aidil mubarock what??!? Do you even know what r/woooosh means or are you just trying to act cool because everyone else is saying it? Yeah it’s definitely the 2nd one
but doesn't relative mean you need a reference pitch (i.e. from an instrument) and that you can't work out a note from memory? in other words, does him knowing that note permanently mean it's more than just relative or no?
@@kaylee6584 i agree i think daves always nice(except when he has to drop a sick diss track). i just thought it was silly is all. and i enjoyed it. roomie and dave plus others are always awesome collabs to me.
Another video because the stars aligned today. Sorry if the quality is a bit messed up, my good mic wasn't working (ironic for a musician test). Hope it's fun anyway! Check out the ones on the other guys channels too :D
Andrew: **hears note** “HAAAAAAA!!!! Hmmm... HAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!” Me: “is that how you do it? Hmmmm...” **at a music test** “HAAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!” Teacher: “(tf is happening to her rn)” Students: Is she being possessed?
@Ismael Zetina I have no idea what kind of alien superbeing has enough perfect pitch to use their voice to tune an instrument. Like, tuning it so it sounds good by itself? Easy. One specific note? Fuck no
@Ismael Zetina Well, i do know about that note and it's kinda useful when singing, but it is the worst reference point you could choose. In my experience, it fluctuates almost a full step up and down depending on weather, health situation, time of the day, and generally can never be used reliably.
- MY FATHER TOOK ME INTO THE CITY TO SEE A MARCHING BAND? :D I think this is how you can tell when someone is a real fan - he recognizes the song with the first tone :D
I remember seeing a photo of you all hanging out a couple months ago on your Instagram, which is when I presume you filmed all these videos, but because it was a couple months ago you can definitely tell that a lot of effort put into your videos which is why I like you Dave! Keep up the good work ❤️❤️
I'm super rusty. I think I would've done way worse LOL. Rob's technique for the tempo differentiation was quite genius. Hey may have lost this "test" but he was the most creative problem solver.
How did they got the final score? I sum all the number and then divide it by 5, which are how many number there are. And it didn’t give me the results they had. It should be: 1st- Dave 2nd-Andrew 2nd- Roomie 3rd- Rob
stephanie Cs they added the numbers up and whoever got the lowest score won. So if you got first place in each test then you would have a score of 5 and if you got last place you would get 20. Rob had 3 4s and two 1s so he got last.
They should go for points. Like for the 1st place you get 3 points, 2 points for being 2nd, 1 point for being 3rd and 0 points for being 4th. That's the best way to do it, imho.
Relatable. "This song sounds off" "Well you do better" But alas, you will always know when something is off key, but because you cannot match their skill/do better, no one will listen...
CyanGaming | ᴹᶦᶰᵉᶜʳᵃᶠᵗ ⁻ ᴳᵃᵐᵉᴾᶫᵃʸ for the second test, for some reason, Dave and rob got first and Andrew and roomie got third. Andrew and roomie should get second. I don't know why he can't math but he can't because he somehow calculated that roomie was second place. The final add up is actually, Rob: 14, Roomie: 12, Andrew: 11 and Dave: 10. Although, I personally would not count up the scores like that. I would say that since both Andrew and rob got two 1st places and Andrew got two third places opposing rob's fourth places, Andrew won. But yeah.
Tbf, this tackles the fundamental mechanics of music, not the emotional side: the emotions a musician can evoke through their playing are far more important, but a lot harder to measure.
This test has little to do with music. Music is not about absolutes. Neither in pitch or in pace. It is about perception; how we feel about it. Now if you are a drummer, it is probably a good thing that you are good at keeping pace and have some sense of which pace it should be. (i remember from my days in bands that some of our performances we started way too fast. Problem is, you cant then while at it, change the pace. And that too fast pace may then lead to problems with guitar solo and quick lines of text later on. Hilarious when you cant make it. ;p For the rest it is of less importance; that is, often you do a specific note a tad after the beat, or prolong it after. Entire genres of music rest upon singing being a tad behind the beat. Of course that means that you still have to know that beat, to be able to be the right amount late. But the first thing i said applies. It is not about absolutes. It is about perception.
