Cutting Apart Belts (Hermes, Gucci, Brooks Brothers & More!)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 лип 2024
- Let's examine the construction techniques and materials used on $2,000 worth of belts from popular brands: gentl.mn/cutting-apart-mens-b...
#belt #buckles #notsponsored
SHOP THE VIDEO:
→ Black Calf Leather Belt: gentl.mn/black-leather-belt1
→ Tan Cognac Brown Calf Leather Belt: gentl.mn/tan-cognac-leather-belt
→ Benedict Silver Solid Brass Belt Buckle: gentl.mn/benedict-silver-belt...
→ Fort Belvedere Belts and Buckles - gentl.mn/fort-belvedere-belts
GUIDES YOU DON'T WANT TO MISS:
→ Hermes “H” Belt: Is It Worth It? - gentl.mn/hermes-belt-examined
→ Louis Vuitton Duffle Bag: Is It Worth It? - gentl.mn/lv-bag-review
→ Cutting It Apart: John Lobb Shoes - gentl.mn/shoes-cut-apart
→ Cutting It Apart: What’s Inside a $285 Wallet? - gentl.mn/wallet-cut-apart
→ Cutting It Apart Playlist - gentl.mn/cutting-it-apart-videos
→ Is It Worth It Playlist - gentl.mn/is-it-worth-it
VIDEO CREDITS:
→ Host: Sven Raphael Schneider
→ Camera & Editing: Chris Dummer
Want to see more videos? Subscribe to our channel!
→ gentl.mn/youtube
Become a part of the Gentleman's Gazette community - support us on Patreon!
gentl.mn/patron
________________________________________________________________________
Gentleman's Gazette
gentl.mn/homepage-gg-website
gentl.mn/shop-fort-belvedere-gg
Facebook: / gentlemansgazette
FREE E-book: gentl.mn/ebook-newsletter-here
00:00 Cutting Apart Belts Introduction
Here at the Gentleman’s Gazette, we’re all about classic and timeless, even with accessories. As any man would know, a great belt will help you look and feel good in the clothes you’re in. Therefore, quality is paramount! Today, we dissect popular brands to know what’s inside of them, how they stack up and find out which would be a good investment.
01:13 BUCKLES: Allen Edmonds
01:51 Gucci
02:28 Brooks Brothers
02:51 Fort Belvedere
03:40 Hermes
04:14 LEATHER BELTS: Montblanc
06:13 Allen Edmonds
08:35 Brooks Brothers
11:05 Hermes
15:11 Fort Belvedere
19:53 Gucci
21:28 A Brief Word on Leather Quality & Tanning - Навчання та стиль
![[Leather Handmade EP27] Making a Luxury Hand Stitched Belt - Epsom ft. Togo Leather](/img/n.gif)
I have been doing leather work and silver smithing for over 10 years. There is no more than $50 worth of material in any of those belts including the buckles. There is also no way the labor accounts for for the prices. A walking foot sewing machine makes it a breeze even for neophytes. Absolutely crazy to spend that kind of money unless you are trying to actively impress someone.
I started dabbling in leather work about 2 years ago (trying to "work" my way up to a nice duffle bag....).. I made a few shave kits, knife sheaths and 2 belts...all hand stitched. The belts were 1 ply from random cow hide (about 4 oz). Anyway....please pass on a few tips...for belt making what type of leather do you typically use (oz and "grade"). Do you usually make them 1 ply or like 3 oz with suede or pig hide backing? And where is a good place for sourcing buckles (I got mine at Tandy). THANKS!!
Agree, but you pay for unique design (supposedly) + branding so its really different strokes for different folks kind of story, not rational but i will go and buy a branded belt if it beautiful enough for me, almost like an art object that i can wear, and im talking actually neat designs not brand patterns over the belt lol
@@wjvlodek8769 4 oz leather will require a two ply belt with stitching. If you want a stiffer belt you will need to put a third layer in between and less wide than the outer two.
