She would be freed this year, 2023, I think. My God. How can you know if she is safe to society at all? 41:21 if at 15 she's already able to torture people, now that she's grown up....
Without the drugs, alcohol, neglect and abuse she could be a completely different person now. I would say though, 14 years is not quite long enough to see a complete change in a person. I think she should be in prison for at least another 5 -6 years. Oh, well, only time will tell which one of us is right or wrong though.
Mary Bell has been the youngest female double murderer for decades. She was 10 when she murdered one little boy and had turned 11 when she soon after killed the second little boy. That was in the late 1960ies.
Yeah. I wonder if they prefer not to draw attention to her anymore due to her living successfully since she was released, and due to the abject horror she lived at home that literally contributed to it? I just learned about Sharon Carr yesterday. Mate, she should never get out.
This kind of misinformation regarding ADHD is extremely dangerous, and perpetuates the erroneous belief that only “bad kids” have ADHD. As a 45 year old woman with ADHD, I can assure you that it doesn’t make you violent, nor does being medicated for ADHD make you violent… A little education goes a long way! 🤯😳
Actually, this is not completely correct. I have been, and currently work, as a mental health provider and there is a link between ADHD and violent behavior. ADHD has also been linked to being predispositioned to ASPD- Antisocial Personality Disorder. Now, this is not to say that every human being diagnosed with ADHD will be violent or will end up being diagnosed with ASPD, what it is to say is that there is a very strong link between these issues and ADHD and research has shown this. It is also, again, not to say that everyone on ADHD meds will become, or have symptoms of violence, which I did not hear anyone in this video say. ADHD, and any diagnosis you may find in the DSM, is not, and never will be, a black and white situation. When diagnosing if course one will take into account the persons history, exposures to trauma and environment… their temperament and general demeanor. Genetics factors in and so much more. Everyone is like a snow flake and fingerprint, each one of us is unique, hence, not everyone , even with the same diagnosis, will behave in the same way, meaning their symptoms may present themselves differently . It is important not to miseducate people to think just because a person does not experience certain symptoms with a diagnosis another person won’t. By that same token, it is miseducation for a person to assume they will experience the same symptoms as someone else. No one is a carbon copy, which is why those of us actively working in the mental health field have a great responsibility to take the proper time necessary to observe, test and vet out exactly what is going on and ensure that there is a proper diagnosis with proper explanation and education, per person, of their symptoms.
@@jordanlennox5435 you work as a mental health provider? So that makes you an expert on a condition I’ve not only lived with my entire life, was raised by father with ADHD, am raising two children with ADHD, as well as a partner of 11 years with dual ADHD/ASD diagnosis. Oh,and my sister I spend a lot of time with. But I guess you being a “professional” sorry, what did you call it-? “Mental health provider”, you obviously would know much more about it. My bad. (Did I mention that one served 25 years as a police officer?) I’ll just step aside and let you educate the masses. 😃
@@jenc4016 Well, there are a whole lot of assumptions going on here. Firstly, how do you know as a mental health provider, and by that I am referring to being a clinician who has been actively diagnosing individuals- including ADHD- for many year. As such, I have focused all of my higher education , and by that I am referring to a Masters degree in Clinical Psychology and Doctorate in Mental Health policies, in mental health. I am also a trauma specialist as this was my chosen area of focus. How do you know that I myself, or my family members, ain’t have the diagnosis you mentioned? You don’t. What does you having family members with these diagnosis and yourself have to do with this? You live with a condition that it appears you were not formally clinically trained about. Lived experience with a diagnosis versus formal, higher education about that diagnosis have zero in common. I lived with Cancer for several years before I went into remission as did many of my family members . Does that mean I knew everything there was to know about Cancer simply because I had that diagnosis or those around me did ? Absolutely not. That is a logical fallacy. In short, I would not Dane to, nor have the temerity to, tell you about what it is to work in Law Enforcement and the same is true regarding those not in my field advising me about it.
Being potentially paroled doesn't necessarily mean she will go free. She will have to go in front of the parole board and if she doesn't show remorse or is still a danger to society, then she will stay behind bars
Thank goodness the UK removed the death penalty back in 1965. If you look at how many people in the US have been exonerated over the years, it makes you wonder how many innocent people were executed over the years.
Unfortunately, many people go through very rough childhoods but don't become sadistic murderers. TBH, I 'm tired of psychologists and others making excuses for people like Lorraine Thorpe. No one ever wants to discuss the very liberal sentencing laws that exist in many Western countries including the UK. Perhaps if there were real deterrents against such anti-social and malicious behavior, there wouldn't be such an increase in criminality. A modern day Albert Pierrepoint could be an effective antidote! Condolences to the families of Rosalyn Hunt and Desmond Thorpe. Someone like Lorraine Thorpe should never be allowed out again.
I wonder if parents were held equally accountable for their minor child's behavior if maybe Lorraine would have stayed on her meds and in school. As it is, one of her parents is dead by her design and the other is now free of all responsibilities except making sure there's enough drinking money.
I agree there's got to be more at play for the girl than the fairly generic risk factors which were reported but the role of those profiling isn't to provide excuses, it serves to offer explanation and to determine motive etc.
there are plenty of cases of children brought up in very nurturing families and still ended up killing their parents. And even more children who had to care of their alcohol or drug dependent mother/father wo went on to live peaceful and productive lives. It's not all in nurture! Nature plays a big roll in this also! I agree that making only excuses is not leading to solutions!
Me and my son has also ADHD. Here is what I've learned so far: It is very important in what kind of environment you grow up in and what help you get and role models you have. When you have ADHD you will need a lot of positive feedback and understanding people around you. This makes it easier to see yourself in a positive light and you will not have so much anxiety that triggers bad behaviour. Also your personality is an important key on how you act. You can have a violent personality with or without ADHD. The privilege to live in a positive and understanding environment is unfortunately rare and therefore many children and adults act out and lose control of their life. This happens to a neuro normal human in a bad environment but the risk of losing control is much higher if you have ADHD, because you have a hard time regulate your feelings, and you are at high risk of become addicted to Alcohol and drugs. If an ADHD person take this fact seriously and really decides to work on her/himself to make it in life, then that person can achieve anything. ADHD is not an excuse for bad behavior and you do have a responsibility to learn how to manage your and/or your child's condition. It is so sad when there are so much misinformation and assumptions about ADHD. It is not what defines you. Your morality and conscience to choose what is right and admit when you have done wrong is what defines you as a human.
People with ADHD are the movers and shakers of this world if their energies are channeled in the right way. The psychologist here wasn’t trying to use ADHD as an excuse for this crime but really trying to explain the inexplicable. My personal opinion for what it’s worth is that complete neglect of a child’s emotional needs starting from a very, very young age causes unforeseeable damage in the psyche of that child.
I have adhd and it got bad as a teen,I refused meds and got my act together. I never once thought of murdering someone! This show always seems to find reasons and excuses.
