You really, really need to watch the In Rainbows 'from the basement'. As a musician, you'll really be able to see how they pull these sounds together. And live!
I loved the album from pretty much the first listen, but watching that made it so much better. I love watching them get so into the music they're playing. I watch it regularly.
Weird Fishes is such a standout track for me. Especially watching it on From the Basement. Being able to see it come together as they all wind that song up is awesome.
I've heard these albums 10000 times but seeing someone else react for the first time literally gives me chills. It's amazing how much these songs have become such a big part of my life.
I would like to experience it all over again. Such an awesome feeling, i really miss it... But that doesn't stop me, playing their songs every night on gitar.
Two thoughts: 1) Down the road, you guys should consider a one-off episode where you swap roles and the son listens to an older classic of the dad’s choosing 2) Future album review recommendation: The Stone Roses debut album…I think there’s some potential deep analysis on all the various sounds and lyrics that can be done on the dad’s part
@@sordel5866 I think in rainbows would probably be their "youngest person" album, my sister and a few of her friends all know a few songs off of this album and they're only about 13-14 years of age, as opposed to other albums of theirs which definitely do cater to an older audience than that
Jigsaw is a favorite of mine since forever; yet, for me, nothing tops the experience of listening to Weird Fishes right after Nude. Such a transcendental pair of songs.
At the start of ‘nude’, the bit where your dad describes as sounding like ‘strings being pulled backwards’ is actually a reversal of Thom’s ‘oooooh’ towards the end of the song (in this video it’s 8:11). I only know this because some guy on the comment section of Nude’s music video said he was high when listening to this song and figured it out.
Yeah, there’s a bunch of places in this where I would’ve probably ruined it by telling him tons of facts like this lol. Like 15 Step being in 5/4, Ed saying his name on Weird Fishes/Arpeggi, and the syncopation on Videotape. I think it’s a good idea to just let his dad have an unfiltered, unguided first reaction, and then tell him later.
Not sure why ads are showing up on this video, we haven't enabled anything. I'm assuming it's UA-cam doing it because it's copyrighted music. Insane amount of comments on this video I'll try to reply to as many as I can soon!
No ads for UA-cam premium but I presume any money is going elsewhere. I think you can monetise vids at 1000 subs, maybe you can put in for fair use at that point? (Perhaps not to actually monetise but at least remove ads)
YT updated their TOS policy regarding monetization/advertising recently. All videos are potentially subject to advert content regardless of weather you've opted into the YT Partner Program or not. Great channel btw, lovely idea with your dad, he's pretty sweet for a dad!:)
The buildup on the "You'll go to hell..." part leading to his held out note on the word "thinking" is a moment that to this day even after hearing the track HUNDREDS of times still gives me incredible tingly feelings. What a song. The thing is, it's more than just the song...it's the performance of masters. In lesser hands, it would NOT be the track it is.
To answer the question on who is doing all the mixing: Nigel Godrich. He is their producer and has done all Radiohead albums since OK Computer and most of Thom Yorke solo work. He's really another member of the band.
@@atrus3823 he also produce Paul McCartney records (cant seem to recall which record). According to one source, the first thing he do when produce PM album is fired all the PM sessions musicians at the times.
These reactions have been S tier. You guys have such a great relationship and appreciation of music that it's just eminently enjoyable to hear your discussions and watch your reactions to each song. If you are interested, Vox did a video analysing the song 'Videotape' from this album called 'The secret rhythm behind Radiohead's Videotape' that is a MUST SEE as it reveals a hidden detail about the nature of that song which completely changes it. I look forward to your future reactions and am excited to see what other albums and, at some point, other bands you might delve into (I'm personally hoping for The Beatles but that's just me lol).
Considering dad's foot, is following the somewhat deceptive (4/4) rhythm of the piano, throughout the better first part of the video, ...to find himself (or his foot) struggling with this same pace as the drums come in, ... he should really take a look at this Vox video, or warrenmusic's original video on this subject. The piano is intentionally not on the beat :) Enjoyed all your reactions.
@Jay Sharp It's based on a meme format of ranking things that originated from video game character rankings within the competitive e-sports scene such as Super Smash Bros. Melee/Brawl and other fighting games. This specific ranking system (Where S is the highest) spilled over into meme culture where people began to use the format to rate everything.
I still remember the night this came out and downloading it immediately. I sat with my jaw dropped listening to the whole thing. It's still my favorite album of all time to this day.
Also, this isn't really, really the whole album. The B sides album has a lot of good stuff. It's actually better than most other bands' regular albums.
Timestamps! 15 Step 3:19 Bodysnatchers 5:08 Nude 7:00 Weird Fishes / Arpeggi 9:29 All I Need 11:19 Faust Arp 12:49 Reckoner 14:02 House of Cards 16:14 Jigsaw Falling Into Place 17:55 Videotape 19:17
I envy you for being able to listen to this stuff for the first time! In addition to Amnesiac and Hail to the Thief, Gotta listen to The Bends as well. Came out like two years before OK Computer and is a lot more straightforward, but still amazing. Side note: I think there's a lot of value in listening to all of their albums from the beginning to listen to how the band evolved over time. Pablo Honey is an OK album that I wouldn't put in the same tier as everything that came after it, but it's still worth the listen. Also, don't sleep on The King of Limbs as well as the "From the Basement" performances of In Rainbows and The King of Limbs. Watching them play some of this stuff live will blow your mind. King of Limbs didn't really grab me right away, but watching them play it live (they have two drummers on that album, the drummer from Portishead joined them full time with that album) just blew my mind and really made me appreciate it. Another thing I thought about (can you tell I love Radiohead? lol), there's an old SNL appearance from when they put out Kid A floating around where they played Idioteque and the National Anthem, and it's incredible watching them (particularly Jonny Greenwood) make those sounds live. The dude plays a radio at one point as an instrument, it's unbelievable.
Confessions of a 50yr old man: I actually fell in love with Radiohead because of In Rainbows - I wasnt a big fan prior to this release... I didn't love "creep" so I didn't really stay connected to the band. .... For me it was the WAY they released this album... pay what you want. So I paid $5 and was absolutely amazed by the music composition ... blown away! ... so after this I then discovered all the work they produced ... I do really love KID A but this release .... IN RAINBOWS is my fav simply because this is my personal discovery album of the band
This is definitely my favourite Radiohead album. Every song works so well in the album but also separately as individual songs. It's also I think Radiohead's most accessible album. If people aren't really into Radiohead, I've found putting this album on is a great way to change some minds/introduce them. Also quick side note, In Rainbows from the basement is a masterclass in sound mixing, and live performance. I literally use it to test out new audio hardware!
