@andresboehmwald9171 there was pleanty of evidence, his family just had connections with law enforcement and the legal system and could use that to get him off
how utterly disgusting. i cannot believe the amount of disrespect and overall ignorance of these officials and DOCTORS! i hope this family finds peace and answers. there has to be some sort of blackmailing to paying off being done - this is ridiculous.
they aren’t ignorant, just paid off, absolutely paid off. when a case is so blatantly mishandled, with suspicious details, it is almost always that they have been paid off, they know better than this, but are either too greedy or too afraid of what these rich people can do to them to say anything
In the days preceding her death, Ellen was Googling "ways to commit suicide", was seeing a psychiatrist for "extreme anxiety," was taking an anxiolytic drug clonazepam with known side effects of suicide, and was prescribed a sleeping drug that was contraindicated (prohibited) to take with her anxiety medication. Stabbing oneself in the midst of making dinner is exactly the kind of spur-of-the-moment 'anxiety attack' rash act one would expect given these circumstances. Ellen also confided in her parents shortly before she died that she wanted to move back home, which showed she was going through some kind of acute life crisis. Calling her fiance a murderer is defamatory, reckless, and irresponsible.
This case makes me SO infuriated!!! There’s no way someone can stab themselves the way they did with that much force. No way. Stabbing your neck/spine/brain yet still be cognitively okay to continue to Stab yourself and your heart??? Clear cover up and I can’t imagine what the family is going through.
There’s so many videos too demonstrating how it’s LITERALLY IMPOSSIBLE to stab yourself that way! I feel so incredibly terrible for her family, Ellen needs justice
In the days preceding her death, Ellen was Googling "ways to commit suicide", was seeing a psychiatrist for "extreme anxiety," was taking an anxiolytic drug clonazepam with known side effects of suicide, and was prescribed a sleeping drug that was contraindicated (prohibited) to take with her anxiety medication. Stabbing oneself in the midst of making dinner is exactly the kind of spur-of-the-moment 'anxiety attack' rash act one would expect given these circumstances. Ellen also confided in her parents shortly before she died that she wanted to move back home, which showed she was going through some kind of acute life crisis. Calling her fiance a murderer is defamatory, reckless, and irresponsible.
@@phil1517 this is quite possibly the dumbest take i've ever heard. this is a clear case of an abusive relationship turned murder, turned cover up. this man comes from money and knows people in high places. it's very evident and absolutely vile.
What??? It was ruled a suicide when she was stabbed in the BACK OF THE HEAD???? Who kill’s themselves by STABBING 20 TIMES? This is insane i cant believe he wasnt sent to prison from that 911 call alone. And the worst part is since he wasnt convicted of the crime we will never know why he did it :(
I’ve been a mental health professional who has spent 27 years in Philadelphia and surrounding suburbs. I do my very best to not speak hyperbolically or exaggerate anything that has a criminal/mental health aspect to it. Having said that.. Your outrage is absolutely 100% spot on. But the reason I started out this reply as I did is because there is sooooo much more damning evidence most haven’t seen bc of their desperation to bury it. Evidence not just of this clearly being a homicide, but (more importantly) also of this being the most shockingly egregious cover-up of the death of a private citizen I’ve ever seen. That also extends to local media(NBC affiliate/Philadelphia Inquirer/Philadelphia Daily News). Sam Goldberg and the entire Goldberg family are part of the Main-Line and Philadelphia elite. Thats the *actual* reason the entirety of PA/Philly law-enforcement and media has dug in and doubled down on this story. They are *all* complicit. The evidence proving that is irrefutable and damning. So all they have left is to try to keep it from the public. So going back to how I started my reply, let that all sink in.
