Norway custody row ends; children arrive in India
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 кві 2012
- After spending nearly a year in foster care in Norway, toddlers Abhigyan and Aishwarya are back in India. They arrived at the Delhi airport a little before 10 am today with their uncle, Arunabhas Bhattacharya; they are expected to leave for Kolkata tomorrow. The children's paternal grandparents received them at the airport.
Who is here after Mrs chatterjee vs Norway
I m
Me2
Who does that?
Insane and inhumane.
ALLAH Maafi.
Me
Me
Came here after watching Mrs. Chatterjee Vs Norway Trailer. Truly heartbreaking. Shame on Norwegian Authorities 😡😡.
Sorry can not support your comment. If Parents are incompetant they are better taken away by state.
Me bhi ..I never visit Norway...
I am an Indian and live In Finland. Vety similar system all over Nordics. I my life certain tjings happened, and from personal experience, I support the Nordics welfare system and not such head less sentiments.
@@indranil56 that is called kidnapping children. If so worried about the child, put surveillance on the family. Make frequent visits there. Live with them. Your comment is so superficial. If you will lose your child someday, on some state's understanding of raising a child, then you might understand.
@@indranil56 if this kidnapping is their welfare system, then it is better they rethink about such pathetic provisions.
Not India nor Africa... Europe is so uncultured..
True. Running naked on beaches is their culture. Sooner they will start living in caves as well.
shitting on the streets is your culture
Sure, now places without toilets are more cultured
@@demonslayer3683 I don't think anyone anywhere wears a jumpsuit or overcoat on a beach either 🤡
@@demonslayer3683 Everyone with a good brain wears swimsuits on beaches and stays naked on nude beaches.
Try doing this with today's India. We have grown so much in these 10 years, I appreciate all the parties for getting India at this spot.
It is happening rn tho
It's still happening and there are so many cases. It's very common thing.
A kid named shah in Germany is going through this
To be fair if you move to another country you have to follow their rules or else stay in India. Anyways salaries in Europe are not even good and very high tax why go their
Its happening in germany
It broke my heart the child clinging to the foster father.
Exactly. Goof up of the Norwegian government has broken the hearts of the foster parents as well . They seem so loving. The kids would have been so confused as well. At least when the boy was away from him mom, he was with loving people. Sweet of them to bring the child themselves instead of just sending the child through the authorities.
It shows how well they were taken care of by the foster parents.
As a breastfeeding mother of one year old daughter, it made me anxious and broke my heart when she said my kid is on breastfeeding in the trailer.... Western culture is suffering in terms of their EQ because they undermine bonding that could take place when children are under 3years of age, their upcoming generations would dread even more due to this. In my experience as a mother, researches does not always hold true for kids as each kid is different and we have to go with our intuitions as a mom and not just push helpless newborns into independence, it would come in a better way once they are emotionally, mentally and physically secure that is why these primitive years hold a lot of significance. India being an ancient civilization has learnt child-rearing through experience and westerners are trying to learn through researches
@Stardust Meant To Shine I totally agree
I see your message almost everywhere
@@AdityaThakur-st2wf Connecting to the issue raised in the movie is a problem? I don't think so
@@prernasharma1307 there's no issue... I just observed it and asked u the same...
@@AdityaThakur-st2wf then it is fine.... This is still happening so would be better if we do whatever we can, already a protest on Twitter is trending for a similar case in Germany happening in the present
So sorry for those foster parents and the real parents
Exactly. Goof up of the Norwegian government has broken the hearts of the foster parents as well. They seem so loving as well. The kids would have been so confused as well. At least when the boy was away from him mom, he was with loving people. Sweet of them to bring the child themselves instead of just sending the child through the authorities.
True . All the three parties will suffer life long .
Unimaginable trauma the children suffered due the insensitive Norwegian laws.
They suffered when they went to the lying Uncle. He was getting money for them, and treated the, horribly. The mother got them. The paternal grandparents are crooks, and so is their uncle.
Never knew Norway has such petty rules for parenting. Co sleeping is backed by researchers as well. For god’s sake can not have laws on how people sleep. I expected this from North Korea not Norway.