You should use a good leather cement. Then stitch. You can either hand stitch or use a machine. I use an old cast iron hand crank Singer for up to 7 oz of leather.
Buckles, I have been making my own silver buckles for years now.
Tandy has very decent leather, if you are making it for your self who cares.
Good luck, you will make a lot of bad stuff before you make good stuff.
In other news, you're paying for the brand name. Especially a luxury brand.
@@user-me8hm9bf5d Agreed....although that "pebble leather" of the Hermes belt looks beautiful, there is no way I would ever buy (spend the money on) a Hermes, Gucci or even Mont Blanc (after watching Sven rip it apart).
Did anybody else have a heart attack when he was pulling apart the Hermes belt? LOL 😂
Cutting things apart without any reason is just pointless and wasteful. The man is a barbarian.
@@AndreiGromit True. But we do have a point, we cut them open so you get the knowledge without having to cut them open yourself. Isn't it nice to know what really is in something without having to cut it open yourself?
@@gentlemansgazette You're absolutely right! There are so many products that look good on the surface for a few wearings and then deteriorate rapidly. I LOVED the video. It was just funny to realize in that moment when you not only cut into the belt but literally ripped them apart to reveal the inner details. Well done! Thanks for being a voice that speaks to quality not just style.
🤚😂
@@gentlemansgazette Thank you for your response. I'm sorry if I have offended. I was just shocked by the beginning of the video. I am not a fan of these brands, but I didn't enjoy seeing their products cut up. It reminded me of dissecting a frog. A shame about the frog.
“Genuine Leather” is trademarked and is the cheapest stuff you can legally call leather. I may have learned that from this channel.
Yeah, I spent 3/4 of my life thinking that was the good stuff. Full grain and top grain are the best, then genuine, then bonded, which os the particle board of leathers.
I have seen so many terrible leathers that were sold and stamped as top grain... I really do not pay attention to that stuff anymore.
Next video:
Tearing Apart a Rolls Royce to See if The Materials are Quality Enough
You should do a series of this with other brands to see if they're worth it. Or at least a Part II. For instance, other brands like Hugo Boss, Ted Baker, Louis Vuitton, Christian Dior, Yves Saint Laurent, Versace and Salvatore Ferragamo. I may have come up with your next video idea. I appreciate your time and effort going into this. Thank you, Mr. Schneider.
IF enough people watch it is certainly something we can expand on.
+1
@@gentlemansgazette would really love to see how salvatore ferragamo belt stands out other brands ! Would really love to watch a review of a ferragamo belt and cut them apart ! Thank you for the video! ❤
@@gentlemansgazette yes please do
Fantastic video! Thank you so much it was very informative. I would also like to say thank you for the quality and attention to detail you comit to your products.
Raphael showed us just how much an expert he is coming up with infos on the fly. Great video, you convinced me of the quality of your belts, unfortunately for you I wear suspenders only.
Suspenders are great, and we are working on versions as we speak.
Your videos are very educational, love watching them learning a lot. Thank you
Another video which makes me nervous watching Raphael use tools.
Lol was thinking the same thing. This dude is so ustable with tools
I was afraid that Exacto Knife was gonna “bite” him!
I have 3 AE Manistee belts (black, tan, chili) and they have served me well over many years.
excellent video! this is super informational about what we are really buying! thank so so much.. please do more like this.. belts, shoes, suits, etc...
Sven is a true madlad. This could have been one episode for each belt.
I love Allen Edmonds belts- I think when matched with a pair of their shoes there is a classic look that doesn’t break the bank.
Man I've been watching your content on and off for over a year, I'm always hesitant to purchase expensive branded things because I don't see the value and quality in it. Seeing how your own branded items stack up to others makes me want to go buy them.
Have a gucci belt I used almost daily for 8 years and it's still in good condition as new. Can't say that with other brands I have.