I cant belive this girl just going out from the jail at age 29 and living life like nothing happend. THIS IS JUST NOT FAIR. She is a sadistic evil person.
The laughter part is interesting to me, as someone who has suffered from (non-hyperactive) ADD as a kid. I think this gets misunderstood a bit. I want to share my perspective here. One thing that can happen for any child but it happens a lot easier tof ADD/ADHD kids is overstimulation. Overstimulation for ADD and AHDH kids can both manifest in hyperactivity. Hyperactivity can be accompanied by feelings of euphoria and, especially if there is also tension, laughter. I don't think you can read too much into the laughter part. Attention Deficit problems also tend to mellow out with age quite a lot. As a young teen I was medicated. As a young adult, I managed with moderate coffee intake alone. In middle age, I have removed even that. I think there is hope for rehabilitation with the right support but that requires a system which understands. I would like to think that might be the case.
Only recently were the parents of Biddy Porter were even allowed to mention their daughter’s name because her killer was a 14 year old girl. Biddy was 10 and butchered by a 14 year old. NSW Australia. The killer cannot be named and after 4 years prison is out on day release.
She was convicted of manslaughter, so she technically doesn't count as a murderer. Shows use technicalities to make catchier titles that are still correct. Otherwise they could only title one case as "youngest female murderer", etc. They'd run out of cases to cover that people will actually click.
The adhd part is so dangerously wrong explained. Me, my husband and my son have all ADHD my husband was deployed into war 3 times and non of us were ever violent. We don’t take medication 💊 bc it makes us depressed, I rather live with adhd than with depression. Anyway, this is a load of bull and whoever made this research is straight up ignorant
I totally agree. I never took any medication as I was in my late 30s when the condition was detected, although I had it my whole life long, of course. I know that some of the more impulsive types on the ADHD Spectrum tend to Violence. But they paint a picture of ADHD here that could raise prejudices further.
Well, not everyone is the same with some type of mental condition. This was about her though. And it's never good to quit cold turkey with mental health medication without professional help and start self medicating with alcohol. Plus the trauma/depression and bad evironment. All these factors are explained so it's not adhd alone. Then again, there are more people in similar situations that will never do this.
Depends on what level your adhd is. I have a friend whose son has it and he DEFINITELY has violent tendencies. Just because your whole family has it does not mean you can excuse everyone from having violent adhd behavior!
Sorry, Thorpe was not Britain's youngest female double murderer. That would be Mary Bell age 10. I didn't watch the video, so if you mentioned Bell I am unaware. I already know this case, but thought the viewers should know about Bell.
The level of sadistic torture is extreme. The fact she seemed to enjoy the results and even returned to batter the victim further indicates antisocial and probably the beginning of a psychopath. Her developmental history would be helpful for a more comprehensive understanding of this extremely deranged personality. Her medical history and any MRI evaluation needs to be considered for evaluation of physical damage. Fetal Alcohol Syndrome is also a strong possibility and is inclusive of ADHD symptoms but the effects of the syndrome can cause a complete break from conscience and consequences. This diagnosis really should have been a consideration.
kids want to be grown ups and do those things they do. influence is enourmous. insane. unstable personalities gets pulled more and more rapidly to dark side.
I have ADHD, and it seems that the discussion was accurate. Stopping meds is problematic to an adolescent. They said it made her "vulnerable." It seems accurate to me. Stopping any mental health meds without medical help is dangerous and makes one "vulnerable" in many ways. She was warped under the influence of (1) an evil man, (2) her own problematic history, and (3) no doubt, her lack of meds that her body once had been accustomed to. Just because the vast majority of us with ADHD don't turn to violence, doesn't mean that a change in meds would cause major difficulty in a young woman who has multiple other troubles. ADHD, as a minor element, seems reasonable to me to include in the psychological profile of this girl.
Those drugs are dangerous to start with! Pharmaceutical industry makes billions off people like you, gets you essentially hooked for life on these destructive chemical drugs that are probably causing all kinds of destruction to your body and brain.
None of the authorities are prepared or even care to address the elephant in the room - Poverty, with all its concomitant factors and outcomes: lack of meaningful jobs and living wages, homelessness, mental health, education with prospects for a future, but no, instead there’s despair, hopelessness, anger, and lack of self esteem that is inevitable when locked into poverty. There seems to be a general attitude of, if they just pulled themselves up by the bootstraps and got on the straight and narrow everything would be hunky-dory! Smugly declaring that if the parenting was better none of this would happen is abrogating an obligation to create a system and a society that serves the needs of all types of people to allow them to lead decent lives, not merely exist. The parents here were in the same pit as their children, the same poverty, hopelessness and degradation. Its generational.
For those of you in comments saying we all have ADHD but we dont take meds, AND WE DONT KILL PEOPLE obviously you dont know what happens to someone who is taking med then just stops, YOU SHOULD NEVER JUST STOP TAKING YOUR MED FOR A MENTAL ILLNESS WITHOUT THE HELP OF DR. AND EVERYONE IS A SEPERATE CASE NOT EVERYONE WHO HAS CANCER DIES, NOT EVERYONE WITH AUTISM IS AN EXTREME CASE, NOT EVERYONE WITH DEPRESSION KILLS THEMSELVES NOT EVERYONE WHO IS BULLIED SHOOTS UP A SCHOOL,.. IM SORRY BUT GROWN ADULTS SAYING I HAVE THIS BUT I DONT DO THAT, ARE THE IGNORANT AS WELL AS IDIOTS. AND NOT EDUCATED IN YOUR MENTAL HEALTH ISSUE
Im so sorry for Roslyn's brother and having to loose his beautiful sister to such horrendous circumstances. And i hope the young man Peter being interviewed gets an opportunity to change his life,he seems like a genuine good soul,just a lost one.
Too many excuses are done for Lorraine's behavior. Despite her background she should have known better she wasn't 10, she was 15 at the time of the crimes.
I do believe she will commit more crimes if released. If you’re not capable of empathy or remorse at 15, it’s unlikely that a couple of years in prison is going to change that.
I am sending out my thoughts and prayers and love to the father's family and his friends I am really! So very sorry for your loss 😢💔 even though it was a long time ago forever young he is gone way to soon he is gone but he will never be forgotten
ADHD on its own isn’t generally responsible for this kind of behaviour. There is immature decision making, need for immediate gratification, focus issues, etc. But if you add abuse, drugs, alcohol with that kind of neurological “tinder”, you will see potential for explosion. Those poor victims.
People are not all the same, so we don't all react the same to the same diagnosis. That goes with kids as well. If your son isn't temperamental by nature, his reduced impulse control from the ADHD won't make him physically lash out when he's frustrated. And I'm also pretty sure your son doesn't come from a dysfunctional background and has become a heavy drinker.
