Carrie: Riverdale vs REAL production of Carrie
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 чер 2019
- Riverdale did an episode where the "students" did a production of the musical Carrie, so, I wanted to compare it myself to one of my favorite productions of it (The Balagan theatre production in Seattle) instead of comparing to the original Off- Broadway production.
I wish they didn't put so much autotune on "Carrie" from Riverdale. Madelaine would sound SO much better if there wasn't as much.
We do stan Toni being a supportive girlfriend in that scene tho
i cant believe how much they autotuned everyone bc they are all semi-decent without autotune but.....yikes
at least it wasnt as bad as heathers.
The thing is Madelaine is actually a really good singer
Because some of them can’t sing they didn’t sign up to sing on this show
Bruh her autotune was terrible
Yas! I agree with every word of that comment!
Surely Cheryl isn’t THAT much of a terrible singer that they have to make her sound like a vocaloid with all that autotune??
A lot of them sound like vocaloid lol
Madelaine is actually a really good singer they apparently auto tuned it so it would sound like a high schooler sang it
She sounds like a robot in this
Hi I wanna say hi I- I don’t even wanna know why they would do that, there are high schoolers who have amazing voices
Doodle dragons Toucans she’s actually a great singer , riverdale just auto tuned the hell out of them
the auto tune on river sales carrie makes me want to ducking scream
Lmao is that Ayuwoki as your pfp?
Duh
CryingTissues it’s a screenshot from a video of a scary michael jackson robot
Jaxon Knapp Yeah I saw that video😔
Same it’s so damn obvious
Notice how the Riverdale actors aren't horrible Singers the auto tune just makes their voices ten times worse.
Also notice how Riverdale’s story was good in theory, but then the directors decided to have a brain malfunction and made it a meme
The sad part is some of the cast (Cami, Lili, Casey and K.J. for example) can actually sing really well, but Riverdale decides to use auto tune anyways.
Anne Boelyn I think technically they had to autotune KJ, he doesn’t have an American accent, so he had to sing in an American accent which is hard enough as it is.
Sofia Lopez Makes sense
Lili*
Esther. O thanks! I’m just bad at spelling lol
I agree.
And this is somehow their best musical episode🤷♀️
Thelma Taco they only did 3 so not much to base off.
Right heathers were terrible Cheryl butchered candy store with all that dam autotune and they replaced pussy with doorknob they be acting like they can't say it when they have sex in almost every episode
Robloxsprinklez apparently saying that would’ve changed their age rating to MA instead of TV-14 it’s stupid because they have sex in the show and can’t say one word but they didn’t want their audience to leav e
It gets worse
Fr. It’s HORRIBLE but the other ones are worse
The way Cheryl sang Carrie should’ve been more vulnerable rather than powerful.
AGREED!!! The song is supposed to show how afraid Carrie is of her classmates, but Cheryl just sounds overly confidant...
And not literally a robot .-.
I think it should be a mix like more powerful and frustrated at the beginning considering you begin the song on a relatively high belt but grow to be more vulnerable then back to powerful as she sings they will know her name it’s a journey song and should not be one note
That's how she was meant to do it bcz cherly doesn't like being vulnerable she wasn't meant to sing in vunerable
e that there is definitely too much auto tune, but in the moment in the show, cheryl was trying to prove that she was worthy of the lead part. so the way she sang it with power rather that vulnerability, made sense in the moment.
I can’t help but laugh every time I see Archie dance like who let him on set
(Edit: oh my god thank you for so many likes)
Bella Luscombe he is not that badd
Berta 009 you’re right I just think it’s funny
Berta 009 yes he is
They take him because there was no one better, at first they didnt want to take him but other people were worse so they take him. i know it because i used to liked riverdale, idk why. Im sorry for that
Us kiwis suck at dancing 😂
I’m just still confused as to why they gave the “It’s the least we deserve after everything we’ve paid” line to Alice lol
Parents pay for prom usually lol
adrian piedra true but Betty’s mom was initially very against Betty sleeping with jughead so why does she want these random teenage boys to get laid
@@cee2485
I think she was just grumbling about the financial cost. Consider it two different conversations in different locations. She is only thinking about how much the prom cost. Some proms are much more expensive. The hospital bills, funeral expenses because some idiot drank alcohol then drove. The boys are only thinking about having a good time
lol true but like she married a serial killer
rachel head FPs not a serial killer lol
why do they keep picking musicals with incredibly difficult vocals when everyone on the show has the range of selena gomez
Lindsey Bean LMAO
literally only kevin seems to have the vocals for musicals , unless he’s gonna be singing entire the time, i don’t wanna hear it lol
I DONT SPOT A SINGLE LIE
Lmaoooo
Actually a lot of the cast can sing really well. All you have to do is look up a video of them.
okay, I'm confused... Riverdale is about teens in high school, in gangs, with a murder mystery and some weird king AND they are in the theatre club?
