Office Blokes React *GUITAR WEEK* | Tina S - Moonlight Sonata (REACTION!!)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 вер 2020
- Link to original video: • Ludwig van Beethoven -...
Comment Below with More Reaction Ideas!
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
She's not bored, she's focused, it's extremely hard piece of music, and she is playing it for over 6 minutes in one take, video is not edited. Look at smile of satisfaction at the end, when she knew she nailed it! It takes really long time even for experienced guitarist to learn song like this and put it into muscle memory.
People often saying "pure talent", but the true is that this is pure hard work, with is much more admirable!
It's massive amounts of talent AND hard work.
I have no talent, and couldn't play that if I practiced 24/7 for 30 years.
BUT.
Without massive amounts of hard work, all her talent would be worthless too.
I totally agree with the talent doesn't make the final cut in the end of it all... I have talent but I hate to practice... I can't play like that now but if I practiced... who knows what i could do?
She went from the guitar being bigger than her to being bigger than the guitar. Just one of:
ua-cam.com/video/iwoVfWTo2nU/v-deo.html
She left UA-cam because of comments her videos were fake, it is claimed.
Someone decided to play this recording through a guitar game Hero. The idea is to play the notes presented in the game at the proper time. A lightening strike means a miss, colour means a hit. I counted 12 misses, possibly a variation in the score. This is testimony to her timing and accuracy. To be clear, she is playing independently to the game's tempo.
ua-cam.com/video/xB9l4U2D1rc/v-deo.html
Pure talent will only get you so far. After that, it's down to hard work. I have the slight suspicion that she needed a lot of both for this.
@András Ács FRUSTRATION ??? HOBBY IS FRUSTRATION ????
Honesty there's not enough adjectives to describe how talented Tina S. Is
For me, she is the best guitarist in the world.
She has an impressive technique, absolute perfection, also at the time of this video she was 17 years old!
No one can dream of doing what she does, period.
Gentlemen, that 'bored' look is the epitome of being in the ZONE. Nothing else maters beyond what you're doing at that moment. If you noticed, for the most of the piece, she didn't even look at the fret broad.
simp
flow theory
@@muratklc1078 huh?
Simp
She had to train for 3 or 4 months before she filmed this amazing piece and played it without the notes on paper. At the time of recording she was 17.
Always the same with everyone: They start watching, then they giggle at the first riff, then it starts getting really quiet...shocked faces, glazed-over eyes, heads slowing shaking side to side in disbelief. All, by the way, completely appropriate. She's that good.
Yep. I was absolutely blown away when I first found her probably 7 or 8 years ago now. I know a friend that knows Eddie Van Halen and Eddie stated that Tina is absolutely insane the way she bends those strings. And Eddie made a living playing that thing.
Why is everybody talking about talent? This is real hard work combined with talent. But don't forget the work that has been put in.
Exactly. Hard work alone does not guarantee a virtuoso - that needs unimaginably immense amount of work over many years with an equal level of required natural talent.
Well sometimes hard work can't get you this Far if you don't have the talent. There are tons of guitarist who must have played and practiced a lot more than Tina but are no where hear her level. Not taking away her hardwork and the years of practice but how often do you see a 17 year old playing like that. Her talent is definitely one of a kind
Absolutely! like Ling Ling she practiced 40 hours a day since she was 4 years old
Because it IS talent. You say hardwork.. she was 17 dude! That's pure talent! I know several guitarist who practice 6~+ hours a day for years and still can't play like that. That girl is a gem
@@ghost500e You have to like what you are doing as well. If you are forced to do something that is not fun then you aren't really going to pay attention and just go through the motions.
She just plays her guitar! No theatrics, just quality! David Gilmour is much the same, when playing one of his iconic solos he just stands still on the stage, head down, often eyes closed pure emotion comes forth. Its' not necessary to throw your guitar around and make faces at the audience.
I heard that she went back to her planet...
bummer.
stop simpin bro
If that so, which planet is she belong. 😂
@@cleric8543 Mars i’m sure of it 🤣
Yeah Tina S. is a true talent.
