The Tragedy of Newstead’s absence

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лют 2024
  • Jason Newstead retired his position as bassist for Metallica in 2001.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 157

  • @sandrab7216
    @sandrab7216 Місяць тому +29

    I will always miss Jason in Metallica😢 it will always be a before and after

  • @novemberzed9163
    @novemberzed9163 Місяць тому +52

    Beat the fan out of him? If that was REALLY the problem (and not your own narcissism) why didn´t you get someone else then? Absolute degenerates.
    I love this band, but the kind of narcissism and downright psychopathy from Lars and James is sickening. Jason really gave it his all, and the amount of hard work, blood and sweat he put into this band was even beyond Cliff´s and even Rob´s efforts. Rob got in, was showered with immediate respect and praise before he even did anything, and got 1 million dollars just because...reason, or more like: Hey dont judge us for what we did to the old guy. We are "the good guys" ya know.
    Jason didn't get a penny for joining Metallica and had to work his ass off and give 1000+ percent to get any recognition.
    They were absolute tools. No wonder they didn´t manage to make an album like And Justice For All, or the black album again. Even Load and Reload are better than the garbage they have put out in the last 20 years.

    • @dalibosch5028
      @dalibosch5028 Місяць тому +8

      You make good points. They explain with so many words...they were basically turds. Jason earned his stripes and FILLED the shoes! That's what pissed them even more i think...

    • @cinnamongirl5410
      @cinnamongirl5410 24 дні тому +2

      Lars is lame and he knows it.

  • @FxsX24
    @FxsX24 Місяць тому +45

    Jason, leaving the band created the Metallica the Jason deserved

    • @barbaradykes7231
      @barbaradykes7231 Місяць тому +1

      Jason was really really cool with me

    • @jerrygallo8314
      @jerrygallo8314 29 днів тому +1

      metallica last good album is AJFA so no

    • @halla359
      @halla359 27 днів тому +2

      @@jerrygallo8314 According to you maybe, i like most of their albums

    • @cinnamongirl5410
      @cinnamongirl5410 24 дні тому +1

      Jason leaving the band created the Metallica that Metallica deserves. Not much exciting has come from them in years.

  • @Libraneast
    @Libraneast Місяць тому +29

    Metallica became the giant band that it is, thanks to the presence of Newsted, with Burton the Black Album would never have existed. The Grammy they lost with AJFA was a lesson that Hetfield and Ulrich had to learn, never lower the volume on the bass.

    • @midnight347
      @midnight347 Місяць тому +2

      That is a bunch of fn nonsense lol. Ppl in 88 were not bitching and moaning about a lack of bass that is a modern internet trend. And Metallica became the band they were because of the great songs James and Lars wrote with some occasional stuff from cliff kirk and Jason (3 tunes total for the ladder). That's what made Metallica great and why they're still great. They succeeded before and after Jason. You know why? Because it's about James and lars always has been.

    • @cinnamongirl5410
      @cinnamongirl5410 24 дні тому +1

      Exactly.

    • @oldfart6938
      @oldfart6938 12 днів тому +1

      Well.. i was 7 when the Black Album dropped… i listened to the old album as well… as a 9 year old back then i thought the first few albums sucked… not of because thrash vs black album..
      After i ve grown up and learned to play guitar.. i learned i didnt like them cuz of lack of bass man.. the FOUNDATION of a song!!
      Now i luv em.. cuz of the edited version on YT with Bass 🤘🏽🔥

    • @Brer247i
      @Brer247i 20 годин тому

      @@midnight347 LOL, Nonsense. The lowering of the bass has always been the main issue about that album.

  • @mackin26
    @mackin26 Місяць тому +33

    Rob sitting there listening to how his predecessor’s predecessor cannot be replaced.

