She sat without any tears hearing of how she slaughtered her own mother and tried to kill her step-father BUT she cries when they are talking about her being a victim too NO she planned it, she carried it out and she boasted and bragged about it. Her lawyer would have a different opinion if she had pulled a gun out on her!!
I so desperately want to believe her but the defence is immediately sunk when Carly told her friend she had 3 bullets for her stepdad. She DID recognize him and that's exactly why she shot him cuz she told her friend she was planning to do it. That's premeditation not insanity.
YES IT DOES. MENTAL ILLNESS IS A BIG ISSUE. I WANT TO KNOW MORE ABOUT THOSE MEDS AND WHY THEY DID NOT WEAN HER OFF THE MEDS BEFORE CHOOSING TO GIVE HER SOMETHING ELSE.
She didn't love mother, she is a cold-blooded killer. She was rebellious and privilege, she doesn't have mental illnesses. She just wanted to do what she wanted
Carly shot her mother in a rage and the only thing that went wrong was step dad survived, took gun and called police so she couldnt pretend it was someome else. As soon as mother dead, she was on social media asking people to come to the house, ffs....Friend who went to the house just as sick and creepy.
She's devious......she used her mother's mobile to text her 'husband' asking when would he be home while her mother lay dead in the killer's own bedroom.......................she text because she wanted to know when he would be home as she wanted to kill him too! She's not a mixed up little girl, she is a teenage killer!!
I know right. The fact she told her friend she was going to shoot him proves a planned "lying in wait" for him to come thru the door. SICK alright but she should not get away with what she did. Clearly mental n needs therapy
At this point , I think “Mental Health@ is screaming out loud somewhere -it wasn’t me. It’s time we start holding people accountable for their actions.
You obviously know nothing about medication, not being weaned off lexapro which is an antidepressant (not an antipsychotic) did not cause this girl to kill her mother in cold blood. This girl is putting on show, did not shed a single tear or look even interested in the prosecution opening statements yet now she is full of tears. That girl is as guilty,.
Mental illness and access to guns is a bad combination. Still, just because her defence claims mental illness doesn't mean she didn't know right from wrong.
Carly look normal to me. Carly, has a hard heart and she is smart enough for her to say, she has a mental illness. Why did'nt Carly ever tell her mother that, she was suffering of mental illness. Carly, is not mentally , she would have shot herself, but she instead wanted to murder her mother. How did she know how to handle a weapon. If she was taking drugs, that means it shows that when in drugs that is what her heart feels to kill and destroy a human life and put her step father in danger. If her step dad, had not lived no one would have known she murdered her mom and her step daughter. A person that has mental issues will try to hurt herself. Carly, needs to pay for the life of her mother and her step father. There is not excuse lock her up for murdering her mother. She did or never warn her mother, she was mental issues , Carly knew how to shot , how did she know that ? lock her up for life. She is a danger to society.
She's emotional for herself because she's realizing now what she's facing. She wasn't crying because of what she did. And to say she has a mental illness, maybe she does, I do. Many people do but most people don't kill their parents for no reason
I think she cried because the lawyer was describing the real situation of that day and she herself is shocked about the person she was when she did these things. That is what happens when you have a mental breakdown and then when you come out of it you hardly believe the person you were.
@@ANANDALEEMA I've had mental breakdowns even when I was her age and didn't do anything to harm another person. She showed her friend her mother's body. What innocent person does that? That's beyond wrong
Doesn't matter if she did have a mental illness or not we all know right from wrong and she knew it was wrong to kill especially her own mom. Those are her actions and shes guilty so she has to be held accountable
Heath cant wrap his mind around that his stepdaughter could do something so evil! Hes loved her and cared for her ! You cant go off of his feelings for being on the monsters side!
Why is she crying now. She didn’t cry during the prosecution’s opening. Also, she was deemed dangerous when she shot her mother 3 times. The opening is not logical, but the defense attorney is doing her best with a horrible client.
The male defense attorney ALWAYS has a look on his face that says, "why tf am I having to deal with this"!?! And he sometimes even looks stunned by what he is hearing about his own client!!!! He is always giving the whole "wow, wtf" look, or he is looking like "if I could roll my eyes any harder, I would"!!!! He is not down for this defense at all, and I cannot blame him one bit.
Just stop with this “mental illness” crap. She needs to be imprisoned for life to protect society from her unhinged behavior. Defense lawyers always default to this lame excuse.
