PREMIUM wedge (£150) Vs BUDGET wedge (£50) - NO difference in performance?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 сер 2024
- PREMIUM wedge (£150) Vs BUDGET wedge (£50) - Any performance differences?
PGA Golf pro Rick Shiels reviews the new TAYLORMADE Milled Grind 3 (MG3) wedges which cost £150 each. After spending some time with the TAYLORMADE MG3 wedges Rick then compares them in performance to the very popular KIRKLAND SIGNATURE wedges from costco that cost £50 each or 3 wedges for £150
►Become a FREE SUBSCRIBER to RICK SHIELS now
bit.ly/SubRickShielsGolf
►Official Garmin Ambassador:
explore.garmin.com/en-GB/golf/
► Hit #Subscribe & #HitTheBell so you don't miss out on any new videos!
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
►My Links:
Facebook ► / rickshielspga
Twitter ► bit.ly/RickShielsTwitter
Instagram ► bit.ly/RickShielsIG
Web ► www.rickshielsgolf.co.uk/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hi I’m Rick Shiels, welcome to my channel RickShielsPGAGolf. This UA-cam channel is designed to help you play better golf, also to help you enjoy your golf more!
I specialise in golf club reviews, golf club unboxing, golf club news, golf club head to heads, and all about golf clubs.
I also want to make you play better golf by providing coaching video on all topics about golf, how to fix your slice, fix your hook, help you drive the golf ball longer, hit your irons more pure, hit your irons closer to the hole and help you draw and fade your golf shots.
I will also help you lower your score by chipping better by stopping you duff and thin chips, pitch the ball closer and also create backspin. Also I will provide you help to putt better and hole more putts!
On this channel I also make fun and entertaining golf content based on crazy and sometimes “gimmicky” golf clubs. I like to cut through the marketing hype about products and I like to give you the honest truth about golf equipment.
If you enjoy the channel make sure you hit subscribe and also tap the notification bell so that you are always notified when I release a new video. - Спорт
THANKS FOR WATCHING! We are fast approaching 2M subs! Be sure to subscribe if you haven’t already 🙌 thanks
Any data to back it up? Spin etc on short shots and full shots? Cheers
This was an Outstanding review. Thanks again for the great Content and review videos, Rick. Keep up the great work, Cheers!
Taylor Made rep on line 2 🤯
Definitely considering saving some money on Costco wedges if the lofts work for gapping after I get my new irons. TXG’s test was eye opening.
Slick Rick, as I build up my bag I use your test videos! Thanks!
Are you sponsored by TM?
Man, that intro with the club throws was slick
Club thrower should get a raise
I want to know if he did it in one take
Mann
And how they stacked vertically was nice too
Magnetic hand
I can already assure you there will be no performance difference.
Mainly because in my hands, both are going to end up in the trees 30 yards off the side of the green because I've overestimated the power
You, too?!?
So when do we have our monthly meetings? Since I do the same lol
Practice more
There are only 3 options for me: chunk it 75% of the time, pull it hard left 10% of the time and blade it (usually at a friend's face) 40% of the time.
Rick: "This wedge is 150 pounds."
Me, an American: "That's really heavy for a golf club."
Lol same
Pounds sterling, £. Not LBs.
@@Jay-we2ek derp
Y’all goin down on Black Friday
@@bstewart8540 lol I already got a set a few weeks ago
I love when Rick does these episodes high end vs budget he is so honest on the equipment sometimes you don't need to dish out the big bucks to improve your game it's all about your technique
He'll never be sponsored because he will compare it to Costco and won't find much difference. Lol.
I have a Wilson triple duty sand wedge that's like 50 yrs old but was in perfect condition when I bought it, it's so perfect that everytime I want to try a vokey or get a callaway to match my lob and gap wedge, I just remember I use this club to show off how good my short game is around the green and in the bunker. The club and it's weight works so well for my swing style. I think different clubs just work better for different ppls type of play
How many takes did you need to catch the three wedges so perfectly at the start? If that was first time then damn that’s smooth!
That's why I'm come straight to the comments lol
Just proves golf is a mental sport
Playing golf at times makes me want to quit, watching Rick Shiels Golf ALWAYS keeps me in. Thanks for all the great content!
Unless you are mad serious about it and doing comps ect I find with golf the best thing to do is take every hole as it comes, you have a bad one don't stress the next is different and just don't worry what you hit, I find it's much more enjoyable when I got into that mind set
Love the Costco wedges. Had them in the bag since week 1 of them launching in the UK. Massively improved my short game and given me confidence.