@Kari F yea I definitely feel like it's being a product of your environment I am horribly adhd and was raised by a violent narcissist alcoholic and when I was younger I was violentttt and frustration in school from not being able to focus or read when someone's talking In class, I would go right to anger and violence because I was taught that's how you deal with all feelings
@@KimmyyCocoa I can relate. Being raised in a violent home does leave a mark on a child's brain. I feared my dad after watching him beat my sister for being fat. She was 10 and I was 4 and my father was an athletic muscular 6ft tall violent man. My mom never ever stopped him. Her advice to me was to pretend it didn't happen. I told her all the cruel things he did to me when she wasn't home. I now realize she didn't care as long as she wasn't being abused. I believe our brains and body are always on alert. Our main focus is to be ready for anything. Sounds smell and always listening for early signs of irritation anger or any escalation of excitement. We never knew what to expect and our brains focus was to be ready for the unexpected. I also believe ptsd can send us right back to the panic we felt as a kid not knowing how to navigate forward.... If I could make a wish for you it would be... To forgive your childhood mistakes and try to love your inner child. A child that needs positive nourishment.... I'm in my 50s and only recently was I able to put it all together. I'm chronically ill and I understand why and how it all ties together. If I could go back and have a do over I would.
That is not what the documentary is saying and I do not understand why people keep saying that. They merely mentioned she was taking meds and then ceased taking them. It is always fair to mention anything that could POTENTIALLY be a contributing, or relevant, factor to something.
Literally no one said that it does. They are giving background on the girl and factors that may have contributed to her subsequent behavior. So, the ADHD diagnosis, the meds or inconsistent taking may have; we don’t know.
A normal family for the first 13 years of her life, and then it all falls into a big mess. Where were the grandparents, aunts uncles and rest of the family members to step in and help these children before they went into this lifestyle. For the father, to become homeless, and an alcoholic, and the mothers start drinking two or whatever the problem was, where was the rest of the family what happened to the other three siblings?
They were really hammering on the ADHD thing seems like medicating your kids and telling them that there’s something wrong with them is not helping a lot of really wealthy people very successful people who have ADHD they’re creative and hyperfocus when there’s something they’re interested I think kids need to reframe the way they think of this look at it as a power instead of something negative.
I truly do not understand how she only got 14 years. She can be out at age of 29. What has been done to help with rehabilitation. I understand that society let her fall between the cracks. The same society that failed her will be the same society that says she is ok to let out. Does not sound like win , win for the people who have to interact with her should she be free.
I was feeling bad for this gurl ,until I found out what all She did ,I dont anymore .Shes evil and whether she was born evil r made that way ,evil none the less and should be locked away .
My son's father has unmedicated ADHD and he literally put his hands around my throat & strangled me. But I don't blame his ADHD for that.. he's just a violent man & I hope to never see him again.
I am sending out my thought and prayers and love to her family and her friends I am really! So very sorry for your loss 😢💔 even though it was a long time ago forever young she is gone way to soon she is gone but she will never be forgotten
It 🤬 if the police had went in the house the first time Roselyn would still be alive now🤬 My Deepest Condolences Go Out To Both Families and Friends✝🙏🏽💜🕊🕊
It was manslaughter (according to the courts). Meaning this video's title is technically correct. It grabs more people's attention this way, which is all channels care about.
ADHD is not an illness it hyper activity that today children are medicated for it. In the early of last century children in the US used to help their parents in farms, city children also helped as much as they could. Later children played outside a lot and they were tired afterwards and calm down, until children started to disappeared, mostly children who played or walked alone, (strength in numbers). So parents stopped letting children play outside without supervision, then parents of hyper active children didn’t know how to deal with their child/ten and also teachers because the children disrupted the class so the solution of psychiatric is to numb those children with medication. Unless those children have violent parents or friends or both, those children just need to have some sort of physical activity they will be focused after getting both therapy and physical activity.
@@krmccarrell No. Sugar can make you hyperactive. That has nothing to do with ADHD. People who really know what ADHD is, do not reduce it to hyperactivity. BTW you can also present hypoactive - so not hyperactive at all - at least from the outside.
All the extenuating circumstances the psychologist presents are true. But she has not mentioned that some people are just born evil. Furthermore, millions of kids have ADHD and don't become murderers, in spite of poor living conditions. I think the psychologist fell victim to her own emotions and her comments are not objective.
I think it was the older guy who was the catalyst. She probably wouldn't have done anything like this without his coaching and encouragement. But yes I agree it is our choice at any age really, especially at this level of torture and killing over days.
That is not at all what I understood of this video. Firstly, I am a mental health provider, focused working in mental Health crisis services, and want to say that absolutely everyone, without exception, responds to trauma differently and everyone also has a different resiliency and breaking point. I could have 20 clients who have astoundingly similar backgrounds regarding traumatic experiences and each one of them will process that and respond to it, mentally, emotionally, behaviorally, and sometimes even physically differently ( such as in cases with somatic disorder diagnosis). Hence, just because you and your 4 Siblings had a similar life to hers does not really mean much since you are all different people, even if your 4 siblings ended up processing issues similar to you.. there are still almost 8 billion people out there who process trauma differently. Genetics, processing, personality, mental Health status and so much more will vary incredibly much. Epigenetic’s has given us incredible insights into how vastly different people are, process and what they are susceptible to. For instance, I have bio family and we were raised in the same home, with the same exposures and lifestyle and upbringing, yet, my family member struggled with Alcoholism while I did not. At the end of the day, everyone is like a snowflake and fingerprint and you can never compare it or black and white the situation. Always remember that you, nor I, am everybody else. Your experience, and that if your siblings, Is yours, but you cannot speak for everyone else in the world.
…it’s unfortunate to have been dealt with these circumstances but not everyone ends up this way, you be one great example. We as humans have the capability but not all of us will ever get to use that ability.
This is a fantastic question. I work within the mental health field as a provider and I can say that what is legally Supposed to happen is that the child has an assigned social worker who is mandated and in charge of getting mental health and medication services for the child approved via court. The only options I see that could have occurred is, someone dropped the ball and did not get orders from the courts.. or when returned to families care, since she was no longer a ward of the court, family did not follow up with her treatment and care, which may be a viable option given the nature of alcoholism from her father… or her assigned social worker and treatment team did not ensure she took her meds after it being approved via court. As I said, I work in this field and not but a few months ago I had a huge battle with, truth be told, a CPS social worker and CPS staff due to this staff informing me that they “accidentally left” a child’s medication in a hotel they were keeping him in due to the current epidemic we are having regarding lack of placements for children. I was able to obtain this child’s medication for him and delivered it to CPS myself because I was not going to let that stand. In this case, prior to them leaving the clients meds, the courts had approved the client to take medication. It’s a long day at work but so worth it to make sure nobody is lost, falls behind or slips through the cracks!
God what a life, however we have one law for everyone and murder means you have taken the life of another person and there is a price to pay! No excuses, do the time and get help. I’m gonna hugs my kids!!
