I usually like your videos but hearing you say Sneha can't possibly have been murdered because she knew how to avoid it was galling and tactless. murder victims aren't to blame for hanging around with the wrong people. only murderers are to blame
Exactly. And just because she had always been safe in the past, doesn't mean that something terrible didn't happen that night. Being safe in the past had nothing to do with whether or not she was safe/unsafe on that night. It irritated me no end that so many people are assuming that she died at the WTC that morning while trying to help the injured. Not only is there absolutely zero evidence for this, but now she's celebrated as a hero and her family benefitted financially. I understand that it probably makes her family feel better to believe that's how she died, and it certainly makes it easier on the NYPD to declare her a victim of 9/11, but there isn't a single piece of evidence for this being the truth. I believe something happened to her the night before, and she never made it back to her building at all on the morning of 9/11. Apparently, it was hard to see the woman at the elevator, and Ron said that the woman "could be" Sneha, but he didn't positively identify her. And she did a lot of shopping the day before, yet the woman at the elevator wasn't carrying anything. I can understand forgetting something small on the bus/train...an umbrella, a book, a small bag...and most of us have done it. But the idea that she accidently left a half dozen large bags behind on the train is ludicrous, that really is reaching.
@@Terri_MacKay to be fair to the idea of leaving your stuff behind, I have literally done that. I left about five shopping bags at my grandmothers house after shopping with her all afternoon. I didn’t even realize I had forgotten them until I got home and out of the car and realized my bags weren’t in the back. People can do crazy things when they’re a little bit tired or off their normal schedule. Because of that, I wouldn’t entirely discount the theory of her forgetting her bags, merely because I have done that exact same thing.
@@justalittleturtle5600 I've done the same thing. Gone shopping, went to visit one of my sisters, and left shopping or something else there. But in the video, they were wondering if the woman at the elevator was Sneha, because she had done a lot of shopping but wasn't carrying anything. They speculated that maybe she had left her shopping on the subway, not at someone's house. I can believe leaving it at someone's house. But, if you're on a subway or bus, you've probably got some bags next to you and some on your lap. It's hard to believe that in that case, she would get off the train without them. There were things left out of this story. Like, her husband thought she may have stayed with a relative overnight because she had done that before, in which case she could have left her shopping there. But it was never made clear if we know for sure that she did stay with relatives, and did she/didn't she take the bags with her when she left in the morning. That seems like a pretty big fact to leave out.
She’s definitely not to blame if she had been attacked. There’s a reason why women are cautious of being alone or near men they don’t know. But your right being cautious won’t prevent attacks from someone
This narration is uneven. It goes into detail her purchases, items she wore and minor incidents, but does not explain the backstop of her addiction and poor performance. Until then she portrayed as a dutiful, high achieving daughter and wife. Something such as addiction does not occur suddenly or without trauma.
Many things don't hold up. She was an alcohol addict. She would spend time with unknown people at gay bars. She spent time wandering in certain pubs. Seems like she and her husband weren't getting along or she was a gay or bisexual. Something is fishy about her. Her husband also didn't care that she wasn't spending time with him is weird. Something doesn't add up. Some of information is hidden in my opinion. My best guess is she left her husband and family maybe because she was guilty of being a gay. There is almost no other explanation of her vanishing. Maybe her family was trying to protect her image being Indians.
I thought it was weird the husband didn’t seem to mind Sneha was openly cheating on him with women. I don’t know if Sneha was gay or bisexual, but she seemed to be more into women.
She clearly had some personal issues and weird, perhaps risky habits---yet this is mostly glossed over in the report, perhaps because there's not enough information about it.
@@afdcg I did not see this at all like you do. There is nothing showing her sexuality has anything to do with her disappearance. Nothing about gay bar hopping is more "fishy" than heteronorm. Some heteros like hanging on gay bars to have more fun or avoid pushy men. It seems like she was LOVED by her husband, rest her soul. Do you know something more about Indians? To me it seems like a universal thing to protect your offspring. We do not know if she was diagnosed as an alcoholic, merely that she, in a tough time, was accused of neglect due to alcohol. Sometimes people put others down with lables to gain from it. We do not know first hand. Rest in peace lovely Sneha. Too soon, wrong girl.
It feels like only 3% are found.... So so so sad.... So sad.... It breaks my heart. I think of my mother, my sister, my boys I mean, do we have to prepare ourselves for such events?...No man!
Feels a little glossed over for me. If we can't be brutally honest about people's lives it can hinder their being found as no body wants to really discuss the whole truth. That's not to say Sneha isn't a good person but this story is like reading through rose tinted glasses.
I'm glad other people are recognizing this. It's too bad how this video does indeed gloss over some of the allegedly "unsavory" parts of Dr. Phillips' life. Personally, I believe she died downtown on 9/11, and I admire her actions that much more _because_ she was such an "imperfect", distinctly human individual. In a moment of supreme crisis I believe she transcended her troubles, fell back on her training, and headed towards danger in order to help other people. Like a good doctor. She doesn't have to be a saint for me to admire her. She shouldn't have to be for anyone to admire her. I wish videos like this would cease _attempting to_ sanctify her.
@debbiekirby3229 EXACTLY! Thank you! I feel like this was just a way to keep her reputation in place even tho the truth of the matter was much different. People drive me nuts being in such denial. It doesnt help find her or help anyone to realize the real truth.
The fact that she didn't come home the night before and didn't call, leads me to speculate she met foul play the day she was last seen. As for the family insisting that she died on ground 0 is rather irrational. There was no proof she was even there.
Exactly. There is no event in recent history more seared into people's memories than 9/11. If she was there, there would be evidence, 100%. Somebody would've come forward. She simply was never there.
I've watched a documentary on this and it's speculated (and I tend to agree with it) that they wanted her to be a hero in death and not as the alcoholic with a criminal record. Her husband admitted she stayed out often, going home with women she met at gay bars, he says it wasn't for sexual reasons. I find that bs, what married woman goes home with strangers, not just once, but several times, for no other reason. Not to mention, having her a victim of 911 gave her husband access to a lot of money, life insurance and other victims funds set up.
@@itsmackenzie The husband probably knew his wife was gay & was feeling embarrassed to tell the real thing about her going home with the women she meets at gay bar, hence the conflict in their relationship & her drinking issue, also him caring more about accessing the 9/11 victim benefits. It seems like there are many gaps in the story, however, reading about this case, there's a one detail that gave me chills. It is said that some years after 9/11, there's was an anonymous drawing uploaded to the anonymous confession website, the drawing was the twin towers with fire raging out of them, under that there was a caption which read: "Everyone who knew me before 9/11, thinks I'm dead". I've a feeling that she's actually still alive under a new identity, probably living in a remote area with her girlfriend. Just my theory
She had a court case, dismissed from 2 jobs and had a substance habit. She did not come home the night before and didn't leave a message. This case is skewered by the girl's family that the real crime has gone unsolved.
Not leaving a message that night for her husband would seem significant. Did she usually leave a message if she was not going to come home--or no? How odd that a well-educated woman from a typically conservative, upper-class Indian background would have some unusual if not worse personal habits.
It's two possible scenarios that could be factuality! And that is that the woman that was captured on video could could have been a very important piece to this puzzle. She could have been involved in the disappearance of Sheha along with a unidentified party who was never mentioned in the police investigation. This gives strong indication as to why this woman was never found or stepped forward. Is she was involved as this could have been a crime of passion! A three way gone wrong which resulted in this woman or the third unidentified party maybe the woman husband or lover killing Sheha. And the reason as why the woman on video was ever identified or tracked down as she could have escape justice and fled back to foreign land! U have to consider this possible given that when you view the video of Sheha and this mysterious woman! She do not look american born so it's possible that this woman have not been tracked down as the reason as her and the other unidentified party left the United States and fled back to their home State. Or my last theory that makes a lot more sense is that Sheha may have been a victim of a serial killer. Considering that In 2001 she disappeared under very suspicious circumstances doing the heart of the then unknown long island serial killer, who was abducting and killing women thru out the state of New York. The man who is now labled long island serial killer rex heuermann I believe was the prime suspect in the disappearance of Sheha Anne Phillips..
Husband's phone showed a missed call at 4 a.m., 9/11/2001, from a phone line INSIDE their apartment. Who was it? I'm not convinced she died on 9/11 as a result of the terrorist attacks.
I highly doubt it she died at WTC. Her running into the tower to help people is mostly a hearsay which has been highlighted as a fact in this shoddily made video.
Our landline phone would occasionally ring itself back in the day when we had one. It's possible the husband picked up one phone inside the house and called his own phone number by accident and won't admit it because he wants to advance the 911 theory.
@@elliebellie7816 It was the landline phone that rang. His cell phone would show if he called the landline. He say he did not hear the landline and that is possible if it rang only once.
@@sebastianelytron8450 The surveillance video from the store showed her with another female. According to witness (store employee) both were clearly shopping together.
@@spacewurmshe was alone and it was captured on video. Unless the employee was mistaken. Or she saw a ghost with her. Perhaps someone was with her and she thought they two women were together but not.
No, it is not evident that she died on 9/11. She was known to go out all night and go home with people she had just met. She drank too much, clouding her judgement. You aren’t safe because you “know what type of person to stay away from”. Also, we NYers aren’t afraid or uncomfortable to talk about 9/11. And there are many photos of those that ran to the towers to help out before they fell. It was being documented on the ground in real time. She is in none of them.
Just because people were taking photos of victims running towards the towers doesn’t mean they’re going to catch every single person that ran towards the towers that day. That’s a ludicrous thought, believing that you can discount someone’s presence at a scene just from photos like that.
@@justalittleturtle5600 If she were allowed into the area close up to work as a doctor (which wouldn’t happened in the first place, firefighters would have moved the injured back as debris and even bodies were falling) she more than likely would have been caught on film. There are hundreds of photos covering the entire area. She never would have been let inside of the buildings, and even then there is video of the lobby.
The fact that her family & husband insisting on her dying in the attack despite the lack of proof and it not making sense in the first place tells me that they're hiding something or withholding other details.
Not necessarily. just as likely for it to be a coping mechanism, would you rather your missing daughter die in a " the 9-11 incident" and thats as neutral as im gonna label it but thats a different matter" but would you rather your daughter died in that a default "heroes tragic death" or was maybe randomly abducted by some random murderer in a foul play case the day before by totally random awful luck chance? You could be right just saying there are reasons why one might claim this is all.
A woman who was having a good day shopping, getting ready for visitors wouldn’t just not come home or call to let her husband know where she was. Something fishy but I’m afraid she fell thru the cracks because of all that was happening
It's mentioned in the video here and I also recall reading elsewhere how it was her habit to party all night without including him at all. Unfortunately by then it was something he was used to. I'm actually wondering if she left the shopping bags at whatever person's place she stayed the night before because she didn't want her husband to see them (her hospital had just told her her contract wasn't being renewed and that was a lot of shopping she did....) Personally I'm pretty confident when she saw the catastrophe happening so close to home, she made use of her medical training and went down to help, which is where she likely died.
@@mcnultyssobercompanion6372 Her husband had to work long hours with early starts. He wouldn't have been up to partying all night, and she had permission to use his credit card so she didn't have to hide anything from him. I think that day she used shopping as therapy to cheer herself up after so many disappointments, and maybe went out for drinks for the same reason.
When I look at the video of her shopping at Century 21, she looks to me like a calm, stable Indian housewife. Her clothes look to me like someone who is a housewife, not a partier and sleeping around with a bunch of strangers. Like, the police's description of her personal life do not match her calm and steady demeanor in that video, IMHO. Not saying she didn't frequent night clubs, but that her appearance there doesn't indicate to me someone who's spiraling out of control. I think she met her fate sometime in the later hours of the 10th or early hours of the 11th. I really don't think she perished in the attacks. I think she had passed before the attacks.
The conclusion is completely flawed. If her family is going to claim that she was a victim of 9/11, then, yes, we do need to be able to substantiate her whereabouts and that includes establishing where she was on the night of the 10th. Saying "Oh, New Yorkers get triggered talking about that kind of thing..." is lame and childish. Also, fantasizing about her running to Ground Zero to help victims of the attack is grotesquely ridiculous, since you have absolutely no evidence to back it up. You're making the facts fit your conclusion, not the other way around.
I agree all of the footage shows everyone being directed away it was 00 visibility and dust and they were not allowing anyone to enter the buildings. I agree the conclusion is flawed
You just took words out of my mouth! I was dumbfounded when the narrator said 'she died helping people at ground zero' like dude you don't even know what happened and you weren't there! He could have said this might be one of the possibilities but he had to conclude with super cheesy and biased remark. I am sorry for whatever happened to her and I wholeheartedly hope her family receives some closure but we cannot declare her hero without any evidence.
If they can prove that she died in wtc then they can collect wtc payments. My sister is a survivor as she was walking to work on the side of the building. She’s had abt 40 surgeries from the debris. She has not taken any money from the victims fund bc she feels guilty abt it. There’s nothing that suggests she was there so it’s pretty dark if that’s their intentions.
@@Chris-kq9lb I've read that the husband was actually allowed to access the place & look for her. But she was no where to be found. I find it strange that they're insisting on including her in the list of victims despite the absence of evidence
Probably the worst point in history you could have gone missing was Sep 11th 2001. Such a strange, sad case. What drove her to alcohol and put her career in such jeopardy? What on earth happened?
Stress to perform and be at their best. It is possible that she was struggling with her sexual identity quite a bit. Her spending nights away from the home and her husband being okay with it tells me either he knew or her family knew about her struggles.
@@cruisepaige They should be in rehab to safeguard their integrity as doctors.I wonder why people don't turn to God when their lives are not going good for them instead of alcohol.
@@mrsTraveller64 God couldn't help!!? That's what He's there for! She was probably mixing with the wrong people giving her wrong advice. The alcohol let her down big time 😥😥😥
9:31 _"Early the next morning, at around 4 AM, Ron's cell phone is pinged with a missed call from a phone line inside the apartment. Sneha is the only other one with access to the home. But Ron doesn't remember receiving a call and says he barely remembers even checking his voicemail around that time."_ So no one is going to talk about this?
Anybody who has been to the 9/11 memorial knows there is a closed off section that acts a morgue. There are still a number of people unaccounted for to this day.
