For those interested in the differences between Brass: Birmingham and Brass: Lanchashire, here is a list. (Please comment if I've missed something or gotten something wrong.) This list is copied from the reply thread to J. Bertels's comment. In Lancashire: 1) The only commodity is cotton. There is no pottery, nor manufactured goods. 2) There are no breweries, nor beer. Double rail actions cost 15 pounds and two coal, but no beer. 3) Players can also build ports and shipyards. Shipyards are high point-value industries that flip immediately after being built. Shipyards with a lock symbol on them cannot be built in any era; they must be developed away. Ports are used to sell cotton. 4) Cotton can be sold either to any player's unflipped port (which flips both the port and the cotton mill) or to the distant market (special fixed locations around the edge of the board, or any player's flipped or unflipped port.) When selling to the distant market, players must turn over a distant market tile, reduce the distant market marker by the number on the tile, and then receive the income bonus on the new distant market spot (in addition to the income received from flipping the cotton mill.) If the distant market marker reaches the bottom of the track, the sale is canceled and no further sales to the distant market are possible that era. The distant market track is reset and market tiles reshuffled at the beginning of the rail era. 5) There are no wild cards. Instead, players may discard two cards (using both of their actions for a turn) in order to perform a build action at any location. 6) Players are not allowed to take loans in the final two rounds of the game. There's a placard placed in the draw deck during rail phase setup to remind players of this. 7) Players score 1VP per 10 pounds left in their player area at the end of the game.
Also, players may take loans of either 10, 20 or 30 pounds upon their choice, and decrease their income levels by 1, 2 or 3 accordingly. And the map is different.
No matter the game, it is amazing how much time Rodney saves everybody in a clear and concise manner and the tip to listen to vids at a faster speed is also a good tip. No wonder BGG picked WatchItPlayed up. Keep up the good work and many happy work hours, Rodney.
@@WatchItPlayed love all your videos. Always brings a smile to my face when I find it's good old Rodney that's done the rules for a game we haven't played before
Having played this game once and watching other UA-cam channels, I can’t quite figure out why they included gold colored cubes rather than gray ones for Iron. It confuses me…🤣
It's helpful to note that the theme ties together some of the rules concepts. In general, *Brass isn't about selling commodities it's about establishing trade routes.* You have to ship coal and not iron because industries (and railroads) require a regular supply of coal to operate, while iron is only needed for maintenance and repairs. Flipping a tile doesn't mean you've exhausted that industry; it means you've established enough trade routes to use its full production capacity. Income represents excess profits, which helps understand why loans operate the way they do. Level 1 industries don't go out of business at the end of the canal phase (they still provide income, and their VPs aren't lost); they're just swamped by the economies of scale possible during the rail phase. Even the canals are still operating; it's just not economical to build more of them once rail is available.
Understanding the theme behind a game can be an excellent way to help rules stick in ones memories, so thanks a lot for these tips Twocinc! Good stuff!
twocinc When I’ve taught Brass L in the past I have always used that theming (businesses are establishing “customers” for what they produce and when supplying at capacity become profitable and (score vps in the scoring phases). Placing a tile on the board is just getting the initial infrastructure and workers in place - hence the initial capital cost. It’s very rare (as in these games) but laudable for the mechanics to so strongly reflect the theme that the theme is implied BY those mechanics. Well done to the designers!
First I watched two instructions in Polish. But in your instruction I understand more than in my own language! First time I seen something in this channel and its amazing! Really god job! SUBSCRIBED
I always go to find Rodney's videos before anything else. He's helped me make informed purchases by watching the videos and getting a clear idea of the rules and finding out if a game will be right for me. Thank you so much.
I love that you pronounce the cities correctly. Thanks for this tutorial - I'm playing it for the first time tomorrow and was hoping you'd made a tutorial video for it!!
Thanks Rodney, I just got my Deluxe Brass Birmingham and this walk through was great in getting me started. It was so much easier to follow than the rule book. Also, I’m British and you did a great job in getting the city names right 👍🏻
Some people thumbs down if they don’t like the game, and others thumb down, probably because they don’t like me. I have some very loyal down thumbers :)
@@WatchItPlayed Not everyone can handle your awesomeness! I'm always so glad to see a new How to Play video, especially for a new game that I won't have to read through a rulebook multiple time! It helps contextualize the rules with your examples. Keep up the good work! Thumbs up!!!!
Thanks Rodney! I realize that we made 3 mistakes overall while playing. The understanding of the network, the scoring for canal and rail link which we did count only for our own tile instead of anybody tile and finally the develop action. We forgot to pay 1 iron to do that. We ended up having spent only 4 iron in the whole game lol. I don't know why we forgot that as I read the rule it's pretty clear. I knew there was something we did wrong. THanks for clearing this up!
Can't tell you how nice it is to hear an American say Birmingham like that :) great overview, I think I'm going to get it not only because it's a game set around my home city but looks like a nice complex step up from our usual games! cheers!
I wanted to make sure I got the names pronounced right, so I'm glad to hear I got close. Thanks for the kind words. I'm Canadian, but that's pretty close to America, I suppose :) Cheers!
@@WatchItPlayed I do apologise! It makes sense that you're Canadian, my sister lives there and she told me people are always very respectful when it comes to pronouncing names :) great channel btw glad I found it
Hi from turkiye We met Brass 2 months ago. We are happy to play with my wife at home. It really deserves to be number 1 in board games. Cheers to Creator 🎉
OUT OF THE PARK Rodney! Your new camera is AMAZING and the video quality is amazing. I also love your titles. I was hoping for you to do this game. We learned about London from you, and it remains one of our favorite games. So, of course when I saw another game by the same writer, I was hoping for a new game to add. Based on your video, I have already placed my order. I think we are going to absolutely LOVE it! Thank you so much for your incredible video!!
@@WatchItPlayed I downloaded the iPad app, and it was not so much. But the art, and it being a Martin Wallace makes all the difference. The iPad app is meh. But we were still wanting to give it a fair shake. The board looks amazing. Hope there a not a mother more changes for the pre ordered version. Also just ordered Legends of Andor. I hope I don't have to start collecting all the expansions for that. BGG seems to suggest that the primary game has a lot of promise. But again, thank you for upping your equipment and editing. Makes it easier to get an idea what to expect!!!! You guys rock it. ( also love how you say Iron in your local Canadian Tongue. My son, native to California said it the same way as you and yours. His grandfather was from French Canadian dissent after all!!
Again great content! High production value. Nice graphic overlays, item fade-ins and just overall editing. I really like the approach of first do the setup and then explain each round/action without adding extra context/clutter to your instructions. Keeping the instructions minimal while still making sure to cover all the rules must take up a lot of time and effort.
I played Lancashire a week ago for the first time. This video is also perfect for repeating the rules while learning Birmingham at the same time. Thank you very much.
