The 'Holly not recognizing Kryten' thing is, imo, a reference to Kryten being played by a different actor when Norman Lovett's version of Holly met him. I know that female Holly is supposed to be the same character with a head swap, but it's a neat little acknowledgement to the past while not totally breaking the 4th wall.
I'm not sure about one arm but people who lose other limbs have been amazing, take for example Sir Douglas Bader an RAF pilot who lost both his legs in a flying accident but when WWII broke out he learned how to fly a fighter plane with metal legs rejoined the RAF and managed to shoot down 22 German aircraft before being shot down and captured he even managed to escape his POW camp twice and because of this he had to be put in colditz and threatened with having his artificial legs confiscated, after the war he help a great many people who were disabled learn to adapt and earned a knighthood for it, the word amazing was invented to describe people like him.
Götz von Berlichingen AKA Götz of the Iron Hand was a German Mercenary he lost his right arm at the elbow when enemy cannon fire forced his sword against him. He had two mechanical prosthetic iron replacements made. The second, more famous prosthetic hand was capable of holding objects from a shield or reins to a quill. Both are today on display at the Burg Jagsthausen. In spite of this injury, Berlichingen continued his military activities. In the subsequent years he was involved in numerous feuds, both of his own and in support of friends and employers.
This was the first episode of red dwarf I ever saw. It was during the run up to series 10 where Dave aired series 1 to 8, but backwards for some reason.
I admit, like many, I did not like season 8. However, it is actually for that reason I cannot wait to hear your more nuanced take on it; particularly after you gave me a much greater appreciation for season 7, despite its faults. :)
This episode is really nice, I do like that it's written to bring some sincerity to Lister's predicament, but it has some fun twists including the nanobots and Red Dwarf's real fate, though they risked that plot being crammed into this alongside Lister's trouble, but I think they weaved things together well enough that it worked out nicely without feeling stuffed and unbalanced, and of course the show's goofy nature help's for not requiring the audience to think too hard over things or take such coincidence too seriously.
I am loving your RD vlogs. I watch them at every meal. Just ordered the new series on DVD. But i remember the part in this episode were Lister is reveled with muscles because it hurt my feelings when everyone acted as if it was strange or gross. I was actually bigger than the model they used for Lister at one point when I was bodybuilding. Seems the only body type people can make fun of without being called out for body shaming. Lol. Still a great episode,but that part always made me huffy,lol. Anyway, keep up the vids!!
I don't think it was the body type they were laughing at, it was the fact it was Lister. any body type that wasn't his would be funny; fat, skinny, white, female, that's the joke.
I remember when I first saw this episode I went back to check the episodes in question and, yeah, the Despair Squid was the last time we saw Red Dwarf until now. Was a nice nod to continuity there. Unfortunately, the gag the end of this episode sets up to start off Season 8 is only the first in a long list of disappointments I have for Season 8. As for how Season 8 ended, well, I'll say my piece when we get there.
I just watched Bladerunner 2049 and realized a lot of things from Red Dwarf. Since the show was inspired by the first movie, I wonder if some things from Red Dwarf got put in the sequel?
I discovered these vlogs a few months ago and think they're brilliant, especially looking forward to a can't smeg won't smeg review, although I didn't peticularly enjoy that special. As for my opinions on the other RD series I think that 3 was the best. Not really a fan of series 6 to 8 but there are a few exceptions and I love series 10 onwards. Anyway enough about me, I have a question for you - how long are you gunna keep these vlogs going, are you going all the way up to series 12?
I have a theory that when kryten is helping lister do everything from playing guitar to dunking biscuits in his tea I think you're right that lister could actually do most of it himself (albeit with difficulty given his only hand is his non dominant hand) but I think he's just acting like that albeit subconsciously to guilt shame kryten.
Recently rewatching VII, I'll admit a lot of it has aged better than on first viewing. The blu-ray removes that fake film effect too. "Beyond a Joke" is my favorite though "Blue" comes close.