I’m having trouble having empathy for the father that was killed. The system and her parents failed her. Allowed her to be manipulated and turned into a damn killer by another fucking low life. As far as she was concerned her life was fucking over. Dangerous thoughts for a person. They either kill themselves or turn into a person causing misery for others.
I thought this crime occurred in England, where people speak English. I can’t tell what the hell Peter Green is saying at all. Rehabilitated? Gladiator school for girls is still Gladiator school. Good luck with that.
Just because someone has ADHD doesnt give them a hall pass from determining between right and wrong. You can tell she had no remorse, no empathy. She is just as guilty and just as evil.
This poor girl likely had a lot more going on than adhd. But I’m glad a country like UK takes these contextual details into consideration when evaluating ppl’s actions.
Whatever the circumstances are & here we hear off very sad but real scenarios of most modern families being played out is still no reason for murder let alone 2. This case had all the right ingredients for murderers & PPL who study social , behaviour patterns need to publish the specific traits to be aware off EG - ADHD, bi polar , teen from broke home, bad anti social groups & older male predators.
I am concerned with how many unwanted children will turn out this way now that the United States government is in the business of forcing women to have children they don't want, don't know how to raise, and cannot afford.
I’m hoping that most women who want an abortion will get one, either with pills or getting to a blue state. It’s outrageous what the Republicans have done (what else is new?).
We have bylaws about drinking in the streets. This is sad because public behaviours attract more people together with the same bad habits, making it OK.
Why didn’t she stay with her mother was she staying with her father Because she was looking after him and worried about him I don’t understand why she wasn’t with her mother if her mother had a stable home
I'm sorry but both deny the allegations, but it doesn't take a brain surgeon th relies that. She has been living with dad on the street and didn't resort to alcohol and violence. That changed after she caught the eye of him. Suddenly she wants to come across as a mature woman. Behaving as badly as he did.
Poverty, alcohol, drugs and homelessness that is the first problem here… the inequality of the wealthy in England Versus everyone else and you have the first issue and the answer!!!
Lorraine could have made better choices regardless of how her parents were, she chose excitement. Lots and lots of kids have a worse upbringing, and turn out to be beautful outstanding citizens.. I speak from experience.
It's odd that so many lives have been lost because of voices they heard in their heads ! 2000 yrs ago those PPL where Hailed as special & many men went to war for them.
I'm so tired of "professionals" making excuses for why people act the way they do. "Excuses are like @$$holes...everyone has one and they all stink". Hold people accountable for what they did and put them in jail. NO early release for good behavior, NO parole just a small cell where they have to spend 24/7 with no television, internet, sports to "distract" them. THAT is called punishment. And if you killed someone, YOU are locked up for as long as your victim is dead.
It’s a good thing the rest of the world is interesting in learning how things happen to help prevent future disaster. You just want to punish people who choose to punish people…luckily for you there are people who can help you with this urge and you can get help before you hurt someone.
Schizophrenia doesn't either. Schizophrenia does not equate violence as per my brother, my experience in the field, research and my own psychotic depressive episode which shared many schizophrenic symptoms. Ignorance.
They didn't say it like that though. They clearly said it was a combination of things like not taking her meds plus trauma plus alcohol plus bad environment.
Please be extremely careful about what you are saying. I am aN active mental health provider and I work in providing mental health care for those in crisis and what you have said is actually not correct and can spread miseducation. Her behavior absolutely does not meet the provision/ criteria to be diagnosed with Schizophrenia, per the DSM, nor was she even the age for such a diagnosis to be onset. You are welcome to your own opinions but I strongly urge everyone to not throw diagnoses out that that they more than likely do not have the necessary formal education in and for those who are not active clinicians/ work with the current DSM.
The level of sadism she exhibited in the torture of that poor woman should tell the courts all they need to know. Girl is a danger.
She would be freed this year, 2023, I think. My God. How can you know if she is safe to society at all? 41:21 if at 15 she's already able to torture people, now that she's grown up....
Without the drugs, alcohol, neglect and abuse she could be a completely different person now. I would say though, 14 years is not quite long enough to see a complete change in a person. I think she should be in prison for at least another 5 -6 years. Oh, well, only time will tell which one of us is right or wrong though.
Si preannuncia un altro omicidio.
Someone failed this child.
This girl should Rot in jail. She is a Danger to society
Mary Bell has been the youngest female double murderer for decades. She was 10 when she murdered one little boy and had turned 11 when she soon after killed the second little boy. That was in the late 1960ies.
And she is out walking today under a different name, you'd never know who she was is what scares me!!
But she's very old now
@@murithisophia8791 according to the above comment she'd be about the same age as me, 63. Not really that old.
She was 10 when she committed the murder so she’s in her 70s
@@lilyvu-deleon no she's 66
Too much excuse making for the girl. Torture & murder aren’t acts committed by a kid who had it rough, they are unconscionable.
Exactly.
Exactly
Amen, if we all used our traumatic childhoods as an excuse for our bad choices and behaviours, imagine the carnage.
The UK is soft on crime. I see these case where the sentence for murder is 15 years. Over here (America) they’d get life without parole.
I completely agree. The one commentator spent the entire documentary giving excuses every time she was on screen.
They always seem to forget about Mary Bell who was 10yo when she murdered two children & Sharon Car too! She was 12!
Yeah. I wonder if they prefer not to draw attention to her anymore due to her living successfully since she was released, and due to the abject horror she lived at home that literally contributed to it? I just learned about Sharon Carr yesterday. Mate, she should never get out.
She's not the only child who has to go through a broken home
This kind of misinformation regarding ADHD is extremely dangerous, and perpetuates the erroneous belief that only “bad kids” have ADHD.
As a 45 year old woman with ADHD, I can assure you that it doesn’t make you violent, nor does being medicated for ADHD make you violent…
A little education goes a long way! 🤯😳
100%. But being MISDIAGNOSED with ADHD and given medication for it can have different affects.
Actually, this is not completely correct. I have been, and currently work, as a mental health provider and there is a link between ADHD and violent behavior. ADHD has also been linked to being predispositioned to ASPD- Antisocial Personality Disorder. Now, this is not to say that every human being diagnosed with ADHD will be violent or will end up being diagnosed with ASPD, what it is to say is that there is a very strong link between these issues and ADHD and research has shown this.
It is also, again, not to say that everyone on ADHD meds will become, or have symptoms of violence, which I did not hear anyone in this video say.
ADHD, and any diagnosis you may find in the DSM, is not, and never will be, a black and white situation. When diagnosing if course one will take into account the persons history, exposures to trauma and environment… their temperament and general demeanor. Genetics factors in and so much more. Everyone is like a snow flake and fingerprint, each one of us is unique, hence, not everyone , even with the same diagnosis, will behave in the same way, meaning their symptoms may present themselves differently .