I already played Birmingham once, but decided to listen to your video, and caught something we had all forgotten: that you'd have to pay with your industries if you had no money and still owed more to the bank during income. I had skimmed the rules during our play and saw the part where you'd lose VPs, but not the one about industries. I think the same rule already existed in the base game, but I hadn't played it in a while, and I've yet to see this happen. Anyway, I'm saving this to point people to it before they play the game. It's extremely helpful, as are all your videos. :)
Rodney you have absolutely outdone yourself with this one mate. Phenomenal video. It is a heavier game but your explanation was so on point...I can't imagine explaining this any better. One suggestion though would be maybe to add some more thematic explanation for the game mechanics. You have done this here (e.g. why Iron can be transported without links) but a few more examples would have been great (e.g. what's up with the weird rules around beer and barrels?). Thanks for everything!
Thanks for the kind words, and the feedback. It's a bit of balancing act, determining how much information to include, particularly in the longer videos. The more I add, the longer it gets, but I agree - the thematic justifications, often lock the information into your brain - which can be useful, especially during the longer videos!
For a long time I had been looking at Birmingham and I couldn't wrap my head around it. I didn't know anybody that had played it let alone anyone who had played Original Brass. It had so many tokens I was very hesitant to pick it up. It's because of this video (and other channels like shut up &Sit Down and other playthroughs) that I think I finally understand how this game works. I bought the Deluxe version of the game and I cant wait to teach my friends. Thank you so much for this Rodney! I think it would be amazing if you could teach this on "Game Night!". Perhaps one day?
You are always a big help Rodney. We are a very small group of people playing these new world board games in India. It's a start. We always see your video first and then start the game. Thanks for the good work....
Can I just say thank you. As someone born and raised in Birmingham, it's good to hear the correct pronunciation of the name and not the over emphasis a lot of people not from the UK put on the 'ham' of Birmingham. Also another great how to tutorial.
Haha Warlock, yes, agreed, no HAM in Bermingum! And not Lancashyer...! Also, how annoying it is that so many south of Coventry pronounce it Birminum! Well done Rodney! I love the American pronunciation of Worcestershire; Warchestershyer!
@@marklong4317 Yes, it's nearly as enjoyable as the British saying 'Hooston' for Houston and 'Ar-KAN-zuz' for Arkansas, amongst many others I have heard. Mispronunciation goes both ways. My favourite American mispronunciation of a British place name is Lye-chester for Leicester...
@Stuart Baird I’m aware Rodney is Canadian, and as he states earlier he tries his best with pronunciation. Sorry if you’re upset by the “American” categorisation but it’s true Yanks have some strange pronunciations, but like stated earlier, lots of people pronounce words incorrectly, including Brits getting their own nation’s words wrong, like Berminum, Soufampton, nuffin’ and bovver! Hope this clears me of messing up...
Thank you so much Rodney. Just picked this up and your video helped immensely (as usual 😁). Keep up the great work! We're supporting you from West Texas!
Thank you so much for this clear video! This helps so much and now it doesn't really seem as bad as people make it. I'm very much looking forward to this!
If not for you I would never be into board games, you've helped me learn terraforming mars which made me fall in love with board games. Thank you for all your content
Usually I watch rule videos in german. We just bought the game. And honestly all german rule videos suck. Since rule videos often contains errors, I still read the rulebook also to know where to look in case of a question. You are explaining this game extremly well and if I match what you say with the rulebook also flawlessly. Thank you for that, I finally think I fully understand the game, can teach it to friends and game night is next weekend
Thanks for clip, just grabbed my copy and rulebook was still confusing despite I've played Lancashire already, as always brilliantly explained all nuances.
Great video as usual Rodney! This is my next game in the queue to learn/play and you’ve once again provided a half hour well spent to enable many future hours of fun!
Question: At 21:36 you can see two tiles of the same player on one place (Wolverhampton). Didnt you say earlier its not allowed to build on a place where you already have a tile?
The only downside of Rodney doing such a great job is, it’s costing me a fortune to buy these games because I want them all 😂 Seriously, great job again. I’ve been debating getting this game for some time and, yet again, you’ve sold it to me. Keep up the excellent work Rodney.
When you "Overbuilt" the Iron Works @18:26 wouldn't you also sell all four iron cubes to the marketplace immediately... as instructed during the first tile placement instruction?
Yes, absolutely - sorry for any confusion there, this part of the video was explaining the overbuild rules specifically, so that's what I was limiting by focus too in the example, but all other rules still apply as normal when you're actually playing.
Best tutorial for a complex game I've seen in a while. Rodney is the god of tuts. I have 2 small questions: 1. Is beer ever replenished on a merchant tile (the outer side of the map, the barrel that gives immediate bonus when taken) once somebody sold , e.g., cotton industry through it? 2. When you take the beer (consume it) from any merchant, or from your brewery, where does it go? Outside of the board in the general supply? Because in the rulebook its noted that the player who receives (or consumes?) the beer (the one player who is fast enough to sell first through that merchant), receives ONE FREE BEER. What do they mean with this?
Thanks for the kind words! The beer is replenished on each merchant tile at the end of the canal era. The beer that you take is simply added back to the general supply, receiving the free beer in that moment essentially means that you don't have to spend one of your own or one from your opponents.
@@WatchItPlayed thanks Rodney. I was kind of confused because I thought I want to spend my beer from my brewery as soon as possible so I can flip the tile and gain the bonuses. Maybe it'll make more sense once I get to play a game of Birmingham.
Hey, everybody, I heard there’s FREE BEER! Come and get it!!!!!! Also, I’m pretty sure the rules are saying that you must have actual beer on hand that you must consume whenever you take the sell action. Game balance at its finest! 😂
Thank you for the clear and concise video! After playing my first game, I have a few questions that arose between the players and that aren't clearly touched upon in the video. For anyone that can answer them: - The written rulebook seems to claim (ambiguously) that it is possible to sell several industries using only one action (paying multiple barrels if needed of course), is it one sale per action or multiple? - when going to the railway era you flip industries of lvl 2 or more back up but do NOT put the resources back on mines correct? Therefore coal and iron mines are sitting on the map but cannot earn you victory points unless you upgrade them. I find it weird the rules don't clarify this anywhere. -This one might be trivial but, when you settle income at the end of the turn, any interest that needs to be paid goes the player token and counts towards turn order right? For some reason one of the players would not accept this so I'm asking. major thanks to anyone who can help on one of theses points.
Hey Gaspard, glad you enjoyed the video! The answers to your questions are covered in the video, so let's go through them: 1) You were wondering whether you can sell several industries in a single action. That's covered here: ua-cam.com/video/Lzxf4tfq9as/v-deo.html 2a) I'm not clear on what you mean by "when going to the railway era you flip industries of lvl 2 or more back up". Here is the section of the video that covers the Canal Era - as you'll see, no where do you flip any tiles: ua-cam.com/video/Lzxf4tfq9as/v-deo.html. 2b) You also asked if iron or coal is returned to tiles in the Canal era - you won't see this question addressed in the video, because coal and iron is never added back to those tiles. Adding resources back to tiles isn't something you do, so it's not something you'd find mentioned in the video. 3) When you say "any interest that needs to be paid", what are you referring to? What interest? Perhaps you could tell me which page of the rule book, and section you are referring to, so I can understand what you are asking about.
