Everything Wrong With CinemaSins: Joker in 19 Minutes or Less
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 сер 2024
- Sinning CinemaSins' Joker video.
Enjoy!
Music in Intro: Weird Part of the Night by Louis Cole: • Weird Part of the Nigh...
Link in the video: • Thanos vs The Joker: W...
======================================================
===IF YOU'D LIKE TO DONATE TO ME===
Paypal: PayPal.Me/Th3Birdman1515
Patreon: / th3birdman
Twitch Donation: streamlabs.com...
===IF YOU'D LIKE TO FOLLOW ME===
Twitch: / th3birdman15
Twitter: / th3birdman15 @Th3Birdman15
Instagram: / th3birdman15
Discord: nQZRn5m
Subreddit: / th3birdman
Facebook: / th3birdman15
Subscribe: / th3birdman
======================================================
Disclaimer: I actually REALLY enjoy CinemaSins, and am only making fun of them here. I do not hate them, nor am I a "hater". This video is all in good fun.
======================================================
***Th3Birdman merchandise can be purchased at either of these links:
teespring.com/...
represent.com/...
======================================================
The "EWW CinemaSins" Playlist: • EWW CinemaSins
CinemaSins' Channel can be found here: / cinemasins Subscribe!
Their "Joker" video can be found here:
• Everything Wrong With ...
My Equipment:
Microphone: Blue Yeti Pro/Blue Yeti
Editing Software: Premiere Pro CC 2020
Thanks for watching, and have an awesome day buds!
#Joker #JoaquinPhoenix #EverythingWrongWith
Hopefully you enjoy this controversial episode. Lol
What did you think about this video? Comment below, you clowns!
Th3Birdman you are awesome and I hope you have long and happy life.
Th3Birdman do you think making a 20 minute video in one day deserves a patreon donation also the video was better then your sucker punch video I know that’s now saying a lot but work with me here
Yay! Future Birdman
Th3Birdman I actually really liked this video
it was good 👍
One detail I really quite liked because they never draw attention to it: When Arthur runs, even out of costume he lifts his feet far more than would actually be necessary. Always in clown shoes, even when he isn't.
And that detail is Joaquin Phoenix's work. When they used stuntmen, they couldn't replicate the running style of Joaquin. The director thought the run was very special and great addition that only Joaquin could do. Todd Phillips mentioned that in one interview.
Ooo.
Kind of like a prisoner who’s forgotten that their shackles were removed
Relatable
I run very similar to that. A lot of people do. A lot of people are born with their bones not aligned right or whatever. Idk what it's called.
CinemaSins: *Uploads a video on Joker*
Th3Birdman: "I am speed."
That’s what caring about your fans is all about
Yep.
The Cloaked Schemer Are you referencing Cars? Because as you can tell by my profile picture I love that movie!
"I am speed", was that a Flash reference? Dangit, now I'm trying to remember if that's a thing he's said. Or one of the Flashes anyway...
@@brennanhearn6342 Flash used that line against Quicksilver in Death Battle. He may have used it in the comics also but I'm not to sure on that one.
"why didn't Joker tell the boss that thieves took his sign?" he did, the boss didn't believe him so Randall gives him the gun that he later ends up using to shoot the three people on the subway. That's such an important plot point in the movie that just... what the fuck LOL
What's interesting about that scene is that he believes Arthur took sign and doesn't care that he had no reason to take it, but doesn't believe that someone else stole the sign because it doesn't make sense to him.
He also waited to tell his boss if he would have immediately told him it would have been different
It’s a “sin” both CinemaSins & Th3Birdman makes in missing that Arthur did try telling his boss but was dismissed.
@@coreyfaith69 how would that have changed anything?
@@conradlorgar5508 if my employee says they just stole my stuff I might belive that but if they come to me and say they stole my stuff 4 hours ago I'm gonna assume something funky happened
I refuse to believe there are actually 5 writers that work at CinemaSins. With the sheer amount of mistakes these videos make, I always assumed Jeremy was just a one man show making these.
that makes it more egregious imo this whole time i assumed that Jeremy was more a less a moron that had struck gold but you're telling me there are 4 other assholes that proofread this shit. that's insanity
Exactly. Especially since SO often their mistakes, are made when pointing out a “mistake” in a movie that if they did 1 second of research they would know it wasn’t a mistake. If you want an example of this, their Moana video is filled with those kinds of sins.
Remember that there's movies and songs that need that much of writers and you still wonder how it is possible to be that simple
@@emilyfisher7060 the moana video pissed me off so much!! they were literally sinning things about the culture!
