Never knew about this case 😦 Just came here after watching Mrs Chatterjee vs Norway 💫 Really happy for Sagarika☺️, she got justice and got her children back Those children had also grown up, hope those children are leading a happy life Best wishes to them ✨
@@sh0gun570 yea they didn't misunderstand I am psychologist i can read his liberal family i think his mother must have beaten him which is considered kind of considered illegal in these countries especially when your child is below 10. i think. foster home took this too seriously. they thought it would be right if child be raised alone.
I used to think that European countries are better in both judiciary and customs, but know after after all this news, i can say that they are in a more hopeless situation than us.
As someone who has live in Europe for most of my life. The European judiciary system has a high sense of integrity but some of their laws are definitely less refined and well thought out. I can't speak about customs since that's more subjective
@@rayfalcone7163 the law is good, but the corruption is rampant. And in case of European countries like Norweigh, it's easy to manipulate a very large part of the population, and also the citizen will only hear and understand what they are saying, rather than asking anything. Corruption is very high in Europe, and it's only increaseing, if you guys dont take steps soon, you guys will be left with just a hollow shell and nothing else.
What a strong mother.....hats off to you. If we can't raise our kids in our traditional way, what is the point of Western society calling themselves as open society.
Nobody is denying you to raise your children in your own cultural way. Its infact encouraged, even in Norway. Just dont do whats against the law, even if its your culture. Like cultures where female genital mutilation is part of their culture, or cultures where forced marriages take place on larger scale, where hitting is just part of discipline, because you do love your children. Dont do anything against the law.... My own kids, born and raised in Norway, I myself was just a child when we moved to Norway, takes the best of two cultures. There are parts of norwegian culture that we dont follow, as those doesnt feel right for us, and some parts of indian culture we dont agree with, so we dont follow them. We take the best of two cultures
@@Ms.P.Sharmahitting a slap is not completely wrong. At least I am not completely against it and I'm basically still a 20 year old who hasn't married and has no children and still studies in college. Sometimes, the children need to be disciplined. Jab seedhi ungli se ghee na nikle toh ungli tedhi karni padti hai. Mere parents bhale hi mere saath thode strict the par unhi ki wajah se mai aaj disciplined hu, jo ki meri umar ke baccho me kam hota hai.
@@ahangautam8471 As I said, it's not for me. I don't automatically look down on them. I just feel that slaps are not needed to discipline. My kids are born and raised in Norway, I remember when we had friends from India visiting us, parents and two children. The mother just couldn't understand that mine were well-behaved and that without any slap ever. I was born in India, moved to Norway in my tween yrs. I remember few slap here and there, me and my cousins Sometimes talk about old times, and laugh. It didn't scar me for life. Here its not the question about if normal physical discipline is ok or not. It's question about why people think that they are entitled to act on that part of their culture, in other countries too. Doesn't matter how normal or Okey it is in your country, when you are in other countrys, follow their laws. That simple.
@@Ms.P.Sharma they didn't accuse her of mutilating genitals, or even of anything in particular because they say the people don't work there anymore. That means they don't trust their record keeping or didn't do it. The UN also says Norway was separating kids too much. In this case they sound like they did it too quick, and for too long. That's a problem with Norway if true that they need to examine.
l am a Norwegian and l can say it is about time this comes out now and - This film will strengthen Norway's bad reputation internationally, and it is deserved. Because the system is so wrong in Norway and Since 2015, the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg has dealt with 40 child protection cases against Norway. But remember this also happens to ethnic Norwegians, and many Norwegians are simply afraid of the children's welfare in Norway, and therefore many people in Norway are afraid to have their children in kindergartens or schools because of the slightest negative remark from them to the children's welfare then the children are taken away from their families even today in 2023
As a breastfeeding mother of one year old daughter, it made me anxious and broke my heart when she said my kid is on breastfeeding in the trailer.... Western culture is suffering in terms of their EQ because they undermine bonding that could take place when children are under 3years of age, their upcoming generations would dread even more due to this. In my experience as a mother, researches does not always hold true for kids as each kid is different and we have to go with our intuitions as a mom and not just push helpless newborns into independence, it would come in a better way once they are emotionally, mentally and physically secure that is why these primitive years hold a lot of significance. India being an ancient civilization has learnt child-rearing through experience and westerners are trying to learn through researches
@@SteveRogers1999 I second that completely. Measuring every aspect of life in just one or two terms is not right. I worked in Amsterdam for a year and often felt that superiority complex but times have changed. Every society has its flaws but meddling that too in this harsh manner is obscene. Honestly, I am not sure whether I have the nerve to watch this but I will have to gain strength from how this mother turned things in her favour amongst all the distress.... Hats off
what can you expect from a skin show in European countries . in which women feel empowered and slept with random men from 14 to 18 years of age. fking insanity
@@user-go9kw6wf4m yes they suffer from this syndrome too. And deny the adverse impacts they made on climate, environment and human rights. On top of it always come to lecture east on anything & everything like Begaani shaadi mein Abdullah deewana....🤣
@@pradnya1228 there are many such cases, sadly. My friend doesn’t leave her babies anywhere, like we Indian mothers keep them at home for just going to neighbours house, the baby is fine, sleeping. She is scared of such things only. They don’t even keep baby sitter for weekend night to go for movie. If any one time baby sitter does wrong, even parents have risk of losing the child.
I've never cried from a movie until I just watched this masterpiece 😭💔 what an amazing story, the strength and courage this mother had to fight for the love of her children God Bless Her 🙏🏽♥️ I hope she is living her best life filled with so much love and happiness with her beautiful children thank you for sharing your story ♥️ I will never forget it 💯
I had so much respect for Norway till now ... The country should issue an apology to the mother and the kids for scarring them for life ... Shame on you Norway !