Britt Verbist basically
I really think the producers be on crack or something cause like riverdale went from a teen drama to a murder mystery to a musical like wtf
Bee.astard oh yeah I forgot about that but still their not consistent with what kinda show they wanna be I prefer my murder mysteries without singing
there’s literally no plot at this point it’s just “creative liberty”
don’t forget when they all joined a cult 😭
I think the biggest issue with Riverdales version is that the characters are just calmly “singing” at the top of their lungs. It makes it so much more obvious that they aren’t actually singing and it just jarring to see people look like they’re whispering to themselves while the audio has them screaming at the top of their lungs
Yeah like in "In" you can obviously tell Betty is lip syncing and it's weird
I can't not laugh when cheryl sings, they auto tuned her so much she went like a semitone down, I-
also I refuse to believe that this entire school doesn't have theatre kids apart from Kevin, they had to get jocks to play the main parts AND THERE WAS A MOTHER IN THE CAST WHAT
Madelaine singing “CAUURRIEEEEE” sounds so forced thank to the auto tune and reminds me of fetus James singing Bruno Mars lol
RIGHT LMAOAOAOAOAO
No one:
Not a single person:
Not any living thing in planet:
Riverdale sound effects: *swoosh* *thump*
The others I can understand, but how can you prefer riverdale’s “Carrie” (the song). It’s auto tuned beyond recognition and odd way they did the vowels made it sound like it was a text-to-speech with how the lines deflated at the end
Riverdale did it better
@@Popcornstar18... Listen to the Broadway cast recording for the musical lmao
@@Popcornstar18 [everyone disliked that]
Side_of_Sour _Grapes if u listen to the non auto tune version it is still better
@@Popcornstar18 thank you
Why is riverdale’s world according to Chris in a school set? Like there were lockers and stuff but that’s supposed be a party...?
Because they couldn’t be bothered introducing and having a new set made
because the show is about teenagers so ofc there gonna be in a school setting and it's a school musical for them so there gonna be in the school for most of it
Alex no name, well I’m in Carrie the Musical rn and the song doesn’t take place in school. That’s what I meant. They should’ve changed set pieces!! Have you done theatre? It’s takes about 60 seconds to change a set background and Riverdale is popular tv show so I think they have enough money to make another set. If they are going to do a musical then they should do it right, and if a party scene is “too inappropriate” for their viewers well A) maybe they should do a different musical and B) I’ve seen worse on Riverdale!! They have sex and parties all the time so...
Jade Warner I agree completely
Jade Warner i’m sure that alex no name meant that riverdale is a show about teenagers and the teens are doing the musical at school so the setting is at school on the theater auditorium stage
I swear most of the people that prefer Riverdale probably have never listened to other performances of Carrie other than the one shown. And even then, these are just short clips. The overall performance is awesome, I especially like this theatre version of The Destruction's scene, Keaton did such a good job at that scene.
I prefer riverdale. And I’ve seen the entire Carrie performance. Yes, it was still great. But I personally prefer the riverdale version
I only know Carrie as a horror film and the only musicals I see are movies.
@@whatisgoingonbruh_ not to be mean but you are very wrong
Madame Corgi it their opinion not yours
Madame Corgi Uhm. An opinion can’t be wrong- it’s a way of thinking. You need to get over it lmao
keaton whittaker is so talented- riverdale is doing carrie DIRTY
WHAT!?😠
Hayley Allman dont even fucking lie 💀💀
@@Popcornstar18 What do you mean "What", it's the truth and you know it lmao
i even like the carrie episode, but riverdale did do carrie dirty
You guys are doing everything dirty
BUT SOMEDaaaaaYYY *OH MY SOME DAY*
Does it bother anyone else that at 6:32 the audience can TOTALLY see the cast people in the wings?
