfotaku
DA GABS ► www.gab.com/sh...
DA MINDS ► www.minds.com/...
DA PARLERS ► parler.com/pro...
DA STEAMS ► steamcommunity....
-----
Credits:
Thumbnail ► some protest
Background ► / cryomancerlex
Music ► • Parasite Eve OST - Out...
#CanadaDay
Brave canadian says he’s not sorry
GIGACHAD
I say sorry our advanced civilization won over the stone age forest dweller. Sorry we had wheels and guns. Sorry we had metallurgy.
@@ShortFatOtaku Finally a lifeform beyond GigaChad: MapleChad
Sorry we had the written word and vaccines. Better luck on your next Civ run
BASED and MAPLE-PILLED. I was just watching a WWI Documentary with my son on BBC Select called 100 days to victory... multiple references to the Canadian infantry being moved up and down the trenches because the Germans thought they were the best and moved their own best troops to shadow the majestic moose men. Just before the attack, the Canadians were moved away at 10 AM and returned to the front at nightfall under a smoke screen to lead the attack at dusk.
"Hello fellow white people!" - Italian man in Canada, 2022.
italian + indigenous
I cooka da meatball
Northen italy it's pretty white, my family is from there, it's almost Austria.
@@johnseppethe2nd2 Meatball and bannock
Italian is considered Caucasian though?
I literally took a class in college about Native History - it was just a racial purity screed for natives. They literally argued that diluting the bloodline would destroy the culture and therefore they need to keep their bloodline's pure. Seriously. I walked out of the class and never returned after that day.
My college had racial group clubs for blacks, latinos, and natives. It's disgusting.
What no actual history aside from loosely connected myths does to a culture. There can't be such thing as a a native American history before the European arrival, it doesn't exist because they hadn't discovered writing, their technolical level was that of the neolithic. The only thing we could ever do is try to figure some things out from archeological evidence.
Based
They literally believe in the "Noble Savage" myth for all non-white races.
5 comments, only 1 is being shown. UA-cam shadowbanning comments now?
The problem with defining racism as "when one culture is dominant and another is disadvantaged" is that it means that the "racist" people change based on your location. Or can even change completely based on politics. So "racism" becomes an incredibly nebulous term that doesn't really mean anything, since a person could be considered racist when living in one place, but if they move somewhere else, then they're suddenly the victim of it. Except that for people like Inutiq, that clearly doesn't apply to white people. They're just always racist. Period. Even when living in a culture that disadvantages them. Because apparently THEIR racism is somehow universal, even if they themselves don't have a racist bone in their body. They're just guilty by proxy. Guilty of the sin of being born white.
That sort of belief seems pretty damned racist to me.
It is very funny to me that I could use similar historical arguments to justify prejudice against Turkish people, because my ancestors were oppressed by the Ottoman empire for half a millennia. But if I were in Canada or the US and expressed such prejudice I'd be labelled racist since Slavs are considered white and Turks are considered 'people of color'.
thats text book Marxism and its totally designed so they can tailor language to meet their ever changing authoritarian needs
By the traditional definition, yes it is an incredibly racist view. However these people don't look at the traditional view, they appropriate the word to apply to any groups they hate.
Thats what I've been thinking for a long time now. Lefties are trying to create the original sin of being white, a sin you will always have to answer for and always seek appeasement.
It makes me wonder how does it apply to me being a mutt of white native and Hispanic like what the fuck does it mean for me like given how they do their nonsense am I guilty of oppressing myslef or what the fuck
As an American, I have respect for those of you Canadians who honked horns to the point that your so-called leader *_declared Martial Law_* in a vain attempt to silence your dissent against overzealous government overreach.
Hope you had a happy Canada day, Dev!
I lost all that respect when they ran away from the RCMP
Honk Honk means Heil Hi..
As an American, I have my criticisms of Canada, but that trucker thing was pretty based.
"Children of a common mother. Brethren dwelling together in unity."
There was a parade in a small town I visited in BC. There were no LGBT flags being waved except on the official govt vehicles, like the ambulances (not even fire trucks though). There was about two freedom fighter floats though (AKA the truckers).
Why can't we have Arab guilt over what they did to Zoroastrians?
or african slaves, or the Constantinople, etc
@@DG-mk7kd Or the christians living in the lands they invaded, hell the list is just too long to fit inside a single UA-cam comment.
@@DG-mk7kd or slavs...or celts..or the norse...
Not the to mention the conquest of North Africa and Middle East and the destruction of all local languages and culture and replacing it with Arab.
I'm sure the Arab nations have their tiny enclaves of extremely leftist self-haters. They just don't get their signal through the noise.
Ah yes, pipelines are too dangerous for the environment - much better off burning fuel in semi trucks to transport it since vehicles so seldom get into catastrophic accidents, especially in harsh winters.
We all know natural gas loves to turn into a toxic black liquid substance.
Lol yeah
In harsh winters across the rocky mountains, notoriously dangerous roads surrounded by nature and one single walmart
The thing that leftists seem to not understand is that we are still dependent on fossil fuels. Yes we need to work on becoming less dependent, but that oil is needed and if you make it harder to get it makes the cost of everything increase, and then they complain about inflation and low minimum wage. How we fix this is finding viable alternatives, most people are not on board with just dying or going back to monke.
Appreciate the shout-out
np m80
As an American. I'm so fucking tired of hearing about the "evils of the white man on the poor Indian." expect for some tribes like the Cherokee most where defeated in wars and other conflicts. and many of the large disease outbreaks happened before people understood what germs really are. The Indians where handled with kid gloves compared to what happened to the many other conquered peoples in history.
No they where not. Also alot of them technically weren't conquered at all. People literally just forgot the Iroquois were a sovereign country
I mostly agree, although the f’d up part is that like with groups like the Cherokee, they had largely begun to integrate into western society before being forced out anyway. The left is a bunch of complete loons over it all, but it doesn’t discount the bad that happening. Don’t let the dumb leftists set the narrative with their insanity, there is a nuanced reality to the whole thing. The leftoids that want to promote racism for brown people can get the same treatment the Klan did
@@cariopuppetmaster
A. Yes they were.
B. A lot of them were.
C. Debatable.
@@Lucas-sk5iy there was no conquest for the vast tracts of land in the middle of North America. Just a sale deed for the land
@@cariopuppetmaster Yeah because there was no one there.