In general, not this particular case, there is no need to apologize, as their jobs is much needed, and we have an agency that truely focus on the best interest of the child. With that being said, this case could be one of those cases where things are misunderstood or misinterpreted. The decision to take over the custody at that time, was based on the information they had back then, how the family is doing right now is not imortant. Why I say that? Because in this particular case the children are doing ok, in a much calmer environment, we wouldnt even be discussing it if the opposite had been the case. You know if the story was: . I have nothing against mother, I am against backlash Norway and norwegian government is reaciving, based on a bollywood movie, with all people buying whatever the movie is selling, without even doing their own investigation. Barnevern is much need, even though it has some flaws, because not all parents are good parents
@@Ms.P.Sharma you support business and child trafficking, shame on you. You're probably part of that whole story 🤬 heartless demons, this earth is hell because of those kind od people
I was really young and I remember my mom crying and I couldn't understand why is she crying watching the news !! 24 today and now I understand it's heartbreaking after watching the movie trailer!
It made me cry although m not nether still my eyes crying now It’s good they have made movie now and these should be shown all over. The world as an immigrant I can feel that pain yes I can do my work peacefully now🥹🥹🥹🥹
This was about a culture and their custodies being judged by a country who knew nothing. Norwegian people live in their own bubble and think they're the elite, which translates to them thinking being fed by hand is a sin of sorts. I knew Norway was weird, but man... and this happened in 2011.. like a few years ago. their government is dumb. the cold is really bad for your brain I guess.
@@ashgrathom Simple, maybe they had the culture of making children killing machines from birth who survive all harsh conditions. In today's world it is called as being independant.
You talk about living in a bubble and judging others, yet you call out Norwegian PEOPLE for this? Do you think we go around supporting this? The Norwegian media is the ones who put immense pressure on the child protective services in Norway, it was a HUGE scandale here. No one defends this. It's a shame it happened and they have made changes after it happened.
I was so shattered after watching trailer & after getting to know that it's based on true story I searched for mother to know whether she got her children back & so happy to know she got them back yes God is with her❤️
I clicked on a standup comedy and watched the trailer as an ad., it broke my heart so much that I was numb, and halfway through the standup, I realized that I was laughing with teary eyes. Alhamdulillah she got them back🤲🏻
I was little back then to understand the sensitivity of this issue during it was all over the news!!! Here after Mrs. Chatteejee vs Norway trailer!!! Was desperately searching the verdict.... so taking a sigh of relief finally 🙏🤟... Kudos to u Sagrika Ma'am ❤💪
An very emotional battle, can imagine what the mother might have gone through. Scary to think that a government agency when not accountable can ruin lives... What a strong mother Sagarika was, hats off to her...
And they say NORWAY IS #2 best country to raise child after nearby DENMARK! By taking them away from their parents?💀 Ps: they have strong child abuse laws n all which is good but this is too far when they don't understand different cultures.. also these parents should have known better before moving there.
May she be the voice for thousands of kids snatched away from their parents who have not done any wrong ( abused / drugged / tortured their kids ) for their so called “ benefit “ leaving kids scarred and emotionally traumatized … Hope this movie and her story brings about change in their radical approach. Theres a lot if criticism about young 20 something who are not parents themselves and who have minimal to no degree facilitating this “ kidnapping to foster care and erasing all cultural identity ( language , religion , customs, traditions) Awfully painful movie to watch , honestly very traumatic!!! God bless this lady and her kids !!!!
Norway didnt back out, they found a solution that could work for both parties, because of political pressure. They made a court ruling that parents were somehow not fit to be good parents, as they should. That is something they didnt take back, its not like suddenly the mother was fit and all. They gave their custody to their uncle, whom they considered to be a better parent. Mother did get custody from norwegian government, but in India. In this particular case, things went ok, but opposite could also have been the case. We could be sitting here, in retrospect, regretting that solution, if children had really been abused or even died due to parents neglect or abuse, during the last few years. It might come as a shock to you, but indian parents can also be serious abusers.
Yet there are mothers who physically (hitting black and blue), emotionally (actually not caring about the child) even se**lly. Yes there are mothers who abuse their kids in either way, even though they are just days - weeks or even months old babies. We are not talking discipline in those cases, are we.
Great fight Mommy. A mother's love will always win, right here is proof. Thank God she has her babies back. Shame on whoever thought that they were doing the right thing taking her children away in the first place. There's a special place in hell for the people that did this to her. God bless
A child’s heaven is under his\her mother’s feet. If one hurts their mother’s feeling, his life will be “cursed” henceforth and he will not even smell the smell of heaven. Proud to be Indian Muslim.
There's another case pending in Germany of that of a young Gujarati couple. The Central Government has intervened with the German Chancellor presently in India. Frankly, the foster homes in so called developed nations work like a nexus.
I really feel her pain..I am not a mother but a woman ofcourse..and motherhood is the most precious gift of a woman..it was tormenting to see the trailer of Mrs chatterjee vs Norway.the cruelty of Scandinavian child welfare authorities in the name of protection of children is just an utter disgrace and shame..Western countries are really on the verge of perishing in terms of humanity,morality,culture,love,bond,affection..Finance and money may be important but not the basic parameter of life.. Mrs Sagarika you are a true mother in real sense. All the best to Mrs chatterjee vs Norway team and Rani Mukherjee and Anirban for their upcoming movie
Remember, it's a balancing act. On the whole, it's better to be a citizen of a western country. The state has to balance the parents rights and the children's right to safety. Children are far more likely to be abused by family members and close friends of the family. That's just the dirty reality. So we can never be too trusting with parents. Every year, lots of kids are abused ... by their parents. When we're dealing with children and possible abuse, it's better to be safe than sorry. Please keep in mind that this is a theatrical story. this couple was being monitored before the children were taken into custody. Then, these same children were sent to their paternal uncle in India. This woman had to go to court and she had to fight all the way up to the Indian Supreme Court. I am interested in protecting children. I keep informed to a degree. India is not a good place for children. In fact, it's dangerous. Especially for little girls. Hundreds of children are abused every day in India. That's just the facts. We shouldn't be fooled by these theatrical stories.
