Tesla Model 3 Performance vs Rivals: M3, C63 S & Giulia QV (EXTENDED) | Top Gear : Series 27
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 жов 2019
- It’s petrol vs petrol vs petrol vs electric as the new Tesla Model 3 Performance takes on BMW M3, Merc C63 S and Alfa Giulia Quadrifoglio in a drag race and handling tests. But is it just the outright result that matters? Or is there more to it than that? Join Chris Harris from episode two of Top Gear s27, then tell us below which one you’d take home. Subscribe to Top Gear for more videos: bit.ly/SubscribeToTopGear
WATCH MORE TOP GEAR:
Series 27: bit.ly/TG-S27
Chris Harris Drives: bit.ly/ChrisHarrisDrives
Tesla: bit.ly/TG-Tesla
MORE ABOUT TOP GEAR:
Want to watch a bit of Top Gear on the internet? Welcome to the most comprehensive collection of official clips you'll find on UA-cam. Whether you're searching for a caravan challenge, Ken Block in the Hoonicorn, cars versus fighter jets, Stig power laps or the latest Chris Harris Drives, you can find all the iconic films here. Make sure you're subscribed to the official Top Gear UA-cam channel: bit.ly/SubscribeToTopGear
This is a commercial channel from BBC Studios. Service & Feedback www.bbcstudios.com/contact/co... - Авто та транспорт
Everyone: Petrol vs Electric ultimate challenge
Me:I'm just happy to see Alfa Romeo competing with the big boys again.
The giulia in red is just mmmmmm mama mia
Itali, always. They can just keep that fridge. No emotione, not alive
For what i know..in a quarter mile..Alfa beat all o them!
Amen bud
@@mugurelgeorgescu6121
This is not true. And I own one!
That Tesla destroys everything in it's path. It quite simply has no equal in its segment/price point.
My Alfa is one of the greatest cars of the last 10years. That Model 3 Performance will go down as one of the most significant cars of all time.
It's frighteningly good. I was quite simply shocked at how good it is. And I mean at the actual real business of driving.
Those who fall back on tired excuses (no noise, no soul blah, blah) have, without doubt, never driven one.
They know nothing and should be ignored and/or laughed at as they lose. Over and over again.
Internet: Download more RAM
Me: Nah, that's a scam
Tesla: Download more horsepower
Me: Wait, that actually works! ?!?!
cant wait to get my free over the air performance upgrade next week
They must be planning to introduce Tesla cloud charging
yea every time a new coal power plant goes online a tesla gets 2hp more!
@@CapitaILetter haha underrated
The competition: Wait, that's illegal.
“An AK 47 disguised as a butter knife”
Haah
The Tesla Model 3 is the most fun car I've driven. Performance is insane. I still like the more sedate Model S. The big screen. Lots of buttons. I think if I had the Model 3 for a week I might be converted. The idea of having the speed and all the controls on the centre dash touch screen seemed a bit alien on the first test drive. After 10 mins it seemed completely natural. Great visibility too.
Phillip.
Fake new. I can't be true because the TM3 make no explosion noises. No noise, no fun.
@@Wirmish oh yes, it can make all sorts of farts. That should keep you happy!
What other cars have you driven?
@@ruimpinho Mercedes, Jaguar, BMW, Fords,, Rover, MG, etc. My last car was a 4L V8 Jaguar XK8 convertible. I now own a Model 3 SR+ and LOVE it. It's not the Performance but I use a car so rarely I can't justify the extra.
Phillip.
@@philliptemple4534 Nice. Thanks for letting me know. Many people portrait TM3 as the best car on the world but they come from Ford Fiesta, Honda Civic, etc. Having driven multiple high end cars, I’m also a huge fan of the minimalist approach from Tesla.
During the drag race at around 1:50 you can see that the power of the Model 3 is limited (5 dots), battery only at 57%. I wonder what would have been the result with full battery and power.
There was recently another power increase too. Free 5% increase in performance via over the air update.
Just shows how mentally fast that Tesla is
It would definitely have beaten the Merc and also a bit quicker in the auto cross. It’s shown on dynos that it pulls harder above ~45mph. 95% is no different than 100, but it’s a smidge more hp than 90, and subsequently so at 90 vs 80, a bit lower at 70, furthermore at 60, and so on. You can tell also in the software at the screen showing dots on the moving black line to the right.
Yet the porsche taycan can do this at any battery percentage (I know its 3x the cost)
Sneaker head 1 sure 👍🏻 only the tacan ua-cam.com/video/YVaebcsHNFU/v-deo.html
I thought this was a Carwow vid 😂😂
Yeah getting pretty tired of them. They're not that entertaining for some reason.
@@po.russki yea they are you on crack. Probably THE best drag race channel there is
carwow does that stick test tho!
Deadass thought the same & the whole time I was thinking "damn they really killed it with the editing to make it look like top gear"
@@mitchallen174 lol
Just bought the model 3 performance last week. Damn it's fast. Passengers say it feels like a roller coaster when I take off. It's fun and comfy 😌..
Got the model y. That instant torque hits you hard
But it lacks character and as a car guy it's a big pass for me. I stick with the e92 m3
@@PuttericThe1
Some of us just like going fast. We in love with the speed. Roller coaster, sky diving , gas cars, electric cars even if the make a car off magic dust as long as it goes fast we good. Some need to hear a sound along with that, others don’t care. To each their own and I understand
@@radiculus27 you are right. Amen to that
@@radiculus27 m3p is faster than y.