"Inital extermination"
**Looks at myself in Micmac** "Am I not actually here?"
Dev, I think you need to learn more about the Rez system. I had a fellow micmac acquaintance who went through university so she could work in Indian Affairs to better her community; she ended up leaving and going to work in Ontario because nobody wanted to better their own situation. The Reservation system is no different than the Welfare system, it kills the incentive to better your lot in life.
It would take someone like Chief Clarence Louie of the BC Osoyoos tribe to turn things around, but that's not in the interest of the government who want to keep a voting block dependant on government handouts, and the idiots who like receiving handouts
Also that "unceded" crap annoys me to no end. It's pandering. The British won. What do these people want? Do they want the tribes completely wiped off the earth so the colonising power can say "we took it from you completely, losers"? We lost the conflict and so now we must be a part of the new system.
Or do they want a complete decolonizing of the country? In which case I'll just say "piss off I'm not living in no damn wigwam"
I was literally told by a white guy I have no right to speak on the Indian fishing issues because I disagree with the people saying they can do whatever they want because they're Indians. White leftists are insufferable
The residential schools were no worse than British boarding schools. Yes, a lot of atrocities happened, but they weren't worse because it happened to someone of a different race. Heck, there was a local School for the Deaf which had these same atrocities happen. It's almost like if you give a person authority over children the creeps who would abuse that authority are attracted to those jobs. We still see that today with grooming in schools
Exactly. The best thing would be to do away with the reservations and force integration and financial independence, but they and the white left that enables them would rather them live in squalor and leave them to drink themselves to death. Plus I've heard the crime rates on reservations are comparable to inner city ghettos. We need to stop treating blacks with kid gloves too. It was the welfare state and the resulting kid gloves that gave us the mess we have today.
For those curious (I know most aren't) my views on fishing and hunting are; if you are living off the land then you shouldn't be beholden to a season when you're allowed to get a food source; and this would apply to anyone regardless of race
If however you are using a natural resource as a means of making money then you should be regulated so you don't destroy your livelihood by going for shortterm gains; and this should apply to anyone regardless of race
The big issue is that the local fishermen want to use modern means to make money year round because they equivocate "feeding your family" with making money which doesn't functionally work under this situation as it's unsustainable. But try telling them that
Sounds like the rational thoughts of someone who knows how to think for themselves... of course you'll have difficulties dealing with those who would be unbending disciples to an ideology.
You have to keep in mind that Canada is a country built on extremely shortsighted compromise. Two of our major foundational problems, the tribes (natives is too contextual and first nations doesn't even make sense) and the French, will likely never be addressed properly. The French possess a disproportionate amount of political power, and the natives were given special status which they can truly exploit now due to the rise of "white guilt" in the wider culture.
Unfortunately, I think its at the point where the only realistic solution is the ultimatum of privileged groups being striped their special status or being shown the door. This is especially true if Canada wishes to continue its trend of increasing immigration. Who honestly thinks that the various ethnic and cultural enclaves growing in cities across the country will be so timid as to see the special status of the natives and the Quebecois and not demand it for themselves?
@@spnked9516 I literally had a guy from India tell me we were stupid and they were going to "send people over and outbreed you until we win" at that point I was ready to slam the borders closed
Boy, I had to take a propaganda course in grad school regarding Indigenous issues, and the number of racist, anti-scientific, and self-contradicting assertions I had to sit through could fill a book. It really was a bizzare mix of blood and soil rhetoric, pagan mysticism, and conspiracy theories.
Tell us more. Seriously.
I teach in a high school. Most people would not believe the insanity being peddled in schools now. The indigenous push is unreal.
@@Aiphiae Where do I begin?
Do I talk about the weird race mysticism tied into the medicine wheel? Where the Great Creator made land "for the white man", land "for the yellow man", land "for the black man", and land "for the red man"? And how each of these races are associated with specific personality traits and abilities?
Do I talk about how we were told that if my professor had their way, all "settler Canadians" would leave Canada or submit to native rule?
Do I talk about the idea that objectivity is a "settler way of knowing" and how when a deer escapes a hunter in the forest, said deer can physically be in multiple places at once the hunter isn't looking at it?
Do I talk about how Indigenous people should be allowed to commercially overfish as much as they like because of some treaty from 1750 written in ambiguous language? After all, Indigenous groups couldn't overfish- they have "treaties" with wildlife such as fish, deer etc
Do I talk about how our scientific understanding of how _homo sapiens_ came to populate the Americas is completely wrong because tradition dictates that the Great Creator placed the Indigenous people on Turtle Island at the beginning of time?
And perhaps the most infuriating of all: "I'm not going to tell you any solutions to these problems. It's not up to Indigenous people to solve problems that the settlers caused for them." followed up by "That solution is bad because Indigenous people wouldn't want that." (This was in response to the suggestion that Indigenous groups become partners in Confederation rather than wards of the state under the Indian Act)
There's too much to go over. Indigenous people in Canada were mistreated for a long time and the effects are still being felt today. But the rhetoric I'd heard from literal professors was downright nutty.
@@TheDolphinTuna damn that's actually mental. I initially didn't understand what you meant by mysticism, but wow that is crazy stuff. Deer have superpowers now XD.
@@TheDolphinTuna Thanks for taking the time to write this. It's pretty eye-opening.
You didn't happen to have Lee Maracle for a prof, did you? She's absolutely insane.
@@Aiphiae It's no problem. Always nice to get crap like that off your chest.
No, I didn't have Ms. Maracle. It is interesting, however, that a lot of the crazier stuff from that course was from videos of and papers written by "respectable" academics like John Borrows, who is considered one of the foremost scholars on Indigenous issues.
This "colonialism" from the US and Canada only look bad when you don't bother examining EVERY OTHER PEOPLE/NATION THIS HAPPENED TO.