@@jenniferhunter4074 what is your source behind all this info that little indian girls are abused in India?? can you plz elaborate further how you found all Indians abuse their kids??
This is what the west is doing in general, I live in Sweden and have witnessed dozens of kids being taken away from their parents over small negligible problems. Respecting other cultures is something challenging for west.
Would you care to explain how exactly foreign cultures are not respected in the west? I mean which part? Yes some stuff from other cultures are simply not allowed, even though you think you are doing it out of love. * Hitting your children, even if its only for discipline, not an actual abuse, is NOT allowed. Follow the laws. * Female genital mutilation, as in circumcision, is NOT allowed, even if it didnt happen in Norway. So people cant go to their own home country to mutilate their daughters and come back and claim, it didnt happen in Norway. This is not about all girls who come to Norway with their daughters, as tourist, and had prior to that mutilated them. They react to those who are "norwegians" meaning living in Norway, permanently or temporary, regardless of citizenship. You coming back with newly mutilated daughter, will have them take custody of your child, and you getting thrown in jail. * Forced marriages are NOT allowed, and no arranged marriage are NOT considered forced. You cant force your children to marry someone you chose, and force them even if they say no. Yes, this is happening even in 2023. No, India is not considered a high risk country in that matter, there are few other countries where this is still happening on large scale. Most international airports in Norway even have an office or a place where young adults, who has this is not a vacation-feeling, who sincerely feel that their parents are getting them married to a cousin or something, they can actually get in touch with that office, and they take care of the rest. Hide that person, whatever it takes, to hinder them taking their children forcefully to their home country. Norwegian government respect and encourage people celebrating their culture, but not in all aspects, as given in my example. I just hate people making assumptions based on a movie, without doing their own research before making their decisions on a whole coyntry. Pls show me an official website that inform us that the reasons given in the trailer are indeed against the law. So now, their is no law against co-sleeping, hand-feeding, using tikka (ala facepaint) and no the government is NOT making money on children taken. Nobody is getting rich.
@@Ms.P.Sharma in sweden you can't tell your kids anymore that they can't hang out with certain friends even if they are not good peers , you can't tell them what to wear , you can't stop your kids from sleeping over their friends places , that's considered a threat to their freedom , am not talking about hitting your kids now but I have witnessed a three year old toddler telling her day care teachers that her mom pushed her with a finger and guess what she was taken from the family, and i had to ask her very specifically how did her mom push her and she showed it with her index finger on her belly, that crushed me , and just recently my own son just four lied about being hit by my dad and we got to attend alot of meetings to sort things out and finally found out it was one of his teachers who hit him and asked him to make the story other way round, we complained but the day care only apologised for the so called misunderstanding, so hope that helped to understand a bit about outside your shell
@@adilahaidari674 I do understand outside my shell. I do agree that barnevern does need to make few changes, so there is absolutely no misunderstanding. I seriously dont know the swedish law, as its not norwegian, there could be different. I certainly tell my kids, and mind you I have daughters, just so you know. I have absolutely decided what they absolutely cant wear, if I as a mother am not comfortable. No revealing clothes, no bikinis, no this or no that, but that only goes until a point. You seriously cant make your 16, or even 18 year old wear only the things you are comfortable with. At some point you just have to let them make their own decisions My youngest is 16, I allow her to sleepover, or have a sleepover with friends I know and am comfortable with. They do that all the time, multiple times during summer vacation. I DO NOT allow her to sleepover at a friends house, I know nothing about. She started highschool last year, and got some new friends, I dont know them, so she is not allowed to sleep at their place, but she is allowed to have them sleepover at our house. I am being safe, if that means being strict, then so be it. Better safe than sorry. I make that decision. If barnevern have a problem with that, then its their problem. My daughters has/have had a lot of freedom. All the things I prohibit them to do, is because I have a problem with those things, not because they are girls. I wouldnt have allowed my kids, even if they were boys. What I tell them, prohibit them is NOT because they are girls. My girls are independent, their wishes are respected, Its in human nature to lie, people do that all over the world. Kids can definetly lie, so can adults. Barnevern knows that. Therefore they have multiple meetings, they do their level best to find out and in most cases rule out any misdoings in the family. But tell me, if a child or teenager tells, even if that is a lie, that they are hit a lot, or their father/mother are touching them in private parts...what would you, if you are a government agency, do? You only have small information at hand, would you let child stay with an allegged abuser, or would you first of all remove the child from a situation, or would you first conduct thoroughly investigation, even if that takes weeks, gathering evidence, and then take away the child from the situation? What would you think would have happened during that time. Multiple abuse? In these cases, along with other serious cases, they remove first, investigate later. In most cases, nothing comes of it. In some cases the allegations are true. In your case, what else would you want the kindergarten to do? In Norway, in extreme cases they are reprimended and fined. The teacher would have been suspended, and you should and would have gotten a sincere apology. What else?
@@Ms.P.Sharma thats it, you untill a certain point can control your kids we can't, the neighbours and everyone around you are more interested in your kids than their own , at times if feels you just give birth to your kids and then the state and society own them , jag förstår det du säger men tyvärr är det inte så i många ställen i Sverige
@@adilahaidari674 I totally get what you mean and feel. I guess my trust in barnevern, in general, could be due to me being a pediatric nurse, with more than 20 yrs of experience. We have had some experience with barnevern, in cases where these children were in connection with us. There has been few cases, luckily, but we have seen different injuries, and even brain damage due to physical abuse. So yes people can be horrible, parents can be abusive monsters. So yes I agree that parents in general knows whats best for their children. I just dont agree with people claiming that parents are loving, dont mess with a mother, norwegian authorities are child kidnappers and so on. Barnevern is doing a very necessary job, they are very much needed, but I do agree they need to reform themselves, they need to make few changes that brings "false" and misunderstanding cases to a very minimum. Yes they can in some cases be wrong. People should google two of the most horrible cases of child abuse, in Norway. Christroffer-saken (Christoffer case) and Alvdal - saken (Alvdal case). There are english websites too. Honestly these cases were cases where barnevern didnt do their job. They didnt see the signs, maybe parents were doing great job with hiding the truth. Jeg forstår deg. Jeg forstår følelsen. Jeg ville også hatt det helt forferdelig hvis mine egne barn hadde blitt tatt fra meg, over misforståelse. Jeg er ikke følelsesløs person, jeg bare prøver å se saken av mer enn sentimentale grunner. Det er mer enn 1,3 milliarder mennesker der ute, som ser på filmen som en sannhet, når ikke en gang grunnene gitt i trailer er sanne. Det er sikkert tilsvarende i Sverige også. Ingen av grunnene er ulovlige i Norge. De burde ihvertfall google saken fra myndighetenes side, før de angriper.