True
But there is a loophole. Sudden infant death syndrome
@@HamzaalAbbasi that’s first 6 months.
They are child thieves
Look into this topic you will be shocked like me. I was in utter shock and horrified that this kinds of things is happening in Europe, apparently its quite a huge problem there and especially for immigrants those kids that are taken away by the official for what ever reason they are just a source of money the whole system profit from it. I read a case where a new born baby was taken from the hospital just few hours after birth. The more the children more the income this particular organisation make they even has been to human rights court of Europe numerous time. I used to think norway, sweden all these countries are pretty good in terms of sensitive matters like this but boy was i wrong. Not an ideal place to live if you have kids and especially if you are immigrants. This Indian couple got lucky they were able to get the children back but most people dont.
Mother's love is unconditional 😍🌹
Every country should fight for their kids and parents!
I cried alot feel sorry sad for sagarika and every mother who go through this it is very bad to seperate baby 😢 from mother God bless you sagarika and your kids u are very strong lady ❤😢
Imagine the plight, if kids were born in Norway. They got relief just because kids are Indian.
So traumatic for the children. 😢😍
Mf Norway 🇳🇴 government
Vikhari bindia🇮🇳😂
Do you know why all Hindus in India are desperately trying to escape India for Christian countries???
One whole Gujarati family from Modi's State perished in the snow in Canada. Very sad. At least Modi, also from Gujarat only ran away from his wife on his honeymoon night, and didn't run away to another country. His poor wife is a destitute. But that is our proud Indian culture!!
@@NahidHasan-xn7ie ata le lo😂😂😂😂😂
Who is here after watching the trailer
After the trailer of Mrs Chatterjee Vs Norway (24/2/23 12:37am)
So sad to see the way the boy is holding onto his foster dad. Goof up of the Norwegian government has broken the hearts of the foster parents as well . They seem so loving. The kids would have been so confused as well. At least when the boy was away from him mom, he was with loving people. Sweet of them to bring the child themselves instead of just sending the child through the authorities.
Agree with you, may god give them a lot of children. they loved the children so much they will be in their hearts forever. They deserve their own children
@@Notamy691 yes the adoptive parents also deserve children. They were a loving couple
@@rohinireddy547 they can go make their own or adopt children that dont have actual parents that want them
@@docaz9453 when you’re adopting, you can’t choose. You have to adopt the child given to you by the system
After the trailer...
Who is watching this after Mrs Chatterjee vs Norway
The foster parents will also bear a painful separation.thank you for taking care of the children in the meantime. Shukran from South Africa.
For a second I thought the guy taking the kid is Rahul Gandhi 😂
Norway government not only separated kids from mother but created huge differences between husband and wife also ,before this incident they were happy family but after this all are separated from family
Poor kids, poor parents, poor foster parents. Tragic story that hurts so many people , crazy
The foster parents seems heart broken !
I’m after watching a movie on Netflix. Emotional 😢thank god, she gets justice finally. She is a brave strong woman...And her husband makes money in that way a married woman makes children and sells them in Norway.......How shameful.
💔💔💔 heart broken
What a selfish father who chose country over his kids, some are saying mother was incapable of handling kids, whatsoever is the reason, she did not give up
Live in Sweden. Knows two families whose kids were taken away from the parents because parents did beat the child. So if you beat your child then ofcourse you can forget your kids there
Even animals don't forget their kids, then how will humans? I know westerners will not understand that as they are worse than animals who only care about money and steal children
Omg even if i get a chance to go to Norway i would never ever go. It's a horrific place in the world. After seeing Rani Mukherjee movie it has terrified me a lot.
Am glad for the parents and India the country.
Ok UA-cam suggested me this after Rani Mukherjee's movie trailer
Foster parents might have taken good care and that is why the boy is clinging on to him
It's horrible that the child had to be returned to his real parents after spending 10 years with the foster parents. It's clearly horrible for the poor child to have been sent in a completely new environment as well as for the foster parent. He clearly loved the child and child clearly loved him. Traumatic
Tha
@@priyak7384 he doesn't look 10 yr old
@@priyak7384 hello.. Who said after 10 years... This case happened in 2011... In 2012 mom won the case and children returned to their parents.. They spent 1 year in foster care in norway...