I road in a model 3 performance at a track with upgraded suspension and tires... the speed was mind numbing, but I agree with everything Chris says. You could really feel the weight and lack of balance compared with other purpose built cars in its class.... that being said, it ran 5 seconds around the circuit better than my 700hp Saleen mustang simply because it can accelerate at such an astonishing pace compared with my rwd mustang
Sell everything. Get a Tesla Model 3 performance. Fuck what your friends say.
"Weight" is a consequence of higher speed. And "lack of balance" too. There are several mods, like custom alinging, sway bars, shocks and springs that will greatly increase M3P performance on track.
I used to own a modified mustang before I switched to Tesla. My 3 Performance is on Mountain pass performance coilovers with zero g wheels on pirellis. My Y Performance is stock. I have an E46 manual M3 with full Dinan suspension and mods for the weekends.
I loved how that AMG was running after the Tesla and getting closer quickly like it's the knight that's protecting the glory of petrol cars.
Perfectly said...
Abderrahman El Bakkali fr one day im going to get a c63s
Hopefully for it, the Tesla was not fully charged and was power limited (you can clearly see it on the display).
UA-cam man Swagroy21 you won’t regret it! Got my (couple of years old) one about six months ago and still love even popping out to the local supermarket :))
@@youtubemanswagroy212 hope you achieve it soon!
Tesla's got a 5% power increase on ota update yesterday. Looks like we gotta reshoot guys lol
Charge the battery fully and run it without a power limit this time too!
@@whyvas And Track Mode on.
Wirmish i heard track mode isnt helpful in drag races and could even make it slower.
Hans von Hansens the only thing TM could adversely affect is battery temp due to the extra cooling it provides. But that’s not gonna be an issue because with sustained full throttle the temps will be quite elevated, particularly if it starts off the high speed run when warmed up properly. So anyhow, if the computer sees too high of a temp it’ll limit power. That’s part of the reason they added TM.
@@lazyhans preach.
Those European sedans are still number 1 in terms of cleaning out your wallet for maintenance and repairs. Nobody can touch them
I own one and have an experience what you’re talking about. Talks cheap but this is UA-cam carry on!
….and about that battery….????
@@GORT70 u mean the ones don’t require 0 maintence other than new tires and panel gaps ??? 😯
You sound like you've never owned one
Shelby Haiketic cheap cars
Can’t wait to see the results of the new Plaid Model S.
Thoughts on it now? It think it’s fucking amazing so amazing they canceled plaid+ cause how fast the plaid is
@@christianmiranda7122 hello! Completely agree with the cancellation of the Plaid +. That next bump in performance can go in the roadster. The market niche of someone wanting a 5 seat sedan with that kind of performance I would think is low vs a true performance super car. Although I can argue that the regular Plaid S is already a supercar. 😜
Plaid is a beast. And power no longer fall off. That tech should be in the model 3/y in 12-24 months. They comparing a 5 seater family car to the Chiron. The plaid should be compared to a bmw 5 series or amg e class instead.
@@radiculus27 but that’s the thing. the tesla plaid out performs the bugatti. that’s why it’s compared to that. and a fraction of the price. yea you don’t get the fancy interior materials but who cares when you’re going that fast!? not like we could afford either of them lmfao
went to drive one but they won't let you. (some knuckleheads smashed one up trying to "go plaid" in the parking lot.) SMH
At 1:31 when Chris launched the Tesla I thought he cheated for half a second. The way the model 3 launches is just crazy.
But how much juice did it use ? that ask must be like everything in life and come at a cost, it must surely speed up the power usage dramatically.
Only over the long term will people see that electric cars for most people simply won't work, and the longer someone has an electric car the more it will be connected to it's charging port, the very same as most laptops tablets and phones.
When i bought my new laptop i could get 4-5hr's usage before it required charging, now it's 5 yr's old i get about 40 mins use, a car will be the very same as it ages.
@@G4RY1159 teslaa have been owned and used heavily by owners for over 5 years already (with no battery swaps), why not go look up some customer testimonials?
@@G4RY1159 you just let your foot off the pedal, and regain a significant portion of the energy used to accelerate. Something none of the others could do.
@@G4RY1159 Electric Cars are for sure the future, this isn't even a question of if but when. Gigafactory 3 is now producing cars in China too.
Gary Steven somebody with a Model 3 recently reached 100k miles and his battery capacity has only diminished by 3%.
"First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win...."
Then they crap themselves in public haha. Tesla owns this!
.....and then you laugh at them.
Only because the RS3 wasn't invited
@@aukevin13 Current prices range from $80,611 to $84,900 for the RS3 Sportback Quattro and RS3 QUATTRO, respectively.
Rossrful you have to have a warm engine too and the ev car was only charged to 50% here. At 100% charge this would be even more of a win. A cold engine/exhaust spits condensation and gargles and the oil is too viscous when cold, so not sure why you are only putting that on the battery. A win is a win, and ice lost here (except for the 4 feet win for the amg that took half a mile to barely do it). Credit where credits due.
Also if you go awd on the other cars they just lose more power through the transmission and the smack down is more embarrassing. There’s a reason why there are so few awd racers that rely on laggy engines.
All cars need to have a steering ratio like that Alfa. Such an amazing steering in that car.
The model 3 was at 57% charge! Charge it all the way up and redo this. The difference is staggering !
But wait! When it's fully charged it will weigh more so it'll be slower, surely?
@@John_L charge doesn't increase weight
@@GreenDriveIndia Of course it does, and what's more your phone is heavier if you have unread text messages. [It was a joke]
@@John_L and if you delete some of the apps it will be lighter
@@John_L lol
There is a good reason Chris Harris Bought a Model 3 after this review. Every time i plant my right foot in my Model 3 Performance i can feel the fluid in my face move to the back of my head.
this is true.