She had mental health problems. She is just 14 years old. Her brain has not fully formed. She needs help. Her stepdad is standing with her. Her mom kept a gun under her mattress, very unsafe, if you are going to have a gun; LOCK IT UP PROPERLY OR DON'T OWN ONE. UNDER YOUR MATTRESS IS NOT SAFE!!
Deceitful child who had a burner phone & secret electronic life & manipulated people would get to that gun, that young girl IS NOT SAFE, she killed her mom & tried to kill another. Look for excuses but i'm seeing facts!
@@2bcYT She killed her mother in anger, and then LAY IN WAIT for her father to get home. There's nothing wrong with her brain, whatever her "gender" is.
How is she going to feel when reality sets in. She killed the one person who loved her more than anyone else in the world and the person she loved more than anyone else in the world. Her own mother who was always her champion. Not intentional? She shot her mother 3 times.
@@rakesfunnyfarm My doctor has me on -you guessed it, your favourite word- MEDS too. I don’t wanna kill anyone. Yea I agree, psychologists and psychiatrists need to do better especially when dealing with young people and meds, but unless Carly admitted to wanting to commit violent acts to her therapist, there is nothing they could have done. Blaming the doc is weak. I’ve been to therapy a lot, one on one and group settings, and both adamantly mention that if any desire to hurt someone else or yourself is mentioned, they are obligated under law to report that to the authorities. So relax and try to put the blame where it belongs. On a little girl that couldn’t get her way so she created a way. And children rarely think of consequences and that’s why she’s going liquid face.
She should have taken the plea deal offered because I think she will be found guilty and get life in prison. Very similar to the Erin Caffey case in GA years ago-girl and BF killed her parents because she didn’t get her way and parents put their foot down.
I feel like I only see this girl cry about her step dad never about her mother. I think she got mad her mom was looking for those weed vapes so she blew her mom away before she could take her vapes.
This girl reminds me of my step granddaughter... I see alot of pretence.. because when carly was listening to events she would stop and cry to certain events when the live coverage shown by the body cam...i dk im not judging and I'm not heartless but its my opinion
I thoroughly dislike seeing lady lawyers with hair not neatly dressed. Whether by nicely curled, restrained, or neatly styled. They look like they just got out of the shower/bed.
Her mother was shot in Carly's room right? Why was she in there? It makes me think that Ashley found something in her daughter's room or was maybe taking something away from Carly. Either way, I think Carly was angry with her mother which led to her killing her. Also I think anxiety and depression were the mental illnesses she has (mentioned in other trial videos), those don't cause you to murder someone. I haven't watched a ton of this trial yet so I'm just guessing.
It doesn’t matter WHY!!! They are right it doesn’t matter she killed her own mother and tried to kill her step father! Lots of people suffer from mental illnesses and don’t become murderers. And most of the time it’s a complete lie a scapegoat from accountability.
Watch More Carly Gregg Court Clips: bit.ly/CarlyGreggTrial
Why ask why? What matters is she must be held accountable. You can’t get a pass for murder.
MEDS
she got a pass and meds her whole life..🙄🙄🙄🙄. shuttle m Skylar m should've been in jail years ago...mental illness is hilarious
She sat without any tears hearing of how she slaughtered her own mother and tried to kill her step-father BUT she cries when they are talking about her being a victim too NO she planned it, she carried it out and she boasted and bragged about it.
Her lawyer would have a different opinion if she had pulled a gun out on her!!
Does anyone else noticed the male defense having a hard time not falling asleep...
She cant even pretend to cry
Those are real visible Tears rolling down Her face.
She was crying, but that changes nothing about her guilt.
But,I'm not saying She didn't Kill Her Mom in Cold Blood.
She is really crying.
THOSE ARE REAL TEARS.
Ethan Crumbly had a mental illness, too. This defense strategy is typical and seldom effective in today’s legal world.
She didn't shoot up a school
@@Madcaps215 especially with the youngens
I so desperately want to believe her but the defence is immediately sunk when Carly told her friend she had 3 bullets for her stepdad. She DID recognize him and that's exactly why she shot him cuz she told her friend she was planning to do it. That's premeditation not insanity.
Why would do you want to believe her?
@@AllAboutPurple clearly because I dont want to believe that 14yr old girl would shoot and kill the lady that is raising her her Mother
Does it honestly matter why Carly murdered her own mother?
Exactly
YES IT DOES. MENTAL ILLNESS IS A BIG ISSUE. I WANT TO KNOW MORE ABOUT THOSE MEDS AND WHY THEY DID NOT WEAN HER OFF THE MEDS BEFORE CHOOSING TO GIVE HER SOMETHING ELSE.
