Making music without hearing it

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 7 тис.

  • @EthalaRide
    @EthalaRide 5 років тому +4472

    Roomie's sounds like a videogame level but with your character in the "one more hit and you're dead" warning mode.

  • @harper2202
    @harper2202 5 років тому +6525

    And here we see the four genres, Rock, Dubstep, Hiphop and Roomie

    • @floodingafvucker1056
      @floodingafvucker1056 5 років тому +51

      CoreyGames LMAO

    • @totori_8008
      @totori_8008 5 років тому +18

      XD

    • @thesmiteguy7619
      @thesmiteguy7619 5 років тому +264

      Hate to be that guy but...
      *iTs NoT rOcK iTs MeTaL!!!1*

    • @thesmiteguy7619
      @thesmiteguy7619 5 років тому +35

      @Wasabi Yeah but that's like saying country is a subgenre of music. Anyways, I still hate being this guy.

    • @230leo8
      @230leo8 5 років тому +39

      roomie was like videogame music kinda stuff.

  • @dirtymonk748
    @dirtymonk748 5 років тому +6281

    I watched this video without listening.
    Beat that

    • @rixfx_
      @rixfx_ 5 років тому +367

      I read your comment without looking at it.
      Beat that

    • @timelordguardian7073
      @timelordguardian7073 5 років тому +227

      Gamerix / Rix i liked your comment without being logged in
      Beat *That*

    • @tem4778
      @tem4778 5 років тому +218

      @@timelordguardian7073 I opened UA-cam without a device
      BEAT THAT

    • @timelordguardian7073
      @timelordguardian7073 5 років тому +98

      babywolfrl I REPLIED TO THIS COMMENT WITHOUT EVEN LOOKING AT WHAT YOU SAID!
      BEAT THAT

    • @Sosorryheheheh
      @Sosorryheheheh 5 років тому +139

      I replied without existing in any timeline ever, without having any body parts, being blind, deaf, mute, disabled in every way possible, and I didn’t read what u wrote, nor did I ever learn to read or write and still don’t know how to, finally, i SuBcRiBeD tO pEwDiEpIe.
      *B̳E̳A̳T̳ ̳T̳H̳A̳T̳*

  • @millerblaylock
    @millerblaylock 5 років тому +2935

    "Hi, I'm Dave from boyinaband!"
    Dave's fans: guys this seems a bit suspicious

  • @Fenrasulfr
    @Fenrasulfr 6 років тому +2376

    Makes you respect Beethoven.

    • @stantalentstanonewe5784
      @stantalentstanonewe5784 5 років тому +52

      BEAThoven cuz his BEATs are sick af

    • @creepyscrawly113
      @creepyscrawly113 5 років тому +35

      Yeah he was able to train himself to tell what the notes were from their vibrations before he went completly deaf.

    • @Jayden3649
      @Jayden3649 5 років тому +2

      @@Jaden0 Supa Hot FireOOHH OHHH OHHHH

    • @thatblondeVA
      @thatblondeVA 5 років тому

      What a legend. Glad yo wrote this in his honor 👍

    • @legeogame1611
      @legeogame1611 5 років тому +4

      What if Beethoven made dubstep?

  • @clontbandicoot4201
    @clontbandicoot4201 5 років тому +792

    I love how each of their laptops perfectly represent who they are

  • @seymonsolomon9545
    @seymonsolomon9545 7 років тому +248

    "I'm just getting my headphones to finish my album."
    What a G

  • @PinkPixelProductions
    @PinkPixelProductions 5 років тому +300

    Everyone: *Making different sounds and knowing what to do in the editor*
    Dave: I have no idea what to put or do

  • @bruh-sf4gw
    @bruh-sf4gw 5 років тому +14446

    beethoven did it without complaining. come on guys

    • @chalkieslunchmoney6885
      @chalkieslunchmoney6885 5 років тому +74

      louis hesketh lmao

    • @IkaSchmika
      @IkaSchmika 5 років тому +396

      "Beathoven"
      *YEAH AIGHT*

    • @sdiaz1681
      @sdiaz1681 5 років тому +117

      @@IkaSchmika y'know like the Beatles

    • @tracyleung8438
      @tracyleung8438 5 років тому +176

      Its baetoven. Get it right.

    • @bruh-sf4gw
      @bruh-sf4gw 5 років тому +38

      @@sdiaz1681 don't know what you're on about.

  • @animebest832
    @animebest832 5 років тому +561

    Laptops:
    Macbook pro 2015
    Macbook pro 2013
    Macbook pro 2017
    48 hour gamer

  • @DyadintheForce
    @DyadintheForce 6 років тому +1334

    puts into perspective how amazing the deaf composers were. Usually I'd imagine they would acquaint themselves with a sound's vibration.

    • @fcgod9157
      @fcgod9157 6 років тому +1

      he blind not deaf tho (atleast last time I checked)

    • @jimdanielhoxworth3374
      @jimdanielhoxworth3374 6 років тому +25

      FcGod "He"?

    • @adambechtel2053
      @adambechtel2053 6 років тому +80

      deaf composers also have longer than an hour to write their songs and probably know a little bit more about music theory
      not discrediting deaf composers though. complete props to them.

    • @patio6
      @patio6 6 років тому +1

      Well put. Understanding that it is all vibration changes everything.