Yep. I drive a Model S p85d with insane+. Last week I was at a traffic light behind a Model 3 performance. Next to that pulled up a BMW M5 with a lot of noise and theater. Green light. Model 3 shoots off, I have to pace my paddle just a little to not hit the 3, pass the BMW, and drive next to the 3 to the next traffic light. We look at each other and laugh. No chance BMW. So next light the BMW is behind me, insane+ turned on. Bye! The model 3 could almost keep up with my 692 horsepower, it's that fast. Maybe just a half a car length of difference. The BMW made a lot of noise l, but was nowhere to be seen and gave up. Next light: both of us drove of with a light foot. Laughing our asses off.
@@WouterZtube great story mate, never happened tho.
TheMartin139 yes it did
WouterZtube i know the exact feeling when my Rs3 leaves you guys behind as well......oh we laugh watching the expressions as I pull away. Your right it’s a great feeling lol
Elon musk: this car will beat anything on a track.
Roadster: Will you release me already?
*anything in its class
@@Pyamamannetje It's going to spank the McLaren, and walk all over anything else. Willing to bet a beer.
"It's also a four seater." - Musk
"What!?" - crowd
@@fredpinczuk7352 what mclaren ?
League359 when your class is the top class... you can say anything period.
That Benz came rushing like a storm 😊
Barely at the end only after 132mph, how often in real world?
Keyboard Warrior. A victory is a victory. In real world it will still win against these
@@MzwandileHarmans who cares after 130 mph, the most fun is who gets it first at the traffic light, the rest does not matter
@@captaincassiuscalhoun. Are you asking for names ? 😂 it’s won 🤷♂️ and was fastest gas engine even off the line
Top Gear: let’s see how the Tesla compares on a drag race.
Also Top Gear: let me adjust the drag race so that the gas cars can have a chance 🤣
How many times do you get to actually drag race? Stupid test
@@paulhancock3844 when I was young, multiple times per day! plus visits to an actual drag strip a few times a year, heh
@@JackMott but that's not normal, sorry
@@paulhancock3844 How often do you do an autocross? None of this is normal, but going fast from a stop is absolutely normal car enthusiast behavior.
@@paulhancock3844 LOL, That's like saying measuring acceleration is a stupid test. how else are you supposed to measure a car's real-world power and acceleration? stomping on the pedal is what people have been doing since the invention of the automobile. And now it's suddenly a "stupid test".
Can't wait for the Roadster. Going to make a lot of supercars look silly
Lourens Engelbrecht minus the lack of noise
And if it's ever made, because there's no way it's gonna be out on time
They delayed it and said they made it “better in every way.”
@@LeMatt87n
There is a noise, it's obviously a lot quieter and more sci-fi sounding.
jon doe what no lmaoo
The model 3 is more like a rail gun dressed as a bar of soap with a tv in it.
Excellent description!
Thank you for fixing his metaphor. The AK butter knife was 🙄 but yours is 👍.
Sounds like something clarkson would say
@@soarabove337 ikr, the ak47 is simple, barebone and lowtech, the model 3 is the opposite
@@manenwan but wait until they make electric AK-47!
AK-47-E !!
Love this presenter, feels like he's bringing back Top Gear...
Good day! I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some
fantastic deals on our eBay listing in Tesla Accessories
That Merc is damn fast for the half mile
Good day! I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some
fantastic deals on our eBay listing in Tesla Accessories
More importantly though. How slow is the BMW.
The Supra?
@@wbwayne8887 what???
It kind of disappeared after the drag race, didn't it?
@@dor1tomcswagger69
I mean BMW.
@@wbwayne8887 maybe if it was a z4 and not an m3 🤦♂️
Im still in love with giulia QV after see this!
Slow response from the driver...or maybe I'm wrong.
Quapadople yea he didn’t drive the giulia in a proper way..
@@arboriavisualdesigns5455 excuses excuses
@@dmcdgames2388 ah yes excuses for being faster xd
What about the reliability
That AMG though caught up like a beast!!! I love Mercedes-Benz
1:50 the tesla was at 57% charge and with a cold battery (see the dots at the end, not available power)
I’d like to see the drag race again with the battery at 100%. I noticed it was at 57%, I hear they lose power as the battery gets lower. Nice performance either way.
@Leonardo Meireles to the engine? Sorry the tesla shit doesn’t have engine
I’d like to see the e63s on the drag race as well as none of those were awd like the Tesla giving it a massive advantage off the line. The e63 is a good second or more faster to 100km than the c class. Might have the grip out of the corners too..
No they dont lose power until really low
I can't help but to watch the drag race and expect Mat Watson to say, "Now, what happened..."
Or Yani to say "come on!"
"it's so close"
Stuart Anderson now what exactly happened
and Doug watching it with his huge tongue out
Good day! I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some
fantastic deals on our eBay listing in Tesla Accessories
This video just made me love the alfa even more...
But it is far more expensive than Teala
Free Bird because it’s a proper car. Not a soulless white goods vehicle made for hemp wearing vegans.
Free Bird well it is far more car than the Tesla, and not because the Tesla is an ev, but because it’s a Tesla...
Viktor Poposki agreed, I’ve been in many Tesla’s. At no point have I ever wanted one. American shit box. If I want a proper American car I’ll buy a mustang. Not some shit box made of plastic.
Jaguar 1991 Tesla is actually a good car compared to other American cars. American cars are half a car in my opinion with very shit handling.
See the Telsa bolt off the line leaving the other cars just standing there. Amazing !
@@mindofvirtuoso3358 Well yea captain obvious lol
That Alfa makes me smile, its the reason why I love cars.