Thanks very much for this video my man,very educational indeed
I never knew belts could be so absolutely fascinating 😝 thanks for the education! 🌞
This is such a great video. I have had a challenging time with finding quality belts in different price ranges. I'd like to hear more discussion about the different grades of leather like genuine and full grain, etc.
After that video on gloves, I would love to see a "Cutting it apart" video on some of the gloves out there. With winter just starting people need to know what's good and what's bad.
This is my favorite video so far… will subscribe and share on my subreddit
An aspect on belts and belt buckles I have started to pay attention to recently is the material and the diameter of the piece of the buckle, that the end of the belt is sewn around. If it is too thin, the belt may well outlast the buckle. This is because of metal fatigue, being tightened every day for a few years. Last year, I managed to break 2 buckles like this, both belts had about 5 years of non-stop daily use on them, One one of the belts, the broken cross section was about 2.5mm in diameter, on the bare brass Camel Active buckle, it was about 3.5mm across.
Love the Austin reed poster in back, I just picked up an old school austin reed suit about a week ago at my local thrifts black Friday sale, I got that one and a burberry suit (doesn't fit me) along with a few other small things for $16
I always read that a good belt will bend and conform to your body over time. Most of the belts I wear are made by w.kleinberg and they are very nicely made, at least in my opinion, and they have all shaped themselves to my waist
Best channel out there for info on men's fashion.
I swear whenever Sven talks about the thought he places in his Fort Belvedere products I want to invest in them more and more 🤣
Thank you, I am honored but at this time we are not looking for investors. We prefer to be able to do what we think is right.
@@gentlemansgazette Hallo Herr Schneider, wann können wir den einen EU Shop erwarten? ich würde gerne eine Krawatte bestellen, sehe aber die horrenden Versandkosten nicht ein. MfG
This is a great idea!!
Very awesome series. More close ups would be cool! Very nice!
I got a belt when I was in the Balkans in 2002, paid $2.75. 19 years later, the belt is in a great condition. 100% leather
That means your belt is made of good quality solid leather, not split or bonded. And the belt maker was good at his craft, from an Aussie saddlemaker of 40 years.
Thank you for the entertaining video. More technical knowledge about the materials and construction would make it more interesting. Thanks.
Another great video Raphael! I would like to ask, what year were these belts purchased? Was wondering since quality and construction may differ over time. Cheers
Love the channel. You’re really helping me understand this. I’m 53 years old still wearing jeans and tee shirts. Employed with County so not the best job so I can get away with that. But I’m looking at new positions. And I can’t dress like a teenager for them.
Ya'll should do a video on leather maintenance, both for shoes and other accessories
The belt “bowing” in the back is because the leather is molding to your body . Each of us is different around the waist. Just like leather shoes form to your feet.
Germany does produce some very great leather and big hides as well (70sqft) plus.
I think there is some confusion with embossing vs debossing. Emboss is press from the back while debossing is pressed or rolled from the front or show side of the leather.
You are correct, I got the term embossed and debossed mixed up. Frankly, I always thought that adding a design from the top is embossing, but it is not, it is debossing. So yes, the leather patterns are debossed in this video, not embossed. Thanks for pointing it out, and teaching me another lesson in the English language!
I love this! I wish you would have done a Ferragamo one as well. I have 2 and they're my favorite! But I have to say that FB construction is impressive.
Would have liked to see more of an effort pulling the FB belt apart. I know you have a vested interest but didn't see the effort compared to the other belts you tore apart. Just throwing that out there. Like to see consistency. Love your content have learned a ton. Vielen Dank!
The algorithm has won again.
Subscribed immediately. 😉✌️
I love this video. As a matter of fact I own that walnut brogued belt from Allen Edmonds. I bought it when I bought the the shoes. I was a little disappointed in the quality. I'm going to invest in one of your belts after seeing the inner quality. Also thumbs up from SUNYAB.