Rob.... You're subdividing, you're subdividing the tempo (specifically in 16th notes). It's a technique used by concert, marching, and orchestral musicians and you're doing very well.
Hi Dave! Just wanted to say that I'm happy that you're making so many cameos or collabs with other youtubers I like! Like Idubbz I can see you hanging out with filthy frank in the future, haha And you have already appeared in an odd1sout, and jaiden animations video; I'm kinda curious on how you met them. Thanks! You're my favorite youtuber musician
i'm coming back to this video because it made me realise perfect pitch was a thing... i was so confused when the test started bc i thought it was a thing that everyone could do
"Oh my god I'm nailing the opposite of nailing right now" - Roomie, 2017
I don't wanna like your comment because it's 69 likes.
Anyone got a time stamp?
@@TheVerybest506 9:27 is when Roomie gives the unforgettable quote
Dave imediatly recognized the g because he heard all the emos screech in the distance.
you did definiteley hear me screech 0.5 seconds ago :D
LOL
me, it was me screeching
WHEN DAVE GOT G-NOTED I STARTED LAUGHING SO HARD OH MY GOD I WAS WAITING FOR THAT TO HAPPEN TO SOMEONE
Yeah
Look at the comment that says "3:11 W H E N I W A S A Y O U N G B O I"
My child soopmon
At the end you can see how disappointed Rob is
Ya it's kinda funny
It made me really uncomfortable
C 6v n vvv cc x CD d
r/whooosh
aidil mubarock what??!? Do you even know what r/woooosh means or are you just trying to act cool because everyone else is saying it? Yeah it’s definitely the 2nd one
G is the only note I have perfect pitch for because of that song.
I'm not really sure if that counts tho...
It does because you can work out every other note using it
you can work your way up from one note
It doesn't count as having perfect pitch, but you can still have a use from it.
That’s relative pitch :)
but doesn't relative mean you need a reference pitch (i.e. from an instrument) and that you can't work out a note from memory? in other words, does him knowing that note permanently mean it's more than just relative or no?
Rob: that was just luck
Dave severely British: y a r e c k o n???
Guitar:Rob
Rapping:Dave
Drums: Roomie
Edits: Andrew
Exotic Budderz Rob is The Best YT guitarist. In the whole world. Ever! 🤘🏻
HateHater
DOVYDAS improvises with a whole band's worth of instruments on stage and kills it every time.
Trent Beckman I shall look into them. Thank you! Sounds great!
Carrots: Andrew
Bass:Davie
“you didn’t get the D”
-Dave (to Andrew), 2k17 (3:26)
👏.👏. 👏
G note plays
Emos: *Our time has come*
Oh sh*t! Andrew owned at relative pitch!
could be the Asian in him
EpicZEVEN dont you me
OH SHIT ANDREW OWNED AT RELITIVE PITCH
The g note
I'm crying
WHEN I WAS
A YOUNG BOY
ChenChan time oh fuck you XD
I just got so emo I fell apart
Yus Fam
FIREEEEEEEE IN MY SOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUL UUUUUUUUUUUUUHHHHHHRUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU JSAFHBDSUYBGUSIZHGIUHRSBGJBJSGFCNGF
1. Dave - 10
2. Roomie & Andrew - 12
3. Rob - 14
They added it up wrong.
the funny thing is they were scoring it through daves system. he had the advantage and he still chose to tie lol..
@@Redfoxx4eva Can't fault him for wanting to be nice.
@@kaylee6584 i agree i think daves always nice(except when he has to drop a sick diss track). i just thought it was silly is all. and i enjoyed it. roomie and dave plus others are always awesome collabs to me.
"it looks like I'm shaking a maraca -"
"yeah it's everyone's first thought"
WHY DID YOU G NOTE ME
Spicyspace Fruit RYRO
F*cking mood
I fell you
My emo past finally came in handy: I knew one note!
Hehe yeah. Past.
Hah, perfect pitch sucks. Trust me, your emo past is good.