Classical is heavy metal without electricity.....
Why...that's very clever. Prokofiev and Shostakovich especially would approve.
Different but so much similar. I really love both
Every time I listen to the William Tell Overture I am always reminded of metal.
@@RicoLen1 Try:
Bartok: Miraculous Mandarin
Prokovieff: Scythian suite
Mossolov: The Iron Foundry.
Shostakovitch: last movement of 11th symphony.
Lots more, esp. early 20th century.
The jaw of the Maestro Beethoven himself would drop to the floor at hearing Tina S's rendition of this movement of The Moonlight Sonata! It is one of my favourite pieces and I've listened to the original on piano more times than I can remember and can honestly say that Tina does not miss a note.
her emotion is the concentration she puts in the performance, see between 5.52 and 5.53 of this video the grimace she make in full concentration when her left hand slides quickly down the guitararm, there is no time in this piece for other emotions than the pure concentration of a faultless performance
Every body talks about her lack of emotion during her playing.after watching this about 50 times i think i have an answer for that.i think her conentration and her confidence in her abilities are utterly and totally complete. A musician friend told me that "guitar face"comes from the player having a way to release tension(think S.R.V.).Tinas' confidence and concentration is so complete she doesnt have any of that tension.by the way she was all of 17 yrs old when she did this.and of all the amazing things she did her age seems unbelievable.great reaction gents thank you
She is classically trained guitarist. It is very rare to see a performance in classical guitar with the player grimacing. Some like Paco de Lucia did it for effect when they became famous but most prefer to express their emotions through their art and not the contractions of face muscles.
Yeah I think she's calm and composed, not bored.
I enjoy her lack of emotion it makes the tiny little things that much more enjoyable. Tiny half smirks, little grimaces in certain parts, that smile just at the end they are all adorable.
Um if you have not yet realized , women don’t need to make facial expressions and ugly faces while playing guitar . Besides that , this is a very demanding piece
She just focus and have a 'Bitch im resting my face' kinda face and thats it
She becomes oblivious to everything around her , she's at one with the guitar and becomes the music . Her facial expressions she would not be aware of .She's brilliant , an absolute phenomenon. 🇬🇧
Guys.. she was already voted the best guitarist in the world and she was only 16 (possibly 17) when she did this.. she is beyond incredible...
Tina S is absolutely amazing, I've been a fan of hers since the first video I ever saw her do! Two thumbs up if I could!
Tina S released this video 4 years ago, and because of haters who did not support this talent, who called her "Fake", she stopped posting videos, and she's now only 20 years old !
When I listen to her, I have chills, I feel from her a love for the guitar and an innate and indefinable talent as she masters her subject. A genius, simply, for our greatest happiness !!! Thank guy for your reactions the same as mine !!
I heard she stopped posting because she went to college/university...and she's the type that when she does something she does it 110% ...so she put her guitar on the backburner while she studies!
She posted this in August 2016 and it was her final video, which means she just started her final year if she's in a 5 years school cursus
Tina S. is God that came to earth in the body of a young woman and decided to show everyone how really play the guitar. She is wonderful!
ok simp
YAHWEH is not a human. HIS Holy Spirit sustains life, but HE never was, is, or will ever be a human being. I pray that you repent of your blasphemy in the name of YAHWEH and Yeshua.
I get so tired of people saying she is bored! She worked at her art so hard that when she did play it for someone she knew it by heart! This in turn made it look like she was bored! She has more talent in her little finger than most people that say she is bored!!!
She once said the only critics which is important for her is the critic of the composers/original
players like Steve Vai etc. That's the spirit !
Beethoven was deaf when he wrote this for piano. I like to think that THIS is what he heard in his mind when he composed it.
Beethoven pieces more than not are actually heavy asf, thats why thye sound so great as metal tracks
@@Mugthraka Very true, his compositions were disliked by many at the time for being so violent in comparison to the norm. He was basically the first Heavy Metal artist, lol.
just don't oversimp bro
He actually wasn’t. He was just beginning to really have hearing issues and would not be deaf for about ten more years. He was still performing on the piano when he wrote this and was forced to quit long before he was fully deaf.
another cause not to simp
It is virtually impossible to explain how difficult the hammer-ons and pull-offs are to execute in this song. The tapping demands perfect timing to complete. If she misses one tap in the long run, it is extremely difficult to get the notes to ring out again. Amazing!!