he was obviously being abusive and eventually killed her, i mean the emails he sent her and the fact that he was trying to bait the security guard, the fact that he’s rich and the dad even said that her work was getting to be too much makes me think his dad was in on it and they managed to pay off all those people or at least the fact that they have connections helped him sway his way into being free
@@antisocialal4799 No lol Crime and poverty are closely linked, both statistically and logically. Numerous studies and data analyses show a strong correlation between high crime rates and impoverished areas. For example, the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) and the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics have consistently reported higher crime rates in low-income neighborhoods. This fact can’t be negated by simply implying money gives one legal and social immunity. We know this isn’t typical unless you’re watching a movie lol Logically, this connection makes sense for several reasons: 1. Economic Stress: Individuals in poverty face significant financial stress, which can lead to desperation and an increased likelihood of engaging in illegal activities to meet basic needs. If you’re down bad or more desperate, you’re more likely to make drastic, potentially criminal, decisions. If you’re wealthy, you’ve much more resources to cope in much more assets to protect. 2. Lack of Opportunities: Impoverished areas often have fewer educational and employment opportunities. Without access to quality education or stable jobs, people may turn to crime as an alternative means of income. 3. Social Environment: High-poverty areas may have weakened social structures and less community cohesion, which can reduce informal social controls that deter criminal behavior. 4. Limited Resources for Law Enforcement: Poorer neighborhoods might have fewer resources for effective law enforcement and community policing, making it easier for crime to proliferate. Addressing the root causes of crime involves tackling poverty through comprehensive social and economic policies. This includes investing in education, creating job opportunities, providing social services, and improving community infrastructure. By addressing these underlying issues, we can reduce both poverty and crime, leading to safer and more prosperous communities.”
Yes her autopsy showed over 11 bruises in different stages of healing. Would be interesting how he treated women he dated before and after Ellen. He is guilty, this is why he called his Uncle the judge.
I did not think the case would end how it did, so upsetting that even in such obvious situations like this where its clear that theres more to a simple S case, still the system betrays families.
Everyone saying "How are they this ignorant?" or "How was he not found guilty?" are missing something very obvious: The man comes from money, and lots of it. Bribery and blackmail are how this happened. End of story.
Facts! Especially when she mentioned the person who did the autopsy didn’t want anything to do with it after the fact and refused to show what she was paid.
And conflicts of interest galore. Larry Krasner recused because he looked at this case on behalf of the victim’s family. Josh Shapiro (now the governor and possibly a running mate for Harris in the 2024 election) should have recused himself once he saw the victim’s name but didn’t.
The fact that he says “she has a knife in her heart” like idk why that wording gave me chills. The specificity of it. The insinuation is like “she’s definitely dead it’s in her heart” you know what I mean?
As someone with diagnosed mental illnesses, I get very worried that if something happened to me and it wasn't cut and dry, any chance of foul play would be ruled out based off of that.
Same here. I have multiple mental disorders that are complex and intense. One of them is BPD. If I was murdered or raped, etc. my case would be thrown out because I’m “making it up” or I committed “suicide.” Insane.
That is ridiculous how could he even be released and or found not guilty when he was definitely guilty. Took stuff out and simply wanted the security to be there with him so he wouldn't be blamed. It was frustrating
This was extremely well researched and delivered. I’ve seen/heard a lot of coverage on this case, and this is by far the most detailed but still concise. The amount of times the cousin gets left out, her texts to her mother, the stories from her students…you did her justice with this.
ur videos really comfort me. i also love your podcast. the way you narrate these cases really puts these terrible things into perspective while also relaxing me. congrats on 1 mil!
Scenario: DV played a huge roll in her severe anxiety! She was preparing to leave him and return home to her parents. She left school early that day due to a snow storm. Before she got home, she filled up her gas tank (which is what I normally do prior to a bad storm. I was raised in SP) She was cutting up fruit. They must of been arguing over something and he snapped! This was a crime of passion. She has her back towards him… she has no defensive wounds! He panics and calls Daddy and Mommy! They call their connected pals including Uncle Jimmy, and POOF “let’s say she unalived herself”!! Sammy and his pals steal Ellen’s personal belongings, I’m assuming they also went “Poof” and disappointed!! Ohhhh Sammy!!! We all know!!!!
Haven’t watched the video yet, but thank you SO SO MUCH for covering this case. It’ll always haunt me and make me insane how still barely anything has happened. RIP Ellen and thank you for covering her case!
i’m trying to correlate the physics of how she was stabbed to her visiting a psychiatrist & anxiety… like w/ out knowing that, what would the autopsy person think, definitely not a suicide.