  • @juancarlosrivas6868
    @juancarlosrivas6868 Місяць тому +33

    so much BS, as soon as Jason left, Metallica lost the drive and attitud they had

    • @truthhurts79
      @truthhurts79 Місяць тому +1

      Jason was never Metallica, only come latelys think that

    • @midnight347
      @midnight347 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@truthhurts79it's cool to think that now it's like a modern internet trend for the "come latelys" I love that name I'm gonna steal that from ya lol

    • @truthhurts79
      @truthhurts79 Місяць тому +1

      @@midnight347 they had the drive and attitude long before Jason, I guess these come latelys don't like the more aggressive and thrash albums before Jason.. Metallica actually got more commercial with the Jason albums.... It blows my mind these come latelys over sensationalize Jason just because they love his head banging because he only contributed 5% of music

    • @icankillbugs
      @icankillbugs Місяць тому

      ​@@truthhurts79I use the term "ham and egger" but this will be a nice one to use in moderation

    • @truthhurts79
      @truthhurts79 Місяць тому

      @@icankillbugs only posers put Jason on a demigod level... They like his headbanging and that's all they can like cause he contributed very little as far as songs, so they bow down to him because they are mind blown by his Head banging technique 😂

  • @acidspit14
    @acidspit14 Місяць тому +24

    The Black Album IS what it IS because of Jason. Bass riffs made that album what it is. the best Metallica Album of all time

  • @jacksonroper22
    @jacksonroper22 Місяць тому +8

    Also a complete lack of self awarness on Lars' part asking when they became the bad guys. They essentially pushed him out of the band...

  • @jacksonroper22
    @jacksonroper22 Місяць тому +6

    I still get so sad sometimes that they pushed Newstead out instead of dealing with their own stuff. Love Rob but man imagine Jason's live vocals during Spit Out the Bone or the "WAKE ME!" part in Sleepwalk.

  • @Obscura0511
    @Obscura0511 8 днів тому +1

    Jason was the energy in that bad. He brought so much to their live shows, no disrespect, that rob just doesn’t have.

  • @barbaradykes7231
    @barbaradykes7231 Місяць тому +9

    Jason was really cool with😢 me

  • @Nirvan-vn6iq
    @Nirvan-vn6iq Місяць тому +20

    If rob will sing in the band, he will be kickout too

  • @KingNero2006
    @KingNero2006 Місяць тому +8

    I just listened to the Audition Tapes with Jason. Saying he didnt play his own stuff is beyond my understanding if you listen to the lines Jason pulls off there....

  • @rickgifford-lp3kn
    @rickgifford-lp3kn Місяць тому +12

    Metallica totally lost it after Jason departure, he was great , a pillar of the band structure , now it' s bs , since st anger up to now

  • @Robert-ij9ih
    @Robert-ij9ih 22 дні тому +2

    James and Lars pride killed the band, they had never reached the level of success without him, after his departure they have ride on the success of their past. Very sad that they saw him as a threat to be choked and stopped when he added so much value to the whole band 🔥

  • @brianhays1797
    @brianhays1797 19 годин тому

    Jason is a cool guy. He was in my dad’s music theory class at Gull Lake, even jammed on the bass with him.

  • @Koake1002
    @Koake1002 23 дні тому +2

    James is like
    Do
    You do whatever you want to play to Jason. They all knew no matter what he played it was getting cut out the mix anyway. The problem was this band didn’t want a bassist for a member after cliff. Jason was never a member of Metallica. He was there for touring live shows. Nothing else. When it came to recording he had no say

  • @forever3797
    @forever3797 День тому

    The saddest part is that ironically Jason, whilst clearly being the most mature of all three was so burned after 14 years, and so hurt and disrespected by Hetfield telling him he could be replaced if he didn't drop Echobrain, that he didn't go through with the group therapy. The other three and management had the wisdom to see they needed impartial help - Jason could have used Phil Tolle as an independent ally and voice of reason and this may have opened up the band to doing side projects (which they all did eventually) and taking the year break that Jason wanted (which they eventually did due to Hetfield going into rehab). Unfortunately Jason was so burned he told Phil to leave the room as soon as he met him, and then proceeded to quit, which he had decided to do three months earlier, even telling Kirk and Lars, but no-one checked in with him or took him seriously or told Hetfield to try to give him a reality check. It's so sadly ironic that everything Jason wanted for the band such as a year's break, side projects, healthier band dynamic, and healthier touring schedules all came to fruition.

  • @4md17
    @4md17 Місяць тому +8

    what did james said to rob about using a pick? i dont understand..

    • @AnibalRodriguez-fi1os
      @AnibalRodriguez-fi1os Місяць тому +5

      It means that Jason followed the guitar parts on his bass and Hetfield doesn't like that. He prefers that the bassist makes scales to generate a counterpoint between the guitar and the bass.
      However, the way he treated Newsted was unfair since he had his own style and talent and was not respected as he deserved. After Newsted's departure, Metallica lost strength live.