Even within the native Americans. Do you think they just shook hands and traded when they met each other? If you are lucky! They had brutal WAR, rapes, pillaging, and slavery amongst tribes regularly.
It was even WORSE among the tribes of Africa! They had such disdain for each other they'd make alliances with complete outsiders just to intentionally wipe other other tribes off the face of the earth! (Or enslave them)
There wasn't any charity, and kind acts were sparse compared to the British to say the least.
How the British acted was about the very BEST one could expect to be treated under those circumstances!
Especially compared to other nations like the Japanese empire who’s actions were barbaric, and yet when I see an modern Japanese person I don’t see some mass murdering mad man I see an normal person why because they didn’t do anything
Read up on the Beaver Wars.
Honestly what the fuck happened to convince people that only whites ever colonized other lands? or that whites where the only ones to own slaves? Oh wait, I know what happened; Hitler.
How, do the people think, the White colonial nations find the Black slaves? They didn't take anyone they find. In Africa they paid for the humans, there own people didn't wanted anymore. - They were happy about it. They lose bad humans and also get paid for them. - It was a Win win for both sides. 🤷♂️
@@are_you_f_serious It wasn't always that, it was a lot of conquered tribes. Having people from a tribe that just got raided or lost a war didn't mean they were low talent. But yes in some cases the low talent people would be shipped off too.
Either way, the portrait the ultra racist CRT Marxists paint is so off base it's laughable.
Imagine being subservient to the people you’ve conquered. Not kind or accommodating, your interests are below theirs.
“Cucked” is a semi-retired term from an older age of the internet, but it comes directly to mind.
is that considered older? geez its still new to me
@@ShortFatOtaku Maybe i live in constant fear of using an old reference. A surefire sign of being "too-online" :)
@@ShortFatOtaku In the current age of the internet, slang, memes and colloquialisms are "old" within two months, at most. Often much sooner.
Shit flies by at the speed of light.
@@Armameteus New meme at breakfast, dead meme by lunch.
I still don't see why you get to keep land for all eternity just because you found it first. Our ancestors had to fight for land. against other tribes, against other species, against our own family.
And who is to say there weren't people here when these Asian crossed the land bridge and spread out across two continents. Natives may very well be the original colonizers. So why don't they apologize to the ancient people who we will never know their names?
The only guilt Canada should have is over the terrible decisions they made when it came to naming holidays.
"Canada day" legitimately feels like it came from a South Park joke
I mean 'Loyalist Day' wouldn't sound any better lmao
National "We Exist" Day. Still better than Australia's "Sorry" Day.
there’s korea day, japan day lol why not canada day?
To be fair Dominion day didn’t sound much better
@@thegamingsentinel9238 Dominion Day sounds awesome. Like we're more than the rinky-dink pushover we've become on the world stage.
That whole "I wanna start off the conversation by acknowledging I'm on X people's land" has been really common in Australia too. Even appears in some video games (like one where you play as a spider)
Untitled goose game was the first place I ever saw that
I’ve heard that at the beginning of nearly every gig I’ve been to in Brisbane over the past few years. If a band doesn’t do it on a bill but the others do there are consequences.
Just start doing it to them, the natives are on extinct tribes land, they genocided them.
You mean Deadly Creatures?
I always cringe whenever I hear that "we acknowledge this is unceeded land" spiel. You *know* they don't actually believe the words they're saying. It's systemic virtue signaling
It’s political shit
Pretty much all land is unceeded if you look back far enough.
At my college graduation - they did that shit. Even had some "natives" doing a "ritual purification dance" or whatever the fuck they called it. It's done to essentially say, "You are all guilty for using our land, now you owe us." Why the school doesn't just hand the university over to the natives then, eludes me.
@@afgone Or why not just buy the land from them
But no, that would undermine their white man bad narrative and be using common sense
Funny how Arabs, Turks and Chinese never make "acknowledgements" to the peoples of their conquered regions
14:00 SUSPECTED gravesite. GPR can't distinguish a body from a piled of buried garbage from the olden days when you would just bury garbage or a cluster of rocks, etc. Until excavation is done saying it's definitively X or Y is dumb.
justin tradeu keeps getting his way or better yet, if the World Economic Forum keeps getting is way Canada is going to be full of real mass grave site filled with everyone who disagreed with them you wait and see
Not a single body has been found and even native leaders in some of these instances have said there are no bodies
It sounds like a classic piece of "experts say" propaganda where someone will say something that fits the narrative and it you have to agree with it because it's sciencey. Meanwhile, the actual details of the experimentation are made vague and obscure in most reports. They'd deboonk gravity if they were paid enough.
The fact they were individual “graves” implies it wasn’t genoc*de because it wouldn’t been one big pile (or multiple) if that was the case. You don’t go to that extent and still show them respect.
@@mrshmuga9 One of these "grave sites" may even be the remains of an orchard that was cut down with the anomalies being the rotten roots underneath the surface.
honestly the whole "sins of the ancestors" thing just needs to go away. it's unproductive nonsense.
It's basically a secular version of ‘original sin’.
@@Lobsterwithinternet At least with original sin, there's a clear, objective path to redemption that doesn't involve the whims of of some astroturfed academics.
@@SkylineFTW97 And that source is actually willing to forgive instead of using it as a political cudgel to beat you (their sworn enemy) with.
There really is no end to that kind of guilt. Especially if the natives are never going to forgive and move forward. What's the point?
@@SkylineFTW97 and it is used to explain humanities dark tendencies rather than blame a group of people and make them the devil. Actions and behaviors become the devil.
Canada really be out here passing laws about how often they say "sorry" 😔
Not on how often, just that simply because you said “sorry” you can’t be blamed for an accident.
@@LEO_M1 Sure, I just meant that they apparently say sorry so much and so instinctively that this became an actual problem. Hence the often-ness leading to the legislation. My wording was intentionally obscure.
Not sorry.
Be proud of your country, I've learned to be proud of my country warts and all. And I'm a South-African so that's at least as complicated as any other major nation.