Yes! As a theatre kid I would get yelled at for standing in the line of sight.
As a stage manager, I had a mini seizure
The dancer in me screeched
Yes hahah
I cringeeeed
No one:
Literally no one:
Kevin: »There's nothing more amateur than inappropriate age casting«
* Josie is the PE teacher *
I remember seeing a video on why the music in the Disney remakes suck and in that video they brough up how much Disney autotuned Emma Watson's voice to make it sound like theres no flaws (even though she did say that she legitimately auditioned for the role so she can most likely sing) and how it removes all the personality and emotion from the song (then they say why the original is good at not doing that as you can hear Paige O'Hara smiling at some points) and I feel like they did exactly that for all of the Riverdale musicals. A lot of the cast can actually sing, we know that, its just they've been autotuned to sound "perfect" that we don't feel anything from what they're singing, especially when you compare it to the live recording of Carrie in which you can see the cast members giving it all even if the recorded version is a dress rehearsal.
Sideways' video! I actually appreciate the animated movie's Little Town a lot more after I heard what he said about Paige O'Hara's performance (not that I didn't before). But I agree, I think some people don't understand that musical singing is a balance of both emotion and vocal control. If you get too emotional, it's really easy to lose vocal control, but if it's too controlled and "perfected", the emotion isn't there anymore. In a show like Riverdale (heavily edited and all), there's little to no chance of it sounding nearly as raw as a live production. It just doesn't fit, and I think they should stop trying to do everything, or at least consult a vocal coach or someone who works in theatre next time (if they already have, they clearly didn't do their job properly).
Emma NEVER auditioned. The director said they picked her from the start
I love the seattle production
Jared Porikos same
Jared Porikos me too.
Same Keaton is so good as Carrie
Sue was falling flat though...
I prefer the Riverdale cast, Even if there's an autotune, it's their voices. Don't say they're just false voices.
I get people like the studio version cuz even I’ll admit I’ll get annoyed when I can’t hear words clearly and have to listen to a recording to hear and understand them but there is no chance anyone could think Keaton’s version of “Carrie” is worse. Girl definitely ripped her vocal chords for that kinda belting power plz give respect where it’s due.
A technically talented singer doesn't rip her vocal chords🙄 unless she didn't get enough rest for her voice. Belting can be done in a healthy way, and that was not it.
ok thea
@@theagaram9581 technically talented singers DO mess up their vocal chords. laura bell bundy who played elle woods on broadway could not do a good belt at the end of her broadway run because it was so high for her. and there’s so many other examples of that type of thing happening
Can we just talk about how amazing the Seattle production is for a second?
It’s incredible
Ethel and Chuck actually have good voices what-
riverdale: autotune
actual musical: pure talent
"You've been praying for that since the seventh grade." was nicer in Riverdale than in the official one.
My ears on the real one started bleeding, god bless that girl s can’t sing 😭
I know
Serenz Side could have just been nerves. The power was there, the intonation was not.
ikr, but that was the only thing that was. also, it was probably taken multiple times, while the live production was taken once
I mean this was certainly an improvement from heathers. But still full of autotune and weird set ups. But at least I actually liked some of the songs in this one. Will always prefer an actual raw musical than a show but oh well.
BlockyLZ they did Carrie before heathers, and boy, did the downgrade suck
Yes, exactly
Archies face during a night we’ll never forget was amazing 😂😂 4:37
I’m dead inside I feel like he had the most fun 😅
Ew- Are really comparing Keaton’s vocals to that auto-tuned mess?
Carralié Alice Whitewood they’re not. The Riverdale version is highly auto tuned and awful😂Keaton has an amazing voice and is so much better than that crap😂
@@bakedbeansontoast487 I agree. The autotune really ruined it...They would've been decent
Tbh I think that Camila (Veronica) did a good job in The World According to Chris
me too. she sounded pretty good and her voice fit it well.
I agree but I think the musical version was so charismatic and the girl playing Chris was so talented I could listen to her everyday. She ended miz Luna tbh
Samesies obviously the production is better but I really think the character of chris really fits veronica.
Midges voice 🥺 I feel like she would have a good raw voice.
who ever likes the riverdale one more than the Seattle one only knows carrie because of riverdale.
ivy wallace I heard of the Carrie musical through Riverdale, I knew of the story though. But I like every other rendition of Carrie more than the riverdale version.
