Nice. I always liked the ENT effect best - it looked like what was actually supposed to be happening: compressing someone into a datastream and reassembling them at the other end
Totally agree, they added this subtle distortion to the person beaming in and out that added a lot more physicality to the effect, like their molecules were really being pulled apart. Compared to the other effects, where it was just a basic cross-fade under some sparkles.
I agree too. Each show seemed like they were trying to advance the effect just a little bit more as technology improved, based on hypothetically what was happening. At least until the new shows where they seem to be more concerned with flashiness. The swirly effect in the Abrams movies is probably the worst.
I liked the transporter effect from The Cage the best. It was the first time we saw the transporter. The idea of these big powerful field generators holding every molecule in place, at the edge of this miraculous technology. It was complex, and it required the skills of a specialist, and two people to run the machinery for safety sake. This was a device that needed precision and respect. It was not a fax machine or email with human PDF file, this was something on the cutting edge, and a little scary.
@@JohnDiMarco hmm have you done a compilation of all the alien transporters? this is mostly the Federation ones. Yeah you've got Klingon, Romulan, Borg, Cardassian, Dominion, Voth and Ba'ku in there too, but not all of the aliens.
@@PhillipLemmon Yeah, lots of neat alien transporters. I think my faves here are Borg and Dominion. Hmm also it's notable that the DS9 Romulan effect is different than TNG.
This was really cool but I wish it included the transporter versions from the different seasons of discovery I do have to give a few special shout outs though to Picard for updating the next generation transports to basically the same but faster and the lower decks teleports being basically a stylized take on the next generation/ deep space 9 styles including the specific red-ish hue and style for Klingon transporters Edit: also would’ve been nice to have the kelvin timeline transports as well, especially since they’re among my personal favorite
I think the Beyond effect is a nice update/modernization of the classic TOS effect, it's faster and doesn't have the shrill sound effect a lot the TOS era effect suffer from. The DSC effect isn't a bad attempt at modernization of the TOS effect either. What I loved about the vid was that you could see the evolution of the "shower curtain" effect from early TNG to PIC as TNG, DS9, VOY, ENT and the TNG era movies all used the same basic effect, while the Picard effect seems like a variation/update of that effect.
Discovery is my favourite. Yeah - their personal transporters were brilliant. I love love love that show. I'm old btw. Old enough to remember the very first episode. "The Cage". Still love Discovery more.
TOS and TNG and DS9's Federation transporter effects are fine and all, but I always loved Voyager's distinctive transporter effect and the very efficient, fast and long-range Dominion transporter effect from DS9. All those lovely sounds are part of the appeal of all of them.
one thing i don't under stand, is that they have all these transporter rooms, in the ships, in different areas ,buildings, offices, etc....they are told to stand on the transporter "spot"....but then everyone is transporting from anywhere, to anywhere, anytime......always emergency beaming..., you can find many, many examples in many episodes, tos and tng....why the need for a "transporter room" ?
The only correct (according to the ST Universe) representation of the Transporter was in TOS. Because, once you are bathed in the visible portion of the Transporter, you would no longer move around until Transport is COMPLETE - completely Complete. TOS does this. The others don't - they are moving all over the place during transport!! LOL!
A lot of people would still probably take the other forms of transportation either for the same reasons as McCoy and Barclay or because in reality using transporters would be extremely expensive so it would probably just be cheaper to drive around
Is it just me or does the effect in the Generations movie look bad even for the time. It has such sharp outer edges with no attempts to blend or feather. It actually looks like a boxed 2D effect lazily super imposed over the footage with out any dimensionality.
My fave was always Wrath of Khan. Amused at some of the comments here saying "X, Y, and Z are the same!" No. They aren't didn't you watch the video? Also amused you just skipped over the existence of Discovery. "Nope! Show never happened!"
The Spaceballs beaming scene was funny. “Why didn’t somebody tell me my ass was so big?!”. True like President Skroob said about beaming, it works on Star Trek but does it work in real life? The world may never know.
The original one was and is the best! It's actually kinda disappointing that they never went back to this effect. Not even the JJ Abrams movies use the original effect.