@@matthewjennings5893 Sadly, and it's truly an awful reality to accept, they will almost certainly never retire, & will, in fact, die long before even a fraction of those remains can be identified, assuming it's even possible in the first place (while I'm absolutely no expert, I don't believe it is possible.)
So just because it’s too insensitive to ask people of their whereabouts the evening before 9/11, were just going to write off the fact she didn’t contact her husband all night or the following morning as unsuspicious?
I don’t believe she died in ground zero. I believe she met with foul play the last day she was seen! Period. Maybe her husband needs to be looked at a bit more closely then fan out from there.
Totally agree. The husband should have been looked more closely! In these kind of cases family should be looked at very closely, it’s often someone close.
WTF😂😂😂 NYPD was not interested in her case and assumed her to be a victim of 9/11. It was her husband who hired private detective to look into the case. If he was murderer he would have just agreed to NYPD. Family of sneha too agreed on the theory that she was the victim of terrorist attack. 😂😂😂😂😂
Sneha's struggles with alcohol and other aspects of her life are treated so lightly in this documentary, it does not take any special powers of observation to come to the conclusion that her life may well have been falling apart and spiraling out of control rapidly, I am surprised by her husband's attitude to her spending night's out and staying away from home, if we are to believe it he was totally at ease with her living like this, even as a viewer I feel extremely uncomfortable knowing that she was out at all hours and the idea that she knew what she was doing ,could spot trouble and take care of herself fall apart as soon as you take into account her drinking problem, the whole thing seems to be steered toward her being a hero during 9/11 but it is hard for me to imagine any individual no matter what their medical skills and training may be rushing into such a horrific scene, I obviously do not know what happened to Sneha but the possibilities remain wide open as far as I can ascertain.
The husband most likely knew all of her friends who she went out with and she did call the police on the intern. She was probably threatened to drop the charges on the intern. Why didn’t she call anyone on the morning of 911 to let them know what she was going to do if she was going to the tower? Someone is hiding something. Someone knows something I don’t think she faked her death she paused going to college for a year for her husband to graduate with him that tells you a lot of her love for her husband
*She knew why she was doing lot's of shopping. It seems she had an affair behind her husbands back and after they used her, she was mudered. The arrow always hit the shooter*
I personally don't believe Sneha ran away (you'd need a lot of planning for that and it doesn't seem like she'd planned for it) but it's intriguing as, from what I have gathered, the items she bought on that day were never found either. She didn't go home that day, so where did she go? I think foul play is equally likely unfortunately, as any evidence of foul play in another area would have likely gone amiss if it was in close proximity to the WTC. So you have two (likely) options - 1) She died when the towers collapsed after attempting to assist but spent the night of September 10th elsewhere (and left her purchases there also? Although I can see unclaimed shopping being overlooked in the chaos) 2) She met with foul play as she headed home from her shopping and the crime scene/evidence was lost or overlooked in the aftermath of the collapse. Additionally, was her husband's card ever found? She had it on her and I'm assuming he didn't immediately cancel it in case he'd be able to track further purchases on it and possibly lead to Sneha? As it's not mentioned I presume it was never used again after September 10th?
As far as we KNOW, the items have never been found. If she was killed or kidnapped, the bag of items could have dropped from her hands and someone picked it up and took it home with them.
Running away & using a different identity wasn't uncommon thing back in those days. Look up the video titled "The book tied to 75,000 disappearances". Several people did that.
@@GhostRangerr Yes who knows if she was planner leave her husband and use September 11 ad a way of escape......also she could have been by the towers as they suggest but her body has never been found...who knows
A puzzling case. Two questions immediately jump to mind: what is the evidence Sneha really was at the WTC when the terror attacks happened and why didn't she come back home that night? Wouldn't it be more logical to think something happened to her at the time she didn't return home after her shopping. The presenter says it wasn't unusual for her to spend the night at the relative's house, but neatly omits to mention if they questioned the relatives about her whereabouts that night. It is very unlikely she tried to fake her own death; it is more likely she met some sort of foul play after her shopping.
From some other comments you can deduce that she expending nights with lovers. It's not so far fetched to think that on the way back she heard the planes or saw what was happening and went to help there. It could also be foul play the day before, but I guess then they should have found more video or eyewitness from what happened
This video is problematic because it seems to be carrying the propaganda torch on behalf of the family, downplaying the significance of Dr. Phillips' nighttime activities. I'm seeing many many comments asking the same question: "why didn't she come back home?" This says to me this video didn't do enough of a job explaining the whole picture adequately. I've read several articles about this case, and basically Dr. Phillips was, by 9/11, going out all night a lot, usually to lesbian bars, and not making any effort to check in with her husband. There's a particularly bizarre beat in this video where the narrator seems to suggest that Dr. Phillips was going to LGBTQ bars primarily so she couldn't be hit on? This is absurd because she was obviously quite attractive and I can't imagine the lesbians and/or bi-women _weren't going_ to hit on her in their own bars. Dr. Phillips was almost certainly bisexual, maybe even outright gay, and her marriage was essentially a mess. I'm paraphrasing because it's been a while since I read about this case, but I remember reading that their marriage was in serious trouble. This is why she didn't come home. She didn't give a damn. People are also wondering why she didn't bring the bags home. Part of her shopping spree involved lingerie; my guess is it was almost certainly not meant for....her husband (I also suspect she didn't want him to know exactly how much she'd spent....) To be fair, IT'S POSSIBLE she was murdered September 10th, without a body anything's possible, but I'm personally pretty convinced, when she saw what was happening downtown, she reverted back to her training and did what she could to help. Which is likely why no one's seen her since. Unfortunately.
It is unlikely Sneha was a 9/11 victim. Based on what is presented herein, concluding that Sneha was a victim of 9/11 is not substantiated. She did not spend the night of Sept 10th with her brother or her cousin. Evidence that she even came back to the apartment on Sept 11th is insufficient. If she was smart, she would have avoided ground zero. If she was going to ground zero to assist, why did she not inform her husband or a family member? When she heard about the attack, why did she not call her husband? What you have presented leads one to the conclusion that she was either abducted or ran away the night of Sept 10th. Lastly, a woman enjoying an active social life is not a crime and should not be judged negatively.
@@brishawn8571 He never heard from her at all for over 24 hours. the fact that she never called to even check on him when the events occurred tells me something happened to her the night before 9/11. She never used his credit card through the night. They do not say if she had other cards on her or not. There is a lot missing from this story.
@@plum_loco I know he didn’t. I was talking about a so called call that he recieved but miss and how he claimed only she had that number. I wonder if that was even checked out or was there even a voicemail
@@brishawn8571 That's what they are talking about that there was a ping to the landline phone but they could not deduce anything more from that with technology. He claims that he never heard the phone ring. There was a time that they used to able to identify the phone number the call came from but it had to be picked up at the other end. So in a way it confirms that he never picked up the phone.
@@danielhicks4826i agree with u.. Makes sense.. Not just women.. Even men need to be alert. This world is never ever going to b a safe place. We shud do our due diligence n stick to a logical protocol
This is a great mystery/cold case. What happened to the pizza delivery boy also intrigues me. Sad that he wasn't included as a casualty of 9/11 and she was just because of her profession. Makes you think that whoever committed a murder on 9/10 or 9/11 in NYC really got a free pass and got away with it if they managed to hide the body from authorities.
How true, there were a few undocumented persons that were never considered victims, never added to the memorial is it fair? Absolutely not one shred of evidence that she was anywhere near the wtc, her brother took vital time from other families that needed to express info about their loved ones to only blatantly lie, her family is what it looks like not what it is and because of that the case will never come to close because of they’re complete denial of who their daughter actually was and about the life style she was involved in
This is so true what are the odds right ? To go missing right before 9/11 but sadly I do believe this is the case and something bad happened to her. I don’t believe she died in the towers.
What you said at the end is true, because shortly before midnight on 9/11/2001 in New York, a Polish immigrant named Henryk Siwiak was murdered after mistakenly entering the wrong street to go to his new job, he was shot and the crime remains unsolved to this day, since at the time it happened, most of the police were still busy with what had happened hours before at the WTC.
@@kimf.8518In addition to Anne Philip, another woman also disappeared (Michele Anne Harris). Harris disappeared on the night of 9/11 just after 11pm after leaving the bar in who was drinking with her friends, and her car was found abandoned at the door of the house where she lived with her children and her ex-husband the next morning. Her case remains a mystery and her body was never found, despite her ex-husband being suspected of murdering her (he was tried and convicted, but acquitted).
Her life was collapsing. Her marriage was probably in trouble, but Ron wouldn't have been stupid enough to discuss that in relation to her disappearance. Edit. Buying three pairs of shoes after losing both jobs argues for her being unable to cope with changed circumstances.
Kinda feel like the theory that she died in the 9/11 terror attacks serves to hide the fact that major shit was going on in her life. She went out all night the night before and didn't call her husband. That indicates some kind of problem they had or secret she had. Due to that we have to equally consider the possibility she ran off with a partner or on her own. Maybe she was closeted LGBTQ and felt she couldn't be herself in her current life.
She probably disappeared before being able to call him. She was probably a witness of those who went into the towers to place the explosions. The terrorists most likely killed her when she saw them
Would be good to get an explanation about her turn to alcoholism and run in with the laws. You kinda just go from their marriage to bam, getting fired and personal problems a year later, but no run up to those. It was so out of nowhere I had to go back and see if I missed something.
@@kastynm.9004 Well when it's an unsolved disappearance more details could help explain her actions and what happened. Also this is a true crime documentary so getting into all the details goes with the territory.
I too thought about this. Something tells me she's not the angelic goody two shoes she's portrayed to be here. The fact that she went missing significantly before the tragedy is proof to me that something else was going on. Also, suppose she did go to help out, what are the chances that she died there? There was more than enough trained professionals to keep her safe, and somebody would've interacted with her and reported on it. I don't think she was anywhere near there, or her disappearance had anything to do with 9/11.
@@kastynm.9004 Considering the fact that her family gained a large amount of money in relation to the 9/11 victim's compensation fund I think that a clearer picture into the sudden change in her personal life is warranted. Was she bisexual or a lesbian and just married a man to cover her situation up to her family, thus causing her to drink and seek out companionship outside of her marriage? It sounds as though she had every reason to intentionally disappear or that she placed herself a situation where she could have been harmed by a casual contact, or even her husband. I find it laughable that the narrator said that she knew how to handle herself in the party scene in New York City. So did every other victim of crime in that exact same situation. 🤔 Something just isn't adding up here.
I think she was murdered that night. The next day's news overshadowed any attempts at finding her and the killer knew he was going to get away with it. Lucky boy.
What an amazing documentary. Thank you for sharing. According to Wikipedia and other sources, Sneha Anne Phillip is 'Legally dead' on September 11th 2001 but to me as to probably most people, it still remains a true mystery.
@@humayrafaizah1428 The official story itself has too many gaps, like it straight jumped from her being a happy woman full of passion to her being alcoholic who got fired From her job & her marriage collapsing. There definitely have to be details in between that could help the case but were left out. This led me to think that the husband & family are hiding something
There's really no evidence that she was even in any of the buildings that day she could have easily have been somewhere else when she ended up disappearing of course it would suit any potential perpetrator to have her declared as a 9/11 victim meaning they will never come under suspicion and will get away with the crime which means even if she was murdered the chances of this case getting solved is extremely slim
Agreed, being murdured during an absolute tragedy like 9/11 makes it even more easy for the guilty person who killed her. It's like during a war when a person is mysteriously killed on their way home, people are preoccupied with death and damage daily. The murderers don't have to hide. Horrific.
I've said several times over the years that if someone was living in NYC at the time and they wanted to disappear....that was the perfect opportunity to do so. (Don't misunderstand that as people DID voluntarily disappear, just that it would be easier then.)
Would it have been that hard to stick with ONE actor couple to portray these two? Sneha was Indian, Caucasian, long and short haired, bangs and none. Her husband was young, older, long and short haired, and sometimes even the real guy. I’m deaf and need to read captions, so it’s already confusing enough.
The idea that Sneha left with no money, no ID, no medical credentials to start a new life is slightly preposterous. How on earth would she begin a new life with no money? She was definitely under a lot of stress - she was likely unhappy in her profession, probably her parents were questioning her constantly, her husband was likely also in conflict with her as she seemingly spiraled and became addited to alcohol - but the "how" of the run-away theory just isn't there. I believe she either died as the towers fell because it wouldn't be out of the ordinary for a trained doctor to want to help and at the time no one could even imagine the towers were going to fall as they did. Or she did meet with foul play and the 9/11 attacks was a coincidence that made it easy to hide the body and all evidence. The chaos of that day, especially in that area of Manhatten, was insane. My thoughts are with her family.
How to set up to disappear. Open a post office box prepaid for three months apply for credit cards, if you do not want the credit card in your name apply for or go to drugstore purchase prepaid credit card this might involve a six month post office box build a record of credit on a pre-paid credit card not in your name the name you were going to assume very very easy to do funnel little bit of money into the new account. Very easy to get a fake drivers license, very easy to take fake drivers license into a bank open an account and do assume name boom you are started This video indicated she had been going out for months if not longer to gay night clubs they claimed she didn’t like to go to regular night clubs because she would be hit on by men. They explain that she didn’t get hit on in the gay clubs. That would be falls and attractive woman from India at a gay club would get hit on a lot. She may have come across a gay person who didn’t take kindly to The way she was misrepresenting herself.
I just watched a episode of Missing where a man did just that. Left his wallet, keys, credit cards family thought something bad happened to him. Come to find out out he relocated worked jobs that paid off the books. They finally closed his case cuz he died from health issues and they realized his name was fake. He was missing for like 15 years, up and left cuz he didn't want to handle his family responsibilities anymore
Misrepresenting herself? Seriously? You DO realize that many, many, many straight people love to go to gay bars. The sound systems are always killer and the music is perfect for dancing.