I agree with you. @@rakesfunnyfarm
@@rakesfunnyfarmmental illness or not she new what she was doing period
@rakesfunnyfarm she is a cold blooded murder
'Exceptional child' ??? Demonic is the correct description.
Psychopaths are intelligent and deeply depraved. She’s not exceptional, she is a cold, calculated murderer.
Why is she only crying during the defence statement? 🚩
There's no tears
@@martinaosullivan1622 THOSE ARE REAL TEARS.
@rakesfunnyfarm writing in caps doesn't make your opinion more valid than others,calm down jeeze!
She also cried when they showed the bodycam footage of the crime scene.
@@rakesfunnyfarm. For herself not her mother or stepfather.
She didn't love mother, she is a cold-blooded killer. She was rebellious and privilege, she doesn't have mental illnesses. She just wanted to do what she wanted
Dear defense, if she hasn’t grieved her mother, maybe that’s because she’s a sociopath.
How is Carly a victim? She is a murderer. The end.
Carly shot her mother in a rage and the only thing that went wrong was step dad survived, took gun and called police so she couldnt pretend it was someome else. As soon as mother dead, she was on social media asking people to come to the house, ffs....Friend who went to the house just as sick and creepy.
She is Not a victim and mental illness is not an excuse for what she did !😑
MEDS
It doesn’t matter why. She clearly is not exceptional. She murdered her mother. End of story.
She's devious......she used her mother's mobile to text her 'husband' asking when would he be home while her mother lay dead in the killer's own bedroom.......................she text because she wanted to know when he would be home as she wanted to kill him too! She's not a mixed up little girl, she is a teenage killer!!
🎯🎯
What mental illness exactly?
I was wondering the same thing, going to have to wait till rest of trial.
She’s on lexapro anti anxiety and depression meds
@@kathismith7441 anxiety and depression doesn't make you homicidal tho, this girl is spending the rest of her life in prison.
@@LordValcour up urs learn to fn read get educated
@@kathismith7441 SHE WAS TAKEN OFF ONE MED WITHOUT BEING WEAN TO START ANOTHER MED.
Why is it when parents discipline their children and they get angry and killed their parents they always claim not guilty of insanity.???
MEDS
Not insanity. She is mentally ill and required medical treatment.
This type of manipulation by someone so young, she knew what she was doing.
MEDS
Omg! Listening to her stepdad is heartbreaking 💔 my heart goes out to him
I know right. The fact she told her friend she was going to shoot him proves a planned "lying in wait" for him to come thru the door. SICK alright but she should not get away with what she did. Clearly mental n needs therapy
Evil little monster.
She can't even cry
THOSE ARE REAL TEARS.
You really didn't see the visible tears running down her cheeks?
@@rakesfunnyfarm those tears r maybe a couple forced down her vile evil monstrous face
At this point , I think “Mental Health@ is screaming out loud somewhere -it wasn’t me. It’s time we start holding people accountable for their actions.
She couldn’t get her way…
MEDS
You obviously know nothing about medication, not being weaned off lexapro which is an antidepressant (not an antipsychotic) did not cause this girl to kill her mother in cold blood. This girl is putting on show, did not shed a single tear or look even interested in the prosecution opening statements yet now she is full of tears. That girl is as guilty,.
@@cutieellabella1260she did too shed tears. Did you seriously not see them rolling down her cheek?!
Fake crying. I didnt see any tears. Did she cry when she murdered her mother and attempted to murder her father? She is not a victim
Mental illness and access to guns is a bad combination. Still, just because her defence claims mental illness doesn't mean she didn't know right from wrong.
MEDS
@@rakesfunnyfarmsmoking the devil's lettuce on top, no less
@div1244 ✨Bingo!🧚
That creepy smile after the attorney talks about her lame test score is beyond weird
She is only crying because she knows shes in trouble shooting her mom then going after step dad im sorry i dont feel for her
MEDS
Carly look normal to me. Carly, has a hard heart and she is smart enough for her to say, she has a mental illness. Why did'nt Carly ever tell her mother that, she was suffering of mental illness. Carly, is not mentally , she would have shot herself, but she instead wanted to murder her mother. How did she know how to handle a weapon. If she was taking drugs, that means it shows that when in drugs that is what her heart feels to kill and destroy a human life and put her step father in danger. If her step dad, had not lived no one would have known she murdered her mom and her step daughter. A person that has mental issues will try to hurt herself. Carly, needs to pay for the life of her mother and her step father. There is not excuse lock her up for murdering her mother. She did or never warn her mother, she was mental issues , Carly knew how to shot , how did she know that ? lock her up for life. She is a danger to society.