@James Smythe It has a higher reliability rate than the Germans
The looks the sound orgasmic
@@shadyyy7490 that’s a very low standard. 😂
it makes my eyes hurt
@@shadyyy7490 ahahahahahahahahah
Bimmer fans left after they saw the m3 lose the drag race lol
You're one of those stupid idiots that know nothing about cars. That M3 is the first variant and around 8 years old, has RWD and only 430bhp. The rest are the top end premium faster versions, they couldn't allow the competition pack BMW because it wrecks even some of the fastest supercars. So dumbass learn facts and don't try and bait with stupid comments like that. Here's some advice go out into the heavily populated area and catch the covid you trash bag!
SuperManBeemerrr Charles imagine being so salty over an internet comment that you want someone to die lol
I paused the video and youre right I'm going, good bye.
SuperManBeemerrr Charles and the m3 comp aint beating no fkn supercar your on crack v8s would still fkn crush that fart can
@@SuperLC1010 yeah you're right! Bmw suuucks
The Merc C63s is just awesome. I love it.
Pi SamYNWA same i really want one
Not as good as a model 3 tho
Shaq Sheq fk electric cars there way more boring
@@caab0516 false. Only if you are interested in 0-100 times.
@@Sierra-hk8jw false yourself bud, in a race type situation, the AMG would take the cup. As a vehicle however, the Tesla is cheaper, is battery powered, require no oil changes/filtration repairs, has bio-weapon defense modes, can travel up to 650 km on one charge, is way more technologically advanced, has the capability to drive itself, and that's just to name some of its perks
If you're a petrol/engine head or car enthusiast, yeah AMG probs takes the w (obviously) it even wins looks wise as well, but as a car, Tesla flies ahead in basically all other aspects
This made me love the guilia even more
I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some
fantastic deals on our eBay listing in Tesla Accessories
The Giulia is ugly, just like the model 3.
It's really weird watching Top Gear and not seeing Jeremy, Richard and James. It's just not the same ...
It's better🤣🤣🤣
@@3lgonView no
Was watching Chris Harris drift on UA-cam long before he was doing it for Top Gear. May not be the same as the old show, but if anyone deserved the big times, it's Chris. Can drive [drift] circles around any of the previous hosts. He's still entirely entertaining, albeit for different reasons.
this aint Top Gear:(
ppl talking about how can a merc be that fast...dude AMG builds pagani engines in a long road you have no chance keeping up with it
Those AMGs are fast they have top speed most times makes other vehicles leap off the start line because of their lighter weight but those AMGs have top speed they will catch up with you later
you are right, although the tesla is a family car not a sports car :)
Since the review, the model 3 has got via updates: 5% more power and regen braking to 0 mph (along with Netflix and UA-cam).
my regen braking only goes to 3 mph....
The power increase was massive tho (still no button to disable T/C)
@@dallatorretdu update in next two weeks gives regen to 0 and more power
How do I confirm this?
@@12vgs8606 you wait until you get the 32.12.4 update
dallatorretdu you can turn on slip start and it turns off tc
Lets try that test with the new 200k roadster against similar priced cars.
NOW that would be interesting
Well. When it comes out
Petrol won’t stand a chance.
There is a new model s tri Motor version. 0-60 mph in under 2.1 sec. 800+ km range the price is something like 150k though
@@Mike-kr5dn under 2 seconds actually
Then let’s see it against the Porsche taycan turbo s LMAO that Porsche is gonna get raped
1:29 When the model 3 blasted away from all of them, I literally got goosebumps haha
it was staged
@@grodt88 lol no. That's exactly how it works in real life. M3P will be a full car length ahead of most ICE vehicles before it hits 60mph.
@@grodt88 i own one. reality!
Dutch number plate
Left side steering
High performance
Impressive car I have to admit
Wait what ahahahahahha
KiratCan Kerem Everything
A steer on the left side is the right position for a steering wheel to be.
KiratCan Kerem you’re not my mum, don’t tell me what to do
Good day! I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some
fantastic deals on our eBay listing in Tesla Accessories
Finally, a comprehensive review with a competent driver, no mocking around, no bias, the best of the electric world against the best of the petrol world. Congratulations Top Gear, thanks for this awesome test. Valuable lessons for both sides of the fence.
@jon doe What? No, he just drove like he always did, although he didn't anticipate the weight of the Model 3. Otherwise it was a decent drive.
@jon doe Let me guess : Clarkson or Hammond would have done it better? Also, this man races in GT3, he's by no means a bad driver.
He's the "worst" because tesla lost to Merc!!
@@monroejenkins5862 Nah, I've checked his comments. He just hates Chris Harris for some reason. Tbh this was quite a neutral test.
@karma tam Good that you ask, after checking in on the other channels, it would seem TG has, once again, faked the numbers to disadvantage the Tesla. The main culprit being that they claimed a 0.4 seconds gap between the two cars at the 1/4 mile, despite the fact that the cars were nearly side by side on the video (so more like 0.1 to 0.15 seconds of a gap at most). Really disappointed.
The Alfa is just so much more beautiful. But I would have loved to have seen an overtake test at highway speed.
The Alfa is a beautiful car and has a nice exhaust note. My friend has one but it has been into the shop many times. It does not seem very reliable.
The Model 3 is crazy to ride everyday launching 0-60 at every light for no extra cost at all.
Longest car commercial I’ve ever seen and Tesla didn’t even have to spend a single dime.
So same as Hammond with his Porsches?
That's the whole point. Tesla do not advertise. when people see what they are actually capable of. Word-of-mouth does the rest!
;) We're seeing a lot of that, these days.