So for the money the Hermes belt is best? Looking for suggestions. Please and thank you.
To avoid having the belt have a bend in the middle, what I do when I notice it is wear the belt backwards (insert into pant loops clockwise instead of counter clockwise), I find that doing this bends it in the opposite direction thereby straightening it out
I'm actually considering a Coach belt purchase and would love to know what you think about that construction. FB is definitely on my list now as well.
I enjoy these sorts of videos. I like the boot cutting videos created by RoseAnvil - he has great leather knowledge
I have some Gucci belts myself and always wondered why designer belts have that leather string attached near the buckle. Can anyone explain ?
Finally! I’ve been curious to see if designer belts are worth it. Now I know not to waste my time and money on any of those. Considering your belts now though.
It is amazing how much a "brand" dictates the price. Granted apples to oranges ( or is it ? ) as it relates to style, but if you spend $150 on a western belt, you wont be cutting or ripping it apart. And honestly if you get a western belt without floral designs, just plain, etc, it doesn't look that much different. I was impressed with your Ft Belvedere belt though, it was tough, but the others are belts I would expect to see for sale in the dollar store based on the quality. Awesome video !!!
Would have liked to see a quality check on a Farragamo Belt. Still nice to see some good testing of products👌🏻
Very informative
My best belt is levis black bovine full grain leather made up of one thick leather hide going for 5 years still new :)
I see that Fort Belvedere products are conscientiously made, with the best materials. Once purchased, they become part of the personal patrimony. When someone buys things thjat are made with nobility, it's like buying a piece of jewelry. Fort Belvedere's belts, as we see in the video, far outperform the most sought-after trademarks.
I like the music playing in the background during the whole video. Feels like a campy Michael Keaton movie.
Very interesting!
when will be the fort belvedere one available again
I love this channel because it is like going to the museum to see dinosaurs.
Thank you for your review. I also have paid good money for a belt that was actually poorly constructed.
Will you cut apart a Coach and a Ferragamo belt next?
Haha I love the Louis Vuitton bashing.
Cheers from Brazil!!
Have you guys come across the Corcoran Jump boot? Good year welted, seems to be a reasonable leather, looks nice under trousers, like a cap toe darby.
Way to go with the heavy duty plating on your Ft Belvedere buckles. It makes a huge difference. I tend to prefer my metals in the sliver colored range... buckles, watches, etc., but if I change my mind...
Yes, recently gold and especially platinum, and rhodium have gotten a lot more expensive, so we need to increase our buckle prices shortly because of that.
Belts should be glued, a hallmark of a good multi layer belt would be that its glued. most leatherworkers use Barge cement which will almost never separate. The black layer is a reinforcement so the belt resist stretching over time, also a sign of quality. Stitches that go vertically at the buckle are a bad sign as this it the source of most failures, but stitches are cheaper than snaps, rivets or the best and most expensive option, Chicago screws. Also the leather itself is extremely important, I have all of my belts made with 7-8oz vegetable tanned leather from herman oaks. Most of these look to be just chrome tan. My main belt which Ive had for 21 years now started out a pale yellow and has aged to a dark cognac.
My point is, go to a local leather shop and have a belt made. Pick out your buckle before hand and get chicago screws, that way you can change the buckle if it gets crumby.
A quick edit. They run between $90-150 but that is a bargain because a quality leather belt will get better with age. You can also have the same leather shop make you matching accessories
any recommendations for a shop that you have bought from in the past ?
I like nice things, and I can afford them, but seriously, paying 7 or 8 hundred dollars for a belt is ludicrous.
Absolutely... Any more than £100 and you're paying for branding/marketing only.
And then cutting them apart.
I asked the question of what the standard of living is for the workers at these companies? They better all own nice homes, right down to the janitor.
How many blades did you go through doing this?
Hey my dude, what do you think about high end sneakers like the Jordan 1s and shoes like that and the way they are now being used heavily in modern outfits. Some celebs even wear them to events with suits, to me it seems off but what do you think?
