Joey's mother, just wait and watch, when gta 4 will get released for Android on December 2018 the whole world will stand still and get shocked. then all you console fanboys will bow down to us Mobile fanboys. if we get gta 4 (mark my words it will 100%come) on Android then in just after 1 year in 2019 we will get rdr. in 2023 we will get gta 5 on Android and it will continue, shit never ends bruh
John vs trevor john revolver and trevor sawn off shotgun john shoots trevor trevor is dead michael tries to run over john in a car no john shoots the tire michael slips into a gas tank franklin comes with chop john with a sawn off shotgun shots franklin john wins the fbi and army come shoots him to death
p p GTA V Story was so predictable and bland that I got bored of it in the first few hours. Red Dead’s story was emotional and gripping compared to GTA V’s. The only thing I liked about GTA V was it’s gameplay and it’s hours of content. Red Dead in my opinion had the better gameplay which made the game never boring for me.
Red dead is way better and I always thought red dead had better gameplay also and I would say gta v has a good multiplayer but red dead has way more fun things to do
The shooting in rdr is badass. The gun sounds are flawless and the blow back effects of the npcs from being shot seem more realistic and well done. Not bad for a seven year old game.
GTA DOESN'T STAND A CHANCE !!!! RDR HAS A BETTER STORY,IS MORE REALISTIC,VOICES AND EXPRESSIONS ARE ORIGINAL,REACTIONS ARE WAY BETTER THAN GTA 5 OR GTA ,RDR IS THE BEST GAME ROCKSTAR EVER CREATED THAT THE AUDIENCE DONT REALIZE AND JUST LIKE AND PREFER GTA,RDR IS THE BEST WHOS WITHME
@The Zexal you know, It's a funny story, but I played rdr since then and now I like it. This is not the first time. There are many more games, I didn't like, until taking a closer look. I'm like this
Red dead redemption also wins when it comes to shooting, in GTA V you do have more weapons but in RDR if you shot someone in both feet they would kneel down and you would shoot them in the head, if you shot them in the elbow the would move like they got shot in the elbow, in GTA V they react very badly, an very similarly no matter where you shoot them.
Yeah it's annoying because both games utilize the Euphoria Physics Engine. And for some stupid reason Rockstar decided to tone back Euphorias influence on the ragdolls in GTA 5. I swear to God Rockstar better amp it back up in RDR2 because thats how people died in the old Westerns movies!
Red Dead Redemption was better. The map and environment was realistic, the shooting was better, infinite random events (store robbery, horse theft, stranger that's got his friend/wife kidnapped), hunt and sell skins and meat from animals, Marston was better than the 3 protagonists, story was emotionally amazing. The only downside is you can't swim
Basically duh RDR is better cause it has a way WAY better story and John is better than all the GTA characters combind cause he is the oldest the among all rockstar characters well 2nd as in protagonist, but in GTA you couldn't sell your animal skins like RDR
so.. i got red dead redemption and GTA V on my ps3, both of those games are fun, but if you played other gta games it will just be boring for you probably, like me, i played GTA IV and San Andreas just the whole Series and gta v is fking boring af for me, RDR is just a 10+ better version of GTA for me, RDR wins for me.
GTA 5 is the BOMB when u play it the first time - it is boring af in 2019 now RDR1 I can still play that and enjoy it just as much as I did in 2010 btw RDR2 is the greatest game of all time don't @ me lol
RDR2 still overrelies on GTA 3+4+5 ( Arthur Morgan's movements similar to Claude and Niko Bellic his tuberculosis four endings like forgetable Grand Theft Auto Five Endings ) ( Leopold Strauss' Missions kinda similar to Grand Theft Auto Vice City Opening Scene ) ( Arthur Morgan + John Marston Train Missions kinda similar to Grand Theft Auto San Andreas + Red Dead Revolver ) ua-cam.com/video/gDmHsLNIAos/v-deo.html m.ua-cam.com/video/ksyhV0Yk17o/v-deo.html
I HATE GTA V MUTIPLAYER. Reason 1: There are too much modders in the game and my friend was so angry at this trigger happy!Reason 2: There are pedofiles in mutiplayer (if your child was playing)Reason 3: RDR has more things to do and have different mounts.Reason 4: you have to have a high level to get new guns and stuff :P I have rest my case... /walks away
literally the worst reasoning I've ever heard about anything ever, even Theresa May stealing her speech from The West Wing was better than that poor excuse for a speech, and I agree RDR is better than GTA, but those reasones were pathetic
GTA 5 is awesome for online but Red Dead redemption has an amazing story. Grand Theft Auto has better weapons but Red dead redemption has better shooting. Grand theft auto is more entertaining in the comedic sense but red dead redemption has a lot more detail. In my opinion Red Dead Redemption is still better. And I have high hopes for Red Dead Redemption 2. Rock Star has been nailing it lately and i cannot wait.