Tens of millions in free advertising, every day.
@@Gepstra Porche is dying man, nobody wants an expensive car when the roadster is out
What a daft comment... top gear is a car show, every maker has had similar features
I died when he branded it a fast fridge.🤣🤣
"If you can't beat them, insult them"
The merc was like “ NEIN I AINT LETTING THIS ELECTRIC SHIT WIN
😂😂
Except it did beat beat em on the quarter mile 😂
@@frankcastle1578 no did u watch the video clearly?! The merc got the electric shit at the very end
I was actually pretty impressed by the quadrifoglio
I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some
fantastic deals on our eBay listing in Tesla Accessories
Honestly I think it doesn't matter that the Mercedes caught up at 130 MPH, that is way over any legal limit except in Germany, and even there it is rare to hit those speeds.
In every real world situation you are just gone with the Tesla before the others can even wake their engines up. And it is way way way cheaper then the others.
You need to be braindead to pay that much more just to be able to say, "hey I am faster at 135 MPH than you"
It's not just that you fanboy. When you buy a Merc you buy luxury, badge, bragging rights, a beautiful car, fun. The Tesla on the other hand is just fast from a standing point.
In real world you wouldnt be drag racing anyway.
I know electric cars are faster than petrol in terms of acceleration, but sorrry, driving is more than that.
Do you see how F1 nowadays is more boring that 15 years ago despite of being faster? Same with tesla.
Ugly looking car, no sound.
I would take any of the others, speacially the Giulia, over the Tesla any day. It doesnt matter if its 1 min soler on Nurburgring or whatever, no gap in acceleration can short the gap created by that V6 sound.
Geno Geno when you buy a Tesla, you get built in Netflix, Hulu, UA-cam, Spotify, and an autopilot system that is leagues better than any other manufacturer. I love my Mercedes s550 but once you have a Tesla there’s no going back. Absolutely no way I’ll be buying any other car after getting a model 3 performance.
@@SuperLisandro86 you should drive one before talking, I own a 66 V8 mustang and model 3. I love the V8 roar but the model 3 is special, nothing like it.
@@bshl3866 I did a test drive in a friend's car and although the electric push feels great, it doesn't make up for the things I look for in a car.
As I said, the exterior is sooll boring, and I dislike too the interior with that big screen and no dedicated controls for the clima. At that price point I want a car that shoes that, and the quality and desing of the Merc interior, or even BMW, and obviously the looks, are way better than the Tesla.
Dont get me wrong, I know someday I will have an electric car, I just hope is not as boring as the Model 3.
Ps: Dont compare the Mustang to these three, I would even pick the Tesla over the Mustang.
Someone brought a Model 3 on RE-71Rs to my local autox and absolutely wiped the floor with us. That's the sum of my Model 3 knowledge.
@n s How does that make sense when the Tesla beat the Alfa on the track in the very video you're commenting on? Also noise pollution is for children.
AMG is that hulk after he become crazy
Nothing beats the Alfa, regardless if it lost to Tesla! It’s the best all round package, it’s Art on Wheels!!
Seb C haven’t had any issues with mine as of yet really, perhaps the newer generation is a lot better reliability wise.
But the mercedes beat the alfa
Recruit Gab In this video yes. But any other videos it doesn’t, such as when they did a comparison on Motor Trend.
Looks like everyone beat Alfa, same goes for F1 🤣🤡
@@jean-gabrielgadpaille7955 youtube has many videos with the BMW M3 Competetion Package, the Mercdedes Benz C63s, and the Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio and the Quadrifoglio is the quickest of the three. The BMW has a top speed of 174mph and 4.0 from 0-60, the Mercedes Benz had a top speed of 180mph and 3.9 from 0-60, and the Alfa Romeo has a top speed of 191mph and 3.8 from 0-60.
Has to be the Alfa for me, but electric power is something to behold.
yea coal powered cars are the future fosho
One of the other... In Portugal Alfa is 40k€ more expensive
@@jaysmith6466 Yep, because everyone knows coals is the only way to generate electricity
@@jaysmith6466 Not sure where you're from but in the USA (where the most Teslas are located) only 13% of the power used is from coal now and this drops every year. In California, the state with by far the most electric cars, only 1% of power used is from coal. If you live somewhere that uses a lot of coal, maybe you should spend your time trying to fix that.
www.eia.gov/state/?sid=CA
www.eia.gov/energyexplained/us-energy-facts/
@@jaysmith6466 The biggest coal company in America just went bankrupt. You are as stuck in the past as they were.
The Merc saved the petrol heads......hooo
After they changed the rules to suit the gas cars... typical. If you can't win - change the rules.
when Audi RS4 raced a Tesla, it was neck and neck for the first 3 seconds, and it was against a Tesla model X P100D which have 70% more horsepower than the model 3 performance here (770hp vs 444hp) . here, those rear wheel drive cars didn't have a chance off the line. Tesla got to a 100 km/h almost a second before them, and since that moment it was lost.
watch "Audi RS4 vs Tesla Model X P100D - DRAG RACE" --- ua-cam.com/video/BfxONVQku6U/v-deo.html
@@nadlantalk4354 what are you talking about? The Tesla stomped the RS4 in the 1/4 mile.
Nadlan Talk, so you seriously think that driver reaction time had no influence on that race? Seriously? Well if that's the case then explain this.......
ua-cam.com/video/_NnNEuxqoPo/v-deo.html
@@terryjohn4567 Everyone knows that the Tesla will win in a shorter distance race. It would have been a boring race
I am from Russia and it's nice to see you buddy, good stories! thank you for your footage and attention to details!