I wish I could’ve shown my dad Radiohead before he passed, but I never got the chance since I didn’t delve into them until a few years later. Watching this kind of filled a void for me, and I’m so happy to see fathers and their kids rejoicing in the art of music. Keep making these y’all! Absolutely heartwarming.
"Nude" is the first Song i knew from Radiohead. Found it by accident on Spotify and fell in Love with it instantly. I never heard such Music and it opened an whole new World to me. I showed it to all my friends and Family. A half year later i first thougt: "What other Stuff are these Guys doing?" And then I fell in Love with the best Band on this Planet.
@@turningthetables hey, can I recommend that you do the recent thom yorke album - "Anima" .. even though it's not strictly radiohead , and its quite weird, especially in parts >> after the other ones .. please, please ! -- haha
@@bill8383 agreed, Radiohead will run out eventually and the logical next step would be side projects including the band's solo work and collaborations (could do a special on Thom alone, with the PJ Harvey song, UNKLE, etc)
Nude is VULNERABLE, when I hear Nude I don't think about wearing a nice tux, that's artificial. The feelings I got were intimacy with somebody who's long in the past. It's like a fleeting moment but memorialized in a song
@@maquettemusic1623 very true, but putting on nice clothing isn't being nude. Still to each their own, love watching different interpretations for songs
i remember that i read somewhere that thome said about kid a "melody is dead and rhythm is the new king." This album is full of melodies with some of the prettiest songs. In rainbows and moon shaped pool are the best albums for me by Radiohead
Yorke says stuff like that all the Time lol..melody was King even in kid a..songs like motion picture soundtrack, how to disappear completely are quite simple rhythmically but great melodies.
@@faraz-m3v oh for sure.. I'm saying Thom says just about anything in the moment. His favorite track off Kid A and from Radiohead's discography really is HTDC and is quite a haunting melodic treat.
Reckoner instantly became one of my top 3 Radiohead songs the first time I heard it. I also sent it to my dad via email, knowing he wasn’t a huge fan of Yorke’s vocal style. At first he wrote back something indifferent, like “the guitar is pretty” or something. Then 5 minutes later he wrote back “I’m listening to this over and over, wow, I love this.” I think this is my favorite Radiohead album, stripping them of all sentimental value and only considering the music. After a fucking balls rad run of albums they went and got even balls radder. Thanks for yet another awesome video.
This album is a banger from start to finish! And I second the comment that your dad has to watch In Rainbows "From the basement" - then he can see how masterful this band is...and how they really do play everything LIVE.
My father loved music. He passed just before I got into music as well. Watching you two react to some of my favorite music has brought me immense joy and a tear to my eye. Instantly my favorite reaction channel. Don't stop with these fantastic videos. Thank you.
Hi Stef. Our condolences on the loss of your father. We are so happy we can bring some joy to your through these videos. Take care & thank you 🙏 for watching
Makes me really happy to see someone older than me having exactly the same reaction to In Rainbows as I did when I first listened to it when I was 15. This is a weirdly nostalgic and heartwarming channel
Randomly found your channel, and gotta say your taste in music is almost indentical to mine. Radiohead, Frank Ocean, Kendrick Lamar are actually my favourite artists of all time. It's so awesome to see you get your dad into the same music.
My absolute favourite album ever. Hugely influential to my music career and thinking in general. I would love to have a beer with you guys, you’re dad has such a great way of breaking down lyrics and music. Great stuff, from Ireland!
Absolutely splendid guys, I’m in England have 3 children all in their twenties. All three of them do this with me and it’s f brilliant, it introduces me to new music and introduces them to “Old” music.we even take each other to gigs! Great job guys,keep it up. Oh Radiohead one of the most incredible bands of all time in my opinion. Trev
Such a beautiful album. Radiohead are masters, so incredibly talented. I’m a bit addicted to watching people react to them, so that lured me to your channel. Been really loving your videos, it’s like a compilation of some of my favourite albums - also, you guys crack me up!
This is my favourite album. Your dad seems really cool and has a great taste in music. I never had a relationship with my dad, so watching you guys makes me so happy. Keep up the good work guys :)
This is my favorite Radiohead album - their sound is so much more grounded in warm instrumentation instead of something like Kid A, which is so cold and electronic. Their performance form the basement solidified it as my absolute favorite in their discog.
I love how Dad man keeps just being blown away by everything and we’re all just sitting here like “yeah, they’re the greatest band in the history of recorded music, we already know.”
I'm not surprised by your newfound success : Your exact way of making this format is what I always wanted to see. A chill, stripped-back listening session with no pause in the middle of a track, with good video and audio quality (both your voices and the record playback), not overly long because you do not dwell on analyzing the tracks or anything. It's just super clean, digestible and authentic, love it!
In rainbows is my favorite album of Radiohead. I revisit it endlessly with great passion. I don’t really know what else to say. It moves me. There is great guitar rock, as well as sultry tones. Great great album.
I came across this video for the first time this morning. Not sure it was your intention but I unexpectedly ended up in tears, real sobbing tears. Sounds pathetic for a 56 year old man , but if I tell you this is my favourite album, and one I used to listen to with my now estranged daughter (we also saw Radiohead together twice, just the two of us). Seeing the two of you enjoying the album together was very evocative
No pathethic at all... How could you not cry while listening to Nude? My father is the same age as you and we’ve never had a good relationship. I made him listen to Radiohead once and he told me to “turn off that funeral music immediately” So yeah. That’s it
While Jonny Greenwood definitely deserves a lot of credit, as do all members of the band, you must give up so much credit to Nigel Godrich their long time producer and un-official member of the band. He's ever present in all of their music and brings in all the weaving that creates the beauty of each album
Not to take away from the album or the reactions, but you're dad mentioning the X-rated version of Bodysnatchers and then following it up with, "I saw that one 8 times!" That had me on the floor with tears in my eyes.