It is important not to miseducate people to think just because a person does not experience certain symptoms with a diagnosis another person won’t. By that same token, it is miseducation for a person to assume they will experience the same symptoms as someone else. No one is a carbon copy, which is why those of us actively working in the mental health field have a great responsibility to take the proper time necessary to observe, test and vet out exactly what is going on and ensure that there is a proper diagnosis with proper explanation and education, per person, of their symptoms.
@@jordanlennox5435 you work as a mental health provider? So that makes you an expert on a condition I’ve not only lived with my entire life, was raised by father with ADHD, am raising two children with ADHD, as well as a partner of 11 years with dual ADHD/ASD diagnosis. Oh,and my sister I spend a lot of time with.
But I guess you being a “professional” sorry, what did you call it-? “Mental health provider”, you obviously would know much more about it.
My bad.
(Did I mention that one served 25 years as a police officer?)
I’ll just step aside and let you educate the masses. 😃
The show says stopping the medication can make you violent.
@@jenc4016 Well, there are a whole lot of assumptions going on here. Firstly, how do you know as a mental health provider, and by that I am referring to being a clinician who has been actively diagnosing individuals- including ADHD- for many year. As such, I have focused all of my higher education , and by that I am referring to a Masters degree in Clinical Psychology and Doctorate in Mental Health policies, in mental health. I am also a trauma specialist as this was my chosen area of focus.
How do you know that I myself, or my family members, ain’t have the diagnosis you mentioned? You don’t. What does you having family members with these diagnosis and yourself have to do with this? You live with a condition that it appears you were not formally clinically trained about.
Lived experience with a diagnosis versus formal, higher education about that diagnosis have zero in common. I lived with Cancer for several years before I went into remission as did many of my family members . Does that mean I knew everything there was to know about Cancer simply because I had that diagnosis or those around me did ? Absolutely not. That is a logical fallacy. In short, I would not Dane to, nor have the temerity to, tell you about what it is to work in Law Enforcement and the same is true regarding those not in my field advising me about it.
14yrs?? That's a crime in itself. She should be in prison for the rest of her life.
Exactly
Jesus says Forgive
@@smurfie8412 fake deities aren't my thing.
Being potentially paroled doesn't necessarily mean she will go free. She will have to go in front of the parole board and if she doesn't show remorse or is still a danger to society, then she will stay behind bars
Typically British sentences
what, she only got 14 years and Paul 27 years. They should get the death penalty. Lorraine has to stay in prison because she is a danger to society.
Thank goodness the UK removed the death penalty back in 1965. If you look at how many people in the US have been exonerated over the years, it makes you wonder how many innocent people were executed over the years.
There’s no death penalty in the U.K. (or Europe, except for Belarus).
Unfortunately, many people go through very rough childhoods but don't become sadistic murderers. TBH, I 'm tired of psychologists and others making excuses for people like Lorraine Thorpe. No one ever wants to discuss the very liberal sentencing laws that exist in many Western countries including the UK. Perhaps if there were real deterrents against such anti-social and malicious behavior, there wouldn't be such an increase in criminality. A modern day Albert Pierrepoint could be an effective antidote! Condolences to the families of Rosalyn Hunt and Desmond Thorpe. Someone like Lorraine Thorpe should never be allowed out again.
I wonder if parents were held equally accountable for their minor child's behavior if maybe Lorraine would have stayed on her meds and in school. As it is, one of her parents is dead by her design and the other is now free of all responsibilities except making sure there's enough drinking money.
I agree there's got to be more at play for the girl than the fairly generic risk factors which were reported but the role of those profiling isn't to provide excuses, it serves to offer explanation and to determine motive etc.
.
there are plenty of cases of children brought up in very nurturing families and still ended up killing their parents.
And even more children who had to care of their alcohol or drug dependent mother/father wo went on to live peaceful and productive lives. It's not all in nurture! Nature plays a big roll in this also! I agree that making only excuses is not leading to solutions!
It's not an excuse It's an explaination
Me and my son has also ADHD. Here is what I've learned so far: It is very important in what kind of environment you grow up in and what help you get and role models you have. When you have ADHD you will need a lot of positive feedback and understanding people around you. This makes it easier to see yourself in a positive light and you will not have so much anxiety that triggers bad behaviour. Also your personality is an important key on how you act. You can have a violent personality with or without ADHD. The privilege to live in a positive and understanding environment is unfortunately rare and therefore many children and adults act out and lose control of their life. This happens to a neuro normal human in a bad environment but the risk of losing control is much higher if you have ADHD, because you have a hard time regulate your feelings, and you are at high risk of become addicted to Alcohol and drugs. If an ADHD person take this fact seriously and really decides to work on her/himself to make it in life, then that person can achieve anything. ADHD is not an excuse for bad behavior and you do have a responsibility to learn how to manage your and/or your child's condition. It is so sad when there are so much misinformation and assumptions about ADHD. It is not what defines you. Your morality and conscience to choose what is right and admit when you have done wrong is what defines you as a human.
Hey 😅
Totally agree
People with ADHD are the movers and shakers of this world if their energies are channeled in the right way. The psychologist here wasn’t trying to use ADHD as an excuse for this crime but really trying to explain the inexplicable. My personal opinion for what it’s worth is that complete neglect of a child’s emotional needs starting from a very, very young age causes unforeseeable damage in the psyche of that child.
I hope they never release her. Someone else would end up dead if she is she’s evil.
There are no excuses for Lorraine Thorpe. She was s just evil and belongs in jail forever.
This is the fault of the social services in her community. Yhey should have never allowed her to remain in this situation.
I have adhd and it got bad as a teen,I refused meds and got my act together. I never once thought of murdering someone! This show always seems to find reasons and excuses.
I cant belive this girl just going out from the jail at age 29 and living life like nothing happend. THIS IS JUST NOT FAIR. She is a sadistic evil person.
The laughter part is interesting to me, as someone who has suffered from (non-hyperactive) ADD as a kid. I think this gets misunderstood a bit. I want to share my perspective here.
One thing that can happen for any child but it happens a lot easier tof ADD/ADHD kids is overstimulation. Overstimulation for ADD and AHDH kids can both manifest in hyperactivity. Hyperactivity can be accompanied by feelings of euphoria and, especially if there is also tension, laughter. I don't think you can read too much into the laughter part.
Attention Deficit problems also tend to mellow out with age quite a lot. As a young teen I was medicated. As a young adult, I managed with moderate coffee intake alone. In middle age, I have removed even that. I think there is hope for rehabilitation with the right support but that requires a system which understands. I would like to think that might be the case.
I agree with you totally ,I have really mellowed and slowed down in older age.
Only recently were the parents of Biddy Porter were even allowed to mention their daughter’s name because her killer was a 14 year old girl.
Biddy was 10 and butchered by a 14 year old. NSW Australia. The killer cannot be named and after 4 years prison is out on day release.
Mary Bell killed two children and was younger than Thorpe.
That’s so strange that she wasn’t mentioned.
She was convicted of manslaughter, so she technically doesn't count as a murderer. Shows use technicalities to make catchier titles that are still correct. Otherwise they could only title one case as "youngest female murderer", etc. They'd run out of cases to cover that people will actually click.