I remember this case from Unsolved Mysteries and over the years have read about it more in depth here and there. I will say CCD drawing their conclusion as that of the husband and families is surprising to me..(I expected there to be an open conclusion for the viewers to decide) anyhow…picturing her just running into danger like some sort of battle field nurse may be better saved for a movie script . She was a medical doctor not a panicked stranger looking to help. A medical doctor knows running directly into public danger (that large) is not going to save many lives when it can result in them losing their life..Also I would assume she would run to help and then maybe run back out trying to help as many as possible. Not just help 1 person & then die right there. She was clearly going though a crisis even though she never lost her medical license I’m sure losing her job would be very difficult to explain to her parents (especially her father) who I’m sure she wanted to make proud. While we like to talk about the many hero’s of 9/11 there were also many 9/11 hero fakers…Im sure her family wanted her to die a hero but there just simply is not enough conclusive evidence to prove that. Her reputation as a person and medical doctor does not automatically merit her a hero.
Just having a ton of medical knowledge without any equipment, without any transportation, you are pretty useless in situations like ground zero at the time of the WTC collapse and more likely to get in the way or become a casualty yourself.
@@vidaliasoleil2714 Honor killings happen on regular basis in that race so who is the dumb dumb here. And who is everybody??? Speak for yourself only please or remain silent.
I'm a NYer who was in kindergarten that day, and I still have vivid memories of the event and am perfectly willing to discuss that day, as is every other NYer I know. If Sneha had left her shopping bags on the train or in a cab, someone would have remembered seeing it. Anyone she stayed the night with, even in anonymous sense, would have remembered. The unsubstantiated reasoning for what it was Sneha in that lobby is completely asinine. The fact of the matter is that there's no proof whatsoever that she was at ground zero. Hers is a case that has no proof that points in ANY direction. This video'sn inclusion seems like an obvious bid to agree with the family at all costs. The fact of the matter is that the proof that is asserted in this video doesn't exist.
Yeah, it's like CCD got silently sponsored by Sneha's family. The whole case looks fishy as hell. There's a good possibility she met with foul play. Given that possibility, people should be on the lookout for possible perpetrators rather than just lazily concluding that she died on 9/11.
I remember this case from unsolved mysteries. a very strange case. shout out to you for documenting it. i like to think sneha perished that morning protecting civilians from the terrorist attacks. but where was she the night before?
The night before is the kicker for me. That's when something must've happened. I think the fact it was September 10th, 2001 is sheer coincidence, and we're reading too much into the next day's events.
Here's a theory: she stayed with a friend who also died in 9/11 therefore they couldn't come forward to say where she was the night of the 10th. Could've been a (ex)coworker, which means they could've been a doctor or nurse who went to help at the Towers. Just a theory.
Police often go to the "this person left to build a new life"..... how often has that actually happened? I've never heard of someone doing this, although I realize I likely wouldn't.
Barely Sociable did an interesting video about people doing this kind of thing (the video is titled something like "the book tied to x disappearances"). Of course, I dunno how the rate of that happening compares to the rate police reach to that as and explanation but it is a thing that definitely happens (if rarely). And as you allude to it's hard to get a count of people who have done it successfully. I do tend to think it's more about police laziness though
@@crystalairgood9845 There are no statistics but it is extremely rare. I have read about 100's of missing persons cases in the last few decades and I've only come across a handful that have actually intentionally caused their own disappearance. However police suggest this all the time. Especially back in the 60's-90's. 2001 is not too far outside that window. Chances are she died a hero and the police basically smeared her by saying she's an alcoholic that likes to cheat on her husband at gay bars. Lovely stuff.
Great mini doc. Very respectful of this woman, her life and her family. And it made me think about all the souls lost on that day that we don’t talk about. So much tragedy and pain. I’m sorry for her family and I hope her widow was able to move on find happiness again. Wonderful job showing the fullness of this woman’s life. I hope she found peace.
How did the narrator introduce the fact that his cel phone was pinged at 4am from the landlines in their own apartment, when this could ONLY have been done by Sneha, then never address it again??? Did I miss something???
If the landline called his phone at 4am, a reason for this would be he had lost his phone in the apartment and called it from the landline to locate it. If this is the case, he was awake at 4am and he's hiding something....
Yes this is an interesting case. And all the confusion that took place on that day especially at Ground Zero. Somebody could just disappear or be one of the many remains that have not been identified.
*She knew why she was doing lot's of shopping. It seems she had an affair behind her husbands back and after they used her, she was mudered. The arrow always hit the shooter*
Wait, I’m confused, the ping came from inside the house? So his phone rang from a call that came from inside the house at 4:30 in the morning and then he woke up two hours later and doesn’t bother to call his wife or try and find out where she is just because she spent the night someplace else, so obviously there were issues going on, but he would think that, a loved one is still trying to find out where you’ve been since I haven’t seen you for the last 24 hours very strange
It was on the landline. In 2001 most people still had a landline and some had a cell phone too but not everybody had one yet. He said he did not hear it.
If she was alive wouldn't she try to contact husband as she must be thinking he must be worried about her disappearance. And in case there was no such incident like 9/11 would she still go missing
This is crazy to say she was a victim of 9/11. She went out the day before and didn't turn on the evening of the 10th. I can't believe the family would move on this way.
It is easier for her family to accept this theory. The husband too. For thee narrator to say this without substantial evidence, is strange. It is based on the theory she returned the next morning as purported by the CCTV. Also her humanitarian personality. This is hardly solid enough to base such a conclusion unless a witness testified she stayed with him or her, and retuned the next morning.
I understand the tendency to paint Dr. Philip as a heroic victim; however, her behavior leading up to 09-11 was erratic at best. While her habits of drinking to excess and staying out all night have [understandably] been downplayed by her husband and family, they are extremely problematic and indicative of an individual not happy in their life or marriage. Additionally, according to The Charley Project, she purchased _over $500 worth_ of lingerie, in addition to the dress, shoes, and bed linens. While it's _possible_ the lingerie was intended for use at home, her behavior didn't seem to indicate it was. And to top it off, there's no reason her home computer would have evidence of researching how to start a new life if the plans were being made with and at the residence of the person with whom she was spending those nights away from home. Sorry, not sorry, this woman does not seem the tragic heroine to me.
I think she was a closeted lesbian. Remember the "female friend" she was shopping with? Either way she ran away under a new identity or was killed, maybe by the other lesbian.
My guesses are that she was in the closet and spent the night with someone and they ran away together or she could have been met with foul play at some point in the night or she unalived herself. Either way there isn't enough evidence to say she was at ground zero. Maybe the husband was just wanting to say that in order to not look into what really could have happened.
Me, either. She's no hero. She was fired from atleast to hospitals. I say they check her passport, or look for her in another state. She ran from all the crap she created for herself. And the family knows what happened. They just want the money. But sorry, typical they are money grubbing. Not sorry.
I'm sure she was under a ton of stress. She wanted to be an artist yet followed in her father footsteps. My experience with Indian families are that they really push their children to pursue careers the family feels are appropriate regardless of what the child wants. I hope she is living somewhere painting and happy but I'm pretty sure she passed in the world trade centers.
You're on point there. The same thought occurred to me, in that her alcoholism could've been attributed to either job stress or disillusionment on her career choice, or both. In regard to choice of careers, it's much worse for Indian men than women. In Sneha's case, I reckon she would have probably done it to please her father, and not necessarily because she was forced into it. But then again, you get to see all kinds.
But she wasn't Muslim, she was Christian, her father allowed her to marry a Jewish man,the father couldn't have been extreamingly religious or strict, I'm sure he did not interfear with her choice of work.
Lots of speculation on this one but Occam's Razor says she met up with the wrong person in a bar after shopping and that was it. That bag of shopping items could have been disposed of anywhere, including the killer's trash bin or could have even been used by the killer in his/her own home after the fact. Things like CCTV cameras weren't nearly as prevalent back then as they are today and even if they were, what camera would you possibly start looking at since we don't even know where she was?
If Sneha was at ground zero, where was she on Sept 10th after shopping at Century21? Did she stay out all night and morning alone? Then decide to help during the attacks? It doesn't sound plausible. Why would she have something to do with it? How very rude. The woman was murdered or killed by something sinister. It just doesn't make sense she wouldn't be home with her belongings the night before that fateful day of the 11th. The NYPD and other detectives have skipped an entire night. She goes shopping and that's it? No phone call to her family or Husband? No check in at her home to feed the cats, spend time with her Husband etc Was she on the run? Due to her past addictive drug problems and the abuse she endured? My heart goes out to Ron and the Family of poor Sneha, smeared with a dirty brush 🖌️ and cast aside. How awful. A human being deserves an answer. 🙏🏼💗🕊️ Rest in peace 🕊️ Sneha ❤️😇
Most likely she went to a bar, and went off with someone, which evidently was a very common occurrence for her...and it ended badly for her this time. Her contract had not been renewed due to alcohol abuse and tardiness. She'd been arrested and in jail. Her brother supposedly caught her in bed with his girlfriend. She was suspended from her new job for failure to meet with her substance abuse counselor, which had been a requirement of her being hired. The rules were not for her. I'm not buying that she was some goody-goody who threw herself into the midst of the WTC destruction and died helping...whom?
I don't agree. She was still a doctor at heart and it makes sense that she would be jolted into helping in that way. Her husband was apparently allowed to pass through which means she would have as well. I think she spent the night with some random stranger and that person would probably be too ashamed or scared to ever come forward.
@@TawnyC_ A doctor is still a doctor, and you don't need to be practicing, to be invited during times of emergency. The services of any stay-at-home female doctor would have been appreciated in the midst of 9/11. That said, I agree with you that she may not have survived the night. If she was alive and helping out at Ground Zero, then how come she didn't call any of her near and dear ones that morning? Wasn't she concerned about Ron? Of course, her starting a new life is a ridiculous theory! Edit: I realise there were no mobile phones, or they weren't too prevalent, in 2001. So, she couldn't have called from Ground Zero. Oh well!!!
29:30 mark Is that for real? I'm shocked that you would say how unlikely it was for her to have met with foul play because she, I'll paraphrase "knew better". Absolutely ANYONE can fall victim to foul play at any given time. No matter how street smart they are or how well acquainted they are with those around her (but let's be serious - she knew EVERYONE out that night? I doubt it).
Especially a woman out partying all night with shady whatevers types, yah that was an absurd biased claim on his part, I get what he's saying he's trying to be as respectful and pc as possible, but it's just an outright lie or ignorant no married woman should ever be out alone on the town with fricking shady weird strangers all night, to say they can "handle themselves" let alone based off another sketchy incident is absurd....
this is exactly what I said in my comment and I'm still getting people now saying you shouldn't hang around with the 'wrong people', as if there's some kind of sign they wear on their head or something. we're more likely to be killed by someone we know anyway. we're never safe from harm
A tad ignorant and bias in this video. No one has any solid proof where she ended up. It was in the families interest to push the 9/11 theory as they would receive a large payout. I doubt strongly that was Sneha in the video at the lift. It's highly unlikely she would forget ALL of her shopping bags....one maybe but not multiple. The marriage doesn't seem solid either. Going out at night, not returning and not notifying her husband on more than one occasion is troublesome. Something untoward could just as likely have happened to her after her shopping spree and before 9/11.
I agree that there's no proof of anything, but the family did not receive a payout. The 9/11 fund was exhausted before Sneha was added to the list of victims. Her family seemed more concerned about protecting her reputation than collecting money. They appear to have been relatively affluent.
I am sorry but your conclusion seemed kinda biased as if you already are very much certain that she died helping the victims at ground zero! This is a mere speculation and you said it yourself. Your own statement contradicts this conjecture. Her behavior was extremely shady leading up to her disappearance and she didn't come home on the night of 10th. It's not like everything was a-okay prior to that. She was not happy in her marriage and hardly spent her time at home. Also as far as I know there are records of people who rushed to the aid of 9/11 victims. If she was among them, there would have been some record. I surmise she met with foul play! However unlike you I am not gonna assert that this is exactly what happened. Your conclusion needs to be open to interpretation! It needs to have room for opinion. Also, her friend was supposed to get married later, not on the 11th! Why would she go there then? If she was there to inspect the place, she must have informed her friend before she went. Did she though? I miss your earlier videos which used to be more well-researched and fact-based.
spot on.. i felt the same points you mentioned.. this is a bizarre disappearance.. if she were dead prior to the wtc incident..her body should have been found or reported to nypd, OR if she died helping victims of the wtc attack.. wouldnt somebody see that and record her position that day?.. i am guessing she must have fled with a new identity to.start over.. or unfortunately passed away.
I hope to one day be able to watch this video, but I can’t just yet. It’s been almost 22 years, but talking about September 11 is still so hard. I guess it’s like PTSD, although I feel unworthy to use that term when I think of all the people who lost loved ones that day. The scenes and feelings from that day have never leftm. In some ways I feel like the US has gone back to normal since 911, in other ways I feel like we will never be back to normal again. I feel like our innocence as a country was stolen. Anyway, I didn’t mean to make this comment all about myself. I just wanted to talk about it. I tried to watch the video and just couldn’t. To anyone out there who still feels the pain of that awful day, please know you are not alone. God bless.
There is somewhat strange about this story because is she was coming back seeing in the camera footage. Then where was she that night? and why does no one come forward about that she was with someone... I assume if she was somewhere or with someone that the person would come forward and say:"yes she was here" so it is still a mystery where she was and why didnt she contact her husband? It wouldnt be suprising to me if she commited suicide or indeed walked away from her life. There was a lot going on Was the window open of the house that wasnt open nefore?. 9/11 could have played a roll, but it would be weird to me. Clearly there was not much she cpuld do about a burning building. She was not stupid. There is no proof that she was killed due the 9/11 attack
That wasn't her in the footage. Simple as that. Either they can definitively say it was 100% her (would you not know a loved one in footage of them?) or it wasn't. The fact it's a "maybe" means it's much more likely not to be her.
That’s a good point about them not honing in on finding out where she was the night before , if they count that as part of her missing timeline that very well changes the possibilities you focus on thereafter and can change it from having everything to having nothing to do with 9/11
I came across her story on Top5s video of 'internet rabbit holes' which went up early during the pandemic and also advertised this channel. Nice to see a new take on it.
I’m sorry for her family’s loss. I think it’s possible she disappeared before the attacks, but in the absence of them she’d either be alive, or the search for her would have been far less complicated. Rest In Peace.
