I'm a veterinarian. It's so weird hearing her talk about her dog's incontinence issues, especially the way she lead into it - saying that her dog ate Johnny's weed, then kind of implying that that caused the dog's lifelong incontinence afterwards? Yeah, that makes no sense, that would be really unusual. the dog was fecal incontinent for some other reason. Weed ingestion can cause urinary incontinence while the dog is high, but fecal incontinence long-term? Sounds kinda... Suspicious. I dunno. It just seems like she put that in there to remind the jury that Johnny does drugs... Rolling my eyes over here. Besides if the dog was really fecal incontinent and they were doing a workup about it, there would be medical records that would confirm this!
Even if any of her story was true... why would you not just clean it up? Why was it left there to be found? Especially if your husband is so abusive and beat you for every little things
My question hearing that was: you know your dog (allegedly) has little to no control over their bowels. Why would you put it on the bed and leave it there while you're out packing for a long time? Common sense says if you suspect your dog will use the bathroom at any point then put it in a pen with a potty pad, not on your bed!
"Bruise kit" and "theatre makeup kit" both refer to kits used to *create* the appearance of bruises not cover them. Color correction for improving appearance (covering under-eye circles, blemishes, bruising) isn't common in theatre makeup because the audience is far enough away that even dark bruises covered with foundation aren't noticeable. Even things as dark as tattoos are just covered with a bandaid, not heavy makeup. "Theatre makeup" could be referring to the Ben Nye brand, which is known for their compacts for creating bruises, but also makes normal color correction kits. So she could mean that. But ultimately, if you're actually trying to cover something, you have to put the corrector *underneath* a concealer/foundation or both. Putting it on top would make it too prominent and would look very odd. But it's consistent with the order you'd use to *create* the appearance of a bruise. Huh. Interesting.
As a side note, Ben Nye makeup works great with watercolors and sculptures that need a bit of a light touch up. I'll fight everyone who says I'm wasting it in the name of art. Back on topic, though, she also stated she put her concealer and whatnot OVER her makeup, which is what you do with bruise makeup. EVERYONE and their cat knows anything to do with correction goes UNDER the makeup!
Exactly! If she puts the colour corrector on top of the foundation and concealer the bruised area will look like a green/peach/whatever blob over the bruised area. The corrector goes beneath the rest of the base makeup.
@@octogonSmuggler See I knew that her "order" was wrong if trying to hide a bruise. Bc I know you'd use the color corrector first b4 concealer & foundation. But my exact question as I watched was wait ... If you are creating a bruise w\a "bruise kit" or theatere makeup, what is the correct "order" they use to CREATE said bruise. & Correct me if I'm wrong, but you ARE saying that those same theatere makeup artists would use the order she gave (foundation >concealer>bruise kit) when creating a fake bruise?! Bc WOW is that telling on herself triple w\just that 1 statement! 👀🙄😳
She totally told on herself with that one. No one who has ever used color corrector would so confidently state that it “obviously” goes after foundation and concealer. Plus, calling it a bruise kit, which means something very specific to those who are actors. I bet Johnny’s ears perked up at that one. Along with saying that lipstick can conceal a split lip twice now, she is really counting on that mostly male jury to not pick up on such ridiculous lies. Her arrogance is astounding.
Amber's cross-examination was like - "You had two apples, right?" "Yes, I had two fruits that looked like apples in the photograph." "And you got two more from the shop." "Yes" "So you had four apples after that, isn't it?" "I would disagree with that characterization of it."
Even the video explanation was wrong! She has Her Purse over her shoulder so was she at a different house, slept on the couch, just woke up, or fighting and leaving? Damn the stories never make sense with or without proof.
For a DV victim, she talks extremely condescending on the tapes to her "abuser"....I would be terrified to talk to him like she does if he was that "abusive" to her....
Definitely! She talks the way an abuser would talk to her victim. No victim would taunt, belittle, blame and berate their abuser the way she did JD. She kept going and going at him, deliberately escalating the verbal fight, and then attacking him for leaving the situation in order to deescalate the situation. She wanted the drama she created, and was frustrated with him for not going along with it. Been there. Done that. My narcissist scarred me for life, and he was a walk in the park compared to AH.
I disagree. I was involved in a relationship very similar to this (minus the millions lol) and I would retaliate verbally during his sober non-psychosis moments and then the pendulum would swing back on his 3rd day no sleep and I was being choked and had my ribs broken. I never sought medical treatment. I was trauma bonded to this person and I relate to Amber so much. To me, she is not lying.
There is no way that Amber Herd & her attorneys weren’t communicating about her testimony during the last week. It’s obvious they went through line by line, formulated ways to correct the inconsistencies, & then rehearsed the questions & answers for the upcoming testimony that’s occurring today. This should be acknowledged & penalized, & it’s very frustrating that it’s being ignored right now 🙄
She’s allowed to review her testimony and to look at what the public is saying. But 100% they are coaching her directly on the stand it’s crazy. Edit: YALL I didn’t say discuss. I said REVIEW. As in she is allowed to rewatch footage/clips herself and make any changes she sees fit (even if I agree it seems like she’s discussed it with her lawyers)
I can't believe this judge is allowing this testimony!! It's completely obvious that they spoke about her testimony during break. WHAT ARE THERE EVEN RULES IF THEY AREN'T GOING TO BE ENFORCED?
I mean you have to have proof right. in court a judge isn't gonna be like hey c'mon guysss it sounds like you guys talked about your testimony!! but yes clearly they had a chat. It didnt help lol
@@Bbelblelo I get ya. It's obvious they could never prove it, I just thought once you made a statement under oath - you made a statement under oath! I didn't think you could go back and correct basically your whole testimony (again not really her WHOLE testimony) and there not be some legal consequence. So why even have them testify "under oath" if they can just change it when they realize their lies didn't add up? To me that's infuriating. And I've noticed a lot of states don't make you swear to God & put your hand on a Bible anymore. Say hello to socialism. The only authority now is the state. And the stoned face liar she is, I pray he wins just because of how badly she lies. Lol
I love how she's trying to frame the video of him slamming cabinets was supposedly him hallucinating when, in fact, he'd just found out his accountants had stolen a massive amount of money from him, his mother was in the ICU and at the beginning you can hear him yelp in pain, so he probably hit his injured finger on something by accident and that all combined to trigger the outburst. Even during the video she's trying to make it about HER when it had nothing to do with her.
Not only that, but the way the whole video was set up just screams that she was purposely putting on an act! The way she said "We didn't fight this morning, u were sleeping so peacefully" in a voice not like her regular one tried to portray her as very meak and intimidated. Like, we hear how she sounds regularly on the stand. We hear how she sounds when she's DEVESTATED on the stand. We hear how she sounds when she's ANGRY in the video and voice recordings. But this one felt very much like a Placed Dialogue, and it didn't go her way.
finding out about the betrayal of his team, & huge money loss. The other thing is the birthday lol Such a big deal he wasn’t there BUT he was out at a business meeting.. she wants that life style that he was funding.. well some ppl work & without his meetings there is no money. It’s ridiculous how she obsessed about the birthday. Get over it.
When I left my abuser he took his life. And I not only left our home. I left the city. I sold all the furniture. Even the car. Bc PTSD is real. She is lying and it’s really upsetting
Absolutely! That's EXACTLY what she's trying to do! She's doing us just like she did him, & trying her damnedest to convince us that we are crazy & didn't just see her lie & contradict herself for the millionth time! Like COME ON! We have instant replay!
She said that she didn’t want to take her divorce public… But according to the tapes or the recordings… She was the one that wasn’t afraid to take a public and Johnny was trying to tell her that he wanted to keep things private! She’s such a liar
She’s straight up friggin pathological. She can’t even keep her lies straight. The things she says aren’t even believable. This is hard to watch. She’s a terrible awful person.
She was also the one who clearly called TMZ and tipped them off so they would be there when she came with her makeup bruise to get the TRO, although she still tries to say Johnny, who had no idea she was going to get the damned thing, tipped them off even though it would have looked bad on him so why the hell would he do that, ya know? She's also the one who got ahold of every publication she could to get her lies and fake bruise pictures out. That's the moment it was all made public. She wanted it public when she was destroying Johnny with lies but wants it private when she's being destroyed by truth.
I said this on an older video but that is what bothers me about AH on the stand is she speaks, acts, answers, holds herself ALL LIKE AN EXPERT WITNESS giving a testimony. Not like a victim giving a testimony.
You know what's scary? If she weren't so insistent on the abuse being over the top she might've actually pulled off making JD out to be a violent monster. You know, like "I was yelling in his face and he slapped me" instead of the "he punched me with his big ringed hand repeatedly". Her pictures could be of a heavy slap or such but there's no way they're from her description of the fights. Thank God she overacts!
It just lends validity to Johnny's sisters testimony that she couldn't take Amber seriously because she was always overreacting and exaggerating things.
Yes I agree. If she had said he hit her once or slapped her but her insane over the top violence where she is claiming he is punching her in the face over and over is obviously ridiculous. Even the picture that shows a slight mark and maybe a shadow under an eye, even a couple days later in bad light like she claims does in no way line up with what an assault like that would look like.
Her overacting is part of the histrionic personality disorder which also contributed to the severity of their fights. Johnny just didn't realize what he was dealing with.
It's so insane she said she put her moisturizer with tint then foundation and concealer THEN color correction with a THEATER bruise kit. Which if you google bruise kit they all look like milani but are the actual bruise making kits. She basically gave the order for how you'd MAKE a bruise, not color correct it.
If AH was so “terrified” that JD would “accidentally kill” her, why would she EVER belittle him for not staying and “fighting” her as she stated in that now infamous audio tape? Why would she stay and secretly record him and get snarky toward him when he was very upset and slamming kitchen cabinets? And, why didn’t Johnny then follow the “usual” abuse pattern as claimed by AH of him, slapping, hitting, striking, etc her in the face and head, pulling her hair, bashing her head with or against something? No, he yelled at her and slammed the cabinets and then as a FU poured himself a “mega cup” of wine all while unaware he was being recorded. Were she really a victim of the abuse that she has so theatrically thrown -up to us with her abysmal acting on the stand, she would not have stayed in that room for 10 seconds let alone goad him and take the chance of being caught videotaping him.
Yep and if hes so abusive why didnt he attack then when hes obviously in a full rage already and shes there instigating and pushing. Seems like thatd be the time, if ever, that hed attack
@@EmmaHolland her friend "got through" to him by treating him like a wild horse. She put her hands up and said NO. (/heavysarcasmjustincaseitwasntobvious) 🐎🤡
I love Ambers “reactive hitting” testimony, considering the fact that, in her own words, the only time she ever hit Johnny was when he was about to “push” her sister down the stairs. 🤭 Hopefully it gets brought up in cross 😋 edit: another thing too, i’ve thought about it for a while, with the video of the cabinets, if your abuser is angry and taking it out on objects, and you were terrified of it turning on to you, you would NOT say something like “stop slamming the cabinets”. that’s like a death sentence. telling your abuser what to do…no victim would do that especially not when they’re angry like that. she’s full of it.
@@Nonameforyoudangit EXACTLY! Nor would she insert herself into the middle of something if the anger wasn't directed at her in ANY WAY! If she's not the object of his rage at that moment, she's NOT going to CALL ATTENTION to herself when he's not looking at her, not mentioning her, nor paying her any mind. At that moment, she's completely irrelevant to him. & Yet she goes OUT OF HER WAY to call attention to herself. You wouldn't want him to shift the focus of his rage to you if you're deathly scared of him! That doesn't make a LICK of sense!
This is totally true. I was in them situations fir way too long and if he was taking it out on something else I wouldn't say a thing because I know then it would be taken out on me.also recording him ,especially if it was obvious. I would be afraid I wouldn't make it out. 6 years later and I still have nerve damage in my face from him. Also when I was hit the way she claimed no makeup would cover it. He broke my nose and I had black eyes and a swollen face for weeks. It makes me sick hearing her lying like this when there is so many people actually go threw. Its not hard to tell what's lies especially if you went threw it of knows someone who did/is. For anyone in this situation, theres a way out. You can get help and first its going to suck but I promise it gets better.picl up the phone and make that first step of the rest of your lives. Speak to someone,theres lots of help and 24 hours crises centers in your area that can help. It breaks my heart to think how many people go threw this every seconds of the day. Stay strong 💙💞🌈
Anyone else find it odd that AH has the makeup skills to cover a broken nose (black eyes assumed), split and bleeding lip, and a myriad of other facial injuries, but not the skill to cover faded scars on her arms?
I’m more amazed at her skills to hide swelling. After her testimony and seeing the pictures all I can remember is Rihanna’s pictures after she was physical abused.
It’s interesting that she can cover a couple black eyes, a busted lip, and a broken nose flawlessly the day after an assault with makeup, but the arm scars were “too hard to hide”
Those scars were far too linear, they're all straight cuts, and are all vertically aligned, and there's only 3 of them, and considering where they are on her arm, they're in a place people couldn't see. She alleged that in that situation she was flat on her back, meaning the front of her arms would of been in contact with the broken glass on the countertop, but somehow the scars are on the backside of her forearm, if someone is holding you down, or on top of you, your palms need to be facing downwards into to try to push upwards. Those scars seem like definite self harm, and she then used the scars to build a whole story around. Notice how they had evidence of the scars on her arms, but no scars on her feet? still no pictures of any other damage she supposedly received during that entire incident?
I think it bothers her a Lot that his finger injury is More Important than her "alleged" injury. She hurt him badly, but she hates he gets any sympathy, because it's always about her to her. Nothing can be more important than her or or anything about her.
@@MasterIceyy I agree, I think she hurt him but then on the plane had to do something to gain sympathy. She had been on the phone with friends & most importantly she had listened to the secretly recorded talks everyone at the house had while he was at the hospital & she was upstairs at the house. Those recorded said it was her, she caused his finger injury, and faulted her clearly. What to do but make herself injured too so they couldn't blame her. She cut herself on the plane, that's why she was in the bathroom so long. Desperate to shift blame & get oh poor me sympathy from her friends. Shrew, she's a Shrew plainly.