This is something that happened 10 years ago, you don't think every country have some scandale in one way or another? If you think Norwegian child protective services can just steal whatever child they want, then you do in fact need a new reality check, you can't just look at one situation like this and then change your mind about the whole country lol
That was some years ago. Finland has been the happiest country in the world for a few years now. But rich countries have a lot of problems too.. if you scratch the surface.
Who’s here after mrs chatterjee vs norway movie
Ami
me
Me
Almost all of us😢
Me
This mother is a hero. She fought an entire country to get her children back ♥️♥️♥️
Never knew about this case 😦
Just came here after watching
Mrs Chatterjee vs Norway 💫
Really happy for Sagarika☺️, she got justice and got her children back
Those children had also grown up, hope those children are leading a happy life
Best wishes to them ✨
Me Too sis, Heavy Acting koreche Rani Di ✌️
@@Mithinga_Narzary akebare thik by the way I'm sis 🙂
@@shikha2439 thik koreche 😁
Yr mai rone laga tha trailer Dekh k bhai sab kya hi kahu akhon se asu nhi ruk rahe aur song toh alg hi level match kiya hai❤️❤️🖤
@@Hid-EntityI guess ye phela trailer hain jise dekh ke aankh mein asu aagaye
Came here after watching Mrs. Chatterjee Vs Norway Trailer. Truly heartbreaking. Shame on Norwegian Authorities 😡😡.
its an exception.....there are many parents in this part of the world who dump kids, feed candy's for breakfast.
Arey Scandinavian countries are like this only. Totally different culture from subcontinent.
@@postwala2667 yeah norway must have misunderstood but this is too much
@@sh0gun570 yea they didn't misunderstand I am psychologist i can read his liberal family i think his mother must have beaten him which is considered kind of considered illegal in these countries especially when your child is below 10. i think. foster home took this too seriously. they thought it would be right if child be raised alone.
@@unknownman6874 ohh interesting....
I used to think that European countries are better in both judiciary and customs, but know after after all this news, i can say that they are in a more hopeless situation than us.
Emotionless re*ards they're, de*d from heart.
As someone who has live in Europe for most of my life. The European judiciary system has a high sense of integrity but some of their laws are definitely less refined and well thought out. I can't speak about customs since that's more subjective
Same bro
@@rayfalcone7163 they took too long to give verdict
@@rayfalcone7163 the law is good, but the corruption is rampant. And in case of European countries like Norweigh, it's easy to manipulate a very large part of the population, and also the citizen will only hear and understand what they are saying, rather than asking anything. Corruption is very high in Europe, and it's only increaseing, if you guys dont take steps soon, you guys will be left with just a hollow shell and nothing else.
What a strong mother.....hats off to you. If we can't raise our kids in our traditional way, what is the point of Western society calling themselves as open society.
Nobody is denying you to raise your children in your own cultural way. Its infact encouraged, even in Norway. Just dont do whats against the law, even if its your culture. Like cultures where female genital mutilation is part of their culture, or cultures where forced marriages take place on larger scale, where hitting is just part of discipline, because you do love your children. Dont do anything against the law....
My own kids, born and raised in Norway, I myself was just a child when we moved to Norway, takes the best of two cultures. There are parts of norwegian culture that we dont follow, as those doesnt feel right for us, and some parts of indian culture we dont agree with, so we dont follow them. We take the best of two cultures
@@Ms.P.Sharmahitting a slap is not completely wrong. At least I am not completely against it and I'm basically still a 20 year old who hasn't married and has no children and still studies in college. Sometimes, the children need to be disciplined. Jab seedhi ungli se ghee na nikle toh ungli tedhi karni padti hai. Mere parents bhale hi mere saath thode strict the par unhi ki wajah se mai aaj disciplined hu, jo ki meri umar ke baccho me kam hota hai.
@@Ms.P.Sharmakam pyar se nahi discipline se hota hai. Discipline nahi toh jitna bhi talent ho, kuch nahi kar sakte.
@@ahangautam8471
As I said, it's not for me. I don't automatically look down on them. I just feel that slaps are not needed to discipline. My kids are born and raised in Norway, I remember when we had friends from India visiting us, parents and two children. The mother just couldn't understand that mine were well-behaved and that without any slap ever.
I was born in India, moved to Norway in my tween yrs. I remember few slap here and there, me and my cousins Sometimes talk about old times, and laugh. It didn't scar me for life.
Here its not the question about if normal physical discipline is ok or not. It's question about why people think that they are entitled to act on that part of their culture, in other countries too.
Doesn't matter how normal or Okey it is in your country, when you are in other countrys, follow their laws.
That simple.
@@Ms.P.Sharma they didn't accuse her of mutilating genitals, or even of anything in particular because they say the people don't work there anymore. That means they don't trust their record keeping or didn't do it.
The UN also says Norway was separating kids too much.
In this case they sound like they did it too quick, and for too long.