RDR MP was better than GTA Online, GTA Online became boring after the games creator was released. You can't find death matches anymore ' Cause people started creating parkour stupid maps, all races are with arcade speed-controlled super cars so on... and don't get me started with micro transactions. I had really good times on Gold rush, and other competitive games on RDR
I think GTA 5 actually has more boring missions than people realise. For example every heist requires a bunch of errands to be run before you can do the heist. A lot of Trevors missions felt like a chore with no reward, eg the Merryweather ship heist.
Mr Pickles i loved gta v 1 year ago.Completed game 6 times.Started again when i bought new cpu and ram and I realized that it is definitely boring game and I uninstalled it.Gettingg ps4 soon to play rdr1 and preorder rdr2.I have never played red dead redemption but i want to play it so much
Rdr has better graphics, better physics, better missions. Rockstar in my opinion dropped the ball on Gta 5. They could've made it a lot better than it is. Although, Gta 5 online is pretty fun. Looking forward to Rdr 2, Wild West Online.
honestly, i don't agree with you giving gta 5 the points for gameplay (red dead's gunplay is so much more satisfying and the horse riding is epic) and online mode (its just a cashcow)
This was a great review man! I've played GTA V Online...A LOT, but I never beat the story, to me it's just..uninteresting, but Red Dead Redemption, a game I HAVE NEVER played but have been really wanting to, seemed VERY interesting, not to mention it has a ZOMBIE mode! Yes I'll admit I'm one of those guys, but having such a great standalone expansion with an already solid game just seems better to me. I can't wait to play Red Dead 1 so I can play 2.
For me Red Dead Redemption is a little bit more better then GTA V.GTA V is really good in the Online but in Red Dead Redemption i love the story,and my i love the story and i think is better then the Online.
gta v is my favorite game but i replayed it so many times that it isnt interesting anymore. I'll probably pick rdr1 for sale sometime soon. RDR2 is great but i still prefer gta v over rdr2, hopefully rdr1 changes my mind. EDIT: I finished RDR1 and i have to say, its really great. But i still love gta v more. RDR2 is still better than rdr1 imo(except for gameplay). RDR1 is now my 3rd favorite rockstar game.
@@vegetasticknodes27 Gta 4, Rdr1, Max Payne 3 and Rdr2 are much better than Gta 5. Gta 5 was already a disappointment due to the "downgrading" of the physics.
jagath3028 Really interesting. Gta 4, Rdr1, Max Payne 3 and Rdr2 are much more realistic than Gta 5. Unfortunately, physics (one of the most important things) has been reduced in Gta 5. But still your choice is Gta 5. I respect!
bigwillchill the graphics are from 2010. Try to go into like you’re going into an old game. Expect an old games graphics. If you do that it may pleasantly surprise you
I agree completely with you on story gta v was very messy and didn't feel relatable in a way or grounded I couldn't get connected with these characters and they tie up loose ends so quickly it's so lost in its social commentary that I feel annoyance with it
Kkp B so you're 12 now? Lol little kids like you should not have an opinion on video games. You guys don't know what a good game truly is. Fuck outta here
Jon Boner thinking about it are you trolling? Because there is no way you honestly think it is that unlikely for a kid to start playing rdr when there 5.
Jon Boner well that took a weirdly anti-semitic twist. But anyway, I just find it strange that you'd accuse someone of trolling just because they said they started playing violent games when they were five. I'm not saying you're wrong about young kids playing games like this, but it's just the world we live in now.