Very impressed with the Guilia QV
Good day! I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some
fantastic deals on our eBay listing in Tesla Accessories
"A very fast fridge" 💀💀
I mean who’s really gonna do a 0-100mph on the streets? Most of the time on the streets it’s 1/8 of a mile and some times barley 1/4 mile. Yes on a closed track others will creep up to the model 3, but on the public roads model 3 will dust its competitors
That’s y u take it to the track
...and that is exactly why it is a king on the streets
Drag races arent really fun anymore, most hot hatches are awd and automatics with launch control. The challenge is gone.
@@DevasionX There's always the Fiesta ST.
Unless you actually take road trips and then you'll have to stop and charge for all eternity while not traveling as far in-between charges
This was the video that sold me on buying a Tesla. I’ve had a Model 3 Performance for over a half a year now and it feels just as exciting to hop in it as it did on the first day. It’s a damn rocket ship.
That's the only time I've ever seen a Tesla beat.
As i know the top gear loves to lower-grades Teslas the Model 3 may have been at low charge for less performance 😁
@@4i4kotrevi4ko100 that's a good point, I hadn't considered that at all.
Really anoys me when people say the tesla got beat. Just remind me what the maximum speed limit is and how many cars can beat it to that? I bet there are no more that a handful of cars and nothing under 100k
@@paulhancock3844 well it did get beat. It's a fact. I'm not leaving reality behind to suit someone's delicate sensibilities.
@@paulhancock3844 god you fanboys are insufferable
Love the "on track graphics"
SOC was at like 50% during the drag race. Had they charged it to 80ish%, it would have totally won.
anything above 70% is full power as tested by MPP
Its not gonna win many races above 130 mph with only 1 gear
@@DuckHunterGaming Probably true, but the race wasn't much above that anyway.
But the motor spins to 17k rpm, to it has plenty of space :)
Yep, and that’s why Tesla is quite useless. If you really push it a few times the battery loses a lot of power. Petrol cars just keep on going (and so does a Porsche Taycan). Tesla also overheats quickly when pushed to the limit.
@@TJ-zq3hl Just to clarify, you're saying the petrol cars never overheat when pushed to the limit for extended periods of time?
Also, the Model 3's "track mode" helps it stay cool and at full power for a plenty long time.
Yesterday a Tesla Model 3 tried to race me and my V222 S500. It didnt pull away, we were absolutely equal.
Yeah course you were. It was probably a long range and not even trying.
@@thomastolster3934 My S-Class has more torque than the Performance-model. From 0-80 my car does not even do a gear-change. Don't think, Tesla is unbeatable.
i love petrol cars and drove M4 and C63, now I have an M3P. the most fun of this three cars i have/had with the Tesla. acceleration and the fun you have with it is insane.
I have a Model 3 Performance as well as an M3 and 911. I love the C63 as well. The Tesla does not have the looks, sound, fit and finish of the German cars. The Tesla is a good daily driver though and saves money on gas. Gas is near $5 per gallon now. I am driving the Tesla a lot more.
Good day! I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some
fantastic deals on our eBay listing in Tesla Accessories
Top Gear “Never let the reality ruins your script”
“We’re so used to Tesla’s being fast off the line” ...that we had to reevaluate the “test” in to a format where it wouldn’t win every time.
Unless it has a fully charged battery.
the '.....' dots you see in the Tesla's display at 1:50 are NOT only due to the charge level being at 57% (which definitely impacts high speed torque output, but more on that in a bit); it is a funtion also of the battery temp, and for the ICE folks, think of your beloved engine in your fave beauty of a car, where you'd give it to me, cold, and I right away drag race it at full beans max attack to 150mph, without warming anything up at all. The Battery Mgmt System is doing it's thing. The fact that this run had FIVE dots, is indicative that it was VERY power limited, at all speeds below ~50mph. It was likely too cold or too hot. Tsk tsk, shucks, definitely not a good representation of the capability. This run was done before the latest power update, which demonstrably made the higher speed pulling stronger, not just the 0-60 (which also improved). In fact we're not even sure if this was done with the prior power update installed that came out (around March or April). Overall conclusion: We all demand you do this again with the latest update circa Nov 2019 onwards, and you show us during the run the bar to ensure there are no dots! Trust me C63S Benz fans, the outcome would be very different ...
We don't need to "reevaluate" what a fast car is because the same car keeps winning. The test is what it is.
@@raheeb1 crybaby. The difference is that the E Car only performe well when the battery is at >65% and the petrol ones performe always same. Tesla lost keep with it
Dominik di Lol does it matter at all, when the Tesla’s DESTROY the high performance ICE car at launch, to 60, to 100, quarter mile, rolling race at most speeds, and even ON TRACK as shown here, and the only domain the ICE currently have a chance is ABOVE 130 mph (over 200kph) purely Because of their numerous gear ratios, which is stupid and not only is it a fantasy to go much faster than that on most roads in the world, but on most race tracks you can’t even go that fast? And even on the legendary autobahn, ask around: three quarters of the time it’s packed with traffic jam.
I’m sorry my friend but the lights out are indeed coming for ICE. It’s just not logical much anymore and it sure ain’t gonna be in 5 years. Watch what developments come. Your mind will be blown (then open).
Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio 🍀 remains the fastest... I wonder who made this video.