This young generation of musicians are amazing!
It's not like when you're jamming, where anything good goes. She's note perfect to the original score!!!
Is it even possible to play the third movement on a guitar, going note for note with the original score for the piano?
I don't think you can replicate every bit of it on a guitar, and I feel like I noticed certain left hand rhythmic sections that went missing in the translation from a piano to a guitar score. Like it's a limitation of the instrument itself.
There's a few places in the original score where I think you play four simultaneous notes across 3 octaves. A guitar only covers 3 octaves and I don't think it's possible without a another pair of hands, and maybe not even then.
At least that was my experience trying to play stuff written for the piano on highland bagpipes, which are quite a bit more limited at just a single octave.
It's been arranged for the guitar beautifully though.
Watch somebody play this on the piano.
This is EXACTLY what Beethoven was going for.
An amazing piece played amazingly by Tina.
PS: Watch her closely. There's emotion there. It's just subdued.
And the smile at the end speaks volumes.
Peace
Just think about the hours, hundreds if not thousands it would take to get this perfect
I have Followed Tina for quite a few years and she is absolutely mind blowing and this is another amazing performance, pure french mastery, her parents must be so damn proud of her
Fortunately, because the equipment and the teacher are expensive
Tina has become one of my favorite guitar player's...
I come back to this here and there cuz I'm still in awe like they were seeing this for the 1st time, and I know every note she's playing by now so I can just look at their faces thru it all 😄
I really like these guys.. I hope when they take vacations to the U.S. they set themselves up for some gd solid times. I'd really like going over there myself and visiting their recommendations. 👍✌️
She's the Mona Lisa of guitar.
simp
I've been trolled by an incomplete word, YEE HAW my life is now complete.
@@donaldcornley9963 huh, simp? why are you simpin? complete enough for you?
@@kbuss10 I'm going to go the extra mile and explain my statement, which I wouldn't normally do simply put what does the Mona Lisa embody, culture, refinement, restraint, knowledge and abilities. That little smile she has means she knows it but she is not a poser about it, to me that's character and class. I'm a TinaS fan not a sicophant.
@@donaldcornley9963 you mean simp
And to think Tina was only 17 when she recorded this. She is absolutely fantastic. Really hope she comes back after graduating from Uni. We need more of her amazing work. Absolutely phenomenal talent. Dedication and hard work. She was only 15 when she did Through The Fire and the Flames.
End of university in 2023
@@0ParisFrance She's back at last!!! (with her band "Spin Twice")!
If the sky is the limit, she left the milky way and got beyond universe.
Looking her play, my wrist start to feel pain ...normal people wont by able to go for 10 seconds like this ...inspiring
Michael Mueller
What are you on about?
Yeah, she is absolutely amazing.
Tina S is from Paris Fr. Nobody can match her skill
She could give Stevie Ray Vaughn a run for best guitarist
TINA VON BOSNIEN
Guy's, you should react to her cover of Steve Vai's "For the Love Of God" she absolutely nails it! Tina is so good Steve Vai personally contacted her and paid her a huge compliment telling her she nailed it.
I see your all as stunned as I am. I certainly agree that Tina is talented, maybe even gifted, but giving too much credence to that discounts the amount of time and work she has put into perfecting her "talent". That performance just defies belief! WOW! Tina is an anomaly wrapped in a conundrum wrapped in an enigma. I'm in AWE! of her and the amount of hard work it took to perfect that flawless performance. So I'll just give it another WOW!! Thanks for sharing that Masterpiece! 💕💕
She is amazing . . . Hypnotic for me at times!
Craziest thing is she was only 16 when she filmed this... I was barely able to walk and chew gum at 16 ^_^
simp
NO 17 y.o.
She was great at 6
*Correction 17.