That's a problem with Norway if true that they need to examine.
l am a Norwegian and l can say it is about time this comes out now and - This film will strengthen Norway's bad reputation internationally, and it is deserved. Because the system is so wrong in Norway and Since 2015, the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg has dealt with 40 child protection cases against Norway. But remember this also happens to ethnic Norwegians, and many Norwegians are simply afraid of the children's welfare in Norway, and therefore many people in Norway are afraid to have their children in kindergartens or schools because of the slightest negative remark from them to the children's welfare then the children are taken away from their families even today in 2023
Shame on your judiciary system 😡😡😡😡
@@akashpatil3777 lol he accepts his govt's mistake and you are even criticizing much more presuming our judiciary is elite class system😂😂😂😂
@@christophergonsalves2179 elite class 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 stealing others children is elite classs 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@barkhachourasia1200 first of all i am not criticizing him.... I criticized their judiciary system
Well do believe govt need to be more empathetic and bring changes such rules that no parents or child has to suffer like that
Never mess with a strong, loving mother
After watching the trailer of Mrs..chayerjee v/s Norway. Really so much strong woman..
🥰
As a breastfeeding mother of one year old daughter, it made me anxious and broke my heart when she said my kid is on breastfeeding in the trailer.... Western culture is suffering in terms of their EQ because they undermine bonding that could take place when children are under 3years of age, their upcoming generations would dread even more due to this. In my experience as a mother, researches does not always hold true for kids as each kid is different and we have to go with our intuitions as a mom and not just push helpless newborns into independence, it would come in a better way once they are emotionally, mentally and physically secure that is why these primitive years hold a lot of significance. India being an ancient civilization has learnt child-rearing through experience and westerners are trying to learn through researches
Westerners suffer from the Superiority Complex from the days of industrial revolution. Racism has gotten a peak only because of them you see.
@@SteveRogers1999 I second that completely. Measuring every aspect of life in just one or two terms is not right. I worked in Amsterdam for a year and often felt that superiority complex but times have changed. Every society has its flaws but meddling that too in this harsh manner is obscene. Honestly, I am not sure whether I have the nerve to watch this but I will have to gain strength from how this mother turned things in her favour amongst all the distress.... Hats off
what can you expect from a skin show in European countries . in which women feel empowered and slept with random men from 14 to 18 years of age. fking insanity
@@SteveRogers1999it's funny how they forget that their industrial revolution was funded by money stolen from India and Africa
@@user-go9kw6wf4m yes they suffer from this syndrome too. And deny the adverse impacts they made on climate, environment and human rights. On top of it always come to lecture east on anything & everything like Begaani shaadi mein Abdullah deewana....🤣
You're the best mom. I can't stop crying after watching it from Netflix.
I can't stop crying 😢
Honestly, I couldn't delete the movie
She is one of my hero’s. Our children are like vital organs. I am so proud of her determination and dedication.
The promo of Mrs. Chatterjee Vs Norway movie attract here. But the movie should contribute for similar kind of cases in future.
I hope none this kind of cases will happen in future.
@@pradnya1228 there are many such cases, sadly. My friend doesn’t leave her babies anywhere, like we Indian mothers keep them at home for just going to neighbours house, the baby is fine, sleeping. She is scared of such things only. They don’t even keep baby sitter for weekend night to go for movie. If any one time baby sitter does wrong, even parents have risk of losing the child.
This is happening again in Germany.
I've never cried from a movie until I just watched this masterpiece 😭💔 what an amazing story, the strength and courage this mother had to fight for the love of her children God Bless Her 🙏🏽♥️ I hope she is living her best life filled with so much love and happiness with her beautiful children thank you for sharing your story ♥️ I will never forget it 💯
Is video par 10 saal me pahli comment hua hai .
Only , after the movie trailer of" Mrs chatterjee vs Norway " so this type of movie we should support.
I had so much respect for Norway till now ... The country should issue an apology to the mother and the kids for scarring them for life ... Shame on you Norway !
In general, not this particular case, there is no need to apologize, as their jobs is much needed, and we have an agency that truely focus on the best interest of the child. With that being said, this case could be one of those cases where things are misunderstood or misinterpreted. The decision to take over the custody at that time, was based on the information they had back then, how the family is doing right now is not imortant. Why I say that? Because in this particular case the children are doing ok, in a much calmer environment, we wouldnt even be discussing it if the opposite had been the case. You know if the story was: .
I have nothing against mother, I am against backlash Norway and norwegian government is reaciving, based on a bollywood movie, with all people buying whatever the movie is selling, without even doing their own investigation. Barnevern is much need, even though it has some flaws, because not all parents are good parents
@@Ms.P.SharmaMyruuu irukuradhu thaan paa kamchangaaa chumaaa sombhuu thukituu vandhurvan
@@Ms.P.Sharma you support business and child trafficking, shame on you. You're probably part of that whole story 🤬 heartless demons, this earth is hell because of those kind od people
I was really young and I remember my mom crying and I couldn't understand why is she crying watching the news !! 24 today and now I understand it's heartbreaking after watching the movie trailer!
bruh...stop lying
Har baat pe crying likhna cool dikhta h kya.
I remember the same. My son was young at that time and this was heartbreaking. I followed the news diligently for updates about the case at that time.
Here after watching the trailer. I'm glad she was reunited with her kids. Now I can sleep peacefully 😄
It made me cry although m not nether still my eyes crying now
It’s good they have made movie now and these should be shown all over. The world as an immigrant I can feel that pain yes I can do my work peacefully now🥹🥹🥹🥹
But damn she suffered for 2 years the pain of it is just unbelievable
Norway image 📉
Happiest country on the shadow of tears of others 😪
Jai hind🇮🇳
Not only norway all west
This was about a culture and their custodies being judged by a country who knew nothing. Norwegian people live in their own bubble and think they're the elite, which translates to them thinking being fed by hand is a sin of sorts. I knew Norway was weird, but man... and this happened in 2011.. like a few years ago. their government is dumb. the cold is really bad for your brain I guess.