@@priyak7384 10 saal purana video hai madam ye ndtv ka.. Kuch to time line dekh lo... Wo baccha kya 10 saal ka dikh raha hai aapko video me? He was 3 n half years old in this video.
so where are the kids now? did they go back to Norway?
They are in west Bengal now , with their mother .
I don't hate other countries. But, really how humanity is now, I am really afraid of the future. Ppl become more realistic and calculative now that may be their IQ raise but EQ becomes so low. How can a child be aparted from his mother? Really inhumane. 😞
shame on that law who takes the kids for small reasons from their parents.
I'm so glad that at that time this news was covered by NDTV. It was such a big issue and I'm glad we have evidences of it.
guys, one thing to remember...foreign country, foreign rule...its not suppose to be like our own country rule.. If you dont know the rule properly then dont plan for settle down in foreign.
aur jao bahar settle hone.....this incident is a perfect smash for them who always wants to settle in abroad.
Children’s organization/office needs to do proper investigation first before removing children from their home. Ask lots of questions from parents, families and neighbors,,,,you will def get a better answer. Adults make quick judgments when removing kids from their parents, and this has a lasting effect on the kids. They take the kids away and place them in foster home, instead of doing a proper investigation.
His foster father was better than his real father ❤
Im hoping the parents sue the government back.. arrgghhh this really breaks my heart
Time to cancel Norway
How do you cancel a country?
@@ItsJoyJeet just delete it of the map and drown the country 😡😡
@@Zeus-7778 then who's the real bad guy ? 💀💀💀💀
@@ItsJoyJeet norway
You have to cancel Germany too
He looks so much like Rahul Gandhi 😲
UA-cam recommended me after 10 yrs..
Movie : Mrs. Chatargee vs Norway
Thumbnail guy looks like Ankur warikoo
Barnevernet is kinda fucked up.
What about Ariha.. Is she back to her parents..?
Chatterjee vs Norway
Just out of curiosity what exactly these western countries were thinking that parents should be separated from toddlers so that these toddlers become independent like what should they change there own diapers or start going out to buy groceries or something?
who's watching this after Rani Mukerjee's new movie??
I hope the kid in Germany also goes back to her parents.
That is why Hindus in India are all trying to desperately excape India for Christian countries!
Hope
Considering that the child in Germany case was thought to be se...ally abused, I certainly hope that parents; if they are the one who did it, should not get their child back, so that they can continue with the abuse. In Germany case they found blood in the diaper of that baby, not diaper rash amount of blood, an actual injury where she even needed stiches.
🥺🥺
england mein kids security is a big issue hai india ki tarah bachhon ko akela ghar mein rakh kar nai ja sakte hai. Yahan meri beti akeli raat mein bhar jaye toh chinta nai hoti. India mein jaane kitne maa baap hain jo apne bachhon ko acche se palte hain. Bus jindgi de di ahshaan kar diya. India waali habits jaati nai hai isliye europe aur uk mein logon ko dikkat ho jaati hai. Waise hi ladki paida hone par kaunkhus hota hai india mein. Sadak par ek hi room mein rahte hue 4 bache hote hai.
After trailer 🫡🫡🫡
It’s surprising that very conveniently we choose to not see the other problems in there. The husband who has no contribution in the house, the greedy brother in law, the insensitive in laws. But no we will never accept that we also are lacking in this.
This case should have been taken to the world court. This Lunatic child kidnapping law making Criminals should be put behind bars for eternity.
More parent less homes = more criminals
Kudos to the Indian government.
The foster parents 😭😭😭❤️
They adapted them for money 💲
What about the biological parents when their children were kidnapped from them?
The son,Abhigyan was an autistic child.For a normal child,sudennly becoming detached from his own family is very painful and difficult to cope up with.Again if that child lives in a foster family for two years who speak totally a different language,try to understand the traumatic situation of the child in the unknown family!! How difficult it was to adjust with the new family!Again when he was trying to cope up with the new environment and learnt the new language and in the mean time he forgot his own language also ,again he wa
s thrown out to a new situation!! If that child is autistic his condition will be definitely worsen....not only that their parents got separated for this incident which was more harmful and pathetic for the children.....this is called Norwegian wisdom !!!😢😢😢
Im here because of Netflix movie
This is the power of Cinema.
aunty ji 10 saal pehle hi aa gye the.... ye video 10 saal pehle ki he
@@animetldr4044 ji uncle ji.. hum itne padhe likhe nahi hai ki itni jaankaro rakh paaye..