    • @tahutoa
      @tahutoa 6 років тому +20

      Beethoven would put a metal nail file in his mouth, and memorize the vibrations for each note. Since he could remember what those notes sounded like, he was able to write music fairly efficiently.

  • @JackieTheCatfox
    @JackieTheCatfox 4 роки тому +515

    Rob: Macbook
    Roomie: Macbook
    Andrew: Macbook
    Dave: BEAST OF A GAMING LAPTOP OMFG

    • @sergiosolomon2250
      @sergiosolomon2250 2 роки тому +1

      laptop*

    • @JackieTheCatfox
      @JackieTheCatfox 2 роки тому +2

      @@sergiosolomon2250 A laptop that (likely) doesn't run Mac OS. So still a PC.

    • @sergiosolomon2250
      @sergiosolomon2250 2 роки тому

      @@JackieTheCatfox a laptop is not refered to as a pc but if u were to a mac os is just as much as a pc as a asus laptop genuis

    • @JackieTheCatfox
      @JackieTheCatfox 2 роки тому +2

      @@sergiosolomon2250 There, edited the comment, you happy now?

    • @sergiosolomon2250
      @sergiosolomon2250 2 роки тому

      @@JackieTheCatfox yes

  • @inflict5192
    @inflict5192 5 років тому +4466

    I like how everyone has a macbook and then boyinaband has a gaming (edit: laptop)

    • @mattbowers4154
      @mattbowers4154 5 років тому +13

      Lol 😂

    • @ilikeboms6233
      @ilikeboms6233 5 років тому +5

      Lol

    • @inflict5192
      @inflict5192 5 років тому +162

      @Space Lettuce 232 sry bout it man, its just what I saw on the screen and you probably saw the same thing. Maybe that's why my comment is similar 😇

    • @aro7966
      @aro7966 5 років тому +1

      not a pc and maybe not a for gaming but yeah that's pretty weird

    • @ay-leck1369
      @ay-leck1369 5 років тому +3

      *gaming laptop

  • @Supernaturlisch
    @Supernaturlisch 7 років тому +1877

    This was absolutely hilarious. I love how you are so dedicated to your art, while at the same time having a blast making fun of yourselves (and each other)!

  • @josearaujo9698
    @josearaujo9698 7 років тому +401

    "To make the challenge more interesting we've got three successful youtube musicians and roomie here" LOL

    • @sillymonk3y
      @sillymonk3y 7 років тому +12

      Morbtsh FUNNY CAUSE HE HAS MORE SUBS THAN ALL OF EM

    • @rusnexx
      @rusnexx 5 років тому +5

      Do you mean rami?

  • @ag2023en
    @ag2023en 5 років тому +253

    "To make things more interesting, we've got THREE successful youtube musicians...and Roomie here."
    Dude, that's evil!

    • @SreenikethanI
      @SreenikethanI 4 роки тому +11

      _when did stating facts become evil_

    • @ag2023en
      @ag2023en 4 роки тому +7

      @@SreenikethanI wow, edgy

    • @killme2675
      @killme2675 4 роки тому +1

      Forbidden roast.

  • @ИльяВитцев
    @ИльяВитцев 5 років тому +3529

    0:10 To make it more interesting, we've brought three successful musicians and Roomie here
    *everybody dies*

    • @skysatlas
      @skysatlas 5 років тому +47

      *WHEEZE*

    • @sophievr8750
      @sophievr8750 5 років тому +19

      UA-cam musicians*

    • @falcon5178
      @falcon5178 5 років тому +28

      noone cares abot you're gramer corecction

    • @caigin
      @caigin 5 років тому +13

      @@falcon5178i am agreed my friend

    • @m4n4h1l
      @m4n4h1l 5 років тому +38

      *roomie dies inside*

  • @robott5177
    @robott5177 7 років тому +86

    A cool way to continue this would be to have everyone redo this while able to listen to it so we can hear what everyone heard in their heads for this idea, and the contrast between the two examples... idk just an idea

  • @Randaalcz
    @Randaalcz 5 років тому +768

    I was kinda hoping for someone to screw up pretty badly....they all ended up with a better track than mine when I hear it

  • @AlbinoYoYo
    @AlbinoYoYo 5 років тому +911

    4:34, they all have mac books and then there is Dave with that extra thicc laptop

    • @warpbeats3577
      @warpbeats3577 5 років тому +9

      AlbinoYoYo THICC

    • @SlytherinTina777
      @SlytherinTina777 5 років тому +25

      Looks like a laptop for gaming...

    • @Platinum_XYZ
      @Platinum_XYZ 5 років тому +52

      The only good Laptop

    • @hatakearashi5637
      @hatakearashi5637 5 років тому +3

      but its an rog brooooo

    • @sparkkoo0
      @sparkkoo0 5 років тому +22

      you know dave is the king when he has that beast fucking laptop

  • @Leviathan431
    @Leviathan431 7 років тому +550

    I love that they're all sitting there with their little Apple laptops, and Dave just has this MASSIVE Asus gaming laptop with no cares given

    • @tako.23
      @tako.23 6 років тому

      Yep

    • @jjws600
      @jjws600 6 років тому +3

      The smart one :P

    • @realkilju
      @realkilju 6 років тому +9

      Leviathan431 the gaming laptop is much much better than those over priced apple ones

    • @ethanbilby9173
      @ethanbilby9173 6 років тому +6

      Dave is smart. Be like Dave. Buy a windows pc, not a mac.