@@moonlobotomy9061 You want a cinemasins video that shits on culture? Watch the one on Coco. It pissed me off so bad.
Birdman: “You’re awful Jeremy”
CinemaSins: “Me? I’m Awful? Oh yeah how am I awful?”
Birdman: “Sinning the movie, making unrelated jokes, calling it bad”
What do you get when you cross a great movie with a channel that beats and treats it like trash
I'll tell you what you get Jeremy
*proceeds to shoot Jeremy in the head*
Birdman: Don't get me fucking started
What do you get, when you cross an unfunny, unintelligent soyboy with A SOCIETY, THAT WILL CLICK ON ANYTHING?!?!
@@premiumloser3988 You get what you fucking deserve! *clicks dislike*
Personally, I don't think the whole movie is imaginary, definitely parts of it, but not all of it
KanitoKawaii it’s a story told by joker. His memory is flaky at best so some parts are 100% real but (like real memories) sometimes things are off
@@legomeaker101potato yeah, but through the whole movie his neighbour is his girlfriend, if the whole movie is told by joker, than how when he get's in her apartment she's afraid of him and doesn't really know him?
Some thing are just in his head, but some things "really" happen
@@38bmxboy because that also happened to him. according to his own memory, she acted strangely that day but the rest of the time she acted "normally" people with memory issues sometimes remember things that didn't happen and sometimes they remember things exactly how they happened
To me, this movie is one of the “multiple choice” that Joker gives for his backstory. Was his pregnant wife killed in a fire? Is his name Arthur Fleck? Was his father a drinker and a fiend? No one knows. Not even the Joker knows at this point. But the thing that strings all of these together, is the one bad day
Yeah, only parts arent fully true. Its an unreliable narrator thing, not fully untrue.
1:43
"Arthur has no good reason to run after some kids who stole his sign. He should just tell his boss it got stolen."
Cinemasins just suggested that a man on the edge of poverty should just tell his boss his sign was stolen, which would most likely result in the sign being deducted from his pay, which he can't possibly afford to have happen to him, as opposed to attempting to retrieve said sign. This is literally what happens when Arthur literally tries to do what you just suggested and tells his boss it was stolen. In short: Jeremy doesn't understand poverty.
**Ding**
In short, Jeremy has never worked a minimum wage job where they treat shit like this your fault.
@@SparkleDeluxe_minecrafter in shorter: Maybe Jeremy needs to check is *_P R I V I L E G E_*
@@MattBnl2ih I know you're joking but he probably actually does need to.
At this point, Cinemasins is just a parody of itself. I also noticed a lot of their 'sins' were things I saw in articles around the film's release, so now they're just copying other people on the internet, which is laaaaaazy
Yeah I know
Ok is no one going to notice how nice his joker laugh was seriously it’s pretty good
Spider-Manfanboi 2004 No.
Yeah, he has like, the best joker laugh in live action.
Edit: I thought we were talking about Phoenix's laugh lmao, but this guy's laugh was spot on to ledger's, yes
Yeah, it was pretty neat.
Yeah, I was like holy sh*t that was perfect!
Yes! His laugh was so... Perfect/real it fascinates me Everytime I watch joker
Uh...Arthur DID tell his boss Raphael that he got jumped. He literally says "I told you." It's almost like his boss doesn't listen to him, and Jeremy doesn't listen to dialogue.
Since the movie was shown by an unreliable narrator, I think that his boss did listen to him, but didn't do much, so in the jokers mind, his boss didn't listen to him
@@fatquickscope4150 Well you really pulled that out of your ass, didn't you?
James Oblivion would be amazing at cinema sins
So, I rewatched the scene, and his boss tells him that there was a complaint that he never returned the sign and Arthur responds, "Because I got jumped. Didn't you hear?" His boss says, "For a sign?", then goes on for a bit more and Arthur says "Why would I keep his sign?" and after the boss talks for a while until it cuts to Arthur kicking trash. So he doesn't actually say "I told you" and "Didn't you hear?" actually seems to indicate that he did never tell him and assumed word got around.
Also, I love the movie, so please don't think I did this out of anger, just wanted to fact-check this.
@@ethanp1348 I stand corrected on the specific line. I misremembered the "Didn't you hear" line. It still indicates that he expected Hoyt to know what had happened. The other clowns knew Arthur got jumped.
I wasn’t ready for that Kobe Bryant joke. RIP.
Thanks Captain Obvious :’(
Kobe died 9 months ago?
@@colorfulmind473 this comment was made 9 months ago.