@@onewotldgovernmentonlywhen9044I don't think you realize how ridiculous that sounds. Planting explosives in broad daylight in a massive building with tens of thousands of people wandering around all day, so they randomly picked one of the potentially thousands of witnesses to kill? Time to take your meds.
Also, don’t forget the brother had lied in an interview saying that she had spoken with him that she was going to run into the building to help the injured. And she was captured on camera with another woman and employee saw her with another female there too, why did that person never come forward and say hey she was with me either. She was also victim or she’s the perpetrator.
I've always been fascinated with this case, recent podcast dedicated to Sneha revealed even more... It bothers me the bad rep I think Sneha unfairly got, and the fact that all her friends seemed convinced that she ran away to start a new life always seemed so odd to me... My theory is she wandered into the ground zero area from a mix of morbid fascination and a willingness to help...
She wouldn't be able to do anything at ground zero. It's way more likely something nefarious happened or she ran off. There is nothing to connect to her to ground zero other than assumption
Same, absolutely fascinating since nothing quite makes sense. I lean more toward her getting killed on Sept 10th evening. Reason: not a soul saw her on Sept 11th morning nor were her bags ever found. If she was, in fact, at the Towers that means she would have spent the night somewhere but no evidence of that exists.
@@billblaski9523 - people get abducted and murdered all the time. Could have been a stranger. Could have been a shifty cab driver. Could have been someone she knew and had an argument with. Who knows? Crazy stuff happens in this city every day.
Heroic? I have never believed there was enough evidence to support that the 9/11 attacks were more than a coincidence when it comes to Sneha’s disappearance. Considering the other aspects of her lifestyle, it seems more plausible that something happened to her the evening before the tragedy.
From what I've seen here and the segment on Unsolved Mysteries, there's really no hard evidence let alone proof that Sneha was even in the area on the night of the 10th or the morning of the 11th. Plus, if she went shopping before (supposedly) going out for the night then where did she sleep? Where's the stuff she bought? The CCTV of a woman (that can't even be positively identified) at the apartment doesn't really hold water for me since she should have had those shopping bags with her if they were indeed for the house and herself. Especially the linens. Also, on the UM segment it states that the store clerk recognized Sneha as a regular customer and saw her with another Indian woman. She asked Sneha if the woman was a sister, and Sneha told her the woman was just a friend. So when Ron went back and re-examined the store footage (which they show you in the segment), it did appear as though there was a lady standing near her at the exit in such a way that it could appear as though they were spending time together, but admittedly that's still debatable. So if the clerk knew Sneha I don't think she was mistaken on who she spoke to, which begs the question: Was the clerk lying about the conversation, was Sneha lying about her connection to this unknown woman, or was there some other misunderstanding/miscommunication at play here? Personally, I think it's feasible that she did her shopping, came to meet foul play sometime that night and was possibly kidnapped and brought elsewhere. It would explain no body or her belongings from the day she disappeared being found anywhere in NY at the time, and why no one she knew heard from her or saw her after the shopping trip.
I think she ran away with her lover and her husband is just opportunistic. Do you really think Sneha would have told a casual acquaintance that the woman was her lover? No, one would say "friend". She had a history of not coming home and for going to gay bars.
Thank you for the time and effort you put into finding visual clips that fit (to the best you can) the visual and not so visual identities of the people in the stories. I appreciate and celebrate your attention to this social justice matter
Whether or not she died the day before 9 eleven or the day of no one will probably ever know. I feel truly sad for her husband and family. My condolences 🌹
I don't think she was killed in 911, what is presented in this video leads me to believe she met with something foul the night she didn't come home. Poor woman...
Nah She was kidnapped yet cops like usual are morons and only want to see one picture. No proof she ever fell into the river yet that's all they want to say. It's embarrassing
So so many people do seem to vanish. So many more than most people know about. I have a good friend that’s been missing since may of 2016. Her car, her and all her personal items. Just poof gone. No news broadcast just a “news release” on day 8 and then nothing. No follow ups no police interviews just she’s gone
There are numerous missing pieces in this story, and even the denouement is disturbingly hypothetical. Clearly, this was a young woman of privilege and promise living a dissolute, worldly lifestyle in one of the country's most worldly and dissolute cities. It's generous to imagine that she died the death of a hero in the midst of one of the most cowardly man-made catastrophes of modern times. Maybe so, but in all likelihood we will never know. I hope she won the battle in the end, but I'm more cynical than the author of this piece. Clearly this lady was in freefall headed for nothing good.
I'm glad at least some of the comments are calling you out for glossing over her alcohol and substance issues and trying to make her seem like a hero. I get the family has financial and other gains from doing it, I don't get why a youtuber needs to do that.
Was CCD paid by Rob to write this story? In the "theories" section there was no mention of Rob as a suspect. His wife lost 2 contracts, was an alcoholic, out partying a lot, potentially having affairs, no job but spending money on new clothes and shoes (3 pairs on the same trip!) using his credit card. Id say he was embarrassed with her behaviour and pissed off at her spending. Its not a stretch to theorise that they fought after she got home or they might have met up somewhere. He could have planned it and drugged her or maybe he stran.gled her while fighting.
maybe because of his behavior after? He has been pursuing it ever since then and not able to move on. Although I think he has finally re-married, he was doing a lot and going everywhere, hiring detectives, following all leads to find her. He could have just stayed silent and let the WTC issue do the speaking, but he didn't. His behavior doesn't exactly come off like a suspect to me. He might have been p whipped, but I don't think he murdered her.
And why is she an alcoholic? What’s the reason behind that? And spending nights away from home? Was life spiralling out of control and becoming unbearable and was she ashamed of her situation that it made her want to end her life? Also, sorry, but such risky behaviour can attract danger.
It's also so weird that she did'nt even call her husband or leave a message in her voice mail at home so when he gets home, just what he did.. He call home right away because the first thing he thought about was her, his wife, why would'nt que do the same? I feel she was kidnaped on the 10th & they used the WTC as a perfect cover for her kidnapping and death after the fact...That's my opinión!!!!! It's just to simple to just say de cant find her, so put her down as a victim of the WTC
Saying that she couldn't have been murdered because she was used to staying out late and partying with strangers is weird logic. It takes only one bad guy in one particular place at one particular time to commit a murder, without any reference at all to anything that may have happened before until that particular point in time. That is the nature of happenstance and caprice. ps: at 9:33 it clearly says the husband's cellphone was pinged at 4 am from a phone line INSIDE the apartment, and that Sneha was the only other person with access to the apartment. That would mean she was inside the apartment at that time to have made that missed call. So surely there is CCTV footage of her having entered the apartment building and leaving it at that time? What was the followup on that? But then again, if she was inside the apartment, why would she give her sleeping hubby a missed call?
If she ever went back to her flat, she would have brought back all the clothes she bought. There’s no mention here of her shopping goods which tells me she never made it back home on September 10 or the morning of September 11. Something happened to her between the shopping center and home.
I live in Somerset County where the plane came down. I was in 11th grade when it all happened. I can remember all the fear, chaos and just the unknown that filled the school when parents came flooding in to get their children. We visit the memorial where the plane came down often. It's ironic. It's such a beautiful area to be the place of such a horrible event. May you Rest In Perfect Peace to all who passed in all the horrendous tragedies of that day.
One cant rule out foul play completely in this case. But what I find truly poignant and intriguing is the change in Sneha from a bright and promising girl to an alcoholic. I feel that she was not happy in her career. Maybe she realised that she wud have been happier as an artist.
Then why didn't she simply change careers ? If her parent did not approve, would being an alcoholic change their minds ? why jeopardise her marriage? I am leaning towards mental illness.
She spent the night out, away from the marital bed, then she did the "walk of shame" to ground zero. Ridiculous. She met foul play then she floated down the East River, lost in the chaos of the 911 (amateur pilots fake news "terrorist" attacks)
I personally believe there is an element of mental illness in Sneha's case, however l do not believe she voluntarily disappeared, i think there was foul-play involved Either the parents or the husband are involved Something just doesn’t seem right with this story
I also feel something else was involved. Nothing to do with the attack on the towers . Where was she all night the night previously on the 10th . Nothing makes sense
I don't believe she went to the TT that day. Where did she spend the night? No one has come forward to say she was with them? It's not likely she left her shopping items at a strangers house. The odds of her being at the restaurant at the top of the TT would be astronomical. She was either killed after meeting someone at one of those clubs or she walked away. The problem with that is if she is ever arrested her fingerprints will ID her. It is a shame no matter what happened. Where was her husband (it's usually always the spouse). He could not have been okay with is wife spending the night at someone else's house all night. No way, not believing that statement.
This video IS bizarre!! The characters in the video keep changing - mostly they have used footage and shots from movies with Indian actors, many are Bollywood movies - one never knows from scene to scene who they are going to show. And amazingly sometimes Sneha is portrayed as an African American woman and sometimes as an Asian (Korean? Thai? Japanese?) Weird!!
I remember this story. I believe her husband needs to be investigated all over. I believe she was murdered by him or someone else but he knows more than anybody knows!!!!
I usually like your videos but hearing you say Sneha can't possibly have been murdered because she knew how to avoid it was galling and tactless. murder victims aren't to blame for hanging around with the wrong people. only murderers are to blame
Exactly. And just because she had always been safe in the past, doesn't mean that something terrible didn't happen that night. Being safe in the past had nothing to do with whether or not she was safe/unsafe on that night.
It irritated me no end that so many people are assuming that she died at the WTC that morning while trying to help the injured. Not only is there absolutely zero evidence for this, but now she's celebrated as a hero and her family benefitted financially. I understand that it probably makes her family feel better to believe that's how she died, and it certainly makes it easier on the NYPD to declare her a victim of 9/11, but there isn't a single piece of evidence for this being the truth.
I believe something happened to her the night before, and she never made it back to her building at all on the morning of 9/11. Apparently, it was hard to see the woman at the elevator, and Ron said that the woman "could be" Sneha, but he didn't positively identify her. And she did a lot of shopping the day before, yet the woman at the elevator wasn't carrying anything. I can understand forgetting something small on the bus/train...an umbrella, a book, a small bag...and most of us have done it. But the idea that she accidently left a half dozen large bags behind on the train is ludicrous, that really is reaching.
@@Terri_MacKay to be fair to the idea of leaving your stuff behind, I have literally done that. I left about five shopping bags at my grandmothers house after shopping with her all afternoon. I didn’t even realize I had forgotten them until I got home and out of the car and realized my bags weren’t in the back. People can do crazy things when they’re a little bit tired or off their normal schedule. Because of that, I wouldn’t entirely discount the theory of her forgetting her bags, merely because I have done that exact same thing.
@@justalittleturtle5600 I've done the same thing. Gone shopping, went to visit one of my sisters, and left shopping or something else there. But in the video, they were wondering if the woman at the elevator was Sneha, because she had done a lot of shopping but wasn't carrying anything. They speculated that maybe she had left her shopping on the subway, not at someone's house. I can believe leaving it at someone's house. But, if you're on a subway or bus, you've probably got some bags next to you and some on your lap. It's hard to believe that in that case, she would get off the train without them.
There were things left out of this story. Like, her husband thought she may have stayed with a relative overnight because she had done that before, in which case she could have left her shopping there. But it was never made clear if we know for sure that she did stay with relatives, and did she/didn't she take the bags with her when she left in the morning. That seems like a pretty big fact to leave out.
Well don't hang around with the wrong people
She’s definitely not to blame if she had been attacked. There’s a reason why women are cautious of being alone or near men they don’t know. But your right being cautious won’t prevent attacks from someone
This narration is uneven.
It goes into detail her purchases, items she wore and minor incidents, but does not explain the backstop of her addiction and poor performance.
Until then she portrayed as a dutiful, high achieving daughter and wife. Something such as addiction does not occur suddenly or without trauma.
Many things don't hold up. She was an alcohol addict. She would spend time with unknown people at gay bars. She spent time wandering in certain pubs.
Seems like she and her husband weren't getting along or she was a gay or bisexual.
Something is fishy about her. Her husband also didn't care that she wasn't spending time with him is weird.
Something doesn't add up. Some of information is hidden in my opinion. My best guess is she left her husband and family maybe because she was guilty of being a gay.
There is almost no other explanation of her vanishing. Maybe her family was trying to protect her image being Indians.
I thought it was weird the husband didn’t seem to mind Sneha was openly cheating on him with women. I don’t know if Sneha was gay or bisexual, but she seemed to be more into women.
She clearly had some personal issues and weird, perhaps risky habits---yet this is mostly glossed over in the report, perhaps because there's not enough information about it.
I agree ,some information missed out ,i believe. @@richardernsberger5692
@@afdcg I did not see this at all like you do. There is nothing showing her sexuality has anything to do with her disappearance. Nothing about gay bar hopping is more "fishy" than heteronorm. Some heteros like hanging on gay bars to have more fun or avoid pushy men.
It seems like she was LOVED by her husband, rest her soul.
Do you know something more about Indians? To me it seems like a universal thing to protect your offspring.
We do not know if she was diagnosed as an alcoholic, merely that she, in a tough time, was accused of neglect due to alcohol. Sometimes people put others down with lables to gain from it. We do not know first hand. Rest in peace lovely Sneha. Too soon, wrong girl.
Knowing how to protect yourself doesn't mean you can't be harmed or killed. I hope she's found 🙏🏽
Simplicity comment. Found where
@@MyJOSE2013 don't you think thats the question from the beginning???
Found? She died back in 2001! All those ashes are gone. I swear the dumb comments we read.
@S Feldman Yea the dumb comments like yours. There's no proof of what you're saying
It feels like only 3% are found....
So so so sad....
So sad....
It breaks my heart.
I think of my mother, my sister, my boys
I mean, do we have to prepare ourselves for such events?...No man!
Feels a little glossed over for me. If we can't be brutally honest about people's lives it can hinder their being found as no body wants to really discuss the whole truth. That's not to say Sneha isn't a good person but this story is like reading through rose tinted glasses.
I'm glad other people are recognizing this. It's too bad how this video does indeed gloss over some of the allegedly "unsavory" parts of Dr. Phillips' life.
Personally, I believe she died downtown on 9/11, and I admire her actions that much more _because_ she was such an "imperfect", distinctly human individual. In a moment of supreme crisis I believe she transcended her troubles, fell back on her training, and headed towards danger in order to help other people. Like a good doctor.