"The Home isn't the Problem" made me furious. That's not how PTSD works. Makes just as much sense as gifting a knife to an abusive partner, when you're terrified and FEAR FOR YOUR LIFE🙄
Right. I flat out cancelled plans to go stay with friends at their cabin because I knew they had firearms and targets there. And a little boat. I got in big trouble for it, too, but I didn't get shot or drowned. There's no way in hell I'd give him anything sharp as a gift. Ffs I snuck both of the expensive kitchen knife sets out the door one night and secretly put them in the dumpster. It was just too scary knowing they were right there for him to grab at any moment.
“The home isn’t the problem” oh really, Amber? Is that why the saying goes “you can’t heal in the same environment that made you sick?” This woman knows nothing about PTSD. The DSM 5 ITSELF discusses places in the PTSD diagnostic criteria.
Timestamp for the THEATER/BRUISE KIT slip up discussion: 3:47:58 At 3:50:28 she says "not bruise kit" and stumbled to correct herself, then says theater makeup kit. The Milani kit isn't a theater kit. Bruise kit would be Mehron or Kryolan. I do drag/cosplay (orange corrector on my brows), I would apply colour correction before foundation. How would you put yellow (assuming she was covering purple bruising) over a tinted moisturizer and not look jaundiced???
I'm a makeup fan. I just use corrector for circeles, dark eyes, side of mouth ash and KNOW this much. I really hope there's a makeup wearing juror, or some guy who does drag.
When I did stage makeup for theatre in high school, we always put the bruise makeup on OVER the other makeup. But didn't she state that she "corrected her bruising" by putting that over the makeup? Isn't it common knowledge that anything for correction goes under your makeup and not over it?
Did we just listen to Amber literally gaslighting Johnny for hours on end? Her attempt to excuse away what we are listening to with our own ears was disgraceful. If she is willing to gaslight him in such an obvious and open manner on the stand can you even imagine what he must have had to deal with in private?
@@daCubanaqt also what made me lol is she says they were hard to cover up, yet she could cover up bruises and «broken noses» at events the day after it happened 😅😅
I have been a nurse for almost 30 years. As a nurse, there would have been absolutely no reason for to fudge any of her records or her history. There would not be in the back of your mind that you need to falsify in case she accuse JD of something years down the road. Every nurse I know abhors domestic violence, we see too much of it's effects and end up picking up the pieces, sometimes the literal physical pieces. To allude to the nurse is in cahoots enrages me.
Yes I doubt that ever occurred, that a nurse intended to aid someone to report something falsely, but a nurse can only write down what information she is told, or things she sees herself so we all have to take all that into account, with any records or witness statements, because it's convenient (for example ) for Amber to put someone on her speaker phone then scream loudly to make a listener think something really happened, but that doesn't necessarily mean anyone or anything made her scream, so it doesn't mean what was perceived to be happening actually did.
I'm replaying the trial and an overcharter because I'm afraid of being subpoenaed and/or sued. I'm also pretty forgetful after so much time has passed and with how many patients we go through in a matter of a week. It was insulting for her to insinuate forging and faking notes. We hate taking notes. It's so much damn paperwork.
It’s months later and I am rewatching this trial from a different perspective but it’s still incredible to me. I’ve actually heard another channel that did an eight year investigation. I listened to them play the depositions and the police call recordings among others. There were two police calls that night and one was clearly IO but the other was “ anonymous” but was clearly Raquel Pennington and she sounds very uncomfortable making the call. I’m glad J. D. got justice but amazed at the number of recordings that were not allowed to be played in court. The recording Amber secretly made in Australia is so sneaky as she left her phone in her purse on the kitchen recording people. It was a toxic relationship and A.H. was clearly mentally disturbed as Dr. Curry testified. It’s such a shame these two got together. Hope JD learned to be more discerning and find peace. Hope his verdict helps him long term.
I am back here again because I have been watching the Surviving Amber Heard series with “The DUI guy”… I feel very stupid for having had sympathy for her
@@michelleeven24 keeping an open mind and understanding a situation differently once you see or hear information is a sign of intelligence. Don’t feel stupid. You are a critical thinker and I think all victims should be believed at first. But they must be able to withstand judicial scrutiny and AH’s testimony was obviously inconsistent and full of lies. The information in the documentary shows much of what was really happening in private. So I’d say good job for learning the truth and making up your own mind.
She said the home or setting does not trigger her PTSD. She asked to stay in his penthouse. She did not see him for a month and did not change the locks during that time. She did not just go to a hotel for the night to get a good night's sleep instead she cleaned up the place. She immediatly filed a TRO the next day instead of deliberating with her attorney like she stated to the police during the first visit. She feared for her life but did not leave and go to a place he didnt have access or staff at. I can't follow any of this and why JD's team has to even waste their cross time when she's the one that contridicts herself.
The TRO was on the 27th while the supposed fight and the 911 calls were on the 22nd I believe. But yes, if she felt that unsafe in HIS PH (by the way...) why didn't she go to a hotel or stay with one of her many friends? Oh right, because they were all freeloading off of JD too...
My mom got a TRO against my dad during Covid because she feared for her life and mine, we changed the locks on the house the first opportunity we got and sold the house the second we could because it didn’t feel like a safe place anymore. We didn’t want to stay in the house any longer than we had to because it served as a reminder for all of the terrible things that happened there. Amber’s behavior is very strange to say the least.
@@ada_pink So she was in danger for her life, and yet she didn't worried about what JD would do to her friends who lived in his properties...? I don't get it.
Geez, when I fled a very dangerous living situation, I was even afraid of seeing anything that resembled that person's CAR! I'd never have wanted to stay in their house. Good lord.
My father was abusive and I left home at 16 because of it. I am now in my 50's and I still get anxiety when I go home for a visit. I get anxious when I listen to the tapes they are playing, but not when AH is describing DV. AH words, facial expressions amd body language just don't mesh. I am just so shocked at how extra she was last week compaired to this week. I hope the jury sees through the BS.
I am a medical professional...actually did wound care nursing for a long time. The scars look way too even/uniform/neat, imo from what i can see here at least, to be from sliding/dragging/being pushed around on jagged irregular broken glass. Looks ALOT more like self inflicted intentional cuts to me. Cuts from glass obtained the way shes stating I would think would be more irregular, wouldnt heal as nicely, not perfect straight neat vertical lines. It isnt ideal to assess from a phone screen but thats what I see.
@@angelalurtz3638 she's right handed and the cuts are on her left arm ! What does that tell you ? If they're from being dragged across the floor wouldn't they be on both arms?
Jerry Judge commented on tape that the only cuts he saw on AH after the Sydney incident looked to be self-inflicted. Also, I doubt very much that the nurse would not have looked after AH if she was injured in any way and also noted any injuries. She has a duty of care towards both the people she was hired to look after AH mainly and JD.
@@shanie7192 now she claiming the nurse lied and falsified her records & notes. She also throwing her legal team under the bus claiming she has photos of everything & turned everywhere over but her team isn't using them. 😱🙄🤷♀️🤦♀️
If your arm was cut on glass, the cuts are not uniform. Broken glass is shards of different sizes and this appears like nails or razor cuts. Also how can makeup NOT cover healed scars on her arm but can cover a broken nose, two black eyes, swelling, and a busted lip????? 🤨🤔🤦🏿♀️
For someone who was repeatedly choked, she is awful comfortable with the high neckline of that outfit. Took me twelve years to be comfortable with crew neck clothing and necklaces, and the fear of necklaces and crew necks has been a bonding moment with other survivors. Her testimony is so fake her clothing calls her out.
🤗 Caregull Hugh? I ve been chocked and ended up on a ER and operating table, and barely made IT.😭 And still van t west things around nu Beck, and panick if I do. I learned tgrough years of therapy to wear kopse things around nu Beck, butt that's IT. So I wanted to give you a Hugh, if you are able to and want one, as I think I van dat I know hoe hard that must be for you.
As a survivor of domestic abuse and Sexual assault I just want to say this is disturbing .. I have attended group therapy for years and heard many different stories but not a single story ever sounded or looked like hers with the emotion and animation it’s so inconsistent when compared with real domestic abuse victims imo .. I’m also a nurse and the injuries without any care are absurd in my experience personal and professional victims usually get medical care but we lie about it
@@RedSquirrelsReturn Yes, it is so obvious I just hope the jury members, some of them at least, have had experience in so far as having known a woman who really was abused, somehow. Weird to say it, but for Johnny, the best thing here would be if some had known an abusive man or an abused womam, maybe seeing it somewhere in their own childhoods because then they'll easily see how much she's lying.
We don't claim her because she is a liar and everyone that's been on this situation can see it. You never push the buttons of an abuser or antagonize them or talk back because you'll get fucking murdered and thrown in the trash. She is NOT a victim
You walk on egg shells afraid of any little mistake you make can set them off. Red flags all over this lady, she is lying and I'd bet my own life on that.
The funniest comment I saw the other day was from this idiot on fb I haven’t unfriended so I can occasionally see their horrendous takes, well she said “I believe amber heard, anyone who supports Johnny depp clearly hasn’t been watching any of the trial” and I’m just like 🤯🤯🤯🤯 are we watching different trials? Even her own team enters evidence of her being the abooser, how on earth can ANYONE be watching this and seeing anything else but a lying female dog (amber)
@@lightasafeather9750 I would also think that DV survivors who file restraining orders do so because they are afraid of their abuser. This is the first time ever that I know of where the victim breaks her own order to meet with her abuser. If I'm a juror who hears that then I don't need anymore evidence. JD wins
Wait. So she has PTSD from abuse from jjohnny but she has no issue with the home where it happened or any other locations. She stops him from leaving. She feels she has enough power to hit him without then ending up in the hospital or dead. And the claims of physical abuse "didn't hurt". I'm sorry WHATTHEACTUALF***.
I can't stand it when people lie about having disorders they don't have or things people did to them for attention. It minimizes the experiences of actual victims and makes people that much more unwilling to trust them. Especially with me-too movement and the fake rape victims that are apart of it. It's absolutely disgusting.
And remember, when she filed for divorce she demanded exclusive use of some of depp’s properties plus the Range Rover!! having him still continue to pay for everything!! that’s not weird at all???
While she read the list of notes from nurse...The eating disorder etc... they were SELF REPORTED by Amber. Nurse didn't diagnose or get from medical reports as diagnosis. AGAIN They conveniently leave out details.
There were So Many Things She Just Would Not Accept Were True About Herself! If she could have one time admitted something bad said about her she may have been seen as a human. But I keep thinking about her hiding her phone on record after Johnny went to the hospital and they were back, when she was supposedly upstairs sleeping. She hid that phone set on recording because she knew they would be talking about her and she Had To Know What Any of Them Said About Her. I have Never met anyone this concerned about themselves, worried about what other people Say. My guess is every person working for Johnny knew how bad she was, worried about him, and gossiped about her a lot. I would have. The whole time cleaning that penthouse. I'd Talk about her meanness the whole time cleaning, I would talk about her to other employees too. Ya think she recorded the employees? I bet that some recordings of maids were on her "lost phone" also.
I find it very strange that she was not triggered by returning to their place in Australia. I had an attempted burglary at a place I used to live and I was triggered so much living there afterwards that I had to move homes. I was on constant guard and would sit watching from the window at night to ensure no one tried to break in again. Considering the place was supposedly a place of a major assault, to me it would be very triggering to return there.
I can’t even look at early pictures of my relationship without getting sick to my stomach because it reminds me of the emotional and mental abuse and manipulation from my SO. We are still together and much better now, but I can’t stand to look back at the past.
Icing something that’s swollen immediately after is not going to bring the swelling down. Swelling can last at least 3 days. And with the amount of hits, and “abuse” she’s claiming you’d think she’d have excessive amounts of swelling. This is too much l!
A broken nose not only causes bruising but the swelling changes a person’s voice, much in the same way that someone with a cold sounds. The swelling forces a person’s voice to sound different. If her nose was truly broken (meaning the cartilage was displaced), It would need to be reset and taped up. No amount of make up would cover that. Her waterlines would also be bruised and the only way to cover that is using the eyeliner pencil on the waterline (I don’t see she did this). A split lip doesn’t stop bleeding by putting lipstick over it and worse, it could cause further irritation and swelling. Her comment about how to cover bruising was all wrong, as well. Purple is covered by using orange, red is covered by using green, and blue is covered by using yellow. She clearly does not know what she is doing on bruise coverage.
Can confirm. I have twisted my ankle three times and all times the swelling would take days to go down entirely. That was just twisting, not broke, so for the amount of abuse she claims happened she would be unrecgonizable for at least three weeks.
@@tatianaameliaify: noticed she mentioned his *rings* today for the first time - of course she been scouring the internet for public*s reaction...........
We are clumsy here and I kicked myself in the eye with my knee by accident and had a swollen eyelid for days. It looked like make up with different colors depending on the bruise stage. Then my kid did the same thing a week later and we had matching kicked ourselves in the face injuries. Hers was from karate though lol There is no way it wouldn't have at least been puffy. And it's very very similar to having injections under the eye lids which I also have had similar bruising in the past
There is no way that amber isn't watching what everyone is saying about her on the internet. She is too much of a narcissist to resist. And she must have relayed all of it to her lawyers. Which she wasn't allowed to do. Absolutely insane.
I was just telling my husband that I thought that she has been watching social media to see what people are saying about her to. she has changed so much about how she is talking and acting. almost like oh you think this about me, I better change up my character a bit.
or... her lawyers saw the favors on the jury and told her.... they dont believe you either so you better stop the drama queen act and try to look real. 😊
I know it's a year later, but I always found it weird that the white coffee travel cup (the one with his recording studio logo) that appears in the bags of weed and breakfast with coke table was actually used by Amber in the kitchen cabinet video...
If she is so afraid he will enter “her” apartment anytime, why not stay with a friend for a while or rent a place or go to a hotel for a few nights? Why does she insist on staying in his property if she wants to lock him out? 🧐
This was so ridiculous! And how she complains that security wouldn't keep him out even though she asked them to. How could they not let him into his own apartment?? Like, if you're financially independent - get your own apartment and leave..
A point I haven't seen made yet: I never modeled but I wanted to since I was a toddler. Her lawyers made a point to say she also models, too. AnD yEt... basically every picture "documenting" her injuries have either no overhead lighting on at all (why would you not turn on ANY lights to show how bad the injuries were) or whatever light (natural or overhead) is BEHIND her, casting shadows automatically. As a model you always know where your light is and you have to find your light before you do anything else... Poor lighting like that will make my dark circles look like black eyes, and since she has absolutely no swelling that can be seen, I just find it hard to believe. She made sure to get pictures... so why is the lighting so bad, especially of herself as a model, plus there's almost more pictures of the house or Johnny instead of her injuries anyway!