I was wondering how the europeans could fight all these wars and even send their armies to fight in this horrible cold weather!!!!! Just stunning.
@@ashgrathom kesay is cutting glaciers for more better sea routes, and here lecturing us to eat worms to save the planet.
@@ashgrathom Simple, maybe they had the culture of making children killing machines from birth who survive all harsh conditions. In today's world it is called as being independant.
You know about the mentality
You talk about living in a bubble and judging others, yet you call out Norwegian PEOPLE for this? Do you think we go around supporting this? The Norwegian media is the ones who put immense pressure on the child protective services in Norway, it was a HUGE scandale here. No one defends this. It's a shame it happened and they have made changes after it happened.
I was so shattered after watching trailer & after getting to know that it's based on true story I searched for mother to know whether she got her children back & so happy to know she got them back yes God is with her❤️
I clicked on a standup comedy and watched the trailer as an ad., it broke my heart so much that I was numb, and halfway through the standup, I realized that I was laughing with teary eyes.
Alhamdulillah she got them back🤲🏻
Who came here after watching mrs Chatterjee vs Norway. I had never heard about this painful story .thanks to the director and the crew of this movie
Plz pray for my brother too. He has been wrongly arrested too. We r fighting for justice. It's happy 2 see family together
May ur brother get set free
I was little back then to understand the sensitivity of this issue during it was all over the news!!! Here after Mrs. Chatteejee vs Norway trailer!!! Was desperately searching the verdict.... so taking a sigh of relief finally 🙏🤟... Kudos to u Sagrika Ma'am ❤💪
🥲🥲
An very emotional battle, can imagine what the mother might have gone through. Scary to think that a government agency when not accountable can ruin lives...
What a strong mother Sagarika was, hats off to her...
Feeling sad for those... Who caught in this kind of scam and still separated from their kids 😔😔
Would you care to explain exact which type of scam?
I am so relieved to know that they actually won the case.
I am really ashamed that I knew nothing about this case before a movie was made on it 🤦🤦
Your biography are also inspiring others and me because your struggle and your loves for children absolutely true. take ❤from Bangladesh 🙂🙂
Here after Mrs. Chatterjee vs Norway trailer!
Same here 😅 but that story 😢heartbreaking 💔
पश्चिमी देश बहुत बदमाश है , बॉलीवुड की अभिनेत्रियों को पश्चिमी गोरी लड़कियों नकल नहीं करना चाहिए ,
Thanx for showing us the bad side of foreign countries 🙏
Ajeebo gareeb rules hai European desho ke.
There's loopholes in all judiciary and some people take advantage of that for there own benefits!!!!
And they say NORWAY IS #2 best country to raise child after nearby DENMARK! By taking them away from their parents?💀
Ps: they have strong child abuse laws n all which is good but this is too far when they don't understand different cultures.. also these parents should have known better before moving there.
@@JhaaSahab it’s the CORRPUT system of Norway, the foster care corruption. Just because it’s sophisticated corruption doesn’t mean it isn’t.
@@JhaaSahab stealing is not a loophole
Every mother have power to protect their children from every evil eyes god bless u🤗
I wish today's news channel's are like this how peaceful and staight forward
Today's news channel's are just like a shouting competition
This is NDTV,and it is pretty much same
Hats off to you sagrika today i watch movie my tears just rolled down .proud of you mother ❤
I can’t even imagine - can’t think of anything more painful.
It’s made me cry When I watched the film .
May god bless you and your childeren always ❤
Thank you 👍 salut
May she be the voice for thousands of kids snatched away from their parents who have not done any wrong ( abused / drugged / tortured their kids ) for their so called “ benefit “ leaving kids scarred and emotionally traumatized …
Hope this movie and her story brings about change in their radical approach.
Theres a lot if criticism about young 20 something who are not parents themselves and who have minimal to no degree facilitating this “ kidnapping to foster care and erasing all cultural identity ( language , religion , customs, traditions)
Awfully painful movie to watch , honestly very traumatic!!!
God bless this lady and her kids !!!!
What a resilient MOTHER. Bless you Mom. I know this case has passed but it is necessary to keep raising awareness ❤️❤️❤️
Even Norway had to back out infront of an Indian Mother ❤
Norway didnt back out, they found a solution that could work for both parties, because of political pressure. They made a court ruling that parents were somehow not fit to be good parents, as they should. That is something they didnt take back, its not like suddenly the mother was fit and all. They gave their custody to their uncle, whom they considered to be a better parent. Mother did get custody from norwegian government, but in India.
In this particular case, things went ok, but opposite could also have been the case. We could be sitting here, in retrospect, regretting that solution, if children had really been abused or even died due to parents neglect or abuse, during the last few years. It might come as a shock to you, but indian parents can also be serious abusers.
Who d hell r u Sharma...everywhere u seem to b supporting for Norway...r u an Indian or some barbarian ....
A purest bond in whole universe is mothers and her childs❤
Yet there are mothers who physically (hitting black and blue), emotionally (actually not caring about the child) even se**lly. Yes there are mothers who abuse their kids in either way, even though they are just days - weeks or even months old babies. We are not talking discipline in those cases, are we.
Ek Maa apne baccho ke liye kuch bhi krt skti hai love u all 😘 Maa
on our last day on earth the whole world should give her a standing ovation 🙏🏽🙏🏽
Great fight Mommy. A mother's love will always win, right here is proof. Thank God she has her babies back. Shame on whoever thought that they were doing the right thing taking her children away in the first place. There's a special place in hell for the people that did this to her. God bless
Its very inhuman to separate a child from mother
After mrs chaterjee trailer i m trilled, hats off to u lady.
A child’s heaven is under his\her mother’s feet.
If one hurts their mother’s feeling, his life will be “cursed” henceforth and he will not even smell the smell of heaven.
Proud to be Indian Muslim.
Here after the trailer 🥺
Felt that!