She doesn't have to be a saint for me to admire her. She shouldn't have to be for anyone to admire her. I wish videos like this would cease _attempting to_ sanctify her.
True!!
@@mcnultyssobercompanion6372 well how can we be ao aire that she died at ground zero?
Amen to that. Sugar coating reality doesn't do anything for society.
@debbiekirby3229 EXACTLY! Thank you! I feel like this was just a way to keep her reputation in place even tho the truth of the matter was much different. People drive me nuts being in such denial. It doesnt help find her or help anyone to realize the real truth.
The "she knew who to meet in bars"
But she also had a an drinking problem.
Yeah, that doesn't mix.
The fact that she didn't come home the night before and didn't call, leads me to speculate she met foul play the day she was last seen. As for the family insisting that she died on ground 0 is rather irrational. There was no proof she was even there.
Exactly. There is no event in recent history more seared into people's memories than 9/11. If she was there, there would be evidence, 100%. Somebody would've come forward. She simply was never there.
I've watched a documentary on this and it's speculated (and I tend to agree with it) that they wanted her to be a hero in death and not as the alcoholic with a criminal record. Her husband admitted she stayed out often, going home with women she met at gay bars, he says it wasn't for sexual reasons. I find that bs, what married woman goes home with strangers, not just once, but several times, for no other reason. Not to mention, having her a victim of 911 gave her husband access to a lot of money, life insurance and other victims funds set up.
@@itsmackenzie exactly what I was thinking, yeah ok “just for fun, no sex” But still, sad story tho
@@watermelon4738
Men ALWAYS hit the sex button! 😂
@@itsmackenzie The husband probably knew his wife was gay & was feeling embarrassed to tell the real thing about her going home with the women she meets at gay bar, hence the conflict in their relationship & her drinking issue, also him caring more about accessing the 9/11 victim benefits. It seems like there are many gaps in the story, however, reading about this case, there's a one detail that gave me chills. It is said that some years after 9/11, there's was an anonymous drawing uploaded to the anonymous confession website, the drawing was the twin towers with fire raging out of them, under that there was a caption which read: "Everyone who knew me before 9/11, thinks I'm dead". I've a feeling that she's actually still alive under a new identity, probably living in a remote area with her girlfriend. Just my theory
She had a court case, dismissed from 2 jobs and had a substance habit. She did not come home the night before and didn't leave a message. This case is skewered by the girl's family that the real crime has gone unsolved.
Not leaving a message that night for her husband would seem significant. Did she usually leave a message if she was not going to come home--or no? How odd that a well-educated woman from a typically conservative, upper-class Indian background would have some unusual if not worse personal habits.
I do not dismiss your theory but I kind of think that's highly unlikely.
It's two possible scenarios that could be factuality! And that is that the woman that was captured on video could could have been a very important piece to this puzzle. She could have been involved in the disappearance of Sheha along with a unidentified party who was never mentioned in the police investigation. This gives strong indication as to why this woman was never found or stepped forward. Is she was involved as this could have been a crime of passion! A three way gone wrong which resulted in this woman or the third unidentified party maybe the woman husband or lover killing Sheha. And the reason as why the woman on video was ever identified or tracked down as she could have escape justice and fled back to foreign land! U have to consider this possible given that when you view the video of Sheha and this mysterious woman! She do not look american born so it's possible that this woman have not been tracked down as the reason as her and the other unidentified party left the United States and fled back to their home State. Or my last theory that makes a lot more sense is that Sheha may have been a victim of a serial killer. Considering that In 2001 she disappeared under very suspicious circumstances doing the heart of the then unknown long island serial killer, who was abducting and killing women thru out the state of New York. The man who is now labled long island serial killer rex heuermann I believe was the prime suspect in the disappearance of Sheha Anne Phillips..
Husband's phone showed a missed call at 4 a.m., 9/11/2001, from a phone line INSIDE their apartment. Who was it? I'm not convinced she died on 9/11 as a result of the terrorist attacks.
I highly doubt it she died at WTC. Her running into the tower to help people is mostly a hearsay which has been highlighted as a fact in this shoddily made video.
Our landline phone would occasionally ring itself back in the day when we had one. It's possible the husband picked up one phone inside the house and called his own phone number by accident and won't admit it because he wants to advance the 911 theory.
@@elliebellie7816 Good point.
@@elliebellie7816 It was the landline phone that rang. His cell phone would show if he called the landline. He say he did not hear the landline and that is possible if it rang only once.
Husband should be investigated also.
The woman she was with on the afternoon of September 11 has never been identified. That always bothered me about this case.
Unless the shoe store employee was mistaken.
She wasn't with anyone. I'll believe video evidence over a one time witness.
@@sebastianelytron8450 The surveillance video from the store showed her with another female. According to witness (store employee) both were clearly shopping together.
@@spacewurmshe was alone and it was captured on video. Unless the employee was mistaken. Or she saw a ghost with her. Perhaps someone was with her and she thought they two women were together but not.
Or possibly that woman was intentionally staying out of the CCTV footage so they won't find & identify her later
No, it is not evident that she died on 9/11. She was known to go out all night and go home with people she had just met. She drank too much, clouding her judgement. You aren’t safe because you “know what type of person to stay away from”. Also, we NYers aren’t afraid or uncomfortable to talk about 9/11. And there are many photos of those that ran to the towers to help out before they fell. It was being documented on the ground in real time. She is in none of them.
I drink but It doesn't cloud my judgement in something over such time without valid reason too move away
Just because people were taking photos of victims running towards the towers doesn’t mean they’re going to catch every single person that ran towards the towers that day. That’s a ludicrous thought, believing that you can discount someone’s presence at a scene just from photos like that.
you are right.
Exactly this. I dislike how CCD tends to glorify all missing persons. Assholes can disappear too, you know.
@@justalittleturtle5600 If she were allowed into the area close up to work as a doctor (which wouldn’t happened in the first place, firefighters would have moved the injured back as debris and even bodies were falling) she more than likely would have been caught on film. There are hundreds of photos covering the entire area. She never would have been let inside of the buildings, and even then there is video of the lobby.
The fact that her family & husband insisting on her dying in the attack despite the lack of proof and it not making sense in the first place tells me that they're hiding something or withholding other details.
I'm certain it was for financial gain from her family. She is alive and well in India. The family knows.
Not necessarily. just as likely for it to be a coping mechanism, would you rather your missing daughter die in a " the 9-11 incident" and thats as neutral as im gonna label it but thats a different matter" but would you rather your daughter died in that a default "heroes tragic death" or was maybe randomly abducted by some random murderer in a foul play case the day before by totally random awful luck chance? You could be right just saying there are reasons why one might claim this is all.
My exact thoughts!
Or hoping for monetary gain as a victim.
@@Ilikerainydayz LMAO All the way in India? What a joke. She is gone!
A woman who was having a good day shopping, getting ready for visitors wouldn’t just not come home or call to let her husband know where she was. Something fishy but I’m afraid she fell thru the cracks because of all that was happening
Right, sounds like something may have happened when she got home
@@despicabledavidshort3806 I don’t think she ever made it home because where is the stuff she bought?
It's mentioned in the video here and I also recall reading elsewhere how it was her habit to party all night without including him at all. Unfortunately by then it was something he was used to.
I'm actually wondering if she left the shopping bags at whatever person's place she stayed the night before because she didn't want her husband to see them (her hospital had just told her her contract wasn't being renewed and that was a lot of shopping she did....)
Personally I'm pretty confident when she saw the catastrophe happening so close to home, she made use of her medical training and went down to help, which is where she likely died.
@@mcnultyssobercompanion6372 Her husband had to work long hours with early starts. He wouldn't have been up to partying all night, and she had permission to use his credit card so she didn't have to hide anything from him. I think that day she used shopping as therapy to cheer herself up after so many disappointments, and maybe went out for drinks for the same reason.
When I look at the video of her shopping at Century 21, she looks to me like a calm, stable Indian housewife. Her clothes look to me like someone who is a housewife, not a partier and sleeping around with a bunch of strangers. Like, the police's description of her personal life do not match her calm and steady demeanor in that video, IMHO. Not saying she didn't frequent night clubs, but that her appearance there doesn't indicate to me someone who's spiraling out of control. I think she met her fate sometime in the later hours of the 10th or early hours of the 11th. I really don't think she perished in the attacks. I think she had passed before the attacks.
The conclusion is completely flawed. If her family is going to claim that she was a victim of 9/11, then, yes, we do need to be able to substantiate her whereabouts and that includes establishing where she was on the night of the 10th. Saying "Oh, New Yorkers get triggered talking about that kind of thing..." is lame and childish. Also, fantasizing about her running to Ground Zero to help victims of the attack is grotesquely ridiculous, since you have absolutely no evidence to back it up. You're making the facts fit your conclusion, not the other way around.
I agree all of the footage shows everyone being directed away it was 00 visibility and dust and they were not allowing anyone to enter the buildings. I agree the conclusion is flawed
You just took words out of my mouth! I was dumbfounded when the narrator said 'she died helping people at ground zero' like dude you don't even know what happened and you weren't there! He could have said this might be one of the possibilities but he had to conclude with super cheesy and biased remark. I am sorry for whatever happened to her and I wholeheartedly hope her family receives some closure but we cannot declare her hero without any evidence.
And 9/11 is a part of a world life.
We could be....... beings!
If they can prove that she died in wtc then they can collect wtc payments. My sister is a survivor as she was walking to work on the side of the building. She’s had abt 40 surgeries from the debris. She has not taken any money from the victims fund bc she feels guilty abt it. There’s nothing that suggests she was there so it’s pretty dark if that’s their intentions.
@@Chris-kq9lb I've read that the husband was actually allowed to access the place & look for her. But she was no where to be found. I find it strange that they're insisting on including her in the list of victims despite the absence of evidence
Probably the worst point in history you could have gone missing was Sep 11th 2001. Such a strange, sad case. What drove her to alcohol and put her career in such jeopardy? What on earth happened?
There are tons of people out there who abuse alcohol. Plenty of alcoholic doctors.
Stress to perform and be at their best. It is possible that she was struggling with her sexual identity quite a bit. Her spending nights away from the home and her husband being okay with it tells me either he knew or her family knew about her struggles.
@@cruisepaige They should be in rehab to safeguard their integrity as doctors.I wonder why people don't turn to God when their lives are not going good for them instead of alcohol.
@@shaheezamajid2118 she probably turned to alcohol for help once she realized God couldn't help her.
@@mrsTraveller64 God couldn't help!!? That's what He's there for! She was probably mixing with the wrong people giving her wrong advice. The alcohol let her down big time 😥😥😥
9:31
_"Early the next morning, at around 4 AM, Ron's cell phone is pinged with a missed call from a phone line inside the apartment. Sneha is the only other one with access to the home. But Ron doesn't remember receiving a call and says he barely remembers even checking his voicemail around that time."_
So no one is going to talk about this?
Yea they didnt finish
Anybody who has been to the 9/11 memorial knows there is a closed off section that acts a morgue. There are still a number of people unaccounted for to this day.
oh wow! i didn't know that.
@@ameliashostak4764ye the city pathologist won't re tire until they have identified ever last person
@@matthewjennings5893 Sadly, and it's truly an awful reality to accept, they will almost certainly never retire, & will, in fact, die long before even a fraction of those remains can be identified, assuming it's even possible in the first place (while I'm absolutely no expert, I don't believe it is possible.)
@@SelfHatingLionsFanLove your username
This is strange considering how much DNA & forensic science have advanced in 20 years. Even remains from thousands years ago can be identified now.
So just because it’s too insensitive to ask people of their whereabouts the evening before 9/11, were just going to write off the fact she didn’t contact her husband all night or the following morning as unsuspicious?
Exactly my thoughts
I don’t believe she died in ground zero. I believe she met with foul play the last day she was seen! Period. Maybe her husband needs to be looked at a bit more closely then fan out from there.
Totally agree. The husband should have been looked more closely! In these kind of cases family should be looked at very closely, it’s often someone close.
Absolutely. The husband had to be better investigated.
WTF😂😂😂 NYPD was not interested in her case and assumed her to be a victim of 9/11. It was her husband who hired private detective to look into the case. If he was murderer he would have just agreed to NYPD. Family of sneha too agreed on the theory that she was the victim of terrorist attack.
😂😂😂😂😂
Sneha's struggles with alcohol and other aspects of her life are treated so lightly in this documentary, it does not take any special powers of observation to come to the conclusion that her life may well have been falling apart and spiraling out of control rapidly, I am surprised by her husband's attitude to her spending night's out and staying away from home, if we are to believe it he was totally at ease with her living like this, even as a viewer I feel extremely uncomfortable knowing that she was out at all hours and the idea that she knew what she was doing ,could spot trouble and take care of herself fall apart as soon as you take into account her drinking problem, the whole thing seems to be steered toward her being a hero during 9/11 but it is hard for me to imagine any individual no matter what their medical skills and training may be rushing into such a horrific scene, I obviously do not know what happened to Sneha but the possibilities remain wide open as far as I can ascertain.
The husband most likely knew all of her friends who she went out with and she did call the police on the intern. She was probably threatened to drop the charges on the intern. Why didn’t she call anyone on the morning of 911 to let them know what she was going to do if she was going to the tower? Someone is hiding something. Someone knows something I don’t think she faked her death she paused going to college for a year for her husband to graduate with him that tells you a lot of her love for her husband
*She knew why she was doing lot's of shopping. It seems she had an affair behind her husbands back and after they used her, she was mudered. The arrow always hit the shooter*
I agree….so little is being made of her addictions which seems obvious was beginning to unravel her life! There’s so much more to all this..
Typical case of alcoholic women , raped and murdered by some known near one or unknown psycho. Nothing new in US , just another day
Maybe they need to look at the family more closely.
I personally don't believe Sneha ran away (you'd need a lot of planning for that and it doesn't seem like she'd planned for it) but it's intriguing as, from what I have gathered, the items she bought on that day were never found either.
She didn't go home that day, so where did she go? I think foul play is equally likely unfortunately, as any evidence of foul play in another area would have likely gone amiss if it was in close proximity to the WTC.