My theory is that she used low light to emphasize whatever discoloration she had around her eyes, due to the shadows created by that lighting and natural features. My eyes look swollen and bruised during allergy season. Depending on the lighting, it’s more/less obvious.
@@elsie412ok the low light has to be intentional!! And the one with the light behind her head just had me shocked, everything was shadowed, like duh! If you're taking the time to take the picture for the reason of using it for documentation, there is absolutely no way you would not make things as clear and obvious as possible unless you are trying to make things darker and more exaggerated.
Wow! Can you imagine the mental abuse AH put JD through by telling him he was doing things he didn't remember! This is insane! AH is actually confessing her mental abuse she put upon him!
That’s why he started recording their fights. Amber would gaslight him and he started feeling crazy. I’ve been in his position. It’s not fun being told that something didn’t happen or you did something you didn’t do or you don’t feel the way you feel. It drives you mad and can blur the lines between what actually happened and what they’re making you believe happened.
Yeah she’s really committing to the story that JD doesn’t remember all this crazy shit he did and is positing an alternate reality that she has clearly fabricated.
Me, over here watching this for the millionth time, hearing new things and getting more upset about Amber twisting everything she did and putting it back on Johnny… EDB says “TMZ this isn’t your video…” 😂🤣😂 oh how much we have learned now! It is, in fact, their video. Crazy how everything makes sense when you rewatch it!
I'm still rewatching this trial. Knowing exactly what she's lying about makes watching it now like a lesson in the behavioral arts. I can see, ever so clearly, that she is very well aware that she is lying. You can see it in her eyes. There is no "her truth," as if she somehow believed that she was telling the truth. The whole thing was preconceived and orchestrated to pass herself off as this pillar of virtue versus his demonic, addicted monster.
My mum fell in the street on 19th March - she still has a bruise on her face today AND it’s still sore. Impossible to cover up like that every day. I gave her a colour corrector palette as it was my wedding the week after the fall and I have covered tattoos in the past. It was enough to reduce it and look ok in photos with well positioned hair but was still visible and swollen and used UNDER foundation to neutralise colour and give a base of an even tone. Also, no foundation would ever give sufficient SPF, let alone for someone with a skin condition. She would need 1/4 teaspoon of a dedicated high factor product every day and reapplied regularly, especially living in LA.
Not only is it odd that she always uses tinted foundation as her sunscreen, WHY would she go to the courthouse without makeup? Wouldn't that irritate her skin issue? She ALWAYS uses makeup except for that one day?
For someone who went out of her way to record every conversation and fight they had, you’d think she’d be taking photos of all this apparent “physical abuse”. Nothing but a few photos where you need a magnifying glass just to see what they are alleging is there….
Amber testified that Johnny sexually assaulted her with a bottle AFTER severing the tip of his finger. They showed a picture of the bottle taken the next morning. She identified it as the same bottle. There wasn't a drop of blood on it. How is that possible if he's holding it in his hand with a severed finger? There would have been blood all over that room. I know because I've severed a fingertip.
Yep. All the secret recordings he didn’t know about yet not one confrontation of her being beaten and serious discussion about him being physically abusive. It was always her
Speaking from experience, those are self harm scars. Being dragged through broken glass doesn’t give you perfectly straight, evenly spaced and clean scars. Also interesting that it’s her left arm in the photos…
Couch definitely wasn’t their safe word…if my memory serves me right she screamed and demanded it a handful of times. Plus she even said “come here” or something like that so I feel she’s lying about it to cover her ass.
I'm re watching all of your coverage on this trial, I absolutely love the way you cover it, so un bias but also so animated I love it. Heards testimony triggers me so much. I am a survivor of dv/sa and I really dislike how she tried to say "all/everyone" people who go through dv do xyz. It frustrates me, no one incident of dv is the same, and no two ppl react the same way, there may be similar experience or reactions but never the exact same
Yeah Exactly..! This is typical narc behaviour, everyone else is a liar and only the narc is telling the truth! The funny thing is that she doesnt even realize that all she does is exposing herself as a liar. Johnnys team should just let her be on the stand since is digging her own grave and it’s getting deeper every minute!
Not only is she calling everyone a liar, but she's basically saying everyone is spineless, moral-less people that would watch a battered woman and do absolutely nothing. So pitiful. Shes disgusting.
She refuses to take accountability for anything that has happened in her life although she has caused the majority of it. Her best thing she could do is accept her responsibility and move out of the country
There is no way that the situation in Australian was as violent toward her as she is claiming and she wasn't triggered by going back there. She claims he violently SA her and she was afraid for her life? But she wasn't afraid of a repeat or similar event when they returned to the same place just a few months later???? That is just unbelievable and inconsistent with DV survivor behaviour and PTSD. I was kind of on the fence before about believing at least some of her story but this was the thing that has pushed me over the edge. She is being dishonest.
Exactly. The mere mention of the city or state would trigger me so badly after I left my very sexually abusive relationship. 15 years later, I still don't ever want to go back to that state or city.
@@Keap16 same here. I left the state in 2009, 2 months after leaving a DV/SA relationship that ended with him trying to unalive me. To this day, I can’t even consider going back there without feeling triggered and terrified.
The truth does slip out every now and then, doesn't it? It is not easy to lie and one's brain tends to leak verbally. I hope it makes sense what I am saying here, english is not my first language so sorry if it doesn't!
So her defense is that he was too messed up on drugs & alcohol that he didn’t know what he was doing/can’t remember? How convenient. A person who is that deep into addiction as she describes would never have been able to function out in the world and anyone coming in contact with him would have been deeply concerned and seeking a higher level of care for him. He certainly wouldn’t have been able to do all that’s required in a leading or supportive role in a movie, which we all know he did while they were together. I’m a licensed psychotherapist & certified addictions counselor, and there’s just no way this makes sense to me. This looks like one giant gaslighting attempt by Heard.
I can't take it. This woman is a liar. The things she is saying has happened to her is not believable. don't you think there would be so many visible injuries..all that broken glass and she never said anyone's feet was cut. And paparazzi would have been all over that. I'm having panic attacks from this case. I was dragged by my hair and beaten in my face until I was unrecognizable and lost my baby. The thought to want to hide the abuse while it was happening is ridiculous. How could her parents have seen her so badly beaten and still close with johnny. When I was abused Everyone that saw me police, and the hospital workers saw. There was proof. She is the biggest liar I ever seen. this defecation case is unreal. Class action lawsuit!!!! This liar is causing damage
As someone who suffers from hallucinations, I hate how AHs team is trying to demonize it and mental health issues in general. If he really did hallucinate, that’s terrible for JD and I really feel for him if it’s true.
I'm sorry for your situation and I agree. If he was detoxing, it is very likely he was hallucinating and she's despicable for using it against him and to gaslight him if she really did care about his recovery. I like how CV is pointing out that the photos and videos of him detoxing is another form of abuse she's putting JD through. She's using it to try to embarrass him and drag him down. She should have been supporting him. I've heard stories of my step dad while he was detoxing in the hospital after almost dying from serotonin syndrome and he was hallucinating all sorts of strange crazy things. Luckily my mom and the nurses were there to help him come back to reality. I wish Johnny would have had the right support during those times. I really think her goal was to get him to OD so she could take all of his money. She didn't want him to get better at all.
@@stormy7318 This is exactly what I believe she decided to do after she realized she could not completely control him or his money, through her various schemes manipulating, intimidating, gaslighting and isolating him (from all his good friends who cared about him and his kids too) when all that did not break him down enough so that he'd just roll over and let her control everything, when he brought up divorce, she decided to start creating evidence she could claim showed how depressed and dysfunctional he was on drugs, and things that would make him look unstable. She intended to push him to kill himself, but thankfully he escaped in time..
Every time she describes Johnny being abusive, I see him turning into The Hatter getting angry and shouting at her in a scottish accent!😂😂😂 She’s making up a story, so I make up one too!😂😂😂
@@amandafeliciano542 Am I a bad person for laughing now when she describes what he’s shouting at her? The whole thing is just so absurd, I can’t help myself!😂
Just commenting on the LINE people were doing beforehand - other LawTube streamers were explaining, it was an EXTENSIVE line, and you had to get there early -- think Black Friday early. The fact that everyone showing up for it was numbering themselves, cooperating, and basically honor-system-ing their places... its amazing. Such a high profile case - youd expect there to be mayhem, but people were reasonable, calm, helping eachother.. i was kind of heartwarming.
So am I hearing this right? At 3:34:00 she said she wasn’t wearing “a stitch of make up,” then at 3:41:00, when asked about the people saying she wasn’t wearing “a stitch of make-up,” she said “they don’t know what they’re talking about, I always wear make up.” Make it make sense!
Of course she has changed! I guarantee that her whole team replayed everything and reviewed her testimony…they have been coaching her from day one! I hope the jury is smart enough to see through her lies!
Assuming sarcasm here, it's like she has watched everything, everyone has said about her testimony and has changed her answers and demeanor to suit. Also, the way she is retracting what she has already said makes it appear that she has consulted with her lawyers, especially the way she was questioned about the makeup, so obvious.
Also, I’m a wound care therapist. A young, well healing adult would not have scars several months later. Maybe a few days. She would be healed and they would be gone. Also these do not appear to be made from running on glass. I treat people with imbedded glass. Too straight. Just my perspective.
The Narcissist's Prayer That didn't happen. And if it did, it wasn't that bad. And if it was, that's not a big deal. And if it is, that's not my fault. And if it was, I didn't mean it. And if I did, you deserved it.
Okay, having such a direct insight into the jury was soo fascinating and informative, so thank you DUI guy and Emily for making this happen! This channel is THE place for trial insight
She said the bathroom door/toes incident was later in that recording, yet you heard Johnny ask at the beginning of the recording “how are your toes”?! He says it in a way as if she may have shut the door on her own toes too!
Wow, that dog is a veterinary marvel, a teacup dog that has bowel movements the size of a human - freaking remarkable! I'm not an attorney, but why is the judge allowing this, doesn't this set up the likelihood of an appeal?
I know and it also has the ability to remove itself from a bed without breaking bones , no kidding a dog that size could snap its legs jumping off a bed
When she said she wanted the Divorce/TRO private & under the radar - takes me right back to her testimony in 2016 where she literally let's slip that "TMZ were already alerted" and as soon as she realised what she'd just let slip, she slap wipes both sides of her face with her hands as though trying to wipe the words away - its the most hilarious thing to witness I can still see it🤣😂🤣
When she said "bruise kit" it sound like she slipped up and was referring to her stage makeup she used to CREATE a bruise, not conceal it. All she's talking about with color correction and arnica cream is everything every person who's ever gotten botox or fillers already knows. This is maddening testimony to watch - especially as someone who's experienced psychological manipulation and gaslighting just like this first-hand. I feel SO bad for Johnny having to sit and listen to this - I've been there and it's devastating. It's psychologically devastating.
Yep and its so easy to make a fake bruise. Im an amateur but ive done makeup for halloween/zombie walk just from using basic cheap supplies and a couple hrs watching tutorials, and it looked VERY realistic.
Johnny is doing battle right now just by sitting there holding onto his sanity and letting the court play out the way it’s supposed to. This is historic for us all. Calling it a bruise kit is a Freudian slip.
Her psychiatrist diagnosed with PTSD and Johnny's did not they found her to be deceptive on the test. She clearly said in her testimony that the home is just a home and that doesn't have memories or trigger memories for her well that is the definition of PTSD being triggered by places sounds and sensations even smells so she's talking crap. Many survivors of DV have trouble with their surroundings where violence has taken place it has triggered for them.
Thank you for your comment. When I left my abuser,I left the apartment and never returned, even though it was in my name. I had my brother deal with everything with regards to that apartment, there was no way in hell I'd ever entered that place again. Even passing by that area gave me anxiety. I now live happily in a different country,this trial brings up all kinds of emotions. I don't believe a word coming out of that woman's mouth.
So true. When I was 10 my brother sa me. When we left the house it happened in I at least had relief from all the places and triggers...bedroom, bed, parents dresser, etc. He still lived with my family in the next house but at least as I got older I learned how to avoid him. Your comment is spot on. Yet another inconsistency in her testimony. Her testimony is better known as stories.
are you a doctor? are you aware that ptsd can manifest in (shockingly) more than one singular way? - saying this as someone who has been dx w ptsd by a psychiatrist btw dont discredit ppls experiences just because it doesnt fit within your perfect narrative and last time i checked personal experience & youtube university isnt enough knowledge to be able to credit or discredit someones experience
There's no way she wasn'tdiscussing her testimony with her attorneys during dark week! Damage limitation is in full force this week. So far I haven't seen any of the previous "my dog stepped on a bee" overacting (mind you, I'm only 30 minutes into the video so plenty of time left to prove me wrong!)
In her testimony, AH never said: "He hit me in the face and then I've immediately went to put ice on my face to mediate swelling." She only told about ice, when she was talking about the "bruise kit".
It's been interesting listening to her testimony and I think one of the things people are confused about-her being fearful of her life yet 'fighting back'-is due to the fact that even though she is going with the fearful story, she also has a consistent need to assert qualities that she thinks would put her in a good light, i.e, she wants to make sure to add that she was brave and daring, which is why she fought back. You also see this connected to her previous language where she mentions (seemingly disappointed about it) that she never managed to 'land one' on Johnny Depp up until the staircase incident. 'Land one' rather than 'punch' or 'hit' expresses more of a sense of victory and pride. Perhaps subconsciously she thinks managing to punch Depp despite bodyguard between them (or her sister, according to Amber's testimony, iirc) is a positive quality because it underlines her physical victory in that moment.
She was clearly coached during the break to adjust to what we've all been talking about online. It feels strange that they are now answering the internet's questions on the stand. The jury is probably confused AF by the change in behavior. This feels wrong to me. Oh wait, around 3:20:00 there's that overacting we saw before the break. 😯did she call Umbridge a liar? Umbridge said that was the compact Amber carried in opening... the way around the truth is just to say "obviously not".. I wish that Milani employee had waited until after Amber testified.