Amazing mother
me here after watching the trailer💥💥💥💥💥💥Anirban Bhattacharya💥💥💥💥💥💥Rani Mukherjee❤❤❤❤💥💥💥💥just outstanding....very emotional❤❤❤
Slamat rhy Abad rhy khush rhy 💕
Happy Mother’s Day to the strong mother ❤
Stay Happy Sagarika mam with your wards....Hats off....
I wish i can give her a hug! I couldn't watch that movie. I was crying through out
I remember sushma swaraj raising this case at the time. Norway should be ashamed
Who came here after watching " Mrs. Chatterjee vs Norway" trailer
Salute to the courageous and strong woman of India. Proud Indian
Hw heartbreaking.. small children taken away from parents..its like kidnapping
Pleasant surprise to see Ms. Palki Sharma Upadhyay anchoring this story 10 years ago. She is on a league of her own now.
ye case ahia wala hai kiya
Sarvam, is that really Palki? Are you sure?
There's another case pending in Germany of that of a young Gujarati couple. The Central Government has intervened with the German Chancellor presently in India.
Frankly, the foster homes in so called developed nations work like a nexus.
They should talk to the same lawyers from this lady. and forgein minister.
As a bengali i feel very happy..God bless them
I just come here after watching the trailer I cried why we didn't hear about this before why ??
Watching this after the movie...😢 Anyway happy to hear all these happened years ago and they are happy living now ❤
Now we cay say that the movie will have happy ending 🎉
What a mother she is❤❤❤
heart touching
Proud of you fighter. Love you. Jai Hind.
Hope the kids won’t be hit by the parents anymore
Your very strong 💪 mother ❤❤❤❤
Proud of you after watching movie you done a great job❤️
Strong mother 👏
Iss duniya sabse badi yodha maa hoti h 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Who Is Here After Mrs Chatterjee Vs Norway ❤️❤️
Hatsoff maam!.❤
Can’t imagine this happened to someone in real life , now to courage of a mother
I'm crying
I really feel her pain..I am not a mother but a woman ofcourse..and motherhood is the most precious gift of a woman..it was tormenting to see the trailer of Mrs chatterjee vs Norway.the cruelty of Scandinavian child welfare authorities in the name of protection of children is just an utter disgrace and shame..Western countries are really on the verge of perishing in terms of humanity,morality,culture,love,bond,affection..Finance and money may be important but not the basic parameter of life..
Mrs Sagarika you are a true mother in real sense.
All the best to Mrs chatterjee vs Norway team and Rani Mukherjee and Anirban for their upcoming movie
Remember, it's a balancing act. On the whole, it's better to be a citizen of a western country. The state has to balance the parents rights and the children's right to safety. Children are far more likely to be abused by family members and close friends of the family. That's just the dirty reality. So we can never be too trusting with parents. Every year, lots of kids are abused ... by their parents. When we're dealing with children and possible abuse, it's better to be safe than sorry.
Please keep in mind that this is a theatrical story. this couple was being monitored before the children were taken into custody. Then, these same children were sent to their paternal uncle in India. This woman had to go to court and she had to fight all the way up to the Indian Supreme Court.
I am interested in protecting children. I keep informed to a degree. India is not a good place for children. In fact, it's dangerous. Especially for little girls. Hundreds of children are abused every day in India. That's just the facts. We shouldn't be fooled by these theatrical stories.
@@jenniferhunter4074 what is your source behind all this info that little indian girls are abused in India?? can you plz elaborate further how you found all Indians abuse their kids??
@@jenniferhunter4074 just shut up
Every women have the power to do anything for her children.
Came here after the trailer. The movie's definitely gonna have some impact
2 years of life without her children which she will never get back. Governments should be held accountable for ruining lives of ordinary people.
m happy that a movie is made on this coz of which we came to know about this case..
The people
commiting these horrific crimes of injustice will suffer. Suffer a lot. Believe me.
UA-cam recommended this after 10 years..
How many of you are here after watching the trailer😂😂😎
is Mrs Chatterjee vs Norway based on her?
i had goosebumps after watching trailer
Salute to this mother
after the trailer, cant wait for the movie for story .
I mean Norway should understand India is not sparsely populated like Norway that everyone will have seperate rooms
Trailer dekhkar yaha pohcha hu, hats of madam,
Never mess with a mother...
Very good story for rani Mukherjee movei. I hope all the world 🌎 see this movie and nobody go to norway 🇳🇴
This is a nightmare 😢
Here foster homes are like hell.
This is what the west is doing in general, I live in Sweden and have witnessed dozens of kids being taken away from their parents over small negligible problems. Respecting other cultures is something challenging for west.
Would you care to explain how exactly foreign cultures are not respected in the west?
I mean which part? Yes some stuff from other cultures are simply not allowed, even though you think you are doing it out of love.
* Hitting your children, even if its only for discipline, not an actual abuse, is NOT allowed. Follow the laws.
* Female genital mutilation, as in circumcision, is NOT allowed, even if it didnt happen in Norway. So people cant go to their own home country to mutilate their daughters and come back and claim, it didnt happen in Norway. This is not about all girls who come to Norway with their daughters, as tourist, and had prior to that mutilated them. They react to those who are "norwegians" meaning living in Norway, permanently or temporary, regardless of citizenship. You coming back with newly mutilated daughter, will have them take custody of your child, and you getting thrown in jail.
* Forced marriages are NOT allowed, and no arranged marriage are NOT considered forced. You cant force your children to marry someone you chose, and force them even if they say no. Yes, this is happening even in 2023. No, India is not considered a high risk country in that matter, there are few other countries where this is still happening on large scale. Most international airports in Norway even have an office or a place where young adults, who has this is not a vacation-feeling, who sincerely feel that their parents are getting them married to a cousin or something, they can actually get in touch with that office, and they take care of the rest. Hide that person, whatever it takes, to hinder them taking their children forcefully to their home country.