She is not bored. She is totally focused!
I watch Tina play this Beethoven piece once a week, it raises your spirits
Sadly this was the last performance she ever posted online, she got sick and tired of trolls constantly attacking her for looking bored all the time. Maybe one day she'll return because she's certainly gifted..... You three also fell into the trap of criticising how she looked, confirming her irritation at how people wrongly judge her, She always claimed that she's in a zone remembering every note she's about to play.
her solo cover from comfortably numb was one of the best ive seen.
I do agree that she shouldn't be judged on how she looks at anytime and judged purely on her talent, ability, and work ethic to play something so brilliant. That being said, if she puts herself out there in the public she should already know what comes along with that. If she is truly "sick and tired" of people saying that she looks bored then she might be in for a rough ride called life. I wish that was the worst thing people had to say about me. This is the most brilliant performance I have ever seen/heard by a woman or a man and she should be damn proud and not give a shit what us mortals think about whether or not she is looking bored during her performance.
Exactly!
@@brianobrian9334 it's actually mine, but it's not pushed by simps bcos I'm not a woman
the simpin here 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
It's not looking bored, it's pure focus.
I love how she just slings her arm over the neck of the guitar at thee end as if to say "and that's how ya do that"
BEST GOD DAMMM GUITARIST IN THE GALAXY ❤️❤️❤️
She was 17 at the time. She is NOT bored. She is trained in classical guitar as well. She is mad focused. Look at classical musicians, they don't show emotions because they are super focused. This piece is super hard to play on a guitar. And she did it in one take. Do you have any idea how many notes are there in 3rd Movement of "Moonlight Sonata"? Look it up.
She is not bored.
She is just in her own space at this time. She does not play it or feel it. She lives it in THAT moment. And that is so precious!
it would have been awesome if after she finished the 3rd movement she would have said "anyway heres wonderwall"
Beethoven was very controversial and "heavy" in his time. He basically put an end to classical era and lead music into more free formed passionate romanticism. He would have loved an electric guitar. Well, he loved fortepiano, and basically was the first one who started massively write pieces to it, cause it had MUCH heavier sound than clavier. Moonlight sonata was for piano too.
I had the same look on my face as you 3 once she started. At 17, I think she was, when this was recorded....amazing!
You forgot to say that she was 17 in that video, I believe it's an important detail.
A lot of professionals that play for decades would not be able to play like that
Ladies week: BAND-MAID, 5 young ladies from Japan. Not only the best all female band but probably the best live hard-rock/metal band on the planet right now - period. There are plenty of live videos on their official channel (I'd recommend "Real Existence" or "Play"). You will not regret it. Promised. Please. Thank you. Keep up the reactions. Like your open-mindedness.
Hello, Chaps. I found this on UA-cam a few years back. Never get tired of it. Amazing the stuff you can find on here that is not in the mainstream. Tina S is right up there. She has not posted for a long while so who knows whats happened, but talent like this needs a public. And you`re spot on about BGT compared to proper genius.
She was 17yrs old there
the brain to the ears to the fingers are unreal she makes it look so easy , she is part of that guitar
According to an interview, she treated these solos sort of like video games. It was muscle memory after so much practice. She started playing guitar when she was 6. Her instructor(I think her brother) was Renaud Louis-Servais. I hear rumors she is putting all that amazing focus into university(law?).
Renaud Louis-Servais is not her brother.
and to memorize more than 6 mins of muzik is another amazing thing too... she has a great gift ...
None none
Sorry! What are you talking about? I must have imagined it when i saw Iron Maiden and Gun's n' Roses play 2 hour sets! LOL
Remember this, Beethoven (in the opinion of many - me included) is the first ever Metalhead!
He would have no problem at all listening to this!
And i´m not just saying this because i´m German! ;)
Also you have to see that Tina was 16 or 17 when she recorded that!
That is massive talent!
Tina S. lives in France and has played guitar since she was small (6? I think?) When she hit 12 or 13 she switched from classical guitar to electric.
In this video she is 17. She dropped out of social media soon after, and that was about 3 years ago.