Just found your vids tonight and am really enjoying them. I have loved music since I can remember. I was born in the early 50's when my parents and their friends, who gathered round our house, were in their early 20's and seriously into jazz. I remember my dad sitting me on his knee and pointing out all the separate instruments and what they were doing and how the music sounded so good because of that. Growing up through the 60's with the Beatles, Stones, Dylan, Kinks, Beach Boys etc, I knew what I was listening to and how each new genre of music was another step forward in how fantastic music progression was a never ending journey. Watching you turning your dad onto Radiohead and his reaction to them is such a mind blowing experience. I was fortunate to get into them when a friend had brought round The Bends to play me just after it had come out and it blew me away, just like every one of their albums has done ever since. I am now catching up on all your vids and having watched the Kid A and this one, I am just about to watch the OK Computer one. These are such great fun to watch. Thank you.
Hi Frank! Glad you are enjoying the videos :) Love your video on penalty kicks!! Connor showed me as I do the same with our dog. Take care and thx for the support.
I'm not often a huge fan of covers but Lianne La Havas does an incredible version of Weird Fishes that is worth hearing. Does new things with the drum beat which still totally works
I thought I misheard when you thanked people for 2k subs in the beginning, then I checked your channel to see it was made in May this year! You've come a long long way and definitely deserve all the success, love watching this father/son dynamic with such a genuine love and appreciation for the music you're listening to.
This, kid a and ok computer are all tied at the nr.1 spot for me. Can't decide between them! Also, second the person who recommended the from the basement version. Its out of this world! Love this content and you guys are both great. Can't get enough!!
This is easy one of my favorite albums of all times and I've enjoyed the experience with you! And yes, you have to be grateful with your dad, he's so open to listen new stuff, that's cool man!
There are few more enlightened experiences than sharing something you love with someone you love. In anticipation of this I had already listened to the album the other evening imagining how this would go down, and I am delighted with your honest emotional reception of what is a truly wonderful album. I’m so looking forward to joining you on your next journey, and maybe someday soon you’ll take a look at In Rainbows Disk 2 from which “Last Flowers to the Hospital” became one of my absolute favourite songs of all time. You have inspired me to embark upon this very same journey with my own father when I soon get to visit my parents for the first time in 18 months. All the very best to you both.
Hi Martin! When my son first asked me to come out onto the porch to listen to an album I honestly didn't think I would be as moved as I was. This has been a truly amazing experience.. Life is crazy sometimes.. We get caught up in this cycle of always being busy and never did I realize that something so simple could fill my head and heart the way it has. I hope you have an amazing time seeing your parents and all the best to you as well :) K
@@kevinfromttt Just wondering, has he decided yet whether it’s going to be The Bends or Hail to the Thief next? Or maybe a curve ball…the video of In Rainbows Live from the Basement…🙏
@@xbenci Having watched OKC and Kid A reaction I have good grounds to think one of those could become his favourite. It's an endless competition between the big 3 after all. Many people consider OK Computer, Kid A better than In Rainbows (including me). Yet still, something tells me In Rainbows will be at the top.
@@Dona543219 exactly, that's why I said that. I think most people believe that OKC and Kid A are the better records (myself included), but there is something about In Rainbows that is so likeable and draws you back everytime. you can ask any Radiohead fan and you'll probably get In Rainbows as the answer to "what's your favorite Radiohead album?"
What an absolute treat this channel is! Popped up in my feel this morning and I ended up watching all 4 videos in a row. Really excited to see where you guys go next. Would love to see reactions to: My Bloody Valentine - Loveless Phoebe Bridgers - Punisher Tom Waits - Mule Variations Purple Mountains - S/T Better Oblivion Community Centre - S/T
Thanks Gary! Loveless and Punisher are for sure albums I plan on showing him in the near future. I think my Dad has listened to Mule Variations but I'll check with him. As for the other 2 albums I will look into them as I haven't listened either. Thank you for the recommendations!
You guys are wonderful! Father and son sharing my favorite band's music. My sons and me (they're early/mid-teen) have listened to Radiohead together since they entered this world. Radiohead's music has shaped their view of just how good music can be. Your review of In Rainbows was excellent. I did want to mention, however, that there is an extended version of In Rainbows with a bonus disc. There are 8 more songs on it and some of them are equally as incredible as the 10 main tracks. I would really like to see you guys add a second review of the bonus disc songs. I think you both will be absolutely blown away that Radiohead actually released 18 full tracks with In Rainbows. Truly amazing. Thanks guys and keep up the great work!
Hi Russ, So great that you have been sharing great music together with your sons. Doing these videos with Connor has really brought back that love for music I lost for awhile and being introduced to new music has really changed my writing style and thought process when writing. Thanks for watching and take care :) Kevin
In rainbows is what got me into Radiohead in the first place and is still to this day my faovrite album they've ever produced. Great from start to finish
I have shared Radiohead with my kids and love it. We saw them in concert before the pandemic, best experience ever. Radiohead is an amazing band, their lyrics, tempo, sound, incorporation of instruments that are sometimes jazz like, unbelievable. Thom Yorke’s voice is amazing. One of the best videos I have seen was an interview with Thom- he could not say enough about Neil Young’s vocals…. They are very similar and I love both of their singing. I really enjoyed watching this video, reminded me of me and my kids.
Meet Philip Selway, the human metronome. Defo my favourite Radiohead album at the moment. I also love The Bends for nostalgic reasons. Look, they're all great. But In Rainbows is the one I keep coming back to.
I'm kind of sad about the camera shutting down during the initial reaction of reckoner. I think something you may have overlooked other than the amazing mixing, is how good the harmonizations are. Honestly, I almost cry when I hear this song.
I feel you. I was disappointed because it shut down right after the song finished and took about 15 minutes to charge, so it kinda killed the moment :/ but we’ve just bought a dummy battery for our camera which will give it continuous power, so we won’t run into that issue again!
Woke up at 3am after a night of drinkin and couldn’t fall back asleep and stumbled onto this vid. One of my favorite albums and awesome to see someone listen to it for the first time from front to back. Your pops would probably enjoy their live from the basement videos.