  • @andrewpappas9311
    @andrewpappas9311 7 років тому +3392

    This was awesome, I especially loved the random synth line from Andrew

    • @Szukk
      @Szukk 7 років тому +1

      Andrew Pappas 666th like

    • @andrewpappas9311
      @andrewpappas9311 7 років тому +5

      Holy balls I didn't expect this to get so many likes to be honest, thanks

    • @juanantonioanderson349
      @juanantonioanderson349 6 років тому +1

      To me it's very Mystery Skulls. Just me?

    • @Patchess
      @Patchess 6 років тому +2

      *Nice beat*
      7 seconds later: BEEEEWEEEEEE

    • @youtubebackup3184
      @youtubebackup3184 6 років тому +7

      IVE GOT A SYNTH! GUYS IVE GOT A SYNTH

  • @raven-yt3iv
    @raven-yt3iv 7 років тому +167

    It's amazing that they can make music without hearing it and I can't even make music when I can hear the results..

    • @blitxaac
      @blitxaac 7 років тому +14

      Raven Tular I suggest you check out Beethoven xD

  • @themandownstairs4765
    @themandownstairs4765 5 років тому +400

    8:22 *"HEY, I'VE GOT A SYNTH! I'VE GOT A SYNTH GUYS!"*
    dead

    • @AbsoluteAbsurd
      @AbsoluteAbsurd 4 роки тому

      lol

    • @eva-2267
      @eva-2267 4 роки тому +2

      Such a mood ngl

    • @AdelaTomankova
      @AdelaTomankova 4 роки тому +1

      That's me especially on social media even though it's just a volca keys played via midi keyboard and I can't even play anything

    • @ireadysucks3026
      @ireadysucks3026 4 роки тому +1

      HE HAS A SYNTH! WATCH OUT, HE HAS A SYNTH. THIS IS NOT A DRILL.

    • @ashlinahan
      @ashlinahan 4 роки тому +1

      I rewatched that bit a dozen times. It had me crying.

  • @lemonfuryrz9729
    @lemonfuryrz9729 7 років тому +1893

    i love that everyone used a slim macbook, but dave has his own bulky giant gaming laptop😂

    • @atom3642
      @atom3642 7 років тому +92

      LemonFuryRZ he's gonna need that for when he plays Roblox 😂

    • @scottbruckner4653
      @scottbruckner4653 7 років тому +11

      #AlienWareForTheWin

    • @Elyygee
      @Elyygee 7 років тому +4

      O respect that

    • @Harolds0
      @Harolds0 7 років тому +28

      yeah, i don't know about the portability, but it sure renders videos really fast

    • @petraschruers611
      @petraschruers611 7 років тому +1

      Scott Bruckner asus

  • @tempest-carabello-baum
    @tempest-carabello-baum 7 років тому +196

    No joke whatsoever, it took me about three or four times of watching the intro to realise that something was off about Andrew saying "Hi, I'm Dave from Boyinaband"

    • @harizwain4969
      @harizwain4969 7 років тому +3

      Jackson Baum ... i didn't eve noticed...

    • @worm8837
      @worm8837 7 років тому +2

      Jackson Baum omg wth I didn't even realise wow

    • @HRRN-gh3wj
      @HRRN-gh3wj 7 років тому +1

      Hariz CIY haha same

    • @taihaileizoe
      @taihaileizoe 7 років тому +1

      wait wHAT-

    • @jonathanvazquez2534
      @jonathanvazquez2534 7 років тому +1

      Wait.....hold on......wait......how did I not notice this

  • @potato_salad9346
    @potato_salad9346 7 років тому +234

    Roomie accidentally created the rival to Tunak Tunak Tun

  • @leor6827
    @leor6827 5 років тому +1609

    5:40
    *Something funny happens that we non-musical mortals may never understand*
    David: *laughs in music*

    • @otterstream1263
      @otterstream1263 5 років тому +62

      Leo R honestly wtf where they laughing at.

    • @m4n4h1l
      @m4n4h1l 5 років тому +34

      Ikr I don’t get it 😂

    • @Varadium_
      @Varadium_ 5 років тому +156

      There's this really weird, but super faint sound effect that gets played a couple times in the background at that part. It's tricky to pick out and honestly I don't know how to describe it, you just got to listen to it and see if you can hear it.

    • @lucaslucas191202
      @lucaslucas191202 5 років тому +60

      It's just when they realize how weird it actually sounds with that faint sound effect. I found it funny at least

    • @renierpupo9669
      @renierpupo9669 5 років тому +112

      @leo R Dave is laughing at the fact that when he was trying to design the sound for the dubstep growl, instead of making it bass heavy and over distorted it ended up sounding like a fly was zooming by lol

  • @Jubawub
    @Jubawub 7 років тому +55

    3 Macbooks, one REAL laptop.

  • @up_374
    @up_374 7 років тому +138

    I love how everyone else has a macbook type thing, and then Dave just has this MASSIVE ASUS LAPTOP

    • @davidbrown5632
      @davidbrown5632 7 років тому

      Waffles _ ikr the others' look like Babies compared to his 😂

    • @bloodredrage3894
      @bloodredrage3894 7 років тому

      I have the same laptop and I know from experience that it is not only big, it's super hot as well.