@@DK-gl3ih I was just surprised how fast time goes by. Now kobe died 11 months ago.. RIP
Please never forget about helicopter safety
Side note for the gun. My grandpa was a sherrif, and his revolver had 8 chambers. Revolvers with 8 bullets isn't such a far stretch.
I own a sw 627 8 shot 357
Say what you want about Jeremy, I still think it's amazing how he manages to edit reviews on films without actually watching them. It's a rare and infuriating talent.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Oh yeah totaaly not biased
I don't even think he read the wiki article for the film.
Jeremy: "This is a great shot. This whole movie is full of great shots. Great acting, great set designs. It's one of the most well made movies I've ever hated!"
THEN WHAT THE HECK ARE YOU COMPLAINING ABOUT?
Get him, Birdman! Get him!
Madcat4301 Something can have all of that and you can still dislike it, it can also have all of that and still not be good. I’m not saying I agree with his opinion at all.
Madcat4301 Oh yeah, I remember that was the first time in the video where I paused and thought “Did I hear that right? Did this dude just sin a movie for having gorgeous shots?”
Because views.
@@Someguyy867 I mean yeah he can still dislike the movie since it is personal taste but sinning it for being good or not liking it is stupid.
Someguyy867, it’s usually the opposite actually because people that hate Steven Universe like myself only hates the series for having shitty music, shitty choreography, and shitty written characters whereas games like Bayonetta are popular and beloved by almost every video game fan is because it has great choreography, well written characters, and it has great music.
The sin about Joker’s laugh should’ve been worth another hundred sins
Honestly I’ve hated cinemasins for a while now, it just straight up feels like they don’t know what they’re talking about and are biting off more than they can chew given the parameters of what their channel sets to do. They need to stop trying to analyze film, and just go back to pointing out the actual plot holes and things in movies.
The whole point is that they don’t know what they’re talking ab tho. But yeah the plot holes were more fun :(
Yeah I know
Cinemawins may be "overly positive" or "too forgiving", but you could tell they understand what makes a film great. And they understand the difference between "chekhov's gun" and a "deus ex machina."
“That’s why people tend to vomit after killing someone... don’t ask me how I k- *ad*
Well it's pretty obvious those who kill for the first time and seeing the dead body even if you don't kill someone and see a dead body for the first time most people vomit , most people aren't used to death at this magnitude . Or maybe he killed someone by accident.
CinemaSins: *Uploads Joker video*
Birdman, CinemaWins, JLongbone, and literally everyone else: *Imma have to stop you right there.*
About the "the stair leads up to hell"
I'd actual interprate the shot that, while Arthur is walking UP the stairs, the camera placement makes the stair look like one of those illusions where u don't know if it's up or down. So while he is ASCENDING on the stair itself, he is basically DECENDING in the camera, because he just feels like every day he is living is just going further downhill. It's reeeeaaaallly good framing here and not giving this frame alone a sin off, earns Jeremy like 20 sins right here.
Wow, nice analysis and I'm not even being sarcastic, didnt even notice that!
That was a good freaking Heath Ledger's Joker laugh, holy moly.
Everything Great About the Birdman:
He's familiar with actual film techniques and literary devices that help him analyze a film beyond just answerable questions that lead no where
bUt HoW iS hE bUyInG mAkEuP?!
I'm glad I realized my error, because I just unsubbed from CinemaSins and subbed to Birdman instead.
@@overconfidentcat nice man
@@overconfidentcat Same lol, and I used to like cinema sins, how sleep I was haha. His Joker video was just so stupid. Wait- I wasn't subscribed to him!
Agreed
Did Jeremy miss the part where Arthur tells his boss the kids stole the sign, and his boss makes him pay for it, hence why Arthur ran after them when they stole the sign?
Now to be completely fair, he makes Arthur pay for it because he doesn't believe it was stolen because Arthur didn't report the incident to anyone immediately after.
Such bull shit if I had to pay for all the shit i have broke at work I would be broke lol
@@jackj9816 Arthur's boss seems like a total dick.
@@ComplexEvil Now, I know this comment is 7 months old, but I'm late to the party so I just wanna add that Arthur does say "I got jumped. Didn't you hear?" Implying that he probably did tell someone, most likely one of his dick co-workers, and they obviously didn't care enough to relay that information to the boss. Or they did, and he didn't care enough to believe it. But then again, I'm just spit balling here.
I think Jeremy noted that.
Why is no one talking about the PERFECT Heath Ledger Joker laugh he does.
Factsss i was gonna say that 😂
“Simply presenting this is not excusing it.”