@@angelgendvilas4254 As Emily has said dozens of times since she began covering this trial, Amber Heard and her lawyers (along with Depp and his team) are not barred from looking at info related to the trial outside of court. They were instructed not to discuss her testimony with her over the break, but it very much seems as though they did. Witnesses who are not listed in the suits and are subject to be called later and jurors are the ones who can't look at or talk about the case.
@@mzcytin ok. I didn’t quite understand the difference I guess. It sure is backpedaling and they clearly discussed testimony. And her fake crying!! I mean come on.
Literally I have been saying that exact same thing. Just from the audio tapes you see how taunting she is to him and who knows what wasn't caught by him, she wasn't gonna record how they got in their fights but she made sure to record him when he finally snapped and couldn't take it anymore. He showed incredible restraint. She could probably make the nicest, most gental person and make them violent. One can only take so much after so long and she seems like she is the reigning queen at that. One can only hope the jury sees that, or thinks about how they most likely would/could have reacted just by what they heard from her and multiple that by 20 as you know she probably wasn't caught on audio as much as him
@@heathermarie428 , as far as I know, AH says that they recorded each other so she could further her narrative of being the victim cause almost all the recordings, if taken out of context, sound like JD was the aggressor but AH was the one who recorded the bulk of their relationship! Suggesting JD recorded when she had no idea, she still didn't sound like the aggressor! JD didn't have a reason to record her because he was being manipulated by her and didn't realize that she had an agenda pretty early in the relationship; that's why she was collecting "evidence" of his supposed abuse yet never really got anything proving it! AH even stated that JD accidentally hit record on her phone, and it recorded for 5 hours that night; she cut his finger, yet at the end of that recording, you can clearly hear AH approach the recording device that she hid somewhere; she's speaking to JJ she approaches the device tears it off of wherever it was stuck on, hiding, and she continues talking as you hear the tape being ripped off the device also... I do not believe it was her phone and that she was without her phone for 5 hours during all the alleged and actual chaos! There are UA-cam videos of the 5-hour audio; I'm not sure why she lied about who recorded it; I think because where ever they were in Australia, it is a one-party rule, so if she said that she or JD purposely recorded for 5 hours then the recording could be used in court, but if no one supposedly knew it was recording I guess it can't be used? I don't get it cause at the end; it was obviously AH that planted the recording device! AH does not want that recording heard; she'll not only be caught lying about recording JD, but over the 5 hours you hear that Dr. Kipper and her nurse, security and others talk about AH's abuse of JD, AH admits she cut his finger off, she is also trying to manipulate the situation! They talk about her drug use and giving her something to calm down, and whether it will effect any drugs she may have taken, they talk about her having an affair, and JJ speaks to numerous people in the house and on his phone about having to send someone who is strong and can handle her manipulations and if she freaks out on her way back to LA! JD's team only sounds concerned about getting her the heck out of Australia and away from JD so he will finally break up with her; they also imply AH put a cigarette out on JD's cheek and tried to blame JD for doing it to himself! JJ also talks in a whisper on the phone about how he has to be careful because AH will hide and listen-in on conversations, and he also says she hides a recording device and records conversations! (Is that not crazy!) The whole recording is very telling! So I guess I'm probably right about why AH said it was recorded by accident! I haven't watched today's afternoon testimony yet, I'm too frustrated by AH, but I'm hoping cross will at least make a bit of it tolerable!! Sorry for the long post. I've got no one to discuss this with!! What I think is so crazy, is that both JD's team and AH's team have heard and seen everything so both teams must be well aware of who was the abuser and who was the victim! I could never defend something so deplorable!!!
I am not a victim and this triggers me. My heart goes out to all those who have gone thru this. I have had to stop and start so many times out of frustration. In my opinion, Her and her lawyers voice are quickly becoming the most annoying sound in the world.
Thanks Amber for clarifying and educating me about the "aemeca cream" 🤣 Arnica is really helpful firstaid for preventing dark bruises, that is true. But not if you got hit with a fist full of metal🤷
🙌 yes!! It’s a like her whole time on the stand is one giant Freudian slip. When she looks around, seeing how she is landing you can see the frustration in her face of being ignored by JD when she glanced at him.
When talking about the dog's incontinence her expression immediately changes as she bites the inside of her cheek in an attempt to conceal her duper's delight, and a smile actually slips out at 'so she doesn't lose control of her bowel.'
@Vangelina Barrow I believe it’s from the CreepshowArt drama thing. When Shannon was exposed for all of her BS behavior, she came out with a 2-hour-long video of her trying to gaslight everyone and that was a line that she used. Everyone needed to “go touch some grass” and get a life or whatever. It was a meme, can’t believe that person is saying it un-ironically
The " trashed house" looks like it's staged by someone who has never seen a trashed house and didn't want to actually break their stuff even the memory box she said was dumped from her childhood. What did he do gently tip it over why would he go in her office and just gentle dump one box why isn't it everywhere it makes no sense
So she was walking UP the stairs to get back to the party, Johnny grabbed her shirt, spilled wine, changed shirt, then she said she walked DOWN the stairs to join the party. Was the party upstairs or down. Like Emily says, I have questions.
This might be a case of the house having more than one staircase. Some mansion houses will have extra staircases at the back so you can go to different levels without having to go to the front of the house, almost like stairs for servants for example.
Doesn’t Amber have a history of hurting herself? a.k.a. the cuts on her arm those cuts look very organized and very methodical isn’t it possible she could’ve done that herself?
Yes. In the recording of depp saying he was going to cut himself she said "trust me, it doesn't work". It's clear she was saying she had cut herself before.
Funny also how she was trying to keep things “quiet” but yet not ONE TIME did she try hiding her face from the paparazzi and instead she walked with her head held high, chin out showing the wooorrrllldddd her face! …and how nice of them to back track the makeup!! 😂🤣😂🤣 lol because they KNEW that was gunna kill here case, must of been nice to have that week off to prep for this!!! Ugh!! I can’t stand liars!
she walked with her lawyer in the FRONT DOOR of a court room where she had no need to be (the TRO can be filed remotely, only a court clerk is needed) and for SOME REASON the press was already hot on her tail, gee i wonder how that happened---- then the video leak of the kitchen 'scene' ? gee i wonder who leaked that one.. etc. etc. etc.
What she called him hallucinating was her gaslighting him. What a disgusting woman! Can you imagine to have to live with her? Hell on earth! I'm so glad justice was served!
Yeah because if he had a book Oh damn no, she had the book. She twisted everything! He had no chance with her, I would think nobody does. The glaring fact that she thinks up until the end of her Rebuttal testimony That She Is Going To Win Money From Him, that she thinks she "got" this jury on her "side", is mind boggling. This case built on nothing but her testimony, a few friends not friends enough to come testify, and her few messed up experts? Her sister was the only one, and that sure does not outweigh Everything else we have seen. They had to get Whitney in there, I'm sure the lawyers told Whitney that much. She had nothing but her "tall tale". And I knew nothing about Depp ever getting married so I listened to this well.
This keeps looking worse and worse for her... I mean he still has a huge mountain to overcome in order to win the case, but she is definitely making that mountain more manageable.
I think the makeup story would be semi more believable if she showed up to court everyday full glam with eyelashes and all. I mean she mastered covering bruises but can't cover under eye circles now? Yookay
I have had a black eye before, it took three days of holding ice on my face for swelling to go down and two and half weeks to completely heal, it was still purple in some areas up until the last few days… I guess AH has magical healing powers
Watching from NZ. The live started at 1:00am our time, had to sleep. Can't believe we're only a few minutes in and it's obvious Heard's been talking with her lawyers to fix her lies.
How can they not see she is literally changing her story after the exact issues social media has brought up. Wtf She wasn't supposed to be on social media since she's on the witness stand right?
I'm a veterinarian. It's so weird hearing her talk about her dog's incontinence issues, especially the way she lead into it - saying that her dog ate Johnny's weed, then kind of implying that that caused the dog's lifelong incontinence afterwards? Yeah, that makes no sense, that would be really unusual. the dog was fecal incontinent for some other reason. Weed ingestion can cause urinary incontinence while the dog is high, but fecal incontinence long-term? Sounds kinda... Suspicious. I dunno. It just seems like she put that in there to remind the jury that Johnny does drugs... Rolling my eyes over here. Besides if the dog was really fecal incontinent and they were doing a workup about it, there would be medical records that would confirm this!
Even if any of her story was true... why would you not just clean it up? Why was it left there to be found? Especially if your husband is so abusive and beat you for every little things
@@ximar0ckstrx I think she’s claiming that she didn’t know.
@@ximar0ckstrx the way AH piles it up hers is bigger than the whole dog
My question hearing that was: you know your dog (allegedly) has little to no control over their bowels. Why would you put it on the bed and leave it there while you're out packing for a long time? Common sense says if you suspect your dog will use the bathroom at any point then put it in a pen with a potty pad, not on your bed!
Yeah, she shit on johnnys bed and is now blaming it on the dog AND johnny... i hope the jury is as fed up with her bullshit as we are...
"Bruise kit" and "theatre makeup kit" both refer to kits used to *create* the appearance of bruises not cover them. Color correction for improving appearance (covering under-eye circles, blemishes, bruising) isn't common in theatre makeup because the audience is far enough away that even dark bruises covered with foundation aren't noticeable. Even things as dark as tattoos are just covered with a bandaid, not heavy makeup.
"Theatre makeup" could be referring to the Ben Nye brand, which is known for their compacts for creating bruises, but also makes normal color correction kits. So she could mean that.
But ultimately, if you're actually trying to cover something, you have to put the corrector *underneath* a concealer/foundation or both. Putting it on top would make it too prominent and would look very odd. But it's consistent with the order you'd use to *create* the appearance of a bruise. Huh. Interesting.
As a side note, Ben Nye makeup works great with watercolors and sculptures that need a bit of a light touch up. I'll fight everyone who says I'm wasting it in the name of art.
Back on topic, though, she also stated she put her concealer and whatnot OVER her makeup, which is what you do with bruise makeup. EVERYONE and their cat knows anything to do with correction goes UNDER the makeup!
Dang guys - this is great inside info.
Exactly! If she puts the colour corrector on top of the foundation and concealer the bruised area will look like a green/peach/whatever blob over the bruised area. The corrector goes beneath the rest of the base makeup.
@@octogonSmuggler See I knew that her "order" was wrong if trying to hide a bruise. Bc I know you'd use the color corrector first b4 concealer & foundation. But my exact question as I watched was wait ... If you are creating a bruise w\a "bruise kit" or theatere makeup, what is the correct "order" they use to CREATE said bruise. & Correct me if I'm wrong, but you ARE saying that those same theatere makeup artists would use the order she gave (foundation >concealer>bruise kit) when creating a fake bruise?! Bc WOW is that telling on herself triple w\just that 1 statement! 👀🙄😳
She totally told on herself with that one. No one who has ever used color corrector would so confidently state that it “obviously” goes after foundation and concealer. Plus, calling it a bruise kit, which means something very specific to those who are actors. I bet Johnny’s ears perked up at that one.
Along with saying that lipstick can conceal a split lip twice now, she is really counting on that mostly male jury to not pick up on such ridiculous lies. Her arrogance is astounding.
Amber: “I didn’t do drugs with Johnny”
Also Amber: “I took MDMA on a plane with Johnny” 🤦♂️
Love how the nursing notes are right when they support her case but wrong when don't.
Amber's cross-examination was like -
"You had two apples, right?"
"Yes, I had two fruits that looked like apples in the photograph."
"And you got two more from the shop."
"Yes"
"So you had four apples after that, isn't it?"
"I would disagree with that characterization of it."
How about blaming the dog lol tee cup Yorke that poops little mice size
The housekeeper (poor lady) wrote a testimony in letter.
Even the video explanation was wrong! She has Her Purse over her shoulder so was she at a different house, slept on the couch, just woke up, or fighting and leaving? Damn the stories never make sense with or without proof.
😂 this is brilliant
For a DV victim, she talks extremely condescending on the tapes to her "abuser"....I would be terrified to talk to him like she does if he was that "abusive" to her....
Isn't she practically taunting her aledged abuser? Not something I would think to be very wise...
Definitely! She talks the way an abuser would talk to her victim. No victim would taunt, belittle, blame and berate their abuser the way she did JD. She kept going and going at him, deliberately escalating the verbal fight, and then attacking him for leaving the situation in order to deescalate the situation. She wanted the drama she created, and was frustrated with him for not going along with it. Been there. Done that. My narcissist scarred me for life, and he was a walk in the park compared to AH.
I think they abused eachother. Toxic.
Exactly!! She would taunt him and instigate. An abused person DOES NOT behave this way towards their abuser.
I disagree. I was involved in a relationship very similar to this (minus the millions lol) and I would retaliate verbally during his sober non-psychosis moments and then the pendulum would swing back on his 3rd day no sleep and I was being choked and had my ribs broken. I never sought medical treatment. I was trauma bonded to this person and I relate to Amber so much. To me, she is not lying.
There is no way that Amber Herd & her attorneys weren’t communicating about her testimony during the last week. It’s obvious they went through line by line, formulated ways to correct the inconsistencies, & then rehearsed the questions & answers for the upcoming testimony that’s occurring today. This should be acknowledged & penalized, & it’s very frustrating that it’s being ignored right now 🙄
And they clearly viewed the criticisms of her testimony and the over the top acting and coached her to change it.
Sadly, there's no way to prove it.
She’s allowed to review her testimony and to look at what the public is saying. But 100% they are coaching her directly on the stand it’s crazy. Edit: YALL I didn’t say discuss. I said REVIEW. As in she is allowed to rewatch footage/clips herself and make any changes she sees fit (even if I agree it seems like she’s discussed it with her lawyers)
@@mscookie3613 no, she is not allowed to discuss her testimony with her lawyers.
@@mscookie3613 she was to be in isolation and was not supposed to discuss her testimony with ANYONE. no one. Not her lawyers, not with ANYBODY.
I can't believe this judge is allowing this testimony!! It's completely obvious that they spoke about her testimony during break. WHAT ARE THERE EVEN RULES IF THEY AREN'T GOING TO BE ENFORCED?
the rules are for anyone not rich or famous!