Her mental illness was mom said no.
She's emotional for herself because she's realizing now what she's facing. She wasn't crying because of what she did. And to say she has a mental illness, maybe she does, I do. Many people do but most people don't kill their parents for no reason
I think she cried because the lawyer was describing the real situation of that day and she herself is shocked about the person she was when she did these things. That is what happens when you have a mental breakdown and then when you come out of it you hardly believe the person you were.
@@ANANDALEEMA I've had mental breakdowns even when I was her age and didn't do anything to harm another person. She showed her friend her mother's body. What innocent person does that? That's beyond wrong
@@lizhunter3998exactly
She’s on lexsapro antipsychotic
THEN YOU WOULD KNOW THAT THE DOCTOR SHOULD HAVE WEAN HER OFF THE MEDS SHE WAS ON BEFORE PUTTING HER ON SOMETHING ELSE!
The reason for a murder is not necessary to prosecute a murderer.
I take prescription , i don't wanna kill anyone specifically my mother
She did the side eye check towards the jury to see how her tears and nodding about her mother was playing out.
"THE EVIDENCE WILL SHOW" is monotonous filler to drive us crazy. This defense lawyer is a menace to society.
Defense lawyers are morally bankrupt and don’t care about victims.
That kinda how most opening arguments go and what lawyers say.
Her manipulation is astounding. She's not a victim, her dead mom is.
The defense attorney made sure the acne on defendant stayed uncovered.
I thought so too
The attorney is awful.
Did the defense attorney seriously just use the Chewbacca defense?
She's a Murderer!!!!
Tears, I’ve seen more believable tears from Baby Born dolls.
What a horrible person.
MEDS
Doesn't matter if she did have a mental illness or not we all know right from wrong and she knew it was wrong to kill especially her own mom. Those are her actions and shes guilty so she has to be held accountable
Little monster
WOW WHAT ABUNCH OF B.S.
This opening statement is difficult to follow. Too many double negatives. Terrible start.
That girl knew exactly what she was doing. Life in prison. She may hurt or kill someone else if she gets out.
Where is her father?
3 victims? No
That’s the bad seed
Heath cant wrap his mind around that his stepdaughter could do something so evil! Hes loved her and cared for her ! You cant go off of his feelings for being on the monsters side!
Why is she crying now. She didn’t cry during the prosecution’s opening.
Also, she was deemed dangerous when she shot her mother 3 times.
The opening is not logical, but the defense attorney is doing her best with a horrible client.
Because a spoiled brat didn't want to get disciplined stop making excuses for criminals because they're a minor...
MEDS
She didn’t recognize heath?? Didn’t she text him from her mothers phone “honey when will you be home”
Lawyer is pathetic….she killed mom, omg….i don’t buy this b/s sold by solicitor🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈
MEDS PLAYS A PART IN IT.
Dangerous evil girl
Did she had visit with her Dad her real Dad where did she get the Drugs?
She was old enough to know better.. nope I don’t feel sorry for her. She murdered her parents!
MEDS
@@rakesfunnyfarmEXCUSES
@@rakesfunnyfarmEXCUSES
You can't tell everyone to go by the evidence and then relay emotions rather than facts.
The male defense attorney ALWAYS has a look on his face that says, "why tf am I having to deal with this"!?! And he sometimes even looks stunned by what he is hearing about his own client!!!! He is always giving the whole "wow, wtf" look, or he is looking like "if I could roll my eyes any harder, I would"!!!! He is not down for this defense at all, and I cannot blame him one bit.
Not a great opening 😳
I feel bad for her and the mother.
Me too
Beautiful attorney
But..she was /is dangerous and killed her mom shot her dad.
Just stop with this “mental illness” crap. She needs to be imprisoned for life to protect society from her unhinged behavior. Defense lawyers always default to this lame excuse.
She had mental health problems. She is just 14 years old. Her brain has not fully formed. She needs help.
Her stepdad is standing with her.
Her mom kept a gun under her mattress, very unsafe, if you are going to have a gun; LOCK IT UP PROPERLY OR DON'T OWN ONE. UNDER YOUR MATTRESS IS NOT SAFE!!
Deceitful child who had a burner phone & secret electronic life & manipulated people would get to that gun, that young girl IS NOT SAFE, she killed her mom & tried to kill another. Look for excuses but i'm seeing facts!
Maybe she was afraid of her own child and needed quick protection.
7 is the age of reason
@@shirleyroth3450 than perhaps mom/dad shouldnt havs leftvthe gun accessible knowing she had problems or even if
she dudnt...