@@WatchItPlayed thank you so much for being so responsive! 1- Gotcha, I watched the whole thing twice but I guess my brain didn't register and its a little unclear in the written rules. 2- thanks, it just felt weird that it isn't possible to get victory points a second time from mine tiles unlike the industries tiles so I felt compelled to ask. 3- I wanted to make sure negative income paid at the end of a turn was in fact counted towards total money spent in respect to deciding who goes first. Yes I guess, so just a stupid question! thanks again, and huge respect for the thousands of comments answered this is crazy work!
@@gd1037 2- All of the tiles are called "Industry tiles". At the end of Canal Era you get victory points for all of your flipped industry tiles on the board, and then remove from the board all level 1 tiles, but leave higher level tiles there (flipped or not-flipped). That means that the flipped higher level tiles WILL be there to score AGAIN at the end of Rail Era: it doesn't matter if they are production (coal/iron/brewery) OR manufacturing (cotton/goods/pottery). VPs are given at the end of an Era, income is given only at the moment when you flip a tile (coal/iron/brewery: last item is taken from the tile; cotton/goods/pottery: using a sell action to flip). That means you CAN get VPs for a higher level industry tile twice during one game, but not income.
@@esarandom Thanks for answering. My question was more relating to resources since production tiles are flipped when all resources are removed, It is impossible to get VPs again in the railway era without upgrading the tile (I wanted to know if you ever added resources back on the tile, which was answered as a NO by the channel)
Fantastic tutorial, you do a cracking job on a very heavy game there Rodney! As someone who has lived in the Black Country my whole life, it’s crazy to hear you talking about my local area! Lol I’d also not heard that pronunciation of “iron” before - always fun to learn the different ways people can say words 😀
I've heard it once before, and wonder if it's a Canadian variant - and it sounds more like the word is actually spelled. Here in Pittsburgh it's often pronounced "arn."
Off-The-Cuff Gaming I'm not actually from Pittsburgh, though I've lived here for 30 years, but yes, many here would say "Arn Man." Iron City is a local beer (a bad one), and was often referred to as "Arn City."
First off, thank you so much for this wonderful video. It got my wife and I started (this was frankly our first board game purchased since childhood) and we are addicted. At 22:00, you describe how a player with a specific industry can sell only if connected via network to the respective merchant tile. I believe my wife and I had been playing incorrectly, but want to clarify. We had assumed that in order for something to be considered in network, you needed to own an industry in a specific city. From what you showed, you can build multiple sequential canals from one industry tile in a city to a merchant tile, without building an industry tile in the intervening cities, and still sell. That obviously has huge implications, because the way we were playing, you could build multiple industry tiles in a city during the rail era and effectively block your opponent from using that route. I guess we were wrong? One additional question I have is whether coal industries (like Gloucester) are considered part of your network, ie. you can build a canal or railroad during any move in the game extending from those spaces?
THIS was your first board game purchase since childhood? You both dove right into the deep end, and I'm so glad to hear you're enjoying it. Bravo :) Your question is a good one. It's a subtle part of the rules that is easy to miss. I was playing again recently and had to remind myself of that rule as well. A location is in your network if either of the following apply: -The location contains one or more of your Industry tiles - The location is adjacent to one or more of your Link tiles So even if Tamworth doesn't have one of your tiles in it, if your link is adjacent to it, then Tamworth is in YOUR network (people can't block you out by filling in all the spaces). This also means you can build links out from it, on any side, continuing to extend your network. So the way it is shown in the video is correct (whew!). I should mention, although no video is guaranteed to be perfect (sometimes things can get missed), all the videos we've created in the last 5 years have been done in co-operation with the publisher - they check over all the rules before I release the video, so you can general proceed with confidence. If we or the publisher do miss something, it will be in the description of the video, or in a pinned comment at the top (or both). And yep, your network can connect through places like Gloucester. Happy gaming!
I think there are two different questions to clear up in the first part. Watch It Played answered what counts as "in network", which is part of the original question. The original question also misstated ome of the rules. The merchant does NOT need to be in the players network. You only need to have the merchant connected to the industry tile you want to flip.
Regarding your last question, I don't think there was anything that said coal merchants are always part of your network. The official reply mentioned that they CAN be part of your network like any other city. In the first round you can build from them because you dont have a network yet.
Question- time 10:48 I understand the box. And what about coal - can I build it first? Before the box? And so is the city of Cannock. Do I have to build a lone coal first and then a box first? Or it does not matter. 1st box 2nd coal / 1st coal 2nd box ✨✨✨✨ Thank you very much for your work. It's a luxury. I'm from the Czech Republic and I don't speak English. Google Translator helps me. Even when watching videos.🎈
Hi Rodney, in 17:06 you mention that "if spaces open up in the market after [the building] has already been built no cubes are then sold to it from there". This can definitely happen for coal if someone buys coal from the market and there is an unconnected coal mine somewhere on the board. But in the video you are using iron as an example and I don't think there can ever be a situation where an iron space on the market can open up while iron cubes are still on the board. Iron need to be consumed from iron mines first and then from the market. Does that make sense?
Hi Michael, it is impossible for there to be iron on the board and demand (free spaces) in the iron market. Rodney essentially makes an error here by using Iron as his visual example, as it can only ever happen to coal, however, what he is saying in regards to selling to the market is correct.
Perfect video which explains such a hard game in about half an hour, well done! I have to admit that I played Brass Lancashire before and I have some doubts regarding both games... 1) Is the rule of building your ferry road in the first round is also applicable in Lancashire (by playing any of the cards you have in your hand)? 2) what if you want to buy a coal mine/ an iron works and there are no resources available in supplies (coal and iron)
1) As far as I remember, yes (but we do have a video that goes over the differences for Lancashire, if you want to check that out to be sure). 2) In the rare case you need extra cubes, temporarily borrow them from the very top spaces of the iron market, and return them back there when they are consumed from the board.
Hey Rodney At 18:26 Here you could sell the 4 iron also immediately on the market, after you have built the iron works and would then receive 18 money and flip the mine over and gain the income is that true?
Today I showed the video to my wife. English is not our first language. But we both understood you very well. And to be honest a thump down for this video clearly shows that you have no idea about heavy board games and how to teach them.
So glad you liked it! Sometimes a thumbs down is just because the game wasn't for them - it's not a vote against the video itself. Or maybe they just don't like me - which is okay too! :) That said, glad you found it helpful!