Nice. Yet, the only thing that has always got me thinking and irritated at the same time, is that; Why TF should beaming have a musical and sometimes mesmerizing sound???
Thanks for watching. For a technobabble answer to your question, perhaps the distinctive transporter sound is a result of the resonance frequency of the Heisenberg compensators.
@@JohnDiMarco Close. Asked the transporter chief onboard my ship about it and this was her response: The sound we hear is the resonation of the annular confinement beam coupled with the materialization/dematerialization process (the object being transported _does_ displace air volume, after all). The difference in tones reflect the increasing sophistication in the beam generators. As the Heisenberg uncertainty compensators are essentially fuzzy logic collators designed to account for the possible locations of sub-atomic particles during beaming and are located within the transporter system itself, they wouldn't make a perceptible noise themselves unless something REALLY bad happened. Like, oh, what happened to Commander Sonak and Admiral Lori Ciana when they were attempting to board the newly refit USS _Enterprise_ .
@@JohnDiMarco Scotty does say something about the "resonator array" and how they changed it when beaming to the Ent-D, so you might be more right than you realize! :D
It really was fairly standardized between parts 2 and 6. Bright light in the middle splitting off into 2 horizontally separating bright lights. It was just blue for Federation and red or orange for Klingon. I suppose that one is my sentimental favorite. I'm guessing the kaleidoscope thing they had going on in part one was more expensive to do. Seeing as they only had to show it twice, and they were leaning heavy on the quality of the special effects as the movie's selling point (like they were trying to be 2001 or something), they had more of a "spare no expense" attitude about it.
The effects are actually different between beam in and beam out (which I loved). The light columns split outward when materializing, and move inward from the edges (essentially playing the effect in reverse) when dematerializing.
Wouldn’t it be nice to escape “real problem’s’ in our world 🌎 by going threw a transporter beam?But,no…..only in the science fiction universe does this exist!😮😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
I have issues with Disco and first season was really problematic. But then, every star trek show and even the best movies have issues. So, it should be included and so should Kelvin trek. I mean, Discovery season four is more proper trek then most there was before.
Discovery showed that tech evolved over time but wasn’t discarded because of obsolescence…basically second(Shenzou), third(Discovery), and fourth generation(Enterprise, after first refit) tech were shown.
Look at you being edgy leaving out Discovery and Kelvin timeline. Next time put it in the title so some of us don’t waste our time watching your videos.
How did they do those effects for the films? They're impressive for the time. I can only think of one case where they show the transport from the transported person's POV.
I do love how each transport links to the previous type. As well as how each species seems to have their own. It really diversifies both the time scale and universe. It's great to see them evolve from the Original series' 'freeze in place before and after transport' to Picard's 'simple as taking a step'
The one thing that bugged me about transporters is how they could beam someone in sitting position and materialize them in a standing pose. Then again Star Trek is a series where they could talk during beaming and the transport cycle time wildly varies.
Once you have a pattern of something in your system's memory, you can do whatever you want with it. I feel that it would be trivial to make a sitting person stand while in the buffer.
I know Star Trek runs on the very softest of sci-fi; but now you got me thinking about what level of abstraction and compression the data in the pattern buffer would need to be capable of to be able to do something as simple as move someone into a standing position without incorrectly placing a muscle inside another or messing up the configuration of all the little actin proteins inside your muscle fibres. I expect that if the transporter just gave the nerve cells in your legs the action potentials that were recorded from your previous seated position you could wind up with a serious leg cramp, or at least a muscle spasm.
I love the sounds of the ST II and III transporters, especially hearing the system power up to operating power for transport in ST II. I’d have to say that for the look, my favorite Starfleet beams was the TNG during Best of Both Worlds p1&2, Barkley’s transport, ST First Contact/Insurrection, I like Nemesis, and I like Enterprise’s, and favorite looking Klingon transporter beam was Sorin and Geordi’s beam to the Bird of Prey in Generations. Wasn’t as fond of the Generations take on Starfleet’s, but it was ok. Definitely improved upon in First Contact and Insurrection. Definitely liked Nemesis’s Starfleet beam, and liked the Reman Scimitar’s transporters also, and their replicators. DS9 Cardassian and Romulan transporters looked good. I also like the take Strange New Worlds has on the Starfleet transporter beams. That gold really looks like it’s almost realistic. Not fond of the alternate timeline transporter beam that has spinning light. SNW has a great grasp on a gold transporter beam that best acts as the modern equivalent of the TOS transporter. Also liked the animated beams in ST Prodigy, they looked pretty cool too.