Storytime! One of my sleep paralysis episodes began with a audio hallucination of the intro percussion to 15-step. I woke up and thought my alarm was going off or something, but I realized I couldn't move. Then I heard something brushing my bed curtain and rapping mutedly against the carpet, rhythmic. Something was dancing at the foot of my bed, just below my line of sight. I lay there frozen for a good 10-15 minutes in thrilling terror, listening to it dance, straining to see it more clearly, picturing a blur of fleshly limbs flailing mechanically. So that's one way to do the 15-step, I guess.
what a pleasant experience. this channel is great, thanks for doing these videos. far down the road after you’ve got though all the albums you want to get to i would recommend a reaction to the band “Godspeed you! Black Emperor”, i think your dad would enjoy it.
not sure how I ended up here but I really enjoyed this!
I see your In Rainbows vinyl in the background of every video so I am not surprised
Hey! It's Danny Gonzalez!
Felt just the same.
same
Their format's entirely new to me and very refreshing. I couldn't subscribe fast enough.
I love all of Radiohead’s albums, but “In Rainbows” is on a different level for me.
Agree
same
yeah
I totally agree. It’s as mind blowing as Ok Computer imo
ture
You really, really need to watch the In Rainbows 'from the basement'. As a musician, you'll really be able to see how they pull these sounds together. And live!
Definitely! It's such an immersive experience
It’s a must-watch if you’re a fan of the album
I loved the album from pretty much the first listen, but watching that made it so much better. I love watching them get so into the music they're playing. I watch it regularly.
Oh 100% used to watch that all the time when I was younger
Scotch Mist is good too.
Nothing better than Julian Casablancas listening to music with his dad
Jordan Peterson's rebellious son
😆😆
I was thinking Bill Skarsgård
I was thinking Jon Heder
THAT'S WHO HE REMINDS ME OF!
Weird Fishes is such a standout track for me. Especially watching it on From the Basement. Being able to see it come together as they all wind that song up is awesome.
Such an amazing piece of art
My absolute favorite.
God the drums make cream everytime
Agree, the whole From the Basement session is magnificent
All I need and Weird Fishes my top 2
I've heard these albums 10000 times but seeing someone else react for the first time literally gives me chills. It's amazing how much these songs have become such a big part of my life.
I totally agree
i have chills too. it’s reminding me of the first time i listened to it
the beauty of music man...
I would like to experience it all over again. Such an awesome feeling, i really miss it... But that doesn't stop me, playing their songs every night on gitar.
In Rainbows is a perfect album. Not a second wasted. No filler. Good shit all around.
Faust arp
@@bjrndencker6728 it's incredible
@@null-cu8tb its my least favourite track from the album but its still an amazing track, it just goes on a bit too long for me
@null house of cards is probably my favorite track from the album
@@bjrndencker6728exactly what I was going to say
Two thoughts:
1) Down the road, you guys should consider a one-off episode where you swap roles and the son listens to an older classic of the dad’s choosing
2) Future album review recommendation: The Stone Roses debut album…I think there’s some potential deep analysis on all the various sounds and lyrics that can be done on the dad’s part
Love both of these ideas! Thank you Saurabh
Yes!! One of the greatest debut albums of all time. Sorely underrated.
"Older classic" ... like In Rainbows you mean? 😂 Radiohead is hardly a young person's music.
@@sordel5866 I think in rainbows would probably be their "youngest person" album, my sister and a few of her friends all know a few songs off of this album and they're only about 13-14 years of age, as opposed to other albums of theirs which definitely do cater to an older audience than that
@@angry3195 That’s encouraging, then. I’d certainly count it among the greatest albums of the century.
Jigsaw and Weird Fishes are my favorites from this album, but honestly, the whole album is AMAZING, I love it
Best two radiohead songs in my opinion, totally agree
Reckoner and videotape for me. But yep, whole album is immense.
@@danc5133 ditto i think that at least twice a day lol
Jigsaw is a favorite of mine since forever; yet, for me, nothing tops the experience of listening to Weird Fishes right after Nude. Such a transcendental pair of songs.
Yeah man, this is the album that REALLY got me into Radiohead.
At the start of ‘nude’, the bit where your dad describes as sounding like ‘strings being pulled backwards’ is actually a reversal of Thom’s ‘oooooh’ towards the end of the song (in this video it’s 8:11). I only know this because some guy on the comment section of Nude’s music video said he was high when listening to this song and figured it out.
Yeah, there’s a bunch of places in this where I would’ve probably ruined it by telling him tons of facts like this lol. Like 15 Step being in 5/4, Ed saying his name on Weird Fishes/Arpeggi, and the syncopation on Videotape. I think it’s a good idea to just let his dad have an unfiltered, unguided first reaction, and then tell him later.
Fun fact: How To Disappear Completely is also Thom Yorke's favorite Radiohead song.
Really? I thought it was the gloaming
He said that in interview more than 10 years ago, I think its different now
@@Alt-fg3ml *what song do you want to be remembered for*
@@doomerdream6042 he just can't get enough of creep these days 😂
no its creep...
I like you guys
Yo thanks dude!! Loved the stuff you did on your channel before you retired. Hope all is going well!
@Bandstand Are you Frank Dukes?
I miss you
Not sure why ads are showing up on this video, we haven't enabled anything. I'm assuming it's UA-cam doing it because it's copyrighted music. Insane amount of comments on this video I'll try to reply to as many as I can soon!
No ads for UA-cam premium but I presume any money is going elsewhere. I think you can monetise vids at 1000 subs, maybe you can put in for fair use at that point? (Perhaps not to actually monetise but at least remove ads)
King of limbs live in the basement is 1000% better than the album ... especially Staircase
@@davelee1935 Staircase and The Daily Mail are really up there for me. Who writes B-Sides like that? I mean, really.
I hope you guys don’t forget about In Rainbows Disk 2! It gets so overlooked and is truly worth your time. :)
YT updated their TOS policy regarding monetization/advertising recently. All videos are potentially subject to advert content regardless of weather you've opted into the YT Partner Program or not.
Great channel btw, lovely idea with your dad, he's pretty sweet for a dad!:)
nude is objectively the best Radiohead song I've ever heard. no one can change my mind.
I love the minimal beat drop at the beginning
It would be if Reckoner was never made...
I don't think you know what objectively means
@@Atom-E.B.E. I think they were half joking
The buildup on the "You'll go to hell..." part leading to his held out note on the word "thinking" is a moment that to this day even after hearing the track HUNDREDS of times still gives me incredible tingly feelings. What a song. The thing is, it's more than just the song...it's the performance of masters. In lesser hands, it would NOT be the track it is.