MONBLOOON,like a beautiful melody in my mind
I'd love to see you cut open some shoepassion belts/shoes. They are somehow still very unknown in the community but the quality seems well above average for the price.
I lucky enough to have a local artisan who makes custom belts.
I have had the same top grain leather belt and brass buckle from Etsy for the past 8 years. Only $45.
Aged beautifully with a little leather lotion every once in while. 👍
Bir ürünü bu turden bir tanıtım hic görmemiştim insanlar ürünün kalitesini bilecek şekilde harika tanıttın diğer videolarda böyle olmalı
Great video!
Watching raised some questions,
- Why don't more belt buckles, spanning from cheap all the way to luxury products, use a metal such as stainless steel which does not require plating and thus can never be worn off - - is this purely a cost thing, are there issues achieving a high shine, or is it just not considered "nice" enough?
- I personally consider edge painting a low-end finish, and think it's great the Fort Belvedere belts lack it, but are there discernable levels of quality within this process? - Because cheaply made products I've experienced in the past have predictably had the paint gradually flake off from body heat or wear, and I'm not trying to defend Hermes here, but they do to my limited knowledge have some elements of workmanship in their products of a higher standard than more "McDonalds" luxury brands eg LV. (I'm thinking bags that are saddle stitched by hand etc...) - Do you think this is purely a case of playing off customers' limited knowledge to maximise profit?
Interested to hear your, or anyone's, thoughts
Please make a video pleated pants vs flat front which is better according to the..Weight, Height, Age
So what type of actual leather belt do you highly recommend???
Plz tell the full detail or model or reference number of the gucci belt because i want to buy it
Regards
I hope you will reply
From pakistan
Thanks for sharing
thank you for showing me what a real belt should look like
I’m 17 minutes into the video and only just noticed that there’s a snare drum (brushed) in the background 😂
my Ferragamo separated like that, but it was after daily use for 12 years. i can't complain for $175.
Good on you for avoiding edge paint! I’ve had various handbags where that edging just peels or wears off. So disappointing.
Oh won’t you please partner with someone who can do a women’s line as well?
I watched this whilst starching my collars, knowing full well that I don't own any belts or even own trousers with belt loops! Just purely interesting!
Its very interesting!!! At least tge Hermes was worth a buy but no to gucci anymore. Im checking out the Belvedere. You got me there..ill definitely buy one to try its quality!!! I really like the tearing of luxury stuff😂 though i baby most of mine😃
Whats the knife you using dude?
white is chrome tanned leather?
Might have to get a FB belt one day. I do love the quality in my luxury belts.
I have almost every brand in this video or tried it, i will always lean to louis vuitton the quality is the best ive felt, it is recognized but the thing which gets left out is LV service and if your belt has any issues even literally 2 years later they will fix it for free, at least in my country
If I understood correctly it seemed like the Ford Belvedere belt was the best value for its buck and best made?
I'm currently trying to buy a designer belt and wonder on the quality and craftsmanship, thank you
I have a couple of mont blanc belts and love it.
Cool I appreciate the Mont Blanc brand alot! Could you tell me which type you purchased and how long you've had it? For all that money I hope you've got a lot of use for it! I personally like the big M plaque belt as far as aesthetic goes.
All of these are junk compared to my $36 belt made by the amish. 1/4 inch think, one solid piece of english bridle leather (top grain veg tanned). I bought two in like... 2008, one black, one light brown. the light brown one I've since had to re-dye to dark brown, but the black one is still going strong. I repurchased the light brown one last year. because of the lighter colour it just gets stained from use. Originally I bought two sterling silver buckles from ebay to use with them, the belts themselves outlasted the buckles, I have to get them both re-welded.
These belts that are two thin pieces of leather are never going to be as long lasting a single piece of thick top grain leather.
Man thats fantastic! Great thinking. You know thats gonna be quality.