The adhd part is so dangerously wrong explained. Me, my husband and my son have all ADHD my husband was deployed into war 3 times and non of us were ever violent. We don’t take medication 💊 bc it makes us depressed, I rather live with adhd than with depression. Anyway, this is a load of bull and whoever made this research is straight up ignorant
I totally agree. I never took any medication as I was in my late 30s when the condition was detected, although I had it my whole life long, of course. I know that some of the more impulsive types on the ADHD Spectrum tend to Violence. But they paint a picture of ADHD here that could raise prejudices further.
Well, not everyone is the same with some type of mental condition. This was about her though. And it's never good to quit cold turkey with mental health medication without professional help and start self medicating with alcohol. Plus the trauma/depression and bad evironment. All these factors are explained so it's not adhd alone. Then again, there are more people in similar situations that will never do this.
Depends on what level your adhd is. I have a friend whose son has it and he DEFINITELY has violent tendencies. Just because your whole family has it does not mean you can excuse everyone from having violent adhd behavior!
Sorry, Thorpe was not Britain's youngest female double murderer. That would be Mary Bell age 10.
I didn't watch the video, so if you mentioned Bell I am unaware. I already know this case, but thought the viewers should know about Bell.
The level of sadistic torture is extreme. The fact she seemed to enjoy the results and even returned to batter the victim further indicates antisocial and probably the beginning of a psychopath. Her developmental history would be helpful for a more comprehensive understanding of this extremely deranged personality. Her medical history and any MRI evaluation needs to be considered for evaluation of physical damage. Fetal Alcohol Syndrome is also a strong possibility and is inclusive of ADHD symptoms but the effects of the syndrome can cause a complete break from conscience and consequences. This diagnosis really should have been a consideration.
kids want to be grown ups and do those things they do. influence is enourmous. insane. unstable personalities gets pulled more and more rapidly to dark side.
I have ADHD, and it seems that the discussion was accurate. Stopping meds is problematic to an adolescent. They said it made her "vulnerable." It seems accurate to me. Stopping any mental health meds without medical help is dangerous and makes one "vulnerable" in many ways. She was warped under the influence of (1) an evil man, (2) her own problematic history, and (3) no doubt, her lack of meds that her body once had been accustomed to. Just because the vast majority of us with ADHD don't turn to violence, doesn't mean that a change in meds would cause major difficulty in a young woman who has multiple other troubles. ADHD, as a minor element, seems reasonable to me to include in the psychological profile of this girl.
Those drugs are dangerous to start with! Pharmaceutical industry makes billions off people like you, gets you essentially hooked for life on these destructive chemical drugs that are probably causing all kinds of destruction to your body and brain.
Bs I stop my meds never wanted to kill someone adhd is not a issue that causes violence in people
My son stop taking it he was 18 excuses
Let us raise our children by setting examples for them to emulate.
Raise them properly before letting them out into society.
None of the authorities are prepared or even care to address the elephant in the room - Poverty, with all its concomitant factors and outcomes: lack of meaningful jobs and living wages, homelessness, mental health, education with prospects for a future, but no, instead there’s despair, hopelessness, anger, and lack of self esteem that is inevitable when locked into poverty.
There seems to be a general attitude of, if they just pulled themselves up by the bootstraps and got on the straight and narrow everything would be hunky-dory!
Smugly declaring that if the parenting was better none of this would happen is abrogating an obligation to create a system and a society that serves the needs of all types of people to allow them to lead decent lives, not merely exist.
The parents here were in the same pit as their children, the same poverty, hopelessness and degradation.
Its generational.
For those of you in comments saying we all have ADHD but we dont take meds, AND WE DONT KILL PEOPLE obviously you dont know what happens to someone who is taking med then just stops, YOU SHOULD NEVER JUST STOP TAKING YOUR MED FOR A MENTAL ILLNESS WITHOUT THE HELP OF DR. AND EVERYONE IS A SEPERATE CASE NOT EVERYONE WHO HAS CANCER DIES, NOT EVERYONE WITH AUTISM IS AN EXTREME CASE, NOT EVERYONE WITH DEPRESSION KILLS THEMSELVES NOT EVERYONE WHO IS BULLIED SHOOTS UP A SCHOOL,.. IM SORRY BUT GROWN ADULTS SAYING I HAVE THIS BUT I DONT DO THAT, ARE THE IGNORANT AS WELL AS IDIOTS. AND NOT EDUCATED IN YOUR MENTAL HEALTH ISSUE
Absolutely cruel. RIP. Lorraine must remain in gaol for the rest of her life.
Im so sorry for Roslyn's brother and having to loose his beautiful sister to such horrendous circumstances. And i hope the young man Peter being interviewed gets an opportunity to change his life,he seems like a genuine good soul,just a lost one.
Great case, you put it together so we’ll. Thank you
Too many excuses are done for Lorraine's behavior. Despite her background she should have known better she wasn't 10, she was 15 at the time of the crimes.
The picture of her on the thumbnail as perhaps aged 6 ....click bait for sure.
Yes! Should be changed!
I do believe she will commit more crimes if released. If you’re not capable of empathy or remorse at 15, it’s unlikely that a couple of years in prison is going to change that.
I am sending out my thoughts and prayers and love to the father's family and his friends I am really! So very sorry for your loss 😢💔 even though it was a long time ago forever young he is gone way to soon he is gone but he will never be forgotten
ADHD on its own isn’t generally responsible for this kind of behaviour. There is immature decision making, need for immediate gratification, focus issues, etc. But if you add abuse, drugs, alcohol with that kind of neurological “tinder”, you will see potential for explosion. Those poor victims.
Mary Bell was 10? How can a crime channel not know that
She was convicted of manslaughter. Not technically a murderer. Shows use the specific wording, so they can grab people's attention.
Some of these kids are born Evil. Others are victims of their circumstances
My son is 10 and has severe c-adhd that can't be medicated and he isn't violent...
People are not all the same, so we don't all react the same to the same diagnosis. That goes with kids as well. If your son isn't temperamental by nature, his reduced impulse control from the ADHD won't make him physically lash out when he's frustrated. And I'm also pretty sure your son doesn't come from a dysfunctional background and has become a heavy drinker.
@Kari F yea I definitely feel like it's being a product of your environment I am horribly adhd and was raised by a violent narcissist alcoholic and when I was younger I was violentttt and frustration in school from not being able to focus or read when someone's talking In class, I would go right to anger and violence because I was taught that's how you deal with all feelings
❤
That's because you are a good parent 👍🏾❤
@@KimmyyCocoa I can relate. Being raised in a violent home does leave a mark on a child's brain. I feared my dad after watching him beat my sister for being fat. She was 10 and I was 4 and my father was an athletic muscular 6ft tall violent man. My mom never ever stopped him. Her advice to me was to pretend it didn't happen. I told her all the cruel things he did to me when she wasn't home. I now realize she didn't care as long as she wasn't being abused. I believe our brains and body are always on alert. Our main focus is to be ready for anything. Sounds smell and always listening for early signs of irritation anger or any escalation of excitement. We never knew what to expect and our brains focus was to be ready for the unexpected. I also believe ptsd can send us right back to the panic we felt as a kid not knowing how to navigate forward....