That’s ok just promise when you get better in a year get rid of those things. It’ll make you a lot better and you’ll be saying holy fuk I didn’t know the ball was supposed to be spinning like this lmao
Started golfing just earlier this year and made my first ever Birdie last week by holing out from 40 yards with a Kirkland 60 degree. I endorse them wholeheartedly! 😂
Nice! I started in June and I'm still working towards that first birdie
I got mine this summer had my first hole out with them last week. Always fun to get a chip in!
@@spenman10 it is elusive! I missed a lot of birdie putts within 6 ft. or so before it ultimately took a wedge shot to get it!
I agree with Rick and bought a 3 wedge set 2 years ago and they work perfectly. Perfectly means that you hit a proper shot :)
Got my first this summer as well! Never really played golf until this year. Just shot 43 on 9 holes yesterday. Was a great feeling!
Ive been playing the kirkland wedges for about a year and they are just soooooo clean for the price. Can't get much better of a performance to be honest.
I bought these after your first video and this was the follow-up I was waiting for. I recently got a surgery and am unable to golf so I haven't even gotten to swing the Kirkland's yet, Rick you been scratching my golf itch and I can't thank you enough, cheers mate
I will say, that premium wedges just feels special.. I've bought some CHEAP wedges and been really really disappointed.. but I own the Kirkland wedges.. and they don't feel like cheap wedges, they do feel pretty premium. I changed to the Kirklands from some TaylorMade wedges (the TMs were just getting old and in need of replacement), and I am really happy with the Costco wedges. They did a good job on them.. they aren't just some cheap knock-offs, they're really good. If you really want the TOP of the TOP, or really want a specific grind (as Rick said here) the Costo option isn't going to fit, but I'm a mid-handicapper who likes good equipment, and for me, the Kirklands fit the bill perfectly
I held them in my hand when in Costco last time and I really considered getting them but I just couldn't do it. Also the degrees didn't suit.
@@Soul-Taker yeah.. lack of options is certainly a strong downside
Just wish they did 50, 54 and 58 though….never liked 60 degree and a normal PW is 45/46 so a big jump to a 52
Couldn't put it any better
Go to your golf bag take it outside and throw it in the garbage
The club throw intro was my favorite part 😂
I have the kirkland wedge set and have been extremely happy with them. Almost bought the taylormade but wanted to update all three and not just one. They really do perform well
I bought the Kirkland wedges, love the performance and feel. The only thing I found was on a sunny day the reflection sometimes dazzles you if you catch the sun on the face at the right angle.
Invest in some sunnies mate 😎 jk
Loved this review. Many have said the same conclusion as you - just as good as the premium priced stuff. My only hope is that Costco starts selling them individually as opposed to as a set. Also, I’d like to see them in other lofts - 50, 54, 58. Thanks for your honesty and open-mindedness in your review, as always.
Let’s go Rick helping the golf game grow! Keep the work up
Riiiiiiick is that you?
@@Soul-Taker ?
@Jane 24 y.o - check my vidéó I hope u get banned
Such a great video. You really do the foot work for people like us so we dont have to spend a lot of money trying to improve our game. You tell it how you honestly feel and that's important. I definitely trust your judgment on all things golf. Thank you for all the helpful content. It has saved me money in golf lessons.
One more time you are sincere and that is why peoploe follow you. My handicap is 16 and I bought the kirkland after I seen your review and I can't stop singing their prases...they gave me so much confidence for my short game.
Thanks again and don't change
This is very interesting theory on performance vs price. I could see this being implemented with putters as well
Had misunderstood wedges for years, and absolutely loved them! They finally came to an end, so I went and got the Kirkland wedges... absolutely amazing, I love the feel of them!
This was a great video Rick! Feels good to have my purchase decision validated. I got the Kirkland wedges here in Toronto for $179. And they are truly amazing. Love them and love that I didn’t have to spend $150 for each instead is used that money for tee times, (or golf balls if I’m real lol). Appreciate all the videos brother!! Can’t wait to see you review the Garmin R10!! Cheers!
Absolutely love my Costco wedges, completely changed my confidence and ability around the green !!
Same here also using the Kirkland Signature golf ball as well . Good ball that doesn't upset me when I lose one considering they are only £29 for 2 dozen.
Waiting for a lefty set.
@@dirtpipedan same dude…. same
Sorry if this is a boomer question, but i wasn't sure if the Costco Kirkland was the same maker of these wedges? That was just too wild for me to comprehend.