She has moved on to University; word is for a business degree.
To play at this level, you have to practice 8 hrs a day for months to pull this off as flawlessly as she does. Most professional classical musicians do.
Well, perhaps stating the obvious, Tina is French.
been watching her stuff for about 6 years , i played guitar in heavy metal bands , and she's amazing
This recent surge of reactions to Tina S reminds me of YT's suggestions column: there are always videos that say "recommended to you" and when you go and check them they're 10 years old.
IIRC she had been playing for ~10 years already when that was made. Incredibly talented and practiced.
This is one of piano's hardest songs to play......and she did it with an electric guitar. I dare anyone in the world to do what Tina S. just did.
She did Not miss a single note 🤯💯
Rumour is that Tina has stopped playing to concentrate on her studies. I'm hopping for a comeback!
When she was 6 and 14, she was also focused on her studies! And then there are the 3 months of holidays !
I like the part where she's playing left-hand pizzicato while simultaneously her right hand is moving up the fingerboard doing Things Guitar Players Don't Normally Do.
Great choice of piece to feature Gents! Tina S is amazing, I particularly like her rendition of Steve Vai's "For the Love of God" and Dave Gilmour's solo from Comfortably Numb :)
Talent,practice...call it whatever you want...She's a Gods gift. The Office Blokes are right,these "talent"shows doesn't even deserve a talent as she is.
giggles...Exceptional differences in someone professionally trained to be a "Master Guitarist"
(who can play anything, note for note, tone for tone, consistently every time) und someone
who has excelled in their music genre "only". She actually played many different parts of this
composition...und did it superbly. :-) Beethoven was quite rebellious...I think he would have
loved watching someone of this exceptional talent..."plug him in". :-)
Tina nails anything she plays , played watch her Yngwie covers Yngwie actually said that Arpeggios From Hell is one of the most insane stuff he came up with and she played it without giving a single shit. Respect.
I love the take on what you see on Britain's Got Talent- "Some knob walking a dog through hoops."
hey! it took me a long time you train that fucking dog and then the bastard thing died!
She's AMAZING btw! WOOOW!!
She makes that guitar talk!!
I've heard several different pieces of Classical music played on the Electric Guitar and they are all among the best Guitar music I've ever heard. I would love an "Electric Symphony/Orchestra" where the entire concert is done like this. No singing required.
You can see just from her eyes she's putting everything in to it
Tina interview : "Even if on my videos I seem, as many say, to be bored, it's quite the opposite. I am super focused, deeply into the solo!"
TINA SETKIC FILMED AT 17 y.o. BY HER PROFESSOR Renaud LOUIS-SERVAIS, in 2016 near Paris in France.
She started to practice when she was 6 yo. It's talent but it's talent that has been grown for over 10 years.
Dedication and practice = Mesmerizing.
I find it amazing that these blokes are practically making fun of her for not over exaggerating with facial expressions.... most good guitarist do not use much if any facial expressions in the studio.... She is not preforming... she is in a recording session.... watch this video of Eddie Van Halen demonstrating in front of a crowd.... notice he does not use much expression at all.... now, mock him
Yes, Tina is a schoolgirl, not a stage performer.
TINA SETKIC. Dragon force through the fire and the flames cover at 15 years old, awesome awesome thanks 😊🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥👀👀🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎🎵🎵🎵🎵🎼🎼🎼🎶🎶🎶🎵🎵💣💣💣💣💣💣💣 really mind blowing awesome 😎same girl
Tina is my favorite guitarist. She has been missing for a few years while she completes her education studies. Be sure to check out more of her covers!
There's a 'Guitar Hero' side by side version of this. Worth a look.
Proof positive that alot of these early composers...if alive today....would be metalheads.