If I could make a wish for you it would be...
To forgive your childhood mistakes
and try to love your inner child. A child that needs positive nourishment....
I'm in my 50s and only recently was I able to put it all together. I'm chronically ill and I understand why and how it all ties together. If I could go back and have a do over I would.
Those poor people. How utterly awful.
Lets face it she has antisocial personality disorder and was on the way to psychopath.
Taking meds for adhd does not turn you into a murderer!
Yeah dat child had already had a motion for killing
But she STOPPED her meds. Maybe that was a part of the story.
It was plainly stated that STOPPING the medication for adhd could have played a part. Keep up.
That is not what the documentary is saying and I do not understand why people keep saying that. They merely mentioned she was taking meds and then ceased taking them.
It is always fair to mention anything that could POTENTIALLY be a contributing, or relevant, factor to something.
Literally no one said that it does. They are giving background on the girl and factors that may have contributed to her subsequent behavior. So, the ADHD diagnosis, the meds or inconsistent taking may have; we don’t know.
A normal family for the first 13 years of her life, and then it all falls into a big mess. Where were the grandparents, aunts uncles and rest of the family members to step in and help these children before they went into this lifestyle. For the father, to become homeless, and an alcoholic, and the mothers start drinking two or whatever the problem was, where was the rest of the family what happened to the other three siblings?
They were really hammering on the ADHD thing seems like medicating your kids and telling them that there’s something wrong with them is not helping a lot of really wealthy people very successful people who have ADHD they’re creative and hyperfocus when there’s something they’re interested I think kids need to reframe the way they think of this look at it as a power instead of something negative.
I call BS on all the excuses for her! She is just evil and should be locked away for life!
I truly do not understand how she only got 14 years. She can be out at age of 29. What has been done to help with rehabilitation. I understand that society let her fall between the cracks. The same society that failed her will be the same society that says she is ok to let out. Does not sound like win , win for the people who have to interact with her should she be free.
I was feeling bad for this gurl ,until I found out what all She did ,I dont anymore .Shes evil and whether she was born evil r made that way ,evil none the less and should be locked away .
My son's father has unmedicated ADHD and he literally put his hands around my throat & strangled me. But I don't blame his ADHD for that.. he's just a violent man & I hope to never see him again.
Notice they don't say how she is behaving in prison???
I am sending out my thought and prayers and love to her family and her friends I am really! So very sorry for your loss 😢💔 even though it was a long time ago forever young she is gone way to soon she is gone but she will never be forgotten
How does the social system put a child with an unstable man where she learnt bad behaviour to be a killer
Classic case of you reap what you sow.
It 🤬 if the police had went in the house the first time Roselyn would still be alive now🤬 My Deepest Condolences Go Out To Both Families and Friends✝🙏🏽💜🕊🕊
Nope. Mary Bell, also an English girl, murdered two other children by the time she was eleven.
It was manslaughter (according to the courts). Meaning this video's title is technically correct. It grabs more people's attention this way, which is all channels care about.
She always had free will. She chose evil over good.
Thank you! From Wenatchee WA!
ADHD is not an illness it hyper activity that today children are medicated for it. In the early of last century children in the US used to help their parents in farms, city children also helped as much as they could. Later children played outside a lot and they were tired afterwards and calm down, until children started to disappeared, mostly children who played or walked alone, (strength in numbers). So parents stopped letting children play outside without supervision, then parents of hyper active children didn’t know how to deal with their child/ten and also teachers because the children disrupted the class so the solution of psychiatric is to numb those children with medication.
Unless those children have violent parents or friends or both, those children just need to have some sort of physical activity they will be focused after getting both therapy and physical activity.
Do you feel that the western diet with so much sugar, plays any role in ADHD?
@@krmccarrell No. Sugar can make you hyperactive. That has nothing to do with ADHD. People who really know what ADHD is, do not reduce it to hyperactivity. BTW you can also present hypoactive - so not hyperactive at all - at least from the outside.
All the extenuating circumstances the psychologist presents are true. But she has not mentioned that some people are just born evil. Furthermore, millions of kids have ADHD and don't become murderers, in spite of poor living conditions. I think the psychologist fell victim to her own emotions and her comments are not objective.
dont kick dogs
I lived in that area in the 90S. I knew of a young 14/15 yr old who hung in parting group and stayed with 40 year old man.
I grew up the same way but didnt turn into a killer. My 4 sisters and brothers didnt either. This show is making us all capable of killing. WRONG!!!
I think it was the older guy who was the catalyst. She probably wouldn't have done anything like this without his coaching and encouragement. But yes I agree it is our choice at any age really, especially at this level of torture and killing over days.
That is not at all what I understood of this video. Firstly, I am a mental health provider, focused working in mental
Health crisis services, and want to say that absolutely everyone, without exception, responds to trauma differently and everyone also has a different resiliency and breaking point. I could have 20 clients who have astoundingly similar backgrounds regarding traumatic experiences and each one of them will process that and respond to it, mentally, emotionally, behaviorally, and sometimes even physically differently ( such as in cases with somatic disorder diagnosis).
Hence, just because you and your 4
Siblings had a similar life to hers does not really mean much since you are all different people, even if your 4 siblings ended up processing issues similar to you.. there are still almost 8 billion people out there who process trauma differently. Genetics, processing, personality, mental
Health status and so much more will vary incredibly much. Epigenetic’s has given us incredible insights into how vastly different people are, process and what they are susceptible to.
For instance, I have bio family and we were raised in the same home, with the same exposures and lifestyle and upbringing, yet, my family member struggled with Alcoholism while I did not. At the end of the day, everyone is like a snowflake and fingerprint and you can never compare it or black and white the situation. Always remember that you, nor I, am everybody else.
Your experience, and that if your siblings, Is yours, but you cannot speak for everyone else in the world.
They makes excuses for her. I hope she is locked up for the rest of her life.
…it’s unfortunate to have been dealt with these circumstances but not everyone ends up this way, you be one great example. We as humans have the capability but not all of us will ever get to use that ability.
This guy manipulated her, don't think she would have done this without him.
No excuses..no Mercy... that's NUTS!
The dubstep drop at 15:05 is crazy lmao
Is drinking alcohol in the streets ok there in the UK? If not, then why isn't the police doing anything about it?
That high pitched sound is awful !!!!!
Oh let’s blame it on everything but the person themselves
She isn’t the youngest their was a 10 yo named Mary bell who killed two toddlers please she did it alone
Why wasn't Lorraine given medical treatment for her ADHD whilst in care of the justice system?