Norwegian government respect and encourage people celebrating their culture, but not in all aspects, as given in my example.
I just hate people making assumptions based on a movie, without doing their own research before making their decisions on a whole coyntry. Pls show me an official website that inform us that the reasons given in the trailer are indeed against the law.
So now, their is no law against co-sleeping, hand-feeding, using tikka (ala facepaint) and no the government is NOT making money on children taken. Nobody is getting rich.
@@Ms.P.Sharma in sweden you can't tell your kids anymore that they can't hang out with certain friends even if they are not good peers , you can't tell them what to wear , you can't stop your kids from sleeping over their friends places , that's considered a threat to their freedom , am not talking about hitting your kids now but I have witnessed a three year old toddler telling her day care teachers that her mom pushed her with a finger and guess what she was taken from the family, and i had to ask her very specifically how did her mom push her and she showed it with her index finger on her belly, that crushed me , and just recently my own son just four lied about being hit by my dad and we got to attend alot of meetings to sort things out and finally found out it was one of his teachers who hit him and asked him to make the story other way round, we complained but the day care only apologised for the so called misunderstanding, so hope that helped to understand a bit about outside your shell
@@adilahaidari674
I do understand outside my shell. I do agree that barnevern does need to make few changes, so there is absolutely no misunderstanding.
I seriously dont know the swedish law, as its not norwegian, there could be different. I certainly tell my kids, and mind you I have daughters, just so you know. I have absolutely decided what they absolutely cant wear, if I as a mother am not comfortable. No revealing clothes, no bikinis, no this or no that, but that only goes until a point. You seriously cant make your 16, or even 18 year old wear only the things you are comfortable with. At some point you just have to let them make their own decisions
My youngest is 16, I allow her to sleepover, or have a sleepover with friends I know and am comfortable with. They do that all the time, multiple times during summer vacation. I DO NOT allow her to sleepover at a friends house, I know nothing about. She started highschool last year, and got some new friends, I dont know them, so she is not allowed to sleep at their place, but she is allowed to have them sleepover at our house. I am being safe, if that means being strict, then so be it. Better safe than sorry. I make that decision. If barnevern have a problem with that, then its their problem. My daughters has/have had a lot of freedom.
All the things I prohibit them to do, is because I have a problem with those things, not because they are girls. I wouldnt have allowed my kids, even if they were boys.
What I tell them, prohibit them is NOT because they are girls. My girls are independent, their wishes are respected,
Its in human nature to lie, people do that all over the world. Kids can definetly lie, so can adults. Barnevern knows that. Therefore they have multiple meetings, they do their level best to find out and in most cases rule out any misdoings in the family. But tell me, if a child or teenager tells, even if that is a lie, that they are hit a lot, or their father/mother are touching them in private parts...what would you, if you are a government agency, do? You only have small information at hand, would you let child stay with an allegged abuser, or would you first of all remove the child from a situation, or would you first conduct thoroughly investigation, even if that takes weeks, gathering evidence, and then take away the child from the situation? What would you think would have happened during that time. Multiple abuse?
In these cases, along with other serious cases, they remove first, investigate later. In most cases, nothing comes of it. In some cases the allegations are true.
In your case, what else would you want the kindergarten to do? In Norway, in extreme cases they are reprimended and fined. The teacher would have been suspended, and you should and would have gotten a sincere apology. What else?
@@Ms.P.Sharma thats it, you untill a certain point can control your kids we can't, the neighbours and everyone around you are more interested in your kids than their own , at times if feels you just give birth to your kids and then the state and society own them , jag förstår det du säger men tyvärr är det inte så i många ställen i Sverige
@@adilahaidari674
I totally get what you mean and feel. I guess my trust in barnevern, in general, could be due to me being a pediatric nurse, with more than 20 yrs of experience. We have had some experience with barnevern, in cases where these children were in connection with us. There has been few cases, luckily, but we have seen different injuries, and even brain damage due to physical abuse. So yes people can be horrible, parents can be abusive monsters. So yes I agree that parents in general knows whats best for their children. I just dont agree with people claiming that parents are loving, dont mess with a mother, norwegian authorities are child kidnappers and so on.
Barnevern is doing a very necessary job, they are very much needed, but I do agree they need to reform themselves, they need to make few changes that brings "false" and misunderstanding cases to a very minimum. Yes they can in some cases be wrong.
People should google two of the most horrible cases of child abuse, in Norway. Christroffer-saken (Christoffer case) and Alvdal - saken (Alvdal case). There are english websites too. Honestly these cases were cases where barnevern didnt do their job. They didnt see the signs, maybe parents were doing great job with hiding the truth.
Jeg forstår deg. Jeg forstår følelsen. Jeg ville også hatt det helt forferdelig hvis mine egne barn hadde blitt tatt fra meg, over misforståelse. Jeg er ikke følelsesløs person, jeg bare prøver å se saken av mer enn sentimentale grunner. Det er mer enn 1,3 milliarder mennesker der ute, som ser på filmen som en sannhet, når ikke en gang grunnene gitt i trailer er sanne. Det er sikkert tilsvarende i Sverige også. Ingen av grunnene er ulovlige i Norge. De burde ihvertfall google saken fra myndighetenes side, før de angriper.
Queen she is.
JUST WATCHED THE MOVIE AND OMG WOW ❤️
*We need update on this family.*
Congrats!!
I hope this is the truly happy ending for the real mother😖 i never imagine how traumatic she is as a mother after passing this bad journey in life😭
I thought Norway was a happiest country, thnks for the reality check!
This is something that happened 10 years ago, you don't think every country have some scandale in one way or another? If you think Norwegian child protective services can just steal whatever child they want, then you do in fact need a new reality check, you can't just look at one situation like this and then change your mind about the whole country lol
That was some years ago. Finland has been the happiest country in the world for a few years now. But rich countries have a lot of problems too.. if you scratch the surface.
I never knew....
This is what justice looks like ...
No matter how hard but c won .