I play both of these online for hours just going on a rampage killing other players and that’s fun for me so I can’t pick because GTA V has a futuristic feel and RDR has that Wild West feel so I really can’t pick cause there both fun in their own chaotic way
for me rdr is better in every way
better story better freeroam better character better graphics
kids still saying gta v is better
Yes animation is 1000 percent better than gta 5 random events side missions story way better
schwartzy65, i hope they bring rdr on Android
Joey's mother, why not? we will get gta 4 on Android in 2018 (10 year anevercery), gta 4 and rdr graphics are almost same. so who knows
Joey's mother, just wait and watch, when gta 4 will get released for Android on December 2018 the whole world will stand still and get shocked. then all you console fanboys will bow down to us Mobile fanboys. if we get gta 4 (mark my words it will 100%come) on Android then in just after 1 year in 2019 we will get rdr. in 2023 we will get gta 5 on Android and it will continue, shit never ends bruh
red dead redemption is better in my opinion
Spencer Bridges I agree with you, Red dead redemption is consider to be the greatest game of all time in my opinion
I like red dead redemption way more, it is more enjoyable for me
Same
I like both games.
But red redemption 1 is 6 gb GTA 5 İS 70 gb
Same, gta 5 is my least favorite gta game except for 3
I like rdr1 too because no stripclub and no stripers
John Marston was scarier than all of the GTAV crew
So true
John vs trevor john revolver and trevor sawn off shotgun john shoots trevor trevor is dead michael tries to run over john in a car no john shoots the tire michael slips into a gas tank franklin comes with chop john with a sawn off shotgun shots franklin john wins the fbi and army come shoots him to death
Adam Treloar that was stupid and hard to read
Danald Trimp what
John vs Trevor john make trevor cry
RDR, never got bored from it.
Sammy Higgs I got bored of GTA after 2 months.
Never get bored of RED DEAD REDEMPTION and got GTA 5 😒
I regret buying gta 5 now I want gta sa but I also want rd and minecraft which one should I get?
@depression is for the rich I already got GTA SA tho ur late😂
@depression is for the rich yea
John Marston is great!!!!!!!!!!
The shooting is 10 times better in RDR!
Ola_RM rdr is boring
Broken Matt Hardy [#DELETE] foh??
Karlo Krivokuća It means fuck outta here because your opinion is trash.
p p GTA V Story was so predictable and bland that I got bored of it in the first few hours. Red Dead’s story was emotional and gripping compared to GTA V’s. The only thing I liked about GTA V was it’s gameplay and it’s hours of content. Red Dead in my opinion had the better gameplay which made the game never boring for me.
Just add 10 more “0” behind your that 10
Red dead is way better and I always thought red dead had better gameplay also and I would say gta v has a good multiplayer but red dead has way more fun things to do
I still play rdr and it's still the best game to play.
Magma CD it still works ?
Im playing it too. Jack missions on the way.
Cameron Davis Good idea!
The shooting in rdr is badass. The gun sounds are flawless and the blow back effects of the npcs from being shot seem more realistic and well done. Not bad for a seven year old game.
GTA DOESN'T STAND A CHANCE !!!! RDR HAS A BETTER STORY,IS MORE REALISTIC,VOICES AND EXPRESSIONS ARE ORIGINAL,REACTIONS ARE WAY BETTER THAN GTA 5 OR GTA ,RDR IS THE BEST GAME ROCKSTAR EVER CREATED THAT THE AUDIENCE DONT REALIZE AND JUST LIKE AND PREFER GTA,RDR IS THE BEST WHOS WITHME
I fucking love it.
Umar Soorty Red Dead Redemption is so underrated and thats why its a masterpiece!!
Until RDR2
It is underrated for a reason. The reason is, that gta is better
@The Zexal you know, It's a funny story, but I played rdr since then and now I like it. This is not the first time. There are many more games, I didn't like, until taking a closer look. I'm like this
Red dead redemption also wins when it comes to shooting, in GTA V you do have more weapons but in RDR if you shot someone in both feet they would kneel down and you would shoot them in the head, if you shot them in the elbow the would move like they got shot in the elbow, in GTA V they react very badly, an very similarly no matter where you shoot them.