I mean you have to have proof right. in court a judge isn't gonna be like hey c'mon guysss it sounds like you guys talked about your testimony!! but yes clearly they had a chat. It didnt help lol
@@Bbelblelo I get ya. It's obvious they could never prove it, I just thought once you made a statement under oath - you made a statement under oath! I didn't think you could go back and correct basically your whole testimony (again not really her WHOLE testimony) and there not be some legal consequence. So why even have them testify "under oath" if they can just change it when they realize their lies didn't add up? To me that's infuriating. And I've noticed a lot of states don't make you swear to God & put your hand on a Bible anymore. Say hello to socialism. The only authority now is the state. And the stoned face liar she is, I pray he wins just because of how badly she lies. Lol
@@Bbelblelo I wish that they would
@@Bbelblelo she might make a note of it in her final statements after the jury rules
I love how she's trying to frame the video of him slamming cabinets was supposedly him hallucinating when, in fact, he'd just found out his accountants had stolen a massive amount of money from him, his mother was in the ICU and at the beginning you can hear him yelp in pain, so he probably hit his injured finger on something by accident and that all combined to trigger the outburst. Even during the video she's trying to make it about HER when it had nothing to do with her.
That part was so fucked up. It actually really made me angry.
Not only that, but the way the whole video was set up just screams that she was purposely putting on an act! The way she said "We didn't fight this morning, u were sleeping so peacefully" in a voice not like her regular one tried to portray her as very meak and intimidated. Like, we hear how she sounds regularly on the stand. We hear how she sounds when she's DEVESTATED on the stand. We hear how she sounds when she's ANGRY in the video and voice recordings. But this one felt very much like a Placed Dialogue, and it didn't go her way.
It’s so horrifying. I don’t know how he is this strong to keep up. And make it through this. He really is something else.
finding out about the betrayal of his team, & huge money loss.
The other thing is the birthday lol
Such a big deal he wasn’t there BUT he was out at a business meeting.. she wants that life style that he was funding.. well some ppl work & without his meetings there is no money. It’s ridiculous how she obsessed about the birthday. Get over it.
The way she does the...."we're not even fighting this morning " shit makes me FUCKING SICK.
When I left my abuser he took his life. And I not only left our home. I left the city. I sold all the furniture. Even the car. Bc PTSD is real. She is lying and it’s really upsetting
💔
I'm sorry for you going through his suicide. I imagine that caused a further mix of emotions:(
She is doubling down on her lies. And trying to gaslight the whole world, not just Johnny.
To quote Mr. Meeseeks, "Ooohh, she's tryin'!"
This is such familiar behavior. Doubling-down…like with the cracked lip on the Cordon show…textbook narcissism.
Absolutely! That's EXACTLY what she's trying to do! She's doing us just like she did him, & trying her damnedest to convince us that we are crazy & didn't just see her lie & contradict herself for the millionth time! Like COME ON! We have instant replay!
She is gaslighting herselfe too. She belives this her selfe. Sad realy, I hope she finaly gets help for her mental illness and Johny gets justice.
you nailed it!
She said that she didn’t want to take her divorce public… But according to the tapes or the recordings… She was the one that wasn’t afraid to take a public and Johnny was trying to tell her that he wanted to keep things private! She’s such a liar
She she's the one sold all kinds to tmz and put it all out there to ruin his reputation. I mean omg such a liar
Good catch !!
She’s straight up friggin pathological. She can’t even keep her lies straight. The things she says aren’t even believable. This is hard to watch. She’s a terrible awful person.
She was also the one who clearly called TMZ and tipped them off so they would be there when she came with her makeup bruise to get the TRO, although she still tries to say Johnny, who had no idea she was going to get the damned thing, tipped them off even though it would have looked bad on him so why the hell would he do that, ya know? She's also the one who got ahold of every publication she could to get her lies and fake bruise pictures out. That's the moment it was all made public. She wanted it public when she was destroying Johnny with lies but wants it private when she's being destroyed by truth.
No worries it is coming the next day on cross
I'm an expert witness and while we are taught to speak directly to the jury, when the defendant does it, it's a bit creepy.
I agree
she's definitely trying to convince the jury. if God made them like he made me, they're all human lie detectors and see through this cloud of bullcrap
Elaine keeps telling her "tell the jury" I think she's been told to do that. So weird!
I said this on an older video but that is what bothers me about AH on the stand is she speaks, acts, answers, holds herself ALL LIKE AN EXPERT WITNESS giving a testimony. Not like a victim giving a testimony.
@@plutomaxwell I think that is because she is such a narcissist!!!!!!
You know what's scary? If she weren't so insistent on the abuse being over the top she might've actually pulled off making JD out to be a violent monster. You know, like "I was yelling in his face and he slapped me" instead of the "he punched me with his big ringed hand repeatedly". Her pictures could be of a heavy slap or such but there's no way they're from her description of the fights. Thank God she overacts!
It just lends validity to Johnny's sisters testimony that she couldn't take Amber seriously because she was always overreacting and exaggerating things.
Yes I agree. If she had said he hit her once or slapped her but her insane over the top violence where she is claiming he is punching her in the face over and over is obviously ridiculous. Even the picture that shows a slight mark and maybe a shadow under an eye, even a couple days later in bad light like she claims does in no way line up with what an assault like that would look like.
Excellent point!👍
@@GretchenTheGreat You are 100% accurate on bruising and gravity.
Her overacting is part of the histrionic personality disorder which also contributed to the severity of their fights. Johnny just didn't realize what he was dealing with.
It's so insane she said she put her moisturizer with tint then foundation and concealer THEN color correction with a THEATER bruise kit. Which if you google bruise kit they all look like milani but are the actual bruise making kits. She basically gave the order for how you'd MAKE a bruise, not color correct it.
yep
Also the kit wasn’t available at that time
That also doesn’t prove depp did it is the problem
She is in action movies so who’s to say is the jury thinking
I have skin lupus also makes welps on my face people think I get beat 🤣
If AH was so “terrified” that JD would “accidentally kill” her, why would she EVER belittle him for not staying and “fighting” her as she stated in that now infamous audio tape? Why would she stay and secretly record him and get snarky toward him when he was very upset and slamming kitchen cabinets? And, why didn’t Johnny then follow the “usual” abuse pattern as claimed by AH of him, slapping, hitting, striking, etc her in the face and head, pulling her hair, bashing her head with or against something? No, he yelled at her and slammed the cabinets and then as a FU poured himself a “mega cup” of wine all while unaware he was being recorded. Were she really a victim of the abuse that she has so theatrically thrown -up to us with her abysmal acting on the stand, she would not have stayed in that room for 10 seconds let alone goad him and take the chance of being caught videotaping him.
It’s interesting they cut the last bit of tape of “mega pint” video when she laughed at the end.
💯💯💪🏿
She can’t make it make sense and that’s going to destroy her (or at least I hope it does)
Yep and if hes so abusive why didnt he attack then when hes obviously in a full rage already and shes there instigating and pushing. Seems like thatd be the time, if ever, that hed attack
@@EmmaHolland her friend "got through" to him by treating him like a wild horse. She put her hands up and said NO. (/heavysarcasmjustincaseitwasntobvious) 🐎🤡
I love Ambers “reactive hitting” testimony, considering the fact that, in her own words, the only time she ever hit Johnny was when he was about to “push” her sister down the stairs. 🤭 Hopefully it gets brought up in cross 😋
edit: another thing too, i’ve thought about it for a while, with the video of the cabinets, if your abuser is angry and taking it out on objects, and you were terrified of it turning on to you, you would NOT say something like “stop slamming the cabinets”. that’s like a death sentence. telling your abuser what to do…no victim would do that especially not when they’re angry like that. she’s full of it.
That's right - a potential victim would make herself scarce *or* try to assuage him, but certainly would not film or provoke.
@@Nonameforyoudangit EXACTLY! Nor would she insert herself into the middle of something if the anger wasn't directed at her in ANY WAY! If she's not the object of his rage at that moment, she's NOT going to CALL ATTENTION to herself when he's not looking at her, not mentioning her, nor paying her any mind. At that moment, she's completely irrelevant to him. & Yet she goes OUT OF HER WAY to call attention to herself. You wouldn't want him to shift the focus of his rage to you if you're deathly scared of him! That doesn't make a LICK of sense!
She also keeps saying every time they get in a fight, he leaves. Which is it? Does he get violent or walk away every time?
There is no way an abused person would aggravate their abuser for fear of them turning on you. She's a manipulator
This is totally true. I was in them situations fir way too long and if he was taking it out on something else I wouldn't say a thing because I know then it would be taken out on me.also recording him ,especially if it was obvious. I would be afraid I wouldn't make it out. 6 years later and I still have nerve damage in my face from him. Also when I was hit the way she claimed no makeup would cover it. He broke my nose and I had black eyes and a swollen face for weeks. It makes me sick hearing her lying like this when there is so many people actually go threw. Its not hard to tell what's lies especially if you went threw it of knows someone who did/is.
For anyone in this situation, theres a way out. You can get help and first its going to suck but I promise it gets better.picl up the phone and make that first step of the rest of your lives. Speak to someone,theres lots of help and 24 hours crises centers in your area that can help. It breaks my heart to think how many people go threw this every seconds of the day. Stay strong 💙💞🌈
Anyone else find it odd that AH has the makeup skills to cover a broken nose (black eyes assumed), split and bleeding lip, and a myriad of other facial injuries, but not the skill to cover faded scars on her arms?
Her face is able to heal 24 hours after a supposed attack, but her arms take months to heal? 😂😂😂
I’m more amazed at her skills to hide swelling. After her testimony and seeing the pictures all I can remember is Rihanna’s pictures after she was physical abused.
It’s interesting that she can cover a couple black eyes, a busted lip, and a broken nose flawlessly the day after an assault with makeup, but the arm scars were “too hard to hide”
Also, she has circles under her eyes. Shouldn’t she not if she is a master in make up artistry?
Those scars were far too linear, they're all straight cuts, and are all vertically aligned, and there's only 3 of them, and considering where they are on her arm, they're in a place people couldn't see.
She alleged that in that situation she was flat on her back, meaning the front of her arms would of been in contact with the broken glass on the countertop, but somehow the scars are on the backside of her forearm, if someone is holding you down, or on top of you, your palms need to be facing downwards into to try to push upwards.
Those scars seem like definite self harm, and she then used the scars to build a whole story around. Notice how they had evidence of the scars on her arms, but no scars on her feet? still no pictures of any other damage she supposedly received during that entire incident?
I think it bothers her a Lot that his finger injury is More Important than her "alleged" injury. She hurt him badly, but she hates he gets any sympathy, because it's always about her to her. Nothing can be more important than her or or anything about her.
@@MasterIceyy I agree, I think she hurt him but then on the plane had to do something to gain sympathy. She had been on the phone with friends & most importantly she had listened to the secretly recorded talks everyone at the house had while he was at the hospital & she was upstairs at the house. Those recorded said it was her, she caused his finger injury, and faulted her clearly. What to do but make herself injured too so they couldn't blame her. She cut herself on the plane, that's why she was in the bathroom so long. Desperate to shift blame & get oh poor me sympathy from her friends. Shrew, she's a Shrew plainly.
Did they ask to see the scars on her arms? If she was slices up she would have scars. I wonder why they didn't ask to see to prove she's lying
"The Home isn't the Problem" made me furious. That's not how PTSD works. Makes just as much sense as gifting a knife to an abusive partner, when you're terrified and FEAR FOR YOUR LIFE🙄
Right. I flat out cancelled plans to go stay with friends at their cabin because I knew they had firearms and targets there. And a little boat. I got in big trouble for it, too, but I didn't get shot or drowned. There's no way in hell I'd give him anything sharp as a gift. Ffs I snuck both of the expensive kitchen knife sets out the door one night and secretly put them in the dumpster. It was just too scary knowing they were right there for him to grab at any moment.
@@lisakukla459 thank you for answering. I hope you are okay meanwhile? Stay safe and healthy 🍀 okay?
Much ❤️ from Austria 🇦🇹
“The home isn’t the problem” oh really, Amber? Is that why the saying goes “you can’t heal in the same environment that made you sick?” This woman knows nothing about PTSD. The DSM 5 ITSELF discusses places in the PTSD diagnostic criteria.
@@aliioana8586 right, that's my opinion, either! Thank you so much for answering me, that's very kind😇
Stay safe and healthy okay?❤️
Timestamp for the THEATER/BRUISE KIT slip up discussion: 3:47:58
At 3:50:28 she says "not bruise kit" and stumbled to correct herself, then says theater makeup kit. The Milani kit isn't a theater kit. Bruise kit would be Mehron or Kryolan.
I do drag/cosplay (orange corrector on my brows), I would apply colour correction before foundation.
How would you put yellow (assuming she was covering purple bruising) over a tinted moisturizer and not look jaundiced???
Thank you!💯💯
@@cvmitchell9368 You're welcome!
I'm a makeup fan. I just use corrector for circeles, dark eyes, side of mouth ash and KNOW this much. I really hope there's a makeup wearing juror, or some guy who does drag.
Thank you for this
When I did stage makeup for theatre in high school, we always put the bruise makeup on OVER the other makeup. But didn't she state that she "corrected her bruising" by putting that over the makeup? Isn't it common knowledge that anything for correction goes under your makeup and not over it?
Did we just listen to Amber literally gaslighting Johnny for hours on end? Her attempt to excuse away what we are listening to with our own ears was disgraceful. If she is willing to gaslight him in such an obvious and open manner on the stand can you even imagine what he must have had to deal with in private?
Sadly, yes
The audacity of her to tell us we see bruises in photos where there are none!
@@stellaallbright4750 I cannot get over the pictures of “scars” from Australia TWO months after the fact. Smh.
@@daCubanaqt also what made me lol is she says they were hard to cover up, yet she could cover up bruises and «broken noses» at events the day after it happened 😅😅
She was tipped off about the make up, otherwise why would she state it was not the exact brand. This could not be anymore obvious. Heads should roll!
I have been a nurse for almost 30 years. As a nurse, there would have been absolutely no reason for to fudge any of her records or her history. There would not be in the back of your mind that you need to falsify in case she accuse JD of something years down the road. Every nurse I know abhors domestic violence, we see too much of it's effects and end up picking up the pieces, sometimes the literal physical pieces. To allude to the nurse is in cahoots enrages me.