Bro, it's so awesome seeing you grow. You're doing such a great job with your videos. I was looking for someone who did stories in depth and covered a lot of things. Your set up has changed so much. Also look at your 1 million subscribers. ❤ that's awesome. You deserve it
Hello Hailey!! Congratulations on 1 million subscribers you definitely deserve it!! Always calming, peaceful and wholesome vibes here, always feel at ease here!! Another wild case forsure.
Hailey, I just wanted to say that I've been watching you for a few years and I really love seeing how you've grown into yourself and the glow up you've had!
I would like to add this comment though, as a fellow teacher who burnt out, I too had everything kept up perfectly until the day I walked out and never returned. Sometimes keeping it up perfectly is the exact thing that does burn you out
In 2011 Josh Shapiro was the AG. He was and is very connected to this family. They all went to the same private HS and are part of the same tight community on the main line.
Hey Hailey! thank you for the video. I would like to also suggest a case that happened in Kazakhstan where there is ongoing trial. The case of Saltanat Nukenova. Would be amazing if you could bring awareness to it! (also our region is not covered at all so it would have been the first)
I wish I could see the whole file. I KNOW Ambien makes me sleep walk, or actually sleep ‘function.’ So, it would help if we could see the autopsy photos. I do feel so bad for her parents. ❤
I didn’t see this comment so I will chime in - how do we know the door latch was engaged? Sam could have made that up to create the story that he couldn’t get inside and needed to break down the door. Stalling for time. Going back and forth to the security guard. Very suspicious and clearly proves premeditation.
Hi Elizabeth,thank you for all that you do. If you can, pleas look at Noah Presgrove, he was beaten so bad at a friend party, broken teeth, cracked skull. I think the family should hired a private investigator. No one is talking.
This case is SO dodgy. It's quite infuriating how at every turn, the people who were supposed to do the right thing folded under pressure, greed, coercion or whatever else made them decide to lie.
i’m commenting as i’m watching, but it’s absolutely sending me that this man tells the dispatcher “oh my god! there’s a knife in her chest!!”, someone give this man an award for worst actor fr update: just finished and….. i’m FUMING. my heart goes out to her family and i hope they get the justice they deserve for their daughter.
As to him not calling her. If the wing lock is what is keeping him out, I assume it’s like at hotels, the door would be open enough for him to be yelling into the apartment. If she didn’t hear him yelling directly into the apartment why would she hear her phone? So I wouldn’t assume to call her either, I’d assume she was purposefully ignoring me.
I haven't heard this case in such a long time and thank you for resurfacing this. Im disappointed that TO THIS DAY the family has been rejected from getting another opinion or look at this autopsy. It's really upsetting... The system or whatever entities involved continue to fail families looking for peace and closure. Congrats on 1MIL
Sam: significant other 🤔 Emails Ellen instead of calling 🤔 Calls ANY OTHER PERSON but 911 🤔 Calls a renowned lawyer instead of police 🤔 Pesters the poor security guard to co-sign his shenanigans to guarantee a witness 🤔 He enters alone but insists guard is present 🤔 Starts coming up with theories right away 🤔 When ask to perform CPR looks around to see where the adults in the room are and only then realizes that he IS the adult. 🤔 All my red flags 🚩 that made me tilt my head and ponder: does this POS think anyone is buying what he’s selling? 25:42
OMG, this case is so frustrating. You don't have to be a doctor to see there's no way it was a suicide. There's no way he isn't guilty and they know it. He MUST have bribed them or something, which makes it even more disgusting! Money should not come into play when it comes to justice, but hey, go tell them that... I hope her family'll be able to find answers and bring her justice one day, may she rest in peace. Also congratulations on the 1M, I love your videos sm I've been watching for years now, I'm so happy you've come this far 🤍✨
You're not the only one with this feeling because I was wondering the same thing. I think she did the video again with some minor text changes here and there because the previous one was probably in the "doing makeup while talking true crime" chapter/era.