I love how you say iron. For us it is a silent R for you it is not. I am going to say it the way you have when I play it for the first time next Wednesday :) Thx for the tutorial
Hi Rodney! There are two questions.Could you confirm it and answer me please? (12:45)First, if there is an unflipped coal mine in Wolverhampton(right side), it is should be traded as the nearest one for the box tile on the left, it is right? (28:45)Second,if there is no any industry tile in Wolverhampton, even though in this case, the link between Wolverhampton and Coalbrookdale will still score from Coalbrookdale, it is right?
1) Yes, coal would be taken from a coal mine tile in the "same" city as a new tile being placed. That would be considered 'closest'. 2) Sorry, this question isn't clear enough for me to understand.
As known, scores are calculated on flipped industry tiles of canal/railway link connecting both sides, my concern is that if there’s is no any flipped industry tiles on one side or there is no any industry tiles put there, how the scores go?
I'm really sorry, it's not your fault, but I can't quite understand the question. I think it might be a bit of a language barrier. I'm sorry I'm having trouble helping.
Watch It Played Sorry I want to clarify that please refer to 28:45, as known the canal link between Coalbrookdale and Wolverhampton can get 5 victory points, my concern is 1) if there is no any industry tiles in Wolverhampton, how many VPs can be got? 2) you can see there is one industry tile flipped and another is unflipped in Wolverhampton, if these are two industry tiles are not been flipped, how many VPs canal link can get?
For those interested in the differences between Brass: Birmingham and Brass: Lanchashire, here is a list. (Please comment if I've missed something or gotten something wrong.) This list is copied from the reply thread to J. Bertels's comment.
In Lancashire:
1) The only commodity is cotton. There is no pottery, nor manufactured goods.
2) There are no breweries, nor beer. Double rail actions cost 15 pounds and two coal, but no beer.
3) Players can also build ports and shipyards. Shipyards are high point-value industries that flip immediately after being built. Shipyards with a lock symbol on them cannot be built in any era; they must be developed away. Ports are used to sell cotton.
4) Cotton can be sold either to any player's unflipped port (which flips both the port and the cotton mill) or to the distant market (special fixed locations around the edge of the board, or any player's flipped or unflipped port.) When selling to the distant market, players must turn over a distant market tile, reduce the distant market marker by the number on the tile, and then receive the income bonus on the new distant market spot (in addition to the income received from flipping the cotton mill.) If the distant market marker reaches the bottom of the track, the sale is canceled and no further sales to the distant market are possible that era. The distant market track is reset and market tiles reshuffled at the beginning of the rail era.
5) There are no wild cards. Instead, players may discard two cards (using both of their actions for a turn) in order to perform a build action at any location.
6) Players are not allowed to take loans in the final two rounds of the game. There's a placard placed in the draw deck during rail phase setup to remind players of this.
7) Players score 1VP per 10 pounds left in their player area at the end of the game.
Thanks for the excellent summary!
Players are not allowed to take loan in the final four rounds of the game ;))
There's also a slight change to the setup of the deck/hands at the start of the game with mechanically similar/identical effect.
Also, players may take loans of either 10, 20 or 30 pounds upon their choice, and decrease their income levels by 1, 2 or 3 accordingly.
And the map is different.
And another difference -- you begin Brass: Lancashire with 30 pounds (17 pounds for Brass: Birmingham).
This guy is the GOAT. Every time
I get a game, he’s the man I want to see
Very kind of you to say Ethan - thank you!
Absolutely without question. Every time I look for a rules vid, I'm so happy to see his smiling face!
Agreed. I only watch other people's game tutorials after I first see that Rodney hasn't made one yet.
We were so confused when we unboxed this game earlier. Now we are only slightly confused, and feel able at least to attempt it. Thank you!
I hope you have fun playing!
No matter the game, it is amazing how much time Rodney saves everybody in a clear and concise manner and the tip to listen to vids at a faster speed is also a good tip. No wonder BGG picked WatchItPlayed up. Keep up the good work and many happy work hours, Rodney.
Thanks as always for the kind words of support Akai! (you remain my favorite Samurai!)
@@WatchItPlayed love all your videos. Always brings a smile to my face when I find it's good old Rodney that's done the rules for a game we haven't played before
Having played this game once and watching other UA-cam channels, I can’t quite figure out why they included gold colored cubes rather than gray ones for Iron. It confuses me…🤣
It's helpful to note that the theme ties together some of the rules concepts. In general, *Brass isn't about selling commodities it's about establishing trade routes.* You have to ship coal and not iron because industries (and railroads) require a regular supply of coal to operate, while iron is only needed for maintenance and repairs. Flipping a tile doesn't mean you've exhausted that industry; it means you've established enough trade routes to use its full production capacity. Income represents excess profits, which helps understand why loans operate the way they do. Level 1 industries don't go out of business at the end of the canal phase (they still provide income, and their VPs aren't lost); they're just swamped by the economies of scale possible during the rail phase. Even the canals are still operating; it's just not economical to build more of them once rail is available.
Understanding the theme behind a game can be an excellent way to help rules stick in ones memories, so thanks a lot for these tips Twocinc! Good stuff!
twocinc When I’ve taught Brass L in the past I have always used that theming (businesses are establishing “customers” for what they produce and when supplying at capacity become profitable and (score vps in the scoring phases). Placing a tile on the board is just getting the initial infrastructure and workers in place - hence the initial capital cost. It’s very rare (as in these games) but laudable for the mechanics to so strongly reflect the theme that the theme is implied BY those mechanics. Well done to the designers!
The new Roxley edition misses this designer's notes from the old edition. They really helped me understand the game from the thematic point of view.
how can I get my hands on these notes?
If you were my teacher, I would've actually enjoyed this game.
First I watched two instructions in Polish. But in your instruction I understand more than in my own language! First time I seen something in this channel and its amazing! Really god job! SUBSCRIBED
Really nice to know this was helpful - I hope you have a great time playing Panek!
I always go to find Rodney's videos before anything else. He's helped me make informed purchases by watching the videos and getting a clear idea of the rules and finding out if a game will be right for me. Thank you so much.
Your tutorials are so amazing. The clarity and method of teaching makes it so easy to understand! Thank you so much!
You're too kind Cory - thank you!
I love that you pronounce the cities correctly. Thanks for this tutorial - I'm playing it for the first time tomorrow and was hoping you'd made a tutorial video for it!!
I hope you have a great time! I really did want to try to pronounce the names of the cities accurately - thanks for the feedback :)
Birmingham wasn't pronounced correctly
Anyone else here since it's now the #1 game on BGG?
Hope you get a chance to try the game!
Thanks Rodney, I just got my Deluxe Brass Birmingham and this walk through was great in getting me started. It was so much easier to follow than the rule book. Also, I’m British and you did a great job in getting the city names right 👍🏻
Ah, that's great to hear (both that it helped and that I didn't botch the pronunciations!)
Who in the world is giving a thumbs down to this video? Seriously? The organization and content of this video is *way* clearer than the rulebook.