False, I knew Carrie far before I knew riverdale. And I prefer riverdales version.
I like the riverdale version better even though they sound fake af
It has mystery and I like that 🤪
I read carrie the book :) I wanna watch the movie but I'm waiting for another year.
oliviA the p o t a t o e ugh I love the book so much 😩
I hate how Carie was played by river dale. It’s not the acting it’s just that Carie is supposed to be an outcast weirdo that’s not exactly attractive and that is what makes Carie so relatable to people. That is what makes us feel for her. Not an already gorgeous girl that has what she wants. Just bugged me a little.
Riverdale did it well!😠
Hayley Allman I’m not saying they did it bad I’m just saying I don’t like how they portrayed Carie. It felt forced.
@@Popcornstar18 Well, it's not about the execution, it's the reason behind the whole of Carrie. The whole POINT of Carrie's character is that she's dislikable at first sight because she looks and acts weird, but she has a heart of gold. It's why she goes insane, she's taken advantage of on her best moment and she can't handle it anymore
Well everyone in Riverdale is gorgeous so I don’t know what else you expected. But I agree.
Jen Sanaa I expect them NOT to preform Carrie. Anything but Carrie.
Ya'll are gonna kill me but I kinda like Riverdale's version of "In". But just as an alternative. Because the original is still as amazing as ever.
On another note, the "That's not my name" on Riverdale frickin hurt my ears. I definitely prefer the theatre version specifically for that one line, sorry I'm picky :c
For Do Me A Favor, it definitely lacked emotion on Chris'part. (I'm mentally comparing everything and some of the differences are astoundingly huge)
I don't think it sounds bad either, especially after seeing how it can get with "Carrie" and... most of the songs in the Heathers episode
just from the clip heard in this "in" doesn't sound that bad it's just flat and like emotionless
The Carrie makes me want to scream!!! Let me just say though Heathers was muchhhhhhhhhhh worse! I also think that The world according to Chris was the only one that wasn’t bad at all!
Also I think the version of the Keaton Carrie you used was the rehearsal (Ik in the episode most of the clips are rehearsal but they recorded it in a studio so like)
Most of the cast have really good voices, the creators just auto tuned them way to much.
I think it was because they keep choosing musicals with vocals out of the cast’s range (because you know, that is the obvious decision)
Wait-
They don't have the destruction?
Niels Ichijo because nobody can sing
Because it doesn't make sense in Riverdale's context... Which is ridiculous because Riverdale literally made these for clout
No Midge gets murdered before they can
Honestly Awful they sing the songs completely out of order. they put evening prayers as the first song in the show because they did in already
no because in riverdale the girl who played carrie was killed by the murderer in the show and it led up to the mystery so they never actually performed the show...
i don’t rlly understand why people prefer the riverdale version. u can literally listen to the autotune in the songs, principally in the last note of carrie and in all the alice parts. u can listen that their voices sound rlly metallic, and that’s who u can listen to the autotune. it’s sad, cause some people of there can sing, like casey, lili and camilla. but the production put autotune in some stupid things. like, i think they put autotune in the last note of carrie to cut the vibrato of her voice, cause ir looks so flat and metallic. is rlly strange...
but we all have to understand that the seattle version was in live and had no autotune, so we had to see that voice cracks are rlly normal, because they sing like all nights!
if they didnt put so much autotune in then it would be so good
@@xgoose3 I’m sure it wouldn’t have
Cause they never watch and experience the triumph and the epic-ness of musical theatre
And the voice cracks only make it better! I legitimately feel that the voice cracks are what make Keaton's Destruction the true version! It legitimately sounds like she's crying out, and it's usually just belted.
they auto tuned it a lot. they aren’t bad singers, they surely didn’t need that much
That seattle productions carrie is the best one ive ever heard, shes just so raw and i feel her characters pain
I love Keaton’s voice, she is such a good embodiment of Carrie. She sounded a bit vocally exhausted in her clip of Carrie but belting like that is bound to cause days where your voice isn’t at its best. Cheryl’s Carrie is not it. I understand they wanted to do Carrie but it’s a high show and if your actors can’t hit the notes then pick something else. Taking Carrie down the octave is just...no
i think the strain really adds to carrie it suits her
Ngl this is their best musical episode and i still hate this...also i just noticed this is the only musical episode where it's actually a musical production
when did riverdale become great value glee
riverdale trys so hard, but can never compare to what glee was
Riverdale could never beat glee in a million years
If glee was still on, I’d love for them to do these musicals, considering the cast can actually sing...