Franklin Michael and you can shoot the gun of someone hand
yeah, the only bad thing about that is that they eventyally die if you do it too many times haha.
Yeah it's annoying because both games utilize the Euphoria Physics Engine. And for some stupid reason Rockstar decided to tone back Euphorias influence on the ragdolls in GTA 5. I swear to God Rockstar better amp it back up in RDR2 because thats how people died in the old Westerns movies!
LyonoX i now i will be pissed asf
Or it can fall off due to the impact of the bullet no matter where you shoot 'em at.@@yo-yw3xs
red dead is the best!!!
Play Red Dead 2!
rdr is 1000x better than gta v
i like both but prefer rdr💯
plus red dead had am open world zombie dlc lol
rdr: the best game i ever played
Red Dead Redemption was better. The map and environment was realistic, the shooting was better, infinite random events (store robbery, horse theft, stranger that's got his friend/wife kidnapped), hunt and sell skins and meat from animals, Marston was better than the 3 protagonists, story was emotionally amazing. The only downside is you can't swim
Red dead does make you like the character you are playing as, I don't know anyone who does not like him.
Basically duh RDR is better cause it has a way WAY better story and John is better than all the GTA characters combind cause he is the oldest the among all rockstar characters well 2nd as in protagonist, but in GTA you couldn't sell your animal skins like RDR
Red dead redemption win
Read dead redemption is beter. I still play it and I never get bored of it
Red dead is better because
1.BULLET PHYSICS
2.GORE
3.REALISM
freeroam
Realism is for loosers
el hacker oh god 😧
@@ghostargento3241 get a life, dude....
So npc walking againts a wall is realistic
49 Salty GTA V fanboys can not handle the truth.
49 kids
oh look, i found a fangirl!
I like both I can’t chose
so.. i got red dead redemption and GTA V on my ps3, both of those games are fun, but if you played other gta games it will just be boring for you probably, like me, i played GTA IV and San Andreas just the whole Series and gta v is fking boring af for me, RDR is just a 10+ better version of GTA for me, RDR wins for me.
ummm, and yeah, gta v loading is my frickin problem
GTA 5 is the BOMB when u play it the first time - it is boring af in 2019 now
RDR1 I can still play that and enjoy it just as much as I did in 2010
btw RDR2 is the greatest game of all time don't @ me lol
RDR2 still overrelies on GTA 3+4+5 ( Arthur Morgan's movements similar to Claude and Niko Bellic his tuberculosis four endings like forgetable Grand Theft Auto Five Endings ) ( Leopold Strauss' Missions kinda similar to Grand Theft Auto Vice City Opening Scene ) ( Arthur Morgan + John Marston Train Missions kinda similar to Grand Theft Auto San Andreas + Red Dead Revolver ) ua-cam.com/video/gDmHsLNIAos/v-deo.html m.ua-cam.com/video/ksyhV0Yk17o/v-deo.html
Red dead redemption is my favorite game of all time
Same bro💯
Same
Yeah red dead redemption
I HATE GTA V MUTIPLAYER.
Reason 1: There are too much modders in the game and my friend was so angry at this trigger happy!Reason 2: There are pedofiles in mutiplayer (if your child was playing)Reason 3: RDR has more things to do and have different mounts.Reason 4: you have to have a high level to get new guns and stuff :P
I have rest my case... /walks away
Milleviathan best speech ever
literally the worst reasoning I've ever heard about anything ever, even Theresa May stealing her speech from The West Wing was better than that poor excuse for a speech, and I agree RDR is better than GTA, but those reasones were pathetic
GTA 5 is awesome for online but Red Dead redemption has an amazing story. Grand Theft Auto has better weapons but Red dead redemption has better shooting. Grand theft auto is more entertaining in the comedic sense but red dead redemption has a lot more detail. In my opinion Red Dead Redemption is still better. And I have high hopes for Red Dead Redemption 2. Rock Star has been nailing it lately and i cannot wait.
i am looking forward to RDR2 so bad!
I know I am as well a,
red dead 3
I AM ILUMMINATI
I don't understand?
+Fritschge128 in the red dead series it is red dead revolver then red dead redemption then red dead __________
+John Marston alright, didn't think of that. thanks.