  • @Ozarkmcclark
    @Ozarkmcclark Місяць тому +11

    Unfan Jason till you want him to be a fan of your needs, narcissistic

    • @midnight347
      @midnight347 Місяць тому

      What are you talking about? They mean they wanted him to act more like their peer and not a fan of the band and contribute more.

    • @KingNero2006
      @KingNero2006 Місяць тому +5

      @@midnight347 Contributing while two bandmembers turn down your tracks on an entire album. Yeah, they really wanted his contribution. We all know James and Lars dont let other Bandmembers contribute too much. Lars even tells Kirk how to play the solos nowadays...

    • @jurgencuypers8350
      @jurgencuypers8350 Місяць тому

      James didnt want Jase to do a solo album. That was it. James is a c-nt.

  • @loicestrade4054
    @loicestrade4054 6 днів тому

    I❤Newsted. I mean like Metallica's most famous album had HIM in it. My top favorite songs have Newsted on the bass. Once I didn't really care much about Metallica (though there were some songs I liked) until I listened to "fuel". got me hooked to Metallica, and once again, Newsted was on the bass. Jason Newsted was HUGELY underestimated by his bandmates for his work. Without him, I'm not sure where the band would've been at right then and now.
    Another thing about him related to his playing. Sometimes people (specifically James in this case) think playing bass with a pick is weird. But when I heard about Newsted, I just know in my heart "It's ok to play bass with a pick". I mean, HE did it, and he's a pro. We can do it too...if it's easier.

  • @RIDDYxMUSICH
    @RIDDYxMUSICH Місяць тому +11

    Humble Backbone one of the band around a bunch of narcissistic ego maniacs.

    • @rafaelalvarez977
      @rafaelalvarez977 Місяць тому

      You guys call yourselves fans of Jason but didn’t even support him on his own music😂 pathetic fan base

    • @RIDDYxMUSICH
      @RIDDYxMUSICH Місяць тому

      @@rafaelalvarez977 “You guys” baaAhaA!!!

    • @midnight347
      @midnight347 Місяць тому

      ​@@rafaelalvarez977too many cliche Metallica hating Jason fanboys

    • @JasonCan-wp2fu
      @JasonCan-wp2fu 8 днів тому

      What about Kirk

  • @robvegas9354
    @robvegas9354 16 днів тому +1

    I miss Jason in Metallica. Absolutely awesome dude! Saw them play here in Melbourne back in '98 on the Reload tour. Jason was at about 500% for the full show. the rest of the band were absolutely terrible and barely phoning in anything resembling a performance

  • @diamondcobra5150
    @diamondcobra5150 2 дні тому

    Ever since Newsteads departure Metallica have been better than ever.

  • @elpablosky6300
    @elpablosky6300 29 днів тому +1

    Too late for tears Jason Gave all to the band ,he must quit on 1986 because this guys we're a 🤬

  • @devildog3575
    @devildog3575 7 днів тому

    What Would Lemmy Do Lars? Lemmy’s right behind you for God’s sake.

  • @louieyumang2654
    @louieyumang2654 Місяць тому +11

    You should give more respect to Jason he sacrifice his life for metallica...yah he's not best bassist but he's the best fit....I would take Jason's side any given time than robert even he's sick playing bass this genre is not for him...

  • @PabloSaavedra84
    @PabloSaavedra84 18 днів тому +1

    Never meet your heroes

  • @lfkk4640
    @lfkk4640 29 днів тому

    He loved other bands, which for some fucked up reason, was frowned upon. Mostly by James. I remember Jason saying he was probably gonna be in trouble, for showing up at Rockfest in Arizona, headlined by Sepultura.

  • @Xmetalfanx
    @Xmetalfanx Місяць тому +1

    not sure if James has changed over the years, but while i love The early stuff up to the black album ... i lost all respect for Lars YEARS ago. Always so full of himself ... Jason didn't "need " (for himself/his happiness) Metallica anymore and i am glad he left for HIS SAKE

    • @Xmetalfanx
      @Xmetalfanx Місяць тому

      Kurt always seemed like a decent "mellow" guy to me

    • @MFGHOST8
      @MFGHOST8 Місяць тому

      Pretty sure he has, Doesn’t seem He and Dave have any hard feelings anymore, Lars I don’t know. Doesn’t excuse how they treated him in any regard. Despite them all being gifted musicians, Ego definitely messed them up (very common for bands iykyk).