To answer the question on who is doing all the mixing: Nigel Godrich. He is their producer and has done all Radiohead albums since OK Computer and most of Thom Yorke solo work. He's really another member of the band.
He's also done a lot of stuff for Air and Beck (check out the album "Sea Change"-beautiful production)
Talkie Walkie by Air is one of my all-time favorite albums he's done. Incredible producer.
I think Nigel is with them since The Bends, actually, if I'm not mistaken.
@@atrus3823 he also produce Paul McCartney records (cant seem to recall which record). According to one source, the first thing he do when produce PM album is fired all the PM sessions musicians at the times.
100%
I am 62 years old I’ve seen Radiohead four times… I’ve seen hundreds of concerts...Love this band
These reactions have been S tier. You guys have such a great relationship and appreciation of music that it's just eminently enjoyable to hear your discussions and watch your reactions to each song. If you are interested, Vox did a video analysing the song 'Videotape' from this album called 'The secret rhythm behind Radiohead's Videotape' that is a MUST SEE as it reveals a hidden detail about the nature of that song which completely changes it.
I look forward to your future reactions and am excited to see what other albums and, at some point, other bands you might delve into (I'm personally hoping for The Beatles but that's just me lol).
Considering dad's foot, is following the somewhat deceptive (4/4) rhythm of the piano, throughout the better first part of the video, ...to find himself (or his foot) struggling with this same pace as the drums come in, ... he should really take a look at this Vox video, or warrenmusic's original video on this subject. The piano is intentionally not on the beat :)
Enjoyed all your reactions.
Gonna send my father the Vox video right now! Totally forgot about that one, I'm sure he'll find it interesting.
@Jay Sharp superb or super - goes above the A in the regular grading scale A-F
@Jay Sharp It's based on a meme format of ranking things that originated from video game character rankings within the competitive e-sports scene such as Super Smash Bros. Melee/Brawl and other fighting games. This specific ranking system (Where S is the highest) spilled over into meme culture where people began to use the format to rate everything.
Pink floyd? We lost the seas?? Isis??? GYBE!? A Silver Mt. Zion????????
Your dad’s analogy for “Nude” was absolutely perfect
Honestly I thought he would've had more to say but he made some great points
This is the perfect late night album. I used to listen to it a lot on the last bus home from my campus after a late night at uni.
I still remember the night this came out and downloading it immediately. I sat with my jaw dropped listening to the whole thing. It's still my favorite album of all time to this day.
Also, this isn't really, really the whole album. The B sides album has a lot of good stuff. It's actually better than most other bands' regular albums.
What do you mean?
@@mendozosa If you could explain which part confused you, I would be happy to answer your question.
@@JohnThomWebb I assume he just didn't know about the b-side
Man i wasnt even born when this came out lol
Timestamps!
15 Step 3:19
Bodysnatchers 5:08
Nude 7:00
Weird Fishes / Arpeggi 9:29
All I Need 11:19
Faust Arp 12:49
Reckoner 14:02
House of Cards 16:14
Jigsaw Falling Into Place 17:55
Videotape 19:17
Thanks
B sides, next?!
I envy you for being able to listen to this stuff for the first time! In addition to Amnesiac and Hail to the Thief, Gotta listen to The Bends as well. Came out like two years before OK Computer and is a lot more straightforward, but still amazing. Side note: I think there's a lot of value in listening to all of their albums from the beginning to listen to how the band evolved over time. Pablo Honey is an OK album that I wouldn't put in the same tier as everything that came after it, but it's still worth the listen.
Also, don't sleep on The King of Limbs as well as the "From the Basement" performances of In Rainbows and The King of Limbs. Watching them play some of this stuff live will blow your mind. King of Limbs didn't really grab me right away, but watching them play it live (they have two drummers on that album, the drummer from Portishead joined them full time with that album) just blew my mind and really made me appreciate it.
Another thing I thought about (can you tell I love Radiohead? lol), there's an old SNL appearance from when they put out Kid A floating around where they played Idioteque and the National Anthem, and it's incredible watching them (particularly Jonny Greenwood) make those sounds live. The dude plays a radio at one point as an instrument, it's unbelievable.
@@cloudshad0ws I find it interesting that people that listen to great underground hip-hop, love Radiohead.
@@mr.nihilz3283 Good music knows no bounds. I don't restrict myself with genres.
Confessions of a 50yr old man: I actually fell in love with Radiohead because of In Rainbows - I wasnt a big fan prior to this release... I didn't love "creep" so I didn't really stay connected to the band. .... For me it was the WAY they released this album... pay what you want. So I paid $5 and was absolutely amazed by the music composition ... blown away! ... so after this I then discovered all the work they produced ... I do really love KID A but this release .... IN RAINBOWS is my fav simply because this is my personal discovery album of the band
What’s with old people and ellipses?
@@christianbrehm5398 what's with people being mean no reason. Nice comment Joe
@@elliotthall6049 I was asking a genuine question. Why do old people use ellipses so much?
@@christianbrehm5398 too build suspense show a pause when they type cause you can't indicate those nuances without the use ellipsis.
Same here. I discovered them through In Rainbows.
This is definitely my favourite Radiohead album. Every song works so well in the album but also separately as individual songs. It's also I think Radiohead's most accessible album. If people aren't really into Radiohead, I've found putting this album on is a great way to change some minds/introduce them.
Also quick side note, In Rainbows from the basement is a masterclass in sound mixing, and live performance. I literally use it to test out new audio hardware!
Kid a is my favorite Radiohead album overall but I feel like in rainbows has better standalone songs
This comment 1000%
I wish I could’ve shown my dad Radiohead before he passed, but I never got the chance since I didn’t delve into them until a few years later. Watching this kind of filled a void for me, and I’m so happy to see fathers and their kids rejoicing in the art of music. Keep making these y’all! Absolutely heartwarming.
Hi Marina, sorry for your loss.
i was thinking the same thing watching this, i dont even know if hed have liked it all that much but id still like to have shared it
You can tell that you and your dad has an genuine love for music and each other, lovely to see and great video, take care!
Thank you!!