Who would win in a duel John or Trevor
John
John of course
RDR is 13 TIMES BETTER THAN GTA 5
what a random number but i don't disagree, so much better than gta 5
More like 13,000,000,000,000,000 times
nah
Red dead redemption is way better. This shouldn't even be debated.
Red Dead Redemption wins , in my opinion RDR is much better then gta V
RDR doesn't make like John's character? A lot of people will tell you they liked him and he is a favorite video game character of a lot of people.
Ah man did rdr2 not exist when this comment came out, arthur morgan is awesome
It's almost time for the 2nd red dead redemption to come out
Joey's mother now 2 months
@@kennycornelis9868 Annnd.....DELAYED!
It's here child
It's here for almost 2 years and released on pc like 8 months ago
This comment is three years old calm down
RDR MP was better than GTA Online, GTA Online became boring after the games creator was released. You can't find death matches anymore ' Cause people started creating parkour stupid maps, all races are with arcade speed-controlled super cars so on... and don't get me started with micro transactions. I had really good times on Gold rush, and other competitive games on RDR
Red dead redemption is better
Right, Rdr is better story, better feelings, better encounters.
Gta is better weapons,better movement. And better speed.
FUCK YEA RED DEAD REDEMPTION I LOVE IT i palyed red dead over over and its fun red dead world is awesome to
I think GTA 5 actually has more boring missions than people realise. For example every heist requires a bunch of errands to be run before you can do the heist. A lot of Trevors missions felt like a chore with no reward, eg the Merryweather ship heist.
Mr Pickles i agree
Mr Pickles i loved gta v 1 year ago.Completed game 6 times.Started again when i bought new cpu and ram and I realized that it is definitely boring game and I uninstalled it.Gettingg ps4 soon to play rdr1 and preorder rdr2.I have never played red dead redemption but i want to play it so much
Are u ok ?
Got a massive poster of bonnie MacFarlane
Best is RED DEAD REDEMPTION ✌✌✌✌
Rdr has better graphics, better physics, better missions. Rockstar in my opinion dropped the ball on Gta 5. They could've made it a lot better than it is. Although, Gta 5 online is pretty fun. Looking forward to Rdr 2, Wild West Online.
my favorit Rockstar game is Red Dead Redemption!!! :)
Me to
honestly, i don't agree with you giving gta 5 the points for gameplay (red dead's gunplay is so much more satisfying and the horse riding is epic) and online mode (its just a cashcow)
For gameplay when it comes down to it I asked myself "which game am I going to put on to show friends and have fun." To me that game is GTA V
You should've put two more points on RED DEAD redemption on #1 Shooting and #2 The Gore
Yeah. Yeah, you're right!!!!!
I played both game's but clearly red dead redemption was wae better in every aspect.
go red dead! whoop gtas hine!!!
I like red dreads story
Red dead redempition
I like how you played The Good The Bad And The Ugly's theme song when RDR wins
I like red dead redemption because GTA 5 is boring but red dead redemption 1&2 are the best and there is a Red Dead redemption 3 coming out
Rdr is so much better it’s just a fantastic story so good it’s a genuine western story
This was a great review man! I've played GTA V Online...A LOT, but I never beat the story, to me it's just..uninteresting, but Red Dead Redemption, a game I HAVE NEVER played but have been really wanting to, seemed VERY interesting, not to mention it has a ZOMBIE mode! Yes I'll admit I'm one of those guys, but having such a great standalone expansion with an already solid game just seems better to me. I can't wait to play Red Dead 1 so I can play 2.
In my opinion both games r great, both has its ups and downs.
OUTLAWS TO THE END!
red dead is way better than gta
Ive played both games and they are so good i dont even know which ones better
Which should i get for my 360 GTA V or rdr?
For me Red Dead Redemption is a little bit more better then GTA V.GTA V is really good in the Online but in Red Dead Redemption i love the story,and my i love the story and i think is better then the Online.
Both are great games...RDR is my favorite of the 2. Probably my favorite game since the SNES days. Can't wait for RDR 2.