Some people thumbs down if they don’t like the game, and others thumb down, probably because they don’t like me. I have some very loyal down thumbers :)
@@WatchItPlayed Not everyone can handle your awesomeness! I'm always so glad to see a new How to Play video, especially for a new game that I won't have to read through a rulebook multiple time! It helps contextualize the rules with your examples. Keep up the good work! Thumbs up!!!!
I'm just now investigating euro games as I'm relatively new to (rediscovering) board games and I am so happy Rodney has a video for this game!
Great to see you giving Euros a try. I came to them late, but found a whole bunch I really enjoyed. Hope you do too!
this how to video is so much better than reading the actual rule book. It's much easier to find the information I look for.
So glad you're finding it helpful!
Best Tutorial on UA-cam for this game. Thank you very much!
Very kind of you to say - have fun playing!
Thanks Rodney! I realize that we made 3 mistakes overall while playing. The understanding of the network, the scoring for canal and rail link which we did count only for our own tile instead of anybody tile and finally the develop action. We forgot to pay 1 iron to do that. We ended up having spent only 4 iron in the whole game lol. I don't know why we forgot that as I read the rule it's pretty clear. I knew there was something we did wrong. THanks for clearing this up!
Sometimes it just takes a second pass to get everything locked into the old noggin' - happy to have been able to assist!
Can't tell you how nice it is to hear an American say Birmingham like that :) great overview, I think I'm going to get it not only because it's a game set around my home city but looks like a nice complex step up from our usual games! cheers!
I wanted to make sure I got the names pronounced right, so I'm glad to hear I got close. Thanks for the kind words. I'm Canadian, but that's pretty close to America, I suppose :) Cheers!
@@WatchItPlayed I do apologise! It makes sense that you're Canadian, my sister lives there and she told me people are always very respectful when it comes to pronouncing names :) great channel btw glad I found it
@@yinbakalu Glad to have you here!
This is the best explanation of the game ever. In my motherlanguage most of it sounds unclear but here everything is on point. Thank you!
Ah, that means a lot - really nice to know that this video was helpful where the rule book created some challenges.
Man I am loving these 4k videos. Really helps in seeing all the text and details when showing the board
I hoped that would be helpful for viewers. Lots of small text in games!
Hi from turkiye
We met Brass 2 months ago. We are happy to play with my wife at home. It really deserves to be number 1 in board games.
Cheers to Creator 🎉
Very glad you've been enjoying it - greetings from Canada!
Je n'ai jamais vu une vidéo de règles aussi bien réalisée et expliquée. Et pourtant, j'en ai vu !! Bravo, c'est réellement très impressionnant !!!!!!!
Merci beaucoup, vous êtes très gentil!
I moved to Birmingham recently, and I am going to play this game tomorrow. Your tutorial is just perfect, clear and organized! Thank you so much!
Hope the move went smoothly, and hope the game play does as well :)
OUT OF THE PARK Rodney! Your new camera is AMAZING and the video quality is amazing. I also love your titles. I was hoping for you to do this game. We learned about London from you, and it remains one of our favorite games. So, of course when I saw another game by the same writer, I was hoping for a new game to add. Based on your video, I have already placed my order. I think we are going to absolutely LOVE it! Thank you so much for your incredible video!!
Thank you so much for the kind words Frank! Glad that I could help you make up your mind on the game!
@@WatchItPlayed I downloaded the iPad app, and it was not so much. But the art, and it being a Martin Wallace makes all the difference. The iPad app is meh. But we were still wanting to give it a fair shake. The board looks amazing. Hope there a not a mother more changes for the pre ordered version. Also just ordered Legends of Andor. I hope I don't have to start collecting all the expansions for that. BGG seems to suggest that the primary game has a lot of promise. But again, thank you for upping your equipment and editing. Makes it easier to get an idea what to expect!!!! You guys rock it. ( also love how you say Iron in your local Canadian Tongue. My son, native to California said it the same way as you and yours. His grandfather was from French Canadian dissent after all!!
You done messed up, A-I-ron
Nat 20 on the LOL.
Again great content! High production value. Nice graphic overlays, item fade-ins and just overall editing. I really like the approach of first do the setup and then explain each round/action without adding extra context/clutter to your instructions. Keeping the instructions minimal while still making sure to cover all the rules must take up a lot of time and effort.
We've tried to hone the process over the years, so thanks for the kind comments!
Rodney never ceases to impress! What a fantastic tutorial... thanks for your videos ... waiting for my game to arrive ...
I hope you're not waiting much longer and have a wonderful time with it when it arrives!
Thanks for the coherency and simplicity of this video! It was both my first time and all my friend's first times and we played without a hitch!
So glad you enjoyed the video - hope you had fun with the game too!
@@WatchItPlayed We did! It's my favorite board game now :)
@ Ah, that’s so great to hear. It’s so good :)
I played Lancashire a week ago for the first time. This video is also perfect for repeating the rules while learning Birmingham at the same time. Thank you very much.
You're very welcome!
It’s the first time I watched your gaming rules and I must admit: holy cow - how simple and well explained. Thank you. Your new subscriber.
Very glad to have you here - and glad you enjoyed!
What a thorough, well-edited, all around excellent explanation! Thank you! I can't wait to play :)
I hope you have a great time - thanks for the kind comment!
I already played Birmingham once, but decided to listen to your video, and caught something we had all forgotten: that you'd have to pay with your industries if you had no money and still owed more to the bank during income. I had skimmed the rules during our play and saw the part where you'd lose VPs, but not the one about industries. I think the same rule already existed in the base game, but I hadn't played it in a while, and I've yet to see this happen.
Anyway, I'm saving this to point people to it before they play the game. It's extremely helpful, as are all your videos. :)
Thank you so much Radu - glad the video helped catch an easy to miss rule!
Very impressive teaching. Clear, concise, and accurate. Thank you.
Just saw you did All Bridges Burning. Nice!
@@WatchItPlayed That one was a beast!
Well done Rodney! That was a very clear and poignant look at the rules for playing Brass Birmingham. Your fellow Canadians applaud you.
Thanks you, fellow Canucks!
Your videos are so high quality. It really makes watching the game enjoyable. Excellent work! Keep going!
Very kind of you to say - thanks so much!
Best board game explanation of Brass Birmingham
Thank you kindly!
Rodney you have absolutely outdone yourself with this one mate. Phenomenal video. It is a heavier game but your explanation was so on point...I can't imagine explaining this any better. One suggestion though would be maybe to add some more thematic explanation for the game mechanics. You have done this here (e.g. why Iron can be transported without links) but a few more examples would have been great (e.g. what's up with the weird rules around beer and barrels?). Thanks for everything!
Thanks for the kind words, and the feedback. It's a bit of balancing act, determining how much information to include, particularly in the longer videos. The more I add, the longer it gets, but I agree - the thematic justifications, often lock the information into your brain - which can be useful, especially during the longer videos!
I know this is silly, but you said Lancashire and Birmingham correctly, and I really appreciate that 👍🏻😂
I did my best! :)
Perfect instruction. So clear and ordered, makes it easy to memorize rules of the game. There are a few, but you made it sound simple. Thank you.