@ Office Blokes... - it is not just talent but hard and persistent work. In addition to electric guitar and rock music, Tina has been constantly learning, practicing and playing classical guitar and classical music since she was 6 years old. The result is visible - absolutely fantastic, absolutely phenomenal!
that moment someone's hand has an after image, almost 3 to be exact, you know they are of godlike skill
To play like this, takes a great deal of time and dedication - PLUS (BIG PLUS!!) phenomenal talent. I bet she's basically, gifted, (photographic memory and really hi IQ ??). Anything she tries to do - she can do and does it extremely well. I love the way she uses the unique features of the guitar (which are not those of the piano) to embellish the music - bends up and down, harmonics, sympathetic string vibrations plus many others for which I don't know the name. I'm a pianist and have practiced this piece (a lot!) and believe me, it's difficult - but on the guitar - Wow - this good? never. PS & FYI - The second movement is MUCH easier. PPS - I'm really glad I don't play the guitar.
Watching her not only gives me hope. BUT TEARS TO MY EYES AS WE LOST EVH. MAYBE SHE CAN CARRY THE TORCH FOR US ALL. LOVE HER BLESS HER TALENT THAT THE WORLD HAS NOW SEEN.
Oooh, I miss Tina S :(
amen to that!
What happened to her?! 😨
@@BronzDano I don't really know tbh. All I know is that some say that she has distanced herself from UA-cam (and social media?) because of the negativity in the internet. But this was years ago and I don't know if that's the real reason. Please someone correct me if I'm wrong. One day she stopped to upload new videos. I'm still hoping for a comeback!
stop simpin
@@reality8o im pretty sure she / they made a statement, that she will be gone (distancing from youtube) while she attends college, and she will come back after it, so she can completely focus to that!
That`s not "only" talent, insane talent, it is also thousands upon thousands of hours of practicing.
Never seen something this perfect.
Hello there folks ! That amazing prodigy not only nailed it in speed but also didn't miss a single note.
Ludwig Van Beethoven himself would applause and bow to her with respect if he was around because the reason he did the third movement so complicated and demanding was to make sure his rivals couldn't get anywhere close to that level , in other words he was showing off his superiority towards other musicians of that era in Vienna , and this "kiddo" not only did that but she played the damn thing 25% faster . In music terms that is like light years away
No, it was Dr VIOSSY who played and created this faster version.
Tina est Parisienne et j'en suis extrêmement fier. Depuis qu'elle a commencé j'en suis comme abruti de plaisir, à chaque fois et pour tout ses morceaux. Le Moonlight à été arrangé pour la guitare par Dr Viossi et, après avoir regardé, sur youtube, un duel de ces deux-là sur ce même morceau, je reste encore persuadé de la meilleure prestation de Tina. Il parait que D.Gilmour, que j'aime profondément, à retweeté un des morceaux de son répertoire qu'elle a interprété. Dès que j'ai un petit coup de fatigue mentale, je l'écoute à m'en faire craquer les tympans. Pour notre malheur elle s'est retirée et personne ne semble savoir pourquoi ni pour combien de temps, pas même son prof que j'ai contacté. Une capacité de travail incroyable, une mémoire de fou, un talent immense, et en plus elle est jolie.
Tina Parisienne ? Ah bon, elle n'est plus Évryenne ? Pourtant son adresse n'a pas changé. Pour Gilmour il paraît seulement ; ce n'est pas Gilmour qui twitte sur Tina mais Nick Mason : twitter.com/nickmasondrums/status/742340757634355200
every note she plays flows from her soul, do not belittle such focus and skill and $heart. | G# - B# - D# - F#, a G# dominant seventh
I drop my food plate from my hand, When I see this young lady move her fingers on the guitar strings, I can't even move my hand back and force this fast, It's look easy than she Chewing her gums. No other words to described beside. OH MY GOD
She's playing a classical masterpiece holding the guitar in classical mode. But you knew that right?😉
Tina revelação do momento 👏👏👏
I watched this video on her own channel. Then after that i watched " Reaction Videos". And your description is by far the best reaction ever. You said she looked bored. I said that the first time seeing it. And the description of BGT. " Never watched it". Was spot on. Bag of shite.
During her playing she sometimes has this look like that she is wondering if she put the laundry in the machine. And that smirk at the end she realises, yes, I put it in the machine.
that is god work ,thank you lord !
No tears? I always get a few tears when I watch Tina S. play this.