G
wHeN i WAs a yOuNG BOy
I haven't even started the video yet and I already know what's going to happen...
Yep the G note is the only one I recognized thanks to MCR
sames
lmao same
Same I nearly shouted out g.
Same
Sierra's Lisp same
"I'm like nailing the opposite of nailing right now"
Dave... The fact that you know the begging of a My Chemical Romance song by one note.. Makes me love you even more lol
Another video because the stars aligned today. Sorry if the quality is a bit messed up, my good mic wasn't working (ironic for a musician test).
Hope it's fun anyway! Check out the ones on the other guys channels too :D
If that's a pun on the word "stars", I'm dead
So happy to see you doing good and uploading regularly again. Love you so much Dave.
Poor Rob isn't actually a musician.
Here's a game thingy that checks your time-keeping skills: www.concerthotels.com/got-rhythm
When you g noted me and then said MCR I got triiiigggrrrrrrennndnfsnflkajnsjkdnf;ernhgvpuiadsnlkjnajsdiufa
3:12 you mcr fans know what it is :D
Dr Benzedrine YAAASS
I flipped out when he said "cuz it sounds like the start of that my chemical romance song"
OOF IT'S 2D WHAT'S UP
Face McShooty .......life
Welcome to the black parade ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
I'm so proud that Dave got the G note! It's the only note I can get every time because MCR has me trained.
I JUST GOT G NOTED BY THIS
MY EMO IS QUAKING
YAS!
Same
I KNOW! I DIED WHEN I HEARD IT
Same!! Dave should put a g note warning in the discription
Fuuucck
Robs face during the point scoring. I cant
Oooh, i felt so bad for him....
David Staljø same
"music is about creativity, self-expression, and winning."
As a musician I can confirm this👍
LOL WHEN BIAB GOT IT RIGHT CAUSE OF MCR. THE 'G' NOTE HAS POWER PEOPLE!
Isagail I DIED..FUCK
I heard that note and frowned. Then he knew it because of MCR and I got happy. Xd
As soon as I heard it, I said aloud "They didn't... Did they...? They did...."
My face actually fell apart XD
I just got so emo I fell apart
Hears g note shreds tear
Swarley1998 obvious b8 is obvious
I just let it all happen
my waterparks romance 182 I recognise that note immediately whenever I hear it. It just hurts, that's how I know
the boys: *doing the video*
the focus on Dave’s camera: y’all hear sumn?
THE FUCKING *G NOTE* ...! DAVE WHAT THE FUCK WHY YOU MAKING US ALL EMO AGAIN?
William Larsson *sobs*
Hes not weirdo
**Hears G Note**
Me: *DEDAN SCREECH*
Thanks MCR for making the G note to distinct
HiBA ikr
HiBA true, I recognised that one immediately
I think it’s a G...
Because it sounds like the start of that My Chemical Romance song
Very good Dave...
*comedic laughter*
Andrew: **hears note** “HAAAAAAA!!!! Hmmm... HAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!”
Me: “is that how you do it? Hmmmm...”
**at a music test**
“HAAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!”
Teacher: “(tf is happening to her rn)”
Students: Is she being possessed?
CrumbsTheKitten // Gacha Studio
Does she have a metal disorder?
XD
she probably has a plastic disorder @coze
@Ismael Zetina I have no idea what kind of alien superbeing has enough perfect pitch to use their voice to tune an instrument. Like, tuning it so it sounds good by itself? Easy. One specific note? Fuck no
@Ismael Zetina Well, i do know about that note and it's kinda useful when singing, but it is the worst reference point you could choose. In my experience, it fluctuates almost a full step up and down depending on weather, health situation, time of the day, and generally can never be used reliably.
Two videos in a day dude, you're on fire. So is your increasing sub count, GJ on your idubbbz collab, and this here obviously ^^
His hair is on fire too
dirty fozzie what are YOU talking about df
TOCCL I thought at 0:51 it was rice gum
Michael I'd rather be an "emo" than support FaZe Banks...
Fucking *lol*
TOCCL a
Rob turns into a Frenchman when he's proud of himself.