    • @Brer247i
      @Brer247i 19 годин тому

      @@Xmetalfanx He's a follower.

  • @DrRock1970
    @DrRock1970 18 днів тому

    They beat the fan out of him so he left. The guys must be happy. They got what they wanted

  • @ThaBigBear
    @ThaBigBear 12 днів тому

    HE FOCKING LEFT THE BAND!

  • @CharliesTrousers-od3lt
    @CharliesTrousers-od3lt 26 днів тому +1

    Why the heck didn't Newsted join Megadeth

  • @YuiYuria
    @YuiYuria 8 днів тому

    Metallica always had fantastic musicians, James, Dave, Kirk, Jason, Cliff, Robert even Ron. And then there is Lars...

  • @jurgencuypers8350
    @jurgencuypers8350 Місяць тому

    All blame on James. If u had been a man of character, u wld have asked him back.

  • @shambles7ful
    @shambles7ful 5 днів тому

    Do you think Iron Maiden would treat a bandmate as such! it would never happen

  • @rinaticson390
    @rinaticson390 Місяць тому +47

    Ive lost respect for this band

    • @truthhurts79
      @truthhurts79 Місяць тому +2

      For what??? Jason contributed very little to Metallica... It's obvious you got into Metallica waaaay later

    • @rinaticson390
      @rinaticson390 Місяць тому +19

      @@truthhurts79 you don't know me , I liked them from the beginning, saw then 2x with Cliff. I'm an old fan and even friends with a cousin of a member of the group. They wouldn't let Jason have a voice . I could go on ,but obviously it won't make sense to you.

    • @truthhurts79
      @truthhurts79 Місяць тому +2

      @@rinaticson390 no old school Metallica fan would care... Matter of fact when Jason first joined Metallica nobody cared about him if he came or went, the fans at the time were just glad they got a replacement so we could get more music and shows from the ORIGINAL members... Fans saw him like fans saw Vinnie Vincent replace Ace Frehley, it's cool they got someone to replace him but they didn't care about him like the original members of kiss... Jason always had the option to leave so I guess it wasn't that brutal considering he knew if he did he'd go right back to playing dive bars and being broke with flotsam... I saw Metallica open for venom in Staten Island NY at the Paramount theater so I know what the outlook of the Metallica fans were at the time Jason joined

    • @rinaticson390
      @rinaticson390 Місяць тому +8

      @@truthhurts79 good for you and your opinion. I have mine . I'm from the same area in the bay area they are. I love the old stuff and that's how it will stay .

    • @truthhurts79
      @truthhurts79 Місяць тому +1

      @@rinaticson390 not an opinion, facts... Nobody made a big deal about Jason till later on... He contributed very little to Metallica, especially compared to how many songs Cliff contributed

  • @franckauger9490
    @franckauger9490 25 днів тому +1

    For my part, I quit METALLICA after, Kill'em all, Ride the lightning and MOP. And I don't regret. AJFA could have been a great album with a good mix with a bass and a real drums sound, but they prefer that shitty sound, so ADIOS and No regrets, no remorse ...

  • @franckauger9490
    @franckauger9490 21 день тому +1

    Jason had the balls to quit Two aasholes : Lars and James ! METALLICA was a the greatest thrash metal band, but after Kill'em'all, Ride the lightening and MOP, they start to do shit : Muting the bass on AJFA was stupid.
    The black album was commercial and no comment for others LP's. St-anger was the worst ....
    No matter on sales and tours. Metallica is dead a long time ago.
    May Jason be happier with real friends to share new music.

  • @fumanpoo4725
    @fumanpoo4725 Місяць тому

    Overwrought...

  • @spw947
    @spw947 Місяць тому +1

    Lars and James are a couple of tools!

  • @jasongoldsworthy6149
    @jasongoldsworthy6149 Місяць тому +7

    Burton was good but not the ultimate bass player.

    • @midnight347
      @midnight347 Місяць тому +3

      It's not about being the ultimate bass player. He was a great musician and more importantly he was their best friend and brother. That is what he means by his shoes could never be filled. The greatest bass player ever couldn't have filled cliffs shoes in their eyes which is what he meant by what he said.

    • @Brer247i
      @Brer247i 19 годин тому

      @@midnight347 Yet he was still replaceable.

  • @Brer247i
    @Brer247i 20 годин тому

    Replaced Jason with mediocrity. Just like they had become.