Very kind of you to say - very glad you enjoyed!
Man, this was an amazing video. Thanks a bunch for letting me not having chaos the first time me and my family play the game. Great stuff!
So glad this was helpful - I hope you all have a great time playing!
For a long time I had been looking at Birmingham and I couldn't wrap my head around it. I didn't know anybody that had played it let alone anyone who had played Original Brass. It had so many tokens I was very hesitant to pick it up. It's because of this video (and other channels like shut up &Sit Down and other playthroughs) that I think I finally understand how this game works. I bought the Deluxe version of the game and I cant wait to teach my friends. Thank you so much for this Rodney!
I think it would be amazing if you could teach this on "Game Night!". Perhaps one day?
Won't be leaving the country for awhile yet, I don't think :) I hope you have a great time playing!
Best explanation ever!!..Mr Rodney is the best game reviewer ever walked the Earth!!!...and of course a wonderful person!!!💖💖💖
You are altogether too kind, but very glad to know you enjoyed the video :)
Second video I have watched from Rodney. Great pace, well written, very clear.
Thank you kindly Patrick!
Thanks for a great overview! Watched your video before I went to play tonight, and I was able to hit the ground running.
Wonderful to hear Chris - glad you enjoyed!
You are always a big help Rodney. We are a very small group of people playing these new world board games in India. It's a start.
We always see your video first and then start the game. Thanks for the good work....
Thank you for the kind words - I hope you have a great time playing (and spreading the hobby!)
Can I just say thank you. As someone born and raised in Birmingham, it's good to hear the correct pronunciation of the name and not the over emphasis a lot of people not from the UK put on the 'ham' of Birmingham.
Also another great how to tutorial.
Thanks Warlock - I sometimes fail, but I do try to get pronunciations right :)
Haha Warlock, yes, agreed, no HAM in Bermingum! And not Lancashyer...! Also, how annoying it is that so many south of Coventry pronounce it Birminum! Well done Rodney! I love the American pronunciation of Worcestershire; Warchestershyer!
@@marklong4317 Yes, it's nearly as enjoyable as the British saying 'Hooston' for Houston and 'Ar-KAN-zuz' for Arkansas, amongst many others I have heard. Mispronunciation goes both ways. My favourite American mispronunciation of a British place name is Lye-chester for Leicester...
@@marklong4317 Canadian! You messed up there!
@Stuart Baird I’m aware Rodney is Canadian, and as he states earlier he tries his best with pronunciation. Sorry if you’re upset by the “American” categorisation but it’s true Yanks have some strange pronunciations, but like stated earlier, lots of people pronounce words incorrectly, including Brits getting their own nation’s words wrong, like Berminum, Soufampton, nuffin’ and bovver! Hope this clears me of messing up...
Thank you so much Rodney. Just picked this up and your video helped immensely (as usual 😁). Keep up the great work! We're supporting you from West Texas!
Thanks for the support Jonathan - glad you enjoyed!
Thank you so much for this clear video! This helps so much and now it doesn't really seem as bad as people make it. I'm very much looking forward to this!
I hope you have a great time playing James!
I wonder how many times someone has said "I drink your milkshake!" while stealing their opponent's beer?
If not for you I would never be into board games, you've helped me learn terraforming mars which made me fall in love with board games. Thank you for all your content
So very nice of you to say - I'm glad to have been a small part of your enthusiasm for the hobby!
Usually I watch rule videos in german. We just bought the game. And honestly all german rule videos suck. Since rule videos often contains errors, I still read the rulebook also to know where to look in case of a question.
You are explaining this game extremly well and if I match what you say with the rulebook also flawlessly.
Thank you for that, I finally think I fully understand the game, can teach it to friends and game night is next weekend
So nice to know that this video was helpful - have fun playing!
Thanks for an excellent tutorial. Concise and wonderfully presented. Much appreciated.
Thanks Helen, so glad you enjoyed!
Thanks for clip, just grabbed my copy and rulebook was still confusing despite I've played Lancashire already, as always brilliantly explained all nuances.
Have a fantastic time playing!
You have high teaching skills, practice or talent and I am so happy to have found your video. Thank you for the time put in this!
Thanks for the kind words - glad you enjoyed!
Great tutorial as always! Greetings from Łódź/Poland :).
Very glad you enjoyed!
Great Video Rodney!! Helped a lot when we started playing yesterday!!!!! Perfect timing!
So nice to hear Bryan!
As usual, just an outstanding job of teaching one of the more complex games out there in the mass market!! Your kung fu is the best!
Thank you kindly!
I read the rules, then watched this and I feel ready to go! Thanks for the excellent work!
So glad it was helpful - have a great time playing!
Great video as usual Rodney! This is my next game in the queue to learn/play and you’ve once again provided a half hour well spent to enable many future hours of fun!
So glad to hear. Have a great time playing!
As someone finally getting this to the table tomorrow, in 2021, thanks Rodney!!! Excellent as always! Also happy 10 year!
It's never too late to get a great game to the table - have a wonderful time playing :)
Question: At 21:36 you can see two tiles of the same player on one place (Wolverhampton). Didnt you say earlier its not allowed to build on a place where you already have a tile?
Correct. You can only do that in the rail era. That tile appears to have snuck into the wrong place when I was creating my example. Good catch!
Thank you for this tutorial man. Your explaination is clean and simple and does always answer my additional questions. 👌
So nice to hear. Have a fun time playing!
Eye-Ron. Great video!
Thanks for checking out the video!
I'm glad I'm not the only one that heard it.
"eye-ron" lol
But it doesn't take away from the incredible good he did teaching this game so well.
The only downside of Rodney doing such a great job is, it’s costing me a fortune to buy these games because I want them all 😂
Seriously, great job again. I’ve been debating getting this game for some time and, yet again, you’ve sold it to me.
Keep up the excellent work Rodney.
Have a great time playing it Mark!
A brilliant explanation, a so well done video. Thank you.
Thank you kindly!
Nice one, Dave. Really good explanation of a fairly complex game.
Not sure who Dave is, but glad you found it helpful!
Thanks for the amazing video. Really helped me out when learning this game!
So nice to hear!
amazing good tutorial to re-again gain the rules after long break from the game ! many thanks Rodney!
A pleasure Jens - hope you have a great time re-playing!
@@WatchItPlayed yes We Played right Afterwards , thanks to your Help we get Brass right ;)
You do a god job of explaining the game. Very easy and clear. Thx
So glad you enjoyed!
OMG this is very heavy... thanks I didn't back it... not my type of game. Great video by the way.
Glad you found it helpful, nothing wrong with discovering a game might not be for you :)
I really appreciate this "Watch It played".
You're welcome!
Nice work on this overview. This is the best one I have seen from you yet!
Thank you kindly!
Great video Rodney, would love you to do a version using Automa rules.
Thanks for the interest - glad you enjoyed the video Shane!