“Maybe she fell on it” … who “falls” on a knife straight to the chest. How was he not found guilty????? this case is pure injustice
Good lawyer
and that many times?? come ON
@@grey6703 exactly!! Lots of people were definitely paid off
How could she pull the knife out of her head and put it in her stomach……????
@andresboehmwald9171 there was pleanty of evidence, his family just had connections with law enforcement and the legal system and could use that to get him off
how utterly disgusting. i cannot believe the amount of disrespect and overall ignorance of these officials and DOCTORS! i hope this family finds peace and answers. there has to be some sort of blackmailing to paying off being done - this is ridiculous.
Absolutely. His parents were rich
they aren’t ignorant, just paid off, absolutely paid off. when a case is so blatantly mishandled, with suspicious details, it is almost always that they have been paid off, they know better than this, but are either too greedy or too afraid of what these rich people can do to them to say anything
Late to the party. But, that guys parents r rich eh? What's the latest here?@@angelabarreras7480
In the days preceding her death, Ellen was Googling "ways to commit suicide", was seeing a psychiatrist for "extreme anxiety," was taking an anxiolytic drug clonazepam with known side effects of suicide, and was prescribed a sleeping drug that was contraindicated (prohibited) to take with her anxiety medication.
Stabbing oneself in the midst of making dinner is exactly the kind of spur-of-the-moment 'anxiety attack' rash act one would expect given these circumstances.
Ellen also confided in her parents shortly before she died that she wanted to move back home, which showed she was going through some kind of acute life crisis.
Calling her fiance a murderer is defamatory, reckless, and irresponsible.
This case makes me SO infuriated!!! There’s no way someone can stab themselves the way they did with that much force. No way. Stabbing your neck/spine/brain yet still be cognitively okay to continue to Stab yourself and your heart??? Clear cover up and I can’t imagine what the family is going through.
right?! and 20 times??? like how could one possibly do that. so ridiculous
There’s so many videos too demonstrating how it’s LITERALLY IMPOSSIBLE to stab yourself that way! I feel so incredibly terrible for her family, Ellen needs justice
And medical examiner is refusing to change it from suicide?!?! Like HOWWWW
In the days preceding her death, Ellen was Googling "ways to commit suicide", was seeing a psychiatrist for "extreme anxiety," was taking an anxiolytic drug clonazepam with known side effects of suicide, and was prescribed a sleeping drug that was contraindicated (prohibited) to take with her anxiety medication.
Stabbing oneself in the midst of making dinner is exactly the kind of spur-of-the-moment 'anxiety attack' rash act one would expect given these circumstances.
Ellen also confided in her parents shortly before she died that she wanted to move back home, which showed she was going through some kind of acute life crisis.
Calling her fiance a murderer is defamatory, reckless, and irresponsible.
@@phil1517 this is quite possibly the dumbest take i've ever heard. this is a clear case of an abusive relationship turned murder, turned cover up. this man comes from money and knows people in high places. it's very evident and absolutely vile.
What??? It was ruled a suicide when she was stabbed in the BACK OF THE HEAD???? Who kill’s themselves by STABBING 20 TIMES? This is insane i cant believe he wasnt sent to prison from that 911 call alone. And the worst part is since he wasnt convicted of the crime we will never know why he did it :(
Exactly how did she pull it out of the back of her head or wherever it hit her spine and put it in her chest to be found?
FR
I’ve been a mental health professional who has spent 27 years in Philadelphia and surrounding suburbs. I do my very best to not speak hyperbolically or exaggerate anything that has a criminal/mental health aspect to it. Having said that..
Your outrage is absolutely 100% spot on. But the reason I started out this reply as I did is because there is sooooo much more damning evidence most haven’t seen bc of their desperation to bury it. Evidence not just of this clearly being a homicide, but (more importantly) also of this being the most shockingly egregious cover-up of the death of a private citizen I’ve ever seen. That also extends to local media(NBC affiliate/Philadelphia Inquirer/Philadelphia Daily News). Sam Goldberg and the entire Goldberg family are part of the Main-Line and Philadelphia elite.