GOSH THAT G NOTE THO
Ginger boi Piranda I WAS ACTUALLY SCREAMING! MY POOR EMO SOUL
lil tear comes of my eye
Ginger boi Piranda ikr I'm so upset how dare they
whEN IS IT GIVE ME A WARNING I HAVEN'T WATCHED YET
3:11
Dave, are you okay? You are uploading videos...
mångata I’m worried
Im not okaaaaayyyyy
mångata ahhhhh what do i do???!?
2 in a single day and like 30 in one day the other day
An Oblivious And Purposeless Consumer more like no videos in a year and 10 in a single day xD
Perfect pitch. Hears note. Instinctual noise of grief. Selects correct answer. Never forget.
bro you're a fucking legend, im subbing for sure
*Ultimate test:* Sing the chocobo theme in one breath
No u
That is really hard!! I just tried!
PlayTheMind AAA
I have a better one: rap kitchen sink in one breath.
whistle the chocobo theme*
3:15 WHEN I WAS A YOUNG BOY MY FATHER TOOK ME INTO THE CITY TO SEE A MARCHING BAND.
So much Dave content lately, I'm living!
Rob Scallon looks so sad when he's loosing
Rip Rob
The Richest Bum ik lmao
The Richest Bum
Losing*
Your spelling is losing worse than Rob did.
We still love you Rob
I WAS THINKING THE SAME THING FOR G
David's eyes are brighter than my future *-*
Rob looks so pissed XDD
Well . . .
This proves you don’t need crazy musical ears to be a talented musician
-Hey Rob, how good of a musician are you?
-hahahahaha
-what instrument do you play?
-yes
i'm dead rob: everything
Rob is THE INSTRUMENT!
@3:12 NO...
WHEN I WAS A YOUNG BOY-
- MY FATHER TOOK ME INTO THE CITY TO SEE A MARCHING BAND? :D
I think this is how you can tell when someone is a real fan - he recognizes the song with the first tone :D
MSadamgasm I was liek
G nOTe!!!!!!!
that was the only note I knew just from that song 😂
Violet Raven when i heard it i was like "NO THATS NOT, AHHH *emo intensifies*
THEY FUCKINH G NOTED ME MY EMO HEART IS NOT READY
Rob has an absolutely insane ability to play random instruments on the first try. Worth noting, I feel.
holy fuck DOUBLE UPLOAD
MatrixWolf that's what I said too
MatrixWolf Scarce?
MatrixWolf Scare be hiding
MatrixWolf chogiwa
trigger warning: g note
Øliver I was honestly so shook when the g note came out of nowhere
Saša Simčič Tišler same
We need this at the top of the comments
Øliver everyone talking about the G note has the TØP "ø" in their name, haha
TØP Obsessed at the *TØP* of the comments.
THAT G NOTE PLAYS WITH MY EMO HEART MAN
Hahaha 3:26 Dave says “you didn’t get the D”
I’m laughing too much
I remember seeing a photo of you all hanging out a couple months ago on your Instagram, which is when I presume you filmed all these videos, but because it was a couple months ago you can definitely tell that a lot of effort put into your videos which is why I like you Dave! Keep up the good work ❤️❤️
8:37 boyinaband.exe has stopped working
Shoulda got Adam Neely.
Fuck that guy, dude is just a big ponce
He would’ve just DESTROYED everyone haha
Yeah he would've nailed everything
*Dave's first "Perfect pitch" question note plays*
Me: *REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE*
CrankThatFrank: *REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE*
MCR fans across the globe: *REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE*
3:11 for reference btw
Crankthatfrankkkkkkkk
This comment gave me aids
CrankThatFrank is so obnoxious. But so is this, so it makes sense that you like him.
oscar fr
Actual Score:
1. Dave
2. Andrew and Roomie
3. Rob
Forget about the old "pulling the chicken", 8:50 Shaking the maraca is the new word :D
Choking the snake.