At the least "Joker" is about a man who was wrong so much and was prepared to die, but before he'd wanted to die he decided to show the world a new punchline, and lived forever. But like American Psycho before it, you don't know what's real and what is not. Maybe the entire story is fake. Maybe he did kill those people but it's just imagining himself as a symbol. At it's most,the film is about class. How people who seem so civilized could be just as bad if not worse than everyone below him. See how Thomas Wayne punches Arthur,a mentally ill man shows that he doesn't care for the people below him. It's not a message for incels,it's about class. Media Outlets don't understand because they were always at the top for being the companies who made awful people famous.
Tldr;Feck the news.
Not gonna lie, that was a spot on joker laugh holy shit
which part in video?
Holy ballz that actually sounds like jokers laugh.
Spot on 10/10
lol ya I was impressed by the whole section. I wasn't expecting it and I think he did well
@@velectro8963 18:44
Joaquin Phoenix: *"Do you wanna know how I got these Oscars"* 🏆
" I was an actor for this movie called The Joker"
oSCARS
He carried the whole film. Just like ledger. Everything around them os trash, so they shine.
@@ExcuseMyWeebRudeness That's not true. Morgan Freeman was also in The Dark Knight.
This deserves to be the most liked comment of all time
Honestly, I used to be a tad too defensive of CinemaSins, but I've now come to realize just how on-point you are with your pot-shots at Jeremy and his content, and he definitely deserves each one of them. (It helps that he's released so much worse stuff in recent memory. Also, I'm sure you were thinking more of the likes of Nostalgia Critic and CinemaSins copycats, but Mauler fits so well into that description of UA-cam critics who just list nitpicks and then act like that makes the movie bad.
Isn't The Nostalgia Critic a good bit older than CinemaSins?
I liked cinemasins at one point when they actually sinned plot problems. But I get tired of "this scene does not contain a lap dance" and "40 seconds of logos" and "I wouldn't touch that pole". These aren't fucking sins.
At least Nostalgia Critic has skits ands knows when a movie is a good movie. Jeremy just looks like he cant pay attention and makes things up.
Nostalgia Critic can maintain the line of satire, jokes and a real criticism
I think he's more messing around with some of his complaints in the more casual stuff like the streams, which I don't watch as much. But regarding his serious stuff, I would barely dismiss MauLer as nitpicky for what he points out any more than I'd label Birdman as that for the way he points out the details of Cinema Sins' issues. I say "barely," because I do occasionally think he is being too fussy about certain things-like how someone phrased a statement or argument. But for the most part, I really admire his analytical abilities, and both he and Birdman are the kinds of folks I'd love to have edit my work as a writer so that I could see all the potential issues and decide what stuff I'll need to fix and what stuff I'll allow to stay for the sake of storytelling. I already know that some stuff is gonna be unrealistic. But I want to be aware of potential flaws so that I can make a conscious decision about what stuff I can tighten up and improve and what things I think are worth keeping.
Mate you haven't seen a single video of MauLer's if you think that the content that he makes has anything in common to Cinema Sins or Nostalgia Critic.
Also, fun fact: the design of the ambulance's back doors at the end was based on Heath Ledger's Joker's make up as a nod to the scene where he blows up the hospital and makes a getaway in a ambulance
"Film film film, film film film film." still more astute analysis than everything Jeremy has ever said.
Precisely
@@kirbysuperstar5494 lol
That Ledger Joker impression was immaculate sir
9:01 to also sin Jeremy,there are versions of the .38 revolver, which is shown to be the one Arthur has because of his boss, that are able to carry 8 shots before having to reload.But even then there is a shot where the guy is running away and we don’t see Arthur so it’s entirely possible Arthur could’ve put more shots in.
Heath ledger joker impression on point. No cap at all. I thought it was him until you said Jeremy
Wu-tang
Lol ikr that was insane
8:46 Arthur's gun is a 22. Cal snubnose revolver. It's known to hold from 5 - 8 rounds depending on the cylinder type. Sure he could have misremembered that event or the gun actually held 8 rounds
its a .38 special that holds five rounds Smith & Wesson Model 36
@@user-yl8pn8od8k Is correct, originaly I thought the gun held 6 rounds. But either way he couldn't of shot 8 unless it was a fuzzy memory
Actually he shot eleven throughout the who,e movie and I didn’t see him get any bullets to reload it with.
Dude, I can't stand Cinemasins. Hearing him speak painfull.
I don't think Joker is the masterpiece everyone says it is, but at least if you criticize it, made valid points.