Thats the *actual* reason the entirety of PA/Philly law-enforcement and media has dug in and doubled down on this story. They are *all* complicit. The evidence proving that is irrefutable and damning. So all they have left is to try to keep it from the public.
So going back to how I started my reply, let that all sink in.
The corruption is strong with this one
he also thinks he has a free pass to MURDER in life
Thank you for covering this case. My father was one of her coworkers, and we rarely see coverage about this.
CONGRATULATIONS ON THE 1 MIL HAILEY! LOVE YOU AND YOUR VIDEOS SM! HAVE A BLESSED YEAR
he was obviously being abusive and eventually killed her, i mean the emails he sent her and the fact that he was trying to bait the security guard, the fact that he’s rich and the dad even said that her work was getting to be too much makes me think his dad was in on it and they managed to pay off all those people or at least the fact that they have connections helped him sway his way into being free
@ganymedelmao Ik too many poor ppl that are career criminals than rich 😂😂😂
@ganymedeHow do you think rich people make their money? By committing crimes.
@@itsjustmyopinionbut1671That’s because the rich can get away with it. They have money, power, and connections. Poor people do not.
@@antisocialal4799 No lol Crime and poverty are closely linked, both statistically and logically. Numerous studies and data analyses show a strong correlation between high crime rates and impoverished areas. For example, the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) and the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics have consistently reported higher crime rates in low-income neighborhoods. This fact can’t be negated by simply implying money gives one legal and social immunity. We know this isn’t typical unless you’re watching a movie lol
Logically, this connection makes sense for several reasons:
1. Economic Stress: Individuals in poverty face significant financial stress, which can lead to desperation and an increased likelihood of engaging in illegal activities to meet basic needs. If you’re down bad or more desperate, you’re more likely to make drastic, potentially criminal, decisions. If you’re wealthy, you’ve much more resources to cope in much more assets to protect.
2. Lack of Opportunities: Impoverished areas often have fewer educational and employment opportunities. Without access to quality education or stable jobs, people may turn to crime as an alternative means of income.
3. Social Environment: High-poverty areas may have weakened social structures and less community cohesion, which can reduce informal social controls that deter criminal behavior.
4. Limited Resources for Law Enforcement: Poorer neighborhoods might have fewer resources for effective law enforcement and community policing, making it easier for crime to proliferate.
Addressing the root causes of crime involves tackling poverty through comprehensive social and economic policies. This includes investing in education, creating job opportunities, providing social services, and improving community infrastructure. By addressing these underlying issues, we can reduce both poverty and crime, leading to safer and more prosperous communities.”
Yes her autopsy showed over 11 bruises in different stages of healing. Would be interesting how he treated women he dated before and after Ellen. He is guilty, this is why he called his Uncle the judge.
I did not think the case would end how it did, so upsetting that even in such obvious situations like this where its clear that theres more to a simple S case, still the system betrays families.
That is an understatement! The case is now being looked at beyond true crime circles and the Philly market because of elections in the USA.
Everyone saying "How are they this ignorant?" or "How was he not found guilty?" are missing something very obvious: The man comes from money, and lots of it. Bribery and blackmail are how this happened. End of story.
Oh ya. Never thought of that 😭
That and she’s an ethnic woman.
Facts! Especially when she mentioned the person who did the autopsy didn’t want anything to do with it after the fact and refused to show what she was paid.
It's definitely connections to people in high places and/or money
And conflicts of interest galore. Larry Krasner recused because he looked at this case on behalf of the victim’s family. Josh Shapiro (now the governor and possibly a running mate for Harris in the 2024 election) should have recused himself once he saw the victim’s name but didn’t.
The fact that he says “she has a knife in her heart” like idk why that wording gave me chills. The specificity of it. The insinuation is like “she’s definitely dead it’s in her heart” you know what I mean?
As someone with diagnosed mental illnesses, I get very worried that if something happened to me and it wasn't cut and dry, any chance of foul play would be ruled out based off of that.
Same here. I have multiple mental disorders that are complex and intense. One of them is BPD. If I was murdered or raped, etc. my case would be thrown out because I’m “making it up” or I committed “suicide.” Insane.