I'm new to the game and really contemplating getting these
Thank you Rick! I bought the Kirkland set shortly after watching your review, it was the defining vote I needed to just get them, and I have been nothing but happy with them! Best money I have ever spent on wedges and maybe even clubs, certainly budget wise. I had a few sidelong glances and some giggling from friends that I was playing Costco clubs. After a few rounds that changed to are those still available? LOL Kirkland knocked it out of the park with these wedges! Now if they would just bring back the 4 piece ball!!!!
Rick man not lying I have been playing golf for 10years now and I haven't seen such a beautiful video of golf in years keep it up
Great video Rick! Thanks for confirming what I have wondered for a while. Just got the Kirkland putter last week and love the performance!
I really apricate this vid Rick, so unbias, so straight up, but more so than anything your helping people set up their bags with some good quality / good performing items, and helping these lesser known brands in the golf world.
I went out and bought the Kirkland wedges on the back of your previous review and I’m glad to say I love them! And so good to see that you rate them against high end wedges. Thanks Rick 👍🏼
Watched your video on the Kirkland wedges and purchased them off your review. Could not be happier with them. Good feel, spin, and durability. For the price, an excellent purchase. Thanks and keep the great product reviews coming.
This fits with what I’ve found to be the case with my wedges. I had a nice mix of “better” wedges in my bag but when they started to really reach the end of their lifespan I opted to give the Bombtech wedges a go. You’re right that the swing “feel” was different, the weight distribution was not the same as the other wedges. I was really pleased with what I was getting from them. I doubt I’d be as happy with their driver (or the irons for that matter) but high cost doesn’t necessarily reflect a proportionate difference in quality with wedges.
Love my Kirkland Wedges had them in the bag a few months now after wanting some Vokeys/MG2’s which I tested and they are lovely looking wedges. Really glad I got the Kirklands and saved some money. Win win.
I’m def a budget golfer right now and currently have the Kirkland wedges in my bag, good to see you play just as good with them.
I started a year and a half ago shooting well over 100 but thanks to yours a finchies videos I’m consistent mid 90’s now with some bad days and broke 90 for the first time a few weeks ago around stadium course, well chuffed i was!!! Keep up the good work!!!
Great comparison. I have been pondering the Kirkland wedges for a while and you have help make up my mind. Relatively new to the game and these seem to be right up my alley. Thanks Rick. Just became a subscriber.
I actually got the Kirklands about a month ago after watching your 1st video on them. Love them! Another great video Rick!
Rick, you’re an absolute gem! Thank you for making this video, it is exactly what I was looking for! Ordered the Kirkland wedges and I’m going to give them a go.
Thank you again for a honest and pure review 🙏👍 sticking with my Kirkland wedges
Just bought the Kirklands last week and saw this video! Bought it because of your previous review video so a big thanks. Now I am even happier!!
Every time I watch your videos I feel comfort and happiness
Thanks, I love and respect the honesty….. from a high handicaper
Rick, I bought the Kirkland's after watching your initial review. As I am on a budget it was the best choice for me, I have been extremely pleased and.. have had allot of looks and questions after good shots! Thanks Rick for your no bs reviews! Love the channel!
I love my Kirkland wedges. They have changed how I play around the green the past year. Thanks for the video!
What an intro. Rick looking like an absolute boss! Recently started into looking at a wedge set to complete my bag (still need a driver though) and really love the look of the new callaway jaws full toes with maybe getting them customised with my kids names on them but this is making me rethink that as the cost would be ridiculous compared to a set like the kirklands
Just goes to show that like a lot of things it's worth looking beyond the brand before you spend a lot of cash. Spend where it's going to make a difference but not where it's not necessary. I'm a fairly recent convert to golf and found I needed a 60 degree wedge. I got a new Ben Sayers for £30 and I'm really happy with it. It does what I want and when I improve my game and have the cash I might upgrade if only so I can get a matched set instead of the mixed bag I have at the moment. I really enjoy these videos and for a new golfer they are really informative. Keep them coming.
I went out and bought these Kirkland wedges after Rick’s initial review. Great clubs with a real premium quality feel about them!
Great review! I’ve just bought the 3 Kirkland wedges online after watching this, can’t wait for them to turn up🥳🎄
Best utility club I had in my bag for ages was a $20 56 degree wedge (then the bag got stolen, I replaced my irons, driver, and woods with the Calloway Edge set from Costco you reviewed, and my wife gave me the Kirkland wedges for Christmas...very satisfied with my replacement set...Thanks, Rick for your advice, especially aimed at us budget minded duffers!!)