It enraged me on behalf or nurses
Yes I doubt that ever occurred, that a nurse intended to aid someone to report something falsely, but a nurse can only write down what information she is told, or things she sees herself so we all have to take all that into account, with any records or witness statements, because it's convenient (for example ) for Amber to put someone on her speaker phone then scream loudly to make a listener think something really happened, but that doesn't necessarily mean anyone or anything made her scream, so it doesn't mean what was perceived to be happening actually did.
she's blamed everyone except herself including her legal team. no one is safe from this woman's wrath
Thank you for the hard, painful work you do ❤️
I'm replaying the trial and an overcharter because I'm afraid of being subpoenaed and/or sued. I'm also pretty forgetful after so much time has passed and with how many patients we go through in a matter of a week. It was insulting for her to insinuate forging and faking notes. We hate taking notes. It's so much damn paperwork.
It’s months later and I am rewatching this trial from a different perspective but it’s still incredible to me. I’ve actually heard another channel that did an eight year investigation. I listened to them play the depositions and the police call recordings among others. There were two police calls that night and one was clearly IO but the other was “ anonymous” but was clearly Raquel Pennington and she sounds very uncomfortable making the call. I’m glad J. D. got justice but amazed at the number of recordings that were not allowed to be played in court. The recording Amber secretly made in Australia is so sneaky as she left her phone in her purse on the kitchen recording people. It was a toxic relationship and A.H. was clearly mentally disturbed as Dr. Curry testified. It’s such a shame these two got together. Hope JD learned to be more discerning and find peace. Hope his verdict helps him long term.
Which was the other channel?
@@renellandrea incredibly Average on YT. They have full depos of AH and Rocky, Full audio recordings of AH and JD. 🤓
I am back here again because I have been watching the Surviving Amber Heard series with “The DUI guy”… I feel very stupid for having had sympathy for her
@@michelleeven24 keeping an open mind and understanding a situation differently once you see or hear information is a sign of intelligence. Don’t feel stupid. You are a critical thinker and I think all victims should be believed at first. But they must be able to withstand judicial scrutiny and AH’s testimony was obviously inconsistent and full of lies. The information in the documentary shows much of what was really happening in private. So I’d say good job for learning the truth and making up your own mind.
You are so lovely! Thank you for your words and kindness. I would so high5 you if I could haha@@kendallneason3645
She said the home or setting does not trigger her PTSD. She asked to stay in his penthouse. She did not see him for a month and did not change the locks during that time. She did not just go to a hotel for the night to get a good night's sleep instead she cleaned up the place. She immediatly filed a TRO the next day instead of deliberating with her attorney like she stated to the police during the first visit. She feared for her life but did not leave and go to a place he didnt have access or staff at. I can't follow any of this and why JD's team has to even waste their cross time when she's the one that contridicts herself.
The TRO was on the 27th while the supposed fight and the 911 calls were on the 22nd I believe. But yes, if she felt that unsafe in HIS PH (by the way...) why didn't she go to a hotel or stay with one of her many friends? Oh right, because they were all freeloading off of JD too...
My mom got a TRO against my dad during Covid because she feared for her life and mine, we changed the locks on the house the first opportunity we got and sold the house the second we could because it didn’t feel like a safe place anymore. We didn’t want to stay in the house any longer than we had to because it served as a reminder for all of the terrible things that happened there. Amber’s behavior is very strange to say the least.
@@ada_pink
So she was in danger for her life, and yet she didn't worried about what JD would do to her friends who lived in his properties...?
I don't get it.
Geez, when I fled a very dangerous living situation, I was even afraid of seeing anything that resembled that person's CAR! I'd never have wanted to stay in their house. Good lord.
My father was abusive and I left home at 16 because of it. I am now in my 50's and I still get anxiety when I go home for a visit. I get anxious when I listen to the tapes they are playing, but not when AH is describing DV. AH words, facial expressions amd body language just don't mesh. I am just so shocked at how extra she was last week compaired to this week. I hope the jury sees through the BS.
I am a medical professional...actually did wound care nursing for a long time. The scars look way too even/uniform/neat, imo from what i can see here at least, to be from sliding/dragging/being pushed around on jagged irregular broken glass. Looks ALOT more like self inflicted intentional cuts to me. Cuts from glass obtained the way shes stating I would think would be more irregular, wouldnt heal as nicely, not perfect straight neat vertical lines. It isnt ideal to assess from a phone screen but thats what I see.
As someone who cut her knee wide open falling on driveway gravel as a kid, I concur.
As a former cutter, I recognized those scars immediately
@@angelalurtz3638 she's right handed and the cuts are on her left arm ! What does that tell you ? If they're from being dragged across the floor wouldn't they be on both arms?
Jerry Judge commented on tape that the only cuts he saw on AH after the Sydney incident looked to be self-inflicted. Also, I doubt very much that the nurse would not have looked after AH if she was injured in any way and also noted any injuries. She has a duty of care towards both the people she was hired to look after AH mainly and JD.
@@shanie7192 now she claiming the nurse lied and falsified her records & notes. She also throwing her legal team under the bus claiming she has photos of everything & turned everywhere over but her team isn't using them. 😱🙄🤷♀️🤦♀️
The reason she's wearing that jacket is because there was a body language expert that commented on her shoulder shrugging as a "tell" for lying.
If your arm was cut on glass, the cuts are not uniform. Broken glass is shards of different sizes and this appears like nails or razor cuts.
Also how can makeup NOT cover healed scars on her arm but can cover a broken nose, two black eyes, swelling, and a busted lip?????
🤨🤔🤦🏿♀️
For someone who was repeatedly choked, she is awful comfortable with the high neckline of that outfit. Took me twelve years to be comfortable with crew neck clothing and necklaces, and the fear of necklaces and crew necks has been a bonding moment with other survivors.
Her testimony is so fake her clothing calls her out.
🤗 Caregull Hugh? I ve been chocked and ended up on a ER and operating table, and barely made IT.😭 And still van t west things around nu Beck, and panick if I do. I learned tgrough years of therapy to wear kopse things around nu Beck, butt that's IT.
So I wanted to give you a Hugh, if you are able to and want one, as I think I van dat I know hoe hard that must be for you.
THIS.
As a survivor of domestic abuse and Sexual assault I just want to say this is disturbing .. I have attended group therapy for years and heard many different stories but not a single story ever sounded or looked like hers with the emotion and animation it’s so inconsistent when compared with real domestic abuse victims imo .. I’m also a nurse and the injuries without any care are absurd in my experience personal and professional victims usually get medical care but we lie about it
You survived, yourself, and you medically attend to people in similar, abusive situations? You are a tough cookie! My hat’s off to you, hero. Rock on.
There’s a weirdness in her telling her stories
I’ve interviewed abuse victims for 30 years, mostly at the first time of telling their story. I’ve never seen any like her.
@@RedSquirrelsReturn Yes, it is so obvious I just hope the jury members, some of them at least, have had experience in so far as having known a woman who really was abused, somehow. Weird to say it, but for Johnny, the best thing here would be if some had known an abusive man or an abused womam, maybe seeing it somewhere in their own childhoods because then they'll easily see how much she's lying.
@@KathyHussey063 I’m also the survivor of horrendous DV so I also know what abuse feels like. She’s a liar and she sickens me
I've seen maybe 10 people support Amber but I have yet to see a DV survivor support her. That's very interesting
We don't claim her because she is a liar and everyone that's been on this situation can see it. You never push the buttons of an abuser or antagonize them or talk back because you'll get fucking murdered and thrown in the trash. She is NOT a victim
You walk on egg shells afraid of any little mistake you make can set them off. Red flags all over this lady, she is lying and I'd bet my own life on that.
Because we won’t. Most of the comments I have seen from survivors are saying she is lying.
The funniest comment I saw the other day was from this idiot on fb I haven’t unfriended so I can occasionally see their horrendous takes, well she said “I believe amber heard, anyone who supports Johnny depp clearly hasn’t been watching any of the trial” and I’m just like 🤯🤯🤯🤯 are we watching different trials? Even her own team enters evidence of her being the abooser, how on earth can ANYONE be watching this and seeing anything else but a lying female dog (amber)
@@lightasafeather9750 I would also think that DV survivors who file restraining orders do so because they are afraid of their abuser. This is the first time ever that I know of where the victim breaks her own order to meet with her abuser. If I'm a juror who hears that then I don't need anymore evidence. JD wins
Wait. So she has PTSD from abuse from jjohnny but she has no issue with the home where it happened or any other locations. She stops him from leaving. She feels she has enough power to hit him without then ending up in the hospital or dead. And the claims of physical abuse "didn't hurt". I'm sorry WHATTHEACTUALF***.
I know right. She sounds ignorant just ridiculous.
I know!!!! I've complex PTSD and everything triggers me
Ikr?! I have a hard time even going back to the hometown where I was abused... let alone the bloody house itself!
I can't stand it when people lie about having disorders they don't have or things people did to them for attention. It minimizes the experiences of actual victims and makes people that much more unwilling to trust them. Especially with me-too movement and the fake rape victims that are apart of it. It's absolutely disgusting.
And remember, when she filed for divorce she demanded exclusive use of some of depp’s properties plus the Range Rover!! having him still continue to pay for everything!! that’s not weird at all???
While she read the list of notes from nurse...The eating disorder etc... they were SELF REPORTED by Amber. Nurse didn't diagnose or get from medical reports as diagnosis. AGAIN They conveniently leave out details.
There were So Many Things She Just Would Not Accept Were True About Herself! If she could have one time admitted something bad said about her she may have been seen as a human. But I keep thinking about her hiding her phone on record after Johnny went to the hospital and they were back, when she was supposedly upstairs sleeping. She hid that phone set on recording because she knew they would be talking about her and she Had To Know What Any of Them Said About Her. I have Never met anyone this concerned about themselves, worried about what other people Say. My guess is every person working for Johnny knew how bad she was, worried about him, and gossiped about her a lot. I would have. The whole time cleaning that penthouse. I'd Talk about her meanness the whole time cleaning, I would talk about her to other employees too. Ya think she recorded the employees? I bet that some recordings of maids were on her "lost phone" also.
I find it very strange that she was not triggered by returning to their place in Australia. I had an attempted burglary at a place I used to live and I was triggered so much living there afterwards that I had to move homes. I was on constant guard and would sit watching from the window at night to ensure no one tried to break in again. Considering the place was supposedly a place of a major assault, to me it would be very triggering to return there.
I can’t even look at early pictures of my relationship without getting sick to my stomach because it reminds me of the emotional and mental abuse and manipulation from my SO. We are still together and much better now, but I can’t stand to look back at the past.
@@imaspecialgirllalala I am glad you are doing better now in your relationship
Amber gives major 'Gone Girl' vibes. Like she planned this stunt for a while.
My thoughts exactly!
Omg yessssss!!!
I have not really been interested in that movie until amber
Yes that was my first thought when she said she kept a diary!!
Plus the wine bottle.
Icing something that’s swollen immediately after is not going to bring the swelling down. Swelling can last at least 3 days. And with the amount of hits, and “abuse” she’s claiming you’d think she’d have excessive amounts of swelling. This is too much l!
Especially with all his rings
A broken nose not only causes bruising but the swelling changes a person’s voice, much in the same way that someone with a cold sounds. The swelling forces a person’s voice to sound different. If her nose was truly broken (meaning the cartilage was displaced), It would need to be reset and taped up. No amount of make up would cover that. Her waterlines would also be bruised and the only way to cover that is using the eyeliner pencil on the waterline (I don’t see she did this). A split lip doesn’t stop bleeding by putting lipstick over it and worse, it could cause further irritation and swelling.
Her comment about how to cover bruising was all wrong, as well. Purple is covered by using orange, red is covered by using green, and blue is covered by using yellow. She clearly does not know what she is doing on bruise coverage.
Can confirm. I have twisted my ankle three times and all times the swelling would take days to go down entirely. That was just twisting, not broke, so for the amount of abuse she claims happened she would be unrecgonizable for at least three weeks.
@@tatianaameliaify: noticed she mentioned his *rings* today for the first time - of course she been scouring the internet for public*s reaction...........
We are clumsy here and I kicked myself in the eye with my knee by accident and had a swollen eyelid for days. It looked like make up with different colors depending on the bruise stage. Then my kid did the same thing a week later and we had matching kicked ourselves in the face injuries. Hers was from karate though lol
There is no way it wouldn't have at least been puffy. And it's very very similar to having injections under the eye lids which I also have had similar bruising in the past
There is no way that amber isn't watching what everyone is saying about her on the internet. She is too much of a narcissist to resist. And she must have relayed all of it to her lawyers. Which she wasn't allowed to do. Absolutely insane.
The Bee earing in her left ear proves she's been watching social media!
I was just telling my husband that I thought that she has been watching social media to see what people are saying about her to. she has changed so much about how she is talking and acting. almost like oh you think this about me, I better change up my character a bit.
I think her new PA is the one keeping watch on the media and probably telling her
or... her lawyers saw the favors on the jury and told her.... they dont believe you either so you better stop the drama queen act and try to look real.
😊
I know it's a year later, but I always found it weird that the white coffee travel cup (the one with his recording studio logo) that appears in the bags of weed and breakfast with coke table was actually used by Amber in the kitchen cabinet video...
If she is so afraid he will enter “her” apartment anytime, why not stay with a friend for a while or rent a place or go to a hotel for a few nights? Why does she insist on staying in his property if she wants to lock him out? 🧐
And with her friends
"her" apt. That would bee JDepps apt, where all HER friends seemed to flop at.
This was so ridiculous! And how she complains that security wouldn't keep him out even though she asked them to. How could they not let him into his own apartment?? Like, if you're financially independent - get your own apartment and leave..
She doesn't even donate a penny from her settlement money. She said she want nothing.
A point I haven't seen made yet: I never modeled but I wanted to since I was a toddler. Her lawyers made a point to say she also models, too. AnD yEt... basically every picture "documenting" her injuries have either no overhead lighting on at all (why would you not turn on ANY lights to show how bad the injuries were) or whatever light (natural or overhead) is BEHIND her, casting shadows automatically. As a model you always know where your light is and you have to find your light before you do anything else... Poor lighting like that will make my dark circles look like black eyes, and since she has absolutely no swelling that can be seen, I just find it hard to believe. She made sure to get pictures... so why is the lighting so bad, especially of herself as a model, plus there's almost more pictures of the house or Johnny instead of her injuries anyway!