I've thought about this sorta thing with myself too
That is ridiculous how could he even be released and or found not guilty when he was definitely guilty. Took stuff out and simply wanted the security to be there with him so he wouldn't be blamed. It was frustrating
“Are you willing to do you CPR over the phone?” “I have to right?” Guilty. 👩⚖️
Don’t forget the sound of disgust when she first mentions CPR. He knew she was gone hours before.
Your interpretation of how he said , "I have too, right?" is wrong. That's not what he meant. His intonation was more like "I've gotta do this."
@@phil1517 even so he sounds so guilty, and with the rest of the video after the phone call everything points to him
I love how you start the video immediately with the story, love you & your vids Hailey ❤
This was extremely well researched and delivered. I’ve seen/heard a lot of coverage on this case, and this is by far the most detailed but still concise. The amount of times the cousin gets left out, her texts to her mother, the stories from her students…you did her justice with this.
what a disgusting injustice
I feel like he kept trying to get the security guard to come as an alibi but dude wasn’t having it 💀
That may be why he called his cousin. His uncle was the longtime vice chairman of the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA).
@@AEMoreira81 He called his cousin for help covering up her murder.
ur videos really comfort me. i also love your podcast. the way you narrate these cases really puts these terrible things into perspective while also relaxing me. congrats on 1 mil!
am i losing it i swear she covered this story already 😭
I’m pretty sure she did I thought I was losing it too😭
She did right? I thought the same
I literally thought I was going mad. I thought she did this back when she first started
Thank you !! I thought I was the only one 😭😭
i also tought i was losing it cus i somehow knew everything she was about to say,, thank u 😭
Scenario: DV played a huge roll in her severe anxiety! She was preparing to leave him and return home to her parents. She left school early that day due to a snow storm. Before she got home, she filled up her gas tank (which is what I normally do prior to a bad storm. I was raised in SP)
She was cutting up fruit. They must of been arguing over something and he snapped! This was a crime of passion. She has her back towards him… she has no defensive wounds! He panics and calls Daddy and Mommy! They call their connected pals including Uncle Jimmy, and POOF “let’s say she unalived herself”!!
Sammy and his pals steal Ellen’s personal belongings, I’m assuming they also went “Poof” and disappointed!!
Ohhhh Sammy!!! We all know!!!!
*** Disappeared
I knew Ellen and I remember when I found out. It happened on a Friday night I found out Saturday
You should add your own theories on what happened in unsolved cases. Also congrats on a mil!!!! One of my favorites on youtube
Haven’t watched the video yet, but thank you SO SO MUCH for covering this case. It’ll always haunt me and make me insane how still barely anything has happened. RIP Ellen and thank you for covering her case!
i’m trying to correlate the physics of how she was stabbed to her visiting a psychiatrist & anxiety… like w/ out knowing that, what would the autopsy person think, definitely not a suicide.
Bro, it's so awesome seeing you grow. You're doing such a great job with your videos. I was looking for someone who did stories in depth and covered a lot of things. Your set up has changed so much. Also look at your 1 million subscribers. ❤ that's awesome. You deserve it
1M BABY!!!! Keep on doing what ur doing Hailey I’ll be here supporting u ♥️
Been here for a while and I can’t help but feel so happy for you and your channels growth. Congrats on the milllll. 🥳🥳
When he said “she stabbed herself!” That was all we needed to hear. GUILTY
CONGRATS ON ONE MIL! 🎉
Congrats on 1 Milllion, Hailey! Lots of good and positive vibes to you!
I so much enjoy your content.
We thank you for it and for your work.
This is Outrageous!! Money can buy you freedom, it seems, if there are enough corrupt people involved. So sad. BTW, loving the camo cardi!
Am i loosing it? I think you already told this story before. Damn, i'm not sure anymore ahaha
fr i thought it was just me
There’s another thread up there, saying the same thing…you are not alone lol I thought she covered it already too 😭
Omg I thought I was going crazy😭 I swore she had already spoken about this case before
i thought the same thing, but im pretty sure it was either kendall rae or danielle kirsty that already covered it lol
A lot of these crimes are eerily similar. Men are scary beings. I don’t give a fuck if it’s misandrist, history and stats don’t lie.