That acknowledgement is happening here in Australia as well, that said it confuses me to point that I ask "we are doing this for people we don't pay taxes or owe reparations to, yet we don't acknowledge the Queen, the monarchy or the commonwealth which governs our nation", the worst part was this also happened at the Royal Easter show this year when Princess Anne was in attendance.
as an abo I find it fucking stupid every time a politician apologises for the past like shit happens get over it and for those that care, I say there are bigger issues we gotta worry about rather than whinging about stupid shit but people won't change so I just do my own thing and say fuck the lot of em.
About colonial expansion, you cannot feel guilty for soemthing you did not do. You are the result of such actions, not the perpetrator, your existence is tightly related to that event. It might seem that people who try to apologize for what happened in the past wants to correct something that simply cannot be corrected
@@priapulida if all white people mysteriously disappeared one day, the people playing the privilege game would just expand the definition of "white". You can already see this in action with Mediterranean people, 50-60 years ago they would not be considered white yet today they are lumped in the same group as Germans or English.
Exactly! And that’s why capitalism is to blame. -some communist probably
I'm not giving up the land past generations got for me though. Not without a fight, now that's something their ancestors would respect.
You cannot feel bad about colonization because literally everyone did it.
It how every big group on earth today got to become strong enough to survive, why only white people have to feel bad about it I will never understand.
Not to mention the fact that almost every surviving culture has committed a genocide to some extent, their used to be many German ethnicity’s before Charlemagne, he either force converted or killed them, killed all their chiefs and so wiped there history. The Iroquois wiped out many tribes to get there hands on beaver lands. The many many tribal wars in Africa. The list is endless as we have done horrible horrible things to each other for a multitude of reasons. We cannot change this and we cannot really blame the descendants of them since they never chose to be a part of it. We can really only deal with the now and punish the actions of the living.
The Canadians who want to be different from the American way, adopt the Americans neomarxist way wholesale ;)
BT. Do they know that orange is the roual color (name) of the Netherlands, which is known for their slave shipping ? Good job Canada! :p
Hey, nobody said these idiots knew anything about history beyond the superficial talking points they vomit everywhere.
It is also the color of the Orange Man
In Australia I can’t sit through a single uni presentation without some acknowledgement of the traditional owners of the land. It’s out of place and clearly not genuine. However, at my graduation ceremony there was a lot of incorporation of aboriginal customs in the ceremony, which felt much more genuine and meaningful. The apology before a conference is like trying uphold a ideology, the ceremony felt like a true celebration of both cultures.
There isn't a square centimetre of this country that, when the first Europeans arrived, was inhabited by the first group to get here. Not even the Inuit. The Vikings got to Baffin Island before the Inuit did.
Claiming they're the sole possessors of territory as though they sprang from the earth the way their stories say should be taken with the same seriousness other young-earth groups are and it seems really infantilzing to be completely honest.
I agree we should all be saying "we acknowledge we're stand over australopithecus soil."
6:39 ok this is just sad to see. This person is so thoroughly demoralized. They don't believe in their own culture, they don't believe they belong in the land the live in. They don't even believe they live in the right body. It's just sad.
Man, before the mass grave thing, the freaking gaslighting and crap I'd put up with from my Canadian friends and Canadian randos was just insufferable. I used to get so freaking mad about it cuz, like any developed country, there is documented history of Canadaians being pretty awful. People not knowing their history or being willfully ignorant has always been a pet peeve of mine.
After the mass grave thing, it felt like everybody shut the heck up. Not gonna lie, it's been kinda nice. I feel bad for the folks like Dev who are always gonna have to deal with them, but I kinda think it is easier to ignore when it is one of your own countrymen being an ass.
I think part of that is the result of our school system. The particulars of our government's actions before 1980 were largely glossed over just 20 years ago, going into current events more (Rwanda genocide, the invasion of Iraq, ect). We've kind of gone the complete opposite direction, now, so kids in school today have a heavy sense of Canadian guilt with little in the way of perspective compared to the rest of the world/history.
@@scienceface8884 Interesting. Makes me wonder if it's even a good idea to teach kids about events as recent as those. It's hard to put stuff into perspective when you're a kid, or at least it was for me. Maybe that's the point though. I dunno how it is in Canada, but in the states, it is almost an open secret at this point that some people are just using the education system to recruit a new generation of political activists.
@@psycholuigiman It's no secret at all. I'm a high school teacher in Canada. The crap being pumped out non-stop in schools should be freaking everyone out. The education system is running gov't propaganda full bore. I've had students cry and express serious anxiety over feeling guilty for things that happened before they (or their parents!) were born.
It's one thing to acknowledge the past, it's another thing to completely blow it out of proportion and act like it's the worst thing in the history of nations.
@@Aiphiae Ooof. I feel so sorry for any kids having to go through all this. It's so crazy how the folks who have claimed to be super empathetic for such a long time are kinda exhibiting psychopathic and sociopathic behaviors on a regular basis.
Love how "Racial Slurs" is above being murdered lol
So you're telling me that, in Canada
Orange man good?
_yes_
The self-hatred for white people that's pushed so hard nowadays is incredibly frustrating and sad. It feels like (and probbaly just does outright) it is pervasive in all facets of life.
On our second to last day of my intro to biology class, my class went to the New York State Museum in Albany. My professor wanted us to focus on something BIOLOGY-RELATED and say what we took away from our visit (she heavily suggested looking at the mastadon skeleton). One of the people in my class instead took all of their notes on the colonial era exhibit and complained about how it didn't villainize white people enough and the language used throughout the exhibit supported white supremacy. I got tired of that real quick and put in my earbuds so I wouldn't have to listen to the stupid and completely irrelevant presentation.
I also had several classes where the first 10-15 minutes of every single class was the professor saying "I'm teaching from my apartment in Manhattan which belongs to (insert eight separate Native American tribes), all of which had their land evilly stolen by white people, such as myself, and I want all of you students to reflect on what stolen land you reside upon today". Those classes were, unsurprisingly, the most useless classes I have ever taken.
"The government is perpetuating genocide".
*Government starts to clap in agreement.
The Spartans had a similar “colonial syndrome”. They constantly reminded themselves they were not natives to the land, which the Spartans justified in being ruthless to the native slave class, the Helots.