  • @liamimweix9983
    @liamimweix9983 5 років тому +2564

    Roomie's sounded like a geometry dash song

    • @zicoezmiro2951
      @zicoezmiro2951 5 років тому +10

      MDK WATERFLAME OR 7FFF TO BE PRECISE

    • @larawabsie
      @larawabsie 5 років тому +82

      I think Dave’s sounded more like a geometry dash song xD maybe extra hard level

    • @sherbet3310
      @sherbet3310 5 років тому +5

      Liamimweix more like a tuber simulator song

    • @evertones4664
      @evertones4664 5 років тому +9

      @@zicoezmiro2951 f777*
      also im pretty sure u just named all the artist u named. It sounds nothing like waterflame and only the bass like f777.

    • @evertones4664
      @evertones4664 5 років тому +1

      @@zicoezmiro2951 alright but there are more

  • @eddie_0584
    @eddie_0584 5 років тому +861

    Everyone: This is harder than I was thinking
    Beethoven: First time?

    • @sophiaredwood5825
      @sophiaredwood5825 5 років тому +5

      Hault Jeverson spot on 😂

    • @hollieisonyt4459
      @hollieisonyt4459 5 років тому +2

      Beathoven

    • @BoxyPlains92587
      @BoxyPlains92587 4 роки тому +2

      @Ho Zoe 5C06 何心言 you would be luckier if you had the 69th like

    • @Argenteux
      @Argenteux 4 роки тому

      He was only deaf on one ear

    • @pepsimanv7883
      @pepsimanv7883 3 роки тому

      @@Argenteux Googled it and it said that Beethoven still had hearing on his left ear so I guess that's true

  • @OrangeC7
    @OrangeC7 7 років тому +66

    The funny thing is that each person thought their own piece was terrible while everyone else thought it was good

    • @benjwgarner
      @benjwgarner 7 років тому +18

      Probably because they knew what it was "supposed to" sound like (how they had imagined it) and it didn't sound like that.

  • @glitched2797
    @glitched2797 7 років тому +162

    I think roomie accidentally started questioning his self worth 😂

  • @MoonshineSazerac
    @MoonshineSazerac 7 років тому +107

    Epic. Roomie managed to write a song for a Sonic game.

  • @gladitsnotme
    @gladitsnotme 4 роки тому +45

    6:16 is the official song of 2020. Starts off upbeat and feeling good, then quickly dissolves into chaos with everything going wrong.

  • @kFY514
    @kFY514 7 років тому +110

    Notice how most of the lulz they have when listening to Andrew's, Dave's and Roomie's tracks come from the timbre of the sounds chosen. That's exactly why Rob's track sounds so amazing - everyone else was busy picking samples and tweaking synth settings on their DAWs, and the effects are hilarious. Rob just fired up Guitar Pro, picked generic metal presets for all the tracks and just focused on writing the tabs. He was essentially just composing, while everyone else was also producing. It's a big difference.
    That's not meant to disrespect Rob's composition skills, which are obviously insane. In fact, all four of you did a great job for what it was. But I think it's worth noting why Rob is so different to everyone else.

    • @mussman717word
      @mussman717word 7 років тому +3

      kFY In other words, the one professional-sounding effort came from the one actual composer of the group. Who'd have thought?

  • @ArnovanZelst
    @ArnovanZelst 7 років тому +142

    That synth line solo won't stop cracking me up

  • @Jazeitonas
    @Jazeitonas 7 років тому +220

    These guys make better musing in 1h without hearing it than me trying the whole week

  • @Salysis
    @Salysis 5 років тому +111

    I'm sampling "I've got a synth GUYS"

  • @cdjwmusic
    @cdjwmusic 7 років тому +61

    "to make the challenge more interesting we've got 3 successful youtube musicians and roomie here" *SAVAGE*

  • @frogbug8478
    @frogbug8478 7 років тому +1997

    I love how the title is all calm but the thumb nail is *WHAT IN THE WHAT OH MY JESUS*

  • @3nv-
    @3nv- 7 років тому +43

    "so to make things more interesting we have three talented UA-cam musicians and roomie here"

  • @zeldagorl
    @zeldagorl 2 роки тому +28

    Andrew: "Hi, I'm Dave from Boyinaband"
    Viewers: 👀

  • @lawrence2992
    @lawrence2992 5 років тому +489

    The second one was literally a dance dance revolution song

    • @jimbo2091
      @jimbo2091 5 років тому +3

      Really… i feel like im about to get r/wooosh:ed

    • @abandonedaccount1231
      @abandonedaccount1231 5 років тому +7

      @@jimbo2091 nah, his statement's pretty accurate

    • @kristyn9977
      @kristyn9977 5 років тому +13

      @@jimbo2091 R/wOoOSh

  • @flochristim9316
    @flochristim9316 7 років тому +199

    May I say that Roomies Track could actually be a rough version of a Pokémon Road theme?
    Also I think you guys all did a great job!

    • @l3oogle
      @l3oogle 7 років тому

      Gives me Megaman vibes.