Hello Hailey!! Congratulations on 1 million subscribers you definitely deserve it!! Always calming, peaceful and wholesome vibes here, always feel at ease here!! Another wild case forsure.
Off topic but congrats on hitting 1 million Hailey!!!!!! 🎉❤
CONGRATS ON 1 MIL HAILEY, YOUR VIDS ARE AMAZING!!!
Hailey, I just wanted to say that I've been watching you for a few years and I really love seeing how you've grown into yourself and the glow up you've had!
I love listening to your story telling. Your voice is pleasant and you’re so informative without getting wide tracked. Thank you for videos. ❤
I agree, her voice is great. Surprised to hear that she considers herself shy.
I would like to add this comment though, as a fellow teacher who burnt out, I too had everything kept up perfectly until the day I walked out and never returned. Sometimes keeping it up perfectly is the exact thing that does burn you out
CONGRATS on 1M🎉❤ your my comfort UA-camr🫶
In 2011 Josh Shapiro was the AG. He was and is very connected to this family. They all went to the same private HS and are part of the same tight community on the main line.
The "tribe" always protects its own.
CONGRATULATIONS ON 1 MILLION 💗💗💗
I’m always amazed by the kindness you describe people with :)
Hailey ur hair is so slay in this. Also my mom walked in during the 911 call and was like ?? and im like yeah he sounds hella guilty
Girl!! Congrats on 1 mill 🎉🎉🎉
it still baffles me how you can get away with ANYTHING just because you have money.
2 Hailey vids in a week!?! Hell yeah! Congrats on 1 million subs. Yo deserve it.
having a dogwater depressive episode rn so you’re right on time :,) congrats on 1 million 🖤🖤🖤
SO INFURIATING!! Is there any way we can help the family get justice??
True crime videos keep me alive
" alive" .. 🙈
The irony
@@emilykenevan222 WAIT NO 😭
@@Sigma48123 😊😊😊
It should be illegal how the witnesses act! Can the parents do a civil suit for wrongful death to get more evidence??
Congratulations on one million!!! So happy for you
I’m so proud of you. I have been watching you back when you had only 100k subs and now you’re at a million and got a new camera! Great job
It’s sad that this poor woman lost her life. Why do the good people suffer?
It’s Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. She went to my high school years before me & I remember my cousins knowing her. RIP
And it’s Jun-i-ata, not Juanita!!!
Am I crazy or did she cover this story already? 😂😭
Congratulations on 1 mil girl you deserve it❤
so happy to see more uploads, I love these videos so much!
I'm LOVING the consistency 💙💙
bruv, the 911 call painted him guilty enough. that’s bad acting if i’ve ever heard it 💀
hailey PLEASE do more conspiracy vids they’re my fav ❤️❤️
Oh yeah, sounds like someone asked mommy and daddy for some, "help."
Rest in Peace, Ellen Greenberg.
Is this a re-upload? I swear I've already watched this video of Hailey on this topic
am i crazy to say you’ve covered this story before? i swear i’ve heard this before?
Congratulations on 1 million
Congratulations on 1 mil !
she deserves justice, i hope he ends up getting time for this because there’s no way he didn’t do this
Hey Hailey! thank you for the video. I would like to also suggest a case that happened in Kazakhstan where there is ongoing trial. The case of Saltanat Nukenova. Would be amazing if you could bring awareness to it! (also our region is not covered at all so it would have been the first)
I wish I could see the whole file. I KNOW Ambien makes me sleep walk, or actually sleep ‘function.’ So, it would help if we could see the autopsy photos. I do feel so bad for her parents. ❤
1 million ! Congrats, Hayley 🎉
i have been following since late 2021 ❤❤
Wait a minute.. I know this voice!
You’re the host of Behind You!?! ❤ Nice to put a face to the voice of one of my favorite Podcasts!!