🤣
How ? 🤔 wow
@F m Nothing wrong with that. If my memory serves me correct in the carwow dragrace for example the Alfa QV did beat the m3 and the c63. And in my eyes the alfa is just a truckload prettier than any other car lined up here :D
@F m Yeah but that was not the point was it. Calling people italian fanboys under every positive comment about the alfa here just makes u look like ur real salty cuz the alfa beat ur dear bmw ;)
@F m So ur calling other people italian fanboys and go this far with ur baseless argument about the bmw being ”older” than the alfa. Its really not alfas fault bmw doesnt update their engines is it? Ur starting to sound a lot like a german fanboy ;)
Just realized, at 1:50 you will note that full power is being limited, car is probably capped off at 90% power there. Had they done a run where the car was at 100% available capacity, it would’ve most likely won.
Makes no difference to power
@@danielblyth2841
It literally does lol
I love how you have to change the rules of a drag race to give the others a chance.. and the Merc won by a hair... and now the tesla got a free 5% performance update.
The only advantage an electric 4WD car vs most gas cars is the 1/4 drag race and it even lost in that....lmao.
They're shit on the track and shit at anything beyond the short 1/4 mile. Look at how the C63 pulled passed the Model 3 and imagine is the race was longer.
Mercedes are known to be pretty dogshit off the line too because they're proper luxury cars and focused more for track racing with RWD (the Model 3 is much slower on Laguna Seca than the C63S).
The Tesla wasn't even fully charged.
@@Gongolongo did you even watch the video? It was a 1/2 mile drag race, not a 1/4 mile. And the battery wasn't even fully charged. Of course it would win any race.
And the Model 3 was faster than the Alfa around the track. No wonder everybody wants one.
@@Gongolongo It was a 1/2 mile you petrol fanboy. Teslas are not track cars, they are sleepers that eat up sports cars on the road..everyday.
@@mcplutt You do realize that the straight line measure for automotive performance is a 1Km run right? Unlike nautical miles quarter of an imperial mile means nothing to earth's physics..
"for a car that looks like a fridge...", I spew my red wine all over the keyboard.
Whereas, of course, the fluorescent green M3 was the epitome of elegance :)
I didn't get that comment actually. I've never seen a fridge that looks like a model 3. If you want to talk "mobile fridge", then look at the Mercedes G-Wagon. THAT is a fridge.
@@ColinFox
I didn't get it either.
There's a win for Petrol.
Okay, my next car will be a Tesla.
It's boring to look at. Your not gonna use that speed on the road. Why not buy something with soul.
@@darthduane6698 to be realistic, the most you’re doing is 30-70 not 0-60. Personally, I don’t see how any Tesla has soul at all, the interior’s are the most boring things ever, the looks are subjective but in my opinion a bit boring as well. I’d choose any of these cars over a model 3 any day of the week.
@@Supraboyes teslas have soul they literally dance
?
@@Supraboyes have you ever tried one? 😀 there’re very fun
It’s a family car after all...
That AMG was ballistic
And the Tesla wasn’t even giving full power! Those dots at the end of the power bar show that
The drag races aren't filmed in 1 shot... That frame was recorded way after the race itself
Yes hence why the power was limited, the battery was probably really hot. The the Mercedes passed north of 130mph when the power was limited
Top Gear has a history of being biased against Teslas
You can have your above 120mph acceleration. I’ll take the 0mph to highway speed any day.
me too brother! THATS where its at! and thats what will get used again and again and bring a smile to ur face while the other guys zooming to 120 or above get some massive fines and endanger others on the road .. no thanks!
Both are useless for normal driving. I'll take the long distance range and quick refuel of Diesel ICE over any current EV. That's something practically useful in real life.
@@deleted2462 CCTV, speed cameras, choppers etc etc. You ever watched traffic cops mate? This isn't need for speed.
Lol that E.V which is determined by the battries percentage even in highway tesla wont stand a chance cause ice engines still has power even the fuel is low on tank. It sucks that e.v acceleration is only impressive when battrey is full lmao
@s n you mean car thats only faster than bmw when the battrey is full lmao fuck that
I would be curious to see these Tesla on the track head to head with other cars for a few laps and not just for quarter mile tests or one minute races
Good day! I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some
fantastic deals on our eBay listing in Tesla Accessories
I wonder how the Tesla Model S would have compared. The S seems like. Better comparison to the petrol cars.
The Giulia start some slowly .....not good start I think
All cars except Tesla started two seconds later on half throttle. It was all staged.
@@felipe7112 That's what instant torque and 4 wheels drive does for you.
Believe me, even the regular Model 3 Dual motor is quite fast. I know because I drive one everyday..
Great cars they are, all of them.
3:00 he made 20 meters in 3 seconds with a car which takes 3.9s to 100kmh.. I could drive my bicycle faster than that.. So FAKE !
Still take the Alfa over all others!
Let him have his own choice.
For sure. Quickness is fast becoming commodity. Connection and enjoyment are the new rare luxuries.
Second.
Good luck when it breaks down
@@ArrowRaider How so? I have the impression that the new Giulia is both stable and reasonable to maintain.
There's one competition Tesla couldn't win . Exhaust sounds 😂
And looks. And coolness.
Or self tuning
How about the lack of sound test? I can leave home without anybody noticing 🤣🤣
It won handily by not having any, which is fucking great.
@@MengLinWu lol only if you are a vegan, gay, or old. Exhaust noise is a freaking important part of any car.
Anyone notice the Model 3 Performance was limiting its power? Notice the dots appearing on the power/regen line (left and right of the shown speed). Wonder if that played a part.
dont care what u ICE lovers say, but i pre-ordered red /white combo performance model Y, driving to grocery market will be fun again.
Congrats! Black/white performance model 3 here. You'll love it.
😁😄😆😂
🤜🏽🤛🏽👍🏾
Gap really? Can you speak from experience? I’ve got a Model 3 performance as well as a Carrera T, E92 M3, S2000 and Rubicon Hard Rock, all with sticks. The sports cars get tracked regularly and the Jeep is off road more than on road. I think the Tesla is just as much fun as all of them.