    • @rlydontwannabehere1613
      @rlydontwannabehere1613 7 років тому +5

      TimFlo Chris It sounds like it could be in a pokemon mystery dungeon game.

    • @panzerjagertigerpelefant
      @panzerjagertigerpelefant 7 років тому

      TimFlo Chris it would be cool if it were used in watch dogs 2

  • @finn8478
    @finn8478 6 років тому +294

    dave's one sounds like a geometry dash level.

  • @guch6309
    @guch6309 5 років тому +86

    *dave laughing gives me a reason to live, i swear to god.*

  • @piersonlawrence3467
    @piersonlawrence3467 6 років тому +596

    "Just a band of really cool guys and just this one dude thats like "* HEY GUYS I GOT A SYNTH HE- HEY I GOT A SYNTH!*""

    • @piersonlawrence3467
      @piersonlawrence3467 6 років тому +12

      8:19

    • @akrobeau
      @akrobeau 6 років тому +10

      ωσω уσυ'яє ѕσ ѕмαят ¢αυѕє уσυ'яє α мυѕι¢ιαи

    • @theshrimplorde3969
      @theshrimplorde3969 6 років тому

      @@akrobeau dude don`t bully him on a different comment too

    • @nafinapkin5439
      @nafinapkin5439 6 років тому +1

      Wow! Its like we watched the same video!

    • @prodpoob
      @prodpoob 5 років тому

      lol

  • @idkhowtoplay7747
    @idkhowtoplay7747 7 років тому +448

    Apple, Apple, Apple, and Dave's laptop is probably bigger than all 3 apples on top of each other.

    • @fivepercentfornothing
      @fivepercentfornothing 7 років тому +16

      I thought that I was the only one that noticed that.

    • @dimitri2216
      @dimitri2216 7 років тому +4

      You mercy main.

    • @DwarvenHydra
      @DwarvenHydra 7 років тому +1

      You beat me to it, lol.

    • @jonoc5
      @jonoc5 7 років тому +5

      Wilson B oh go away. People can use what they want.

    • @Jayden3649
      @Jayden3649 5 років тому +3

      @@jonoc5 APPLE FAN BOY stop wasting cash and get a better pc for the same price

  • @rosethebaka
    @rosethebaka 5 років тому +154

    idky but i feel like the music they produced sounds like _this is what goes on in my head_ type of thingy

    • @wokeupnew
      @wokeupnew 5 років тому +7

      That would make dave’s brain sound like it was on some dodgy drugs

    • @hollieisonyt4459
      @hollieisonyt4459 5 років тому

      Rose Dah PoTehToeh same

  • @slydesigns9691
    @slydesigns9691 5 років тому +67

    Loving how everyone else has Macbooks, while David over here has a god damn Asus gaming laptop.

  • @_snippy
    @_snippy 7 років тому +86

    I love how everyone's sat there with their macbooks then there's fucking Dave, dave with the ASUS ROG gaming laptop that's probably thicker than them 3 laptops combined

  • @christopher7148
    @christopher7148 7 років тому +430

    Left to right mac, mac mac, asus gaming beast.

    • @ifazahmer159
      @ifazahmer159 7 років тому +5

      Fush 2013's gaming beast

    • @passingby642
      @passingby642 7 років тому +10

      +Ifaz Ahmer i don't mind that
      still way better than my stupid computer

  • @welsan2074
    @welsan2074 6 років тому +180

    The laptop arrangment by them :
    Mac,mac,mac,an asus ROG

  • @TheScottGillies
    @TheScottGillies 4 роки тому +18

    Roomie's is my favorite. It makes me think of 90's video-games. I feel like it's an underwater level.

  • @habelebubele
    @habelebubele 7 років тому +168

    i love that everyone is sitting here with their cute mac books and then there's Dave, with the fattest laptop on earth xD

    • @zerologic7912
      @zerologic7912 7 років тому +3

      habelebubele you should see acer's $9000 predator 21x LOL

  • @Cuarentaydos
    @Cuarentaydos 7 років тому +624

    Better than anything I'll ever do.

    • @thatsme2044
      @thatsme2044 7 років тому +7

      Cuarentaydos thank Work on it

    • @krystofpavlis4407
      @krystofpavlis4407 7 років тому +12

      Not with that attitude

    • @threenplustwo9105
      @threenplustwo9105 7 років тому +6

      You can at least do better than Roomie.

    • @lowstaar
      @lowstaar 7 років тому

      Second and the third song sounds just like the stuff I did when i started lol

    • @Cuarentaydos
      @Cuarentaydos 6 років тому

      Oh, hello.

  • @Crit-Chance
    @Crit-Chance 7 років тому +104

    6:11 You guys are full of it, that was sick. It sounded just like Sega Genesis BGM in like a later level with ALIENS.

    • @janisteri6398
      @janisteri6398 7 років тому +5

      Completely agree with you man!

    • @lyberoASMR
      @lyberoASMR 6 років тому +3

      Same, I actually liked it a lot. Sounds like something that would be found in a 16 bit game.

    • @halokitten5569
      @halokitten5569 6 років тому

      It was just the fact that it was chill and then BAM it didn’t easy into it I mean still sounds good just need to have it eased in and it would sound awesome

  • @saima024
    @saima024 5 років тому +645

    I keep laughing at whenever Roomie’s song plays because compared to everyone else his sounds so childish 😂😂

    • @Platinum_XYZ
      @Platinum_XYZ 5 років тому +3

      Timestamp?