Rick, thank you for videos like this. Videos like this are thoughtful and helpful for those of us who love golf but who aren’t financially able to spend hundreds or thousands of dollars on high end golf equipment.
This is why i subscribe to this channel. No brand snobbery and no golf snobbery. Thank you Rick.
I just bought my set of Kirkland wedges not too long ago and I’ve loved them. No reason to spend a fortune on wedges, I have owned Callaway Cleveland and Taylor made wedges in the past but I don’t think I’m going back now.
Rick.. thank you for doing this review. I have been intrigued by the Kirkland wedges. I almost bought the Kirkland putter but I found to good of a deal to pass up on a older odyssey putter. I actually use the Kirkland golf ball and I love it!
Used Kirkland wedges this year…so far so good…great performance at an outstanding price…highly recommended
2 weeks in to my golf adventures, I have a basic set of clubs that cost me $950 (New Zealand dollars). But I also treated myself to a lovely 60 degree lob wedge and ended up with a Vokey and it is a pleasure to use. I have one club in my bag that is worth nearly 1/3 of the rest of my set in total, and I love it.
Great stuff like always Rick!
Quite an honest test . Congrats. Best wishes from Argentina.
1st off.. I love EVERYTHING you do! Between you, Pete, Matt and Andy, my game has improved drastically (started back playing 2 months ago after about an 8 year lay off). Not sure if you've done it already or can you review PXG clubs? I'll be in the market for new clubs and I wonder if the "hype"(from the commercials) is legit. Thanx in advance. Keep up the great work!
My mate who’s off 4 bought some of the Kirklands and these and had a go of them the other day. Really nice. Look a bit like Vokey sm7’s, soft and versatile soles. Very impressed
Love the vid Rick!!! Very unbiased opinion. Love to see it.
That was a very interesting review, Rick. Didn't expect you to be so honest. 👏👏👏
Thanks Rick , you just fixed my slice over the weekend. I wanted to buy Kirkland but was bit doubtful, now it’s seems clear I am buying Kirkland wedges.
Saw initial reviews, plus a head to head against Vokey SM8. Then tried one that a buddy had and immediately bought a set to replace my older SM's. Only downside for me was had to buy 3 and only wanted 2 of them but the price difference is crazy. Changed the grips to something else but that was personal preference. Very happy with the 56 & 60 that I use.
Great video as always. I'm trying to find a video you might have done that would explain when looking at wedges what bounce we should be considering for what circumstances in which we typically play. I generically think low bounce for the club we would use from short grass (although I have no particular idea what percent that would be). And higher bounce for shots from the rough and possibly the sand. But I am utterly confused by the options.
Bought these about 2 months ago... this video makes me glad I did.
Rick,
WOW! Great show. I am amazed that the Kirkland wedges performed so well!! Peter
I liked the video simply because how impressed I was with those three tosses and catches on the KS Wedges
Short game on point in this vid rick, keep up the good work 👍
Very good review and enjoyed the feedback I’ve used secondhand wedges rather than brand new ones and usually just as good
Great video Rick! Will have to try the Costco wedges.
Great video Rick. This is very true when it comes to wedges. I like the mid range wedges that are not too expensive but still has great performance. Like you said, performance s still the same. I have a set of Cobra wedges, that are the same as my clubs, and they work just as well as any Cleveland or Vokey wedges, I even get a little more forgiveness, since they are cavity back wedges.
I love when new models come out because I can pick up older ones for a discounted price
Good point made on the wedges there many of my friends are like i just like the brand more than the latter but they really do the same job. Well done and good honest vid
Next time I need new wedges, I’m definitely going to try the Kirkland wedges. I love my Cleveland wedges, but probably not enough at the price point. Thanks for doing these reviews for golfers on a budget
Ideal for beginners in a way. Not having to pay a lot but getting more clubs for the same price. Good video Rick
Honest evaluation, thanks
How about the grips for the Kirkland set? Were they of quality and seem as though they would last? Thanks Rick for ALL your amazing content and making golf videos fun, interesting, and motivational!
I actually spoke to a Callaway Master Fitter/ Regional Rep last week about wedges and he explained the differences between the patents of all the major brands and such and mentioned that there was a 6% or less variance between spin rates and overall performance of the wedge. The major difference is being fitted for them because the sweet spot on the wedge changes based on design patents. When I jokingly asked about Kirkland wedges he just looked at me and said, "6 percent". Great video as always.
Absolute honest great review.