@@ulfberht4431 That's something I insist upon, they shield themselves behind the fallacy of "you have to respect other's opinions" to which I reply that that is wrong! I merely have to respect others' right to an opinion, but the content of the opinion itself is fair game.
I will never understand “artist bad so work is bad”
It's from boycotts and protest movements against hate speech by various ethnic rights liberation movements since the '60s. It is also to prevent convicted criminals from profiting from publishing their crime confessions in true crime books, cutting hit records or selling fine art. For example, Charles Manson sang folk music and lots of serial killers have art talent.
What Darla Lathan applies. I also think it's about the principal. To a lot of people, some pieces of media feel ethically wrong to consume after learning about what the creator did. For instance, I would never say anyone is bad for enjoying the Beatles, but knowing about John Lenon makes listening to them very difficult.
o o f fair enough.
Especially when the artist isn't going to be getting anything out of it.
@@joobletmaster5000 still makes no sense
Gotta be honest with you, that Joker impression you did was really good. I can easily imagine the voice and laugh you used being an actual Joker interpretation.
Drako Wulf But he use the Joker impression on the Spiderverse video
@@MovieManReviews | Yeah, what's your point?
CinemaSins: Everything wrong with Joker is probably the worst CinemaSins ever made.
Jeremy became a SJW who just hates everything and makes excuses. Cinemasins used to be good but now he just makes up sins and pulls sins out his ass
mathinflames 00 I think it’s the best one. Joker is what someone who doesn’t know what a good movie is thinks is a good movie lol. Unless you’re interested with the political concept, this movie is a vapid attempt from a filmmaker out of his depth. Phillips hides behind the great work Pheonix and crew put in, but the script just isn’t there
Yeah. Just watched it earlier. I used to think that the Everything Wrong With The Emperor's New Groove video was their worst, because Jeremy clearly had a biased hatred for great comedy, but after seeing this... I'd say it might be a tie.
@@aaronsanders6162 Yeah, the writing was terrible. I remember when they had that talk show scene, and the dialogue was just awful.
And the directing, ugh, don't get me started. It's almost like they went ahead and made an amazing film with brilliant cinematography and excellent acting
Aaron Sanders YES!!! Thank you for stating this i thought Joker was a great performance from Joaquin but the movie itself was so average and subpar
5:30 Jeremy seems to think characters in movies can't make mistakes, when basically every movie ever is caused by a mistake of an important character.
For real, especially considering Arthur's mental issues. That could have made him even more adverse to confronting his boss about this. And maybe that is also the reason the boss dismisses him, to take advantage of him bcause he knows Arthur won't quit. He is the employee he can bully around. Things like this totally happen
Jeremy sins characters for acting in character cliché, ding
So I didn't know the joker's condition was a real thing. I knew that plenty of people in high stress situations laughed but not that this was a real thing.
Thanks TBM!
Jeremy: Joker bad!
Me: Sorry, i don't speak wrong.
@Sad Bart Simpson xoxo that's the point
@Sad Bart Simpson xoxo Yeah but usually he does talk about the movie being good but throughout this movie he talks about how terrible it is
Joker isn't bad... its just not as good as it is hyped up as being. I think that's the reason why CinemaSins made the video. Less to be controversial and more to point out that fact.
@@august297 Jeremy said many times how bad the movie was plus all the hype came from the media
That would be funny if it wasn't in the dialogue format that is way too common in comments lol
I love how CinemaSins did this video the day before CinemaWins did his review and now you are countering Jermey's. Good job.
Sorry if I sound stupid, but I thought Cinemewins and Cinemasins were the same people. LMAO
Electra Heart I did too until I heard both of them speak and that Sins' name is Jeremy and Wins' is Lee (and added bonus that Lee sounds like Ryan Reynolds)
Are they like different channels though like as far as the people are unrelated or is cinemawins just a facet or branch off of cinema wins?
Topher Gofer CinemaWins is basically anti-CinemaSins before Birdman or other people. He made CinemaWins for a happier more positive less bullshit way of reviewing movies
10:15 Tommy Cooper died of a heart attack on stage and not only did nobody help him; they actually laughed and clapped as he fell down behind the curtain.
This sin was Jeremy at his worst
8:46 Not gonna lie, that part went over my head too.
Also, thank you for saying what we're all thinking about Martin Scorsese.
I knew this would happen soon, the original video is some of Jeremy's very worst in my opinion. And that's saying a lot.
only seen the intro thus far, but I wanted to comment and show my appreciation for all your work
I watched it and couldn't help but notice Jeremy's SJW seep through, like how he horribly misinterpreted the whole part of Arthur killing the 3 guys on the train.