@@englisharc good answer.
Sm Krishn the only good thing you did in your entire career was helping this NRI family somehow, apart from beautiful daughter Divya forgot to mention though ...slurp
Suddenly I feel like North Korea is another ideal for Europe too.
Both of them had weird laws.
Yes, it is better for Hindus from India to flee to North Korea than to Christian countries!
Which laws in Norway or Europe are you referring to? Which law concerning children is weird?
India should also look through the adoption industry. Many children are being sold to the western world even though they have a biological family... Its so sad
You are so right should stop all this adoption selling babies for peanuts price.
Why UA-cam recommending this video after 10 years lol is it because of that new Rani's movie..??
Absolutely.
Now kids were so clingy to foster parents and it’s the second trauma they will have to suffer.
Now Aahira Jain
For a second I thought he was Rahul Gandhi
Same thought
Thrown stones upon Norway embassy
Tere bindia🇮🇳 ko chodke rakhdenge wo log 😂
Tera India nahi hai madarchod
@@Edwinsk43453 cultured.. My foot 👟.
@@xyzyyy34 aapka foot v cultured hai wow
That is a crime and you should be arrested for trying to stage a riot!!
Good Indian Government that protect and fight for their people
Just puzzled as to why the parents did not come to receive the children?
Watch Mrs. Chaterjee vs Norway movie for more details
@@be_creative5 does the movie show why parents did not come to airport to receive the children and instead grandparents came? Movie is not available for screening where i am
@@Davinci957 Because custody was given to uncle and mother was not allowed to see their children as per law
@@officerschoiceethank you. finally saw the movie and understood why. Am just glad custody was finally given back to her. Her husband sorry to say was a real creep
Good Norway realised their big mistake n released the kids, no ego, n no adamant nature, very human. God bless the children 🙏🏻💖
Don't say good to norway is a pathetic stupid country
Theie mistake cost this family alot
Here, after the release of the movie trailer in 2023
Rani Mukherjee movie
Wonder, how come Norwegian law or rules etc be applicable on Indians??
If u are living in india, then u are in heaven my friend
You misspelt the word heaven when actually bit should read Hell
@@lorrainerane2158 That's why you are living in a non freedom country
India are very rich country actually all other countries make lots of money from India China and other countries. Fact is fact don't take sides.Bad and good are all over the world. Marks and Spencer cloths are India make and Bangladesh and Indonesia.selling in UK for higher prices.
Just out of curiosity, I wonder how our honorary current EAM would have handled this situation..
much better , unlike the incompetent leaders of Con-gress had
Now this type of one case is running in Germany since 1.5 year
@@youthindian1593 oh really. Thanks for the information!! Can you please share more details, i would really like too follow up with that case..
@@shilpa200
Ahira Shah look it up
May be in the current case lies the answer...to the question.
L3arn to love your children and treat them with care. Hope you parents have learnt a lesson.
Is norway that bad regarding children and breastfeeding mother relation
Mrs Banerjee vs Norway is d movei
But why didn’t paternal uncle get in trouble for taking money from that government. You need to remove this video, because this was not the outcome. They went back to their mother.
To all not Understanding the Norway pov, children in Europe face child abuse a lot. Recently I saw a video where a mother making a video and instructing her 5 year old for an outro when she was sleepy, she was threatening and it was captured in the opposite mirror and the child was frightened. Luckily it was a live and she didn't get time to edit and people noticed it. So as you can see the empathy is really less as many gets pregnant from rape or face teen pregnancy and become mother when they don't want the country wants to make sure the children are safe.
In India light spanking is allowed but this would create suspicion of abusing the kid there and threatening them, as the pain from the mother side shown to the audience who are okay with this kind of parenting, people are not seeing the source of such laws.