@@Cyborcat have just done some red dwarf art from series 7 with lister and co on starbug, sending an sos to find red dwarf. It originally featured kris and no Arnold, however Rimmer took her place after careful deliberation. There’s a shot of red dwarf at the bottom with a sketch of a corridor featuring Holly, scutters near a vending machine, and the original Kristine as a hologram. Way I see it, Holly could still generate a temporary hologram with Rimmer so out of range. He didn’t generate her after the accident, Holly thinks it wouldn’t have worked out with Dave
I had about the same feeling as you did about Nanarchy. However, the only real problem I had with it was that I hate it when people call biscuits "bik-biks". I also found it quite annoying that Kryten was treating Lister like a baby and almost spoon-feeding him. Kochanski was right about him giving Lister some space. Since that was only the weakest part for me, the rest of Nanarchy was really good. I really liked the idea of the Nanobots and how Kryten was talking to them. They were better than the Epideme virus, and the whole episode was better than Epideme.
Season 8 really grew on me over the years. I love the added dynamic of Kochanski for the most part, and Rimmer and Lister being more chummy. Plus I really hate season 9 so anything looks good compared to that for me.
I'm surprised you didn't mention this is the season where Rob Grant left which is why a lot characters changed and the story took a hard right in continuity. It's also why so much of the show was hit and miss and why the next season was so much miss for older fans.
I have no idea why I love Nanarchy so much... maybe because it's the last gasp of 'oldschool' Dwarf before we get into what I think of as the modern era? And as we all know, everything was better back then.
I think the biggest problem with S7 was its best episodes were the first two. Tikka to ride and stoke me a clipper were classics and the rest couldn’t quite measure up.
Cyborcat Meh, your show, your opinions. I can watch it, it's just that some of the jokes fall flat to me. KK is not at her best here, I like her more in S8. The 'Surprise skill' moment worked for me though, mostly because of how it was done and who with. Either way, I still look forward to hearing what you have to say. 😊
I loved when season 8 came out, away were bad memories of the dreadful season 7 and the boys from the Dwarf getting back together and all that could be great was great again.
actually series 7 was better than 8 in my book, once the crew were back aboard a crewed red dwarf it got a lot stupider and less interesting. I don't understand people bitching about 7, rimmer was still in most of it anyway and kochanski wasn't that bad
And now we reach what I think is the absolute worst of the post season 6 Red Dwarf content, I've always hated season 8 (Mind you, most of the seasons post 6 are a bit rubbish)
I think series VIII has a lot of good scenes in some truly terrible episodes. I think Cassandra ends up being the best episode for its simplicity and one-liners, but... yeah, Back in the Red, Krytie TV, Only the Good... and most of all Pete suffer quite a lot. All of them aren't so great, but have some hilarious singular moments or scenes.
The 'Holly not recognizing Kryten' thing is, imo, a reference to Kryten being played by a different actor when Norman Lovett's version of Holly met him. I know that female Holly is supposed to be the same character with a head swap, but it's a neat little acknowledgement to the past while not totally breaking the 4th wall.
aw christ
I realize I am kind of randomly asking but do anybody know of a good site to stream newly released series online?
"And to compound matters, taking over our ship and turning it into a planetoid is unbelievably... Naughty!"
The drummer from Def Leppard has one arm and hes awesome
Wow, i typed a nearly identical comment before scrolling down and seeing this one! Glad I'm not the only one!
Yeah, I did a double-take at that XD
I'm not sure about one arm but people who lose other limbs have been amazing, take for example Sir Douglas Bader an RAF pilot who lost both his legs in a flying accident but when WWII broke out he learned how to fly a fighter plane with metal legs rejoined the RAF and managed to shoot down 22 German aircraft before being shot down and captured he even managed to escape his POW camp twice and because of this he had to be put in colditz and threatened with having his artificial legs confiscated, after the war he help a great many people who were disabled learn to adapt and earned a knighthood for it, the word amazing was invented to describe people like him.
Holly coming back makes me love this episode.
On another note if my body was rebuilt all buff like that I wouldn't be upset.
seriously loving your red dwarf analysis videos!
Hattie Hayridge needs to come back as Holly maybe for Red Dwarf Season 13
Götz von Berlichingen AKA Götz of the Iron Hand was a German Mercenary he lost his right arm at the elbow when enemy cannon fire forced his sword against him. He had two mechanical prosthetic iron replacements made. The second, more famous prosthetic hand was capable of holding objects from a shield or reins to a quill. Both are today on display at the Burg Jagsthausen. In spite of this injury, Berlichingen continued his military activities. In the subsequent years he was involved in numerous feuds, both of his own and in support of friends and employers.