A couple of years ago Andrew Biasiago (project pegasus) divulged information that the Government has had Teleportation since the mid 1980's. Not the Star Trek effect, soldiers dematerialized like vanishing Ghosts.
'not that I'm a fan of the Kelvin-universe, but I failed to see the "Tasmanian Devil" spinning effect of those films featured. Moreover, I think that the most critical element of transporter effects is time. If the effect fails to last for five seconds, it looks cheap.
I think they ran in to the same problem that prompted the writers of the original series to invent the transporters. As a way to get the characters where they needed to go quickly and keep the story moving.
@@ugochukwuanadyk6954 I assume Worf's comment means that the moon was in between the Enterprise and the Vulcan ship, while the Phoenix was "out in the open."
Worf stated that the moon obscured the Enterprise (from the moon being between the Enterprise and the Vulcan ship), which made sense given technology at the time.
I’ve always preferred the annular confinement beam matrix from Star Trek II the Wrath of Khan (so I’m a tech-head Trekker and call thing by their correct designation)
I recall the Ferengi having a pretty cool transport effect Similar to the Star Fleet, only that there was a stream of light that coiled around them from head to toe like a ribbon
the goey inny zhing from enterprise is my favorite i also like the cool up and down dots from voyager, the orange transporter from ds9 really sorta gives it the more alien less federation vibe the really quick transporters in picard are also cool, there they waök in and dont even stop walking
You can really tell that Roddenberry wanted to pick up where he left off with TOS and TMP when he made TNG. The approach to the effects from TWOK onward was flat-out ignored in favor of something similar to the original transporter effect.
In three movies we only get that one brief scene of the Enterprise E transporter room - despite that we know the room backwards. Same Voyager set after all, and they got it from the Enterprise D!
I always preferred the transporter sound from TOS.
I love that they used it in Relics when Scotty came out of the pattern buffer.
Nice. I always liked the ENT effect best - it looked like what was actually supposed to be happening: compressing someone into a datastream and reassembling them at the other end
Totally agree, they added this subtle distortion to the person beaming in and out that added a lot more physicality to the effect, like their molecules were really being pulled apart. Compared to the other effects, where it was just a basic cross-fade under some sparkles.
I agree too. Each show seemed like they were trying to advance the effect just a little bit more as technology improved, based on hypothetically what was happening. At least until the new shows where they seem to be more concerned with flashiness. The swirly effect in the Abrams movies is probably the worst.
"Enterprise...what we got back...didn't live long. Fortunately."
I liked the transporter effect from The Cage the best. It was the first time we saw the transporter. The idea of these big powerful field generators holding every molecule in place, at the edge of this miraculous technology. It was complex, and it required the skills of a specialist, and two people to run the machinery for safety sake. This was a device that needed precision and respect. It was not a fax machine or email with human PDF file, this was something on the cutting edge, and a little scary.
No Star Trek Discovery. Boo...
No that's a YAY!
LMFAO!
Discovery sucks!
@@PhillipLemmon in your mind, yes. I read otherwise on the comments.
Yes, Discovery sucks so much, but it is part of Star Trek, so it should be here. And new movies too.
A lot of the minor races and factions had unique transporter effects even if they only appeared in single episodes
yeah I'd love to see a compilation of those.
I like the Borg effect with the little flecks.
@@Empyreanabove And it's cool that we got to see different versions of it.
Love the cut from “where would the whales be by now?” to “Admiral, there be whales here!”. perfection.
Thanks!
" Transporter, two to beam up."
" Now just a damn minute!!".
Get a laugh every time.