Will the evidence show that Carly wanted to transgender which was something her parents opposed?
Why would that matter?? She picked up a gun and shot both of her parents, killing one and injuring the other, AFTER she lay in wait for him.
@@janegardener1662 It goes to motive.
@@janegardener1662 It's a potential motive.
If that was what the police discovered. I haven't done any research on this case so I'm just speculating.
@@2bcYT She killed her mother in anger, and then LAY IN WAIT for her father to get home. There's nothing wrong with her brain, whatever her "gender" is.
@@nightshadewinter6915 Motive isn't the only thing involved in a murder. Means, motive and opportunity are all looked at.
Fake tears. 🙄
Too late for 😢😢
How is she going to feel when reality sets in. She killed the one person who loved her more than anyone else in the world and the person she loved more than anyone else in the world. Her own mother who was always her champion. Not intentional? She shot her mother 3 times.
Why does she only cry when her defense makes the case? This girl needs to go to jail she will kill again.
evil
AND WHY OH WHY were there guns available all over the house for a troubled teen?
It’s the defense attorneys job to stop or alter a conviction.
However, that doesn’t mean the attorney believes her. Which suggests deception to me.
The guy next to her is so worry for the case 😴
Find help before you put 3 in your mother. Guilty
DOCTOR NEEDS TO DO THEIR JOB!
@@rakesfunnyfarm My doctor has me on -you guessed it, your favourite word- MEDS too. I don’t wanna kill anyone.
Yea I agree, psychologists and psychiatrists need to do better especially when dealing with young people and meds, but unless Carly admitted to wanting to commit violent acts to her therapist, there is nothing they could have done. Blaming the doc is weak. I’ve been to therapy a lot, one on one and group settings, and both adamantly mention that if any desire to hurt someone else or yourself is mentioned, they are obligated under law to report that to the authorities. So relax and try to put the blame where it belongs. On a little girl that couldn’t get her way so she created a way. And children rarely think of consequences and that’s why she’s going liquid face.
She should have taken the plea deal offered because I think she will be found guilty and get life in prison. Very similar to the Erin Caffey case in GA years ago-girl and BF killed her parents because she didn’t get her way and parents put their foot down.
She passed the MHE. The false defense, many Defense Court Appointed Or Provided by the Defendant’s Attorney tried as an excuse or alibi.
I am sure the vapors help, and drugs if being used. Evidence is the fact she used a gun on her parents.
She does not look mentally ill to me. If she’s facing charges, she’s not considered mentally ill.
WHAT IS A MENTAL ILL PERSON SUPPOSE TO LOOK LIKE. SMH
There was TWO victims, TWO!
Is it bothering anyone else that the lady pronounces “mental” like “mennil?”
I don't feel sorry for her in no way
Evil
Sad but she will have to spend her life in jail, she is not mental to the extent she didn't know what she was doing. Guilty as charged.
Lack of discipline
I feel like I only see this girl cry about her step dad never about her mother. I think she got mad her mom was looking for those weed vapes so she blew her mom away before she could take her vapes.
This girl reminds me of my step granddaughter...
I see alot of pretence.. because when carly was listening to events she would stop and cry to certain events when the live coverage shown by the body cam...i dk im not judging and I'm not heartless but its my opinion
Did the step dad get life insurance for the wife??
No worries now. Poor kid... Sad one 😢.
Almost end of the video, but I can't listen anymore.
Aint Been keeping up on this one
I thoroughly dislike seeing lady lawyers with hair not neatly dressed. Whether by nicely curled, restrained, or neatly styled. They look like they just got out of the shower/bed.
Had mental illness? So she doesn’t anymore? 🙄
Her mother was shot in Carly's room right? Why was she in there? It makes me think that Ashley found something in her daughter's room or was maybe taking something away from Carly. Either way, I think Carly was angry with her mother which led to her killing her. Also I think anxiety and depression were the mental illnesses she has (mentioned in other trial videos), those don't cause you to murder someone. I haven't watched a ton of this trial yet so I'm just guessing.
Whats on her face?
looks like acne to me, she is 15...
@@scotty-beam Yes, and she likely picked at it.
Coldsores
Defense leaves untreated and ucovered on purpose for sreategic reasons
Throw away phones
Another great kid give me a break i was crazy give me a break 100 yrs giulty rip lady
It doesn’t matter WHY!!! They are right it doesn’t matter she killed her own mother and tried to kill her step father! Lots of people suffer from mental illnesses and don’t become murderers. And most of the time it’s a complete lie a scapegoat from accountability.
MEDS
GUILTY