  • @brianhays1797
    @brianhays1797 19 годин тому

    Could never stand Lars

  • @cinnamongirl5410
    @cinnamongirl5410 24 дні тому

    Your loss he left.

  • @Thedesertguy75
    @Thedesertguy75 Місяць тому +4

    I lost interest after the black album honestly. It was the end of their perfect streak.

    • @midnight347
      @midnight347 Місяць тому +4

      You missed alot of good material then.

    • @jaketaylor8176
      @jaketaylor8176 Місяць тому

      ​@@midnight347 handful of good songs later. No great albums.

  • @drclawm.a.d.2413
    @drclawm.a.d.2413 25 днів тому

    Yes well this was some time back. They are all twenty years older now.
    His fault, thier fault, my fault assignment of blame isn't helpful. Bands have broken up before. Some bands bigger than Metallica called it quits after loosing a member.
    Not right or wrong
    There are bands that touring casinos and clubs that started in the fifties with the second drummer, third Bassist owning the rights.
    Far as I know they burried the hatchet. None of them ever have to worry about needing to find a job, or how they will put thier kids through school. The four members who recorded the album Kill Em All all those years ago were not even the first incarnation of the band. Anyone remember Dave Mustaine?
    He was thrown out.
    Last I heard he was doing all right for himself.
    This is basically gossip.

    • @babywah3290
      @babywah3290 19 днів тому

      No, it’s history. And it can’t be gossip if it coming from their own mouths on video.
      This is how it actually went down and should be a cautionary tale for other groups.
      James stifled Jason’s creativity because he was afraid of his projects being better than Metallica, essentially.
      That’s pretty stupid when you don’t take his contributions for albums in the past.

  • @chrisselfridge9841
    @chrisselfridge9841 Місяць тому

    A tragedy is when Cliff died. Jason leaving was a choice. Metallica continues on to rule the world.

  • @stanky9875
    @stanky9875 20 днів тому +2

    It's sacrilege to say this, but Newsted was the best bassist for metallica. All things considered with Cliff's death, Jason fit perfectly in Metallica. Rob is insanely talented, but i never warmed up to him.

  • @chrischoir3594
    @chrischoir3594 Місяць тому +2

    Jason was a below average musician who never had any real talent

    • @jaybirdk7414
      @jaybirdk7414 Місяць тому +4

      His lack of talent was what gave us Doomsday for the Deceiver, then?

    • @chrischoir3594
      @chrischoir3594 Місяць тому

      @@jaybirdk7414 Flotsem was one of 10000 cheezy 80s metal bands that no one cares about. You really think he has talent? why hasn't he done anything since Metallica? Mustaine got kicked out of Metallica too and he has 5 platinum albums. Jason is below a average musician.

    • @jaybirdk7414
      @jaybirdk7414 Місяць тому +5

      @@chrischoir3594, Jason beat out Les Claypool for the bass slot in Metallica. I don’t believe for a minute that James or Lars would have even given him the time of day, had he not already been established as a bass powerhouse.
      Having been a bass instructor, I’ve taught his technique to more students (and quite a few of my fellow bass players) than I can remember. As someone who plays 80 percent fingerstyle, I can attest I t’s definitely not for the faint of heart, nor the guitarist who dumbly thinks they can slop their way through it, and I should know; I have forty years of guitar under my belt.
      As far as credibility, well, Cliff’s parents gave Jason their blessing!
      He’s not talented, and that’s why litte Lars is having a meltdown here? 😂 And look at how quickly Jason was replaced, right?

    • @icankillbugs
      @icankillbugs Місяць тому +2

      ​@@chrischoir3594Doomsday is one of the best metal albums of 1986, what kinda crank are you smoking? That's a record "that noone cares about"? If you're into metal, you know and like that record.

    • @chrischoir3594
      @chrischoir3594 Місяць тому

      @@icankillbugs I remember 86 very well but didn't hear of doomsday until Newsted won the lottery. it was just a mediocre record. 86 was puppets, Reign in blood, In the Dark, Fatal Portrait, Peace Sells, Game over. I never heard of Doomsday till Jason Joined Metallica in 86. Neither did anyone else. The guys sucks and he is a chronic complainer. Metallica was beterr before him and they are better now. If he is that great he should do something great but he is not capable. Being a great . Let's say for the sake of Argument doomsday is good, there were 4 other members and if you want to be great you have to do more than just get lucky 1 time.