Omg I miss glee sm
@@cyberelf0080 the riverdale cast are amazing singers...the autotune really messed it up
I feel like a lot of the casts voice’s aren’t bad but if they really want to do musical episodes they should choose songs that actually suit their voices and lose all that auto-tune lol
Oh Riverdale really did Evening Prayers and Carrie dirty 😷😷
I forgot Riverdale did Carrie, I’m still not over The Heathers horror scene🤦🏾♀️
Why is Betty’s mom in a high school musical???????????
Kevin said that "there's nothing more amateur than inappropriate age casting" lol
Malu Vieira Elesbão but it’s a HIGHSCHOOL production... not a “anyone with a mediocre vocal range who fits the character’s description and lives in riverdale” production 🙄
@@cyberelf0080 that's on kevin I guess lmao
@@maluvieiraelesbao4270 daldksfjalfjldskjflaksjf josie is Mrs G lmaooo
Let’s be honest though, Lily Reinhart is an amazing singer
I REALLY wish this was the only musical episode on Riverdale. You know a show’s run it’s course when it starts making musical episodes a regular thing.
“Better to screw, then get screwed” is she a top
They actually do a pretty good job with The World According to Chris. There’s not as much auto tune and the editing is great.
also i can’t hear this song without the harmonies
Remember when archie was the only one who sang
I feel like in the river dale version they're so concerned with making everything perfect and beautiful, and through that the emotions get lost and it feels less real and ugly to me
i love archie’s little dance for some reason
What you've done here is great. I've worked in musical theatre from 1974 to 2015, and have been a collector of musicals of all sorts for several decades now. I kind of do this same thing when I pop on a cast recording. I usually listen to two or more recordings of a show to see how numbers are changed from one production to the next. What you have done here is very much appreciated. So, thank you for taking the time to put this comparison together. Also, I have the video of the Balagan Theatre production of "Carrie", and have to admit that it's one of the best amateur productions I've come across. And, I have to say that same thing about their production of "Annie" as well.
It's great to know that there are others out there who actually appreciate this musical. I find it sad that such an amazing musical has never received the acclaim and respect that so long overdue, simply because Stephen King wrote the story.
Thank you for this video it’s amazing
I know this a comparison video, but does anyone else think the fact that a parent is in the dressing room would ruin the fun kind of. It’s always so fun for my group when we have no adults in there with us cause we just bust out any song we want.
riley hietla I agree!
As someone who watches Riverdale (shudder) and follows the cast, I will say a lot of them actually have good voices. I don't think the song Carrie is best for Madelaine's range, but I thought she sounded lovely in the You Shine reprise. Also that show adds so much autotune it's ridiculous. And the choreo is the Heathers ep is.... something else.
The mothers voice in Seattle is haunting 🤍
4:16 was a nice I liked it, when she sang the line it was autotuned but it sounded cute
THANK YOU I've been replaying just the line
The actual Carrie production is far better for a number of reasons but I rlly do wish it wasn’t modernized, it taking place in the 80s just made more sense ya know?
Totally agreed. The modern version looks too much Next To Normal or any other angsty teen-family drama. The weird costumes and 80s sound of the original made it stand out.
4:16 was honestly the only well sung line in all of riverdale and guess what they did to that character.......
Alice Mc frrrrr
Exactly what I was thinking, the best singer in the episode
Midge was an incredible singer and I cants top replaying and then the real version just was almost a disgrace, my ears are bleeding 😭😭
They have that same running into the auditorium shot every musical episode and it makes my cry
I like the live show but the river dale version of the world according to chris bops
Claire A Covers facts
Riverdale really finds a way to ruin my day, props to the actors for not leaving the show yet
Seems almost unfair to compare riverdales version of evening prayers to Alice Ripley
YES THE SEATTLE VERSION HELL YES! That's the version that got me into the musical and the movie, and book. And it's one of my favorite properties.
The audio from Riverdale makes me wanna cry. And the choreography. The butchering.
I love Kj Apa clicking and waving his hands everywhere when the riverdale version comes on
the fact that literally every song got copywritten has me so dead
wdum? they obvs got permission to do it?