Rick, your chipping is getting better everyday, you did great with both kinds of wedges today, now bring that to the next challenge with the boys and we won’t hear any polls of fun with those shots. I agree about the wedges, I can’t afford the high price wedges so it’s good to know that the lower price ones work just as well. Nice video Rick as always
I don't often hit my 60 degree wedge 180 yards ... but when I do, it's from a greenside bunker.
I have the Kirkland signature wedges. I really love them. My MacDaddy wedges are living in the garage.
That was quite informative. If I win the "ANY SET OF IRONS" prize you offered, I'm not asking for a Kirkland set but I've got my eyes on some mid range options that would just look pretty in the bag...and probably perform just as well as the top rated sets.
I bought the Kirkland wedge set off the back of your test and can say anything other than great things about them. I changed the grips immediately as I felt the grips were a little thin and because I’m used to playing the Golf Pride Tour Wrap 2. £21 for new grips and I wouldn’t change them for any other wedge set! Brilliant bargain!
Great video … I have bought the Kirkland set and LOVE them . Work as well as any others that I have had …. Great value for money imo
I love my Lazrus wedges off Amazon! Replaced the shafts with KBS Hi-Rev 2.0 125s and CP2 wrap. Even cheaper than Kirkland, has extra grooves on face.
Hey Rick! Hope you’re doing well thanks for the awesome vids 😁
I’m doing really well thanks for asking Chris
I play the kirklands. Gave my old vokey's to my wife. The gaping was perfect for my irons. Love them.
Your a stand up guy Rick..I know I get the truth from you..much appreciated..
Love my Kirkland wedges. bought them after your previous review.
I bought the Kirkland Wedges after watching your other video about them. Like em alot, thanks!
Couldn't agree more!! I had and hand me down Vokey wedge that was in great shape, and yes it was amazing! I purchased the Kirkland wedges because of the price point, oh and because of your review! I personally love the Kirkland wedges. I hit them very well and they feel great! If you want a great alternative to spending $500 just on wedges, Kirkland wedges are your way to go!
Just got my Ksig wedges this week. Can’t wait to get them out to the course this weekend and give them a go.
I’m literally going with a buddy of mine to Costco this upcoming weekend to get the wedge set by Kirkland so get out of my head Rick!!! Thanks for the quality content brother
Can you make a video about what to do if you feel like you've lost your swing on the course? I'm curious to hear your tips! Thanks for everything you do!
Omg mate, the video that I’ve been waiting for the review of the MG3. Thanks so much, Rick. Now the question is, will the MG3 go in your bag?
Great video guys. I currently have a set of the K-sig wedges in the bag, and I'm super happy with them. Out of all the clubs in my bag, they will probably stay the longest. My other clubs are a set of 521c Tour Edge irons, 4 thru P, a Cleveland Launcher from the early 2000s that I like, but I'm not very good with yet. A pair of department brand woods, 3 and 5, which are the two remaining "legacy" clubs from my original bargain swap buy when I got into golf. I do well with with those, but they are on deck for replacement. My putter is a $20 dollar buy from a second had store, a Dogleg Right "Hog" which i had resized and gripped and actually preforms wonderfully. All in all, my clubs cost around $780 US. If you are a bargain golfer like me, i think the K-sig wedges are perfect addition for your bag.
Great videos Rick! What I would have found interesting to see is a direct comparison with gcQuad. How would the spin differ etc, a bit more numbers oriented not just feel.
Great TM MG vs Kirkland Wedge review and comparison. I'll stick with my MacDaddy 2 wedges a friend of mine gave me. Best wedges I've ever owned.
Still the best golf channel on the tube Rick, fantastic review on the club that can ruin a good score, most handicappers struggle with the wedge into the green
Great video Rick, been watching a lot of yours while on holiday. Can I just recommend a wind muff for your lapel mic too, should help reduce a bit of the wind noise. All the best 👍
Editor could add a high pass at 80hz or a slower roll off high pass at 100hz. That’d get rid of 90+% of it
I play Kirkland wedges right now and I traded out my vokeys for them. They’re actually great. Good video Rick!
Love the Costco wedges, improved my getting up and down for par.
I’ve been testing out the MG3 and I’m not a big Taylormade guy but I’ve really been enjoying them and am surprised by their forgiveness honestly. Really think they are the best looking wedges right now too.
That's what I've been hearing. People say they're better than vokeys and that's a pretty big statement but when everyone says it.
@@Mikesmeyer88 I wasn’t really expecting much of a difference when I got them but after a few days of hitting them I have been impressed. Definitely worth a try. Have a great feel through the tuff, which that and the forgiveness I wasn’t expecting at all. I’m a fan of them. Plus I think their the best looking wedges personally.