This was the first episode of red dwarf I ever saw. It was during the run up to series 10 where Dave aired series 1 to 8, but backwards for some reason.
Cat is such an unbelievable dingus this episode. 😂
I must say that I always enjoy this episode
The drummer from Def Leppard had one arm. And he was awesome!
I admit, like many, I did not like season 8. However, it is actually for that reason I cannot wait to hear your more nuanced take on it; particularly after you gave me a much greater appreciation for season 7, despite its faults. :)
Alexander Matthews I’m just looking forward to see Rimmer again
glad I'm not the only one who thinks 7 is better than 8 I don't understand the hate for 7 really.
Awww yisss, Can't Smeg, Won't Smeg! Some of Cat's skills coming back!
The best Kyten giving the bird is Jake Bullet in my opinion
Ah, I forgot about that one somehow.
DROPS EVERYTHING
This episode is really nice, I do like that it's written to bring some sincerity to Lister's predicament, but it has some fun twists including the nanobots and Red Dwarf's real fate, though they risked that plot being crammed into this alongside Lister's trouble, but I think they weaved things together well enough that it worked out nicely without feeling stuffed and unbalanced, and of course the show's goofy nature help's for not requiring the audience to think too hard over things or take such coincidence too seriously.
I remember when I first saw I this when I saw Holly. I shouted Holly!
I am loving your RD vlogs. I watch them at every meal. Just ordered the new series on DVD. But i remember the part in this episode were Lister is reveled with muscles because it hurt my feelings when everyone acted as if it was strange or gross. I was actually bigger than the model they used for Lister at one point when I was bodybuilding. Seems the only body type people can make fun of without being called out for body shaming. Lol. Still a great episode,but that part always made me huffy,lol. Anyway, keep up the vids!!
I don't think it was the body type they were laughing at, it was the fact it was Lister. any body type that wasn't his would be funny; fat, skinny, white, female, that's the joke.
Mauricio Eduardo Santana you're probably right. thinking of it that way makes it a bit better actually. :)
I remember when I first saw this episode I went back to check the episodes in question and, yeah, the Despair Squid was the last time we saw Red Dwarf until now. Was a nice nod to continuity there. Unfortunately, the gag the end of this episode sets up to start off Season 8 is only the first in a long list of disappointments I have for Season 8. As for how Season 8 ended, well, I'll say my piece when we get there.
I like all your vids.
never noticed the mech arm on lister from future echoes. huh...
I just watched Bladerunner 2049 and realized a lot of things from Red Dwarf. Since the show was inspired by the first movie, I wonder if some things from Red Dwarf got put in the sequel?
Dave Lister was the original Jaime Lannister!
I discovered these vlogs a few months ago and think they're brilliant, especially looking forward to a can't smeg won't smeg review, although I didn't peticularly enjoy that special.
As for my opinions on the other RD series I think that 3 was the best. Not really a fan of series 6 to 8 but there are a few exceptions and I love series 10 onwards.
Anyway enough about me, I have a question for you - how long are you gunna keep these vlogs going, are you going all the way up to series 12?
Thanks, and that's the plan!
can't smeg won't smeg was part of the 10th anniversary of the Red Dwarf and part of the Red Dwarf Night.
I have a theory that when kryten is helping lister do everything from playing guitar to dunking biscuits in his tea I think you're right that lister could actually do most of it himself (albeit with difficulty given his only hand is his non dominant hand) but I think he's just acting like that albeit subconsciously to guilt shame kryten.
series 7 gets way too much hate I had no issue with it, it was series 8 that took a down turn for me.
Recently rewatching VII, I'll admit a lot of it has aged better than on first viewing. The blu-ray removes that fake film effect too. "Beyond a Joke" is my favorite though "Blue" comes close.
This series is sadly maligned, Rimmers shoes are very big to fill but Chloe did a great job considering
It's hit-or-miss, but the "hit" episodes are great.
@@Cyborcat have just done some red dwarf art from series 7 with lister and co on starbug, sending an sos to find red dwarf. It originally featured kris and no Arnold, however Rimmer took her place after careful deliberation. There’s a shot of red dwarf at the bottom with a sketch of a corridor featuring Holly, scutters near a vending machine, and the original Kristine as a hologram. Way I see it, Holly could still generate a temporary hologram with Rimmer so out of range. He didn’t generate her after the accident, Holly thinks it wouldn’t have worked out with Dave
I had about the same feeling as you did about Nanarchy. However, the only real problem I had with it was that I hate it when people call biscuits "bik-biks". I also found it quite annoying that Kryten was treating Lister like a baby and almost spoon-feeding him. Kochanski was right about him giving Lister some space. Since that was only the weakest part for me, the rest of Nanarchy was really good. I really liked the idea of the Nanobots and how Kryten was talking to them. They were better than the Epideme virus, and the whole episode was better than Epideme.