Perfectionism, a sense of urgency, defensiveness, and fear of open conflict can all be signs of anxiety. If only we had a term for denigrating a mental health condition by conflating it with a prejudice and legal protections against it in Canada.
Sorry for pointing out government endorsed ableism, eh?
If Canada and the US are told to pay reparations and have guilt over the atrocities committed to their Native populations then the Natives should also pay reparations and feel guilt to the atrocities the committed against each other!
Exactly, until the native tribes pay reparations to each other for thousands of years of warfare, I'm not giving them squat
It's not just that they fought. Rather, archeological evidence shows clear displacements of civilizations over time. Pre-historic native cultures are gone, wiped out completely by later tribes.
How many people has tobacco killed in the last 500 years? Are the natives ever going to apologize for that or are they just going to make some gimmick organic cigarettes and trick hipsters into thinking they are somehow better for you?
I read a book called “Empire of the Summer Moon” about the Comanche. Those people were ridiculously brutal and merciless; they routinely butchered other tribes. But somehow all Native groups have been reduced to victimhood status regardless of what their ancestors did. It’s only ever white people who are in the wrong for the actions of their ancestors. For the record, my ancestors were poor Portuguese peasants who didn’t particularly reap any benefits simply because their country was building an empire. I have nothing to feel bad for; don’t tell me I do.
THE BODIES ARE IN DEVS VEGETABLE GARDEN!
Be proud of who you are and the sacrifices of your ancestors, that you may live well. A belated happy Canada Day to you Dev.
"Be proud of who you are and the sacrifices of your ancestors, that you may live well" putting thouse to togerther implys they are linked. so who you are is defined by your ancestors which is an extrmaly racist sentment.
you probley don't mean that though.
@@danpop1235 I did mean it as our attitudes and general outlook are shaped by our parents and theirs. If you want to take that as racist, I can't stop you. It would be nice if you tried not to make an unfounded accusation however.
Every country has bad shit about it
What matters is owning up to it and not repeating it
Yeah the mass grave thing was a hoot. Had a far lefty Canadian friend who flipped out about it when the news broke. I didn't buy it one bit but our other friends did.
You can feel a bit bad that you are Canadian, Dev; tho, it'd be worse if you were Norwegian. *wink's in Warhammer* ;)
often leftists are low information people that think with their emotions. more often than not they are the *actual* racists
people like leftists are the reasons why authoritarian governments get away with *actual* genocide
I mean can we SEE the gaves? or talk to someone who has? no one has seen them? lol
Yeah it literally happened in my city. They had a healing ceremony and stuff where relatives of people who went missing in the schools came to pay respects, but it was kind of fishy that noone was allowed to see the scans they did and how they got to the conclusion that kids were buried there. I'm kinda 50/50 on the whole thing. People got fucked up in residential schools though, I'll tell you as much.
@@Born_Stellar it would've been an unmarked mass grave. What I heard is that they used some kind of radar or sonar system to scan the ground around the school, though they haven't done any excavations and the technician has since stated that there's no conclusive evidence that human remains are buried there until excavations can be done, which is unlikely to happen any time soon if at all.
Wink is in warhammer?
Love how the natives want it both ways. They want all the benefits of a society, but all the benefits of being their own nation with their own rules. Maybe it was better in ancient times when invaders just killed everyone to make room.
Then, there wouldn't be all this hirable injustice for descendants.
The same can be said about Quebec, who in their own heads are a nation within a nation, but to everyone else they're a pain in the ass to have as part of Canada.
@@TheSubatomicCheese agreed.
They are ignorant of the rest of the country and arrogant to believe to be the centre of it.
Dude first off not all anti ace Americans think the same. Second off that’s more of leftist types saying that and three the American government forced them off their lands broke treaties put them reservations where they were treated horribly and even forcibly re-educated.
It’s not wanting both ways when haven’t got any way for years
@@elliottgaal9774 hey we ain't all like that, but I do feel there is a lot of separatist propaganda going on. I believe the main issue comes from Quebec's intent to gatekeep the english language from becoming more popular. Ever since I started using english only on the internet, my wish to move to another province in Canada has grew immensely. The Loi 101 is the cause of the Quebecois hivemind.
All in all, I fokin love my fellow Canadians. Don't use bad apples as a rule to dismiss a whole demographic
@@fookinkoont That is true.
The issue is we don't how many of the good apples fought or opposed the bad ones thus giving an very bad image.
Mass graves are by nature built in a hurry to dispose of bodies you don’t have time to bury individually, such as in a disaster. If there was a mass execution of hundreds of Canadian Indian children in the care of a school so dramatic that it required a mass grave, it would have been taught in every school not just in Canada, but in every school on planet earth as one of the greatest crimes in human history.
That is not the kind of thing history just covers up and forgets in 100 years
I work in a grocery store and wore red, exclaiming a happy Canada 🇨🇦 Day to all
was glad to see illegal fireworks going off today:)
Based
Honestly these people that go around acting like they deserve something because of the "feel guilty" bs should have a good long look in the mirror as well as well history.
- They would not be born in the Americas were it not for colonialism.
- White Europeans are not the only ones guilty of colonialism.
- Blacks sold blacks to slave ships in Africa and there were Blacks who engaged in the slave trade, even fighting on the Confederates' side.
- Aztecs enslaved & killed millions all for the sake of their Sun beliefs.
- The Natives did war with each other a lot, also engaged in slavery.
- Many Natives helped people like Custer wipe out tribes.
- Witch Trials, child slavery, and genocide is still happening in Africa perpetuated by Africans.
Racial purity? There's no such thing. I'm white, yet I am also a member of the Sioux Tribe. Your skin color doesn't mean anything, its just an external appearance, nothing more. And who said "I have a dream that men an women will be judged by the content of their character, and not by the color of their skin"? Oh Yeah, Martin Luther King Jr, the man who led the Civil Rights movement.
Who did judge people by their skin color? The KKK.
So these people calling for "white guilt" are spitting in MLK's face while promoting ideals of the KKK, and call it "social justice". Irony abounds.
@@GK-mr9ko I think you missed the point.