    • @saima024
      @saima024 5 років тому +19

      Platinum XYZ 09:36 is Roomie’s song, but if you listen to the other ones before they’re completely different to Roomie’s.

    • @Platinum_XYZ
      @Platinum_XYZ 5 років тому +20

      I really like his, the other ones are so boring to me

    • @imaperson8500
      @imaperson8500 5 років тому +31

      Saifana Maryam I wouldn’t really call it childish. It’s just a different sounding genre of music

    • @Edward.v.R
      @Edward.v.R 4 роки тому

      @@ivuriya jeh me to, I don't get the laughter lol

  • @droptopsalvador1864
    @droptopsalvador1864 7 років тому +720

    I love how they're all using these small ass Macs
    And then David whips out this massive fucking ASUS workstation 👌👌😩💦

    • @starsatsad5434
      @starsatsad5434 6 років тому +34

      Denzel Morok asus bigger then my future

    • @lynksedm6777
      @lynksedm6777 6 років тому

      My Inspiron's even bigger XD

    • @SameerWaheed1
      @SameerWaheed1 6 років тому +1

      LastLife Music OFFICIAL must be “inspiring”

    • @3zk1i_93
      @3zk1i_93 6 років тому +5

      Please tell me that use of emojis was ironically

    • @dedender0726
      @dedender0726 6 років тому +2

      oh god no its an apple

  • @SleepSoul
    @SleepSoul 7 років тому +891

    Melodyne has this thing that's called polyphonic...
    ...
    *_..._*

    • @JanneSala
      @JanneSala 7 років тому +11

      You need to practice more.

    • @nuclearfunk2001
      @nuclearfunk2001 7 років тому +73

      **Silence Intesifies**

    • @tooni3497
      @tooni3497 7 років тому +7

      Simon The Human Holy shit I was just at that part when reading this comment 😂

    • @KidPerfect1
      @KidPerfect1 7 років тому +1

      TeenyTooni me to

    • @cqnzr-clipsgameplay5706
      @cqnzr-clipsgameplay5706 7 років тому +9

      He still ponders to this day.

  • @elbowee7127
    @elbowee7127 7 років тому +60

    They are the type of people who say they're gonna fail on the exam but still get an A+

    • @wadv474
      @wadv474 7 років тому +2

      LMAO! Perfect comment XD

  • @GuyFromSomeWorld
    @GuyFromSomeWorld 5 років тому +139

    I honestly think these were pretty good.
    Except Roomie's.
    Roomie's one was amazing.

  • @Kyndragoon
    @Kyndragoon 7 років тому +164

    This was hilarious! I enjoyed everyone's piece actually. It was interesting seeing what you all would come up with

  • @Minecraftian09
    @Minecraftian09 7 років тому +62

    This is essentially Beethoven Simulator 2017.
    (Edit) fricc someone else already thought of this

  • @onyxcrimson
    @onyxcrimson 6 років тому +2631

    When you're the only one without a mac

    • @mintybar
      @mintybar 6 років тому +108

      When you the only one to like your own comment

    • @onyxcrimson
      @onyxcrimson 6 років тому +30

      Taya Dupouy true :/

    • @oracity
      @oracity 6 років тому +63

      Taya Dupouy when you try your best but you don’t succeed

    • @xchugsxahoyx
      @xchugsxahoyx 6 років тому +143

      his rog laptop is way better

    • @swandooper7657
      @swandooper7657 6 років тому +53

      *picture of slave master whipping slaves, but the slave masters face is windows and the slaves are macs*

  • @jacobparker1325
    @jacobparker1325 5 років тому +1931

    How cardi B makes her music

    • @jimbo2091
      @jimbo2091 5 років тому +31

      LMFAO

    • @asimov4979
      @asimov4979 5 років тому +72

      She can't even do it

    • @gumass4534
      @gumass4534 5 років тому +62

      extremely epic joke, bro. it’s funny because she makes music that you don’t like.

    • @oryza1650
      @oryza1650 5 років тому +28

      @@gumass4534 ua-cam.com/video/NY4G-wgqQYM/v-deo.html

    • @oinfsosafjn50
      @oinfsosafjn50 5 років тому +21

      @@oryza1650 Damn really finessed him on that one

  • @itszozzy
    @itszozzy 7 років тому +1074

    Are you kidding me? This is fucking awesome!

    • @wadv474
      @wadv474 7 років тому +21

      I know right?! I wouldn't be able to do half as good even if I had 4 ears

    • @itszozzy
      @itszozzy 7 років тому +1

      WADV Exactly!