Hannah McMillan i’m talking ab the youtube video not riverdale haha
So! I'm going into this completely blind! I have yet to watch the episode/Riverdale as a whole or Carrie so I'm here to give an unbiased opinion! Well, as unbiased as possible, I still have war flashbacks from the Heathers episode.
1rst clip Riverdale: Not too bad a singing though the girl in purple sounded slightly slurry or stuffed.
1rst clip Seattle: The harmonies were pretty good! Also, it looks like there's supposed to be a wider view from everyone instead of just two girls which I find interesting.
1rst clip: Overall I think both a decently even, though Seattle gives more world depth then Riverdale.
2nd clip Riverdale: The shorter girl was actually pretty good! It's just that the taller girl's voice contrasted with the shorter girl's voice because (I think) it was in head voice. I dunno it just sounded odd together. Though the choreography is MUCH better than whatever Heather's episode was. At least it is for now.
2nd clip Seattle: Oh wow! Both of the girl's singing was so checking talented! Also, Their harmonies work so much better! It's also important for me to mention that there is a lot more emotion with these two girls. Or at least, with the goth girl she seems more fired up and confident than the double sad Riverdale was going for.
2nd Clip: Overall, Seattle wins this one because of the better harmony and overall emotion, though Riverdale's version wasn't awful.
3rd clip Riverdale: Ok so the pronunciation for the song is weird as heck. It sounds super blunt, kind of like she's trying to portray a child singer. Also, there's little to no emotion in her singing as well as facial expression. It bothers me quite a bit.
3rd clip Seattle: Oh my! Her singing voice is so beautiful and satisfying to listen to! I absolutely love the facial execution and all the emotion portrayed in her voice!
3rd clip: Overall, Seattle won by a landslide, their character actually showed emotion instead of just singing. I also can't get over how weirdly the girl in Riverdale pronounced their lyrics.
4rth clip Riverdale: Yet again lack of emotions is there. The singing is better than the previous clip and the choreography was actually really fun to watch but everyone looked so serious and dead inside. The girl looked more pissed than smug and it threw off the vibe of the scene.
4rth clip Seattle: Ok this cast has some amazing voice talent! Also there so much emotion! It's really fun to watch and I'd honestly love to play this girl's character if I ever got the chance. There's also more participation from the other characters. You can tell who the scene is highlighting but the other characters still act like people and not mindless backups.
4rth clip: Overall Seattle definitely won! There's so much more to watch and enjoy than Riverdale's tired and emotionless version of the scene.
5th clip Riverdale: Ohh oh no... that lack of emotion is just... wow. So, what I also noticed is how NO ONE sounds really that excited, it sounds like they're trying to sound excited but they also don't feel like trying to sound excited. It's super distracting from what the scene is supposed to be, which sucks because the faces are actually pretty good this time. With the exception of the girl in the purple robe.
5th clip Seattle: Yes! Excitement is what we need here! I do think some of the voices sound a bit off together but it's not that distracting. The people sound like they're actually holding witty conversations and it's nice to see them get excited over what I'm going to assume is a party.
5th clip: Overall Seattle won by a LANDSLIDE, it seems that the further I go into this, the worse Riverdale becomes, which is interesting because the songs get more interesting as the story progresses so you'd THINK they'd try to pick up their act.
6th clip Riverdale: Not too bad, the emotion was there, it was pretty good. They seemed like they actually care for each other which seems to be the point of the entire song. The red head's voice sounded a bit awkward with the other girl's voice, though, that could be because of the male to female vocals needing to be changed.
6th clip Seattle: Oh I really hope this doesn't turn out to be like a JD and Veronica situation because I love how cute they act together! There seems to be really good chemistry between them and it's so cute to see how they look and giggle at each other!
6th clip: Overall, Seattle tips the Iceberg for top, only because there's just more chemistry that goes on between the two characters in that scene. It's just, so cute. Riverdale's wasn't awful though.
7th clip Riverdale: So the lack of emotion here is SO evident that it's not even funny. As soon as I heard Seattle's version I was shocked to see how there was SO much more sorrow in the other woman's song! Riverdale's looks so fake, and dead that it just makes me uncomfortable to watch.
7th clip Seattle: I love, so much emotion and sorrow form both parties, I can't even comprehend how much better it is than Riverdale's because the older woman actually sounds sorrowful!