My theory is that she used low light to emphasize whatever discoloration she had around her eyes, due to the shadows created by that lighting and natural features.
My eyes look swollen and bruised during allergy season. Depending on the lighting, it’s more/less obvious.
@@elsie412ok the low light has to be intentional!! And the one with the light behind her head just had me shocked, everything was shadowed, like duh! If you're taking the time to take the picture for the reason of using it for documentation, there is absolutely no way you would not make things as clear and obvious as possible unless you are trying to make things darker and more exaggerated.
Wow! Can you imagine the mental abuse AH put JD through by telling him he was doing things he didn't remember! This is insane! AH is actually confessing her mental abuse she put upon him!
That’s why he started recording their fights. Amber would gaslight him and he started feeling crazy. I’ve been in his position. It’s not fun being told that something didn’t happen or you did something you didn’t do or you don’t feel the way you feel. It drives you mad and can blur the lines between what actually happened and what they’re making you believe happened.
Yeah she’s really committing to the story that JD doesn’t remember all this crazy shit he did and is positing an alternate reality that she has clearly fabricated.
Me, over here watching this for the millionth time, hearing new things and getting more upset about Amber twisting everything she did and putting it back on Johnny… EDB says “TMZ this isn’t your video…” 😂🤣😂 oh how much we have learned now! It is, in fact, their video. Crazy how everything makes sense when you rewatch it!
I'm still rewatching this trial. Knowing exactly what she's lying about makes watching it now like a lesson in the behavioral arts. I can see, ever so clearly, that she is very well aware that she is lying. You can see it in her eyes.
There is no "her truth," as if she somehow believed that she was telling the truth. The whole thing was preconceived and orchestrated to pass herself off as this pillar of virtue versus his demonic, addicted monster.
Me too
Same
Same
Same
My mum fell in the street on 19th March - she still has a bruise on her face today AND it’s still sore. Impossible to cover up like that every day. I gave her a colour corrector palette as it was my wedding the week after the fall and I have covered tattoos in the past. It was enough to reduce it and look ok in photos with well positioned hair but was still visible and swollen and used UNDER foundation to neutralise colour and give a base of an even tone.
Also, no foundation would ever give sufficient SPF, let alone for someone with a skin condition. She would need 1/4 teaspoon of a dedicated high factor product every day and reapplied regularly, especially living in LA.
Not only is it odd that she always uses tinted foundation as her sunscreen, WHY would she go to the courthouse without makeup? Wouldn't that irritate her skin issue? She ALWAYS uses makeup except for that one day?
No clue what it says about me but I listen to your -Lawyer Reacts- videos as I fall asleep…specifically the Depp v. Heard trial
Lol I thought it was just me! 😅
Join the club! Lol 😂
Ditto!!!
I thought it was just me!
Me too!
For someone who went out of her way to record every conversation and fight they had, you’d think she’d be taking photos of all this apparent “physical abuse”. Nothing but a few photos where you need a magnifying glass just to see what they are alleging is there….
Amber testified that Johnny sexually assaulted her with a bottle AFTER severing the tip of his finger. They showed a picture of the bottle taken the next morning. She identified it as the same bottle. There wasn't a drop of blood on it. How is that possible if he's holding it in his hand with a severed finger? There would have been blood all over that room. I know because I've severed a fingertip.
@@stevep2380 exactly!
Yep. All the secret recordings he didn’t know about yet not one confrontation of her being beaten and serious discussion about him being physically abusive.
It was always her
Speaking from experience, those are self harm scars. Being dragged through broken glass doesn’t give you perfectly straight, evenly spaced and clean scars. Also interesting that it’s her left arm in the photos…
Jerry Judge said the same thing!
@LucciAnne Agree. The marks / scratches and bruises all seem very exact.
I hope you’re in a better place now. 🖤
@@TeejayTheAussie thank you, lovely human 💕 I am doing much better these days!
If couch was their ‘safe’ word, why didn’t Johnny use it when he needed a break instead of having to lock himself away from her in other rooms.
She probably didnt respect when he used it i could imagine at least from the recordings we heard
Couch definitely wasn’t their safe word…if my memory serves me right she screamed and demanded it a handful of times. Plus she even said “come here” or something like that so I feel she’s lying about it to cover her ass.
I agree - judging by jds reaction she made it up.
@@changuk_biased2010 I agree she made it up. She lies easily on the spot and with impunity
He said “she was ordering me to the couch.” So maybe she was trying to make him sleep on the couch?
I'm re watching all of your coverage on this trial, I absolutely love the way you cover it, so un bias but also so animated I love it. Heards testimony triggers me so much. I am a survivor of dv/sa and I really dislike how she tried to say "all/everyone" people who go through dv do xyz. It frustrates me, no one incident of dv is the same, and no two ppl react the same way, there may be similar experience or reactions but never the exact same
I don't understand how the obvious "coaching" during the break wasn't addressed and dealt with.
She's throwing everyone under the bus.. from the police to the nurse and anyone in between. So everyone's a liar except her. 🤨
Yeah Exactly..!
This is typical narc behaviour, everyone else is a liar and only the narc is telling the truth!
The funny thing is that she doesnt even realize that all she does is exposing herself as a liar. Johnnys team should just let her be on the stand since is digging her own grave and it’s getting deeper every minute!
Not only is she calling everyone a liar, but she's basically saying everyone is spineless, moral-less people that would watch a battered woman and do absolutely nothing. So pitiful. Shes disgusting.
This would be an excellent time to bring Dr. Curry back on the stand. 😂
Ah, so typical-my dad was the same way-and “we” were the ones that made him beat us up.
She refuses to take accountability for anything that has happened in her life although she has caused the majority of it. Her best thing she could do is accept her responsibility and move out of the country
There is no way that the situation in Australian was as violent toward her as she is claiming and she wasn't triggered by going back there. She claims he violently SA her and she was afraid for her life? But she wasn't afraid of a repeat or similar event when they returned to the same place just a few months later???? That is just unbelievable and inconsistent with DV survivor behaviour and PTSD. I was kind of on the fence before about believing at least some of her story but this was the thing that has pushed me over the edge. She is being dishonest.
Exactly. The mere mention of the city or state would trigger me so badly after I left my very sexually abusive relationship. 15 years later, I still don't ever want to go back to that state or city.
@@Keap16 same here. I left the state in 2009, 2 months after leaving a DV/SA relationship that ended with him trying to unalive me. To this day, I can’t even consider going back there without feeling triggered and terrified.
1:09:22 she said I'M repeatedly punching MY head...
I'm so glad she lost but I love re watching this stuff
I said the same thing! X
The truth does slip out every now and then, doesn't it? It is not easy to lie and one's brain tends to leak verbally. I hope it makes sense what I am saying here, english is not my first language so sorry if it doesn't!
So her defense is that he was too messed up on drugs & alcohol that he didn’t know what he was doing/can’t remember? How convenient. A person who is that deep into addiction as she describes would never have been able to function out in the world and anyone coming in contact with him would have been deeply concerned and seeking a higher level of care for him. He certainly wouldn’t have been able to do all that’s required in a leading or supportive role in a movie, which we all know he did while they were together. I’m a licensed psychotherapist & certified addictions counselor, and there’s just no way this makes sense to me.
This looks like one giant gaslighting attempt by Heard.
Meanwhile, she, on the night of her being ill due to taking both MDMA AND Mushrooms quote:
"I remember everything that night."
Apparently JD been abusing her during his passed out drunk or passed out high. According to AH though. loL
Did anyone else notice she reached to the wrong side of her face when she was talking about the phone hitting her in the face?
Yes, she gestured to her left side but the pics highlighted her right side.
Yes I did too!!
I can't take it. This woman is a liar. The things she is saying has happened to her is not believable. don't you think there would be so many visible injuries..all that broken glass and she never said anyone's feet was cut. And paparazzi would have been all over that. I'm having panic attacks from this case. I was dragged by my hair and beaten in my face until I was unrecognizable and lost my baby. The thought to want to hide the abuse while it was happening is ridiculous. How could her parents have seen her so badly beaten and still close with johnny. When I was abused Everyone that saw me police, and the hospital workers saw. There was proof. She is the biggest liar I ever seen. this defecation case is unreal. Class action lawsuit!!!! This liar is causing damage
@@amylee2569 could the pictures be flipped though?? depending on which camera was used?
(actually asking not arguing)
Yes
As someone who suffers from hallucinations, I hate how AHs team is trying to demonize it and mental health issues in general. If he really did hallucinate, that’s terrible for JD and I really feel for him if it’s true.
I'm sorry for your situation and I agree. If he was detoxing, it is very likely he was hallucinating and she's despicable for using it against him and to gaslight him if she really did care about his recovery. I like how CV is pointing out that the photos and videos of him detoxing is another form of abuse she's putting JD through. She's using it to try to embarrass him and drag him down. She should have been supporting him. I've heard stories of my step dad while he was detoxing in the hospital after almost dying from serotonin syndrome and he was hallucinating all sorts of strange crazy things. Luckily my mom and the nurses were there to help him come back to reality. I wish Johnny would have had the right support during those times. I really think her goal was to get him to OD so she could take all of his money. She didn't want him to get better at all.
@@stormy7318 This is exactly what I believe she decided to do after she realized she could not completely control him or his money, through her various schemes manipulating, intimidating, gaslighting and isolating him (from all his good friends who cared about him and his kids too) when all that did not break him down enough so that he'd just roll over and let her control everything, when he brought up divorce, she decided to start creating evidence she could claim showed how depressed and dysfunctional he was on drugs, and things that would make him look unstable. She intended to push him to kill himself, but thankfully he escaped in time..
Every time she describes Johnny being abusive, I see him turning into The Hatter getting angry and shouting at her in a scottish accent!😂😂😂 She’s making up a story, so I make up one too!😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣 why does this make it so much more fun lmfao
@@amandafeliciano542 Am I a bad person for laughing now when she describes what he’s shouting at her? The whole thing is just so absurd, I can’t help myself!😂
@@indylwth2327 absolutely not, he's been chuckling too, it's just SOOOO over the top lol
I love this 😂
Just commenting on the LINE people were doing beforehand - other LawTube streamers were explaining, it was an EXTENSIVE line, and you had to get there early -- think Black Friday early. The fact that everyone showing up for it was numbering themselves, cooperating, and basically honor-system-ing their places... its amazing. Such a high profile case - youd expect there to be mayhem, but people were reasonable, calm, helping eachother.. i was kind of heartwarming.
So am I hearing this right? At 3:34:00 she said she wasn’t wearing “a stitch of make up,” then at 3:41:00, when asked about the people saying she wasn’t wearing “a stitch of make-up,” she said “they don’t know what they’re talking about, I always wear make up.”
Make it make sense!
I feel like amber has watched replays of how she presented her self
She’s changed just a bit today.
Of course she has changed! I guarantee that her whole team replayed everything and reviewed her testimony…they have been coaching her from day one! I hope the jury is smart enough to see through her lies!
Seems like she’s a bit sedated today.
@@joycemarie9702 agree
She can’t take back that theatrical lying behaviour
Assuming sarcasm here, it's like she has watched everything, everyone has said about her testimony and has changed her answers and demeanor to suit. Also, the way she is retracting what she has already said makes it appear that she has consulted with her lawyers, especially the way she was questioned about the makeup, so obvious.
Also, I’m a wound care therapist. A young, well healing adult would not have scars several months later. Maybe a few days. She would be healed and they would be gone. Also these do not appear to be made from running on glass. I treat people with imbedded glass. Too straight. Just my perspective.
AH is a perfect example of a narcissist, she blames everything on JD! AH not taking any kind of responsibility is just weird!!
The Narcissist's Prayer
That didn't happen.
And if it did, it wasn't that bad.
And if it was, that's not a big deal.
And if it is, that's not my fault.
And if it was, I didn't mean it.
And if I did, you deserved it.
@@cindi4031 A prayer none so true!
True but not true She slipped up and said I'm repeatedly punching My head that's what caused the bruise😲😂🤣 1:09:24
2:27:33 lots of details here. So much details! But when it comes to her attacks, her memories are a bunch of flashes. Not remembering much.
The way she was talking to Johnny on the tapes. When you are being abused you do not talk to your abuser that way.
Okay, having such a direct insight into the jury was soo fascinating and informative, so thank you DUI guy and Emily for making this happen!
This channel is THE place for trial insight
She said the bathroom door/toes incident was later in that recording, yet you heard Johnny ask at the beginning of the recording “how are your toes”?! He says it in a way as if she may have shut the door on her own toes too!
Wow, that dog is a veterinary marvel, a teacup dog that has bowel movements the size of a human - freaking remarkable! I'm not an attorney, but why is the judge allowing this, doesn't this set up the likelihood of an appeal?
I know and it also has the ability to remove itself from a bed without breaking bones , no kidding a dog that size could snap its legs jumping off a bed
Just wondering if anyone got an actual photo of it, gross I know but it would prove the point.
@@shanie7192 - yes there was a picture. It was NOT dog poo, unless they have a Rottweiler that no one is aware of.
@@stephm.3407 Ghost Dog that Shits on your Bed and Frames your Significant Other is my favourite D-tier Cryptid.
Came here from the murdaugh trial to see some competent lawyering..... I even miss Elaine at this point.
When she said she wanted the Divorce/TRO private & under the radar - takes me right back to her testimony in 2016 where she literally let's slip that "TMZ were already alerted" and as soon as she realised what she'd just let slip, she slap wipes both sides of her face with her hands as though trying to wipe the words away - its the most hilarious thing to witness I can still see it🤣😂🤣
When she said "bruise kit" it sound like she slipped up and was referring to her stage makeup she used to CREATE a bruise, not conceal it. All she's talking about with color correction and arnica cream is everything every person who's ever gotten botox or fillers already knows. This is maddening testimony to watch - especially as someone who's experienced psychological manipulation and gaslighting just like this first-hand. I feel SO bad for Johnny having to sit and listen to this - I've been there and it's devastating. It's psychologically devastating.