Im on my second playthrough of rdr2. Its amazing 🤩 the end is so sad tho oop xd
Red dead is way better in every single way
I like red dead redemption
Win RDR
gta v is my favorite game but i replayed it so many times that it isnt interesting anymore. I'll probably pick rdr1 for sale sometime soon. RDR2 is great but i still prefer gta v over rdr2, hopefully rdr1 changes my mind.
EDIT: I finished RDR1 and i have to say, its really great. But i still love gta v more. RDR2 is still better than rdr1 imo(except for gameplay). RDR1 is now my 3rd favorite rockstar game.
To be honest no game can beat gta 5
@@vegetasticknodes27 Gta 4, Rdr1, Max Payne 3 and Rdr2 are much better than Gta 5.
Gta 5 was already a disappointment due to the "downgrading" of the physics.
jagath3028
Really interesting.
Gta 4, Rdr1, Max Payne 3 and Rdr2 are much more realistic than Gta 5.
Unfortunately, physics (one of the most important things) has been reduced in Gta 5.
But still your choice is Gta 5.
I respect!
@@MinecraftvsBurnout sabre nafa'2
i wanna buy and play this game in 2018. ive played gta 4 and 5. do you think ill like it or will the graphics put me off? how are the graphics?
bigwillchill the graphics are from 2010. Try to go into like you’re going into an old game. Expect an old games graphics. If you do that it may pleasantly surprise you
@@Sirnekk i just bought it and played the first couple missions. i like it so far
i was hoping this wouldve included the shooting mechanics
Rdr 100%
Anyone here to feel how much better gta 6 is gonna be than rdr2
Love Red Dead
gameplay is better in rdr1
I agree completely with you on story gta v was very messy and didn't feel relatable in a way or grounded I couldn't get connected with these characters and they tie up loose ends so quickly it's so lost in its social commentary that I feel annoyance with it
Gta online is better than rdr multiplayer.
RED DEAD REDEMPTION multiplayer is the best
I mean RDR win but you put 2 points to gta v its oh man.....
GTA V has really died down after a while because of Red Dead Redemption II and you can free style in both games so I can't choose.
Red Dead also has Undead Nightmare. GTA V never got any single player dlc.
J gta 4 did
RDR OBVIOUSLY
ive been playin gta v for a while and i got red dead today and itbis so damn goof
Rdr is awesome gta is fun but fells rushed
I also found that the shooting and the control's are way better in red dead redemption than gta5.
Red dead redemption is a better game i love it and the main character
Rdr is better than gta v
ref dead redemption
i love red dead it was my first game i ever played p.s i was 5 when i played it and i still play it
Kkp B so you're 12 now? Lol little kids like you should not have an opinion on video games. You guys don't know what a good game truly is. Fuck outta here
Jon Boner like it or not 5 year olds know about video games to, especially if they have older siblings.
Jon Boner also have you ever played any multiplayer game ever? Cuz like half those people are straight up babies.
Jon Boner thinking about it are you trolling? Because there is no way you honestly think it is that unlikely for a kid to start playing rdr when there 5.
Jon Boner well that took a weirdly anti-semitic twist. But anyway, I just find it strange that you'd accuse someone of trolling just because they said they started playing violent games when they were five. I'm not saying you're wrong about young kids playing games like this, but it's just the world we live in now.
RDR is better than the GTA V, but I prefer SA over both of them.
Did anyone else go into the comments to see if there are 12 year old gta fans that make no sense
you could have added another point for gameplay mechanics, where the shooting and generally operating john is far better than anything in gta 5
for this top i suscribe to this channel
I have them both and i still play red dead
rdr is better
i enjoy both, but i do feel like red dead is more special, since there is only 1, and there is a lot of gta, and gta like games
Rdr has a better story
2 games are my favourite games ever
YEAH I KNEW RED DEAD REDEMPTION WAS BETTER THATS Y ITS MY FAVORITE GAME
Gta always has a corny who cares story and so much space with no where 2 really go into red dead is by far better
Did not see that coming
love both of them but after playing them i would say that gta is more kid oriented and rdr is for older gamers
Rdr way way better than gta5
I play both of these online for hours just going on a rampage killing other players and that’s fun for me so I can’t pick because GTA V has a futuristic feel and RDR has that Wild West feel so I really can’t pick cause there both fun in their own chaotic way