When you "Overbuilt" the Iron Works @18:26 wouldn't you also sell all four iron cubes to the marketplace immediately... as instructed during the first tile placement instruction?
Yes, absolutely - sorry for any confusion there, this part of the video was explaining the overbuild rules specifically, so that's what I was limiting by focus too in the example, but all other rules still apply as normal when you're actually playing.
Best tutorial for a complex game I've seen in a while. Rodney is the god of tuts. I have 2 small questions:
1. Is beer ever replenished on a merchant tile (the outer side of the map, the barrel that gives immediate bonus when taken) once somebody sold , e.g., cotton industry through it?
2. When you take the beer (consume it) from any merchant, or from your brewery, where does it go? Outside of the board in the general supply?
Because in the rulebook its noted that the player who receives (or consumes?) the beer (the one player who is fast enough to sell first through that merchant), receives ONE FREE BEER. What do they mean with this?
Thanks for the kind words!
The beer is replenished on each merchant tile at the end of the canal era. The beer that you take is simply added back to the general supply, receiving the free beer in that moment essentially means that you don't have to spend one of your own or one from your opponents.
@@WatchItPlayed thanks Rodney. I was kind of confused because I thought I want to spend my beer from my brewery as soon as possible so I can flip the tile and gain the bonuses. Maybe it'll make more sense once I get to play a game of Birmingham.
You're probably right! You might want to use yours, but you definitely don't want to use an opponent's beer.
Hey, everybody, I heard there’s FREE BEER! Come and get it!!!!!!
Also, I’m pretty sure the rules are saying that you must have actual beer on hand that you must consume whenever you take the sell action. Game balance at its finest! 😂
If i am going to play a game for the first time and i really want to go into the rules, the first thing i check is if you made a tutorial. Thanx!
So glad to hear it Tim, I'm glad you find them helpful!
Thanks for the video. I’m looking forward playing
Have a great time!
Hi ...
Im from Iran🇮🇷 and im one of your fans .
Greetings from Canada!
I just love your teaching. You have a real gift!
Very kind of you to say - thank you!
Very clear and helpful video, saved me a lot of trouble! Grats, looking forward to play it!
Have a great time!
Thank you for the clear and concise video! After playing my first game, I have a few questions that arose between the players and that aren't clearly touched upon in the video. For anyone that can answer them:
- The written rulebook seems to claim (ambiguously) that it is possible to sell several industries using only one action (paying multiple barrels if needed of course), is it one sale per action or multiple?
- when going to the railway era you flip industries of lvl 2 or more back up but do NOT put the resources back on mines correct? Therefore coal and iron mines are sitting on the map but cannot earn you victory points unless you upgrade them. I find it weird the rules don't clarify this anywhere.
-This one might be trivial but, when you settle income at the end of the turn, any interest that needs to be paid goes the player token and counts towards turn order right? For some reason one of the players would not accept this so I'm asking.
major thanks to anyone who can help on one of theses points.
Hey Gaspard, glad you enjoyed the video! The answers to your questions are covered in the video, so let's go through them:
1) You were wondering whether you can sell several industries in a single action. That's covered here: ua-cam.com/video/Lzxf4tfq9as/v-deo.html
2a) I'm not clear on what you mean by "when going to the railway era you flip industries of lvl 2 or more back up". Here is the section of the video that covers the Canal Era - as you'll see, no where do you flip any tiles: ua-cam.com/video/Lzxf4tfq9as/v-deo.html.
2b) You also asked if iron or coal is returned to tiles in the Canal era - you won't see this question addressed in the video, because coal and iron is never added back to those tiles. Adding resources back to tiles isn't something you do, so it's not something you'd find mentioned in the video.
3) When you say "any interest that needs to be paid", what are you referring to? What interest? Perhaps you could tell me which page of the rule book, and section you are referring to, so I can understand what you are asking about.
@@WatchItPlayed thank you so much for being so responsive!
1- Gotcha, I watched the whole thing twice but I guess my brain didn't register and its a little unclear in the written rules.
2- thanks, it just felt weird that it isn't possible to get victory points a second time from mine tiles unlike the industries tiles so I felt compelled to ask.
3- I wanted to make sure negative income paid at the end of a turn was in fact counted towards total money spent in respect to deciding who goes first. Yes I guess, so just a stupid question!
thanks again, and huge respect for the thousands of comments answered this is crazy work!
@@gd1037 No worries at all, very happy to help. Have a great time playing!!
@@gd1037 2- All of the tiles are called "Industry tiles". At the end of Canal Era you get victory points for all of your flipped industry tiles on the board, and then remove from the board all level 1 tiles, but leave higher level tiles there (flipped or not-flipped). That means that the flipped higher level tiles WILL be there to score AGAIN at the end of Rail Era: it doesn't matter if they are production (coal/iron/brewery) OR manufacturing (cotton/goods/pottery).
VPs are given at the end of an Era, income is given only at the moment when you flip a tile (coal/iron/brewery: last item is taken from the tile; cotton/goods/pottery: using a sell action to flip). That means you CAN get VPs for a higher level industry tile twice during one game, but not income.
@@esarandom Thanks for answering. My question was more relating to resources since production tiles are flipped when all resources are removed, It is impossible to get VPs again in the railway era without upgrading the tile (I wanted to know if you ever added resources back on the tile, which was answered as a NO by the channel)
Impressive explanation! So clear and well-structured. Thanks!
Hey, so glad you found it helpful - thanks for the kind comment!
Fantastic tutorial, you do a cracking job on a very heavy game there Rodney! As someone who has lived in the Black Country my whole life, it’s crazy to hear you talking about my local area!
Lol I’d also not heard that pronunciation of “iron” before - always fun to learn the different ways people can say words 😀
Thank you for the kind words :) I do hear that my pronunciation of this word is different than some!
Watch It Played lol Variety is the spice of life! Any game featuring the Avengers will take a neat twist 😁
I've heard it once before, and wonder if it's a Canadian variant - and it sounds more like the word is actually spelled. Here in Pittsburgh it's often pronounced "arn."
Eric Kaun oh cool, I did not know that. Do you use the same pronunciation for Iron Man?
Off-The-Cuff Gaming I'm not actually from Pittsburgh, though I've lived here for 30 years, but yes, many here would say "Arn Man." Iron City is a local beer (a bad one), and was often referred to as "Arn City."
As someone from Cannock, it always excites me seeing it in-game. 😂
Same for myself and Walsall. 😂
Thank you, Rodney, as there is no other video with such a clear explanation as always you're the best.
Thank you kindly Juan!
First off, thank you so much for this wonderful video. It got my wife and I started (this was frankly our first board game purchased since childhood) and we are addicted.