Yep and its so easy to make a fake bruise. Im an amateur but ive done makeup for halloween/zombie walk just from using basic cheap supplies and a couple hrs watching tutorials, and it looked VERY realistic.
@@thriftynurse same.
Johnny is doing battle right now just by sitting there holding onto his sanity and letting the court play out the way it’s supposed to. This is historic for us all. Calling it a bruise kit is a Freudian slip.
Her psychiatrist diagnosed with PTSD and Johnny's did not they found her to be deceptive on the test. She clearly said in her testimony that the home is just a home and that doesn't have memories or trigger memories for her well that is the definition of PTSD being triggered by places sounds and sensations even smells so she's talking crap. Many survivors of DV have trouble with their surroundings where violence has taken place it has triggered for them.
Thank you for your comment. When I left my abuser,I left the apartment and never returned, even though it was in my name. I had my brother deal with everything with regards to that apartment, there was no way in hell I'd ever entered that place again.
Even passing by that area gave me anxiety.
I now live happily in a different country,this trial brings up all kinds of emotions. I don't believe a word coming out of that woman's mouth.
So true. When I was 10 my brother sa me. When we left the house it happened in I at least had relief from all the places and triggers...bedroom, bed, parents dresser, etc. He still lived with my family in the next house but at least as I got older I learned how to avoid him. Your comment is spot on. Yet another inconsistency in her testimony. Her testimony is better known as stories.
are you a doctor? are you aware that ptsd can manifest in (shockingly) more than one singular way? - saying this as someone who has been dx w ptsd by a psychiatrist btw
dont discredit ppls experiences just because it doesnt fit within your perfect narrative
and last time i checked personal experience & youtube university isnt enough knowledge to be able to credit or discredit someones experience
I still avoid places 20 years after things happened....
There's no way she wasn'tdiscussing her testimony with her attorneys during dark week! Damage limitation is in full force this week. So far I haven't seen any of the previous "my dog stepped on a bee" overacting (mind you, I'm only 30 minutes into the video so plenty of time left to prove me wrong!)
She is acting completely different
In her testimony, AH never said: "He hit me in the face and then I've immediately went to put ice on my face to mediate swelling." She only told about ice, when she was talking about the "bruise kit".
It's been interesting listening to her testimony and I think one of the things people are confused about-her being fearful of her life yet 'fighting back'-is due to the fact that even though she is going with the fearful story, she also has a consistent need to assert qualities that she thinks would put her in a good light, i.e, she wants to make sure to add that she was brave and daring, which is why she fought back.
You also see this connected to her previous language where she mentions (seemingly disappointed about it) that she never managed to 'land one' on Johnny Depp up until the staircase incident. 'Land one' rather than 'punch' or 'hit' expresses more of a sense of victory and pride. Perhaps subconsciously she thinks managing to punch Depp despite bodyguard between them (or her sister, according to Amber's testimony, iirc) is a positive quality because it underlines her physical victory in that moment.
She was clearly coached during the break to adjust to what we've all been talking about online. It feels strange that they are now answering the internet's questions on the stand. The jury is probably confused AF by the change in behavior. This feels wrong to me.
Oh wait, around 3:20:00 there's that overacting we saw before the break.
😯did she call Umbridge a liar? Umbridge said that was the compact Amber carried in opening... the way around the truth is just to say "obviously not".. I wish that Milani employee had waited until after Amber testified.
How can they do that? No one was supposed to look on social media!! Plus they obviously told Amber not to do so many things! Ugh!!
@@angelgendvilas4254 As Emily has said dozens of times since she began covering this trial, Amber Heard and her lawyers (along with Depp and his team) are not barred from looking at info related to the trial outside of court. They were instructed not to discuss her testimony with her over the break, but it very much seems as though they did. Witnesses who are not listed in the suits and are subject to be called later and jurors are the ones who can't look at or talk about the case.
@@mzcytin ok. I didn’t quite understand the difference I guess. It sure is backpedaling and they clearly discussed testimony. And her fake crying!! I mean come on.
@@angelgendvilas4254 the fake crying, faces, and head shaking, returned around 3:20:00 🤦♀️ how did this woman ever get paid to act?!
JD must have felt like he was going insane the way she gaslights him! I'm actually surprised JD didn't actually hurt her for real!
I'm honestly surprised he didn't off himself. She was so horrible to him.
He's a stronger person than I. Id have kicked her butt
Literally I have been saying that exact same thing. Just from the audio tapes you see how taunting she is to him and who knows what wasn't caught by him, she wasn't gonna record how they got in their fights but she made sure to record him when he finally snapped and couldn't take it anymore. He showed incredible restraint. She could probably make the nicest, most gental person and make them violent. One can only take so much after so long and she seems like she is the reigning queen at that. One can only hope the jury sees that, or thinks about how they most likely would/could have reacted just by what they heard from her and multiple that by 20 as you know she probably wasn't caught on audio as much as him
@@heathermarie428 , as far as I know, AH says that they recorded each other so she could further her narrative of being the victim cause almost all the recordings, if taken out of context, sound like JD was the aggressor but AH was the one who recorded the bulk of their relationship! Suggesting JD recorded when she had no idea, she still didn't sound like the aggressor! JD didn't have a reason to record her because he was being manipulated by her and didn't realize that she had an agenda pretty early in the relationship; that's why she was collecting "evidence" of his supposed abuse yet never really got anything proving it! AH even stated that JD accidentally hit record on her phone, and it recorded for 5 hours that night; she cut his finger, yet at the end of that recording, you can clearly hear AH approach the recording device that she hid somewhere; she's speaking to JJ she approaches the device tears it off of wherever it was stuck on, hiding, and she continues talking as you hear the tape being ripped off the device also... I do not believe it was her phone and that she was without her phone for 5 hours during all the alleged and actual chaos! There are UA-cam videos of the 5-hour audio; I'm not sure why she lied about who recorded it; I think because where ever they were in Australia, it is a one-party rule, so if she said that she or JD purposely recorded for 5 hours then the recording could be used in court, but if no one supposedly knew it was recording I guess it can't be used? I don't get it cause at the end; it was obviously AH that planted the recording device! AH does not want that recording heard; she'll not only be caught lying about recording JD, but over the 5 hours you hear that Dr. Kipper and her nurse, security and others talk about AH's abuse of JD, AH admits she cut his finger off, she is also trying to manipulate the situation! They talk about her drug use and giving her something to calm down, and whether it will effect any drugs she may have taken, they talk about her having an affair, and JJ speaks to numerous people in the house and on his phone about having to send someone who is strong and can handle her manipulations and if she freaks out on her way back to LA! JD's team only sounds concerned about getting her the heck out of Australia and away from JD so he will finally break up with her; they also imply AH put a cigarette out on JD's cheek and tried to blame JD for doing it to himself! JJ also talks in a whisper on the phone about how he has to be careful because AH will hide and listen-in on conversations, and he also says she hides a recording device and records conversations! (Is that not crazy!) The whole recording is very telling! So I guess I'm probably right about why AH said it was recorded by accident! I haven't watched today's afternoon testimony yet, I'm too frustrated by AH, but I'm hoping cross will at least make a bit of it tolerable!! Sorry for the long post. I've got no one to discuss this with!! What I think is so crazy, is that both JD's team and AH's team have heard and seen everything so both teams must be well aware of who was the abuser and who was the victim! I could never defend something so deplorable!!!
It’s no wonder his drinking etc was getting worse. I’m convinced she drove him to it, and then used it against him.
Sooooo... she has no problem with coming back to the home she was allegedly abused, beaten up and violated in?
What happened to her PTSD then?!
I am not a victim and this triggers me. My heart goes out to all those who have gone thru this. I have had to stop and start so many times out of frustration. In my opinion, Her and her lawyers voice are quickly becoming the most annoying sound in the world.
She's awfully logical for such high anxiety times when your pre-frontal cortex is mostly offline .....
are you a doctor?
@@penis2020_ I am unclear why you ask.
Thanks Amber for clarifying and educating me about the "aemeca cream" 🤣
Arnica is really helpful firstaid for preventing dark bruises, that is true. But not if you got hit with a fist full of metal🤷
It only aids with bruising, doesn't erase it. It's a good cream but it's not magical.
But do you KNOW if she was wearing amica cream that day?? 🤔 lmaoooo
@@Smaugette yep, thats it. I was very surprised when I applied for the first time (diddn't really believe in its usefullness)
Arnica gel is good for bruises it's used after botox and other things but certainly won't take a bruise away! Maybe just speeds up healing!
Arnica gel is good but it's no bruise removal miracle even the pure arnica. It helps but doesn't remove them.
Everytime she makes an accusation, it's an admission of her own bad behavior. Once you see it, it's everywhere. Projection is textbook HPD.
Thank you!
🙌 yes!! It’s a like her whole time on the stand is one giant Freudian slip.
When she looks around, seeing how she is landing you can see the frustration in her face of being ignored by JD when she glanced at him.
When talking about the dog's incontinence her expression immediately changes as she bites the inside of her cheek in an attempt to conceal her duper's delight, and a smile actually slips out at 'so she doesn't lose control of her bowel.'
Good catch
She sheet the bed on the stand... again.
Oh God please log off and touch grass you're so weird for this
@Vangelina Barrow they’re commenting this kind of stuff on everything. 🚨Dookie Defender Alert🚨
@Vangelina Barrow I believe it’s from the CreepshowArt drama thing. When Shannon was exposed for all of her BS behavior, she came out with a 2-hour-long video of her trying to gaslight everyone and that was a line that she used. Everyone needed to “go touch some grass” and get a life or whatever. It was a meme, can’t believe that person is saying it un-ironically
The " trashed house" looks like it's staged by someone who has never seen a trashed house and didn't want to actually break their stuff even the memory box she said was dumped from her childhood. What did he do gently tip it over why would he go in her office and just gentle dump one box why isn't it everywhere it makes no sense
It's fun to watch this knowing that the jury is buying none of this.
So she was walking UP the stairs to get back to the party, Johnny grabbed her shirt, spilled wine, changed shirt, then she said she walked DOWN the stairs to join the party. Was the party upstairs or down. Like Emily says, I have questions.
This might be a case of the house having more than one staircase. Some mansion houses will have extra staircases at the back so you can go to different levels without having to go to the front of the house, almost like stairs for servants for example.
Doesn’t Amber have a history of hurting herself? a.k.a. the cuts on her arm those cuts look very organized and very methodical isn’t it possible she could’ve done that herself?
They look self inflicted
They look like old scars from burns. Not cuts.
They are 100% wrist cutting scars. I've seen them so many times. Not on myself, but on several of my friends'.
Yes. In the recording of depp saying he was going to cut himself she said "trust me, it doesn't work". It's clear she was saying she had cut herself before.
They look exactly like my sh scars
Funny also how she was trying to keep things “quiet” but yet not ONE TIME did she try hiding her face from the paparazzi and instead she walked with her head held high, chin out showing the wooorrrllldddd her face! …and how nice of them to back track the makeup!! 😂🤣😂🤣 lol because they KNEW that was gunna kill here case, must of been nice to have that week off to prep for this!!! Ugh!! I can’t stand liars!
she walked with her lawyer in the FRONT DOOR of a court room where she had no need to be (the TRO can be filed remotely, only a court clerk is needed) and for SOME REASON the press was already hot on her tail, gee i wonder how that happened---- then the video leak of the kitchen 'scene' ? gee i wonder who leaked that one.. etc. etc. etc.
What she called him hallucinating was her gaslighting him. What a disgusting woman! Can you imagine to have to live with her? Hell on earth!
I'm so glad justice was served!
Yeah because if he had a book Oh damn no, she had the book. She twisted everything! He had no chance with her, I would think nobody does. The glaring fact that she thinks up until the end of her Rebuttal testimony That She Is Going To Win Money From Him, that she thinks she "got" this jury on her "side", is mind boggling. This case built on nothing but her testimony, a few friends not friends enough to come testify, and her few messed up experts? Her sister was the only one, and that sure does not outweigh Everything else we have seen. They had to get Whitney in there, I'm sure the lawyers told Whitney that much. She had nothing but her "tall tale". And I knew nothing about Depp ever getting married so I listened to this well.
I think she pictures these events in her mind and truly believes them.
This keeps looking worse and worse for her... I mean he still has a huge mountain to overcome in order to win the case, but she is definitely making that mountain more manageable.
Did you mean imaginable
She needs to prove one incident of abuse occurred. It's easier for her to win than Johnny.
@@velcro-is-a-rip-off and so far, they haven’t proved a single one… soooooo
@@velcro-is-a-rip-off she has no proof as why she blamed her lawyers for no proof being shown.
I think the makeup story would be semi more believable if she showed up to court everyday full glam with eyelashes and all. I mean she mastered covering bruises but can't cover under eye circles now? Yookay
They should bring the dog in and if he doesn’t crap all over then Amber is proven liar
She did that with glee. Her whole face lit up like a Christmas cracker while explaining how she covers up bruises. How does her head work??
Yeah, bring in the dog!
@@sadie1079 when it was young it ate some weed, no amount of weed causes everlasting shits disorder
@@Fee.1 yorkies live for a long time. It is conceivable that it could still be alive
@@veronicavatter6436 wouldn’t surprise me
So are JD’s team nearby to constantly “back him up” or are they far away and not around to hear him supposedly assault her?
The way she wears her blush makeup makes me think she ALWAYS has bruises. Even while she is in court now.
I have had a black eye before, it took three days of holding ice on my face for swelling to go down and two and half weeks to completely heal, it was still purple in some areas up until the last few days… I guess AH has magical healing powers
Watching from NZ. The live started at 1:00am our time, had to sleep. Can't believe we're only a few minutes in and it's obvious Heard's been talking with her lawyers to fix her lies.
So it looks like she is no longer doing her soap opera testimony but this persona is way more terrifying. She looks like a stone cold sociopathic.
Which she is
She sure does! The stuff nightmares are made of!
First of all can’t stop rewatching
But Emily reaction never fail me 🤣🤣
Spatially when she have questions always love you ❤
I’m ready for Camille to ask “did you consult with your attorney this last week”?!? She so obviously did!!!!!!!
How can they not see she is literally changing her story after the exact issues social media has brought up. Wtf She wasn't supposed to be on social media since she's on the witness stand right?
She might think she's the only one going on social media.
She was allowed to be on social media.