And Indian mothers who went there in the old times after their marriage were mostly naive and unaware. It's totally palatable they didn't took time to see around them and the atrocities of people or the laws made to protect them. She was naive in my opinion and the way channeled her inner turmoil they only took it as a proof that she is insane... But yeah she is also at fault she should have been careful about her surroundings as we say Jaisa Desh Vaisa Bhesh... All will judge according to their standards
So much for the so called Happiest country .
What are you saying ...she is accused of Tilak and teaching kids indian culture ...just bcozz she is staying in other country ...she won't do Tilak and will not teach indian culture ...
Indian children are abused way more than that and not every European parents are like
@@bansarimehta1204
Omg. That is simply not true. There is no reason to take someones children on cultural differences. There is no law against teaching your children your religion and your culture. We all teach our kids our culture.
I wonder, how much more masala, will people add, before the movie is even released.
just by the way you write English I am not sure I trust anything you say. It tells me that you may not have got a full education. A little knowledge can be a dangerous thing.
Shame on Norwegian Government
Unnecessary trauma for the kids
Only news channel covered news 11 years ago.. handsoff to ndtv
Jai hind … will never go to Norway
Why didn’t they return kids to the parents??
I don't know may be according to Norwegian authorities parents were un-fit for the custody rights. Instead the parental uncle got the custody rights and he brought them back to India. But by then the couple got divorced. After another legal battle for the custody rights in India. The mother got the custody rights and now she lives with her children in Kolkata.
Because giving the kids back to the parents would mean they were wrong and we know, these white asses could never digest the fact that they were wrong...
Tge law should change … the child should not suffer .. keep parents in foster xare for training rather keeping the baby
Do they give citizenship to kids that they take in custody foster home
These kids get into the system and are often adopted by Norway citizens so yes they do
i never knew that this kind of weird law is exist. glad i live in indonesia and don't need to face this kind of bullshit
"We should thank the norwegian government", what a joke
Wonder, are European specially Norwegian human being!!!???
Do your research before entering an unknown country. That is my advice for Indian people in India.
Norway's law ki MKC.
Finally movie helped some bit that government intervened
It is 11 years old news you fool
Thanks to the then govenment and foreign minister S M Krishna.
Kon kon yaha movie dekhne ke baad aya hai 😊
The child clinging to the foster parents illustrate that the kids were really taken care of in a good way!!
No child will cling on to someone if they were ill treated. Human life is more important in the west and Europe unlike in india where human life is taken lightly.
No. There are good parents in India and every part of the world!
I agree good parents are everywhere
What ? Are u listening to yrself? Everyone will clings to something or someone is familiar. That doesn’t mean it’s safe or healthy. Let’s talk about the habits that we cling to, does all the habits serve us good? Nah, yet we cling to it because it’s familiar. So yr point is not valid. Stop bullshitting people with yr half knowledge.About the human life taken light in india would take few hours for me to explain. I don’t think u are in the position to understand it.
Just what on earth you are trying to imply that Indian don't take their people's life seriously well you are wrong because we Indian value it's people more than anyone just because you don't know other country culture doesn't mean that children are not loved they took Mrs Chatterjee children just because they don't know how Indian woman raises their child
yeah they did a nice job taking care of the child but the amount of suffering they inflicted on the parent is unforgivable
Ps if the west is that much caring for the children well and good but don't compare it with east we have different way for raising children because unlike west we don't throw children out to fend for themselves when they grow up we let them go when they are ready that's why West has many East people have higher post than Westerners themselves
@@shivangichatterjee7308 you are really a joke.. the brown skin will always work for the whites. That’s why you are still a third world nation which only barks but nothing to show or prove. If you think the westerners are not smart look at all the CEO’s who work for them and are just yes sir no sir men slogging their arses for peanuts while the white owners of these corporations are enjoying and living their lives kingsize on a private island and on private yatch’s .
I’m the west people follow rules and the law and those that do not are given the treatment they deserve. Before you comment do your research lady and guess what have you seen any westerners lining up outside your country looking for work? Guess what…. you people cannot feed your own leave alone feeding others. Just don’t make me laugh with another of your stupid idiotic comments.
There is another similar case going on in Germany and see if your illiterate teleprompter ketliwala is able to help this family.
Shame on Norway government shame on Norway people