    • @walkerspectre
      @walkerspectre 7 років тому +1

      And you are fucking beautiful *smooth* XD

  • @teddybearjelly704
    @teddybearjelly704 6 років тому +597

    Friend: what kind of music do you listen To?
    Me: 6:13

    • @Adoniz24
      @Adoniz24 5 років тому +6

      I was about to coment on that and how I listen to that kind of music

    • @pepega4373
      @pepega4373 5 років тому +17

      Is it only me or this would be good for a old school video game like water/beach area

    • @betabee1221
      @betabee1221 5 років тому +1

      @@pepega4373 i heard it more as a Factory theme

    • @no-vo9bm
      @no-vo9bm 5 років тому

      It's so cool😂😂

    • @ZivaMoon
      @ZivaMoon 5 років тому

      Literally me

  • @UnclePootis
    @UnclePootis 6 років тому +89

    This is how Chainsmokers was born

  • @rthrmusicofficial
    @rthrmusicofficial 5 років тому +6

    Dave taught me so much throughout my musical journey. Still in love with using reason because of him. Glad to see all of you working together :)

  • @ogredanhibiki
    @ogredanhibiki 5 років тому +281

    I wonder how a slight alternative to this challenge would go. 10 minutes to listen and gather samples without any editing, then 50 minutes to compose something without listening.

    • @cianlee6123
      @cianlee6123 5 років тому

      noice profile pic

    • @bxoomi
      @bxoomi 5 років тому

      Zebster aka Zebia is a true intellect

    • @rosytimes9456
      @rosytimes9456 4 роки тому

      im late, but that sounds pretty cool. maybe too easy.

    • @lumityandowlhousefan
      @lumityandowlhousefan 4 роки тому

      Rosy Times3 30minutes to compose

    • @rosytimes9456
      @rosytimes9456 4 роки тому

      Андрей Лукинов I mean that would be really hard, cause they would have to come up with lyrics and a catchy song, 50 mins is good.

  • @SupremeDP
    @SupremeDP 7 років тому +61

    I love how Andrew realized there was a joke coming before it was even finished.

  • @LimeBuild
    @LimeBuild 6 років тому +186

    Roomie's music should be in a game called Roomie's Adventure

  • @janLilin
    @janLilin 5 років тому +26

    "Hi, I'm Dave from Boyinaband!"
    _Hang on..._

  • @DanSutherland
    @DanSutherland 7 років тому +14

    Robs easily has the most potential to sound good with proper mixing, Roomie's actually does sound good I think. I actually like the "off" timing, I think it makes it more interesting. It'd make for a nice videogame soundtrack

  • @diogoepronto
    @diogoepronto 7 років тому +45

    If you think about it, that's almost how all classical composers made their orchestral works, because, you know, they couldn't play all the instruments at once so they had to rely on their imaginations to "hear" what they were writing.

    • @annyongpanda
      @annyongpanda 7 років тому +4

      This is a very good point.

    • @annyongpanda
      @annyongpanda 7 років тому

      This is a very good point.

    • @ChristianIce
      @ChristianIce 7 років тому +12

      Minus a piano, but yeah, pretty hard job.

    • @falconportofficial
      @falconportofficial 7 років тому +5

      annyongpanda To be fair, most composers had a piano for reference. Beethoven is an exception, though, he was deaf. Be somehow managed to write beautiful music, even though he couldn't hear anything.

    • @diogoepronto
      @diogoepronto 7 років тому

      Even though they had a piano for reference there were no way they could play all the melodies and chords from every instruments at once. Besides that, the sound of a violin , a flute or a tuba is very different from the sound of a piano. And what about the percussion instruments? There is no way they could play the "notes" of those instruments with the piano.

  • @casualcommons8320
    @casualcommons8320 7 років тому +88

    Andrews piece sounds like somethig casey niestat would use

  • @daveslamjam
    @daveslamjam 5 років тому +200

    Now, Jaiden/James/Rebecca/idksomeyoutubeanimator painting art without seeing it!
    hear me out; artists do digital art, but on top of the drawing they have a layer that is covered in a white, so they can't see what they're drawing, but they can see *where* they're drawing. pretty much the same sort of challenge as this video.

    • @mariacamilavega1720
      @mariacamilavega1720 5 років тому +13

      Or you can just set the layer opacity to 0

    • @PrimrosePetals
      @PrimrosePetals 5 років тому +5

      *Oh my god I'm going to do this*
      *New challenge*

    • @dinac8357
      @dinac8357 5 років тому +3

      i feel like jazza's done this...?

    • @daveslamjam
      @daveslamjam 5 років тому +1

      Maria Camila Vega
      yeah i guess

    • @tiildeath
      @tiildeath 5 років тому +2

      Yes

  • @theblackphoenix6498
    @theblackphoenix6498 7 років тому +43

    i love how everyone has a macbook and BIAB is just chillin with his big ass asus ROG

  • @LPSnep
    @LPSnep 7 років тому +45

    I just watched 4 dorky grown men make music that sounds like the stuff my music teacher trys to get the students at school to make, react to it, and then smush themselves on to a small couch whale silently fight over how much leg space they have. 10/10 gud video

    • @culturesex3803
      @culturesex3803 6 років тому

      WeenieMaster 69 music like that isnt very hard to make, playin an instrument requires more skill imo

    • @culturesex3803
      @culturesex3803 6 років тому

      NekoPlays02 you dont have to develope any technique, so it isnt as hard.

    • @Spirit5902
      @Spirit5902 6 років тому

      WeenieMaster 69 Very good indeed, btw I didn't know you watched these kinds of videos. (If you are a reader and are confused, this person is my friend.)

  • @Dragobot7
    @Dragobot7 7 років тому +15

    Please make this a series, this was awesome!