@@GK-mr9ko You still missed the point.
@@GK-mr9ko Oh, so you did not want to address the main point? You just wanted to nitpick?
@@GK-mr9ko I’m pretty sure both of us are neutral in emotion. The internet don’t trigger me.
@@GK-mr9ko
bro if you're going to always call out bs when you see it then you're going to be screaming into a void for your entire life and never accomplish anything.
also if this is a troll then gr8 b8 m8
"I'm happy to be here, also I recognize I'm part of a country perpetuating genocide" 🤔🤔 We seem to have a genius in our midst
I'm in Nova Scotia and every day I long to move to Florida. My province is completely cucked
"Challenging a racist joke"
A Chinese guy, a Mexican, an American and an Indian are in a hot air balloon. It springs a leak and they're falling fast. They need to dump weight to slow the descent. The Chinese guy grabs a bag of rice and throws it out and turns to the group "we have a lot of this in my country so I can always get more", the Mexican grabs a bag of beans and throws them out and turns to the group "we have a lot of these in my country so I can always get more", the American grabs the Mexican and throws him out then turns to the Indian and says "don't even think about it"
Genuine question. How long do you have to have conquered a land before it is no longer _their_ land ? How long do you need to be there to be considered the new Native Americans or Indigenous Canadians? I’m born in the US, I’ve never lived in Europe. I _am_ native, I _am_ indigenous.
Until the separatism penalty goes away, or to be extra careful, until their core is gone.
I mean even in Europe the people currently living where they are living are not the original people living there, for example the saxons took what is now England from the Roman’s who themselves took it from the British tribes who themselves have been taking land from each other for hundreds of years, and they themselves if the African theory is believed took that land from the species of human that lived there.
Integrating or genociding the natives. There’s no “how long”, look at Israel. Native Americans weren’t given either and it’s just been left as a festering wound until their birth rate will collapse in the next 100 years (which won’t look any better).
It was never conquered, there are treaties signed as recognized by the crown as land reserved to the indigenous people.
That makes us all anchor babies!
I like to use the phrase: "Not worth a Canadian sorry" to indicate a thing that is made meaningless with over-use.
ha, I think I'll borrow that phrase.
I remember being taught about the shit that happened to natives when I was in school and being like,
"Not my problem."
Something just isn’t right about hating your own country 🧐
When the guy started at 7 minute, i would have just left.
Calling yourself a coloniser and say that you are participating in a genocide is ridiculous, whatever you say next don't matter to me
You couldn't attend any Canadian event and a decent chunk of our churches then. It's kind of ridiculous. Although the colonial rhetoric is new. It used to just be recognising land claims.
"Yeah I don't listen to mass murderers and thieves, thanks."
@@KyriosHeptagrammaton here’s the thing you can do, apologizing for the loss and genocide of the tribe before the other, the east coast tribes likely killed another, smaller tribe to be there so you can apologize to those tribes and there decedents for having lost both there land and their culture.
I find it really interesting hearing about the hi-jinks that Canadian natives get up to, since I share ancestry with them before the borders between the U.S. and Canada were firmly decided. It seems to me that these burial grounds controversies only exist because First Nation people don't use more permanent grave markers, like stone. I've walked through some Reservation cemeteries before, and the more traditional the Reservation, the more likely everyone's grave is marked by these wooden house like structures. Maybe you'll see a wooden clan marker, or many personal effects. They have to be continually maintained. Nothing is being "hidden", they just don't use more durable materials. The Catholic Church let natives keep certain traditions that didn't conflict (and sometimes ironically did conflict) with Christian traditions. Ironically, letting them bury their dead in a more culturally sensitive way caused this problem.
what happens when you spoil a group of people and don’t encourage them to be independent and integrate.
In other words, the Natives didn't make it clear about their traditional burial ceremonies and because of that, leftist attacks on every kind of Christian church happened. Leftist sophists who happened to be Native should be more than ashamed for this.
@@npcimknot958 Integration didn't really end up working in the end. They're plenty "integrated", it just didn't improve their lot at all. Independence is a mixed bag though. Much of the trouble has to do with Tribal leaders embezzling both Tribal and Federal funds. They're independent where they shouldn't be, and not independent where they should be independent. They shouldn't be receiving so many federal funds, but Tribal leaders also should be investigated for embezzling. Take out the corrupt leaders, and the tribe does a lot better very quickly. My own tribe elected a weird drunk guy a couple years back, and there's been a massive spending spree on public infrastructure. Turns out the drunk guy isn't corrupt and doesn't embezzle. Turns out you don't have to be that competent, you just need to be trustable, and everyone does better. Who knew?
IMO nobody should feel ashamed of being a winner. Our people are strong and intelligent so we got this far despite being a worldwide minority.
And so are the natives.
They just got beaten by someone who got a headstart on the tech tree.
I'm German and only know one Canadian personally and his whole cultural identity seems to consist of being NOT American so I think you have a point.
He is very obsessed with the USA, as if he couldn't define Canada culturally without mentioning the USA
I guess that's different from you Europeans that manage to hate our guts without making it part of their identity.
Canadians shouldn't be surprised that they turn out similar to the US. We're both English civilizations based in North America.
I notice a lot of Canadians basically define themselves as “white people in North America who aren’t Americans”. I’ve even watched a video on Canadian demographics that goes into this phenomenon. Exception to this is the Quebecois people.
I'm native to canada&my family is mixed and i was raised in germany.
Here the feeling of shame, reflection and retrobution is pretty strong. It's possible to be patriotic of your tribe/country/State/nation and be left/right/whatever as long as you remind yourself what dark shit your homeland did.
As a Kamloopsian I was not expecting so much of your video to focus on our local news. (THIS CITY IS ALMOST ALWAYS UNDER THE RADAR). Even hearing about the Shuswap in a vid felt weird because generally I feel like it's tribes from Vancouver, Manitoba, and Nova Scotia that get most attention.
Canadian politeness always feels a tiny bit weird to visiting Brits, like it's more actively trying to be nice compared to our manner which amounts to just trying not to annoy each other.
Still, you're alright eh.