Jordan Garcia Same here, I watched the original with my friend who wasn’t too familiar with Jeremy’s bullshit and even he could tell it was a regular occurrence. There is nothing more frustrating when someone misses the point of a movie, not getting it is fine, choosing to see it a different way is stupid.
Eh, at least it wasn't as bad as his Cabin in The Woods vid. That's still my least favorite of all of cinemasins
I was honestly suprised how tame he was, I figured he'd do much much worse
Fr Jeremy was on his fucking bullshit during this one
Birdman: "Are you giving inconsistent critiques?"
Jeremy: "All I have is inconsistent critiques"
Jeremy’s Trump joke was pretty bad, and I say this as someone who doesn’t care much for him. Trump has never come across as mentally ill or a loner.
Even then, you can’t diagnose someone based off of public appearances they’re prepared for. You’d need to be with them in a personal level to give a likely diagnosis
Well, not a loner, anyway. Lots of psychoanalysts diagnosed him with narcissistic personality disorder.
The reality is most people could be diagnosed with narcissistic personality disorder because almost everyone has an inflated sense of self.
@@Camia-nb2zy That's not the only trait of someone with said disorder. I don't understand how you could be on the internet and still be so ignorant.
Darla Lathan You must have one thick skull
Rest in peace Kobe.
_"This is what happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object."_
*~ The Joker*
Some people never learn
@@Eli-dx5zr I agreed. Sorry about the argument last time though.
Jeremy: De Niro is super awkward at comedy.
Midnight Run: exists
Jeremy has never seen King of Comedy with Jerry Lewis. Which was directed by Martin Scorsese.
18:56 That’s actually a pretty decent Joker laugh
Thank you so so much for making this video! Cinema Sins went from a decent inconsistency finding movie to reveal that they actually have no concept of cinema or film analysis. I wish more people made videos like yours. I feel like you delivered your corrections of Jeremy in an appropriate way as well. Keep doing what you're doing :)
Cinema Sins: “I used to hate school because kids laughed when I said I wanted to be a comedian, well who is laughing now?”
Th3BirdMan: “You can say that again pal.”
No ones laughing now*
@@TheJoker-ym4yz You just explained the joke.
Nice pfp :)
If you have to explain the joke, there is no joke.
@@nathan.d7201 If you have to explain the joke to everybody, probably. If you have to explain to one out of over 300 people, probably not.
Cinema sins is basically a nitpicking show that goes off on unfunny tangents
wasnt the case at the beginning, back then he criticized ACTUAL FLAWS in movies ... but the bigger the channel get the pettier and DUMBER the "sins" ...
@@Asghaad I know. It's as if he got corrupted and addicted to criticize every single thing.
@ nah its just cold ruthless greed at this point ...
more sins = longer video = more adds = more money
more false sins = more angry comments = more "engagement" and more recommended status = more views = more viewed adds = more money
@Adrian metzler-holden no, they changed the base of the comedy from factual to made up ... so i stopped watching them, unsubscribed years ago and now instead follow CinemaWins and this channel that criticizes the stupidity of CS made up nonsense xD
He has basically become what he was criticising: a poorly written show that isn't funny.
I like cinemasins but birdman you are the legit goat man. These videos are stupid funny I be dying at your commentary
4:11 “Oh my God!! Who the Hell Cares??!”
Birdman:this is adrenaline this is why people vomit after killing someone, don’t ask me how I know.
Me: Just how many people have u killed
Birdman: How many breads have you eaten in your life?
@@knightofberenike9633 IS THAT A MOTHERFUCKING JOJO REFERENCE!?
@@knightofberenike9633 DIOOOOOOOOOO
JoJo fans can GoGo away
@@knightofberenike9633 783 loaves.
15:33 I have a problem with this sin in particular. Just because a man is outed as a horrible person doesn't mean that everything they've ever done should be completely shunned and avoided. The Hey Song is really fun to listen to and play (I'm in band), and that hasn't changed just because a bad person made it. I believe that a man should always be separate from his work, pedophile or not.
I like to watch cinema wins instead because i need some positivity in my life
I used to watch "evening at the improv" on TV back in the early 80's, so ya, there could be more than one camera at the club. cinema sins has gotten quite lame.