What you describe is a belt in English. In the German language it would be a Riemen and what we cut apart are dress belts. It's a bit like saying, my bulletproof vest is much more durable than my suit. Sure it is, but it is an entirely different category. The belt you describe is not suited for a suit, it is meant as a work horse belt. Same with socks, you can have really thick gold toe socks with polyester and cotton is guaranteed to outlast any fine silk socks. But when you wear a tuxedo, you want fine, thin socks, not thick ones. Are both socks? Yes, but comparing them is pointless as they serve very different purposes.
@@gentlemansgazette Thanks Raphael (I assume). Mine are finished to look like dress belts.
Love this new series! Can you take apart a Brioni suit jacket? I can donate one to you if you like! Cheers! 🥂
i would like to see this one
Very interesting. Allen Edmonds on sale doesn’t seem too bad for what it is, considering retail price and quality on the others you showed, imo. 👍🏼
I have two of them well one my son took the other this weekend, One is about two years old still looks new i wear at least 4x a week, It does have a bow and I am not sure if that is food or bad, I am looking at buying the Cordovan Avenue Dress Belt,
i have a question...is it really supposed for the beltr s to be ripped apart that easy?? because all of myleather belts cant even be ripped,because theyre all just one thick piece of leather...and they havent cost me more than 35$ each
Love your pinky ring,sir
Legend says the viewers' screaming when cutting the Hermes is still audible to this day.....
Cool video
I am personally a huge fan of Anson belts, and have three that I've had for years. I wonder how they would stack up given that they are of quite a different level of price than most of these belts.
The gold we use to plate our belts cost more than an entire Anson Belt. I have met the owners of Anson Belt and I like them a lot. Would I personally wear an Anson belt? No I do not like the quality of the leather and buckles. Last time I saw them in person, they had a new elevated line with better leathers, which was of higher quality than their normal range. At the end of the day, each to his own.
@@gentlemansgazette Thank you for the reply.
Raphael was very gracious in his reply, true gentleman. I’ll be more blunt - Any item (like Anson) peddled by influencers, is not of the highest quality. 😉
@@007cheburashka Be that as it may, I have found their belts to be quite adequate, and very practical. They may not last me a lifetime, but at the price-point, they have lasted years for me, and are still going strong. One of the selling points for me was the interchangable buckles, which makes matching leathers and metals a lot easier.
Thanks for the reply. :)
@@jarofthoughts Hidden elastic waist pants have ridden the need, finally, for a belt. I've always felt somewhat uncomfortable with belts in general, but I put up with them regardless. Nowadays thanks to these better pants I don't miss the belt at all. My back is in better shape, so I'm comfortable and the style is cleaner without even trying. The belt, to me, always breaks up the silhouette of a dressed man.
Incidentally, Raphael doesn't wear belts because all of his things are altered/fitted to himself. In my case, alterations are not an option besides shortening and cuffing them. That's money saved, which means I don't need 2 shades of brown belts and 1 black belt. I can instead wear an extra 2 different pairs of pants in my rotation per 6 - 9 month seasonal window. This truly frees me up for the first time in my journey of dressing up. Will eventually experiment with removed the belt loops since I'm in the middle of an upgrade/update.
Sooooo which one is the best?????
Very interessing
When is Fort Belvedere getting a restock??
I love my Hermes belt.
What is achieved by making belts from multiple layers of leather that are glued and/or stitched together, rather than from a single piece of leather? Or would a belt made from a single piece of full grain leather be considered superior?
With gluing and stitching, you can introduce anti-stretch materials for example, which would definitely help in a belt. And with a single layer, you always have an open flesh side, which works for many occasions, but not necessarily for a fine dress belt.
12:32 time without incident. At least it wasn't early like the video with the shoes. lol
Belt buckle design,thickness,thinness matching according to the formal and causal outfit.
thankyou rose anvil...
Giveaway on the Hermes buckle? 😂