Radiohead is one of few musical artists that immerse you into a state of complete surreal sadness, and somehow make it all totally worth it.
They are truly an amazing band, Thom Yorke is also a musical genius.
Agree. Such sad and beautiful at the same time.
@brittanygonzo5686 Sadness is beautiful, it is just harder and deeper to witness or experience.
Also, like Elation - Hard to pull back from.
@@myekal147 Very true
Weird fishes is my favorite from the album, I'm never tired of it. I'm excited for hail to the thief only for your dad's reaction to There, there :)
My love for Weird Fishes increased immensely after seeing the basement performance.
"Nude" is the first Song i knew from Radiohead. Found it by accident on Spotify and fell in Love with it instantly. I never heard such Music and it opened an whole new World to me. I showed it to all my friends and Family. A half year later i first thougt: "What other Stuff are these Guys doing?" And then I fell in Love with the best Band on this Planet.
This song is pure magic indeed.
I did the same exact thing!
Been here since you guys did A Moon Shaped Pool. I'm not really sure how I got here but I'm glad that I am :)
Thank you for sticking around!
Blame the algorithm lol (Welcome to the Internet by Bo Burnham plays in the background)
@@turningthetables hey, can I recommend that you do the recent thom yorke album - "Anima" .. even though it's not strictly radiohead , and its quite weird, especially in parts >> after the other ones .. please, please ! -- haha
@@bill8383 agreed, Radiohead will run out eventually and the logical next step would be side projects including the band's solo work and collaborations (could do a special on Thom alone, with the PJ Harvey song, UNKLE, etc)
Nude is VULNERABLE, when I hear Nude I don't think about wearing a nice tux, that's artificial. The feelings I got were intimacy with somebody who's long in the past. It's like a fleeting moment but memorialized in a song
Spot on. A tux seems pretty much opposite of what the song emits.
The thing with music is you can listen to the same thing and have a different feeling.
@@maquettemusic1623 very true, but putting on nice clothing isn't being nude. Still to each their own, love watching different interpretations for songs
Holy fuk iv always tried to think of how to explain it that’s on the nail
9:50 Ed Obrien's backing vocals at this part are maybe my favorite Radiohead moment. So damn perfect.
EEEEEEEEEEEEEED
@@kevs_____ EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEDDDDDDDDDDD
It's an overused word but I truly find those backing vocal moments on this song to be magical.
If u trip with this album, it will stick with you forever. It's a gem.
Tripping on nude sounds life changing
@@arkad4357that’s what got me banned from Walmart
i remember that i read somewhere that thome said about kid a "melody is dead and rhythm is the new king." This album is full of melodies with some of the prettiest songs. In rainbows and moon shaped pool are the best albums for me by Radiohead
Ye olde Thome Yorke
Yorke says stuff like that all the Time lol..melody was King even in kid a..songs like motion picture soundtrack, how to disappear completely are quite simple rhythmically but great melodies.
Akshit that's true. But in rainbows got way too many melodic moment than kid A.
That's what i was talking about
@@faraz-m3v oh for sure.. I'm saying Thom says just about anything in the moment. His favorite track off Kid A and from Radiohead's discography really is HTDC and is quite a haunting melodic treat.
I pray that one day I’ll be able to sit with my son and discuss the beauty that is Radiohead. This is absolutely amazing. Much love to you guys.
You should get your dad to react to Frank Oceans Blonde after all the Radiohead discography
I doubt anyone is looking back for this but the fact that one of your first videos was already so entertaining and well produced is amazing!
ive been binge watching their account and I 100% agree
Reckoner instantly became one of my top 3 Radiohead songs the first time I heard it. I also sent it to my dad via email, knowing he wasn’t a huge fan of Yorke’s vocal style. At first he wrote back something indifferent, like “the guitar is pretty” or something. Then 5 minutes later he wrote back “I’m listening to this over and over, wow, I love this.” I think this is my favorite Radiohead album, stripping them of all sentimental value and only considering the music. After a fucking balls rad run of albums they went and got even balls radder. Thanks for yet another awesome video.
Same here dude.. Reckoner is the shit... Killer song!!!!
All I Need is melancholic bliss. The slow simmer to that crescendo, and the piano - magical.
This album is a banger from start to finish! And I second the comment that your dad has to watch In Rainbows "From the basement" - then he can see how masterful this band is...and how they really do play everything LIVE.
My father loved music. He passed just before I got into music as well. Watching you two react to some of my favorite music has brought me immense joy and a tear to my eye. Instantly my favorite reaction channel. Don't stop with these fantastic videos. Thank you.
Hi Stef. Our condolences on the loss of your father. We are so happy we can bring some joy to your through these videos. Take care & thank you 🙏 for watching
7:03 must be everyone’s reaction when listening to Nude’s intro for the first time
Exactly!
Love it
Makes me really happy to see someone older than me having exactly the same reaction to In Rainbows as I did when I first listened to it when I was 15. This is a weirdly nostalgic and heartwarming channel
It’s so cool, as a Radiohead fan, to see other’s take on their music hearing it for the first time
Randomly found your channel, and gotta say your taste in music is almost indentical to mine. Radiohead, Frank Ocean, Kendrick Lamar are actually my favourite artists of all time. It's so awesome to see you get your dad into the same music.
My absolute favourite album ever. Hugely influential to my music career and thinking in general. I would love to have a beer with you guys, you’re dad has such a great way of breaking down lyrics and music. Great stuff, from Ireland!
i’m based around old hiphop but this immediately caught my ears, great album
My favourite radiohead album and one of my personal favourite albums of all time
Absolutely splendid guys, I’m in England have 3 children all in their twenties. All three of them do this with me and it’s f brilliant, it introduces me to new music and introduces them to “Old” music.we even take each other to gigs! Great job guys,keep it up. Oh Radiohead one of the most incredible bands of all time in my opinion. Trev
I will always, until the day that I die, will be coming back to this album, it's just magnificent, every single song of it.
In Rainbows is the best album ever imo. its just perfect in everyway
been waiting for this one
Such a beautiful album. Radiohead are masters, so incredibly talented. I’m a bit addicted to watching people react to them, so that lured me to your channel. Been really loving your videos, it’s like a compilation of some of my favourite albums - also, you guys crack me up!