@@JohnDiMarco hmm have you done a compilation of all the alien transporters? this is mostly the Federation ones. Yeah you've got Klingon, Romulan, Borg, Cardassian, Dominion, Voth and Ba'ku in there too, but not all of the aliens.
@@marhawkman303 I haven't done a compilation for all the alien transporters, but that might be a future project. Thanks for watching.
Discovery? Pretty lacklustre considering you’re leaving out the current flagship show.
6:57 - Data: "In the event of a water landing, I've been designed to serve as a flotation device."
So, is Data farting air to inflate his pants?
Someone doesn’t like Disco
Indeed. Not my type of music.
@@JohnDiMarco I think they may have meant discovery
@@keeptv1918 Hmm. I haven't watched the discovery channel in a long time.
@@JohnDiMarco oh sorry, I meant Star Trek Discovery
@@keeptv1918 Interesting. I'm not familiar with a Star Trek show called Discovery.
The transporter effect stayed consistent in STII thru VI and when the TNG films began that effect remained the same as well
*4:46*
It's hard to pick which Transporter effect I like the best.
I know what you mean.
I like Enterprise
You mean you don't like DragonBall z type instant transmission transport effect?!
I would have thought that was the best, lol
@@PhillipLemmon Yeah, lots of neat alien transporters. I think my faves here are Borg and Dominion. Hmm also it's notable that the DS9 Romulan effect is different than TNG.
Unfortunatelly Discovery is missing
“Unfortunately” 😂
Someone should do a video on the evolution of Spock's eyebrows. lol
Sounds fascinating.
Great vid! What are about the ones from discovery?
funny the SFX used for the transporter in Prodigy is the exact sound samples from the old Interplay games Star Trek 25th Anniversary/Judgement Rites
Fascinating.
Always liked the TNG effect. It had more to it than just sparklies.
And you missed the Ferengi transporters in TNG The Battle
This was really cool but I wish it included the transporter versions from the different seasons of discovery
I do have to give a few special shout outs though to Picard for updating the next generation transports to basically the same but faster and the lower decks teleports being basically a stylized take on the next generation/ deep space 9 styles including the specific red-ish hue and style for Klingon transporters
Edit: also would’ve been nice to have the kelvin timeline transports as well, especially since they’re among my personal favorite
Thanks for watching.
@@JohnDiMarco you’re welcome, thank you for making the video and seeing the transport effect from Star Trek Prodigy is really cool :)
I think the Beyond effect is a nice update/modernization of the classic TOS effect, it's faster and doesn't have the shrill sound effect a lot the TOS era effect suffer from. The DSC effect isn't a bad attempt at modernization of the TOS effect either.
What I loved about the vid was that you could see the evolution of the "shower curtain" effect from early TNG to PIC as TNG, DS9, VOY, ENT and the TNG era movies all used the same basic effect, while the Picard effect seems like a variation/update of that effect.
STD is a crap show, made by woke idiots who don't really know or care about what Star Trek as a whole is all about.
01:39 My favorite transporter effect of all time would be from Star Trek - The Motion Picture (1979). So very colorful, decorative, and neat looking.
TMP has my favorite warp
And it goes wrong very easily, resulting in blobby organic messes that "don't live long, fortunately".
and showed how deadly it can be if it’s not working properly, thus O’Brien wasn’t standing around all day!
That effect is kind of tainted though. I can't think of it without thinking about that horrible incident
I agree. The random swirls of pale blue light, and the blue sparkles are beautiful!
Mmm no Discovery... Not complete!
You shouldn't want ANYTHING from discovery dude, lol
@@PhillipLemmon you don't have the right to tell someone else what they do or don't want.
Discovery is my favourite. Yeah - their personal transporters were brilliant. I love love love that show. I'm old btw. Old enough to remember the very first episode. "The Cage". Still love Discovery more.
Whats discovery
Fuck Discovery lmao
TOS and TNG and DS9's Federation transporter effects are fine and all, but I always loved Voyager's distinctive transporter effect and the very efficient, fast and long-range Dominion transporter effect from DS9. All those lovely sounds are part of the appeal of all of them.