Ahh I see this is becoming a me vs you as always
straden79 I have an MX with the same color combo. Get a ceramic coat and you’ll forever turn heads. Also highly recommend black or grey wheels.
Thanks I take Tesla for sure.
1:48 why was there a power limit there? I've never had a power limit until i was
Was gonna say the same thing about Track Mode lol, did they even use it?
@@Dubitz Track mode v2 wasn’t available back then
The model 3 is amazingly impressive, especially with the recent price drop. Pleased to see the giulia almost matching it!
Hold on. Why is that an NL license plate on the tesla?
Insanely good b-roll from the top gear team!
You need to get some experience to drive tesla model 3 in track mode. You do approach corners differently in tesla model 3 due way traction work when "Track mode" is enabled.
No experience can eliminate the boat loads of body roll that car has...
Great car, but the handling isn't there yet
Who cares about tesla
@@kevinmahoque5608 There is few videos where after some simply work on suspension and brakes tesla model 3 performance is absolutely monster on autocross and autocross is all about handlind
John Smith we’re talking about stock cars here if you didn’t know, I’m sure a Fiat could beat a Ferrari with some upgrades
@@jack14kd Many, many people
I wonder if the Performance mode was used in the slalom. It makes a big difference in handling for me.
Chris Harris is just great 👍🏼
it’s very honest to say “we had to change the rules so that we could make petrol win”, but you have to ask, Why? Why invent a test (that’s nearlly double the UK speed limit) just to fudge the result. Again, Chris was totally honest about it but, why do it?
Because these cars do, in quite a few cases, see usage scenarios at speeds well-beyond those observed in the quarter mile. But this wasn't a win for petrol as much as it was an impressive display of how rapidly electric is advancing.
because it was fun... nothing else... everybody knows EV's will be faster in all areas one day. The real problem is it takes Netflix and UA-cam and Whoopie cushions to try and make them emotive engaging products, in this area they are a fat zero... it will be down to the mainstream brands to make cars exciting if they can. I don't think Tesla knows how.
Why? Simply because everybody already knows the Tesla will win the quarter mile. At least with a half mile there will be some suspense.
Ovidiu Diumea Sure, I get it. But if it wins on acceleration in any sensible test (0-60, 40-80 etc) show it! Find tests where it doesn’t win (without being contrived). Set up a slalom where it’s weight might be an issue. And if it wins everything but in a boring way, show that! Show how it’s less engaging for the driver. Show someone’s feet, manual gears - dropping down for engine braking etc... If petrol has a future, show us why.
@@paulbarton957 Unfortunately petrol has no future, like the dinosaurs it's made from They're about to go extinct, I've been a car enthusiast since I got the game Sega Rally back in 95, the sounds of a roaring rally car is my symphony No5, Me and my impreza have been inseparable since I past my driving test, but... I borrowed a Model 3 for a week just to see what all the fuss was about... I can see Elons future and what he wants to achieve, and the Model 3 is just a stepping stone to bigger and better things in the not to distant future.
Anyone here remember the original Top Gear, Tesla review?
is that where they pretended the car ran out of battery/broke down?
TG hasn't changed too much...
The one with the lawyers?
@@chapman_7265 No, the lawyers was a response to the lawsuits resulting from the original one.
After decades of reviewing and loving ICE cars, sponsored by fuel companies; what do you expect?
I saw a Giulia QV starting a drag race and I assure my friends , that this, is not what Giulia can do, but I don’t want to upset your opinion so... 🤐
ua-cam.com/video/h8R7kZGvAUk/v-deo.html just watch how slow the Giulia starts for the handling part. Is this a joke from Top Gear?
Awesome video
I heard that the Model 3 is even quicker with Track mode OFF for drag races!!! Could have win with it disable!
It wouldn’t make a difference.
@@akzebraminer5679 and battery wasnt fully charged
@@ConstantijnKool and no software update with power increase
In general Model 3 should be quicker in track mode. Even better would be if he had more than 57% charge.
@@youtubeaccount5631 And it wasn't the next generation model....
Damn the Merc is fast, gotta admire it while it still has a glorious V8.
@The Truth rumoured 2.0 inline 4 from the A45S which I really hope they won't use
@The Truth Tbh that inline 4 is great but it is still not as good as a V6 or V8 plus it is a C63(S) which should have a bigger engine than a non AMG
@The Truth Well that would be great for AMG fans
Hey guys, I currently have lexus nx f sport and want to purchase little bit more fun car but can’t decide between tesla model 3, bmw and mercedes c43 amg. Any recommendations?
I would hear the C63 sound for all my life awesome 😍😍😍😍😎😎
Impressive results for the Tesla being at 57%. In the drag race @1:50, you can see that your acceleration is reduced. Give a nice charge to the Tesla and warm up the battery and it would’ve probably won the drag race
All of the other cars in its class are quite a bit more expensive
No they aren't, it's all within a few thousand dollars
@@abhishetty2637 Yes they are. The Model 3 performance in my country the netherlands is 63k (euro). c63 amg 2019 is 110k
@@abhishetty2637 a maxed out model 3 is around 75 80k out the door maxed out c63s around 110k
Tesla is the only car you can plug in at home and wake up with a full charge. Can't do that with the mercedes or bmw. Such an inconvenience of having to go to a gas station
@RealCapo88 I noticed people always hate on cars they cant afford.
I say, you have a way with words, Chris! 🤗
Alfa Romeo made in Italy😍cuore sportivo👊
uglyness made in Italy