  • @pugsly4lyfe200
    @pugsly4lyfe200 5 років тому +188

    Adrew: Hi im dave from boy in a band
    Everybody: Wait thats illegal

  • @jt2197
    @jt2197 7 років тому +79

    Should be called Beethoven Challenge

    • @andrewp5402
      @andrewp5402 7 років тому

      Ooooooh

    • @tbow13gbr22
      @tbow13gbr22 7 років тому

      Except Beethoven wrote on an actual piano, therefore he could feel the music

    • @havuraivio4832
      @havuraivio4832 7 років тому

      Trevor Bowman yeah he had this metal pole in his mouth (connected to the piano) so the sound would resonate through his teeth in to his body and inner ears

    • @jt2197
      @jt2197 7 років тому

      Havu Raivio No, he is right, when you play the piano or any other instrument you can feel the vibration it generates while generating sound.

    • @havuraivio4832
      @havuraivio4832 7 років тому

      Jim Tsolakidis of course yes, but since we were talking about Beethoven i wanted to mention that metal pipe because it actually is a fact as long as i know

  • @kinocomix
    @kinocomix 7 років тому +230

    GUYS I HAVE A SYNTH

  • @DIYDamian
    @DIYDamian 7 років тому +47

    6:18 You can immediately see the confusion on his face when he sees that the automation messed up

  • @AttractionSpot
    @AttractionSpot 4 роки тому +355

    Why worry about earplug or whatever why not just mute your volume.

    • @landonking9433
      @landonking9433 4 роки тому +73

      real instruments on his end

    • @AdelaTomankova
      @AdelaTomankova 4 роки тому +10

      Won't work unless you're using an electronic instrument

    • @-.2..
      @-.2.. 4 роки тому

      Maybe the vibrations in the air would help them + real instruments

    • @Hi-vf9wx
      @Hi-vf9wx 4 роки тому +1

      @@-.2.. You said it yourself, you don't hear *vibrations* you feel em

    • @flmngphnx1706
      @flmngphnx1706 4 роки тому +3

      he wanted to record real instruments.

  • @chrisdrew1768
    @chrisdrew1768 7 років тому +63

    It's like a parody of an andrew huang video

  • @akikzza
    @akikzza 7 років тому +78

    #unlistedsquad thanks rob

  • @Jolontokhalilswork
    @Jolontokhalilswork 7 років тому +93

    all legends in one frame

  • @jay-rad8303
    @jay-rad8303 5 років тому +53

    Roomies low key sounded like a washing machine lmao

  • @dhruvchawla5476
    @dhruvchawla5476 7 років тому +160

    Dave is the only one with a gaming laptop lol

    • @0800sofa
      @0800sofa 7 років тому +5

      Dhruv Chawla he's not the only one... I have one as well :)

    • @dhruvchawla5476
      @dhruvchawla5476 7 років тому +32

      Not in the video, are you?

    • @massman1216
      @massman1216 7 років тому +2

      0800sofa Boi

    • @bjellida3976
      @bjellida3976 7 років тому

      Dhruv Chawla ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh mahgod

  • @sweotsmc9085
    @sweotsmc9085 6 років тому +614

    Beethoven wants to: *know your location*

    • @milk3n858
      @milk3n858 5 років тому +5

      MUAHAHA

    • @hollieisonyt4459
      @hollieisonyt4459 5 років тому +1

      Beathoven

    • @Sephyricon
      @Sephyricon 4 роки тому

      www.google.com/maps/@58.3428177,11.6909737,3a,75y,175.45h,80.22t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1svAymxK-EqVgBV4K31maHgw!2e0!7i16384!8i8192

  • @Ferotiq
    @Ferotiq 6 років тому +666

    So should it be called the Beethoven challenge?

    • @piersonlawrence3467
      @piersonlawrence3467 6 років тому +7

      Beethoven was PARTIALLY deaf he wasn't full deaf...
      I know this cause i'm a musician.

    • @清风两袖-o6s
      @清风两袖-o6s 6 років тому +63

      Pierson Lawrence So cocky.

    • @iconnected6816
      @iconnected6816 6 років тому +24

      Pierson Lawrence Good job on knowing a fact that everybody knows..

    • @galaxiikat1249
      @galaxiikat1249 6 років тому +28

      Pierson Lawrence You're not just PARTIALLY stupid, you're ENTIRELY stupid.

    • @h3llonwh33ls
      @h3llonwh33ls 6 років тому +19

      Pierson Lawrence r/iamverysmart

  • @sammy3212321
    @sammy3212321 5 років тому +27

    The thing I love about all these compositions is their diversity and strength in character that was still projected through the music despite the auditory disconnect

  • @kiazoblack.566
    @kiazoblack.566 6 років тому +287

    I love these, the first one really grabbed my attention, the second reminds me of an old indie fight boss scene, the third sounds like an off beat Pokemon beat but I really loved it, the last, reminds me of a cool hip hop type of song, kind of like gorillaz. I'd buy each of these if they were full songs.

  • @mrmcmine
    @mrmcmine 6 років тому +41

    I love how everyone has a mac, and Dave is like Asus ROG FTW!!!

  • @nerfff5964
    @nerfff5964 6 років тому +118

    "Beethoven would like to know your location"

    • @1r587
      @1r587 6 років тому

      GG.