You both got it mixed up. It's Choking the chicken ffs
You know moving to Switzerland may be cool, plus the flag is a big plus
As a musician, watching Rob have the same problems I do with pitch makes me feel a lot better lol
I'm super rusty. I think I would've done way worse LOL.
Rob's technique for the tempo differentiation was quite genius.
Hey may have lost this "test" but he was the most creative problem solver.
AntonioKowatsch It may be use he learned an Asian language at an early age due to the extremely subtle pitch differences in there languages
Musicians are, for the most part, horrendously competitive people. And they have a lot of goddamn fun beating each other. I miss those contests. :(
|It's how we progress faster on our instruments and musicianship. Breaking out of complacency needs to be done regularly.
3:45 when you get a 96 on a quiz you had no clue about
Two Boyinaband videos in one day ? Is it christmas already ? well happy holidays everybody.
WHEN THE G NOTE PLAYED I ACTUALLY FELT MY HEART STOP
When Dave got g-noted I screamed (even though it is now post reunion)
Two in one day? Must be my lucky day? Wait. Three in one week?! Omg what??!! Theyre all to with music??
THE G NOTE BROKE MY HEART
How did they got the final score? I sum all the number and then divide it by 5, which are how many number there are. And it didn’t give me the results they had. It should be:
1st- Dave
2nd-Andrew
2nd- Roomie
3rd- Rob
stephanie Cs I did that as well but I didn’t divide them by 5 because you can just tell by looking at the summed up total
stephanie Cs they added the numbers up and whoever got the lowest score won. So if you got first place in each test then you would have a score of 5 and if you got last place you would get 20. Rob had 3 4s and two 1s so he got last.
The point is they did the math wrong. Dave got 10 points. Andrew and Roomie got 12, and Rob got 14.
They should go for points. Like for the 1st place you get 3 points, 2 points for being 2nd, 1 point for being 3rd and 0 points for being 4th. That's the best way to do it, imho.
PixelShader
The only thing that that does is waste time.
He can’t be stopped!!! Video after video!!!!
I love how at 3:12 2 songs immediately popped in my head, welcome to the black parade by mcr and runaway by kanye West
Andrew has absolute perfect pitch. Thats amazing
I got about .675 Hz apart, reliably being able to tell apart the .75 Hz differences...
If only I had as much musical talents as my ears :(
Relatable.
"This song sounds off" "Well you do better"
But alas, you will always know when something is off key, but because you cannot match their skill/do better, no one will listen...
Patrick Hector time to start a band Dude!
Holy shite dude. pick up something, ( preferably fretless) and you shine!
0.975hz here. Never had any musical training. I've been wasting my life.
lol i youldnt tell apart the 1.5, but i had tv in the backround as well as fridge
2:55 i immediately thought of linkin parks in the end
Or the beginning of A Place For My Head
Chase Holloway me too
The E flat right?
lol me too
shaqloco ya
I miss this. I can't believe this is an era so far past now.
If you add the scores up it's:
12
14
12
10
so Dave actually won, and Andrew was tied 2nd.
CyanGaming | ᴹᶦᶰᵉᶜʳᵃᶠᵗ ⁻ ᴳᵃᵐᵉᴾᶫᵃʸ thats not how you do averages.
CyanGaming | ᴹᶦᶰᵉᶜʳᵃᶠᵗ ⁻ ᴳᵃᵐᵉᴾᶫᵃʸ for the second test, for some reason, Dave and rob got first and Andrew and roomie got third. Andrew and roomie should get second. I don't know why he can't math but he can't because he somehow calculated that roomie was second place. The final add up is actually, Rob: 14, Roomie: 12, Andrew: 11 and Dave: 10. Although, I personally would not count up the scores like that. I would say that since both Andrew and rob got two 1st places and Andrew got two third places opposing rob's fourth places, Andrew won. But yeah.