Way funnier than Jeremy will ever be, especially at that Hulk Hogan bit
Interestingly, he also said Ni...😂😂😂
@@kdh2484 Also, Booker T called Hulk Hogan a Ni-😂😂😂😂
Honestly I’ve come to a point that I no longer watch cinemasins, but am still subscribed to them to as a preview to what the next birdman video could be about
subscribe to birdman instead seems like a smarter option if you ask me
i watch both, I guess which things birdman will criticise... 👍
"U. S. A. U.S.A"
Freaky DollHouse seems like the fact that I watch his videos alone one can safely assume that I am already subscribed to him? Idk seems like a pretty obvious thing here
I like to think that the 11:11 on clocks symbolizing jokers nervousness is changed to a different time when he’s on the talk show because he doesn’t feel nervous about being on the talk show as he’s been through the scene many times in his head and he finally embraces the side of himself that he tried to hide but doesn’t want or have too anymore prompting him to feel at ease and not anxious. That’s why it’s not 11:11 when he’s on the talk show
It’s like watching two old guys having a one sided argument about a movie. I love it😂
For using the mememe girl at 16:37 you good sir. Have won another patron supporter.
“You wanna know how I got these scars? Jeremy kept misusing the term Deus ex machina” love the call back 😂💯
Prince The Omega, it’s funny how truthful that is though because Deus Ex Machina is the plot device whenever a writer/writers write themselves into a corner, and whenever they can’t get out of it they just write a bullshit way to get out of that corner like in Injustice whenever it took another Superman to defeat Superman, but the scenes that Jeremy calls Deus Ex Machina the majority of the time isn’t actually a Deus Ex Machina.
15:41 him calling it a sin on the fact they used a p3do’s music is kinda of funny to me since he made very creepy and p3do like lines towards young Hermione Granger when he did video’s on the Harry Potter films
When I came here I was but a cinemasins watcher, now I am a Birdman watcher
It's funny. When I watched the cinemasins video on this. And he sinned the movie for having good cinematography, I actually quoted you in the comments. "Jeremy sins something he likes cliche. Ding!" Lol
You are gorgeous
@@tonyacosta4574 not good opening statements if you're trying to flirt man
@@somedudeintheinterweb8665 works for me buddy not everyone has the same playbook
10/10 intro, and amazing work. So many sins I thought you were just going to counter with the "Unreliable Narrator" trope, but you kept the video fresh and dived deep into just how much this movie truly has to offer, and just how arrogant Cinemasins can be. It's truly a shame you don't get more attention.
Also 10/10 Joker laugh.
i love how literally all the comments on jeremy's joker video are ones correcting him or mocking him
Jerermy: I've outsmarted you
Th3birdman: I have outsmarted your outsmarting!
cinemasins : sins Joker
Th3Birdman : so you have chosen, death.
Been waiting for this patiently and it looks like it’s gonna be worth it.
Just Some Guy without a Mustache What ever happened to ur mustache 👀
@@sincerelysimba8990 A true mystery.
Just Some Guy without a Moustache have you commented on BTD videos? I feel like I see you everywhere lol.
Hey! WHERE DID YOUR MUSTACHE GO?!!!!
You're everywhere 😠
Dang. Watching this video made me realize something about myself (and in part, why Cinema Sins is still a thing after all the inconsistencies). I loved CinemaSins way way back, before I had a therapy for depression and cynicism. Then after I gradually start to feel better, I find myself more and more unable to enjoy it and I gravitated to another type of series. That is, "Everything Great About ----". And now that I objectively know what side I am rooting for now, I know that I love what you're doing here.
The fact that this is done in the almost exact style of cinemasins video
while highlighting all of there mistakes in the original video
and still is a more entertaining video is why I love birdman
So between today and yesterday we got
Everything great about Joker part
Everything wrong with Joker
Everything wrong with Cinemasins:Joker
Everything great about Joker part 2
HULK HOGAN: bRoThER!
Birdman: Interestingly, he also say Ni- *ad starts*
Me: 😂😂😂
I wish that had happened to me. Sounds pretty funny alright!
moon hilarious, my man!!! 😂
@Daniel Ezulike well I mean, birdman thought it was funny, that's why he included it
The best timing ever 😂😂😂
Lmao I had a heart thing fall off my finger at the hospital once, and it flatlined, (While I was asleep) leaving my poor mother to freak out and slap me (To wake me up) because she thought I was dead
That was actually a really good Heath Ledger impression, great job!
Literally the entire Batman's rogue gallery is based on villains being victim
Except for Hush. He's just a massive asshole.
Yeah, Harely, Ivy, Clayface, Killer Croc, Mr. Freeze., Riddler, Music Miester, but dunno about Penguin, forgot his backstory
@@librathebeautifulwarmonk1283 He has several different ones. In some, his family was as wealthy as the Waynes, then somehow lost it and he holds a grudge against the Waynes.