So you have two (likely) options -
1) She died when the towers collapsed after attempting to assist but spent the night of September 10th elsewhere (and left her purchases there also? Although I can see unclaimed shopping being overlooked in the chaos)
2) She met with foul play as she headed home from her shopping and the crime scene/evidence was lost or overlooked in the aftermath of the collapse.
Additionally, was her husband's card ever found? She had it on her and I'm assuming he didn't immediately cancel it in case he'd be able to track further purchases on it and possibly lead to Sneha? As it's not mentioned I presume it was never used again after September 10th?
As far as we KNOW, the items have never been found. If she was killed or kidnapped, the bag of items could have dropped from her hands and someone picked it up and took it home with them.
Running away & using a different identity wasn't uncommon thing back in those days. Look up the video titled "The book tied to 75,000 disappearances". Several people did that.
@@GhostRangerr Yes who knows if she was planner leave her husband and use September 11 ad a way of escape......also she could have been by the towers as they suggest but her body has never been found...who knows
@@GhostRangerr In those days ? lol
She bought that for a girlfriend and spend the night with her.
A puzzling case. Two questions immediately jump to mind: what is the evidence Sneha really was at the WTC when the terror attacks happened and why didn't she come back home that night? Wouldn't it be more logical to think something happened to her at the time she didn't return home after her shopping. The presenter says it wasn't unusual for her to spend the night at the relative's house, but neatly omits to mention if they questioned the relatives about her whereabouts that night. It is very unlikely she tried to fake her own death; it is more likely she met some sort of foul play after her shopping.
Yes this is what I was thinking, between leaving the store & heading home something happened to her.
@@MsVivi66 or after she got home
From some other comments you can deduce that she expending nights with lovers. It's not so far fetched to think that on the way back she heard the planes or saw what was happening and went to help there. It could also be foul play the day before, but I guess then they should have found more video or eyewitness from what happened
Why didn't whoever she was with the night before, wherever she stayed, come forward? Unless they died in the WTC or for more nefarious reasons.
This video is problematic because it seems to be carrying the propaganda torch on behalf of the family, downplaying the significance of Dr. Phillips' nighttime activities. I'm seeing many many comments asking the same question: "why didn't she come back home?" This says to me this video didn't do enough of a job explaining the whole picture adequately.
I've read several articles about this case, and basically Dr. Phillips was, by 9/11, going out all night a lot, usually to lesbian bars, and not making any effort to check in with her husband.
There's a particularly bizarre beat in this video where the narrator seems to suggest that Dr. Phillips was going to LGBTQ bars primarily so she couldn't be hit on? This is absurd because she was obviously quite attractive and I can't imagine the lesbians and/or bi-women _weren't going_ to hit on her in their own bars.
Dr. Phillips was almost certainly bisexual, maybe even outright gay, and her marriage was essentially a mess. I'm paraphrasing because it's been a while since I read about this case, but I remember reading that their marriage was in serious trouble. This is why she didn't come home. She didn't give a damn.
People are also wondering why she didn't bring the bags home. Part of her shopping spree involved lingerie; my guess is it was almost certainly not meant for....her husband (I also suspect she didn't want him to know exactly how much she'd spent....)
To be fair, IT'S POSSIBLE she was murdered September 10th, without a body anything's possible, but I'm personally pretty convinced, when she saw what was happening downtown, she reverted back to her training and did what she could to help. Which is likely why no one's seen her since. Unfortunately.
It is unlikely Sneha was a 9/11 victim. Based on what is presented herein, concluding that Sneha was a victim of 9/11 is not substantiated. She did not spend the night of Sept 10th with her brother or her cousin. Evidence that she even came back to the apartment on Sept 11th is insufficient. If she was smart, she would have avoided ground zero. If she was going to ground zero to assist, why did she not inform her husband or a family member? When she heard about the attack, why did she not call her husband? What you have presented leads one to the conclusion that she was either abducted or ran away the night of Sept 10th. Lastly, a woman enjoying an active social life is not a crime and should not be judged negatively.
That call he claimed he had gotten was off as well
@@brishawn8571 He never heard from her at all for over 24 hours.
the fact that she never called to even check on him when the events occurred tells me something happened to her the night before 9/11. She never used his credit card through the night. They do not say if she had other cards on her or not. There is a lot missing from this story.
@@plum_loco I know he didn’t. I was talking about a so called call that he recieved but miss and how he claimed only she had that number. I wonder if that was even checked out or was there even a voicemail
@@brishawn8571 That's what they are talking about that there was a ping to the landline phone but they could not deduce anything more from that with technology. He claims that he never heard the phone ring. There was a time that they used to able to identify the phone number the call came from but it had to be picked up at the other end. So in a way it confirms that he never picked up the phone.
@@danielhicks4826i agree with u.. Makes sense.. Not just women.. Even men need to be alert. This world is never ever going to b a safe place. We shud do our due diligence n stick to a logical protocol
This is a great mystery/cold case. What happened to the pizza delivery boy also intrigues me. Sad that he wasn't included as a casualty of 9/11 and she was just because of her profession. Makes you think that whoever committed a murder on 9/10 or 9/11 in NYC really got a free pass and got away with it if they managed to hide the body from authorities.
I'm not finding any other videos on Fernando Molinar, either.
How true, there were a few undocumented persons that were never considered victims, never added to the memorial is it fair? Absolutely not one shred of evidence that she was anywhere near the wtc, her brother took vital time from other families that needed to express info about their loved ones to only blatantly lie, her family is what it looks like not what it is and because of that the case will never come to close because of they’re complete denial of who their daughter actually was and about the life style she was involved in
This is so true what are the odds right ? To go missing right before 9/11 but sadly I do believe this is the case and something bad happened to her. I don’t believe she died in the towers.
What you said at the end is true, because shortly before midnight on 9/11/2001 in New York, a Polish immigrant named Henryk Siwiak was murdered after mistakenly entering the wrong street to go to his new job, he was shot and the crime remains unsolved to this day, since at the time it happened, most of the police were still busy with what had happened hours before at the WTC.
@@kimf.8518In addition to Anne Philip, another woman also disappeared (Michele Anne Harris). Harris disappeared on the night of 9/11 just after 11pm after leaving the bar in who was drinking with her friends, and her car was found abandoned at the door of the house where she lived with her children and her ex-husband the next morning. Her case remains a mystery and her body was never found, despite her ex-husband being suspected of murdering her (he was tried and convicted, but acquitted).
I always flip back and forth with what I think happened in this case. It’s crazy
Her life was collapsing. Her marriage was probably in trouble, but Ron wouldn't have been stupid enough to discuss that in relation to her disappearance. Edit. Buying three pairs of shoes after losing both jobs argues for her being unable to cope with changed circumstances.
She did NOT lose a job! It was a residency and it wasn't renewed. She already had another job starting soon at a prestigious hospital. Sheesh!
@@joanodom2104 Tsk, tsk. She had two positions, both of which she lost. You focus on just the one. Sheesh!
Kinda feel like the theory that she died in the 9/11 terror attacks serves to hide the fact that major shit was going on in her life. She went out all night the night before and didn't call her husband. That indicates some kind of problem they had or secret she had. Due to that we have to equally consider the possibility she ran off with a partner or on her own. Maybe she was closeted LGBTQ and felt she couldn't be herself in her current life.
I do agree with this comment
9:11 happened the next morning and it worked to her advantage to use it to disappear with her gay lover
She probably disappeared before being able to call him. She was probably a witness of those who went into the towers to place the explosions. The terrorists most likely killed her when she saw them
Would be good to get an explanation about her turn to alcoholism and run in with the laws. You kinda just go from their marriage to bam, getting fired and personal problems a year later, but no run up to those. It was so out of nowhere I had to go back and see if I missed something.
Yeah shit happens without warning almost like this is the story of someones life & you're not entitled to more details
@@kastynm.9004 Well when it's an unsolved disappearance more details could help explain her actions and what happened. Also this is a true crime documentary so getting into all the details goes with the territory.
@@kastynm.9004 in her case shit didn't just happened. She created it she has choices. Just like she made a choice to be a doctor.
I too thought about this. Something tells me she's not the angelic goody two shoes she's portrayed to be here. The fact that she went missing significantly before the tragedy is proof to me that something else was going on. Also, suppose she did go to help out, what are the chances that she died there? There was more than enough trained professionals to keep her safe, and somebody would've interacted with her and reported on it. I don't think she was anywhere near there, or her disappearance had anything to do with 9/11.
@@kastynm.9004
Considering the fact that her family gained a large amount of money in relation to the 9/11 victim's compensation fund I think that a clearer picture into the sudden change in her personal life is warranted.
Was she bisexual or a lesbian and just married a man to cover her situation up to her family, thus causing her to drink and seek out companionship outside of her marriage?
It sounds as though she had every reason to intentionally disappear or that she placed herself a situation where she could have been harmed by a casual contact, or even her husband.
I find it laughable that the narrator said that she knew how to handle herself in the party scene in New York City. So did every other victim of crime in that exact same situation. 🤔
Something just isn't adding up here.
An odd tale with more questions than answers. I wasn't convinced by the summing up at the end - it just felt like projection based on no evidence.
I think she was murdered that night. The next day's news overshadowed any attempts at finding her and the killer knew he was going to get away with it. Lucky boy.
how do you know it was a he? could very well have been one of the random women she went home with
I think so too
@@howdareyouexist yeah could have been a woman too. Or could have been RON too as he has his own good reasons to kill her
What an amazing documentary. Thank you for sharing. According to Wikipedia and other sources, Sneha Anne Phillip is 'Legally dead' on September 11th 2001 but to me as to probably most people, it still remains a true mystery.
How come they’ve never found out where she spent the night and what happened to her shopping 🤔
Right? Too many plotholes that need to be filled. This video seemed biased as hell.
@Humayra Faizah It's almost like Sneha's family/husband secretly sponsored this video.
@@humayrafaizah1428 The official story itself has too many gaps, like it straight jumped from her being a happy woman full of passion to her being alcoholic who got fired From her job & her marriage collapsing. There definitely have to be details in between that could help the case but were left out. This led me to think that the husband & family are hiding something
That probably because she never got the chance to spend the night anywhere
That probably because she never got the chance to spend the night anywhere
There's really no evidence that she was even in any of the buildings that day she could have easily have been somewhere else when she ended up disappearing of course it would suit any potential perpetrator to have her declared as a 9/11 victim meaning they will never come under suspicion and will get away with the crime which means even if she was murdered the chances of this case getting solved is extremely slim
Agreed, being murdured during an absolute tragedy like 9/11 makes it even more easy for the guilty person who killed her. It's like during a war when a person is mysteriously killed on their way home, people are preoccupied with death and damage daily. The murderers don't have to hide. Horrific.
I've said several times over the years that if someone was living in NYC at the time and they wanted to disappear....that was the perfect opportunity to do so. (Don't misunderstand that as people DID voluntarily disappear, just that it would be easier then.)
Would it have been that hard to stick with ONE actor couple to portray these two? Sneha was Indian, Caucasian, long and short haired, bangs and none. Her husband was young, older, long and short haired, and sometimes even the real guy. I’m deaf and need to read captions, so it’s already confusing enough.
You skip through what was going on in her life before. Why was she drinking and what was the false complaint?
The idea that Sneha left with no money, no ID, no medical credentials to start a new life is slightly preposterous. How on earth would she begin a new life with no money? She was definitely under a lot of stress - she was likely unhappy in her profession, probably her parents were questioning her constantly, her husband was likely also in conflict with her as she seemingly spiraled and became addited to alcohol - but the "how" of the run-away theory just isn't there. I believe she either died as the towers fell because it wouldn't be out of the ordinary for a trained doctor to want to help and at the time no one could even imagine the towers were going to fall as they did. Or she did meet with foul play and the 9/11 attacks was a coincidence that made it easy to hide the body and all evidence. The chaos of that day, especially in that area of Manhatten, was insane. My thoughts are with her family.
How to set up to disappear. Open a post office box prepaid for three months apply for credit cards, if you do not want the credit card in your name apply for or go to drugstore purchase prepaid credit card this might involve a six month post office box build a record of credit on a pre-paid credit card not in your name the name you were going to assume very very easy to do funnel little bit of money into the new account. Very easy to get a fake drivers license, very easy to take fake drivers license into a bank open an account and do assume name boom you are started
This video indicated she had been going out for months if not longer to gay night clubs they claimed she didn’t like to go to regular night clubs because she would be hit on by men. They explain that she didn’t get hit on in the gay clubs. That would be falls and attractive woman from India at a gay club would get hit on a lot. She may have come across a gay person who didn’t take kindly to The way she was misrepresenting herself.
I just watched a episode of Missing where a man did just that. Left his wallet, keys, credit cards family thought something bad happened to him. Come to find out out he relocated worked jobs that paid off the books. They finally closed his case cuz he died from health issues and they realized his name was fake. He was missing for like 15 years, up and left cuz he didn't want to handle his family responsibilities anymore
Misrepresenting herself? Seriously? You DO realize that many, many, many straight people love to go to gay bars. The sound systems are always killer and the music is perfect for dancing.
@@Chris-kq9lb In 2001 there were no pre-paid credit cards that I can remember.
She was probably a witness of 911 or and had someone who had an obsession with her
I remember this case from Unsolved Mysteries and over the years have read about it more in depth here and there. I will say CCD drawing their conclusion as that of the husband and families is surprising to me..(I expected there to be an open conclusion for the viewers to decide) anyhow…picturing her just running into danger like some sort of battle field nurse may be better saved for a movie script . She was a medical doctor not a panicked stranger looking to help. A medical doctor knows running directly into public danger (that large) is not going to save many lives when it can result in them losing their life..Also I would assume she would run to help and then maybe run back out trying to help as many as possible. Not just help 1 person & then die right there. She was clearly going though a crisis even though she never lost her medical license I’m sure losing her job would be very difficult to explain to her parents (especially her father) who I’m sure she wanted to make proud. While we like to talk about the many hero’s of 9/11 there were also many 9/11 hero fakers…Im sure her family wanted her to die a hero but there just simply is not enough conclusive evidence to prove that. Her reputation as a person and medical doctor does not automatically merit her a hero.