How the hell does anyone live any form of a functional life with all this self perpetuated guilt they give themselves...?! Jesus christ, I'm exhausted just hearing it
7:08 jeez, this person checks all the oppression boxes on top of having a UN sustainable goals pin
I feel the same about my country. A lot of my friends seem to hate my country because of the stupidness that we are doing. I really don't care anymore. I love my country, it's not perfect, but no country is and we have it pretty good. the issues we face are real, but they're not my fault, my friend's fault, or really many of the civilian's fault. I'm tired of not being able to draw something to celibrate on the 4th of July because it's bad because it was made by some old people that aren't related to me but did what they could for me weather they knew it or not. So screw it, I'm gonna make some drawings for my country's birthday if people hate me for it, well I cant really stop them from spewing hate, but I'll at least spew some positivity no matter how perverted it may be. some people ask for the weirdest drawings on the internet :D
You're one of the most underrated and one of the best in Canada, I wish you had more reach here , I've stumbled on your channel some years ago looking for videos about Trudeau
There was an article already up about some protests in Ottawa regarding today. The piece wrote "freedom" in quotes and framed the protesters as looney rednecks. And it wasn't even 9am yet when I read this.
better get ready for full blown Communism
i wish i was exaggerating
the pure irony is there was so many poc in ottawa more than white today. and many actually protesting along with celebrating canada day. A LOt OF INDIAN AND BLACKS
If these people were to argue that we should help keep native tradition alive, id completely agree. Our differences make us "special". That is their philosophy right? Then if we just "integrated" more, theyd be happy? Or is that not enough?
its literally not enough until you are dead or enslaved
If I were born in Canada, I would slap the silliness out of everyone who embarrasses themselves enough to call me a SETTLER!
Colonial expansion is something we should be proud of. In the competition of social, political and technological systems, we won. Hell, we won so hard that the losers are still whining about it hundreds of year later because we had enough of an advantage to show mercy to the conquered. Make no mistake the "natives" conquered the people who were on any given piece of land, the only difference between us and them is they didn't let the conquered survive to complain. Nobody stole land, we conquered and should celebrate that victory.
@Dragonlord Pete The truth is based.
I wish there were new conquest, these people need to learn what the natives learned over many generations ago
I think htat's too far in the opposite direction. Conquest is stealing. It's bad Russia is bombing the shit out of Ukraine. Thats not honourable or good. It would be bad if Russia or China started conquering the US or the UK. Conquest is a crime. And yet, also, once it has happened, paradoxically, it can benefit the cultures that were conquered. But, just because we might receive a more technologically advanced and industrial society if China conquered us tomorrow, that wouldnt make the conquest ok, would it?
@@umwha what can we do when another nation wants what it wants? War obviously. If china decided to invade north america (lol) I guess I'd have to fight to keep my slice of life but the winner would be china.
@@umwha Agreed.
It is bad and we should know better now and we shouldn't do it anymore.
The issue is the descendants of conquered people are trying to leverage the guilt of things done centuries before into concessions now as though the people alive today are just as guilty of the crime as their ancestors were.
There's also the issue that the crimes happened so far in the past that any meaningful compensation would be impractical at best and impossible at worst.
Great video(as always)! I had a good chuckled going through friends’ inst stories as every even person was celebrating and every odd person was condemning the day for an “ongoing” genocide
America might have its issues but Canada is on another level of nuts sometimes.
majority of canada isn’t its jist thr gov and these small groups. majority of canada is poc indian to be precise- you think they gaf about this stuff? watching cbc? lol no
I've always found the idea of Canadian niceness to be largely a myth of their own creation. Personally I've always found Canadians to be rude in a passive aggressive kind of way. Its probably just how they interact with Americans, but they seem to have a need to tell you just how morally superior the Canadian master race is but without the honesty and courage of a direct insult.
The whole "polite' thing has just made me not to want to visit Canada. I don't like this idea of a Stepford Nation. But I agree, it's a myth for leftist Americans.
Isn’t unapologetic and Canadian an oxymoron?
Just thought I’d add this as I have seen a few people talk about it in the comments. The land acknowledgment stuff that the Canadians have started doing is the out right adoption of the Australian welcome to country/acknowledgment of country. The Australian case it is the adoption of an Australian Aboriginal custom when two tribes would meet each other. It has nothing to do with apologising to Australian Aborigines, where as the Canadian seems to do that. Just for context I am an Australian Aboriginal and even I think that the welcome/acknowledgment does get a bit over used. With that out of the way, great video Dev.
A lot of this seem like empty platitudes meant to make the speaker feel better or give off the illusion of compassion. If they were really serious about their guilt surrounding occupying native lands they would move out and give the country back to the natives.
Look at Dev, standing up for himself and being all patriotic
Happy Canada Day sir. You deserve it
Canada writing a law to protect Canadians from their own kindness is the most stereotypical Canadian thing ever.
Also, it's worth noting that many of the Indigenous groups WANTED those pipelines. The group that started the "shut down Canada" by blockading the railways in Ontario, 85% of them WANTED the pipeline. The hereditary chiefs didn't. So the democratic vote for the pipeline was undermined by the chiefs who thought they knew better than their community. What did Canadians see in the news? *"Indigenous band fights against government to stop pipeline from being forced through their land!"*
It's such a joke.
I was having a debate about this stuff with a family friend who works for the government of Canada and it’s creepy how much they indoctrinate their employees.
This Canadian agrees with you, but I was already at that point a year ago. Empathy is what I feel, not guilt.
Australian's been doing that apologizing for stolen land thing for a while now too. In fact government buildings will even have signs acknowledging it when you come in.
I really don't see a point in trying to separate ourselves from the US. Just accept it, we're a married couple and that's okay.
No lie, I wish a gov't would have the balls to scrap all the land claims, treaties, and Indian Act and say "You're equal. It's done." If people want "reparations" for the past, how about 3 generations of free education or trade-skill training. Anything but land and money. That doesn't work.
This notion of multiple "sovereign" nations inside Canada is divisive and absurd.
As a great man said: “A house divided cannot stand.”