ᴹ ᶦ ᶰ ᵉ ᶜ ʳ ᵃ ᶠ ᵗ ⁻ ᴳ ᵃ ᵐ ᵉ ᴾ ᶫ ᵃ ʸ
@CyanGaming he said that he's adding up the scores and like golf whoever got the lowest tally wins.
ayy i know you
What we do here is go back
*low-fi kicks in* _Duun DUUUUUUUUUUNNNN... dun DUUUUNNNN..._
Josophobia "la"
Doofenshmirtz Evil Incorporated Perry the platapus. My arch nemesis
Doofenshmirtz Evil Incorporated ♪
*jumps off counter* IM GAY
I guess, pewd's camera quality is contagious. 😐
that MCR note
DID U JUST G NOTE ME WITH NO WARNING
emo self is quaking
Dave: Alright Rob... How good of a musician are you?
Rob: * laughs *
Rob Scallon everybody XD
No offence to everyone else but in my opinion Rob is the best musician
Tbf, this tackles the fundamental mechanics of music, not the emotional side: the emotions a musician can evoke through their playing are far more important, but a lot harder to measure.
It's all SO subjective but I'd agree just because I'm a rock/metal kinda guy.
Daniel Cooper I came here to say this. I felt like this was more of a music technique test rather than a musician test. Still fun to watch!
Which one is Rob
This test has little to do with music.
Music is not about absolutes. Neither in pitch or in pace.
It is about perception; how we feel about it.
Now if you are a drummer, it is probably a good thing that you are good at keeping pace and have some sense of which pace it should be. (i remember from my days in bands that some of our performances we started way too fast. Problem is, you cant then while at it, change the pace. And that too fast pace may then lead to problems with guitar solo and quick lines of text later on. Hilarious when you cant make it. ;p
For the rest it is of less importance; that is, often you do a specific note a tad after the beat, or prolong it after. Entire genres of music rest upon singing being a tad behind the beat. Of course that means that you still have to know that beat, to be able to be the right amount late.
But the first thing i said applies. It is not about absolutes. It is about perception.
g note: plays
me; throws laptop
Rob.... You're subdividing, you're subdividing the tempo (specifically in 16th notes). It's a technique used by concert, marching, and orchestral musicians and you're doing very well.
You know, at first i didnt like your hair, but the more i look at it the more i like it
Hi Dave!
Just wanted to say that I'm happy that you're making so many cameos or collabs with other youtubers I like!
Like Idubbz
I can see you hanging out with filthy frank in the future, haha
And you have already appeared in an odd1sout, and jaiden animations video; I'm kinda curious on how you met them.
Thanks!
You're my favorite youtuber musician
HOW DARE YOU G NOTE ME IN 2017 YOU GOD DAMN HALF-RED-HAIRED GERARD WAY
Points:
1=3
2 = 2
3= 1
4=0
Andrew:
3+1+3+1+0=8
Rob
0+3+0+0+3=6
Roomie
1+1+2+3+1= 8
Dave:
2+3+1+2+2=10
YOU WERE THE ONLY WINNER
BiopticPlays you read it correctly right?
Gotta love Roomies crop on the thumbnail lmao
*G note plays*
Me - *screams* WHEN I WAS A YOUNG BOY
WHY DIDN’T YOU PUT A G-NOTE WARNING????
why?
Hears a random note,
Me: errr, no clue
Hears a G note
Me: AAAAAHHHH AHWHAJDJHAHAHAHHAHAAAAAJHEHWJJAJAJAJ!!!!!!!!!!!
Demon Cat SAEM
Cyborg2d_ nahhhhhhhhhh
Samee
Demon Cat OMG FALLOUT BOYS REFERENCE FANDOM FANDOM
i'm coming back to this video because it made me realise perfect pitch was a thing... i was so confused when the test started bc i thought it was a thing that everyone could do
14:45 Auto captions: "[Music]"
I see the captions have great taste as well.
I was about to watch the collab with Ian, but this was uploaded 2 minutes ago haha
0:40 Alright Rob how good of a musician are you
Rob: **laughs**
3:11 THE G NOTE
We need an ultimate musician test 2!
It's awesome to see some of my favourite creators all in one video ❤️ also I wanna take the tests too haha
i scored 34hz apart it says I have a pitch perception deficit. thank god im not a musician
I love how the face on your profile picture goes right along with your comment