Congratulations on 1M girlie!!! love your content
I love listening to your videos while I work. Thank you for creating such good quality content 💖
Congratulations on the 1 million ❤
I didn’t see this comment so I will chime in - how do we know the door latch was engaged? Sam could have made that up to create the story that he couldn’t get inside and needed to break down the door. Stalling for time. Going back and forth to the security guard. Very suspicious and clearly proves premeditation.
23:11 “OMG SHE STABBED HERSELF”!
He sounds more excited than distressed when he says that.
Hi Elizabeth,thank you for all that you do. If you can, pleas look at Noah Presgrove, he was beaten so bad at a friend party, broken teeth, cracked skull. I think the family should hired a private investigator. No one is talking.
This case is SO dodgy. It's quite infuriating how at every turn, the people who were supposed to do the right thing folded under pressure, greed, coercion or whatever else made them decide to lie.
Congrats on 1 million subs!!! :') sososo happy for you!
I'm so happy that you hit 1M! I've been watching your channel for years.
Congratulations on your success.
✌🏻💜😇
i’m commenting as i’m watching, but it’s absolutely sending me that this man tells the dispatcher “oh my god! there’s a knife in her chest!!”, someone give this man an award for worst actor fr
update: just finished and….. i’m FUMING. my heart goes out to her family and i hope they get the justice they deserve for their daughter.
As to him not calling her. If the wing lock is what is keeping him out, I assume it’s like at hotels, the door would be open enough for him to be yelling into the apartment. If she didn’t hear him yelling directly into the apartment why would she hear her phone? So I wouldn’t assume to call her either, I’d assume she was purposefully ignoring me.
WOW this story is heartbreaking. Justice for Ellen!
no way they got away with this, at this point I have no hope in humanity
I haven't heard this case in such a long time and thank you for resurfacing this. Im disappointed that TO THIS DAY the family has been rejected from getting another opinion or look at this autopsy. It's really upsetting... The system or whatever entities involved continue to fail families looking for peace and closure.
Congrats on 1MIL
Congratulations on 1 million subscribers ❤
CONGRATS ON ONE MILLION!!!🎉
Sam: significant other 🤔
Emails Ellen instead of calling 🤔
Calls ANY OTHER PERSON but 911 🤔
Calls a renowned lawyer instead of police 🤔
Pesters the poor security guard to co-sign his shenanigans to guarantee a witness 🤔
He enters alone but insists guard is present 🤔
Starts coming up with theories right away 🤔
When ask to perform CPR looks around to see where the adults in the room are and only then realizes that he IS the adult. 🤔
All my red flags 🚩 that made me tilt my head and ponder: does this POS think anyone is buying what he’s selling? 25:42
Who EMAILS someone to open a door 😂 just phone! This case is so fishy
There's not even any hesitation marks! Self inflicted knife deaths almost always have hesitation wounds! I call BS
There is NOTHING that would stop me from giving mouth to mouth to my partner immediately begging them to tell me how
Congratulations on the 1M !!! You've come a long way, I have enjoyed watching your journey since 100K 😅
OMG, this case is so frustrating. You don't have to be a doctor to see there's no way it was a suicide. There's no way he isn't guilty and they know it. He MUST have bribed them or something, which makes it even more disgusting! Money should not come into play when it comes to justice, but hey, go tell them that... I hope her family'll be able to find answers and bring her justice one day, may she rest in peace.
Also congratulations on the 1M, I love your videos sm I've been watching for years now, I'm so happy you've come this far
🤍✨
is this a re upload ? i really feel like i remember watching you cover this case
You're not the only one with this feeling because I was wondering the same thing. I think she did the video again with some minor text changes here and there because the previous one was probably in the "doing makeup while talking true crime" chapter/era.
She moved to Pennsylvania! Not New York I’m from Harrisburg
Me too
Congrats on one million!! 🥳🥳
He couldn’t call her because he already killed her and the call would have went to voicemail.
shoutout to that receptionist she was super helpful
Congratulations on 1 million!!!!!!! 💞💞
Congrats on a million subscribers!
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania
There’s a video on UA-cam where a woman of the same build as Ellen tries to replicate the stab wounds and it’s… wild.