This is a fantastic question. I work within the mental health field as a provider and I can say that what is legally Supposed to happen is that the child has an assigned social worker who is mandated and in charge of getting mental health and medication services for the child approved via court. The only options I see that could have occurred is, someone dropped the ball and did not get orders from the courts.. or when returned to families care, since she was no longer a ward of the court, family did not follow up with her treatment and care, which may be a viable option given the nature of alcoholism from her father… or her assigned social worker and treatment team did not ensure she took her meds after it being approved via court.
As I said, I work in this field and not but a few months ago I had a huge battle with, truth be told, a CPS social worker and CPS staff due to this staff informing me that they “accidentally left” a child’s medication in a hotel they were keeping him in due to the current epidemic we are having regarding lack of placements for children. I was able to obtain this child’s medication for him and delivered it to CPS myself because I was not going to let that stand. In this case, prior to them leaving the clients meds, the courts had approved the client to take medication.
It’s a long day at work but so worth it to make sure nobody is lost, falls behind or slips through the cracks!
They all should be charged as adults doesn’t matter if they are teenagers
God what a life, however we have one law for everyone and murder means you have taken the life of another person and there is a price to pay! No excuses, do the time and get help. I’m gonna hugs my kids!!
I’m having trouble having empathy for the father that was killed. The system and her parents failed her. Allowed her to be manipulated and turned into a damn killer by another fucking low life. As far as she was concerned her life was fucking over. Dangerous thoughts for a person. They either kill themselves or turn into a person causing misery for others.
neglect by parents
Why show a picture of a 6 yo? She was 15. What she did is dispicable and I feel sad for people around her when she comes out. RIP to the victims 😢
"Nature" not " Nurture"..
A " bad seed"
Britain's youngest female double murderer - that's not true. Mary Bell was 10.
I thought this crime occurred in England, where people speak English. I can’t tell what the hell Peter Green is saying at all.
Rehabilitated? Gladiator school for girls is still Gladiator school. Good luck with that.
Just because someone has ADHD doesnt give them a hall pass from determining between right and wrong. You can tell she had no remorse, no empathy. She is just as guilty and just as evil.
This poor girl likely had a lot more going on than adhd. But I’m glad a country like UK takes these contextual details into consideration when evaluating ppl’s actions.
Deranged minds are born deranged.
Most of them
Breakdown of family values has resulted in rich but lonely people.
Whatever the circumstances are & here we hear off very sad but real scenarios of most modern families being played out is still no reason for murder let alone 2. This case had all the right ingredients for murderers & PPL who study social , behaviour patterns need to publish the specific traits to be aware off EG - ADHD, bi polar , teen from broke home, bad anti social groups & older male predators.
I am concerned with how many unwanted children will turn out this way now that the United States government is in the business of forcing women to have children they don't want, don't know how to raise, and cannot afford.
I’m hoping that most women who want an abortion will get one, either with pills or getting to a blue state. It’s outrageous what the Republicans have done (what else is new?).
NO ONE is FORCING anyone to have (or keep ) a child they don’t want, don’t know how to raise and cannot afford.
@@MelodyRose124If only that were true.
😐
@@studiosandi it is true
Slavery
We have bylaws about drinking in the streets. This is sad because public behaviours attract more people together with the same bad habits, making it OK.
Why didn’t she stay with her mother was she staying with her father Because she was looking after him and worried about him I don’t understand why she wasn’t with her mother if her mother had a stable home
I enjoy listening to the narrator she sounds like the lumbley actress..
The society is what that same society want it to be...if you normalise those behavior in society, don't wonder how this could happen
Her 14 years sentence should be over this year. Was she paroled? Any updates?
I'm sorry but both deny the allegations, but it doesn't take a brain surgeon th relies that. She has been living with dad on the street and didn't resort to alcohol and violence. That changed after she caught the eye of him. Suddenly she wants to come across as a mature woman. Behaving as badly as he did.
Poverty, alcohol, drugs and homelessness that is the first problem here… the inequality of the wealthy in England Versus everyone else and you have the first issue and the answer!!!
Lorraine could have made better choices regardless of how her parents were, she chose excitement. Lots and lots of kids have a worse upbringing, and turn out to be beautful outstanding citizens.. I speak from experience.
Well, I'm pleased, I'm sure, that you turned into a beautiful, outstanding citizen. Could you then please try to be less judgemental?
Alcoholics love only alcohol.
Nothinh else existx for them
Stop making excuses for her behavior
well worth watching. TCC narrated another brilliant chilling crime story, thanx & keep em coming
Actress reminds me of actress MacKenzie Phillips who also had a substance abuse problem.
It's odd that so many lives have been lost because of voices they heard in their heads ! 2000 yrs ago those PPL where Hailed as special & many men went to war for them.
This is why I don't believe everyone is entitled to having children and there should be some sort of regulation regarding breeding. But whatever.
Or about alcoholism?
The hope that she can be rehabilitated! Good Lord. No possible way,
I have ADHD and can’t be medicated with my epilepsy medicated
In the transition to the epic to south Africa you can see how people replicate foreign accent to sell drugs and Mariana overseas
Thank God the Brits are not allowed to carry guns.
I'm so tired of "professionals" making excuses for why people act the way they do. "Excuses are like @$$holes...everyone has one and they all stink". Hold people accountable for what they did and put them in jail. NO early release for good behavior, NO parole just a small cell where they have to spend 24/7 with no television, internet, sports to "distract" them. THAT is called punishment. And if you killed someone, YOU are locked up for as long as your victim is dead.
Agree completely, and that includes the torture and killing of innocent animals.
Prison is supposed to allow for the possibility of rehabilitation, or have you forgotten that?
It’s a good thing the rest of the world is interesting in learning how things happen to help prevent future disaster. You just want to punish people who choose to punish people…luckily for you there are people who can help you with this urge and you can get help before you hurt someone.
Why did Rosie's brother when she and her daughter needed her?
Why did Rosie's brother what???? Your question makes absolutely 0 sense with very conflicted grammer!
ADHD does not cause that kind of behavior. She like schizophrenic or something
Unbelievable what they said about adhd
Schizophrenia doesn't either. Schizophrenia does not equate violence as per my brother, my experience in the field, research and my own psychotic depressive episode which shared many schizophrenic symptoms. Ignorance.
Bipolar most likely.
They didn't say it like that though. They clearly said it was a combination of things like not taking her meds plus trauma plus alcohol plus bad environment.
Please be extremely careful about what you are saying. I am aN active mental health provider and I work in providing mental health care for those in crisis and what you have said is actually not correct and can spread miseducation.
Her behavior absolutely does not meet the provision/ criteria to be diagnosed with Schizophrenia, per the DSM, nor was she even the age for such a diagnosis to be onset.
You are welcome to your own opinions but I strongly urge everyone to not throw diagnoses out that that they more than likely do not have the necessary formal education in and for those who are not active clinicians/ work with the current DSM.