You can hate all you want about Discovery, But It's a part of the Star Trek canon now.
Nah
No it's not.
AND NEVER WILL BE.
@@PhillipLemmon You sir deserve a raise
Seriously. I understand the hate for season 1, but season 4 was easily the best Discovery has been.
NuTrek is woke garbage.
one thing i don't under stand, is that they have all these transporter rooms, in the ships, in different areas ,buildings, offices, etc....they are told to stand on the transporter "spot"....but then everyone is transporting from anywhere, to anywhere, anytime......always emergency beaming..., you can find many, many examples in many episodes, tos and tng....why the need for a "transporter room" ?
I assume that beaming from a transporter pad is generally safer, although this safeguard can be bypassed for urgent situations.
This would put Amtrak
out of business.
The only correct (according to the ST Universe) representation of the Transporter was in TOS. Because, once you are bathed in the visible portion of the Transporter, you would no longer move around until Transport is COMPLETE - completely Complete. TOS does this. The others don't - they are moving all over the place during transport!! LOL!
If we could do that in reality it would make every mode of transportation optional or obsolete.
A lot of people would still probably take the other forms of transportation either for the same reasons as McCoy and Barclay or because in reality using transporters would be extremely expensive so it would probably just be cheaper to drive around
I always thought the TNG movie transporter effects looked and sounded worse than the TNG series effects.
32nd century transporter is the best one
Is it just me or does the effect in the Generations movie look bad even for the time. It has such sharp outer edges with no attempts to blend or feather. It actually looks like a boxed 2D effect lazily super imposed over the footage with out any dimensionality.
My fave was always Wrath of Khan.
Amused at some of the comments here saying "X, Y, and Z are the same!" No. They aren't didn't you watch the video?
Also amused you just skipped over the existence of Discovery. "Nope! Show never happened!"
The Spaceballs beaming scene was funny. “Why didn’t somebody tell me my ass was so big?!”. True like President Skroob said about beaming, it works on Star Trek but does it work in real life? The world may never know.
Even if it did I bet it would be extremely expensive
Why have you not included anything from Discovery in any of these compilations?
The HMS Bounty transporter beam could GO THRU the cloak!!!!! Just realised this...
The original one was and is the best! It's actually kinda disappointing that they never went back to this effect. Not even the JJ Abrams movies use the original effect.
Personally I think Discovery's is the best.
Discovery is not canon
And Star Trek: Discovery?!?...
You missed the Hunter transporters from DS9. Best transporter effect of all!
God is Good
38 seconds Kirk,let's get the hell out of here.
Where the new star trek trilogy? 🗿
The big omission. The Hunters' transporter from DS9 'Captive Pursuit'
Nice.
Yet, the only thing that has always got me thinking and irritated at the same time, is that;
Why TF should beaming have a musical and sometimes mesmerizing sound???
Thanks for watching. For a technobabble answer to your question, perhaps the distinctive transporter sound is a result of the resonance frequency of the Heisenberg compensators.
@@JohnDiMarco Close. Asked the transporter chief onboard my ship about it and this was her response: The sound we hear is the resonation of the annular confinement beam coupled with the materialization/dematerialization process (the object being transported _does_ displace air volume, after all). The difference in tones reflect the increasing sophistication in the beam generators. As the Heisenberg uncertainty compensators are essentially fuzzy logic collators designed to account for the possible locations of sub-atomic particles during beaming and are located within the transporter system itself, they wouldn't make a perceptible noise themselves unless something REALLY bad happened. Like, oh, what happened to Commander Sonak and Admiral Lori Ciana when they were attempting to board the newly refit USS _Enterprise_ .
@@JohnDiMarco Scotty does say something about the "resonator array" and how they changed it when beaming to the Ent-D, so you might be more right than you realize! :D
It really was fairly standardized between parts 2 and 6. Bright light in the middle splitting off into 2 horizontally separating bright lights. It was just blue for Federation and red or orange for Klingon. I suppose that one is my sentimental favorite.