This is my favourite album. Your dad seems really cool and has a great taste in music. I never had a relationship with my dad, so watching you guys makes me so happy. Keep up the good work guys :)
wow, seeing this again. And ur at 2K subscribers back then. Love you two. And so happy I've been a part of your journey xx
This album... I discovered it two days ago... one of my all time faves
Check out disc 2!
This is my favorite Radiohead album - their sound is so much more grounded in warm instrumentation instead of something like Kid A, which is so cold and electronic. Their performance form the basement solidified it as my absolute favorite in their discog.
This one and Ok are the ones I can listen to in entirety and never tire of any song.
This is for sure my fave of the holy trinity from Radiohead. Gonna suggest Deathconsciousness by Have A Nice Life again cause it kicks all the ass
Please, that would be awesome...
What is the holy trinity for you? Mine: 1) Ok Computer 2) In Rainbows 3) Amnesiac
@@charlesbogle6544 1) In Rainbows 2) Ok Computer 3) Kid A but to be fair I haven’t listened to Amnesiac as much as these three
@@sambailey5372 King of Limbs is amazing too... Haven't listened to Moon 🌜 Shaped 🌖 Pool yet... Gotta soon...
@@charlesbogle6544 get ready to cry. But in a good way
This has been very enjoyable to watch, thank you.
thanks for watching Nick!
I love how Dad man keeps just being blown away by everything and we’re all just sitting here like “yeah, they’re the greatest band in the history of recorded music, we already know.”
Exactly!
I'm not surprised by your newfound success : Your exact way of making this format is what I always wanted to see. A chill, stripped-back listening session with no pause in the middle of a track, with good video and audio quality (both your voices and the record playback), not overly long because you do not dwell on analyzing the tracks or anything. It's just super clean, digestible and authentic, love it!
In rainbows is my favorite album of Radiohead. I revisit it endlessly with great passion. I don’t really know what else to say. It moves me. There is great guitar rock, as well as sultry tones. Great great album.
I came across this video for the first time this morning. Not sure it was your intention but I unexpectedly ended up in tears, real sobbing tears. Sounds pathetic for a 56 year old man , but if I tell you this is my favourite album, and one I used to listen to with my now estranged daughter (we also saw Radiohead together twice, just the two of us). Seeing the two of you enjoying the album together was very evocative
No pathethic at all... How could you not cry while listening to Nude?
My father is the same age as you and we’ve never had a good relationship. I made him listen to Radiohead once and he told me to “turn off that funeral music immediately” So yeah. That’s it
This is my favorite Radiohead album, it's been such an honour to watch this journey with both of you. Love from Brazil!
Loved the Dad’s reaction to Videotape and Jigsaw Falling into Place, those are my two favourites off the album and some of my fav songs ever.
This album makes me extremely happy and unbearably sad at the same time. I love it
Such an appropriate description.
While Jonny Greenwood definitely deserves a lot of credit, as do all members of the band, you must give up so much credit to Nigel Godrich their long time producer and un-official member of the band. He's ever present in all of their music and brings in all the weaving that creates the beauty of each album
After you're done with radiohead, your dad should listen to the Microphones' record The Glow pt.2! amazing sound and ambience
YES!!!!
This needs to happen
Also 'A crow looked at me' by Mount Eerie
Yessss
@@nahumjames Yes!
Its so exciting to see people react to radiohead albums fresh and new. They are such extraordinary musicians!
Body snatchers is actually a reference to the movie! Cool dissociation metaphor thingy moment.
What a great vibe between you two! Its been long since I last heard Radiohead, and you guys totally bring back my most cherished memories.
Thanks Marco :)
Not to take away from the album or the reactions, but you're dad mentioning the X-rated version of Bodysnatchers and then following it up with, "I saw that one 8 times!" That had me on the floor with tears in my eyes.
I want radiohead to do a bootysnatchers version now
You guys are awesome. These videos are so sweet. Love from the UK.
your dad would love the basement live version of this album :)
Would definitely watch that reaction
Just found your vids tonight and am really enjoying them. I have loved music since I can remember. I was born in the early 50's when my parents and their friends, who gathered round our house, were in their early 20's and seriously into jazz. I remember my dad sitting me on his knee and pointing out all the separate instruments and what they were doing and how the music sounded so good because of that. Growing up through the 60's with the Beatles, Stones, Dylan, Kinks, Beach Boys etc, I knew what I was listening to and how each new genre of music was another step forward in how fantastic music progression was a never ending journey. Watching you turning your dad onto Radiohead and his reaction to them is such a mind blowing experience. I was fortunate to get into them when a friend had brought round The Bends to play me just after it had come out and it blew me away, just like every one of their albums has done ever since. I am now catching up on all your vids and having watched the Kid A and this one, I am just about to watch the OK Computer one. These are such great fun to watch. Thank you.
Hi Frank! Glad you are enjoying the videos :)
Love your video on penalty kicks!! Connor showed me as I do the same with our dog.
Take care and thx for the support.
I'm not often a huge fan of covers but Lianne La Havas does an incredible version of Weird Fishes that is worth hearing. Does new things with the drum beat which still totally works
Seconded your Lliane La Havas recommendation! She has a wonderful take on this classic.
I thought I misheard when you thanked people for 2k subs in the beginning, then I checked your channel to see it was made in May this year! You've come a long long way and definitely deserve all the success, love watching this father/son dynamic with such a genuine love and appreciation for the music you're listening to.
This, kid a and ok computer are all tied at the nr.1 spot for me. Can't decide between them! Also, second the person who recommended the from the basement version. Its out of this world!
Love this content and you guys are both great. Can't get enough!!
This is easy one of my favorite albums of all times and I've enjoyed the experience with you! And yes, you have to be grateful with your dad, he's so open to listen new stuff, that's cool man!
There are few more enlightened experiences than sharing something you love with someone you love. In anticipation of this I had already listened to the album the other evening imagining how this would go down, and I am delighted with your honest emotional reception of what is a truly wonderful album. I’m so looking forward to joining you on your next journey, and maybe someday soon you’ll take a look at In Rainbows Disk 2 from which “Last Flowers to the Hospital” became one of my absolute favourite songs of all time. You have inspired me to embark upon this very same journey with my own father when I soon get to visit my parents for the first time in 18 months. All the very best to you both.