I been over the guilt since 2018. You feel bad or sad? That’s on you. There’s no way I’m an ahsshole for accepting respect for what I’ve done, not for who I am.
on the subject of the whites and culture: could it be that the culture of the whites defined by those of othe cultures is literally just coexisting in a civilized way? Of course that's dominant. Other cultures are acceptable, but they are not the groundwork for society that has laws and the absence of public executions. We'll see how long that lasts...
this whole vid could be summed up as
Woke tard
"Reee you colonial descendant!"
Chad canadian :
"Yes"
canadian immigrant- it’s not about you. o work i pay taxes, stfu.
"Yeah I fucked up these people in war, what are you gonna do about it?"
12:56
Minor mistake. The residential schools were run by both Catholic and non-Catholic Christian churches.
14:04
Another mistake. These are not mass graves, but potentially unmarked graves located near residential schools. Some of these sites aren't even residential school graveyards.
Regarding 12:56, the residential schools were set up by the government but contracted out to to whoever was teaching at the time. When residential schools were created, Church-run schools were the only people running schools in Canada. Catholic religious orders had the largest piece of the pie by virtue of being so prolific, but as you note everyone got into the action. Once the government took a more direct hand in education, they also took over the schools.
As a Texan who happens to have many canadian friend via online gaming (and currently in the beginning of the video)
The polite Canadian thing really does.feel like BS. Very often I have hear some.canadina friend touting their politeness while actively disparaging people.
It feels less polite and more high horse.
Oh look at how polite we are, not like you rude americans! Hohoho!
It's downright funny when someone insults you to your face and then immediately talks about how much nicer they are.
Some canadians are great.... but dang have I met quite a few I wish to slap.
I consider that courtesy. Rude courtesy.
Canada might be a democracy but we're definitely not Liberal anymore... we haven't been for a while.
did you mean to type "defiantly" or was that autocorrect? i only ask because i see it often used interchangeably with "definitely."
@@snowcloudshinobi Ya that was autocorrect, Thanks for pointing it out.
10:20 “Trans Mountain”?! We’re on to you oil pipeline guys. You changed the gender of the Canadian landscape you bastards.
Trudeau himself did it by Par-taking in a 200days long geh orgie on top of the Mountain...
IT was neeva da same after it.
Unapologetic Canadians: The Ultimate Chads
Is it bigoted of me to say I hate Canada at this point?
As an Australian I too hate Canada. They’re kinda like kiwis but gay and lame.
Nope. Canada belongs to America.
Not wanting to actually dig down and exhume the bodies to confirm the validity of a claim...that's surely the sign of the pursuit for the truth.
I’m an enrolled member of a federal tribe, my mother’s family still lives on the reservation. This patronizing, noble savage shit has to stop. We were no better than the European settlers that came to this land, and many tribes were in fact far, far worse - including my own
Honestly I'm all for a "warts and all" version of pre-Columbian Canadian history being a mandatory course in like late elementary or early High school. The number of people I've seen who are completely ignorant on pre-european arrival indigenous history is the cause of like 99% of the activism.
@@reviveempires The expatriation of land to give it back to “original” owners is very bloody and soil. Our tribe landed in the great plains as a relative newcomer, after murdering our way across Minnesota and the Dakotas and Montana.
Expropriated everyone in our path, enslaved the ones who were pliant, and raped and murdered and pillaged as a matter of course.
And the reason *we* wound up being pushed further south is because our original lands in the north woods of Canada were being raided and we were getting our ass kicked out.
In short, human beings doing things that human beings have always done The self-flagellation is just weird.
0:10 Can it be nullified if the other party says "I'm going to whoop your sorry ass!" or "Your driving skills sure are sorry. You shouldn't be on the road"?
It's literally if an accident happens and a person reflexively says "Sorry" that's not taken as an admission of guilt because the other person could have been at fault
As someone from QC, it's interesting to see how different our little bubble is. People from outside consider us the asshole of Canada. Pretty much because we aren't into all the posturing that the vocal minority has pressured everyone else into doing. I would like to say that's just how we are, but academia has its way with the kids from an early age all the way to the end of extended infancy. We were just behind a couple years.
Honestly I feel old Quebecers who give no shits are my favourite people to meet. I'm so disappointed when I see Quebec youth buying into all the woke crap like like Anglo-Celtic-Canada.
@@reviveempires I share the sentiment, although I don't know what Anglo-Celtic-Canada refers to specifically. Can't really blame the youth though, it's the world failing them while simultaneously prompting them to misguidedly fix the world before they're even thought to care for their own person.
the sins of/bad deeds people's ancestors should not be passed to their descendants nor should the grudge of those wronged be passed onto their descendants
Oh seriously!? Orange is now a political color, hell no I won't let them have my favorite color by a landslide.
It has been a political color since 2016 after Trump got elected.
o remeber white settlers , farmers volunteered to fight in ww2. a few natives volunteered but not many. there were asians who at that time did not have rights in canada that also signed up .
most people that came from canada weren’t rich they were poor. and they worked hard for everything.
Can we speak about the Québécois? Seem the definition of genecide match historical/cultural discrimination that hapend There.
I’m telling you, all the government systems of every country needs a good healthy reset. It’s clear who theyre working with and who they support. They placate the absolute worst types. If we want freedom, we’re gonna have to fight for it.
Or the people can simply do their job.
All these lies literally robbed me of my youth. Nothing left to give now.
Also, something that's never talked about, aboriginal opinions towards immigrants are apparently getting worse.
Source: _'We all have brown skin': Sask. woman says racism between immigrants and Indigenous people must end_ by Janani Whitfield, Jun 18, 2019, 4:00 AM CT. CBC
Indigenous people are very tribal and clan based- racism is their basic level of loyalty and their deepest value.
Non-western civs also lean into this.
Who that actually understands racism would be suprised? Its not about skin color, non-western racism is much more extreme. ”We are not from the same tribe, so you are not even human unless you can threaten me physically I will do with you as I want”. Is pretty much how clan cultures think.
I feel no guilt for any ancestors I have, because I judge myself and others based on their merits and actions.
I like how these people commonly call being nice being white.
Do they not see what they are actually saying...?
They're not self aware enough