At 22:00, you describe how a player with a specific industry can sell only if connected via network to the respective merchant tile. I believe my wife and I had been playing incorrectly, but want to clarify. We had assumed that in order for something to be considered in network, you needed to own an industry in a specific city. From what you showed, you can build multiple sequential canals from one industry tile in a city to a merchant tile, without building an industry tile in the intervening cities, and still sell. That obviously has huge implications, because the way we were playing, you could build multiple industry tiles in a city during the rail era and effectively block your opponent from using that route. I guess we were wrong?
One additional question I have is whether coal industries (like Gloucester) are considered part of your network, ie. you can build a canal or railroad during any move in the game extending from those spaces?
THIS was your first board game purchase since childhood? You both dove right into the deep end, and I'm so glad to hear you're enjoying it. Bravo :)
Your question is a good one. It's a subtle part of the rules that is easy to miss. I was playing again recently and had to remind myself of that rule as well.
A location is in your network if either of the following apply:
-The location contains one or more of your Industry tiles
- The location is adjacent to one or more of your Link tiles
So even if Tamworth doesn't have one of your tiles in it, if your link is adjacent to it, then Tamworth is in YOUR network (people can't block you out by filling in all the spaces). This also means you can build links out from it, on any side, continuing to extend your network.
So the way it is shown in the video is correct (whew!). I should mention, although no video is guaranteed to be perfect (sometimes things can get missed), all the videos we've created in the last 5 years have been done in co-operation with the publisher - they check over all the rules before I release the video, so you can general proceed with confidence. If we or the publisher do miss something, it will be in the description of the video, or in a pinned comment at the top (or both).
And yep, your network can connect through places like Gloucester.
Happy gaming!
I think there are two different questions to clear up in the first part. Watch It Played answered what counts as "in network", which is part of the original question. The original question also misstated ome of the rules. The merchant does NOT need to be in the players network. You only need to have the merchant connected to the industry tile you want to flip.
Regarding your last question, I don't think there was anything that said coal merchants are always part of your network. The official reply mentioned that they CAN be part of your network like any other city. In the first round you can build from them because you dont have a network yet.
Question- time 10:48
I understand the box. And what about coal - can I build it first? Before the box?
And so is the city of Cannock. Do I have to build a lone coal first and then a box first? Or it does not matter. 1st box 2nd coal / 1st coal 2nd box
✨✨✨✨
Thank you very much for your work. It's a luxury. I'm from the Czech Republic and I don't speak English. Google Translator helps me. Even when watching videos.🎈
As long as you have a way to pay the cost of the tile you want to place, you can build them in any order.
@@WatchItPlayedThank you very much. I am very happy. ✨ We will finally play it as it should. You are a very kind guy. 🎈
Well this came out just in time. Can learn this game and play it a lot sooner than I normally would. Thanks for the great tutorial as usual!
You're welcome! Glad the video was a help to you!
Thank you Rodney. Just Ace. Now i know how to play Brass Birmingham 😊
I hope you have a great time playing!
Nailed it, as always. You are so good at this, Rodney! Thanks for all your effort.
Very kind of you to say Stacie!
Hi Rodney, in 17:06 you mention that "if spaces open up in the market after [the building] has already been built no cubes are then sold to it from there". This can definitely happen for coal if someone buys coal from the market and there is an unconnected coal mine somewhere on the board. But in the video you are using iron as an example and I don't think there can ever be a situation where an iron space on the market can open up while iron cubes are still on the board. Iron need to be consumed from iron mines first and then from the market. Does that make sense?
Hi Michael, unfortunately, I’m travelling right now, and can’t easily check the video itself. Sorry I can’t give a more definitive answer right now.
Hi Michael, it is impossible for there to be iron on the board and demand (free spaces) in the iron market. Rodney essentially makes an error here by using Iron as his visual example, as it can only ever happen to coal, however, what he is saying in regards to selling to the market is correct.
Unbelievably clear and concise. Thank you !
Very kind of you to say - have a great time playing!
Perfect video which explains such a hard game in about half an hour, well done! I have to admit that I played Brass Lancashire before and I have some doubts regarding both games...
1) Is the rule of building your ferry road in the first round is also applicable in Lancashire (by playing any of the cards you have in your hand)?
2) what if you want to buy a coal mine/ an iron works and there are no resources available in supplies (coal and iron)
1) As far as I remember, yes (but we do have a video that goes over the differences for Lancashire, if you want to check that out to be sure).
2) In the rare case you need extra cubes, temporarily borrow them from the very top spaces of the iron market, and return them back there when they are consumed from the board.
@@WatchItPlayed Thank you very much, for sure I'll watch it🙂
Hey Rodney
At 18:26 Here you could sell the 4 iron also immediately on the market, after you have built the iron works and would then receive 18 money and flip the mine over and gain the income is that true?
Yep, you've got it! (I was just showing Overbuilding there, so didn't follow it through, but you've got it exactly right).
I only learned about this game recently, looks great! It's very strange to see my little home town on an international board game haha
The game has been quite a hit - I hope you get a chance to try it!
Brilliant explanation once again. Love your vids👍🏻
Thank you kindly Lee!
Today I showed the video to my wife. English is not our first language. But we both understood you very well.
And to be honest a thump down for this video clearly shows that you have no idea about heavy board games and how to teach them.
So glad you liked it! Sometimes a thumbs down is just because the game wasn't for them - it's not a vote against the video itself. Or maybe they just don't like me - which is okay too! :) That said, glad you found it helpful!
Another excellent tutorial! Cheers to you Rodney! You've opened so many doors for so many people in this hobby!
Thank you kindly Tim - have fun playing!
I love how you say iron. For us it is a silent R for you it is not. I am going to say it the way you have when I play it for the first time next Wednesday :) Thx for the tutorial
This did prompt a lot of responses :) Have a great time playing!
Hi Rodney! There are two questions.Could you confirm it and answer me please? (12:45)First, if there is an unflipped coal mine in Wolverhampton(right side), it is should be traded as the nearest one for the box tile on the left, it is right? (28:45)Second,if there is no any industry tile in Wolverhampton, even though in this case, the link between Wolverhampton and Coalbrookdale will still score from Coalbrookdale, it is right?
1) Yes, coal would be taken from a coal mine tile in the "same" city as a new tile being placed. That would be considered 'closest'.
2) Sorry, this question isn't clear enough for me to understand.
As known, scores are calculated on flipped industry tiles of canal/railway link connecting both sides, my concern is that if there’s is no any flipped industry tiles on one side or there is no any industry tiles put there, how the scores go?
I'm really sorry, it's not your fault, but I can't quite understand the question. I think it might be a bit of a language barrier. I'm sorry I'm having trouble helping.
Watch It Played Sorry I want to clarify that please refer to 28:45, as known the canal link between Coalbrookdale and Wolverhampton can get 5 victory points, my concern is 1) if there is no any industry tiles in Wolverhampton, how many VPs can be got? 2) you can see there is one industry tile flipped and another is unflipped in Wolverhampton, if these are two industry tiles are not been flipped, how many VPs canal link can get?
My game group is going to be playing this and my only thought was thank god Rodney has a video for this game
I hope you all have a great time playing!