I'm guessing the kaleidoscope thing they had going on in part one was more expensive to do. Seeing as they only had to show it twice, and they were leaning heavy on the quality of the special effects as the movie's selling point (like they were trying to be 2001 or something), they had more of a "spare no expense" attitude about it.
The effects are actually different between beam in and beam out (which I loved). The light columns split outward when materializing, and move inward from the edges (essentially playing the effect in reverse) when dematerializing.
Wouldn’t it be nice to escape “real problem’s’ in our world 🌎 by going threw a transporter beam?But,no…..only in the science fiction universe does this exist!😮😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
I have issues with Disco and first season was really problematic. But then, every star trek show and even the best movies have issues. So, it should be included and so should Kelvin trek. I mean, Discovery season four is more proper trek then most there was before.
Discovery showed that tech evolved over time but wasn’t discarded because of obsolescence…basically second(Shenzou), third(Discovery), and fourth generation(Enterprise, after first refit) tech were shown.
Where's discovery?
Look at you being edgy leaving out Discovery and Kelvin timeline. Next time put it in the title so some of us don’t waste our time watching your videos.
Sorry you didn't like it. The description lists what is covered in the video. Have a nice day.
How did they do those effects for the films? They're impressive for the time.
I can only think of one case where they show the transport from the transported person's POV.
TOS, Star Trek III, Star Trek VI
Thank You for making this. This is Great!
Thanks! It was fun to make.
FINALLY!!! I have been looking for something like this one. The II-VI beams are my fav.
Flotation device 😆
Very enjoyable.
Thanks!
While the transporter sound for TOS is iconic, I kinda prefer the TNG transporter sound. Just my opinion though.
Realistically, it wouldn't seem likely the transporter effect would change that much
Amazing
ST III THE BEST
For me the TNG transporter effect will be the benchmark. FC, Insurrection and ENT did have pretty slick effects though.
What about star trek continues?
While I enjoyed Star Trek Continues very much, I don't cover fan films on my channel. Thanks for watching.
I do love how each transport links to the previous type. As well as how each species seems to have their own. It really diversifies both the time scale and universe. It's great to see them evolve from the Original series' 'freeze in place before and after transport' to Picard's 'simple as taking a step'
Now just a damn minute! 3:26
Hmm I played it again but I not😢it was missing the transporter from Disco...
Any chance of an update with Kelvin timeline, Disco, and SNW?
Y'all are saying this isn't complete without discovery, do you really need that bull to complete this
Transports look and sounds Video. Cool,thank you. I like The way it was done in the pilot the Cage the most.
The one thing that bugged me about transporters is how they could beam someone in sitting position and materialize them in a standing pose.
Then again Star Trek is a series where they could talk during beaming and the transport cycle time wildly varies.
Once you have a pattern of something in your system's memory, you can do whatever you want with it. I feel that it would be trivial to make a sitting person stand while in the buffer.
I know Star Trek runs on the very softest of sci-fi; but now you got me thinking about what level of abstraction and compression the data in the pattern buffer would need to be capable of to be able to do something as simple as move someone into a standing position without incorrectly placing a muscle inside another or messing up the configuration of all the little actin proteins inside your muscle fibres. I expect that if the transporter just gave the nerve cells in your legs the action potentials that were recorded from your previous seated position you could wind up with a serious leg cramp, or at least a muscle spasm.
this is very good. i like it. my personal favorite transporter sound effects are tos at :42 and voy at 10:24-10:43.
I love the sounds of the ST II and III transporters, especially hearing the system power up to operating power for transport in ST II. I’d have to say that for the look, my favorite Starfleet beams was the TNG during Best of Both Worlds p1&2, Barkley’s transport, ST First Contact/Insurrection, I like Nemesis, and I like Enterprise’s, and favorite looking Klingon transporter beam was Sorin and Geordi’s beam to the Bird of Prey in Generations. Wasn’t as fond of the Generations take on Starfleet’s, but it was ok. Definitely improved upon in First Contact and Insurrection. Definitely liked Nemesis’s Starfleet beam, and liked the Reman Scimitar’s transporters also, and their replicators. DS9 Cardassian and Romulan transporters looked good. I also like the take Strange New Worlds has on the Starfleet transporter beams. That gold really looks like it’s almost realistic. Not fond of the alternate timeline transporter beam that has spinning light. SNW has a great grasp on a gold transporter beam that best acts as the modern equivalent of the TOS transporter. Also liked the animated beams in ST Prodigy, they looked pretty cool too.