Just having a ton of medical knowledge without any equipment, without any transportation, you are pretty useless in situations like ground zero at the time of the WTC collapse and more likely to get in the way or become a casualty yourself.
Honor killing.
@@vidaliasoleil2714 Could be.
Not sure. Is common in that race.
@@vidaliasoleil2714 Seriously.
Bug off.
Take it or leave it.
So stupid.
@@vidaliasoleil2714
Honor killings happen on regular basis in that race so who is the dumb dumb here.
And who is everybody???
Speak for yourself only please or remain silent.
I'm a NYer who was in kindergarten that day, and I still have vivid memories of the event and am perfectly willing to discuss that day, as is every other NYer I know. If Sneha had left her shopping bags on the train or in a cab, someone would have remembered seeing it. Anyone she stayed the night with, even in anonymous sense, would have remembered. The unsubstantiated reasoning for what it was Sneha in that lobby is completely asinine. The fact of the matter is that there's no proof whatsoever that she was at ground zero. Hers is a case that has no proof that points in ANY direction. This video'sn inclusion seems like an obvious bid to agree with the family at all costs. The fact of the matter is that the proof that is asserted in this video doesn't exist.
Yeah, it's like CCD got silently sponsored by Sneha's family. The whole case looks fishy as hell. There's a good possibility she met with foul play. Given that possibility, people should be on the lookout for possible perpetrators rather than just lazily concluding that she died on 9/11.
🤣🤣🤣 if you were in kindergarten guarantee you have no accurate details of that day. Not significant ones.
I remember this case from unsolved mysteries. a very strange case. shout out to you for documenting it. i like to think sneha perished that morning protecting civilians from the terrorist attacks. but where was she the night before?
The night before is the kicker for me. That's when something must've happened. I think the fact it was September 10th, 2001 is sheer coincidence, and we're reading too much into the next day's events.
@@sebastianelytron8450
Agreed.
Here's a theory: she stayed with a friend who also died in 9/11 therefore they couldn't come forward to say where she was the night of the 10th.
Could've been a (ex)coworker, which means they could've been a doctor or nurse who went to help at the Towers.
Just a theory.
no
Police often go to the "this person left to build a new life"..... how often has that actually happened? I've never heard of someone doing this, although I realize I likely wouldn't.
Thank you! How often does that scenario really happen?
@Crystal Airgood well how would we know? The person has never been found
Barely Sociable did an interesting video about people doing this kind of thing (the video is titled something like "the book tied to x disappearances"). Of course, I dunno how the rate of that happening compares to the rate police reach to that as and explanation but it is a thing that definitely happens (if rarely). And as you allude to it's hard to get a count of people who have done it successfully. I do tend to think it's more about police laziness though
@@crystalairgood9845 There are no statistics but it is extremely rare. I have read about 100's of missing persons cases in the last few decades and I've only come across a handful that have actually intentionally caused their own disappearance. However police suggest this all the time. Especially back in the 60's-90's. 2001 is not too far outside that window. Chances are she died a hero and the police basically smeared her by saying she's an alcoholic that likes to cheat on her husband at gay bars. Lovely stuff.
You know, it does, but it's still rare. Brenda Heist is one example.
Yeah, she had a dream life and then she's being suspended for substance abuse?! What happened there?!
I think she was a closet lesbian and got married from familial pressure.
Great mini doc. Very respectful of this woman, her life and her family. And it made me think about all the souls lost on that day that we don’t talk about. So much tragedy and pain. I’m sorry for her family and I hope her widow was able to move on find happiness again. Wonderful job showing the fullness of this woman’s life. I hope she found peace.
How did the narrator introduce the fact that his cel phone was pinged at 4am from the landlines in their own apartment, when this could ONLY have been done by Sneha, then never address it again??? Did I miss something???
No, this video is a joke!
If the landline called his phone at 4am, a reason for this would be he had lost his phone in the apartment and called it from the landline to locate it. If this is the case, he was awake at 4am and he's hiding something....
Yes this is an interesting case. And all the confusion that took place on that day especially at Ground Zero. Somebody could just disappear or be one of the many remains that have not been identified.
I remember seeing Sneha 's case being profiled on "Unsolved Mysteries" years ago...I've often wondered what happened to her.
*She knew why she was doing lot's of shopping. It seems she had an affair behind her husbands back and after they used her, she was mudered. The arrow always hit the shooter*
I saw her case on unsolved mysteries too years ago I hope she's OK and happy did yu see that post secret card 😮?😳
@@torrijones8434 I remember the post secret card soooo creepy
@YoMike91 yea it was 😳😳😳😳😳😳😖
I’ve lived in Poughkeepsie ny almost my entire life and never heard this story. Thanks for this hometown story.
Wait, I’m confused, the ping came from inside the house? So his phone rang from a call that came from inside the house at 4:30 in the morning and then he woke up two hours later and doesn’t bother to call his wife or try and find out where she is just because she spent the night someplace else, so obviously there were issues going on, but he would think that, a loved one is still trying to find out where you’ve been since I haven’t seen you for the last 24 hours very strange
Seems like he was fed up with her drunk shenanigans and didn't react cuz it was a normal behavior
@@FaithandNova But he went to a lot of trouble to find her.....
Not inside the house but inside his apartment. The same building is all they can say
It was on the landline. In 2001 most people still had a landline and some had a cell phone too but not everybody had one yet. He said he did not hear it.
If she was alive wouldn't she try to contact husband as she must be thinking he must be worried about her disappearance. And in case there was no such incident like 9/11 would she still go missing
Rest in peace to those that passed away. I hope she's okay.
This is crazy to say she was a victim of 9/11.
She went out the day before and didn't turn on the evening of the 10th. I can't believe the family would move on this way.
It is easier for her family to accept this theory. The husband too. For thee narrator to say this without substantial evidence, is strange. It is based on the theory she returned the next morning as purported by the CCTV. Also her humanitarian personality. This is hardly solid enough to base such a conclusion unless a witness testified she stayed with him or her, and retuned the next morning.
I understand the tendency to paint Dr. Philip as a heroic victim; however, her behavior leading up to 09-11 was erratic at best. While her habits of drinking to excess and staying out all night have [understandably] been downplayed by her husband and family, they are extremely problematic and indicative of an individual not happy in their life or marriage. Additionally, according to The Charley Project, she purchased _over $500 worth_ of lingerie, in addition to the dress, shoes, and bed linens. While it's _possible_ the lingerie was intended for use at home, her behavior didn't seem to indicate it was. And to top it off, there's no reason her home computer would have evidence of researching how to start a new life if the plans were being made with and at the residence of the person with whom she was spending those nights away from home. Sorry, not sorry, this woman does not seem the tragic heroine to me.
Same here! It's like the narrator already made up his mind before the video was documented that she is one of the fallen heroes of 9/11.
I think she was a closeted lesbian. Remember the "female friend" she was shopping with? Either way she ran away under a new identity or was killed, maybe by the other lesbian.
My guesses are that she was in the closet and spent the night with someone and they ran away together or she could have been met with foul play at some point in the night or she unalived herself.
Either way there isn't enough evidence to say she was at ground zero. Maybe the husband was just wanting to say that in order to not look into what really could have happened.
Likely a victim
Me, either. She's no hero. She was fired from atleast to hospitals. I say they check her passport, or look for her in another state. She ran from all the crap she created for herself. And the family knows what happened. They just want the money. But sorry, typical they are money grubbing. Not sorry.
I'm sure she was under a ton of stress. She wanted to be an artist yet followed in her father footsteps. My experience with Indian families are that they really push their children to pursue careers the family feels are appropriate regardless of what the child wants. I hope she is living somewhere painting and happy but I'm pretty sure she passed in the world trade centers.
You're on point there. The same thought occurred to me, in that her alcoholism could've been attributed to either job stress or disillusionment on her career choice, or both.
In regard to choice of careers, it's much worse for Indian men than women. In Sneha's case, I reckon she would have probably done it to please her father, and not necessarily because she was forced into it. But then again, you get to see all kinds.
@@satyannair4837 yes. And she was a keralite. Malayalees are most serious about education and Kerala is the most literate state in India.
But she wasn't Muslim, she was Christian, her father allowed her to marry a Jewish man,the father couldn't have been extreamingly religious or strict, I'm sure he did not interfear with her choice of work.
@@thebobbysisters oh okay
@@thebobbysisters so in India there is still a caste system?
Lots of speculation on this one but Occam's Razor says she met up with the wrong person in a bar after shopping and that was it. That bag of shopping items could have been disposed of anywhere, including the killer's trash bin or could have even been used by the killer in his/her own home after the fact. Things like CCTV cameras weren't nearly as prevalent back then as they are today and even if they were, what camera would you possibly start looking at since we don't even know where she was?
excellent sleuthing
If Sneha was at ground zero, where was she on Sept 10th after shopping at Century21? Did she stay out all night and morning alone? Then decide to help during the attacks? It doesn't sound plausible. Why would she have something to do with it? How very rude. The woman was murdered or killed by something sinister. It just doesn't make sense she wouldn't be home with her belongings the night before that fateful day of the 11th.
The NYPD and other detectives have skipped an entire night. She goes shopping and that's it? No phone call to her family or Husband? No check in at her home to feed the cats, spend time with her Husband etc
Was she on the run? Due to her past addictive drug problems and the abuse she endured?
My heart goes out to Ron and the Family of poor Sneha, smeared with a dirty brush 🖌️ and cast aside. How awful. A human being deserves an answer. 🙏🏼💗🕊️ Rest in peace 🕊️ Sneha ❤️😇
Most likely she went to a bar, and went off with someone, which evidently was a very common occurrence for her...and it ended badly for her this time. Her contract had not been renewed due to alcohol abuse and tardiness. She'd been arrested and in jail. Her brother supposedly caught her in bed with his girlfriend. She was suspended from her new job for failure to meet with her substance abuse counselor, which had been a requirement of her being hired. The rules were not for her. I'm not buying that she was some goody-goody who threw herself into the midst of the WTC destruction and died helping...whom?
I don't agree. She was still a doctor at heart and it makes sense that she would be jolted into helping in that way. Her husband was apparently allowed to pass through which means she would have as well. I think she spent the night with some random stranger and that person would probably be too ashamed or scared to ever come forward.
@@hajji1509 Yeah and it took him 6 hours. She didn't have any medical credentials either. She was suspended from her job.
@@TawnyC_ A doctor is still a doctor, and you don't need to be practicing, to be invited during times of emergency. The services of any stay-at-home female doctor would have been appreciated in the midst of 9/11.
That said, I agree with you that she may not have survived the night. If she was alive and helping out at Ground Zero, then how come she didn't call any of her near and dear ones that morning? Wasn't she concerned about Ron?
Of course, her starting a new life is a ridiculous theory!
Edit: I realise there were no mobile phones, or they weren't too prevalent, in 2001. So, she couldn't have called from Ground Zero. Oh well!!!
How come she was honor killed doing what she did.
@@Adriana-vp1rm ???? honour killing? Where was that suggested?
29:30 mark
Is that for real? I'm shocked that you would say how unlikely it was for her to have met with foul play because she, I'll paraphrase "knew better". Absolutely ANYONE can fall victim to foul play at any given time. No matter how street smart they are or how well acquainted they are with those around her (but let's be serious - she knew EVERYONE out that night? I doubt it).
Especially a woman out partying all night with shady whatevers types, yah that was an absurd biased claim on his part, I get what he's saying he's trying to be as respectful and pc as possible, but it's just an outright lie or ignorant no married woman should ever be out alone on the town with fricking shady weird strangers all night, to say they can "handle themselves" let alone based off another sketchy incident is absurd....
this is exactly what I said in my comment and I'm still getting people now saying you shouldn't hang around with the 'wrong people', as if there's some kind of sign they wear on their head or something. we're more likely to be killed by someone we know anyway. we're never safe from harm
Especially bc she said she was groped before hand. Like bad stuff can happen to anyone
A tad ignorant and bias in this video.
No one has any solid proof where she ended up.
It was in the families interest to push the 9/11 theory as they would receive a large payout.
I doubt strongly that was Sneha in the video at the lift.
It's highly unlikely she would forget ALL of her shopping bags....one maybe but not multiple.
The marriage doesn't seem solid either.
Going out at night, not returning and not notifying her husband on more than one occasion is troublesome.
Something untoward could just as likely have happened to her after her shopping spree and before 9/11.
I agree that there's no proof of anything, but the family did not receive a payout. The 9/11 fund was exhausted before Sneha was added to the list of victims. Her family seemed more concerned about protecting her reputation than collecting money. They appear to have been relatively affluent.
I'm sorry she disappeared and I wish her no harm, but one has to admit that she was a bit of a mess..
Trace Evidence did an almost hour long story on this. Very thorough. I recommend it.
The 10th,she disappeared on the 10th,the night prior to 9/11
I am sorry but your conclusion seemed kinda biased as if you already are very much certain that she died helping the victims at ground zero! This is a mere speculation and you said it yourself. Your own statement contradicts this conjecture. Her behavior was extremely shady leading up to her disappearance and she didn't come home on the night of 10th. It's not like everything was a-okay prior to that. She was not happy in her marriage and hardly spent her time at home. Also as far as I know there are records of people who rushed to the aid of 9/11 victims. If she was among them, there would have been some record. I surmise she met with foul play! However unlike you I am not gonna assert that this is exactly what happened. Your conclusion needs to be open to interpretation! It needs to have room for opinion. Also, her friend was supposed to get married later, not on the 11th! Why would she go there then? If she was there to inspect the place, she must have informed her friend before she went. Did she though? I miss your earlier videos which used to be more well-researched and fact-based.
spot on.. i felt the same points you mentioned.. this is a bizarre disappearance.. if she were dead prior to the wtc incident..her body should have been found or reported to nypd, OR if she died helping victims of the wtc attack.. wouldnt somebody see that and record her position that day?.. i am guessing she must have fled with a new identity to.start over.. or unfortunately passed away.
I hope to one day be able to watch this video, but I can’t just yet. It’s been almost 22 years, but talking about September 11 is still so hard. I guess it’s like PTSD, although I feel unworthy to use that term when I think of all the people who lost loved ones that day.
The scenes and feelings from that day have never leftm. In some ways I feel like the US has gone back to normal since 911, in other ways I feel like we will never be back to normal again. I feel like our innocence as a country was stolen.