In others, he's just a businessman who falls into super villainy because of his looks.
@@TimedRevolver I think it's only telltale where penguin lost his wealth. Penguin is a rich guy
@@Ok-eg8dg Think it was also in The Batman cartoon where he was broke.
lol that ending was perfect. Birdman, "I don't want to stop making videos on Cinemasins......you complete me"
omfg... the "Weird Part of the Night" homage is sending me, it's so perfect
2:10 Alternate explanation; It's always possible that Arthur who always tried to be a good person simply wanted to not lose the sign and the city's reputation for teeming with douches and maybe worried he would lose his job if he didn't get the sign back, as a matter of fact this is given credence when the boss shrugs off his reason for not having the sign and berates him for not having it. Whilst he didn't lose his job no one WANTS to be berated either.
"So here's the end of the movie"
But... it's not... there's another scene
where it shows the movie might have all been in Arthur's hea-OH MY GOD HE DOESN'T GET IT BECAUSE HE DIDN'T WATCH THE ENDING THAT EXPLICITLY EXPLAINS THE FILM TO HIM
he obviously didn’t watch the whole movie Lol
@@spookyhours607 He hardly ever does
I think the real joker here is Cinemasins thinking they can critique this masterpiece of a movie.
He's an agent of chaos after all
@@edoardoprevelato6577 Ian Malcolm was right. Chaos theory! 😱
This movie? The most overrated pile since Titanic? Anyone could - and should - criticize this film.
@@ryanhall7607 i guess 11 oscar noms, a venice lion for best film, golden globes for best actor and original score, AFI award for movie of the year, SAGA award for best actor and another dozen of others, plus literally hundreds of nominations are completely wasted.
Ryan Hall Just not Jeremy. He..seems to be challenged at giving valid criticisms. If he gave valid criticism that'd be one thing, but this clown sinned this movie for literally saying "Thomas Wayne". For a channel all about cinema Jeremy sure seems to struggle with it.
I absolutely loved your use of ultimate psycho for the joker in the beginning of the video! It couldn’t have been more perfect!
Went from zero to a hundred real quick. Literally.
at this point, it's not easy to even at least like CinemaSIns
I stopped watching him, Nostalgia critic and Honest trailers a while ago.
I kind of got annoyed with them at the fact that they don't ever talk about the movies we want to hear about they did like 5 videos before they finally did the Joker
4:11 has to be a perfect representation whenever Jeremy goes on about his ex girlfriend in college, when he had sex... with his ex girlfriend in college, how his ex girlfriends college said hi- ya know ever he opens his mouth
SKIP
ever since i discovered your channel, I haven't watched a single cinema sins video directly lol I can't stand them so thanks for opening my eyes
Watching Birdman is like watching cinemawins slapping Jeremy on the wrist for his bs and I’m living for it
This video particularly highlights just how vapid CinemaSins really is. They can kinda, sorta, a little pass with their bullshit on standard blockbusters. But as soon as they tackle something with a modicum of artistic depth - stuff with high metaphorical and symbolic content...they fucking flounder so hard.
This is genuinely one of CS's worst videos. And that's saying A FUCKING LOT. I could barely finish B3rdman's take down it's that bad.
Back then we didn't criticize them so hard only because we wanted to have fun so we just ignored it. Nowadays there's barely any good content so now we know what is wrong with our culture.
Tldr;Yes,you're correct.
R.I.P. Mamba 🖤
gabriel catabran 😭
😭💔
I used to watch cinemasins, I thought they were funny but then they started to suck. Then I found Cinemawin and you, definitely an upgrade.
Can you tell me when they started to suck according to you? Not provoking, just plain curiosity.
@@antoniettabombardelli8868 What put me off was when they started sinning movies for things that weren't actual flaw of the movies themselves, then the jokes were sounding less like jokes and more like someone complaining about either non issues or things that were clearly explained, and the final nail in the coffin for me is all the political jokes and references that they shoehorn in to try and be woke.
The clocks (credit to UA-camr TheCanadianLad) slowly count down from 11 to 1 in the movie, with 1 being the moment that Arthur stands on the car and fully embraced himself as the Joker
Th3Birdman Joker, Cinema Sins Joker, Cinema Wins Joker, all relatively within 24 hours. Best day of my life.
Heck yeah. What a time to be alive
Amazing
One of these things is not like the others, one of these things doesn't belong.
ok that intro was bomb af
There HAS to be a record for 99 cinemasins in less than 40 seconds.
15:02 Jeremy would have probably said some shit like "flatline when someone dies cliché." If it did include one.