A couple of years ago Andrew Biasiago (project pegasus) divulged information that the Government has had Teleportation since the mid 1980's. Not the Star Trek effect, soldiers dematerialized like vanishing Ghosts.
'not that I'm a fan of the Kelvin-universe, but I failed to see the "Tasmanian Devil" spinning effect of those films featured. Moreover, I think that the most critical element of transporter effects is time. If the effect fails to last for five seconds, it looks cheap.
14:25 Vulcan...happily cheering?
Merely her quite logical relief that Starfleet had not lost a highly proficient crew.
I like how Pakled transporting is obviously the slowest.
What, no transporter malfunction from TMP?
I've always found that scene unsettling, so I decided to go with the successful transport of Bones instead. Thanks for watching.
@@JohnDiMarco Good idea. The screams are nightmare fuel. "Oh no, they're forming..."
@@cinemascope53 What we got back, didn't live long...fortunately.
I remember seeing that in the theater back in 1980. Gruesome
One of the things I think Enterprise actually got best.
Your forget star trek Discovery and that's star trek as well
1 year has passed and Discovery Season 3&4 are the scariest as it takes like 1 second to activate and its portable
Anyone ever see the transporter in Stone Trek?
I never thought the nx 01 should have had transporters.
I think they ran in to the same problem that prompted the writers of the original series to invent the transporters.
As a way to get the characters where they needed to go quickly and keep the story moving.
The TWOK to TUC are the best by far, withe the finest of them being in TUC
Where's Discovery, man?
i always liked the red klingon tranporters
The motion picture was the best
You missed a transporter scene from Star Trek Vi where Sulu and a security detail transported from the Excelsior.
True, I didn't include that scene. However, I was going for a representative sample, not necessarily comprehensive. Thanks for watching.
McCoy was right!
Star Trek First Contact, How come the Vulcan ship didn't detect the USS Enterprise
According to Worf, the moon obscured the Enterprise's warp signature.
@@JohnDiMarco That's a lame explanation.
Because that means that the Phoenix warp signature shouldn't have been detected too.
@@ugochukwuanadyk6954 I assume Worf's comment means that the moon was in between the Enterprise and the Vulcan ship, while the Phoenix was "out in the open."
Worf stated that the moon obscured the Enterprise (from the moon being between the Enterprise and the Vulcan ship), which made sense given technology at the time.
Why no discovery? Personal preference?
Your supposition is correct. I have a strong dislike for Discovery.
Team Voyager!
6:53
I always liked the first season TNG Ferenghi spiral transponporter effect.
9:00
4:15
The Enterprise B transporter sounded like Enterprise D and looked blueish and was a Mark VI.
I’ve always preferred the annular confinement beam matrix from Star Trek II the Wrath of Khan (so I’m a tech-head Trekker and call thing by their correct designation)
I recall the Ferengi having a pretty cool transport effect
Similar to the Star Fleet, only that there was a stream of light that coiled around them from head to toe like a ribbon
the goey inny zhing from enterprise is my favorite
i also like the cool up and down dots from voyager, the orange transporter from ds9 really sorta gives it the more alien less federation vibe
the really quick transporters in picard are also cool, there they waök in and dont even stop walking
Star trek 3 is my favourite transporter effects for both the Enterprise and the bird of prey
I prefer those transporter effects that are speckled to the ones involving bold columns or balls of light.
You can really tell that Roddenberry wanted to pick up where he left off with TOS and TMP when he made TNG. The approach to the effects from TWOK onward was flat-out ignored in favor of something similar to the original transporter effect.
In three movies we only get that one brief scene of the Enterprise E transporter room - despite that we know the room backwards. Same Voyager set after all, and they got it from the Enterprise D!
3:28-3:42. My favorite transporter effect.