7th clip: Overall, Seattle won this one on such a higher margin that it's not even a competition. There was so much more personality put into their version that Riverdale is barely noticeable!
8th clip Riverdale: Oh boy there is so much wrong with this scene. The choreography was really weird, like, why did they run into the auditorium and just sit in a circle of chairs? The hand movements and chair choreography were just strange. Also, the camera is in a super weird place above the circle. The amount of autotune used is just... outstanding, like, seriously why?
8th clip Seattle: Pretty voices all around! And I love love LOVE that choreography! It was just so fun to watch and well-executed in general.
8th clip: Overall, Seattle won because it was well executed and they didn't need fancy camera shots to look cool.
So, yeah, the Seattle version is amazing and I need to go listen to the Carrie soundtrack. Riverdale wasn't too bad this time, at least not compared to the outstandingly bad Heather's episode they tried to pull. Anyways, dunno if anyone will care to read this through but it now exists for your viewing pleasure.
It was so interesting to read, I'm amazed! Thank you.
This is literally my FAVORITE production of Carrie😍 my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE
I loved the Balagan production! It was one of the best that I've seen!
Lmao the difference between evening prayers 😭😭
It's seriously terrified me The musical is much better
tbh the only better song was either the world according to chris (barely) or In (just because the actual cast sounded unnatural.)
The Seattle production is my favorite!!!
woah the world according to chris from the stage production is amazing
Yeah it just makes you want to sing and then you remember there are people around
The Riverdale version is a mess, but I do kinda enjoy Veronica and Betty as Chris and Sue in Do Me a Favor and The World According to Chris
Where'd you get the clips for the musical from. All I've seen is the horrible quality one
When they ran into the theatre and did the circle thing it made me want to cry
I love how in the song Carrie at the end Cheryl has absolutely no vibrato while the Seattle production it’s beautiful
For me, i have know Carrie with Riverdale. But i prefer the real version. The version Riverdale is like a makeup of the musical and i hate that. But thanks for Riverdale, because i know the musicals now. Like in Heathers, the story of a girl writing suicides notes in love with a guy who want burn their school.
Riverdale was just give me the way to go at the world of musicals.
This is my opinion.
To be fair on the cast, they are asked to sing musical songs which are quite hard if you aren’t a simger
Good job! They're both very good Carrie Musicals. I love what you've done. :) i know im looking at this a whole entire year later. HEHE. sorry.
I think the biggest reason Cheryl sounds the way she does is that they lowered the key. Her voice became dark and heavy and "robotic" sounding because while she may have not been able to do the original key of the song because it is so high, they clearly gave her a key that was so drastically low it didn't do her voice any justice. If they had just decided to give her some lessons with the song or choose a more appropriate key, it wouldn't sound like the slowmo filter on snapchat.
Everybody makes fun of Riverdale and yet this show actually kept me interested
Yes the show is really good
Personally, I think Riverdale did Carrie the Musical pretty well. Heathers is....oof
Mish Y I liked them both
@@Ellie-ix5qc Its treason then
yeah riverdale's heathers was a total mess.
I feel like somehow the songs actually fit the characters and showed different sides of them. And that applies to both Carrie and heathers. But they don’t really do them well. (Heathers). I feel like Carrie did more for the plot, cause it was semi understandable and they actually had an effective plot. But S3 was a train wreck anyways
ok but i did not expect that wii opening and i love it
Yeaaaaah finally one with the Carrie one :D
i had to take my headphones out for riverdales singing bits
Also we need a Carrie the Musical movie with Shannon Purser as Carrie like ASAP
Nah she’d be better in a actual movie version based on the novel , not the musical.
it's crazy how this is still lightyears better than their heathers musical episode
okay but the balagan theatre's carrie is SO POWERFUL like THAT BELT DAMN
This is for Riverdale: please stop using musicals. It makes me uncomfortable. Thank you
Sometimes I get frustrated because Riverdale did a production of Carrie and they didn't include The Destruction then I remember how dirty they did the other songs and I think "eh it's probably for the best."
I want a public apology from Riverdale’s choreographer for making KJ do that old man jig.
I only love the Riverdale version is because it sounds more pleasing to the ear with all of the music in the background. I know that a lot of it is auto tuned but still. The Seattle production sometimes sounded off