Anyway, I didn’t mean to make this comment all about myself. I just wanted to talk about it. I tried to watch the video and just couldn’t. To anyone out there who still feels the pain of that awful day, please know you are not alone. God bless.
That's understandable. I lost my brother in a plane crash 30 years ago. To this day I cannot watch the news about crashes and 9/11 was no different.
There is somewhat strange about this story because is she was coming back seeing in the camera footage. Then where was she that night? and why does no one come forward about that she was with someone... I assume if she was somewhere or with someone that the person would come forward and say:"yes she was here" so it is still a mystery where she was and why didnt she contact her husband?
It wouldnt be suprising to me if she commited suicide or indeed walked away from her life. There was a lot going on
Was the window open of the house that wasnt open nefore?. 9/11 could have played a roll, but it would be weird to me. Clearly there was not much she cpuld do about a burning building. She was not stupid. There is no proof that she was killed due the 9/11 attack
That wasn't her in the footage. Simple as that. Either they can definitively say it was 100% her (would you not know a loved one in footage of them?) or it wasn't. The fact it's a "maybe" means it's much more likely not to be her.
That’s a good point about them not honing in on finding out where she was the night before , if they count that as part of her missing timeline that very well changes the possibilities you focus on thereafter and can change it from having everything to having nothing to do with 9/11
I came across her story on Top5s video of 'internet rabbit holes' which went up early during the pandemic and also advertised this channel. Nice to see a new take on it.
I’m sorry for her family’s loss. I think it’s possible she disappeared before the attacks, but in the absence of them she’d either be alive, or the search for her would have been far less complicated. Rest In Peace.
Or saw when they were placing the explosions the day before when she wanted to see the restaurant
@@onewotldgovernmentonlywhen9044I don't think you realize how ridiculous that sounds. Planting explosives in broad daylight in a massive building with tens of thousands of people wandering around all day, so they randomly picked one of the potentially thousands of witnesses to kill? Time to take your meds.
Any chance of her having found a new partner and eloped with him. May be fighting for ISIS in Syria?
@@krish-3225 I'm no fan of many mainstream medical professionals, but fighting for ISIS? Really?! 😵💫
Yeah back then we had the crowd around television sets to see events like this because the smartphone wasn't a thing yet.
This case is so sad was there any responders that remember her being there to help? I hope her family gets answers
In actuality, if she was that close, the others are probably dead also.
I hope their cats survived inhaling all that soot
Nope sorry
i don’t much care for cats
@@timmyshore3755ashole
Also, don’t forget the brother had lied in an interview saying that she had spoken with him that she was going to run into the building to help the injured. And she was captured on camera with another woman and employee saw her with another female there too, why did that person never come forward and say hey she was with me either. She was also victim or she’s the perpetrator.
I've always been fascinated with this case, recent podcast dedicated to Sneha revealed even more... It bothers me the bad rep I think Sneha unfairly got, and the fact that all her friends seemed convinced that she ran away to start a new life always seemed so odd to me... My theory is she wandered into the ground zero area from a mix of morbid fascination and a willingness to help...
She wouldn't be able to do anything at ground zero. It's way more likely something nefarious happened or she ran off. There is nothing to connect to her to ground zero other than assumption
Same, absolutely fascinating since nothing quite makes sense. I lean more toward her getting killed on Sept 10th evening. Reason: not a soul saw her on Sept 11th morning nor were her bags ever found. If she was, in fact, at the Towers that means she would have spent the night somewhere but no evidence of that exists.
@Angela who would kill her tho? Even her friends think she just ran away and started a new life
@@billblaski9523 - people get abducted and murdered all the time. Could have been a stranger. Could have been a shifty cab driver. Could have been someone she knew and had an argument with. Who knows? Crazy stuff happens in this city every day.
Hi! Yes, I’ve been following Sneha’s case for years, it’s very perplexing. Which podcast are you referring to? I’d like to check it out too!
it's crazy to think there might be someone watching your vidoe right now that could 1 day be on your video as a missing person.
That's extremely frightening to me. Anyone could go missing for a number of reasons.
signs point to you unfortunately
Are you still around? Or have you now gone missing?
Well done CCD team... RIP Sneha
Heroic? I have never believed there was enough evidence to support that the 9/11 attacks were more than a coincidence when it comes to Sneha’s disappearance. Considering the other aspects of her lifestyle, it seems more plausible that something happened to her the evening before the tragedy.
Thank you so much for re uploading this I was so worried that I had missed it 🙏
Its been years..
She either died at the site of the fallen buildings..
Or was murdered...
My gut feeling says she's not alive .
She was murdered.
From what I've seen here and the segment on Unsolved Mysteries, there's really no hard evidence let alone proof that Sneha was even in the area on the night of the 10th or the morning of the 11th. Plus, if she went shopping before (supposedly) going out for the night then where did she sleep? Where's the stuff she bought? The CCTV of a woman (that can't even be positively identified) at the apartment doesn't really hold water for me since she should have had those shopping bags with her if they were indeed for the house and herself. Especially the linens. Also, on the UM segment it states that the store clerk recognized Sneha as a regular customer and saw her with another Indian woman. She asked Sneha if the woman was a sister, and Sneha told her the woman was just a friend. So when Ron went back and re-examined the store footage (which they show you in the segment), it did appear as though there was a lady standing near her at the exit in such a way that it could appear as though they were spending time together, but admittedly that's still debatable. So if the clerk knew Sneha I don't think she was mistaken on who she spoke to, which begs the question: Was the clerk lying about the conversation, was Sneha lying about her connection to this unknown woman, or was there some other misunderstanding/miscommunication at play here? Personally, I think it's feasible that she did her shopping, came to meet foul play sometime that night and was possibly kidnapped and brought elsewhere. It would explain no body or her belongings from the day she disappeared being found anywhere in NY at the time, and why no one she knew heard from her or saw her after the shopping trip.
I think she ran away with her lover and her husband is just opportunistic. Do you really think Sneha would have told a casual acquaintance that the woman was her lover? No, one would say "friend". She had a history of not coming home and for going to gay bars.
Great analysis!
There doesn't seem to have been effort to locate the "friend" and get their account of what happened.
Thank you for the time and effort you put into finding visual clips that fit (to the best you can) the visual and not so visual identities of the people in the stories. I appreciate and celebrate your attention to this social justice matter
Literally the worst day in the history of NYC to have something horrible happen to you that was UNRELATED to 9/11
Whether or not she died the day before 9 eleven or the day of no one will probably ever know. I feel truly sad for her husband and family. My condolences 🌹
I don't think she was killed in 911, what is presented in this video leads me to believe she met with something foul the night she didn't come home. Poor woman...
So sad I wonder where she is? It's like the woman who has just gone missing in the U.K Nichola bully who seemingly just vanished into thin air
Nah She was kidnapped yet cops like usual are morons and only want to see one picture. No proof she ever fell into the river yet that's all they want to say. It's embarrassing
So so many people do seem to vanish. So many more than most people know about. I have a good friend that’s been missing since may of 2016. Her car, her and all her personal items. Just poof gone. No news broadcast just a “news release” on day 8 and then nothing. No follow ups no police interviews just she’s gone
nicola likely drowned in the river and was dragged out to sea or dragged under the water who knows as of now
@@TheConorsmithusa No she wasn't. This is the most obvious case of foul play I've ever heard.
@@TheConorsmithusaNo way did she drown. Why would she have gone into the water? Her dog Willow wasn’t wet for a start. Definitely foul play.
There are numerous missing pieces in this story, and even the denouement is disturbingly hypothetical. Clearly, this was a young woman of privilege and promise living a dissolute, worldly lifestyle in one of the country's most worldly and dissolute cities. It's generous to imagine that she died the death of a hero in the midst of one of the most cowardly man-made catastrophes of modern times. Maybe so, but in all likelihood we will never know. I hope she won the battle in the end, but I'm more cynical than the author of this piece. Clearly this lady was in freefall headed for nothing good.
I agree. They're trying to minimalize her sketchy lifestyle.
Priviledge. She's not white, but her husband is Juu wish so maybe she had that priviledge.
Another great video!
I'm glad at least some of the comments are calling you out for glossing over her alcohol and substance issues and trying to make her seem like a hero. I get the family has financial and other gains from doing it, I don't get why a youtuber needs to do that.
Maybe the UA-camr is related??
Great show friends thanks for the DL cheers 🥂...
Was CCD paid by Rob to write this story? In the "theories" section there was no mention of Rob as a suspect.
His wife lost 2 contracts, was an alcoholic, out partying a lot, potentially having affairs, no job but spending money on new clothes and shoes (3 pairs on the same trip!) using his credit card. Id say he was embarrassed with her behaviour and pissed off at her spending.
Its not a stretch to theorise that they fought after she got home or they might have met up somewhere. He could have planned it and drugged her or maybe he stran.gled her while fighting.
Was asking myself how come he was never a suspect
Exactly what I was about to comment.
Well said. I was thinking exactly the same thing. Because something about this whole scenario just doesn't add up..
maybe because of his behavior after? He has been pursuing it ever since then and not able to move on. Although I think he has finally re-married, he was doing a lot and going everywhere, hiring detectives, following all leads to find her. He could have just stayed silent and let the WTC issue do the speaking, but he didn't. His behavior doesn't exactly come off like a suspect to me. He might have been p whipped, but I don't think he murdered her.
And why is she an alcoholic? What’s the reason behind that? And spending nights away from home? Was life spiralling out of control and becoming unbearable and was she ashamed of her situation that it made her want to end her life? Also, sorry, but such risky behaviour can attract danger.
It's also so weird that she did'nt even call her husband or leave a message in her voice mail at home so when he gets home, just what he did..
He call home right away because the first thing he thought about was her, his wife, why would'nt que do the same? I feel she was kidnaped on the 10th & they used the WTC as a perfect cover for her kidnapping and death after the fact...That's my opinión!!!!! It's just to simple to just say de cant find her, so put her down as a victim of the WTC
Saying that she couldn't have been murdered because she was used to staying out late and partying with strangers is weird logic. It takes only one bad guy in one particular place at one particular time to commit a murder, without any reference at all to anything that may have happened before until that particular point in time. That is the nature of happenstance and caprice. ps: at 9:33 it clearly says the husband's cellphone was pinged at 4 am from a phone line INSIDE the apartment, and that Sneha was the only other person with access to the apartment. That would mean she was inside the apartment at that time to have made that missed call. So surely there is CCTV footage of her having entered the apartment building and leaving it at that time? What was the followup on that? But then again, if she was inside the apartment, why would she give her sleeping hubby a missed call?
The dark side of medicine: 5 doctors who became serial killers.
She was from my State Kerala. Never heard of this case until now.
I watch Kerala on Guddha Singh vlogs when he travelled there.
Reading through these comments... the arrogance a d "holier than thou" attitude on display is disgusting.
What do u mean?
If she ever went back to her flat, she would have brought back all the clothes she bought. There’s no mention here of her shopping goods which tells me she never made it back home on September 10 or the morning of September 11. Something happened to her between the shopping center and home.
I think she met with foul play on the night of the 10th overnight into the 11th. She was likely dead by the terrorist attacks.
I live in Somerset County where the plane came down. I was in 11th grade when it all happened. I can remember all the fear, chaos and just the unknown that filled the school when parents came flooding in to get their children. We visit the memorial where the plane came down often. It's ironic. It's such a beautiful area to be the place of such a horrible event.
May you Rest In Perfect Peace to all who passed in all the horrendous tragedies of that day.
💔🙏🏾
There was no plane
Never heard of this case, thank you kindly for this video.
One cant rule out foul play completely in this case. But what I find truly poignant and intriguing is the change in Sneha from a bright and promising girl to an alcoholic. I feel that she was not happy in her career. Maybe she realised that she wud have been happier as an artist.
@@thebobbysisters ???? What society?? I see gey people EVERYWHERE , being totally open. It's not 1923. Turn the page.
People always are happier doing what they are talented withy than what with forced to study in college.
Then why didn't she simply change careers ? If her parent did not approve, would being an alcoholic change their minds ? why jeopardise her marriage? I am leaning towards mental illness.
@@xxxxxxxxx3944 It's not easy for those families like it is for white people.
She spent the night out, away from the marital bed, then she did the "walk of shame" to ground zero. Ridiculous. She met foul play then she floated down the East River, lost in the chaos of the 911 (amateur pilots fake news "terrorist" attacks)
I personally believe there is an element of mental illness in Sneha's case, however l do not believe she voluntarily disappeared, i think there was foul-play involved
Either the parents or the husband are involved
Something just doesn’t seem right with this story
I think she was Bi Polar -
I also feel something else was involved. Nothing to do with the attack on the towers . Where was she all night the night previously on the 10th . Nothing makes sense
She could of come back home and husband did something to her how do we know she didn’t come back home cause he said so
Husband most likely involved. But if that’s true he will receive his KARMA in this life.
I don't believe she went to the TT that day. Where did she spend the night? No one has come forward to say she was with them? It's not likely she left her shopping items at a strangers house. The odds of her being at the restaurant at the top of the TT would be astronomical. She was either killed after meeting someone at one of those clubs or she walked away. The problem with that is if she is ever arrested her fingerprints will ID her. It is a shame no matter what happened. Where was her husband (it's usually always the spouse). He could not have been okay with is wife spending the night at someone else's house all night. No way, not believing that statement.
This video IS bizarre!! The characters in the video keep changing - mostly they have used footage and shots from movies with Indian actors, many are Bollywood movies - one never knows from scene to scene who they are going to show. And amazingly sometimes Sneha is portrayed as an African American woman and sometimes as an Asian (Korean? Thai? Japanese?) Weird!!
I remember this story. I believe her husband needs to be investigated all over. I believe she was murdered by him or someone else but he knows more than anybody knows!!!!
maybe her family grew to be ashamed of her. possible "honor killing"
Exactly why women make poor detectives. Everything is based on emotion and "beliefs" 🤣🤣🤣. never facts or logic.
Her husband didnt do anything Karen.
@@meghanmisaliar what's so funny that you are rolling on the floor? Lol
@@b294-r7q this woman was a Hindu not Muslim so the honor killing theory doesn't fit