Hi Martin! When my son first asked me to come out onto the porch to listen to an album I honestly didn't think I would be as moved as I was. This has been a truly amazing experience.. Life is crazy sometimes.. We get caught up in this cycle of always being busy and never did I realize that something so simple could fill my head and heart the way it has. I hope you have an amazing time seeing your parents and all the best to you as well :) K
@@kevinfromttt Just wondering, has he decided yet whether it’s going to be The Bends or Hail to the Thief next? Or maybe a curve ball…the video of In Rainbows Live from the Basement…🙏
you have the best dad,he has the best son,wicked dynamics ,keep coming back this wonderful video :) thanks,and greetings from the uk
Not finished watching yet, I have a feeling it's gonna be mr. Dad's favourite
just like for everyone else
@@xbenci Having watched OKC and Kid A reaction I have good grounds to think one of those could become his favourite. It's an endless competition between the big 3 after all. Many people consider OK Computer, Kid A better than In Rainbows (including me). Yet still, something tells me In Rainbows will be at the top.
@@Dona543219 exactly, that's why I said that. I think most people believe that OKC and Kid A are the better records (myself included), but there is something about In Rainbows that is so likeable and draws you back everytime. you can ask any Radiohead fan and you'll probably get In Rainbows as the answer to "what's your favorite Radiohead album?"
@@xbenci Hmm, fair enough :) No other Radiohead record has the spirit that In Rainbows has, I think that's what we're talking about.
@@Dona543219 woah I just noticed somehow youtube copied the answer 3 times. don't know ho that happened, sorry if I bombarded your notification feed
What an absolute treat this channel is! Popped up in my feel this morning and I ended up watching all 4 videos in a row. Really excited to see where you guys go next.
Would love to see reactions to:
My Bloody Valentine - Loveless
Phoebe Bridgers - Punisher
Tom Waits - Mule Variations
Purple Mountains - S/T
Better Oblivion Community Centre - S/T
Thanks Gary! Loveless and Punisher are for sure albums I plan on showing him in the near future. I think my Dad has listened to Mule Variations but I'll check with him. As for the other 2 albums I will look into them as I haven't listened either. Thank you for the recommendations!
You guys are wonderful! Father and son sharing my favorite band's music. My sons and me (they're early/mid-teen) have listened to Radiohead together since they entered this world. Radiohead's music has shaped their view of just how good music can be. Your review of In Rainbows was excellent. I did want to mention, however, that there is an extended version of In Rainbows with a bonus disc. There are 8 more songs on it and some of them are equally as incredible as the 10 main tracks. I would really like to see you guys add a second review of the bonus disc songs. I think you both will be absolutely blown away that Radiohead actually released 18 full tracks with In Rainbows. Truly amazing. Thanks guys and keep up the great work!
Hi Russ, So great that you have been sharing great music together with your sons. Doing these videos with Connor has really brought back that love for music I lost for awhile and being introduced to new music has really changed my writing style and thought process when writing. Thanks for watching and take care :) Kevin
One of my favorite albums of all time… Weird Fishes being my “go to” song as often as possible. Great vid fellas! SUBSCRIBED!!
I love how with each video the quality increases in one way or another.
I subbed when he whispered the your mom joke into the mic as son leans away.
You two are great. Glad you like one of my favourite albums. :)
Probably the greatest album of all time
The son reminds me of a Canadian Julian Casablacas! I loved this video, such a wholesome and authentic reaction to greatest album ever!!
In rainbows is what got me into Radiohead in the first place and is still to this day my faovrite album they've ever produced. Great from start to finish
"All I Need" is my favourite Radiohead song of all time, that synth does something to me. Full blast through headphones, nothing better.
I have shared Radiohead with my kids and love it. We saw them in concert before the pandemic, best experience ever. Radiohead is an amazing band, their lyrics, tempo, sound, incorporation of instruments that are sometimes jazz like, unbelievable. Thom Yorke’s voice is amazing. One of the best videos I have seen was an interview with Thom- he could not say enough about Neil Young’s vocals…. They are very similar and I love both of their singing. I really enjoyed watching this video, reminded me of me and my kids.
Thanks Ken. Being Canadian and a Neil Young fan I like Thom ever more :). Thanks for watching !
Meet Philip Selway, the human metronome. Defo my favourite Radiohead album at the moment. I also love The Bends for nostalgic reasons. Look, they're all great. But In Rainbows is the one I keep coming back to.
Hey The Real Sam Poole.. You are bang on with that.. He's is rock steady all the time. Cheers Kevin
I'm kind of sad about the camera shutting down during the initial reaction of reckoner. I think something you may have overlooked other than the amazing mixing, is how good the harmonizations are. Honestly, I almost cry when I hear this song.
I feel you. I was disappointed because it shut down right after the song finished and took about 15 minutes to charge, so it kinda killed the moment :/ but we’ve just bought a dummy battery for our camera which will give it continuous power, so we won’t run into that issue again!
Woke up at 3am after a night of drinkin and couldn’t fall back asleep and stumbled onto this vid. One of my favorite albums and awesome to see someone listen to it for the first time from front to back. Your pops would probably enjoy their live from the basement videos.
Storytime! One of my sleep paralysis episodes began with a audio hallucination of the intro percussion to 15-step. I woke up and thought my alarm was going off or something, but I realized I couldn't move. Then I heard something brushing my bed curtain and rapping mutedly against the carpet, rhythmic. Something was dancing at the foot of my bed, just below my line of sight. I lay there frozen for a good 10-15 minutes in thrilling terror, listening to it dance, straining to see it more clearly, picturing a blur of fleshly limbs flailing mechanically.
So that's one way to do the 15-step, I guess.
this reviews are absolutely fantastic, really enjoyed every second of the video
Hey Francisco! So happy you are enjoying the video's. Thank you for the support .. grazie
what a pleasant experience. this channel is great, thanks for doing these videos. far down the road after you’ve got though all the albums you want to get to i would recommend a reaction to the band “Godspeed you! Black Emperor”, i think your dad would enjoy it.
Thanks Jake :)
my favorite Radiohead album. watched all your videos in one run today! Thanks for doing this guys, cheers from germany!
In Rainbows was digitally released as 'Pay what you want'
this is the first video im seeing of yalls and i love it. keep doing it!!
Thx Amelia :)