I'd never heard "bik-bik" before, so I thought it was funny.
Season 8 really grew on me over the years. I love the added dynamic of Kochanski for the most part, and Rimmer and Lister being more chummy.
Plus I really hate season 9 so anything looks good compared to that for me.
there isn't a series 9
unless you mean back to earth, which isn't series 9.
Sirs, the scanner indicate an attack of Shark Jumping is Imminent! Recommend going from blue alert to red alert! Replacement bulb on standby!
I'm surprised you didn't mention this is the season where Rob Grant left which is why a lot characters changed and the story took a hard right in continuity.
It's also why so much of the show was hit and miss and why the next season was so much miss for older fans.
Well, I don't pay much attention to the behind-the-scenes stuff like that.
That’s kinda a blessing if you know what happened to Craig Charles between series 6 and 7
I'm curious if you'd care to fill us in.
He got arrested for trumped up rape charges
@@Cyborcat Craig got arrested in 1994 on trumped up charges
I have no idea why I love Nanarchy so much... maybe because it's the last gasp of 'oldschool' Dwarf before we get into what I think of as the modern era?
And as we all know, everything was better back then.
It's a weird and fun episode.
It certainly is! :)
I like the modern era sure not as much as the classic era but it has its good stuff Lister jamming with Hitler will be a new classic scene
Oh no doubt! I just think that maybe RD should have ended with series 8... maybe even 6.
I feel like Red Dwarf is one of those shoes that’s never gonna have a conclusion which annoys me as I have a perfect idea about how to end the series
I think the biggest problem with S7 was its best episodes were the first two. Tikka to ride and stoke me a clipper were classics and the rest couldn’t quite measure up.
I agree with that.
Okay I'm looking forward to you review of Can't Smeg, wont smeg for one reason, I find that special to be cringey as hell.
Rip it to pieces Dena.
You might be disappointed, because I mostly think it's funny.
Cyborcat Meh, your show, your opinions.
I can watch it, it's just that some of the jokes fall flat to me.
KK is not at her best here, I like her more in S8.
The 'Surprise skill' moment worked for me though, mostly because of how it was done and who with.
Either way, I still look forward to hearing what you have to say.
😊
Yeah, it's got its ups and downs, and I agree that Kochanski was handled really badly.
Seriously you are going to love season 12 (spoilers) it includes talkie toaster , holly , captain hollister and the bunk room from season 1 and 2
I've seen it now, fortunately.
Cyborcat can’t wait till you do a vid on it
The worst season is incoming
series 8 isn't too bad (watching it at the moment !) ,back to earth is the stinker for me !!!
I don't hate season 7, but it is prbly my least favourite.
I loved when season 8 came out, away were bad memories of the dreadful season 7 and the boys from the Dwarf getting back together and all that could be great was great again.
Season 8 has its own set of problems, IMO. I think 7 and 8 are both flawed, but have their moments.
actually series 7 was better than 8 in my book, once the crew were back aboard a crewed red dwarf it got a lot stupider and less interesting. I don't understand people bitching about 7, rimmer was still in most of it anyway and kochanski wasn't that bad
And now we reach what I think is the absolute worst of the post season 6 Red Dwarf content, I've always hated season 8 (Mind you, most of the seasons post 6 are a bit rubbish)
Sadly you're getting onto the worst part of Red Dwarf. I won't spoil but yeah probably gonna dislike a lot of what's to come.
Yeah, I'm not too much a fan of Season 8, tho I think it has its moments.
Pete was pretty good.
I think series VIII has a lot of good scenes in some truly terrible episodes. I think Cassandra ends up being the best episode for its simplicity and one-liners, but... yeah, Back in the Red, Krytie TV, Only the Good... and most of all Pete suffer quite a lot. All of them aren't so great, but have some hilarious singular moments or scenes.
It took a while but series 10 came to save us from silicon hell